#Jenna Moran Games (Nobilis, Chuubo's, Glitch, WTF)

1 messages · Page 32 of 1

vivid wraith
#

ideal

narrow tartan
#

I might get a hat made.

vivid wraith
narrow tartan
#

I keep thinking. Strategist who somehow finds a mortal roomate who somehow has worse life skills

obsidian dagger
#

Trying to figure out what arc it would be if you're in a world where people genuinely have special psychic (or ki, or magic, or whatever) powers, and every major character in the setting uses those powers, but you are firmly convinced those powers are completely fake and not real and don't exist and whenever someone else uses them they're just faking it. And because you think they're fake, you're totally unafraid and actually sometimes beat them in ways.

#

Creature of Fable, probably. You get to Cut the Soul to do away with troublesome evidence of those powers being real.

narrow tartan
#

I once. Spent a bunch of time brainstorming an overcomplicated way for a strategist to just. Like. Bring a city into tje world.

#

Or add a bridge

#

Basically.

#

A gift based on Greater Casting to make dimensions inside of a notebook

#

Something that let ypu draw in the notebook and have that drawing fill a dimension in the notebook

#

And a gift based on Greater Trust to pull stuff out of the notebook

#

11-5-1-1+1=5
11-3-1-1+1=7
11-5-1-3+1=3

#

So fifteen points.

#

Or seventeen if you want pulling stuff in and out of the notebook to be free.

#

Or nineteen if you want it to be free and consider "in and out" to be too flexible for "a single trick"

#

I imagined this would be a Strategist who was mostly a REMF in the war

patent tiger
#

Me tbh

restive ridge
vivid wraith
#

Thanks lord entropy

obsidian dagger
#

Thinking about how often "conspicuously keeping a secret For Their Own Good" is a Wicked Action.

narrow tartan
#

'turn back turn back'

magic mason
#

Assigning Every Deadlock Charecter A Chuubo's Marvelous Wish Granting Engine Arc

Abrahams: Wounded Angel
Apollo: Ace
Bebop: Either Gatecrasher or Become Somebody, something Actual Coded like that
Billy: I Have No Idea Please Help
Calico: Troubled
Celeste: also Troubled I think
Doorman: either Creature Of The Light or Awakening, not sure which
Dynamo: Child Of The Ash
Drifter: Indomitable
Graves: Either Wounded or Gatekeeper depending on how you see the Lich
Grey Talon: Allegory I think
Haze: Creature Of Fable
Infernus: Troubled
Holliday: I also wanna say troubled
Ivy: Weirdly difficult, I almost wanna say Reality Syndrome?
Kelvin: Spiritual
Lady Geist: Gonna say Star Quality actually
Lash: Allegory
Mcginnis: Fulcrum Tech flavored Flore?
Mina: Gatecrasher
Mirage: Chained Prophet
Mo and Krill: No Idea
Paige: Adept, she even has a weird extant enemy
Paradox: Awakening(playing as all of Paradox)
Pocket: Unironically might be accursed, other stuff is a magical skill but pocket is a strategist
Rem: Something green, probably World Walker? Vastness rem would work but has nothing in the source material
Seven: Spiritual or Child Of The Ash but like... the green fortitude pc flavor?
Shiv: Troubled again I think
Silver: I think she is more of an indomitable werewolf than a Child Of The Ash werewolf
Sinclair: Reality Syndrome
Venator: Prophet, not sure what of, but I think it fits him better than a yellow
Victor: Become Somebody
Vindicta: Allegory
Viscous: Primordial, and I will stick with this one
Vyper: Troubled, lots of troubled in this roster
Warden: Flore, in a botanist way
Wraith: Architect I think
Yamato: Adept

#

Update: Billy Is Accursed, but like low level accursed

candid compass
#

Bebop is Gatecrasher I think
Into the secret world of pit fighters

magic mason
#

Yeah tht tracks

restive ridge
#

Thank you Fluffy

magic mason
#

ur welcome

#

Anyone got contests here?

#

or ideas for what Mo and Krill

narrow tartan
#

Thas a lot of characters

magic mason
frank light
magic mason
frank light
#

I wanna argue that Ivy has spiritual

#

She has plant powers

candid compass
#

I also argued for Vastness Ivy to fluffy

frank light
#

Also no haze has ace

#

That’s my argument

#

Her invisibility? Technique.
Gun skills? Technique
Knife? Technique

#

Girl is competent in everything

#

Not only that, her best stories would be gold arcs

magic mason
frank light
#

Her getting forced to get into social situations is perfect for her

magic mason
#

I think I was in the red dimension because I was focused on the whole Dream thing

#

I suppose she could have a magical/superior skill about it

candid compass
#

It could also be a stored Technique or something

#

That one Aspect miracle that lets you learn a specific trick

frank light
#

Or a superior skill yeah

#

Cus she could just have superior dreamer or superior sandman

narrow tartan
#

I should have ideas

#

Glitch. Is interesting, just. Strategists are apocalyptic threats. But they do see something worth valuing even if the world stands in the way

narrow tartan
#

My enemy list includes.
-time
-the sun

fleet harbor
#

-wasps

vestal mist
#

-capsaicin

narrow tartan
#

The Game loves Gender reveals

#

Or does the rule? Or do they both

#

No definitely the game

#

But. Maybe it was the Rules idea that the game ruined?

#

I dont know. I am really bad about conceptualizing the rule

obsidian dagger
#

The Rule wants stability. Progress should be measured and incremental, always one step in front of another on a well-paved path. Everything is orchestrated. Everything is perfectly planned.

#

The only reason it does not want to perfectly preserve all of humanity exactly as it is right now is because if that happened, it would intrinsically change humanity, because the nature of humanity is to grow and change and one day die.

vivid wraith
narrow tartan
#

Dying of a speck in your eye

magic mason
restive ridge
#

NOBLE THAT FOUGHT A STRATEGIST: God it's so good to see you again. It's been so long

FUJOSHI IMPERATOR: How was it...

narrow tartan
#

Hmm. It is interesting. Strategists are valid. Like. They experience. Hostility from the world. And it is real to them.

#

Just. I havent seen the minecraft movie. But. I think there is a theme of running from the world/escapism.

patent tiger
#

It’s an interesting little conceptual tangle

narrow tartan
#

Physical essence of divinity

obsidian dagger
vivid wraith
gloomy oasis
narrow tartan
#

I am wrong. But.

#

I think. Thing I thought up

#

I al proud of

#

"The Dark is humanities shadow but the Light in turn is our reflection."

grand knot
#

I wonder what arcs the characters from project moon would have
Each sephirah had an arc about resolving a problem related to a lesson/virtue, then in the sequel help Roland and Angela with these lessons

obsidian dagger
#

I have not finished Lobotomy Corporation but I could definitely see... most of the Sephirot, if maybe not all of them... getting True God arcs?

#

They definitely like Creature of the Ash, and not just for kaiju mode. They also appreciate the ability to go Wicked Mode. And a lot of them engage in Wicked Actions reasonably frequently (I'm thinking of Netzach and Chesed primarily, I think?) There's an argument they wouldn't mind something Blue (especially looking at Yesod) but I think that could be a Wicked Action too. They also Suffer Transformation and Suffer Sickness reasonably frequently.

#

And ||their meltodown forms frequently have many limbs in a way which tonally fits being Primordial||.

#

They could also definitely be Called Away. And Awakening would not be wrong, especially when you look at Tiphereth.

#

The alternative would be something Blue. There is certainly an argument for Wounded Angel. And I don't remember all the details, but some of the later ones would not dislike being mimics (||Geburah|| and ||Binah|| in particular, who are also very mechanically different).

vivid wraith
vivid wraith
grand knot
obsidian dagger
#

Random thought bouncing around in my head about how nothing is like anything else and metaphor is violence

gloomy oasis
obsidian dagger
#

This is Principal Entropy II I think.

#

oh I was too slow on it and didn't see it was already posted here. My bad.

narrow tartan
#

What if... You gave a strategist a powerful gift. Then intentionally never used it because you were laying low?

#

Like. "Yeah I have this immortal flame stolen from heaven. I could twist it into an abhorrent weapon... But that goes against the not ending the world thing"

#

"And if I kept using it to twist mortals into undying abominations capable of fighting Nobles people might complain"

narrow tartan
#

Strategist using a Purify gift to skip showering. And laundry day

#

*discovers Glitch doesnt include purify"

vivid wraith
#

uhhhh limited Unfettering gift or something

narrow tartan
#

That. Doesnt srrm right

candid compass
#

There are no downsides to this clearly

restive ridge
#

Truth Breaker's Hand

vivid wraith
fleet harbor
#

lol

narrow tartan
#

Magic pixie Game-er girl

obsidian dagger
#

...what's that one book I heard of once where the protagonist can only see the magic girl because he is actively dying of mad cow disease? Because I think that's what you're describing.

#

Manic Pixie Dream Girls might sometimes be Game and might sometimes be Angels honestly.

#

Going Bovine. I haven't read it but I've heard of it.

magic mason
#

https://youtu.be/zyUMk-XiVsA

I really like this as a games magister song

Provided to YouTube by Fueled By Ramen

Fences · Paramore

Riot!

