#history

1 messages · Page 212 of 1

spring briar
#

Turenne

shrewd pecan
#

Foch (French pronunciation: ​[fɔʃ]) was the second Clemenceau-class aircraft carrier that served with the French Navy from 1963 to 2000. The carrier was the second warship named in honour of the Marshal of France, British Field Marshal and Marshal of Poland Ferdinand Foch
After serving with the French navy, the vessel was sold to Brazil and ren...

manic latch
#

Ok I can go with Turenne

shrewd pecan
#

Foch has already historically been a carrier

manic latch
#

Yes

#

Bad name still

#

Mistake shouldn't be repeated

spring briar
#

why is it a bad name

manic latch
#

How about Joffre

spring briar
#

NO

eternal veldt
#

How about you call her Jean Bart and send her off to patrol off Somali then MurmWat

spring briar
#

fuck that man killer

shrewd pecan
#

Richelieu đŸ‘ïž

spring briar
#

actually we should probably not name carriers after people

#

let's call her Lorraine

shrewd pecan
#

Normandy

remote monolith
fierce sparrow
#

WarZoom bulldog like face...

desert agate
#

Elsaß lothringen

spring briar
#

Spon

#

listen here

eternal veldt
#

Flugzeug-Avion Elsace

remote monolith
shrewd pecan
#

đŸ‘ïž Norman the conqueror

eternal veldt
#

Fixed

desert agate
#

I have angered the french

spring briar
#

call it Rhinelande

desert agate
fierce sparrow
#

Norman the Conqueror? that doesn't fit well

eternal veldt
#

Actually

remote monolith
#

have you French not used Pepin as a name for anything? It sounds like a decently cool name from a series of decent majordomos

shrewd pecan
#

eh fuck it piss of everyone around France, build two of them, name the first one Saar and the 2nd one William the Conqueror

desert agate
#

WILLIAM

remote monolith
#

or hell, use Merovingian

eternal veldt
#

Jena-Auerstedt

#

Germany can cope harder

spring briar
#

Guillaume le conquérant

fierce sparrow
remote monolith
spring briar
#

jena-auerstedt

#

austerlitz

fierce sparrow
#

why not named after one of the 3 musketeers..?

remote monolith
#

how about after Rollo?

fierce sparrow
#

Rollo maybe yes -ish...

spring briar
#

nah

#

Charlemagne

#

Astolfo

fierce sparrow
spring briar
#

Roland

remote monolith
#

too mainstream,

eternal veldt
#

Or just go the way of the Brits

#

Return to Terrible and Invincible

spring briar
#

oh you don't want mainstream?

#

alright

remote monolith
#

how about Assurancetourix?

spring briar
#

Rochambeau

eternal veldt
#

Or...just go harder and call her Sans Pareil

manic latch
#

Notredamus

fierce sparrow
spring briar
#

no

#

we call her

eternal veldt
#

Actually, I forgot the best name of them all

spring briar
#

"germany you can't just abuse your larger population to win wars by marching on paris"

eternal veldt
#

France, just France

remote monolith
#

here's a good name, Panoramix

spring briar
#

bruh

#

idéfix

fierce sparrow
#

So... no Vercingetorix?

remote monolith
eternal veldt
#

Obelix

maiden citrus
#

I have half a mind to give that sad looking wallaby a speech bubble so hit can use it for a reaction image

eternal veldt
#

People literally go ahead and call her a fatty

spring briar
remote monolith
eternal veldt
#

... I dont want to know what "magic potion" is brewed on board.

#

Also have a tendency to shit on Italy.

spring briar
#

Anything but charles de gaulle, nivelle, petain is fine

eternal veldt
#

Rip Italian FREMMs

#

Gamelin BuckyPrideZoom

spring briar
#

Shut

fierce sparrow
#

Wotspite Gamelin...

#

and pls don't name after a certain Admiral in an infamous Mers-el-Kébir.
... for CV

spring briar
#

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties
The numbers used in this video count both military and civilian deaths caused by World War II. Each number is counted as if it were rounded to the nearest 100,000. Figures are based on 1939 borders, and they may not be exactly accurate.

LimeTube Reddit account: u/RealLimeTube
LimeTu...

▶ Play video
#

RUSSIA RUSSIA RUSSIA RUSSIA RUSSIA

#

Etc

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

Could be worse

manic latch
eternal veldt
#

Laborde or Darlan

#

Both instantly would have France up at arms

#

Remember, the French community on WoWS was absolutely livid when a new commander was revealed and looks awfully like Darlan

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

... Turns out it's just a Russian bloke that bears too much resemblence to him

manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

đŸ‘ïž just think about it, all of Europe had Napoleon living rent free in their heads

spring briar
delicate beacon
#

Oh wow, replacing one image reduced the file size of my book by 3mb UniHappy

#

It's discord shareable now. cirComfy

remote monolith
spring briar
eternal veldt
#

What kind of image takes up that much space

#

... Sang, did you eat another blueprint?

spring briar
eternal veldt
#

Add a big moustache to his face

spring briar
#

Now he looks like Clemenceau

#

Father victory

delicate beacon
#

dis one.

spring briar
#

Oi

#

Quad turret algerie

delicate beacon
#

also boat

#

very cute boat

spring briar
manic latch
#

QE fans malding

#

feelssadman Would be Ulyanovsk if collapse didn't happen

desert agate
manic latch
#

I miss her so bad

eager dove
#

Soviets got nae nae’d by the Chinese

#

Atleast they’ve finally graduated from cope slope academy

spring briar
#

very nice air group

#

flying party tents

tender monolith
#

ugly

fierce sparrow
eager dove
#

The hull is generally fine

#

The superstructure is wack as hell though

spring briar
#

it looks like a destroyer ss

#

lol

eager dove
#

It’s too small, narrow and long

spring briar
#

it's absolutely tiny

desert agate
#

Lift layout is shit too

eternal veldt
#

No masts too, but I suspect those will be added later.

chilly osprey
#

Yeah, not a fan of the superstructure either

chilly osprey
# desert agate Lift layout is shit too

It's basically just doing the same thing as Type 002.

It's important to remember, as much as Type 003 is a major leap forward, with it being CATOBAR and all, it is still very much an iterative ship like everything else the PLAN does. Structurally there is a lot that is carried over from the earlier carriers - the elevators probably being the greatest example.

eager dove
#

I expect a lot of issues still

#

Although of course they won’t be public

#

First real domestic designed and built carrier, far larger and with EMALS

#

No way there isn’t gonna be problems

chilly osprey
#

Yeah, naturally we're never going to hear about any development issues they have

#

Unless it's something extremely obvious

#

Or they show off more footage of them demonstrating how not to do damage control

delicate beacon
#

Tiny French cruiser. cirMini

manic latch
#

Since Type 004 will be a thing for China's 6 carrier plan

#

Problems that occur on 003 should be fixed for 004's construction or design

#

Like how Gerald's problems are going to be fixed for her sisters

#

Especially the Enterprise will get more operational data

#

For French's PANG. I don't think France will build their own EMAL, but purchase it from US. Like they purchased steam catapults from US for Gaulle

#

For British? I think they will stick to cope slopes for a long while

eager dove
#

I don’t even think 004 will be much different

#

Nuclear propulsion for your first major combatant is a huge leap and will cause many issues

manic latch
#

They have to start from somewhere

#

It could be also bigger than 003. Reaching to Ford's level

eager dove
#

I mean I do not think 004 will be much different than 003 in regard to being a test bed

#

Your first nuclear powered large vessel is a big hurdle

#

Especially with chinas issues and inexperience with nuclear power

manic latch
#

True on that. But they need experience.
Maybe diesel instead like QE class?

