#feedback-readonly

1 messages · Page 90 of 1

craggy dagger
#

It becomes very tedious to figure out who can do a play and who can’t based on anything besides what gamemode you’re playing

runic dragon
#

I always call it PR strats. There are a good number of PR members that nail it to a T. But people copying cost us games

floral heath
#

Can’t hurt to try 😂

runic dragon
#

No!!! My points!!!!

#

Frikken rv forky aura.... Ffs.

craggy dagger
#

I don’t think they should be outright bannable plays, but I think if Maria or DearS etcmessed it up and got mislynched because they were trying to be fancy then it’s fair game for Guardians to punish them

runic dragon
#

I don't see them ever getting mislynched for one of their strats

#

They can do it. They're that good

craggy dagger
#

Case by case is probably the way to go here

runic dragon
#

Maria did the fake info while nightmared last night. Nailed it. Because she's Maria

craggy dagger
#

In mafia terminology they call that kind of stuff Fancy Play Syndrome or FPS for short, use it at your own peril.

runic dragon
#

Not all of us are Maria. Don't. Do. It.

#

Maria is so pro you'd swear she hacks

craggy dagger
#

Do it, but accept the consequences if it backfires.

runic dragon
#

Ew. No. Don't accept. Those are my points bruh

#

Go accept it in QG

craggy dagger
#

So they’re for XYZ player and anyone else shouldn’t do it or attempt it at all. Gotcha

runic dragon
#

Be humble. Unless you know you can nail it, don't do it

#

I'm quiet. I'm sus. So you make up info about me. Meanwhile I'm in a lobby and have interest in talking. Boom. I'm hhs target. Rip.

craggy dagger
#

My point here is that neither Maria or DearS would’ve done that sort of stuff without experimenting with it or being coached on it, they’re so good at it because they had a chance to trial and error

I want all players to have that chance at trial and error.

runic dragon
#

Nightmare is new. There's no experimenting.

#

They just know, same as sect

tidal monolith
#

I’d recommend doing it if priest still in game

runic dragon
#

Sect knows all roles by day 3 latest. Ald too.

forest rover
runic dragon
#

Welp.

#

moves thanks @forest rover

craggy dagger
#

Reposting suggestion again here as its further up the thread.

Suggestion

Please make intentionally outing the solo killer directly based on knowing who the solo killer is in ranked detective games on day 1 or day 2 considered a gamethrow because it directly causes your team to be at a disadvantage.

hot valley
#

Suggestion to recover old battlepass items:

I suggest there could be an event that works in stages:

  • each stage has their own challenge. Examples of challenges:
    • Get three wins in a row
    • Level up twice
    • Open a lootcrate
    • Buy an item in the inventory
    • ....
      These challenges should vary in difficulty but some should also be very specific to make them hard to complete. You do not know what the next stages challenge is until you completed the previous one. IF you complete all stages, you get to pick an outfit from the battlepass this event is about. On average, only 5% of the participating players should get to the last stage. There are no rewards in between so you have to work towards the end goal. Idk if there should be an entry fee but it should not be too high in my opinion
vale gyro
#

Emanuel doesn't answer to the daily rewards gender question, could someone else help maybe? GWchadThink

astral spruce
#

he said "no"

vale gyro
#

Yes. I asked for reasoning.

vivid blaze
#

Giving alpha a double vote is more of an opportunity for the alpha to gamethrow by deliberately voting sk/random voting. Literally almost everytime I see alpha messing up votes at night. The double vote hardly has any upsides.
Can we please remove alpha double vote to reduce gamethrowing

vivid blaze
#

@astral spruce that suggestion is quite different from this. My suggestion is simply to remove double vote

#

Rather than the complicated one that's posted

astral spruce
#

your suggestion is to turn alpha to a regular werewolf

vale gyro
#

No. Regular ww doesn't get the perk of getting seen as unk by aura.

astral spruce
#

yeah

#

not strong enough point

#

unks will be asked for role anyways

#

if they dont claim

#

gunner/jailer will kill them

vivid blaze
#

Indeed @vale gyro I was gonna say it too

astral spruce
#

doesnt prove anything

#

Gunner/Jailer will shoot them as the Aura says they're unk and they dont have anything to claim

vivid blaze
#

@astral spruce well having a double vote doesn't make a difference to their unk role so....

astral spruce
#

it actually does

vivid blaze
#

...

astral spruce
#

it does

vivid blaze
#

Out with it then

astral spruce
#

when your noobish allies are going for the obvious fool

#

will you vote with them for fool?

vivid blaze
#

Mate. Plz go and read what I wrote on my initial message

#

Secondly, the argument rn is about your unknown claim

astral spruce
#

I was the first to read it.

#

Omg

#

This dude is really annoying.

vivid blaze
#

Having a double vote doesn't make a difference to whatever they claim when called out by aura

astral spruce
#

i was telling you the difference between it

vivid blaze
#

@astral spruce you're the one bringing in out of context arguments

astral spruce
#

your very own message

#

to change the context

vivid blaze
#

U misunderstood but nvm

astral spruce
#

thats just nerfing a good wolf for no reason

#

d00d

vivid blaze
#

We were talking about double vote, and u bringing in the unknown thing makes no sense

#

Anyways what's your point now?

astral spruce
#

lmao this guy

#

I am not interested in changing your mind.

#

Soon enough you'll see when a Staff member comments.

vivid blaze
#

When you say "noobish allies"
I didn't come here to argue without thinking of something so obvious like this.
Tell me yourself. What are the chances of 1 guy gamethrowing and 2 guys gamethrowing?

#

Noobish allies going for the fool, no.
It's more often that the alpha deliberately messes up the votes and I mentioned that in my first message

#

And use commonsense. The chances of alpha gamethrowing or rather be 'noobish' is double than the other 2 ww being noobish so.... simple math

#

And its proven by stats

#

@astral spruce try arguing with facts rather than excuses like "lmao this guy" and stuff... or just admit that your arguments make no sense

#

Lol ofc u won't 'care' now. Well thx anyways for trying

astral spruce
#

lmao

vivid blaze
#

Helpers plz check my suggestion out and we can discuss if you want

astral spruce
#

You really think you won the argument

#

First of all

#

Alpha is a Leader.

vivid blaze
#

I don't even need to think. Numbers and facts speak everything

astral spruce
#

They must have 2x vote at all

#

Get noob #1

vivid blaze
#

Mate ffs have you even read my first message as to why the 2x vote is a con??

astral spruce
#

Second of all
Please make more sense and don't ping me

#

did you check the message

#

or not

vivid blaze
#

...

#

That's not even for the point

astral spruce
#

okay

#

then

#

shut

vivid blaze
#

Your only argument for keeping the 2x vote is bcoz u say sometimes u have 'noobish allies'. If you apply simple math the chances of the other 2 ww being noobish is half than the alpha so...

#

Which I clearly mentioned in my first message.
"Alpha deliberately messes up votes"

astral spruce
#

@calm pollen send your fricking message for the love of the god.

calm pollen
#

Why transfering payed items SHOULD be a thing. Deleting is an escape from the games that you lost or just you dont want to play anymore.
While transfering is an option when you dont want to Play on this account and have payed items on it. Its a good option because these items will be almost forever!

Now you will think but what if the person is banned and just wants dodge the ban? That's why the Guardians come in. The Guardian will have Access to information for ex. Is the person banned or how many games lost/won. So its like this. The person needs to send his account name he wants to transfer items from with the Ask for transfer. The Guardian then will have an option to cancel the transfer or not. If the transfer is canceled he will need to atleast wait 1 month for another request for transfer. If the transfer is accepted, then the person will have to enter the alt account name and alt account will need to accept request send in game. @astral spruce ok lmao

vivid blaze
#

Secondly burrrkey please try to be polite. We're here to discuss, not to show ego

modest arrow
#

I think the unknown role of the alpha is an great add-on, because or else the alpha would be worse

vivid blaze
#

The unknown role obviously should be there.
You have misunderstood the point

#

The argument is to remove double vote only.

modest arrow
#

I’m sorry sir😂

#

Didn’t know you are mad

vivid blaze
#

This discord server is literally almost the same as the game. Where people just come to waste time and joke around trying to make fun of people.

#

Anyways, helpers when you get my message and wanna discuss plz ping me. Thx.

astral spruce
#

Alpha's aura is prob because

#

He is a bit good

#

As he's trying to take care of his wolf pacce its its nature

#

not an evil activity

#

Meanwhile the good activity mixes with evil and outputs unknown

vale gyro
#

Or it's just like that because it makes the game a bit more balanced.

modest pebble
#

If cupid lover is tagged from arso/bomber and if their lover is arso/bomber, cupid lover must be changed automatically so it doesn’t affect the autosuicide

calm pollen
#

(This is a repost with some changes, made by me because the original didnt get any attention).Why transfering payed items SHOULD be a thing. Deleting is an escape from the games that you lost or just you dont want to play anymore.
While transfering is an option when you dont want to Play on this account and have payed items on it. Its a good option because these bought items will be almost forever!

Now you will think but what if the person is banned and just wants to dodge the ban? That's why the Guardians come in. The Guardian will have Access to information for ex. Is the person banned or how many games lost/won. So its like this.
-The person needs to send his account name he wants to transfer items from with the Ask for transfer.
-The Guardian then will have an option to cancel the transfer or not. If the transfer is canceled he will need to atleast wait 1 month for another request for transfer.

  • If the transfer is accepted, then the person will have to enter the alt account name and alt account will need to accept request send in game.
stoic sapphire
#

I'm not sure if this is a bug or not, so I'm sending that here. In special games (is it that In english?) if only ww seer and sorcerer are left of werewolf, ww seer cant vote, so its impossible for the ww to do anythin as long as the sorcerer lives.

calm pollen
#

Its not a bug

#

You have to resing being the ww.seer

#

Then you can become a normal ww

#

And you can vote

stoic sapphire
#

I did. I didn't have the seer power, but my vote disappeared after a second.

calm pollen
#

And he didnt die?

stoic sapphire
#

You mean the guy I voted? No

calm pollen
#

Well sorcerer is team ww so i think you cant kill him. Still go to the #bugs-readonly and write about it. someone will help you.

astral spruce
#

@stoic sapphire ww seer cant vote unless they resign

#

Sorcerer cant vote at all.

#

Last Sorcerer is just the guy who is left alone and his last chance to win is to make town believe him.

calm pollen
#

Alright what do you think about the transfer idea or im going to need to repost that again :@

stoic sapphire
#

I wrote to bugs about the problem

astral spruce
#

its not a problem

calm pollen
#

Am i getting ignored lmao

astral spruce
#

idk

calm pollen
#

@astral spruce you part of this disc?

vivid blaze
#

Don't you think werewolves should get banned for revealing sk? When ww are losing they spoil the game by revealing the sk which just further helps the village, let alone that the game is already so so tough for the solo killer.

calm pollen
#

That's gamethrowing

#

Its already reportable

#

I think cupid should be solo. Its because he can choose who to help. And that's not cool. He can 2 things:

  1. Betray the village and do everything to make lovers win
  2. Leave the lovers alone like a piece of shi# saying something like " 🥰 😍 😍 😍 🥰 🥰 😘 😘 😘 😍 😍 🥰 🥰 gOoDlUck mY CuPLe😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 🥰 🥰 🥰 😘 😘 😘 😘"
    Choosing option one is betraying everyone while everyone thinks he is good! EVEN after seer checks his role he is still good and trusted! That's why he should be atleast unknown. People should know to how to treat cupid. I even had some games where i cupid trolled everyone to think im aura seer. And won easily.
#

Cupid can lie the whole game just to make lovers great again

#

That's why he should be unknown. People should know that cupid some times is their worst enemy.

heavy yew
#

so he's solo?

calm pollen
#

Yep

#

He can be solo or dont

#

Well solo but he needs to make lovers survive

#

Everyone else dead

#

Kinda like sect leader

heavy yew
#

so your feedback makes him solo and not village ??

calm pollen
#

Umm, i guess? I just want to make him so people wont trust him that much

#

Being solo is pretty cool so yeah

#

Yeah its probably for the best to make him solo

#

I will make the solo version give me a minute

#

Whay

heavy yew
#

Dont copy paste

#

If u copy paste the emote wont show correctly

#

So cupid will be HH then?

#

What happens if the lovers die?