℗ 2007 Atlantic Recording Corporation for the United States and WEA International Inc. for the world outside of the United States. All Rights Reserved.

Bass Guitar: Brian Weaver
Digital Editor: Dan Korneff
Engineer: Dan Korneff
Mixing Engineer: David Bendeth
Percussion, Synthe...

▶ Play video
vivid wraith
magic mason
#

(you aren't allowed in)

vivid wraith
#

heaven is full, and all the goombas are here

obsidian dagger
magic mason
narrow tartan
#

Hmm. Would
Adept have destroy enemy before or after protect from enemy

#

Shield and Blast.
Shield comes first in the Arc. So probably shield?

#

Different than Wyrd

candid compass
#

Shield would still be first probably

narrow tartan
#

Angel with Enemy: Humanity and Adept 7

still blaze
#

This is off topic, but is anyone here a fan of Weather Factory's games like Cultist Simulator and Book of Hours?
I feel like they have a kinda Nobilis vibe somehow

magic mason
#

Little bit yeah!

restive ridge
#

Im a big fan

#

I think Nobilis is way more contemporary and sillier than it

still blaze
#

Definitely true about being more contemporary yeah
Playing BoH now and it's great

restive ridge
#

The Chandler is however 100% from Nobilis tho

still blaze
#

What's that?

restive ridge
#

Certaintly She Who carries fire in darkness; Who leaves a place without entering it; Whose endeavours are profitable.
Definitely romanian.
Most likely trying to write itself into the History retrocausally from the future.
Likely whatever is posessing the current king of Britain.
Probably the God of nuclear bombs.
Possibly a metaphor for capitalism
Mayhaps a remnant of the Egg.

narrow tartan
#

I think they are interesting but wasnt very good with them

still blaze
#

BoH is more chill than CS and more easily approached

narrow tartan
#

I once had a thought related to. Cultists Simulator being contemporary to Chuubos

#

Alternatively.

#

The Lionsmith and the Colonel are a pair of Warmains in a relationship

narrow tartan
#

Would. Angels have any straightforward miracles that serve to make one of them not stick out? I dont think so.

obsidian dagger
#

Angels struggle with that, I think. Rulers are good at it as part of Awakening, though.

vivid wraith
#

I think Aspect is supposed to get a "fit in" miracle in nob4?

narrow tartan
#

nodnod

vivid wraith
#

maybe a weird Fade variant gift? less "you're inconspicuous" and more "you're gone as soon as they notice you"

narrow tartan
#

nodnod

frank light
#

I think because of holy angels generally stick out even when they’re hiding

#

But in the way that like

#

A really cool person might stick out

#

They’ve got odd lightning and cinematography but I think people won’t tend to question it

candid compass
#

since Holy can also let you exit scenes and make it be as if you hadn't been there

narrow tartan
#

Mhmm. Fair.

narrow tartan
#

Honestly. Was. Thinking about the, "Young angel who is maybe supposed to end humanity and ends up going to college"

obsidian dagger
#

Makes me think of a very specific kind of Good Omens fanfiction.

narrow tartan
#

There is also one of the fallen involved...

obsidian dagger
#

Adam Young (from Good Omens, I mean) has some striking similarities to Chuubo in some ways.

narrow tartan
#

Huh. Yeah that is a good comparison

narrow tartan
#

Just remembered. World where time flows backwards. So if you live long enough you become a world war 2 vetran

#

Or maybe bi directionally.

narrow tartan
#

Strategist coding

narrow tartan
#

Sid from Toy Story develops Dementia Anima

narrow tartan
#

Angel attending university gets locked out of the dorm when her roomate closed the window to their room and what is she going to do. Walk in the front door of the dorm like a plebian?? Its not like she has pockets. Where is she gonna keep her keys

#

So. Holy would have Stunt as a Miracle probably related somehow to their Divine Warrant. And their Miraculous Will from Chuubos

vivid wraith
#

pretending Leonardo posted this

magic mason
#

TRUE

obsidian dagger
#

...it suddenly occurs to me that it would probably not be incorrect to write Leonardo as having Actual Realistic Bipolar Syndrome.

narrow tartan
#

I still like my idea that warmains temper people who have a unique relationship with their test

magic mason
#

Far roofs theory: The Real Goblin is that shadow in the goblin roofs and the rotating cast of volcels that compose our impression of the goblin is just how that entity easily affects our reality

obsidian dagger
#

That is very nice but there is also something very funny about Goblin not casting a long metaphysical shadow and just being a horrible little guy who sneaks into your house to use powers

obsidian dagger
#

Hm. I was kicking around ideas for representing a cultivator's Dao in a hypothetical cultivation story as a pState in terms of what could be done with it, and then wrote up hypothetical rules and by the time I realized my mistake I had an entire ruleset which basically treated it as a pSelf and I'm not sure if that ought to be fixed or is fine.

magic mason
#

Persona
Adept
Aspect
Holy

narrow tartan
#

Gamer who is a skinny science guy. Likes to see his creations put to use.

#

Gamer. Who is a friendly old witch lady associated with diabetes.

#

Gamer. Who is Dionysus and wants to get back to his youth when he was trim and fit and maddening to behold

#

Gamer. Who is kind of a Prometheus figura nd annoyingly keeps winning arguments.

obsidian dagger
#

I still wonder if rather than having a pSelf, the Zu just cultivate a Self.

#

...also, I should know this, but: can Deceivers apply their pState properties to themself, or is that a blind spot in their powers?

vivid wraith
#

They can!

frank light
#

yeah easily

#

their miracles for persona work entirely the same

#

you can use miracles on a deceiver after all

vivid wraith
#

their auctoritas can be a nightmare but they're not affected by their own

frank light
#

ye

magic mason
narrow tartan
#

Blehp. Strategist who can Wonderful Life people with their Destruction

vivid wraith
#

I'm enjoying LiEat and its Creature of Delirium protagonist

#

(a lie-eating dragon)

narrow tartan
#

Oh I think ive heard of that

vivid wraith
#

it's cute! sat down expecting a six hour game and it was like a one hour game lol

narrow tartan
#

There are werewolves right?

vivid wraith
#

First part had a "wolf" ||that was a cover story for vampire attacks||

restive ridge
fleet harbor
#

“Sponsored” wat

patent tiger
#

The demiurge would advertise on tumblr I think

fleet harbor
#

That's true

magic mason
# restive ridge

@frank light

Also, not Jennagames but this is The Seers Of The Throne

restive ridge
#

This IS the Seers yes, shit

#

Thank you for the enlightenment

fleet harbor
#

That's true

#

Well, actually. Isn't part of the Seers' whole deal that they have no pretensions whatsoever about being the good guys?

magic mason
#

Some Prelates post like this, but they have exarchitis

#

(Instead of brain there is exarch)

fleet harbor
#

"We are here to cause oppression and misery, and we're all out of nah just kidding we have so much more oppression and misery we can cause."

magic mason
#

(Seriously it’s actually kinda terrifying if you go inside of their dream world they have a exarch ochema instead of a Goetia defending it)

candid compass
#

Some do pretend, some are open about it, to various levels of enthusiasm about that

frank light
narrow tartan
#

Seer of the Throne who embraces Divine Command Theory.

#

Gamer who is an evil moon rabbit and is associated with light pollution

#

Actually no. She would be associated with power outages

obsidian dagger
#

Peculiar request but does anyone know of any songs/music videos which do a good job of depicting Actual infection? I'd call that an overly specific niche but I can already name two of them.

#

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-M1AtrxztU and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F90Cw4l-8NY are both Actual infection but especially the first one.

magic mason
# obsidian dagger Peculiar request but does anyone know of any songs/music videos which do a good ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cr7df9eRoQk
This is one of my favriotes

Don't forget to subscribe for more great exclusive videos: http://bit.ly/1xR6CmV

Purchase Bad Moves: http://dongiovanni.co/BadMovesEP

Lyrics:
I was backed against the traps of my teenage plan.
I was stumbling over gaps and feeling beat up again.
I was staring down the corpse of a lifelong dream,
But I was willing it to get back on its feet aga...

▶ Play video
#

(the video)

#

https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=R3BBj06JAfc
in terms of songs, I always felt like this one was very Actual Coded

Provided to YouTube by Universal Music Group

Dental Care · Owl City

Ocean Eyes

℗ 2009 Universal Republic Records, a division of UMG Recordings, Inc.

Released on: 2009-01-01

Recording Engineer, Producer, Composer Lyricist: Adam Young
Mixing Engineer: John Goodmanson
Composer Lyricist: Owl City

Auto-generated by YouTube.

▶ Play video
#

hmmm its less of an actual-infection song and more of an actual-personality song

#

the latter I mean

#

like I can imagine this bit plying

When hygienists leave 
on
long vacations
That's when dentists 
scream and lose 
their patience

As an actual like, kinda brutally kills someone and someone else reacts in despair, but the actual doesn't really process things like that

obsidian dagger
magic mason
#

Yea
Originally I latched donto it as a triangle agency anomaly but it works so well for Actuals

obsidian dagger
#

I'm thinking about the MESS from Gatchaman CROWDS and their habits of imitating moving objects or people, sometimes without understanding why. Like, one imitates a person who goes up an escalator, then down the adjacent one, then up the first one again, in a loop.

obsidian dagger
#

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73JO_qNfCUc I can't tell if this is an Actual or what but it's something. (I should probably also consider some of these for my arcs as songs project but Become Somebody is a slot with a lot of competition so I want to be really picky.)

