#history

1 messages ¡ Page 224 of 1

frigid karma
#

"blblbllblblblbllbblb"

spring briar
#

Dolphin waifus

frigid karma
#

not prime english materials

strong plank
#

why NASA?

spring briar
#

😩

frigid karma
#

space dolphins

strong plank
#

like how's that within their area?

spiral cedar
#

I mean

#

It’s pretty obvious

#

They found the dolphin in space

tough quail
#

because they need to seduce PLAN officers on the moon ocean

strong plank
#

douglas adams type shit

frigid karma
#

this is the 60s

#

china is uh

#

not a strong geopolitical power

#

i doubt they had anything bigger than an an shan

tough quail
#

oh my brain jumped to the 2014 date

spiral cedar
#

In 1939, French Lick Springs, Indiana, passed a law requiring all black cats to bells on Friday 13th. A piece of forward-thinking wildlife conservation to help the local birds, you ask? Oh, no – this law intended to protect people! According to a 1942 New York Times article, it was ‘a war measure to alleviate mental strain upon the populace’. Presumably, hearing a cat’s bell, residents could avoid one crossing their path and bringing bad luck. The article also mentions that when the law wasn’t enforced in 1941, ‘a number of minor mishaps occurred‘.

tough quail
#

VMF officers on the moon ocean then

strong plank
#

are we not gonna talk about how its called

#

French Lick Springs

manic latch
spring briar
#

Do not look up “space dolphin 1956”

spiral cedar
#

And that’s my one allotted emote for the day

spring briar
#

Jaba don’t look at me like that

spiral cedar
#

Also, clearly the lack of enforcement of the law in 1941 is what led to Pearl Harbor

manic latch
# tough quail VMF officers on the moon ocean then

The Soviet Navy operated a research facility to explore military uses of marine mammals at Kazachya Bukhta (44.5800°N 33.4023°E), near Sevastopol. The Russian military's dolphin program is believed to have languished in the early 1990s

somber knoll
#

speaking of le funni but unironical history, @desert agate gib the emu war story please

frigid karma
#

It's pretty loud already

desert agate
spiral cedar
frigid karma
#

a

spiral cedar
frigid karma
#

a black cat

spiral cedar
#

I know

frigid karma
#

SECOND EMOTE DETECTED

strong plank
#

get his ass

spiral cedar
#

(This emote is provided for illustration purposes only. It is not distributed for entertainment value)

frigid karma
#

reported and banned

maiden citrus
somber knoll
spring briar
#

07

spiral cedar
#

3 men 2 machine guns 1 truck

desert agate
#

ive been to the sites where the "emu war" was fought

#

just a couple of small towns out in rural WA

spiral cedar
#

I mean, that’s all that’s left now

desert agate
#

not that interesting but the wheatbelt has some cool sights to see

manic latch
spiral cedar
#

<4 emotes>

manic latch
#

Nah it's historical reference

#

4 Soyuz class

spring briar
#

Banned

manic latch
#

Oi

spiral cedar
#

Beaned

spring briar
#

You should post 15 then, krem

desert agate
#

i will say

manic latch
desert agate
#

the RAAF is ridiculously uncredited for its participation in the crippling of the Japanese merchant navy

tough quail
#

additional soyuz

spiral cedar
#

In 1800, France passed a law against women ‘dress[ing] like a man’. This peculiar law was intended to prevent women taking men’s jobs. If women could wear trousers rather than massive, flowing frocks, they could take better paid and more interesting jobs! France modified the law in 1892 and 1900 to reflect changing times. These amendments allowed women to wear trousers when ‘holding a bicycle handlebar or the reins of a horse’. These changes preserved women’s modesty. Otherwise, women had to get express permission to ‘dress like a man’.

desert agate
#

the USN submarines constantly get credit for their role in obliterating Japans merchant forces

spiral cedar
desert agate
#

but they would not have achieved the level of success that they did, were it not for the RAAFs aerial mining operations

spiral cedar
#

So that she can wear trousers

desert agate
#

those mining operations allowed Japanese ports in occupied Indonesia to be clogged up with ships waiting to enter while the ports were swept of mines

tough quail
#

i will be your ticket to trouser town

spring briar
#

Horse stay away from meee

tough quail
#

what the fuck did i just type

spring briar
#

Haha historical

desert agate
#

while submarines, deployed from Fremantle and Pearl could sit outside these ports and pick off these ships with ease

manic latch
spring briar
#

Kremlin look!

#

Soyuz

#

points at the moon

manic latch
desert agate
#

the mining operations were however not acknowledged in post-war histories because they didnt actually sink that many ships

manic latch
spiral cedar
manic latch
spiral cedar
#

It’s a real (historical) place

spring briar
#

Time to build more R7’s

spiral cedar
#

So you’re in the clear

spring briar
#

Can someone post an r7 rocket

#

To drive the point home

frigid karma
spiral cedar
#

idk

manic latch
spring briar
#

No

#

Not this

manic latch
#

Shut

spring briar
#

So no

manic latch
spring briar
#

Shmoll

spiral cedar
#

“Don’t talk to me or my son ever again”

manic latch
#

Imagine if this happened

#

Astronauts trying to fight

spiral cedar
#

(“son” here is used affectionately and not in terms of design lineage)

somber knoll
desert agate
#

LC_Rage no one cares reeeeeee

manic latch
desert agate
#

no

#

about what i was saying

#

i meant

manic latch
desert agate
#

about the RAAF aerial mining operations

spiral cedar
#

In 1963, the Swiss government passed the first measures to make sure every inhabitant had access to a nuclear shelter. These laws are still enshrined in Articles 45 and 46 of the Swiss Federal Law on Civil Protection. Most buildings erected since 1963 have their own bunkers.

desert agate
#

reminder that apollo, gemini, etc wouldnt have been possible were it not for the tracking and communications stations established in Australia

spiral cedar
#

It is illegal for your home to not have access to a nuclear bunker

somber knoll
#

as much as I like about my home nation battlefront, the stories I heard often is gonna be either Sumatra bombing party or the IJN trying to get bio fuel in Borneo for the Takaos and Mogamis

spiral cedar
#

In 1336, Edward III of England got so sick of his chubby soldiers he passed laws to make them diet. In the law’s words, obesity made people ‘not able to aid themselves nor their liege Lord in time of need’. The law banned people eating more than 2 courses at mealtimes. It also defined soup as a separate course to prevent people calling it a sauce or condiment. Edward also saw overeating as a wider social evil which made people poorer and more sinful. 3 courses could be enjoyed on Feast Days, however.

