#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 50 of 1

safe charm
#

Nah i think it was either a Nightmare or a flash

#

Forward tbh

snow mauve
#

Bro is too lazy to listen reading it

safe charm
silver vine
#

anyway

#

thats not the point

#

the point is

snow mauve
safe charm
snow mauve
#

Which is too much effort

silver vine
snow mauve
#

Neither am I

#

The kid gotta go listen to it

silver vine
#

yes

snow mauve
#

In order to learn

safe charm
#

I already have though lmao

#

But i fell

#

Asleep

silver vine
#

fell asleep = did not listen

snow mauve
#

That's not an excuse to not understand properly

safe charm
#

The nights

snow mauve
#

Man quit lying

silver vine
safe charm
#

Maybe not that smart

snow mauve
#

You learned nothing

#

While not paying attention

safe charm
#

Fine

snow mauve
#

Finally you admit it

silver vine
#

this is why I prefer real books made out of paper

#

not pixels on a screen nor audio from a device

safe charm
#

I like audio books

silver vine
#

I dont

#

you like audio books cuz you're too lazy to read an actual one

safe charm
#

What ik about the time loops is

#

The whole town is going back to september

silver vine
#

...

safe charm
#

Or fall

snow mauve
silver vine
#

the whole town keeps going back to NOVEMBER 2ND randomly

safe charm
#

Oh right

silver vine
#

dont talk in lore chat unless you actually KNOW the lore

#

anyway

#

the point is

#

many of the ppl think that the beta barn sequence was supposed to be the fate of MJ

#

cuz thats what was recorded in the tape

snow mauve
safe charm
teal imp
#

I havent got around to book 7 yet how does it work?

silver vine
#

too complicated to explain here

#

ya need to read the book to actually understand it

teal imp
silver vine
#

maybe in DM

safe charm
#

Isnt just if you know the lore its about

#

Discusing it as well

#

Smh

snow mauve
safe charm
#

Alright gotta go

tribal talon
#

Howdy.

#

Anyway, this invention has a high chance of not being limited to November 2nd.

#

It would be rather queer for it to only be this specified date. There is no evidence it can't reach beyond November 2nd, just that it recently has been resetting to November 2nd.

#

This theory definitely does have ground.

#

And until book 8 or later, we won't know if it can or cannot go past November 2nd.

shell gull
safe charm
#

Except book 5 and 6

shell gull
safe charm
#

Becouse book 5 doesnt exist

#

On

shell gull
safe charm
#

The website

#

I listen too

shell gull
shell gull
#

Anyways

safe charm
#

Sadly

shell gull
#

I highly doubt the Beta Barn segment to be a Time Loop scenario

safe charm
#

Like theres a chance yes

#

But sadly i doubt it

safe charm
#

You gonna type?

shell gull
#

First off, in a Nightmare when your in a near death experience or scary sequence in that nightmare it’s common to wake up, in the Beta after The Guest Jumpscare it cuts to Quentin waking up, there’s also the factor after his next near death experience with Teds car he starts drinking coffee, and we get a shot of the back of his car overflowed with Coffee cups, symbolising he’s been dozing off, and is trying to stay awake till he gets to RB.

#

To me it’s a Nightmare

safe charm
#

Yes what would the guest Role be after

#

The trap

#

You think

shell gull
safe charm
#

The beta trap

#

With fake aaron

shell gull
# safe charm The beta trap

That wasn’t a trap, just a cover up, that Quentin ended up getting himself into, leading to his high chance demise.

safe charm
#

So no more story

#

After

shell gull
safe charm
#

Do then

#

They cant just have the same story

#

For the full game there has to have been more

safe charm
#

A time skip

shell gull
#

That was all we have of Old HN2

safe charm
#

So no

#

Theres more

shell gull
safe charm
#

They even said

shell gull
#

Of Current HN2

safe charm
#

To be continued

shell gull
#

They called it spoiler free

safe charm
#

So no

shell gull
#

Because they switched the lores

#

FG is AS

#

Beta was Old HN2

safe charm
#

Nah they wouldnt

shell gull
safe charm
#

They likely changed it after

shell gull
tribal talon
shell gull
#

It was as they were making the beta

tribal talon
#

Why'd they stop?

