#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 121 of 1

old spoke
#

He said that the salute emoji makes it seem sarcastic

wanton roost
old spoke
#

I don't know then. If he ain't supernatural he still appears to have supernatural aspects.

#

Which is weird if he is only a human

wanton roost
#

It'll probably be explained in the guest episode

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

But can someone just explain the shapeshifting part to me then?

wanton roost
old spoke
vagrant igloo
#

by saying "was never supernatural" it kind of sounds like he was never intended to be supernatural

vagrant igloo
# wanton roost

being made of flesh and bone quite literally means nothing

#

and he did specify the AS

old spoke
#

Jason Voorhees is supernatural and he has flesh and bones.

vagrant igloo
#

my dog is made of flesh and bone

#

he isn't human

#

also

#

think about this

#

even if the guest was a creature
that doesn't mean he is supernatural

#

in the hn universe, LUCK CAN LITERALLY BE MANIPULATED

#

so a bird monster is not out of the question

old spoke
#

Yeah didn't think of it outside of supernatural.

#

He's still a creature with powers

wanton roost
#

It's hard to tell tbh they still say he isn't supernatural and there will be a guest episode

#

They keep saying it too so

#

Maybe the guest episode will tell us

vagrant igloo
#

and alex specifically said the AS

wanton roost
vagrant igloo
#

well that is literally just not true

wanton roost
#

After he said "was"

old spoke
#

But ain't every Hello Neighbor content in the same universe. Even if they contradict eachother.

vagrant igloo
wanton roost
#

It's all Canon so

old spoke
#

So wdym specifically AS

vagrant igloo
#

oh yeah

#

but then again
if the AS does it's own thing on everything else
why not with the guest too

old spoke
#

Well true. It's basically a mix of the books and games.

vagrant igloo
#

i stand by this

old spoke
#

But i don't get the early 2000's part.

#

If it's basically confirmed to be in 1996

vagrant igloo
#

it is literally confirmed by alex that the AS takes place in early 2000s

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

I mean there's so much contradicting that it's becoming a mess.

#

So Diane died in 1999?

old spoke
#

So explain to me then how AS is set in the year 2000 if they say that Diane died last year and in the books she died 1995

vagrant igloo
#

did you ignore this

old spoke
#

Did you ignore when i asked that when was it confirmed

wanton roost
#

Why is it that small

vagrant igloo
vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

Then it makes 0 sense

wanton roost
#

I'll find it

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

Why would change it to the year 2000. There's still gonna be a 7 year gap between smartphones.

wanton roost
#

this is all i could find

#

a bit later

vagrant igloo
old spoke
wanton roost
#

Season 2 is hello neighbor 2

#

Or am I wrong.

vagrant igloo
#

the AS did

#

trinity had one

old spoke
#

Yeah AS, but not HN 2. Alex said that they had smartphones

vagrant igloo
#

he did not specify either

#

but the AS had them and hn2 did not

#

so he prob means AS

wanton roost
#

but mayor and leslie were in it and other HN2 characters

#

Soo

wanton roost
#

It's just the same

old spoke
#

Do you mean that it's the year 2000? And the shows event actually took place in 1997, but they retell it with more modernised stuff?

#

Like in the kids memories

vagrant igloo
#

i did not say the year 2000

#

i said early 2000s

old spoke
#

Which means the year 2000

wanton roost
# vagrant igloo and?

And thats why the AS has smartphones ig smartphones weren't in HN2 but they were in the AS for Some reason and season 2 is hello neighbor 2 so

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

Well it does?

vagrant igloo
#

early 2000s
means the first bit
of the 2000s

old spoke
#

In the Hello Engineer loading screen Brave has a tablet, doesn't mean that it's canon.

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

The year 2999 is NOT early 2000's?

vagrant igloo
#

bruh

#

read my message again

old spoke
#

So it's from the year 2000 forward

#

It's literally the year 2000

#

If it's early 2000's

vagrant igloo
#

....
EARLY 2000s
MEANS
early on in the 21st century

#

that's alll

old spoke
#

So it's prob the year 2001 in the show

#

Idk then

vagrant igloo
#

smartphones were invented in around 2007 i believe

old spoke
#

I know. But it doesn't necessarily have to be in the year 2007.

vagrant igloo
#

true

#

my theory
since the AS doesn't fit in
is
in the early 2000s
the kids were thinking back to when everything happened
and they remembered some things wrong
which is why
things are different
than the books
and the games

old spoke
#

That's what i asked earlier.

#

Well i said that it was the year 2000, but that was a mistake.

vagrant igloo
old spoke
#

So im confused are the actual events happening in the show when it's 2001-2009 or when it's like the 1990's?

vagrant igloo
#

we don't know
but like i literally just said
i think everything in the as happens in the early 2000s
and it's just a combination of their memories
and they remembered some things wrong

old spoke
#

😂

vagrant igloo
#

???

shell gull
vagrant igloo
shell gull
#

Everything has to do with how each character perceives things, this is even further backed by the original concept of The Nest being a twisted version of the real world all in Quentin’s head, to me it seems it’s always been on a perspective situation.