#

Careful going to the soup store. Counts as contraband

somber knoll
#

das UK though

spring briar
#

Soup sauce

#

Typical british

desert agate
#

WHY ARE YOU BUYING CLOTHES AT THE SOUP STORE

tough quail
#

floats away

spiral cedar
#

Would need to be one hell of an uppercut

spring briar
#

Gets caught in jupiter’s gravity well

desert agate
spring briar
spiral cedar
desert agate
spring briar
#

Jaba’s relativistic punch

manic latch
#

Shhh

spiral cedar
#

Basically if you could punch another astronaut into space you could likewise punch into the ground to send yourself into space

strong plank
#

wasn't that the entire plot of For All Mankind

spiral cedar
#

Shhhh, don’t discuss any other forms of historical media here

spring briar
#

No they had AR’s

#

Space AR’s

#

Still overheats

#

No convection

spiral cedar
#

Piss on the moon to cool your machine gun

spring briar
#

Seadragon was the best thing about for all mankind

strong plank
#

"moon's haunted"

chilly osprey
#

Two headaches later and a lot of frustration at conflicting information around Arsenal de Lorient, I have finally mostly mapped out the capacity of various French yards in terms of interwar naval construction.

NGL it is definitely weird that there are quite a few yards that only ever built a single destroyer in the interwar era and nothing else, but that seems to be mostly explained by the fact that French government made the navy build certain ships in private yards as part of an effort to secure jobs in those yards that would otherwise be lost.

spiral cedar
strong plank
#

how would height over bore work in space

frigid karma
tough quail
#

tfw no space kalashnikov

frigid karma
#

They are used to almost floating off

spring briar
manic latch
#

Space Battleship Soyuz Rossiya_Pet

frigid karma
spring briar
#

Also the ar’s being white will make them radiate heat away slower than if they had been black
Very sensible

strong plank
#

thats

spring briar
#

Very smart

strong plank
#

what I just posted

#

qwerty

frigid karma
#

Scrolling up is hard

desert agate
#

oh man this jokes gonna hang around for a while isnt it

frigid karma
#

Quite ableist of you to say that regal

spring briar
#

Ablative

strong plank
spiral cedar
#

inb4 space Stg-44

tough quail
#

yooooooo we did it

ivory ridge
manic latch
strong plank
#

also some of the space M16s have M203s....

ivory ridge
strong plank
#

I would love to find out how that would work

ivory ridge
#

VLS

spring briar
ivory ridge
#

vertical launching statue

strong plank
#

long range democracy delivery system

#

i cannot type

spring briar
#

Me with my PU scoped mosin from 1931 on the moon

chilly osprey
manic latch
spring briar
#

Krem…

#

Why

chilly osprey
#

ALERT 4 BOILERS ACROSS SPOTTED INITIATE TORPEDO ATTACK

somber knoll
chilly osprey
#

Richy was built minus her bow and stern

spring briar
#

Yea

#

The biggest slipway was busy making ocean liners

chilly osprey
#

Dunkerque only needed to have part of her bow built seperately

#

And Clemenceau was going to require the same cut as Richelieu

manic latch
somber knoll
#

reads back to some French shipbuilding tl;dr
oki. so only Saint Nazaire was able to do a full scale building.

desert agate
#

italy can take the eastern coast US

frigid karma
desert agate
#

Australia gets the west

chilly osprey
frigid karma
desert agate
#

its basically home

#

we can fix it

frigid karma
#

Uh

#

No

#

It isn’t

spring briar
manic latch
#

Give Soviet Union Kansas Rossiya_Pet

frigid karma
#

Jaba can attest

frigid karma
#

Kruschev will bust a nut

shrewd pecan
#

👁️ realgun

manic latch
somber knoll
frigid karma
#

But corn can be a missile

#

Wheat cannot

chilly osprey
#

'artificially short battleship launcher go BRRR'

frigid karma
manic latch
spiral cedar
desert agate
#

i can attest to that

chilly osprey
somber knoll
frigid karma
spiral cedar
#

Only if your house was built before 2002 and I can write it off as a historical structure

humble mulch
#

20 year rule?

spiral cedar
#

You got a better cutoff?

somber knoll
#

25?

#

like jdm import rule

frigid karma
#

My house is built in the 60s

manic latch
somber knoll
#

btw, can I post a car history video? I've been binging some, in particular Cammisa's Revelations series.

spiral cedar
#

Probably, if the car is old enough

somber knoll
desert agate
#

no damien your 1999 toyota camry with a smashed window and miscoloured doors is not a "historical relic"

dusty kraken
#

Do I become a historical relic when I am >20 years old

somber knoll
#

no

desert agate
#

better hand myself into a museum then

somber knoll
dusty kraken
#

This is outrageous, it's unfair, how can you be more than 20 years old and not be a historical relic

spiral cedar
#

The only ones who know are the ones with long wavelength colors in their names

somber knoll
spring briar
#

I want to post shells

spring briar
#

Undy don’t bulli

ivory ridge
spring briar
spring briar
#

Where mle.1936 K type shell

ivory ridge
spring briar
manic latch
#

Ships like Kutuzov, Salem, Belfast is still around

#

Or maybe he mean still in service

ivory ridge
#

and not like averof, actual service

manic latch
#

"Troop Carrier"

spring briar
#

Krem you are literally playing a character in pentagon wars rn

manic latch
cinder escarp
#

It was originally a pretty pure troop carrier

#

Alas, legendary scope creep happened

spring briar
#

Yes

ivory ridge
#

"Brazil will launch the tender for the new 8x8 combat vehicles on July 20. The companies interested in winning the contract will be able to present their proposals for the new armored vehicles for the Army that day"
https://www.infodefensa.com/texto-diario/mostrar/3818158/ejercito-brasileno-lanza-solicitud-propuesta-vbc-cav-msr-8x8

Infodefensa - Noticias de defensa, industria, seguridad, armamento, ejĂŠrcitos y tecnologĂ­a de la defensa

Lanzamiento de la Solicitud de Propuesta (RFP) para el Proyecto de AdquisiciĂłn de un VehĂ­culo de Combate de CaballerĂ­a Media Blindado 8x8 (CAV-MSR 8x8) para el EjĂŠrcito BrasileĂąo. ...

