#lore-and-universe

1 messages · Page 472 of 1

faint stone
#

Elite ai in ce frightens me

jade wave
#

Reach elite ai were superior to halo ce elite ai

tepid vault
#

The melee was nightmare fuel in reach

pulsar pivot
#

Oh

#

That one ultra in tip of the spear

terse lava
#

I think the CE ones are still better then reach. The always seem to keep their distance rather then attempt to close with you

versed helm
#

They certainly love to jump off bridges in CE.

jade wave
#

I think I had a stroke when I read this cause what I read was not what you said I am very sorry

versed helm
#

what was this suppose to be the flood i remember seeing this when i was little

#

ew it burns my eyes

#

I believe that was fraudulent art work for Halo 4.

#

ohh

#

There is no purpose behind the image, other than to deceive people and gain their attention.

#

gotcha

pulsar pivot
#

Either way I dont want to see that gravemind ever

versed helm
#

The relevance of my description is pretty amusing, lol. It applies to every false statement regarding Halo Infinite.

#

goi on

carmine sleet
versed helm
#

Yeah, to summarise, people keep spreading misinformation about the game.

carmine sleet
#

Still wish that one person hadn't made an April Fools Joke about the game being delayed again

versed helm
#

That entire event demonstrated how eager everyone was to believe in such lies, lol.

carmine sleet
#

To quote Quentin Beck, it's easy to fool someone when they're already fooling themself

versed helm
#

It also proved that 343i are the only credible source of information for the game, at the moment.

carmine sleet
#

I mean, that was kinda obvious

versed helm
#

It was not blatant enough, apparently.

#

I believe that Kotaku made the mistake of publishing the post as official information.

carmine sleet
#

They did

versed helm
#

you think they will make the halo movie

vocal aspen
#

They already have

versed helm
#

the one for hbo or stars what ever it was

#

is it worth watching this

#

WOW thats a long video

pulsar pivot
#

That's not a official movie

versed helm
#

it has evething though to catch up right

#

for halo infinate

pulsar pivot
#

Yeah

#

Touche

versed helm
#

Landfall includes footage from a cancelled film that was being directed by Neill Blomkamp.

vocal aspen
versed helm
#

This is my favourite trailer that Bungie ever released.

#

i heard district 9 is halolandfall

versed helm
#

How

lyric cedar
#

i feel like the didact is a marval Villon

carmine sleet
#

District 9 rose from the ashes of the Halo movie

gilded mason
#

I can't believe we're finally getting a sequel.

carmine sleet
#

Halo Landfall is not footage from the Halo movie as they never actually got that out of preproduction

vocal aspen
#

Didact doesn’t really act like any marvel villain iirc.

lyric cedar
humble yacht
#

He does monologue a bit and he’s got cosmic powers

lyric cedar
#

kinda like ultron but without the comedic lines

carmine sleet
#

To be fair, Ultron in the MCU isn't the most accurate depiction of a villain in the MCU. His comic book counterpart is much less comedic

#

And allot more cold and calculating

humble yacht
#

James Spader brought some life to ultron

lyric cedar
#

didact and ultron both have badass voice actors

versed helm
#

Film's will never be perfectly accurate to lore

humble yacht
#

I’m pretty sure that footage that was supposed to be in the halo movie was repurposed for district 9

versed helm
#

Landfall was a Halo:3 trailer. They were trying to find the Chief's landing coordinates

versed helm
humble yacht
#

Nope

pulsar pivot
#

I mean

#

Is there any halo reference

pulsar pivot
#

So since graveminds learn from what they infect I wonder what all that one gravemind knew when he got the prophet of mercy

unique rune
#

Probably just bits and pieces of Covenant history blended with political maneuvering

slim thorn
#

That makes the main question I give couple of days before was like remains questionable. I kinda doubt that Gravemind possess strong attitude, considering he is manipulative, but applies mind-invasive doctrine. Someone from Yuri could mind-control him with ease if his mind is actually weak.

humble yacht
#

Why would you think the gravemind would have a weak mind?

#

Everything about it suggests it has a strong will

pulsar pivot
#

And it is very intelligent

craggy sierra
#

Also all gravemind's are the same. It downloads it's consciousness from the intergalactic flesh cloud or whatever.

#

So the gravemind of H2 is functionally the same one that saw the encounters with the forerunners up to the firing of the array.

pulsar pivot
#

Interflood

#

The google of flood

shy hedge
#

Are there any reasons the covenant speak English? Other than gameplay

gilded mason
#

Mostly because of translators, sometimes because they want to taunt you.

storm helm
#

Wouldn’t English be extinct by the 2500’s?

#

Atleast in it’s current form?

gilded mason
#

Probably

craggy sierra
#

Hard to say

#

But apparently Hungarian is still alive and well then too

storm helm
#

When I say English I mean Modern English

#

Yeah many things about Earth in halo aren’t realistic

vocal aspen
#

But then again, we are talking about a game with modified humans that fight in robotic suits

ruby cobalt
#

Is chief just lucky or is he truly the greatest spartan in the universe. Cuz I often hear people saying that he is just lucky.

gilded mason
#

He's an average Spartan that has the benefit of being the guy we play as

#

The actual """"best"""" Spartan would probably be Linda or Fred

#

If such a thing could be quantified

ruby cobalt
#

But the books?

#

He got some crazy feats

gilded mason
#

Yes, though they're all things other Spartans could do if they had access to the equipment or opportunity.

ruby cobalt
#

And the arbiter? Is he just lucky or actually powerful. Cuz he seems wayy more powerful than most elites. After all isn’t he that ordered the assault on Reach?

gilded mason
#

He's a pretty skilled guy as well.

#

Others like Rtas are also similarly skilled

stable flower
#

Arby is lucky he didn't get infected by the Flood even when walking in contaminated areas.

terse lava
#

Funny how that never really is addressed

ruby cobalt
#

Maybe it’s the shields

humble yacht
#

If the shields could keep out spores then they’d probably also keep out air

terse lava
#

Always just chalked it up to plot, or you could try arguing nanobots in Thel's body like in Broken Circle

versed helm
gentle ridge
#

How much can a spartan lift in and out of armour

pulsar pivot
#

Well they can flip a scorpion tank over so

#

Probably a lot

gentle ridge
#

Has that happened outside of game mechanics?

vocal aspen
slim thorn
carmine sleet
#

Chief doesn't have a natural trait that enables him to save the world

steep ether
carmine sleet
#

He just happened to be the Spartan on the Autumn that was able to fight in CE

#

He happened to be the only Spartan available during Halo 3 to stop the Flood

#

And in turn, that led to him being the only one able to stop the Ur-Didact in Halo 4

slim thorn
carmine sleet
#

Didn't need to tag me

#

And you don't need to have some "I save worlds" trait to be trusted by someone

#

That's not how trust works

slim thorn
#

Don't forget his leadership capabilities.

steep ether
#

good point, but the choices he made got him into those positions. ex: he being the natural team leader

