#transistor

1 messages · Page 9 of 1

upper portal
#

I always though it was about Sybil

#

Maybe

#

Idk

low cypress
#

I don't know that Sybil held any major significance to Red

#

more like the other way around

rare moth
#

ooooh i love that actually, a really fresh take!!

low cypress
#

Sure, they knew each other, but I think it takes a lot more to write a song about someone

rare moth
#

what if sybil sings she shines to herself....thinking about red ;o;

tardy slate
#

The more they mention its an entirely 2d engine the more I recognize the kinda tricks they pull

low cypress
#

Go head and make that your headcanon, but it's not the case

spring plover
#

Mojken, you can disagree with people all you want but please don't shut down discussion.

low cypress
#

I didn't intend to come off that way

#

I'm just saying that they confirmed on stream that it's one of Red's songs

cedar grove
#

its not sybil's song but she can still sing it to herself thinking about red

#

its not not canon

low cypress
#

That is true

#

I took what they said more as She Shines being Sybil singing about Red, rather than that just happening

#

So, slight misunderstanding

random saddle
#

i always thought she shines was about cloudbank itself

#

like personifying the city

upper portal
#

Whoa

#

I never thought of it that way

#

That makes sense

slow ridge
#

That was always my read on it

low cypress
#

I'll ask, but I most likely won't get an answer

#

They read the comment three above mine, then mentions refreshing chat

#

Let's hope it was before that then, not after 😄

upper portal
#

They’re talking about it!

low cypress
#

They read, it, said that they want it to be up to interpretation, it's from Red's discography, and is partially about the city to some part

#

But Greg holds steadfast to not explaining symbolism

slow ridge
#

Cool

low cypress
#

But, yeah, I agree with what he said, many songs are tangentially about something, but they don't have to explicitly tell a cohesive story about that thing, but instead are just vague references to related experiences that evoke feelings

#

So, basically, summarizing She Shines is hard, and not everything is about the City at face-value, but that is the subject, yes

tardy slate
#

Yeah welcome to Deep up for interpretation Lore

upper portal
#

I think I’m gonna ask about ÍÕMPÆØË

low cypress
#

Ì*

upper portal
#

Oh whatever

low cypress
#

lol

#

They have mentioned that it means something, but dodged a question about if it was just æsthetic or mapped to the language of Cloudbank by saying yes

tender frigate
#

lul

#

it says that on my poster

#

but i dont care what it means coz it looks super sexy

#

i just roll with it

low cypress
#

Darren said my name perfectly yesterday I think, but Amir butchered it 😂

#

But chat is much calmer today, pretty nice

#

"They are just friends who chose to have the same last name" - Greg

tardy slate
#

How did you even type that

low cypress
#

I use Dvorak

tardy slate
#

No thats music

#

👉😎👉

#

And I mean Iompaeoe

low cypress
#

Yeah

tardy slate
#

.... it’s a lot less impressive written that way

low cypress
#

I use Dvorak, lets me combine symbols into joint letters and such

#

It's at least three button presses per letter, and unusual ones so it's pretty hard, but it works

#

ÌÕMPÆØË

#

Takes a while lol

#

`I~OMPAE/O:E, with the combine button before every pair

#

I get the impression that Greg can't stand people who don't readily accept the LGBTQ community. I respect that.

cedar grove
#

well, can you stand people who think others are lesser just for existing?

jolly radish
#

popping in to say i missed the kendrells convo. what was said

cedar grove
#

it does mean a lot to me though, because people who think like that really are out there

low cypress
#

I respect that
*personal attack*

cedar grove
#

it wasnt a personal attack, im sure you can see how its a personal/touchy subject

#

sorry though

low cypress
#

Eh, don't worry about it, it was mostly a joke

#

This scene seems very Japanese to me

foggy fable
#

Fkdkdndkapa

#

Re: cloudbank and unplugging

cedar grove
#

woah what am i missing

foggy fable
#

It’s a leisure city holy shoot

#

I’m freaking out tbh

full peak
#

#confirmed

low cypress
#

Meaning...?

#

All these red lights everywhere...

#

Coincidence?

foggy fable
#

It’s more of a place that folks go to enjoy themselves tbh

low cypress
#

I've always kinda gotten that impression of Cloudbank though

#

That you chose to be there

#

Just like everything else

#

Leisure, red lights, ...

tardy slate
#

Can someone ask if the Proxy is based off a 90’s mac

#

My chat won’t work >:v

fresh void
#

I gotcha

low cypress
#

Ninja'd

fresh void
#

Nevermind

upper portal
#

Cloudbank is a leisure city?

#

I had to leave the stream for a bit

low cypress
#

Lol, he hit a haircut(), then dodged it into where it landed

#

I don't understand, what would it be if not a leisure city

#

Movark, we didn't get an answer

#

I'll ask again

#

Actually, I'll wait a bit more, since the chat hasn't buried it yet

upper portal
#

Cloudbank always reminded me of San Junipero

#

Just a little

foggy fable
#

My chat keeps shooting out, I really hope that this is being recorded;-;

#

The whole thing about leisure cities for me is that I live in one, and I know that those places run fast and efficiently because someone behind the scenes works REALLY hard

#

So like

low cypress
#

They are reading it

#

Not a direct reference, no, but there are very strong connections to an iMac. They both started laughing. @tardy slate

tardy slate
#

Dam

low cypress
#

It was basically like "Yeah, I mean, basically, but it's not supposed to be a reference per-se"

#

So, I take it like it is one, more or less

#

That was a really nice answer

tardy slate
#

when your stream starts cutting out right as they get into Royce’s lab

full peak
#

It s telling you something

tardy slate
#

🙃

#

Skipped the entirety of putting tbit o the cradle

#

And Royce showing up

full peak
#

I got u

#

God royce is so elegant

#

How

tardy slate
#

Sunkish

full peak
#

That and

#

The SMOOTH animations..

tardy slate
#

Boxer is tall

full peak
#

👍 YEP

#

Giant

low cypress
#

No concrete answer

#

But they are as tall as they want to be

#

So I'd wager 1.87 or so

#

Which is a bit taller than me, but beyond that it starts becoming a problem (at least in this world, and that's the only reference we have), and 2m is just scary for everyone

#

I've experienced being much taller than everyone else when I lived in Japan, and you really don't notice it until afterward

#

I look at pictures and it shocks me how short people are by comparison

#

sorry

#

Thank you again @fickle maple and today @frigid raven for yet another amazing stream! It's been a joy watching it, and I'm gonna stay up all night trying to finish Pyre in preparation for tomorrow.

#

Also, thank you for answering all of my questions :3
Much appreciated!

full peak
#

thanks a lot guys!

#

i tuned in to the stream a bit late, was it recorded by anyone?

#

few people recorded it

#

myself included , but you know how steam is a bit iffy and gets stuck at random gilmanangst

#

so some small parts will be missing

#

it's alright!

#

may i have the link?

low cypress
#

It ended a like a min ago, there's no way it's already uploaded somewhere

full peak
#

i haven t uploaded it yet ! i still have to edit it ’n’ stuff too

low cypress
#

Don't bother, that's a LOT of work

#

And a whole bunch of footage to go through

full peak
#

oh i just need to trim some parts is all

#

it s alright ~

low cypress
#

Some simple compression and uploading it to YouTube should suffice

#

Ah, I suppose

full peak
#

@full peak thanks, thats really nice of you

low cypress
#

Cut it when they open the menu at the end, their awkward ending doesn't need to be immortalized heyred

full peak
#

squirtdevious i ll consider

lethal crow
#

hahaha

inland mirage
#

nooo I wanna see the whole thing

#

uncut, uncensored

cedar grove
#

uninhibited

full peak
#

i ll give what i can !!

cedar grove
#

trna stream: directors cut

full peak
#

though it s like 4 am right now and im . deceased

cedar grove
#

god please sleep

full peak
#

i ll do the simple trimming and share some other time !! sorry for those who r excited squirtnya

lethal crow
#

Get some rest!

full peak
#

yes’m , yessir

#

sleep my g

frigid raven
#

@low cypress Thank you!!

#

Thank you folks for tuning in if you caught the Transistor stream today.

languid trail
#

Wait did someone say the kendrells are just friends????

wintry trench
#

Aw, fish.

#

Did I just miss it?

devout ledge
#

Unfortunately yes! They ended about an hour ago.

wintry trench
#

Noooo! *pout*

#

Oh well.

#

I really needed to go outside.