#

That begs the question of which character in the lore has the closest perception of the real world?

manic dirge
#

Trinity’s definitely isn’t due to how she perceives Ted’s house

#

Or perhaps Quentin

ripe berry
#

Quentin's perspective in what we have of HN2 is what I'd say is the most accurate

#

HN1 claims 1997 when other sources- including others from Nicky himself claim 1996

#

HND makes Nicky Trilogy's accuracy more questionable due to Nicky remembering it decades later

#

and Idk how to classify Aaron Trilogy here

shell gull
shell gull
low kite
#

One perspective we haven't seen is Mr. Peterson's, as far as I'm aware. Maybe the Hello Neighbor Movie will tackle his perspective of the story.

unkempt sleet
#

i still dont think the perspectives arent whats going on, at least mostly

#

Because some things just isnt able to be explained with that

#

Like how Aaron is friends with Trinity even before Trinity came to town in her perspective

#

im just going with same canon but different continuities across media until they decide to give an actual explanation

shell gull
unkempt sleet
#

i meant Aaron Trilogy (Aaron's perspective) and the Show (Trinity's perspective)

#

considering with the perspective theory

shell gull
#

Yeah true, it’s definitely weird.

wanton roost
#

I hope everything can be put together well somehow

#

I don't know what they mean about the AS does its own thing

stiff spire
#

True

sick bone
#

Hello @stiff spire @wanton roost @shell gull

sick bone
#

İ want talk lores

shy siren
#

Ok @sick bone

#

I'll talk lores

#

I think I have a decent understanding of the lore

#

Also wheres the Aaron's perspective?

ripe berry
shy siren
#

I have alot I wanna talk about

#

The guest

#

I'm honestly really confused

#

Is he supernatural or not

#

He shape-shifting in the vr games

#

But nikita said he was never suoernatural

sick bone
#

Guest is franklin + aaron i think

midnight cedar
#

true

#

The timeline of HN is so mixed up. I don't know which games are canon or not!;\

jagged mist
#

He is not supernatural

#

In the VR Games, it’s all illusions and dreams

#

hes not actually shapeshifting

shell gull
# sick bone Guest is franklin + aaron i think

I doubt that theory, The Guest isn’t super natural (Even though he also kinda is with certain things) but I doubt The Guest is two people, Aaron doesn’t make sense, Franklin is a maybe.

shell gull
silver vine
#

How is this chat so alive

#

What lore is there to talk about

severe vine
#

I like reading this channel before I go to sleep. There's plenty to talk about.

brisk hearth
#

I know he didn't exist at the time but why didn't the guest never attack nicky in the books since he had so many chances.

wanton roost
obtuse wedge
brisk hearth
vale topaz
brisk hearth
chrome maple
#

human flesh

ripe berry
#

HNVR is an exception due to being in the Guest World or Dark Dream or whatever it's called

vagrant igloo
#

dark guest dream world

wanton roost
#

dark foggy guest dream world

#

ngl we need more guest world

shell gull
#

Is the most I can use to give it a name.

stiff spire
#

Ngl I’ve always found the nest world interesting in HNVR definitely one of the most coolest things in the franchise in the games

shell gull
stiff spire
#

Me too

#

imagine if it comes back in HN3 in some way I think that’d be cool but idk

shell gull
vagrant igloo
#

will we ever see the guest lair I wonder

#

if it still exists

#

considering it's from hg times

late jackal
#

This kind of random but is the hello neighbor books Canon

#

If so I don't like how Mr Peterson acts

wicked heath
#

Like he should ve

late jackal
# wicked heath He’s deranged

I just never thought of him to act like that. I never liked to think of like that was like think of him like he was normal guy till his wife died then he became the deranged

wicked heath
#

The man was fully aware theres murderous cult trying to kill him since he moved in Raven Brooks

#

I’d be on the edge too if I were him

#

But i get what you mean

#

Between his book depiction and the way he was portrayed in Hide&Seek, its pretty different

late jackal
wicked heath
#

And in both of them, theres a cult on his back

late jackal
#

Hold up the books and show is cannon like to the game

#

?

wicked heath
#

And we have Hello Neighbor2

wicked heath
#

We were told that « everything » was canon to the games

#

They just didn’t tell us how that makes any sense

#

And they said to just wait a bit

#

For Hello Neighbor 3 and season 3

late jackal
#

Ohhh ok

#

Thanks for the information

wicked heath
#

Yes, I too am not a fan of this kind of cliffhanger they left us on

wicked heath
vagrant igloo
stark spade
#

its sad when you realise why mr peterson locked his son in the basement

#

he lost almost everything he loved to where he became mentally unstable and overprotective of his son, to the point where he locked his son in the basement to shield him from the real world

#

and nicky (us) was locked in the basement with aaron since the neighbour was so paranoid of anybody finding out about his family tragedy

#

he's not a villain

#

he's just broken

wicked heath
wicked heath
stark spade
amber sonnet
unkempt sleet
#

Buried Secrets

#

Book 3

shell gull
#

HOW have I missed this, if everything is supposed to be revolved around perspectives, we see in AS S1 Ep 6 when Nicky says “I’ll be your friend, your best friend” after being trapped and traumatized in the basement, I am pretty sure he’s referring to Aaron as he’s the only other person who was down there with him, which would explain why from Nicky’s perspective which is twisted in times he believed Aaron was his best friend while in Raven Brooks.