#

blue teams real leader is fred

#

yet chief still calls him blue 2

humble yacht
#

no, blue team's real leader is chief

slim thorn
#

Blue Team's actual leader is chief

humble yacht
#

you're mistaking Fred's rank with his role in blue team

slim thorn
#

Fred is just taking his position when he's away in solo missions or not involving Blue Team

steep ether
#

i guess

slim thorn
#

Fred yield his leadership position to Chief when he returns to Blue Team

carmine sleet
steep ether
#

but he still chooses to lead, not to be led

humble yacht
#

led*

steep ether
#

thank you

rustic nimbus
#

leded

steep ether
#

lol

slim thorn
carmine sleet
# humble yacht that trait is his luck

Yeah he's lucky but I wouldn't say that is really the thing that means he can save the world. I'm pretty lucky at times yet I've not found a way to save the world from climate change

humble yacht
#

different type of luck

steep ether
#

also, before anyone asks, we are not adding that he is the main plot character in the games

humble yacht
#

Chief's luck lets him survive otherwise unsurvivable scenarios

versed helm
#

I want that luck when I play

steep ether
#

falling from space, ecscaping the ark/rings, etc.

versed helm
#

Exactly

steep ether
#

and in halo 5, fred basically says that Chief is choosing to go on all these operations nonstop

humble yacht
#

yes, chief was purposefully driving himself really hard on nonstop missions so he wouldn't have to deal with the loss of Cortana

steep ether
#

thats part of it, but even though he could have just taken a break from fighting for a while, he chose to fight

humble yacht
#

if he took a break then he'd have time to think about it

#

he didn't want to think about it;

#

it's a common coping mechanism to overwork yourself to avoid processing grief

#

albeit unhealthy

steep ether
#

i guess

#

im not the best at debates

jade wave
#

They both reasons for why he kept himself busy

#

He is a Spartan

gleaming vapor
gilded mason
#

Luck isn't a natural trait somebody could have.

gleaming vapor
#

u havent played fallout then ✋

jade wave
#

😬

#

This ain’t fallout man

gleaming vapor
#

lmao ikik

steep ether
#

some people i think are misunderstanding what we mean by luck

#

he's lucky cause he can fall from space and survive, he can escape a ring he nuked, etc

#

not hes lucky he was on earth during the invasion

versed helm
#

So, just recently re-watched the starry night trailer for Halo 3. Isn't it funny that everything bungie made was canon. Cause that scene really happened

undone kestrel
#

erol

#

esrevinu

steep ether
#

?

humble yacht
#

they're just typing words backwards

#

not sure why

#

probably to get people to go "?"

slim thorn
versed helm
#

The Banished seems to be a faction that will eventually destroy itself.

slim thorn
#

Doubt it because Jiralhanae at their homeland now supports the Banished

gilded mason
#

It's a cult of personality

#

Once Atriox is gone, it'll probably implode.

versed helm
#

Banished forces were already fighting amongst themselves before John arrived on Reach.

#

Eliminating the "diplomatic" leaders will probably result in chaos.

#

Do you think that is an intentional flaw, their degree of organisation?

slim thorn
#

I think it does, considering they are the members that were originally set to be killed by the Covenant because of "heresy" or failures.

pulsar pivot
#

Mabye until then they will somewhat hold themselves together because of John being there

versed helm
#

They will undoubtedly compete over technology and equipment. We might even be able to witness that occur from a distance in Halo Infinite.

pulsar pivot
#

Yes brutes arent the most civilized creatures

versed helm
fair hazel
#

isnt it a common movie theme too

stable flower
#

The Banished were technically already fighting amongst each other in HW2, going by Yapyap's description.

#

I bet there'll be something like Halo 2's Gravemind level, where you get caught in the middle of the Great Schism after rescuing the marines.

fair hazel
#

A lot of the yapyap isn't canon

stable flower
#

Yeah, cause a lot of it seems like something out of a children's story IMO

timid skiff
#

do you think guys we will see humans affiliated to the Banished?

#

I personally dislike the idea but who knows, maybe that would add some tension. You know, humanity is struggling to survive, and then it shows off who are its heroes and who are its traitors.

slim thorn
carmine sleet
#

Why would ONI join the Banished?

versed helm
#

The banished should wipe out Oni 👍

humble yacht
slim thorn
carmine sleet
#

That's different to saying that ONI should join the Banished

#

That would be them sending someone to infiltrate the organisation, not ONI joining them

#

Plus, you don't send everyone from one your intelligence agency to join the enemy

versed helm
#

Is there any aliens in oni at all, or have been?

#

Yes we got grunts working for counter intel

#

Also jackal snipers

carmine sleet
#

While not actually part of ONI, the Sangheili mercenary Ayit 'Sevi was employed by them during Halo Escalation

pulsar pivot
#

So technically we have no spies in the covenant

carmine sleet
#

Ayit was working with them in the post war

#

ONI did not have spies within the Covenant during the war

pulsar pivot
#

Thought so

#

Do we know the average life span of all the creatures in the covenant

versed helm
#

Hard to b a spy when you're another species

pulsar pivot
#

Yeah

jade wave
still ibex
#

What is cortanas goal regarding the guardians and the mantle, and how does it actually effect the average person? Like, what are the negatives of being under the guardian rule?

carmine sleet
#

Basically no freedom, she wants to rule the galaxy with an iron fist

#

You step out of line and do something she doesn't want and you'll be punished for it

versed helm
#

All hail cortana and her beautiful galactic dominance

versed helm
#

These ambitions sound very similar to a specific faction in an alternate franchise.

shut dew
carmine sleet
#

Didn't need to tag me

shut dew
#

I don't even want to see 343i's take on the civilian's POV - it's so predictable that anyone who's read dystopian fiction from past and present would know exactly what's going on.

versed helm
#

No one is forcing you to read it.

shut dew
#

It's just Injustice Gods Among Us's Regime with shiny robots and EMPs.

gilded mason
jade wave
#

Do you know where thats stated, I only remember the old sangheili from Broken Circle

gilded mason
jade wave
#

Actually that might be what I’m thinking of

#

But thanks

terse lava
#

@gilded mason didn't he specify the navy though?

versed helm
#

more Halo movie for Halo lore plz

terse lava
#

So really.he could have been serving for longer in the military before becoming a shipmaster and higher

teal ice
#

Your forefathers wisely set aside their compassions. Steel themselves, from what needed to be done.

versed helm
#

Who are you referencing?

pulsar pivot
#

Truth

#

When he was about to light the rings in 3 he said that to Johnson

versed helm
pulsar pivot
#

But that was before the firing of the rings

versed helm
#

Also sangheili have better medical technology

pulsar pivot
#

I mean covenant

versed helm
#

Ancient humans lived for thousands of years

#

Spartans could possibly live for a hundreds of years

#

Johnson was in his 70s

pulsar pivot
#

Master chief is like 40 or 50

versed helm
#

Yes and he runs around like his in his 20s

pulsar pivot
#

Exactly

jade wave
jade wave
gilded mason
#

Ye

versed helm
# jade wave Where did you learn this?

