#Warhammer and Such

1 messages · Page 71 of 1

jaunty dawn
#

also limited to visible targets

#

black templars transports got extra capacity??? wild

#

ah no thats a space marine wide thing, interesting

#

enables full bladeguard + character in an impulsor

#

all greater daemons now have an aura of shadow of chaos

#

swolf detachment gets one free oath at the start of the game

#

ooh tyranids

#

synapse now gives +1 s in melee, shadow in the warp battleshock tests are now at -1 if a synapse creature is within 6"

#

-2 when combined with neurotyrant might be enough to push that into a real ability?

#

neurotyrant can join zoanthropes and neurolictor are now synapse creatures

#

as are broodlord and parasite

#

tunneling stuff got vanguard organism

#

gunbeast buffs but I don't have any of those lol

#

this is kinda wild but I think actually makes sense?

#

devastating wounds are back to being mortal wounds, but hazardous and devestating mortal wounds do not rollover at all

#

so all the fnps against mortal wounds have been fixed but devestating wounds still just gets past armour saves

#

indirect cannot hit on better than a 4+ regardless of bonuses!

#

that is to say unmodified 1-3

#

hazardous is also now just always 3 mortal wounds regardless of keywords thanks to the no-rollover rule

#

idk if that affects anything off the top of my head but any 4 wound plasma infantry, rejoice

mental birch
#

Non roll lover?

jaunty dawn
#

if they kill a model all remaining mortal wounds from that source are lost

#

command reroll has been 'fixed' for fast rolling so you don't have to do the 'save a dice incase I need a reroll' thing and we can go back to the intuitive way before ppl pointed out it was cheating xP

#

tank shock is now based on toughness rather than a melee weapon, and is one vehicle model specifically

#

heroic intervention is now 1 cp!

#

quality rules writing

#

(means lion, gulliman, and cawl are treated as infantry for this stuff despite being monsters)

jaunty dawn
#

hierodules just got removed from tyranid index? fucked up

tired cairn
#

I hate that primarch/cawl exception lmao

tired cairn
#

Also, I was not expecting the generic Tyranid buffs. That's neat

jaunty dawn
#

only because it no longer breaks like almost every ability designed to be anti psychic lol

#

tyranid buffs are big. strength breakpoints are such a big part of the game

#

the admech stuff is fun too

tired cairn
#

AdMech have figured out how to use the firing deck on the Dunerider! Perhaps one day they will learn to use the assault ramp

zinc field
#

Zoanthrope + neurotyrant is actually going to be nasty. 3 lascannons hitting on 2’s, with +1 to wound if you battleshock the target, and rerolls if you have an exocrine

#

And battleshock is now easier

tired cairn
#

Oh man, I totally forgot about the Neurotyrant's leader ability lmao

zinc field
#

Zoans also heal if someone gets battleshocked within 6”

tired cairn
#

If that happens, something has gone very wrong for the Zoanthroapes

zinc field
#

Lol true

spice flicker
#

Neurotyrant being able to attach to zoans could have been the only thing for nids in the new updated and I'd be happy, all the other stuff is just delicious extra stuff.

#

Like the fact that thr tyrannofex's lotto gun now can get precision

tired cairn
#

The damage change to the rupture cannon is so nice

#

Also, did they add Doctrina Imperatives to everything but the robots (and datasmith)?

#

Yes. That's hilarious and dumb

#

Why not just let them move through walls GW:

#

It's weird they buffed the hive tyrant on foot and not the swarmlord

spice flicker
#

Kinda want to see about building a 500 point list centered on a neurotyrant+zoans now

thin ibex
tired cairn
#

Are ripper swarms now the only unit that don't have a straightfoward points scaling by multiple of models?

#

Which is a funny change now that there isn't any point in taking them

jaunty dawn
#

no there's a few

jaunty dawn
thin ibex
jaunty dawn
#

the base has to fit

thin ibex
#

I don't know that the sw change makes it better than just taking storm lance or Ironstorm, however it means you're no longer the only Detachment who has to earn having a Detachment rule

#

Honestly I'd have thought they'd just add a separate, lighter rules effect instead of handing one over for free

tired cairn
#

Can you still only earn one at a time? That seemed like an annoying restriction

thin ibex
#

I believe so

tired cairn
#

Oh, and I guess they were willing to basically improve the BS value of AdMech by 1 across the board

thin ibex
#

I can't decide if army wide sustained hits 1 or fnp 6 is stronger to start with sw

upper bluff
#

Not necessarily. You only get bs 3 in protector imperative which means no bonus ap

#

So it makes it a choice instead of conqueror for objectives and protector for everything else

tired cairn
#

Oh, that is withing 6" of your own units not the enemy whoops lol

#

Yeah, it does make it harder to justify Conqueror if you aren't a melee army

spice flicker
#

As someone else explained it, the changes foe tyranids are spicy

thin ibex
#

I need to look myself but I'm kinda looking these changes overall

#

Now to wait for them to hit new recruit and wahapedia

spice flicker
#

And battlescribe

thin ibex
#

Any changes to the votann?

tired cairn
#

New Recruit and Battlescribe use the same datasource iirc

#

Man, not only did the swarmlord not get buffed, it also got nerfed lol

spice flicker
#

I mean swarmy is the punching bag of the nids so makes unfortunate sense

#

The fact that nexus and Vanguard got such a buff for nids might bring them back on the radar for me

tired cairn
#

... am I dumb? I don't see the mortal wound change anywhere

paper bluff
#

As a custodes player, I am now moisturized. Not longer begging for crumbs

thin ibex
#

the regenerating unit as once per battle was probably necessary

#

the change to custode's auric champions is like one little text change that makes it SO MUCH MORE useable

#

and its probably actually good now

#

say hello to the vertus praetors being led by shield captain on one actually being threatening all around to chosen targets

paper bluff
thin ibex
#

im kinda sad they didn't change the strength profile of hte eradication beamer

#

or attacks, between the two modes

#

but i wont complain about more attacks

#

the twin onager phosphor guns might legitimately be quite threatening now

#

it has similar attack volume to something like a reaper gladiator, but also keeps twin linked and ignores cover

paper bluff
#

I have never fought an admech army and saw a whole large army in the used army case at one of the game stores i go to

#

Some one might actually buy that now

#

I like that knights can go through buildings now

thin ibex
#

imp guard detachment means no lethal hits for infantry against monsters and vehicles, and no lethal hits from squadron units against infantry

paper bluff
#

The pivot rule seems like it'll take getting used to. But functionally what does it do

thin ibex
#

BA gets +2 str on the charge now? That's new?

paper bluff
thin ibex
#

doesnt say it doesn't stack with lance right?

paper bluff
#

I should say it's like the WE charge ability

#

That's +1 strength +1 attack on the charge

thin ibex
#

ba be getting +2 str +1 attack

#

potentially stacking with hte lance keyword as well?

#

DA inner circle's detchment rule change seems cool

#

deathwatch detachment change will make running hard into bolters cool

#

step aside imperial fists, there now stands TWO bolter marine armies

#

bolter aggressors seem a bit firghtening

#

with access to anti infantry 2+

#

what weas the knight faction ability before this change btw?

#

votann changes are tiny, only really affect the onslaught mode; but also you get a cp for kiling grudge targets

#

0 changes to tau

#

sadge

jaunty dawn
#

think the ba was there last time

tired cairn
jaunty dawn
#

technically it's an errata to the core rules directly

#

coupled with the removal of the dataslate making devestating wounds not mortals

tired cairn
#

Yeah, but it should be in the dataslate like the movement changes!

spice flicker
#

Hmmm... for the upcoming crusade that starts at 500 points but goes up should I go with infantry+tank spam guard, chaos knight war dog (which are battleline) spam, or something with tyranids (nexus, Vanguard, invasion, or crusher if so?)

zinc field
#

New Tyranids look spicy

#

Actually hang on - the OOE and Carnifex brick with is going to have str 8 deathspitters in synapse. That’s a pretty big breakpoint

spice flicker
#

You're right

paper bluff
#

Go tyranids for fun

spice flicker
#

Aye but besides neurotyrant+zoan what should I take at 500 pts?

zinc field
tired cairn
#

Though full deathspitter carnies + OOE were pretty fun already

#

Though now that the hive tyrant gives lethal hits, the higher attack one might be fun

zinc field
#

Reading comprehension😔

tired cairn
#

Strength 5 genestealers though

#

Especially now that you don't have to spend 20 points to give the broodlord synapse

desert jay
#

A strat with "Unending" in the name being 1/battle is pretty funny IMO

tired cairn
#

Slightly Longer to End Horde

spice flicker
#

So sentinels are both Regiment and squadron meaning they get lethal hits against all things pretty much. At 1125 for 18 (9/9) sentinels, that still leaves room for the stormlord anti-everything party bus plus some spare points