#

Centauro 2 vs whatever the chinese thing is called

#

also a LAV but whatever

manic latch
#

ST-1

cinder escarp
ivory ridge
#

ST-1 is just the uh

ivory ridge
#

export version of the ZTL-11

#

isnt it

#

ZTL ZLT whatever it is

cinder escarp
#

Note: the US Army considered both the AMX-10P and Marder 1 in the '70s.

#

The army was quite impressed with AMX-10P, although they considered the Marder 1 too big, heavy, and complicated.

manic latch
cinder escarp
#

(It will be noted Bradley ended up bigger, heavier, and more complicated than Marder)

ivory ridge
#

It's Centauro 2 with 120, LAV 700 with 105 and ST-1 with 105

cinder escarp
#

AMX-10P went nowhere primarily as well, it wasn't American.

manic latch
#

I wouldn't risk buying from China as Brazil. Centauro could be nice option

cinder escarp
#

That's literally what the historic pieces say

ivory ridge
#

reminder that Brazil already has Iveco factories in the country

#

because of the Guarani

cinder escarp
#

The army also wanted a brand-new vehicle, which is why the AIFV wasn't bought despite otherwise meeting all requirements

manic latch
spring briar
#

A cute dragon?

cinder escarp
#

XM765 is the AIFV

manic latch
cinder escarp
#

XM723 is what became Bradley

spring briar
#

Very funni krem

cinder escarp
#

By the way, the very next bit pointed out the bullshit of the army

manic latch
#

Subculture

junior trench
manic latch
#

It's bigger but not heavier?

#

Marder has more armor?

junior trench
#

No

#

Marder 1 is just not great

manic latch
junior trench
#

And the scope creep is less creep and more an understanding of what happens to ATGMs launchers that aren't under armor when prep arty is being thrown around*

#

*they fucking die

#

And your units are stripped of ATGM capability

cinder escarp
#

I double checked, and yes the Marder is actually a few tons heavier and I had it backwards.

#

Apologies.

#

That said, ATGM capability wasn't in the MICV requirement until the late 70s - the ATGM capability was itself scope creep.

#

Justified scope creep, but it was. Bradley was built with a single man 20/25mm turret to start, and that met the requirement.

junior trench
# cinder escarp

I fail to see how a thought terminating cliche about a subject barely related to the power train of an armored vehicle is "calling out bullshit" unless you're approaching this with an agenda

#

Though I suppose that's the whole point of the paper

#

What paper even is that anyway

cinder escarp
#

Because the AIFV completely met the MICV requirement and the army had no reason to turn it down other than that they didn't want a M113 derivative no matter how good it was?

#

Let me go dig out the paper, it's not some "bradley sucks lmao" rant

#

It's "The Bradley and how it Got that Way"

#

Contributions in Military Studies, Number 180 from Greenwood Press

#

It actually points out the Bradley ended up being a very good machine, but covers the tortuous history of the MICV in US development history and thought

#

I am not some pro-gavin reformer

shrewd pecan
#

smh just meet in the middle between the Gavin and the Bradley

ivory ridge
#

Bravin

shrewd pecan
#

I’m generally curious so a question for both of @cinder escarp @junior trench were there any earlier attempts to make a Bradley replacement pre MGV and GCV programs?

#

like we’re there any 90s programs that took a swing at that can of warms

cinder escarp
#

There were '90s updates, but nothing serious before FCS

eternal veldt
#

I am already working on an (annually) updated document for all PR ships. Of course, details had to be brief to fit them in one page, but also intentional to spark interest (and maybe actually prompt someone to ask more detailed questions here).

#

As for @frigid karma's comment, ngl, not entirely sure if my doc is exactly "lore" stuff, but I don't want to bring back up the shitstorm 7 hours ago.

cinder escarp
shrewd pecan
#

the ideal platform

junior trench
#

Picking AIFV leaves the army with an absolute dog once it becomes necessary to do even the basic sorts of upgrades done to M2A2, and something like the A3 is absolutely not happening.

If one of the options meets "all requirements" but could easily need a total replacement within a decade, then it's no surprise it'd be passed over.

frigid karma
#

Shouldn’t the requirements be longevity in design

cinder escarp
#

I mean, AIFV was ready in the very early '70s and an A2/A3 level upgrade wouldn't be done in the US Army until the '90s.

#

AIFV has a good 20 years at least in it.

tough quail
#

oh no

#

sarc posted the Forbidden Bradley

eternal veldt
#

Oh, forgot to mention yesterday (as those in WoWS discord already knew), the MoD lost Plymouth's design papers because of water damage, possibly from a leaky roof.

#

Someone thought the papers were unimportant, and chucked them.

