@forest rover hey hey ^^ I'm sorry for the late answer. I really see, why you would like to replace it and wow this are really good reasons 
Do you have anything to add?
#feedback-readonly
glacial warren
forest rover
Tbh,no.I wrote all the reasons I have 😅
Np about the late reply it’s better than a no reply @glacial warren 
glacial warren
@forest rover okay ^^ then I think I will post it in #feedback-devs ^^
forest rover
Thx you @glacial warren 
glacial warren
Sure 
rigid bronze
@median elbow I totally forgot to add it, I apologize, will do asap 😅😅😅
glacial warren
@plain elm hey ^^ if they act against the rules, make sure to report them in game so the guardians can look at it 😉
plain elm
okkk
median elbow
@rigid bronze dats ight
rigid bronze
runic dragon
As Hyde said report it in game so our guardians can see reports 
forest rover
Sometimes it’s important to see who killed some player,and it takes a lot of time to check always the chat,even worse if it happened 2/3 days later.So,what about that in the under left corner of the player that is dead it’s added the death reason?
I know that the under left corner has already an use,that is to know the interactions that happened (like being coupled/revealed/sected/doused/bitten) but these interactions just happen while players are alive (unless med heart) so I think that it would be a good place to put it and just put the med heart up.
List of how they died and the icon:
**Lynched:**A pitchfork.
By werewolves: A wolf/paw.
By frenzy: The frenzy horn.
By witch: The killer potion.
By jailer: A grey bullet.
By gunner: A black bullet.
By avenger: A sword.
By junior werewolf: The blue paw.
By marksman: Marksman’s arrow.
By priest: A holy water bottle.
By visiting an evil player as rl: Red lady letter.
By visiting an attacked player as rl: Idk
By beast hunter: 
By serial killer: A knife.
By arsonist: Arso fire/
By bomber: Bomber bomb/
By corruptor: 
By cannibal: Cannibal skull.
By suicide as sect member: Sect member icon.
By suicide as lover: Lover icon.
By suicide: A rope maybe?
These are just examples but I would like to see something like this ig.
median elbow
Well you know when the corruptor kills when the question mark appears
forest rover
No if you’re playing custom with hidden roles 👀
sacred sable
What if rl visits attacked, too?
forest rover
Hmmm
median elbow
That's a good thing to bring up
sacred sable
And should leave suicides blank unless they suicided by sl
forest rover
Someone has a idea for rl if visiting an attacked player?
sacred sable
Blue lips?
runic dragon
@forest rover ehy ^^ I like your suggestion a lot, but since the square box is already full of things and this way it'd be a mess, why not dislpay these symbols in the chat when a player dies for whatever reason? You'd just need to scroll the chat a see how someone died!
forest rover
In that case you can scroll up to see who was revealed,when they sected you,with who you were coupled...
The reason is that I want not to scroll up because if I can see it in the game would be quicker @runic dragon
No need to waste time finding it if I can have it in the player
runic dragon
Uhm okay ^^ I will post it and see what people think about this 😀
Thank you for suggesting^^
runic dragon
Ahahaha you're very right
forest rover
Too weird
median elbow
It could be used as an advantage tbh
median elbow
Alternatively it could still tag the same people just tap the same person like 4 times
median elbow
Well landscape mode needs to exist oof
median elbow
That's what I just said. It's just a concept design
rain fiber
Make special offers previewable ingame,because most of the time,items are not visiable
noble storm
saboteur is too anoying. When you’re glitched you cant do anything but you have to wait a hole day (in game) to die. You can’t leave because you will get banned if you do that too often. So you need to wait. Im a person who just want to play a fast game and go to the next one when i die. The saboteur makes playground horribly boring ._.
forest rover
It’s just 90 seconds tho.However,you can check if corruptor is in the game list and leave before it starts if corruptor is in game @noble storm
vivid blaze
Since even until now village is so overpowered than other teams, I have a simple solution that can make things even
How about we add another solo role to the game?
Imagine fool and hh both in one game. Would be so much fun. If not them, maybe any other new solo role that can replace a boring village role, mayor for example.
And overall perfectly balancing the game
forest rover
You deserve to die if you think mayor is boring 👀
floral heath
Suggestion #1: A Mercy Rule
If there are killed victims after the first night cycle and the game checks No Medium’s alive at that point, then the game should not count for the victims.