#

I looked at a tree today and though, "Whoa, these graphics are really high resolution."

spring plover
#

A few people recorded it! @full peak is gonna have a copy up in a little while

#

I'd record/watch but the time is literally my overnight ^^;

wintry trench
#

Oh, that's great news!

languid trail
#

I need answers :'D

spring plover
#

Did you see the previous years' transcripts above?

devout ledge
#

Someone did ask about their relationship, but I assure you the answer was not they're just friends.

spring plover
#

Oh wait, about that, sorry :')

languid trail
#

Thank you @caitlin there was a quote out of context and I was freaking out a little bit XD Ive been packing for a trip all day so i couldnt watch

spring plover
#

Yeah, Greg would never say that hahaha. I think the quote was just a joke

languid trail
#

Thanks for clarifying! :D

#

Worst part is ill be away without internet all week so I wont be able to watch the stream for quite a while :'D

#

Also just want to say I love this discord, everyone is so nice

wintry trench
#

Yep!

jolly radish
inland mirage
#

I love the turn() messages

#

"These messages will not be repeated"

foggy fable
#

‘Can you read?!’😂
‘You are mean’🤣

#

At the same time, it’s a little creepy that the world responds like it has its own morality system tbh😨

#

(I’m just gonna get into why I’m excited over ‘leisure city’ now) I feel like we got confirmation that there are other cities besides cloudbank tbh.

#

As mentioned earlier, leisure cities need a lot of work to run. Some of these materials (petroleum, diamonds) aren’t offered in the city, so you have to get them from somewhere else, and use trained labor to get these specialty goods. Thus, the need for ‘working’ cities, tbh.

#

(I mean, there’s also wherever the hell that the Process came from-maybe the Process were from a working area, got tired of sweating it off while cloudbank partied, and decided that they wanted their turn in the sun? 🤷‍♀️)

spring plover
#

I always thought it was kind of implied that the Process provided whatever was needed, and were responsible for making the changes in the city

#

If you have these things that can apparently rewrite whole structures at will, it makes sense that they could produce just about anything else

wintry trench
#

coughfabberscough

spring plover
#

nanofabricators
i think

wintry trench
#

Pick your favorite recycling/fabrication technology.

slow ridge
#

Taking the name litterally, they are the process that anything is done and probably similar to a computer process

spring plover
#

imo it was the fact that the process existed in cloudbank - whether they're "natural" or invented - that allowed Cloudbank to be a leisure city at all

#

if people don't have to be concerned about production, they can be "anything they want"

#

without being concerned about their value in a strictly capitalist, production-based system

#

does that mean social value systems don't still exist, of course not

#

but, you know. different

slow ridge
#

There would be no working class then, and that'd be... Weird

spring plover
#

There is probably still an underclass though

foggy fable
#

Scary stuff, tbh. It changes everything

spring plover
#

Whether they're underclass because they do hard labor or not

#

Niola's whole thing was advocating for "underrepresented" populations

#

the "rule by majority vote" thing obviously leaves a lot of people on the sidelines

foggy fable
#

(I’ve always wondered what causes she was working for.)

spring plover
#

And it's implied that Bailey faced discrimination from a young age despite the whole "you can be anything you want in this town" bit

#

if you're a minority, you're still...well...a minority

#

and that, combined with the ability to change the whole city structurally through voting, brings direct power to a tyrannical majority

slow ridge
#

Explains Red's disillusion

foggy fable
#

There’s a joke about American politics here, but I’m too tired to make it.

spring plover
#

I mean

#

Transistor is an explicitly political game, imo

#

most cyberpunk is. or should be.

#

it's responding to problems we still have, things we still value or look down on as a culture, etc

#

which is why I thought it would be cooler if Cloudbank was a post-technological singularity world, rather than just a simulation, or the inside of a computer

#

once you remove it from human society it gets a lot less...interesting

slow ridge
#

It took me far too long to realize Cloudbank is probably a server bank supporting a cloud

foggy fable
#

@spring plover Then they lose that recursion part, which I want to say is tied closely to the ‘working overthrowing the leisure’ part, but I’m not sure how, tbh. Unless there’s a way to keep it in that I’m missing.

#

@slow ridge same😩 It makes me wonder if it was the cloud that got wiped, or the server that got wiped

spring plover
#

I honestly never thought too hard about recursion, which is my own mistake

#

I sorta just treated it like new game+ lol

slow ridge
#

I asked a tech friend if recursion is a tech term and it is

spring plover
#

Yeah, it is

#

recursive functions are functions that call themselves, if I remember correctly

#

if you don't close it properly a function can call itself infinitely, locking up the program

slow ridge
#

Betheda joke here?

foggy fable
#

Ngl, recursion is hard to think about tbh. I remember the steam forums tearing themselves apart over it😅 I almost want to say that’s because you can’t really read red.
(But if the program locks up, wouldn’t it just freeze?)

spring plover
#

Technically you don't have to recurse

#

You could view it as Red trying things again, somehow, only to realize eventually that it always ends the same way

#

and just, stopping

slow ridge
#

Could also be that recursion is a on theme term for New Game +

spring plover
#

I mean that's how I always took it 😛

slow ridge
#

Then again, there's the opening line...

spring plover
#

y'all know watsonian vs doylist explanations
sometimes you can admit that there's a "doylist" or meta-explanation for something that is outside the lore of the game
but it's just so much more fun to be watson and stay inside the story

#

different people like different answers and usually it's possible to accept both

slow ridge
#

I agree, having read The Dark Tower as a teenager and talking that over and over...

spring plover
#

i don't like thinking about recursion too much because there's not really a good answer and it just makes my head hurt lol

#

i tend to just say "it's just ng+" but i know a lot of people have fun thinking about it too, and there's a lot of cool possibilities

slow ridge
#

I mean, if the Transistor is a giant USB, is there a back up of Cloudbank in it?

#

It's monkeys all the way down!

spring plover
#

Cloudbank's logo is a transistor diagram

#

monkeys, huh? I always heard it as turtles all the way down in school 😂

#

it sure is something all the way down

slow ridge
#

Same but monkeys are funnier

#

Squirts all the way down

foggy fable
#

If there’s a backup; is it the same folks in there, or new ones? Are they gonna make the same mistakes?

glass quail
#

I vote squirts

spring plover
foggy fable
#

I read a kids book about that. Scary stuff lol

spring plover
#

Here's a fun little bit

#

in the final fight with Royce, you see all the traces you've collected in their trace banks

#

mr. nobody isn't there

foggy fable
#

jesus

slow ridge
#

Oh good,, that is a great thought

glass quail
#

oh damn

#

Personally I'd always liked the theory of Cloudbank as an isolated server a la Tron's Grid, and the individual people as programs developed to simulate a world-setting

#

sort of like a modeling-system?

#

but then you have someone like Mr. Nobody, who's possibly a Flynn, or a Clu

#

so they're developed as people, and they fall into human patterns of behavior

slow ridge
#

Maybe he intragrated into the Transistor, as his is the only voice coming out?

spring plover
#

I personally think he's stuck somewhere he shouldn't be. not just that Red can hear him because she knows him, but that he's not actually in the place he "should" be in

#

in a filter of some sort

glass quail
#

but without the RL historical context that predetermines where prejudices fall in here

slow ridge
#

Nobody.exe can't be found?

spring plover
#

he can only communicate with traces while they pass through the Transistor, once they're gone, they're gone

foggy fable
#

Like norton antivirus’ quarantine system

slow ridge
#

I'm due for another play through after I beat Bastion again and soak in all the lore

foggy fable
#

Yessss

#

We need to have a sgg stream, TPP style

spring plover
#

Because like the way Mr. Nobody describes the inside of the Transistor is weird, imo

#

It sounds like he's too close to the surface

#

It's certainly different from where he and Red are in the end of the game

glass quail
#

I always assumed it was something like, Boxer couldn't be processed

spring plover
#

"nothing" doesn't sound like a description of wheat and a nice blue sky

glass quail
#

properly, I mean.

slow ridge
#

So if Cloudbarnk is a pleasure city, then what is the country?

spring plover
#

The natural counterpoint to The City

slow ridge
#

In classical American literature, it depends on the tone of the novel

#

So, Cloudbank is a utopia corrupted, then the country is old school wide open freedom?

foggy fable
#

That’s a good question, because I’m not sure how folks here irl see the countryside.

spring plover
#

it's an ideal, imo
i like to think of it as a real place that became a metaphor for the afterlife

slow ridge
#

I live in Kansas, depends on who you ask

#

There' a sense of do it yourself grit and endurance and quiet, peace

glass quail
#

huh

foggy fable
#

Folks are proud of coming from there.

glass quail
#

I'd always thought of the country as, like, an afterlife/program deleted concept

#

maybe a maintence set

spring plover
#

i think what you think of the country has a lot to do with what you think the nature of cloudbank is

glass quail
#

a place people say they want to visit bet never go, and they don't know a ton about it?

slow ridge
#

With the Process consuming Cloudbank and people getting taken into the Transistor, then the country would be individual focus, as there's room for everyone

glass quail
#

a descriptor for what happens when someone gets removed from the server-system

#

but also, to be fair, I've always viewed Cloundbank itself as an isolated post-scarcity society and less of a straight leisure-city

#

like a model for "in a post-scarcity society, what do we see with human behavior?)

spring plover
#

hmm this is what i wrote...uh...two years ago

#

Farmland seems to be aligned with the Country, a place that seems both made-up and very real in the way it’s spoken about. Either way, it does have a sort of fantastic quality - if they consider farmland to be fantastical or magical, it’s unlikely that they have much of it just lying around in Cloudbank, and while they know about it in concept, it’s almost mythological in the collective mind. Food can’t be brought in from the Country, because no one returns from there.

slow ridge
#

The way Red sings about it in "We All Become" lends to it's mythic status

spring plover
#

people would rather die with their city than flee it, assuming fleeing is an option...