#

Peak preservation care

frigid karma
#

😔

eternal veldt
#

I dont think its wise to touch papers 50 years old

#

Some of the BdA prints are already in a pretty shit shape

#

@tough quail

#

The Panzerschkolade is real tasty today

tough quail
#

if only the wehrmacht was capable of making good firearms, so we didn't need to constantly see cope this inane

eternal veldt
#

How good was the MP40? I keep seeing it getting wanked.

frigid karma
#

It’s pretty good, main thing with it being wanked is how common it was

tough quail
#

it's alright

#

the biggest issue is that, well

#

the magazines are fucking terrible

tough quail
#

what ppsh envy does to a mfer

junior trench
#

Which is to say it's a bad blowback smg for massed warfare

#

Because you're fancying up the dead simplest automatic action ever

#

You get marginal ergonomic benefits to a weapon which ideally should be getting shit out en masse to the Nth degree

#

Which is why the Germans eventually just copied and adapted the sten several years too late

tough quail
#

there's also the funny issue where if you catch the bolt handle on mp40s up to like mid 1942 i think and pull it back about midwayish and release it

#

it just

#

chambers and fires

junior trench
#

That's just a blowback smg thing

#

Or at least fixed firing pin thing

tough quail
#

yeah

#

they tried to fix it but the retrofitting never really went anywhere and i think the bulk of the guns were made by mid 42 given they kinda got poor after that

#

though in the mp40s case its pretty bad because the bolt handle is like

#

an enormous hook

humble mulch
#

Had it been used as like

#

An actual fucking smg

#

Then yeah it’s better then nothing and isn’t that bad

#

But if you’re German command
It exists simply to send men with rifles to meat grinders

junior trench
#

It exists to give to the guy in charge of the ammo bearers for the MG

humble mulch
#

Western media also hypes the fuck out of it and does a poor job

#

Some hip firing hipster bullshit

frigid karma
tough quail
#

its not like, the worst thing

junior trench
#

Which actually reminds that German infantry are pathetic as hell on the offense in MoWAS2 (unless it's some Wehrb mod)

frigid karma
#

Cod vanguard allows you to hipfire mg42

#

With laser accuracy

humble mulch
#

Even tho it
Has a fucking stock

tough quail
#

its at least easy to take apart and not convoluted garbage like most german guns

frigid karma
#

While sprinting around

humble mulch
#

Yes cause

#

Media

#

Literally proving my point

junior trench
#

Though

humble mulch
#

It’s shown off as some hip nazi command Tommy gun

junior trench
#

Come to think of it

humble mulch
#

Spray and pray in nearly every mother fucking ww2 movie

junior trench
#

I'm kind of curious if using a light bolt and a very heavy spring would help alleviate the drop safety problems blowback SMGs have

humble mulch
#

By from the hip

#

Oh you mean it firing when dropped right

tough quail
#

that should make it a little better at least

humble mulch
#

Can’t wait to get a repro mp40 for my Romanian kit

tough quail
#

get mags that dont suck ass

humble mulch
#

I’m in CA
I
I don’t think I can legally even get mags for it

tough quail
#

lmfao

humble mulch
dapper parcel
humble mulch
#

I got my yugo M48, which is close enough to a fucking kar 98
Just need a Luger, Italian, or Soviet pistol, and then an smg

tough quail
#

tokarevs are cool and good

humble mulch
#

And I can’t be fucking to actually build a ppsh

#

Wanna be able to show up to the historical reenactments and just pester the Soviet and Nazi cosplayers “tank pls, armor pls, ammo pls”

tough quail
#

yfw the russian guy walks off and just actually rolls back up with a t-34

#

da

#

here u go

humble mulch
#

Romania got a metric fuck ton of guns from Italy

#

They also used the carcano in “decent” numbers

#

Along with the Italian smg iirc but more limited

tough quail
#

everyone should have carcanos

somber knoll
humble mulch
#

If reenactment are anything like milsim events, I just point and shoot blanks

#

Also yeah I’m not an inbreed I know not to hold shit by its mag

somber knoll
#

Carcanos and Beretta Modello 1918 is my ww2 smg fetish

humble mulch
#

I love the look of them

#

And the Romanians smg looks a lot like it

somber knoll
#

The Beretta is just mmm

chef's kiss

#

also, what's the British lmg with mag being vertically challenged again?

humble mulch
#

I don’t think I’ve ever seen the reason for why

somber knoll
#

I remember it for being my former second president's weapon of choice during our independence war.

humble mulch
#

Lewis makes sense cause it’s a pan and they just work better that way

cinder escarp
#

You want a simple, stamped blowback SMG that is drop safe?

#

you must go to brazil

humble mulch
#

and yeah I know that’s not really an lmg

#

That’s interesting

#

Brazil of all places made a drop safe gun

cinder escarp
#

Oh and the gun is absurdly simple

humble mulch
#

Like I’ve seen the utter bullshit those guys make there

somber knoll
#

.303 British yah, not exactly LMG

cinder escarp
#

It makes the MP40 look complex

somber knoll
#

as in STEN simple or beyond that?

because you can build sten with just a drill, grinder, blacksmith tools, and appropriate materials and blueprint

humble mulch
#

I don’t think you can beat a grease gun tho

junior trench
#

Finger bolt hole

spiral cedar
#

My brain read that as "butt" not "bolt"

#

Earlier today I had someone arguing with me that you can effectively defeat modern warships by firing .50 cal rounds at them from 8000 yards

somber knoll
dapper parcel
#

Thinkpitz
How many .50 needed to bring down a barn?

#

I refuse to believe that this isn't already done

somber knoll
spiral cedar
#

That's the thing

#

The ballistic range of the bullet doesn't even reach 8000 yards

#

Let alone effective range

somber knoll
spiral cedar
#

For its part, General Dynamics officially lists the effective range as up to about 2000 yards for "area targets"

somber knoll
#

see, the 3500 meter record is a lucky thing

#

for the anti-materiel rifle variant I mean

spiral cedar
#

This person wanted to destroy the radars

dapper parcel
#

Not helped at all when you consider the exposed part of a radar is the most robust part, often literally steel bar

#

and most of it are passive

#

although I guess you can be lucky to hit the feed horn or elements, but that's often literally a stick

strong plank
#

so what I’m hearing is 5000 yards is the sweet spot

spiral cedar
#

But it will of course depend on what gun you fire it from

dapper parcel
#

I guess that's hotter load, or ignoring minimum velocity as long as the bullet arrives Thinkpitz

spiral cedar
#

Ja

strong plank
#

go after an Arleigh Burke with an elephant gun

spiral cedar
#

MV is 3050 fps for this table

tough quail
#

typo below the model too

"it is assumed that WG that WG"

eternal veldt
#

reee

#

Third time's the charm.