#

Safer option I guess

#

But still. China passing from ramps to emals does show they can take risks

#

So nuclear 004 is option for me

eager dove
#

Yea it’s expected

#

But it will have issues

#

It takes many decades to mature your design and operations for carriers

manic latch
#

Ulyanovsk feelssadman

chilly osprey
#

Six carrier force includes the older carriers

#

So if Type 004 still needs improvements before they build a multi-ship class, well, that isn't exactly going to put the PLAN's carrier force in a brilliant position come the 2040s

manic latch
#

Or going for improved designs as 005 006

#

Will be interesting

chilly osprey
#

Remains to be seen

eager dove
#

USN and USAF personnel have been waiting decades to get a shot at sinking a carrier

#

LRASM, JSM, Mark 48’s, MST

#

Better be up on your game if they come to a conflict or it’s bye bye carriers

manic latch
#

Best air defense. It cancels the pilot or the operator who shot a missile at her

#

Then cancels the missile as well

spring briar
#

yes school children and maritime weaponry

manic latch
manic latch
#

Do it Manjuu

ivory ridge
#

That looks fucking stupid

fierce sparrow
manic latch
ivory ridge
#

You're literally simping for ch*nese military hardware

spring briar
#

Hmmmmmm I really wonder what happened in the 60's

#

HMMM

fierce sparrow
#

ummm what is this?

manic latch
#

feelssadman she is a distant cousin of Ulyanovsk

ivory ridge
manic latch
spring briar
#

oh Russia

tough quail
spring briar
tough quail
#

it just aint the same my guy

#

have some self respect pensive_cowboy

ivory ridge
twilit plume
#

The timer before the first mechanical failure has started

frigid karma
#

TBF Chinese navy probably has far better carriers

#

No cope slope to start with

#

It basically looks like kuznetsov is the hand me down at this point

dusty kraken
#

Speaking of kuznetsov how is it doing

delicate beacon
#

Kuznetsov possible states:
[_] on fire
[x] in drydock
[_] both

dusty kraken
#

Where the option that says a crane fell on it

tough quail
#

and i said "building off of"

dusty kraken
#

We're now 40 years away from the 1980s

tough quail
#

and about 40 years off from qwerty sprouting that second brain cell

fierce sparrow
#

CleveDerp 40 years old... ohno

tough quail
#

well, 38 if you count completion date

manic latch
#

Wait

#

When you forget Gerald Ford is almost 10 years old now Despair

#

Now this is a good crest

#

Ship is perfectly detailed, F18 and 35 is a nice touch. Kennedy at back with a Moon reperesent Space race?

#

CIX means 109 I guess. But what for

ivory ridge
manic latch
#

Type 001: Varyag. Sister of Kuznetsov

Type 002: Improved design of Varyag. Can be called sub Kuznetsov class with good improvements

Type 003: Marriage between Soviet and West designs. Got the elevator design of Kuznetsov while emals from West

#

Type 004: Could be nuclear and slighty larger version of 003 with some design changes. Maybe even 4 catapult and 3 elevators like Americans

#

We will see

#

Catapult gang

Charles De Gaulle
Nimitz sisters
Ford class
Type-003 Fujian

Cope Slope gang

Kuznetsov
Type 001 and 002 (Liaoning, Shandong)
Vikrant
Vikramaditya
Cavour
Garibaldi till Trieste
Anadolu
Queen Elizabeth and Prince of Wales
Canberra
Juan Carlos I

#

Who I miss

ivory ridge
#

Garibaldi till Trieste is commissioned

manic latch
#

Fuck I missed Gari Sadge

ivory ridge
#

Then there are the STOVL carriers without slope like the Izumos and american LHDs

manic latch
#

Ye they got their own gang

ivory ridge
#

Then there are the sloped carriers without planes like the turkish and australian JCIs

manic latch
#

Also yeah I also missed Canberra Sadge

#

Let's edit

spring briar
#

bruh

remote monolith
#

I know Mark here means this as a comparative illustration, but that doesn't make the rex any less goofy to look at with those mismatched eyes

frigid karma
#

Even if they weren’t mismatched it would still look funny

manic latch
#

Seems Fujian also got CIW radar upgrade ThinkZed

#

Box instead circle

#

Lmao they edit it

#

Added United Kingdom

#

QE supercarrier confirmed

spring briar
delicate beacon
#

đŸ‡§đŸ‡·

desert agate
#

I'm still upset there's no RAN

delicate beacon
#

uh fuck

#

I broke the average

spring briar
chilly osprey
#

No RAN and so many nations at 55% real ships

#

That's pretty disappointing

#

I won't lie, the trend of made up ships in historical games really does grind my gears

#

And it's not like you need them to fill out lines in AL like you do with WoWs

delicate beacon
delicate beacon
#

Next up SIAM

fierce sparrow
#

Biblical not-so-accurate Abrams Angel

spiral cedar
#

I have been unceasingly and assiduously devoting both my waking and even my sleeping thoughts to submarines, and oil and the oil engine is the germ of their vitality..... The oil engine will govern all sea-fighting, and all sea-fighting is going to be governed by submarines...

Fisher, 1913

#

“Submarines,” he insisted to Arnold White on 13 March 1913, “are the coming Dreadnoughts...

#

In May, Fisher again wrote to Jellicoe, urging that “for God’s sake, do get on SOMEHOW with building more submarines at once, no matter what drawbacks.”

#

And in June, Fisher welcomed the prospect of the hostile naval powers building dreadnoughts that he expected would be useless in war in the face of the submarine. “Austria and Italy,” he explained to Corbett on 22 June 1914, “will continue to dig out vigorously to build Dreadnoughts against each other, and the Grand-Admiral Köster, the head of the German Navy League, will carry his point for 2 extra Dreadnoughts, so the Triple Alliance will lavish their money on vessels that will be securely blockaded by our submarines, as the Mediterranean and North Sea will be securely locked up.”

spring briar
#

Fisher was a great advocate for submarines

spiral cedar
#

Yes

strong plank
#

alt history where britain conducts unrestricted submarine warfare

delicate beacon
#

Should probably do Denmark and Norway at some point

delicate beacon
#

Huh

#

We have a hellenic ship in game

ivory ridge
delicate beacon
#

E-class DD Echo

#

aka Navarinon

#

Too lazy to do each european country seperate, it includes poland atm

#

Greece do be carrying

ivory ridge
delicate beacon
#

I should split Europe in south and north so Netherlands looks better cirLurk

frigid karma
delicate beacon
#

Ya, DMing

rapid junco
# delicate beacon

I'm surprised you included the J class
Which never came to us
And those two Amazonas class? RichelieuThink

zealous vine
#

Have there been tactics in avoiding torps by observing enemy torpedo launchers directly?

