💡 Make the results of every single ranking ticket public in a read only channel. Fixes the outdat...

[umbral cradle]

Please discuss this idea civilly, don't forget to vote on this idea in #📝︱server-suggestions!

[grave tendon]

while that would be cool, that would be absolutely terrible for people who leak their games code

As someone can just copy paste

So maybe you could ask if you want this public or nah to balance privacy out

[hushed grove]

True, but this does seem like an issue mainly for scripters

[grave tendon]

yup

[polar swift]

nah

[hushed grove]

elaborate

[polar swift]

I think people should be allowed to get roles while still having the privacy to not have to display everything they want to get ranked off of

also pretty sure we alr had something like this for a couple weeks and it was removed

[hushed grove]

why would you want privacy on your stuff?

u get free exposure

[polar swift]

uh cause some people just dont want people seeing them stuff, or getting like rejected from a role

like a lot of people alr get a bit nervous making ranking tickets I think this would just make quite a few people not wanna get a rank

[hushed grove]

only show the approved ones in this case, and ask the rejected ones if they want it public

[hushed grove]

wdym dont want people seeing their stuff

[polar swift]

some people might just not wanna post their stuff cause they dont want people to see, or they might not be able to share it cause its for like a game or something

[hushed grove]

95% of the time its portfolio pieces

[hushed grove]

they dont want other people to see that they (may have) lucked out on getting the rank?

[polar swift]

yeah but sometimes its not, and people can just be kinda shy about posting stuff

I jus don see a reason to

[hushed grove]

ok in this case, jus ask the guy if he wants it public lol

[hushed grove]

still seems like a bs reason but okie

cuz 99% of times if u ask the guy what they sent for rank, they point to their portfolio or twitter or #✅︱creations anyway

(im jus making up stats so ignore the number)

[polar swift]

yeah but some might not, just like people should have the right to not have their tickets put on display

[hushed grove]

fixes the issue of ranking guidelines showing too little of what considers to be that rank, by having a lot of work displayed of that rank

[hushed grove]

yea jus give the people an option

[polar swift]

if anything I feel like it would make it more confusing, when its a guidlines the rankers can choose what they want to represent that rank, but as ranking is a subjective thing having so many unfiltered examples can just give a worse idea of what the rank is

[polar swift]

this is also just difficult to implement cause then it cant be done automaticaly

[hushed grove]

its just to represent it better, nobody even uses the guidelines cuz its worthless

might as well use ai generated text for it and slap a single work on it

boom

you got your current guidelines

[hushed grove]

same reasons as you said?

[polar swift]

guidlines would be less worthless if people ever bothered to check them out, like almost all tickets the person doesnt look at it all, and having another form of this which is just even more difficult to read and look through is even less likely to have people actualy look at

[hushed grove]

because it feels worthless. there just isnt enough visual examples in it

not to mention

it doesnt cover all genres

[polar swift]

I mean if you find that an issue just go annoy the rankers for that role and get them to make it better

doesnt change the fact people never read them anyways

and they probably wont read this either

tbh

damn

[hushed grove]

true

[hushed grove]

what about this

[polar swift]

idk

it was like a thing where anyone could make a post for a role and the rank2s and above would vouch, and then it was changed so you alr had to be rank 2 or above, and then they just removed it

[hushed grove]

how is this similar

[polar swift]

everything was public

only dif is not just rankers coudl vouch

[hushed grove]

are u talking about public ranking?

[polar swift]

yeah is that not what this is

ranking made public

its the same thing just in tickets

[hushed grove]

no, in this you would get the rank by the rankers only, no public will be involved in the ranking process. just only the ticket content will be viewable by the public after the ranking ticket has finished

[polar swift]

yeah thats the same thing accept rank 2s could also vouch,

[hushed grove]

in public ranking u could get ranked by the public by vouches

[polar swift]

not much dif, and they alr removed the old one

[polar swift]

yeah but it was only rank2s+ so it was mostly just rankers anyways

[hushed grove]

in this there is nothing new, except just post the ticket content in a channel

[polar swift]

this cant be automated tho as well

just annoying, ruins the privacy of ranking, probably wont be read anyways

idk bad idea

[hushed grove]

dats the thing

ranking shouldnt be private

if u got the rank

you deserved that rank

and should be able to tell others how you got the rank

so they can see the standard

removes any sort of biasness

[polar swift]

then just go and ask someone with the rank what they submitted and if they wanna show you they will

[polar swift]

it doesnt ranking will still be subjective tho

it wont make the ranking any more fair

now just everyone can watch the shitshow instead of it being kind of obscurred

[hushed grove]

no, you can question the ranker or the guy getting ranked on it

[polar swift]

you can do that anyways though

just go ask the guy

[hushed grove]

would be entertaining tho

better than #🤡︱clownery

lel

eh

[paper patrol]

I agree with this

[glacial crypt]

no this isnt happening

a lot of people dont want their shit leaked

even though its mostly "just scripters" theyre the biggest skill role in the server

at best we could have people opt into that, but that defeats the purpose

cuz they can just send their shit in the respective creation channel

[wintry summit]

yea thank god

[sage thunder]

privacy issues and also youre gonna get people in tickets like

"oh this guy made this work and got this role but his work is shit and im so much better ur biased" and then 20,000,000 false ranker reports come in

[hushed grove]

Privacy only makes sense for scripters (but then again trakktors reasoning of scripters being the biggest skill role also makes sense)

And at the level 4 ranks where they MIGHT have an nda

[hushed grove]

Atleast u can get to know how they got the role this way tho. What things they did better etc so that you could learn from it

[sonic bane]

I disagree

It will just have shit tons of bloat

Not everyone wants to see the tickets

[hushed grove]

Then jus dont open or jus hide the channel lol

[sonic bane]

Still

Disagree