frigid karma
eternal veldt
frigid karma
#

Oh fuck I just talked about a pr ship oh god oh fu-

eternal veldt
#

Let's go to the shadow realm together

sullen canyon
spiral cedar
#

It has been an honor to know you two purisalute

sullen canyon
#

Yes, how dare we talk about upcoming mechanics for Azur Lane here

tough quail
#

off to the pain dimension

strong plank
#

send his ass to detroit

spiral cedar
#

Azur Lane ships? In my Azur Lane server?

tough quail
#

dtroit

spiral cedar
tough quail
#

man you really cant have shit in detroit

#

not even the e

spiral cedar
#

The e is superfluous anyway

#

It’s silent

eternal veldt
#

Either way, long live Murmansk

#

The murmies will not be stopped

frigid karma
#

Death comes to the fortunate murmies, the mutant ones are trapped in his emote servers for life

eternal veldt
#

undie just improves them

eternal veldt
#

Huh, russian source and Rowher are at odds for the primary armament of 71B, 8x 1 100mm (Rohwer) vs 8 x 2 130mm (RU) RichelieuThink

tough quail
#

the latter seems more likely to me

#

single 100mms seems

#

Odd

eternal veldt
#

71A called for singles

#

Its not too far fetched given that its the chosen one too

#

I'm leaning on the Russian side for this one for now

dapper parcel
#

was there even 1x100 Thinkpitz

#

ah, the old non-stabilized

eternal veldt
#

Thanks for the murmpixel, very useful

tribal mortar
#

I just realized that I'm still subscribed to Mark Felton

#

should I keep or nah

spring briar
#

no

#

unsubscribe

tribal mortar
#

ok then

desert agate
#

oh i cant ping sang 2D_charlotte_ugh

eternal veldt
#

Would be nice if someone was able to see it, but unfortunately...

#

He knows already though, don't worry

desert agate
spring briar
#

07Z

#

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

#

AOT music starts playing

fierce sparrow
spring briar
#

@manic latch

#

my water skipping shell

spring briar
#

isn't it beautiful

manic latch
#

Why you need water skip shell

spring briar
#

because it eliminates the z-direction as a variable

#

it travels in a straight line over the water surface

#

so as long as your bearing is correct it will hit

cold pumice
#

But how does it work in rough seas

spring briar
#

it doesn't care about that

#

it's a shell going at 400 meters per second at least

cold pumice
#

And at long distances wouldn't it come in at too steep an angle

spring briar
#

that's why it's as light as possible

#

to have a flat trajectory for as long as possible

#

I have to adjust it a bunch tho

cold pumice
#

But how high does it skip

#

Could it end up skipping over a smaller ship

spring briar
#

unlikely

#

it won't skip that high

#

I'm debating if I should put rocket engines on the shell

#

so increase velocity during the skip

#

the shell is very niche

#

but could be very useful for shooting at groups of ships in port

#

but my main concern is to get the shape just right as to where it will skip at any given angle of entry into the water

#

so it needs a blunt head

#

and a long tail

#

like a teardrop shape

hollow wind
#

I found my way to the nerds hideout

#

it's a dead chat

#

Great

ivory ridge
#

Skill issue

spiral cedar
#

40 pages of messages in this channel in 24 hours

#

Ah yes

spring briar
spiral cedar
#

Dead chat

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

I mean, feel free to raise a topic to discuss?

spring briar
#

Hmm

#

How about soviet SAP

eternal veldt
#

Shells are not my forte, so I can't comment MurmWat

spring briar
#

Hmmm

#

Then

#

Augie Maru

eternal veldt
#

and I'm more pointing it for the new guy

#

Tell you what Riche, you want Augie loods?

spring briar
#

Yas

manic latch
#

Augie boobs? booba

eternal veldt
#

Close enough 😛

spring briar
#

Ah

#

The USN stern of death

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

again, did caught me off guard yesterday that NO didn't use ER/BR alternating arrangement

manic latch
#

Newbies holding the urge to post Super Yamato images the moment they join

#

Tho I prefer this over H-45

eternal veldt
#

See, the funny thing is, the 15.5cms would have been eliminated completely

eternal veldt
#

By Shinano, the IJN would have been using 10cm guns on that position instead

eternal veldt
spring briar
#

I don't think she could have been as light as she was otherwise

spiral cedar
#

Believe they went away from that arrangement as part of the NO class weight savings

#

To fit more armor on

spring briar
#

ergo jaba takes the words out of my mouth

spiral cedar
#

And came back with the St. Louis subclass

spring briar
spiral cedar
spring briar
#

dammit jaba

eternal veldt
#

That so? So Brooklyns are also just ER/BR?

spiral cedar
#

Yep

#

Until St. Louis and Helena

spring briar
#

what ships did the USN use unit machinery on

#

other than iowa

spiral cedar
#

Depends on what you consider “unit”

spring briar
#

staggered shafts

spiral cedar
#

Is ER/BR alternating “unit” as some authors use it

spring briar
#

no

#

not necessarily

spiral cedar
#

Or is only combined MR “unit” as other authors use it

spring briar
#

the boilers can be in a seperate compartiment forward

#

that's how I see it

#

as long as the engines are all in seperate compartiments

#

with staggered shafts

hollow wind
#

Battle of Kursk but Germans are better

gilded girder
#

What is unit machinery?

#

Me no know

spring briar
#

jaba show him the iowa

spiral cedar
hollow wind
#

The massacre of Kursk

eternal veldt
gilded girder
spring briar
#

@gilded girder

#

here

eternal veldt
#

Compared to earlier arrangements, where turbines and boilers are separate, usually with the boilers forward and two groups of turbines behind

gilded girder
#

Oh. So every engine in a separate room...kind of thing?

eternal veldt
spring briar
#

which is what the iowa's had

manic latch
#

URAAAAAAA

spring briar
#

saves even more space

eternal veldt
#

And then you have the Littorio's arrangement

gilded girder
#

Wait. So engines and boilers are separate units?