#

To go plasma or Las with the sentinels?

paper bluff
#

I wonder how quick auspex tactics will have his dataslate video up

#

Nothing yet but I bet he will by 3 hours from now

spice flicker
#

A lot changed so it could take him a minute

paper bluff
#

He didn't have a video up after 45 minutes. terrible channel, 0 outta 5. Smh

#

day ruined, sun burnt out James buff my favorite factions and nerf all others

#

Jk of course. Yeah there's alot to cover

spice flicker
#

Sentinel escort for the party bus

Combined Regiment
1990/2000 points

Cadian castellan, warlord, power fist, plasma pistol

1x10 cadian shock troops
1x20 infantry squad, two lascannons

3x3 heavy weapon squads, lascannons

3x3 armored sentinels, plasma cannons, sentinel chainsaws, hunter killer missiles
3x3 scout sentinels, lascannons, sentinel chainsaws, hunter killer missiles
Stormlord, 4 lascannons, 5 heavy bolters, 2 heavy stubbers, vulcan mega bolter

#

Look we don't have an AT-AT for the Imperial Guard yet so this is the closest we can get to the Endor garrison in the Imperial Guard by having one heavy armored transport proxy for another.

desert jay
#

Huh, Skitarii Rangers and Vanguard are still <100 points even with the big army rule buff

rocky shale
#

Aledari got slapped pretty hard for being at like 52%WR ouchy

#

The 4+ minimum for indirect hurts dark reapers a surprising amount, and point increases for pretty much all the good aspects

#

War walker gang stays winning

paper bluff
#

The custodes discord: thriving having a wonderful timedab
Necrons discord: BlazinTrazyn what happened to my forge world units....

spice flicker
#

The custodes discord crusade is actually the one I'm prepping for currently

past sphinx
floral herald
#

Wow what a pile of changes

#

This is kinda a 10.5 in scale I think

past sphinx
#

so martial mastery just happens every single turn now?

#

nice

spice flicker
past sphinx
#

good to see its still the only detachment worth even glancing at

past sphinx
spice flicker
#

So you're going the tank+infantry route?

past sphinx
#

gonna try to go for an infantry supported by armor but the whole thing is built around a stormhammer

spice flicker
#

I was debating that, infantry+transports (not anymore on that), or sentinel spam.

spice flicker
#

Also considering nids now

floral herald
#

Glad to see big changes to factions who need it

#

Little sad the CSM part of it is just point nerfs

#

But I think we gain a lot from the changes to strategem discounts

spice flicker
#

Nids got nearly everything they wanted for months but at the cost of swarmy being dunked on as per tradition.

#

Indirect fire is now dead since it always misses on an unmodified roll of 1-3

tired cairn
#

Ugh, why aren't things like that in the balance dataslate

#

Did they even mention it in the overview?

floral herald
#

1 way shooting is still strong even if it is harder to buff

#

It did get hit harder in the guards detachment but that's a separate thing

jaunty dawn
#

theoretically the difference is that the core rule changes are like permanent unless overruled

#

and you can technically play without the balance slate?

#

contrasting the core rule changes with like, the -cp change I think it's kinda a thing of like

#

the battle tactic rule didn't work out, so they're trialing a -1 cp rule instead

#

whereas they've now committed to devestating wound change, though it takes a different form to solve issues with the trial implementation

#

it's all kinda semantic

#

but that's the logic behind it

tired cairn
#

I hate it lol

#

I want a changelog and a collected list

#

The movement change is in both >:|

jaunty dawn
#

wow mega heals

tired cairn
#

Though I'd probably be less annoyed if they linked it in the main article

jaunty dawn
#

went from 1 at the start of Your hero phase to d3 at the end of Both turns

tired cairn
# jaunty dawn

Are wounds more likely to be spread between units in AoS?

jaunty dawn
#

woods can be killed now though I suppose

#

treesong being locked to the sylvaneth lore probably makes lore a non-choice haha

#

oh interesting

#

I think this is the first recursion rule to address single model units

tired cairn
#

Are all single model units definitionally monsters?

jaunty dawn
#

no

#

don't think there's any multimodel monsters in sylvaneth though

lofty warren
floral herald
#

I think it mostly matters for charge shenanigans

#

GW heed my cry bring back front and fear facing

tired cairn
#

Pivots always mattered for movement, though I was always unclear how you were supposed to measure lol

#

It only matters for like, tanks and oval bases

#

I thought it would be mostly matters for going through weird gaps. But I really shouldn't underestimate charge shenanigans

paper bluff
floral herald
#

I like how Sheavy walkers can smash through terrain now

#

Big QoL for a lot of people but especially knights

spice flicker
#

Debating between nids, generic guard+tanks, death korps sentinel spam, or see if I can make Tempestus Scions focused army work

thin ibex
#

would it be safe to assume polearms are used more often by space marines than depicted?

storm schooner
#

Considering they're depicted as using polearms almost never probably. I think they've got rules in HH but I can't think of any actual art of them using them or anything

junior robin
#

the white scars biker upgrade came with a spear iirc

spice flicker
#

Now all power weapons are the same so you can kitbash a power spear or power Halberd if you want.

storm schooner
#

Yeah White Scars have unique lances, I think Khans can still get them in 10th

thin ibex
#

So as far a I know the dark angels sometimes have halberds, the white scars have spears/ lances, death watch have a halberd, minotaur chapter master has a spear

floral herald
#

I think that's reasonable since a big part of why they don't is that long weapons are hard to model well

#

But also I think space marines generally favor one handed weapons so I don't think there's a huge number of them

thin ibex
#

yeah i figure it'd be something all marines train with, because you know, generalized weapon mastery good; but that in most cases a spear or polearm would be used by more specialized or personalized individuals

#

you might see it more, say, in the wolfguard

#

Victrix Guard use axes right?

past sphinx
#

just powerswords i think?

#

atleast nowadays

thin ibex
#

i think i have the older version in mind

past sphinx
#

i think the old honor guard kit had poweraxes but GW hates that anything other than powerswords are used

thin ibex
#

i thought it was kind of a cool affectation for there being power axe guys in the UM

#

as like a prestige position and weapon

#

that probably had some kind of cultural weight

past sphinx
#

im not sure why basically all other weapons besides the powersword and chainsword have been culled

thin ibex
#

well power fists are still a thing

past sphinx
#

true

thin ibex
#

or do you mean like as far as power weapons being printed/sold

floral herald
#

Lore wise the Axes of Ultramar are a victrix guard thing I think

#

But model wise they have swords (boo)

past sphinx
#

theres like 3 power axes in the range

#

an upgrade kit with a kinda wonk looking lightning claw

#

and i dont think primaris have thunder hammers at all

#

though BT have a single power maul in the brethren kit

#

homeboy got given the dollar store lighting claws

thin ibex
#

intercessor sarge can have a th

#

nut dont know wher it comes from

#

but*

past sphinx
#

hmm yeah its not on the sprue from what i can see

#

ah the salamanders upgrade kit

thin ibex
#

lol isuppose thats fitting

compact gate
#

you know, for once, I am extremely glad i was completely fucking wrong

#

we're so fucking back!

desert jay
#

Custodes kinda took the hat of "the ones with pole weapons" regardless of if it'd make sense for others to use them too

thin ibex
#

i always thought the GK were the poster boys for marine polearms tbh

#

but custodes got it going on too

#

also gk have more options i suppose, or had

floral herald
#

GK were more that before they got other weapon options in 5e IMO

desert jay
#

Due to Poorhammer I keep thinking of GK as "the ones who used to have Nemesis Daemon Hammers and now don't"

thin ibex
#

they still look sick with the halberd

#

at least

floral herald
#

for sure

unreal cosmos
past sphinx
#

if they had just a little more mass to them id be more partial to them

#

they just kinda look like wolverine claws from walmart to me

lucid scarab
#

Reading Infinite and Divine has given me the itch for a Retro Geezer academic necron

past sphinx
#

i know what it is, its that thyre attached to the forearm

paper bluff
paper bluff
lucid scarab
paper bluff
lucid scarab
#

Going to need to eventually get a few of these guys as an honor guard for this fella

paper bluff
#

i always meant to skulpt a res orb in into the one with the broken hand

floral herald
#

Oh damn those are some ooooldcrons

paper bluff
#

I tried to make a deal with a guy to get his OG immortals he said nah

floral herald
#

real

lucid scarab
#

I’ve got to finish my Retro nid collection first, but after that I’ll be after a couple oldcrons for my menagerie

tired cairn
#

Big Guns Never Tire is worded to allow the Neurotyrant give zoanthropes it (but I think it's very unintended given how models are sometimes referenced in those rules)

desert jay
#

There's a few other Nid monsters that could already lead infantry, weren't there?