This includes especially if 1 or more victims have the Medium role.
They have no more control on what happens to the game they’re in because they are dead and they can do nothing about how the game ends. After Night 1, whatever a player does will affect the course of the game, but only AFTER surviving the very first night.
If this occurs in a Ranked game, then the victims don’t gain or lose any skill for that game regardless of the outcome. In regards to this, the Medium role should be reworked so that games are more consistent with the Mediums ability.
There should also be a statistic on how many times a player dies Night 1.
Suggestion #2: Ranked reports
There are many players reporting others because of silly mistakes that they make in game. Although some of these mistakes are borderline game throwing, I believe that usage of the report system in this way is wrong because making mistakes is built in feature of the game.
My fix to this is to make a separate “Ranked Problem” report option specifically for players to report players in Ranked that can hence be evaluated differently by the Guardians given the circumstances of the report.
uncut tusk
@noble storm Heya, if you are corrupted it does not necessarily mean that you will die, if you're lucky corruptor will be killed before the end of the day ;)
@vivid blaze Hello, thanks for suggesting! Hmm, in which game mode would you suggest to do that? In quick game, I guess?
(And I don't think it's a good idea to replace a rrv with a solo role 😉 Even if they are "boring")
@floral heath Heya, thanks for your ideas! About suggestion #1, don't you think it's relevant only for solo voting roles (fool and hh)? 😉 As a pacifist who dies first night still can win with his village team. It has been suggested right here, you can upvote it if you like 😉 https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/647125167415492618
Suggestion #2: It's not very clear what you're trying to accomplish here. You would like players to report in this new category "small mistakes"? But, ehmm... As you said, making mistakes is part of the game. If it's not gamethrowing, then there's no need to report it. And who would report someone for "small mistakes", anyway? They'd report them for gamethrowing.
Also, guardians see which game mode it is when they check reports anyway.
You always can report under "Other" if there's no clear category for your report. Anyway, I highly doubt that devs would agree to add yet another report category 😅
vivid blaze
@uncut tusk atleast in quick game
Secondly, I really don't wanna waste my time arguing about ideas and stuff as we've discussed a lot about it before.
Village is clearly overpowered so we need to do something to balance things, ofc it will have a minor drawbacks but u have to accept that the pro will outweigh the con
Adding another solo role will make the game more interesting and will improve balance
uncut tusk
Alright I'll add it to #feedback-devs. Thanks for suggesting!
floral heath
@uncut tusk the first suggestion is not to give Villagers immunity like that suggestion you posted. A pacifist that dies first night can still win with the Village team yes but they basically play no role in helping the Village win, they are just a villager who died first.
It’s not fair on them to win or lose after doing nothing but joining the game
uncut tusk
? That suggestion I posted is only about fool and hh.
Also... with your logic, no one should die during the first night.
Oh, and seer shouldn't be able to check, because if they find a bad role, then that bad role will be lynched next day, out of pure randomness, which is not "fair" either...
runic dragon
uncut tusk
(I know you mentioned Medium, but still)
normal wyvern
After the end of the game it should be still possible to send roses. Sometimes people send roses to celebrate a win and I never can send a rose back because the game already ended. It is incredible sad for me.. :(
floral heath
@uncut tusk it’s still possible to counter a first day Seer Claim (I know it won’t work most of the time but they have time to react). I’m only saying that for the people that do die on the first night cannot do anything (even if they were ww killed by sk who was checked by the seer) because it always happens and it’s frustrating to lose a game that was completely out of your control or even just getting a free win.. that doesn’t reflect your skill at all
woeful mesa
Hi, for the last feedback, solo role describes only fool/hh, or all solo roles like sk, arso...?
uncut tusk
@woeful mesa Hi, I updated the message there. It was fool/hh.
@floral heath So what do you suggest? Make no one die during the first night as it's pure randomness?
Of course there's randomness 😉 It's part of all games.
@normal wyvern Heya, thanks for suggesting! Hmm I'm not entirely sure that it's possible, servers are very buggy for various reasons when the game is over, but it's worth a shot 😄
warm swan
Can someone please read my feedback 👀
uncut tusk
Hello,
Oh you meant that one: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/416576750991048705/647808084902936607 ?
