#Alternate History of Sorland - What if the Civil War of 1928 was avoided?

292 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

azure remnant
#

Let's do a bit of Alternate history here because why not.

Let's imagine in another world that General Rikard won't attempt to seize power from General Luderin, what would Sorland in 1954 would look like?

austere bluff
#

SergeWolkner Serge president

hollow pulsar
#

Artor Wisci was a very large idealist and liberal and would've done many reforms too expand the freedoms and rights of Sordland

#

We could see a new ideology about Freedom and Protection of rights for the people

#

Wiscism

#

I think the guy was also a massive Centrist

hollow pulsar
austere bluff
hollow pulsar
#

👑SergeWolkner : All Hail King Serge First of His Name and King of Sordland!

fresh hill
#

Assuming the coup doesn’t happen? The BFP become the main opposition party (per the codex) and Wisci’s SRP continues in government. The SRP eventually splits as the years go by due to the lack of cohesion now that the republic has been built

#

But say if Luderin coups and Rikard doesn’t rise against him? He establishes a fascist dictatorship. Might pull a Franco where he goes “yeah we’re technically a monarchy but I’m the regent”

hollow pulsar
fresh hill
hollow pulsar
fresh hill
#

Certainly. Sordland would be a much better place if Luderin didn’t coup

hollow pulsar
#

Rumburg may not even start destabilizing Sordland with the country being so stable. Their military might would be much more significant

#

The scars inflicted by the civil war were significant and halted Sordish growth significantly

fresh hill
#

I think that Rumburg would still try to destabilise Sordland. After all, Beatrice is an expansionist and there will always be weaknesses in Sordland that she will seek to exploit

austere bluff
#

artor would sell sordland out to rumburg

#

this is very true

#

verified by real NFP patriots

hollow pulsar
hollow pulsar
# austere bluff verified by real NFP patriots

On the subject of the NFP. Theyd probably be given another name but would not attract much support from the public. Nationalism thrives in hardship and there ain't no hardship in this timeline

ember slate
#

BFP being a mostly bludish based party would struggle to keep up as Wiscis party loses the post revolution support it once had

#

All while communist, monarchist(there was one mentioned in the codex), and nationalist parties gather a base from disgruntled Wisci supporters

hollow pulsar
#

The Sordish Monarchist Restoration Party

#

SMRP

fresh hill
ember slate
ember slate
tiny dirge
#

Luderin would probably still be in charge

#

and there would be a lot of intrique as to his succession

#

Sordland would also be pro-Rumberg

hollow pulsar
hollow pulsar
#

Rumburg never liked Sordland and i doubt that Luderin would take that lying down

tiny dirge
#

presumably he would have returned the favor

#

and Rumberg at that point was shopping for a new ally since they'd lost Valgsland to the Communists

hollow pulsar
#

They hoped that they'd get new trade agreements and maybe some land

ember slate
austere bluff
#

Wisci would likely establish a multi-party parliamentary republic.

#

I'm actually uncertain whether Sordland would be as prosperous -- Soll did a lot to develop Sordland's industrial base.

#

Perhaps if Sordland solicits greater Western investment it could develop rapidly, but that's a strong "perhaps."

ember slate
hollow pulsar
solar folio
#

Luderin would be quite old by the time they start looking south

#

Roughly the same age as Soll

#

Or Artor Wisci

#

Probably younger than Artor, but old by 1954 nonetheless

hollow pulsar
austere bluff
austere bluff
hollow pulsar
hollow pulsar
austere bluff
hollow pulsar
#

But Artor would maintain friendly relations with Rumburg inmo since they have a more empowered army and more modernized infrastructure

#

Much at Beatrice's dismay

austere bluff
#

Rumburgian King Edward saw an opportunity to claim the riches of Renan when his country was still suffering under economic problems due to the War of Dying Roses. He seized the moment and attacked the northern borders of Renan, razing many settlements. As the battles went on, the war slowly started to look worse for Renan when Rumburg inched closer to the heartland of Sords. At this time Albrecht was growing too old to lead the nation, already in his late seventies.

https://codex.torporgames.com/renan-aristocracy

feral heath
austere bluff
#

Like you'd have to occupy the entire country, which is massive, in order to bring Beatrice to justice.

