#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 32 of 1

ripe berry
#

(Rocket Event)

silver vine
#

the point is

#

they do

#

they do put plan to action

#

they successfully save Nicky

#

HE is def after Nicky's escape

ripe berry
#

Ok, give something that's proof of that

silver vine
ripe berry
#

This is basically a "at what point was Act 2 retconned" thing, where leaning one way or the other makes it more likely HE is in one spot in the timeline and not the other

silver vine
#

if HE takes place before they break in, that means HE should take place in ep 5 as ep 4 is HN1 Act 1 and ep 6 is SN and act 2

#

and we know that ep 5 isnt HE episode

ripe berry
#

Ep. 4 is start of SN

ripe berry
silver vine
ripe berry
ripe berry
#

I was talking original canon and if it's a retcon or not, now we've just gone to using AS to prove something from old lore's not been retconned

#

But yeah in AS universe HE probably happens after Act 2

#

But in Old Lore it's more likely to be before Act 2, as that works with what the game shows (Nicky Missing Posters, lack of Nicky anywhere else in the game indicating but not confirming him still being missing)

#

Just add it to the pile of stuff AS Retconned

#

I'm not arguing HE's placement in new lore other then the slight possibility of them putting it in-between episodes and using that to explain why they've skipped 2 months forward in the timeline

#

(assuming Act 2's placement relative to Act 1 is the same as in Old Lore)

#

But they could also just skip time and not explain why

strange lance
#

If we're talking original lore, HE is before Nicky escapes, the squad never saves him and his missing posters are still around during HE and he's not with the squad at all during the game. If we're talking new lore it would be after, because now the squad saves Nicky.

teal imp
#

I feel like nothing is canon anymore

strange lance
#

AS already retcons HE anyway because now Nicky is part of the inventors club despite never being shown to have ever been in it in HE

#

It was just Enzo, Trinity, Maritza, and Ivan

teal imp
strange lance
#

Yes that is what happens

#

If goes HN1 act 1, SN, HE, hn1 act 2, hn2 and so forth

#

Also again, we do not know how HE ends yet

#

Plus the game is also getting post launch content

teal imp
#

what is the gameplay of HE like? like is it only Hn related cause of the characters?

strange lance
#

The only Hn related things, are everything but the gameplay

#

The gameplay is the weakest part of the game

#

Everything else is great

teal imp
#

seems like more care was put into it for some weird bizzare reason

blazing latch
#

One message removed from a suspended account.

shell gull
#

You clearly haven’t, nowhere in it has it shown or said It can morph, no one else agrees with you.

#

God forgot abt that

#

Bro tf

snow mauve
#

What the hell?

shell gull
#

We’ll point proven you don’t know what tf you’re talking abt

strange lance
#

The Guest can shape shift, but he's only seen doing that in people's minds

snow mauve
#

He can even go into people's dreams

strange lance
#

The only thing Guest does in both minds and the real world is his amazing power of turning into goop

shell gull
#

It can’t ACTUALLY morph

strange lance
#

What a awesome ability

snow mauve
#

Bro what the hell are you even talking about?

strange lance
#

I guess it makes him be able to move quicker

shell gull
#

Aight I’m out

snow mauve
strange lance
#

I did indeed take those with my camera

thin wadi
shell gull
#

Aight I’m out

strange lance
#

EMU

thin wadi
#

OH

#

I remember now

#

Its been a while since I read the books

#

I miss quintin's old coward but curious character

#

It fit him more

silver vine
#

Aaron doesnt save Nicky

#

Nicky saves Aaron

#

this is the way

thin wadi
#

Wat

#

How-

silver vine
#

and I dont think this is a new retcon

thin wadi
#

Aaron saves nicky in hn1 and nicky escapes

silver vine
#

distorted memory

thin wadi
silver vine
thin wadi
#

Or he saves Aaron and gets himself trapped

strange lance
#

Did Aaron really unlock the door, or did Nicky just feel trapped is the question

silver vine
#

Nicky prob felt trapped

#

he saw Aaron threw the keyhole and opened it

strange lance
#

Makes sense with the giant fences on the surface

silver vine
#

what Norman said makes much more sense now

#

Nicky did save Aaron

strange lance
#

not really cause of hn2 lmao

thin wadi
#

Make up your mind alex

silver vine
silver vine
strange lance
#

he said it looks like he did

silver vine
#

he said in HN1, it LOOKED like Aaron saved Nicky

#

but that was a distorted memory

thin wadi
#

Oh

#

Ooook

silver vine
#

what should've happened is that Nicky must've seen Aaron thru the keyhole and NICKY opened the door and freed Aaron

#

but Nicky, as he felt trapped, remembered that he saw Aaron threw the keyhole and Aaron opened the door

#

thats what he remembers

#

but what happened is that he saved Aaron

strange lance
#

I love HE's environments

#

they do storytelling really well

thin wadi
#

What do you think happens to the rescue squad. They break into the house and get caught or they break in and leave?