#

this essay was about people actually worshipping Cloudbank

#

like...as a quasi-religion

#

we do see churches in game

slow ridge
#

"She Shines" certainly is a song dedicated to Cloudbank and those exist here

spring plover
#

Cloudbank does a lot of the things deities do. It shelters the people that live there, it provides for them, it “listens” to their requests and changes shape to suit them. It can change the weather, the landscape, even the very color of the sky. It is an entity of incredible power and incredible generosity and to those who know nothing of the Process, it seems to act autonomously, it seems to have agency. It is hardly strange that a population living with such an entity would consider it divine, or a deity in its own right, and would build up a mythos around it and around its peculiar physics and its own type of reality.

This explains a lot of things, including the fervent love many people seem to have for Cloudbank; the feeling that Cloudbank comprises the entire world for these people, that they would rather die with it than flee (assuming fleeing is a possibility); the characterization of one entire sphere of the world, not as “Earth” (as opposed to Heaven), but as “City” (as opposed to Country).

Even for those of a less religious bent, the “way the world works” is still a study for the faithful. Royce can be described as “an atheist looking for god”. It’s safe to say that he found it, in exactly the way he had hoped. Physics, science, and math are their own sort of faith, a belief in the way that the world holds together, and those theories panning out would be like holding the mathematical key to the universe in the palm of your hand. It would be its own sort of revelation.```
#

oh yeah there seems to be a difference between going to the Country and dying

#

with going to the Country being a conscious choice made almost like retirement

#

which would imply, you know... a real place, somewhere

#

even if it's just a soylent green type deal

slow ridge
#

Cloudbank is sitting on a server loaded into the Bastion and Rucks isn't that good of a programmer

#

bam, wrapped up with a bow

primal glacier
#

I feel like the characters themselves contradict each other on what the country is sometime

hollow sable
#

Wow so much discussion, that was great to read

spring plover
#

found what i was looking for!
this is a window used in the sanctuary area of Fairview, with sanctuaries being a seeming equivalent to churches

#

there's some symbolism for ya

slow ridge
#

...Huh

#

My second playthrough will be a deep dive cause that makes me quite curious

#

In "She Shines", Red refers to the city as female but that's nothing new. Cloudbank is certainy something of a mother figure, providing everything for the people

spring plover
#

my own tags are poorly organized so i keep going there to dig up my own writing lol

slow ridge
#

I'll have to check when I'm more awake, as my brain is failing me

#

I'd love to have a conversation about themes and what we each drew from the game

languid trail
#

If im not mistaken, isnt there an ovc terminal where they talk about the citizens gathered at the edge of cloudbank

spring plover
#

yep

#

That's Amelia's final report

languid trail
#

Chilling and watching the world burn

spring plover
#

she basically says there's nowhere to run

#

which implies hard boundaries around Cloudbank of some sort...water, maybe

#

which, again, raises the question of where exactly Mr. Nobody thought he and Red were gonna escape to at the beginning of the game

languid trail
#

I had read it as past some sort of threshold

#

Like you go past point x and the process just leaves you alone

spring plover
#

I think it's even mentioned that the Process don't like water

slow ridge
#

Process are vampires confirmed

#

Wait, thats running water

languid trail
#

Also, jumping in late to an earlier point, theres a theory floating around somewhere that while the transistor is in the possession of a user the traces are locked up like in royces fight, but when its inactive they go to the country area

#

Doesn't explain boxer but

slow ridge
#

...intruiging

languid trail
#

Doesn't explain boxer but

#

Its interesting nontheless

#

Curse you internet, sending double messges

slow ridge
#

I love this place, will return after sleep, thanks for the compelling conversation!

iron atlas
#

Is there a recording of transistor stream?

spring plover
#

Saba is working on it

#

I think she probably had to go to bed

iron atlas
#

Ah alright,thank u! Also hi Ven

spring plover
#

Heyo!

wintry trench
#

Eeheeheeheehee

#

I figured out how to get the Transistor ringtones into my computer for custom alert sounds.

young yew
#

Backreading this was so interesting

inland mirage
#

I love Drunk Transistor's little "woooo" when you win a fight

full peak
#

ikr

#

drunk boxer is so cute

#

i just read this entire conversation and found it really interesting, im glad there are other people who think so deeply about transistor

#

some really good arguments in there

boreal lily
#

did you guys see the game as literature transistor episode?

wintry trench
#

I think it's posted somewhere in here.

full peak
#

about to watch it rn

#

it was posted so many times

boreal lily
#

oh okay

tardy slate
#

The first thing I see on that blog is a redraw of the Spy saying "Gentlemen" but it's Royce

#

And I love it

#

Also this is rleateed to yesterday's stream

#

But they said the Spine hallway used to be some stand in art for like moving around Cloudbank or something like that, and I do remember a GameInformer article saying that the art used there was something like backdoors Red can use to traverse the city, not the gut of The Spine

cedar grove
#

i think this might be what they meant?

tardy slate
#

That may havebeen it too

#

I'm not sure. IT's been 4 years since reading that article

full peak
#

guys i dont mean to be annoying but is there any link up for the transistor stream yesterday or not yet?

#

workin on it

#

Awesome!

#

thanks!

calm jackal
#

did anyone ask about the spooky ghost reds that pop up from time to time?

cedar grove
#

iirc theyre "ghosts" of other players

calm jackal
#

yeah, but like, why?

devout ledge
#

It follows the theme/ominous hinting of recursion.

calm jackal
#

I guess it is pretty thematic when you put it that way

wintry trench
#

[Dark Souls intensifies]

tardy slate
#

Is that what they are?

inland mirage
#

Supposedly. I asked but never got a response.

full peak
#

what do you guys think Recursion actually is?

inland mirage
#

I don't know if there's actually a plausible reason for it in-game like in Bastion. The only reason Royce speaks at the beginning is more than likely just a programming joke

fringe ledge
#

To respond to an earlier point, the process does not like water because even the water by the stage has only been 8% processed when you get back to it near the end. Hence boxer suggesting they don't seem to enjoy water.

pulsar lily
#

Except that Clucker they pointed out that pops out of the fountain. That one doesn't seem to mind, lol

fringe ledge
#

I think recursion is just the ultimate expression of the Camarata's credo. Everything changed, so nothing changed and Cloudbank rebuilt itself. We never know where these people come from, just that they live in Cloudbank. What if once the transistor has everybody the process just starts the program of Cloudbank again, ultimately resulting in the same glitch. What if Red herself is the glitch? Her selections are strange in Cloudbank, and boxer is also an anomaly. Thoughts on thoughts on thoughts

#

@pulsar lily that clucker is a trendsetter lol

hollow sable
#

Do you guys think Boxer was an outsider?

#

The stuff about nonselection in his bio-- does that mean that they have no data on him ever voting in anything? But his bio also says 0% of citizens chose nonselection, so does that mean he's not really from cloudbank?

#

There's also how his status is different, not "integrated" like everyone else but that could just be because they got him by accident since he wasntmeant to be transistor'ed

calm jackal
#

They talk about selection in some throwaway lines near the stage. It's where people choose who they'll be in life or something. The reason his status is different is probably because he got hit with a sword or something. His nonselection messes up the sword, hence breach()

devout sandal
#

Anyone has some opinion on Red's death? I mean not the one at the end, but the one when all of the functions are lost. She glitches, disappears, and then we can hear Boxer calling her name. That's what made me think about if the Cloudbank city is actually a city or some kind of program. On the other hand we can see people's corpse in the game and I'm not so sure if it could be a part of programmed thing were there are no actual people but programs. Even Red does not die this glitched way at the end of the game and her body stays in Cloudbank next to Boxer. To bo honest I don't really know what to think about it right now

inland mirage
#

I think it's the transistor completely overloading (like the functions) and then sucking nearby people (only Red) into it, similar to the Cradle incident with Royce.

knotty moth
#

I know there's theories to the contrary, but I for one am 1,000% convinced Cloudbank is something like a full immersion social media platform VR simulation, sorta like a crazy Second Life of the far future. At the end, you see something like stasis pods containing all the people who've gone to the country, suggesting they're in cryosleep or something.

#

To respond to the death question, I think you're right on the money. She gets sucked into the transistor. Either that or it just burns out and the whole simulation collapses catastrophically.