#

She's not letting you execute her, lmao.

hollow pulsar
#

And it would NOT look good at the next AN meeting

#

But so we all agree with Artor still in charge that Sordland will basically be OP?

hollow pulsar
#

With Artor in charge Free speech would be preserved. He maintains good relations with the West and increases trade volume. Infrastructure will remain untouched and continue to grow. People will not be discriminated against on a larger scale compared to Soll

feral heath
hollow pulsar
#

He is a BIG upgrade

feral heath
austere bluff
austere bluff
hollow pulsar
#

All we need is an Anton Rayne to lead Sordland into GREATNESS

#

But that's a big IF since I think the civil war had a big effect on the people in government

#

Anton Rayne may just be some random joe in Holsord

agile plume
#

I don't know if anton rayne would be intrested to be the president if there is no civil war in sordland

#

But i think he's still gonna enter the world of politic

hollow pulsar
austere bluff
#

It seems like Rayne's involvement in politics does kind of stem from the civil war to some extent.

#

Plus, the establishment of a new party like the USP enables his greatest career opportunity.

agile plume
austere bluff
#

Not everyone wants to desperately cling onto power until they die.

fresh hill
#

Wisci would probably retire after a term or two. He’s an old man

agile plume
#

He's to powerfull to let down

#

And sordish population love him

#

But yes he's probably not intrested to be lifetime president

fresh hill
# agile plume Doesn't mean he can't

Any politician with enough popular and party support can continue to be in power. But being in power does take a toll on your mind, body and other aspects of life

agile plume
austere bluff
#

Wisci would probably serve as President under the SRP for perhaps a single more term (1928 - 1932) before retiring.

#

I don't see the coalition outliving his tenure as President, either.

hollow pulsar
#

He would probably go into writing just like his college days in Lespia after retirement

agile plume
#

AntonRayne :Its finnaly my time to shine

austere bluff
fresh hill
#

The codex doesn’t mention when exactly Artor began his political activities but I’m guessing he’s been at it for decades. He’ll serve 1-2 terms and then retire to live out his days in peace, being well-respected and seen as the father of the country. If I were in Artor’s position, I’d go for a max of 2 terms and then let someone younger take the Presidency

hollow pulsar
ember slate
hollow pulsar
agile plume
#

Sordland people would praise wisci like tarquin soll

austere bluff
#

I don't think he would ever codify a specific ideology named for himself, that seems out of character for him.

austere bluff
ember slate
austere bluff
#

Soll went to personal lengths to cultivate a cult of personality.

#

I don't think Wisci had any such intentions.

ember slate
agile plume
# austere bluff I highly doubt that.

I mean, he did alot for the country, just like tarquin soll, but his short term probably gonna be remembered to be one of the greatest reform of sordland

austere bluff
#

There's a clear difference.

fresh hill
#

Wisci wouldn’t have the same legacy as Soll. People would still try to claim Wisci’s legacy but Wisci wouldn’t build a cult around himself (unlike Soll)

hollow pulsar
austere bluff
ember slate
austere bluff
#

And, I mean, of course there'd be a faction of liberals in a Wisci tradition.

agile plume
austere bluff
#

Or that they mandated it.

hollow pulsar
fresh hill
ember slate
austere bluff
austere bluff
#

Is it a little weird? Sure.

#

But it's a different thing to what Soll does.

#

Seeing as Soll was literally President when that policy was enacted.

hollow pulsar
agile plume
#

Indeed and wisci is not a person like that

ember slate
austere bluff
ember slate
austere bluff
#

Allowing the player to make "alternate history" in a game diminishes the main project.

#

IMO.

hollow pulsar
#

I don't think we should PLAY as Wisci. More like get extra dialogue and info about him and what he did

fresh hill
#

I’m not really in favour of a Wisci dlc but I’m down for more lore on Wisci

ember slate
fresh hill
#

The whole First Republic era (1923-27) is a lost time for Sordland. I can only imagine the frustration and depression felt by the revolutionaries of 1923 once Luderin couped and the ensuing civil war

austere bluff
#

I think The Death of Malenyev would be a cool game.

ember slate
austere bluff
#

You'd have a loading screen with maybe 3 or 4 playable characters, and you'd get a short post-Malenyev power struggle story to play through, with a few different outcomes and an epilogue.

