Command coords x y z dx dy and dz are broken?

[wooden thistle]

/execute at @s[x=-48,dx=50,y=-64,dy=382,z=-2043,dz=50] run say hi

why?

Why are coordinates shifted by 1?

[pulsar karma]

probably because of player hitbox and how the game calculates player position for the display

[snow dome]

As mittens said, it's the player hitbox. dx dy dz does not select by position, so the selection box is effectively widened by 0.3 blocks.

Think of it this way: If you placed a block at (-48, 66, -2043) and stood beside it, you would not be selected, since the player's hitbox is not intersecting that block. While you stand beside the block, you are more than 0.3 blocks away from the selection. Remove the block and stand partially inside it, then you will be selected.

[frigid heart]

Just a pictorial representation 😅
Your standing on -1,y,-1 and you are trying to detect any entity on the block 0,y,0 and it will trigger even if your not in 0,0 . Because your hotbox it touching that detection region.

[frigid heart]

That's why sprunkles suggesting to add 0.3 block from the detection.

That way if you standing on corner of the -1,-1 [towards 0,0] it only detect if that hit box is on 0.3,0.3

Sorry if there is any grammar/spelling mistake.

Happy new year 🎊

[frigid heart]

.

Hmm I think i write wrong coordinates there 🤦

[wooden thistle]

is that a bug or not?

It worked before and has been that way since the update

[frigid heart]

Not a bug!

[wooden thistle]

worst feature ever

[frigid heart]

I think if you use ”r” in there instead of checking hotbox. it will work perfectly

[wooden thistle]

i cant

is a square

[frigid heart]

Use -47.7,50,-63.7 then!

[wooden thistle]

uff i have to change that for every command ... i dont understand why did they changed that?

[frigid heart]

Just bear it 🤣

[wooden thistle]

not funny

[frigid heart]

This thing is logicaly correct so no need to blame on it . 🐣

[wooden thistle]

/execute at @s[x=-47.7,dx=50,y=-63.7,dy=382,z=-2043,dz=50 and this would work perfect=?

it will work from 48 until +50 so =98

[frigid heart]

You can test it in an easy way. Using
/tp 0 0 0 will tp you to that block's center 0.5,0.5,0.5
If you use /tp 0.00,0.00,0.00 it will tp you exactly that point
Idk this is related to your question

[wooden thistle]

so the command should stops at x coords 3

i test that later

[snow dome]

It works this way in Java Edition, and has in Bedrock since 1.19.70.

[wooden thistle]

sorry to anoy u again but how do i detect the player on the right y coords

/execute as @s[y=72,dy=0] at @s run msg TeeWhiteBlack jds

i want the player ont the exact y coord 72 not 71 not 71.5 not 73 only 72-72.99

[frigid heart]

When you are in block 72 then the hitblox is in 72 also is in 73 because player hitbox is 1.8 block higher.[or 72 and 71]
If you want to detect exactly on the block 72 then another condition need to perform.

Hmm which part do you want to detect when you on the block?

[wooden thistle]

hmm the bottom

like the feet

[frigid heart]

Feet part only!

[wooden thistle]

yes

[frigid heart]

@a[y=72,dy=0] unless entity @s[y=71,dy=0]

[wooden thistle]

it execute the command on x=70 and says no target matched

i got it , /execute at @s[y=73,dy=0] unless entity @s[y=74,dy=0] run msg TeeWhiteBlack jds

this is so anoying

[frigid heart]

Do you getting the result?

[wooden thistle]

yes

thx

but now i need that for x and z coords

i dont get the result i want

ok got it for x-2

/execute as @s[x=-1.7,dx=0] at @s unless entity @s[x=-0.7,dx=0] run say hi

only problem 0 and -1 doesnt work right

i give up i dont know how this shit works

[frigid heart]

For zero use x/z=0.3,dx/z=0
For -1 use x/z=-0.7,dx/z=0

@wooden thistle

I don't test it . Simply write on base of the logic!

What i doing is just adding 0.3 on that coord
Eg: for +ve number 1 -> 1.3 | 10 -> 10.3
For -ve number -1 -> -1+0.3 -> -0.7 | -10 -> -9.7

[wooden thistle]

nah i only want that with x coord

if the player is at -1 x it should run the code

[frigid heart]

X and Z are same here

[wooden thistle]

/execute as @s[x=-1.7,dx=0] at @s unless entity @s[x=-0.3,dx=0] run say hi

like this ?

this doesnt work

[frigid heart]

x=-1.7,....x=-0.7

Work on x=-2

[wooden thistle]

yes

but what are the coords for -1 and 0

or only 1

[frigid heart]

x=-0.7,....x=0.3
Work on x=-1

x=0.3,...x=1.3
Work on x=0

[wooden thistle]

nope that isnt right

[frigid heart]

x=1.3,....x=2.3
Work on x=1

[wooden thistle]

if iam at the corner middle it doesnt work

[frigid heart]

Then there is a bug i think

[wooden thistle]

i mean if i use tp at the bottom it shows this /tp -0.02 53.00 0.44

[frigid heart]

I didn't check that so I can't really say what you want to do in there

[wooden thistle]

but coords show -1 52 0

[wooden thistle]

just checking if the players is at the coords yes or not thats all

[frigid heart]

I will be back after checking the cmd then

[wooden thistle]

ok thx

[frigid heart]

Sorry for the delay.

I tested the thing and forgot one thing that we only offset one side of the block according to player hitbox. Need to add another condition there for offset opposite side also 🤣

/execute as @a at @s if entity @s[x=0.3,dx=0] unless entity @s[x=1.3,dx=0] run ...

[frigid heart]

This is for x=0 block test
First removing hitbox when you are in x=-1 [ using if ] then need another condition to remove hitbox when you are in x=1 [using unless]

If you want to add x , z in a cmd then you want to add unless-seperate,if in same position.

Eg- /execute as @a at @s if entity @s[x=-0.7,dx=0.z=0.3,dz=0] unless entity @s[x=0.3,dx=0] unless entity @s[z=1.3,dz=0] run...

For testing player is in x=-1,z=0

Idk there is an easy way to do it or not. If so someone will info that in here 🐣

@wooden thistle

[wooden thistle]

i dont need z coords only checking if the player is in any x=-1

[frigid heart]

/execute as @a at @s if entity @s[x=-0.7,dx=0] unless entity @s[x=0.3,dx=0] run ...

For x=-1

Check is that working or not

@wooden thistle

[wooden thistle]

ok does work now

thats mean for coords like 0 i use this
/execute as @a at @s if entity @s[x=0.3,dx=0] unless entity @s[x=1.3,dx=0] run
for -1
/execute as @a at @s if entity @s[x=-0.7,dx=0] unless entity @s[x=0.3,dx=0] run

and any other coords i use this
/execute as @s[x=-3.7,dx=0] at @s unless entity @s[x=-2.7,dx=0] run