tired cairn
#

Nothing that could shoot

desert jay
#

Oh, Tyrant Guard can't shoot. Hah

jaunty dawn
#

weirdly it gives them big guns never tire but not the penalty of big guns never tire

tired cairn
#

Yeah lol

#

Clearly everyone is too distracted by the big scary monster to dodge the zoanthropes

paper bluff
#

As a custodes and world eaters player, if I'm not charging you, I've done something wrong

jaunty dawn
#

wonder if thats why it didnt already lead zoanthropes and they just forgot/no longer care

pine matrix
floral herald
#

They're just such fun little assholes

#

I could say the same but for my CSM

pine matrix
#

If this is the Most Awful And Worst Setting Ever why not play the greatest bastards in that setting?

pine matrix
jaunty dawn
#

this is why I play word bearers

paper bluff
solemn gull
tired cairn
#

We can go older:

#

The middle one was so goofy

jaunty dawn
#

wuh

desert jay
#

Shit, deleted the wrong message while aiming for mine

#

Sorry

jaunty dawn
#

lmaooo

#

no worries

#

pokemon (user was banned for this post)

pine matrix
#

Off Topic!!! Mods!!!! Mods!!!!!!!!

jaunty dawn
#

I like this a lot more than the modern

floral herald
tired cairn
jaunty dawn
tired cairn
#

oh, huh

jaunty dawn
#

you have these shield wing things instead

#

and I'm not a fan!

floral herald
#

I kinda dig the new tyrant guard for similar reasons as those old biovores

tired cairn
#

I think they should have gone more centaur instead of weird dedicated feet hands

upper bluff
#

Big gorilla arms?

tired cairn
#

The really old ones were pretty funny:

#

I kind of liked the shield (whcih was a ranged weapon lol)

jaunty dawn
#

tyranids had this weird thing where they made a bunch of finecast models in 5th ed (venomthropes and hive guard) and then immediately deprecated them in favour of new dual kits like a year later

#

but never did the obvious pyrovore/biovore one

floral herald
#

DNA is stored in the pauldrons

paper bluff
#

Finecast... BAH!

still warren
#

Pre-order Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2: https://store.focus-entmt.com/w/warhammer40000spacemarine2?utm_campaign=SM2_GameplayOverview&utm_medium=post&utm_source=YouTube

We're incredibly excited to unveil a new detailed Gameplay Trailer!
Narrated by the game’s Creative Director, Oliver Hollis-Leick, this 6-minute Gameplay Overview Trailer div...

▶ Play video
floral herald
#

ooh a hubworld

pastel rampart
tired cairn
#

They Tyranid Warrior took a lot of plasma blasts to the face

thin ibex
#

ima be playing a reiver i tell you h-what

lucid scarab
#

Removable ejection cloud on the top.

#

It fits on the 80mm round base of Biovores in 10th edition now

#

There he is next to the original 2e version

finite compass
paper bluff
lucid scarab
paper bluff
#

Really just the retro cyptek would be great! Lol

solemn gull
#

@floral herald dunno if I’ve ever asked you this but do you prefer DH1 or DH2

floral herald
#

So I prefer DH1 but I have brainworms around it and a lot of house rules

#

So I don't know that this means that you should prefer it as well

solemn gull
#

Understandable I can’t decide. DH2 seems like it was better written but it never really got to bloom.

#

Meanwhile DH1 is rough but has so many splats and so much stuff

south axle
#

I kinda preferred 2nd Ed over 1st Ed

floral herald
#

DH2 is a much better put together game in most respects but I like some of the quirks for 1e and really prefer the psychic rules in it

past sphinx
#

DH1 was some of the most comprehensive lore dumping the setting had seen at the time and had the kinda fiddly mechanics i adore

#

but boy

#

i would never make my friends play it

finite compass
#

My favorite thing about DH1

#

Is that a psyker had a 1 in 400 chance of just fucking dying every time they used their powers.

floral herald
#

It could potentially be higher!

#

And in very rare situations could be lower

finite compass
#

Well maybe not favorite but it was certainly the thing that seemed to come up the most

#

Also the setting was great. The stuff with the Tyrant Star was just chef's kiss

#

I think a lot of the problem to begin with was everybody was expecting Eisenhorn: the Ravenoring, and what we got initially with 1e was WFRP in Space.

desert jay
#

I remember someone talking about a DH campaign where in the campaign villain's first "on-screen" appearance they fail a perils roll and die and the whole thing derails

spice flicker
#

Thoughts on this?

500 pts Scions
Combined Regiment
500/500 pts

Militarum Tempestus Command Squad, command rod, master vox, medi-pack, hot-shot volley gun, plasma gun, warlord

2x10 Tempestus Scions, vox-caster, 2x volley guns, 2x meltaguns
1x5 tempestus Scions, vox-caster, volley gun, melta gun

2x taurox primes, Storm bolter, twin autocannons, taurox missile launcher

desert jay
#

You can't fit a 10-scion unit plus command squad in a taurox prime but otherwise seems fine for 500pts

spice flicker
#

That's what the five man squad is for. I need something to hold the rear objective sometimed and that's the one to do it if they're not busy deepstriking.

desert jay
#

Also AFAICT can't make use of the command rod

#

Oh I missed the 5-man

spice flicker
#

Might out them in valkyrie or another taurox in the future.

jaunty dawn
#

oh yeah not enough orders for the command rod to do anything

#

in this list

#

other than with stratagems I guess

spice flicker
#

Well the command rod let's it give two different orders to the same time though you might be right in that there isn't enough officers.

jaunty dawn
#

command rod lets the unit receive two different orders

#

the tempestor still only gives one though

#

I don't think more officers is really gonna happen efficiently at 500 pts though

spice flicker
#

Not with scions

#

But would changing the command rod to a plasma pistol make this a good list to go with?

desert jay
upper canopy
jaunty dawn
#

ooooh

spice flicker
#

Hmmm... to take lord solar in the future for the crusade or nah....

jaunty dawn
#

awesome

thin ibex
#

personally i wouldnt take lord solar even tho he's amazing

#

cause he cant earn xp

jaunty dawn
#

I'd probably just add a stopgap +1 order battle honor

#

for crusade

#

while the codex isn't out

thin ibex
#

also i just love the idea of a command squd with a ogryn bg and a militarum attaches as my like central command hierarchy during a crusade

#

I do kinda wish they had a Lord General model rather than just a platoon command squd tho

jaunty dawn
#

generic horse man

#

tried to google leontus centaur to see if anyone had made that

#

just came up with a bunch of people making command centaurs (the guard vehicle) to proxy as him

#

which is a cool idea

still warren
brittle salmon
#

Man I'm still dumbfounded Rhinos of any stripe are 75 points

#

I remember the good old days of 35 point metal boxes

floral herald
#

It’s honestly really weird for me too

#

I guess they were too much of a no brainer?

upper canopy
#

In 10th's meta I'd be REALLY surprised at 35 point rhinos

#

related

brittle salmon
#

I'm not saying they should be 35 now, but being 75 points when a Chimera is just 80

#

It feels very off

floral herald
#

Yeah it’s weird for me too

#

I’d expect more like 50-60 maybe

thin ibex
#

I invasive its cause of what rhinos carry

#

Like a rhino can be carrying a melta gun and a lascannon via firing deck, and a bunch of 2 wound, 3+ models

#

While the chimera gets some guys at 1w and a s3 gun, and doesn't get anything stronger than str 6

floral herald
#

They carried that stuff back when they were 35 pts tbf

thin ibex
#

sm had 1 wound back then

#

😛

floral herald
#

What stuff is allowed in a chimera these days?

#

Hard to find on waha

jaunty dawn
#

pretty much any infantry

#

it can firing deck heavy weapon teams too

floral herald
#

No more 4x special weapon veteran squads these days though

solemn gull
floral herald
#

Yes honestly

#

But its in a module so no one knows

solemn gull
#

I need to get some more DH modules

#

The ones I’ve got from a humble bundle were fun

thin ibex
#

I still need to buck up and actually run WanG

brittle salmon
past sphinx
#

its uhh well kinda mid

brittle salmon
#

lmao

floral herald
#

That's also my recollection it wasn't as cool as the lore theories

past sphinx
#

Folks the Fw spears and FW terminators are now heavily discounted

lucid scarab
#

Shipment of goods arrived

finite compass
#

TBF, the Haarlock explanation sucks

floral herald
#

SM2 multiplayer chapter/legion skins

finite compass
#

They've got my boys

#

I am satisfied.

