#Trying to fix piloting by NOT actually fixing piloting

1365 messages Ā· Page 2 of 2 (latest)

candid wren
#

this thread just hit 1k comments is crazy

obsidian willow
#

Gotta get agooose and Leo to protest outside Lilith HQ tomorrow

narrow sluice
#

here is a thread made by a popular content creator, the poll in King's Codex is def more neutral in that sense Froge

fading ember
#

and there is a poll made by a popular community figure

#

what are you trying to say

narrow sluice
#

You assuming that community would attack anyone selection "Other options"

craggy forum
#

Unlimited rss for everyone upvote

narrow sluice
#

You surely familiar with the comm and you know how fair things go

fading ember
#

That's what it suggests from the title of the other options

wanton elm
#

do people really have a problem with this

fading ember
narrow sluice
#

it literally granulates the options to the max for less bias

fading ember
#

Regardless where it's done or who hosts it's irrelevant data because people are defiantly lying one way or another about how long they play or if they use or not.

#

The only valid statitical numbers has to be provided from a API or the developers themselves

narrow sluice
#

EPG Piloting peeps are always around in King's Codex discord, there 0 animosity towards pilots, piloting, or using it

fair light
#

there is a stigma

#

to openly admitting you use them

wanton elm
lethal mauve
civic finch
#

m

sweet drift
fresh eagle
#

How is the situation? It seems like Lilith is making the players unhappy about this experiment.

wanton elm
#

this doesnt stop select piloters it basically stops it all

#

whos in wars 16 hours anyways

timber shard
#

Why can't they limit an account to 2 devices and put a cooldown of 48 hours on how often you can change the authorised devices?

timber shard
steady dagger
#

Lmao

craggy forum
fresh eagle
#

As you know, this kind of thing shouldn't happen because it causes problems for the kingdoms that have been fighting for 2-3 days.

#

Don't even mention A seeds. Even C or D seeds can fight for 2-3 days.

wanton elm
#

it resets

fresh eagle
#

The answer is quite clear now. Waiting for Lilith's answer on what to do.

wanton elm
#

this only affects the small amount of passionate players that do fight over 16hrs a day

#

and the other part of people who actually use pilots

fresh eagle
#

The kingdom leader probably wouldn't like this because he was always watching the flag in battle.

wanton elm
#

it affects all sides

fading ember
#

Last kvk our zone 4 was about 3 days non stop in lower seeding.

wanton elm
#

fights were that long sure but individuals swap in and out majority dont play 16hrs plus regardless

craggy forum
wanton elm
#

its not an alliance wide fighting cooldown

#

this will definitely impact imp and high A seed most definitely considering like 99% of them use pilots

fresh eagle
#

Let's get it back to normal and improve the KVK matching.

fading ember
wanton elm
fading ember
#

You’d have to tell half or a good chunk to save their frenzy sit.

wanton elm
#

does the frenzy reset on reset did they say

craggy forum
#

stĆ­ll its 16h war frenzy not 16h gameplay

fading ember
wanton elm
#

^

#

yikes

steady dagger
#

So enlighten me on this one then

fading ember
#

It’s constant 16h stacking until you take a break for 8h then it rests back to ur 16h limit

#

Reset does not clear it

steady dagger
#

If I don't take a break of at least 8 hours and my war frenzy keeps popping on for 16 hours in a row it'll stack up and I will eventually be forced to take a 8h break right?

fading ember
#

Yes

#

That’s the current understanding of their mail

craggy forum
steady dagger
#

Had understood it correctly then, so people who don't take full 8 hour breaks are so fucked if they're in kvk with war frenzy on and off all the time lol

wanton elm
#

lilith cares

#

šŸ’•

steady dagger
#

They could send me 10% of their profit šŸ’•

#

But anyway

fresh eagle
#

If I press green, does that mean I don't agree with this?