Miike Snow's official music video for 'The Wave'. Click to listen to Miike Snow on Spotify: http://smarturl.it/MiikeSnowSpot?IQid=Wave

As featured on Happy To You. Click to buy the track or album via iTunes: http://smarturl.it/MiikeSnowHTY?IQid=Wave
Google Play: http://smarturl.it/MiikeSWvPlay?IQid=Wave
Amazon: http://smarturl.it/MiikeSnowHAmaz...

▶ Play video
vivid wraith
fleet harbor
#

Lake Superior as a chancel

#

and/or Lake Superior as a True God

#

Estates, hm ...

#

Storms is almost too obvious

#

Might be a plotline there tho

#

The Angel of Storms is dying for some reason and various powers throughout the Ash are chomping at the bit to get the estate either overall or locally

narrow tartan
#

Straregist Elsa. Hurting Anna was the Glitch.

obsidian dagger
#

Siames probably has an actual infection song. They have all kinds of weird stuff.

obsidian dagger
#

...I think that when Black arcs reference bearing witness to a miracle, if you define a miracle as a moment where everything is indelibly changed in ways beyond the physical, that absolutely includes a death.

obsidian dagger
#

Is the Joker a Warmain?

obsidian dagger
#

I think he is. His "one bad day" is a Test he inflicts on people, he has powers to corrupt and control and improve people (most pointedly Harleen Quinzel), and he's definitely Immortal in the narrative sense.

narrow tartan
#

He is trying to find rhe perfect backstory

fleet harbor
#

snrrrk

narrow tartan
#

i mean it seems to make perfect sense

obsidian dagger
#

Warmains frequently make sense as existing because they exist. Their backstory is partial or apocryphal or uncertain. They hail from a distant unreachable place or time, given Impresario.

#

...by that metric, the way you pass the Joker's test is by killing him, probably.

narrow tartan
#

oh okay

obsidian dagger
#

I mean, a lot of his interactions definitely feel like he's testing Batman, and trying to make him break his no-kill rule.

#

Or occasionally other people.

narrow tartan
#

With batman definitely. But part of it was me thinking about the "one bad day" test and the whole "do you know how i got these scars" thing from the nolan films

obsidian dagger
#

I haven't seen those but... okay I recently read the weird semi-canonical official webtoon, which made me discover the existence of Signal, who I think Joker also tested?

narrow tartan
#

Dunno. Just musing.

narrow tartan
#

what if like. darklords were really hot

patent tiger
#

I suspect for a certain set of the population that would not make much difference

frank light
#

I think that is just dark lords

restive ridge
#

Yeah I think Dark Lords being hot is the default setting

magic mason
#

Game lords are hot in a bad boy way and Rules Lords are hot in a Milf way send tweet before my internal mechanisms stop me

patent tiger
#

Yeah

#

That's true

restive ridge
#

The Estate of "And Such"

frank light
#

is that freud

restive ridge
#

By @/FlexuallyT

fleet harbor
#

I'm afraid I'm banishing you to the Outside for this

vivid wraith
#

Gatecrasher

patent tiger
#

Real

vivid wraith
#

deep cut Serpent names for ye: Rahab and Ophion

fleet harbor
#

Yes this is good

gloomy oasis
#

I need to read the Glitch book today. :V

obsidian dagger
#

Randomly encountered this Creature of the Light quote for a character description:

Has mastered the art of sitting menacingly so the light always hits him in just the right way.

narrow tartan
#

Glassy medium

pure cape
#

Spiderman pointing meme

narrow tartan
#

Glitch is good. I should reread it

gloomy oasis
#

So my Glitch character is dying of automobiles. Back in the 70s gas crisis, they were a normal mechanic, who installed one of those scam devices which were supposed to improve gas mileage on a friend's car at his behest, knowing it would never work. But it did.

#

They spent years trying to destroy the world in general and cars specifically, culminating in a Flower Rite which was supposed to destroy or at least severely damage the concept. It failed; the two laws they tried to set at odds flexed and scraped across each other instead of breaking. The only side effect is that now electric cars are becoming more popular.

#

And they were like, "Y'know what? Fuck it. I'm done."

gloomy oasis
narrow tartan
#

My PFP is a Strategist.

narrow tartan
#

I should come up with new idea for strategist... Maybe.

narrow tartan
#

My brain is going, "man is very annoyed to find out his liver is going to heaven without him"

gloomy oasis
#

That's what happens when you drink the wrong spirits. Or the right ones.

narrow tartan
#

Hmm. Characters. Who represent ideological struggles. And. Due to the nature of the media cannot ever find resolution

#

Magneto and Professor X

narrow tartan
#

I have requested someone make a miramie mesmer hat. Maybe with a feather

restive ridge
narrow tartan
#

Somefay i might do miramie mesmer cosplah

obsidian dagger
narrow tartan
#

And as a first step. I shall aquire tiny top hat

narrow tartan
#

thinks
Blech. I wish to consume all media and ascend.

vivid wraith
narrow tartan
#

Also. I think Miramie Mesmer's hat should have a feather

fleet harbor
#

I agree

#

This is a good take

#

Tiny top hat with feather > tiny top hat without feather

patent tiger
#

A consistent trend in my collection of tiny hats is that they come with feathers

#

So I agree

fleet harbor
#

Ru seal of approval!

narrow tartan
#

nodnod basically at local market there is woman selling tiny hats. And I requested she make one in the style, showed her a miramie mesmer picture

fleet harbor
#

That's awesome

patent tiger
#

Lovely

narrow tartan
#

watches video about cosmic voids
is scared
reframes things
A far and sunless land... It is beautiful

restive ridge
#

Game Lord wearing this

vivid wraith
#

yeah

fleet harbor
#

Yeah

vivid wraith
restive ridge
vivid wraith
#

uwu

obsidian dagger
restive ridge
#

If you cut a worm in two, those two pieces regrow into two worms, how many souls will eventually enter the cycle of reincarnation:
A)1
B)2
C)3
D)3!/1!
E)None of the Above

vestal mist
#

E)

#

Worms are not possessed of souls

gloomy oasis
#

That's why they can be divided like that.

frank light
#

I one time wrote soul worldbuilding that they could be divided infinitely

#

And this new souls are born from other souls by dividing infinitely small pieces of themselves and adding them up into another soul

fleet harbor
#

Like quarks

gloomy oasis
#

incidentally, I don't believe ants have souls, but an anthill has one.

frank light
#

its more like the uh
the weird sphere paradox

fleet harbor
#

I'm sorry Karen, it's too late

#

Quarks are souls now

#

That's how panpsychism works, it's canon

vivid wraith
#

xenocide by orson scott card

frank light
#

sdfha

magic mason
#

Had an idea a while back inspired by a thing mentioned about True Gods In Glitch

A mortal(maybe with the assistance of something miraculous, but it gives them more of an iconic status if they figure it out on their own)
who breaks into a true god(preferably the players patron true god, but just one they know is good too) and STEALS/fuses with one of the primordial violence only True Gods that the newer true gods Ate
so you have this human/humanoid with True God Stats, but probably not any estates
kinda Idigam esque ig

gloomy oasis
#

It involves rotation.

#

Speaking of rotation, I just realized that the Imperator whose estate includes USB has to be a Mimic. That's why you can't insert the plug until you've rotated it 180 degrees twice.

narrow tartan
#

Guy whoae face is not visible. Because there is always something in the way

obsidian dagger
narrow tartan
#

I desire world breakrrs hand to get rid of things that annoy me

obsidian dagger
#

understandable

fleet harbor
#

Something something I told him it sounds like he's just feeding John F. Kennedys to death and then his daughter started crying

narrow tartan
#

They actually remove your wisdom teeth in order to prevent you from getting into heaven.

fleet harbor
#

What about people who don't need them removed? Are they just ontologically bound for hell?