Halo wiki the war went on for 1000 years the human guy forthenchenko not sure if I'm saying it right served throughout the whole war and still looked fit after all those years

jade wave
#

Oh I see

#

Very interesting

jade wave
#

I mean you are technically right

#

I was just sayin

terse lava
#

We don't know how long ancient humans could live, but 1000 years seems to be near the limit. Also no, Spartans don't live hundreds of years

versed helm
terse lava
#

Centuirea work just as fine as well. We see Forthencho himself comment on the lifespans of humans and forerunners. Humans were candles compares to the blowtorch that was forerunner life extension

versed helm
#

Centuries wouldn't work because the commander was already high ranking and his still alive after end. Of the war aged but still fit

#

Also yes human lifespan paled in comparison to forerunners who probably were biologically immortal and could live for tens of thousands of years

#

Humans who were responsible for the war a thousand years ago were also executed so they had to have many years of experience to be in those positions of power

#

Thousands seem likely

terse lava
#

Why wouldn't centuries work? Look how far someone can go in decades, or look at Nizat, who held Fleetmaster in 200 human years

lyric cedar
#

folks need heros chief

jade wave
#

Wait no

#

It just says that forthenchos military career lasted for a thousand years at least

versed helm
#

The guy by the end was aged but still in fighting condition

versed helm
terse lava
#

It doesn't prove that, we see how aged he was by the end. Am I saying AH is not capable of it? No, but we don't have anything showing they can live for multiple thousands. I figure an Ancient human average lifespan would be 12-1500 years long

jade wave
#

That sounds realistic enough considering forerunner lifespan

#

too bad Greg Bear didn't go into any detail about it

terse lava
#

Indeed, we don't even have an actual name for the AH civilization

jade wave
#

I doubt it really needs an official title

#

I think Ancient Humanity has plenty of interesting lore while still retaining some sense of mystery

#

like the Precursors

#

plus the forerunners are just called the Ecumene or Forerunner Ecumene

#

or however u spell it

terse lava
#

Eh always annoyed me they lack a title for neither their own civilization, or even the alliance they had with the San shyuum

jade wave
#

perhaps

versed helm
#

At the very least

slim thorn
versed helm
#

So who placed the Primordial in that asteroid at the galaxy's edge?

pulsar pivot
#

Mabye the primordial

versed helm
#

Or what else is known about the location of where the Primordial was imprisoned, other than it being some sort of small but damaged planetoid or asteroid

limpid meadow
#

It may have placed itself there, it may have been placed there by other Precursors, it may have drifted there over the 9 million years it was floating around. We really don't know one way or another.

versed helm
#

I can't remember what glassing beams where used for aggh

red finch
#

Vermin thats what.

slim thorn
#

I was just praying that Chief will visit the Primordial Prison at 07, or what was left of it.

red finch
#

That would be cool

chilly shuttle
#

Indeed.

river moon
#

what do yall think happened to fireteam osris?

versed helm
#

Buck left, Tanaka is still annoying, Locke is working at a bar now and Vale idk

carmine sleet
#

Locke isn't working in a bar, he's still active duty, same with Tanaka and Vale

vocal aspen
#

What made you think he worked at a bar?

carmine sleet
#

My guess is they didn't read Bad Blood properly

#

Because while Locke and Osiris are seen in a bar, Locke isn't the one serving drinks

jade wave
#

I think he was joking man

vocal aspen
#

They seemed serious

#

Or else they would’ve corrected us by now.

carmine sleet
versed helm
#

with all their augmentations why even drink alcohol as their bodies so effecient at removing toxins they would never get drunk

humble yacht
#

Symbolism, probably

carmine sleet
#

Even if their bodies filter out the toxins, it's still a recreational activity that no doubt helps them all relax

versed helm
#

Does alcohol even leave an effect on Spartans?

carmine sleet
#

It doesn't

steep ether
#

it quenches their thirst

versed helm
#

Not every type of alcoholic drink "quenches your thirst".

steep ether
#

idk i dont drink

#

lets change the subject

carmine sleet
#

Alcohol literally dehydrates you

steep ether
#

good point

versed helm
#

Did the alien races produce alcoholic drinks, or ones that left similar effects?

steep ether
#

i assume so, the unggoy had benzene which is sorta similar

humble yacht
#

Lol benzene is not similar to ethanol

versed helm
#

I think he was referring to how benzene left similar effects to alcohol, upon consuming it.

steep ether
#

halopedia directly said that it is a recreational drug, so its basically alcohol for grunts

#

also i didn't relate it to ethanol

humble yacht
#

Ethanol is the active ingredient of most alcoholic beverages

#

Well, all alcoholic beverages

#

Other types of alcohol like methanol and isopropanol are too toxic to humans for consumption

#

Chemically, benzene is way different from any alcoholic molecule

steep ether
#

what im saying is that its probably addictive to grunts and is a recreational drug like alcohol to humans

#

and dont correct me saying that alcohol is not a drug or whatever, I know

versed helm
#

No, I believe that it is actually considered as being a drug.

steep ether
#

sometimes

delicate notch
#

Which youtube channels on the Halo lore do you guys follow? I do SameToken, HiddenXperia and EckhartsLadder. I was a subscriber to "HaloFollower" a while too, but I heard he was basically copying others work so I stopped.

versed helm
#

I watched Same token vid on the Halo timeline

#

I liked how he told most of the story in only 35 minutes. And it wasn't boring

delicate notch
#

(Watching that again as we speak tbh 😄 )

versed helm
#

Lol nice. Yeah he has a nice delivery to his videos. Puts life into em. And his jokes are nice xD

delicate notch
#

I agree! His channel do deserve more followers imo, but I guess his pretty slow upload tears into that.

versed helm
#

Yeah imma check out more if his videos

#

I mean I rather have 1 very nicely made video every month then 20 crappy dumb videos every month

delicate notch
#

Yea. And I like how he doesn't give too much of his own opinion too, he just say it likes it told, no 3 minute tangent about what he thinks. I like when they give their own opinion too, dont get me wrong, but its nice to have one channel without it.

versed helm
#

Yeah that's nice

vocal aspen
delicate notch
versed helm
#

Flood I doubt will be in Infinite because I'm 90% sure it'll be rated T

delicate notch
#

And yep about that with HiddenX.

#

Rated T? Teenager?

versed helm
#

Halo 5 was

carmine sleet
#

Basically some people are still not happy Halo 5 was rated T in the US because somehow the game rating, which is decided by an outside organisation from 343i, has a baring on the quality of the game according to a select group of people

versed helm
#

Technically I think all Halos in Europe are Rated 16 but in the US all the FPS games are M besides 5 and and everything else like Halo wars is T

#

Spartan Strike might have been E10+ too

delicate notch
#

A really gory Halo game would be cool tho.

versed helm
#

Not imo. U want gore go play something else. I don't like gore lol. It's just gross

carmine sleet
#

I'd rather Halo not go gory for the sake of being gory

delicate notch
#

No ofc. not gory for the sake of gore. But wars are pretty gruesome and slimy aliens like the flood aint "Rated PG"

versed helm
carmine sleet
#

I know, I'm going into the games industry

versed helm
#

Rated T is as far as I go. I don't play rated m because it's mostly just gore n cussing

delicate notch
#

Movies I can understand developing a movie with a certain rating in mind, since it will increase the number of potential cinema goers. But unless you're making a game directly aimed towards kids or a game extremely gory, developing a game for aimed for a rating seems stupid.

versed helm
#

It can be

#

It just depends on the game as u stated

#

343 may or may not even care about what their games are rated

#

Halo imo is kinda on the line between Teen and Mature. It's more of in-between probably then either of them

delicate notch
#

I would rather see a mature game than a teen one, or at least a setting which would enable mature for those who are of age.

versed helm
#

It depends on the game

#

Not to go too off topic. But a game like no man's sky having tons of gore n language and being rated Mature would be dumb. Halo on the other hand can be a bit brutal at times

delicate notch
#

I have been talking about Halo the entire time 😉

versed helm
#

Yeah I meant me making an example of NMS lol

delicate notch
#

NMS with gruesome aliens in Deadspace style would be cool tho. But I guess I got Deadspace for that 😄

versed helm
#

Yea

#

NMS is too colorful to be gruesome lol

delicate notch
#

Think of all the colorful gore!

versed helm
#

xD

#

Imma go now. Interesting conversation. Cya

delicate notch
#

It would have been like a mexican party with a pinata!