wanton elm
#

anything that fucks piloting is good in my book

steady dagger
steady dagger
#

Originally

craggy forum
steady dagger
#

That seems to be what's gonna happen

flat storm
steady dagger
#

But u would need to have war frenzy deactivated for 8 hours, so a NAP for a day (non aggression pact) would fix it

narrow sluice
#

each time you in war frenzy it nibbles from your 16h stock, once you use 16h of active warfrenzy then its dead. 16h of war frenzy is around 20 hours of active fighting time

wanton elm
#

it doesnt affect me i dont fight for 16 hours straight

steady dagger
narrow sluice
#

the understanding of having 8h mandatory is weird

#

and makes no sense

flat storm
narrow sluice
#

its 8h hours of non-frenzy, split as you want

sweet drift
craggy forum
wanton elm
fresh eagle
#

Why make a fighting game if you're going to limit the time of the fights?

steady dagger
flat storm
#

do you think the big whales will continue to spend like they do now?

wanton elm
#

idk people were saying it would kill the game just as you are saying with this change

flat storm
#

lol

wanton elm
#

those big whales will play regardless

#

or move to call of dragons

flat storm
#

move to call of dragons? lol

steady dagger
flat storm
#

sure thing where you already have the cooldown

fresh eagle
#

It's better for people to stop playing because of this than to make the game worse.

craggy forum
fading ember
#

If the devs provided the data to back up this change then would have no issues with it at all as someone who genuine stays up 24h, but they did not do that so ppl will have issues with it. You just need to trigger war frenzy 64 times in a day to reach the cap limit without triggering it within a 8h time frame, so no poking, no killing swarmers, no situational attacking, no hitting returning marches from city rallies or regular rallies on structures, no teleporting in on a good kill, nothing. This forces people to be more manageable of how they field and attack the enemy.

craggy forum
steady dagger
flat storm
wanton elm
wanton elm
#

i didn't read all

steady dagger
#

I do think the plain 8 hour wall is a trash way to do this tho tbh

craggy forum
fresh eagle
#

Now they will test it, if the majority doesn't agree then just remove it.

wanton elm
#

would refreshing the cooldown on reset make it any better

steady dagger
wanton elm
#

nvm

fading ember
craggy forum
steady dagger
#

Oh that yeah maybe

#

Thing is, this seems like a horrendous change for the reason we're being given it, and the way we're being given it

craggy forum
#

its can be balanced in maybe ways soo we will see after testing what lilith really want šŸ˜„

fresh eagle
#

Do you think he will remove it or test it?

narrow sluice
#

you should try it to judge it

steady dagger
#

It's not gonna stop piloting and it's gonna be horrendous having to stay 8 hours sitting around if the cap of WF were to be hit, they can tweak things around and maybe just maybe make something work but with other reasons, if they said it is for the players health and it would be executed some other way it would be a whole different story

fresh eagle
#

Hot issue even before the experiment

fading ember
narrow sluice
#

issue isn't defined yet, all we discussing is a mail

#

and interpretations

steady dagger
#

Did they ever try to do the pre kvk in kvk map or did they back down from that one without actually testing?

narrow sluice
#

Ive read they did it already

#

forgot which kds

steady dagger
#

They may pull back from this one as a lot of people including spenders are pissed

steady dagger
craggy forum
narrow sluice
#

well I totally agree the prekvk being done like that is neither pleasing spenders or leadership or f2ps or anyone

steady dagger
#

My point was that I believed they backed down without trying because of the community discontent

fresh eagle
#

It's better to wait for the email. Now it's time to express your opinion whether you agree or not.

steady dagger
#

But that doesn't seem to be the case

steady dagger
narrow sluice
steady dagger
#

It's a double edge sword to be honest

fading ember
#

7 years straight of this bull shit

#

of non-transparency

narrow sluice
#

soon 8 kek

sweet drift
#

See how bad the implementatiom of the "watchlist" feature was

#

then apply it to this

fresh eagle
#

Yes, it would definitely not be good if the top players spoke up themselves, like what happened last time.

narrow sluice
#

expect 1, get 2

#

same applies here

#

you'd never know what Lilith is prepping

fresh eagle
#

Every answer will have consequences depending on how it is resolved.

reef vigil
#

I think a viable way to fix the pilot problem (without working out the logistics to ban pilots) and without this rest mechanic is just have better matchmaking.