wanton roost
shell gull
wanton roost
wanton roost
#

Thought ths devs said they'll be fine just like nicky

#

Not devs

#

Or idk mb

#

It's probably either a joke or real

shell gull
# vagrant igloo stupid AS ruining the lore

I mean it’s very obvious to be the case but AS is still its own set of perspectives, we see Nicky’s and Trinitys and others so we still don’t have a valid turf of perspective with it.

vagrant igloo
#

you forgot tho
that act 1 is NOT a memory and is happening in the moment
and act 1 lines up with the books
implying Nicky WAS actually Aaron's friend

eager ivy
#

Also in season 1 the writing is normal because nicky wasn't traumatized and in season 2 it starts to get more and more misspelled and distorted

silver vine
#

What the hell is going on

wanton roost
#

lore

ripe berry
#

Hello Neighbor Diaries

#

there is an unhandwavable photograph of Aaron and Nicky together in HND

sick bone
ripe berry
#

this can only exist if Aaron and Nicky ACTUALLY knew each other at some point
and there's literally 0 points in the timeline where this photo can work outside of before AS Episode 1

#

During AS Season 1: Aaron's in the basement, photo appears to be outside
Between AS Season 1 and 2: Aaron wouldn't still be missing if that was the placement
after AS Season 2: Nicky's no longer in RB

#

(however I'd say Nicky having brown eyes instead of blue here is due to lack of communication between the teams, as it's using his HN1 Model as a basis, besides it's something minor enough that it can reasonably be ignored)

stiff spire
#

Yeah

ripe berry
ripe berry
# shell gull HOW have I missed this, if everything is supposed to be revolved around perspect...

What if Trinity's perspective doesn't involve Aaron because she wants to forget about the GAAP incident, and that's why the events of Aaron's Trilogy are somewhat being fused into the Waking Nightmare-HN2 Time Period in AS, she instead imagines herself as moving in after Aaron's already missing (so that way she doesn't have to acknowledge Aaron), Lucy Yi is simply missing instead of dead, and Aaron only has cameos.

shell gull
shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
#

It doesn’t make sense as to why they would just forget them.

ripe berry
#

yeah...

ripe berry
#

Act 1 is split across two days and happens during a storm in the books

#

perspectives seems to both be the correct answer while at the same time having the most weirdness to it

#

like- the Guest

#

the Guest is clearly already existing in HNVR

#

but won't exist in his current state until AS Season 3

#

or what source is more reliable

stiff spire
#

didnt act 1 in the books happen at night rather than in the day

ripe berry
stiff spire
#

Ah right

#

have we gotten one where the books took place in act 3 I dont think we did

#

would've been cool if there was i would've liked to see how the books would've handled it

ripe berry
#

closest we got is Reset Day, which the math indicates occurs in 2021

stiff spire
#

Yup

#

there has been talks in the works after the movie comes out we'd be getting more books

#

it would be cool to have another gn and another novel would be nice

ripe berry
stiff spire
#

true

#

I'm glad that Nikita came and told us everything is still canon but everything is very confusing to understand since we don't have any explanation as to how everything's canon

ripe berry
#

like- above I had to pull out a photo from HND to prove Nicky even knew Aaron and wasn't just misremembering things

#

(assuming the perspectives thing is correct)

stiff spire
#

yeah

#

I find it sad at first that Nicky wasn't the main premise of the AS, but rather Trinity but I would like to believe the perspective theory makes sense a lot

#

I mean the AS is still enjoyable in its way

ripe berry
stiff spire
#

True

#

hn has always been interesting lore wise you would think that its about "oh break into your neighbors house and find out what hes hiding" but goes more than that in depth

ripe berry
#

and RD + HN3 probably I guess because nothing else even reaches those time periods

#

perspectives makes the most sense but is also the most annoying to even try to make theories using

stiff spire
#

Yeah for sure, I wonder how and if HN3 will tie into GN2 since GN2 takes place in 2021 and HN3 is confirmed to take place in (correct me if I'm wrong) 2028

#

right?

ripe berry
stiff spire
#

so theres like a gap

ripe berry
#

it can be any time between 1996 and 2021

stiff spire
#

interesting

#

never took the time to go deeper more into the hn lore but I have dug deep a bit like Nicky was always a lonesome kid until he moved to raven brooks, made friends, and lost them basically Raven Brooks has been a wild game changer for him ever since he moved in

wanton roost
#

theres 1 thing I'm looking forward to

#

Will there be new books

#

Or novels

stiff spire
#

Yup

#

#hello-neighbor message

ripe berry
#

I personally believe it comes right after Hello Engineer's main campaign but before HN2 Patch 9 or HE's Sandbox Mode.

stiff spire
#

Mr. Murtaugh

#

there has to be something idk

ripe berry
#

the kids start the club

#

but the teacher made it an official school club

stiff spire
#

Yeah makes sense in that way

#

would be sick if we got a murtaugh mention in a hn book or a game

ripe berry
#

or no wait

#

actually

#

Murtaugh dies in AS Season 2 and the club is shut down

#

but the kids remake the club

#

(because gotta account for the club existing in ~1953)

#

(the club existed when Theodore was a kid)

stiff spire
ripe berry
#

plus it gives Murtaugh an actual legacy of sorts.

