#Elden Ring (DLC hype room)

1 messages · Page 62 of 1

proven cloak
#

Castle Morne multiplied in size, loads of new spells (and a new spell-progression system), tons of classes, npc opponents, bosses...

#

other guy I know thinks its a little 'unsubtle' compared to From's storytelling

#

like Seilia is just full of Nox now

languid tiger
#

oh, i wouldn't exactly go to fans expecting improved lore

#

plenty of fanfic is great

#

but writing's always hard

#

and i don't expect "good story/fixes to story" and "good gamedev" to overlap super heavily in free fanwork spaces

tropic stream
#

Okay as if I couldn't like Caimar even more

#

They gave him Gundyr Kick

glossy delta
#

I think a lot of caimars stuff may be the twinblade guys from Sekiro

languid tiger
#

ahhh

#

that'd make some sense

#

been a hot second since I touched sekiro

#

gotta dust up

stone cove
#

So, amusing discovery

#

after all this arena play

#

a lot of bosses seem, well, slow

#

...also that doesnt mean i cna dodge em eany beter XD

#

but i did manage to take down ||Messmer, Scadu Tree Avatar & Midra|| tonight all solo, no ashes, no summons

#

so i'm happy

outer flint
#

🤝

vivid spire
#

Antspur Rapier obtained

stoic sleet
#

give them the ol rot

outer flint
vivid spire
#

How does it scale with dex

obtuse halo
#

it's primarily a dex weapon

frail sky
#

It’s very funny if you infuse it with poison/bleed/frostbite though

obtuse halo
#

yeah, sadly (though probably for the best) the rot doesn't scale with anything though

#

I used Bleed Antspur my first time through and it's very functional though

atomic plinth
#

...Jesus Christ I forgot how terrible Gaius is

outer flint
#

🙈

outer flint
#

thinking of using it with poison blade ash, bleed infusion, and frozen needle

#

status rainbow

proven cloak
#

the Alloyed Needle

#

its just got fucking everything on it

frail sky
#

Thrusting sword with inherent frost (and a strong attack that shoots a projectile)

obtuse halo
#

Frozen Needle + Antspur is definitely a funny dual-wield

atomic plinth
#

Oh neato

obtuse halo
#

Though you’re stuck with impaling thrust if you want the shot

atomic plinth
#

God, Scholar's Armament is really fucking good

#

Shame it costs this much FP

#

...also wish it didn't paint your weapon blue

spring marlin
#

oohoohoo lightsaber go vvvvvvmmmmmmm

vivid spire
#

Fire giant keeps fucking me yp

#

Uuuugh

obtuse halo
outer flint
#

but my great katana is cold so I can't blue it up

atomic plinth
#

Well, it's not the blue I take issue with

outer flint
#

which infusions allow elemental buffs?

atomic plinth
#

It's the fact that it paints the ENTIRE weapon blue rather than just painting the bit you smack things with

stoic sleet
outer flint
#

oh what

#

weird

obtuse halo
outer flint
#

did it do that in ds3, i'm not sure

atomic plinth
outer flint
#

I've only used magic weapon there

obtuse halo
#

makes the list of weapons that make decent-looking lightsabers shorter than it might otherwise be

outer flint
#

👅

obtuse halo
#

(Milady is the new best one, I think)

outer flint
#

ooooh

#

that would look really cool, gonna try that

outer flint
#

alas, i have 14 str and 17 dex

obtuse halo
#

(before it looked best on Cane Sword and basic Twinblade, which unfortunately are not the best options for being good weapons)

outer flint
stoic sleet
#

Didn't someone do a video cosplaying Count Dooku in the Yoda boss fight

outer flint
#

I'm so weak..

stoic sleet
#

Using Milady

outer flint
#

OMFG

#

this is hilarious

#

😭

stoic sleet
#

Lol yeah that's the one

vivid spire
#

I’m using a bleed build

#

What do I do yall

stoic sleet
#

Bleed em dry

atomic plinth
#

Level your dex at least a BIT

outer flint
#

why 😭

atomic plinth
#

Speeds up cast speed

outer flint
#

damn..

#

i was planning to level it to 18

#

but i forgot about casts

obtuse halo
#

Radagon Icon does a lot fwiw

atomic plinth
#

Aye, aye

#

Gives 30 virtual dex iirc

stoic sleet
#

I think it benefits cast speed up to 40 iirc

atomic plinth
#

Isn't it 70?

stoic sleet
#

Leveling Dex I mean

#

Maybe

vivid spire
stoic sleet
#

I think I just hear 40 tossed around as the break point a lot

outer flint
#

I see...

#

I'll consider Radagon Icon gladeline

#

this is what I have off the top of my head

atomic plinth
#

Oh thank god you leveled vigor

stoic sleet
outer flint
outer flint
atomic plinth
#

...ugh

#

I wish Dragonscale Blade was better

obtuse halo
#

wing stance has a surprisingly big hitbox

outer flint
atomic plinth
#

Coolest looking katana but it deals such piddly damage

proven cloak
#

cool lorewise, kinda goofy

#

esp the ds1 version

outer flint
#

looks like fireworks

vivid spire
#

GOT HIM

#

Switched from

#

Antspur to my basic longsword

proven cloak
#

beware my sorcerous might

proven cloak
outer flint
#

nice scrble :D

atomic plinth
#

...how the fuck do you get through the artillery mausoleum again

obtuse halo
#

honse

#

if you can get under it it should be safe

#

relatively safe.

atomic plinth
#

I don't get why they programmed it with this many projectiles ngl

warped quest
#

thats the only part in the baes game that have framerate issues

atomic plinth
#

It wouldn't be as bad if the projectiles weren't just

#

BAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAMBAM

#

Y'know?

#

Like it feels like someone's blasting me with a GAU-8 loaded up with HE rounds

outer flint
#

how do you get to the one northeast of the academy?

#

i tried to jump down from the cliff on the stones but died twice, got salty, and left

stoic sleet
#

I think that is the correct approach

#

You just need to, well, not miss?

atomic plinth
#

You can plink away at the skulls with a bow

#

It also lies down for about 15 minutes at night

stoic sleet
#

This I did not know

outer flint
#

eepy...

