#Team Up Phase Matchmaking Idea

8 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

rugged pecan
#

I've been thinking about matchmaking, and while i can't change how Lilith does things, what i can try, is suggest ways to make it better. Regarding Team Up Phase, the idea is not bad. One idea to make it better is by introduce more Kingdom Classes, like S+, S, A+, A, B, C, and D. This could make the Team Up phases more balanced and exciting because now A seed Class is consist of very different kind Kingdom. The difference is too far apart. So it need more classes to be better. Example of how team up will look like is S+ solo, S and B, A+ and A, A A B B and C C C D D D

Another idea is to show Kingdom Ratings during the registration phase. This way, KDs would know their seed beforehand and could plan accordingly. It's not a perfect system, but it'd give us more insight.

I also think penalizing and making No Match Found big KDs for running from fights (like registering in low-pool KVKs to snipe weaker KDs) is a solid idea. It'd encourage everyone to play fair and participate in the KVK spirit

eternal matrix
#

180b kp and 3T kp kingdoms both being “A” is crazy

pearl creek
#

😭

pastel comet
modest forum
rose copper
#

w suggestion

lone jay
#

"Another idea is to show Kingdom Ratings during the registration phase."
^this doesnt work because ratings are relative to other kds in the pop and how many kds register.
in theory it could live update but i doubt lilith have the capacity to do that.

honestly, people are overly fixating on the fact that top imps and random A seeds are both 'A' rated, it ultimately doesnt matter because they should never end up actually fighting each other because the matchmaking phase's job is to match up similarly powered teams.

i do think that pretty obviously 1606 and 1365 should have both been S in this HA pop but other than that there's no real issue with the rating system and adding extra ratings doesnt really help with anything, it just limits team making.

with the teams that were created, its very possible for everyone to be put into a good kvk.
weather or not lilith do it right or mess it up? i guess that we'll see at reset.

rugged pecan
# lone jay "Another idea is to show Kingdom Ratings during the registration phase." ^this d...

If there no problem with MM, there wont be suggestion. But you can see how its almost every KVK have not good MM or bad placement. And now in team up phase even the seed look lopsided with how 1365/1606 as A seed.
The additional class will help to decide if KD too low to be S but too high as A seed. What it will help is regarding campmate. A seed have 3 campmate. KD that type as they already big, given another 3 campmate is overkill.

While KD rating, is not mean seed 100% but more as framework. Because in the end seeding in the KVK itself based on pool.