#

Though not my Tabletop army

floral herald
#

I'm a little confused by all the stuff marked 6

finite compass
#

It should really be Ave Domine Noctum, but Warhammer is always funny with the NotLatin

uneven ember
#

SPACE SHARKS!

past sphinx
#

sharks but no blood angels?

#

iron hands

dense sedge
#

No tsons?

past sphinx
#

hats to big to ride

#

thought this is probably a small slice tbh i cant fathom releasing a customizer for space marines and not even having all the main legions

#

theres not even an ultramarines badge there and the feckin games about the blueboys

floral herald
#

If its like SM1 (which it may not be) these would be like special model changing skins

#

While UMs and such might be represented with normal armor customization

thin ibex
#

I am not ashamed to say I'd spend the real dollars to be a space wolf reiver

#

You know, one thing I'm a fan of BA for is being able to bring a chainsword focused army and it working well

finite compass
floral herald
#

That might make them the default tbf

past sphinx
#

this is just the heraldry editor

#

weird to crop out literally everything else in the image

floral herald
#

oh lol that explains a bit

thin ibex
#

There a mp horde mode too right?

past sphinx
#

4 player PVE from what it seemed

floral herald
#

Yeah coop horde mode and pvp

#

I had some hopes for a pvpve but its probably out of scope

#

Space marine extraction shooter with oodles of tyranid mobs

tardy vault
#

I'm old school and prefer good old team deathmatch

floral herald
#

Well, you'll likely get that

tardy vault
#

They explicitly called it out

floral herald
#

IIRC SM1 was TDM, 3 point control, and some kind of KOTH

paper bluff
tardy vault
#

tho, I lied and generally like the objective modes (which they also will have)

floral herald
#

I think there was a weird assassin/juggernaut mode

tardy vault
#

The 6 classes for the PvE mode

paper bluff
#

I'm so bulwark

tardy vault
#

Yes you get the shield

#

And also a buff banner

floral herald
#

what fhe fug

#

why "heavy" and not "devastator" lol

paper bluff
#

look i assume the normie market would be small, but it would be there

brittle salmon
#

i am heavy weapons marine

#

and this

#

is my weapon

remote wharf
#

Because you're a Primaris, Primaris don't have devastators, yet.

finite compass
#

I hope they do what they did with the first one

#

And have a Chaos PvE mode

past sphinx
#

Enforcers responing in refurbished Venators? are they poor or something?

#

Its a specially modified Astartes rhino outfitted with spaced armor, firing decks and stormbolters what could it cost Brother Michael? ten thousand thrones?

floral herald
uneven ember
remote wharf
floral herald
#

Given that is a devastator marine pictured I certainly don't agree lol

brittle salmon
#

That's a goofy justification when Devastator is right there

floral herald
thin ibex
#

I'm gonna want to love vanguard but I'll probably play more bulwark or tactical

#

It's probably a fluency thing, like the vanguard isn't called a reiver.

#

Though personally, devastator is pretty descriptive too

#

But heavy reads better into a role I'd hazard

tired cairn
floral herald
#

Maybe if Games Workshop named their PDFs they'd mess them up less lol

desert jay
floral herald
#

You know that's fair

#

That's the most likely reason for "heavy"

desert jay
#

Like if you're looking at Primaris unit loadouts, it's Intercessor, Assault Intercessor, Reiver, Bladeguard, Eliminator, Heavy Intercessor

tired cairn
#

Oooh nooo, the rules between matched play and the core rules are written differently for pivoting rules

floral herald
#

Oh?

tired cairn
#

This refers to base the model is on, whereas the core rules are if it is a vehicle or monster :/

soft willow
#

It hits bike units and some other weird base sizes.

tired cairn
#

I just don't understand why they have two different rules

floral herald
#

Yeah that's weird

tired cairn
#

It's the reserve rule weirdness all over again

peak olive
#

What’s the difference between Red Box warcry and Orange Box warcry

#

I know nobody posts warcry but still

mental birch
#

There's a 25 point Enhancement that does nothing

peak olive
#

Ah

floral herald
#

Afaik there’s no way to trigger Puretide Engram Neurochip now

tired cairn
#

Oh lol

#

I'm not sure where they wrote the rule exactly, but it's reflected in the app: unit restrictions for the divergent chapters is now independent of detachment choice

jaunty dawn
#

i think the idea is that in non competetive minded play they dont expect people to abuse bike bases

#

but its also weird cause. its written like its a rule replacement? so does it still apply to round based monster/vehicles or?

#

nvm went back and checked and theyre actually excluded by the default rule

#

whuch makes sense since theres no reason to pivot a round base

#

in the errata for codex: space marines

#

the space wolves one is really annoying though. like sure they dont have 'apothecaries' but they squatted wolf priests so like???

thin ibex
#

Well, wolf priests have just been chaplains for a few editions now, just that they also had an Apothecary stratagem at one point

jaunty dawn
#

yeah it's been annoying for me a few editions too

desert jay
#

And at the other end, the Deathwatch one is also silly because tacticals are gone but intercessors are fine, devastators are gone but eradicators and hellbasters and desolation mariness are fine...

#

And Deathwatch has primaris kill teams (unit), Fortis and Indomitus and Spectrus

tired cairn
#

Though poorly implemented, having unit restrictions across all of the divergent chapters could partially address the complaints about them being strictly superior to compliant ones

#

Though my ridiculous idea would be to have separate points costs for each divergent chapter for the entire range lol

desert jay
#

And Blood Angels and Dark Angels are "yeah take whatever you want battle bro"

desert jay
thin ibex
#

wits true, but sw dont have tac squads or dev lore wise too

desert jay
#

Yeah but all the intercessors/etc that they want

thin ibex
#

thats cause logan convinced the rest of the chapter after being super opposed for a bit

#

to take the primaris reinforcements

solemn gull
#

He probably didn’t want to argue and said “take em” before going back to his nap

tired cairn
#

Maybe they will forget how to use intercessors whenever they get special space wolf ones

desert jay
#

It'd've been funny if the chapter went "okay but only the cool ones"

paper bluff
#

What makes a space work is culture so the wolf spears have to hajj to fenris

uneven ember
spice flicker
#

Thoughts on this 2k bugs list that i feel is almost a hybrid of synaptic nexus and crusher stampede?

Synaptic Nexus

Neurotyrant, warlord, power of the hive mind
Neurotyrant

2x10 hormagaunts

1x11 neurogaunts
2x neurolictors
3x3 zoantropes

3x exocrine
3x haruspex
2x maleceptors
1995/2000 pts

#

Not a lot of screens I know but face tanking has always been fun in the past.

floral herald
#

Which is a little more expensive and gets a multi-melta

#

It's a very strange quirk of 10e space marines that one of the most distinct black templars things is that they just slap multi meltas on everything

tired cairn
#

I would recommend against two neurotyrants and do a 6 strong Zoanthroapes squad

#

I would also be a bit concerned about the relatively low amount of synapse creatures for that detachment

spice flicker
#

Well the Tyrants have the nodes that let them attach to units to give synpase, neurolictors/zoantropes/neurogaunts/maleceptors also all give synpase. Only units without natural synpase would be the gaunts, haruspex, and exocrines.

#

Though I see your point about swapping the 2nd tyrant to upgrade a zoan squad to 6 man.

