If anyone could do this it would be amazing'
#MULTILOADER SUPPORT
wintry crypt
tribal fiber
Ignoring for a moment the laziness of an ai-generated description, why do you suppose this hasn't been done before?
verbal kelp
im gonna be blunt here, but this is just not gonna happen, especially for free
do you have any idea how vastly different 1.7.10 is to 1.21.9
wintry crypt
also btw
verbal kelp
do you have any idea how vastly different 1.7.10 is to 1.21.9
not even considering the modloaders, just minecraft itself
wintry crypt
ai generated cause when i tried to explain to someone and they got confsed
its been done before
but needs to be done again because its outdate
tribal fiber
its been done before
Link
wintry crypt
like not fully what i want
but somewhat
like backporting mods
remapping
this can become good bro
tribal fiber
Lmao
minor rose
like backporting mods
Yes, that requires manual work, it can't be done automatically unless it's very, very minor. This is not.
minor rose
its worth it
It's not possible.
wintry crypt
it can be
minor rose
!!ivegotareallygoodidea
bright stoneBOT
@minor rose: Unknown tag, use !tag to see all available tags
minor rose
Dang it
verbal kelp
its worth it
i wouldnt say so considering the insane amount of work this would need when you could just.. use the version the mod was made for
wintry crypt
ik
tribal fiber
Find a server that allows commissions and pay someone oh idk like $120,000 and in a year you might have it
minor rose
!!ivegotareallygreatidea
bright stoneBOT
@minor rose: Unknown tag, use !tag to see all available tags
tribal fiber
but its done before
False
verbal kelp
!!ivegotagreatidea
bright stoneBOT
verbal kelp
but its done before
what was it called, link, proof of any kind?
minor rose
bro mojang removed it
??? Mojang has never added mod support
verbal kelp
i dont see why mojang would remove something like that unless it contained code from the game
wintry crypt
but it got to out of hand and too dangerous for the game
and they did some bad stuff
minor rose
Source please
verbal kelp
what?
minor rose
Source please
Archive.org or articles
tribal fiber
Source: "trust me bro"
wintry crypt
look
verbal kelp
but it got to out of hand and too dangerous for the game
even if this was true (i doubt), whos to say they wouldnt do the same to this theoretical mod
wintry crypt
wait guys if u play thios mod i will give. areward
minor rose
That doesn't make it possible
minor rose
verbal kelp
uh, no thanks
minor rose
Someone wanna reverse engineer that? It is the Modrinth cdn.
wintry crypt
if u beat me in pvp
tribal fiber
That isn't even related
rough musk
bruh this mod is literally not possible
wintry crypt
i wont make thjis mod
rough musk
let alone for free, "quickly"
wintry crypt
and if i win watch me wake it
minor rose
and if i win watch me wake it
I'd love if you made it, that'd be awesome.
wintry crypt
technically i have a model
but its like slow
like rlly rlly slow
like slow slow slow
like slow slow slow
like slow slow slow
like slwo sloww
like slow slow slow
verbal kelp
we get it
tribal fiber
Okay this is just trolling atp, I'm out
wintry crypt
ik
bro why does it show that in most downloads
its literluy a messed up mod
there LITERLY ! MIL DOWNLOADS
minor rose
technically i have a model
If it's automatic, it's revolutionary. If not, it's what we've always had.
wintry crypt
if my brother owns hypixel u have to give me a lambo
if he doesnt than ill give u a lambo
minor rose
Goodbye!
verbal kelp
what, were not even talking about the request at this point
north sleet
wintry crypt
true but just do u believe my brother owns hypidel
north sleet
whats his name
wintry crypt
simon
north sleet
guys its real
quasi trench
ChatGPT failed you and then you made this request
verbal kelp
true but just do u believe my brother owns hypidel
id like to think if simon was your brother youd know how much of an impossible request this is in the first place
wintry crypt
ik but it could be possible
bro 1.21.9 looks impossible wjhen the first versio came out
BRO once something becomes discovered its possible now
also if u still dont belive me ill tell u my last name
bright stoneBOT
To start modding Minecraft using Fabric, it's strongly recommended to know Java.
Minecraft, in its codebase, and mods, using Fabric API, use more advanced Java concepts like lambdas, generics and polymorphism.
If you don't know all of these concepts, you may have some difficulties modding.
Here are some online resources that will help learning Java
JetBrains Academy (free online course): https://www.jetbrains.com/academy/
Codecademy (free online course): https://www.codecademy.com/learn/learn-java
University of Helsinki (free online course): https://java-programming.mooc.fi/
Basic Java Tutorials: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/
Introduction to Programming using Java by David J. Eck (free online textbook): http://math.hws.edu/javanotes/
After Learning Java
For most mods you will want to make, you will have to use the Spongepowered Mixin Java library.