#

Cya! 🙂

versed helm
#

😂

lean karma
#

Not sure why game ratings is in lore and universe chat tho

#

Big question I do have is we know there were around 75 spartan II candidate finalists but I'm curious as to how many Orion project candidates there were and how many like johnson made it through as I think we only ever here of three in lore ever... Johnson, Parongowski, and Mendez I think??

#

May be wrong I only own half the books need to keep collecting them

versed helm
normal moon
versed helm
#

maybe

#

I have Gamepass so technically I can get it free

celest leaf
#

Yeah get it, its very worth it

normal moon
#

Well what are you waiting for man

nimble heart
velvet canopy
#

Hello, I have a question, why did humans not see forerunners as gods like many other species in the Halo universe?

nimble heart
#

Is the short answer

#

If you want the long answer, let me know

velvet canopy
#

well, I know that the other species believe in them because their planets have technology but the earth has the portal to the ark, it's a bit strange for me

jade wave
#

They did not know the portal was there

steep ether
jade wave
#

And earlier iterations of humans worshipped the forerunners

velvet canopy
jade wave
#

The forerunners could have installed various dazzelers and bafflers

nimble heart
jade wave
#

Or perhaps most humans have a geas that causes them to stay away from it

#

Also humanity of the unsc’s time is still relatively new

#

All other species have had countless years of interaction with forerunner stuff

velvet canopy
#

interesting answers, thank you very much

limpid meadow
#

I think people grossly underestimate how deep beneath the surface the portal was buried.

#

Any sort of geas being used to keep Humanity away from the portal seems unlikely if only because it was such a last-minute addition.

#

That said, it's certainly possible, and besides just being deep, there could have been other Forerunner tech that camoflagued it in some manner.

jade wave
#

Dazzlers and bafflers probably

limpid meadow
#

Basically, yeah.

#

But mostly I think it's just buried pretty deep in a place Humanity had no desire to dig deep in.

fair hazel
#

One thing I like about the construction of the portal is how rushed it seems

strong tinsel
#

Forerunners hid it too well

fair hazel
#

Like last minute attempt by the librarian

strong tinsel
fair hazel
#

Diverting chant to green from her post. Like heeding the call that would sage Chant’s life

#

The giant forerunner ship being repurposed

#

Humans being saved and catalogued

#

A narrow key point

jade wave
#

Is this explained in silintium or a story from fractures

#

Or however you spell silintium

terse lava
#

Yeah, it talked about in Silentium, and a Bungie era comic as well focused on a primitive human

karmic bluff
#

hey ado

#

i invited yu

limpid meadow
#

All that was done because the Didact has committed last-minute genocide against Humanity

#

A huge chunk of the collected specimens the Librarian had were killed, so she had to rush back to Earth, gather a few of the remaining humans, then modify her plans

#

The comic Ado is talking about is "Cradle of Life", which was part of Halo 3's IRIS ARG.

fair hazel
#

The sense of urgency from that event and improvisation

#

I don’t know how to fully describe the feeling

limpid meadow
#

Yeah. It's amazing how well that comes across in the text of Silentium.

#

That whole book oozes with escalating tension in a way I never thought a book could really do.

fair hazel
#

I cried I think. Or had teary/wet eyes

#

Silentium

limpid meadow
#

I felt like I was reading through chapters faster and faster as the ending approached, simply from the rising tension

fair hazel
#

The imminence of it all.

#

Also the certain calmness of rebirth later on.

#

The stories with the forerunners at the end or post firing have a certain feeling to them.

#

And even point of light blended modern elements with those elements

lean karma
nimble heart
#

Gunnery Sergeant Gladys Wilson
Gilly
James Lee
Morales
Orion Candidate 047

limpid meadow
#

James Lee. Who later changes his surname to James. Becoming "James James", lol

#

I would love to hear the though process behind that. From a production standpoint and in-universe

fair hazel
#

I recently listened to the interview with Eric trautmann

#

Yikes. Too bad he doesn’t follow halo anymore. Halo would be very different without him and his tenacity

#

Thankful for him

limpid meadow
#

Same

#

I'm really happy with the HGN, but I'd love to hear the pitch for his monthly comic.

fair hazel
#

I saw you talk about it on Twitter so I looked it up. When was the interview from?

limpid meadow
#

2011

fair hazel
#

Oh wow. It would honestly be cool if he was interviewed more recently and brought up with the history of halo’s fiction expanding and how his work impacted what is halo now and the shifts.

dense falcon
#

Was Bungie ever questioned about the canonicity of Halo: Reach? With Spartan-IIIs being a secret until Halsey went to Onyx and all. Was there ever an answer to that canon question?

jade wave
#

yes

#

Halsey mentions it in her journal and I think either glasslands or ghosts of onyx

#

she just says she didn't know who's spartans they were

#

and that was about it

dense falcon
#

I thought she said she knew every Spartan-II there was 🤨

jade wave
#

not spartan 2

#

all of noble team was spartan III except for Jorge

dense falcon
#

Yes I know that, hence why I ask

jade wave
dense falcon
#

Why is Halo Reach canon in the sense of Dr. Halsey meeting the rest of Noble team? She acts like she knows exactly who they are, but they were supposed to be a secret until she found out in Ghosts of Onyx

jade wave
#

She just acts like they are military personal

#

Halsey's journal tries to offer more insight

gilded mason
#

She basically wrote "Who in the world are these Spartans? I know I didn't make them. Did they continue the Spartan II program without me?"

#

She just doesn't know the specifics until GoO

versed helm
#

Does zeta halo orbit around planet?

gilded mason
versed helm
#

Anyone know exactly what planet? Becuse at the end of halo5 we can see planet but in infinite gameplay and trailers we don't see any planet?

gilded mason
#

We don't know much about the planet

versed helm
#

Maybe ring teleport ever few month to new location

jade wave
#

I doubt Zeta Halo would have enough power to create such a portal

gilded mason
jade wave
#

I know

#

Zeta Halo is installation 07 right?

gilded mason
#

Yes

jade wave
#

In Primordium the way they described it generating power seemed to say it took alot out of the ring when it opened up a portal

versed helm
#

Guys right now banished is on the ark or reach? Or zeta halo?

jade wave
#

could be all 3 of them

gilded mason
#

Not on Reach anymore

versed helm
#

They have enough man power?

gilded mason
#

Apparently

versed helm
gilded mason
#

Nope, he left the Ark

delicate notch
#

Ola Salo left "The Ark", not Atriox.

gilded mason
#

wut

delicate notch
#

Search for "The Ark - It Takes A Fool To Remain Sane" (On Youtube). The singer is Ola Salo, its a bad joke mostly swedes will understand. The band is really great tho, so I recommend them 😄

gilded mason
#

Ah, I was wondering what you were referencing

carmine sleet
#

The joke really didn't work

delicate notch
#

Well, he left The Ark, so it worked - For me 😗

#

(Or the band was dissolved)

limpid meadow
gilded mason
#

I'll double-check

delicate notch
#

Ofc it does, the moon has water and we all know the moon is haunted.

limpid meadow
#

Ghosts aren't life, duh

delicate notch
#

I wonder what kind of artifacts will be reviled in Infinite.

#

Depends on the ghost.

limpid meadow
#

A cursory glance at the text doesn't mention life on the anchor planet, as far as I can see.

gilded mason
# limpid meadow I don't think it's been said whether it supported life, was it? I just recall th...