#

What is their point

#

I guess s&r and AS will answer that

strange lance
#

Well considering they are adults in other episodes they do escape

thin wadi
#

So they learn nothing

#

The break in things go wrong they escape

#

Actually thats very similar to Nicky's story: he breaks in to save Aaron, gets trapped, and then escaped

#

Except he does actually free aaron

strange lance
#

Oh Ted this is what happens when you mess with the forces of time

silver vine
#

I hope Ted messing with time to save his family is still canon

snow mauve
#

Where do you guys find these

#

Images

strange lance
#

tB posted 5 "new" membership teasers on their youtube

snow mauve
#

Ohhh

strange lance
#

(3 of them are ones the public have already seen)

#

so only 2 are actually new

snow mauve
#

Gotcha

#

Thanks

strange lance
#

alright which ones getting the best rituals

teal imp
teal imp
#

Hn lore is weird

#

HE objectively looks better and cooler

strange lance
#

In hn1 act 3 is a giant build up of all of Nicky's ptsd and trauma which he then concurs and defeats. In the new lore the house is just real

#

so it no longer has meaning

teal imp
strange lance
#

HE factually has a better art style

thin wadi
teal imp
snow mauve
#

Hmm secret neighbor

thin wadi
#

Enzo is saying "blue key needed"

strange lance
#

Why are finch and delroy side lined so much

#

it's kinda sad

#

they were cut from HE and don't seem to have big roles in the AS

snow mauve
#

Here we have HE and S&R characters

#

The main 4

strange lance
#

yet the clubhouse in HE has 6 seats??

#

SR at least has all 6 of them

snow mauve
#

Really?

#

Oh wait nvm

#

Mb

strange lance
#

SR kinda makes SN's story pointless

#

The whole point of SN was to show they never tried and in HE the karma came for them

#

but now they do break in

#

and they do save nicky

thin wadi
strange lance
#

yes in the new lore the rescue squad saves Nicky

#

and they all escape

thin wadi
#

Oh

#

What about aaron

snow mauve
#

This honestly sucks man

snow mauve
#

They left him behind

silver vine
thin wadi
silver vine
thin wadi
#

Trinity enzo and maritza do

snow mauve
#

They be making plan

strange lance
#

in the new lore they do not know them, that's a valid reason for not saving him

#

because they do not really care

#

in the original they never saved either

thin wadi
#

New lore is so dumb

strange lance
#

because they were cowards

snow mauve
#

And Nicky thinks Peterson killed his kids in the new lore

thin wadi
#

What is the lore of HE

snow mauve
#

Kids

#

Wanna build cars

#

Then neighbor

#

Be evil

#

And kids got teleported

#

To another universe

#

The end

silver vine
thin wadi
#

New lore is so stupid they changed Mya's name to Mia

#

What was wrong with Mya? Plus its so inconsistent

silver vine
#

if we are gonna time jump to adults in ep 9

#

then

#

how will Peterson be involved apart from trauma

snow mauve
thin wadi
#

But the name was involved with a secret code

teal imp
thin wadi
#

I think nicky still is

glacial whale
#

Ok I haven’t seen a lot of the AS stuff. If it was a community thing on YouTube I can’t see it due to my phone being outdated so I’ve mostly seen what’s been shared here.

ripe berry
#

So Act 3 is real, Guest is demon, Act 2 is heavily retconned

#

HE's timeline placement is changed

#

What haven't they messed up from the games

#

Every Game's Story has to be changed to work with AS

#

Hn1, He, Sn, Hnhs, Hnd

#

(had to make them lowercase so bot doesn't delete them)

#

All retconned in some way

teal imp
thin wadi
#

I'm fine with the guest being a demon

#

Everything else is dumb

crude dew
#

I’m not
Every second show has cultists and demons
There is nothing unique in it anymore

cold gull
#

Omgggg u dumb????
These guys have already explained it like a hundred of times 😀😀
SN = Planning phase, it's the kids' imagination 🌈☁️
Every question / statement you've done so far is truly out of logic ☝️🤓

#

Excuse me, but ignorance it's on top of this conversation, questions that have already been answered, make me p on my pants

#

Of course it's canon, otherwise there's no point in creating stuff just bc

#

And neighbor transformation according to what i've read, represents the fact of kids' awareness of a traitor among them, doesn't have to be literal since everything it's imagination, of course it doesn't make sense, such as going to the moon to rescue a kid 🤗

#

It's canon somehow

shell gull
#

No and Yes, SN is the kids imagination as they come up with a break in plan.

#

Guest Demon things isn’t 100% (as the one who contributed highly on that), though It is for sure an entirety at the least, though all the evidence was through the OG tapes and many other factors.

silver vine
#

SN was always canon

#

the kids dont trust each other, they think one of them is secretly working for Peterson

#

SN is an imaginary plan to break into the house

#

AS shows how they actually break in

raw sail
strange lance
#

Unless you've seen the rocket event ending most don't know SN is imagination

#

All of SN is just them sitting in the lobby

shell gull
#

Not trying to start anything, your new and from my understanding don’t know the lore, but yet argue about it?

shell gull
silver vine
#

exactly

teal imp
silver vine
#

Idk why Micheal is telling HNHS is also retconned

teal imp
#

I swear to god If I want to play it takes up to 5 minutes to get a lobby

strange lance
#

I guess the ending is "retconned"

#

Since it's the cults fault now

#

And not completely Aaron's

silver vine
#

it always was

#

even in the old lore

strange lance
#

How is Aaron pushing Mya off the roof the cults fault

silver vine
#

they cursed them

strange lance
#

With bad luck

teal imp
strange lance
#

Aaron pushing Mya is not bad luck

teal imp
#

why cant it just be a freak accident

silver vine
#

book 6 clearly says that all the bad things happening to the Peterson family is cuz of the curse