stiff spire
#

Agreed

#

I still find the scene sad in the AS, Ivan really looked up to Murtaugh as a role model wish we could've gotten more bonding with them both

versed yacht
ripe berry
wanton roost
stiff spire
#

Oh yeah that one lol

#

bro needed to study more

ripe berry
#

my current timeline under the idea of perspectives:
1984: Bosco Bay
1991-1992: Aaron Trilogy
1995: [-Missing Pieces, -HND, the HNHS Launch Trailer, -HN1 Nightmare Sequences, and HNHS], -Waking Nightmare
1996: [-Buried Secrets, -AS Eps. 1-4, and HN1 Act 1], -AS Ep. 5, SN Launch Trailer, [HNVR, -HN1 Act 2, -AS Ep. 6], HN2 DLCs, -AS Season 2, -AS Season 3, HN2, Layout V2 Vid, Hello Engineer, Raven Brooks Disaster, HN2 Patch 9, Hello Engineer Sandbox, -+Secret Neighbor (mix of memories, latest memories in SN are from the storm period of the timeline so it comes after, but I don't know how to even list this game)
circa 2008: +AS
2017: +HN1's Nightmare Sequences, +HN1 Act 2, HN1 Act 3 and Finale, [HND, +Missing Pieces, +Waking Nightmare, +Buried Secrets, +HN Movie (possibly)]
2021: Reset Day
2028: HN3
(Minuses are for what I think are distorted memories, and pluses when in the timeline those memories were actually recalled, brackets are to group things happening at the same time)

eternal chasm
#

do you guys think my pet bird plays a part in the lore

brisk hearth
#

Don't mean to spoil your dreams but...

wanton roost
amber sonnet
wanton roost
amber sonnet
#

oh

#

like thats ever going to happen

wanton roost
#

unless if someone here is an actual actor which I highly doubt and his some Age like 12 or 13 then maybe

#

But nnnoo

#

Who would suit acting as nicky though

amber sonnet
#

imagine chris pratt as nicky

#

specifically the one from act 1

#

because that would look really funny

wanton roost
#

that'd be crazy

vagrant igloo
wanton roost
dreamy sluice
#

jack black plays nicky roth, obviously

wanton roost
#

That could work

stiff spire
#

I could see the kid from the minecraft movie play a young Nicky Roth

wanton roost
#

Nope

inland folio
#

jamie foxx obiously

ripe berry
stiff spire
#

oh these dudes they're the neighbors they love

#

idk

vale topaz
stiff spire
#

Yeah

ripe berry
wanton roost
#

Keys and locks!

#

The mayak...

#

Coming in basement

#

Please pick jack

stiff spire
#

first we hello then we neighbor

eager ivy
#

đŸ—ŁđŸ”„đŸ”„Keycard and crowbar THE BASEMENT

wintry hill
#

nonono

wicked heath
#

This is the house of a very special neighbo-or

wanton roost
#

big ol crow ones

potent harness
stiff spire
#

I was stuck like a kid down in the basement til you came along

#

I don’t wanna be running from neighbors for the rest of our lives

onyx ivy
#

is wtrb canon?
You may think this is a stupid question but its because, if hello neighbor takes place before phones were made and allat, then why does maritza have a phone in wtrb. Also what does the ceo of hn percieve wtrb to be like it. Is it not canon but has similarities?

vale topaz
ripe star
#

you could just say certain events from the show happened similarly in the games

vagrant igloo
marsh idol
#

while HN isnt sci-fi, i forgot whats the explanation for the bad luck coins?

jaunty onyx
#

So I was rewatching WTRB and I was thinking:
Why is Aaron happy about GAAP? In the books he was worried about it n stuff

onyx ivy
gusty flint
#

We should get a large (very large) GAAP

#

like, its own map,

glacial whale
left fern
#

THEORY THE NEIGHBOR IS THE GUEST

inland folio
#

you failed the test

left fern
inland folio
#

thats the old hn2 story line i think

#

the new hn2 storyline

#

the neighbor is not the guest

#

the guest is its own entity

left fern
#

well hn2 never released so it couldnt have changed

inland folio
#

its on steam

left fern
#

what

#

i thought it didnt realse

inland folio
#

its been out

#

for 2 years dude

#

actually 3 years ago

#

we are already on hn3

left fern
#

this is just an alpha

inland folio
#

search hn2 right now.

#

its there you can buy it

left fern
#

what is this

#

they butchered the game so hard

inland folio
#

listen hn2 is not bad

#

its actually very decent

#

even more then decent its alright

left fern
#

ok youknow what im gunna buy it and tell you what i think gng gng

inland folio
#

i also dont like the artstyle but thats not gonna do anything

inland folio
#

it takes a long time since theres a bunch of stuff

left fern
#

ok

inland folio
left fern
#

I know

left fern
inland folio
#

hes weird

left fern
#

since when was the neighbor apolice man

#

@inland folio

inland folio
#

thats not the neighbor

#

this game has a bunch of neighbors

#

mayor police man

#

baker

#

then after that you get to the neighbor scenes

#

there are 2 of them

#

i think

#

then theres the guest scene

left fern
#

why so many locks

inland folio
left fern
#

the house looks diff

#

ima watch a tut

#

why is there a t posing neighbor

#

@inland folio whats the code

inland folio
#

you ahve to find the code

#

in the map

#

also thats a doll

left fern
#

oh ok

inland folio
#

its for a puzzle

#

better get that doll

left fern
#

is the code 1984

inland folio
#

i think the codes random

left fern
#

what happend to that big basement

inland folio
left fern
#

why is the neighbour under my bed

inland folio
#

because hes the neighbor

#

hes crazy

left fern
#

who is that and is that the cat from hn2 alpha 1

inland folio
#

another neighbor you have to get past

left fern
#

ooh

#

i threw paint at her and she mad

inland folio
left fern
#

wheres her basement

inland folio
#

you need to get into a safe i think

#

for the key

left fern
#

is this floating key supposed to be here

inland folio
#

probably a bug

left fern
#

who is this

inland folio
#

its the neighbor

#

actually

#

why does that screenshot look so cool

left fern
#

ima troll him with the fire thing i found by flying around i recognize it from hello guest