#

Just afraid of too few characters (been list building for guard too much I think)

uneven ember
#

I guess that is something we've been doing since the OG LR Crusader?

tired cairn
#

Oh, I mean that some of the strats care about the unit providing synapse (e.g. reinforced hive nodes)

#

I think pariah Nexus cares less about having a lot of characters (the Ritual equivalent doesn't need them iirc)

spice flicker
#

Also trying to brainstorm an endgame idea for a crusade that ends at 2000 points so I was seeing if this was worth working towards?

tired cairn
#

It's probably perfectly fine for that tbh. My only caution would be it's unusual to want both 3x haruspexes and 3x exocrines plus the model is easy to magnetize, so you might want to steer away from 6 of them for that reason. But of course if you like how they look that doesn't matter

spice flicker
#

It's on tabletop simulator which is why I was fine taking 3 of each. Their cheap with decent melee and decent shooting respectively for their cost

#

Any suggestions on how to reduce that down to 500 points as a good starting point if that list is the endgame?

pastel rampart
solemn gull
#

I don’t get it?

lofty warren
#

thought

#

tzeentch cultist with knuckle tats that read "CHANGE IS GOOD"

solemn gull
#

Damn the mutation gave him that extra finger just for knuckle tats

upper canopy
#

art of an oc

solemn gull
#

Also I love watching oldhammer

#

It’s so charming when every model has a beer gut or derpy pose

#

I have a second edition marine and the power stance is adorable

spice flicker
desert jay
#

AIUI they were pretty good before too, the point drop is surprising

tired cairn
#

It's not going to be good for them if it's the battle of Endor

spice flicker
#

Well I mean...

tired cairn
#

oh lol

floral herald
#

I always found that comic funny because that’s exactly the type of 40k shit that would crush a semi-armored scout sentinel like a tin can in 40k

tired cairn
#

lol

desert jay
#

Yeah, how many unaugmented soldier-men with combat knives does it take to beat a sentinel? You may pick ones that really good at stabbing, but no dupes of epic heroes, no chainswords, no power weapons

upper canopy
#

I could kill a sentinel by having enough grots punch it to death

tired cairn
#

Really they would probably just tie it up in melee for the entire game

spice flicker
#

Narrowed down my upcoming crusade force to either the 527th (random number chosen) Cadian Armored Battalion (infantry+tanks) or the 105th Rodne Heavy Scout Division (sentinel focused that might be changed to also focus on Death Korps of Kreig but haven't settled yet and thus would be the 105th Krieg instead of 105th Rodne .)

mental birch
#

I've killed a sentinel with kroot carnivores

#

pre codex its veryf unny

#

since they got enough food to have a feel no pain form that

spice flicker
#

Just need to finally stop being indecisiveness and settle for one of them

uneven ember
# spice flicker Well I mean...

So this is still funny to me bc years and years back, with the first Star Wars: Battlefront, I decided to play Empire on Endor because I was in my edgier "teddy bears killing and eating Storm Troopers is goofy and not cool as hell" period
But like five minutes later my friends are giving me shit I've died IDK how many times to unseen brown and grey ewoks in a brown and grey forets & been reduced to wildly firing my blaster into the woods screaming about "RUXPIN IN THE TREES MAN, RUXPIN IN THE FUCKING TREES!"

solemn gull
#

those battlefront teddybears terrified me

thin ibex
#

yeah logs would crush a sentinel

#

i do think in general scifi fiction often overstates the degree to which the scifi hardware is immune to like normal, terrestrial or natural stuff

#

giant rocks stay dangerous to just about anything when they roll down a hill

bright dove
#

Don't forget they're big trees too!

finite compass
#

I mean it's basically a scout vehicle. So that armor's not going to be super thick.

lofty warren
#

logs work on the same principle as power fists

solemn gull
#

I feel like there is a mythbusters episode about this

topaz elk
#

It’d at the very least knock them over

#

Which like, that’s already enough

#

Sentinels don’t look super good at self fighting

finite compass
#

It's a big heavy object hitting a hollow metal box

#

At the very least it's gonna get stove in decently

uneven ember
topaz elk
#

It’s trying really hard but it just makes it worse

#

Eventually it fully flips itself

#

It’s legs shaking in the air

solemn gull
#

It is an actual job in the guard to go around with a recovery vehicle and haul back vehicles. I wonder how much of that is picking up sentinels and putting them on their feet

topaz elk
#

Sentinel pilot angrily recounting the time some tiny bear xeno knocked his sentinel on the ground and he had to wait 8 hours for the guard to toe his thing back to base

uneven ember
#

Just imagining the training a Guard EOD would have to deal with.
"Do not look at the hazardous object. Do not listen to the lies whispered by the hazardous object. After the hazardous object has been neutralized, report to The Room (don't worry about it)"

finite compass
#

On that note. We have an actual canonical recovery vehicle on a Russ chassis

#

I wonder if they make Baneblade chassis super-heavy recovery ones

thin ibex
#

Eod getting trained on how to defuse dynamite alongside aeldari soul bombs

#

Then again, having read the imperial infantryman's uplifting primer, EOD training is probably "do not concern yourself with the traps laid by xenos, heretics, and traitors. Imperial armor is proofed against their weak and faithless weaponry"

floral herald
thin ibex
#

"The pernicious Eldar's weak and unreliable nature translates to their explosives as well, and they often fail to explode alltogether. When they do explode, the thrice blessed hull of an Imperial vehicle and the superior flak armor of the Militarum is proofed against the feeble display.

finite compass
#

"Like their other weaponry, Greenskin explosives are crude and unreliable, often failing to detonate, or causing little more than a harmlesss shower of sparks."

Meanwhile the entire command squad just got wiped by a Bomb Squig

uneven ember
desert jay
#

You get a Knight to drag it like a sled

#

If you're lucky you can put it in neutral and not have to get skids under the treads

uneven ember
#

yes

soft willow
#

Remember that the Admech have several vehicles that are larger than the baneblade by an order of magnitude.

desert jay
#

Look, Titans are too big and important to task with recovery efforts of non-Titans

pastel rampart
uneven ember
#

what would you call a guy who makes bolter rounds
Like a fletcher but for bolters

#

I just really like the idea of a skilled artisan worker going "with a lifetime of practice and skill I can make six functional bolter rounds a day. Seven, on a really good day, if I skip midday meal"

runic swallow
#

That’s probably more for the specialist rounds, especially since even the guard uses heavy bolters pretty extensively

#

Like, there’s the whole mechanicus factory worlds that produce ammo

#

Though, I could see that for the Deathwatch specialist rounds and such

uneven ember
#

Well yeah but also this is 40K, their idea of an auto-loader for city-sized spaceships is a work crew.
Like half the time "automation" means "lobotomized cyborg slaves"

uneven ember
runic swallow
#

I remember reading something talking about guardsmen doing shell scrimshaw (like is common in WWI trench art, though significantly more Space Catholic) with specifically Astartes bolter shell casings

#

And I think it’s sometimes been said that’s illegal lol

plucky token
#

i'm pretty sure there's even stats for such rounds in the Fantasy Flight TTRPGs

solemn gull
#

there are a lot of ammo options in the fantasy flight games

tired cairn
#

In W&G, there are these shotgun shells:

#

I also love this tidbit abotu them:

upper canopy
#

Lmao

#

But yes the astartes shell casing is used as a lucky charm

#

Which will get you killed because non astartes are forbidden for having them

uneven ember
ebon forge
still warren
#

Kole,

I know what everyone's saying. Listen to what I'm saying now. I've ranged as close to the Chain as any dare, and I'm telling you that it isn't just ratmen lurking there. Most of the land's been smashed flat, and the hammering you hear from the mountains... it's too methodical for the Skaven. There are oil slicks that melt flesh right off your bones and smoke that coils in the sky like screaming faces. 'Please, believe me. Inform the Marshals. Something is coming, and I don't know if we're ready for it.

Stay cautious.

Jazra

Hashut, Hashut, Hashut!

finite compass
#

HASHUT! VORGUND! ZHARR-NAGGRUND!

solemn gull
#

How can they tell the difference between a marine’s shell casing and a normal boltgun casing

#

Also are casings canon again?

runic swallow
#

Always have been, it’s just been weird about how it’s simultaneously rocket propelled

solemn gull
#

Yeah

runic swallow
#

Also people want to have a cool rain of casings when shooting

solemn gull
#

I thought they were canonically caseless

runic swallow
#

Canonically rocket propelled

#

But have casings because it’s cool

solemn gull
#

I mean yeah but there are other weapons that work for that, would be weird if lasguns had casings

#

Guess it’s just “boltgun is iconic”

jaunty dawn
#

bolts are a 2 stage thing

#

first stage is a conventional cartridge propellant and second stage is the rocket in the bolt

solemn gull
#

Neat

jaunty dawn
#

also space marine bolters are bigger

#

as are the bolts

#

it...kinda only makes sense cause 40k has magical microexplosives

solemn gull
#

Right but what stops a worshipper from saying “no this was fired from a guard/SoB/etc” storm bolter or heavy bolter

jaunty dawn
#

cause like

#

a space marine bolt is in between a human bolter and a human heavy bolter

#

plus theres all sorts of markings on the case

runic swallow
#

Human bolters are .75, Astartes are .995

floral herald
#

“Mortal” bolters are .75 cal iirc and space marine ones are .998

jaunty dawn
#

human bolt is basically the size of a large shotgun shell

solemn gull
#

I was referring to the mounted weaponry

#

Like a lemun russ’s sponsons are the same type of heavy bolter marines lug around?