#

(I assume though at such distances, you have better things to worry about)

frigid karma
#

Cant really see them

fierce sparrow
cinder escarp
#

tower of hats in tank form

tender monolith
#

Can you even say that if only one mockup and two turrets were ever built? That isn't different from literally any other tank.

#

No one builds a first draft of fucking anything

cinder escarp
#

The Maus went through a hilarious amount of revisions

tender monolith
#

Too bad none of them saved it from being the dumbest waste of metal on the continent

#

I was going to say 'since the Yamato class was first built' but for some reason some people like those

dusty kraken
#

Or should I say Maus droid

tender monolith
#

Dohoho

tough quail
#

there's absolutely zero comparison between them in terms of effectiveness unless you're just aimlessly shitting on the axis for being axis

tender monolith
#

don't act like that isn't worthwhile

#

but they could have built two normal size battleships for the same amount of steel is my point

tough quail
#

that's a bad point though

#

because that's far more expensive, time consuming, man power intensive, and requires more docks

#

nothing of which japan was in huge supply of

tender monolith
#

japan didn't have a huge supply of steel either

tough quail
#

it would've taken much longer to build 5-6 treaty size battleships for japan, and costed them out the ass

#

unless they started cancelling carriers for it

tender monolith
#

fine whatever yamato was the best thing they could have built rah rah

tough quail
#

it's counter intuitive to surface level thinking because YO they're FUCKING HUGE

#

but just doing a handful of huge battleships is in effect pretty much the budget version of a full five ship class of treaty BBs

#

or multiple classes

tender monolith
#

well i suppose i did come here to learn boats since i'm ok on tanks

#

sorry for being short with you earlier

tough quail
#

it's aight

junior trench
#

the Yamatos are literally the only modern* BBs Japan ever had

#

so uh

#

I sure hope they do something exceptional with them

#

because they're the only ones they're building before shit hits the fan

#

*treaty/post-treaty

tough quail
#

another counter intuitive thing is that uh

#

battleships are dirt fucking cheap ton for ton

#

they're basically bulk buying for warships

tender monolith
#

the fuck

#

how is that the case

tough quail
#

it's kind of why germany had like four "modern" battleships

#

but jack shit of everything else

tough quail
#

like

#

you need a dock to build each one

#

you need to effectively duplicate the electronics

#

chunks of the propulsion

junior trench
#

the hard part of building a ship makes up a small percentage of the tonnage when you build large

tough quail
#

much larger crew sizes

#

etc, etc

#

just scaling up the base becomes cheaper and cheaper over time

#

the crew sizes isn't really part of the initial build tonnage but lifetime costs of smaller ships vs a battleship of equal tonnage is also

#

muuuch bigger

#

carriers being fucking nightmares in this regard

maiden citrus
tough quail
#

yeah you're just slapping straight metal on for loads of it

#

it's my favorite uno reverse card i like to pull about kriegsmarine-vmf comparisons

#

four more battleships built!

less cruisers and half the number of destroyers

#

still poor actually

maiden citrus
#

jaba has a neat chart for this iirc

tough quail
#

yeah ive been trying to find it

remote monolith
#

Basically in this case the "cheaper" option isn't actually cheaper because even though they're smaller units they each need individual maintenance, have lesser survivability thus higher chances of needing total replacement as opposed to repairs, and less concentrated firepower in one package

tough quail
#

plus my main point was yamato can still do things a normal sized BB can do

#

yeah she's a fuel hog but i dont expect her to eat more fuel than two treaty BBs running at the same time

#

meanwhile maus uh

#

just can't cross terrain properly at all

remote monolith
#

this is probably a poor example given my relative lack of knowledge about ships, but maybe an example scenario is this; you need to send a naval unit to coastally bombard an enemy position that needs at least the equivalent of 1 battleships worth of firepower to neutralize. If all you have are destroyers and cruisers, you naturally have to send more than one to compensate the lesser firepower of those units. In turn, this drive up fuel and ammo costs because your running several units to equalize one that can do the job cheaper and potentially faster. Am I on point with this one?

dusty kraken
#

"Guys our super tank is literally too heavy to cross bridges what should we do"
"Put a snorkel on it"
Bloody geniuses

eternal veldt
#

know what would be funny

#

it gets bogged down in mud

shrewd pecan
#

not to play devils advocate regarding the entire maus situation

#

but to be fair, they never did end up mass producing maus

#

and everyone was pretty much dicking around tanks that they knew they were never gonna mass produce or be able to realistically field

#

Maus wise only a handful of Maus hulls were produced and only one functional tank was ever made

cinder escarp
#

Krupp kept fucking building hull and turret sets till the end

#

because they never actually canned the contract

tough quail
#

yeah

shrewd pecan
#

I mean E-100 was still kicking

tough quail
#

it's also needed to be taken into context with other German projects

#

like the tiger 2 and it's dipshit casemate version they actually were trying to mass produce

#

Ferdinand's kind of get a pass because Porsche was an imbecile and already built the hulls

shrewd pecan
#

I feel Ferdinand is a worse example than Maus in terms of German procurement incompetence

remote monolith
#

what do you mean you already produced 90 hulls before you even secure the fucking contract

tough quail
#

Ferdinand is just salvaging otherwise useless hulls built by hopes and dreams

cinder escarp
#

p o r s c h e e n g i n e s

#

k r u p p s t e e l

#

nothing can stop us

remote monolith
tough quail
#

my nuclear take is that regular ol tigers are fine in context of what they actually are

junior trench
#

wait

#

wait wait wait

#

the Porsche Tiger is rear engine rear wheel drive, right?

remote monolith
#

They're not bad bad and is perfectly serviceable

tough quail
#

yes I believe

junior trench
#

the Tiger I is fit for purpose as a breakthrough/assault tank

#

it was never used that way

#

but anyway

shrewd pecan
junior trench
#

this means the Porsche Tiger is just a proto Porsche 911

dusty kraken
#

Only if the Tiger 1 was less of a box

#

😔

tough quail
#

if what you're asking is what I think you are, yes, the Porsche tiger is actually the first 911

#

yeap

#

there we go

dusty kraken
#

If it's rear wheel drive can it drift

junior trench
#

according to GuP it can

shrewd pecan
#

have it burst into flames mid drift to ensure max coolness

junior trench
#

and apparently Shermans are able to drift while shooting up AT guns based upon actual AARs from the Netherlands