shell gull
safe charm
#

Did say

shell gull
safe charm
#

A lot of hn 2 would take place

tribal talon
#

Stupid.

safe charm
#

Before act 3

#

Keyword a lot

shell gull
safe charm
#

Not the whole game

shell gull
safe charm
#

More then the beta

shell gull
#

Carly left because of it

shell gull
#

Like I said

safe charm
shell gull
#

They called it spoiler free

safe charm
#

Same as me

shell gull
#

Beta was Old HN2

safe charm
shell gull
#

That’s why they called it spoiler free

shell gull
safe charm
#

Mouserflash thinks theres more

#

For example

shell gull
safe charm
#

Same do i

tribal talon
#

So, will the graphic novels continue?

shell gull
#

Since that contradicts to books

safe charm
#

Becouse why would they use old lore for a beta if they already changed it

#

Like no

shell gull
#

Even though AS isn’t Canon

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
#

Okay

eternal mica
#

How is Peterson in book 7 if he died in gn2

snow mauve
#

By the Guest

eternal mica
#

Ik

#

I know that but how is he in book 7

snow mauve
eternal mica
#

O

whole tapir
#

My whole perspective on hello neighbor has entirely changed, things like the realtor’s death, that could’ve been the guest (since the guest can transform to a crow), and when trinity wakes up from her nightmare (in ep. 2) there was crow in her room and even gave trinity a look, like it knew something

whole tapir
eternal mica
#

Is the neigbor in Act 3 also possessed by guest?

teal imp
#

because the neighbor in act 3 isnt the real neighbor

#

act 3 is a nightmare

#

its bassically the manifestation of nicky`s trauma

cunning sand
whole tapir
cunning sand
#

no its just sus

cunning sand
#

are the comics canon

strange lance
#

yes

#

all the books are canon

cunning sand
#

cool

#

no spoiles for comics pls

strange lance
#

no problem

lilac oxide
shell gull
#

And it’s all Nicky’s imagination

#

Fuss his Trauma

lilac oxide
shell gull
#

Cuz it ain’t

lilac oxide
#

The Guest felt like a reboot of the Shadowman at one point tbh

wicked heath
#

That one universe where Nicky does not know what Fear is:

safe charm
#

@shell gull

#

I’m here

shell gull
#

?

#

Anyways

safe charm
#

What did he mean

#

There’s no scene

#

Of the mr Peterson house surrounded

#

In hn 2

shell gull
#

Simple.

#

Oh hey Micheal

safe charm
#

Is coming back

shell gull
#

💀

safe charm
#

I mean

ripe berry
# safe charm What did he mean

Unless he meant the Police Arrive Scene, which I don't like to think about because that means HN2 was always meant to be AS Lore after Alpha 1.5

safe charm
#

The animation

#

The police arrive

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Nog Simming Animation might never come back

safe charm
#

alpha 1.5 was made

#

After the final games content got locked in

shell gull
#

Like gameplay.

safe charm
shell gull
shell gull
safe charm
#

Locked in

shell gull
safe charm
#

He said content got locked in

#

And story is content so

cedar merlin
shell gull
safe charm
#

Lmao

shell gull
safe charm
#

I’m just going of what he said

ripe berry
#

So the current consensus is 3 Timelines: Main, HN2/Proto AS, and AS, and maybe a 4th timeline for HG if you're stretching it a bit, right?

shell gull
#

This really gives off

ripe berry
#

?

shell gull
#

Ahem

ripe berry
#

oh Wait HN1 Betas wouldn't fit with the others

shell gull
#

Books exclusive, Games Exclusive, AS exclusive, Canon, AU, HN1 Betas and HG.

