Stepperonline Motors at 48v or LDO Motors at 24v??

[kindred axle]

Soo I want the best motors possible for my Voron 2.4 build, And initially i wanted to use the ldo2504 motors but the long shaft version is wayy more costly, so should I go for cheaper stepperonline ones (17HS19-2504S-H-V1) but I'll use 48v for X-Y motors for better acceleration. The resistance and inductance of both both motors are similar.

Also if i use bigger motors like 65Ncm rated steppers from stepperonline, will perform better than LDO? (Will it be able to achieve high rpms as the ldo2504?)

[pseudo mesa]

very similiar but better compared to LDO

but no need for 48V unless u are REALLY pushing speed

[kindred axle]

you are talking abt 65Ncm right?

[pseudo mesa]

no im talking about the ones in your screenshot

[kindred axle]

no no the are slightly worse than ldo speedy power and super power

[pseudo mesa]

nope 😉

[kindred axle]

wow are you sure? Its hard to believe as they are cheaper and better too? how?

[pseudo mesa]

yes im sure, otherwise i wouldnt have wrote it 😅😅

[kindred axle]

i also saw a vid on yt which said ldo ones are better

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNTuMiNC2TU

[pseudo mesa]

the ones in your screenshot are the number 1 motors u get recommended on the Monolith server

[kindred axle]

then thats gr8, can you tell me which printer are you using and what speeds are you getting?

[kindred axle]

Oooh damn

[pseudo mesa]

i can not, because im not using them.
but its basic knowledge if u are on the mono discord

[kindred axle]

ooh i see, also can you tell me how resistance and inductance of motors affect print quality ?

like i saw a post on reddit

[pseudo mesa]

i can not.
dont think too much about it

there is a reason they are number 1

[kindred axle]

and someone said ldo super power motors introducs a lot of vfas in the prints due to lower inductance

[pseudo mesa]

we are not doing rocket science here, its a hot glue gun moving around

yes. 2804 are VFA monsters

[kindred axle]

yeaah i get it!

[kindred axle]

ooh damnn so why do people even buy them for vorons?

[pseudo mesa]

unediucated or they want to push >800mm/s speeds

[kindred axle]

wow

i see

btw whats the cofig of your printer?

you use ldo2504 motors?

at 48v?

[pseudo mesa]

click on my profile here, click on the github link, enjoy