I'm very sorry that it got skipped 😓
Thanks for suggesting. Hmmm it's part of the role, to have a con, so priests don't just water at random and hope to hit a ww ;)
And it's not so risky, just wait for information from someone confirmed seer that someone else is evil and you can water. Actually, it's more useful to keep it until either a day happens where 2 bad people are revealed (you can water one of them and the other one will be lynched), either until near the end of the game and you have good reasons to suspect someone 😉
tidal carbon
Maybe add more background in game, or maybe we could buy backgrounds with gold
runic dragon
buff zombies. They should be able to bite everyone night 1 and they will instantly turn to zombie. And wws can be bitten too
forest rover
I already suggested a lot of zombie buff but I don’t know why all of it got rejected @runic dragon
quaint bramble
Zombies need nerfs, not buffs, I really hope you are trolling and if so, please stay out of this channel.
eternal veldt
i report player in game nd tjat doesnt change anytging i report them to guardians they say report ig
quaint bramble
Reporting in game does work, not right away but it helps for sure.
So please just keep doing that when you find people who break rules
eternal veldt
yeah if 10 players report them it does they dont care one report cuz they know it wont make a diffrence
uncut tusk
It's rather 12 reports that make them visible for guardians. And cumulated, so not necessarily in a single game. If someone really gamethrows, many people will report them.
eternal veldt
thats very reliable @uncut tusk how do you define 'really throwing' ?
uncut tusk
What I mean is that it's something that everyone can clearly understand that is not allowed. If gunner shoots a revealed seer day 1, then most villagers will report gunner.
wispy shuttle
Make Sheriff show only the person who killed your target
runic dragon
The word "Bulgarian" is censored in the chat, same for "Ungarian" and other nationalities ending with "-arian", Can someone fix this?
quaint bramble
The word arian has a bad meaning, so that part is censored
thats how our censor works, there is no better solution atm
median elbow
- 1 free weekly spin from the ad wheel. This free spin will likely occur when the quick play gamemode changes.
- 1 free monthly (or seasonally) spin from the rose wheel
- When you sign you sign up are eligible to spin the wheel on the upcoming season/week, not the current one.
median elbow
Just another sect balance....
Make the sect not a legit "solo" role similar to the sk, corruptor, bomber, arsonist, etc. The sect leader isn't a solo killer at all. It's not even a killer. It's a bad villager with a team separate from the village. Don't make the sect 'village or sect' just add a solo killer into the village with a sect leader roaming around. 1 solo killer, 4 ww, 1 sect leader, 1 solo voting role, 9 villagers or potential sect members.
Since the sect is considered a solo "killer" the ww team doesn't automatically win when they are outnumbered since the gunner and jailler may be alive and alive kn this "killers" team
The question is which villager should the sect leader potentially replace in quick play and ranked since sandbox is there to simulate how future games are going to be played
In ranked the Sect win is the equivalent to a village win for the village side of things. The sect leader would get a skill bonus for converting everyone since that is the Sect Leaders goal to win, convert everyone.
And currently in sandbox there is a point when the village decides the village can't win at all and everyone wants to be converted. Adding a solo killer in with the sect leader would balance the role slightly. And for shits and giggles what if the solo killer(s) could get converted?
Hell the solo killer doesn't even need to be converted. The sect leader helps the village tbh. You know who is sected, and the sected members are confirmed on your team so everyone else is confirmed suspicious killers on the wolf team. The sect helps the village in it's personalized way.
mighty granite
@median elbow First one, I'm sure it's a new suggestion, since it was suggest as a free spin ticket. Smart idea! But for Rose wheel, I don't think it's good, because not everyone knows where it is, and it give too much gold to be free.
Second one, I think it's already balance though, but in quick game, I think 2 solo killers (or 1 solo killer and 1 converter) would overwhelm the new players, since there would be 5 teams in-game.
And in ranked it would still be a good idea to add one more team (sect), but not sure if everyone in ranked likes it.
median elbow
@mighty granite The sect vs ww vs village is already op adding a solo killer increases the chances of the sect leader dying and overwhelming the village. The sect leader overwhelms people, including me already as a stand alone role. Having a solo killer and sect (or zombie tbh) would add the balance it needs
And if you ask me new players wouldn't be overwhelmed by this at all because they are experiencing something new for the very first time. It would be like nothing even happened since they never experienced the past.