#

hey theo im flying over you wit ts fire thingy

#

uhhhhh @inland folio i was flying in his house with this and went through the roof and im here what do i do

inland folio
#

thats the place where the final boss triggers

left fern
#

oh so do i restart'

inland folio
#

find a way back

left fern
#

i restarted and it tok me to this cutscene

inland folio
#

so i dont know much

left fern
#

ok wait im looking at the cameras and does this man have a gun

inland folio
#

hes more annoying then the others

#

he will try to shoot you to slow you down

left fern
#

HE SHOT ME

inland folio
#

told you

left fern
#

whos this guy

#

@inland folio

inland folio
#

thats the mayor

#

warning his dog is cute

left fern
#

cool

#

brufghrughrughru

#

it took some time but i made it here again @inland folio

inland folio
#

congrats

left fern
#

nnow what

inland folio
#

i don know

#

find the key i guess

left fern
#

hes not catching m

#

e

#

@inland folio lol

inland folio
#

hn2 ai is really goofy

#

which is why i like hn2

left fern
#

hes so damn fast

#

i forgot to send these but is this aron

#

@inland folio

inland folio
#

yes

left fern
#

he looks different

#

oh hell naw

#

@inland folio

inland folio
#

congrats you just beat hn2

#

now go do the guest part

left fern
inland folio
left fern
#

which one

inland folio
#

first one is the one from the first game

#

where the neighbor is stuck behind a door with the thing next to him

#

i felt bad for him

#

oh yeah i just realised this

#

actually no it was stupid what i was about to say

ripe star
# left fern

every family photo in my grandparent's house looks like this

fickle garden
#

Does Mr. Peterson have hammerspace? Because he kinda has infinite tomatoes and glue.

ruby patio
ruby patio
inland folio
#

im jealous of him

#

man has infinite milk

amber sonnet
inland folio
#

one is the end of hn2 where the crow thing fals over the neighbor

#

the second one is when he was trapped with the thing next to him in hn1

marsh idol
inland folio
#

havent played it so no

#

i dont feel bad for him in hide and seek(i dont know whats about i only know theres a cops and robbers level)

#

and a graveyard i think

marsh idol
#

i guarantee you hide and seek has the more emotional scenes then any of the ones you listed.

#

actually

#

watch the hide and seek trailer

inland folio
#

ok

dreamy sluice
#

(pretend that didn't @ you, i didn't see the time)

wicked heath
ripe berry
#

question: do we label the HN Showcase Pre-Stream as one of the "canon until something replaces it in the timeline" things like with Layout V2?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8iml-S-DsA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3UfsSin0TI

Wishlist Hello Neighbor 2 on Steam now: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1321680/Hello_Neighbor_2/

Join us for the Hello Neighbor Showcase

#HelloNeighbor #SecretNeighbor #HelloEngineer

▶ Play video
ripe berry
frigid pumice
#

has anyone written full lore until now of hn?

unkempt sleet
#

That happens regardless of the showcase

#

unless i forgot something else that happens in it

ripe berry
#

which he's known to do due to SN

vagrant igloo
compact crag
vagrant igloo
#

and you actually aren't telling me you think the SN events are things actually physically happening 💔

compact crag
#

I mean they have to want to do something with him if he is in all the alphas for hn2 and hello guest

#

And they put him in sn

vagrant igloo
#

Easter egg

#

very obviously

compact crag
#

In hello guest he is a big part at the end cutsceen

#

Ik that's not cannon

#

But why even bother with him if he's not

vagrant igloo
#

things changed

shell gull
tiny verge
#

how

#

is this some kind of random detail..?

tiny verge
vagrant igloo
#

hello guest was always hello neighbor

tiny verge
#

I don't think it originally was meant to be

#

pretty sure Alpha 1 of Hello Guest does have the cut Peterson model where he's apparently the Guest but

#

that was a retcon I believe of an older idea which I feel HN2 kinda brought back, just expanded

#

and it also was retconned too

vagrant igloo
#

not to mention hg has the mayak

tiny verge
#

their concepts were fundamentally different

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

I'm not sure what the mayak is

vagrant igloo
#

...