safe charm
#

Lol I searched it up

shell gull
#

You can say the same with

#

The fact

#

That literally

#

Half of the content

#

Isn’t there

safe charm
#

Well I’m confused

#

Content lock means it’s near shipping quality

shell gull
safe charm
#

Just fixes

safe charm
shell gull
#

And then Last second…

safe charm
#

So I guess they didn’t fully lock the content then

#

If they made changes

ripe berry
#

And by last second you clearly mean (12-7=) 5 Months before the game came out because evidence suggests that there was content not in the Full Game existing as early as August

shell gull
#

When taking account of the beta

ripe berry
#

(As in a entire room cut from Back to School, and also September is when the Patches seem to have started development)

safe charm
#

What

#

September

#

But the game haven’t even released

ripe berry
#

Tape Recorder existed in the files of the Demo, which was made in September iirc

shell gull
#

There was more too

ripe berry
#

or... well... a very early version of the Tape Recorder

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
ripe berry
#

I know some things included the audio for every cutscene in the game

safe charm
#

By demo I think Alex just meant

#

The beta

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
#

When he talked about content

ripe berry
#

I referenced the entire Back to School DLC

#

and I'm talking about the Steam Demo here

#

There was also Aaron's Model

#

Parts of the Museum

#

All the CCTV Footage

#

and that's all I remember being leaked but I'm sure there was more

#

(Also all of Aaron's Audio Files)

#

in fact I think ~90% of the Audio was leaked

#

Even shit like Crowman Shelter was in the leak

#

and most of Gerda's Puzzles on the Switch Edition when it was in hell (Patch -1)

safe charm
#

Also what does crowman transformation

#

Mean

#

Like huh

ripe berry
#

No clue

#

Maybe a Storm of some kind

#

or smth

safe charm
#

Where do you think

#

The guest will be during the day

ripe berry
#

Shelter

#

Den

safe charm
#

Doubt he’s just gonna despawn

ripe berry
#

whatever it's called

ripe berry
safe charm
#

Imagine during free roam

#

If you are close to him

#

Will he just disapear if it becomes day

snow mauve
ripe berry
#

*Visitor Den

snow mauve
#

Guest world

safe charm
#

Where was it supposed to be

snow mauve
safe charm
#

In the open world

snow mauve
#

Nowhere

ripe berry
#

There was a house that played Crowman Shelter in the Switch version

ripe berry
#

I remember someone mentioning

#

it

snow mauve
#

Yeah that's probably some place holder

snow mauve
#

But got patched now

ripe berry
#

I assume the Portal to the Guest World was probably meant to be somewhere in that area

snow mauve
#

Why so surprised lmao

ripe berry
#

hence why the theme would play in that area

snow mauve
#

Crowman shelter :0

ripe berry
snow mauve
#

Some random portal would be weird tbh

safe charm
#

So is it that far fetched to assume the nest is the guest home world like he came from there instead of him being a manifestation

ripe berry
#

Thing seems to have it's own world, so Manifestations seem to have worlds created alongside them, which they can call home

safe charm
#

Is even a manifestation

snow mauve
#

Alright we solved the mystery now

safe charm
#

He could be some sort of demon that’s just like

#

To torment people

snow mauve
#

Well actually

#

Kinda

safe charm
#

With trauma and grief

ripe berry
ripe berry
safe charm
#

If you are

#

Refering to the statue

ripe berry
#

Ye... I was...

safe charm
#

Anything more

#

Then that because that’s not really proof

#

Tbh

shell gull
ripe berry
#

I mean I personally don't think it either but it doesn't cause too many issues if it ain't

ripe berry
safe charm
#

Like he could just be some sort of demon like thing that likes to torment people who suffer from grief

#

And or trauma

shell gull
ripe berry
ripe berry
#

Also you find it odd both seem to be tied to the Host of the Manifestation

safe charm
#

Like where do people get the manifestation theory from like I love the theory

#

Like where’s the big

#

Implication

ripe berry
shell gull
#

I remember how stupid I was

shell gull
ripe berry
safe charm
#

Also the guest becoming stronger in reset day

safe charm
#

Could just be because he’s possesing

#

He’s body

shell gull
#

No

ripe berry
safe charm
#

Doesn’t mean he’s a manifestation

#

Of he’s emotion

#

Tbh

shell gull
snow mauve
#

This dude..