  1. Everyone benefits because we all want this
  2. If a KD is heavy on using pilots then they will get weighted higher in the matchmaking system as in theory the reason people don’t like the pilots is people have used them to fight better / longer / etc. So by default you no longer are matching KDs that appear to be the same strength against each other (except one KD uses pilots so it’s uneven) so the pain felt by pilots is way less šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø
slender ice
#

any high seed/imperium kvk has atleast 50% of players using a pilot/sharing account

#

So if you dont use pilots you will have to join a different kingdom?

bleak abyss
#

crazy that I still see so many people saying that locking to a device will fix piloting, have people seriously never heard about teamviewer?

slender ice
#

Is there anyone here who actually fights with war frenzy for more than 16 hours a day without using pilots? Without lying?

blazing wharf
fresh eagle
#

This means that if you don't fight as hard as your pilots, you can move to a new kingdom, because the kingdom with the most pilots is the one that fights the hardest. You just need to be in the right place.

narrow sluice
fresh eagle
#

You are in a highly competitive KD, that is what you need to know, the fight will definitely not be less than 16 hours.

#

Seed A wins in 16 hours, I have never seen that before, even C seed can't win in 16 hours unless they meet Farm.

narrow sluice
#

18*

#

18 hours

#

16 is not crazy

#

if 16 was enough Chadski wouldn't complain

#

because 16 is exactly the hours you get

fresh eagle
#

Being in a highly competitive KD is about accepting it, not blaming it on others.

narrow sluice
#

you said if you don't fight as hard as your pilots

#

why id fight if I can fully lean on pilot

#

why the 50/50

#

I can aim for a 70/30 of this

#

and only be myself piloting my account third the time

fresh eagle
#

I mean, it's a very difficult fight and takes a lot of time in a highly competitive KD, which means that if you have a pilot, you're going to fight even harder.

narrow sluice
#

never heard of this logic, Pilots are here to alleviate effort

#

not make it harder for the one buying the service

fresh eagle
#

The pilot came to your rescue while you were resting.

fresh eagle
wanton elm
#

some guy in chadski's chat justified piloting because some whales can only play like 2 hours

sweet drift
#

Brian Kuh put up a good response to the video

wanton elm
wanton dagger
#

how is it biased isnt it just called having an opinion?

wanton dagger
# fading ember

if u think an emoji is stopping people from voting for their preferred option then ur just delusional plus its a riot emoji for a ā€œrevert changeā€ option its completely appropriate

fading ember
#

It wasn't the emoji it was the wording

#

Why would I click on a poll option that says "uses pilots"

tulip olive
#

I fully expect Lilith to read all 1200 comments 🤣

I think an IP and device ID restriction is not a good solution. I personally play on an iPad and my phone. What would happen if someone's phone breaks and they need a new 1....
A device limit on an account still wouldn't be a proper solution.

The best I could come up with is if RoK tracked locations. If I teleport from the US to Vietnam in 1 hour then that's suspicious, but people can use a VPN to bypass this.

wanton elm
#

this change is ok they just need to tweak it a bit

fading ember
# wanton dagger how is it biased isnt it just called having an opinion?

Well then I apologize for taking it the wrong way. Just see when ppl have to result into calling ppl certain things to make their points as biased towards the side they are suggestively supporting. It's the same for chad when I saw him insulting ppl here and in his YouTube comments, it shows a bit of biased.