#

the family is doomed

#

Aaron makes that clear in the end

silver vine
strange lance
#

It being the cult is boring. Because everything that happens can just be blaimed on the cult. Aaron pushing Mya and feeling guilty? Not really him it was the cult!

silver vine
#

it was partly Aaron's fault

#

hes not entirely free from blood

#

Mya's blood is still in his hands

#

I never said it was never his fault

teal imp
silver vine
#

dont you want to see how Peterson gets his revenge?

teal imp
#

how is a kid killing his own sister boring???

unkempt sleet
#

The thing is, The cult might be the source of the bad luck, but the reason of Mya's death was Aaron

silver vine
#

exactly

strange lance
#

Ok what if Aaron didn't go on the roof. Would Mya still die somehow

silver vine
#

no

strange lance
#

She'd probably slip or something

silver vine
#

Idk

teal imp
#

the ladder from the back?

silver vine
#

trampoline

unkempt sleet
#

They can teleport

teal imp
silver vine
#

there is no ladder either

teal imp
#

the games where it DOES happen

silver vine
silver vine
#

thats literally how she goes to the roof

#

in stage 5

teal imp
#

that makes no sense

strange lance
#

That takes her up some stairs

silver vine
#

she uses a trampoline

strange lance
#

Also that's just for gameplay

raw sail
unkempt sleet
#

Thats not a reason, They're talking about something that happened in HNHS

strange lance
#

You can hear Aaron unlocking a door in stage 5. They went outside, and climbed up a ladder

teal imp
#

I hate Hello neighbor

strange lance
#

The trampoline is just there to get over a gate

raw sail
unkempt sleet
teal imp
#

Im just heavilly frustrated with the games

#

theres just so much missed potential

#

and hn in its current state is kind of a joke

raw sail
#

We’re all in the same boat

strange lance
#

The Library lore

#

Is so funny

teal imp
#

a vandal

strange lance
#

Yeah I have a machine in my giant basement

#

That's it

raw sail
#

Btw Does Aaron die later? Never read the books in depth so I dunno if he follows the fate of his family

strange lance
#

We do not know Aaron's fate

#

Hn2 was meant to do that

#

And guess what

#

Guess what happened

teal imp
raw sail
#

We still don’t know

strange lance
#

Yeah!

teal imp
raw sail
#

Like we freed Aaron from the cage and that’s our last info on Aaron’s fate

teal imp
#

honestly I dont even care if he lives or not

raw sail
#

Yikes

snow mauve
teal imp
#

the kid had a chance to escape but yet he ran to his abusive father and tried to help him get the crow thing off of him (ted would have been fine)

strange lance
#

Well considering in gn2 he is not with Ted there are a 2 options. He is dead, he is with other people

snow mauve
#

That's crazy

raw sail
#

At one point in time

teal imp
#

then an attic

raw sail
#

Because he was scared

snow mauve
raw sail
snow mauve
#

Welp Ted is stuck with Aaron

#

Rip him

strange lance
#

Hn really likes to kill of females huh

raw sail
#

I mean he still loves his son

snow mauve
#

They really hate

#

WOMAN

raw sail
#

The baker:

snow mauve
#

Barely any men death

strange lance
#

There's Ike

#

And

teal imp
boreal blade
#

Hey guys, I wanted to clear a doubt, whenever I leave the game I can't continue from where I stopped my progress, does anyone know how to solve this?

teal imp
#

so hey thats lucky?

#

also Beatrix isnt even canon so she cant die

snow mauve
strange lance
#

Beatrix was scrapped, piper's mom got taken, Trinity dies as an adult, the 2 female leads from bosco bay suffer injuries, both female leads from gn2 suffer injuries, mrs. Tillman dies, Maritza gets ptsd, Diane dies, Mya dies

#

And Gerda of course got tramautized as a child

strange lance
#

So yes HN really likes to make female characters suffer for some reason

#

Oh yeah Lucy also died

teal imp
strange lance
#

She's implied to have been married to Enzo in reset day, their children say their mom died

snow mauve
strange lance
#

The realator too

viscid portal
strange lance
#

Ted didn't even kill that cashier guy

#

It just looks like he did

snow mauve
#

Least he gets to steal stuff

#

Without anyone looking

#

Since he be unemployed

strange lance
#

Ok which HN game has the coolest mannequin lore (HE)

teal imp
#

since she is bassically the protagonist of the AS

strange lance
#

Who knows

teal imp
#

I doubt they would kill her off

#

but if they do I honestly just would not care

strange lance
#

The AS lore sucks anyway

teal imp
#

the AS has ruined any attachment I had to the characters at this point

snow mauve
#

Maybe if you can just ignore it

#

And act like it never existed

strange lance
#

Lets talk about how Ted is abusive towards the mannequins and how they are sentient 🙂

teal imp
snow mauve
#

I scare ya

#

Behold, new act 1

teal imp
#

them being actually real and not nicky`s weird memory of ted

#

like in act 1 and 2 there were none

#

hn2 none

#

them being sentient isnt all that surprising to me

strange lance
#

In HE you can find mannequins in cages, crashed roller coaster carts, water, and in piles with many many other mannequins. They are all dead

#

Some mannequins have chalk, with tally marks next to them

teal imp
#

the hell

teal imp
#

why isnt any of this stuff in HN2

snow mauve
#

Because screw it!