#

My interpretation is that the transistor itself is a representation of a top level admin control program, and the process are more or less the worker ants that build Cloudbank from behind the scenes, run amok when the Camerata lose control of the transistor.

#

So what would death mean in that view? The process are denying the current user access to the transistor program's functions until they deny her access altogether?

#

Or the "damage" they're doing is corrupting parts of the transistor program until it becomes catastrophically corrupt and... something happens.

#

I don't think it would be inconceivable to speculate that the transistor program has code with self-healing properties, represented by the burning out of functions. If too much gets burned out, however, it's possibly too much for it to self-heal through and it crashes.

fathom scarab
#

What if recursion is actually only the transistor going back in time

knotty moth
#

Or resetting?

fathom scarab
#

I don't think I ever seen a theory about the player

knotty moth
#

You're just playing as Red, arent' you? Not something like the reader in Pyre.

fathom scarab
#

Like what if the game is about playing through the memories of the transistor

#

Only played transistor

knotty moth
#

Oh totally play the other two. They're magical.

#

I think the player's perspective in Pyre is sorta what you're talking about. With maybe a bit of he framed narrative from Bastion.

fathom scarab
#

I'll definitely play them

foggy fable
#

I completely support the 'social media/second life type game' theory because on both transistor and sl, i've seen folks dress up in the gaudiest outfits, behave in the most off kilter ways, and get mad about the most bizarre things

#

I'm surprised that half the cast hasn't coded themselves to dress like memes lol

#

But with all seriousness, the internet grants folks a certain level of anonymity, which lets them act like that. i wouldn't be surprised if some of character's weirder traits came from them being someone else's avatar.

wintry oxide
#

Anyone know if there'll be more Transistor Vinyl's printed ever?

rare moth
#

fun theory: ashers cat is a seperate person using a cat avatar, asher/grant/cat are a poly couple

fickle moth
#

best headcanon

blissful blaze
#

so........ asher and grant and Idk, Some Furry I Guess,

rare moth
#

furry: (picks up the trna from empty cloudbank) aha....i will buuld this plave anew

inland mirage
#

I wonder if there's actually a scoring system for Jump Rating

fathom scarab
#

There was a launcher that said something like "jump algorithm unknown"squirtnya

inland mirage
#

Transistor, 1st playthrough: "oh wow royce can use turn"
Transistor, all other playthroughs: "hissouchthatstungimpossiblenoitcan'tbegonepleasedon'tbegone"

#

his fight doesn't exist once you do recursion

rare moth
#

what?

#

thats weird....i fought him when i replayed 🤔

inland mirage
#

well yeah, but it's over so quickly

rare moth
#

OHHHH

#

ok gotcha

inland mirage
#

because you can instantly delete him

rare moth
#

wait can you?

#

gjgkjgjkghjk ive been just........playin along..............didnt kno the cool hacks.....

inland mirage
#

void(tap, purge) three times on him, bounce(crash, flood) twice on his back and he dies

rare moth
#

OH.....NO WAY GJKGKHK

inland mirage
#

just rinse and repeat twice more for his other lives

rare moth
#

cool hacks...

blissful blaze
#

get rekt

rare moth
#

itd be fun if you could use switch() on him

blissful blaze
#

rekt like the empty set

rare moth
#

pink royce...

#

AAAAA GJKGKGKJGJK

inland mirage
#

royce gets deleted quicker than red's life

#

skadoodle

blissful blaze
#

pink royce? 🤔

rare moth
#

pink royce....

blissful blaze
rare moth
#

PINK ROYCE

#

@jolly radish @full peak ohhhhh you gotta see this

jolly radish
#

PINK ROYCE!!!!!

#

colored like a friend

cedar grove
#

i dont remember if i read that he has a line when you use switch on him or that someone wishes he had a line

#

i never tried

pulsar lily
#

does switch even work on him, i never tried either

cedar grove
#

i could test, maybe? i might have a save file near the end

calm jackal
#

royce is also weak to the stealth move

#

i beat him pretty easy my first run with that

wispy stratus
#

👆

upbeat crown
#

If you guys haven't tried it, Get() upgraded with Spark() and Load() is probably the most busted combo in the game. I beat all of newgame+ with all the limiters on without using Turn() and it felt easy. Only supplement I needed was Crash() upgraded with Jaunt().

devout sandal
#

I'll have to try it then. Thanks!

calm jackal
#

What does load add to get? Aoe damage?

devout sandal
#

"Load forms Packets that draw in nearby targets"

viral token
#

Whaaaat??! 😮 😮 😮 That sounds crazy!!!

devout sandal
#

Oh wait

#

I think I mixed Load upgraded with Get and Get upgraded with Load xD

#

Yeah, that was Load with Get

#

Get with Load: Get becomes slightly stronger and deal damage in a blast radius.

brave halo
#

Load with Get was my favourite combo

#

I think I used Jaunt (Spark) along with that

devout sandal
#

I depended on combos out of Void, Crash and upgraded Breach

#

And Jaunt 'cause it helped me a lot in escaping from enemies

frail fulcrum
#

I just stayed alive with bounce and purge on passives

foggy fable
#

Amen to that tbh. ()Bounce as a passive has bought me a few extra seconds on the Royce battle more times than I can count. 😅

#

Or consider equipping four ()Helps as passives to up your chances to go super user to 100%. I haven’t done it yet, but you know what they say about bringing a rocket launcher to a knife fight🤷‍♀️

fringe ledge
#

Just got my platinum trophy on PlayStation for Transistor! So stoked

low cypress
#

The parentheses go after the functions

calm jackal
#

I don't think you even can equip more than 2 of a function

fringe ledge
#

You can equip the same function in the active and upgrade slot together. I used to double up on spark() to make it rain bombs. With load() on passive?! Forget about it

calm jackal
#

i meant that as a response to 4 passive helps

young yew
#

Oh hmm

frail fulcrum
#

How much damage does superuser's attack do? I only equipped it for the lore and never got lucky

lament creek
#

Was it 500? I feel like it was 500.

inland mirage
#

it's 500

#

I got it all the time

calm jackal
#

the aoe is too small to be that good imo

#

also can't you just mash spacebar until you get lucky? you can exit turn if you havent made any moves

cedar grove
#

its good in the early game

#

also its pretty

calm jackal
#

how early can you unlock passive slots anyway

#

maybe I'm misremembering

languid pawn
#

Sounds like high time for another replay

calm jackal
#

yeah, I've been meaning to do a clean save for a while

hollow sable
#

Hey so u know how Sybil was kinda obsessed with Red and set things up to get rid of Blue/Boxer? What if instead Sybil decided to try to literally obtain Red by trapping Red in the Transistor instead, like how Boxer is trapped in it in the actual game?

#

So say Sybil is successful in trapping Red in the transistor, but before Sybil can take it back Boxer runs off with the transistor

#

And Red & Boxer's roles as they are in the actual game would be reversed

#

from within the Transistor, Red would sing to Boxer as he fights off the process

boreal lily
#

That is 100% valid

hollow sable
#

thank u

calm jackal
#

why would you tease the "play as sybil" and then just tear it away

boreal lily
#

well i guess if Sybil was playable and Red was in the Transistor then Red would'nt say anything or only sing In Circles

calm jackal
#

red would sass sybil the whole way

#

the reason i like sybil as protagonist is because she's the socialite, and sword-holders hear the voices of people they know well. sybil knew all the people in the sword well. it would be very loud

hollow sable
#

Oooooh

#

Lmao then she would hear just about everyone sassing her bc she's the one that put them in there

#

Imagining Red only singing In Circles to Sybil the whole way is hilarious tho

#

"Can you PLEASE just sing something else"

boreal lily
#

"I won't save you"

viral token
#

That's an interesting idea.....Hmmmmm......very intriguing.....

shell widget
#

that

#

would be amazing

viral token
#

TheCakeFlavor--would it, though?? She's an event planner so I assume she knows tons of people only superficially; acquaintances...can you hear people in the Transistor only if you have a personal connection with them, like friendship?? Because then wouldn't Mr. Nobody hear Preston Moyle and all the souls he seems to have background with?? 🤔 transistor wait maybe this doesn't make sense...

rare moth
#

he can, cant he?

#

like he talks to their traces and stuff

viral token
#

face palm

#

Oh yeah.....

#

😛

full peak
#

Has anybody ever brought up the similarities between Blank Canvas' Humming, and Paper Boats' lyrics?