#

also not even sure how you thought it was the emoji, I clearly had that cropped out from that screenshot

wanton elm
#

its hard to deny the use of pilots

#

this change really only affects 0.1% of the playerbase who plays that extensively

narrow sluice
#

The poll is way more neutral and representative than this thread vote

sweet drift
narrow sluice
#

Alot of opinionless upvoters driven by group sentiment

tulip olive
#

Wardaddychad goons made this vote bias, only takes 200 subscribers to swing this vote

hybrid raven
#

All of 606 pilots upvoting

wanton elm
sweet drift
wanton elm
#

He's basically saying a player's worth isn't about their talent or how much they spend but about how many hours they can commit a commitment he only manages by hiring other people (pilots) which is pretty funny to me lol

narrow sluice
#

Emotional just like his whole statement

tulip olive
#

YouTubers should have more dignity than to flood discord votes. They have community managers to communicate their thoughts to

hybrid raven
#

As if 606 had 1 fight over 16hrs last kvk. Or the kvk before 😭

fading ember
#

like I said ealier in this thread, any community poll or take will be useless data because you will never get the truth out of people and it's always maniplatiable. I could ask a 100 ppl discord to upvote for example and no one would know the wiser.

sweet drift
#

All data is useful in context FrogePray

narrow sluice
#

The poll settings and environment people wise couldn't be comparable to chadski's, the community you refer to gathers alot of the concerned pilots themselves.
so I'd take that data for now

#

You simply cannot discredit the poll with the same arguments we discredit this vote here

tulip olive
#

I'd guarantee Lilith has already been tracking player War Frenzy time, they already know who and how many have exceeded 16 hours. Most accurate place to poll is in game and compare people's war frenzy time with how they voted.

fading ember
#

after just joining kings codex

#

I can most certainly apply the same logic

hybrid raven
#

From my personal experience, when you used to have downtime in kvk, it made the zones last a lot longer. Push and pull. Each kingdom makes progress in their respective uptime and they burn in downtime. Now if you have downtime at all you wake up and pilots burned all your territory and kvk is over.

narrow sluice
fading ember
#

Yeah, but the fact still remains that anyone can manipulate both.

#

If they wanted to put in the effort if they had enough connections.

narrow sluice
#

Talk about probabilities, as it's all approximations in the end, theres no truth but theres something thats closer

fading ember
#

And if data can be manipulated = it's not valid

narrow sluice
#

As I said its most likely to be manipulated here than there

fading ember
#

Yeah, but you just said earlier that you can't compare this poll to that servers poll manipulation.

wanton elm
#

^

fading ember
#

When just gave you a perfectly valid reason why you could

wanton elm
#

i see differing opinions between different places 1 poll isn't accurate

#

chadskys new video is full of people in the comments calling it out as more a biased rant

#

like be honest who is really having 16 hours of straight war frenzy all day

#

they can tweak it to make it better sure

sweet drift
#

It's hard to vote that you use pilots anyway, because it technically breaks TOS, which biases the poll

narrow sluice
#

Comparing to affirm what's better data to do some thinking yes,
not comparable in neutrality

#

is the conclusion

#

like lol

#

you just stretching it

wanton elm
#

try making a poll in the fleish server

#

i can imagine how the poll will end up lol

tulip olive
#

I want to drink wardaddychad's tears. Lil cry baby is sad because "he" can't play 24 hours straight. Some of us have jobs.
Even if someone does play 24 hours straight, they can't play 48, 72, 96... hours straight. Sir cry baby wardaddychad, tell me how long you can play until you collapse

narrow sluice
#

It's all biased

#

but something gotta be closer

#

that's where it goes different, and ends up comparing how it is here and there etc

wanton elm
spare willow
#

you can check apocalypse's poll data, bilegt's poll data and the kingscodex's poll data and you can see which one has the most majority

fading ember
tulip olive
#

People don't want to have to take time off work 🤣

spare willow
narrow sluice
fading ember
wanton elm
#

i can understand why chisgule likes the change wasn't he told to start piloting lol

fading ember
#

Like during Choonis time (not during when piloting got heavy)

sweet drift
spare willow
#

also chadski opposing something is not new as when ruz point out a suggestion that the new crystal tech that allows routed marches to gem to instantly get back to their city is op, caused some anger and backlash, this includes chadski

tulip olive
#

Even for people who take off work, they still need to sleep. Forcing people to play 24 hours straight is unhealthy. What happens after the 24 hours? They got to sleep!