teal imp
#

seriously why does random spin off with completely diffrent gameplay have more care put into it?

unkempt sleet
#

I dont think sentient mannequins would fit HN2, even the old versions

teal imp
teal imp
unkempt sleet
teal imp
#

from what Ive seen and heard it not only looks better but has more interesting stuff going on

raw sail
unkempt sleet
#

I was talking about sentient mannequins

teal imp
raw sail
silver vine
teal imp
unkempt sleet
#

I dont think sentient mannequins fit with the wackiness of hello neighbor tbh

teal imp
raw sail
teal imp
silver vine
#

thats prob why Ted decided to test time travel

unkempt sleet
#

I love mannequins though, I wish they were in HN2

silver vine
raw sail
#

Quentin is neither a kid, or sleeping throughout the journey of HN2

snow mauve
teal imp
#

I wonder if GN2 is still canon I love how the guest was an actual threat there

silver vine
teal imp
#

in hn2 he is just a random bird on the street

#

more goofy than anything

silver vine
snow mauve
#

Okay?

raw sail
silver vine
#

she does have an ink machine tho

#

but its blue ink

teal imp
#

also they reduced his height after hello guest which made him even more goofy cause he became the same height as Quentin

unkempt sleet
#

He was taller in HG?

#

I didnt know that

teal imp
strange lance
teal imp
#

normally I would hate HE

#

but theres actually some care put into it

#

I can respect it

#

still a cashgrab tho

boreal blade
#

Hey guys, I wanted to clear a doubt, whenever I leave the game I can't continue from where I stopped my progress, does anyone know how to solve this?

raw sail
crude dew
#

of course, he was taller. he was a different person duh

strange lance
#

Ted what are you doing

#

Don't decapitate them

crude dew
#

do you guys ever imagine Peterson and Ike showing up anywhere
tall handsome guy, and the little chubby friend, who's always smiling.

teal imp
crude dew
strange lance
#

Real

#

The mannequins are actually real

teal imp
#

honestly I wish they kept him that tall cause atleast that makes him somewhat more intimidating

crude dew
#

what did the writers of HE lore take...

strange lance
#

And they're all dead

teal imp
#

being chased around by a 6.6 foot bird demon

crude dew
#

sweet

#

theory: HE is purgato- /shot

strange lance
#

Ted making sentient mannequins only to kill them saddummy

#

Why even make them sentient if you're just gonna torture them

#

And experiment on them

crude dew
#

maybe I'd do the same, if I were in that state of mind
who knows
I was never a genius

teal imp
crude dew
#

I wish HE didn't have an actual story, like
by the time I suffer through a level, I entirely forget, what happened

strange lance
#

Well if HE had no story no one would really play it

#

There'd be no point

teal imp
#

neighbor lore

#

cant wait till they retcon the AS and make something even worse

crude dew
#

I don't play it anyway, the actual gameplay demotivates me
I still don't get the logic behind some things, I guess I'm old/too realist for this game

#

as for map exploration, it is interesting
but the car part...

strange lance
crude dew
#

family friendly

strange lance
#

Let him down :(

#

Also that crow is huge

crude dew
#

baby was raised well

#

I'll fix this picture, but it might get deleted instantly

teal imp
strange lance
#

And has a cork in his forehead

#

Bro lasted 15 days

silver vine
#

I hope AS explore HE as well

strange lance
#

What did he do to get locked up

crude dew
silver vine
#

thats default

crude dew
#

I think these rather symbolize something, than being tormented.

silver vine
#

maybe

snow mauve
strange lance
#

Who knew Hello Engineer would be the darkest game in the series..

teal imp
#

HS litterally has a kid die

snow mauve
teal imp
#

oh wait the guy at the store

strange lance
#

Guy bleeding from his head

#

Realator hit by truck and somehow lodged in tires

teal imp
snow mauve
#

But now it's gone

teal imp
#

no I mean

#

how is it show on youtube

bleak spear
#

The red stuff (presumably blood) is dark grey instead of red on the youtube ver

bleak spear
#

Yep

snow mauve
#

They tried to make it look like oil

teal imp
#

wait so what happend in episode 2? did he just drill himself or what

snow mauve
#

We really don't know

teal imp
#

random death that is confusing

#

cant wait till episode 3 has someone slip on a banana peel and die

snow mauve
#

Episode 3 i think it's gonna be Mr. Murtagh

snow mauve
#

The inventors club teacher

snow mauve
teal imp
#

I just dont like him

snow mauve
#

I think he'll die by flammable

#

I think that because of this

teal imp
#

I assumed they would have them at only like when nicky is captured

snow mauve
#

I also think episode 3 we will see Otto with Enzo

teal imp
#

what was enzo like in the books?

#

in the AS his only personality traits seem to be that he is a nerd and that he has a crush on trinity

snow mauve
#

He's like a chicken (coward) and nerd

teal imp
snow mauve
#

And does have a crush with trinity

#

So it's like the same as AS

teal imp
#

is he as cringe as the AS?