#

Listen to how Red hums in Blank Canvas, and then listen to Paper Boats' lyrics.

calm jackal
#

yeah, she's definitely humming to paper boats

#

but think about it

#

if you have a blank canvas, and then you fold it

#

📰 ⛵

inland mirage
#

she also hums paper boats when there's no music iirc

viral token
#

oh my gosh, I never thought about it that way before....!!! 😮 😮 😮

smoky cliff
#

so the pizza scene has some easter eggs from bastion, do you think the doll face on the left of the shelf is a nod to anything?

calm jackal
#

rite mask prototype?

foggy fable
#

Bummed that pyre didn’t have a transistor shoutout tbh

primal glacier
#

Maybe it did and we just haven't looked hard enough yet lol

calm jackal
#

Falcon Ron is junction Jan the whole time

ebon scarab
#

But Junction Jan's stuff was free, wasn't it?

calm jackal
#

You right... maybe they're mortal enemies

ebon scarab
#

Yes. That makes perfect sense. Ron dosn't like that they sell stuff for free, and they don't like Ron because.....ummm.

calm jackal
#

Jan doesn't like Ron bc Ron smells

ebon scarab
#

Yes. That logic is flawless. Whose Jan anyway?

calm jackal
#

Jan of the junction

inland mirage
#

sEa MoNsTeR's ReAlLy ThE OnLy ChOiCe HeRe

calm jackal
#

Sea monster.... DELUGE!!!!

#

Deluge was on the pizza the whole time

wraith palm
#

🤔

cedar grove
calm jackal
#

found a higher res picture, and it looks like this character you've suggested

smoky cliff
#

@cedar grove That's awesome, great find! I've been curious about that for a while now, thanks!

knotty moth
#

Wow I NEVER noticed that shelf. Thanks for pointing it out, eveyrone.

young yew
#

Whoaaa

knotty moth
#

Didn't Greg or Amir say that the skullgirls artist and Jen were super old friends?

rare moth
#

ohhh really? nice!!

viral token
#

really?? cool if true! Haven't played that game yet, myself...

#

Yeah, an Easter egg in Pyre would have been cool, but on the other hand since it's SOOOOO drastically different than the previous two, I can see why they didn't....although I kept on expecting the Camerata's logo or the hilt of the Transistor (maybe that one is too on-the-nose, though) or SOMETHING to appear in Falcon Ron's bulging packs.... 😋

rare moth
#

falcon ron scooped up the transistor out of red's body and sold the parts downside....despicable 😂 😂

calm jackal
#

Falcon Ron uses the transistor to make his products

viral token
#

Nuuu that is too sad to contemplate! XP

#

😭 😂

full peak
#

"The process, you think they're afraid of heights? <laughter>" <- this is literally the best quote from transistor, don't @ me

#

i love drunk Boxer so darn much

viral token
#

Yeah that's a good line!!

#

I LOVE the one he says about stairs, during that same part. "You know what I hate more than stairs? ....Nothing. Right now, nothing." [I'm paraphrasing...]

#

Him being 'infected'/drunk with pain from the Spine makes me sooo sad, every single time. 😢

rare moth
#

poor guy feels every bump

viral token
#

yeah 😢

#

that must hurt, aches everywhere. Dizzy, confused, disoriented...

calm jackal
#

"When I look up... at where the sky should be... I see you... and I know you can hear me"

inland mirage
#

but also there's the classic

#

"woooooooooooo"

random saddle
#

drunk boxer best boxer

wispy stratus
#

I agree

dire pollen
jolly radish
#

"imagine: royce and sybil cooking"

rare moth
#

omg

#

whwhwhwhwhat are we aiming at

jolly radish
#

IM GONNA DIE

elder prairie
#

"we toast marshmallow chocolate, we know that's a schmore-"

jolly radish
#

help

elder prairie
#

"we march to the beat of our own avocado" - royce bracket from the game transistor

rare moth
#

for the sake of a comedy bit look what ive done. im so sorry. this is horrible i kin

slow ridge
#

Trying to picture the Transistor being used as a kitchen knife and failing

rare moth
#

HFHJFJHFHJ

jolly radish
#

imagining sybil cackling like that at the end and im slain

slow ridge
#

"So we need to sear the fish..." uses Crash

slow ridge
#

...I see we have an artist in our midsts

#

Hope they don't used Processed cheese

jolly radish
#

KAM SCREAMS

rare moth
#

eyyyyyyyy ajfingerguns

jolly radish
rare moth
#

Royce uses the transistor as a giant letter opener and disintegrates all the mail

slow ridge
#

Would the mail just go in the Transistor?

#

Or just the data on the paper?

sturdy gale
#

Sybil is a fan girl lonve her shirt

rare moth
#

the whole thing just gets processed i guess

#

"sorry we didnt go to your wedding i unmade the invitation"

slow ridge
#

...Gives a whole new meaning to the term "Don't shoot the messenger"

#

Or I suppose "Impale the messenger to get the message"

viral token
#

Kamilla your art is so good and funny! Arg I wanna try digital art

rare moth
#

thank u!!! u really should, if u can get a tablet!!

slow ridge
#

Playing Transistor was weird for the first time due to me having a friend nicknamed Red, with red hair and also sang, mostly obsene songs about his computer that died on him with an acoustic guitar

young yew
#

Amazing. Did Saba see this yet?

#

@full peak

full peak
#

Planning to GWfroggyZoomeyes

full peak
#

If you mean Kam s art then i ve been staring at this for 5 hours now

#

If you mean the video i watched it 2-3 times GWfroggerHyperXD

manic lava
#

kam everything u draw makes my life better

viral token
#

Oh wow, Shoshana, that's CRAZY coincidence wow!!!!

#

AWWW Kamillia you are so encouraging thank you!!!!!!!!! My brother miiiight have one still, I don't know, but if he does I want to try this weekend!! Thanks!!! 😄 😄 😄 volfredthink

rare moth
#

oooooh if u get a chance show me what u drew :0!!

viral token
#

Ok!! 😄 😄 First I have to get use to holding the pen and how it works in general compared to physical paper, ehhhhehehehehe, I've never done it before in my life but I'd love to show you (if he indeed still has the tablet for me to borrow!) 😄

rare moth
cinder arch
#

can un post art

cedar grove
#

@cinder arch in #fan-works you can

thick coyote
#

Hi!

full peak
#

hello hello welcome !!

hallow summit
#

Hello to every Transistor

random saddle
#

heh

#

hello

ashen flame
#

I had to stop my transistor play through awhile back because i got stuck in one of the levels by killing stuff to fast

#

the next door never opened and i couldn't go backwards either was very unfortunate never went back to start over to finish the game

lethal crow
ashen flame
#

DOPE

#

as soon as i get done with my destiny stuff will do

dawn ridge
#

best company

cedar grove
#

bless supergiant tech support

#

yall are great

ashen flame
#

honest to god anytime someone ask for a game recommendation i say either bastion or transistor the story the art ITS AMAZING

cedar grove
#

yup transistor is my first recommendation always

viral token
#

YES!

#

I always recommend their games ❤

sick panther
#

i've found home ❤

left plinth
#

i got my gf to cosplay red by talking about transistor every day of my life

#

im proud of this achievement

modest snow
#

I'd like to register my complaint that beating the six young ladies in that one room doesn't give XP

pseudo pulsar
#

think it's intentional

modest snow
#

I mean, I wouldn't be the least bit surprised

#

"you coulda just run away ya dingus"

slow ridge
#

Taking the quote about young ladies out of context is somewhat tragic

lofty aurora
#

do you get XP for killing any of the enemies outside of a battle?

modest snow
#

don't believe so

#

again, much to my chagrin

lofty aurora
#

i think it's cool, especially because at that point in the game there are quite a few normal process not in battle, showing that the process really is taking over, but the few enemies that you do end up getting XP from are the newly introduced process-induced humans

calm jackal
#

is man canonically people?

#

I thought limiter logs showed that man was just imitating people, like snapshots were imitating cameras

viral token
#

Proceeded humans?? You don't face anything like that, do you...?? What are you talking about...? 🤔 🤔

#

Wha? How is the young ladies "out of context" tragic, Shoshana??

slow ridge
#

You beat up six ladies in a room

viral token
#

oh lol I guess if you take it like that. But it's word choice. Technically you destroy them utterly....

#

shrug

#

😛

slow ridge
#

I'm aware

viral token
#

😃

slow ridge
#

But strip out the context and many things sound quite odd

viral token
#

yeah, I know. 😛 I do that sometimes with random book sentences XP

#

ever played that game with several people who all read out a random sentence of different books, on the same page, and see if they make a "story"? It's hilarious!!