#

Can we identify The Elect by wisdom tooth surgeries

narrow tartan
#

No no. People with wisdom teeth can get into heavan. Thats why they get removed. See. Its like a key

fleet harbor
#

Right but some people just get their wisdom teeth in and keep them

#

Like me

#

Which leads me to believe that having a jaw that large is a sin???!

narrow tartan
#

nodnod

#

thinks about how humanity destroying angel would help someone transition
Gets jealous of angel using fire magic to remove body and facial hair

vivid wraith
#

quick search of the tumblr didn't reveal anything but: do we have any hints or reasonable extrapolation for what the notional genre of nob4 is for spotlight actions etc?

magic mason
#

/earth

#

Maybe the mythic has its own genre

frank light
#

I could imagine the mythic having a new genre but I’m betting earth is still immersive fantasy

#

Betting at least

magic mason
#

What if the first ruler and the first gamer were in love send tweet

patent tiger
#

They should kill each other

vivid wraith
#

(quotes from the first ruler and first gamer)

magic mason
#

They were probably like

Still figuring things out, at the first of their respective kinds

#

They were at that point in history closer to each other than anything else

narrow tartan
#

Strategist who keeps their day job from before they glitched.

narrow tartan
#

Is there a good elevator pitch for Glitch

patent tiger
#

Usually by selling people on Nobilis first, getting them to do a bit of that, and then pitching a game about playing the burnouts of the villain squad

vivid wraith
#

i like "retired supervillain void gods"

narrow tartan
#

nodnod

restive ridge
obsidian dagger
#

🔁 toasthaste

When people say things like "Behold the Accursed One!" that doesn't imply any ill intent on their part -- quite often it's meant as a neutral or even helpful statement. But the problem with this sort of language is that, however well-intentioned it may be, it foregrounds the curse at the expense of the person behind it; auguries have shown that this can have a priming effect that subtly reduces empathy. For that reason, experts today encourage people to use one-first language, such as "Behold the One who Bears the Curse," to better emphasize the dignity of the individual.

vivid wraith
#

Child of the Ash

magic mason
frank light
#

yeah

restive ridge
vivid wraith
#

i think i will continue to sketch out the Power of Past Lives

#

That feels productive

gloomy oasis
#

I unfortunately can't make future games of this Glitch campaign, but I did make my character in Heroforge.

candid compass
#

Nice

narrow tartan
#

Hmm arcana that are people

candid compass
#

A lot of them are

#

Well, they're not-people

patent tiger
#

Everything is people, the question is how much you focus on it

candid compass
#

also that, yes

#

everything is sentient mythically

narrow tartan
#

True.

#

Was basically thinking about an angel idea. The angel of sex, drugs, and rock-'n'-roll. And. They have these.

#

But gonna start rereading glotch

patent tiger
#

Sex drugs and rock 'n' roll don't feel super angelic to me

#

Are those beautiful things?

restive ridge
#

When you lowkey get bored midway through your Green Arc so you stab your crush and their gf

narrow tartan
#

Every ten years the angel of (x, y, and z) sends their servants to find the good and (something) and take them off to heaven.

narrow tartan
vivid wraith
#

Oh this rules

narrow tartan
#

...Rinley has Creature of Fable? If I ever play Rinley I might do something like this

#

(also i have a joke thought that Rinley has met Chuubo's parents offscreen)

narrow tartan
#

My girlfriend is telling her girlfriend about Glitch.

vivid wraith
#

it spreads

magic mason
#

I made aa Rulees Magister Playlist

#

@narrow tartan

narrow tartan
#

Neat

narrow tartan
#

Even if Serpents had called an invading army the Excrucians they summoned would be snakes and prone to falling from their horses

#

Hmm. Lesser excrucians.

magic mason
#

(Creature From Outside Creation Dedicated To Destroying Creation that Isn't A God)

narrow tartan
#

nodnod

vivid wraith
#

I would absolutely use "hey there's an Excrucian with an unknown MO, that's weird and scary" and then it turns out to be an Abhorrent Weapon

vivid wraith
candid compass
vivid wraith
#

excellent

obsidian dagger
#

Thinking about how... like, Strategists can hurt the people around them. Their Banes frequently risk collateral damage and/or involve them turning evil. But if they try hard enough, they can manage their actions and manage their bane and avoid hurting the people they care about.

And Mimics just kind of... can't. Just by existing they cause harm to reality and make it a worse place. There is no action they can take that will totally prevent this. Strategists have to struggle to not harm the things they love, but Mimics will harm the things they love.

#

How can you be a good person if by existing you cause harm to others? How do you negotiate with that horrible knowledge that your hands can never be fully clean, not even because of what you once did, but because of your continued existence?

#

I have Thoughts about a mimic game.

frank light
#

mimics ❤️

vivid wraith
#

I think Mimics have about the same chance of Not Causing Problems as Strategists tbh

#

Strategists need to stay in control constantly, Mimics need to Not Die Ever

#

for both it's never something that ever truly goes away

#

but at least Mimics won't have to be around to see it fall apart, I suppose

obsidian dagger
#

Aren't they also causing problems just by existing? Like, even if they don't die, they are still one of the pillars holding up reality, and also fake.

#

That's the whole reason Mimics are created. Their existance erodes reality. Or am I wrong?

vivid wraith
#

"words in the same language, used to different intention" in Nob3 suggests they're not fundamentally erosive, imo, but i'll check glitch

patent tiger
#

This is the closest Glitch gets to that

vivid wraith
#

hmmmm okay

patent tiger
#

Which is a bit distant, and mostly about the blasphemy at their heart

vivid wraith
patent tiger
ruby ivy
#

Chatgpt is a mimic estate

vivid wraith
#

It's still describing "the horror inside" there

#

And at the start it talks about successfully holding the world together for a time

obsidian dagger
#

...so, uh, side note: should be worried about the implications of "Flowers" being potentially a Mimic estate?

vivid wraith
#

don't worry about it ;)

patent tiger
#

Well, the world is wrong, so it makes sense that something that underpins it would be-

candid compass
obsidian dagger
#

I am half-convinced that Pain is a mimic estate, because if Pain worked properly it would always indicate an injury of some kind (physical or mental) but it's broken and that's why chronic pain conditions exist.

narrow tartan
obsidian dagger
#

That is a good answer.

narrow tartan
#

I dont trust Ananda.

obsidian dagger
#

I have it on good authority that he is not a horse, at least.

vivid wraith
#

Which splat has the funniest mix of "mythic archetype" vs "one specific anime" in their stats

obsidian dagger
#

Hm. Probably Creature of Delirium? I'm not sure, though.

magic mason
magic mason
#

Simultaneously being Angels and Magical Girls

obsidian dagger
#

I misread the question.

narrow tartan
vivid wraith
#

Warmain or Deceiver

#

place your bets

narrow tartan
#

Hmm. Maybe. I should find a way to steal a plot from the tragically dead glitch quest. And to go back in time and laser the people who bullied the author over using ai image generation before everyone realized how horrible ai image generation is for the world

magic mason
#

He has rules

tall jolt
#

I bet a Domain of Respect can do a lot of damage if used right lol

narrow tartan
#

Nuclear spirits for reasons unknown are giant lizards.

narrow tartan
#

Power of Byssus.

#

Considered spooky because most people dont wven know what it is

obsidian dagger
#

...I don't know what it is. A kind of fabric?

narrow tartan
#

Yes

vivid wraith
frank light
#

so pretty....

narrow tartan
#

The lack of an allegorical deepness splat surprises me

#

Also. Assigning splats to fictional characters and then going with the implications is funny. Like
"Is Aang secretly a giant snake?"

vivid wraith
#

That's true he is

narrow tartan
#

looks up raava huh

#

I remember. Watching a video once that complained about the Spirits in Korra.

gloomy oasis
#

I really need to read a guide to Chuubo's, I think.

candid compass
#

Chuubo's is at the same time fairly simple and very complicated

narrow tartan
#

New answer to the Bleak, "I don't care if I bleapheme it [the Not]"

magic mason
# narrow tartan New answer to the Bleak, "I don't care if I bleapheme it [the Not]"

I think the trick to conceptualize answering the bleak is that

The Bleak doesn't necessairly represent The Not, Noble Destruction is also bleak iirc

Is that a bleak miracle is fundamentally unfair, so answering a bleak miracle can be done even by a mortal by refuting that unfairness

Calling to Things You Love, or a Grandiose Asspull

frank light
#

yeah

#

i think the biggest thing about defending against the bleak is that its not guaranteed

#

the point is that you only have a little bit of hope

#

you have to bring out how much you care, you have to focus your attention
and from there, it isnt that it doesnt work, it just...is defended against a little

#

maybe you dont die, you only get corrupted a little

or if the goal was to corrupt you, maybe it only lets you say that you get corrupted very slowly.

or maybe not everything you have is destroyed, the parts that were important survive

narrow tartan
#

Huh

vivid wraith
vivid wraith
candid compass
fleet harbor
#

Correct

narrow tartan
#

The best part about Byssus as an estate is that the associated species of clam is known asPina nobilis

obsidian dagger
#

is Candace from Phineas and Ferb a Creature of Fable?

#

Or are the titular kids? Or... both? (I need to actually watch Phineas and Ferb and not just clips but there are so many other things I need to watch first)

narrow tartan
#

Perry the Platypus?

obsidian dagger
#

...honestly? Yeah he might be. "Going off to have your own adventures Off To The Side" is very Creature of Fable also. And arguably getting gadgets from being Called Away to OWCA?

#

Plausibly there's some Gatecrasher going on also, but he's not an imposter in the world of super agents so I don't know.

obsidian dagger
#

I am convinced that somewhere out there, there's a Creature of Fable who does parkour, and is convinced that they can get where they need to by simply following the clear line of conspicously yellow-painted objects. But nobody else ever seems to notice or do it! It's baffling. They insist "oh, that's just someone growing yellow flowers in a windowbox, not some grand cosmic sign" or "sure, that fire hydrant happens to be yellow, but that's perfectly normal" or "why are you climbing up the ledge someone spilled yellow paint on? Wouldn't that have worse grip?" They just don't get it.