#

so, sure, why the hell not

#

drift the Porsche Tiger 911

tough quail
#

at least this one is visually distinct

junior trench
#

wait a minute

#

you sly bastards you

humble mulch
#

Does your tank sliding out of control backwards when going up a hill count as a cool J turn?

tough quail
#

yes

shrewd pecan
#

the arma 3 and warthunder tank experience?

cinder escarp
#

Krupp cut 30 sets of hull armor plates in '43

tough quail
#

Pain

#

anyway can I get one of those cool Italian casemates painted up to look like a Ferrari to counter this new lore

shrewd pecan
#

I mean they had the material for it kept but I can't really find any mention of them continuing production up to the end of the war

#

I am reading the same article you're

tough quail
#

43 is obscenely late to be doing this stupid shit too tbh

shrewd pecan
#

nvm I'm stupid

#

or not

#

"Nevertheless, Krupp continued some work. Six hull and seven turrets (not counting the ones used in the prototypes) were in various stages of completion at the end of the war. However, by mid-July of 1944 it was clear that there was no point in working on either the Maus or its competitor, the E-100. Hitler ordered that the design and production of superheavy tanks should cease. Nevertheless, various work on modernizing the Maus continued until early 1945. Around this time the second prototype received the MB.517 diesel engine. It is not known when this happened, but a letter dated December 1st, 1944, says that the engine was already installed but not yet tested. In any case, these trials would have already been pointless."

#

seems to be varying levels of work

tough quail
#

like imagine Kursk being a thing and going mmm

#

mmyaes

#

180t barge

cinder escarp
#

Basically Krupp never got an actual contract cancellation, they just kept at it

shrewd pecan
#

I mean, that's not really as bad it could of been

#

its not really like the materials being invested anywhere else was gonna change much

tough quail
#

you would not believe how much steel was wasted on these tanks

#

the hulls themselves do not tell the whole story

cinder escarp
#

Only like the first few have the really stupid side plate layout

tough quail
#

oh thank god

cinder escarp
#

The whole, "we need more room for the suspension" so we'll mill out the 20cm plate to 16cm over the running gear

shrewd pecan
#

I'm guessing 15 hulls worth of Maus steel wouldn't of produced a game changing amount of other armored vehicles

cinder escarp
#

how dare you propose using separate 16cm and 20cm plates and just mating them, that would produce a weak point!

tough quail
#

still though this is kinda like arguing that purposefully driving your car into a lake isn't so bad

#

because you could've shot yourself in the head instead

shrewd pecan
#

I mean, you can basically make the argument about any prototype tank that doesn't end up in mass production

#

while I agree Maus is a extreme example of material use considering its a 188 ton tank

#

the US produced like 100 T23s/T20s and never ended up using them

cinder escarp
#

POV: an actual waste

#

Porsche Typ 101 air-cooled V-12

tough quail
#

it's an extreme amount of material use in tandem with other stupid prototypes and multiple other mammoth dipshit tanks actually in full production

cinder escarp
#

The Porsche air-cooled V-12s proved to be a disaster

tough quail
#

in 1943, when they've experienced literally more tank combat than anyone else in the world

#

it is absolutely horrifyingly incompetent in it's full context

shrewd pecan
#

đŸ‘ïž 70 ton tanks in WW2 when what they already had was good enough for purpose

tough quail
#

they should know more than anyone what a good tank is and instead they chronically refuse to learn any lessons at all

shrewd pecan
#

idk I'm not defending tiger II or Jadgtiger or anything, I agree those designs should of never been mass produced nor really left the drawing board

#

I agree maus should of never left the drawing board

#

tho, I don't think Maus is the worse example of German procurement incompetence, especially when you have Porsche tiger sitting around alongside jadgtiger

cinder escarp
#

So: there are four key figures in German tank design & procurement (one of which is a group and not a individual). These are... Big Daddy H, Kniepkampfy Chair, Albert "Speer Hoodie" Speer, and the poor suffering professor porsche and his panzerkomission.

shrewd pecan
#

regarding actual material use, how intensive even were the maus prototypes

#

like for example how many panzer IVs hulls could you of produced with the material needed for a maus

cinder escarp
#

And programmatic complexity is a mess - here's a diagram drawn during the Maus program, with funny windmill edited out

shrewd pecan
#

đŸ‘ïž visualizing it a bit would probably help since obviously I'm agreeing with you if those materials for 15 maus hulls was enough to produce a few divisions worth of panzer IVs

cinder escarp
#

Most damage to German AFV production was done by H and Kniepkamp, with Speer being given the impossible task to meet military procurement needs despite the other issues, and Porsche being dragged along for whatever ride the leaders cooked up.

#

The Panzerkomission was actually a creation of German industrial firms who were tired of being jerked around by constantly changing decision making, and so set up a board lead by Porsche to discuss the issue. It had pretty much no legal power, but the angery mustache man was a huge porsche simp.

#

So whatever Porsche said always, always affected him.

#

(It dates back to the angery lad's days in Austria, where Porsche was a huge national hero - he had become something of an idol in adolf's eyes)

#

The entire trend of German vehicles getting big cat names came from this - Porsche jokingly referred to one of his (several) VK 45 concepts as a "tiger" and it stuck. Adolf liked it so much he not only made it official but then made it actual policy to give out predatory, mainly feline, names to AFVs

shrewd pecan
#

moving past the entire maus thing

#

anyone have any idea if this designation "M1047" is a real vehicle that's apparently a LAV-25 variant

#

all I can find is a mention in the Sheridan's wikipage and some weird ass RP nation thing that for some reason has a wiki

#

"In 1987, the Army tested a version of the LAV-25, classified as the M1047. The Army determined that these were unsuitable for LAPES, and could not match the firepower of the Sheridan. Congress did not favor the M1047,[55] though a few were deployed with the 3/73rd Armor in the Gulf War.[47] The Marine Corps also developed the LAV-105 to meet its requirements,"

cinder escarp
#

The vehicle is real, the LAV-AG

#

Later became the LAV-105

shrewd pecan
#

so its the LAV-105 prototype

#

but I'm guessing it was never actually deployed

cinder escarp
#

Correct, mixture of various issues including congress, DoD priorities (gibe MGS plox) and the like

shrewd pecan
#

" Of course, had timing and this been the sole problem, the LAV-105 might well have entered service at a much later date, but the second problem was much more serious. It wasn't discovered until the Marines finally began to fire live ammunition from the LAV-105 in the mid-1990s that the LAV I chassis and suspension could not withstand the recoil of a 105 mm gun --- not even a low recoil force gun. The recoil caused the vehicle to buck violently (reminiscent of the M551 Sheridan light tank of earlier years), overwhelmed and seriously damaged the suspension, and caused widespread stress cracking throughout the chassis', including its Bisalloy 500 steel armor.

