#lore-discussion

1 messages · Page 20 of 1

shell gull
#

God Dang It

lyric zephyr
#

I’m sure they’re not gonna get rid of the brand new story they worked sooooo hard on…

ripe berry
#

They already said it's canon to Acts 1/2 and SN

lyric zephyr
#

They said it’s supposed to connect those events but
Anyone with half a brain can guess how they can connect

shell gull
#

I’m Dying Inside Why They Do This

ripe berry
lyric zephyr
#

While also decanonizing those same games

ripe berry
#

Yep

shell gull
#

Now The Story Feels Dumb To Me

ripe berry
#

AlexN said everything is canon so I got no fricking clue anymore

lyric zephyr
#

I think that was part of a joke

ripe berry
#

I know

lyric zephyr
#

“Everything is canon we’re all gonna die” or whatever

shell gull
#

The Idea Was Nicky Trying To Find Out What Happened To His BestFriend Aaron

ripe berry
#

Just referencing it

shell gull
#

NOW

#

It’s Just

lyric zephyr
ripe berry
#

Now Nicky is trying to prove Ted's a murderer because why the frick not

#

He doesn't even seem to really know the Petersons

ripe berry
#

He doesn't say "Aaron" or "Mya" ONCE

lyric zephyr
#

Nobody in the friend group even know the Peterson family outside of saying Peterson is evil

shell gull
#

But Did They Say Nicky Doesn’t Know Aaron Or Mya

lyric zephyr
#

Nobody says Aaron or Mya in the series

lyric zephyr
#

And he seems to care more about breaking in than actually saving anyone

shell gull
lyric zephyr
#

But the thing is he doesn’t care. He doesn’t even want to break in to save anyone

ripe berry
lyric zephyr
#

He wants to break in so he can have the satisfaction of being right on his theory of Ted being a murderer

ripe berry
shell gull
#

I Can’t Handle This, Why TinyBuild You Ruin The Best Character

lyric zephyr
#

Because they ruin everything HN they touch

shell gull
#

But AS Isn’t Canon To The Full Timeline As That’s Different

ripe berry
#

You Fool!

shell gull
#

Some Things I’m Guessing Would Be But Not All

shell gull
ripe berry
#

AS IS Canon to the Full Timeline

sand loom
#

Guys I have a lore question.

#

Why did they have to make the last 2 acts of the game a dream?

sand loom
lyric zephyr
#

AS is the full timeline now

shell gull
sand loom
#

Also, is there a HN2 Speedrun chat?

lyric zephyr
ripe berry
shell gull
lyric zephyr
#

Even HN2 isn’t fully canon to the AS

#

Since it’s set in 1996 and has different house layouts

shell gull
#

Exactly

#

I’m Guessing Nicky Is Still Friends With Aaron, Aaron Goes Missing

#

Trinity Moves In

#

Gets Pulled Into It

#

Nicky Goes Missing

#

Rescue Squad Tries To Save Nicky

#

Here Making It Simpler

lyric zephyr
#

Tbh, I’m going with Nicky isnt friends with Aaron at all. He doesn’t even know the kids, just thinks they’re dead.
If anyone Ivan was probably friends with them, since he’s supposed to have a “secret connection” to the Petersons

shell gull
ripe berry
#

That makes him panic when Peterson's mentioned

#

They never said Acts 3 and Finale are canon still, only Acts 1 and 2

lyric zephyr
shell gull
#

Still Though

#

Book 1 Still Canon In Full Timeline

lyric zephyr
#

Nope

#

AS retcons that too

ripe berry
#

They never said Hello Neighbor: Diaries was going to use the same clips it currently does when it comes out for real

lyric zephyr
#

It retcons every. Single. Thing.

ripe berry
lyric zephyr
#

Imagine it straight up just plays clips from the AS

shell gull
#

I Refuse To Believe Nicky Isn’t Friends With Aaron I REFUSE

lyric zephyr
#

Not 3D not drawn

ripe berry
#

Nicky may not be friends with Aaron at the time of what we have in AS

#

But after ending up in the Basement they could become friends

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Who said it's still a Underground Theme Park

shell gull
ripe berry
#

That detail is only in the Non-canon Books

shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
ripe berry
#

Semi-Canon is what the Games are

#

Books are clearly less canon then the games

#

The only thing less canon then Semi-Canon is Non-canon

shell gull
#

I Bet The Peterson Isn’t His Canon Last Name Anymore

#

The Only Canon Person At This Point Is Probably Harold Our Savior

ripe berry
#

Harold is only in the Non-canon books

#

Therefore he's non-canon

shell gull
#

Not Harold He Was The Only Good Character

ripe berry
#

If a Good Character is canon then they'll change them to make them a Bad Character

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Or they'll die within the Episode they're introduced back into the Canon

lyric zephyr
#

Don’t forget in HN2 that there IS no basement labyrinth
It’s 1 singular room

ripe berry
#

OR BOTH

lyric zephyr
#

Don’t forget how Enzo and Maritza’s mom is still alive for some reason

shell gull
#

What?

lyric zephyr
#

Yep

ripe berry
#

It's a throwaway line in Episode 2

lyric zephyr
#

Mrs Esposito is alive

shell gull
#

I’m Done Series Makes Makes Zero Sense Anymore

#

Let Me Guess The Series Is Non-Canon

lyric zephyr
#

The AS is the hip new canon

ripe berry
#

Series is Canon

lyric zephyr
#

AS is replacing all the canon with its own

ripe berry
#

That's just how it is now

shell gull
lyric zephyr
#

Just like the rest of us

ripe berry
#

Yep

#

Welcome to the Club

shell gull
lyric zephyr
#

Oh it DEFINITELY could

#

They just didn’t want to try

#

They gotta have it be modern so it’s easy to write for

#

And trendy

ripe berry
#

AS Pilot is probably their only attempt to make it fit in Animation

lyric zephyr
#

But even then they broke that canon too

ripe berry
#

After people hated on that they chose to scrap everything to make this new canon

#

Literally just because they got a little bit of hate they chose to scrap the Book Story

shell gull
#

Well, The Non-Canon Can Still Fit Into The Full Timeline No Worries

ripe berry
#

Like bro

#

Just make the AS follow a different set of characters

lyric zephyr
#

Or make it noncanon

#

Be it’s own universe

ripe berry
#

And have it be sometime after Act 2 and before GN2

ripe berry
lyric zephyr
#

Heck have it set before during and after Act 1 and have it as just people around town