Cursed could be the replaceable villager.
Cursed can be sect leader, zombie or cupid
Cursed being a sect leader would still benefit the ww team since if the ww kill the sect the villagers die
mighty granite
🤔 You're right though.
median elbow
Are both of these worth posting to #feedback-devs ?
median elbow
And the only reason I am suggesting it to be redesigned this way is because it's a similar concept to how the WW telegram bot does this. There is a cult (no sect leader), solo killer, and ww team to balance the sect. This was a 30-50 man lobby however.
The rose wheel could be nerfed but 1000 gold is very easy to get even without roses
That's why every 2 months wouldn't cause damage to the game
mighty granite
Hmm... Okay, give me a moment. 
median elbow
Toon say something oof
runic dragon
In the case to be added free spin/rose wheel tickets, I would like to win those free spin in the season rank prizes
median elbow
@mighty granite follow up suggestion for the one before mine to send roses when the match ends. And maybe a way to fix the already buggy village viewing trick
mighty granite
Should I separate both in the #feedback-devs?
quaint bramble
@median elbow sending roses after match has been suggested literally a few days ago, its already posted ^^
yesterday even
median elbow
@quaint bramble you misunderstood what I said. I mean it's a follow up suggestion on how that would work.
That's why I said "for the one before mine" since it wasn't my oringal suggestion
quaint bramble
I dont really see any explanation?
median elbow
It's how his suggestions could be implemented
Add an eye ball, which alone is a suggestion to fix the already buggy viewing village mechanic after the game is over
floral heath
@uncut tusk no my suggestion is not to stop people from dying first night. You are right, first night kills are pure random, so my suggestion only affects people that die on the first night. I’m saying that the game for them only should NOT count due to my aforementioned reasons.
median elbow
Sk buff: Allow the sk to instantly stab the person he selects. The corruptor is already a buffed sk and easier to win with since it has the power to role block and hide roles
viscid tulip
Idk if somebody had the idea before but
There should be an option where you can mark a player who shouldn't be allowed to send your clan an join request
modest pebble
Do you see how dumb it is? The CD game start timer got beaten up again
runic dragon
@viscid tulip ehy ^^ you mean like a black list for the clan?
runic dragon
Nice, I will add this ^^
Thank you for your suggestion😄
viscid tulip
runic dragon
Same for friends
Blocking them should make that they don't be able to send friend request
That has already been suggested If I remember correctly ^^
I hope it will be added soon🙂
@median elbow do you mean sk being able to go through protections?🤔
Yeh just 4 month ago, but it's kinda different what I mean it's be also a List of all the players you have blocked in the main menu to be able to unlock them out of a room, at the moment you need meet them again to unblock them
median elbow
@runic dragon if they are fast enough and the player isn't protected at that second then yes bypass the protections 100%
normal wyvern
It is kinda sad when you put so much effort in this game to get level 400 or something and still get only crap in your lootboxes. I'd like to get every 50 levels, can be decreased/increased, an item which you can only get when you reach level 50, 100, 150, .... This would be a whole skin then when you have more than one item. This would honor people more who spend a lot of time to get a high level and people would try to get these items..
lament knoll
^ yes but, it would also encourage grinding and reward grinders... it would make people want to get as much xp as possible in as little time as possible...
So i personally don't like the idea of adding a whole skin, tho i'd think it'd be good to add new epic or legendary items into lootboxes for players with a higher level.
Or increase the probability of getting epic/legendary items in your lootboxes, maybe making it less likely to get normal rarity items when you're a higher level but not giving it a too high advantage, as the game should still be for fun and not for grinding xp to get better cosmetics and get "a higher status/rank among others"
normal wyvern
Yes, this would be also cool. I mean, I mostly get only normal stuff which doesn't encourage the time I spend in this game
lament knoll
Alrighty! @normal wyvern after a bit of research i couldnt find this having been suggested before and i really like the idea!
I am currently around level 180 and opening lootboxes really got something which doesnt get me excited anymore...
I'm gonna post it in a sec!