shell gull
snow mauve
ripe berry
safe charm
#

I don’t believe the manifestation or the summoning theory longer

ripe berry
#

also both Act Finale and Guest World in HNVR have giant Mr. Petersons

snow mauve
safe charm
snow mauve
#

Congratulations

shell gull
snow mauve
#

You'll end up asking more questions for no reason

#

👏

safe charm
#

The guest origin might have nothing to do at all about our theories lmao

shell gull
#

DAMN I was so bad at connections

#

Micheal def thought I was dumb

snow mauve
#

The time I wasn't even active nor interacted much in the server

ripe berry
#

I think it could either way with Summoning or Manifestation, either way I'm gonna come up with a (probably shit) explanation to tie him to the cult

shell gull
#

So I mean better than nothing

#

Anyways Manifestation is the best explanation for the Guest and also solves plot holes in HN1 with Nicky’s “Imagination”

safe charm
#

Likely

#

Not confirmed

shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
#

Also

#

That explains Nikita’s big idea

#

We can take manifestation further

#

With things like

#

Sleep Paralysis

#

WW2

#

Veterans seeing things

#

From there P.T.S.D.

ripe berry
shell gull
shell gull
strange lance
ripe berry
shell gull
#

😭

strange lance
#

is that MAYAK in the background?!

snow mauve
snow mauve
shell gull
snow mauve
ripe berry
shell gull
#

Also I need to update the Manifestation Doc

#

Also can we come up with a short term for Manifestation

#

I don’t wanna have to keep typing it

#

Here

ripe berry
#

I still feel like something had to control crows back in HNHS because of the HNHS Alpha Ending Cutscene and the Stage 5 Crow preventing Mya from dying in any of way then Aaron doing it

shell gull
#

Entity of Manifestation will be E.O.M.

#

Wanna get specific

#

Then

#

Entity of Sadness/Depression

snow mauve
shell gull
#

E.O.M.S.

#

Same with E.O.M. Of trauma

ripe berry
snow mauve
#

Now the guest is pretty much probably one of the crows watching

snow mauve
shell gull
snow mauve
#

I mean I'm glad that's sort of the case

ripe berry
#

Hell we know he's a Crow in GN2

snow mauve
#

Yeah

shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
snow mauve
snow mauve
#

Like the thing being just a own entity

ripe berry
#

I thought that much was somewhat obvious, mainly because the Thing existed in Act 2 (then again at the time I thought Act 2 was fully real so-) and also that the Thing being there after Ted put up the Missing Poster in that one thing in Act Finale made no sense

snow mauve
#

(Guest I'm referring to btw)

shell gull
#

And just grew

#

As Nicky’s fear got worse

safe charm
#

Like a normal person shadow

#

Basically

shell gull
snow mauve
#

Last year I used to think the Guest is the thing and thought Nicky finally defeated the guest

#

But I'm pretty much wrong

#

As I had to reread gn2

shell gull
#

Shut up @waxen sigil

#

Damn

#

Never shuts

#

Hate him

#

Ahem

ripe berry
#

At the time I also remember thinking Act 1 was in November for some reason, and that Act 2 was Febraury

shell gull
#

Anyways

snow mauve
#

I used to think hn1 takes place at December (winter) 💀

#

Just cuz hn1 initial release

ripe berry
ripe berry
shell gull
#

Alright this sounds really dumb, but I thought Nicky and Trinity were dating, don’t Laugh!, I misread the books, I’m sorry.

#

Just

#

Misread

safe charm
#

I used to think taxidermist was the guest( don’t laugh depkis)

shell gull
safe charm
#

Because I thought he was a person

shell gull
ripe berry
#

I remember thinking MitH was the Guest in HN2A1...

#

despite MitH literally being there

shell gull
ripe berry
#

(I never saw him in the footage)

shell gull
#

Alright real talk

#

I’d imagine MITH is Gordon cleave

#

He fits his description

#

He’s always hiding

#

Maybe cuz he was a cultist

#

But eh

#

Just a theory

ripe berry
safe charm
#

Tbh

ripe berry
safe charm
#

Or maybe datdogger and neib

shell gull
safe charm
#

Just brainwashed me

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
#

Ok bye

ripe berry
#

Cya!

sullen hatch
#

the lore of the lorry

#

lolly

#

lol?

tribal talon
#

I agree.

shell gull
# ripe berry Parts of the Museum

Ah yes I remember the good ol days when people were freaking out about the Cult Painting and Statue, and also the fact that every Lore Maniac thought The Guest and Aaron were one, and that the boss fight was gonna be Aaron turning into The Guest and fighting him, ahh the good ol days.

eternal mica
snow mauve
viscid portal
snow mauve
#

To be honest I don't know what year he died

#

But all I know is he got killed by the guest

silver vine
#

hes an editor

teal imp
shell gull
shell gull
dry magnet
#

Ayo guys I have a theory

#

Alr alr here me out.