To learn more about Mixin, you can use the faq/mixin bot tag by typing !!faq/mixin in #bot-posting .
verbal kelp
what are you trying to prove, even if simon is your brother how does that remotely relate to this request or make it possible
wintry crypt
BRRRURRURRURUR
wintry crypt
because if my brother can create hypixel literly out of a yt channel then this is possible
i already asked him bru
some of his devs are doing it
north sleet
what did he say
wintry crypt
he said it posible but rlly hard
quasi trench
Aren't 12 and below not alloed in discord? against TOS? hmmmm... the rules says you need to comply with the TOS so we may be able to ping the moderators
verbal kelp
he said it posible but rlly hard
'really hard' is a massive understatement
wintry crypt
bro
verbal kelp
i dont know what else you want me to tell you
north sleet
get a life
meanwhile #player-support
quasi trench
get a life
Ah I got one, and it's at least 20 times bigger than yours
elfin valve
winged owl
This is one of the few requests that I would describe as impossible. It is possible, though highly nontrivial, to enable running Forge and NeoForge mods on Fabric within the same game version (see Kilt, for instance). However, it is not possible to create an automated mod translation tool that is capable of translating arbitrary mods to arbitrary versions of the game—even within the same loader.
Your description mentions "API translation"; there is actually no API in Minecraft for modding. That's why things like Fabric API, Forge, and NeoForge exist.
Unfortunately, the modloader APIs don't cover everything; modders do have to interact with and depend on Mojang code—code that changes between versions! That's why mods don't just automagically work across many versions: Minecraft's code is a moving target, and mods need to interact with it very precisely and accurately.
The base code of Minecraft has changed massively over the years. For example, The Flattening completely rewrote how block and item. Mods made before that that add blocks will not be compatible with versions; from what I understand, they'd have to be rewritten to a major degree.
That's just one example; major breaking changes happen every few versions, and some (most?) mods have to be almost totally reworked. You can't just simply emulate the environment; it doesn't work like that.
What about changed mechanics? Minecraft adds new things every version; what if you try to run a mod that depends on those features in an earlier version? Or what if you try to run a mod that depends on removed features in a later version? More insidiously, what if you try to run a mod that depends on behavior Mojang reworked—like attack mechanics, or parts of the dragon fight, in 1.9?
I'm running out of message length, so I'll end it here. It is not possible to make a mod to run any mod from any version from any loader on any version.
sharp remnant
guys can we close this post already
reef phoenix
technically i have a model
from your grammer and how you speak i highly doubt you were able to make one
twilit junco
guys can we close this post already
lock it so we can come back and stare in awe every once in a while
thorn gazelle
hall of fame request right here 🔥
winged owl
I feel like that mod's description supports my point, though, doesn't it?
Craftmine is a fork from Minecraft 1.21.5's release candidates, hence, unlike previous April Fool's versions, closely resembles the codebase mods targetting 1.21.5 are working to. There are of course some differences, but it is these differences that this mod seeks to bridge.
Craftmine is very similar to 1.21.5, which means that the differences are minimal.
tulip hemlock
Can't you just use multiple loaders at once /j
-# sorry for continuing this post
winged owl
Can't you just use multiple loaders at once /j
-# sorry for continuing this post
Yes, sometimes, using Connector or Kilt; that hardly ever works cross-version, though!
stark lake
Can't you just use multiple loaders at once /j
-# sorry for continuing this post
you can actually launch forge with fabric loader
sharp flint
though Fabric over Vanilla is different to Fabric over Forge
stark lake
not really
you can write a game provider for forge and launch fabric + forge at once, allowing both to load mods
most fabric mods probably won't work due to broken mixins (and different mappings) though
sharp flint
most fabric mods probably won't work due to broken mixins (and different mapping...
that’s what I mean
leaden garnet
This is one of the few requests that I would describe as impossible. It is possi...
I think you are responding to the trolls too seriously
This would be a nice response to other devs though
winged owl
I think you are responding to the trolls too seriously
This would be a nice resp...
Oh, is this a troll post? I tend to just assume that post authors are well-meaning but uninformed, not malicious (Hanlon’s razor, if that’s not too insulting). I figure it’s a more generous basis to work off of than assuming people are malevolent by default. I know well enough that I stand in need of such grace myself, often enough!
vast nest
Oh, is this a troll post? I tend to just assume that post authors are well-meani...
agreed
I actually took the time to read thru the whole post and wow
sharp remnant
Uhh