#

I will wait for it to eep then

#

i thought there was a spiritspring or similar that I was missing

atomic plinth
#

God this is just stupid

warped quest
#

i recomend yeah just running as fast as you can at it

atomic plinth
#

...holy shit

#

I got summoned for Godrick and the other Furled Finger killed him so fucking hard that it took the game a solid few seconds to realize "oh shit wait he's dead"

#

Oh my god

#

Fucking melted him with Euporia

#

Holy shit I need to get my hands on that thing

stoic sleet
#

Yeah, it sounds like the buff did great things for it

vivid spire
#

Godskins dead

stone cove
covert schooner
#

MIYAZAKI!! MY LIFE IS YOURS IF YOU DROP THE SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE OST!

vivid spire
#

Maliketh scary

vivid spire
covert schooner
#

That’s not an official pat

#

*OST

#

that’s a rip someone made

#

All of the official OSTs are from the fromsoft sound team

vivid spire
#

Yeah it’s on there

covert schooner
#

Yeah again I don’t think that one is official

#

It happened with ac6 and persona reload too where people just post rips of the songs until the official drops

vivid spire
#

Oh

#

Yeah I was disappointed at first

#

Because not all the tracks weee there

#

But then I remembered

#

It’s a dlc

#

Not all the tracks will be there

covert schooner
#

They will

#

They almost always upload literally every track

vivid spire
#

Oh?

#

Fuck yeah.

covert schooner
#

They haven’t really been in a position to do a dlc ost yet on Spotify but idk why they wouldn’t

#

Considering that elden ring and AC6 OSTs were extensive

vivid spire
#

That’s true

#

Why haven’t they been in a position to do so?

covert schooner
#

They just didn’t upload stuff before DS3 and Bloodborne is up to Sony

#

Sorry, DS3 included

warped quest
#

i think some of the older stuff comes from cds

covert schooner
#

That makes sense

vivid spire
frozen olive
#

Radagon does not care if you have some kind of projectile weapon

#

he will swat that shit away and just beat you to death like planned

obtuse halo
#

Radagon is one of the few bosses I have been unable to beat Bow-only

#

(okay technically I've beaten Radagon, but not with enough resources left over to still beat Elden Beast)

warped quest
#

i wonder if it would be an actual idea to use keyboard and mouse to quickly craft more arrows and stuff in that short time window before it gets to you

obtuse halo
#

(yes, I did go speedrun that death rite bird at low level with only two talisman slots)

#

...And wrongwarp into leyndell for some early fashion and other loot

proven cloak
obtuse halo
#

you can really scuff up the map if you play the game like I do tbh

outer flint
#

oh yeah btw, could you guys please spoiler mark DLC boss names and related spoilery stuff if possible, since I've just started working through the DLC for the first time maddyhug peeps have been pretty good about it but I just wanted to put it out there c:

outer flint
#

💖

spring marlin
vivid spire
#

The last larval tear for my final boss save is in that fucking runebear

#

I’m going back to a dex faith build and trying what I’ve learned from melee

#

I have no desire to relplay the SOTE stuff on other characters anymore

#

To put it bluntly

#

This build fucking sucks

#

The runebear is taking almost no damage at all

#

And I’m all out of larval tears

#

My lvl 210 build just started sote and it means I gotta play it all over again

warped quest
#

you used 20 larval tears?

vivid spire
#

Just to try and gain an edge on ||Radhan|| yes I did

proven cloak
#

did you get all the ones in the land of shadow?

warped quest
#

what build were you trying to do

vivid spire
#

Bleed arcane

#

But it’s doing no damage to the runebear whatsoever

#

And I fucking hate runebears

#

So I’m gonna go back to my lvl 120 build and grind.. which tires the hell out of me but fuck it

proven cloak
#

rip

vivid spire
#

This save is unsalvagable

#

And my 220 character hasn’t even started the dlc either

warped quest
#

220 is really high for the dlc

vivid spire
#

Yes. But I’d have to start the dlc all. Over. Again.

#

That means finding every fragment from scratch

warped quest
#

what is your build currently

vivid spire
#

Current character is my dex faith melee with 50 dex and 40 faith at lvl 120

warped quest
#

no the one you used all the tears on

vivid spire
#

I’ve been killing albinaurics for the past week to get there

#

Oh

#

30 dex 40 faith 60 arcane

#

And I’m not having fun with it anymore

#

But I used every single tear

warped quest
#

use the faith for vow and crab for phase 1 defense then phase 2 use the hardtear physic

#

morgott's sword is pretty decent you can also change into a spear and shield strat with bloodfien'd fork or messmer solider spear

vivid spire
#

I see

#

I’ll try that.. but tbh arc just isn’t as fun as pyromancy

#

I feel weirdly limited coming back to my old characters because I gotta basically relearn

#

Or maybe it’s because I’ve been playing nonstop

grave plinth
#

any tips for fighting the furnace golems?

warped quest
#

don't honestly

#

ive heard pest threads

#

but it didn't work for me

#

i don't think people have datamined them yet sadly

vivid spire
#

Like im having fun replaying with a completely new build style and stuff

#

The idea of fighting ||Radhan|| over and over again doesn’t fill me with joy

warped quest
#

there is also a way to one cycle them by throwing a furance firepot into them right after a ripose

#

but its tricky and theres not a good farming spot for furnace visages

vivid spire
#

On my new save I’m at Maliketh

#

And tbh

#

I do not feel motivated to fight him

#

Found this idk the artist

#

Idk y'all

#

Do I continue grinding with my new character

frozen olive
#

If you want to

#

If it sucks, hit da bricks, you don't owe it to anyone to beat the final boss

warped quest
#

i feel like your messed up one is saveable tbh

#

even more so with spirits

outer flint
#

i got another boss! ||rellana||

#

i was honestly getting half decent at deflecting over time

#

visions of royalguard....

warped quest
#

i really think there should have been a 2nd milady

#

somewhere

vivid spire
#

I’m sure it probably is but idk

warped quest
#

what is even your battleplan

#

what are you doing

vivid spire
#

Spam flies. I have milady scaled to arcane. Scarlet rot

#

And uhh

#

Pray

warped quest
#

what about spirits?

vivid spire
#

Taylew

#

I’m getting more comfy with melee

#

On my other character

warped quest
#

yeah taylew is really strong

#

what abotu buffs?

proven cloak
#

wont be satisfying if you're feeling like its forced

vivid spire
warped quest
#

i would ignore flame its really short

#

slap on some crab instead in its place

#

it stacks with bow

vivid spire
#

Alright

warped quest
#

wait

vivid spire
#

I’m really debating continuing this or playing the dlc from scratch

warped quest
#

for phase 2 you could use holy fort

vivid spire
#

I’ll definitely try that

#

Yeah I used that too

warped quest
#

also remember vow does buff summons too

vivid spire
#

I tried Thorns as well

warped quest
#

what tears are you using

vivid spire
#

Before they were nerfed

#

Opaline and uhhh

#

Another one

warped quest
#

you could also slap on gloveworst tear

#

boosts spirit damage

vivid spire
#

Hmm

#

That seems too specific

#

I think for now I’ll do the dlc with my new build

#

It’ll work with milady since it’s predominantly dex focused

#

Idk have yall beaten the boss yet

warped quest
#

i have not

proven cloak
#

I have

warped quest
#

i gave up the boss just isnt good to me a lot do not like the final boss

vivid spire
#

Hmm

#

Although I’ll admit

proven cloak
#

used ||Marika's braid + Lords fort + A big hammer|| and a lot of attempts

vivid spire
#

The base final boss took me dozens of tries

#

So maybe it’s just a skill issue and I need to get over it

vivid spire
proven cloak
#

yeah, I was lucky in that the hammer I used had 80% block, I don't recomend trying to roll every attack

#

even then I mostly flailed until the fight clicked

vivid spire
#

Oh

proven cloak
#

the one good thing ||about phase 2 is he moves similar to phase 1||

vivid spire
#

Maybe I’ll go back and try it again..