#

also I heard that they were literally dating in the books

snow mauve
stiff spire
#

imagine when Mr. Murtaugh dies he still smiles

#

that would be dark

#

I actually wonder why he keeps smiling though maybe we'll get to know in future episodes or maybe he's very happy about his job or something

uncut mulch
#

Why him he was my fav

#

💀

#

Why is delroy and Nicky dirty

snow mauve
#

Because

#

Flammable

#

Duhhhh

uncut mulch
#

I know it was by flames

#

You already said

uncut mulch
#

Its a joke

#

He’s creepy

uncut mulch
#

I think because I saw him in an episode 7 teaser

#

Its like 50 50

uncut mulch
urban fulcrum
teal imp
shell gull
#

Right before that segment

gentle elm
#

Hey, Alex just dropped the script of first episode of the AS.

wicked heath
#

months ago

gentle elm
#

The script

unkempt sleet
#

Hes talking about the script of the episode 1

gentle elm
#

He dropped the script of the first episode

wicked heath
#

okey?

unkempt sleet
#

#hello-neighbor message

teal imp
#

I wonder if I hello engineer is even canon

strange lance
#

It's totally not anymore. And if it is, they had to change quite a bit

strange lance
#

Well for one Nicky is now part of the inventor's club in the AS despite never being a part of it in the game. In the games they never save Nicky, they leave him. In the AS they do save him and all escape, also making the sandbox non canon.

teal imp
#

maybe HE takes place before act 2 now?

strange lance
#

It's always been before act 2

#

It would have to be after act 2 for it to still happen in the AS

teal imp
#

Maybe the AS has a gap?

#

There has to be some sort of timeskip for ted to build the act 3 house

thin wadi
#

I wouldn't be surprised if he builds it in one episode

dense ice
#

can anyone send me the opening cutscene for the prototype with that music and eletric pole?

#

like the early early one

lapis sonnet
#

hey everyone! after a long while im active again

#

and i might make a youtube video about my new timeline theory

#

it still supports the old lore and new lore theory which im 99% sure is true

#

but it answers a lot of questions

snow mauve
#

Looking forward to see that

#

Like finally someone is gonna talk about the modern HN timeline

#

In a YT video

lapis sonnet
#

this theory explains so much about the retcon, and if anyone was doubting the old lore and new lore theory, they wont anymore

#

and its honestly a theory most people probably knew, so it will be targeted towards doubters

#

also im gonna truly start production on my HN full timeline series after i get this theory video out, i made the thumbnail and script for the first episode of the HN full timeline series but haven't started recording yet

#

its going to be a series recapping the "old lore" timeline, then a sequel series recapping the "new lore" timeline once HNVR is out

#

im not going to wait for AS to come out and to get HN2 story/content updates because that will take until the end of the year

#

instead im gonna make a series on what we have now and if anything changes ill make reworks

lapis sonnet
#

we still dk

#

also I have proof that HNHS is part of new lore incase anybody was doubting that

strange lance
#

HNHS can still be part of the new lore that shouldn't be a debate

lapis sonnet
#

also whats this talk of the HN2 intro having GN references? how does this make the GNs new lore?

strange lance
#

The "reference" being the Guest standing Infront of Quentin on the road

#

like how in gn2 he stands infront of Regina and Pris

#

while they're in their car

teal imp
#

in hn2 is looks like an accident

#

in gn2 it was clearly intentional

strange lance
#

yeah

teal imp
#

I hope HE can somehow fit into new lore

lapis sonnet
#

HN2's intro references that

teal imp
#

Damn so the GNs can still be canon

#

I hope so cause I liked gn2

lapis sonnet
#

im working on a YT video that explains what is and isnt canon

#

but ive only got script done

teal imp
lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

Damn

lapis sonnet
#

the new lore version of the novels is the AS

teal imp
#

Like I dont think gn1 and 2 contradict anything

lapis sonnet
#

actually since that video is gonna take forever to make and u have a basic understanding of the lore, ill just make a visual timeline rn

#

an image

lapis sonnet
#

one for old lore and another for new lore

#

new lore:

strange lance
#

this seems about right

lapis sonnet
#

So now I've made a image version of the timelines, a text doc version of the timelines, now I just need to make the biggest and most challenging of all: a video format of the timeline

manic dirge
#

well this a lore breaker

lapis sonnet
#

thats just how they roll

lapis sonnet
#

and we dk whether HE is gonna be old or new lore but i hope its old lore bc this karma thing youve brought up makes sense

#

and before people say it cant be old lore bc of the retcon, its shown TB still sometimes makes games post-retcon that fit into old lore (diaries)

#

and then HE also started production pre-retcon so maybe they want to stay true to what they originally came up with

lapis sonnet
# shell gull He did say this though

love this clarification, this is why in my timeline I put all 4 hello neighbor acts into one spot and put it in 2016-future because technically the entire game of HN1 takes place when nicky is an adult, its just a foggy retelling through a therapy session

#

(when I say timeline, i mean my old lore timeline)]

lapis sonnet
#

hope it is bc HE being in old lore creates some symbolism

shell gull
lapis sonnet
#

in old lore that happens around 1997ish

#

im talking about old lore

pale urchin
lapis sonnet
#

think about it

pale urchin
#

You may ask MouseFlash13, he even knows that it can be an older lore

lapis sonnet
#

ik me and him are hoping its old lore, it came out on stadia pre-retcon so it must be old lore

pale urchin
lapis sonnet
#

since the recent demo stayed true to original story from the stadia build

lapis sonnet
#

aka my timeline

#

i made a visual of it

pale urchin
#

Ik, but that's what the CEO wants, a change of the story

lapis sonnet
#

are u talking ab the retcon? bc ofc i know about the retcon who doesnt

pale urchin
pale urchin
lapis sonnet
#

retcon timeline

pale urchin
#

Yep

lapis sonnet
#

old lore timeline since its peak

#

deleted the images since they didnt have my watermark and i dont want them being stolen