“Most anchors are gas giants to avoid the possibility of life arising in the shadow of a ring or luring in potential settlers. Not only is this planet solid, but it contains water and atmosphere. The choice is quite extraordinary, though perhaps a choice of necessity.”

At seven hundred kilometers out, long-range scanners perked up. Rion glanced at her integrated pad as Niko relayed relevant information. “Looks like the UNSC has a couple nice comm towers set up on the planet’s surface and a few commsats in orbit.”
Well, it has atmosphere, but it doesn't say what its composition is. I probably just assumed.

limpid meadow
#

Yeah, that's what I remember.

#

I wouldn't be surprised if there were life forms present, I just wanted to make sure it wasn't explicitly mentioned and I'd missed it.

delicate notch
#

Anchors = Large planets used to hold rings and artifacts in place?

limpid meadow
#

Halo rings specifically in this case.

#

This is why each Halo ring orbits a planet, and why they're usually gas giants.

#

I have a theory that planet that Installation 03 orbits used to be a gas giant, but some cataclysmic event basically stripped it of its layers, leaving only the partially destroyed, rocky core behind.

delicate notch
#

Must have been a weird event if it managed to create a solid planet from gasses

limpid meadow
#

Gas giants aren't entirely gas. Heck, they mostly aren't

#

The upper layers are gaseous, but as you go deeper and pressure builds, the gasses are compressed into liquids, then solids. And at the center would be a solid core of some kind.

pulsar pivot
#

Yup

delicate notch
#

Isnt that more of a "the pressure is so high that gasses and metals starts to behave like liquid"

#

Rather than actual "surface"

limpid meadow
#

they basically are liquids and solids.

pulsar pivot
#

And some gas as well

limpid meadow
#

I was responding to MyScnd's statement, specifically.

#

Anyway, I don't know if it's possible to blow a gas giant's atmosphere away in such a manner. It seems unlikely. But something happened to that planet Gamma Halo orbits, and it's weird that it isn't a gas giant.

pulsar pivot
#

Mabye a bigger rock

limpid meadow
#

More likely another planet.

pulsar pivot
#

Probably

limpid meadow
#

And the fact that the ring is unaffected is interesting, too.

#

Like, regardless of whether the planet was a gas giant or not, that ring survived something wicked!

pulsar pivot
#

Yup

lucid depot
#

Wait

#

I've never looked into it but just played the games

#

But after the great war, are the citizens under the UNSC mostly xenophobic

safe inlet
#

no?

#

the unsc is a multicultural place

jade wave
#

If an alien race tried to exterminate my race for existing I thibk I would be pretty xenophobic

lucid depot
#

^

fair hazel
#

It depends

jade wave
#

Most are probably xenophobic

#

Most people in human controlled space probably have only interacted with alien species when getting glassed

safe inlet
#

people in the human world won't dislike all "aliens"

#

and not all humans/unsc will dislike elites

lucid depot
#

That's why I said mostly

safe inlet
#

grouping everyone together and saying they are all "xenophobic" isn't always the answer

#

that's like saying are all britihs people xenophobic

jade wave
#

Nobody said all

#

We said mostly

safe inlet
#

yes some are but not everyone is

#

okay mostly then

#

still my point stands

#

did all/most people hate the Italians aftey they switched sides in ww2?

#

no they didn't

jade wave
#

Do most people hate Nazi’s?

safe inlet
#

i have no hatred towards them the same way i have no hatred to soviets

gilded mason
#

Most aliens wouldn't even have ever fought humans.

safe inlet
#

^

lucid depot
#

Most people do hate nazi's, even if they havnt met them

safe inlet
#

hate is a strong word

lucid depot
#

Same with pedophiles, although pedophiles are more hated

#

It's not an everyone will

#

It's a good amount of people will

#

And with the amount of people affected by glassings and losing their families across the galaxy to an enemy they have not met, they will develop negative views towards them

#

Likely resulting in widespread xenophobia

#

Not everyone will

#

But a large amount of people affected will

gilded mason
#

I wonder how many people even survive glassings to get to that point.

safe inlet
#

i mean hatred towards the movement not to the peple

lucid depot
#

Didnt say they survived the glassings, I said affected by glassings

safe inlet
#

people disliked the moveent in ww2 but look at germany now

#

most people don't just the german people of the past

lucid depot
#

Such as being offworld and then finding out your home planet has been glassed

safe inlet
#

generalisation is a problem

lucid depot
#

Your home and family reduced to nothing

#

I do think that after the events of halo 5 inter-species tensions would lessen with a new common enemy

#

But prior to halo 5 is what this question focuses on

pulsar pivot
#

Think for a second, not everyone is gonna hate or dislike elites because of what they did

#

People are gonna forgive

safe inlet
#

people would still dislike the species that were involved in the covernant dont get me wrong, but same as ww2 most people will not mind the species involvement in the conflict (in our time line the germans) but mind the no no germans or the covenant in halo

#

^

jade wave
#

I don’t really think using a human conflict is one of the best ways to compare these two events

#

We are talking about an alien species here, that is not human and is completely different from you

#

And the Covenant-Human war hasn’t been over for that long

safe inlet
#

i mean war is war

#

the enemy is enemy

lucid depot
#

But the issue is this wasnt just war for Conquest or anything

#

This was extermination vs survival

#

The covenant was outright trying to exterminate humanity

safe inlet
#

a lot of human vs human wars are the same

lucid depot
#

But they are still human

#

Not an alien species

jade wave
#

I feel like you are not understanding the gravity of the human covenant war

lucid depot
#

That you barely know anything about

safe inlet
#

i mean in our time line a lot of interrace wars each side considered the other non-human

#

or inter-religion

lucid depot
#

Even though the covenant was lied to by the prophets, there would still be many that would hate those species that participated in the attempted eradication of humanity

safe inlet
#

hating some groups doesn't automatically make you "xenophobic" a current context human word

#

one person could like most known species but hate the profits and the elites

#

does that make them purely xenophobic?

lucid depot
#

If you like asians or blacks but hate whites, does that make you racist?

jade wave
#

I do not understand the point of this debate anymore

safe inlet
safe inlet
#

this is why one word fits all does not work

#

this is why gender/racial politics is just wrong

#

this is just a hole we shouldn't be going down

jade wave
#

Why don’t we just go back to your original point

safe inlet
#

"grouping everyone together and saying they are all "xenophobic" isn't always the answer"

#

basically what i was saying

#

i haven't really moved from my point

jade wave
#

But what does that have to do with humanity and ex-covenant species

safe inlet
#

people forgive

#

and people realise that lets give that real life example again

#

not all germans were (the word)

#

lets go here as well not all muslims are terrorists

#

generalisation is a bad thing

#

not all covenant wanted to kill humans

#

it was just what they were ordered to do

jade wave
#

Can you prove that?

#

I highly doubt most covenant didn’t want to kill humanity

safe inlet
#

just look at most human conflicts which is all we have to go off

jade wave
#

We are not talking about a human conflict

safe inlet
#

yeah i know that

#

but just look at elites

#

they started to side with the humans

#

did the majority of the ones in halo 3 want to kill their fellow allies ?

gilded mason
# jade wave Can you prove that?