#

Til

#

🗿

spring briar
#

yeah

hollow wind
#

Battle of Leyte Gulf

eternal veldt
#

Boilers make the funny steam

#

Turbine makes shaft go speen

spring briar
#

the boilers provide steam which then gets used to drive a turbine that drives the shafts

hollow wind
spring briar
#

then there's the diesel propulsion
which is just a big diesel engine

#

and diesel electric

#

is for crazy people

eternal veldt
#

Riche, what about turbo electric?

#

As in New Mexico?

spring briar
#

turbo electric is fine

hollow wind
spring briar
#

since you need that anyways for power in a ship

eternal veldt
#

How does it work? Still a BR/ER?

hollow wind
#

That's a lot of damage

spring briar
spiral cedar
#

NC, SD, Iowa

spring briar
#

Want me to make a spreadsheet of all propulsion systems?

eternal veldt
#

By Leyte, what's left of the IJN carrier force is used as bait anyway, since most of the freshly trained aviation crew are dead during the Philippines sea

gilded girder
eternal veldt
#

Of course it's a beat down

spiral cedar
#

NC and SD are both the purest form of unit machinery, both boilers and turbines in the same compartment, and each compartment powers a shaft

hollow wind
#

Or something like that

spiral cedar
#

Marianas

eternal veldt
#

Marianas' Turkey Shoot, yes.

hollow wind
#

They did start using kamikaze there

eternal veldt
#

No.

spiral cedar
#

Iowa is still “unit” in practice but with an asterisk because each “unit” is subdivided transversely between the boilers and turbines

eternal veldt
#

Kamikazes started at Leyte, in the aftermath of Samar.

spiral cedar
#

But still functionally unitized

spring briar
hollow wind
dapper parcel
hollow wind
#

Ships that escorts destroyers

#

Can you believe the Japanese navy

spring briar
#

Did any other navies than USN and MN use unit machinery?

eternal veldt
#

I don't know man, try getting your flagship torpedoed and swim for your life, getting swarmed by US planes, losing one of your battleships, then encounter enemy forces while you are rearranging into a new formation

gilded girder
eternal veldt
#

Ah yes

#

The madman's arrangement

spiral cedar
#

So the rooms at the far ends are the turbines

eternal veldt
#

I think most other nations are running with ER/BR

spiral cedar
#

And then the boilers in the middle

hollow wind
dapper parcel
hollow wind
#

And still losing 3 battleships

gilded girder
eternal veldt
#

A single carrier isn't worth it to pull TF38 out of position for the Centre Force to break through San Bernardino Strait

#

A carrier task group, however, is.

spiral cedar
#

Bismarck’s is

 EBB
E BB
 EBB
hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

So what? It's all in or die

spiral cedar
#

Basically each EBB group is arranged longitudinally rather than transversely

eternal veldt
#

The IJN wanted their decisive battle badly, and they'll get it no matter the costs

#

Unfortunately, just not in their favour by that point in the war

spiral cedar
#

Which, theoretically protects the center shaft better, but also means that there’s a high chance that any hit that defeats the TDS abreast machinery can take out a shaft entirely

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

(And also the center shaft kinda sucked)

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

And the Soviet Navy is relevant to Leyte because?

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

And here’s KGV

eternal veldt
#

Oh right, speaking of shafts

eternal veldt
#

Soyuz's, hang on

hollow wind
#

So let's track how they started losing

spiral cedar
#

Effectively the KGV layout comes out to

EBEB
EBEB
eternal veldt
hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Strip your turbine with 70k ShP in style

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

Where the KGV basically uses its backup diesel generators as an additional TDS layer to compensate for the rather shallow dedicated TDS

eternal veldt
#

To analyze the defeat of the Japanese Navy purely by major naval battles only is a gross oversimplication

spiral cedar
#

And then we have Yamato

hollow wind
#

there's more

spring briar
#

Oh no

eternal veldt
#

Ever wonder why the Japanese kept themselves hulked up at the home islands by late war?

hollow wind
#

The wake island battle

spiral cedar
#
E BBB
 EBBB
 EBBB
E BBB
eternal veldt
#

It's because they're losing their merchant marine in embarrassing fashion

#

It's the boring small ships that keep the gears turning

spring briar
#

Yamato vs one AP bomb

#

Who wins

hollow wind
#

the Japanese losing bcs they didn't bomb the oil repair and sub port in pearl harbor

eternal veldt
#

Irrelevant.

hollow wind
#

which meant the Us- oo

#

Ok

eternal veldt
#

If Japan could not secure a negotiation within 6 months of commencing the war, the war is lost.

hollow wind
#

Not power

eternal veldt
#

Bombing Pearl Harbour ensured that a negotiation is not possible in the first place.

spiral cedar
#

Note how with Yamato and Bitchmark, all the boiler rooms are grouped together and all the engine rooms are grouped together

hollow wind
hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

Yes, they have extra longitudinal bulkheads to ideally shield deeper machinery spaces from flooding from a single hit

#

But that comes at a cost in listing moment from off-center flooding

hollow wind
spring briar
#

Normally this wouldn’t be the biggest problem yet

hollow wind
#

And a big target for the strategic bombers

spring briar
#

Bismarck has no deck

#

Well

#

Ofc she does

#

But no main armor deck

eternal veldt
#

Landing a hit from a high altitude strategic bomber is difficult

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

You're likely more afraid of a dive bomber or a torpedo

spiral cedar
#

TFW Bismarck’s horizontal protection is about equal to an unmodernized 1911 design battleship

spiral cedar
hollow wind
#

Bcs torpedo bombers don't need to calculate where to drop it

eternal veldt
#

They absolutely do

hollow wind
#

Bcs it ain't moving

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Not even remotely close

hollow wind
#

Oh yes AA

eternal veldt
#

You're flying under extremely heavy anti aircraft fire when you are commencing a torpedo run