#

like the entire story
kinda revolves around it

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

the prototype, where everything was alot more unfinished

vagrant igloo
#

hg literally happens in the gaap

tiny verge
#

but I'm talking about the development history mostly

amber sonnet
#

but the prototype had the mayak

vagrant igloo
amber sonnet
#

and mayak is like the hn lore buildng

amber sonnet
vagrant igloo
#

hg was always the hn sequel

tiny verge
#

I don't think that'd make it fully count tbh

#

would it be canon..? sure yeah

#

but still as a game itself the concept is different

amber sonnet
tiny verge
vagrant igloo
#

...
are you telling me that
even though hg revolves around the mayak
the center point of the lore
it isn't hn

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

yes

#

that

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

obviously it was always apart of the franchise but

#

it was still it's own game too though

amber sonnet
tiny verge
vagrant igloo
tiny verge
# tiny verge I doubt it

you can't call it a Hello Neighbor game if it's not really in any way involved with that home invasion aspect

#

when they actually started calling it Hello Neighbor 2, I feel that they realized they actually do need to bring that back

#

and yeah I don't consider Hide and Seek to be like HN1 or HN2

amber sonnet
tiny verge
tiny verge
amber sonnet
tiny verge
amber sonnet
#

like just because a mainline hn game doesnt have you breaking into a house

#

doesnt mean its too far away from a hn game

tiny verge
#

we're not considering Hello Engineer a mainline game

#

you can't make me

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

I don't consider it mainline either

amber sonnet
#

before it became hn2

#

if it had been expanded into a full sequl

tiny verge
#

again, that Captain Toad comparison
but here's another one, the Mario Kart games and the Sonic Racing games

amber sonnet
#

no but like

#

maybe the developers didnt want a sequl game with you breaking into neighbors house again

tiny verge
#

so HG probably was gonna be a spinoff

#

still it's own game

#

with a good budget too

amber sonnet
tiny verge
amber sonnet
#

its called hn2 pre alpha now for a reason too

tiny verge
#

yeah because it's DEVELOPMENT changed

amber sonnet
#

because it was meant to be the big sequl

tiny verge
vagrant igloo
#

since it is the HN2 pre alpha

amber sonnet
#

they had to scale it down

tiny verge
amber sonnet
vagrant igloo
#

it was called hello guest because

#

the roles are swapped from hn

#

you are the "neighbor"
guest is a "visitor" aka the intruder

tiny verge
vagrant igloo
amber sonnet
#

instead calling it hello guest

#

because youre saying hello to the guest in the sequl of hello neighbor

#

and since at that time the guest was the neighbor

vagrant igloo
#

yeah

amber sonnet
#

it’d be like a progression of hn

#

instead of saying hello to the neighbor you say hello to the guest whos the neighbor

#

which wouldnt make sense if the game was a spinoff

tiny verge
#

which basically means Peterguest is very short lived

vagrant igloo
amber sonnet
#

how do you think the guest isnt peterson in the prototype

tiny verge
#

the Guest was designed to be like those myth creatures

amber sonnet
#

considering in the prototype he had ties with the mayak

#

which peterson also does

vagrant igloo
amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

sure there's the Mayak

#

but that doesn't mean there was lore in the prototype

#

or atleast very developed lore

vagrant igloo
#

oh yeah
schnabelperchten

tiny verge
#

and then it all got scrapped once the project became Hello Neighbor 2

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

some

#

keyword, some

amber sonnet
tiny verge
vagrant igloo
#

hg alpha 1 had some
keyword, some
aswell

amber sonnet
#

with the theme of 3 kids going into a forest iirc

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

actually no

#

I take back Pre-Alpha

#

but that's kinda how I see the Hello Guest prototype lore

#

not really developed, the next version is obviously more developed as the game was developed more entirely

vagrant igloo
#

same lore between hgp and hg somewhat right?

#

or are they different

tiny verge
#

most of the Hello Guest lore wouldn't come from the prototype

#

that doesn't mean they're different

#

but that also doesn't mean that you can really say that Hello Guest always had the lore in the prototype

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

and that Peterguest

#

probably was an Alpha 1 idea

tiny verge
#

at the time

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

I can't really see that being the case

#

if you want my honest opinion about it

#

game development reasons

amber sonnet
#

like what if it just wasnt displayed well in hgp yk

#

but when the game progressed in devlopement so did the story

tiny verge
#

that'd be like saying the old HN1 lore was developed in the prototype, but didn't get displayed

#

prototypes are prototypes for a reason

amber sonnet
tiny verge
#

yeah

vagrant igloo
#

yea

tiny verge
#

literally what I just said

amber sonnet
#

you could say something similar to what i said regarding pre alpha though

#

because it had a bit of the devil story sprinkled in there

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

the idea of this weird myth creature

#

it obviously was expanded in Alpha 1, but not in that way you'd expect

#

even though it was cut, that cutscene was basically trying to expand on that idea
but it instead made it to where the myth creature really is just a myth

#

does that mean the prototype actually planned that..?