The USMC later in the 1990s attempted to resurrect the LAV-AG program later that decade, via the LAV-90. This vehicle was essentially an LAV I equipped with the Cockerill turret, armed with a smaller Mecar KEnerga 90 mm gun, but the test firings once again overwhelmed the chassis and suspension. After once again rejecting an LAV-AG candidate, the USMC and the industry quickly abandoned the entire concept, and have apparently never spoken of it again."

#

yeah I wasn't entirely sure what the hell the "M1047" was referring to

#

wiki article around it with the additional context seems to be entirely bullshit

cinder escarp
#

Cadillac Gage's insistence on Bisalloy 500 has always been an issue

shrewd pecan
#

guessing the M1047 designation was never really a thing either

cinder escarp
#

M1047 was in fact reserved for the LAV-25 itself.

#

The army was going to buy them for 9th ID

#

The wacky motorized experimental division up here at Fort Lewis

shrewd pecan
#

honestly the LAV-25 doesn't seem like the worse platform for the army especially for the time

#

would of made a good cav scout vehicle for infantry units

shrewd pecan
#

eh never noticed that Belgium is also planning on phasing out their NH-90s

desert agate
#

The good ending

spring briar
#

spon

desert agate
#

Richy

spring briar
#

mon ami

spring briar
manic latch
#

T23/20 is more of Panther

#

While T32 is more of Tiger 2 or Tiger 1 I guess

manic latch
#

Rich's 380mm?

spring briar
#

yea

manic latch
#

Make it for 406mm and sell it to Soyuz

#

Then I shall support it TOOBASED

ivory ridge
spring briar
#

we did

#

as I said

#

but we ain't gonna sell it

shrewd pecan
#

that’s a waste of production time and resources that could of gone for example to 100 Sherman’s

manic latch
#

Shame T32 was looking sexy

shrewd pecan
#

I was pointing out that Germany wasn't the only nation wasting resources on prototype designs that went nowhere

desert agate
#

I'm on board the titty maid

shrewd pecan
#

load the shells and destroy that god forsaken gas station

manic latch
#

Spon are you taking a world travel tour

#

You were at Turkey and France not long ago

shrewd pecan
#

đŸ‘ïž this entire time I could of compared TOG to maus

#

The Tank, Heavy, TOG II* was a prototype British tank design produced in the early part of the Second World War in case the battlefields of northern France devolved into a morass of mud, trenches and craters as had happened during the First World War. When this did not happen the tank was deemed unnecessary and the project terminated. A developm...

#

while not as bad obviously

#

since they bothered building two of the damn things

#

that and they aren't nearly as resource intensive as Maus

#

o T23 was worse than I thought

#

it wasn't just 100 tanks

#

it was 200+

remote monolith
#

Tog is better by virtue of being a massively popular meme machine thanks to WoT

shrewd pecan
#

idk I think the better way to phase what I'm saying is I believe it would be better to frame maus better as a vehicle that ended up being a prototype/test design that went nowhere like various other prototype vehicles during the war

#

I don't think its the worse example of its type in terms of resources invested and it has the virtue of never actually being put in mass production

#

in terms of waste for a prototype vehicle T23 and the Porsche tiger are out there

#

and in terms of wasted on actual german vehicles I think the King Tiger and Jadgtiger outweigh it due to the sheer fact of both being mass produced

desert agate
ivory ridge
#

Wdym you were in turkey /s

manic latch
remote monolith
#

Turkoman

#

Turkopoles

dusty kraken
#

Turkiye or Turkey doesnt matter, they're delicious regardless

dapper parcel
#

🩃

ivory ridge
#

They can call it whatever they want in turkish

#

But english is english

#

And kindly fuck off

manic latch
manic latch
#

For now they are not relevant enough for people to call it Turkiye instead Turkey

ivory ridge
#

That's not really how it works

manic latch
#

Well they are trying

#

Made a request to UN

desert agate
manic latch
#

Lick it

desert agate
#

Was a gate in the way

tender monolith
#

Sounds like you didn't try hard enough

desert agate
#

It's England I don't want the death pentalty

tender monolith
#

Coward

#

They'll just transpor-
Pffft

eternal veldt
#

I can't believe Hit got deported

manic latch
#

Closed to prevent people licking

#

Sound but immoral

manic latch
#

Huh

#

Is Latest export Typhoon is better than F-16 Block 70?

chilly osprey
#

most positive procurement effort they could embark on ATM is trying to procure new political leadership

fierce sparrow
#

Typhoons... not sure that's good idea.

dapper parcel
#

It's just interim, supposedly. They can just pick whatever.
Although the timing isn't great to fumble around

manic latch
#

Declares war on Greece to keep the power

rapid junco
#

@spring briar Do you like Mirage? MakinaSmug

spring briar
#

of course

rapid junco
spring briar
#

absolutely amazing plane

rapid junco
#

Do you believe those planes here intercepted a Cuban IL-62 during the Falklands War?

spring briar
#

dunno

rapid junco
#

Besides the Avro Vulcan our F-5s intercepted

spring briar
#

the cold war doesn't really interest me

dapper parcel
#

Hey, at least the flying pencils are fun to look at

rapid junco
#

So basically a IL-62 of the Cubana de AviaciĂłn invaded our airspace
It was carrying the Cuban ambassador to Buenos Aires
It was quickly detected and two Mirages of AnĂĄpolis air base were scrambled to intercept it
It was a rainy night, and the IL-62 was not that cooperative until it's pilot saw the two Mirages on his side

#

The Cubans were so confident that weren't going to be intercepted
That the ambassador took his grandson on the flight

ivory ridge
#

Ignore how Italy decommissioned the last one in like

#

2004

chilly osprey
#

Thanks, tortured Eurofighter program

ivory ridge
chilly osprey
#

1990s just sucked for procurement in general

rapid junco
#

This one is for you, Undie LittCool

ivory ridge
#

Me looking at the DDP class destroyers that wont be replaced till the 2030s

chilly osprey
#

Worst part is the fact there was supposed to be four of them to replace the Impavido-class and Andrea Doria's

#

But they held off because of the Horizon program

#

And by the time that produced ships there was only two and the Audace class was retired too

rapid junco
#

Another time a Mirage was scrambled was in 1988
When a guy hickjacked a Boeing 737 of the VASP
And a single Mirage was scrambled to accompany the flight

chilly osprey
#

'Hey guys where did all my AAW ships go'

spring briar
#

WHO ASKED

chilly osprey
#

Warspite fanboys

rapid junco
rapid junco
#

But that's just...
WHY

spring briar
#

30 years of difference between these two classes

#

there's also about 30 years between ironclads and super dreadnoughts

#

lmao

manic latch
manic latch
#

PepeStare So what happened to the pilots

rapid junco
#

I didn't mentioned that they shot down the aircraft MiniSip

manic latch
#

Oh my bad. I thought you guys literally intercept it Sadge

rapid junco
#

They just made it land on BrasĂ­lia airport
And that's where you discover that the passengers were the Cuban ambassador and his grandson

manic latch
manic latch
#

Wait can you use word intercept for both situations

rapid junco
#

Yes... SaraSmile

manic latch
#

"Preventing from continuing destination"