#

What will the cupid be?

calm pollen
#

I think cupid should be solo. Its because he can choose who to help. And that's not cool. He can 2 things:

  1. Betray the village and do everything to make lovers win
  2. Leave the lovers alone like a piece of shi# saying something like " gOoDlUck mY CuPLe😍 🥰 😍 🥰 😍 "
    Choosing option one is betraying everyone while everyone thinks he is good! EVEN after seer checks his role he is still good and trusted! That's why he should be atleast unknown. People should know to how to treat cupid. I even had some games where i cupid trolled everyone to think im aura seer. And won easily. Well what if lovers will Die? Then cupid will become the villager!
runic dragon
#

@calm pollen you can say your feedback once, not sending it several times btw

#

Staff will read it

calm pollen
#

@runic dragon what if everyone will ignore my feedback?

runic dragon
#

They don't ignore anyone's feedback, they answer when they are available

calm pollen
#

Oh sorry

runic dragon
#

lmao

calm pollen
#

Ok i will edit my feedback again. Everything will be there.

rigid bronze
#

Sincerely sorry for the late answer everyone, don't mind the coloured squares, it's only for me !
Sorry for the double pings you might get

@median elbow You dont have to scroll anyway, and it if you want to set one as a preset, I guess you know where it is located 👀 I find it a bit useless tbh 🟥

@spare tundra Yea that kind of thing was already suggested but denied because lovers teams is already very powerful :v sorry and thanks for suggesting ! 🟥

@runic dragon I see what you mean 🤔 you'd like revealing solo as ww to be forbidden right ? I will talk with Lisa abt that 🟧

@dense rain He is very busy, try recontacting him again ! 🟦

@runic dragon I see what you mean 🤔 you'd like revealing solo as ww to be forbidden right ? I will talk with Lisa abt that 🟧 even tho, I'm not sure for fool ; you can easily lose even as we by the fool if you don't reveal it to the village 👀
@craggy dagger Same
@floral heath Same

@hot valley It looks cool but Devs don't want the old bps items to be obtainable again ; what about another reward tho ? 🟧

@astral spruce @vale gyro One of you should DM him abt it 🟦

@vivid blaze I agree double vote is more a gamethrowing tool than anything else... But sadly it cant be deleted for nothing else ; if you find something else another ability that would be good for it, I will post it to #feedback-devs for sure ! But for now nop sorry 🟥

@calm pollen So you're suggesting a transfer system if you delete your account ? Only for paid outfits ? I understand why and I will post it to #feedback-devs but I'm not sure if people/devs will like that... 🟩

@modest pebble That was already suggested multiple times and idrk the outcomes of it ; imma see after posting that msg and I'll tell you ! 🟧

SECOND PARD INCOMING

#

@vivid blaze same as Jasmin and the others ↑

@calm pollen Okay okay, I will post it to #feedback-devs, what do you think about voteno No to everything ; 1️⃣ Make Cupid unknown ; 2️⃣ Make Cupid a solo role that wins with couple

calm pollen
#

@rigid bronze ty so much

astral spruce
#

@rigid bronze my double vote remove idea was posted in feed-back devs

#

with a solution for it

#

got 64 dislikes

rigid bronze
#

Make another one 👀

calm pollen
#

Lmao XD

rigid bronze
#

But when was it posted ?

astral spruce
#

ugh

#

wait

hot valley
#

@rigid bronze Another reward would be cool 🤷 But it should be something important/big as I intend this to be pretty difficult. Did they give a definite no to the old battle passes though?

runic dragon
#

@rigid bronze I think we need different rules for rank. I'm really bad at explaining but... If your revealing of solo does not result in a win you should be reported and banned. Like I get if solo dies werewolf aura wins. Day 1 you're costing your whole team

rigid bronze
#

@hot valley Pretty sure yea... You may want to ask them directly with your idea, it's very tough and could be liked

runic dragon
#

Rank is meant to be for serious players. Can't be have a stricter rule setup?

hot valley
#

Ill hit them up with a dm 😉 Thanks though ❤️

runic dragon
#

Many things. Like you can't be hey I'm hh my target is x day 1

#

Nor can you be hey I'm aros shoot me day 1

rigid bronze
#

@astral spruce Yea I see, maybe find another ability ? Mention me if you have any idea :3

thick bolt
#

the first part was good but the second one was so bad

runic dragon
#

@thick bolt how do you link? No one will tell me

thick bolt
#

lol

runic dragon
#

And you call me noob when I was picking on a friend :(

rigid bronze
#

@runic dragonlong press message -> share -> copy link

runic dragon
#

Thank you

rigid bronze
#

Yw

thick bolt
#

exactly

#

@runic dragon Did I call you noob?

runic dragon
#

If rank is for serious players surely it can come with much stricter rules?

rigid bronze
#

And for the rules... It seems to be a big thing, I will talk with Lisa abt it, if something real comes out of it, Dev will be notified and maybe something will happen

runic dragon
#

@thick bolt haha. I called @dreamy burrow noob for not shooting. And you said noob priest

rigid bronze
#

Jasmin second time you get too off topic 👀

#

It's not a huge deal, but please keep this channel as clear as possible cute_heart

runic dragon
#

Sorry. I get it. It ends up being spam. I must get used to DC and taking it to general

rigid bronze
#

Don't worry 💙

thick bolt
#

Sorry @runic dragon. About my link now.. why to give less points to ww?

#

WWs are so weak and unbalanced. You need to remove hh from ranked. The only solution

astral spruce
#

just increase alpha 2x vote to 4x

thick bolt
#

@astral spruce How can it helps?

astral spruce
#

it helps

thick bolt
#

how?

astral spruce
#

when all ww votes randomly

#

3 votes for a non-sense forkman

thick bolt
#

but if alpha voted randomly then it's worse

astral spruce
#

4 votes for doc

thick bolt
#

lol

astral spruce
#

then you sell out alpha lmao

drowsy jungle
#

Guys please help too many teaming at ranked please help developet

#

There fool teaming with wolf and village teaming with wolf

#

I will prove it later bcz everytime i play always saw those teamer fk

glacial warren
#

Report them in game ^^ also the fool is solo and can help the wws if they want

drowsy jungle
#

Btw there village teaming with fool too

#

The village let fool win

#

The village is seer

#

They play 2 account at sametime

#

I hare teamer

glacial warren
#

Teaming is known ^^' please report them in game

drowsy jungle
#

Alredy report nothing work

#

I will screenshot those teamer

#

Pls permenent ban them

glacial warren
drowsy jungle
#

Oh okay thx

runic dragon
#

I played a game and people found out that 'Di*d *' is blocked but if you say it like this 'Dì * d *' then it isn't blocked
(It also works with other swear words, also I'm very sorry for saying the words even with **)

glacial warren
#

@runic dragon hey ^^ censor things like this has been suggested before tho ^^
Also could you please change your nickname so it is pingable by adding some normal letters ^^

runic dragon
#

Okay, sorry

#

I have changed it ^^

silver ruin
#

For feedback dev of the transfering items:

That shouldn't happen, because it will allow selling of account, transaction that never should had occurred . Once you have the account, you shouldn't really delete it anyway if you planned to play it longer. Deleting is more like, you literally don't wanna relate to this game anymore , etc . And it would cause some bugs like what if I bought certain costume that I have in my alt, what would essentially happen to those costume? Even the daily sign in have their respective cosmetics, and it would be a easy way to earn more money by using 2 account at once, then transfer it at a time later

runic dragon
#

Hi.
Brought up stricter rules earlier for rank.
Just thinking.... It would actually be good for another reason... If it's known as a serious strict mode others might be detoured

#

Sorry I wasn't don't typing and I got bumped...

#

If it's known as a very strict mode with many many rules maybe it'll hell?

#

Bans can just be a rank bans. Oh you gave away solo day 1? Here's your rank ban. You can use other modes until it's over

#

Maybe we can do a vote on rules?

#

Three things I think should be instanted

#
  1. Giving away the solo is fine because they're not on the same team. Please change this.
#
  1. Solo can ask to be shot day 1 as they're not hurting their team as they're a one man team. Please change this
#
  1. Headhunter going hey I'm hh target is 1 remember 1 is good. Defeats the purpose of their role. Yes headhunter can lie but majority don't. A day 1 headhunter claim and target should not be allowed
#

I know with 3 it's been said it's game throwing but we need a rank list of rules

#

You not okay with rank rules? Don't play rank

#

It's strict rules just for rank

calm pollen
#

@silver ruin i guess if the transfer will be a thing, then selling accounts or transfering items for money probably going to be reportable/banable

I think trading system is going to be soon in the game i dont know how but i have an Item that never showed up normally but still i unboxed it.

silver ruin
#

But the problem is @calm pollen

#

It's impossible to find those player

#

They can claim their account transferred are just their alt

#

It would be a black market of literally account selling but disguise as swapping alt

calm pollen
#

I told you that Guardian will have informations such as where the accounts are located. I guess if they are too far way from each other Guardian will not accept the transfer

silver ruin
#

Well the thing is

#

Selling account for real money

#

Require a meet up for that

#

Even if you want online, people don't trust online that much

#

So you can only narrow down so much

#

But it would still be an issue

calm pollen
#

Well selling accounts is not related what im writing about. Transfering is diffrent

silver ruin
#

It's literally, and nearly impossible to stop that if transferring account were a thing

rigid bronze
#

Hum selling accounts is forbidden by wwo terms of service 👀

#

Even giving account for free is

silver ruin
#

But by transferring an account to a person

#

Imagine that happening to just sell account

#

You can't imagine the scenario so I will write it down

#

Imagine a level 100 player sell their account to another level 100 player, and they transfers account, nobody would be able to know if this transfer were really transfer, or a part of a selling scheme

#

Even if you ask them personal, they will simply hide it as : Transferring their alt account to their main ones

#

It would make a lot easy access to selling accounts

#

It's making selling account way too easy to do if you introduce transferring accounts to it

#

And there's even the possibility of people playing 5 alts just to transfer it upon one account and earn 5 times as much

#

Imagine those limited battle pass item X 5

#

Well, I don't think I need to mention anymore eh

shut pecan
#

Would it be strong if WWs kill your target as HH, you become Werewolf team?

#

Without knowing who the wws are

#

Nor killin at night

#

U just win with wws

languid cape
#

Yes it would be too strong, but it wont be strong yet balanced if headhunter can see their targets role

#

Emanuel downvoted it soooo

sacred sable
#

Suggestion:
Make Doc role only have a limited number of protects
But can use them on itself, too

Hue

languid cape
#

53 to 30 votes

sacred sable
#

And if hh could suddenly win with three teams, that's too op
My opinion

upbeat sentinel
#

I have a suggestion

×ADD SELL TO THE INVENTORY SO PLAYERS CAN SELL THE ITEMS THAT THEY DON'T WANT ANYMORE.

slow flume
#

I think... Maybe if you're revived after the sect leader has died, you're no longer sect?

dense rain
#

@pallid merlin i wait ed you 1 day plss

#

Answer me

astral spruce
#

@slow flume you die as sect and get revived as sect

#

Also sect has damn much hp

#

so a revived Sect member Gunner

#

can carry Sect

#

even if SL died

slow flume
#

Okay... This isn't questions though, it's feedback that I think a revived sect member shouldn't be sect anymore since leader is dead.

astral spruce
#

Dude... For example Alpha is a leader as well but when Alpha dies Wolves don't extinct.

rigid bronze
#

@dense rain Did you contact him in DMs or is it for something else ?

astral spruce
#

Same for the Leader Zombie, when first zombie dies Zombies don't get cured.

vale gyro
#

Yeah but, as revived sect member you lose no matter what so most people have zero motivation to even play afterwards. I've seen way too many of them just staying off after the rev or just committing suicide because it's a pointless waste of time

forest rover
#

The shouldnt play for village since they don't belong to village team

#

If I'm revived as sect member with dead sect leader I help wolves 👀

vale gyro
#

You still lose. No matter whether you help wws or villagers. It's literally pointless

forest rover
#

That's why the most logical reason is that sect members shouldn't be able to rev if sect leader is dead.It's the only role that belongs to other team that can be revived.Imagine rev a werewolf.It doesn't make sense.Why rev a sect member does?I don't get it.

vale gyro
#

Or how about after getting revived they realize how stupid they were for joining a sect and convert back to normal villagers GWchadMEGATHINK

pallid merlin
#

@dense rain I've told you several times that I will. I have many dms and a life. If you keep on pinging me, it will only make matters worse.

forest rover
#

They doesn't decide to join,they're forced to join.Getting back to the villagers team just breaks the whole idea of sect leader and gives medium an amazing buff that could make gamethrow.

vale gyro
#

Mind elaborating the "amazing buff" part?

forest rover
#

Giving to medium (which is already strong because it can talk with the dead + revive a dead player) the ability of changing the team of a player to help them makes med really op,at least to me,and,as I already said,it breaks the whole concept of the sect leader,and that doesn't seem fair to be,imo.It could also create rose bribing.It is a problem but making med able to unsect players isn't the solution imo @vale gyro

zenith kayak
#

Add another solo killer to ranked

next escarp
#

^ maybe cannibal

runic dragon
#

I feel like outfits that you need to pay real money for should be made available to purchase for gold or roses for a limited time in your inventory. I can’t purchase skins I really like because they cost $$$.

craggy dagger
#

I’m okay with cosmetic items having a paywall to owning them. Developers gotta eat and drink too

runic dragon
#

Yeah same

#

Just I’m not willing to pay money for every outfit that’s comes

#

So I feel like there should be some outfits made available to people who can’t pay.They don’t have to make everything available just some.

forest rover
#

What you're describing is clan quest 👀

runic dragon
#

Yeah I know

#

But like it still should be available to people not in clan quests

#

Not everything, maybe like seasonal

#

Like once every 3/4 months an outfit is made available to purchase with gold or roses for like a week

forest rover
#

That happens with items in the inventory sometimes.Not full outfits most of the time,but still full outfits of celebrations like Christmas or Easter

runic dragon
#

But what I want comes seasonal but isn’t focused on a celebration

#

Like now I have a special offer for an outfit and it’s $2.99 , so in like 3 months that same outfit can be made available in the inventory for roses and gold.