#

Probably 8 - 10 hours of content total?

agile plume
#

I mean, we would learn about him but in other dlc

fresh hill
# ember slate I feel if needs it’s own codex page to go into detail of the lead up to the civi...

Agreed. The current lore on it is “there were protests and unrest, Luderin took things into his own hands and couped on grounds of rising communist influence and unrest, Rikard counter-couped and then the civil war began”.

We still don’t know what exactly led up to Luderin’s coup though. Did Wisci piss off the conservatives and the Church too much? How did he anger the military? Stuff like that

#

Coups don’t happen out of nowhere. My guess is that the relationship between Wisci and the army was shaky, troubled and weak from the start

ember slate
ember slate
fresh hill
# fresh hill Coups don’t happen out of nowhere. My guess is that the relationship between Wis...

The codex mentions that although the revolution started with Heron Walt’s resignation, it wasn’t until the army joined in that Egmund was finally ousted.

Piecing together inferred info from the game (in that the army went along with Luderin and didn’t question him until some time later) and Naro’s statements on Rikard, I think that the relationship between Wisci and the military was uneasy from the start. The reluctance of military officers to counter-coup Luderin to restore Wisci and the Republic shows that they didn’t value him. They only supported him because he could challenge Egmund. And once Luderin challenged Wisci and won, they toed the line and accepted Luderin

agile plume
fresh hill
#

Traditionally speaking, the officer corps of most militaries tend to be from the upper and upper middle classes who lean conservative and right wing - especially in the time frame of the 1920s. There are, of course, exceptions to this but the socioeconomic composition of the officer corps can’t be ignored in understanding how Wisci was couped and why the army didn’t come to his aid

#

I can imagine most military officers being skeptical and concerned over Wisci’s reforms and democratisation

ember slate
fresh hill
#

Aye

#

After all, it’s one of their own

#

In group vs out group dynamic

ember slate
#

Military officers are also more receptive to marking with the military

#

Most probably had their moral compasses suppressed until it got to the breaking point that caused Rikard to counter coup

#

It could also be that they were biding their time to counter coup until a good moment

hollow pulsar
#

Wisci knew the dangers of letting Military into politics and didn't let them. That was his undoing

ember slate
#

Getting a coup to work is about striking fast as seen in the 50s coup in the Kingdom of Iraq when all it took was one division driving by Baghdad to take over government before a response could be organized or leaders to flee

hollow pulsar
#

Too much change way too fast

hollow pulsar
ember slate
hollow pulsar
#

Where they more Markian than Sordish? What kind of Kings and Queens did they have? Did one of them leave a lasting mark on Merkopa? Or did one of them lead a dark period in the countries history?

#

This is the type of shit I wanna know

hollow pulsar
#

So little info about an amazing period of history

agile plume
#

Lets hope the 2.0 amandement update also bring more info

#

In the past

ember slate
#

So it could be interesting

hollow pulsar
#

They were initially a Markian Trading family

#

It would be awesome to see the culture blend

ember slate
hollow pulsar
#

I swear if I get another riot I'ma go all Soll on them

ember slate
#

Info on the warlord period could explain why the Marks aren’t around anymore (genocide) and how someone presumably as young as Egmund was able to secure his own kingdom during the century of revolutions

#

The power dynamics of other nations trying to get their guy on top

timber cave
ember slate
agile plume
abstract charmBOT
#
restoria374 has been warned

Reason: Mass emoji

hollow pulsar
ember slate
agile plume
#

True

ember slate
#

This universe version of The Great Game

agile plume
hollow pulsar
#

But yes I need more info on the history of Sordland

#

There is so much lost info I've yet to learn

agile plume
#

Are amandement 2.0 update also bring more info for sordland history?

timber cave
#

Yea they said they’re adding a lot of new codex articles

agile plume
#

Yay

ember slate
#

I need more info to create dumb theories like “What if X warlord united sordland instead of Egmund”

timber cave
#

Egg mound

ember slate
#

Now I most return to two of the best songs ever created

hollow pulsar
#

Renan has so much history but all that's been labelled in the codex is "They made healthcare and all died lol"

#

They deserve more in the codex

#

Also I want more info about the Markians if there's a chance

#

What happened to them? Are they still around?

