Lumien231's Bloodmoon for Fabric

[oak palm]

I'm looking for someone to do a remake from scratch (original is ARR, so a direct fork form that isn't possible) of Lumien231's take on Bloodmoon mod to Fabric 1.21+.

I want this specific mod because, differently from other lunar event mods, it only adds the bloodmoon event itself (no custom stuff and no other events), and it allowed via config to tie the bloodmoon to a specific lunar phase (like full moon) or to happen every x night (others have a percentage to happen in every night, which i dont like).

For sake of references:
CF: https://legacy.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/bloodmoon
GH: https://github.com/lumien231/Bloodmoon

[oak palm]

bump, really missing that mod on my pack

[idle fossil]

I will try to make it for fabric

ah

any forge modder here? I need some help in understanding the code... ;-;

[oak palm]

oh thanks a lot!

[oak palm]

maybe on #mod-dev-1 ?

[idle fossil]

hmm, you find one

:>

[oak palm]

i know Squid works with Forge as well

but mentioning modders here is against the rules

[idle fossil]

yeah

is squid your friend?

[oak palm]

not friend

but i owe a lot to this guy

[idle fossil]

oh

I have DMed the author of the mod

so I can take permission from him

[oak palm]

if he didnt picked up ComputerCraft after dan200 left i would never left 1.7.10 D:

[idle fossil]

I'm pretty sure he will say "yes"

[oak palm]

i hope so

[idle fossil]

what is computer craft

[oak palm]

basically a mod that add computers and robots (called turtles) in the game

his fork are here:
https://modrinth.com/mod/cc-tweaked

[idle fossil]

oh

[idle fossil]

the code seems complicated, i need help of some forge modder or i will have to learn modding

which i do will after my exams

;-;

or maybe i should not try to convert it to fabric

[oak palm]

no problem mate

[idle fossil]

instead write my own code

[lyric turret]

Fabric
https://github.com/Draylar/crimson-moon

[oak palm]

Differently from other mods, it only adds the event and the moon red color, without add any other items or shenanigans.
I put this sentence on OP exacly because i used that mod you refered, and i dislike it because it wasnt simplistic as Lumien's mod was

[lyric turret]

But you can remove/configure the other aspects and get the result you want...

[oak palm]

i really don't like this approach...

i mean, get a mod and need to turn everything off except one feature

i got a lot of issues with other mods like that (appleskin is one of them)

i prefer to wait if @idle fossil got help to port the lumien's work directly

[lyric turret]

At the very least it's open source, fabric, and you or anyone could remove the added additions.

[oak palm]

maybe using the code of that can be a start

[idle fossil]

i have messaged the author of the bloodmoon mod

but he hasn't replied yet

[oak palm]

if he doesnt, maybe you can use that other mod as a starting point

just peel off all the unecessary things

[idle fossil]

yeah

what is the difference between crimson moon and blood moon

[oak palm]

i mean, the basic logic (how to tint the sky, change mob spawning rate...)

[oak palm]

basically, while Lumien's mod only add the bloodmoon event (once after nth moons or in every full moon it increase hostile mobs spawing rate at night)

crimson moon add this but also a lot of other stuff that i dont want

like new tool tiers

i really dont think the game needs yet another items after the huge stuff that it already has

[idle fossil]

oh

[oak palm]

and i'm not a fan of "just turn the extra features off" approach since a lot of times it just doesnt worked for me (like in appleskin the annoying overlays in hunger and health bar doesnt go off even disabling it in config)

or mods like create that i will never put on my pack just to get a single feature

often this causes incompatibilites with other mods or even with dedicated server

that's very interesting for me

since i'm just leaving 1.12 forge behind

[idle fossil]

fabric 👍

[oak palm]

that was in this server?

[idle fossil]

another server

[oak palm]

ah i see

of course you can do straight conversions only for mods that have FOSS licenses

in other cases you will need to rebuild it from scratch

[idle fossil]

yeah

[idle fossil]

idk about that, it is still going to be copying

[oak palm]

more or less like @jade nebula did with some of the requests he did for me

[oak palm]

if you do both code and assets from scratch, it isnt copy

concepts cant be copyrighted i think

btw if you still have that server please DM the invite to me

just enabled DMs for this server

[idle fossil]

but recreating something that is copyrighted

[jade nebula]

Oh, there’s was already a fork for fabric, I didn’t make it myself, I just updated it

[oak palm]

oh sorry for my confusion (and the resulting ping)

[jade nebula]

No problem

[idle fossil]

this is the server

[idle fossil]

wait which one

[oak palm]

the one for the ports you mentioned earlier

[idle fossil]

oh

https://discord.gg/7ZgzR6Fe

[oak palm]

thanks

[oak palm]

bump

[gray mason]

What about this?

https://modrinth.com/mod/enhanced-celestials

[gray mason]

You can disable the custom items through the config

[oak palm]

i already tried that

but didnt like the style

plus it doesnt had any GUI to config (need to do via commands like a datapack what is er... bad)

[gray mason]

Is not bad to use datapacks for config mods

Also, you can just use a config gui like this

https://modrinth.com/mod/forge-config-screens

[oak palm]

bump, i still someone do this port...