jaunty dawn
#

and you can easily make a shotgun fire bolt shells once

floral herald
#

I think the heavy bolters are also bigger but it might be easy to pass off a mortal HB case as a space marine bolter shell

jaunty dawn
#

cause the relevant technology is just in the shell

solemn gull
#

Would definitely blow up the shotgun in someone’s hand though

jaunty dawn
#

it should be in there

uneven ember
jaunty dawn
#

or in rogue trader

solemn gull
#

lol

jaunty dawn
#

good tbh

#

they should eject brass

#

but also famously theres not much like 'common knowledge' around firearms in the uk

#

and the internet wasnt as accessible like 30 40 years ago

#

its funny seeing the difference in approach between gw and forge world in the early days of the latter

#

like codex imperial guard will be like the demolisher cannon fires a big boomy bang gun yesss while the imperial armour books will be like 'we know how tank ammo works and introduce rules for making a leman russ pick between AP and HE and APFSDS'

#

cause forge world had the milhist nerd background

runic swallow
#

It’s the Historical Wargamer turned 40k Zone

solemn gull
#

Props to them for trying to military sci-fi the sci-fi wargame

runic swallow
#

Also, as usual I’ll mention that historical wargames are often very fun and pretty darn cheap

jaunty dawn
#

boltguns also figure out how when to explode by gravity or something

runic swallow
#

It’s more they detect a change in density

#

Basically it’s a delayed impact fuse tho

floral herald
#

Speaking of funny dark heresy bolters I liked the “Angelus” bolter which fired Astartes bolts which fell off of a truck

runic swallow
#

You’re in the inquisition it’s fine

#

Just ask dad for a permission slip

floral herald
jaunty dawn
#

but yeah even beyond the caliber thing anything made for astartes is gonna say that on it somewhere and probably have like various blessings and makers marks and shit

peak olive
#

What even are the giant plastic shells on chainswords and bolters?

runic swallow
#

Explain further

peak olive
#

Is that like the slide, main body or for decoration

solemn gull
peak olive
runic swallow
#

Well, for the chainsword that’s probably just a housing so it’s one sided and maybe holding some mechanisms

solemn gull
#

I was thinking of the spitfire

jaunty dawn
#

i think its mostly giant for practical model painting and sculpting reasons

runic swallow
#

For the bolter that’s probably just part of the receiver

jaunty dawn
#

and then just becomes part of the aesthetic

peak olive
#

Aight

floral herald
solemn gull
floral herald
#

Storm bolter but it looks like bolter internals are very bulky

runic swallow
solemn gull
runic swallow
#

.22lr and 12ga are very different pressure-wise lol

upper canopy
final tide
#

I think im onto something (WIP)

floral herald
#

👀

final tide
#

Old! School! Orcs!

runic swallow
#

Crossposting from #1171221956775907408
This is what I’m working on currently. Since I’m not great at coming up with paint schemes, I’m looking for some help. Anyone have any ideas what FAL guy’s sweater and hat color should be? And the PKM guy’s shirt/sweater?
I’m pretty sure I’m gonna do all the boots as a kinda khaki or tan, but less sure about the various hats and scarves, or how to do the wood, gunmetal, and RPG warhead. I realize this isn’t exactly 40k, but this is another place us painting gremlins reside, so thought I’d give it a shot

#

Also, painting gremlins, we have the #1171221956775907408 channel, come on by and check it out/show off your stuff

#

And I forgot to post the picture like a dumbass:

#

Featuring unpainted Generic Insurgents and DELTA/CIA Advisor guys in the background

paper bluff
#

Lost but it was a close one. I tried out the bikes but those were not as good as they could be

paper bluff
#

Wait turns out a win. I forgot to total up my holding points

tired cairn
#

@floral herald Very belated, but re: Eldar Racism, it's pretty funny how the romance path with the Eldar character involves her discovering that a human has the same complex inner life as herself

lucid scarab
tired cairn
#

Nice

pastel rampart
#

Hell yes, peak zoanthrope

spice flicker
upper canopy
#

Can't tell if the Marika pronouns stuff is laziness of copy-pasting or galaxy brained

pastel rampart
thin ibex
#

Are you sick of your Rogal Dorn getting stuck beneath low bridges? Well our Enginseers are proud to announce that the STC they found between the grav-sofa cushions contained a new type of nail clippers and the Sigismund pattern tank destroyer!

You can see how I built and painted this turretless Rogal Dorn for the Tallarn regiment over on my ch...

Likes

5386

solemn gull
#

Why Pete why!!! Trench crossing casemate 🤢

finite compass
#

Because sticking a big gun in a hull position knows no chassis limitations.

solemn gull
#

I was referring to the fact that the lower front plate is so exposed

floral herald
#

tbf it might just be a very heavy lower plate with a design like that

thin ibex
mental birch
solemn gull
thin ibex
#

To be fair, imperial armor design is not often about efficient armor angles

jaunty dawn
#

a lot of given armour thicknesses are laughably low too

paper bluff
#

(Might be the most clever thing I say today)

floral herald
#

Unless it’s like an ork bouncy ball shell if the direct impact didn’t pen the explosion nearby won’t

soft willow
#

I assume this is like the flyer graphic from the uplifting primer. It’s better for reasons, the commissar said so.

hearty wasp
#

Reading an internet discussion thread which was critical of how the the Imperium is portrayed as the heroic faction. Later parts included someone rewriting the Imperium in a way that was pretty cool imo

paper bluff
#

Well human perspective bias and all that

floral herald
#

I’m kind of skeptical that the Imperium is presented as a heroic faction

hearty wasp
#

Personally I think that the Imperium isn't shown as heroic but a lot of the settings heros are from the Imperium.

tepid stratus
#

There's a lot of stuff from non-imperium pov books that points out how monstrous the imperium is

floral herald
tepid stratus
#

In Angron: Red Angel, the grey knights casually doom a world to try to settle a grudge against Angron

soft willow
#

I’d also say that a lot of folks can’t distinguish between “protagonists” and “good guys”

floral herald
#

There's a pretty good number of actually just heroic "Imperial" characters who fight in spite of the general awfulness of the imperium

hearty wasp
#

One of the big features of the rewrite was breaking up the Imperium in a more significant way.

tepid stratus
#

Not to mention the imperium is constantly fighting with itself for a myriad of reasons that don't even involve chaos or xenos. It's just so big we rarely see those conflicts

#

Entire sectors gone to war over taxes

floral herald
#

Yeah - like how the Land Raider Redeemer was invented to kill tax cheats who didn't even mean to do it

hearty wasp
#

Basically. The Segmentum Solar is the most similar to canon Imperium. There are several rival Imperiums which aren't quite as dysfunctional/terrible. Most of the loyalist Legions ditched after Guilliman was wounded and were presumably never divided into chapters. Chaos is less dominated by the Chaos Gods, many of the traitor legions are not affiliated with the gods.

spice flicker
#

Working on plotting out progression for a tank+infantry crusade force in 250 point chunks and in the current step I am plotting i actually have 290 points to work with so which would you suggest? (For reference at this point I had 2 officers (no tank commander), 3 hellhounds, a standard Leman russ, a demolisher leman russ, and a trio of infantry squads)
A) standard Leman russ, engineseer, and infantry squad
B) Leman russ vanquisher, engineseer, and catachan squad
C) trio of hydras (no anti-fly in list so far)
D) a single rogal dorn with an engineseer
E) Double Leman Russ Vanquishers
F) Tank Commander plus infantry
G) Tank Commander plus hydra
H) 2 catachans, 2 castellans (or engineseers), and a hydra

floral herald
#

I've seen a couple and they generally seem to maybe paradoxically seem way more laudatory of fascism than the GW canon

#

If I were to take my own swing at it I would soften chaos from being incomprehensibly awful to merely bad, or at least put more of a range on it (kinda like how the Black Crusade RPG did it but broader and maybe more extreme) to make it so the Imperium and Chaos are approximately as awful as one another, or chaos is slightly less bad

#

To make another "viable alternative" to the Imperium's system

#

But also chaos being incomprehensibly awful is fun to write

tepid stratus
#

I like the interpretations of chaos being a spectrum from incomprehensibly awful to benign and esoteric with everything along that spectrum in some way feeding into chaos.

floral herald
#

Same, it just doesn't appear as much as I'd like

tepid stratus
#

The darkoath in AOS have a pretty interesting relationship with chaos. Living semi nomadic lifestyles and having a somewhat transactional relationship with chaos. Make an oath and as long as you're fulfilling it they'll help you, but mess up too many times and they start being fucking you over in kind.