#

The experience of Creature of Fable is seeing something obvious, something straightforward, that you can't seem to explain or prove to others. So from the outside it looks like Ominous Posturing or Mysterious Scheming or Aura Farming. But internally? That's just how the world works.

#

Creature of the Light is about being convinced that you are a major character in the world's story as well, but unlike Creature of Fable, this is pretty self-evident. You can easily prove that you are what you say you are. And Creature of Delirium... well, you prove your story to people by forcibly pulling them into it.

narrow tartan
#

Huh. Thats pretty good.

#

Makes me wonder if CoD and CoF should have their Sickly/Frantic status switched.

#

No. I think the vibe of the rules fits better.

gloomy oasis
#

I had a really weird thought.

#

What if there are no actual Imperators? They're all Mimics. But every one of them believes they're the only one.

narrow tartan
#

Spy Family as Mimic game

narrow tartan
#

Darklprd of Instant Noodles

obsidian dagger
#

Isn't there a canonical Noble of Instant Noodle?

frank light
#

Unknown I…forgor

narrow tartan
#

Hikkimori failgirl gamer

vivid wraith
#

Ha-Qadosch Berakha who's on the Council of Four because he's Creation's master of the void. High Summoning, dealing with Deathwrights, etc.

narrow tartan
#

Wait. Is that canon?

vivid wraith
#

nope!

#

only thing that's canon is that he "treats the world as his playground"

#

but this gives you a way to attach some implied Glitch NPC hooks to a Nobilis campaign

candid compass
#

possible we find out more in 4e

obsidian dagger
#

I'm thinking about I Can Friday By Day again, and how very True God it is to realize that while you believed yourself to be a singular conscious entity you are actually an elaborate mech piloted by an entire crew of aliens.

#

Unrelatedly, I'm trying to think of which XP action it would be to say "this horrible person is dying in front of me, and if they do not die here it is very probable they will continue to do evil things, and their death would make the world a better place... and I am going to save their life because I Am A Doctor and doctors save lives and don't choose who does or doesn't deserve it". It... feels like a Wicked Action but specifically the kind that gets sheltered under a Divine Warrant?

#

...is it? Or is it the opposite of that, where it's an XP action for staying true to your morals even when they make your life harder? It's probably contextual.

obsidian dagger
#

Also, just rediscovered my idea for House of the Sun Excrucians with Gatekeeper/Wounded Angel/Prophet/Star Quality.

#

They are each the seed of a world which is not but could be, a potential future. There is some thread of possibility which they represent. And everybody around you says that this is a horrid and nightmarish world and it is no good and should not be.

restive ridge
obsidian dagger
#

And you know, really and truly, that they’re mostly right. If that seed begins to carelessly sprout it would bring untold destruction. And it would be much easier if you cast it away, turned back, strangled the wicked plant taking root inside you.

But… you won’t. You can’t. Even as horrible as it could be, there’s something really truly beautiful there. There’s a sliver of real unalloyed Good. You cannot turn away from this potential world or the creatures that represent it, because even if they’re usually bad, you know they don’t have to be.

#

I think this concept is slightly sideways of the original idea and possibly needs Called Away.

magic mason
obsidian dagger
#

Just had a brain blast. Team Rocket from the Pokemon anime specifically (Jessie + James + Meowth) are Creatures of Delirium. Or possibly a single one who is three people.

narrow tartan
#

I think i see it

magic mason
obsidian dagger
#

The main counterargument is that to my knowledge they don't blackmail or control the original owners of their stolen pokemon very often. But otherwise, in a sideways sort of way, it fits.

obsidian dagger
#

So, I'm thinking about Wardens again. And I gave them Gatekeeper/Wounded Angel/Prophet/Star Quality but I increasingly think they need Called Away somewhere in there, because when I tried to describe one I ended up with the phrase "flames of dead hope" and if that isn't a Called Away pseudo-element I don't know what is. But at the same time I don't know what to replace for that.

#

Also I'm thinking that Mourning of the Six Sins (who is listed as Accursed and picking up Wounded Angel but who is probably supposed to be on Strategist arcs and Wounded Angel was just subbed in for the blue) could, feasibly, be one of these.

obsidian dagger
#

...honestly, Mourning probably should stay a Strategist and the only reason why I doubt his ability to fit as one is due to seeing Strategists as being primarily about their suffering rather than their, well, strategies.

restive ridge
#

New Hell/Heaven discourse fuel just dropped

fleet harbor
#

Yeah that tracks

restive ridge
#

Is Hell Bourgeoise gkat, time sensitive question

fleet harbor
#

Not categorically, and bourgeoisie is actually a Rules estate

#

But liberal democracy is a hell estate

frank light
fleet harbor
# frank light Elaborate on that

The bourgeoisie …

… are financially, politically, and educationally privileged. (3)
… have a place in the status quo. (1)
… monopolize expertise. (1)
… minimize change and disruption by appropriating it. (1)
… tolerate petty difference but not meaningful disagreement. (1)

#

In effect, the Rules are the bourgeoisie

frank light
#

Hmm

#

I

#

I don’t know if I agree with that

#

Maybe I’m just someone who likes the rules a lot but

#

I wouldn’t call them the bourgeoisie

#

I dunno. It’s a comparison that feels reductive to them as a whole

#

You can make the argument that the rules contain the bourgeois as an estate among them but…to call them as a whole that feels too flat

#

Misses nuances I really like about them

#

They run the spectrum of “faceless emanation of the status quo” to “that screaming voice in the back of your head that urges you not to give up”

#

Given their two purple arcs and holy, they’re defined a lot by being inspirational and caring deeply

fleet harbor
#

In Theory(tm), the petit bourgeoisie comprise civil servants, university professors, scholars, scientists, and other very serious people who are legitimately important but whose very importance keeps things as they are

frank light
#

I still think that the rules, as a whole, does not necessarily have to mean stasis.

Invention is a part of the rules, and their powers are transformative and catalytic.

fleet harbor
#

Sure, but always in a way that preserves their own importance

#

The Rules makes a very sound argument for why the Rules are important

frank light
#

I mean in that sense all imperators are the bourgeoise

#

I don’t think “imperators make themselves important” is necessarily solely part of the rules

fleet harbor
#

Lemme find the bit I’m thinking of

frank light
#

Which, sure yeah I can get behind that

fleet harbor
frank light
#

Yea I know that bit

#

But Shortly after

#

To say that they want to keep that status quo is I think, at least for all the rules, not exactly true.

They don’t understand how to change that status quo

#

They want to make humanity immortal so badly but they don’t know how. The ways they can make things immortal would make us no longer human

fleet harbor
#

Right, and the thing about the petit bourgeoisie is that they are not the real class enemy, and indeed frequently agitate for change

frank light
#

Which is why I feel like there’s a lot of nuances

#

You started this statement with the bourgeoisie rather than the Petit bourgeoisie which is why I felt so strongly about it

fleet harbor
#

Ah, in fairness I have been mostly describing the petit bourgeoisie, not the ownership class

#

Capitalism is a Games estate >_>

frank light
#

Mhm mhm

#

I see I see

fleet harbor
#

But the Rules are absolutely petit bourgeoisie coded insofar as even when they want to make things better the human status quo is deeply embedded in their very existence, and to truly change things they too need to surrender their crowns (which they might even be willing to do, but are sort of ontologically incapable of)

frank light
#

They’ve got 2 purple arcs which is the most interesting part

fleet harbor
#

The Rules are the extremely Marxist sociology department at Harvard university, and also the civil service class of Imperial China, and also philanthropist tech billionaires, and also

frank light
#

Of every single splat they’re the most defined by trying

fleet harbor
vivid wraith
#

shout-out to the purple quest miracle that guarantees a happy ending that thing's crazy

frank light
#

YEAH

#

The rules if nothing else know how to give a happy ending-is that an innuendo?

fleet harbor
#

Like, to draw a comparison to Dark Souls

frank light
#

They are anime boys I guess

frank light
#

I can

#

Guess

fleet harbor
#

The Rules relights the Fire

frank light
#

Dark souls is game propaganda im tellin you

#

If we’re making game comparisons I’ll also bring up disco Elysium

#

Volition is my reference for the positive end of the spectrum for the rules

fleet harbor
#

And the Rules has a very good rationale for relighting the Fire

#

Like, relighting the Fire is in some ways the objectively moral thing to do

frank light
#

No matter what, thick and thin, volition does not give up on you.
Volition wants you to be better.
Volition is your better impulse
Volition is this little voice telling you not to die. To keep going. Keep clawing at self control

Volition is the rules, to me. At least at their best

fleet harbor
#

It’s hard to articulate a reason to go willingly into the unknown darkness

frank light
#

It is

fleet harbor
#

To accept total transformation with no guarantee or even indication that it will be better

frank light
#

There’s fair evidence that it is death even

#

Or at least the death of what you are

fleet harbor
#

The Age of Dark is an absolute unknown, and the only real argument for it is a refusal to accept the way things are.