#

Let's have doctors and nurses take off work for a game. Lives of people in hospital are an acceptable sacrifice for the kingdoms success

fading ember
#

One of the highest spending ppl in the game was legit in the medical field, ever hear of mad phantom

sweet drift
spare willow
tulip olive
wanton elm
#

all this money down the drain cant play 24h straight

spare willow
sweet drift
#

If you've been in VC long enough you hear things

fading ember
#

While I agree Chad should've been more modest while making his points in his video and not being like "I wil be the most valued person in this game". It still stands that every person has their own disposable time to invest into whatever time they can afford to do. Some people work at home so they can in theory have all the time to do both.

spare willow
#

people got mad at lilith just because they updated to implement a bedtime period cause they're worried about their health is crazy

wanton elm
fading ember
#

The people that genially don't use pilots and actually commit the hours (doesn't matter if they trigger frenzy or not) have perfectly every reason to be pissed as hell about this, but obviously they can't prove it without the developers saying they never indulged in piloting.

tulip olive
#

They can still fill garrisons... So this only affects the open field. If someone truly plays 24 hours then have fun filling garrisons and watch Netflix 🤣

sweet drift
#

Fill and chill?

#

Wait no

wanton elm
#

shit

#

i wonder how imps kvks will change after this

fading ember
#

Just would mean less field fights potentially.

#

KvKs would still preceed the same.

tulip olive
#

They will actually take a financial hit from this. Less 50% expansions will be bought šŸ˜‚

fading ember
#

Pass 7 might be actually pointless though in the last day or two depending how this pioneer testing goes. So KDs might not bother to rally and maintain reinforces for X period before kingsland.

#

No one wants to use like 4h-6h (which is perfectly reasonable account uptime) of their 16h quota then be fucked in KL without it resetting back to 0.

wanton elm
spare willow
fading ember
#

Since when did rallying not do it? Just dropped alliance tag right now and joined a farm shell and got this notifcation.

#

Garrison for sure doesn't add ur frenzy.

#

But constant rallying 100% it does

#

also did the mail state that if you were in a rally stature it wouldn't count?

#

no?

#

So where did you get that information

#

Did VIP support say that?

tulip olive
#

In their notes they say you can "join rallies", I'm betting that refers to barb fort rallies, non-pvp rallies

fading ember
#

Oh he's talking about reinforcing rallies

#

Nvm

#

Thought he was talking about the captain

#

mb

tulip olive
spare willow
tulip olive
#

I think you still war frenzy when joining a pvp rally, which is why I think this might refer to barb fort rallies

spare willow
#

joining rallies or even counter rallies is cool and all but initiating a rally would definitely lead to kds needing another backup rally leader

tulip olive
#

Small kingdoms definitely don't have many premium rally leads

spare willow
tulip olive
#

People who pilot will just put their best march in a rss node in the front line 🤣
I'll bet my life savings on that

fading ember
#

kek at this point I'd make another suggestion for the developers to be more transparent about their patch notes.

#

It causes too much missing speculation.

#

In the past their justification for it was for the players to figure out themselvs basically a EA statement

wanton elm
wanton dagger
wanton dagger
fading ember
tulip olive
#

Piloting is against TOS, risky to admit doing it

mossy blade
#

I did 50h in my last Z5 it's feasible

#

Just need some breaks to not crash out

tulip olive
#

With enough caffeine and nicotine I bet I can do 30 hours, but my health ain't worth it

mossy blade
#

While if it's an imperium I wouldn't see a point if people will be awake regardless

tulip olive
#

In wardaddychad's video, he has copy and pasted responses to people disagreeing with him in comments. He literally has a pilot for the comment section. His opinion is not valid

fading ember
#

Oh I read the screenshot wrong, never mind. That's what I get for reading Discord first thing in the morning.

