#Other by karma

1 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

vernal canopyBOT
#

Welcome @willow spire! Any feedback from the community will show up here.
Please note that this thread discussion may be shared with SMG, but its primary purpose is for the RISK community to discuss ideas and provide constructive feedback.
If you would like to submit feedback to SMG directly, use this link.

vernal canopyBOT
analog viper
#

Hmm.. I like the idea in theory but I'm also like... idk, there's a lot of petty reporting and I don't know if I really wanna hear about it? Also not sure about the notifiying other players about reporting thing... feels like a way people could gang up and be petty maybe.... uncertain

#

I think if there was any kind of notification about being reported then there'd have to be an immediate appeal for this to make sense, bc if it tells you someone reported you and you don't think that's fair you should have the right to make that point

wheat bloom
willow spire
#

it’s just information. So petty reporting doesn’t matter. If it’s not true you can ignore, but if it is true, you should get nervous. The idea is to provide INSTANT feedback. Currently players have no clue what exactly triggered a ban. Instant feedback will also act as a deterrent.

Gang ups will not be a problem as reports are still reviewed by SMG, and as noted in the idea, false reports, especially gang ups, will be penalized. No need to appeal unless SMG actually agrees with the report, same as today.

lime swan
#

Instant feedback also provides instant triggers for malicious actors - whom you definitely don't want having that data

willow spire
#

i don’t understand. what data would they have other than “one or more of the players i am playing right now muted/reported/blocked” me? and what harm could they do with that info?

analog viper
#

they can guess and retaliate

cloud crane
#

I don't think it is going to play out like you think it will. I think people will use the mute future to troll people. Imagine someone unmuting you and re-muting you just to get at you. A troll will troll nomatter what. Same with the other reporting feedback as you described. Imagine people intentionally reporting you and using this as a means to get at you further. Not only did a troll predatorly report you, but now you don't know until after you forgot who was in the match. Could add insult to injuries.

willow spire
#

the behavior you describe would be trivial to detect and punish/prevent

cloud crane