#

because if so, then I could actually see why HN2 ended up so badly

#

you can't just develop lore for a gameplay prototype, focus your resources on that first

#

alphas are one thing since they're more developed

#

but an early prototype is an entirely other thing

#

so no I don't consider Hello Guest a mainline game
never said I considered it uncanon, but I consider it the same way I do with a Sonic Racing game (mostly the Triple AAA one that's come out)

#

especially since I don't like the idea that spinoffs can't be as high quality, or high budget, or even as big as a mainline game

#

they're simply just expanding the franchise's world in different ways

tiny verge
#

cause that's what I've been arguing the entire time

#

well not entire time, but once we got to the prototype discussion yeah

vagrant igloo
#

I missed that then
this whole time I just thought your argument was just that hg wasn't originally hello neighbor

tiny verge
#

like mainline

vagrant igloo
#

even tho it totally was

#

!!!

tiny verge
#

your whole reasoning is that "it's a sequel" or that "it's canon"
but that just discredits spinoffs

vagrant igloo
#

being a sequel would make it a mainline game

#

cuz it's not a spinoff

tiny verge
tiny verge
#

which we can not really argue about

#

I don't consider sequel or prequel games to immediately be mainline if the gameplay is different enough
and yes, reversing the roles infact is different enough

#

but if you consider them to be mainline games, we cannot argue

#

it'd just be pointless

#

so I think we should just agree to disagree

#

especially since the main thing that really started this is Hello Guest isn't even canon anymore, we already agreed on that
also quick edit, if someone involved in Hello Guest's development comes out to say that I'm wrong then I'll eat my own words, I'll literally print out screenshots and eat the paper

tiny verge
vagrant igloo
#

oh nvm

#

you said how

#

mb

tiny verge
#

no no I meant like

#

how the game revealed it

#

I didn't clarify but

#

yeah that answers my question

vagrant igloo
#

yeah

tiny verge
#

that's something I do need to work on, I word things pretty badly

vagrant igloo
#

when patch 9 first released the grave wasn't closed
which meant it wasn't an out of bounds Easter egg

tiny verge
#

man that sucks though, they could have atleast just repurposed him to fit a new role

vagrant igloo
#

yeah

tiny verge
#

I mean I guess they did do that

#

but just not in a way that feels as cool as making him a new HN2 character

#

or even just apart of the cartoon

#

whatever I guess

vagrant igloo
tiny verge
#

well I mean with a role

#

that's cool though

#

I like how the cartoon also references some of Tiny Build's other stuff too

#

even though I hadn't really grown up with their other stuff I still always respect when a company respects other things they own, especially when it's a reference in their bigger franchises or even a first party collab

ripe berry
#

and then HN2A1.5 is the next one we know anything about the storyline for

#

(we know bits and pieces of HN2A1's plotline but not much)

stiff spire
#

Prototype of HG was interesting like the ending i liked the way we had to get to the ending to ride the coaster, smash the Mayak open with a ride

#

that was fun

chrome maple
#

I loved (and still do) the hgp music

stiff spire
#

I love the good ending music

#

especially the echoing chorus

#

How it starts like nice and calm and then later like all dramatic and creepy

ripe berry
#

I don't think he ever died

#

when do you think he dies timeline-wise

compact crag
#

Yeah I'm pretty sure he is not dead just removed from the game ngl

vagrant igloo
#

not just Easter egg

#

upon patch 9 release the grave was open

#

and not just an out of bounds Easter egg

stiff spire
#

Would've been cool to know what he would've done if they had completed hn2 hes gone through so many alterations

in HG he was some boss man who bought the park who recruited Beatrix and Quentin to find the Mayak to (probably gain profit out of it)

HN2 we dont know much of what he would have done maybe he would've been some reporter

#

But i suppose it is what it is but I think they made him into some reporter

#

we do see him in the AS though so they hadn't forgotten about him

ripe berry
#

because

#

the White Tape pushes his death to AS Season 3

#

which MIGHT be occurring at the same time as HN2

ripe berry
#

COULD it have lore significance? maybe
but I'm not sure

ripe berry
#

Green Tape confirms the Guest existed before MitH died

#

Guest, in it's current form, will only begin to exist in AS Season 3

#

same with Blue Tape

#

(Although the Church mixed with Blue Tape does still imply MitH's death...)

#

because even now
you can't tell me the Purple Tape seemingly taking place in a segment of the Catacombs, Blue Tape having MitH/MJ taking pictures of the Guest from a higher place, and then at a higher place in the Church from the floor where the Catacombs are you can find a random hat that has no reason being there isn't trying to tell us something

#

said hat being the exact one MitH wears

ripe berry
ripe berry
silver vine
#

We literally do not have anything new. Y'all just keep talking about the same stuff over and over again

ripe berry
silver vine
#

Btw hi

#

Long time no see

ripe berry
#

'ello

ripe berry
silver vine
#

I literally still can't understand how this chat is not dead

silver vine
#

I feel like we've already found all that has to be found

fickle garden
#

What about the secret fifth act in HN1?

#

Where you have an epic anime battle after the Neighbor goes super saiyan.

ripe berry
#

we may have FOUND everything but we don't know what it MEANS

vagrant igloo
shell gull
ripe berry
#

Quentin's already in RB in S2 Ep. 3

#

MitH's still alive in S2 Ep. 4

night sky
#

Does anyone know what that music is in season 2 episode 4 when Trinity calls and Crowface is there? I need it

wanton roost
#

we really need some thoguh

ripe berry
vagrant igloo
#

duh

sick bone
vagrant igloo
#

...

vale topaz
sick bone
#

Stop ragebait

vale topaz
#

You just have to stack every box of all levels in a tower on top of the grave

vagrant igloo
#

that's an important step

sick bone
#

You ragebait

brisk hearth
#

They're just joking

chrome maple
vagrant igloo
inland folio
#

your the only one he hates

#

out of every other person that was in this "argument"

vagrant igloo
#

peak

#

I feel so honored

wanton roost
sick bone
#

İt Donkey joke

#

İt no funny

wanton roost
#

?