#

Yeah should be

rapid junco
#

Remember that during the Falklands we were a neutral country

manic latch
#

Nah accidents can happen

rapid junco
#

That's why we intercepted both a Cuban IL-62 transporting the ambassador to Buenos Aires
And an Avro Vulcan bomber returning from a Black Buck Mission

manic latch
spring briar
#

omg guys guess what

#

the Iowas won

tepid mulch
#

How did the Europeans use firearms for warfare in the 13th and 14th century? Like the general tactics and strategy in use then

manic latch
frigid karma
#

They’ll probably make a vid where they compare iowa to a pt boat at this point

manic latch
#

In 1965 during the Vietnam War, it was the objective of many attacks by US Air Force and US Navy aircraft which would fail to destroy the bridge until 1972, even after hundreds of attacks

#

Tfw took 7 years to destroy French build bridge TOOBASED

desert agate
#

But... it was opened in 1965

#

By Ho Chi Minh

remote monolith
#

thus necessitating innovations from European countries like full plates and Tercios to fully adapt them into armies

#

which then leads into 15-17th century warfares being a fairly schizoid era of pike and shot tactics

manic latch
remote monolith
#

it should be noted too than even when muskets are becoming more commonplace plate armor doesn't actually get obsolete and actually flourished alongside gunpower until the 17-18th century when line infantry begins to replace armored infantry and lighter cavalry replace full plate heavy cavs

#

and its less because they can't protect wearers anymore and more because by the 17th armies tend to comprise of cheaper mercenaries+professional corps combined with proliferation of guns making armormaking more trouble than its worth than just giving people guns

somber knoll
#

Even then, nations didn't consider armor concept out of fashion, but it wasn't until WW1 that they experimented again with ballistic breastplates, only to find out that even if it could give a layer of protection against projectiles, you still have to reduce the trauma caused by the bullet's energy. So by WW2 they pretty much abandoned it.

shrewd pecan
#

body armor was still employed during WW2

#

Soviets widely employed it

#

Steel breastplate, or Stalnoi Nagrudnik (Russian: ĐĄŃ‚Đ°Đ»ŃŒĐœĐŸĐč ĐœĐ°ĐłŃ€ŃƒĐŽĐœĐžĐș) is a type of body armor similar to a cuirass developed by the Red Army in World War II. The native Cyrillic abbreviation for the vest was "СН", the Cyrillic letters Es and En. It consisted of two pressed steel plates that protected the front torso and groin. The plates were 2...

#

on top of that allied aircrews made wide usage of flak vests and other forms of body armor

remote monolith
#

personal armor still see usages in some capacity for sure even in WWII and beyond, but there's basically no return to the full plate models of the early modern by the world wars, excepting some cases in WWI like the Arditi

manic latch
#

Keep forgetting Italy was in this project

remote monolith
#

basically, unless you're freakishly strong there's really no way both of those can directly penetrate plates

#

neither do swords and spears, for that matter

somber knoll
remote monolith
#

of course this just leads to weapons being developed to bypass the armor(warhammers) to techniques designed to aim for weakspots like the armpits

somber knoll
#

already know the armor myths and the counter developments(I practiced both the western and East Asian variant of the classical fighting arts), so no comments there.

So 2 essentially just recycled WW1's concept, which can be acknowledged due to the limitation of material development of the era as well as other factors.

I found at least one literature that discussed the transition slash "vacuum" era of armor development up to the point where plate carriers started to proliferate but it seems like I lost it.

#

which also raises my question on that specific era's progression.

ivory ridge
fierce sparrow
manic latch
manic latch
shrewd pecan
manic latch
#

Tho can I ask if Turret has armor?

#

So many electronics

fierce sparrow
#

Wotspite I kinda didn't like the EMBT new turret design...

manic latch
#

The fuck

#

It's beautiful

shrewd pecan
#

why wouldn't it?

#

for once the Euros were able to make ka turret with a dog house that doesn't stick right into the turret armor

manic latch
#

Risky but still

#

Need to try

shrewd pecan
#

?????

#

what are they sacrificing there?

manic latch
#

Ah. Turret has crew?

shrewd pecan
#

yes

manic latch
#

My bad

shrewd pecan
#

you can clearly see the gunners hatch right there

manic latch
#

Sadge man you ruined it

shrewd pecan
#

seems like 2 turret, 2 hull

#

doesn't seem to be a center hatch, looks to be some type of opitcal system only

#

crew are further back in the turret and the actual parts of the turret with the crew are pretty low profile

#

the 2 RWSs also suggest the vehicle being mostly likely a 4 man crew

#

since who the hell would be crewing the 2nd one if it wasn't a 4th crewmember

chilly osprey
# ivory ridge Plons

First one for 6° Stormo, so looks like 13° Gruppo at Amendola is at full strength now.

#

Also I would like to point out that the aircraft pictured is Cameri's 38th F-35, and that plant alone has assembled more stealth aircraft than Russia has in totality

tough quail
shrewd pecan
tough quail
#

excellent

#

i want to die post haste

#

we really are living in the nightmare world where only the east can make new tanks that dont look like complete ass i guess

spring briar
#

also mother of god
rangefinder time

tough quail
#

i can at least tell like

#

it's the same turret philosophy of the leclerc

#

just more extreme

manic latch
#

So it has autoloader? booba

#

Fuck manual.
Next gen gang use auto TOOBASED

tough quail
#

well obviously

manic latch
#

Oh fucking great

#

Yes this girl has great potential

#

So let's count

Autoloader MBT gang
T series
Leclerc
Type-10
K2?
EMBT
KH-51 Panther

#

Hopefully the Next gen Abrams. And perhaps Altay if K2 has it

tough quail
#

K2 is autoloaded yes

manic latch
#

So by the looks of it. Italy and British will stick to Manual loaders?

#

And maybe US if New Abrams doesn't have it

chilly osprey
#

There isn't much clarity on what either is doing in the future

#

The British are observers to MGCS, and the Italians have wanted to join

manic latch
#

Chal 3 for British no? Or they will go for new tank?

chilly osprey
#

Challenger 3 is just a modernization for the Challenger 2. It's fundamentally the same tank

#

It's a stopgap solution in the same way the Ariete upgrade program is

manic latch
chilly osprey
#

They want to modernize enough tanks to tide them over (i.e. maintain a minimum capability to operate in a modern combat enviorment) until they can replace the entire fleet

manic latch
#

I would tell them to join French-Germany program.
But well they are British

chilly osprey
#

Like I said, they're observers on the program already

#

Main issue is the Franco-German program is basically revolving around KNDS and nothing else

#

They've refused to date to let anyone else into the program to cooperate at a higher level

#

Which is not acceptable to most nations that need specific requirements met or have significant defense industrial bases themselves

#

Italy atm has been stuck between bashing their heads against the wall that is KNDS and the official Franco-German project, finding an alternative path into the program with Rheinmetall, or trying to figure out an alternative program with other partners such as Poland, Spain, or Israel

#

The latter of which basically isn't a realistic option

#

On the one hand, it might seem like a good idea to wait until the MGCS project falls apart and they can try and start a new program with France or Germany, on the other hand they need the new MBTs to be entering service in 2030, so they really don't have much time to wait.