#

I don’t want to ;-;

proven cloak
#

so if you practice against that one, you're also practicing against the second

#

no completely fair

vivid spire
#

I need to kill the runebear

proven cloak
#

I'm NG+ the dlc and I am not looking forward to the final boss again

vivid spire
#

And remake my build to something I’ve tried over and over

proven cloak
#

wishing you good luck

vivid spire
#

Or maybe I don’t and just grind on my new character

#

Idk

proven cloak
#

you might just have to sleep on it, unironically. It can take a bit for the muscle-memory to lock in

outer flint
#

||hippo is hard|| 😔

proven cloak
#

though imo you should do whats confortable, if thats starting over or using a build or w/e

outer flint
#

boss is kicking my butt

proven cloak
#

it embarrassed me so much as the boss I died to more than ||Beast or Rellana||

#

all my friends beat it like 1 or 2nd try pensob

frozen olive
#

Personally i won with against the final boss with ||Golden Vow, Lords Divine Fortification, Flame Skewer FKGS, no skill Haligtree Crest Greatshield and Scarlet Aonia. Used Dragoncrest, golden braid, shard of alexander and carian filigreed for talismans and Opaline for physick||

vivid spire
#

I’ve been trying to killl Malenia for a few days

#

And.. that’s going poorly too

#

Maybe I’m just burnt out

frozen olive
#

She's a real bitch to defeat

proven cloak
#

so pretty similar

#

||think I used Crimson Seed+1 while learning the fight though, because I didn't have all my flasks or tears||

frozen olive
#

Kinda bummed i'm done now that i ||defeated the new hardest boss in the game solo, as well as previously having taken out Malenia solo||

proven cloak
#

and even with this my first winning attempt I was down to 0 flasks

#

that phase 2 is brutal

vivid spire
#

I wanna play er but like

#

;-;

#

Idk maybe I need to sleep

frozen olive
#

I'm kinda done with ER for a bit

vivid spire
#

Well ofc you beat the game

frozen olive
#

I beat the game like 3 days after the DLC released

#

Finally went back and fought the boss solo now tho

#

Before i summoned

vivid spire
#

Maybe I need to get good

frozen olive
#

Unfortunately since i'm kimda burned out on ER i'm left with playing more Sekiro instead since ER has been my main game for a while now

proven cloak
#

I started an int/faith full caster playthrough and commited to not switching to int/bonk like I did on another

#

and that's been hard

#

I am not kidding when I say the first thing I did after beating ||Promised Consort Radahn|| was ||die to mad pumpkin head like 5-7 times in a row on a fresh character||

#

why are wizards so frail. and weak.

#

why can I beat morne + margit + stormveil without dying at level 12 on bonk and struggle against leonine misbegotten as a caster double that level

vivid spire
#

I think I’ll sleep on it

#

Idk what to do other than keep grinding to get to lvl 150

left willow
languid tiger
#

that sounds like a skill issue, my wizards are swole and huge

#

just be big

#

radahn is a fucknormous wizard

#

follow his glorious lead

#

rykard is a snake wizard, even

#

level vig

#

level str

#

become the 80 int king

left willow
#

Leonine Misbegotten is an especially odd case. The reasons Wizard builds struggle (ime) are:

  1. his attacks have a lot of forwards movement tied to them, letting him close the gap you wanna build as a wizard to be able to spell
  2. he has a number of big sweep moves that will body your summon(s) even if you're holding aggro
  3. dodge timing is a little fucky for ranged characters in general, imo
covert schooner
#

Thinking about that “just like you” thing I posted again and
Yeah man Ranni might ACTUALLY have been an inspiration for Miquella growing up

#

Well

#

“Growing up”

#

||Them both using the thousand year voyage term while Ranni is significantly older and has been at this for a long time is potentially telling||

glossy stag
#

||Is Ranni significantly older?||

obtuse halo
# glossy stag ||Is Ranni significantly older?||

She's definitely older, since Malenia and Miquella were born after Radagon left Rennala, but the actual time gap isn't clear. Could be like five years, could be fifty, could be five hundred when we're talking deities

proven cloak
#

Ive always seen her as the youngest of the Carians

#

but yeah who knows the relations between the different sibling groups

proven cloak
proven cloak
# languid tiger level str

I’ve done like 2.75 str runs already its the crab of ER builds to me I’m trying to ignore its siren call

#

pure str, arcane str, faith str, int str, quality….

atomic plinth
#

Wish I could squeeze more AR out of Nagakiba

#

Best I've gotten is a measly 708

stone cove
#

Slap two-hander talisman on that, and get antoerh 15% ontop of that

#

Now this did take a minium of 179 levels as a wretch so

atomic plinth
#

That's still a lot less than my INT katanas though

outer flint
#

wamly what's your build for bloodhound's fang

#

i tried keen great katana with magic weapon, but it got outperformed by cold

stone cove
atomic plinth
#

Nothing hugely fancy. 52 STR, 60 DEX, 75 INT, +10 BHF, +10 Carian Regal Scepter, and Scholar's Armament

stone cove
#

The real issue is it's mostly slash damage, which tens to alternate between "Stupidly strong" and "Lol, why are you trying to cut this"

frozen olive
#

lol yeah

stone cove
#

@outer flint this might help

#

Cold Uchi & Naa are dex with some int (Though Cold Uchi is surpsignly close to being a quality weapon, lol) while Magic is basically pure int

#

and tbh, if you want a magic katana you should probably be just using the Moonveil, or the new one that's in the dlc

#

er, Int Katana*

outer flint
outer flint
#

that makes sense

stone cove
#

This site is very useful for figuring things out

#

Just remember: having two damage types means you hit two sets of resistances.