I don’t think the guest is the neighbor one bit. In fact I think the neighbor and the guest aren’t even working together.

Alr so in hello neighbor two in the beginning of the game when you crash into the barn it’s caused by the guest scaring the player. BUT you also see the neighbor by his house. Meaning these are two different people. And In the hello neighbor 2 alpha when instead of the neighbor there’s the guest you can see him running around at a fast paste. Not any normal human can do that right? And yes I know it’s a game but still.
Instead I think the guest may be one of two people.

The original player that you play in hello neighbor one.
You never know it could be him. After all the devs do surprise us a lot

Alr so I think it may actually be some mysterious person we don’t know about…or someone we already know from the old game..hell they might make his identity be the original neighbor design.

What do you guys think?

pale urchin
#

Teen titans go plot moment

dry magnet
#

Lol

#

Nah bro I’m stressing on who Red X is

#

💀

wicked heath
#

So the guest is the Nurse from Team Defence 2nd. Huh… never heard that one

dry magnet
#

Yup

#

Jk)

#

Earlier I was thinking it could be the mother but than I realized she ain’t built like that

oblique drum
#

originally he was the neighbor during the hg storyline
but thats the old story which is not canon

wicked heath
#

They said they had no idea what the hell they were doing before release

#

tB basically were like:

Nikita. We will steal your cool-looking birdman character that everyone likes. Muahahaha. Now uhh… how do we use it…

safe charm
#

Could guest kid

#

actually be the guest?

wicked heath
#

Idk. Did they find the costume?

safe charm
#

Only

wicked heath
#

But did they

safe charm
#

No

#

They didnt

#

They didnt find

#

Guest kid

wicked heath
#

If anything that costume could be in someones home

safe charm
#

Where do you think guest

#

Comes from?

#

Im still clueless

#

Lol

wicked heath
#

Idk. Ritual summoning?

safe charm
#

Maybe

safe charm
#

In your opinion

wicked heath
#

It made Goose sound more low pitched, similar to that crow chandelier

safe charm
#

Has anything to do with the guest

#

Its called ancient curse

#

On achivements

wicked heath
#

Im pretty sure. I mean, people in black dresses worshipping big bird, and all

safe charm
#

You think its trying to tell us something

#

Or is it just there to be spooky

wicked heath
safe charm
#

So what do they mean by ancient curse do you believe

#

In achivements

wicked heath
#

Nightmare1 was just to make us understand Nibor is an actual threat, Nightmare2 wants us to think he is a messed up guy

wicked heath
safe charm
#

Is the guest the curse

#

Or is they unrealated

wicked heath
#

Not sure

safe charm
#

Makes guest sounds when falling

#

On mr Peterson

#

In the ending

shell gull
#

In AS

#

The Guest is the ancient curse

#

It was quite clear in Nightmare 3

safe charm
#

Its not ancient though

#

He was summoned

#

Pretty

#

Recent

safe charm
#

Why is it called ancient

cold gull
#

Maybe it has been existing a lot of time earlier, but he was just summoned

#

Like, existing but maybe not in a physical form

#

Yet

ripe berry
#

yeah that's the most likely

safe charm
#

Explonation

dry magnet
#

Ayo guys

#

What if the guest…

#

is the cat

#

think about it

quick dagger
#

you found out the secret.

#

the entire of hn2 lore is solved.

snow mauve
#

Of course!!!!

#

They're always watching!

shell gull
teal imp
silver vine
silver vine
#

I doubt hes pretty new to the town

safe charm
#

Do he just exist for no reason

silver vine
safe charm
safe charm
#

His role will be in hn 2

silver vine
#

time will tell

#

hopefully patch 9

safe charm
#

With patch 9

silver vine
#

Im not a dev to answer your questions

safe charm
#

Like believes

silver vine
#

nothing

#

it will stay that way till patch 9

shell gull
viscid knot
#

He's Asian?

shell gull
pale urchin
viscid knot
#

I don't think this looks ancient

shell gull
viscid knot
#

Is he supposed to to be a crow or a raven?