#

It's not a pretty situation

ivory ridge
#

2 nations not getting a new tank arent getting a new tank

#

Incredible thinking there

chilly osprey
#

The hilarious thing is that if the French and Germans were willing to let the Italians and Poles into MGCS it would increase the number of hulls procured by 2.4x. And there probably wouldn't be any more bickering in the program than there already is because the French and Germans are always the ones who cause most of the arguments on European projects

ivory ridge
eager dove
#

christ poland ball hasn't changed at all

#

still chronically unfunny

ivory ridge
shrewd pecan
#

I'm going to be honest

#

the capability leap with the next gen tanks how they currently look isn't really justifiable for replacing entire tank fleets unless you're literally operating 1980s leftovers with no modernization

#

there isn't really any reason to go beyond chally 3 or Ariete since the capability improvements with shit like EMBT don't really justify the investment especially when a lot of the upgrades can just be applied to chally 3 or ariete

#

K-2 makes more sense since Korea is going from a fleet of K1s and M48s and K-2 is a significant improvement on both of them

#

and the other nations operating or looking at K-2s are either operating Leopard 2A4s, pissed off at KMW or are operating primarily M60s or Leopard 1s

#

we'll have to see how EMBT turns out as the program progresses since that thing isn't suppose to be operational until the 2030s but I can see why most nations are just modernizing their current fleets

manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

and?

#

just modernize your current tanks with the new technologies

#

its not really like the next gen tanks are gonna have considerable leaps in armor or firepower

manic latch
#

A sound decision yes. But won't last long. If other nations start getting their next gen. You will somewhat feel the need

#

Arms race and all

#

I like it tho. Opens innovation

shrewd pecan
#

again what do you really gain with the next gen tanks

#

that can't be applied to current platforms

manic latch
#

And with better ideas on how future tech will be. Maybe better designed for future refits

#

Like Gerald ford for carrier

#

She is designed for future planes and tech refits in mind

shrewd pecan
#

ships are different since there's considerable improvements to be made there

#

and there is only so much you can prolong a ships lifespan

#

tank wise you can constantly rebuild them

#

and basically every current tank platform still has room to grow

#

things like APS, fully digital controls, new fire control systems can all be applied to current gen tanks

manic latch
#

How about drones

midnight ore
manic latch
#

Like the new KH51

midnight ore
#

they're all pushing 70t

shrewd pecan
#

and?

midnight ore
#

that's a lot

#

should be less

shrewd pecan
#

your telling me the next gen tanks aren't going to be pushing that

#

again there's not really been any major improvements in armor technology to justify making the tank lighter

manic latch
#

Well you do hurt the max speed that was designed originally

midnight ore
#

well currently the kf 51 has all that and is only 59t

#

as well as armata

shrewd pecan
midnight ore
#

even though its vaporware

shrewd pecan
#

abrams has basically maintained its top speed despite the weight increases due to transmission upgrades

manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

I mean

#

T-14 is a actual leap over the rest of the t series tanks

manic latch
#

So shows importance of next gen

shrewd pecan
#

since its not a development of the T-64

#

EMBT or KF51 doesn't really offer any considerable leap to leopard 2 or abrams

ivory ridge
#

But le funny drone

shrewd pecan
#

deadman also how the fuck is KF-51 59 tons

shrewd pecan
#

that's only 4 tons lighter than a leopard 2

manic latch
#

Ain't that advantage

shrewd pecan
#

autoloaders aren't necessarily a advantage

manic latch
midnight ore
shrewd pecan
#

leopard 2A6 is only 63 tons

ivory ridge
#

It's a 2a4 hull with probably barely additional armor and the turret is probably

midnight ore
ivory ridge
#

Not that armored

shrewd pecan
#

you can throw all of those upgrades on a leopard 2A6

#

and keep it in relatively the same weight class

manic latch
#

Autoloader Leo 2 weight MonkaW

midnight ore
#

it only uses the Leo engine and some other parts

#

and it's a good engine

ivory ridge
#

You're right, it's worse, it's a lynx hull

shrewd pecan
#

again manual loader can load as fast as a autoloader in most cases

#

you don't really need a autoloader unless you're upsizing the gun

manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

shells aren't getting heavier

midnight ore
manic latch
#

Don't they hmm

midnight ore
#

you need one

shrewd pecan
#

who is fielding a 130 MM or a 140 MM right now?

midnight ore
#

yeah the 120mm dont need one

shrewd pecan
#

what is the point in the 130 or 140 MM?

#

No one has purchased KF-51

midnight ore
shrewd pecan
#

I don't even think

manic latch
shrewd pecan
#

next gen MBTs would be utilizing 130 or 140s

#

since there's no point

#

there's been no considerable leap in armor technology to justify it

manic latch
#

105mm gang :what's the point of 120mm

shrewd pecan
#

120 also still has plenty of room to grow

#

đŸ‘ïž M900 out of a 105 had equivalent penetration to a lot of the 90s 120 MM rounds

manic latch
#

I mean history shows tank guns are keep getting bigger and bigger

shrewd pecan
#

tank guns have been static for the last 40 years

ivory ridge
#

Out of very specific 105s while killing barrel life*

desert agate
manic latch
ivory ridge
#

Not in the next decade

#

Or 2

midnight ore
manic latch
#

Drone shells= larger gun TOOBASED

desert agate
#

Rheinmetall says a lot of things

shrewd pecan
#

it hasn't

manic latch
#

L77 Despair

#

wait a minute

#

Why develop 130mm then

#

If 120mm didn't reach peak

ivory ridge
#

Hype

manic latch
#

hmm hmm

ivory ridge
#

My brother in christ most nato tanks had either prototypes or blueprints for 140mm versions... in the 90s

manic latch
#

Good times feelssadman

ivory ridge
#

Also friendly reminder

chilly osprey
#

Seems kind of impossible to argue about KF51's protection and the like when we basically know nothing about it

ivory ridge
#

The KF51 is like

#

99% export only

manic latch
#

Why

chilly osprey
#

KF51 is basically Rheinmetall trying to get sales for anyone who wants to replace their tanks with something newer than Leo 2A6 or A7, and doesn't want to wait for MGCS