This can be anything from Not a big deal, to a huge problem, to actually an advnatage

#

and gets kinda fucky depending on your stats.

atomic plinth
atomic plinth
#

I just wanted to use the Washing Pole

outer flint
#

real

atomic plinth
#

Cause I mean, it's a Dark Souls staple

outer flint
#

I used it for a while, it was fun gladeline

#

long range! :3

atomic plinth
#

Looks good with my current fit too

outer flint
#

I went back and upgraded my washing pole in ds3, I'll give it a try later

frozen olive
outer flint
#

hand it over. that thing, your 859460 runes

stone cove
#

EG if you go minimum investments for using the Nagakiba, and then 80 int - You have 688 AR on the Uchi, and 673 ar on the Nagaika

But it's 232 Physical (Slash, sometimes pierce), and 455 magic. for the Uchi (and slightly lower for the Nagakiba)

frozen olive
#

some sephiroth shit lol

outer flint
atomic plinth
#

Real and true

atomic plinth
outer flint
#

but I already knew that

frozen olive
#

i would give them to you if i could tbh

#

it's not a lot of runes

outer flint
stone cove
#

Comparably, just going straight dex gets you 591 ar/588 - and most of that is physical, with onyl a bit of magic

outer flint
stone cove
#

which is very different in how that'll play out

frozen olive
atomic plinth
frozen olive
#

i personally farm the albinaurics

outer flint
#

i will kill the bosses many times over

#

the thrill of battle...

stone cove
#

You do the bird and the albinaruacs!

#

it's effficeny!

outer flint
#

I want to play sekiro now 😩 deflecting tear was fun, I'd like to see how the game built around it plays

stone cove
#

you shoot the bird once, swithc to the godslayer and cast that

#

boom booom

outer flint
#

but it'll come later

outer flint
stone cove
#

though tbh, if you're in the dlc, just like... fucking murder stuff in the dlc

#

it vbomits runes at you

atomic plinth
frozen olive
#

i guess i could do both

stone cove
#

tbh, if your on pc and consdierng farming runes jsut like.. cheat engine is right there.

#

do better things with your life

outer flint
#

:3

atomic plinth
#

Eh

#

I'd rather work for it

outer flint
#

I don't exactly enjoy farming, I like beating stuff up instead! >:3 but I use the gold scarab and sometimes gold feet so I guess it works out about the same

#

127 frost is very nice

#

but I wonder if it's worth it, the dlc enemies do have a decent amount of hp

#

so even with Ranni's moon, the extra magic damage might not be worth it

atomic plinth
#

God I wish I could like the great katana but it has a moveset REALLY similar to the longsword of Monster Hunter, and the only reason I like longsword is its combos

#

Which the great katana lacks

#

It just feels so

#

Stiff

outer flint
#

i definitely see where you're coming from

stone cove
#

tbh, the stiffness of the weapons in genral is a huge problem for me with the souls series

#

I'd really like them to take milady as a model moving fowar,d and do more flowing and combo-based moveests

#

Like fuck, reduce the number of weapon types if it means the ones that survive THE PURGE get deeper movesets

#

that have more smooth chains between r1/r2s etc

atomic plinth
#

Real

#

We need Bloodborne style weapons

#

Quality over quantity

stone cove
#

also less movesets that involve foolishly smashing your weapon in the ground.

#

Thjere's osme stuff that's just really werid choices to me actually, like the jump attack heavies for Bakchand blades is atrocious

#

Like why are they not being used to land on someone like piericng fangs? Why are you slashing in the air randomly.

#

(You can actually notice a lot of the movesets are totally disconected upper and lower body - your upper body does one thing, your legs do a notehr, its' very silly)

#

@atomic plinth Spoil that shit now.

frozen olive
#

@atomic plinth spoilers

stone cove
#

That is huge endgame spoilers.

#

@dusty kraken Could we get the spoiler in Wamly's post hidden please?

dusty kraken
#

Can't spoiler images for others but I did delete it.

stone cove
#

Thank you

frozen olive
#

thanks

vivid spire
#

Alrighty

#

I think I’ll play a bit more today

stone cove
#

You can doo eeet scrble

#

MURDER THEM ALL

#

EAT THE RUNES

#

FEAST ON THE SOULS

vivid spire
#

Need to kill the runebear

stone cove
#

DANCE THE DANCE OF THE RATS

#

@vivid spire ||You know there's larval tears all over the dlc, right?||

stone cove
#

Nooo?

vivid spire
#

I got them all iirc

stone cove
#

there's WAY more than 4.

vivid spire
#

Wait what

#

I DONT NEED TO KILL THE RUNEBEAR!?

stone cove
#

||Prospect town, scorched ruins, Supressing pillar, Church of the Crusade, Abadoned AIling Village, Rabbath's Rise, Messmer Army encap, and x2 in Rauh Base area||

atomic plinth
#

sorry

stone cove
#

looks like there's 17 in the base gmae and another 9 in the dlc.

vivid spire
#

Bless ya

#

I feel motivated once more

stone cove
#

also wrt to Rune Bear: they're weak to sleep, anyhting like Unseathe/impaling thrust etc does a nubmer on them, and bleed/slash damage always fucks them up

vivid spire
#

I don’t have the funny sleep sword yet

stone cove
#

You can just use the base game sleep sword?

#

Or throw sleep pots.

vivid spire
#

Oh

stone cove
#

Eternal sleep just puts them to sleep forever

#

Normal sleep will still open em up for a crit

vivid spire
#

Concept: Ranni can change her body type at will. Dollmaxxing

vivid spire
#

I think I’ll do dex faith, primarily melee

#

And level to 200

stone cove
#

That's what my lass is at currently

vivid spire
#

I have more fun with dex faith

stone cove
#

Her stats are offhand.. 60 vit, 30 mind, 25 end, 80 dex, 60 faith

#

tbh, i could cut faith down to go for 99 dex if i really wanted

#

but also i like throwing some of the various DLC spells

#

and having the Spherical Dunk (Name obscured for prupsoes of spoilers) in my backpocket

#

Highly reocmmend farming the Curseblade's mask if you go dex, as a headpiece that gives you 5 dex is crazy good

#

even at 80 dex, getting ot 85 is still a nice upgrade in AR (Realstically i'd get more out of the Divine Beast helm, but also, fashion)

#

and Keen Milady with Electric weapon on it is some mean bullshit - 600ish physical ar and an extra 210 lighting

#

579/587 ar (1h vs 2h)

#

and Milady's moveset is so good for Dex/Faith builds

vivid spire
#

What level are you?

#

And are there any good dlc farming spots

#

For runes

stone cove
#

I am level 200

outer flint
#

there are so many cool knights and stuff cat_wow

stone cove
#

Good rune spots: RIught outside castle ennis is great.

