#The state of Catan (toxic)

3 messages · Page 1 of 1 (latest)

elder vessel
#

The game has become so toxic and stupid. First, racism and bad players do not get punished. See photos.

Second, the friendly robber unspoken rule has destroyed the game. Basically you can't rob anyone unless you want to get ganged up on. This leads to a massive advantage for those who get development cards because they will steam roll everyone.

What kind of stupid game is this. Can't believe I spent so much money on it!

vital elm
#

I’ve played against ak00stik and they acted similarly. I also agree that the friendly robber has ruined the game.

heavy cairn
# elder vessel The game has become so toxic and stupid. First, racism and bad players do not ge...

You have expressed my feelings exactly: super toxic players in chat and some bizarre version of Friendly Robber which gives the early leader a huge advantage, usually until it's too late to stop them. The real Friendly Robber rule- no robbing or blocking a player with 2 - isn't so bad (though it's recommended for games with children) but waiting until all have 3 (I have played recent games where players get mad if you rob before 5 or 6!! ) completely changes the game. The robber is an elemental part of the game!