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

You'd need to slow down as well, because otherwise the torpedo would broach or jackknife into the water

hollow wind
dapper parcel
#

Screw redundancy, make every shaft interconnected and feed them off a single flow

eternal veldt
#

They are not stationary? The ship is likely moving at extremely high speeds

#

Enterprise famously narrowly avoided a torpedo at Santa Cruz by executing a sharp turn

hollow wind
#

But yes

#

hm

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Damage control would likely get the ship running again unless you somehow also manage to knock that out (which did happen for Yamato)

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

What I am sort of curious about is when the US went over to alternating ER/BR for destroyers

hollow wind
#

They were usin people holding sticks to determine targets

hollow wind
spring briar
hollow wind
#

And just scream generally at the enemy direction

spring briar
#

and not a dumb idea

eternal veldt
#

They're..literally directors

#

that's why it's called a director

spiral cedar
maiden citrus
hollow wind
#

That moment when the yamato's magazine explosion downed more planes than the many AA guns

spring briar
#

is that even confirmed

hollow wind
spring briar
#

since taking out planes with a blast wave is not particularly easy

#

they aren't subs

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Likely eyewitness reports, something about circling planes above

hollow wind
#

so I guess that's just a history theory

#

Ah yes the Kaga

spring briar
#

which is unlikely

spiral cedar
#

First I heard of the idea was Drach just subtracting known AA losses from total failures to return and attributing the rest to the magazine

#

Which is

#

suspect

hollow wind
spring briar
#

nor does it check out with what we know about explosions

#

at all

eternal veldt
#

5 hits.

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

Yes

hollow wind
#

Bombs and torpedo was laying around the deck

#

Of planes

eternal veldt
#

Because bombs and aviation fuel below were not stored properly in the haste to rearm the planes

hollow wind
#

In the inner deck

spring briar
#

that's normal

eternal veldt
#

Franklin also had a close call with a single bomb

#

But damage control saved her

dapper parcel
spiral cedar
#

Ah, here

#

1937 apparently

spring briar
#

oh noe

#

drach released a le fantasque video

hollow wind
#

Well the Akagi

spring briar
#

oh no no no

eternal veldt
#

Time to watch Drach shit on the turbines

#

CTs are a joke, clearly

spring briar
#

I can't wait

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Tribal good

#

Akagi was... Unlucky

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Dick Best and his Wingmen broke off to engage her

spring briar
#

mf is pronouncing contre torpilleur in italian

hollow wind
#

Even the fighters that was about to take off

spring briar
#

Vauquelini

#

hahah

spiral cedar
#

One of the weird little things that no one mentions in paper stats but actually matters a lot for damcon

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

water main metal quality

#

Akagi and Wasp both had iirc cast iron piping

#

shattered from explosions

#

Made firefighting very hard

eternal veldt
#

Damage control in general seems to not be mentioned a lot

#

Generators alone imo are important enough

hollow wind
#

What was the most brutal death of a ship in history?

hollow wind
spiral cedar
eternal veldt
#

"Oh fuck, our generators are knocked out, pumps cannot be used"

#

"Get the buckets"

#

Usually a violent explosion is pretty bad

spiral cedar
#

USS Mount Hood (AE-11) was the lead ship of her class of ammunition ships for the United States Navy in World War II. She was the first ship named after Mount Hood, a volcano in the Cascade Range in the US state of Oregon. On 10 November 1944, shortly after 18 men had departed for shore leave, the rest of the crew were killed when the ship explo...

hollow wind
#

Named after a volcano exploded like a volcano

dapper parcel
#

Balancing act, comrades
Pump too good you risk sinking your own ship

maiden citrus
dapper parcel
#

Cries in SS Normandie

spiral cedar
#

“Hood” is just a very unlucky name

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

But, if we want to talk about brutal deaths in a warship...

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

I'll have to give it to the sailors at Pearl

spring briar
hollow wind
#

And burning

eternal veldt
#

And the poor sods that have to clean the "meat locker" out later

spring briar
#

Drach saying Lee Indompdabble

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

I... Dont think they're usable

#

Not for damage as bad as Wee Vee at least

spiral cedar
#

I mean, usable eventually

hollow wind
hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Hence the meat locker comment

hollow wind
maiden citrus
#

like how mahan has double reduction gearing, cruising turbines, etc

dapper parcel
#

Not any worse than any shipwreck tbh

#

Watery graves are always nasty, that's why most don't bother and just declare the wreck as graves

hollow wind
#

Which war operation was better and more mind blowing?

dapper parcel
#

It only need 1 day in the tropics for everything to be liquified

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

The latter

#

Falklands was very scuffed on both sides

#

The Argies just messed up more

spring briar
#

desert storm was a pure display of world power

hollow wind
#

Damn nice

dapper parcel
#

Desert Storm was like shooting at literal sitting duck

spiral cedar
#

Sitting duck that had been bombed for a month

hollow wind
#

But Operation Barbarossa that's a lot of encirclements in a span of some months and a lot of land taken

maiden citrus
#

when you are winning so fast your enemies can't even report to their superiors how fast they were losing

dapper parcel
#

To describe the Iraqi as having no clue was an understatement

spring briar
#

literally macedonia vs late persia all over again

hollow wind
#

All that in half a year

spiral cedar
#

Barbarossa is one operation as opposed to an entire war

#

So not really 1:1 comparable

hollow wind
#

hm

#

I guess fictional operations it is

#

hm

#

All I got is ace combat 7 when erusea conquered that many with belkan drones

spring briar
eternal veldt
spring briar
#

Belka did nothing wrong

spiral cedar
#

Video game discussions can get you evicted permanently from the channel due to certain moderators, be careful

eternal veldt
#

Partition Belka

spiral cedar
spring briar
#

Belka totally not being Prussia amirite

#

except belka actually has modern tech

#

prussia was still using a 1836 design in 1870

eternal veldt
#

Well, that, and they nuked themselves

spring briar
#

exactly

eternal veldt
#

So nobody commenting how its a war crime

hollow wind
#

ok

#

so no game talk

spring briar
#

ye

#

the reds will get your ass

spiral cedar
eternal veldt
#

Zuikek had her airgroup chipped quite a bit though

hollow wind
#

hm

#

No game talk then let me get a big battle

eternal veldt
#

Thus why the 5th Cardiv not being present at Midway

dapper parcel
#

The thing is, in IJN it only need 1 damaged ship for the entire Carrier Division to be inoperational