#

So you don’t have to spend that $2.99 on something every time

forest rover
#

Not fair for the people that already bought it imo...

craggy dagger
#

Well, devs make some revenue off people watching ads

The best way to ensure players at the very least end up watching ads is to get them to play a lot and have more opportunity to click on the “watch an ad” button ie the gold wheel

Which is why the game promotes grinding.

runic dragon
#

True

#

Maybe make special outfits for that purpose? Not like clan quest though. It just isn’t fair to the people who can’t spend money on the game

upbeat sentinel
#

Suggestion:

Add trading system so we can trade outfits or items.

lament knoll
#

Heyy @vale gyro and @slow flume

About the sect leader suggestion -> not going to happen... Once selected you stay sect member no matter what, it's the same principle as for zombies

Otherwise the sect members, like seer for example, would only get encouraged to reveal their sect leader as once the medium revives them it's like they have never been in the sect before

If the sect leader forced them to converting and they commit suicide because their leader died it's just logical even if revived they will still be of the convince that the ideals and goals of the sect leader, even if dead are the ones that must get transferred onto other people

Thanks for your feedback tho! HR_KyoThumbsUp single_rose

Andddd @forest rover sure that has already been suggested before but I'll check how long ago and maybe give it a repost cz_round_heart

Hello @zenith kayak and @next escarp

New solo killers will get added once they are actually bug-free, we would prefer only putting flawlessly working roles into ranked instead of getting ranted at because we added a buggy role into a competitive game mode... I think ranked has enough issues at the moment to work on so a buggy role on top wouldn't really be in favor, would it?

So as soon as the new solo killing roles are bug-free they will get added to ranked voteyes cz_round_heart

calm pollen
rigid bronze
#

That's how the designer drew it 👀 I think it's Kem, contact via DMs 👌

calm pollen
#

K

zenith kayak
#

@lament knoll hai,

Then will ss be taken out soon? It's very buggy still, I see sk as blue still

slow flume
#

Hm. True. Was just really annoying since I got reved as tough guy after the sect leader had died, and I basically couldn't win at all then.

calm pollen
#

@rigid bronze Can you tell me his name? I cant find im.

rigid bronze
#

KemTrangTien#9980

#

He is guardian + designer manager so dw if he doesn't reply asap

lament knoll
#

Aaah @zenith kayak

That's happening consecutively?
I mean a new season will start soon so maybe it's already planned to take ss out, if not I could forward it to Philipp/Emanuel and ask them to take ss out for the upcoming season because it's still bugging HR_KyoThumbsUp cz_round_heart

zenith kayak
#

I check sk 2/5 times and see it blue, when a kill happens, it's sadly still happening often :c

upbeat sentinel
#

Can someone tell the dev to make a shirtless item so I can finally make my dream character Ricardo Milos.

zenith kayak
#

@lament knoll ^^^^^

rain fiber
#

enable already bought offers to be shown when they re appear

#

if i have outfit thats currently the offer ,i cant see it. :(

lament knoll
#

Heyyy @sacred sable

Sure,,, why not?
Tho I could imagine the being able to protect yourself making many docs never protecting someone else because they want to stay alive

About which amount of protects were you thinking? S3NaoSmile

Hello @shut pecan

Yeah that would indeed be too strong... Like that you literally almost wouldn't be able to lose as hh unless you actually get killed before your target does

Plus when you're lucky and wws kill your target you will get more xp even tho you didn't do anything for it, same for village but ww win gets more xp👀

Hey @upbeat sentinel

Frequently suggested option, being able to sell your items, tho I don't know if/think it's possible that these items actually get deleted from your inventory

Also how would that even work? Adding a flea market option where you just have to check if an item you have got is there?

Would take the exclusivity of legendary items to be honest...

So nice idea in theory, just not really realisable...

Thanks for the suggestion tho AwooLove cz_round_heart

#

Heyyy @runic dragon

You might want to upvote that suggestion: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/662015012092510208

Seems to be similar to the one you suggested!

Thanks for your suggestion single_rose S3NaoSmile

Hello @upbeat sentinel

Similar to the second last #feedback-devs but we do not encourage that, because like that you could easily sell/give away your account/the avatars that come within your account without it actually looking like it,,,

Also it makes it easier avoiding your ban or also to troll and escaping punishment with deleting your old and creating new account...

In general it's bringing more bad than good so it's most likely not going to be added...

Still thanks for your suggestion! HR_KyoThumbsUp cz_round_heart

have a nice day/lovely evening everyone! owoAwoo ❤️

#

@zenith kayak alright, thanks for your feedback I will redirect that! S3NaoSmile ❤️

zenith kayak
#

MochaLoveMilkLove Minnn

lament knoll
#

Also @upbeat sentinel

We don't really encouraged nudity in wwo, that is why you cannot select to not wear a shirt, there are a couple of shirtless items tho with shading which indicates muscles HR_KyoThumbsUp

Hello @rain fiber
Yes that's a known issue FlusteredKitty
You can see it if you enter the store and 'send a gift' and then you see 'special offer' and which offer it is

I know the devs are aware of that and probably working on probably changing that, either way I think a small heads up in form from a repost wouldn't hurt!

Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day/lovely evening! owoAwoo cz_round_heart

#

||@zenith kayak owoMilkLove I love u too mashi||

rain fiber
#

minamelie

#

u have cute lips

sacred sable
#

@lament knoll Four max, three preferrable
But... this was more of a joke... sorry Min >>""
(Town of Salem's Doc can protect self or others up to three times)

upbeat sentinel
#

woah there moondog

marble bolt
#

Una duda, en mi gremio el líder hace casi medio año que no se conecta, no hay co-líderes y tiene más de 1000 monedas en las arcas. Debería haber alguna forma de poner a otro de líder si el líder lleva mucho inactivo

forest rover
#

@marble bolt here you need to talk in english 😅

marble bolt
#

I don't know how to say it in English

forest rover
#

Let me translate it then 😁

forest rover
#

I have a question: In my clan,the leader hasn't been playing in half a year,we have no co-leaders and we have more than 1000 coins in it.There's any way of deleting the leader if the leader hasn't been playing for a long time?

#

Yeah that's what he wanted to say 👀

runic dragon
#

Hey ! I have a problem with my account someone can help there ?

forest rover
#

Sure @runic dragon!Go to #questions to ask about what you need and I'll help you if I'm able to,but probably someone will.

runic dragon
#

Thanks !

lament knoll
#

Yeah, I did understand it :p
I can understand insert language bc I am not sure which one of the two it is bc for me one is just the same as the other but with an accent :p

But I'm not good enough for speaking it :p
@forest rover can you tell them that there is no fix for that yet but that it has been suggested before and they can upvote it at the link provided? FlusteredKitty cz_round_heart

quick smelt
lament knoll
#

thanks moondog btw, even tho that's off topic talk :p

quick smelt
#

Ehh

lament knoll
#

@quick smelt yeah,, you can bypass words by using spaces there isn't really a fix for that....

Just report them in game and check #ingame-reports-archieved for a list of guardians and report them to a guardian again voteyes

quick smelt
#

Oh

#

Okay

#

Thanks

lament knoll
#

Also would you mind deleting your screen now?
We don't wanna see such expressions, even not in a screen where it isn't said by yourself single_rose

#

@quick smelt ^ AwooLove

runic dragon
#

Can we have multiple divisions of rank

  1. Seer and aura
  2. Det and aura
  3. Spirit seer and aura
craggy dagger
#

No seer in gold ranked thanks

runic dragon
#

Ya well rank season has to start somewhere and I hate it too

craggy dagger
#

seer is just outright stronger than detective or spirit seer.

lament knoll
#

Working like the role rotation in SB?
Like every couple of games you get thrown into a different set up?S3NaoSmile

craggy dagger
#

I’m okay with detective switching for spirit seer, but not for it to switch for seer

runic dragon
#

Like we have seer games and then det games. Can we have three. Seer. Det. Spirit seer.

craggy dagger
#

I predict seer games will lead to a higher village win% than det games or spirit seer games

runic dragon
#

It starts at seer

lament knoll
#

Sure!

Only for Silver and Bronze then and for gold only Spirit Seer - Detective maybe?

craggy dagger
#

Simply because seer is unaffected by shaman and can check exact roles

runic dragon
#

Three modes instead of just two

craggy dagger
#

Silver and Bronze having seer games is fine, if you want silver and bronze games to have a seer/det/spirit seer rotation that is fine

I don’t want gold to have seer in a rotation.

runic dragon
#

So you make it to det games and later you make it ss games

craggy dagger
#

I think spirit seer being stronger than detective is arguable.

lament knoll
#

spirit seer being buggy most of all rn eh

runic dragon
#

Ss is more challenging than det

craggy dagger
#

Inexperience with the role itself is to blame there I’d suspect

runic dragon
#

Wws don't kill. Welp. No info

#

It's a whole new level

craggy dagger
#

Wws don’t kill, villagers don’t die

runic dragon
#

And zero info

#

Yolo

lament knoll
#

Sooo, could you form your suggestion a bit detailed again so I can post it to #feedback-devs ? @runic dragon S3NaoSmile single_rose

craggy dagger
#

It makes werewolves deliberately choosing to not kill a fascinating strategic decision

#

I’m on board with it.

runic dragon
#

Eek I'm so bad at that

#

Sov don't you think it'll be awesome for a top rank level?

#

No more than an idea but Can you add where we can report the game for a random vote? Or the people who voted for it?

lament knoll
#

Rotation in Leagues or in Games is my main question point rn :p

austere relic
#

The role description of roles like sect members, couple and bitten would be cool...

runic dragon
#

Ww may not kill on purpose to buy and fake protection

craggy dagger
#

I like the idea of spirit seer rotating with detective, I don’t like it rotating with seer

runic dragon
#

And village will try and counteract it

#

Oh like ss and det switches like arso and sk?

craggy dagger
#

Yes it promotes distinction in metagame

runic dragon
#

That's actually a good idea so players can get used to it

craggy dagger
#

No, I think I might be misunderstanding your suggestion to a degree

#

Right now here is what I think your suggestion is

runic dragon
#

Well you inspired an idea for a new season of rank

#

Like the games switch detween arso and sk it can switch between det and ss

#

It can be a main role. Not an rv.

lament knoll
#

Heyy @runic dragon

Guardians can unfortunately not see who voted who so they lack of evidence for such reports...
You can report in under "others" tho

You can report anything not listed under "others" tho as I said guardians won't have evidence of random voting but it's also not a thing that's bad enough to report to a guardian in dms so... Difficult topic FlusteredKitty cz_round_heart

craggy dagger
#

Suggestion

Right now in ranked there are games with a confirmed seer and games with a confirmed detective

Please change the system so that there can be a confirmed spirit seer in game as well

In bronze/silver elo games there is a confirmed seer. That doesn’t need to be changed

In gold elo games there is a confirmed detective. Jasmins suggestion is that instead of games always having a confirmed detective, sometimes there should be a confirmed spirit seer instead of a confirmed detective to promote strategic depth.

#

Have I understood right?

runic dragon
#

I'll try...
Can rank have more modes..
Start : seer games
Once you get to say 1700 you move to
2nd : det mode
Once you get to 2500
You get to spririt seer mode.
An alternative is that higher switches between detecide and spirit seer. Just like it switches between arsonist and serial killer.

craggy dagger
#

Similar to how ranked games switch between having a fool or a hh and having SK or arso, the suggestion entails gold ranked games switching between having a detective and a spirit seer.

runic dragon
#

Wow it's so spaced out. Haha. Sorry

lament knoll
#

Heyy @austere relic

Bitten, Couple and Sect member aren't actually roles tho, they are rather team changers, they don't change anything for your role

Tho, maybe there could be added a Description for it in your roles list right underneath the role you got converted from once you get converted...