#

The messmer soliders drop all kinds of good stuff and are very frutful, plus you can throw down summons

outer flint
#

I want to do runs with their armor and weapons

stone cove
#

Belrut is very good if you go on a tear, as the Big cleaver horsnet drop al ot of runes, and the little guys drop Silver Horn Tenders

#

(ugpraded silver fowl feet)

outer flint
#

does ||rellana|| (early ish dlc boss) have a summoning pool somewhere

outer flint
stone cove
#

And they drop them at a pretty high rate

outer flint
#

oh do both the tenders have greater effects than the feet?

stone cove
#

like you can with 7 arcane, equip the silver scard, pop a silver tender, and usually get it back and several others

outer flint
stone cove
#

Yeah, they're 10% more.

outer flint
#

ooh

stone cove
#

it's not worth farming for the Gold Tenders though as they're still bugged last i checked - item drop buffs do not increase the drop rate of them

#

which is very silly.

vivid spire
#

i wanna give messmer chocolate and a kissy

outer flint
#

the gold ones don't seem to be craftable either

#

😔

stone cove
#

Neither hte gold nor silver ones are craftable

#

but they drop at such a good rate (When the item drop works...)

outer flint
#

i guess i'll go hunt some penguins sometime if i'm bored goofeline

stone cove
#

Even without het item drop buff, just running north of scorched ruins to the little crew of inqustiors (Where you pickup the backhand blades)

#

i got a gold horn every 1-2 runs

outer flint
#

ooooh

#

yeah that could be chill while waiting for summons

stone cove
#

1-3* runs is probablym ore accuate

outer flint
stone cove
#

I thogut htere was one

outer flint
#

oop

stone cove
#

but i have just stomped her every time solo

#

so ???

outer flint
#

I didn't see one near the door anywhere 😔 ah well

stone cove
#

I've def been summoned to fight her

#

She's such a fun fight to do solo though

#

eps with milady, because you can jump all her shit and stab her good

outer flint
#

did you use a sign or the effigy?

stone cove
#

I put my sign down

#

This was a pretty messy fight vs her

outer flint
#

3.1k holy moly

#

||YOU CAN JUMP SLASH 5??||

stone cove
#

You can jump a lot of stuff >.>

#

I think that case it's les i jumped it and more my hitbox was to the side

outer flint
#

i see

#

||does the hippo do physical then phys+holy in p2?||

#

I am getting shredded...

#

boss spoilies ^

frail sky
#

He does yeah

vivid spire
atomic marsh
#

Yknow bte

#

Btw

#

Considering Trinas flowers

#

||How likely is she was the first thing Miquella sacrificed?||

grave plinth
#

very since she's also his restraint

vivid spire
#

LARVAL TEAR GOT

vivid spire
#

Also

#

I got 60 poise as a medium load build

outer flint
#

I should grab the silver scarab

frail sky
#

I wonder why the silver scarab is so far into the game

vivid spire
#

noooopo

#

FUUUUUUCK

#

GOD DAMMIT

#

I was so close but the flashes gave me a headache

#

this Chad parried EVERYTHING

#

I'll never see him again I don't think knowing the summon system

icy creek
#

Just came back after a long break... did light greatswords get... better? Am I reading that right? They were already insane.

kind garden
#

they do more poise damage now

#

so you're more likely to interrupt stuff

vivid spire
#

Oh my fucking god

#

I died in the first second

#

):

#

Today I'll beat him

#

I won't have any time next week

#

I must beat him mow

#

):

#

Are some of his attacks one hit kills?

icy creek
#

Yes if your vitality is low enough

vivid spire
#

60 vitality

#

I'm blocking too

icy creek
#

You should be fine then

vivid spire
#

I keep dying constantly

#

And my attacks barely seem to scratch with a scaled and fully upgraded milady

icy creek
#

Some of his attacks can kill you but they're multiple attacks back to back. Which isn't normally what people mean by one hit kill.

icy creek
vivid spire
#

Wing stance keen scaling

kind garden
#

I only know of two one-hit-kills on that boss

vivid spire
#

This is the closest I got and it's because the dude I played with parried every single attack and stabbed

kind garden
#

||the orbital strike, and the Starcaller combo||

icy creek
#

My strategy is always to get him off guard and to use frostbite.

vivid spire
#

I see

median rock
vivid spire
#

I'm doing black flame

#

How long did it take y'all

icy creek
#

Oh I still haven't beaten him lmfao

vivid spire
#

I wanna discuss the story in full I can't because the boss isn't dead

#

Ok after four deaths the fun vanished

#

Im clearly not ready for the boss even at 178

#

I should just do a meta cheese build or something

median rock
#

if you just want a guaranteed kill, "fuck my build I just want death", try ||a high guard boost shield (fingerprint or verdigris), heavy armor (bullgoat or solitude or something), and blood/frost antspur rapier. he's weakish to rot still. throw on phys def/holy def talismans. respec into high str n endurance and upgrade things so you can shrug off pretty much everything and he'll die relatively quickly with enough shield rapier pokes||

warped quest
# vivid spire

||i will warn that this boss gives massive and i mean massive health increases with npc/player summons||

median rock
#

||you can try to optimize for like, specific armor to resist slash or holy or whatever but you really don't need to. the important part is a high guard boost and preferably 100% phys block shield, with decent holy resist, and the ability to shield poke for bleed procs||

#

||golden vow or ironjar or something for def buffs if you're still struggling||

warped quest
#

||100k hp at two summons doulbing his hp||

vivid spire
#

Jesus Christ

#

I ought to just

#

Do it solo

median rock
#

all NPC or pc summons are +60% each

vivid spire
#

It's been weeks and people are already done with the dlc

median rock
#

spirits ashes don't give the boss any hp bonus

#

so yeah large hp pool bosses will benefit a little more practically speaking tbh

vivid spire
#

It's just

#

When I do solo I get overwhelmed

median rock
#

yeah that's fair

#

||this boss in particular has decent combo strings let alone the bullshit that is the second phase rave||

#

||fuck the second phase rave all my homies hate blonde twinks with light magic||

vivid spire
#

Idk I just

#

I feel like if I don't beat him now

#

I'll stop playing

#

And if I come back

#

I'll be so rustu

median rock
#

there is no shame in changing your build to beat specific bosses tbf

vivid spire
#

I went back to something I thought would work

#

50 dex is good right

#

It's 50 dex 60 faith

warped quest
#

what arey ou using the fiath for?

vivid spire
#

Incantations

icy creek
#

Remembering when I died to Malenia 200+ times, and this dude is supposed to be even harder.

vivid spire
#

I took a break right before the perfume exploit was nerfed

#

Now my only chance lies with a dex antspur build

median rock
#

||do you have the str or endurance to spare for a high guard boost greatshield?||

vivid spire
#

No

median rock
#

||at lvl 178 you have like 160 points tho so im assuming that's 50 vigor 50 dex 60 faith?||

vivid spire
#

I have 17 str

#

25 end

median rock
#

damn

median rock
#

try a med shield even maybe. the shield poke animation is a little faster for building shit like bleed/rot

#

like it's faster attacks than just r1 for the stamina costs iirc

proven cloak
#

||Sacrificing doubts seems like something you'd want to do early - and if Trina disagreed with Miquella about seeking the gate, he'd want to divest her early||