#

New events and game events from a different perspective

#

Like each episode could be a different resident of Raven Brooks

ripe berry
#

Kinda like they were planning

ripe berry
#

But with Time Periods instead of just Characters

lyric zephyr
#

The Cops going through their Nog Simming story, Quentin’s first day in town, A group of 3 costumed kids exploring the forest on Halloween

#

Perfect for episodic stuff

shell gull
#

I’m Gonna Believe In The new Theory Timeline Of AS, Games, And Mostly Books Are Mixed Into A Conduct Timeline From Now On

ripe berry
#

Yeah they had the perfect chance to make new stories from pre-existing lore

lyric zephyr
#

But now they gotta make new lore

shell gull
#

Ima Be Back In A Bit

shell gull
#

I’m Back

#

If The Halloween Kids Are Canon And They Went Missing Why Are There Costumes In The Museum

#

?

#

My Guess Is If The Theory Of Each Golden Apple Coin Possesses A Soul Then They We’re Prob Murdered

dry depot
#

First that is not true

#

Cause the museum is a public place

#

So ppl would just walk in and see dead ppl I don't think that would be good for business

#

2nd in the game although the museum is closed that's only due to the fact that they lost the museum key

#

Other wise the museum is open

#

So I don't think ppl are comfortable with dead ppl in the museum

shell gull
dry depot
#

No

ripe berry
#

My Current Timeline Theory accounting for AS (and yes I'm putting Books 4-6 + 1 in there but only because they can be edited to work with WtRB):
1984 - Bosco Bay
Late 2011 - Bad Blood
Summer 2012 - Grave Mistakes, Puzzle Master
Early 2015 - Missing Pieces, Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek
Early 2016 - Welcome to Raven Brooks Episode 1, 2, and 3
March 2016 - Welcome to Raven Brooks Episode 4, Act 1
Spring 2016 - Rest of Welcome to Raven Brooks, Secret Neighbor, Hello Neighbor: Search and Rescue, Hello Engineer
May 2016 - Act 2, Hello Neighbor 2
2016-2035 - Raven Brooks Disaster
March 2035 - Act 3, Finale, and Diaries
2046 - Reset Day

dry depot
#

That isn't true

#

Cause mr. Peterson is there

ripe berry
#

It never was a Forest Protector Hideout

dry depot
#

And he isn't a forest protector

shell gull
#

Forgot To Put The Theory Is:

dry depot
#

So

#

That's no true

shell gull
#

But

dry depot
#

No I was talking about Mr. Peterson when I said that

shell gull
#

There’s A Theory It’s A Forest Protector Hideout Since That’s Where The Guest Was Summoned and Why’s There A Bunch Of Forest Protector Cult Items There Also Mr. Peterson Is Forest Protector Maybe?

#

He Helped Hide The Stolen Keys

#

For The NPCs Around Town Who Are Forest Protector

dry depot
#

Yea

#

But no

shell gull
#

The Theory Goes Like This

#

Basically

dry depot
#

Because the forest protectors are the ones who made his life miserable

#

They gave him bad luck

shell gull
#

Here’s The Theory

#

In AS

dry depot
#

Yes but here's the point

ripe berry
dry depot
#

He won't help them

#

Just because they have new goals

#

Won't change his mind

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Besides if they(The Forest Protectors) knew anything they'd know Peterson historically has bad luck

#

and that it might affect them

dry depot
#

Yea

shell gull
ripe berry
dry depot
#

Yea

#

Exactly

ripe berry
dry depot
#

Yea

shell gull
#

There’s A Theory That This New Group We’re Trying To Summon The Guest.

dry depot
#

You made that theory

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Also if Ted and the Forest Protector Cop(Keith Nielsen) were working together why would Ted need to hide in the Museum

ripe berry
#

The heck does Aaron have to do with that?

shell gull
#

What I’m Trying To Say Is Not That Ted Is Forest Protector But, He Had To Do With The Guest Being Summoned

#

He’s Collecting Golden Apple Coins In AS

#

The Statue Is Filled With Golden Apple Coins

#

At The Museum

ripe berry
#

Guest, technically speaking, has existed since at the earliest Secret Neighbor (because how else would the kids imagine it)

ripe berry
shell gull
#

Cuz The Forest Protector Rituals All Other The Place Around The Statue

#

The Statue May Be Some Sort Of Prototype Guest That’s Atleast My GUEST

#

Hahahah Pun Funny

ripe berry
shell gull
ripe berry
#

Ted's killing Forest Protectors

shell gull
#

Then Something Went Wrong That The Forest Protectors Did And They Summoned The Guest That’s Why They Stole The Keys So No One Finds Out.

ripe berry
#

There's no way they'd work together

#

He Wouldn't put them in the Statue

#

That's just wasting his little Luck he has for (to him) no reason

shell gull
#

Yeah, Exactly They Summoned It It Ran Away And Too Make Sure No One Found Out About The Guest They Stole The Keys And Locked The Place Up.

ripe berry
#

H U H

shell gull
#

Finally Someone Understands

#

The Theory

ripe berry
#

Where was Mr.Peterson when it got locked up

#

BC I don't think he'd let Forest Protectors do rituals when he's there

shell gull
shell gull
#

Early SN

ripe berry
#

Ted would need to already be in the building for them to lock up the "rooms with evidence"

shell gull
#

He Isn’t He Knew That’s The Only Place Cops Wouldn’t Search So He Ran Their

ripe berry
#

Because in your theory the Crow Statue IS Evidence

shell gull
ripe berry
#

and to lock that room they'd need to have locked up the entire building

shell gull
ripe berry
#

and for Ted to be in there after it was locked up he'd need to be in there when it was locked up since there's no signs of breaking through a window as far as I remember

#

Imma make sure just in case

shell gull
#

No He Did That’s How He Knew About The Museum

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Since that would be the only way he'd be able to enter after it got locked up

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Again I'm saying the Main Room would count as a evidence room