Thanks for the Suggestion and have a nice day! 
❤ 
normal wyvern
Pls add your name to it as well 
Thank you very much ❤️
runic dragon
@median elbow what do you mean by that?
median elbow
@runic dragon If the player being protected is protected fast enough then it will be a confirmed kill
runic dragon
So you mean protection has a time to activate or something like that?
runic dragon
Isn't that the case now?
median elbow
What the case?
runic dragon
As sk you can kill if a player isn't protected (?)
runic dragon
I don't get your suggestion then..😅
median elbow
If the doctor or whatever is on the aura then the doctor can save the aura. If the aura was slow then the aura will die.
Just have the sk instantly stab people
That's all
runic dragon
Slow? Could you explain that please?
glacial warren
So you mean, that you want to give the sk the possibility to stab someone, if the protecting role didn't choose yet?
As example:
1 Doc chooses seer on the 15 sec mark, but sk chose on the 20 sec mark. In this case the seer would die?
runic dragon
Oh, thank you hyde ahah
That would be a very strong buff then, it would just be a race for who taps first the seer, don't you think?
median elbow
That's okay is it not? The sk is already weak everyone will likely agree on this already, so the instant stab would be the way to give it a buff
And sometimes racing to the seer isn't the best option since the doctor could be faster 3 nights in a row
So maybe instantly killing someone else is the better option here
runic dragon
Mmh ok so:
You have 1 stab during the night and can use that whenever you like and if the stabbed player isn't protected at that exact second they will get killed in the middle of the night, right?
median elbow
Yes
runic dragon
Ok ^^ I will add this then
Thank you for your time and for the suggestion
median elbow
Well I'm ban I got nothing better to do tonight so I'm gaming
tidal carbon
Maybe add more background in game, or maybe we could buy backgrounds with gold
(Nobody answered me yesterday)
glacial warren
@tidal carbon I'm really sorry ^^' I wanted to answer and felt asleep.
So you probably mean the background like Christmas, Halloween etc right? If yes, this already has been suggested before ^^ I like the idea too.
Thank you for your suggestion
uncut tusk
@floral heath Alright I'll put it in #feedback-devs. Thanks!
tidal carbon
Yes exactly and that’s okay you were tired, and np @glacial warren
glacial warren
vivid blaze
I'm pretty sure than this suggestion also will be ignored by the staff but still here I go with the idea.
When someone deletes/logs out of their account on their device, they should have like a time restraint to log back in/create an account.
For 1 or 2 days for example
I hope you can understand the reason for this. Which obviously is to reduce fake acc creation
Coz when people log out/delete accs, 99% of the time its because they're making fake accs
So imagine having like a 2 day window which will reduce fake acc creation, and everytime even if their fake accs are banned, they won't be able to make another one so quickly
uncut tusk
@vivid blaze Heya, we don't ignore suggestions, but we may not accept all of them, it depends on the suggestions ;)
Regardless of whether it would be a good idea or not, it's technically impossible to do, anyway. Someone could bypass it by reinstalling the app/clearing the game data/cache.
frozen mirage
If Fortune Teller will be released... Will be so hard to play with solo roles
charred kiln
@median elbow this is the worst suggestion ive seen imo
Just luck based
Confusing noobs extremly
next escarp
on a player's profile, it should say their past usernames under/above the joined date. It gets very confusing when someone changes their name but doesn't tell you
mighty granite
@next escarp Smart idea, and also useful. I'll post in #feedback-devs. Thanks for suggesting!
vivid blaze
@uncut tusk well its ironic coz I've given hundreds of good suggestions and absolutely none of them have been implemented or considered.
Also, plz bear in mind that I mentioned reduce in my message. Ofc there can be several ways to bypass it but that doesn't mean u don't wanna reduce the problem
vivid blaze
Here's an excellent example of something that happened in today's game to support the argument
And tbh, he is not wrong. And does have a point lol
tidal carbon
We should be able to report if we are spectating someone (I don’t think it’s a bug?)
silver jetty
it really should be possible to split the game ||> picture||
Also
The clan list should look more like this. it would be easier to distinguish between leaders, cos, members.
quaint bramble
@tidal carbon I dont think its a good idea to allow spectators to report. It's usualy friends of players in the match, so they could flood fake reports and give guardians a lot of extra work.