It was said that the younger generation of Sangheili was increasingly sympathetic to humanity's plight. A good number of other elites wanted humans in the Covenant and didn't get why the Hierarches won't let them, and according to Vale, many Elites on less central colonies disliked all the bloodshed.

safe inlet
#

^

#

this good lord another person with a bloody brain

jade wave
#

Bruh

safe inlet
#

and not trying to get the high ground on a bloody discord chat

jade wave
#

I am trying to understand your point dude

#

Not trying to get some high ground

safe inlet
#

i don't know how to set my point better than i have

#

i've laid it out

jade wave
#

Ok

#

What I am saying is the majority of humans do not like any aliens

#

And that’s about it

safe inlet
#

i mean

#

you are wrong but okay

jade wave
#

I don’t understand how this is difficult for you to grasp

#

How

#

How am I wrong

safe inlet
#

have you seen what's it called that series during halo 5 release

#

you can see other species

jade wave
#

Humanity just got out of a 30 year long war where the opposing faction was a genocidal fanatical religious group bent on destroying humanity and almost succeeded

safe inlet
#

covenant != all "aliens"

#

not all other life forms were in the covenant

jade wave
#

Most aliens were in the covenant that humanity interacted with??????

#

Bruh

jade wave
safe inlet
#

did i say all?

#

and anything non human

#

is a alien by definition

jade wave
#

I am saying the exact same thing

safe inlet
#

what are you even arguing then

jade wave
#

Ok

#

I’ll say it again

#

Most humans do not like aliens in the halo universe

#

That is it

#

That is literally it

#

Why is this hard to understand?

safe inlet
#

same thing you gave me

#

can you prove it

#

we are colliding have opinions

jade wave
#

Listen to any human talk about aliens in any form of halo media

safe inlet
#

what like how the yonhet traded with humans after the war?

#

or how the elites sided with the humans near the end of the war

jade wave
#

Or how ONI is specifically designing plans to destabilize the SOS by giving arms to dissident factions and trying to figure out ways to poison their food supply

#

The elites sided with humanity out of necessity

safe inlet
#

the only reason the yonhet traded limity with humans during the war was cause of the covenant say don't do it

jade wave
#

It is an example

#

Jul’ Mdama and his faction despised humans

safe inlet
#

did most use people want the cia to interfere with the politcs in south america last century?

#

there were some humans in that faction

#

generalisation like i said before is a bad thing

jade wave
#

I do not know what to say man I really don’t

safe inlet
#

nor do i

jade wave
#

I can list other examples of humans and aliens hating each other

safe inlet
#

nor do I i just dont'

jade wave
#

But I don’t think it would matter

#

List them

#

And I will go look at them and maybe you will change my opinion

safe inlet
#

wrong reply

#

but you get the picture

jade wave
#

I don’t disagree

#

But the war has only been over for seven years

#

At least when infinite is set

safe inlet
#

did most people hate germans after 7 years?

#

no, no they did not

jade wave
#

I cannot answer that

#

Are you sure?

safe inlet
#

look into history

#

i got a bloody degree in it

jade wave
#

Poland? France? Russia?

safe inlet
#

are they all humans?

#

and did you know most french people said they thought russia helped most in the war right after

#

but after 70 years they say it was americans

boreal bane
#

Let's keep the chat more to Halo please - reminder that real life politics aren't allowed in discussions here

safe inlet
#

but I will listen

gilded mason
#

Honestly, we have a fair amount of examples of both dislike and the opposite. Rion's series with aliens and humans working together and having positive feelings for each other, Buck calling the SoS elites his brothers, Venesia's whole deal, some characters in Hunters in the Dark. And we have other media where we mostly tend to interact with characters that were personally harmed by the Covenant.

There's really just not enough info to for sure know what percentage of the human population feels what.

safe inlet
#

^

jade wave
#

I disagree

safe inlet
#

again generalisation is a bad thing

jade wave
#

I doubt most humans have had similar interactions with aliens

#

That is one of my points

#

Most humans have only interacted with aliens through the covenant

safe inlet
#

time heals

jade wave
#

Ok but you still are missing what I am saying

safe inlet
#

and seeing the covenant break up and the elites side with humans

jade wave
#

Most of these humans still have not interacted with aliens

#

Only from the covenant

gilded mason
#

Most current humans probably haven't interacted with the Covenant at all.

safe inlet
#

would have persuaded a lot of people to sympathise with them

gilded mason
#

Or at least, a fair amount

safe inlet
#

during infinite

#

look at the human time line

#

at this point after the war most people didn't mind the germans

#

but still disliked the german movement

gilded mason
#

Though either way, it's for the best that most humans shouldn't hate aliens at this point in time, anyway. 343 isn't going to do massive time jumps at this point, so things have to heal now, otherwise we as the audience will never see it.

safe inlet
#

i mean the hitler likers

safe inlet
#

the war is over

#

new allegiances will emerge

#

factions have / will split

#

humans are siding with the banished and elites are split between both sides

gilded mason
#

humans are siding with the banished
Sadly, not anymore. 343 seems to have already retconned that

safe inlet
#

the aftermath of the human - covenant war isn't 2d

safe inlet
#

if so i wish 343 could just keep a solid bloody lore

gilded mason
#

Yeah, Shadows of Reach has it so Atriox hates humans now

safe inlet
#

it changes way too often

#

another example is the ditact dying twice

gilded mason
#

And then we have that Infinite transmission where Escherum says "humanity will burn". Not the UNSC.

safe inlet
#

and there are humans within the banished

#

it's just not consitant

jade wave
#

Are there any humans confirmed?

safe inlet
#

?

jade wave
#

The only ones I know of are the ferret squad in the Keepers

safe inlet
#

oh makes more sense since your edit

gilded mason
#

Previous media talked about humans working with the Banished, and that the Banished would welcome any humans that wishes to join.

steep ether
#

atriox doesnt like humans

#

tho

safe inlet
gilded mason
#

Spartan Field Manual.

jade wave
#

Oh i see

humble yacht
#

the field manual represents the perspective of humans, namely the UNSC, and their working information and theories about the Banished. it's not from the perspective of banished themselves

#

it simply means that the unsc was wrong about Atriox's feelings on humans, or the info was out of date

delicate notch
#

Where in the timeline was the ark found by the covenant? Was it an early find or was it first after they had found a ring?

jade wave
#

I would assume after they found the ring

#

Seeing as the lesser ark was at the boundaries of the Milky Way

delicate notch
#

And the banished are on the ark, not the lesser one, right?

jade wave
#

the ark is the lesser ark

#

the greater ark was destroyed during the forerunner-flood war

#

i should have just said ark

delicate notch
#

Ah, thought it was the lesser which was destroyed. My bad.

slim thorn
delicate notch
#

Have there ever been a keymind made out of mostly forerunners? Gracemind was mostly human and covenant, wasn't it?

#

The Primordial and the master builder seemed to have a similar way of thinking/being a sadist, imagine a hive mind with a bunch of builders (I assume there was many)

gilded mason
delicate notch
#

My mane

gilded mason
delicate notch
gilded mason
#

The body was destroyed by the rings firing.

#

But the mind is everlasting.