#

So it'd also be locked up

shell gull
#

What About The Door On The Roof

ripe berry
shell gull
#

I don’t Know How To Describe It’s White It’s Square

#

You Open You Drop Down

ripe berry
#

Can you send a picture

shell gull
#

Here I’ll Load On HN2 Rn

ripe berry
#

I'm going to double check for evidence of Ted breaking a Window you find this door you mentioned

shell gull
#

It’s Like That

ripe berry
shell gull
#

Here I’m On Xbox It’s Gonna Take A Bit

#

It Not Pn The Roof It’s On Second Floor Balcony

ripe berry
#

I was going to check for Unexplained Broken Glass on the Floor or smth like that

shell gull
#

Loading Into My Save

#

Yeah I Might It’s Easier On Foot Though

#

Here Going To Museum

#

HERE it is

#

Sorry About Shaking On Camera By The Way

#

Yeah Ik I Meant Second Floor

#

And Plus If Quentin Can Mantle I Think Mr. Peterson Can

#

Exactly

#

Ik

#

Same well Gotta Go See Ya

ripe berry
# shell gull

Pretty sure that room is in a spot where Ted wouldn't be able to get in still

#

It look to be above the map room

#

(Yes that's what I'm calling it)

#

The Map Room has no way without access to the rest of the Museum to get to any other room

#

At least not logically with how the other rooms are set up

#

Into the Garage? Only possible with outside help (which Ted wouldn't have)

#

Into the Main Room from the Room with the Forest Protector Painting?

#

The Side the Board's on makes this impossible

shell gull
#

I’m Back What Makes What Impossible

ripe berry
#

Yep

#

The Boards and Stuff make it impossible for Ted to get into the Main Room from the Trapdoor

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Or the way the boards are set up

#

Even if The puzzle was set up after the fact it would still be impossible BC of the Boards and how the Garage Vent works

shell gull
#

Me Too

#

Here’s The Problem

#

Only The Areas Where You Need A Key Were Pre Put There Everything Else Was Ted

#

So He Can Still Get To The Main Room Through The Garage He Just Put Up Boards To Make Sure Also I Forgot To Mention Ted Got In There Through The Garage Probably

#

He Probably Just Slid It Up The Garage Door And Parked His Car Then Boarded Up The Garage

#

Basically

#

Also Rooms Like This We’re Used For Rituals:

#

Don’t Think So

ripe berry
#

They do have lore but it's mostly self contained

shell gull
#

Oh Which DLC Was The Best Prob For Me Was Late Fees

#

Idk Didn’t Focus On DLCs

#

Yeah

ripe berry
#

Only in Back To School since we got the most info for it

#

So the Janitor is a old Principal of the Raven Brooks Middle School

#

Kids went missing and since no one could get proof for what happened eventually the School got shut down

#

Yep

ripe berry
#

Yeah

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Meaning BtS happens years after AS, Acts 1/2, SN, HE, HNVR, and HN2 Base Game

shell gull
ripe berry
ripe berry
shell gull
#

To The School Cuz He Got Knocked Out In HN2

shell gull
#

He Must Have Went There If It’s Implied That The Person Who Went And Investigated The School Went Missing Must’ve Been Him

#

Yeah But Quentin Wasn’t The Actual Person Who Went Their In The Canon

#

Right Or Am I Wrong?

halcyon cliff
#

Knock knock

shell gull
#

Whose There

halcyon cliff
#

Peter

shell gull
#

Peter Who

halcyon cliff
#

Peterphile

shell gull
#

Huh?

halcyon cliff
#

Shout it out loud

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Late Fees only gives hints at a story since we don't got the intended ending

#

But there's the Unknown Heart in the Restricted Section

shell gull
#

Cuz He Went Missing After HN2 Right

ripe berry
#

Implications of it be a family buisness

#

and that's about it

halcyon cliff
#

Cool peterphile

shell gull
#

And He Appears Back In Town To Solve Another Mystery Doesn’t Make Sense?

halcyon cliff
#

I think Mr Peterson is a peterphile

#

OMG

#

Figure it out

shell gull
halcyon cliff
#

Yeah

#

That’s the mystery if real life

shell gull
#

No Don’t Search That

#

Just Search On YouTube Hello Neighbor Realistic

halcyon cliff
#

Seen

#

It

shell gull
#

Please Don’t Tell Me You Searched Up Peterphile

halcyon cliff
#

It so funny what he is buzzlightyear

shell gull
#

Search Up Hello Neighbor If It Was Realistic And Watch That

ripe berry
#

(Just know the deleted message this is in reply to is talking about where Guest Kid is in HN2 FG)

shell gull
#

Gotta Go For A Bit

ripe berry
#

see ya both

halcyon cliff
#

Lore

#

P

#

So when the neighbour dies the guy who hits qeintin in the back of his head who is he

ripe berry
#

We don't know

#

It's one of the few things we don't know

halcyon cliff
#

Ok

ripe berry
#

Along with who takes Quentin back to the Banner

ripe berry
halcyon cliff
#

Oh no he is back

#

The guy from toy story

#

Potato a man

shut hill
ripe berry
#

Inserts Hello Neighbor Lore Explanation here

halcyon cliff
#

How does the DLC connect with the story

#

Ok

ripe berry
halcyon cliff
#

I will listen it midnight here I. Uk

#

Oh thanks

#

The librarian is strange

#

Though

shut hill
#

No

halcyon cliff
#

Yeah

#

Yeah

shut hill
#

Idk he just was still under bird, because we don’t see what happens next

ripe berry
#

Just going to send My Current Timeline Theory accounting for AS(Welcome to Raven Brooks/WtRB) again (and yes I'm putting Books 4-6 + 1 in there but only because they can be edited to work with WtRB):
1984 - The Secret of Bosco Bay
Late 2011 - Bad Blood
Summer 2012 - Grave Mistakes, Puzzle Master
Early 2015 - Missing Pieces, Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek
Early 2016 - Welcome to Raven Brooks Episode 1, 2, and 3
March 2016 - Welcome to Raven Brooks Episode 4, Act 1
Spring 2016 - Rest of Welcome to Raven Brooks, Secret Neighbor, Hello Neighbor: Search and Rescue, and Hello Engineer
May 2016 - Act 2, Hello Neighbor 2
2016-2035 - The Raven Brooks Disaster and Hello Neighbor 2's DLCs
March 2035 - Act 3, Finale, and Diaries
2046 - Reset Day

shut hill
#

Ok nvm

ripe berry
#

I don't really know

halcyon cliff
#

Same

#

Is it?