#

Anyway I should get to sleep, goodnight all!

calm jackal
#

Man is based on royce, and one of the features the process decided to replicate was the haircut, because royce's hair is very important to him

hollow sable
#

man after hearing Pantheon from Bastion I really want Logan Cunningham to sing a song in Boxer's voice

#

Speaking of which, is the male voice in Paper Boats Logan Cunningham or Darren Korb?

blissful blaze
#

i'm pretty sure it's darren, but don't quote me on it

#

seems like something to ask him

spring plover
#

I'm like 99% sure it's Darren
The 1% is because I can't remember where I heard that

hallow summit
#

Wait! Why Darren Korb and Ashley Barrett are not in this discord. or they are in disguise? Show yourself, beauties! 😄 ❤

calm jackal
#

darren's definitely in here, he's just offline so you cant see him in the team list

hallow summit
#

@calm jackal That's cool.. so now i have to look all those offline people. :)) but what about Ashley?

calm jackal
#

I dunno

hallow summit
#

Yeah I found Darren.. B) but no sign of Ashley.

manic lava
#

they're doing an ask session today so you can ask then

misty rapids
#

Is Ashley officially part of the Supergiant Team? I thought she was free lance or something and Darren knew her.

viral token
#

I think she is officially a part! ^_^ (and at this point, how can she NOT be?? XP )

tight swallow
#

crossover with VA11-Hall-A when?

thorny lotus
#

@hollow sable Logan does the very beginning ("The river always finds the sea...")
Then it switches to Darren ("Paper Boats floating on a stream...") for the rest of the song

#

Youll notice the eq is kinda different if you pay attention transistor

viral token
#

whoa!!!!

#

That's amazing!!!

viral token
#

Hey, anyone Google "Gustav Klimt" just when Jen Zee mentioned him in the chat?? You gotta look him up!!! It's really amazing, and the influence on Transistor is awesomely clear as day; INCREDIBLE work!!!!!! Look him up! 😄

cedar grove
#

hes one of my favorite artists!!

#

its another reason i love transistor that much

mighty spade
#

the name is familiar, I'm pretty certain I have his name somewhere on my Art's History book from highschool (or the equivalent in my country)

tight nacelle
#

Yeah! I studied him a bit since I had friends in art history (I had math instead of history)

split cove
#

that Klimt painting with a predominantly gold color with the couple is iconic

mighty spade
#

@tight nacelle u portuguese, right? I figured when you mentioned Iberanime 😄

tight nacelle
#

@mighty spade I am!

viral token
#

It's iconic?? Whoa! Cool! He is definitely amazing; I'd never heard of him before. But there's one near the top/first row of Google images that look almost exactly like Red and Mr Nobody 😍 transistor heyred

split cove
#

that's the painting i'm talking about 😄

#

when people think of klimt, that's the first painting that usually comes to mind

gloomy rain
#

Fun fact, the museum where that painting is exibited has a room at the side with a reproduction and much better light for your selfie needs

blissful blaze
#

i love it

split cove
#

hahaha omg

cedar grove
#

i have a canvas print of it on my wall

split cove
#

best piece of trivia i've heard all day

cedar grove
#

its like, giant

mighty spade
#

don't you mean...

gloomy rain
#

The original is huge too, I did not expect that

mighty spade
#

super giant?

#

kill me

tight nacelle
#

pew pew

gloomy rain
#

No, not that big

#

But it's bigger than I expected

tight nacelle
#

That sounds

#

Slightly wrong

#

I'm sorry

gloomy rain
#

Oh, sorry, I forgot to say that I don't do phrasing

sacred delta
#

I find it cute that all of the Steam emotes are here as emotes, too.

#

heyred still the best.

viral token
#

I love the Steam emotes!

#

Yeah, that painting is amazing, must be huge in real life!! It's so pretty!!

boreal lily
#

@blissful blaze i saw a transistor edit of that one

cedar grove
#

yeah i saw fanart of it v recently !

#

ohh havent seen that one actually

cedar grove
#

i drew one myself once, but its red and sybil, and its old and unfinished

mighty spade
#

I think I just found a new wallpaper for my phone

tight nacelle
#

@boreal lily your icon!! Is that you?! Momma Jodi!!!

boreal lily
#

yeah that's me :3

tight nacelle
#

@boreal lily it's so well done!!

viral token
#

those....are.....

#

amazingggggg

#

stunned!

#

they're so GORGEOUS..

viral token
#

I don't know if that's funny, or heartbreaking, or amazing....

#

All of them. nod

young yew
#

I've only seen one or two of those Transistor renditions of The Kiss

#

They are all so gorgeous

bright hearth
#

Transistor but its the Sword wearing the coat and he's hopping around using Red as a sword

boreal lily
#

ok now i gotta draw it

bright hearth
#

Red is Tposing

lofty aurora
#

I'm late but I always thought Man was actually humans, as in the designation Royce says one of the Camerata says that it is a "living sculplture", but Royce continues that it is "something rather troubling" going on instead. I assumed that meant it was taking over humans, but I could be wrong.

ornate hull
#

My thoughts on it is that Man is an imitation of people that starts to act like people. Like if a statue started walking around and tried to be a person.

rigid hull
#

I've had both of those impressions. Not sure which one I like more, they both seem troubling. Though I do suspect it's more of them being imitations that start to act like people, almost like it's adapting and trying to make the city full of people again but they're just mimics.

ornate hull
#

That fits even better. Since if the mimic gets to be good enough, who's to say its not the real thing, or that it wasn't that way to start with.

jolly radish
#

to me the most unnerving interpretation is that the process has started emulating people and royce has absolutely no idea why

#

i've often thought that royce knows the process better than anyone else and yet he still understands almost nothing about them

blissful blaze
#

when the average person knows absolutely nothing of a subject, it becomes remarkably easy to be the most knowledgable

fringe pivot
#

Heya red looking to trade?

jolly radish
#

important note: tangent is one of the most beautiful tracks in..... anything, ever

#

thanks for coming to my ted talk

#

really listen to it if you haven't, guys, it's so complex.

calm jackal
#

uh, waterwall

#

apex beat

#

but tangent is really evocative, sure

jolly radish
#

did you mean: the entire gotdang ost

viral token
#

Xel: My thoughts exactly!! 😃

languid trail
#

I remember the year Transistor released Austin Wintory expressed his disappointment that Darren Korb wasn't nominated for a Grammy

viral token
#

Wow!

#

He should have, Transistor's sound track amazes me every single time!!

#

😍 heyred 🎵

graceful cave
#

thinking about how like. the game kinda falls into the bury the gays trope but. it's a bury the everyone trope so tbh it cancels itself out

viral token
#

What are you talking about?! Why do so many people assume "obsessed with Red" means in love with Red? Red herself is totally, obviously, straight; she's in love with the man in the Transistor! Sybil can be creepily, completely obsessed with a potential victim without it always being love. 🙄 😒

#

In fact, it's creepier that way--straight, utter obsession, she's a twisted fan-stalker with a superior agenda; one thing I've learned about storytelling over the years is that a lot of the time, the simplest explanation makes for the most compelling.

full peak
#

you ll never take the potential of red being bi from me

graceful cave
#

thats. not the thing im talking about

#

and also its very clearly implied whtever feelings were there were not reciprocated

#

so red's sexuality is still undetermined

#

and not relevant

viral token
#

To each their own, I guess, Booby, by all means, that is just my view, you can totally have yours, no harm meant or anything.

#

😃

graceful cave
#

not to mention that saying that "she loves a man" meaning she's straight is kinda a big ass disservice to bi ppl

viral token
#

I didn't mean to come off as stiff or something, I'm sorry about that, if I did.

graceful cave
#

theres no evidence one way or the other, but saying that she's clearly straight is. there's nothing there

viral token
#

there's nothing saying she's straight? But there's nothing saying she isn't, either? 🤔 Huh?

spring plover
#

To be fair, Jan, the info for sybil as far as i remember says something to the effect of her being infatuated with Red

graceful cave
#

it's like it's ambigious and it's possible to be bi and never mention to someone you meet that fact

viral token
#

....I guess....Hmmmm....🤔

spring plover
#

Its possible to interpret that as nonromatic but it's...a stretch imo

graceful cave
#

straight shouldn't be the default

spring plover
#

You're kinda doing more mental work to assume she's not into Red than to just take the profile at its word

viral token
#

infatuate= "be inspired with an intense but short-lived passion or admiration for.".....

#

I see your point.

spring plover
#

I have never ever seen that word used non-romantically

#

And I like to think I'm pretty well-read lol

glass quail
#

Regardless of Red's feelings on the matter, Sybil's framing, at least to me, was very... romantic view gone wrong

spring plover
#

Yeah

viral token
#

I get what you are saying!

glass quail
#

so I kinda stand with @spring plover on this one

viral token
#

I see what you're saying, Soliam...

spring plover
#

Red is relatively ambiguous

#

I've seen people interpret In Circles as Red being disgusted with Sybil even, turned away by her advances

viral token
#

I hope I'm not coming across as too argumentative, btw!! 😋 Sorry guys.

#

if i am. was.