#

fixed

lapis sonnet
lapis sonnet
strange lance
#

I doubt they'll change HE to new lore, that would not only be a waste of time...actually that is all, it would just be a waste of time

#

I think it's ok to put it in old lore

#

I don't see why they would change it anyway

#

they had every chance to change HND and haven't

lapis sonnet
shut hill
#

I feel like Otto might sound goofy in AS

quick dagger
#

he's gunna sound nasally or something

shut hill
#

Yea probably, I’m kind of scared to see

thin wadi
#

I don't like Enzo's voice in the AS

#

I think they should have swapped Ivan and Enzo's voice actors

lapis sonnet
pale condor
#

Do you guys know when ep 3 of the AS is dropping

lapis sonnet
#

which btw all they need to do for episode 6 is audio its done being animated

#

so we can guess ep 3 will come out around early may

#

episodes 3, 4, 5 and 6 will be released weekly

#

starting prob early may but we dk the date yet

pale condor
#

Thanks

lapis sonnet
#

np

teal imp
teal imp
# lapis sonnet

The remake is likely to have act 3 since it was the longest part of the game so shouldnt it be moved?

#

Also I would add secret neighbor to the new lore aswell since the AS will literally have it be part of it

silver vine
teal imp
thin wadi
silver vine
#

no

#

but Alex said he doesnt like Enzo's voice

#

he didnt say that they are going to swap Enzo and Ivans voice actors

unkempt sleet
#

Yea, We saw these

lapis sonnet
lapis sonnet
#

bc in new lore it doesnt take place in future and rather when they are kids bc act 3 house is real now

teal imp
#

also I noticed you seemed to have changed your mind on the graphic novels?

teal imp
teal imp
#

its nicky`s nightmare

#

seperate from the event

#

also as much as I love hello guest isnt it unfinished?

#

I doubt it can be even included

#

also I would put gn2 before hello guest

#

since ted was the guest in it

lapis sonnet
#

when the remake comes out they will probably do story changes

teal imp
#

act 3 is like act 2

#

so no

lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

they would have to cut the longest part of the game for it

lapis sonnet
#

it might not be a 4 act system since hn2 wasnt

#

we literally dont know anything about the remake either than that its happening

teal imp
#

its canon to hg

lapis sonnet
#

i know but im ignoring that since its just alpha 1 and story wise we didnt know who the guest was back then, even if TB posted that around the same time

teal imp
#

at that point it would be an entirely new game

lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

im sorry if im being nitpicky but it just doesnt seem to work for me

lapis sonnet
#

bc its just alpha 1

teal imp
#

also what happens to Quentin/Beatrix?

teal imp
#

it might have even damaged the park

lapis sonnet
lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

the town was going to be in hg chapter clearly post flood looking at all the mess

lapis sonnet
#

and since its old lore the protagonist is basically just norman darby, since norman darby is the old lore version of quentin

#

and beatrix is just beatrix

teal imp
#

idk man I would rather not include it or move it after gn2

lapis sonnet
#

ik what the game was going to be but it never came out so im going off of just A1 story, which didnt have a lot to it

teal imp
#

which means the hat man takes them

lapis sonnet
#

sure

#

still doesnt contradict anything

teal imp
#

it just feels so wrong seeing as how the guest was 100% ted

#

we knew this since hgp

lapis sonnet
#

we wouldve seen it in game if it fully released

#

but again, it didnt

teal imp
#

but that was clearly the intention

teal imp
teal imp
#

hg was unfinished I feel like it would be best to just not include it since it doesnt contribute to anything

lapis sonnet
#

i include it as an introduction to the guest

#

bc in old lore unless u count nog simming there is no prior knowledge to the guest's existence before gn2

#

it seems too random

teal imp
#

idk thats just making things up at that point

lapis sonnet
#

i mean think about it

#

if u ignore all teasers and just go off of alpha 1:

#

the story is you play as a nighttime security guard monitoring the abandoned GAAP, you can either play as quentin/norman darby or beatrix, you make your way to the park when you notice a large storm near the statue, you go to investigate but encounter an entity named the guest, so you must avoid the guest while traversing the park and solving puzzles, by using hardware u buy at the store after every shift. once you make it past a specific building, it brings you outside the park to where a cutscene plays featuring a mysterious man pulling up in his car, and grabbing you

teal imp
#

ehh

#

also Quentin being norman darby is off

#

like they might have done similar things

lapis sonnet
#

how? they look the exact same.

teal imp
#

but quentin was clearly meant to be his own character

lapis sonnet
#

have u read the books

teal imp
lapis sonnet
#

here ill find it

teal imp
#

when you save

#

it literally says "Quentin"

#

thats how we got his name

#

same with beatrix

lapis sonnet
#

thats why i said quentin/norman darby

#

and again they look the exact same

#

im trying to find the page

teal imp
teal imp
lapis sonnet
#

"I step toward the voice to find someone not much bigger than me in size and stature. He's small to the point of looking almost frail, with glasses too big for his face on his slender nose. He wears a windbreaker and pants even though it's summer, and though his hair tries to hide underneath a baseball cap, there's only so much unruliness a hat can hide." Chapter 9, page 124

teal imp
#

quentin has a helmet in hg

lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

hg clearly wanted Quentin to be his own character

lapis sonnet
#

well it didnt full release so haha

blazing latch
#

One message removed from a suspended account.