@silver jetty What do you mean by splitting the game?
silver jetty
just like on the ss👀
quaint bramble
ANd the clan list suggestion was already posted before, i will get you a link
ow you mean splitscreening 2 apps? That doesnt seem like good idea
silver jetty
quaint bramble
we want people to focus on the game.
Not encourage them to watch videos or team with their discord friends
tidal carbon
O oki
Then we can convince dead ppl to report? If we can proove this is a good report
quaint bramble
yes yoi are always allowed to encourage others to report!
@silver jetty Here is the link for your 2nd suggestion;
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/630982585782108170
silver jetty
okay thank you
median elbow
@charred kiln what
charred kiln
That what i said
uncut tusk
@vivid blaze Thing is... Some people have good reasons to log out and log back in, like testing something, some debugging cases, using another account for a friend you lent your phone to, etc. We cannot really "punish" people by not letting them back in for a long time just because of double accounts... And since it's so easily bypassable, it's really not advisable to add that. It's too much oriented against gamethrowers, at the cost of gameplay.
Thanks for suggesting though!
woeful mesa
I was med but after dying I couldn t see the last chat I had as med with the deads. I think it should still see seenable
median elbow
Wwb didn't need to be nerfed?
forest rover
I agree with @median elbow,we’re not crazy.Not a good place to talk about it tho @charred kiln
#wov-chat better 👀
charred kiln
No in #feedback-readonly you discuss shit and ur opinion
But u guys obv playing only sandbox
forest rover
Not if you’re not going to give a feedback
median elbow
The ww team is already hard to win with. The berserk was 1% of the balance that the ww team needed
charred kiln
Berserk is no skill based
median elbow
It is
charred kiln
Hahahahaha
median elbow
Berserk the gunner, or seer
charred kiln
Wow
forest rover
Did you use play sandbox as an insult?I play ranked tho 👀
median elbow
Or save it until late game
forest rover
As difficult as check random as seer in night 1
charred kiln
Most time wwb ig ww win
forest rover
Should we don’t let seer to check first night because it’s random @charred kiln?
median elbow
The lone we concept is "op" is you wanna get on a serious note
forest rover
It’s an ability that does not depend just in himself.None of this kind of ability are op.
median elbow
The berserk has a skill behind it. Day 1 is one of the several skills
charred kiln
How is killing all bullets off village noght 2 not op
forest rover
Nightmare is better imo
charred kiln
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Sorry but thats just funny
Is normal ww better too than berserk🤣
forest rover
Jailer fault then.It’s jailer the one who decides,not berserk.It’s not op.
median elbow
I don't berserk the gunner day 1. I active it day 2 and berserk the gunner
charred kiln
Still
median elbow
Players are getting smarter and not jailing the gunner night 1
charred kiln
Gunner carries whole village
Yes
But still op
Look the killing seer method aint op
Since doc tg bg all sus af
But killing all bullets is op
forest rover
So you call me noob but you think that gunner carries all the village?lol
median elbow
And as the berserk I would intentionally berserk the tg so the tg can't reveal anyone
forest rover
That’s even funnier 👀
quaint bramble
the change was already made, so i kind of disagree this belongs in feedback right now
it was changed like this after a pretty high demand
besides youre mostly trash talking eachother at this point anyway
rigid bronze
Please don't use the word noob since it can "hurt" some people
median elbow
I have good stats. My biggest reason why berserk shouldn't have changed was because the ww team is already weak, nerfeming9the we team just makes it weaker
rigid bronze
We can totally talk about that, but we won't go anywhere by talking like that 🤷🏻♂️
charred kiln
@median elbow ign
median elbow
RGTube
lament knoll
it's stated above in emanuels message
"Should the activated Werewolf Berserks Frenzy ONLY kill the protectors?"
serene lotus
After each ranked season, there should be some sort of „Afterparty“. People should still be able to play in their league of the ranked game mode after the season ended, just without getting skill points. It’s because many players do not enjoy playing sandbox/quickgame.