safe charm
#

Him into existence lmao

pale urchin
safe charm
#

No but seriously

#

What are they saying lol

pale urchin
#

Idk, because I'm at school Lmao

shell gull
safe charm
#

Ik

#

Lol

safe charm
#

Just singing

shell gull
safe charm
#

Smh?

shell gull
safe charm
#

The guest kid

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
#

Alright bye

teal imp
#

I like that theory

strange lance
#

It makes sense imo. Remember, that's not a statue of the guest, it's just the park mascot with it's eyes covered with tape. The guest's real form isn't even like clothed it's just a black blob lol

#

I wonder what his face really looks like

teal imp
strange lance
#

The guest is venom

strange lance
#

Gn2

#

It shows the what the guest normally looks like when he doesn't have a normal body

#

Blob

safe charm
#

What do we learn of him in reset day

#

Is he blob

#

There as well

#

I feel asleep

#

Listening to it lol

strange lance
#

In reset day he's just a more monstrous version, more powerful, Ted still inside

#

No blob

safe charm
#

We have

#

What is even the proof he’s a manifestation

#

Of mr Peterson emotion?

safe charm
strange lance
#

I really do not like the word manifestation anymore

snow mauve
#

hello Manifestation

#

🙂

strange lance
#

My theory was just that the guest was made from Ted's grief because the guest only ever appears to ted when his emotions were at play, and the same with Aaron in hnvr, and the same with Regina in gn2, and based on gn2 Ted was depressed over the time travel failure as well, which is why I came up with the guest taking the statue's form because there is no reason for the eyes to be covered other than it being some connection to the guest. So yes the guest is most definitely born from emotions there is so much too it

#

it's literally just the same as The Thing

#

except instead of being "made" from one person, it's from multiple

#

and the thing isn't real

#

also this is all the way from 2021 "found in garbage"

snow mauve
#

apple -my precious

strange lance
#

this is literally just, Elenaor from fazbear frights

#

of fnaf

snow mauve
#

AHHH

#

William Afton!

manic dirge
#

any1 know what teds office in the basement looked like?

strange lance
#

Elenaor: born from evil from afton, becomes more powerful than afton, manipulates people, takes form of thing afton made, real form is black shadowy thing
Guest: born from greif from Ted, becomes more powerful than ted, manipulates people, takes form of thing Ted made, real form is black blobby thing

#

everyday fnaf and HN become more and more connected

safe charm
#

Clothes

#

Ew guest

safe charm
#

Then

#

Because Nicky has guest drawings

#

In his room

strange lance
#

yes

safe charm
#

Damn

#

I thought it was after

#

But where’s Nicky?

manic dirge
#

i wanna know wut teds office in the basement looked like

shell gull
safe charm
#

It’s before act 1

#

According

#

To mouseflash

shell gull
shell gull
safe charm
#

HE

manic dirge
safe charm
#

Hello engineer

shell gull
#

He was always looking into them

teal imp
safe charm
#

I guess Nicky was just somewhere else

shell gull
manic dirge
safe charm
#

Or during that time period

#

And we know guest existed

#

Before act 1

shell gull
# manic dirge anything else?

There were markers and pens, tons of arts and crafts, from my knowledge, there’s also the fact that Ted had glasses, I’m pretty sure but unsure, but eh:

shell gull
safe charm
safe charm
#

Like a physical being

shell gull
safe charm
#

Um nope

#

Not how it could

snow mauve
#

There now you can shut

shell gull
snow mauve
#

And let's move on

safe charm
#

Just kinda weird

snow mauve
hazy grotto
#

Hello what did I miss

snow mauve
#

Nothing

shell gull
snow mauve
#

Other than @safe charm still asking the same damn questions about the guest

safe charm
snow mauve
#

Since he so called likes the guest

manic dirge
#

and also what was in the underground amusement park?

safe charm
shell gull
snow mauve
#

No need to lie

shell gull
#

I’m not explaining any further cuz it’s clear your brain dead rn

safe charm
snow mauve
shell gull
#

Here’s the theory if you want it so badly

#

SN

#

Guest lightning noises

#

Mayak = lightning

#

Done

safe charm
#

Fine

shell gull
#

Mayak Lightning + emotion from person = Goose

#

Done

#

So uh

#

@snow mauve

snow mauve
#

WHAT

shell gull
#

Any theories cuz I’m hella bored

snow mauve
#

Nope

shell gull
#

Man

snow mauve
#

Plus I don't wanna end up like Trinityyy (Guestyyy) who always make up the same theories

