Damage sensor is not getting triggered in player.json

[haughty shoal]

Hey, I am trying to make a combat logger using player.json, but for some reasons my event is not getting triggered by the damage sensor, as per I know, I did everything fine and tried various alternative ways to fix the problem, but the event is still not getting triggered by the damage sensor. Also, I did try to run event command and it worked perfectly fine.
Here's the code for my damage sensor,

{
                        "cause": "entity_attack",
                        "on_damage": {
                            "filters": {
                               "all_of": [{
                                    "test": "is_family",
                                    "operator": "==",
                                    "subject": "other",
                                    "value": "player"
                                    }]
                            },
                            "event": "wrs:in_combat",
                            "target": "self"
                        }
                    }

[safe depot]

Take out the cause.

It will default to all. The filter is the only thing you need. I think the entity attack is conflicting with player

[haughty shoal]

Still it is not working

But, it is working when someone hits me and I fall on the ground and takes fall damage, then the damage sensor is getting triggered and the combat timer made by me starts which is weird

[haughty shoal]

I fixed it

[safe depot]

What was the problem?

[haughty shoal]

There was one more damage sensor which also uses same conditions, but different target which was "other" so, both the damage sensors were conflicting with each other so, none of them got executed, so I removed the other damage sensor and made it so that when the combat damage sensor is run, then inside the event I added one more trigger which executes the other event but on the target "other"

Although I have one more problem now

My one more damage sensor is not running again

But this damage sensor shouldn't conflict with any other sensor

{
                        "on_damage": {
                            "filters": {
                                "all_of": [{
                                        "test": "has_damage",
                                        "value": "fatal"
                                    },
                                    {
                                        "test": "is_family",
                                        "subject": "other",
                                        "value": "player"
                                    }
                                ]
                            },
                            "event": "wrs:kill",
                            "target": "other"
                        }
                    }

This is the other damage sensor, and the event should trigger on the other player, but it is not getting triggered by the damage sensor and this time there is no conflicting with any other damage sensor

I am literally so much annoyed with this damage sensor now

It is basically a kill counter system you could suppose

[dry fox]

Why do you need a damage sensor to make a kill counter?

For that I would use this method
https://wiki.bedrock.dev/animation-controllers/death-commands.html#using-minecraft-on-death

[haughty shoal]

Actually, it is not a kill system but you can make a kill system through this, anyways it is actually when a player dies during a combat session, then the other player's combat timer will get reset by setting the all the combat scores to 0.

[haughty shoal]

Also, it only detects the player when the player has died, but it doesn't detect who killed the player

Sorry for the ping if you get one

[haughty shoal]

For that, it requires to setup a damage sensor to check who killed the player

[haughty shoal]

And add a kill (score) to the player who killed the other player

[haughty shoal]

By executing an event which consists of all the necessary commands, but the damage sensor itself is not getting triggered

[dry fox]

Any content log errors?

[haughty shoal]

Nope

[haughty shoal]

Can someone send me some full documentations for events and damage sensor?

[dry fox]

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/minecraft/creator/reference/content/entityreference/examples/entitycomponents/minecraftcomponent_damage_sensor

https://wiki.bedrock.dev/entities/entity-events

[haughty shoal]

Am I doing something wrong in events? Holiday creator features experimental is also enable

"wrs:kill": {
                "run_command": {
                    "target": "self",
                    "command": [
                        "scoreboard players set @s in_combat 0",
                        "scoreboard players set @s combat_timer 0"
                    ]
                }
            }

[haughty shoal]

Is there any alternate way to detect a player who killed an other player? (Except Script API)

Damage sensor is not really working properly

[haughty shoal]

I don't know why, but I fixed it by changing the location of this on_damage to a different location in damage sensor and it worked! (Bruh)

[safe depot]

This is my kill counter
damage senor partjson { "on_damage": { "filters": { "all_of": [ {"test":"has_damage","value":"fatal"}, {"test":"is_family","subject":"damager","value":"player"} ] }, "event": "ev:kill_count" } } eventjson "ev:kill_count": { "sequence": [ { "run_command": { "target": "other", "command": ["scoreboard players add @s kill_count 1"] } } ] }

[haughty shoal]

I did exactly that, but for some reasons my on_damage was not working in the last position of damage sensors, so I moved its position to up in damage sensor and it starts working, which was really bruh moment. I literally just moved the on_damage code position up in the damage sensor and didn't even change anything in the on_damage code and it worked after doing it

Now I am not going to touch damage sensor again

[safe depot]

only one sensor will be caught and it goes in physical order. So must be something else that matches... can you send the whole damage sensor?

[haughty shoal]

Well, I can't send the whole damage sensor code in chat because it is too long to send, so I am sending it in a file

[haughty shoal]

This damage sensor works perfectly fine now, previous the kill counter on_damage code was in below the combat on_damage code

Due to this, it was not working

Looks like the damage_sensor.json file is not getting send properly in discord

Is there any alternate way to send a json file in discord?

[dry fox]

If there is too much text just send the file like you did there, that’s the only alternative

[safe depot]

drag the file and it loads

[haughty shoal]

This is the file

Also, I am in phone