This would also be a nice way for new players to get familiar with the roles so they can decide if they really want to participate in the upcoming season.
peak knot
@charred kiln No frenzy night 2
@median elbow 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
bErSeRkeR dIdN't nEeD tO be nErFeD
😂😂😂😂😂
sorry I had to chuckle
thin dome
Make it so people can’t add their own reactions to #feedback-devs
eternal veldt
open up the ranked already im sick of throwers in sandbox
quaint bramble
@serene lotus Hm that sounds like an interesting idea, it gives the seasons a smooter transition and can let new people try ranked without messing this up too much ^^ I will add it for sure!
@thin dome There's usually no problems with this, we can still remove them on a case to case basis, such as if it becomes too spammy or if people add the 
we usually remove them ^^
quaint bramble
What part exactly?
eternal veldt
and this time zone thing is ridicilous new season must start right after other ends
thin dome
Like the adding of another thumbs up or something because it not on all of them
I cant explain it
It just stresses me out and frustrates me
quaint bramble
@eternal veldt it never used to start right away, just like the BP there used to be a few days inbetween. Which does help against these messy problems we have been getting in the past few...
@thin dome This has been happening since they added the wwo-voting hands to the bot command instead of the basic yellow ones. Some people prefer to use the old thumbs because they do not have a certain skin colour.
lethal storm
Hello There
The +playerinfo should give informations about the badges owned, since it's an important information about players!
runic dragon
@lethal storm I totally agree with you ^^
I will post this!
Thanks for the suggestion
sacred sable
Suggestion:
Add how long staff has told people to wait for random anything.
I.E. - I've been told that you should wait at LEAST until day 3 to random kill/jail/reveal/vote, because by then people should know who has what role, and anyone unknown should speak up and claim.
Otherwise it'd be considered random killing/gamethrowing, etc. 👀
quaint bramble
The ingame rules/faq are currently undergoing improvements, so this wll probably be in there soon ^^
sacred sable
Rose for staff
runic dragon
Maybe make it so that every daily reward skin comes in both male and female versions?
I have the female versions of whatever daily-reward-skins but I also have a few male skins too—it’s a big (I’m a female)
I like both versions and there’s a few outfits where the items are male-limited and female-limited, and I like those items.. I’ve come up with several outfits but they involve gender-limited items 😦
vivid blaze
Today, the gunner shot confirmed priests, seers, villagers etc etc. Gamethrowing, random killing, and hate speech and what not.
How about u remove the gunner role... coz it's too powerful and easy to mess up games with. And since u dont have a system to deal with the throwing people, there's no point in giving such power to players
meager gyro
@runic dragon Heya, I do understand your point, it has been suggested before
Some outfits are only available in either the female or male version bc some designers prefer to design only one of them, which is absolutely their right 🎨
But the 'guidelines' got updated recently so designs now need both, a male and female version (sale and battle pass) or need to be gender neutral (daily rewards)
Thanks for your feedback 
@vivid blaze Removing roles like gunner, zombie has been suggested before, but won't happen most likely. Thanks for the suggestion!
There's not really a point in removing whole roles just because of a few who use them to throw games
We do have a system to deal with throwing players or other rule violations, you may report them directly in the game and our guardians will handle it once that player got enough valid reports
vivid blaze
@meager gyro you're mistaken. It's not few, its many
Nearly every now and then each game is messed up by gunners
And your 'system' doesn't work like I said hundreds of times before that the gunners keep coming back with fake accs if they get banned. Most biased and lazy players dont even report them in the first place
Apparently I've heard that it's your 'procedure' to repeat the same thing again and again about the reporting system even after you too know real well that it's not effective at all. So nevermind
Putting it in summary, gunners hardly even get banned coz of biased and deluded villagers, and if they do, they keep coming back with fake accs.
So in anyway, it'll always be a big problem unless u can come up with a report system that can actually work
meager gyro
I mean it like if you look at all games not only the ones you play 😅
Fake accountes -> are getting banned as well till they are too tired of creating new
You can ask others to report, a player doesnt need to get 12 reports in one game btw that counts for multiple games... players that used too shoot randomly most likely will get these amount of reports quickly
The guardians are banning a decent amount of players every single day and they're doing it voluntary
Procedure? 🤔
vivid blaze
Apparently this is the only game that has such pointless issues. I don't wanna bring up my email verification thing in. This is the only multiplayer game I play that doesnt use such a basic security feature let alone other advanced ones
Fake accounts will never stop. It's hard to get them banned in the first place coz gunners hardly even get reported.