#

And so like

#

The Rules have a compelling case against that

frank light
#

Yeah

#

They’re bad at giving up

fleet harbor
#

But also I’m sure from my language you can tell I have my doubts

frank light
#

Even if that means transformation

#

Yea

#

That’s fair

#

I’ve just been a rules enjoyer for a while

#

And feel they get a lot of judgement ;-;

fleet harbor
#

It’s easy to just take them as tyrannical

#

Which is not their deal

#

Heaven is tyrannical

frank light
#

For me, as y’know, who I am…

I dunno. I really like the embodiments of our perfect selves, no matter how distant.
I like the embodiments of not giving up and continuing to live. I like…not dying.

The core appeal is “I don’t want to die” and the rules don’t want that either.

#

The fact that they don’t know how to help, but so desperately try, charms me

#

They have gardener and architect, two stats that are all about caring and trying but not how a human cares

fleet harbor
#

I am a very memento mori sort of person

frank light
#

They can’t care how a human does, they don’t know how.

But fuck do they want to

#

I mean I getcha

#

I just finished outer wilds recently

fleet harbor
#

That is something Robin got straight from me

frank light
#

So holy hell do I getcha

#

But also

#

Well. Transgender woman

#

Fearing death and accepting death, imo, are allowed to be equal

#

I think you can accept that death is inevitable.

#

Make peace with it

#

But also be terrified of it

#

Terrified of everything you leave behind

#

I don’t want to give up

#

If I’m gonna die I’m gonna do it after living a long fucking life clawing to existence tooth and nail

#

And that’s the rules to me

fleet harbor
#

Well, I don’t see it as giving up

frank light
#

Tooth and nail and claw

#

I mean it isn’t

#

I just…I can get behind the desire

#

I think it is a noble desire, to not want to die.

#

Struggling to live is something I find deeply relatable

fleet harbor
#

I see it as accepting change and impermanence, of which death is only a small part

frank light
#

And I have a fixation on holy beings

#

They’re cute what can I say

fleet harbor
frank light
#

I think about entropy 2 a lot

#

Entropy 1 was evil as this horrible thing humans do to eachother, this awful wretched desecration we commit to ourselves

#

Entropy 2 was evil as…an opposite

#

Evil as a thing we can strive to avoid

#

Evil as this improving force because of its oppositional nature

#

Something we may become better through

fleet harbor
#

The Rules are about permanence, but me personally I find that one quote from He The Lord Of Death’s Dominion He to be super compelling >_>

frank light
#

His evil was cleaner, less about desecration and more about…I dunno. A core lesson to it.

A synthesis

#

Citations are nightbird’s feather and glassmaker’s dragon

fleet harbor
#

Gk is #1 death fan in chat /hj

frank light
#

Entropy in nightbird’s feather(e1) showed a character the seed of evil and demonstrated that every single human deserves to meet a horrible tragic humiliating end

Entropy 2 in glassmaker’s is a transformative person that wants people to become better and also loves and defends the evil world, and seeks ä coexistence between evil and good

#

E2 exists because e1 broke

#

E1 committed a good deed.

And so evil, this thing that could not ever be good, had to somehow square that paradox

#

And e2 is the answer to it

fleet harbor
#

I also take a lot of influence from Baccano

frank light
#

If something that is evil can cause good to happen, then that means evil must be able to do that.

E2 can do that while e1 can’t.

fleet harbor
#

“Mortals and immortals both enjoy life equally” etc etc

frank light
fleet harbor
#

Have you watched Baccano?

frank light
#

Nope

fleet harbor
#

It’s real good but sorta the core thematic thrust is that the length of a life and its value are just completely orthogonal to each other

#

I would check it out even if that doesn’t interest you, it’s fantastic

frank light
#

Mhm

fleet harbor
#

Has a great English dub

frank light
#

I recently finished outer wilds and need to go through the dlc

#

So

#

One digestion of the value of life at a time I suppose

#

Heheheh

fleet harbor
#

Because it’s canonically set in 1930s USA

#

So they got the performers to do the accents and everything

frank light
#

Wow

fleet harbor
#

Claire Stanfield aka The Rail Tracer explains his unorthodox philosophies. One of which being solipsism. Source: Baccano Episodes 11 and 12

Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news, reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is...

▶ Play video
#

Claire is great

#

Actual solipsist

#

Most Wildlord character in fiction

narrow tartan
#

Reading a fanfic. And. Character just tells someone to stop existing and it works.

gloomy oasis
#

So how much do Nobles and Imperators know about the motivation of Excrucians?

#

I do know that, when a human becomes a Noble, they become completely incapable of seeing the Glitch afterwards.

fleet harbor
#

Given Excrucians will not shut up about their motives, they probably know them pretty well

#

The issue is that they lack the experiences which lend those motives weight

#

But like, rambling about how the world is a lie, exhibit A, and then exhibit A is a hedgehog? That’s Excrucian 101

fleet harbor
gloomy oasis
#

And most Strategists don't get to die of their Bane in front of the forces of Creation, because if they do die it's because they're fighting said forces.

candid compass
#

To Nobles, anything a Strategist might say is glitched and wrong just looks normal

#

Maybe a little weird, but not to the point they'd understand

candid compass
fleet harbor
#

It’s just a hedgehog

patent tiger
candid compass
candid compass
#

They might very well just go "Huh, I guess their weird evil powers backfired on them, oh well"

patent tiger
fleet harbor
#

Strategists do, in fact, have Bane-themed powers

ruby ivy
vivid wraith
#

yeah

magic mason
candid compass
magic mason
candid compass
#

Lmao

#

True

frank light
#

Malakai is such an asshole

candid compass
#

That one too, yeah

fleet harbor
#

Right, it’s not that the Power is literally incapable of perceiving the tooth man who shoots the strategist with a gun

#

It’s that they cannot perceive the Glitch

frank light
#

when they see the tooth man theyre like "yeah thats fucked up huh"

#

but they dont see/connect to the fundamental incorrectness

frank light
#

holy shit

magic mason
#

This was a tweet….

patent tiger
#

Nobilis Bluesky goes soft for sure

fleet harbor
#

The Power of Microblogs

frank light
#

but sometimes a god shows up and just says "had to recalibrate all beetles again"

fleet harbor
#

Well the thing is people already say stuff like that on bsky

#

So the only difference is that they’re not bullshitting

narrow tartan
#

...what social media would each splat use.

#

I think Serpents are on Tumblr

magic mason
#

Nono
Angels use tumblr

candid compass
#

This tracks

#

Equally judgemental

narrow tartan
#

Hmm.

#

Ah I see.

#

I think my exposure to tumblr is attpical

fleet harbor
#

Serpents use snumblr

obsidian dagger
#

Serpents feel like they would use either tumblr or blusky, but not in the sense of being a Poster™? They'd look like one of those gimmick accounts which pretends to be a cat or something, or posts daily videos of seals, or something like that.

#

err, twitter or blusky, probably. They aren't going to ever make longer-form posts. Hell is already posting on tumblr.

fleet harbor
#

Snitter or snusky

obsidian dagger
#

I feel like if any criticism could be levied at Serpents, it would be a sort of indifference. They would use Twitter even after it became X because they wouldn't want to bother moving their presence. They wouldn't be Twitter Users™ but they would, nevertheless, use Twitter.

obsidian dagger
#

I have a punchline without a joke and don't know what to do with it

#

chancel culture

fleet harbor
# obsidian dagger I feel like if any criticism could be levied at Serpents, it would be a sort of ...

Provided to YouTube by Legacy/Columbia

From A Distance · The Byrds

20 Essential Tracks From The Box Set: 1965-1990

℗ 1990, 1992 Sony Music Entertainment Inc.

Released on: 1992-01-14

Producer, Bass, Vocal: Chris Hillman
Associated Performer: The Byrds
Producer, 12- String Guitar, Vocal: Roger McGuinn
Vocal, Guitar, Producer: David Crosby
...

▶ Play video
#

And it is also the problem with serpents

#

Because people do not live at a distance

#

Like all Imperators, they're not even wrong

#

They just fail to understand critical about being a person who lives in the world

#

That's kinda the brilliance of Glitch, imo

#

Because the Excrucians, barring maybe Warmains, do seem to understand what being a person is like

#

And Glitch really brings that home

#

Fable of the Swan and Night-Bird's Feather achieve something similar

frank light
#

the critical part of warhost excrucians, to me, is their alienation from the world

#

strategists suck ass at the whole person thing

#

and deceivers do not see you and only see this perfect image of what you could be (Much like the rules)

#

except worse cus that perfect image is something theyre perfectly willing to kill you to achieve

vivid wraith
#

It is kinda hard for me to picture them settling down before giving up on the war

fleet harbor
#

Oh I don't see them settling down

#

But like

#

How do I put this

#

Strategists suck at the whole person thing in the way that people suck at the whole person thing

#

They're ... soggy

#

And bad at being alive

#

And unlike an Imperator that's not because they have the option of going off to do something different

#

If that makes sense

#

They are miserable and imperfect beings, trapped in a world they never made

narrow tartan
fleet harbor
#

I look at an Imperator and I see a fragment of the human condition, exaggerated at the expense of all others

frank light
#

I think deceivers and strategists can comprehend people inasmuch as they pity them for their existence, but there is a fundamental disconnection that exists until an excrucian retires

#

Cus they have to look at everything a person is and say “and it should be destroyed”

fleet harbor
#

I look at an Excrucian and I see a person who is having a really bad time and is making it everyone else's problem, on some level

frank light
#

Deceivers don’t see you, they don’t see who you are, really. Only some perfect image that is foreign and alien