Other than that I don't really see convenience in that, does that seem alright to you? S3NaoSmile cz_round_heart

craggy dagger
#

@runic dragon the main issue with your suggestion as you’ve described it is that it contains a playerpool split from 1700 to 2500, right now they aren’t planning to implement playerpool splits at the moment.

austere relic
#

I mean

runic dragon
#

Wait. I was fixing spacing

austere relic
#

Fir bew players it might be a bit confusing

runic dragon
#

Well I made up a figure

craggy dagger
#

It’s already confusing for new players when they reach det games from playing seer games, that’s a separate issue roleeater

runic dragon
#

Whatever det mode is add like 500 and go from there

#

Which can't rank be like a ladder

craggy dagger
#

Jasmin, that still results in a player pool split.

runic dragon
#

I adore whoever created spirit seer. It's a sus role and week det but OP with fool

#

New roles come in.
Wws : everyone claim the new roles!!
Fool : I'm fc

#

Ss is so much harder. Zero kills means no info. Make it the highest rank info giver

lament knoll
#

Okay @runic dragon

You're good with your suggestion like that?
Can I post it or do you want to add anything more? AwooLove

runic dragon
#

If anyone can reword it better please do

#

I even just guessed figures

#

What if every 500 level we made it harder

#

Fight your way to that end

#

Like you just got into det game.. You know if you lose this you're going back to seer hell. You really play your heart out that game

#

It's into fair it stats at seer for new players

#

It's been det games for ages so maybe we can try the switch between det and ss like sk and arso

#

But I think it would be awesome to come up with more levels and ideas

#

"I made it to det games"

lament knoll
#

Can rank have more modes?

Like, you start with Seer games, once you get to... let's say 1700 you move to the next mode which is
Detective mode, and once you get to 2500
You get to Spirit seer mode.

Or

An alternative is that higher ups, switch between detective and spirit seer. Just like it switches between arsonist and serial killer.

It's been det games for ages so maybe we can try the switch between det and ss like sk and arso.

Like that maybe?

rigid oriole
#

Hello, Grifus is a player of your game. She was named in Lp when she was unmasked. she denounced the lp. I don't find that normal. basically she cheated

craggy dagger
#

@lament knoll thanks for making a clean format!

lament knoll
#

I'm a format freak smh,,, I re-format almost all suggestions tehehehe

#

@sacred sable
Smh only serious suggestions here Kit :p
If it was a joke no need in posting I guess? S3NaoSmile

shell crystal
#

How do you invite a friend to play a game of Werewolf? Or where does that invite request pop up? After inviting my friend they get no invite to the lobby 🤔

runic dragon
#

!unban

#

Next time please use #questions but anyways to invite a friend you must use play with a friend in the selection screen and hit the pink button at the bottom that says invite friends. The notification will appear on their account a popup in the bottom left corner will appear saying they got Invited. @shell crystal

lament knoll
#

Yumi smhhh

#

@runic dragon do you think your ban isn't justified and want to dispute it with a guardian? S3NaoSmile cz_round_heart

runic dragon
#

Thx i found a guardian in french chat

honest canyon
ancient wasp
#

Ok so

  1. Bronze/Silver: Seer games
  2. 1700: Detective games
  3. 2500: Spirit seer games
  4. 3200: Random info giver? (Seer/Det/Ss)
  5. 4000: Random killers ? (Random info giver too) (excludes sl/zombie)
#

@runic dragon

#

To devs: But seer and detective is in random strong villager

#

And spirit seer is in random regular villager

#

So spirit seer has to be turned into random strong villager?

#

Otherwise it isn't valuable and easily faked

#

Like there is supposed to be four random strong villagers in game and now there are only three

#

(Original: Seer/Detective, Med, Jail, Gun)
(New: Med, Jail, Gun, ??)

craggy dagger
#

Seer is easily a stronger villager than detective and that will translate to an increase in village winning if they have a Seer over a Det @ancient wasp

Spirit seer and Det I’m not sure if either would perform better or worse than each other, if I had to guess I think a spirit seer being in game would lead to a higher winrate than a detective

hardy glen
#

Det is better than spirit seer

floral heath
#

Spirit seer info can’t be shamaned 😏

runic dragon
#

Detective can check even if no one kills. Ss cannot. but when wws kill, ss is way more effective in finding wws. but I don't think they can be compared unless a scenario is given. for example ss is stronger in sk games.

high fable
#

If HH target is converted into a Zombie/WW, HH will stay in HH team, until their target dies. But will still win if target is lynched.
I want a change : HH won't win if his target being a converted Zombie/WW is lynched

runic dragon
#

ADD A VOTING LOG W/ COOLDOWN FOR CHANGING VOTES

#

Consistency between Zombies and Sect Leader?

#

Zombies can bite solos and turn them into a zombie, but Sect Leader can't convert Solos into sects

#

Both can't convert werewolves, and that's fine

ancient wasp
#

@craggy dagger ikr I mean if spirit seer has to be added into ranked, it should be regrouped to strong villager?

#

Lol btw if det and ss switch, it would be funny like "This is a det fool arso game" "This is a ss hh sk game" lol

high fable
#

@runic dragon Zombie cannot bite Solo -.-

runic dragon
#

They can lol

#

I tried

craggy dagger
#

I mean det is a worse aura most of the time!

It can’t differentiate between different types of non village besides getting = on two wolves

It checks against 2 people so more likely to be affected by shaman.

Aura seer can differentiate between different non villagers besides alpha ww and only checks 1 person so less chance of being shamaned

#

Having an alpha ww is the only reason why having an aura is worse for wolves than a detective.

languid cape
#

Ss is a better version of det that cannot be effected by shaman but is dependent on the evil roles killing

craggy dagger
#

^

languid cape
#

I think spirit seer is way too strong to be a random villager and so is aura but it gives ww and solos claim space

runic dragon
#

I claim that solos can be bitten by Zb

#

Because I've tried before in Custom

sudden dock
#

There should be a badge exclusive to people whom have participated in 10 quests.

runic dragon
#

There should be new tutorials in the game
Currently there is only a tutorial teaching you the very basics of the game
What I am proposing is that there should be a tutorial regarding rrv roles when you join ranked and sandbox for the first time
It can be made just like the current tutorial, something of an introduction about rrv roles. For example:
There is/are one(sandbox)/three (ranked) rrv roles in this game mode. Rrv roles can be (list all rrvs). Keep in mind that there may be more than one bh/doc in game!
because when I first joined ranked it was very confusing for me, I had to learn the mechanics on my own and it took a long while to get used to. this could help new players to adopt to the rrvs. it might improve gameplay too.
it doesn't have to be in-depth. just the basics will do.

balmy lark
#

**The requirement fixing of Silver and Gold Ranked Games, For new players that just joined ranked, the replacement games can help shoot up their skill points into 1.7k sp if their village carry them.

Thus, the requirements for the league games should be re-organise since new players that come into gold league because of replacement games ruin the game.

Yes, we can report the player BUT they cannot pay our skill points back

The requirements for Bronze league should also be the Win percentile like 45% so the players that consistently loses wouldn’t ruin the game

runic dragon
#

it's a problem but this doesn't look like the best solution

balmy lark
#

Yes but anything that helps will help

#

Because Gold League is really ruined

runic dragon
#

good players with low wr because of quick game -> not able to join ranked -> forced to grind wr on quick -> wr becomes even lower

balmy lark
#

it’s supposed to be a place where the best players of the game come together and compete with each other

runic dragon
#

I get what you're saying

balmy lark
#

When Season 15 ends, the gold league standard = bronze league standard in Season 12

runic dragon
#

at least state how to reorganise the requirements
and it's been suggested, rejected, suggested again and rejected

balmy lark
#

The bronze league is even worse

#

It’s just another place for Quick Game players

#

But with more wins

glacial warren
#

@ancient wasp many users say, that the spirit seer is too weak BlobThonk so you just want to say, that spirit seer should be rsv?
Also I think it always depends on how you use them ^^

@high fable has been suggested before a few times already. The problem is, that the hh is not supposed to be a seer role.

@runic dragon already has been suggested before ^^ thank you for your suggestion

@runic dragon what's your suggestion? I can't really see it

@sudden dock there are already many badges in game and I don't think you need one for this unnecessary reason ^^'

@runic dragon more and different New tutorials have been suggested before ^^ thank you very much for your suggestion and time to describe it 👍

high fable
#

@glacial warren
No, what I mean is, HH won't even know that their target got converted. But when the target is lynched, HH simply won't win.
Did you even read my message properly? -.-

zenith kayak
languid cape
#

I predicted that before the role actually came out and sent a suggestion to wwotc but no response 😂

#

Oh I still dont know if the hh wins if their target was converted

quaint bramble
#

@languid cape yup hh still wins if target is converted, both in kww and zombie cases

#

the devs went for the easiest option

languid cape
#

Yeah kiten ww is weird and shouldnt be in ranked

quaint bramble
#

I agree, but thats not really a feedback for now

high fable
#

@zenith kayak Mine is still different

zenith kayak
#

Yours is the headhunter still sees the target, but when lynched it's not a game over, correct? @high fable

high fable
#

Yeah...

zenith kayak
#

That's also what I suggested :/

high fable
#

By what you wrote, I didn't think so

#

Maybe the Dev also misunderstood

zenith kayak
#

The devs are just taking the easiest option and ignoring the kitten hh thing

#

What did you think I suggested @high fable

high fable
#

idk

#

lmao

runic dragon
#

i suppose yall need to read back to the thing philipp said regarding kww and hh target

twilit fjord
#

Need to raise the level for sb. I get new players not knowing the sb specific roles, but most of them dont even know the quick game roles like how to revive as med, or be jailer, or dont know how to be wws. Left quick game partly cause of this and now sb is just as bad. And as far as the sb roles, new players dont take the time to read the role description or learn to play. Most players that say they're coupled when they're coupled are new players. I never did that when cupid was first intriduced. It's because alot new players don't take them to read or learn the role. Please raise the level for sb.

twilit fjord
#

(Continuation from above message) Also, I really don’t win that much xp unless I play with my friends, cause they know what they’re doing and how to play. When I play solo, I get like 15-30 xp per game cause of new players. I play with my friends and the majority of the time I’ll get anywhere from 70-120 xp.

serene lotus
#

Add two countdowns to the ranked info board. It would be quite useful to know when a season is going to end (or start) exactly, so you‘re able to plan how much skill points you might want to get in order for you to rank up.

runic dragon
#

heavily suggested @twilit fjord

jagged pagoda
#

Where I can talk with guardians?

#

Just idk

runic dragon
#
How to dispute your WWO Ban

Message one of the following guardians and make sure you include your in-game name and name any reasons why the ban is invalid in your initial message. If it comes to discussions do not be rude or your ban will not be taken away.

List of guardians:

  • Kem => @crisp thistle (@KemTrangTien#9980) :flag_vn:
  • Alisonn => @naive whale (Alisonn_#4655) :flag_ca: :flag_fr:
  • Boy => @arctic nova (@BoyHanQuoc#6473) :flag_vn:
  • Oliver => @elder dew (@Oliver#8960) :flag_de:
  • Renard => @snow ruin (@Renard_eau#9157) :flag_fr:
  • Catjojo => @hollow hinge (@catjojo|Jenn|#7139) :flag_de:
  • Artemiis => @sharp cedar (@Artemiis#9648) :flag_fr: :flag_es: :flag_nl: :flag_de: :flag_it:
  • SionnY => @dreamy vortex (@SionnY#2590) :flag_th:
#

^ you may dm one of them

#

Suggestion: If there were some consistencies between Zombies and Sect Leader, that would be nice. Because in some of the custom game modes I made, I found out that Zombies can bite and convert solo, where it's the contrast for Sect Leader

#

@serene lotus agreed. I now and again get a notification but I'd like to be able to check when it ends. Some people know and I don't know how they know. Keep track of time?

quaint bramble
#

@twilit fjord Increasing the entry for sb has been suggested many times before so its no use for us to post that again, the devs will conaider it when they think its necesary

The xp thing doesnt sound like a feedback? yes you get a +40xp bonus if you play with friends, thats normal

#

@serene lotus We got this for battlepass now and I agree it would be nice for ranked too, I will post this!

runic dragon
#

Would it be bad idea to have two sandboxes?

#

One for all and another for level 50 up?

#

Ya

#

There won't be much difference

#

It's there to also test roles so it should be open to all

quaint bramble
#

The devs arent looking to add new modes right now so yeah thats just not something i can post

floral heath
#

And guess how many people suggested that xD

runic dragon
#

Sandbox has a really sad suicide rate. Would he nice to play with legit players there

#

I get tired of rank. Pop into sandbox. Oh wow three roles suicided. Aaand then I go back to rank.