#

Merry Christmas

#

Yeah me know soz

ripe berry
#

Depends on if Missing Pieces is still (somewhat) canon

halcyon cliff
#

I don’t know either

#

I am being useless

ripe berry
#

Let me get something that'll help catch you up to speed on the pre-Welcome to Raven Brooks version of the lore

#

HN2 is still using Beta Lore here and HE isn't included but still for the most part it works

#

I know but at the very least it'll give him a better idea of some details

#

(I.E the Cultists/Forest Protectors)

#

and more, just mentioning them first

#

Of it does have HE in it

#

I just put really put the old Google Doc there so he has a better understanding of what we're talking about

#

Yeah

#

(Also I didn't make the Google Doc, GavinWK (who you probably have little to no clue who he is) did)

halcyon cliff
#

Thank you Festive Aiden I read the whole thing I understand

#

Yeah

#

Nicky has had a tough time from trauma to a long nightmare was act 3

#

K yeah

#

Yeah

shell gull
#

It Takes Place After HN1 Where Nicky Tries To Remember What Happened When He Was A Kid To Understand Where His Trauma Came From

#

Eventually He Remembers Everything And Now Understand Why He Had PTSD

shell gull
#

Everyone Knows That It Ties In With The Books But, Game Isn’t Fully Out So Might Be Changed

raven kiln
dry depot
shell gull
dry depot
#

Yea there you go

shell gull
#

Don’t Know Pretty Sure It Is

dry depot
#

Yea

manic dirge
crude dew
sage haven
ripe berry
#

(it'll exist even after I nail down months for the rest of the stuff in that listing bc I just listed "rest of Welcome to Raven Brooks" there)

ripe berry
#

and Secret Neighbor, due to being a imaginary plan, is also going to last until they actually do the plan(HNVR/SR)

cosmic vine
#

there should be a real gun in hn to kill mrpeaterson once so he will never return am i right

halcyon cliff
#

Yeah

ripe berry
#

Entire HN Lore summarized new:
Alpha Lore: So u in coma
Beta Lore: So you are the son of someone, you have a dream of that person, you go visit their grave at the end
Full Game lore: You are trying to save your friend, named Aaron, and end up having life-long trauma
Books 1-3 Lore: Basically the person whose son you tried to save in-game is a theme park designer and you now have 3 friends
SN Lore: 6 people try to save your player character from HN1
Books 4-6 Lore: You, Aaron Peterson, with the help of a couple friends and family members, nearly destroy a entire secret society that gives the whole town bad luck
GN1 Lore: ...
GN2 Lore: Theme Park Designer uses father's weather machine to cause a flood, and fights with a birb man before becoming the birb man
HE Lore: read message below
Book 7 Lore: TIME LOOPS
HN2 Lore: You Journalist that break into Homes on 3 streets to try to save Aaron
HND lore: A CUP OF COCOA WI-
WtRB lore: Everything isn't canon!

shell gull
tribal talon
#

so anyways whats the deal with the cult

#

i thought they were worshipping the ravens

#

but a raven killed that woman that maybe was a part of the cult

#

because of the golden apple coin that she had

#

and also in hn2 we saw the taxidermist yell at the ravens or something

ripe berry
#

The cult uses objects known only as "Luck Devices" in rituals to give them Good Luck but the town Bad Luck

#

They can also curse a family with Bad Luck

#

The Peterson family is proof of that (referring to cursing a family)

shell gull
shell gull
ripe berry
#

Yep

#

There's also the incident in Australia

shell gull
ripe berry
#

I thought in Book 1 there was mention of a Incident of a Park in Australia

shell gull
ripe berry
#

In Melbourne specifically

shell gull
#

Also Didn’t Ted Make A Famous Theme Park In Japan Aswell

ripe berry
#

You just got confused because I said Australia and not specifically Melbourne

ripe berry
shell gull
#

Idk

#

Also Isn’t There Like A Giant Statue Of The Guest Inside The Museum It’s Just Broken Threw Many Rooms

#

Such As This Room If You Look

#

In The Middle It’s A Big Pillar

#

And Through All The Rooms When You See This You Can Find Hands, Feet

#

Possibly A Head It’s All In The Shape Of The Guest

#

I Was Guessing It Was Based On The Big Guest Statue In HG

#

Here This Is What I’m Talking About

#

Cuz What Significant Does It Have In The Lore

#

I’m Guessing It Was The Forest Protectors Way Of Spreading More Rituals Across The Museum

ripe berry
#

I didn't list HG Lore in my lore summarized thing but it has no connection to Forest Protectors

crude dew
#

I don't think the meaning of the HG statue, and the meaning of the HN2 cultist statue is the same, but who knows

shell gull
#

The Structure Is The Exact Same As The Statue In HG

crude dew
#

I'm just saying in general, wasn't a reply

shell gull
#

HN2 Is The Rebranded Version Of HG

#

The Plot Is Very Similar

#

HG: Figure Out What The Secret Of The Guest Is And Where It Came From

#

HN2: Figure Out The Secrets In The Museum And How They Connect To The Guest.

#

The Main Plot Of HN2: Rescue Aaron

shell gull
languid geyser
#

thats great

#

but there was no need to call it HN 2 might i add.

shell gull
ripe berry
#

We know some of the stuff that happens between Acts 2 and 3

#

Like (Most likely) Trinity and Enzo getting married

#

(because we don't know if it was Trinity or not but it's heavily implied to be Trinity)

#

Or the Neighbor's House being burned down by someone

#

(Implied to be Aaron due to a statement that Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek would reveal who burnt down the house and Nicky def didn't do it, Theodore has no reason to do it, and the other characters in HNHS are all dead)

#

HN2 didn't really solve much of the unknown stuff that happened in-between Acts 2 and 3

crude dew
#

I'm still amazed, how many people think that you will get married to the first person you ever fell in love with lol
I'm saying in general, I don't really pay much attention about the Trinity and Enzo thing

ripe berry
#

Again with the Trinity and Enzo thing it's heavily implied because the way Piper describes Jess(One of Enzo's Kids in Reset Day) is almost exactly how Trinity looks

shell gull
#

Yes You We’re A Security Guard But Your Main Goal Was To Get To The Top Of The Mountain And Get To The Guest Statue

shell gull
#

In My Opinion It Did

ripe berry
#

Honest Hello Guest Lore Question: Why are we guarding a abandoned park?