#

@wanton dagger apologies, I was stupid about the whole thing. Just understood the context of the entire poll post. It had both options for ppl who used and who didn't. Quick read it while reading back the thread FrogeFacePalm.

wanton elm
#

the whole video was just copium

fading ember
#

Real talk though, lock the thread. It's already made it's point and the people have made well enough over the discussion topic of it and even into branches that are off topic about it.

wanton dagger
#

are u sure that was me

reef knoll
#

was like late at night so cant blame u

wanton dagger
reef knoll
#

but that never stopped me

wanton dagger
reef knoll
#

😭

reef vigil
# slender ice what does matchmaking have to do with pilots

I think part of the reason people are so annoyed with pilots in seeds lower than imperium is you enter a kvk with an opponent that is seemingly as strong as your KD and then their accounts are online 24/7 and you get crushed. Like that experience sucks to play against.

reef vigil
wanton elm
#

Kvks with loads of pilots feels so inauthentic

reef vigil
#

I am just concerned about the people who

  1. Actually love taking off work and playing all day and night for a day or two with their friends
  2. How this affects defending in your downtime. If all of your KD is on cooldown (or whatever it is called) how do you defend flags (you can no longer swarm, control field or counter rally)? What happens if the enemy fort drops? Do you have to let it free build?
#

I think if you could somehow address 2 it would lessen the burden on KDs a lot.

#

Because stuffing flags as we all know isn’t an infallible defense. This just opens your KD up to getting cooked and back flagging for 8 hours

#

Would be nice to at least allow counter rallies (I.e on cooldown you can at least rally anyone with war frenzy on)

tulip olive
#

How does the life of someone look when they manage to do 16 hours of war frenzy in a 16 hour period?

  1. No showers
  2. No working out
  3. No driving anywhere
  4. No cooking and eating with the family
  5. No household tasks or chores
  6. No work or family time
  7. No touching grass

If someone does literally 16 hours straight of war frenzy then forced break is healthy.

queen fjord
#

I’m used to 30 hr shifts for zone opening, realistically I’ll just pilot the kd fillers until my 8 hrs is up gg

brazen prairie
#

Chadski's crash out is because he is American. American idea of freedom is based on a liberal, individualistic framework, while in many parts of the world, views are rooted in a communitarian framework that prioritizes social harmony and collective well-being. Why not just wait and see what the pioneer test reveals? If the change is good for the community, why not give it time to play out?

steady dagger
#

Dawg what

#

If I agree with what he says that means I'm American then? šŸ’€šŸ™

steady dagger
#

And people will find ways around it.... Double accounts or whatever

fair light
#

It gives everyone with multiple accounts that plays with 1 at the highest level to want to put both in the same kd

#

And bam their change has if anything widened the gap

reef vigil
# tulip olive How does the life of someone look when they manage to do 16 hours of war frenzy ...
  1. Shower before the pass opens. Assuming 1 shower per day you have at least 24hrs before you need to shower again.
  2. Again work out the day before and have the pass opening be your rest day.
  3. People don’t drive anywhere on a normal day anyways so 🤷
  4. A lot of people live alone and can meal prep
  5. Again do your chores before pass opening. Would be wild if your main rally couldn’t burn a flag because they had to clean the kitchen
  6. Take the day off. Sometimes not working for a day is healthy
  7. It’s only one day they will live. Also touch grass before pass opens.

In just 5 mins it’s easy to come up with ways to satisfy your made up constraints for how people should live a healthy lifestyle. 16hrs is no where near a limit where a game should make decisions for you

#

People are on planes for 16+ hrs every day and they turn out just fine

bleak abyss