#

Non stop

snow mauve
#

When not everything can be answered

shell gull
#

You aren’t wrong there

#

Anyways

shell gull
safe charm
#

Before getting summoned

shell gull
#

He’s a curse

#

We don’t have answers

#

That’s the thing about curses

#

You aren’t gonna have an origin

#

They are just there

#

Like before time started

#

You can’t get answers about that

safe charm
#

He’s a curse

shell gull
#

Demons are parts of curses

#

The curse is the demon

snow mauve
safe charm
#

Does a curse mean it’s always summoned by a someone

#

Or can it basically just exist

snow mauve
#

Then you'll know

#

Like it ain't that hard

shell gull
#

We need Micheal to sort this out, like lore is barren, without Micheal there’s no entertainment of lore.

safe charm
#

They used

#

Any theory

shell gull
#

That’s the thing

safe charm
#

Does Nightmare 3 really showcase his summoning or is it just showcasing like him

#

Like the curse

safe charm
#

Who is Quentin

#

Representing

snow mauve
#

A journalist

#

Duh

shell gull
#

What?

snow mauve
#

A "replacement"

safe charm
#

In the nightmare

shell gull
shell gull
safe charm
#

Like is he representing the cult getting attacked

#

By the guest

shell gull
#

He’s figuring it out

#

Following M.J. Footsteps

safe charm
#

hn 2 really does have more questions

snow mauve
#

no

safe charm
#

Then answers

shell gull
#

Pretty damn simple

#

Your overthinking

teal imp
#

hn2 is worth nothing it serves 0 purpose you should uninstall the game NOW (or not I cant force you ¯_(ツ)_/¯)

shell gull
#

The f-

safe charm
#

Hn 2 story is

#

There’s this cult who summoned a bird creature because they believed him to be their god

#

And it escapes

snow mauve
#

And a waste of time

safe charm
#

And then you arrive and gets knocked out

shell gull
# safe charm Hn 2 story is

Quentin looking for Peterson kids, gets bonked, finds out keys missing, finds out cult, finds out what goose is, saves Peterson child, gets bonked.

safe charm
#

And wakes up in your office and then you nearly succeeds

#

In saving Aaron but instead gets your skull crushed

shell gull
safe charm
#

By a shadow

teal imp
#

do it

#

you need that precious pc space

safe charm
#

It just isn’t a satisfying narrative currently

shell gull
# teal imp uninstall it <:MenacingMoustache:1053101954773033020>

I tried, but damn, Alex’s cartoon is too damn good, it’s like it’s mind controlling me, like it’s making me play HN2, I’ve been playing for 40 days straight now, I can’t stop, I have been feeding off of my mattress so I don’t have to get up and leave, been drinking the water from the left over soda cans, help.

#

/j

#

And especially /j to that Cartoon part

shell gull
teal imp
safe charm
#

Why are you sending

#

This 3 times

shell gull
shell gull
# safe charm This 3 times

Cuz it’s what you want, Quentin looking for Peterson kids, gets bonked, finds out keys missing, finds out cult, finds out what goose is, saves Peterson child, gets bonked.

#

It’s the HN2 story

safe charm
#

Well not really a story

shell gull
#

The entire script

shell gull
teal imp
#

alex made the issue of the games barely having a story WORSE

#

to get any lore from hn2 you need to watch the shitty cartoon made for 5 year olds

shell gull
safe charm
#

Mr Peterson isn’t really Einstein genius

#

In hn 2

#

He’s literally hiding in a museum a street away

#

From the police

shell gull
#

I mean to be fair the bakers bathroom has like two windows for creeps to watch through, I mean literally the red house near by has a view into the bathroom 💀

safe charm
#

Well I miss the mature sad

#

Tone

#

The most

shell gull
#

I miss the horror

#

In the books

safe charm
#

Yes

#

Same

shell gull
#

Gotta go

safe charm
#

Okay

teal imp
hazy slate
whole tapir
#

Is the thing still part of the lore?

snow mauve
whole tapir
shell gull
shell gull
hazy grotto
manic dirge
#

does any1 have pictures of the nest?

fallow spade
#

GUYS

hazy grotto
#

?

viscid portal
#

What?