#

it doesnt need to be funny

sick bone
#

İt ragebait

wanton roost
#

how is it ragebait bruh

#

your the only guy thats mad

sick bone
#

İt ragebait me bro so if it ragebait me if it rage bait one person just one person it mean it ragebait jonah just ragebait every time every day i gues

wanton roost
#

its a j o k e

#

if uhateit

#

ignore it

sick bone
#

İt can joke and ragebait same

fickle garden
#

The truth is Karvilax is ragebaiting you.

wanton roost
#

that doesnt changethe fact about ignoring

wanton roost
#

its not considered ragebaiting anymore

fickle garden
#

Karvilax is just cool and epic like that.

sick bone
#

Lore

#

Not jonah stupid ragebaits

sick bone
#

Yes i am Cool and Epic i gues

wanton roost
# sick bone Lore

there is no new lore ig we just talking about oldlore that hasntbeen explained

fickle garden
#

Have we ever figured out who the guest is yet?

sick bone
#

İt 2 soul in one body

fickle garden
sick bone
#

Bro but it no like this

#

İt mix

#

Like how mans put few fruits to juice (apple watermelon btw) and then say it mix juice not just one like apple juice just it like literal mix

versed yacht
#

Karvilax secret fruit juice recipe

vagrant igloo
sick bone
#

İ not see

#

Man

vagrant igloo
#

they replied to the same message

sick bone
#

OKAY

warm hollow
#

istg if i could tell the hello neighbor story and cast actors in the game gng the game would change forever bro

#

i would remake all the game

#

and make it so that all are connected

warm hollow
#

BRO ID KILL FOR A REMAKE OF ALL THE GAMES WITH VOICE LINES AND CONNECTED

warm hollow
clear lynx
silver vine
silver vine
#

honestly Ive never rewatched the AS after its initial run at all, not even once

#

which is crazy since I used to constantly rewatch S1 a lot before S2 came out

vagrant igloo
silver vine
#

show

silver vine
vagrant igloo
#

gotta find it rq

warm hollow
warm hollow
#

i said i would tell the dev

#

welp ik for a fact your to dumb to understand stuff

inland folio
#

if there is voice acting

#

then the game is just spoon feeding you the lore

vagrant igloo
#

i can't find it

vagrant igloo
warm hollow
inland folio
#

no

warm hollow
#

instead of needing A game therost to get u lore

#

im nott saying to give the full lore

#

im js saying for cutscene

inland folio
warm hollow
#

ik

inland folio
#

2 of them were outdated

warm hollow
#

this is how we dont even know the story

inland folio
#

in this channel

warm hollow
#

no what i mean

vagrant igloo
warm hollow
#

ik

#

im saying that this is why the story is kinda confusing

vagrant igloo
#

but it isn't

#

it's like really laid out

warm hollow
#

ok so ur telling in hn 1 the last time we saw the neighbors house it was big nott act 3 big act 2 and then in hn 2 the house is the same as hn 1 act 1

#

and also we saw the neighbors house burn

#

in hn 1

#

its back in hn 2

vagrant igloo
#

act 3 is a dream

#

well the house part

warm hollow
#

so him moving in is a dream

vagrant igloo
#

hn2 is directly after act 2

vagrant igloo
warm hollow
#

ik

vagrant igloo
#

hn2 happens before his house burns down

warm hollow
#

so act 3 is not cannon

vagrant igloo
#

it is

inland folio
warm hollow
#

it takes place after act 2

inland folio
#

no

#

act 3 doesnt take place after act 2

#

act 3 takes palce in 2017 i think

vagrant igloo
#

...

warm hollow
#

this is why the lore is confusing

inland folio
#

and act 2 in like 1996

vagrant igloo
#

ok ok

#

so

#

basically

inland folio
#

when were talking about hn lore

warm hollow
#

the game doesnt tell us the lore

#

lets be fr

#

it doesnt

inland folio
#

ok you

#

are something special

warm hollow
#

wym bro

#

the game doesnt tell is the storyy

#

except from

#

hide and seek

#

bfr bro

inland folio
#

the story

#

is in front of your eyes

#

is it that hard

#

to just look

vagrant igloo
#

ACT 1 - 1996
not a dream
not a memory
everything is actually happening

ACT 2 - 1996
nicky's memory
a bit distorted

ACT 3 - 2017
nicky moves back home
goes to sleep
dream stuff
wakes back up

HN2 - 1996
same day of act 2, beginning directly after nicky escapes

HND - sometime after act 3
nicky looking back

AS - sometime in early 2000s
basically a retelling of the act 1 and 2 events through different perspectives

HIDE AND SEEK - date unknown (i think)
the neighbor's lore

HE - no idea personally
no idea personally

RESET DAY - 2021
neighbor house been rebuilt
nothing to do with hn1 and hn2 lore

HN3 - 2028
separate storyline from hn1 and hn2

SN - sometime during act 2
happens in the rescue squad's heads

HNVR - during act 2
retelling of act 2 from different perspectives basically

inland folio
#

at what nicky is doing

warm hollow
#

give me one part in the hn 1-2 the game is a story

inland folio
#

is it that hard

warm hollow
#

bro im talking abt the neighbor story

#

the back storys

warm hollow
#

so thats why

#

hm come to think abt it tiny build is smart for doing this