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon The zombie and sl interaction with other roles has been changed a few times recently due to a bug.
It should be possible for both of them to convert fool/hh, but not other solo killing roles

runic dragon
#

It's a pity because sandbox is more creative

floral heath
#

Usually I just make my own game in custom that way if everyone suicides I got nothing to lose

runic dragon
#

One of the other reasons I run back to rank is preserve my win rate

floral heath
#

There’s also nothing saying you can’t play sandbox games using alts

#

As in not multiple in same game

#

Just not your real acc

quaint bramble
#

Thats just the game rules in general, ofc its not allowed >.>

twilit fjord
#

@quaint bramble thank you, and it’s not a feedback, supposed to be part of the feedback I gave tho, also sorry for the long post 🙈

runic dragon
#

Hm, I understood that, but I could counterclaim that Solo Killers can't be converted by Zombies

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon yeah they arent supposed to be convertable to zombies as far as i know 🤔

#

zombies are solos themselves

runic dragon
#

Yep

#

So my suggestion in short: The devs could try to fix that one bug, or make the Sect Leader be able to convert Solo Killers into sects as well

#

I dunno 👀

#

I can see why Zombies and Sect Leader should be able to convert Fool/HH/Any upcoming Solo Lynchers into their team

#

But not how Zombies can just convert Solo Killers. That'd be an overkill, for Solos that just want to work on their own

quaint bramble
#

So what are you saying is the problem then? When were you last able to bite a solo killer?

#

it should be fixed by now

runic dragon
#

In any of the Custom modes I try

quaint bramble
#

when?

runic dragon
#

I can't remember exactly, maybe a few days ago?

quaint bramble
#

Alright well, if it happens again could you pleas report it in #bugs-readonly ?

#

with screenshot proof

runic dragon
#

Hm, I will

quaint bramble
#

cause at this point it should be a fixed problem, solo killers shouldnt be able to be converted/bitten

runic dragon
#

Alrighty, thanks @quaint bramble

#

Hello I've been banned and I don't know why?

#

My name is ItzUni

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon heya the reason should already be in the message, but if you think its not right or you want more info, the please direct-message a guardian.
And next time use the #questions channel instead, thanks ^^

runic dragon
#
How to dispute your WWO Ban

Message one of the following guardians and make sure you include your in-game name and name any reasons why the ban is invalid in your initial message. If it comes to discussions do not be rude or your ban will not be taken away.

List of guardians:

  • Kem => @crisp thistle (@KemTrangTien#9980) :flag_vn:
  • Alisonn => @naive whale (Alisonn_#4655) :flag_ca: :flag_fr:
  • Boy => @arctic nova (@BoyHanQuoc#6473) :flag_vn:
  • Oliver => @elder dew (@Oliver#8960) :flag_de:
  • Renard => @snow ruin (@Renard_eau#9157) :flag_fr:
  • Catjojo => @hollow hinge (@catjojo|Jenn|#7139) :flag_de:
  • Artemiis => @sharp cedar (@Artemiis#9648) :flag_fr: :flag_es: :flag_nl: :flag_de: :flag_it:
  • SionnY => @dreamy vortex (@SionnY#2590) :flag_th:
#

And where I can contact the Guardian?

#

I don't know if this is a silly request but can our items have the artists name on them?

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon I posted the list right there, click on one of their blue name 😅
if it says 'invalid user' its a discord bug, then try the same list in #ingame-reports-archieved channel

runic dragon
#

I know sorry

#

Whew. I have posted the bug in #bugs-readonly. It's definitely still ingame

#

it's probably being fixed

#

Hopefully

#

it takes time for devs to fix bugs

#

just wait a bit

#

Yeah, I will

#

I just felt like I had to mention the bug, because it makes me feel bad for the Sect Leader

#

Who can't convert solos-

rich karma
#

I have feedback on the photographed vote. the worrying thing about this vote are all the no-voters, I mean, who's going to vote no if he doesn't practice cheating?🥴🙈

rigid bronze
#

The vote doesn't make the decision :3

silver ruin
#

A suggestion for zombie nerf:

Stop zombie bite from bypassing protection, and let zombie be affected by protection role (bh can kill them, tg can see them(but not die)), etc

Reasoning: It's a simple logic actually. As zombie myself , I often win those games. But there are few simple conclusion that zombie loses, it's either :

1: Zombie bitten a ww in the first few day
2: Ww killed a zombie/bitten in the first few day
3: Being discovered really early(luck).

But, by this logic apply, why does making zom cannot bypass protection nerf it harsh rather than just a small amount ?

1: Villager at least know that, protected player cannot be converted until protector died/protector got turned , thus making it quite easy to find zombie until protector dies.
2: Wolves often target unprotected player, increasing the chance of killing a potentially bitten player/zombie.
3: Zombie cannot bite through protection, meaning there's more chance for failure from protection/biting wolves.

I believe a nerf like this is sufficient enough to bring zombie back from its op ness, and will make zombie a lot more fun to play against.

runic dragon
#

Just a very minor suggestion:
I notice that we can choose the backgrounds when we want to share our avatar. It would be nice if those backgrounds were purchasable content (Gold or real currency works, gold preferred), and be used while playing some matches. Only you can see the background, and it'd give your playing experience a bit of a personal touch!

dense rain
#

@meager gyro i answer you

meager gyro
#

@dense rain I wont reply faster if you ping me here 😅

fickle blade
runic dragon
#

Hey do you have feedback?, @fickle blade

#

@runic dragon hmmm i don't really know how it will look in game. But idea is nice voteyes i like idea but i'm not sure if it will look weird?

#

Trust me, it won't! I mean, it'd be nice to have personal backgrounds for your own playing experience. The background for your avatars and your gameplay is pretty much identical

#

So it won't be a problem

#

I think backgrounds that are able to have repetitive patterns would blend in pretty neatly voteyes

#

Yeah especially if you do youtube videos about wwo 🤔

#

Yup

#

Instead of having to see backgrounds based on the season and update, which can get slightly boring, you can totally have a new eye-catching experience!

#

All for the cost of some real cash or some gold

#

@silver ruin hey something like it is already suggested. But thanks for your suggestion zombies are too op it is true GWinfxHeart

#

Hm, also, for the Zombie nerf suggestion

#

I think the BH one can slightly be reworked

#

BH's traps are designed to work SPECIFICALLY on werewolves only

#

So if Zombies bit the person who was trapped, BH should be notified with "Your trap was activated, but the enemy was too strong..."

#

Much like Sect Leader's conversion

silver ruin
#

I mean that's true, it is for ww only

#

Though it shouldn't bypass protection, the bite

runic dragon
#

Yes, it shouldn't

silver ruin
#

I still remain by that fact just because there's that possibility tg gotten bitten and something strange happens

runic dragon
#

True

silver ruin
#

So it's better if I take ww interactions and make it zombie like

runic dragon
#

Anyways, you can make it so the trapped one won't get turned, but the trap won't kill the Zombie

silver ruin
#

Though bh shouldn't work = yes it shouldn't

#

(well it is suggested sooo)

runic dragon
#

Yeaaahh

#

Just saying

unreal turret
#

O_o

glacial warren
#

@high fable yes I read it. This has already been suggested before

high fable
#

Okay

dense rain
#

@pallid merlin i write my tag discord in my Instagram post and now

pallid merlin
#

Now you wait and you stop pinging me or I won't give you any rewards 😄 This is now the 4th time I tell you to stop pinging me.

#

Better be the last.

dense rain
#

Ok

sonic kraken
#

Selam

#

Türkçe kanalda yazma yetkim yok. Burada birileri vardır umarım

#

The cudy arkaplanı uygulama indirmem karşılığında alabileceğim söyleniyor oyun içinde. Uygulamayı indirdiğim halde arkaplan hesabıma gelmedi. Ne yapmam gerekir ?

runic dragon
#

Err, I'm lost

#

@sonic kraken Turk channel was closed and the reason are listed there

To get The Cult mask you have to download The Cult, go to Setting and insert your WWO username, to get The Cult Background you have to buy the Pro Version

sonic kraken
#

Teşekkürler @Toon

#

Thanks @Toon

floral quail
#

so at the end of the game, if you are converted, write the original role of the user before converted for easier reports

#

like

5 3061LRTAGSPKJMORMRT (jailer) werewolf

signal lodge
#

Report's threating should be not allowed in the game. For example; Vote 4 or i report you.
This isnt on the guardian's guideline and it should.

quaint bramble
#

@floral quail heya that's definately been suggested before 👍 I dont think it needs a repost right now

#

@signal lodge heya I checked the ingame rules and while it sounds obvious to me, its indeed not specified. I'll pass it on the the mods

floral quail
#

@quaint bramble also, maybe have a small log?

like

night1:
wws checks 1 (med)
wws decided to kill 3
sk decides to stab etc.

#

I sometimes wanna know what happened

quaint bramble
#

Like during the game or after?

floral quail
#

oh and the logs is only available when you finish the game

#

After

quaint bramble
#

yeah also suggested before, but i can add a +1 in the feedback database

dreamy burrow
#

@signal lodge i dont think it shuld be. Its just a kind of strat. If someone cant think for themselves and get under pressure, he doesnt deserve to win anyway.

floral quail
#

like you only can view xp for 1 time, like that

#

@dreamy burrow I highly disagree with that

#

it's not a strat

quaint bramble
#

Strat.. I dont think so... falsely reporting people is not allowed for sure, too many invalid reports can lead to a punishment

floral quail
#

^

quaint bramble
#

and threatening doesnt sound like fair play at all

floral quail
#

it can be counted as gamethrowing right?

#

I have received messages

#

gimme Rose or I shoot det

dreamy burrow
#

Rose bribing is diff

#

But if i want to confuse a priest to vote proven med in a 3v1

#

I have to do that

#

The fact that he cant use his brain is his fault

#

The game is about lying and bluffing

#

Also no one actually reports. Its just to confuse the person in game

floral quail
#

no

#

reporting can lead to a ban

#

the person ofc won't want a ban

#

it's pyscological

runic dragon
#

is it possible to have a thing where accounts get deactivated after a certain period of inactivity (only if it’s clear that the user won’t be coming back ig) bcs usernames just get taken up-

dreamy burrow
#

I mean that I'm just threatening to report. To confuse the person to vote proven med instead of me. Cuz i want to win as ww or whatever. Im not actually reporting. If that person doesnt realize he's voting med instead of fake rv aura claim or smthng he doesnt deserve the win anyway 😂

floral quail
#

You are forcing a person to listen to you and giving him a threat.... the person will have to listen or they think you will report since they can't know if you reported or not

dreamy burrow
#

Lol

#

If i reported, then i shuld be banned instead

#

Hence the logic

#

Why would i report a villager for voting me and playing his role 😂 even if im confusing him

signal lodge
#

Update the guardian's guideline

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon You can already claim names of inactive accounts if
-they are below level 20 (or 25 im not sure)
-they got no loyalty tokens (so never bought anything)
-they havent logged in for 6 months

runic dragon
#

@quaint bramble do they have to meet all three criteria ? also does the username just become available

#

sorrysomanyquestions-

quaint bramble
#

@signal lodge I passed it on to staff team and yeah they're aware the guidelines are outdated compared to the ingame rules, but its not a big priority right now. As I said, the ingame rules apply when it comes to reporting.
They are rules, the other is just a guideline

#

@runic dragon Yes they have to meet all 3 criteria, and the name will stay on their acc until someone else tries to change their name to it

signal lodge
#

Okay, thanks maje boy. I wont bother ya anymore @quaint bramble

runic dragon
#

okay tysm :’)

pine jacinth
#

We must do something about the matching, i cant stand being matched with player whom rank was bronze last season in my ranked game , my own fkin ww seer telling to the whole village day who is the sk

#

Wtf is this

calm pollen
#

Well, what your suggesting?

#

We can do stuff about it but what?

#

What do we change about it?

zenith kayak
#

Make reviving an off person impossible

calm pollen
#

Yeah.

#

That should have been already implemented in game.

pine jacinth
#

U match gold player with gold

runic dragon
#

is it possible to be unbanned?

pine jacinth
#

Even if gold is clown fiesta sometimes

#

Still better than playing with clown in seer game

runic dragon
#

@runic dragon Contact a guardians

#

where do i find them?

#

Here

#

thanks

#

Please remember to not be rude when talking to guardians.

#

for sure

floral quail
#

just do ?h ban next time @runic dragon 👀

fast marsh
#

Most people only play for xp, like they don't care about anything that happens as long as they win, they want the game to end as fast as possible or do xp boosting. To loosen the problem a bit, I'd suggest an extra "currency" for the battlepass so you can unlock the tiers not only with xp or money.
The battlepass points are calculated on how good you're playing. For example as ww, you can earn points with how many villagers you've killed during the night or during the day votes. A solo killer can earn points the same way. Also special things like "last ww standing" or something can be added and will give extra points, to prevent gamethrowing then on the other hand that last ww should be only happening after night 4 or something.
Villagers can earn points with how many evil players they've voted out or depending on their abilities. For example, seer can earn points with how many people they've checked, gunner with shooting evil players, bh with how many ww walked into their trap, and so on...
Of course you'll also get battlepass points also for completing a game, how many depending on if your team won or not, similar to xp.

I don't know if it's a good idea or even doable but I got this idea while playing, so yeah if it isn't then excuse me 🙏 🙈

floral quail
#

yes

#

I agree with @fast marsh

#

reduces xp farming

#

especially in rank

sacred sable
#

But what if you die n1 every time and are a non-rev role?