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Seems honestly kinda odd that our player characters would choose to work as a Crow Guard for an abandoned location

shell gull
ripe berry
#

and that Beatrix would go after Quentin goes missing after Hello Guest Chapter 1(also known as Hello Guest Alpha 1)'s ending

shell gull
#

I Feel Like I’m A HG Nerd Honestly

ripe berry
#

Me who's been trying to figure out what future Hello Guest Chapters would contain for the past 3 months now:

dry depot
#

Probably not

shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
dry depot
#

?

shell gull
#

There’s The Secret That The Guest Is For Some Reason Guarding A Wall That Leads To Mayak

ripe berry
#

Actually in HGP the Guest seems to be trying to blow up that wall

dry depot
#

He destroyed the wall that leads to mayak

ripe berry
dry depot
#

Yea

shell gull
dry depot
#

I'm not sure

ripe berry
#

It seems like Quentin and the Guest have the same goal in HGP

dry depot
#

Not rlly

ripe berry
#

There's also the mystery person who turned on the window in HGP

dry depot
#

Quinton goal is to get to the top of the mountain

dry depot
ripe berry
ripe berry
dry depot
#

Yes

#

I agree

ripe berry
#

I never said Missing

dry depot
#

Oh srry

ripe berry
#

Mystery means we don't know much

dry depot
#

I read it wrong

ripe berry
#

Oh, it's ok

dry depot
#

I just like skipped the word and assumed it said missing

#

Bloopers

#

Lol

ripe berry
#

I'm going to start a Pinboard of Hello Guest Lore information so we can see what we have and what we need to know

dry depot
#

Yes

shell gull
dry depot
#

Who's mith

ripe berry
#

The Man in the Hat

dry depot
#

Oh

shell gull
#

He Was Supposed To Be The Secret Antagonist Of HG

ripe berry
#

The Guy in the ending of Hello Guest Alpha 1

dry depot
#

I'm who he is

#

I just didn't know he had a shorted name

dry depot
#

But I'm not ,too, updated on the HG side of things

#

So I wouldn't know

#

But I don't think HG is canon

#

So I'm still questioning that

shell gull
#

Idk

dry depot
#

I mean sure

ripe berry
#

Here's one question: Why does MitH try to grab our player character in HGA1's Ending

dry depot
#

Um maybe bc Quinton interacted with the guest

ripe berry
#

What does MitH have with Quentin and Beatrix that he seems to be invetigating them only to try to kidnap them

#

even BEFORE Quentin and Beatrix start their job at the GAAP

dry depot
#

He did

shell gull
#

MITH Is Trying To Get Rid Of The Guest, That’s Why He Snatched You, Cuz You Found Out Too Much About The Guest, He Didn’t Want Someone Getting In His Way.

dry depot
#

We didn't see Quinton and Beatrix until HG

ripe berry
#

Because he's the one holding the clipboards when we select our player at the start of HGA1

shell gull
dry depot
#

We see the clipboards in the HN2A

ripe berry
#

This may not count but he(MitH) also drives past when Quentin and Beatrix go to the GAAP in the intro

#

You can't see him in Quentin's Intro but they put him there anyways

dry depot
#

Guys you know where I think I've seen these things in real life

ripe berry
#

brb

shell gull
dry depot
#

(Unfunny joke moment) ohio

dry depot
#

Because Quinton in HN2 know a lot

#

And he never goes simming

#

Or does he

#

?

shell gull
dry depot
#

I mean yea

shell gull
wicked heath
#

but does he

dry depot
wicked heath
#

im pretty sure in any future update, we will play as the same character

shell gull
dry depot
#

So this could be a very difficult thing to solve

#

Not that it isn't already

shell gull
dry depot
dry depot
ripe berry
#

Back

shell gull
ripe berry
shell gull
ripe berry
#

and the Guest ends up kidnapping our player character(s)

dry depot
dry depot
#

But it's probably not canon

ripe berry
dry depot
#

Sense it was scraped

ripe berry
#

most of this stuff IS scrapped

dry depot
#

I mean true

ripe berry
#

Also this stuff(The Secret Ending) was intended to be Hello Guest Alpha 2's intro

dry depot
#

Ok

shell gull
#

Exactly, That’s Why Anything Before The Beta Is Practically Scrapped

dry depot
#

I'm kinda leaning into uncharted territory here

#

I don't know much about the HG stuff so I'm just using what ik in whole

#

Which is the Canon stuff

shell gull
#

From What Ik The Only Canon Thing There Is From HG Is The Mountain A.K.A The Guest Hideout

#

Or Mayak For Short

ripe berry
#

The Guest Hideout (Visitor_Den) is actually Rumble on the Mill

#

It's not at the Weather Station

dry depot
#

I'm pretty sure the Mayak isn't the guest hide out

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Tell me, does this look like it could be meant to be Mayak

dry depot
#

No not really

shell gull
ripe berry
#

That's the Mill

shell gull
#

Also The “Guarding Post” Was A Scrapped Idea Of A Place The Guest Protects

ripe berry
dry depot
#

Hence the name guarding post

shell gull
#

The Farm House

ripe berry
#

It's actually the Security Post shoved into the ground

shell gull
#

It Was Apparently Next To Mayak From What IK

ripe berry
#

The file for the area was left-over in HGA1

ripe berry
dry depot
#

Hmmm

shell gull
ripe berry
#

It's right where the ending gets trigged in HGA1

#

That's nowhere near the Top of the Mountain where the Mayak resides

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Right there is the Cafe Building

shell gull
#

Ahh Okay So Not Atop The Mountain

#

There’s Still That Scrapped Idea Though

ripe berry
#

What Scrapped Idea?

shell gull
#

There Was A Scrapped Location Atop The Mountain Where The Guest Would Protect For An Unknown Reason

ripe berry
#

Where did you hear about this?

shell gull
#

It’s Where I Heard Of The Mill

ripe berry
#

Do you still have the site?

shell gull
tribal talon
#

Guys i have an idea

dry depot
#

What is it

#

Tell us the I D E A

tribal talon
#

What if somehow quinten is kidnapped and is taken into the neighbors basement (ny whoever kidnapped us in the end of hn2)

wicked heath
#

you mean the basement with a COP IN THERE??