#

Graveminds are simply monitors or arms for the mind that exists elsewhere, basically.

delicate notch
#

Really? I thought they needed the physical form.

humble yacht
#

they need a physical form to manifest the consciousness in reality

gilded mason
delicate notch
#

But wouldn't that make all kind of minds equal? If they can plug into the "neural network" (or what it's called) as fast as they are formed.

gilded mason
#

There's only a single Gravemind

humble yacht
#

yea

gilded mason
#

He just has multiple bodies he can control

humble yacht
#

if two graveminds exist at once, it's not two individual minds

undone kestrel
#

does the precursor still exist?

gilded mason
#

Yes

undone kestrel
#

ooo where?

humble yacht
#

not that we know of

gilded mason
#

PoI stuff for anyone that doesn't wanna look:
||Precursor "eggs" are being taken care of by a Forerunner in a far away place.||

humble yacht
#

gross

undone kestrel
#

imagine if we meet a precursor in infinite

#

would be pog ngl

jade wave
#

Isnt keeper of tools mission to bring them to another galaxy for reseeding

gilded mason
#

I forget the specifics.

undone kestrel
#

yo another question

#

how old do spartans get before they are considered "old"

delicate notch
#

So when they collect biomass it's not to make that particular body more powerful, but to collect the intelligence of these beings into the consciousness? Ie. The knowledge the mind from the forerunner war had is still there in the Halo 3 gravemind?

gilded mason
#

The knowledge the mind from the forerunner war had is still there in the Halo 3 gravemind?
Yup

undone kestrel
#

ooooo pog

jade wave
undone kestrel
#

i see

jade wave
#

I doubt 343 will ever address that question either tho

delicate notch
#

Always thought that the different minds was independent but connected.

slim thorn
#

Their members are around 40 now

jade wave
#

I am saying beyond those ages

slim thorn
#

Linda will be 50 years once reaches 2561

jade wave
#

Yes

#

Let me rephrase it

#

Most Spartans die before reaching ages that would be considered old

slim thorn
#

The only youngsters we have for S-II is Red Team

undone kestrel
#

didn't del rio say something about masterchief being old?

jade wave
#

He called him an aging Spartan

undone kestrel
#

ooo i see

delicate notch
#

Haven't they already declared the age when Mc dies?

undone kestrel
#

they did?

#

ayoo?

humble yacht
#

any and all reports of chief's death have been fabricated

delicate notch
#

Okedokey

flat iron
slim thorn
#

Bruh, he's at between 70 to 75

undone kestrel
#

johnson is a spartan?

humble yacht
#

not really

#

project orion subject were retroactively referred to as Spartan Is but they are not nearly as augmented as later spartan generations

undone kestrel
#

i see

stable flower
chilly shuttle
#

I mean, SPARTAN-IVs are a thing.

#

Makes me wonder, if the games continue past Infinite, we'll eventually see SPARTAN-Vs.

craggy sierra
#

No

#

There's no real reason.

chilly shuttle
#

Improvements in technology, especially as Forerunner tech is further understood.

craggy sierra
#

New spartan programs only come about when there's a large leap in the technology. For narrative purposes theu've gotten it as good as it needs to get.

#

So any new spartan recruits from hereon are just gonna be under the 4 program I imagine

chilly shuttle
#

I think it's less "leaps of technology" and more "philosophies".

craggy sierra
#

Again' nothing to really change there narratively

#

Cause they've gotten to the point of consenting adults only.

chilly shuttle
#

S-II: Immoral program to create supersoldiers based on the original PROJECT: ORION, using kids.
S-III: "Disposable", mass-produced SPARTANS, still using kids.
S-IV: More moral program using adult volunteers (Kind of taking it back to their roots, really.)

craggy sierra
#

I don't think the logical reasoning was to take it back to its roots

#

As much as it just was to stop using kids

chilly shuttle
#

Well, it was an unintentional side effect.

#

Since ORION was adult volunteers as well

#

Also, I have to ask.

humble yacht
#

the biggest reason was because Musa and Jun knew that more spartans would be needed if humanity were to continue surviing in the future

#

but obviously the use of kids was neither sustainable nor right

chilly shuttle
#

Was that scene at the start of Halo 4's campaign, with the interrogator chewing out Halsey like she was bubblegum over her actions with the S-II program, part of the original campaign, or added in for MCC, like the "H5" opener was for the H2:A campaign?

craggy sierra
#

That was always there

chilly shuttle
#

Alright. I just didn't remember it, then.

craggy sierra
#

It's kinda meant to set up chief's personal problems

chilly shuttle
#

And Halo 5 builds on it?

#

(Hasn't played H5 yet.)

craggy sierra
#

Uhhhhhhhhh

#

It's complicated

chilly shuttle
#

Speaking of, I should play Halo 5 and Wars 2 at some point before Infinite drops...

#

And yeah, I could just binge-watch Hidden Xperia to get caught up, but I'm one of those "I need to experience it myself" types...

unique rune
#

Probably the better approach to it

chilly shuttle
#

Indeed.

#

I'm just not looking forward to Wars 2, since I'm not the best when it comes to RTS games.

#

Also, is it just me, or are the Lekgolo pretty much the Covenant's "End-all" solution when it comes to controlling tech?

gilded mason
#

What do you mean?

chilly shuttle
#

They control the Skitterers, were used to explore the inner workings of the Forerunner Dreadnaught, control Scarabs, etc.

stable flower
#

I think they're used because combat AI were forbidden

terse lava
#

Would say the Lekgolo did end up being a good substitute for more direct AI creations. We know the ancient Covenant had better AI, but contact with Logic Plague remnants forced them to drop that technology.

versed helm
#

I thought the reason as to why the Covenant stopped using AI was because they probably heard stories of what Mendicant Bias did to their "gods"

#

Also, were there any other space-faring civilizations that shared the Milky Way alongside the Covenant and Humanity, like those that existed in the same time frame as them

timid skiff
#

do you guys think Halo Infinite will give us some UNSC energy-based weapons (for once, and aside from the Spartan Laser)

#

I like the way we fight through bullet means but idk, i feel like we need to have at least one laser blaster for example

versed helm
#

Well you got that one Scorpion tank variant that can fire lasers

rain imp
tepid vault
#

We have a lot of covenant weapons, maybe Hannibal would be generous enough to give us handheld variants of some of their weapons

nimble heart
#

Spartan 1337 should be canon

versed helm
#

ever be asked whose arm is this, to me it looks like that of a Spartan, but who?

unique rune
#

Probably Carter’s arm, considering he’s the only one of Noble wearing those colors.

dim holly
#

yeah definitely him

chilly shuttle
#

Either Carter or a custom Noble 6.

versed helm
#

I don't know, Carter has a line on his arm and it doesn't seem to match, this Spartan's seems more worn

chilly shuttle
#

And there's a line on this arm, too.

versed helm
#

but the armor seems to have a brown hue

#

carter has a metal hue

unique rune
#

The blue stripe on Carter’s wrist is still there in the cutscene.

#

And those hue differences are probably because of the lighting.

versed helm
#

also if we see the arm of the spartan in the photo it seems thicker than that of carter

unique rune
#

It’s not B312 because he’s sitting in the ‘Hog down there with Kat.

versed helm
#

yes

#

noble six is on the warthog

unique rune
#

...How can you tell it’s thicker from that one image?

unique rune
#

That... really doesn’t tell me anything.

The blue wrist stripe alone should be enough to say it’s without a doubt Carter-A259.

versed helm
#

welp maybe

#

for the moment let's say it's carter

rain imp
#

It's Carter. Pretty obvious as they were all there during the operation.

#

Especially as he talks to Kat after the crash, so it makes sense if he's coordinating units not to be in the ground assault directly.

#

Also you end up on the same Falcon Carter is on in the end cutscene of the level.

versed helm
#

We are supposed to assume that is Carter overseeing the attack, lol.

rain imp
#

He's overseeing his assets, yes. Coordinating a spartan fireteam that is under request from multiple sources I imagine is fairly hectic in battle. 🙂

versed helm
#

You are probably correct.

undone plume
#

there's one thing I've always wondered in between Halo 3 and 4

rain imp
#

"How did the cryopod chief was in, move?" 🙂

undone plume
#

lol that how did the pole switch sides and did anyone wake up 3 and 4

rain imp
#

the pole?