#

IE any role in Sandbox that isn't Seer or Spirit Seer

languid cape
#

Literally me everygame?

thin dome
#

Can we add to hh desc who his/her possible targets could be? It would help out newer players alot!

forest rover
#

^Adding to that,in villagers roles,like the team appears,another information that shows if that role is able to be headhunter target or not.

reef pastureBOT
#

XMARK6 GR33NR3AP3R, you can't use that

light edge
#

Hi any chance we can get role restrictions for new players who play ranked but just started playing?
Like no access to bullets until you are at least lvl 30?

burnt iron
#

How do I get the discord shirt

#

? discord shirt

#

?hwlp

#

?help

warm swan
#

@burnt iron do ?discord shirt in #bot-commands, this channel is only for feedback cute_heart

sacred sable
#

@thin dome
A list of villager roles that CAN'T be targets wouls be shorter.

thin dome
#

@sacred sable that way works too

#

that can be a second option

lament knoll
#

Hello @pine jacinth

So you mean matching players that ended in gold league with one another in placement games or throughout the whole season?
I do believe either way it has been suggested before and reposted pretty recently so I don't think that specific idea is worthy of a repost yet

Thanks for your suggestion tho, and have a nice day! I could maybe pick out the link and give it to you so you can upvote it?S3NaoSmile cz_round_heart

Heyy @zenith kayak

I do agree with that, the current way is showing a pop up that this person is offline but still some people just want to throw or manage to ignore that completely not sure if a "do not show again" button exists tho

I know it used to be impossible but for some reason that got changed... I mean it could be because of the players showing offline when they are actually online issue/bug but no idea...

I'll re-check and might give it a post, thanks for your feedback and have a nice day! HR_KyoThumbsUp

Hey hey @fast marsh

Hm... How would these points work tho?
How many points for which thing, how many points to finish a tier?

It needs to be equally hard as getting the xp or otherwise you would only make the bp easier

Could you elaborate the details further?
The mere idea is good but it lacks of detail and depth on how it'll work and how the correlation between xp and these points would be and it's also a huge question of being lucky tbh cz_round_heart

#

Hello @thin dome

I personally don't see how, which role your target could be would help new players if I am being honest...
I doubt that players which are totally new in the materia will actually try to figure out their target's role and claim it before they do in order to arise suspicion against it and probably get it lynched

I personally think newer players are more the ones that go yolo acussing their target as evil on day one hoping on getting their target killed by that, they wouldn't care about what the role could possibly be

But from the aspect I think it could be interesting, not for newer players, to get that list, tho they most likely already know which could be the hh target and which can't

Anyways, why not? :p
I might give it a post! Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day! HR_KyoThumbsUp cz_round_heart

Hello @forest rover
Hm, I don't think there is actually need in adding a whole new information on each role which only affects one role, which even isn't always in the game set up

I think adding it into the hh description should fairly be enough, as everyone can just look it up there HR_KyoThumbsUp

Thanks for your suggestion tho, and have a nice day/lovely evening! cz_round_heart S3NaoSmile

forest rover
#

Not in custom with random roles,but,who cares about custom?

thick bolt
#

Guys. People in top 500 or top 750 should start in Gold League

#

If you don't implement this I will quit this game..

#

Why? Because in silver, people gamethrow all the time

vale gyro
#

Thought this here is of relevance for people who asked about this before. As suspected it's not possible to program it in or it's too much work to bother. In either case it's finally a reason though a bit saddening 😔

lament knoll
#

Hello @light edge :p

That sounds like an... extraordinary idea,, I get your point behind that and honestly I would welcome that for every game mode except quick mb

But there might be a bigger conveniency for it in ranked indeed, I think I will give this a post and let it get evaluated in #feedback-devs

Thank you for your feedback and have a lovely evening! HR_KyoThumbsUp single_rose

Hey @thick bolt

It has already been suggested before indeed to make people start in Gold which have been in high placement last league, we have posted and reposted these suggestions for a couple of times now and sorry but that's all we can do...

It's very unfortunate that you want to quit the game, because of this issue but a threath into this channel won't really help solving this issue to be honest...

Especially because it's only discord staff seeing these suggestions,, and we can't really change these things...

I can re-check again if I might be able to repost this suggestion, if it was a while ago and not seen by the devs, but that's all I can do

Sorry for the inconveniences and have a nice day! AwooLove single_rose

light edge
#

thank you min ❤

fast marsh
#

The points you'll need to finish a tier would be similar to xp, so around 700/800 points. Or if that's too easy then also around 1000 points per tier
For ww I'd suggest they get like 5-10 points per kill, the last ww could get 2 or 3 points extra for a kill. If the werwolves win they'll get 25-30 points.
For villagers as well around 5 points if they find a ww/solo role. For the roles abilities they will get 2/3 points extra. (If abilities are hard to use/work for example for bh, the points could get more but that doesn't have to be). For winning villagers will get 20 points.
Solo roles can earn as well around 5 points per kill. For solo role wins they'll get around 30 points.

Doesn't have to be like that with the points aka can be changed anytime 🙈

formal wasp
#

Hello

calm pollen
#

Custom games have gotten out od hand. Players now have started to make "XP farms" where players go afk and just leave the game running while they gather xp. I think the best way to kill xp farms is to get less xp from custom games. This should eliminate the problem. Other then that devs should do something about it. because this causes to eliminate the pourpose of playing games like ranked/quick.

sterile elbow
#

I have a problem, I was a werewolf and I was coupled with beast hunter, it was the end of the game and there was cupid, me, beast hunter, another ww and doc, and I voted my ww team mate so I could win as couple and all ww reported me and now I am banned for 2 days!!! Please help?

calm pollen
#

Uhhhh... Report that to mod/ Guardian or just send email.

runic dragon
#
How to dispute your WWO Ban

Message one of the following guardians and make sure you include your in-game name and name any reasons why the ban is invalid in your initial message. If it comes to discussions do not be rude or your ban will not be taken away.

List of guardians:

  • Kem => @crisp thistle (@KemTrangTien#9980) :flag_vn:
  • Alisonn => @naive whale (Alisonn_#4655) :flag_ca: :flag_fr:
  • Boy => @arctic nova (@BoyHanQuoc#6473) :flag_vn:
  • Oliver => @elder dew (@Oliver#8960) :flag_de:
  • Renard => @snow ruin (@Renard_eau#9157) :flag_fr:
  • Catjojo => @hollow hinge (@catjojo|Jenn|#7139) :flag_de:
  • Artemiis => @sharp cedar (@Artemiis#9648) :flag_fr: :flag_es: :flag_nl: :flag_de: :flag_it:
  • SionnY => @dreamy vortex (@SionnY#2590) :flag_th:
sterile elbow
#

Any english guardians?

lament knoll
#

@sterile elbow please only post feedback in this channel cz_round_heart
You can ask questions in #questions

Contact a guardian with your problem and it will get solved, all guardians speak English those are just the other languages apart English they speakHR_KyoThumbsUp single_rose

sterile elbow
#

Ok sorry I am new to this discord

#

I wont do it again

lament knoll
#

Don't worry cz_round_heart

runic dragon
#

Hi i have a suggestion to make ranked more meritocratic,what if every 1000 skill points you get 1 less point if you win with every role?
Example,if at one point you gain an average of 10 measily points for winning with village and you lost the usually 16 points with ww and 3/4 with solos it will be thought to gain points and here's where the skills come in play,where the players that can actually win with ww and solos and don't lose with villager will keep climbing rank and the others will stop at one point unless they get better.I suggest this because the current method favores players that get to play more,i mean till you win with villagge and play a lot you will improve your rank.I will like to propose even special games related to the fact that i notice many people have the tendency to avoid fool games(don't take me wrong me too when i'm tired don't play fool games) so what if we include special games that will be played when a player played a set number of fool/hh games?in this games there will be zombie and sl for solos,and it's possible to add special rules like you will gain more points based on how many zombies or sected there are at the end of the games and after all ww dies you have 2 nights to infect/sect people and so on,this will simulate people to actually play fool games in order to play these special games worth high number of skill points.
Related to this can It be added the fact that sect leader can tank an hit?i mean i understand that the role Is higly strategic but except zombie is the only one that can be killed by ww is a bit unbalanced,and it Is a shame.Last think, can the modality spectator added again to ranked?It was such an intriguing thing that permitted the player to watch and improve their games,was it removed for the risk of some players colluding with each other and foul play?if so that can be resolved adding an update where spectators can talk with deads only if medium is dead.Thank you for listening.

languid cape
#

Zombies is overpowered rather than weak tbh. They can even bite through traps and even if they die they still have a chance of wining because of the player they bit last night

#

And sect leader in ranked will make ranked unbalanced since wws can just kill off sect leader

#

If you make sect leader immune to wws then the village wont lynch the sect leader cuz at least some villagers will say they are sected like gunner and such

west shoal
#

I agree it's so anoying ..ww can just find the sect leader and kill so many players

runic dragon
#

In fact i proposed zombies and sl Just for these speacial games that in case will be rare,like every 100 games played with half fool half hh.The propose i'm more interested on Is the first,the one for get less skill for game based on how many skill points you have.

hot aurora
shut pecan
#

Can u make Doctor unavailable as RV in seer games?

#

I believe is very confusing for new players

#

When theres more than 1 doc in game

runic dragon
#

if you remove Doc as RV in seer games once they reach Det mode they will be more confused when they realize Doc is RV in Det modes

thick bolt
#

@lament knoll About the "threat". I am a fed up. I only play ranked and I am mostly gold league. Every new season I start in silver league where most of player just gamethrow. Gunner shooting only med claim, auras and seers being afk, people voting random during 1st turn. While ranked games have another purpose. Their purpose it to let you prove if you can make other people believe that you are good and not voting you. These silver games have as a purpose to get you make other people not to game throw. Why? Is this the purpose of this game mode? Who to get @light edge to compete with people with no experience. During the last 5 games in silver I was reported so many times (I guess) for giving info while I was med or priest because it was obvious but nobody believed me. They blamed me for cheating, teamming, being a noob etc. People with 30% wins who believe hh and cannot understand cc of doc, claiming doc in arso games etc. The problem is that we waist or time for what? For people who cannot understand scapegoats and the fact that "when there are 2 docs and auras no aura or doc sees "2rrvs" ". Sorry for this awkward situation but the whole community of wwo has asked about measures in order to make this game more interesting and user friendly. I know that all people working in this community, Mods, devs, helpers, mini mods, translators, mentors, managers, guardians etc, work so hard and try their best BUT some things should change. It's a win-win situation. Both users and the company wins.

Thank you very much for your effort and time. I hope you will understand that I am not blaming anybody. Just trying to start a conversation to make this game even better, fair and funny for everyone.

#

Sorry for my poor English

runic dragon
#

Is better than my English GWcorsairNomNomNom

light edge
#

I was summoned?

thick bolt
#

lol

#

You were just an example

placid cove
#

So I am coupled with alpha. 5 is med. 9 jailer doesn't have a bullet and kept jailing alpha. My target was 1 cupid. Who got turned and is dead now. The game ended in a tie cuz to not gamethrow I didn't lynch 3. Even though I could lynch 3 and win. So I suggest to change the rule where couples comes first by adding the couple can go to win as their 2nd team if they want to in impossible situations like this. If in this situation I could lynch 3 and it's not gamethrow, then I got some wrong info here. Cuz I was told in even in these situations, couple teams comes first.

lament knoll
#

Yeeeesss @thick bolt

Attaboy/Attagirl!! That's exactly what we are trying to do too :p
I can understand your struggles, I am aware of the issues with ranked and I agree with many points you have mentioned

I totally think experienced ranked players should come up with solutions, with improvements, with critique, with engagement in making a difference!

And I am very thankful to everyone being here suggesting, even if it's resuggesting improvements as long as I can see we are following the same goal, which is making this game have a good and enjoyable environment HR_KyoThumbsUp cz_round_heart

You just must also understand our point of view, we get ranted at, aggressive users on mass, in some cases even insulted by such I don't only mean the harmless insult like "stupid" etc we've had worse

And unfortunately some ranked suggestions here sometimes came across rather as a complaint/frame that we don't care about the game than wanting it to improve

That has changed in the last couple of weeks for sure, just that might be why staff is handling some ranked feedback rather with carefulness and from a distance and that's also the reason for my wording

Thank you for trying to create a better environment in game, it's highly appreciated cz_round_heart AwooLove

#

got longer than expected

placid cove
#

I don't play ranked. But I have a feeling we need a separate channel for ranked people to chat. Cuz who knows, from the idle chat between two or more people might bring a good idea for improvement. And also people who don't play rank or new to rank can go for some serious advice from other players.

lament knoll
#

Heyy @runic dragon

Sorry, but I am honestly not sure if I quite understood your feedback...

Would you mind adding in some more spaces into the message and maybe elaborate your first idea more?
It was a bit difficult to read

About the second idea I have to agree with Yumi, and also with the sect leader, that's the whole point of it,, being strategical
Zombies and Sl are different in interactions with werewolves because they are another type of role...