hollow wind
spring briar
#

battle of Thermopilae
but people don't only remember the 300 spartans

#

imagine

hollow wind
spiral cedar
#

1000 Thebans(?)

eternal veldt
#

The air groups were quite rigid, I think

#

Can't pull a "transfer Sara's airgroup to Yorktown" thing

maiden citrus
#

the 300 spartans weren't even fighting, they were just going out for a walk

dapper parcel
#

Not only the airgroup, the entire CVBG is inflexible

hollow wind
hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Even damage control groups are like that DunktsukiStare

spiral cedar
#

The airgroups at the time were conceptualized as the specific ship’s weapon

dapper parcel
#

Zuikaku has to sortie with Shoukaku, period

spiral cedar
#

Not as a self-contained fighting force that just happened to be based on this particular ship that sortie

#

I’m unfamiliar with whether this concept changed by 1944 but the IJN certainly had started including “shuttle bombing” in their planning by Philippine Sea

spring briar
#

Japan trading their oldest BB's while keeping the new ones in port due to oil shortage
lovely

dapper parcel
#

That Zuikaku will sortie with Kaga for example would be unthinkable

hollow wind
#

We know that Montgomery was having the big dumbs on the West Europe 1944 - 1945 campaign which is why Eisenhower ess the boss

spring briar
hollow wind
dapper parcel
#

That's just Eisenhower being practical

hollow wind
#

hm

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Their full CV...conversion would have been interesting, to say the least

maiden citrus
#

old and bad even new

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

23 knot CVs, likely poor hangar capacity too unless they decide to massively rework the whole hull

spiral cedar
eternal veldt
#

Unfortunately Hyuuga decided to do a gamer move and blew up her 5th turret

spring briar
#

anyways Belgium and the Netherlands remaining neutral at the start of ww2 has to be the biggest oof in benelux history

spiral cedar
#

Then we reach the most popular idea: attacking the fuel tanks. While a visceral mental image, the fact of the matter is that the Japanese themselves recognized that the Kido Butai lacked the ordinance needed to destroy Pearl Harbor’s fuel storage capacity. In addition to 54 major fuel tanks and numerous avgas tanks, the moored oiler Neosho also carried substantial fuel. To put this into perspective, the entire Pacific Fleet surface force at Pearl Harbor that day could have been fueled up to full more than nine times over with the 563,000 tons of storage available. On top of this are the numerous fleet oilers:
Prewar, Pearl was serviced by three commercial tankers making a continuous shuttle from the California oil fields. They were delivering about 40–50,000 tons of fuel monthly, enough to meet the fleet’s training needs plus build up reserves to near capacity. The Pacific Fleet had a total of 11 tankers, of which four were fitted for underway replenishment.

dapper parcel
#

What BB was not old in IJN anyway....

eternal veldt
#

Kongous, if you consider them as Fast BBs

hollow wind
#

but yeah

maiden citrus
#

only the yamatos really

spring briar
#

Mutsu an Nagato can be argued
but by that point

eternal veldt
#

Nagato's still alright in their book

spring briar
#

Mutsu died

spiral cedar
#

That’s a lot of ordinance that would be needed to substantially cripple the fleet’s fuel storage, and even that would not prevent quick replenishment within weeks. And machine gun fire was out of the question; the steel tank walls were sufficiently thick to stop the rounds of Zeroes, and the Japanese lacked API rounds that could both perforate the steel wall (AP) and ignite the fuel (I).
For fuel oil or diesel, a bullet would not ignite the fuel. If the bullet penetrates below the liquid level there is no air to support combustion. Even if there was oxygen, the flash point of the fuel is too high, and any bullets hitting a pool of fuel would not carry enough energy to raise any significant volume of fuel to temperatures where ignition could be sustained.

dapper parcel
#

Kongo got high utilization simply because they're fast

spring briar
#

and Nagato got modernised to some degree

spiral cedar
#

So bombing would be needed, bombs not allocated to the substantial remaining surface assets of the Pacific Fleet. Already very un-Japanese, but regardless the question about the potential damage remains.
A real measure of the impact of the destruction of the tanks and fuel would be how long it would have taken to restore the damage. Oil tanks are simple constructs—a steel shell, a floating top, and a roof. The shell was essentially shaped sheet metal, something easily handled by the shipyard. It would have taken about 5,000 tons of steel to reconstruct the damaged or destroyed tanks. That amount of metal could have been provided by one cargo shipment from the West Coast. The consequences might have been on the order of imposing a two-month delay in the construction of two destroyers.
Hardly a crippling cost to the United States.

#

But what of the lost oil? How long could it take to refill the storage tanks? To replace the lost storage in a month it would have taken 12-20 tankers. For comparison,
At the end of 1941 there were about 120 tankers under US registry, with another 80 in Allied service under Panamanian registry and other flags of convenience. Ships were there—it was a matter of which tasks had the highest priority.
Certainly, the initial, shocked statements of leaders of the time should be subject to scrutiny rather than taken merely at face value.

dapper parcel
#

Nagato was considered old tbf

spring briar
hollow wind
#

Extra unlucky as the carriers wasn't in the harbor but outside the harbor as well

spring briar
#

not compared to the kongo's or fusos

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Nagato at least got a couple more refits in the 1930s

#

Compared to the running shitshows that are Fusos

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

Granted, their first designed BB and all

spring briar
spiral cedar
# hollow wind they forgor

Basically, attacking the fuel tanks wouldn’t have actually achieved much given the US’s replenishment capabilities

hollow wind
eternal veldt
#

Think RA Burt had a book on it, I'll check later

#

Also included the memes that are the horrible living conditions

alpine onyx
eternal veldt
#

so bad that you have to stay on the weather deck

spring briar
dapper parcel
#

If Fuso was considered shitshow, then IDK what Ise was

alpine onyx
#

Type 1939 FTBs had unit machinery

spring briar
#

fair

alpine onyx
#

Precious little workers