#

i.e. they want to sell to Eastern Europe and the Middle East

shrewd pecan
#

regarding L/55

#

US has been squeezing L/55 level experience out of the L/44

#

and the M256 still has more room to grow

shrewd pecan
#

so again I don't really see any move away from 120 MM

#

since armor hasn't really made any type of considerable leap

manic latch
#

Why US didn't go for L55

shrewd pecan
#

L/55 didn't work well with abram's stabilization

manic latch
#

Interesting

shrewd pecan
#

there was a M1A1 with a L/55 version of the M256 called the M256A1

#

there was no real point in the L/55 for the US

#

M256 already ran at higher pressures

#

and DU just performed better than tungsten

midnight ore
#

isn't that also partly because the newest US rounds are freakishly long?

shrewd pecan
#

penetrator is

midnight ore
#

that's what i meant

shrewd pecan
#

think another point regarding the next gen MBT discussion

#

Leopard 2A7V and M1A2C only get up to about 66 tons

#

reasonably any technologies for lightening future MBTs can be introduced to both platforms

#

again these tanks have been constantly rebuilt to new spec and still have plenty of growth room

#

and assuming the Next gen abrams is what it implies a further evolution of the abrams there's no reason why current gen tanks can't be rebuilt with new turrets or other features

tough quail
#

66

#

you're low balling that

shrewd pecan
tough quail
#

wikipedia

shrewd pecan
#

that's short tons

tough quail
#

yes and that's a m1a2c with barely anything on it

#

the conversion is still well over 66 tons with trophy installed

shrewd pecan
#

and?

tough quail
#

closer to 74 tonnes with APS slapped on

shrewd pecan
#

platform is still able to operate just fine with the additional weight

tough quail
#

🙄

#

bridges cannot into real

midnight ore
#

idk man, if you can get similar or better capabilities at 25t less, i'd say that's a good deal

#

also yes

shrewd pecan
midnight ore
#

bridges and logistics

shrewd pecan
#

infrastructure already exists in both the German and US armies for supporting these vehicles

midnight ore
#

ok but what about bum-fuck nowhere?

tough quail
#

excellent we have fleets of specialized equipment dedicated for supporting our bloated 40 year old chassis

desert agate
#

Bro imagine if

#

The bridge

#

Comes to you

tough quail
#

its also a good thing that weight has absolutely no detriment to general terrain crossing or bogging down either

shrewd pecan
#

has it?

#

mobility for both platforms has remain relatively the same despite the weight increases

midnight ore
#

yet despite that

#

[CURRENT EVENT]

shrewd pecan
#

they still get bogged down regardless

#

as [CURRENT EVENT] has shown

midnight ore
#

so yes, tanks do get stuck

tough quail
#

which definitely means tanks weighing dramatically more will just uh

#

not get stuck

#

through the power of witchcraft

midnight ore
#

shaving 20t off a tank will just make everyones lives easier

#

imo

shrewd pecan
#

yeah but are you actually shaving 20 tons off of a tank

tough quail
#

and it's not like germany or the US are too poor to just finally make a new chassis

#

like germany is currently doing

shrewd pecan
#

KF51 as you said is only shaving off some 6 tons

desert agate
#

Bro making a tank lighter to prevent it bogging just gives you a shittier tank to unbog

shrewd pecan
#

yeah

midnight ore
#

it's better

desert agate
#

And the US is working on a new chassis

#

Right now

shrewd pecan
#

how are you shaving

#

20 tons off of a western tank

midnight ore
desert agate
#

Highly classified but they are

tough quail
#

by

shrewd pecan
#

T series tanks are only in the weight class they're due to the compromises made in the design

tough quail
#

integrating new features into it from a ground up level

#

instead of slapdash bandaid additions over the years

#

because you can fit a ton of shit on more efficiently that way

desert agate
#

Yes and they are literally working on it

midnight ore
#

like you really think when a leopard 2a7 will finally get all it's APS and other shit slapped on, it wont weigh over 70T?

shrewd pecan
#

Horse you're gonna have a 55-60 ton tank regardless due to the weight of the armor and systems involved

midnight ore
#

really?

desert agate
#

The US hasn't decided that the Abram's is the be all end all of tanks

shrewd pecan
#

KF51 as claimed here is still 59 tons

desert agate
#

They have actually realised the platform is reaching obsolescence so they're extending the service life while the new mbt program is being worked on

midnight ore
#

who knew

shrewd pecan
#

realistically you're only shaving off 8 tons for a new more expensive platform

#

yeah saving 4 tons for a tank germany won't buy

desert agate
#

And [current event] is not an observation of the be all end all of tanks and tank operations

#

Tanks were getting bogged in those fields 80 years ago just as hard as they are today

#

It's the seasonal geography of the area

midnight ore
desert agate
#

Which experiences mass rainfall at this time of year causing the entire ground to turn to mush

midnight ore
#

new tanks that have those features integrated and have much more room to grow are just a better investment

#

imo

tough quail
#

again uh

#

the KF51 is actually

desert agate
#

Yes that's why new tanks are being worked on right now

tough quail
#

fitted out

#

the leos and abrams are only hoovering around 65 or so tonnes when they're mostly naked

midnight ore
#

especially since some of the newer upgrade packages are almost as expensive as getting new tanks all together

tough quail
#

as soon as you start kitting them out with APS and such the weight bloats like mad

tough quail
#

tato's the one going "eh but who cares though?"

desert agate
#

Yes and new tanks also take a long time to develop and prepare for production

#

So you know

#

You need to upgrade what you have

shrewd pecan
#

I don't think saving 5-10 tons really justifies a new investment unless the platforms are really that much of a improvement

desert agate
#

To keep it relevant

midnight ore
desert agate
#

Until that replacement comes down the road

#

At some point in the next half decade

midnight ore
#

i remember when people were clowning on the f-35 for being a bloated mess

midnight ore
#

and now it's the best plane in the world

shrewd pecan
#

in their current form I don't think they're really worthwhile

tough quail
#

its 5-10 tons compared to a naked M1A2C

shrewd pecan
#

tho that doesn't change the fact the current platforms are indeed aging

tough quail
#

with a bigger, better gun

#

and almost certainly better armor given its not stuck with the goofy abrams front plate

midnight ore
#

it doesn't even have to be the KF-51 specifically, it's just an example

tough quail
#

like the 130mm isnt just, uh

#

weightless

midnight ore
#

it's fuckin massive

tough quail
#

they didnt build it out of cardboard

spring briar
#

Ello guys

shrewd pecan
#

yeah but its there really much point in going from a Leopard 2A7 to a KF51?

tough quail
#

oi vey

midnight ore
#

i think the prices wont be that different

shrewd pecan
#

better off waiting 1-2 decades and just modernizing what you got

#

my main argument is that in their current forms there isn't really much of a point in these platforms as they exist right now

midnight ore
#

well if you have old leopards that's a different story

#

but again

shrewd pecan
#

yeah I argued earlier

#

it makes sense to go from a leopard 2A4 to a K-2

midnight ore
#

some of the new upgrade packages are very expensive