#

also, I'm not sure that was a complete sentence. 🙂

undone plume
#

In the last cutscene, she's on his right but when chief wakes up shes on the left how did it move?

rain imp
#

Ah. Same question area as the one I mentioned, hehe. Artistic licence would be the answer. 😉

undone plume
#

lol i was like uhhhhhhh

carmine sleet
#

Aye, plus, the Dawn in Halo 4 is inaccurate to how it should look because they wanted to make a bigger play space for the first mission

chilly shuttle
#

That, or Cortana was busy in the four years or so.

carmine sleet
#

She was busy, but I doubt she was somehow able to make the Dawn larger than it was

steep ether
#

she did, however update chiefs armor

stable flower
#

They The Maw'd the Dawn in Halo 4 for gameplay reasons

versed helm
#

"its like linguine, buts it the kind that can kind of jump into your mouth and get into your stomach and spread out from your limbs and turn you into a nasty nasty thing!" - random grunt i heard while playing halo 3 one time

#

flood is spoopy

main rivet
#

What's dumb about changing the look of it for gameplay reasons is no one was all that bothered by the fact that The Maw didn't fit in Pillar of Autumn.

#

If they wanted that open area for the exterior part of the mission, they could have done it and just messed with the scale, and few people would have complained.

#

Certainly far fewer than did about changing the look of it randomly.

#

The Chief's armor is a whole 'nother thing, but especially with the final cutscene I really wish they'd just left him with his bashed-to-hell MkVI and given him new armor in Halo 5.

versed helm
#

I wonder, is it possible to find any remains of Marontik?

#

Also, what actually happened to the United States in the Halo universe, like what could've caused it to fall apart?

gilded mason
#

stuff

humble yacht
#

What makes you think it fell apart?

versed helm
#

Probably civil war

#

Political schism

#

Washington D.C still exists

jade wave
#

The civil war ended with the Formation of the United Republic of North America?

#

URNA or something like that

undone kestrel
#

oooooo pog

versed helm
#

Did the Covenant ever produce cryo-chambers as well?

gilded mason
#

Maybe, but I don't remember any ever being mentioned

versed helm
#

They certainly do not require them when considering the speed of Slipspace travel.

dusty prawn
#

The Sangheili might have long ago, maybe, but since the covenant was founded their ships were probably fast enough to negate the need for it

terse lava
#

Yeah, and willing to bet it would be stasis-based rather then cryo

versed helm
#

Is there a difference between the two techniques?

#

I thought those were interchangeable terms.

humble yacht
#

Not always

#

Dead space stasis is not based on temperature. More like a temporal stasis

versed helm
#

Ah, I see.

slim thorn
#

I think the Covenant does, since San'Shyuum possess a Statis technology known as Timelock.

#

But most likely exclusive to San'Shyuun.

humble yacht
#

they got that from the forerunners

warped gust
#

Are any Spartans Swordsmen trained by Sangheili?

gilded mason
#

No actual "swordsmen", but apparently Thorne might have been getting some training from them...maybe?

versed helm
#

Anyone know what series had the son of an architect, a human and something else find the big prothean that becomes the gravemind underground?

gilded mason
#

The Forerunner Trilogy?

#

Cryptum, Primordium, Silentium

versed helm
#

@gilded mason YOU'RE THE BEST! Was that the end of Cryptum?

gilded mason
#

No idea

versed helm
#

Fair enough.

#

@gilded mason Do you who the Spartan 2 was that died in Ghosts of Onyx so that Kelly, Linda, Fred and the rest could get away?

gilded mason
#

Kurt

undone kestrel
#

guys , who was the first spartan?

jade wave
#

John halo

undone kestrel
#

also , does any spartan have number 1

jade wave
#

Probably died tho

#

Seeing as there is no mention of it anywhere

undone kestrel
#

rip in peace

jade wave
#

I don’t know how I feel about that emoji

undone kestrel
#

lol

gilded mason
#

I imagine 001 was simply not taken

undone kestrel
#

maybethinkingchief

#

yoooo is there a 007

jade wave
#

No mention of it

undone kestrel
#

ight

#

sad!!

proven parcel
#

Who is actually writing Halo Infinite?

fair hazel
#

Halo infinite does not have a single writer

gilded mason
#

Yup, it has no writers.

fair hazel
#

haha

delicate notch
#

Will it be based on a novel or will a novel be based on the game, you think?

versed helm
#

It will be based on a pamphlet.

thorny elk
#

why are we making fun of Infinite?

gilded mason
#

We're not

craggy sierra
#

No Halo game’s been based off a novel and only one novel’s ever been based off a game

versed helm
#

Lowering expectations, if you expect it to be bad and it's good then it's a pleasant surprise, if it's bad then it's not a letdown.

thorny elk
#

i guess

craggy sierra
#

I’m a wait for reviews kinda guy

thorny elk
#

i am too but the multiplayer is free so i’ll play that

#

at least for a bit

#

i hope no ground pound or anything tho

versed helm
#

I'll be content so long as it keeps the promise of having local co-op.

vernal notch
#

Splitscreen too

#

Maybe forge ai?

chilly shuttle
#

I wouldn't mind the ability to make your own campaign-style levels.

pulsar pivot
#

What is in the middle of the ark?

gilded mason
#

A ball of resources

pulsar pivot
#

Oh

#

A stockpile?

#

Or

#

A planet full of em?

gilded mason
#

The latter

chilly shuttle
#

A literal planet being stripmined for resources.

vernal notch
#

Does it move planet to planet?

gilded mason
vernal notch
#

Neato

#

So was the Ark ever colonized after the battle of installation of 00?

unique rune
#

The UNSC established some research facilities but otherwise no

versed helm
#

I always wondered what that skull looking thing was.

unique rune
#

Skull-looking thing?

versed helm
#

The planet being strip mined, looked like a skull while glimpsing at it while frantically speeding towards the frigate.

unique rune
#

Ah

lucid depot
#

Did the unsc actually purge all the flood that landed on earth, or did they manage to contain some to study for a time

#

Before destroying the whole area

versed helm
#

The covenant lead by the shipmaster glassed that entire city.

pulsar pivot
#

A really big burn go Brrr

stable flower
#

MC was ordered to overload the crashed ship's engine cores and destroy the city. That objective gets completely forgotten about midway through Floodgate.

versed helm
#

I forgot it immediately after hearing it.

lunar stirrup
#

Wtf is that arm thing at the beginning of long night of solace when they go into the cave

carmine sleet
#

That was the leg of a Scarab

slim thorn
#

Not to mention ONI probably decides not to experiment it further after what happened to Mona Lisa. Considering the flood was extremely dangerous.

versed helm
#

Not just the Mona Lisa. I'm pretty sure they got to know from Johnson and Chief (and Chips) what went down on the Ring

hidden briar
#

Had this thought while looking through a lore video from Halo Canon

mostly about the Cole Protocol and the Covanent's access to a Luminary

#

Especially since most to all UNSC planets had Forerunner artefacts (Like Harvest, Reach and Earth itself)

#

I understand the intentions... its just with the Luminaries... it wouldve been hard to stop the advance (until Truth lust for power got the best of him and lead to the great Schism)

slim thorn