#

I understand your statements!

spring plover
#

It's cool, I just feel the wording is pretty unambiguous on that point at least! :P

#

Greg is vague about a lotta stuff but he wasn't very vague about Sybil

glass quail
#

Also I think the main earlier thing about the bury your gays quote kinda also

graceful cave
#

"bury the gays" also applies to trans characters, too, and in the game i forget who has a very clear "gender - x" marker with an androgynous character design in their trace profile, leading me to believe very heavily that she (pronoun used in the bio) is a nonbinary woman

glass quail
#

was more about The Kendrells

#

too

graceful cave
#

yep

viral token
#

But that kinda loops this around to the beginning, I thought we were saying the matter IS kind of supposed to be foggy, you're saying he wasn't vauge? I suppose, but a lot of the files were only summeries...

glass quail
#

but yeah no since everyone dies its more just a whole thing

trim turret
#

man i love transistor

viral token
#

well I don't want to make this more complicated LOL....

trim turret
#

songs bop

graceful cave
#

a lot of the time the trope applies to works where straight relationships are allowed to go off without a hitch, but the gay characters get to enjoy torture and pain to make a "tragic" and "emotional" impact

spring plover
#

There have been a lot of conversations about where the treatment of the Camerata falls within the bury your gays trope, the "villainous queer" trope, the predatory lesbian trope...

graceful cave
#

but since this is a work thats pretty much leaning into tragedy and constant loss as a theme

trim turret
#

t-they were queer?

spring plover
#

The kendrells were married

viral token
#

apparently.

spring plover
#

So uhh

trim turret
#

i beat the game twice and i didn't even notice

graceful cave
#

it's Word of God, too, right?

glass quail
#

^ yeah what ven's saying

viral token
#

i never figured that out until ages and ages afterward.

spring plover
#

Not sure Greg has said anything explicitly but. No other explanation really holds water

viral token
#

Well--I thought they were BROTHERS. :p

#

:p

spring plover
#

I've seen people reach for "asher is grant's son" lol

viral token
#

😛

trim turret
#

:p

viral token
#

Brothers could work, adopted.

spring plover
#

If you tried, sure

glass quail
#

Their sumaries talk about how they first met don't they?

trim turret
#

anyways man i'd love for a remix soundtrack of the ost

spring plover
#

Again it's an occam's razor thing

upbeat sky
#

I’m with Janeen on this one. Always thought they were brothers

spring plover
#

The simple explanation is staring you in the face

viral token
#

makes sense to me but then again their relasionship isn't exactly the focus of the story..

spring plover
#

I'd grab text but I'm at the store lol

glass quail
#

People can obviously interpret what they want XD

viral token
#

lol

#

of course!

lofty aurora
#

Doesn't something about Asher in the game say something along the lines of he met someone that is far more important to him than any of the change he wanted?

upbeat sky
#

More I think about it though, the more it seems less likely

viral token
#

I mean...the game and story and themes is about CHOICE after all, so us players can choice interpretations, right? 😜

upbeat sky
#

They’d look more alike I suppose

glass quail
#

Yeah, Asher's file

pulsar lily
#

@graceful cave Bailey Gilande (Get(), I think?) is the "gender: X" lady!

graceful cave
#

yep!

trim turret
#

hopefully at the next event where supergiant is at they'll have Junction Jan's pizza there

glass quail
#

is framed that they'd never met before Asher was interviewing Grant

graceful cave
#

ty

pulsar lily
#

("gender: X" neutral... person ayou know what the profile uses feminine pronouns so I'll stick with "lady")

calm jackal
#

I'd like to say that the kendrells being gay was confirmed word of god

viral token
#

ugh this is so much fun!!! but I need to take a shower...

#

That would be AWESOME if they had Junction Jan's pizza/flatbread!!!!

trim turret
#

yo like the pizza looks good

viral token
#

i know right!

graceful cave
#

this also gets into the fact that in lots of works straight relationships are allowed to be accepted when written through the tool of subtext, but theres definitely a cultural push to assume all characters are straight unless explicitly stated, due to the fact that for so long subtext was ALL we got and it was more bait than anything, so delicate writing isn't really allowed to exist due to miscommunication of attempt.

upbeat sky
#

Sea Monster’s really the only choice here

viral token
#

😋 🍕

lofty aurora
#

yeah Sea Monster would go much more quickly than any of the other flavors

trim turret
#

when is my miku x red collab tho

glass quail
#

@graceful cave I will say that I really sorta like how, on that front, Transistor kept a lot of things very subtext-y for nearly everyone

lofty aurora
#

Dang Miku x Red would be pretty cool

graceful cave
#

yes!

viral token
#

Yeah! Even the main plot was pretty vauge at points. I liked that. The story wasn't "spoon-fed" to you.

glass quail
#

Like I thought it was very interesting that even though Red/Boxer as dating was all very subtext and subtly written, the one time he confesses was

graceful cave
#

transistor does so much with subtext

trim turret
#

theres no way supergiant hasnt existed for this long and not heard of miku

glass quail
#

when he was literally drunk and malfunctioning

graceful cave
#

its this weird balance

#

of dense and "hard" but delicate and flower-like

trim turret
#

like i havent even heard of like, fanmade stuff too

glass quail
#

it was very neatly done, I thought, and I think they did a very good job with it, overall way better than a lot of others who have tried

viral token
#

yeah, really we don't even know if they are husband, boyfriend and girlfriend, fiance...

trim turret
#

wait nvm

viral token
#

But then again the song is "OLD FRIENDS"....telling some of the story right there. Obviously known each other for ages.

glass quail
#

Exactly! Like, all the subtext hints are there

#

but its the same hints that are there for the Kendrells

#

which i thought was very neat.

trim turret
#

nvm all the fanmade stuff is bad

glass quail
#

Like, everyone got treated on the same playing field, which I enjoyed

trim turret
#

i think miku and red would be a neat lil duet

glass quail
#

There's more with Red and Boxer, simply because they are basically the two characters we follow throughout the game

viral token
#

I've heard people say that growing into a romantic relationship with a childhood friend is such a special thing....cherished, you know?

#

Yeah....

glass quail
#

but otherwise EVERY relationship is all subtext

viral token
#

Miku?? Hastune Miku????

trim turret
#

yes

#

that miku

viral token
#

Yeah!! 😍

glass quail
#

and how-where you interpret that relationship is cool

trim turret
#

i mean is there any other miku

glass quail
#

as far as Vocaloids, personally I think Red would go better with Gakupo but thats just me

viral token
#

no, I suppose not....

trim turret
#

who

viral token
#

I LOOVE how all the Functions, connected to their people/users, have backstories, and I guess you're right, we are free to fill in the details ourselves, and that's what's so cool....

trim turret
#

yeah transistor is pretty dark soulsy with their info and lore

#

:^)

lofty aurora
#

I'm not sure I would have appreciated Transistor as much if I hadn't played Dark Souls beforehand

#

so I'm glad I did

upbeat sky
#

Is it ever explained exactly what a “trace” is? Why they have the effects they do on the transistor?

lofty aurora
#

because they are both in my top 3 favorite games

viral token
#

Arg, I gotta peace out. See all of you fantastic people later!!!!

graceful cave
#

also doesn't sybil's trace have some sort of heart/pink aesthetic with one of its uses?

trim turret
#

well you see, in the series fate/stay night, shirou uses trace-on as a means to...

glass quail
#

@trim turret Gakupo? He's the purple-haired one based off the same guy who voiced Genesis in FF Crisis Core

viral token
#

What? How does appreciatng Dark Souls have to do with Transistor....?

lofty aurora
#

See ya!

glass quail
#

whos an actual japanese singer

#

Dark Souls Lore is like

#

all implied

#

and in object text

graceful cave
#

no that's another character

trim turret
#

very heavy implications

viral token
#

I think a Trace is like their soul, which is then uploaded and "translated" into a Function based on who they were when alive....

lofty aurora
#

Because I played Dark Souls I grew to appreciated subtext and cryptic lore more, which is definitely present in Transistor. So since I played Dark Souls first I appreciated Transistor more than I would have otherwise

viral token
#

ohhhh, cool!

#

That's great!

#

I've never played that before; heard it's hard, though.

trim turret
#

yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah it is

lofty aurora
#

It's not that hard for me anymore

#

but difficulty is subjective

graceful cave
#

also i wanna say that the designs for all the trace characters are. amazing and tbh my only dissapointment with the game is that there wasn't anything done with them

trim turret
#

they were used as stepping stones LMAO

graceful cave
#

i think it'd be amazing to see an animated anthology series that handles vignettes into their lives before they were processed if the world were ever to get extensions

spring plover
#

ok i got text, lemme clean up the formatting

#
Background 
Most children learn to stop asking 'why', but Mr. Asher Kendrell never outgrew it. His hunger for knowledge and his eagerness to spread it made him a prolific writer, who enjoyed a career as a culture-and-current-events editor for OVC. When Mr. Kendrell wasn't busy reporting, he occupied himself studying the history of his city. But the deeper he delved, the more frustrated he became with all the dead ends and contradictions. The facts simply did not add up, so he started piecing together the unwritten history of Cloudbank. He conducted interviews with venerable members of society, those who willingly worked past retirement age or could speak first-hand about the past. The most remarkable among them was an administrator.