tribal talon
#

So we get to see the neighbors basement still exists but is covered to look like it doesn't exist

tribal talon
#

Is a secret doorway to get into tbat basement

wicked heath
#

theres a cop though

#

And you will take an eternity to convince me Keith is a Raven

tribal talon
#

The cop leaves the house and has no idea about the secret basement

dry depot
#

But I'm not gonna bother trying to convince you

wicked heath
#

Proofs?

dry depot
#

Well, I'm not sure I can

wicked heath
#

The books clearly shows he is against the cult and his game description tells us he always tries to be a good police officer

dry depot
#

I just herd in this chat that the npcs in HN2 are part of the cult

wicked heath
#

Only one so far

dry depot
#

So

#

Yea

opal steeple
#

he couldve been bribed i guess?

dry depot
#

Maybe

#

Never thought of that

tribal talon
#

Anyway that's just my lil idea

I wouldn't be surprised if the second part of hn2 is basically gonna turn out more crazy then part 1

Since i think thats fairly a hello neighbor trend tbh

opal steeple
#

i mean, he gives a key to baker gerda when you wake up on day 2, right?

#

you can see it on the cameras

dry depot
#

Yea

wicked heath
dry depot
#

That's one proof he is in cult

wicked heath
#

Just a key

dry depot
#

Being bribed or no

opal steeple
#

he's in some way connected to helping theodore, one way or another

#

not saying he's in the cult but

wicked heath
#

Its not even the museum key

opal steeple
#

who knows at this point lol

dry depot
#

Yea

wicked heath
#

exactly

dry depot
opal steeple
#

i doubt he does if he's not apart of it

wicked heath
#

He is defnitely on Brendas side though

dry depot
#

Most ppl don't know about it

opal steeple
#

"huh. hrrm"

#

brenda??? 😭

#

i think you mean gerda

wicked heath
#

Ugh

#

Brenda Yi

opal steeple
#

OH

wicked heath
#

the mother of Lucy

opal steeple
#

forgot about her

dry depot
#

Yea

opal steeple
#

havent read the books in 2 years

dry depot
#

That part of lore is really useless

#

To like the whole plot of HN

#

1 and 2

wicked heath
#

Also, just based on her cute room with stuff animals and even a pet cat, Gerda doesnt look like the kind of person who would commit murders

opal steeple
#

my question is

dry depot
#

But like she did lose her own child to a roller coaster

opal steeple
#

why would theodore choose these random people, like gerda, to hide keys to his home to keep his kid away from the public

#

wouldn't it be smart to just hide the stuff yourself??

opal steeple
#

?

dry depot
#

The key Gerda is keeping is to like a freezer room if I remember

opal steeple
#

the key in the cash register goes to the entrance of the museum

dry depot
#

Yea

#

Idk

#

This series is always changing and it's hard to keep track of everything

opal steeple
#

and the people theodore's convincing to help him are obviously very convinced to help, i mean gerda taking out the literal buttons to her register to hide the key

#

when in doubt, blame hello neighbor

dry depot
#

But this is lore chat

#

Not HN1 chat so thats besides the point

#

No HN2 is right after act2

#

So ye

#

Cause in HN1 Aaron distracts mr. Peterson

#

To help Nicky get away

#

And in HN2 we can see Aaron

#

Well you had too

#

If you were to get past the full game

#

K

ripe berry
#

I feel like HN2's Intro is right after Act 2

#

At least the part with Aaron

#

Yeah

#

Before Act 1 doesn't really make a whole lot of sense to me

#

and between Acts 1-2 also wouldn't make too much sense

tribal talon
#

Im fairly sure its not straight after act 2

ripe berry
#

Is it bc the Fortifications in Act 2?

#

Act 2 does happen just not as we see it

tribal talon
#

Well thing is hn1 and hn2 kinda feel like they have somewhat different universes kinda but ig so and just the changes to the house

Plus the neighbors beard and stuff

#

The neighbor gets driven more mad

ripe berry
#

The general Story Act 2 gives (Aaron helping Nicky escape the Basement and the ending cutscene) is correct, but the rest of it isn't

#

Tho the position of Theodore is different in the Cutscene so it works with the Tall Fence

#

He's prob actually just on his front porch in the Real in-universe Act 2's Ending

tribal talon
#

Naughty naughry

ripe berry
#

Exactly!

tribal talon
#

Makes sense

#

I guess what also makes sense is we see nickys posters around hn2

#

Ok ig it could be around the time nicky escapes

Hence the cops and stuff

ripe berry
#

Actually people have said that before

#

But hey glad to see others figure it out

tribal talon
#

Unless nicky had trauma and couldn't confess for a while which adds some time

#

Tho idk seems kinda useless

#

I still wanna know how does the neighbors house go up in flames

Thats why I think in hn2 we will be revisiting the house in the extention and perhaps it has more to offer then what we seen so far

ripe berry
#

As far as I'm aware it was never proven but heavily implied

ripe berry
#

that Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek was (at the very least) meant to reveal who burned it down

#

this means that A PERSON burned it down

#

and that this person had existed at the time of Hello Neighbor: Hide and Seek

#

Now the only characters that existed at this time was Nicky, Mr.Peterson, Diane, Aaron, and Mya

#

Diane and Mya are dead

#

So therefore it must be Aaron

ripe berry
tribal talon
#

Eh nah i don't believe in aaron burning the house anymore

#

I mean hide and seek is before hn 1 and the house is still there in hn2

Plus atm ut seems like aaron isn't angry at theo or anything

ripe berry
#

Also supporting evidence for Aaron being the one who did it if Mr.Peterson was going to burn down the house you think he would've done so before the cops showed up

tribal talon
ripe berry
tribal talon
#

Maybe the guest or just some other character all together

#

I can imagine if hello neighbor becomes a ghost game all of a sudden

ripe berry
#

Now then again Peterson's House burning down was seemingly retconned by Reset Day

tribal talon
#

I mean the game features weird entitys

Thing tho hes just an imagination of nickys of what represents fear to him

The guest whos a literal demon of some sorts

#

Ngl thing just feels like something fairly forgettable now after the guests appearance XD

#

U sure

We never rlly see him suffering from it

#

I mean only nicky sees it

#

I dont really think so as much honestly

#

Never really been a moment where theo was shown to see him

He could have his own demon or perhaps guest haunts him

Idk maybe he imagines myas ghost

#

Nicky or quinten seen the guest?