They are converting people into their team, they don't kill, and they won't be on their own, meanwhile the solo killers are alone, they have no team with them which makes it harder for them to win as it's basically a 15 vs 1

The sect leader should try to convert protectors into his team in the first place to protect him and zombies are just endlessly op they don't need that type of protection for ww S3NaoSmile cz_round_heart

Hello @hot aurora

Do you mean once they are dead? Or also while they are alive?
And where and how would the hierarchy be displayed?
Could you elaborate that a bit further? AwooLove cz_round_heart

Hellooo @shut pecan

I do agree with Toon, if you remove it as rrv for one set up but add it for the other it will be more confusing and it would either be a bummer for that confusion to happen in higher leagues than in lower ones S3NaoSmile single_rose cz_round_heart

#

Hello @placid cove

Well, that is like a situation with a sl, a sect member and two unsected Villagers from whom one is jailer...

You are in a 2 vs 2, you aren't on the village team anymore once coupled and it would just be unfair for your lover... this situation transfered onto the sect situation with jailer jailing sect leader consecutively it would also result in a tie...

I don't think you should change the couple winning condition just for one specific case, also there are still a couple of players being for couple, once it is coupled, shouldn't be able to win with their original team anymore...

So that would solve that dilemma between gamethrowing or winning as well...
The ww didn't choose to get coupled and now it's either he looses but so do the villagers or he looses and the village wins due to betrayal of his lover...

When you are in love it's just logical that even you being able to win wouldn't just make you kill your lover... S3NaoSmile cz_round_heart

#

Heyy @placid cove

If you are interested in becoming engaged in ranked and learn from experienced players you should try to dm @light edge

He is within in charge of a great server, dedicated to making ranked better and we already got a couple of great suggestions from that side

I don't think we should really add a new chat room into this server only dedicated to one mode especially because we already have way to many channels to take care of at the same time AwooLove cz_round_heart

silver jetty
#

You should get the bp unlocked "for free" when you reach tier 100.
You shouldnt get the gold tho since thats what you would pay normally.
its kinda useless to grind gold and then spend it on the bp to just get it back again.

light edge
#

I was summoned again!

#

Ye ranked grinders come to me. My sect is nice and cozy

quaint bramble
#

@silver jetty well, the gold tiers add up to 1200 coins so you do get it for free... how's that different from what you are suggesting?

silver jetty
#

if your at 0 gold you have to get gold through the wheel what is just a waste of time in my eyes

quaint bramble
#

it's a free to play game, spinning the wheel and watching ads is how they make up for that

#

you want some cool bp stuff, you spin the wheel, and in the end maybe you didnt profit in gold, but you got all those outfits

silver jetty
#

that wasnt what i was saying but i get the point yea

crisp widget
#

I feel like the season shpuld reset differently. If you above 2000 then you reset to 2000. This going to 1600 and then loses cause of noobs and ending at 1300. Skill is bad. I would like the season reset to change a bit

runic dragon
#

Well, spinning the wheel means hard work, and only through hard work you can earn what you want

#

It's a chore, but worth it in the end

quaint bramble
#

@crisp widget Heya this is quite a popular suggestion and multiple posts about it are already in #feedback-devs 👍

calm pollen
#

I've got ingored... Again

#

Why

#

Y

quaint bramble
#

@calm pollen zombie xp farms are allowed.. they are not illegal like the boosting mentioned in#dev-vote
Custom doesnt affect win rates and its a more time consuming process

calm pollen
#

Ok thank u i guess i just didnt know tzat

quaint bramble
#

ofc its not a fun way to play, but some people just want easy xp sometimes

runic dragon
#

Hm, I thought XP farms were illegal

#

So what's the difference between Boosting and XP farms?

quaint bramble
#

in custom games: no, in other game modes: yes

#

Like I said, custom games dont count for win rates, and they need to last at least 5 mins to get xp from them

#

They also dont really rely on people breaking rules like revealing all roles

#

Because of these differences, they are accepted

calm pollen
#

So custom games are like no rules? Except od course swearing and related stuff to that.

quaint bramble
#

Rules still apply, not all customs are meant to be xp farms and people should still play them seriously if thats expected of from the setup

runic dragon
#

Customs are more light-hearted and more free from the restraining rules of other modes

#

But you still can't use profanity, racism, other actions that will hurt people, etc.

#

That's global rules for the game

#

Gamethrowing/Suiciding/Any other actions that affects gameplay experience won't really damage the win rate in Custom

calm pollen
#

I think ill write somsething about getting banned to easily. I just got banned for gamethrowing for some reason that i dont know about.

runic dragon
#

Well, you're gamethrowing, so that's not allowed

quaint bramble
#

If you arent sure why exactly you got banned, then you can message a guardian and ask for more info or an example...

runic dragon
#
How to dispute your WWO Ban

Message one of the following guardians and make sure you include your in-game name and name any reasons why the ban is invalid in your initial message. If it comes to discussions do not be rude or your ban will not be taken away.

List of guardians:

  • Kem => @crisp thistle (@KemTrangTien#9980) :flag_vn:
  • Alisonn => @naive whale (Alisonn_#4655) :flag_ca: :flag_fr:
  • Boy => @arctic nova (@BoyHanQuoc#6473) :flag_vn:
  • Oliver => @elder dew (@Oliver#8960) :flag_de:
  • Renard => @snow ruin (@Renard_eau#9157) :flag_fr:
  • Catjojo => @hollow hinge (@catjojo|Jenn|#7139) :flag_de:
  • Artemiis => @sharp cedar (@Artemiis#9648) :flag_fr: :flag_es: :flag_nl: :flag_de: :flag_it:
  • SionnY => @dreamy vortex (@SionnY#2590) :flag_th:
calm pollen
#

Uhh i just did

#

I was not gamethrowing

quaint bramble
#

Or you might wanna reread the rules and maybeyou'll find the reason yourself ^^

calm pollen
#

Uhh from my first 5 min ban i learned enough to know what not to do

#

Still i will find out tomorrow

tepid shell
#

How do I report someone on Portuguese?

quaint bramble
#

@tepid shell Same as in every other match, you open the player list ingame, select the person you wanna report, and the reason
if its something in portugese then maybe write a little translation ^^

fast marsh
#

Did the addition to my idea get flooded? :c

runic dragon
#

Suggestion for Seer Apprentice: Since dependent roles aren't allowed in the game, I'd like to change how the Seer App works. In my theory, Seer App should be a buffed Aura and a nerfed Seer (Duh). Seer App can check if someone belongs on the Village team or not, regardless of the aura. Seer App can still get affected by Shamans, Illusionists, roles that can disguise people, etc.

#

I dunno if this was suggested before, but I thought it'd be worth a shot, so Seer App won't totally be useless with Seer around

runic dragon
#

Cause i wanna write something to the poll but dont know where

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon This is a suitable place to reply to the booster vote

#

@runic dragon dependent roles indeed arent allowed but seer app isalready there and wont be removed..
making it actually able to see stuff would be extemely unbalancing

runic dragon
#

But it isnt really a feedback what i wanna say

#

Well, that's fine

quaint bramble
#

If its relevant to the vote, I think this is still your best place to say it ^^

runic dragon
#

Ok a vote reaction would be better tho

quaint bramble
#

Theres almost never any vote polls though, its usualy just avatars

runic dragon
#

Ok so 30 games sound like much but if we say that each game goes from like 5-10 minutes in avergae it would be only like 2,5-5 hours and i know people who player way longer than that

quaint bramble
#

Thats not what the vote was about at all though... its about 30 games in an hour

#

which is only achievable if you cheat it

#

@runic dragon

runic dragon
#

Oh yeah my bad

sudden dock
#

Spirit seer (booster) looks so much like sorcerer... maybe change the spirit seer color to Gold? Or black?

timber helm
#

Mega gut

#

Mich würde freuen wenn es Belohnung für die gipt die seit der Beta da bei sind :D

#

I would be happy if there was a reward for the gipt that have been there since beta: D

quaint bramble
#

@timber helm heya what do you mean with gipt?

#

And you can claim a tester hat here in the server, which is a beta item ^^

runic dragon
#
I saw someone with the tester hat/ discord shirt. What are the special tester items, how do I get them?

Go to #bot-commands and type ?tester hat and/or ?discord shirt. Please make sure to check your direct messages!

sudden dock
#

I think they are saying that they would like a reward for playing the game since beta

#

But at the moment i believe we are still in beta.

quaint bramble
#

Yup thats true, still in beta. There is early bird hats you can buy, which might disappear but we dont know that for sure

median elbow
#

#feedback-devs so you mean to tell me level 30+ player randomly shoot in ranked

sudden dock
#

did you see what i sent above?👀

next escarp
#

i also agree with a color change, gold would be nice since black would be hard to see

runic dragon
#

Discord shirt is the oldest fanmade skin

hot aurora
#

I would like to implant a strength system for the wolfs depending on how strong their roles are.

They will be using a simple dot system and the scales will be like this:

●●●● Strongest.
●●●○
●●○○
●○○○ weakest.

Because sometimes while playing as wolf its get confusing on who the strongest one is. Atleast I think so.
I will attach a file on how it could look like. (Sloppy example)

runic dragon
#

@hot aurora the strength of the wolf, really, is the player’s opinion and each player may have a different rating for each wolf, making a “strength scale” for wolf is not very ideal and it might cause a lot of arguments

#

for example in my opinion, guardian wolf is easily among the weakest

hot aurora
#

I just mean a scale that who dies first if hitting a beast hunters trap.

runic dragon
#

is it really necessary?

#

Yes.

#

then 4 dots wouldn’t be enough

#

I think it is for couples and especially jww

#

or you need like numbers instead of dots.

#

But also agree with the dots

#

Not enuf

hot aurora
#

Yes it would cuse there are maximum 4 wolfs / game 5 if kitty Is in it.

But regular werewolf are weakest so they are at ●○○○

runic dragon
#

so the dots would change in every situation.

#

Think so

#

some interactions are really common sense and don’t need this “dots” ngl

#

the word junior or regular already somehow implies weak

light edge
#

reg ww gets triggered first by bh trap
and seer last 😉

runic dragon
#

^

#

they want it to be stated in the role list

hot aurora
#

You might know that. But what about new players?

runic dragon
#

they can learn that through gameplay ngl

hot aurora
#

There are no list IG on who the strongest wolf is.

#

Nor any info.

But w/e I thought it could come to use for some players that's why I suggested it. Then it's up for someone else if it's to any use.

runic dragon
#

Heyyy, I keep getting some pretty disturbing ads popping up on my game? I took some screenshots but I dont think you guys want them posted here. Who should I report something like this to?

meager gyro
#

Send me the screenshots in dms pls single_rose @runic dragon

@hot aurora There was a suggestion to order the wws by strength in the role list, would that work as well?
A info in the faq could work as well I think 🤔 Just ingame descriptions should be too full or they are getting messy
Thanks for the feedback cute_heart

opaque pollen
#

@runic dragon You can report it to Google/Apple too

runic dragon
#

Oh okay. Not sure how to go about that but I will look into it! Thanks :)

opaque pollen
runic dragon
#

I lost a total of 700 points in ranked. I lost in werewolf lost 140+ and continued to lose and lost 700 in total and after i won it gave me 35+. What happened?

#

Now im too tired to play ranked game since im still confused and frustrated.

runic cedar
#

I play quick and sandbox a lot so I don’t know. Sorry dude.

#

I played ranked twice since I started (2 months ago)

runic dragon
#

It's too much losing 700+. I think what you did there is very wrong.

placid cove
#

@lament knoll this is not like sect. Since sect members can't win with village team. I meant in my game, I was hh a solo role. My target dead so I am village team at the end. I could vote alpha and kill him and still win. But I couldn't do it apparently cuz it's gamethrow. So changing the rules so that it doesn't become gamethrow in such situations I think is a good idea.

I also shared a similar story to this hh one. But I was jr and alpha was coupled with canni. So I told alpha that as not to gamethrow, I would tag canni and kill canni with me. Or if he wanted to win, lynch canni with me.

I'm sure many similar situations would come. The same situation as jr might happen with avenger.

I think such situations needs to be an exception since we all want a win if possible right. Otherwise despite the game mechanics this doesn't make sense does it? And it doesn't look illogical to kill the lover. A lot of people do it. But let's not get too much in reality on that as it might get too dark and depressing for a game like this.

I do remember suggesting to make couples win with only couple team. That would uactually solve the gamethrowing problem and this dilemma if I should lynch my couple for the win or not.

Thanks for telling me about the ranker server.