#

Strategists see you as trapped in the muck of the wrongness of the world

#

And warmains can be kind and courteous but only approach people as prey

fleet harbor
#

Warmains I made the exception for :P

frank light
#

Until an excrucian stops fighting there is a disconnect to their understanding of people or the human experience

#

It’s even pointed out in glitch

#

Particularly flore

#

Strategists universally tend to have low flore

And the low flore descriptions demonstrate a clear…barrier between understanding being a person

patent tiger
#

Not even humans understand the human experience, really.

frank light
#

True enough I guess

#

But I think excrucians are characterized by being alienated

patent tiger
#

I do agree there, yeah.

frank light
#

At odds with existence itself

fleet harbor
patent tiger
#

Excrucians can be looked at from a human lens, but what they are is a destructive thing.

fleet harbor
#

I see it as a very human experience, if anything

frank light
#

That alienation shows up in some imperators too tbh

#

It’s just that if imperators represent the experience of the world, for all that is good or bad

fleet harbor
frank light
#

Excrucians tend to represent the things that alienate you from the world

#

Whether it be some foreign concept that is better than it but not there

fleet harbor
frank light
#

Or its pains and sorrows

fleet harbor
#

Being at the mercy of the deadly space turnip

frank light
#

I’m afraid I don’t follow

fleet harbor
#

To paraphrase Sartre, you arrive on the stage without being told your lines and then a weirdo in purple chases you around without explanation for twenty-five minutes

frank light
#

Gotcha

fleet harbor
#

... the part about the purple guy may not be Sartre

frank light
#

Excrucians and imperators both feel like they’re at the mercy of the other

#

Strategists and deceivers and warmains want to destroy the world because of its unworthy nature

Deceivers and strategists see the world as this awful thing and the people in it as its victims

Something they cannot escape truly without its destruction

#

However imperators cannot escape excrucians

#

No matter how they try, for all that they are infinite, they cannot escape death

#

The true death

#

The death of everything

fleet harbor
#

And like, to some extent I guess strategists and deceivers kinda read themselves onto humans

frank light
#

The ages march forward without end

Imperators are at the mercy of an infinite void that wants them gone

fleet harbor
#

Actually, I think that's my big thing

frank light
#

And by extension all of existence

fleet harbor
#

Deceivers and strategists see the world as this awful thing and the people in it as its victims
Because they see themselves as its victims first and foremost

#

Or, that's half of my big thing

frank light
#

For sure

#

At least, strategists

narrow tartan
#

Ive reached the conclusion. That deceicers are very performative.

frank light
#

Voidborn deceivers and deceivers in general are weird

fleet harbor
#

The other half is that they are engaged in saying

it's not okay
In a way Imperators don't really know how to be

frank light
#

Coming to the world to save you from it

#

I think its odd

fleet harbor
#

A lot of my deceiver-thinking is very Fable of the Swan

frank light
#

Imperators aren’t exactly static either.

#

Angels and the rules are constantly obsessed with improving things, hell is taken to its sacred duty of witnessing

#

True gods protect and maintain the earth from both

#

Serpents….

#

Well

#

Serpents

fleet harbor
#

The world is blue and green

frank light
#

They all make answer to the world

fleet harbor
#

And the snow-capped mountains white

frank light
#

It’s just that the void’s answer to the world is sniffing it out

#

The knife, swishing this way and that.

#

While I’m deeply sympathetic to each individual excrucian, I find myself becoming less sympathetic to their cause

#

Death is inevitable but it also kinda sucks

#

Dying sucks

fleet harbor
#

I dunno, Nobilis circa glitch does a very good job of making all of the Imperator types feel fragmentary

#

Oh I'm completely unsympathetic to their cause

#

But what could be more human than doing something asinine in blind fury

frank light
#

Maybe

fleet harbor
frank light
#

I guess I see them more as embodying something uncaring, and in the act of interfacing with existence and its people, become complicated

fleet harbor
#

Like a very particular sort of neurodivergent rationalization of their own pain

frank light
#

They’re the embodiments of the faceless force of annihilation and entropy and everything meaning nothing

#

And then upon contact with the world become…infected with it

#

All of them do

#

Including warmains

#

Allegory is the stat for becoming entangled with the world

#

Very explicitly so

fleet harbor
#

It's just like

#

I know people who remind me of strategists and deceivers, not in their malice, but in the way they rationalize their pain as meaning something about the world

#

I'm trying to capture what exactly leads me to think this way

#

And I think like

#

The various Imperator types all feel like parts of people to me

#

Whereas 3/4 Excrucian types feel like very unhappy people

#

And whereas Imperators feel like they occupy a space between being deeply wise and kinda stupid as hell

#

Excrucians never feel wise

#

They are 0% wisdom

obsidian dagger
#

The great virtue of Serpents is that that they don't understand why one person would want to hurt another, and the great failing of Serpents is that they don't understand why one person would want to hurt another.

#

They're not infinitely forgiving like Hell is; they just don't understand. I feel like the concepts of "vengence" or "justice" or even "hurting someone by accident by playing too rough with them" would just kind of... slide off of them.

fleet harbor
#

Sneace and snove

#

Are easy things to believe in, from a distance

obsidian dagger
#

I could see Angels demanding you always forgive the other person, always be better, always be kinder, never snap back when hurt. But I think Serpents would moreso just be... confused. They're as kind as a river.

#

They never want to hurt anyone, but sometimes they do, usually without realizing.

frank light
#

They’re natural forces

#

Storms hurt people. A lot

#

Even when they don’t mean to

#

They’re just too…big

obsidian dagger
#

Normally I like the Chuubo's arc names, but Vastness is definitely a fitting name for a thing they have.

magic mason
gloomy oasis
gloomy oasis
fleet harbor
magic mason
#

The upside of killing a Lord Of Games in Nobilis is that you finally get them to stop bothering you for a bit and maybe you teach them a lesson.

the downside is hearing the distant
I WAS REINCARNATED AS THE KNIFE PRINCESS AND NOW I HAVE TO REASSERT DOMINON OVER MY OLD KINGDOM!!!!

Every time you do it

candid compass
#

augh

restive ridge
#

This is you must first wage economical warfare on their kingdom before going in for the kill

magic mason
#

idea:

Rules Magister who is Doing A Scheme To Try To Restore Divinity To A Portion Of Humanity(Probably like, a city)

But in the process they are ritually unmaking themselves and their estates doing a lot of damage to creation in the process, and your nobles are sent to like.... do SOMETHING

fleet harbor
#

Yes

#

This is good

obsidian dagger
#

Thoughts: some Deceivers really feel like they probably ought to have Creature of Fable, and the reason I think that is probably because I've misinterpreted something. But I'm looking at Gwenpool.

obsidian dagger
#

So, is there a name for the law that Nobles are not allowed to fall in love, and/or a stated rationale for it? Because I was just randomly thinking that Miquella the Kind sort of independently came to that conclusion from first principles.

patent tiger
#

The Windflower Law.

obsidian dagger
#

Miquella's rationale, as I understand it, is that a person would sacrifice the lives of two strangers to save the life of one person they love, and therefore love is evil (or, at least, should not be permitted in divinity).

patent tiger
#

And, as for justifications for it, here's the text on the subject from Nobilis 2e.

obsidian dagger
#

...are Imperators allowed to love? (Whatever that would even look like.)

#

Or is that also a crime to some extent?

vivid wraith
#

reconsidering "never let a mortal get the best of you" as a plot hook generator

patent tiger
#

Strictly speaking, these are laws applied to the Nobilis and only the Nobilis.

vivid wraith
#

We don't hear as much about the permitted and healthy relationships though

patent tiger
#

Lord Entropy is probably unhappy when other Imperators fall in love, but he doesn't have the law on his side.

vivid wraith
obsidian dagger
#

Isn't that the crux of the Arachne myth?

vivid wraith
#

I don't remember Athena being pressured by Lord Entropy at all

vivid wraith
#

exactly

obsidian dagger
#

Anyway, I have no idea what Miquella is doing (my first guess would be a Fallen Angel turning themself into a mimic, bizarrely) but it definitely feels appropriate to this channel.

#

I say "bizarrely" and then immediately remember Leonardo.

vivid wraith
#

Very fascinated by this Walmart shirt. Could they not use the actual phrase or something? It's not even specifying "when you're mean to me" it's just when you're mean in general this particular bunny gets hurt. She carries all suffering. This bunny experiences all evil in the world.

restive ridge
narrow tartan
#

I exist

vivid wraith
#

-Firstborn

narrow tartan
#

Random thing i found

fleet harbor
#

Hmmmmm Ace + Child of the Ash

#

For when you just need to be judo Godzilla

gloomy oasis
#

What other games let you be judo Godzilla?

obsidian dagger
#

just had a horrible realization

#

this is literally how Making Answer to the Bleak works

#

The inescapable prison of suffering may be softened by duty and by love.

frank light
#

Yea

vivid wraith
magic mason
#

Allegorical

obsidian dagger
#

definitely something Orange

#

yeah probably Allegorical.

narrow tartan
#

Warmain allegorical?