#

Oh never

#

Idk i read tbat different the first time

#

Ngl tho

I wonder who makes the better entity

The guest or the thing

#

I mean I would say guest cuz 1

It seems hes possibly more real then the thing

Tho I will say the thing did feel more crazy

#

Guest is more funny

#

But the thing was more distorted

His animations where weird and unhumanly for a humanoid figure

The sounds he makes

ripe berry
#

The Thing is literally a representation of Fears and Trauma

tribal talon
#

Tbh his figure is more slim like nicks whereas the guest from the chest side of things looks more like the neighbors figure

#

Or the guest could represent quinten too

ripe berry
#

Guest is more real then the Thing is

#

Guest is also a demon of some kind

#

A literal Demon unlike the Thing

#

(or not demon but supernatural being)

tribal talon
#

Im so scared they gonna go with a satanic route with hello neighbor

I really just hope that doesn't happen abd still kinda go with the more kid friendly thing

#

Tho in hn acc kid friendly

ripe berry
#

and has actually been shown to be able to take over people

tribal talon
#

Tbh i can imagine the neighbor having things of his wife and daighter

ripe berry
#

yeah

#

Fun Fact: The Guest wasn't intending to remain in Ted

#

It's heavily implied the Guest wants to possess Pris for some reason

#

Well I mean: in the intro of the Book when the crow flies by something seems to calling out Pris's name, in the red thingie (or as I call it Guest_Nest) it takes the form of Pris at the end there, and more I'm probably forgetting

#

and you deleted the thing I was about to reply to

#

Hey there you go, that's the most likely reason why

#

(that and maybe it's the only way the Guest can maintain a physical form for extended periods of time so why do a 2for1 by taking over someone that is taken for granted AND use them to have a physical form in this world for a extended period of time)

#

Perhaps the Guest is unable to leave physical form when possessing someone

#

To stop it off from getting turned off making it so that someone would have to go down there leaving Pris by herself

#

(That's my guess at least)

#

It also seems to need water to switch/enter bodies so it needed Pris in the water

#

But Pris was pulled out before it could get to her leaving the Guest inside Ted

shell gull
#

Can Someone Fill Me In On What’s The Topic

ripe berry
#

I mean, you wouldn't say Water is wet would you? and the Guest seems to be made with water

shell gull
#

Ok What About Him?

#

Ahh I See

ripe berry
#

I mean it forms from Water in GN2 and it's a goopy blob in the red space

shell gull
#

The Guest Possesses People Cuz His Goal Is To Spread In Order For Him To Spread There Needs To Be Agony In People That’s Why He Takes From People To Make Agony Worse

ripe berry
#

You know the space where among other things it mentions Regina's Dog Flan being dead and temp takes the appearance of Pris?

ripe berry
#

Yeah but before it does the Guest is a goopy blob

shell gull
#

The Nest Is Where The Guest Consciousness Resides

#

Early In Chat I Saw Some Talks In Chat About The Thing Connection With The Guest

ripe berry
#

Again the Guest probably uses water to form it's "Physical Form" so it wouldn't be able to be wet since water would just help keep it's physical form held together for longer

shell gull
tribal talon
#

Guess what

#

I am the guest

#

Click click

shell gull
tribal talon
#

Maybe the guest is made of ink and this is just the bendy and neighbor merge thing all over again but canon XD

ripe berry
ripe berry
#

Would also allow for that to exist without any of the SN kids having heard of the Guest

ripe berry
shell gull
#

There’s Also The Fact That At The End Of Hello Neighbor You Can See The Thing Is Breaking Into Teds Mind And Wouldn’t You Know It He Got Possessed By The Guest

ripe berry
#

Yep, wouldn't ya' know it

shell gull
ripe berry
#

Act 3 is not a dream

shell gull
#

True

ripe berry
#

Nikita said as much

shell gull
ripe berry
#

It's not actually happening IRL but it's not a dream

shell gull
#

True Remember Nicky Fell Asleep At Evening Then He Wakes Up It’s Still Evening

ripe berry
#

The only statement given as to what it(Acts 3 and Finale) is was that it was "Self Therapy"

shell gull
#

It’s Him Relaxing His Mind Getting Over It

ripe berry
#

thx

shell gull
#

How Many Times Has Nicky Had Therapy

#

He Had Therapy When He Was Kid Daily

#

He Went From Getting Therapy To Making Therapy

ripe berry
#

and the Thing Blowing up in Act Finale is Nicky getting over his trauma and fears of the past

#

(Note to get past the Basement where the Thing resides Nicky needs(or at least is intended to have) beaten those minigames specifically referred to as Fear Rooms)

#

The scene with the Neighbor trapped in the house is kinda symbolic of how the Neighbor was trapped because he couldn't stand up to his fears of losing his family

manic dirge
ripe berry
#

Don't really know but Nikita said so so it has to be true

manic dirge
manic dirge
#

@ripe berry

silver vine
#

so , guys

#

what if ||the person who knocks Quentin in HN2 ending is Norman Darby?||

unkempt sleet
#

Isn't Norman also Ted's friend?

silver vine
unkempt sleet
#

I mean if the guy at the end was Norman, He would help Ted instead of bonking Quentin on the head

silver vine
# ripe berry Explain

from the shadow, it looks like hes wearing a jacket similar to Quentin, and who we know wears similar clothes to Quentin? Norman Darby

silver vine
silver vine
#

or hes bald

#

if hes bald, I'd say hes the missing journalist, but, why would he be involved in this

lyric zephyr
#

He went missing, maybe he was taken and indoctrinated into the cult?

#

Like he's probably also the one who takes Quentin all the way back to the Banner

silver vine
#

like poor Ike

#

cuz he found Otto's cultist stuff

lyric zephyr
#

Also, I really doubt it's Norman Darby, since the AS ties into HN2 directly apparently and it isn't using the book story

#

and they share the same writers for the cartoon and the game

royal lake
#

Hi where's the General text

silver vine
lyric zephyr
#

They took the cult from it then threw the rest away

silver vine
#

I doubt they took only the cult

lyric zephyr
#

Oh right, sorry
The cult and character names

silver vine
#

the golden apple inventors club photo in SN and HE

#

it was added very recently in HE too

lyric zephyr
#

Yeah? They
Still have the inventors club as a thing even in the AS. Somehow still active.