Edit: added bonus, I think making couple it's own team might help couple survive longer and possibly win. For example, if avenger is coupled with ww, and the ww isn't the last ww, he could threaten to take seer and do so without that being a gamethrow. So personally I hope that couple is made into it's own team. But that would mean to remove the lynch win condition for hh and fool otherwise they would be in 2 teams and can win with either.

warm swan
#

This has just happened to me, I was jww and I tagged 15, then, 15 got converted by kww, make that the pat dissappears on that player because if you don't realize and get killed by gunner, mm or any killer, you don't kill one of your teammates (I kinda find it unfair)

umbral peak
#

Ok I move it. Deleting from here

sudden dock
#

Spirit seer (booster) looks so much like sorcerer... maybe change the spirit seer color to Gold? Or black?

quaint bramble
#

@runic dragon It's called placement games. The first 10 games of the season, you get bigger point loss/wins, to determine what league you're gonna be in.

hearty drum
#

@warm swan Hey, so sorry I don't like this idea 👀 This is similar to fact that you tag cursed and after they transform into the wolf the footprints still show on them. You have 30 seconds in the night to discuss with kww who they choose and change your tag 😅

warm swan
#

But what about if jww is afk for a while and get killed, then you can't change the tag..

hearty drum
#

@warm swan hmm, that sadly 🤔 but I think can't GWmythicalFeelsSadMan

runic dragon
#

It would be cool if med could resurrect corrupted people even if the dead person is a werewolf. It would add more difficulty to the game. :)

#

That way a dead corrupted wolf could try to fool the med

#

I've done it once but since med couldn't revive me because I was a werewolf, it didn't work

umbral peak
#

Idea proposal: Ηi i have problem with input whle in game or while texting. Sometimes navigation bar overlaps game and i have to wait for it to dissapear (1 or 2 sec). Can you add a setting to force show navigation bar for us with problem. Phone: Pocophone F1, android
[ Came here after reporting as a #bugs-readonly ]

placid cove
#

Okay so couple betraying each other to win cuz it's impossible to win as couple is illogical but jr having paw on another ww that got turned and the paw not disappearing with the possibility to kill a team mate which can definitely be mistaken as a gamethrow is logical, okay and sad if it happens and nothing can be done about it? My opinion is if a tagged person is turned, jr paw must disappear. This would help avoid accidental gamethrows as well. You guys might have a point in the couple case but in jr case, I think it should be changed.

sudden dock
fickle nest
#

It would be great If there were more divisions in ranked. Getting to gold is really easy and it's really frustrating to have high skill and play with teammates that are new to gold league and still make mistakes like random shooting, ignoring day one infos by confirmed auras detectives etc. It Is really frustrating having people throw the game all the time.

languid cape
#

^

sterile sage
#

indeed, it is.

pallid merlin
#

@sudden dock I'll take a look into that 👍 (booster)
As for reporting custom games, I'm pretty sure it was already suggested but I can't find it so I'll repost it

@runic dragon There are "placement" games, which influence more your sp 😅

@umbral peak That's interesting 🤔 I'll post it though I'm not sure it's possible. Thanks for suggesting SylvLove

sudden dock
#

curious- which feedback are you talking about? The spirit seer/sorcerer color or the reporting custom game names

pallid merlin
#

Edited 👀

sudden dock
#

Ty

pallid merlin
vale gyro
void shale
#

Even after completing tutorial I didn't get that hat can anyone please explain how to get that hat?

#

I m talking about this hat 👉🎓

calm pollen
#

@void shale your talking about the discord tester hat or what?

weak wharf
#

Sandbox has bugs, kitten converts more than one

#

Happened more than twice in 2 days

runic dragon
#

@weak wharf You can take SS and report those bugs in #bugs-readonly.

Also if red lady visits the player who was chosen to be converted; they both get turned into a ww

astral spruce
#

Roles Icons&Chat

If Seer is revealed by the Pacifist for example instead of
"13 ProGamer4125 : 3 is Werewolf." it would show as "13 ProGamer4125 seer : 3 is Werewolf."

Not all chat messages will appear with roles, only players who was revived/revealed. If Marksman tried to shoot a player it will seem as "13 ProGamer4125 voteyes : 3 is Werewolf." Revealed Mayor also works as well. Role icons won't update, in order to be update they need to be proven by Pacifist/Marksman (and other proving roles) once again.

Also make players who was muted by Grumpy Grandma never speak at all. Even if it only shows as "..." there could be a code language between 2 players and they can just say "..." 3 times and it has a meaning but nobody understands. To prevent just make muted players never talk at day.

hushed fiber
#

Hii, how about make layer of hair superimposed on layer of mask?

#

Usually hair becomes useless with large masks

night path
#

@vale gyro when anyone is converted to sect (including cupid), they are part of the sect team & no longer their own team. They win with sect, so if lovers win they cannot win with sect. If the lover was sected, the same result would happen.

#

sect would win

#

@void shale sounds more like a bug to me, how about reporting it in #bugs-readonly Peek

#

@weak wharf this is a known bug, except for red lady. If a red lady visits someone who is about to be converted, the red lady will also be converted. isn't this more suitable for #bugs-readonly anyway?

#

@astral spruce Regarding the grumpy grandma, pretty sure this was suggested before. right here! - https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/620325197446381568 But regarding your roles icon with chat, i'm not too sure what you mean. could you elaborate or make it easier for me to understand? when revealed a role icon is shown to the entire town. are you trying to say aswell as seer seeing the role on screen, in the day they will also be able to see the role icon (to themselves?)

astral spruce
#

I mean in chat

#

nNext to their names

night path
#

@hushed fiber Is this suggesting hair being above masks, because sadly that has been suggested and declined beforehand

hushed fiber
night path
#

so you mean like this?

mayor 5 Sharon: Hello! any info?
4 Kinara:2 is werewolf!
the pacifist revealed 4 (Kinara) as headhunter, there will be no voting today
headhunter 4 Kinara: darn it!

astral spruce
#

Yep

#

Their roles won't be shown next to their names if they were not revealed by a role

#

Marksman is also a role that can prove so I thought there should be a voteyes next to their names

night path
#

That seems pretty cool actually, i'll just check for you if this was suggested before 😄

hushed fiber
#

I love the way that I was used in the example unicron_seer single_rose

night path
#

I just chose who I thought of first Hehe

astral spruce
#

marksman 8 tried to shoot 2 but 2 is villager!
Day 3 starts.
voteyes 2 Progamer : I told you I was good

eager niche
#

this isn't a bug but feedback: you should include total amount of gold each member of the clan donates, cause the ledger isn't necessarily helpful

night path
uncut tusk
night path
#

Thanks! @uncut tusk AYAYAsmile . Yeah Jackie, go upvote that!

eager niche
#

i upvoted it ahhaah

#

thank you !!

#

the filter ooption sounds really good as well !!

#

maybe just adding on to it, like be able to sort by "most good" or like "most xp" like a spreadsheet kind of vibe

night path
#

Most good is quest heroes, and you can see xp by just looking at clan members

#

there is also quest history

candid flower
#

-

night path
#

Hi! @candid flower unless you have feedback please don't speak here and go to #off-topic wAvE

astral spruce
#

Grumpy Grandma Idea

I thought of 2 different abilities for grandma.

1 - Revealed 🔇 : Your target's mute will be revealed to the village, 1 time use only.

2 - Unrevealed 🔇 : Nobody will know your target is muted except them and you, 2 uses only.

I think it should have limited uses for mutes as they can be used to gamethrow easily.

languid cape
#

Or none of your abilites show that you muted a target

#

Meaning that you mute them and only you and they know, also they wont be able to type ... either

uncut tusk
#

@languid cape Heya, thanks for suggesting! Hmmm, and why do you feel there's a need to buff that role? Villagers are strong already, and grumpy grandma isn't underpowered, in my opinion

languid cape
#

Woyld make the game interesting like pretending to mute someone 😂

#

No it buffs evil

#

Granny wont be able to prove

#

And evils can fake muted

#

Like I say my ww teammate will be muted tomorrow

#

Im 9 and 10 is my wolf teammate and I say 10 will be muted tomorrow im granny

#

Granny will lose credit get weaker and less proveable I think its more of a nerf than buff

eager niche
#

everyone in the game is silent next day: we were all muted

languid cape
#

It not like you have 5000 grannys

#

And granny is a villager role why would granny mute seer and stuff

median elbow
#

Granny mites the ss aura and seer back to back. Then finished with muting the jailer

#

Granny wouldn't claim either

night path
#

I mean, granny muting confirmed townies is gamethrowing and something we can't even change. corruptor is different because the muting is the main mechanic of hiding a persons role. it wouldn't make sense if you can fake being muted from granny haha

astral spruce
modest arrow
#

Dark mode needs to be enabled!

astral spruce
#

No.

languid cape
#

I played another game where there was role effect that when used, you could make the person speak gibberish like random words hdkwishksiw people would fake getting effected to avoid being questioned for role

#

If granny had this effect they could either claim rv and say they muted 12 so thats why they cant respond or wolves could fake this role perfectly cuz the granny is silent and mislynch a villager. Its all about how the person is playing

#

And proving granny would be much harder since a random wolf can say they are granny and at night tell their teammate to stay silent the next day

astral spruce
#

i stated granny should have one revealed mute

#

so granny claimer noober will be asked to use the revealed mute first

languid cape
#

Its already so strong why should they be able to prove?

#

We need more non proveable rvs

#

No claim space for wws except tg bg and rv doc if they are weak ofc

#

and why would you need a non-revealed mute if they have a revealed one???

#

Its the same purpose but one of them shows to others the other one doesnt but if you have both then the other is useless

night path
#

O

#

Oops

#

@modest arrow how would this exactly work?

modest arrow
#

Just like all dark modes, the theme is black and saves some battery

night path
#

Isnt the wwo theme blue though, and not white?

#

@languid cape seems cool! But wouldnt this mean spamming?

modest arrow
night path
modest arrow
#

Ok!

languid cape
#

@night path umm how is that spamming?

#

If the muted person cant even write “...”

night path
#

No, with the scrambled text

languid cape
#

I said the scrambled text is used in another game thats just a example how people can fake being muted

#

Like a evil saying I will use my power to another evil and telling the teammate at night to not speak next day

#

Or maybe they can still write “...” after being muted but no one would know for sure that they are muted

#

Like there wont be no pink text or a indicator showing the person is muted but when they try to talk they will be like “...”

#

So the final feedback from me is that granny using power shouldnt be shown to everyone. Only granny and the muted person should know that a person is muted. If a person is muted they will still be able to type “...” but village wont be able to determine for sure if its a granny mute or a evil role avoiding to be questioned. This would also allow wolves to fake granny and make the real granny have less credit. Eg 5 wolf says they will mute 10 which is also wolf at night 5 tells 10 that he would only say “...” the next day so 5 can be confirmed as granny?

#

The system that granny has right now is overpowered imo, leaving no chance for the fake rrv claims

night path
#

I suppose granny is overpowered in a way, but if you take that concept then wouldn't corruptor be the most OP role in the world? Just makes little sense unless we nerf corruptor you know? It does give more claim space, however granny isn't really confirmed rrv unless granny says specifically she is going to mute someone or is revealed 😅 . I personally do not think granny needs a nerf but im happy to add it for you

languid cape
#

@night path why would it overpower corruptor tho? If a person is muted they can still type “...”

night path
#

Ohh, that makes more sense

#

completey muting would of been different

quaint bramble
#

Hm, if granny mute icon is no longer visible/no chat message
I think maybe it should show up at the end of the day/the next morning that 'Player 5 was muted by grumpy grandma'
It's a bit gamethrowy if they can mute seers and get away with it, or if players can team up and claim there is a gg while there isnt etc.

night path
#

^^ Yeah, agreed.

languid cape
#

@quaint bramble if someone wants to gamethrow they could just mute the seer right now with the current system too. Theres no way around gamethrowers

#

You dont know who witch is either if they poison random day 2 but eventually they get known

quaint bramble
#

but then you can report them easily cause you can 100% confirm that the seer was actually muted

languid cape
#

Seer can type “...”?

#

Its the same granny mute but no indicator

quaint bramble
#

hm thats better yeah

languid cape
#

Yeah thats how im trying to make it xD

#

I explained it too long so it got confussing I think

#

New proposal for Grumpy grandma,
Granny can mute a player, the player will only be able to type “...” whenever they try to type something. Only the granny and that player will know that they are muted, there wont be a pink text or an idicator that they are muted. Which allows more fake claim space and granny cant confirm their role that easily, an example of a fake claim would be 5 saying I will mute 10 then at night 5 tells 10 to only type “...” in chat so people would think that 5 actually muted 10

Also this will make the granny either force claim because a player they actually muted is getting lynched, not the player faking muted by typing “...” or to not mute unless they have solid info that a player is evil

I saw many med jailers docs get muted just because they cant prove their role day 1 which cost us the game sometimes

night path
#

@languid cape I'll post, but may I copy and paste what you wrote? It explains things very well

languid cape
#

Okk

#

Thanks 😁

astral spruce
#

HE STOLE

#

ME

#

IDEA

#

BANN

#

BAN NOW

languid cape
#

@astral spruce your idea was different

#

I just got inspired by it and turned it into something else