#

Update hello neighbour VR?

manic dirge
sage obsidian
kindred veldt
#

the guest might be arron or nickey from the vr game

hazy grotto
#

I like to imagine guest as a manifestation of the darkest hour of someone greiving and making them more do something disastrous rather than be a physical being (if we're talking old lore, not HN 2 idk what Alex has in mind for guest there)

#

I could be wrong but it's my thoughts and whatnot

shell gull
hazy grotto
#

Man yeah it's a bit of a bummer

teal imp
#

But the guest seems somewhat real

#

He can interact with Aaron and help him get his friends out

hazy grotto
#

Yeah

stiff spire
#

at least he kept his manipulative trait from GN2

#

however instead of being an entity caused by fear he's a demon

silver vine
#

remember, Bakery's bathroom doesnt even have a door

solemn sleet
#

Ok so hear me out, the guest caused the neighbors car crash

silver vine
#

good theory

#

I like it

#

but

solemn sleet
#

In gn2 and hn2 the guest just stands in the road and causes car crashes

#

In gn2 people describe the guest as a creature that takes what people don't appreciate

#

In the og books the neighbor mistreats and lashes our against his family

#

It would give the guest a motive to cause the crash because he was taking what Mr. peterson didn't appreciate, his family

strange lance
#

except the guest didn't exist during the crash in the timeline. The guest was "born" from Ted's grief in the park, which is way after Diane and Mya die.

#

He was born when Ted was sad over not being able to go back and save him family, which can only happened if they are already dead

solemn sleet
#

How was the guest "born"?

strange lance
#

He just kinda...was

#

It's like the thing from hn1

#

except the guest is actually real

#

and only came from one person

#

and is more deadly

solemn sleet
#

But the guest doesn't revolve around peterson, he does his own thing most of the time

safe charm
#

Wdym?

strange lance
#

except he kinda does

#

the Guest's main goal is to get Ted

#

we see that in hnvr and gn2

#

yeah he does his own stuff

#

but he mainly wants Ted

solemn sleet
#

His main goal is to got Aaron, he's the last one of petersons family alive, that's why ted locks him in the basement

strange lance
#

His main goal is not to get Aaron lmao

solemn sleet
#

To protect him from the guest

strange lance
#

hnvr shows what the guest really wants

#

which is Ted

#

the achivement for Aaron meeting the guest is literally called "do me a favor", and Aaron unknowiningly helps the guest get to Ted

#

then the guest mind melds with ted

solemn sleet
#

He goes after ted because he's in his way, he's taking what ted didn't appreciate, his family

strange lance
#

bro, did you play the game. Aaron was just a stepping stone

#

Ted was not in the way the guest straight up goes after him

#

and when he's gotten Ted he does away with Aaron

#

cause he no longer needs him

#

and because Ted did not care enough for aaron

solemn sleet
#

Exactly, his goal is to torture ted, which involves taking his family

strange lance
#

yes, once he got into Ted's mind, he took Aaron away since he no longer needed him and because Ted was ungrateful

#

it's that simple

#

The guest never messed with Diane and Mya because they were already dead

#

those were accidents

#

and because of those accidents Aaron and Ted were vulnerable

#

which made it easy for the guest to mess with them both

#

and once the guest has Ted, he can basically just make him do whatever, which is what we see in gn2

#

and when Ted tried doing the right thing

#

he gets possessed

silver vine
#

(pls dont kill me for mentioning the AS)

solemn sleet
silver vine
#

but in the AS/HN2 lore, hes ancient

solemn sleet
#

Yeah but I'm talking about the new lore

snow mauve
#

Ew, yucky new lore

silver vine
#

but ppl hate calling it new lore cuz ppl hate everything from the cartoon

wicked heath
#

they call it the "non-canon lore"

silver vine
#

or AU lore

wicked heath
#

even tho yes its the new canon, but whatever ig...

snow mauve
silver vine
#

as much as I hate to break it to everyone here, it IS the new canon, but, its actually upto you to accept what you want to accept, if you want to accept it, fine, if you dont, ignore it or shit on it 24/7

#

Im fine with both lores

#

both are good in their own ways