#

One message removed from a suspended account.

pale urchin
#

Ikr, I feel like I noticed my own mistakes and realized I can live better with FG Quentin, so far life is good

crude dew
#

I'm afraid the lore kept nonstop changing, as Carly also wrote the books, so nothing makes sense now
yay!

snow mauve
#

Oh but wait!

#

We got our lovely precious

#

Animated Series

#

That will explain everything!

#

Yes!

#

(Totally)

uncut mulch
#

Is the blue basement door cannon

lapis sonnet
#

which game has a blue basement door???

snow mauve
#

The new act 1

lapis sonnet
#

ohh okay ty

teal imp
snow mauve
#

You'll see on ep10

teal imp
#

still I dont get why Alex said act 1 and 2 are in a therapy session while they are quite clearly a nightmare

snow mauve
#

Because

lapis sonnet
#

the AS is different and the HN1 remake might also be

lapis sonnet
#

besides the AS thing

teal imp
teal imp
#

that would just ruin everything act 3 was trying to do

lapis sonnet
#

two diff therapy thingies

teal imp
#

I got the impression that he moved away not long after escaping

lapis sonnet
lapis sonnet
#

anybody know why in diaries the neighbor's house is different?

snow mauve
#

Because

#

Nicky's trauma

lapis sonnet
#

it looks different and in the books its described how it is in diaries

snow mauve
#

There you go

lapis sonnet
snow mauve
#

Like I said

#

Trauma

lapis sonnet
#

but in the memories its supposed to be accurate not trauma

teal imp
# snow mauve Trauma

I dont recall trauma messing up the way the way you remember certain buildings

#

maybe events are fuzzy but still

#

(I might be saying total bs Im sorry If I am)

#

lemme look this up

snow mauve
#

Hnd

#

Is act 3 sequel

#

Like literally

teal imp
#

ok so something like this is happening to nicky?

#

does this mean in HND he is trying to correctly remember everything?

unkempt sleet
#

Yea
The whole story of HND is Adult Nicky trying to remember what happened to Aaron

#

He got over his Trauma of Mr. Peterson in act 3 and now he's trying to remember the exact memories

lapis sonnet
lapis sonnet
teal imp
lapis sonnet
#

and then this game art:

#

and plus in the books the house is described differently than the act 1 house, despite the act 1 house being on the front cover

lapis sonnet
unkempt sleet
#

Its just Artists that draws them are not being accurate, i dont think its related to lore

lapis sonnet
#

ok i get the game art thing but in the memory its supposed to look and be accurate

unkempt sleet
#

I dont think most of the memory art is too accurateneighborlol

lapis sonnet
#

hm

unkempt sleet
#

Look at Long Leg Aaron for example

lapis sonnet
#

but also in the books the house is described differently

#

the 2nd floor is sounds like how it is in hn2

#

oh but also hn1 act 1 is a distorted memory so nicky prob doesnt remember the 2nd floor correctly

#

act 1 and the books have diff 2nd floors but it makes sense

lapis sonnet
#

u gotta accept the act 3 house is real

shell gull
shell gull
shell gull
lapis sonnet
#

but also yknow

#

hn1 is inaccurate

shell gull
lapis sonnet
shell gull
#

Since you should that HND art

languid geyser
#

i hope the remake happens.

shell gull
#

It’s a remake

lapis sonnet
shell gull
#

It’s gonna be the same

lapis sonnet
#

nah probably not

languid geyser
#

i mean

languid geyser
shell gull
#

Only problem I have is the weird extra floor the house has in AS, and most likely HNSR.

lapis sonnet
languid geyser
#

i feel like

#

you need to play hide and seek first

#

to then play hn 2

shell gull
languid geyser
#

its not hn hide and seek then 1 any more

#

its more like

#

hide and seek

#

then hn 2

lapis sonnet
#

correct

languid geyser
#

i feel like if they just called the 2nd game a reboot

shell gull
languid geyser
#

it would've fix the issue

lapis sonnet
#

its confirmed HNHS is also new lore

shell gull
shell gull
#

And where

languid geyser
#

i feel like if they just called the 2nd game a reboot, it would've fix the issue untill they have time to work on HN 1 remake

shell gull
languid geyser
#

they do but sometimes they mess up and thats okay

#

other devs have must up with there games

#

i can kinda forgive them time to time

#

even tho sometimes i feel like i shouldnt.