#

Were they even around of the Markian Empire collapse?

#

I need ANSWERS

agile plume
hollow pulsar
#

I will finally rest

agile plume
ember slate
#

Like it says King Egmund conquers Agnland when in fact he didn’t

#

It had been apart of “Sordland” for a century

wind olive
wind olive
ember slate
wind olive
wind olive
hollow pulsar
ember slate
wind olive
hollow pulsar
#

So basically the royal family like the UK?

ember slate
wind olive
#

but i could see wisci doing a major peace conference between agnolia and valgsland on heljiland

#

and creating an eastern merkopan union

ember slate
#

Or attempting at least

wind olive
#

there was an rp on what would have happened if wisci didnt get couped

#

but it ended up that it became more of a 1984/squid game combo

ember slate
hollow pulsar
stray spade
#

Is it just me or do Holstron and Livingston have a similar skin color?

#

If not the same

hollow pulsar
#

Maybe he has rummish heritage?

#

It ain't impossible since the countries are so close and immigrants used to come back and forth a while ago

timber cave
#

Remus would kill himself if he wasn’t a 100% purple blooded

hollow pulsar
#

Dude would have a mental break

hollow pulsar
#

RemusHolstron : Fuck A Morgna Wes Core! Long Live Rumburg and god preserve the queen!

agile plume
hollow pulsar
#

Wiscism is the true path to prosperity

low wraith
#

To answer the question of if the civil war was avoided does that mean Luderin doesn’t coup Wisci at all or does Rikard not intervene/is removed which prevents him from stepping in when he tries to stop Luderin

hollow pulsar
#

ArtorSWisci fly high my sweet prince, too good for this world 🕊️

low wraith
hollow pulsar
#

Monarchism would still have a bit more traction tho later on, rather than monarchists being all but stomped and exiled from Sordland in our timeline

#

I still like to think that theirs a party that's pro-monarchy and wants to put Jules on the throne, while promoting Neutrality and Self sufficiency

low wraith
low wraith
hollow pulsar
#

This one

hollow pulsar
low wraith
#

Ah then yeah I’d agree with that

#

Maybe even lead by Jule if she were allowed back into the country

hollow pulsar
hollow pulsar
low wraith
hollow pulsar
#

Maybe give her the equivalent of a Member of Honor title so no one can touch her and so she's protected

low wraith
hollow pulsar
#

Artor would also be loved by the younger population too, since he was a huge sponsor for equal education

low wraith
#

I think that the support amongst the youth would vary based on the region

hollow pulsar
#

The more wealthier and more rural towns and regions (Nargis region and Narbel for example) would have alot of support for him since he opened rural institutes and schools and colleges within the city's and rural areas

low wraith
low wraith
solar folio
#

I should point out that up until Luderin's coup, Sordish ethnic nationalism and monarchism were tied hand in hand. Egmund claimed to be of "purple blood", an idea that is still promoted by Sordish nationalists in the game. Without Luderin, I could see nationalists and fascists within Sordland remaining firm royalists, which honestly might cause some alternate civil war down the line. In our timeline, the nationalists are willing to partake in the democratic process and change the republic from the inside, but they might be less willing if they are straight up calling for the restoration of the monarchy

timber cave
#

Erm actually Luderin was a monarchist 🤓☝️

solar folio
#

Really? Is that an addition to the lore from 2.0? Neat if so

hollow pulsar
#

Hm so even if we didn't have a Monarchist Restoration Party, we could have a party that'd want to preserve Sordlands past and that is very reactionary (Don't tear down symbols of the kingdom, fuck the Bluds, self sufficiency, no ATO or CSP)

timber cave
hollow pulsar
timber cave
#

Which was added in 2.0

hollow pulsar
#

It could be a WPB situation where they are constantly being accused of having ties with the terrorist group and having a bad rap

timber cave
#

But the 4 factions being monarchist/nationalist, communist, wisci, and sollism has been around since the end of the suitcase ARG I believe

hollow pulsar
#

BFP is in line and agrees with alot of Wiscis ideals

#

Just throwing it out there

hollow pulsar