#

"I swear to protect my land from the colonizers" can end with you being lauded as a hero jacked off khorne blessings or turned into a wilderfiend stalking the now colonized lands bound to the remnants of your tribe

floral herald
#

Yeah they're cool

#

1 of 2 factions I'm looking at collecting if I get into AoS

#

(The other is flesh eater courts)

#

I like the idea of a sort of moderate chaos which offsets the really intense ones

#

Like there's maybe millions of people in a hive city who may leave protein-packs out to spoil with a few words to the grandfather about relief from buboes because they all live in a toxic waste dump but while they know the tiniest bit about Nurgle the Death Guard are a bunch of extremist freaks

hearty wasp
floral herald
#

Yeah I think there's more to change chaos

#

But I think that the Imperium's project was from the outset horrific, and it "inevitably" becoming a horrible stagnant corpse of itself is sort of important for the basic themes of the setting

#

Which is (IMO) that 40k's satire (as debated as this is) is that it presents a heavy-metal world where fascist history wins - an unending nightmare from which there is no hope of escape or relief

#

So a lot of attempts to "clean up" the Imperium come off to me at least as accidentally lending credence to the Emperor's authoritarian nightmare state he wanted before it all went to hell

desert jay
#

I think if you discard the pile of lore making up the Great Crusade and Horus Heresy, you can make it work, but otherwise yeah

floral herald
#

Yeah that's fair, if you aren't including the HH (which I think is reasonable given how much it postdates the rest of the setting) then its definitely thematically easier to do

solemn gull
floral herald
#

Yeah its not universal but there are a lot of actually decent or traditionally heroic protagonists in 40k

thin ibex
#

i do wonder, like... im sure theres a critical basis for it; but imperial characters generally think highly of hte imperium; but thats not an endorsement of the imperium

#

I think also a lot of imperial characters (not sm) think that the imperium is bad but its the better alternative to the rest of the galaxy

#

and sm are actively indoctrinated to be in the imperium's favor

jaunty dawn
#

characters (not space marines)

thin ibex
#

so characters will be portrayed reflecting these attitudes

floral herald
#

Though honestly a lot of space marines don't really seem to have much of an opinion on the wider Imperium

#

Or are themselves sort of critical of it

#

Though I do think it's probably relevant that the most popular faction is functionally "allied" to the Imperium but is an independent fighting force which doesn't follow a lot of their precepts

#

While mainline "Imperium" factions are usually less popular

lucid scarab
#

In a recent book Deathworlder a lot of time is spent with philosophical bickering between a Genestealer cultist and a Catachan jungle fighter. It’s pretty interesting to me because it was so close to being an interesting in universe conversation about how overwhelmingly awful the imperium is that even noblemen who for all intents and purposes benefit from the fascism of the imperium would turn to a cult to escape

#

But it fell flat because most of it was tinged by the overwhelmingly more evil result of the Genestealer cult’s unwitting actions

tepid stratus
#

Yeah unfortunately it's hard to use GSC as a foil to the imperium when you know what the endgame is for them

lucid scarab
#

Well I think it’s importantly that their really endgame is not known by anyone inside the cult

#

And it’s arguable it’s “known” to the purestrains

#

So it’s easy to sympathize with them but it’s also a weird bit of metaphor that your only effective citizens uprisings against the imperium are devoured by something infinitely more destructive then the imperium when they are successful

#

Like chaos cults are usually not sympathetic at all, their worship of the gods ends up making them do evil stuff. The GSC are usually like, normal miners who joined a new religion promising freedom from the imperium

#

Miners doing a revolution against fascists are pretty sympathetic usually. Just undercuts everything since their actions lead to tyranid invasion unwittingly

desert jay
#

I've always wanted to write a genestealer cult that's in weird zone of being like a low-level revolution for two centuries and due to the efforts of the Inquisition and some dumb luck there's no actual hybrids surviving, it's all bog standard human recruits who are left and kept recruiting others with the rhetoric, and the Inquisition is perplexed at their inability to find "genuine" cultists anymore

#

And it's been so long, the current Inquisitor on the case was born on this world, trained by his predecessor, and has never seen a hybrid himself, the last one was discovered before he took up the rosette

lucid scarab
solemn gull
lucid scarab
#

It would be cool to explore what a cult's beliefs would be even after losing the idols of their belief (purestrains, etc)

jaunty dawn
#

gsc that thinks blessings like a third arm are just a metaphor

solemn gull
#

Maybe just latching on to mutations in general? Like “hey this guy who lived near the waste plants has 3 arms! Maybe he’s a new prophet”

lucid scarab
#

The four armed emperor becomes a literal offshoot religion of the imperial faith

#

Four Armed Emperor reformation

solemn gull
#

Speaking of all this new necromunda genestealers just dropped again

jaunty dawn
#

hes just a guy

floral herald
#

Those models are so good

solemn gull
#

Also they have the Corpse Grinder masks rules

#

Too spooky to charge

lucid scarab
# desert jay I've always wanted to write a genestealer cult that's in weird zone of being lik...

Kinda hard to see but I ordered some of these Genestealer sculpts by Drew Williams. I'm planning on using them for my 1e campaign which has a similar twist on GSC, the story goes that an imperial research facility accidentally Jurassic Parked some Tyranids, so a genestealer cult also spread. But these Genestealers being so cut off from the rest of the imperium just sort of keep on going on like nothing is wrong. So theres entire hybrid settlements on the planet who just think they're normal humans.

#

Thus the need for the child hybrid and the farmer guy

south axle
solemn gull
final tide
#

I’ve gotta bunch of the old black orcs/ard boys I can probably throw together a good list if I get that battalion box,,, Hrmnn

#

Might need the boarboyz purely so I have somewhere to stick the warlord I built

#

And my roomies are inviting me to a 2e 40K league so I need to figure out how to make a DA list for that

paper bluff
#

I'm very much in the "there are no good guys in 40k" camp. I wonder what the Votann version of it will be.

thin ibex
#

something i was thinking about with the imperium talk is the idea that hte imperium is kind of consistently at war with itself in various ways. I don't think its often portrayed as a mainline thing

floral herald
#

I think the "we don't give a shit about you, give us your nice things and/or we'll kill you" covers them mostly

paper bluff
floral herald
#

You can at best have a mutually beneficial trade agreement with the Leagues

thin ibex
#

Honestly ive never gotten the vibe that the votann were too nice for 40k

floral herald
#

(Though this doesn't apply to the Votann as a whole - some of them have defected to the Tau for example)

thin ibex
#

they're like... hypermaterialists from day 1 on release

floral herald
#

But the leagues are ruthless and materially greedy

paper bluff
#

And the tau were "every one is equal in the greater good, but some are more equal than others" on release

floral herald
#

Ehh, the Tau have never said everyone is equal

thin ibex
#

rather everyone has a place xD

floral herald
#

Just that everyone has a place in it and can join

paper bluff
#

If some one thinks the imperium are the straight up good guys..... I think they might like Homelander from the boys

thin ibex
#

i do think tau portrayal in teh early days was maybe a bit more subtle than needed; but yeah they've been their own brand of bad for forever

paper bluff
lucid scarab
paper bluff
#

Seems to be. But no books yet from them yeah?

thin ibex
#

oh tangential but i often hear AoS is celebrated as being a bit more balanced than 40k; does that sentiment remain into the new edition?

floral herald
#

There's short stories but they have comparatively little lore

#

Which is a shame since the Codex doesn't have as much as I'd want

#

And codexes are always a little wonky to use for lore since they're always pretty glazing in tone

thin ibex
#

yeah its understandable that the dex would hype the faction they're for

#

but we have little else as far as lore for interactions with other factions

lucid scarab
#

I recently finished Infinite and The Divine and that book Glazes the necrons like crazy. Its very funny

floral herald
#

We've got some and the Kill Team booklets they get are great

thin ibex
#

tbf, Necrons within 40k SHOULD be glaxed tbh

floral herald
#

I should post some of the stuff from Termination

paper bluff
lucid scarab
floral herald
#

Honestly the Necrons have eventually landed on a really charming combination of eldritch horror and oldest man yaoi as a faction

lucid scarab
#

I had flashbacks to reading The Culture books reading I&D. Like Trazyn and Orokin are easily on the same level as a person from the culture whos got a ship mind as a friend. Just evil as fuck.