Secrets
Mr. Kendrell was struck by the administrator's wisdom and depth of experience, and the two shared a passion for seeking the truth of things, and for much more, as it turned out. One day the administrator took Mr. Kendrell aside to a place unlike any he'd seen before, and revealed to him something he never could have imagined. With it, the administrator said, together they could learn so much -- about the past, and about the future -- as long as Mr. Kendrell was willing to keep it a secret. Mr. Kendrell accepted without a second thought. The administrator was much more to him than just a source at this point.

Goals 
Mr. Kendrell continued writing for OVC, now with an ulterior motive, having joined the administrator's inner circle. The administrator needed someone like Asher to help keep a low profile, someone who could speak directly to the hearts and minds of the population, and truly understand their needs. That way, they could conduct their work in service of the people. Cloudbank would enter a new era.```
trim turret
#

so does anyone know when when you start the game a second time, that one villain dude is the person that says the beginning sentence?

graceful cave
#

maybe have some sort of like. element of the traces interacting with each there after processing to link the vignettes together or have some sort of play off of what their stories mean to the core themes

#

it's so the game begins and ends with a brackett, like a function or method in real programming

#

thats the best i got

#

o've never been able to decipher it past that

spring plover
#
Background
Known in elite social circles throughout Cloudbank, Ms. Sybil Reisz organized many of the city's popular public events, from ground-breaking ceremonies to contemporary festivals. She was everywhere, and yet somehow she made time to lead a second, hidden life. As one of the Camerata, Ms. Reisz was responsible for gathering information about potential high-value targets, people who could contribute to their cause. She did this job to perfection, drawing no notice, though one target in particular caused her much frustration.

Meeting Red
Ms. Reisz met Red while putting together a small program for up-and-coming artists, and became infatuated first with Red's music then with her. According to diary entries there was something inscrutable and confident about Red that Ms. Reisz could not explain. However, Ms. Reisz was frustrated to find that Red grew distant. Through all this, Ms. Reisz observed the aloofness of one of Red's companions, and decided he must have been insinuating Red against her. Ms. Reisz thought through various ways to rectify this.

Recommendations
One night Ms. Reisz nominated Red as a target for her Camerata colleagues, citing Red's surging popularity in the city and her unusual set of selections. Red could substantially advance the Camerata's agenda, and was not yet so ubiquitous that her sudden disappearance couldn't be sufficiently disguised. Ms. Reisz promised that the Camerata could get to Red at a time when she would be completely alone. Trace data reveals an 85% chance she falsified this claim.```
#

the text in transistor is so much easier to clean than pyre's....

misty rapids
#

Thank for text

frail fulcrum
#

Is recursion considered canon? Like in Bastion?

fringe ledge
#

@frail fulcrum definition I found for recursion is interesting
"a computer programming technique involving the use of a procedure, subroutine, function, or algorithm that calls itself one or more times until a specified condition is met at which time the rest of each repetition is processed from the last one called to the first"

jolly radish
#

late but ah, if there's one thing i wish we'd gotten to see explored in greater detail in transistor it's grant and asher's relationship...

#

(well, that and that good good bracket content but i have a tiny but of a bias)

#

but the story is so dense as it is

manic lava
#

dude dlc where it's a vn of grant and asher's everyday life

blissful blaze
#

the true genius of recursion

#

is that it begins and ends

#

with a bracket

#

🥁 ba-dum tsh 🥁

dire pollen
#

oh my gosh

jolly radish
#

honestly transistor has one of those settings where i just genuinely want to see the slice of life content

#

of course the fact that it's just out of reach is probably what makes it seem so appealing...

#

but cloudbank seemed pretty rad when it wasn't actively being deleted

#

babs i'd fund that

#

i bet whatever courtship occurred there was cute

dire pollen
#

same, it's probably one of the top fictional places I'd want to visit
those credit drawings of red and boxer really really made me curious about the day-to-day life there

manic lava
#

hey canon fact: asher's cat vitriolically hates everyone except asher BUT it likes grant too and that's how asher knew grant was the one

jolly radish
#

lfnanfvdj

#

is asher's cat the only like. non-process animal we see?

#

i guess there are birds too aren't there

manic lava
#

mmmaybe

full peak
#

@jolly radish i always thought if transistor were to be turned into a show, you could spend an entire season with each episode episode respectivdely focussing on the the camerata's targets and how they lived their lives before getting attacked, building up to the events that happen in Transistor with Red (I dont know if that makes sense)

#

respectively*

manic lava
#

that'd be cool as hell

dire pollen
#

I need it

viral token
#

That'd be awesome!

jolly radish
#

haha it's funny you say that, i'm watching oitnb right now and imagining that sort of timeskip style of storytelling

rigid hull
#

One of the reasons I love Transistor is how subtle a lot of the story is. If you never read the text closely, you could miss so much.
I never noticed Grant and Asher sharing a last name until after my first playthrough and taking a moment to browse online for more info that I might’ve missed. 😄 Second playthrough I paid a bit more close attention to things, especially the text you see before interacting with terminals (like the missing person report going up by the thousands as you watch).

mortal pilot
#

It's defenetly not an on-your-face story with characters spouting out exposition, the characters don't feel like they're there just to drive the plot, they feel a bit more real than that

#

Which yeah, it's great. I just think Transistor has a bunch of elements that make it feel fresh, be it the way that it's written or the gameplay

tough galleon
#

Asher always wanted to die with the one he loved

#

I guess you could say that his wish was

#

Granted

viral token
#

oh my gosh

tough galleon
#

What does Royce use to take pictures?

#

A camerata

rare moth
#

hey does anyone have a cap of the overload-function lost screen?

languid trail
#

The first time I played, when Asher first mentions Grant I thought "People ship these two so hard dont they" then when I saw their bios and that they shared a last name my head exploded XD

rare moth
#

people ship them....bc they ship each other lol

full peak
#

@rare moth i think i have what youre looking for but cant seem to send pictures on here

rare moth
#

can you dm me pls

full peak
#

@mortal pilot yeah, i really like the subtlety of transistor, and the characters are pretty well developed considered how short the game is. they arent good or bad, the camerata do crappy things but when you look at it from their perspective you can sympathize a bit

viral token
#

Oh, you totally can. They started off trying to do something good, but it...spiraled drastically out of control. They confess, they barricade themselves in because they can't take the Process--which I love. Their mistake had grown so huge they were unable to handle it. You relate to them and kind of feel sorry for them at the same time....I always like/admire that part, because it gives them so much depth from that fact alone!

full peak
#

guys guys guys i finally got all the achievements in transistor

#

we did it reddit

cedar grove
#

👏 👏 👏

calm jackal
#

Which limiter was the hardest for you?

jolly radish
#

the one that doesn't let you uninstall functions without breaking them tbh

#

i am far too inattentive for that

#

or the one that seriously reduces mem...

full peak
#

Pyre and bastion with full handicap are hard but transistor with all limiters, how do you guys not go mad ? I'd flip it.
Well, congrats 👏

full peak
#

the protected cells one is the hardest

#

ping() + jaunt() as a backup usually does it tho

violet nimbus
#

guh I had to take off protected cells I think when I reached the spine

full peak
#

i found a really good loadout (i think thats what it's called?)

#

i dont know if i wanna post it tho, dont wanna ruin the achievement or whatever

calm jackal
#

protected cells are weak to spark

#

there's plenty of good loadouts floating around for those who want them

#

the most boring possible good loadout is spark(switch())

#

in my first playthrough, that's how i got through man

#

and also bounce on passive

#

anyone here made ping viable?

full peak
#

ping has saved my life

#

like there would be times where my tap would overload and i would have nothing else but ping to attack with

#

underrated function smh

slow ridge
#

I don't care if it is the worst attack in the game, but the sound of it firing makes it one of my favorites

#

It's so chunky and rapid firing, I love it

full peak
#

its fun to spam

calm jackal
#

i love the animation

full peak
#

The brapbrap is really funny but it's just so weak

calm jackal
#

did yall notice that they specifically nerfed the interaction between ping and crash? crash doesn't apply its full debuff if done through ping

#

imagine a world in the sgg labs where ping was actually "too good"

slow ridge
#

Slander!

full peak
#

Was there other nerfs/buffs ?

calm jackal
#

seems like ping switch would be another candidate, but I don't remember

full peak
#

Mainly used load on launch and still do but it never seemed to have changed

calm jackal
#

load on passive has saved me so many times

slow ridge
#

I'm dubbing Ping as Lars Ulrich, the drummer from Metallica, that everyone puts up with but no one really likes

full peak
#

Sparks would be noel gallagher #diss

#

Load on passive pops randomly, right ?

#

it spawns random packets iirc

#

not a big fan really

#

Love it on active

#

In the end of the game everything gets os'd

#

what does os'd mean? sorry for my ignorance

#

One shot