#

||We enter at the gravesite planes, but its possible Miquella came ashore||

outer flint
#

very strange

vivid spire
covert schooner
#

Yeah I ended up picking away at him with the sword spear

#

From behind the fingerprint

warped quest
covert schooner
#

would def change out the fire talisman for a holy one

warped quest
#

thats lightning i think

median rock
#

no that's holy

#

lightning is just a little brighter yellow

warped quest
#

also you should be able to get the upgraded holy amulet

vivid spire
median rock
#

there is ||an upgraded holy prot talisman + an upgraded stamina regen talisman in DLC, if you would like to track them down||

vivid spire
#

I decided to grab the death knight armor

#

Because it looks cool

warped quest
#

oh i see

#

i thought this was you fighting the final

median rock
#

||turtle is in the bottom of the river iirc in a cave and the upgraded holy is a braid, and it's in shaman village (near the gaius entrance, behind a secret passage)||

#

scrble, if you want, i have a final boss bleed antspur shield build on a mule character i just tested - but i'm not sure how aggressively this will get downscaled when it's at lvl 287 to your 178. lmk if you want to give coop a shot?

#

(the answer is obviously very aggressively scaled, but i don't need hp, i'm more concerned about max stamina being downgraded? i don't remember if ER does that - i know older games don't but i think it migth)

vivid spire
#

I’m on Xbox

median rock
#

ah, rip

warped quest
#

yeah deathknight is cool but sadly if i recall very weak to holy

median rock
#

honestly if you just want that mf dead you might be best off farming 20 golden fowl foots off the birds at impassable greatbridge + that pond in altus (for materials), getting sacred relic sword, and brain-off farming albinaurics until you can overlevel the shit out of him or something

#

throw on a youtube video essay about why dlc final boss is horrible game design n zone out for 4 hours straight

covert schooner
#

nah overleveling doesnt work

#

p sure the dlc has level scaling

median rock
#

in this case, i think scrble is out of larval tears

#

so i mostly meant getting the levels to greatshield cheese

covert schooner
#

oh

#

youve used all 20?

median rock
#

yeah lol which is an insane statement to me but i respect it

outer flint
#

do fowl feet/tenders' effects wear off when resting at a bonfire?

median rock
#

no

outer flint
median rock
#

i'm pretty sure the best farm is still mohgwyn palace approach, sacred relic sword the albinaurics

outer flint
#

does the buff timer (also all buff timers in general) wear down while resting?

median rock
#

yes, but it's quick enough to rest + stand back up

#

DLC has some really high rune drops but i dont think it beats the <20 second loop you can get while keeping your golden foot active in moghwyn palac e

#

the bird isn't even worth it because its only like 3 albinaurics worth for +5 seconds lining up a shot

vivid spire
#

Not dlc though

median rock
#

oh yeah it does add a couple

warped quest
#

you need to plan when you use tears up

#

like you need to justfiy every thing

median rock
#

also if you're trying to hardcore farm, fill up your group pswds with random popular ones

warped quest
#

not just throw rando mstuff

median rock
#

like vaati's, the fextra one, the reddit one, etc. just google a list

warped quest
#

like why 60 faith what incatantions specifcily do you need 60 for

median rock
#

you get a mini rune boost when anybody in a group kills a shardbearer or becomes elden lord

outer flint
#

what does it mean when someone has become a Lord

#

instead of Elden Lord

median rock
#

the ones i remember off the top of my head are SEEKERS (vaati), FEXTRA (fextra), straydmn for r/eldenring and btf for r/beyondthefog (the co-op subreddit for ppl to request help, mostly exists because its really hard to get co-op for certain bosses in older games)

#

oh it just means elden lord

outer flint
#

o

median rock
#

the msg just doesnt say "has become elden lord" it just says "has become a Lord"

#

i think in-game characters use both interchangeably as well

vivid spire
#

I finally got through the weird eye catacombs

#

Got the long haft ace

#

Through lore deductions I humbly state

#

The Death Knight set is closest to a fia simp set

#

“Armor of the PERSONAL BODYGUARDS of Godwyn and his surrogate corpse”

#

I’m onto something

median rock
#

yeah i'll guard his body 😏 ---- Fia

vivid spire
#

Death polycule

proven cloak
outer flint
#

i'm so tired

#

😔

median rock
#

i thougth it was like 5

proven cloak
#

dlc adds 9

#

but you can only find them at night

#

so you'll prob only run into a couple

atomic plinth
#

These gauntlets look decent enough, or should I swap to something else?

vivid spire
#

I like it

median rock
#

"Larval Tears in the Realm of Shadow can be found in the middle of a ring of glowing gravestones that glow blue. These locations and the Larval Tears within only appear during nighttime." what

#

thats wild

obtuse halo
#

yeeeep

frail sky
#

I think it's mentioned somewhere in the game, but I'm not sure where

atomic plinth
#

Is there any point in light rolling over medium rolling?

obtuse halo
#

more roll distance

median rock
#

slightly better frames, more roll distance

obtuse halo
#

this can be huge whether you're trying to space attacks or rolling through them (when rolling through, your hitboxes move further over a given length of time so you're that much more likely to clear the hurtbox before losing i-frames)

#

it doesn't technically improve your frames, the animation is the same length with the same i-frames

median rock
#

note that the roll distance is a sidegrade - it's not really better or worse, since it's really annoying when dodging certain attacks if you're used to medium

#

doesn't it come out faster?

obtuse halo
#

don't think so

median rock
#

huh

obtuse halo
#

that said I'm a lightroll addict

median rock
#

i meant like framedata in general when i said better but maybe im just running on weirdly debunked info

obtuse halo
#

midrolling feels awkward to me now

atomic plinth
#

Right

covert schooner
#

wait it doesnt have better frame data?????

warped quest
#

what is the point of lightroll

median rock
#

distance lets u space things really good if you know how to use it, i guess. i know it makes waterfowl really easy (for me at least)

#

but idk i keep rolling into things like an idiot even after a full playthrough w it

lilac condor
#

it would be really cool if light roll was a bloodborne style dash

median rock
#

now that's only remembered by the bones of the dead 😔

obtuse halo
#

the distance still matters imo

#

there's a reason I keep bow-only to lightroll

#

again, even without technically having a frame data advantage, the increased distance over the same number of frames lets your hitbox get through things you can't midroll through, or at least with easier timing

atomic plinth
#

||...you can stagger Putrescent Knight out of his phase 2 attack???||

obtuse halo
#

Like how a greater horizontal speed on your jump will let you cross bigger gaps even if it's not technically a higher jump

kind garden
#

a lot of moves can be staggered but have outrageous requirements

proven cloak
#

oh there was a patch?