floral herald
#

I didn't super love the Newcrons when they first came out but they've grown on me a lot as they gain lore

lucid scarab
final tide
lucid scarab
#

very accurate

paper bluff
lucid scarab
# paper bluff

Just make two absolute geezers fight and you're easily making one of the best 40k books lmao

lucid scarab
paper bluff
paper bluff
hearty wasp
#

So the rewrite/alt take. I shall talk about it a little because I am stubborn and have no one to talk to.
-Weirdest departure was making the Emperor a much better person. Who actually wasn't a human supremacist. The only thing he hated/feared was Chaos. Gave the legions a lot of autonomy while tunnel visioning a human webway with plans to reform the Imperium when completed. Including retiring the worst of the legions and setting up a civilian government.
-Chaos is a much more neutral force. The big four are dangerous corrupters. But Chaos itself is a more neutral force of change. Those who embrace it are fundamentally transformed into more of themselves.
-Horus "fell" because the Emperor told him that he wanted to reign in the legions/bloodthirsty primarchs. Horus like most Primarchs was perfectly fine being a boot stamping on the face of the universe embraced the power of ascension Chaos offered him.

paper bluff
#

Also the ork in that books were great

final tide
#

Hey also has anyone looked at 2e Warhammer in living memory

final tide
#

Bc fuck I gotta learn it, can’t be that different from RT

floral herald
lucid scarab
#

I've looked at the rules but haven't played yet.

final tide
#

maybe slightly easier to listbuild than RT

floral herald
#

I just poked through some of the PDFs to look at pictures ngl

final tide
#

Awww dang

lucid scarab
final tide
#

Well I gotta find them same pdfs then ahaha

lucid scarab
#

Like vehicles.

paper bluff
#

Aas that the warhammer fantasy of the 40k editions?

final tide
floral herald
final tide
#

The rest of the game seemed easy enough to walk through

floral herald
#

Not that it isn't a change but it doesn't change that much

lucid scarab
paper bluff
#

I hear great things about warhammer fantasy but respect people that play it like I respect people who write code. "That looks really complicated and I have no doubt it's easy to understand in theory. No I do not want to learn all of that"

floral herald
#

I think 2e makes listbuilding a little easier

#

1e was... so open ended with models

final tide
#

Unfortunately I am trying to throw a marine list that I haven’t really updated since 2006

#

At every edition

#

Three troop squads, a captain, a dread, and a tank

#

Let’s gooooooo

floral herald
#

For 2e you've also got Codex Angels of Death

#

Which is the first time the DA really got that much lore aiui

lucid scarab
final tide
#

Oh that’s right, I can actually use my deathwing in 2e

#

Gotta BUILD them but still

floral herald
#

mood

final tide
#

my gf threw the new army box at my head and she’s threatening the same with the plush

#

her stores doing well so uh, go to the gw in Puyallup i guess

past sphinx
#

Legitimately i think I might be driving through there in a month or so

jaunty dawn
#

ooh bsdata has been updated for mfm and new codexes

thin ibex
#

Eyyy

#

The dataslate too?

jaunty dawn
#

ye

spice flicker
#

With kastelan robots being 2 for 190 and 4 for 360, is it worth the extra points and board presence to go 2x2 or just do 1x4?

jaunty dawn
#

is there a good strat for them

spice flicker
#

Not in particular that I can tell

jaunty dawn
#

auto divinatory could be something?

#

I thin with the added cost relative plus having to get 2 datasmiths instead of one 4 is probably the way to go

#

transcendant contagion could be fun with punch bots now

still warren
#

Amazing poster for pre-orders

finite compass
#

Say what you will about being the edition that dialed up the grimdark and thus began the long slide into Missing the Point... I really got slapped in the face with nostalgia just by the artstyle.

#

All the random incidental Wayne England flavor drawings and such

past sphinx
#

in my mind this IS chaos

#

everything is derivative of this in my mind

floral herald
#

Yeah this stuff is iconic

bold halo
#

this is the one that really stuck with me from the 3e csm codex

floral herald
#

Ahhh, the chosen of Abaddon

mental birch
#

Trying to remember the image the lolmarines

#

Was referencing because I swear it's a reference

finite compass
#

Also from the 3.5 CSM codex it was the one portrait of a relevant marine on each page going over the 4 gods that really stuck in my head for me

#

Black and white in the book itself, but still

bold halo
#

that book was honestly packed with fantastic art

past sphinx
#

i do my best to not have the "better back when" grognardian mindset but digital art never seems to really capture stuff that working with a medium can

#

though dnd suffers far more than 40k

floral herald
#

Yeah a lot of digital art feels idk

#

Too polished and clean

#

For art which benefits from the grunge

bright dove
#

This is the art that unironically got me to stay in 40k for a good bit.

#

CSM was my first codex.

desert jay
floral herald
#

I have high hopes for the EC book

#

All the recent chaos sculpts have been Super Bangers

desert jay
#

Bare midriff, one boobplate sculpted onto the armor, face super fucked up, leg armor so tight it looks like leather pants

past sphinx
#

boy i have hopes for the EC book

#

foolish and ignorant hopes

#

kinda baffled what all they need to add to make an actual army book out of them

#

Tzangors of course but what else really

#

theres gotta be a new lucious and a proper noise marine kit right?

jaunty dawn
#

hope they get a new dread

floral herald
#

I’m guess noise marines, some kind of elite CSM unit

#

Maybe Phoenix termies, maybe something else

#

Fulgrim

#

New Lucius

#

New leader model or two

#

Some kind of mortal cultist or some stripe unit

finite compass
#

Maybe something melee centric to back up the short-ranged shooty Noise Marine profile

#

Assuming they go with noise marines as noise marines have typically been

desert jay
#

My pick would be a sonic tank but you still want more. Maybe a light/no armor speedy melee squad

jaunty dawn
#

death wheel!

finite compass
#

Sonic Dreadnought

#

(I still refuse to call it a Helbrute)

past sphinx
#

just to fuck with me personally

floral herald
#

Call em… Doom Riders

#

Maybe not trademarkable enough

#

Deum Ryders

past sphinx
floral herald
#

Yeah honestly

#

I’d be here for it

desert jay
#

I mean the 40k codices don't have them

#

But yeah AOS does

final tide
#

I’m quoting my Old Texts but yeah they did give Khornigors back to the AoS khorne boys

#

Didn’t they,,,

floral herald
#

The kinda world eaters version is Jakhals

#

And maybe Poxwalkers for DG

finite compass
#

I'd say it's a weird choice, but this is modern GW we're talking about

#

Who kills AoS armies precisely because they're showing up in Old World, and would rather remove an army entirely than have one you can play in two games.

bright dove
#

I am still so angry about BoC.

upper canopy
#

The concept of Horus being stoned until right at the end of the final battle is really funny

#

That wasn't him regaining his humanity right at the end he just came down and was like "Hey wait what the fu-"

paper bluff
#

A big "dude...... where's my crusade and legion...."

paper bluff
#

Funny though that Fabius Bile is still CSM but not EC

raw vessel
#

I mean that fits lorewise, he was offered to lead a part of the legion again but turned it down when it was revealed to be a harlequin ploy. He's pissed off pretty much all of the traitor legions in some way but they still grudgingly work with him because his skills are that valuable.

pastel rampart
paper bluff
junior robin
#

man this is a real conundrum

still warren
#

bull centaurs confirmed

junior robin
#

I hope you are right, that would be nice.

floral herald
#

Primaris Lieutenant with Bull centaru armor

thin ibex
#

Primaris bull lieutenant

#

That's right, primaris is coming to other factions and games

#

And they're all lieutenants

pastel rampart
#

Given the 3 circles there it could be Nurgle.

junior robin
#

true, it does have a mysterious 4th circle above it though 🤔

#

stealth nurgle

thin ibex
#

Lesser known cousin blurgle

solemn gull
#

The bell is also pretty nurgle-ey

paper bluff
#

Snarlfang expansion some one had guessed in a server I'm in

desert jay
pastel rampart
finite compass
# thin ibex That's right, primaris is coming to other factions and games

And you thought Kaldor Draigo appearing in the End Times was merely a subtle reference.


Considering pre-ordering Eternal Crusade (the upcoming 40k MMO)? Use my referral code when signing up for 4,000 extra blingbling points: EC-2QHHBV8RGCTS7
https://www.eternalcrusade.com/account/sign-up/?ref_code=EC-2QHHBV8RGCTS7
PS. EC at pre-order costs $...

▶ Play video
#

Old, but still relevant

pastel rampart
uneven ember
#

JBR is great

thin ibex
desert jay
spice flicker
#

Radiation doesn't hurt ad mech...but they'll make sure it hurts like hell for you.

peak olive
#

What have I done
Army: Orks (Mono Gretchin)
Units: 4
Models: 41
Point Cost: 470
-Killa Kanz (250)
-6 Killa Kanz
-2 w/Grotzooka
-1 w/Skorcha
-Mek Gunz (100)
-2 Mek Gunz
-1 w/Bubblechukka
-Gretchin 1 (80)
-20 Gretchin
-2 Runtherds
-Gretchin 2 (40)
-10 Gretchin
-1 Runtherd