#

Powrr of meeples

vivid wraith
gloomy oasis
#

I'm thinking about stuff that λ-exists, and I believe I have a mental model of it.

#

You know that factoid where 1+2+3+4+... = -1/12?

#

Well, it's not -1/12, it's a nonconvergent series, but saying it's -1/12 is less wrong than saying it's 2, or π.

#

Similarly, a λ-centipede is not a centipede, but saying it's one is less wrong than saying it's a banana.

#

And its λ-properties can be determined the same way.

magic mason
#

That’s fun

magic mason
# gloomy oasis You know that factoid where 1+2+3+4+... = -1/12?

My mental model of the Not sort of leans into the Fairy Tale aspect of excrucians

A fictional Apple has all the same properties of an Apple, but its not like you can eat it

A fictional world can have insanely structured and cohesive lore that you can care about deeply, but it didn’t happen

patent tiger
#

The Not is like worldbuilding in a ttrpg...

magic mason
#

Originally the warmains desmene was in perfect harmony forever and always

Now it is in crisis forever and always, due to the presence of creation

#

Things like Eide for strategists and mimics and the red arcs of Warmains and Deceivers very much give the Impression of them as characters to me

#

Like the way a fictional character is distinct from a real person

#

The fundamental ways

restive ridge
#

The Not is one of those medias that shouldnt have had a fandom (Creation)

magic mason
#

Even more minor things

Like the way Not-Things look the way you expect them to look, rather than having a defined appearance , gives them the impression of something born from the written word

#

Or well

Operating on its logic

narrow tartan
#

I figure. Things in the not do change gradually but it can change backwards or side to side as well

#

And it tends to be indeterminate

#

Or something

#

Strategists definitely have wide dreams

#

Deceivers I guess have deep dreams

#

While Warmains have long dreams

#

Mimics have tall dreams

fleet harbor
#

I just focus on the fact that in the Not things are Of Themselves

#

In Creation, an apple is an apple because the whole rest of Creation looks at it and says, “apple”

#

There’s a web of connections and relationships in which the apple is intermeshed; a sequence of properties and causal connections that make it an apple in the context of the whole rest of Creation

#

A not-apple, on the other hand, sees itself and says “apple”

#

Or, well, “not-apple”

#

It is lit with its own inner light

#

Not given form by the light of the sun

fleet harbor
#

It simply isn’t an apple

#

That’s all

#

Not-things have specific relationships to each other, whereas things are all related to each other

narrow tartan
#

Hmm. I lack inner light

fleet harbor
#

I think there’s something deeply wonderful about being part of something vast and strange and complicated, and that’s the virtue of Creation that the Not fails to understand

candid compass
gloomy oasis
#

I thought of a potential pState for a Deceiver. The Multiple Choice Past of [Name]:

  • ...is different each time.
  • ...explains their current skills and talents.
  • ...has other people who encountered them then.
  • ...takes a while to explain.
    And I'm not sure about the others. Any suggestions?
magic mason
#

Both Because applying that offensively is good and because I love deceivers with a bit of angst

#

I still think about how (Those who listen to Coriander Hasp) started off as soldiers under his command that he was forced to execute and one of the properties is (Thinks he is kinda hot)

gloomy oasis
#

Yeah, I was thinking something like how all their enemies are from their past, even if it overlaps with the third property.

narrow tartan
#

Blehp

#

Uhhh.
Pathfinder adventure and it turns out that the evil cult is worshipping Coriander Hasp

magic mason
#

I had a stroke of inspiration

narrow tartan
#

Inception but the dead wife is a Deceiver.

#

Or strategist. Which. Is really screwed up

narrow tartan
#

What miraculous arcs would make most interesting fight anime power system if you included all the greebles.

vivid wraith
#

Gatecrasher sets up a whole hidden world's capabilities, not just yourself

#

and also it's Fate

#

so

#

historically demonstrated juice

narrow tartan
#

nodnod fair enough

#

I had the thought about Called Away. And. You could twist it into a fight scene where both people summon an otherworld

#

And are trying to get in an advantageous positiob

obsidian dagger
#

That's how some xianxia goes

narrow tartan
#

I feel like. This is the best summation of deceivers

obsidian dagger
#

...I was going to suggest Reality Syndrome, but that's not a power system. It's like the kind of thing where you have powers that are not part of a system.

narrow tartan
obsidian dagger
#

Honestly, Qualia the Purple is just Deceiver romance?

obsidian dagger
#

Thinking about Yomi no Tsugai/Demons of the Shadow Realm and slight spoilers but ||Break is really just the World-Breaker's Hand isn't it?||

#

||And Seal might be as well, honestly.||

narrow tartan
#

Nobles probably know that there is a thing that kills strategists. Like. "Yeah she turns to chocolate and eats herself" but it is not seen as a flaw in creation.

frank light
#

They are aware of banes and curses

#

And can intuit that creation itself rejects strategists

#

But they don’t tend to follow that into “so the world is wrong”

#

Cus it is possible that the world isn’t wrong! Who knows

Strategists are rejected by the world, that much can be seen to be true

#

But there isn’t much evidence from the noble perspective that the strategist pov is true

narrow tartan
#

okay

fleet harbor
#

They don’t perceive The Glitch, but they can perceive the tooth man just fine

obsidian dagger
#

this is barely comprehensible, thank you

#

meanwhie this is happening in general

vivid wraith
fleet harbor
#

Dogs wish to save the world, obviously

obsidian dagger
obsidian dagger
#

I honestly think Qualia the Purple highlights all the Deceiver arcs? It definitely has a great example of Deceiver Awakening.

obsidian dagger
#

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TYIg36-F2YY is this Creature of the Light? (I need to listen to more of the Dear Hunter stuff for sure.)

The Dear Hunter's 'Act V: Hymns With The Devil In Confessional' is available now. Get the album here: https://bit.ly/tdh-merch

Lyrics:
Open-eyed oversight led me to here
Looking for an avenue to simply appear
One too many steps into the wrong direction
Leading me to throw up my hands

Soon, I'll know exactly where I stand
Found in a flood of in...

▶ Play video
#

I saw it associated with Leonardo de Montreal also, and it could be Wounded Angel also.

obsidian dagger
#

I have no idea what this is.

#

Creature of Delirum? Creature of the Light? Primordial? Wounded Angel?

narrow tartan
#

Hmm. Using Extraction for therapuetic purposes

obsidian dagger
#

Very possible! Most Creatures of Delirium think this is ultimately what they're doing but it is entirely within the realm of possibility for them to be right.

#

I would suggest watching Artiswitch for something resembling an example, but it has some real CWs for suicidal imagery/discussion and isn't the sort of thing to watch if you're in a bad headspace.

obsidian dagger
#

...what happens if a Noble loves someone prior to their enNoblement?

restive ridge
#

Better swear it isnt the case anymore

frank light
narrow tartan
#

Hmm. Ideas and headcanons. How often to redo them

#

Probably when you start a new game

obsidian dagger
obsidian dagger
#

...this is fascinating, uses a lot of specialized vocabulary I don't fully understand, and I still don't know if holes are real.

magic mason
#

@obsidian dagger for your consideration for creature of delirium song
https://youtu.be/3PuMk6e24I8?si=B5PDgHujFMG_6fo3

'Whisper' from the 2014 EP 'Melodies for the Outsiders' available on iTunes here: http://t.co/wl6oseKV01

Lyrics -
Come in sit down sweet angel leave me all your tears
Tell me all of your troubles the weight of your
short years
Love is only a river drowning all of your cheer
Sell me all of your laughter and I will take some of
your fear
His fav...

▶ Play video
patent tiger
#

This one's a classic

magic mason
#
So give me your fire 
give me your fear 
give me your faith when love gives you tears
Give me your heart
give me your fate 
give me your hand when love gives you hate
Give me your prayers up on your feet and I'll give you a show 
it helps fill the seats
So give me your sins 
give me your lies 
but whisper your love
And I'll whisper mine
narrow tartan
fleet harbor
#

Dying of being spider man

narrow tartan
#

Dying of reboots

vivid wraith
#

dying of youth

obsidian dagger
#

this is just how Horizon works

narrow tartan
#

Ended up thinking about weird world where history runs backwards

#

Possibly. Populate it with shapes

restive ridge
#
The Trials of Red Desire:
-Escalate in Intensity
-Help Red Desire grow stronger
-Cast beloved ones as opponents
-Are always surmountable
-Posess a higher purpose
-Go well with an expresso martini
-Deny good-rest
vivid wraith
narrow tartan
#

I am contemplating renaming the glitch miraculous arcs based on random aesthetic preferences

#

Allegory becomes Archetype

#

Monsttous becomes Dire

#

Gatecrasher and Wounded Angel are replaced by Gaslighter and Girlbosser.

fleet harbor
#

Snrrrk

fleet harbor
#

Reposting from #av-club

vivid wraith
#

Incredible

gloomy oasis
#

I just realized why Glitch is about Strategists, and why the Riders Abstinence Society has so many more of them than Deceivers or Warmains.

#

The starting point for Strategists is "This whole world is rotten and I should burn it." So if one discovers something worthwhile about Creation, that's the first step in ceasing to wage war against it.