#

bug fixes only

#

well

#

good news at least

median rock
#

yeah it was a super small patch w some minor bug fixes only

covert schooner
#

would balance changes be bad news?

proven cloak
#

no I love things getting nerfed and other things buffed

#

😇

#

But bug fixes are never bad

old brook
#

For me lightrolling in bossfights feels better because like.. unless my armor is wild, or the boss is tiny

#

the 'sit around 51 poise' thing rarely brings up

#

I could be 5% less dead in three hits or I can dodge far enough to not get nuked by some sort of ____flame explosion

proven cloak
#

I pretty much only midroll

outer flint
#

I've only ever seriously midrolled, I've light rolled for some overworld exploration for funsies

#

maybe I'll try light roll on some bosses

stoic sleet
#

I like having armor

outer flint
#

yeah!

#

I look cool

#

😌

stoic sleet
#

I would probably heavy roll if it weren't so bad tbh

#

Pretty universally my playstyle in games tends to be "I'm not good enough to avoid getting hit so I'm gonna try and make getting hit be as little of a problem as possible

#

...and then I main Switch Axe in MonHun

old brook
#

There's too much nice fashion in the lower weight tiers but getting light roll is such a pain

#

Kind of weird but understandable that like

#

the stat that helps you get there is also the one that'll let you wear enormous armor

#

Idk, make dex give you an easier threshhold for light %, not more carry weight just don't need to be soooo underweight

outer flint
old brook
#

oh uhm, well it really depends on the vibe you're goin' for with your character it's primarily aesthetics at that kinda weight

outer flint
#

ah gotcha

#

i'll go looking through my pocket dimension

old brook
#

Crimson/Navy hoods are solid all-rounders that look nice and give a freebie stat, plus their capes have like three different positions depending on whatcha wear

outer flint
#

yess I love those hoods

#

I used the crimson one for most of my playthrough, then switched to the navy one when I respecced to int

stone cove
#

i'm in nearly super heavy armor (Full radahns except for the head), and i'm still zooping wooping around the place

outer flint
#

ooh true!

obtuse halo
#

here's archer lady's pre-dlc fashion

outer flint
#

whoaaa!

#

i like that a lot 😌

obtuse halo
#

(Crimson Hood, Traveler's Manchettes, Rotten Gravekeeper Cloak (Altered), Nox Greaves. Plus the Black Bow.)

#

I added an alternative look in the DLC, and here's them side by side lol

#

Gravekeeper Cloak actually comes in both red and beige!

outer flint
#

I can use this to tank more in co-op...

obtuse halo
#

Yeah this is actually part of the strat with bow-only

#

I do allow myself spirit ashes but only if they're archers, and adding Woe helps a lot with keeping heat off of them

#

I am significantly better at dodging than most summons and spirit ashes are

outer flint
obtuse halo
#

it was a particularly key element to bow-only Malenia because it's how I kept her from eating Ogha for free heals lol

outer flint
#

LOL

#

😭

stone cove
#

Ogha, you're a chump man 😦

#

Actualyl he's really good until the boss can get past his posture brekaing or out aggress him, then he eats shit

atomic plinth
#

Y'all know any gloves/pants that go well with the Fingerprint chest armor?

obtuse halo
#

I’ve found Ogha to be a pretty damn solid summon tbh

#

You’re right that he’ll have a bad time in a heartbeat if a boss starts focusing him though

#

He’s damn solid if you can hold aggro and unlike Latenna he can actually hold his own somewhat in melee

#

I don’t think I could have managed Those United in Common Cause bow-only without him

old brook
#

Scaled Greaves sort of fit but they're offcolor..

#

A lot of the Knight legs are like 10x shinier so it's awkward >:|a

#

Mausoleum Soldier legs might work

stone cove
#

Has the horned warriro curved sword moveset, plus he likes to fly off and rain feathery doom on people

obtuse halo
#

Something that I haven't checked but might work is Blue Silver Mail pieces - they tend to run into a similar problem of not matching with things due to being off-color with most of the game's metal

#

I've heard good things about ornis but haven't checked that one out

#

Divine Birds are so un-scary compared to Horned Warriors or Divine Beast Warriors ingame that I just kind of assumed he'd be a pushover lol

stone cove
#

if you get the hang of parrying, Horned Warriors become pushovers osmehwat

#

They telegraph pretty well and then you can punk em

atomic plinth
#

20 points of AR in exchange for frost buildup is a good trade, right?

obtuse halo
#

I mean, I killed a bunch of them bow-only, they're not 2hard5me or anything

#

they're just vastly more dangerous in my experience than divine bird warriors, which look like they'd be in the same weight class

atomic plinth
atomic plinth
obtuse halo
#

Cold is very frequently better than magic for infusions

old brook
#

||Ornis|| feels like summoning your own Boss Enemy it's great

obtuse halo
#

20 AR isn't nothing but if you're hitting enough to proc cold, yeah it's probably better

atomic plinth
#

Aye, aye

#

And it's a difference between 813 per greatsword and 833

#

Which is not particularly huge tbh

median rock
#

lmao yeah that feels very in favor of cold

#

what's the frost buildup?

obtuse halo
#

oh yeah lol who cares when AR's that high

#

20 really is nothing at that level

#

if you were still lowish level and we were talking 180 vs 200 or something that's at least worthy of note

#

like, 20 AR on a bow matters because you really need every ounce you can get 😛

outer flint
#

got a huge slab of a ultra greatsword 😌

obtuse halo
#

yeah at that point you'll notice a once-per-fight cold proc more than 20 AR

atomic plinth
#

Identical stats for each sword, the other just has Carian Sovreignity

median rock
#

i mean the frost proc makes up for itself w the 20% extra damage lol

atomic plinth
#

Aye

#

...goddamn, yeah, that frost buildup is NOTICEABLE

outer flint
#

ikr

#

127 is a LOT

#

it's what i have on my great katana >:3

atomic plinth
#

||Wish that Putrescence Knight coop summons got teleported right into the arena||

covert schooner
#

The Alliance of Night and Flame began with Rauh and the Smithing culture, who evolved into the Astrologers and Fire Giants. Rauh originated the idea of the “wisdom beyond stone”, the technology underlying the golems. The Astrologer’s conceptualization of the primeval current originated with Rauh. Their culture was responsible not only for contro...