[smoky kernel]

Not the same, but you might be interested in https://modrinth.com/mod/lunar

[oak palm]

i just had checked up this

[oak palm]

bump, following the release of 1.20.4

[oak palm]

Bump, this time i found this fork here that someone did to Fabric, unfortunately it was updated until 1.19.2.

I wonder if this is still being developed and if there was any changes in funcionalities between the original mod and this.

@jade nebula would an update of this be feasible since it was worked on until 1.19.3?

[sage escarp]

Would you still be interested in a port of this to 1.20.4?

[oak palm]

of course

[sage escarp]

I think I could try my hand at this but it might not go very well

[oak palm]

no problem

take your time

[sage escarp]

Where is the license lol

[oak palm]

i think it will be done from scratch

since it's arr 😦

[sage escarp]

I mean possibly could fork this https://github.com/BluSpring/Bloodmoon-Fabric

[oak palm]

it also doesnt have a license 😦

i can try opening an issue questioning about that

https://github.com/lumien231/Bloodmoon/issues/58

Also sent a DM to lumien on CurseForge

[sage escarp]

Actually I think a fork of either will work
By either I mean the original forge one or the ported fabric one

[oak palm]

seems like the author of the fork replied in the issue above

[sage escarp]

Oh if you could do that it would be amazing! Actually, i asked because someone at Fabric's Discord server was interested in doing that for 1.20.4+, but due to the lack of license he was scared off.
LOL that's a nice way to put it

[oak palm]

bump, a recreation of this mod is still relevant for me, since the current alternatives (datapacks and/or mods) doesn't satisfy me due to the different goals and features that they have.

[oak palm]

bump?

[smoky kernel]

https://modrinth.com/mod/a-blood-moon

[oak palm]

https://github.com/ChongYuCN/ABloodMoon wtf

[sage escarp]

They probably don't want to publish the source code

[oak palm]

so... arr

[sage escarp]

Yep

[oak palm]

bump, still relevant to me (other options didnt fit to my needs)

[oak palm]

@nimble flume maybe you could have interest in this concept

[oak palm]

🆙

[lone crown]

I can give a hand here.
Is this paid? If so, what's your budget?

[oak palm]

unfortunately no

dont have funds currently

[plucky thorn]

#moderator-messages message

[oak palm]

yeah, this time they came in the thread itself (since i closed my DMs)

[oak palm]

@knotty sorrel wonder if you have interest in this concept as well (need to be done from scratch because code isnt available)

[knotty sorrel]

Seems interesting, but I am really busy with school right now so I don’t know if I’ll have time. If someone else wants to do it, they should go ahead, but if not, then I might give it a shot when I find time

[oak palm]

no problem, i think nobody will have interest on this on the meanwhile

[oak palm]

Pingging @high ibex to see if he has interest (maybe after neodymium)

[oak palm]

🆙

@knotty sorrel do you still have interest?

[knotty sorrel]

I’m extremely busy with school right now, so sadly I don’t have time

[oak palm]

🆙 🎃

[jagged violet]

joining bc im interested

i dont have the time to work on it but i will if it's still needed when im done with my ongoing project

[oak palm]

right

[rotund mica]

I might take a look at it next week. Although I'm just a beginner in Minecraft modding, so I'm not sure if I can get it done.

[oak palm]

i bet the worst part would be tinting the moon red

[primal coral]

Not at all

[oak palm]

@stark dove this one is also a complex one, i think

see what you think about the concept basically

[stark dove]

definitely very cool

shocked this isnt updated

[oak palm]

unfortunately the author left modding

[stark dove]

yeah honestly i could do a clean room implementation of this

but.. honestly what I would like to do for this one is make a 1.14 version of it then release all versions from 1.14 to 1.21

[oak palm]

no problem

[stark dove]

💀 gets stuck on 1.14

maybe i should start on 1.21 and go backwards idk

ehhh who plays pre 1.16.5

[oak palm]

i would like it

[oak palm]

speaking about this

[stark dove]

ah ok

mannn i gotta find a time to fork https://modrinth.com/mod/legacy-buildcraft and work on it

i need buildcraft