#

but i do

shell gull
lapis sonnet
#

with aaron's fire costume from HNHS

shell gull
lapis sonnet
shell gull
# lapis sonnet

Ik that, I meant I don’t remember seeing it in the game.

lapis sonnet
#

its a chalk drawing in front of petersons house

#

and plus AS ep 2 shows a scene from HNHS and AS and HN2 are a shared universe so boom

shell gull
shell gull
silver vine
snow mauve
#

I honestly can't tell

#

And no I'm not color blind

silver vine
#

it is green

#

blue is the color of the house

snow mauve
#

Alright

#

Thanks

shell gull
#

They should’ve went with the HN2 basement door, instead of a generic door that isn’t ominous whatsoever, like really the basement door in HN2 is spot on with the eerie vibe, meanwhile you got this shitty AS version.

teal imp
#

the SN/HN1 menu door is far more fitting in my opinion

#

seriously its criminally underused

#

it really good

grave rivet
tribal talon
#

they should use that door but put the alpha 1 door handle on it

lapis sonnet
#

this alpha 1 coma story still confuses me

#

i get that our car gets hit with a utility pole but why was the neighbor on the road too? is the neighbor real or no? I understand this is very old scrapped story I just think it is interesting

#

nevermind

teal imp
teal imp
#

I heard an interesting theory saying that the neighbor ingame was satan himself (who took the form of the last person you saw) and you were fighting for your survival

#

Which is well bizzare

#

A bit unrelated but I find interesting that all of plots used during the devrlopment of the game took place in the players head

#

From alpha 2 to beta 3 it was a nightmare about an abusive father from what I can tell

#

In fg all 3 acts are nightmares

#

First 2 being distorted memories

lapis sonnet
#

alpha 2 was straight forward

#

alpha 3 didnt have much except the thing was there

teal imp
lapis sonnet
teal imp
#

Alpha 2 is still clearly a dream

lapis sonnet
#

prototype-alpha 1 is the coma story

#

alpha 3 had no story

teal imp
#

Also theres a childrens bedroom there for no reason then

lapis sonnet
#

and alpha 4 and beta 3 had it so the neighbor was your dad and was abusive, so when u move back u have the trauma dream of the house being huge, but u face ur fear and in a secret beta 3 ending it shows that the basement was just a closet and u beat ur fear, then shows nicky start walking to the church to visit his fathers grave

lapis sonnet
#

ive created what i call the HN expanded universe, which is made up of multiple alternate timelines (the neighborverse lmaoooo)

teal imp
#

Have you seen the state of it? Also why would he have a childrens bedroom

lapis sonnet
#

with the main one being the retcon/canon timeline

#

then with the most important alternate timeline being the old lore timeline since it used to be canon

#

and then all the alpha timelines can be percieved as alternate universes too

#

like the prototype-alpha 1 coma story, whatever alpha 2 was, the alpha 4-beta 3 father story

#

not counting alpha 3 bc it has nothing

#

so i like to percieve HN lore as its own like multiverse

#

with a bunch of different timelines, the main and canon one being the retcon timeline

#

and judging by the HE ending we know that alternate realities exist in HN

teal imp
#

I just group them cause its clear what story they did have wasnt all that far off from the hello dad plot

lapis sonnet
#

the only bit of alpha 3 lore was the ending which is just him crying and it looks like he just moved in, with The Thing being in one of the rooms

teal imp
#

I think alpha 2/3 were an early draft of the hello dad plot

lapis sonnet
#

maybe

shell gull
#

I really predicted the Guest Origin

ripe berry
shell gull
grave rivet
#

Lol

#

Do you want a spoiler

unkempt sleet
#

We already know that

teal imp
#

he got such a huge downgrade

crude dew
#

poor soul
went to the wiki

how do we tell them?

shy kindle
#

LLet me tell you something..... What if Peterson in hn2 is not just a re-design, but it is him, but older? What if the Aaron (he is already not looking as he should in FG) as we saw him in the Museum, wasn't actually him? What if the guy, who hit us at the end of the game, IS the actual, grown up Aaron?

unkempt sleet
#

What

#

That's a really weird theory and i dont think there's any proof for that

shy kindle
#

I know

shy kindle
#

And did we actually know the story after the act 3 and hnd?

ripe berry
ripe berry
#

(HN1 pre-retcon was in 1996 except for Act 3, which was in 2017)

lapis sonnet
#

bc thats all old lore

#

and hn2 is new lore, and in new lore it takes place way too early to have aaron be an adult

shy kindle
ripe berry
#

Nicky never calls Aaron by name in the AS (he doesn't name drop Mya(I know her name is now Mia but I don't care) either) so he probably didn't know either of them

#

he just calls them "Peterson's Kids"

#

This makes it likely he never met them

#

(He also thinks they're dead, something he probably wouldn't want to think about if he knew them)

shy kindle
ripe berry
#

HND is Old Lore

#

You can tell because they use the name Mya and it directly copies text from the books

teal imp
#

I dont get why they made nicky and Aaron no longer friends

shy kindle
#

Again, the Neighborverse)

tribal talon
#

The reporter with the hat is he still cannon?

#

Or related to our story?

shut hill
#

Or missing journalist?

tribal talon
#

That one guy who fought the guest in hello guest

tribal talon
#

Shows up hidden in hello neighbor 2 alpha 1 a#

#

Yes

#

Yea him cause it can be him who hit us from the back from the ending cutscene

shut hill
#

Well he is canon to SN because he was an event so it’s kinda hard to answer that, ask a lore master about that

tribal talon
#

Well Michael does know more about the lore

#

He has an entire paragraph of the lore from Peterson birth to the game now

shut hill
tribal talon
#

Yea Michael huff has a huge page of the lore

#

In my old account he gave me the page but I lost it lol

shut hill
#

But I would say MITH is canon

tribal talon
#

I hope so

shut hill
tribal talon
#

Because if not it’s like they made him for nothing

#

Same for that other lady I forget names 😭

shut hill
tribal talon
#

Second player in hello guest ima write a list

#

Of names to get it right

shut hill
tribal talon
#

Yup

shut hill
#

Her name is Beatrix