▶ Play video
#

Some REALLY interesting timeline stuff here that also reminds me of the ruins that are all over the fucking place that are probably Ruah

atomic plinth
#

Oh?

covert schooner
#

like snow valley and seaside

#

theres implications through there that ruah: made the golems, and were the oldest empire in the setting

#

so old weve lost much knowledge about them

atomic plinth
#

Oh that is juicy

proven cloak
#

I've been thinking about the Astrologers and da Fingees recently

covert schooner
proven cloak
#

||given the Manus Cathedral(s) + star interest, with Metyr as the first star to hit the Lands Between||

#

esp with ||fingercreepers|| being really common in the mountaintops

proven cloak
atomic plinth
#

Like "Oh, yeah, I guess y'all live nearby. Cool."

covert schooner
#

so the empire timeline seems like
Fire Giants, Ruah, Dragons

Ruah falls for reasons we dont understand, dragons become rulers of lands between and a ton of architecture is created by them like the divine towers which have the exact same architecture as farum azula

Marika rises, Farum Azula splits off probably because of civil war. Golden order does its shit

current state of the world

#

oh no

#

why would that be what i wanted discord

proven cloak
#

theres a period where the Ice Dragons are pushed out by the Fire Giants

#

in the mountaintops

#

and those dragons were drakes, given Borealis

covert schooner
#

probab.y part of the civil war causing the dragon empire to fall

proven cloak
#

so ||Bayle must've already been around? before Fire Giants in the North?||

#

so...

#

I think Ruah -> Dragons -> Fire Giants?

#

with Astrologers and Hornsent contemporary?

#
A smaller imitation of the furnace golem's visage. Material used for crafting items. Exceedingly rare to find. A stone mask surrounded by curled horns, depicting the fell god of fire that haunts the sagas of the hornsent.
#

or maybe Fire Giants slightly before Hornsent, but still around until Marika gets Funky™️

covert schooner
#

no ruah and the fire giants are at least partially contemporary
the forge of ruin is in ruah style

proven cloak
#

and the Ruined forges seem really old too

#

hmmm

covert schooner
#

so maybe were contemporary before they drove out the dragons

proven cloak
#

I've been thinking of the Fire Giants as a split from the Ruah culture

#

after it fell

covert schooner
#

thats also possible

proven cloak
#

like how Caria descends from the Astrologers and the Nox, but is its own thing

covert schooner
#

this video also suggests carian astrologers, the ones on the mountain, are also ruah

#

i woulld watch the video, its crazy

#

i love it

#

I love mostly that like

#

we dont know a bunch of shit

#

this was all before the elden ring

#

so who knows what it was about

lilac condor
#

Don’t some of the item descriptions talk about an ancient smithing cult? It could be the forges are an early iteration of that

covert schooner
#

that seems likely

#

i love that the land of shadow LITERALLY fills in the missing pieces of history

#

and also paints marika as a brutal historical revisionist!

kind garden
#

hmm

#

the Lands of Shadow seem to bridge the Carian - Mountaintop divide

#

so I guess that explains how the astrologers and giants were once neighbours

covert schooner
#

mhmhmh

#

also

#

sidenote

#

i think it's possible that farum azula once rested inside of teh big dragon mountain from the dlc

proven cloak
#

yeah

#

Troll Hammer, I think?
and the new smithscript items + talisman

kind garden
#

considering the way that the dragon mountain is shaped with the indentations and stuff

#

yeah

proven cloak
#

the really interesting thing about the smithing cult imo

lilac condor
#

There’s also the astrologers ruins on the mountaintops

proven cloak
#

is that its said to "imbue weapons with souls", and you can see runes written along the talisman really prominently

lilac condor
#

And our jellyfish summons meets with her sister there to see the stars

covert schooner
#

Yknow this actually does really give hope for

#

The age of stars

proven cloak
#

I'm curious why the Crucible's touch was so strong in the Lands of Shadow

covert schooner
#

The world existed without the elden ring before

#

And functioned fine

#

It will do so again

proven cloak
#

it cant just be that Marika sealed it away with the unwanted essence, cause Ruah and the Hornsent show its influence is old

grave plinth
#

The Ruined Forge civilization might have been the ancestors of the misbegotten

covert schooner
#

i think the light of the erdtree [probably

#

to user dramatic langauge

grave plinth
#

Since Misbegotten are found around two of them

covert schooner
#

burns away stuff like the crucible

#

so in a land without that light

#

it never lost that link

covert schooner
grave plinth
#

Hewg might actually have worked at those smithscript forges

#

Marika as well given her use of a hammer and anvil

proven cloak
#

if the smithing cult was using Runes, does that imply Elden influence?

covert schooner
#

thats fair!

proven cloak
#

Do runes predate the Elden Ring, or postdate it?

proven cloak
grave plinth
#

The Ring might be omnipresent, just the Great Runes that comprise it are currently in the Lands Between

covert schooner
#

its also possible that the elden ring itself is not actually the greater wills real gift? like it might just be a part of the world

#

marika revising history to make her religion the one that gave the world the laws of physicws makes sense

#

and the longer we look at it, the less sense it makes that the greater will was always in control

grave plinth
#

Its also debatable if Marika is really blessed by the Greater Will

proven cloak
#

I'd think the opposite, given ||Ymir echoing Hyetta's words about the GW creating life itself||, and ||How early Metyr is in the timeline||

grave plinth
#

According to the admittedly untrustworthy Count Ymir, the Greater Will peaced out long before the Shattering

proven cloak
#

||she had to arrive before any Meteoric builds, including the divine towers golden ore, or the Meteoric Greatsword of the 'old gods'||

grave plinth
#

If its even truly self aware to begin with

covert schooner
#

||but why would the greater will even need agents like metyr, why would metyr make as warlock or a vassal out of marika, if it was always the true creator of all||

#

it just doesnt make sense to me

proven cloak
#

||Imo, she was seeking Empyreans (or the Fingers were) for the same reason many other characters latch onto symbols - as a surrogate.||

#

||The GW needing agents... idk. Need might not be the word, but it might just... create life by nature, or choice. You can pretty much replace all mentions of the Greater Will with "The Cosmos" and the meaning is the exact same.||

covert schooner
#

regardless my point was more that the world will survive the age of stars

#

this much is clear

proven cloak
#

oh probably

#

though!

covert schooner
#

it has survived upheavels before

proven cloak
#

theres quite a bit of evidence to suggest ||Darkness and Stars are the nature of the GW, too||

#

someone on one of the reddits noted something about the translations

#

||In that all the space ones use the same phrasing, and that phrasing is directly connected to the Greater Will in a few places.||

#

idk implications of this

#

I've been thinkin' about it since the dlc dropped

covert schooner
#

yeah idk that stuff

#

i mostly believe that ranni is smarter than me

proven cloak
#

lmao true

covert schooner
#

and she seems to think the greater will is something that CAN be warded off

proven cloak
#

well she doesn't like the fingers - but she never mentions the GW

covert schooner
#

oh fair enough i guess

proven cloak
#

I do think its kind of darkly ironic that she slays a finger

#

and it looks like the Carians used to have a pretty prominent Finger Cult

#

Age of Stars might still be against whatever the GW wanted, if it did truly send the Elden Beast to the Lands

#

||but I think its been gone or uncaring for a long, long time||

warped quest
#

i always saw the ages of stars as the erasing of god influence

proven cloak
#

I see it as a veiling of divinity

#

forces will still exist, but distant - unknowable

#

influencing your life, but not in a way that bends things around them