crafting wont work for blocks with custom geometry (not experimental)

[safe shard]

i tried shapeless for stonecutters and shaped for crafting table, both do not work

{
"format_version": "1.20.30",
"minecraft:recipe_shapeless": {
"description": {
"identifier": "test:acacia_wall"
},

"tags": [
  "stonecutter"
],
"ingredients": [
  "minecraft:planks:4"
],
"result": {
  "item": "test:acacia_wall",
  "count": 2
}

}
}

{
"format_version": "1.20.30",
"minecraft:recipe_shaped": {
"description": {
"identifier": "test:birch_wall"
},

    "tags": ["crafting_table"],
    "pattern": [
        "/  ",
        "/  ",
        "/  "
    ],
    "key": {
        "/": {
            "item": "test:birch_wall",
            "data": 2
        }
                    },
        "result": {
            "item": "shapestudio:birch_vertical_slab",
            "count": 6
        }
    }

}

[eternal pivot]

Any content log?

[novel hull]

Something I noticed is that with 1.20.30, there is a new component that sets what item will unlock the recipe(I'm not at my computer ATM, so I can't see it) If that isn't included, it seems to make the recipe not work if unlockable crafting is enabled in the world

[safe shard]

Nothing. There was no errors. Didn't even recognize it

[safe shard]

Is that component necessary?

I tried the crafting table component and it just turned my block into a crafting table

[novel hull]

Sorry, I meant a component in the recipe file. The component is unlock. An example of it in the vanilla diamond pickaxe recipe:```json
{
"format_version": "1.20.10",
"minecraft:recipe_shaped": {
"description": {
"identifier": "minecraft:diamond_pickaxe"
},

"tags": [ "crafting_table" ],
"pattern": [
  "XXX",
  " # ",
  " # "
],
"key": {
  "#": {
    "item": "minecraft:stick"
  },
  "X": {
    "item": "minecraft:diamond"
  }
},
"unlock": [
  {
    "item": "minecraft:diamond"
  }
],
"result": {
  "item": "minecraft:diamond_pickaxe"
}

}
}```

This would make it so you can use the recipe once you have a diamond.

Upon further inspection, this recipe component only works for vanilla crafting tables. So the only real solution seems to be turning off recipe unlocking in the world settings

[safe shard]

i tried it in 1.12 too and it didnt work

this is the same crafting recipe in a different pack that i downloaded onlin

and it dont work in my pack

{
"format_version": 1.12,
"minecraft:recipe_shaped": {
"description": {
"identifier": test:birch_wall"
},
"tags": [
"crafting_table"
],
"pattern": [
"W ",
"W ",
"W "
],
"key": {
"W": {
"item": "minecraft:planks",
"data": 2
}
},
"result": {
"item": "test:birch_birch_wall",
"count": 6
}
}
}

i tried tinkering with the min engine. nothing i put worked

[safe shard]

how do i turn off unlockable crafting

actually nvm the other pack worked regardless

so not sure if thats the problem

[novel hull]

You turn it off in the world options.

[safe shard]

I will try it

[novel hull]

With this recipe, you have the result as test:birch_birch_wall. Is that the item identifier, or is it test:birch_wall?

[safe shard]

It's a different name altogether. I'm changing it so you don't know what the real block name is

Nda

[novel hull]

Gotcha

[safe shard]

recipes unlock is not on

maybe if i switch to the new component documentation in 1.20.1 it might agree with the block its trying to craft

1.12 is super far away from 1.20.30

[novel hull]

Weird. That's the only issue I've run into preventing recipes from appearing without something being wrong with the json itself. I know that some json errors will prevent the file from being parsed without throwing anything into the content log, so I'd reccomend double checking everything as well as whatever other solutions you have

[safe shard]

ill try it

[safe shard]

yeah i tried it with the unlocking component

didnt work either

[safe shard]

i fixed it

I code in vs and then use notepad to mass produce that code and change the block ids and texture in each file

but notepad doesnt handle json files that well

recipes require json files to work, so i had to do them in visual studio instead