#

But in the AS, Maritza doesn't even know Mya!

silver vine
#

true!

#

neither does she know about Peterson!

lyric zephyr
#

Nobody does except potentially Ivan!

#

Nicky Trinity Enzo and Maritza were never friends w/ Aaron and Mya, heck I don't think they've even met them personally

#

They know OF them! But they just don't care. They're breaking in for the hell of it, or at least Nicky is.

silver vine
lyric zephyr
#

He's not, I can already predict. He never refers to Aaron by name, he keeps thinking Aaron and Mya were murdered, he doesn't even have the foresight to see what Ted does outside of his house like he does in the books

#

He just says "Mr Peterson murdered his kids! I gotta break in, hey you guys wanna break in I wanna break in"

unkempt sleet
silver vine
lyric zephyr
#

Sorry, AS doesn't match up with that. Can't possibly be canon

#

AS is the new canon.

silver vine
#

:(

unkempt sleet
silver vine
lyric zephyr
#

No idea

#

Heck they're not even blueprints they're just copypaper doodles

silver vine
#

its in Peterson's study too

lyric zephyr
#

Asset reuse without lore implications I guess? Unless Nicky stole a copy he had lying around

unkempt sleet
#

That sounds like a thing Nicky would do tbh

silver vine
#

wait

#

why does AS and HN2 have different principals

lyric zephyr
#

because

#

They do not care about the lore

#

Heck why isn't the school abandoned?

#

They legit made it from a different school to the HN2 School intentionally, they added the broken clock last minute

silver vine
#

prob gets abandoned later ig

lyric zephyr
#

But in HN2 it's implied the school's been closed for

#

Years

#

Janitor was the Principal back when he still had color in his hair

silver vine
#

the old design for the school in AS was red

lyric zephyr
#

And it didn't have a clock tower

silver vine
#

and no clock

silver vine
lyric zephyr
#

They legit changed it last minute bc "Hehe hey what if we made it VAGUELY HN2 without changing the lore at all.."

#

because the school shape isn't even right

silver vine
#

maybe its just an easter egg, and not the actual HN2 school

lyric zephyr
#

Yeah

#

Let's go w/ that

frosty wedge
#

Wait

#

I just found out that Mr. Gershowitz's full name is Ike Quentin Cornelius Gershowitz

#

I mean it could've been found

#

But just wanna point it out

toxic mist
#

Yeah it was

#

Seems like a funny coincidence

#

Unless the true ending of hn2 is gonna be him getting chased by the fps and dying which is the prologue of book 4

#

That would mean his nickname is quentin

#

Of course why tf would the neighbor be in the hideout then

#

Nevermind

frosty wedge
#

Yeah lol

frosty wedge
#

Maybe they just found a random corpse in the factory

#

Btw where'd you guys get the deluxe detective role?

opal steeple
#

you can't get it anymore but you got it if you filled a forum showing proof that you preordered HN2

#

at least i dont think you can get it anymore

manic dirge
opal steeple
#

the role?

manic dirge
opal steeple
#

i forget but it was a pinned message on the main channel

manic dirge
#

dang i got deluxe but i was too late

opal steeple
#

rip

manic dirge
toxic mist
# frosty wedge Btw where'd you guys get the deluxe detective role?
loud tartan
#

it doesn't work anymore

#

wdym

strong coral
#

What is your favourite HN books

wicked heath
#

First 2 trilogies

#

everything after that is awful

proud sable
shell gull
tropic sedge
#

hey

shell gull
#

Ok This Is For Something In #hello-neighbor

#

Basically The Reason Why We Don’t See The Guest That Much Is Cuz They Currently Don’t Have An AI Ready For It But

unkempt sleet
#

Thats not true

#

They have an ai for Guest

manic dirge
shell gull
unkempt sleet
#

They literally made him a good Ai in the Alpha's

pure ivy
#

they do

#

they have an AI

shell gull
pure ivy
#

im pretty sure like

#

lore-wise

#

he actually is still here

#

just not VISIBLE

#

-opening
-shovel nightmare cutscene (at the door)
-the crow statue above the museum (makes sense in the ending too)

manic dirge
#

for 1 SECOND

manic dirge
pure ivy
#

his MODEL, was in the game

#

for 1 second

#

the character is still basically in, but its not obvious enough

shell gull
pure ivy
#

lmfao

shell gull
pure ivy
#

origin?

#

dude

#

there IS no origin

manic dirge
shell gull
tropic sedge
#

dude this is so disappointing, guest was my favorite thing about the alphas and the fact that he isn't in the final game is such a massive let down

pure ivy
pure ivy
#

we have no idea

pure ivy
#

all we have are theories

#

theres no CONFIRMED theory

manic dirge
#

they couldve used the AI from hello guest

shell gull
# pure ivy the guest???

Yeah There’s A Theory A Couple Guys Made Don’t Have Their Discord Names But, If You Look Around The Museum There’s So Many Guest Related Things Even Though Cultists use The Place, Possibly They We’re Trying To Summon The Guest But When They Did It Went Horribly Wrong And The Guest Ran Into The Neighborhood, They Then Stole The Keys To Make Sure No One Could Enter And Find Evidence. Pretty Cool Theory I’m Not 100% On It But It’s A Cool One

pure ivy
#

uhhhh

wicked heath
#

ravens is an entire cult

#

the Guest is independent

shell gull
# pure ivy <:detectivewhat:614537899450433546>

Lemme Explain The Cultists Believe The Guest As A God, They Filled The Statue With Golden Apple Coins, As A Offering Finally When They Tried To Summon The Guest It Was Disobedient, And Ran Off Into The Town They Didn’t Want Anyone Finding Out So They Stole The Keys To Make Sure No One Would Find Out.

pure ivy
#

dude

#

this is

wicked heath
#

Again: The guest is NOT the statue!!

pure ivy
#

no

shell gull
pure ivy
#

i literally have a theory that makes more sense than this

shell gull
pure ivy
#

Guest World still being in play

pure ivy
#

it sounds stupid, but hear me out

shell gull
pure ivy
#

We've seen what the guest can do