Besides, bullies like to annoy people... so they will never get tired of making new accs especially considering it's so so easy to make one
And when I do ask others to report the gunner, the genius gunner shoots me also
'Procedure' about u reminding us about your useless reporting system again and again which we both already know is not effective
And besides, we come here for a reason. If ur gonna direct us back to the game why would we come here in the first place
Whatever we say in here is something that the game cannot do, and it's clear that it can't
meager gyro
Email verification has been suggested before as well, there are reasons to not add it, such as the relation of rule violations and legally playing players and others.
Most multiplayer games in that range are pay 2play 🤷
Oh believe me they will get tired and some well known already got tired ^^
The reporting system is not useless, not at all
like I said guardians are hard working to keep the game as safe as possible and they are banning a lot of players every day
It's more likely balancing itself if you keep false reports etc in mind -> like I said above clear rule violations dont need many games to reach 12 reports
Who directs you back to the game with what?
Many many suggestions from #feedback-devs were and are added to the game 🤔
vivid blaze
Please elaborate on the reason why it hasnt been added. What do you mean by rule violation
And you also have to believe me... by the time the throwers get tired, the good players will get tired of this nonsense much earlier and give up on playing. I at the least am on the brink of literally deleting it coz its total bs now. So in the long term you're just paving way for throwers to accumulate.
You cannot just close your eyes to wait and hope for something to fix itself. This is something that won't be fixed by itself. It has to be fixed manually
And I'll give u a very simple example. Look at fortnite. It's not pay to play but it's still so good for a reason.
I play fortnite more than werewolf, and there's a reason why gamethrowers and rude people are almost non existent on it. Coz they have a basic email account verification system, let alone all the advanced security features.
And there are millions that play fortnite more than werewolf yet it still has less gamethrowers.
meager gyro
The developers decide whether a suggestion gets added to the game or not. They decided not to add email verification. If you plan on ruin/ throw games cuz its fun, email verification wont stop you, it will just bug all others and prevent normal players to play the game
That's based on experience, other games solved it by being pay2play now.
That doesnt mean none is searching for solutions, or none implemented solutions, that doesnt mean we're closing our eyes from flaws and not trying to fix those.
Rule violations are behaviour ingame that breaks the rules. Things like racism, harassement, gamethrowing, random killing (good roles) will be reported quite fast and guardians can take care of those quite fast as well. I totally agree that random killing bad roles is a problem atm because many wont report those cuz they personally got an advantage out of it. We fixed the rules to clearify that it's wrong and reportable aswell
No offense but you can't really compare fortnite and wwo
vivid blaze
Again... email verification doesnt 'stop' u but it'll reduce the problem so so much. If you cannot fix something would u refuse to even reduce it? That's such a big mistake you guys always make.
And I'm not really comparing fortnite to ww, but rather the strategy. It's not just fortnite that uses email verification and stuff.
There's a reason why those games are so successful. Coz they atleast do basic security features. Obviously, gamethrowing can never be fixed in any game but it can be minimized by a huge extent through simple measures
In my perspective, making it so hard to make fake accs is virtually a fix rather than a reduction.
I personally would seriously never make a fake acc if it's so hard to make.
meager gyro
I never said that we don't do anything against gamethrowing
Security doesnt need to affect all players.
Out of my experience here I can tell you that not even a mix of phone verification and email verification stops someone if they really wanna harm you 😄
vivid blaze
What do u mean all players? Once someone makes an account it isn't a problem for them. It's when someone tries to make a fake acc which obviously is supposed to be a hassle then.
And again... plz... if u can't fix it u wanna keep it the way it is?? Obviously we can never stop people who really wanna harm us but making it so hard for people to make fake accs, it'll make nearly all of them actually give up
Coz right now, path to making a fake acc is like a red carpet. All we're asking you is to make the path a rocky one
So that most of them wouldn't even go into that
There's a reason why games like fortnite, pubg, 8 ball pool, etc are so successful coz they all have basic measures for security
Give me one example of a successful game that doesnt have email verification... I'll wait
meager gyro
Again.. no to email verification doesnt mean no to any security
Inform yourself about the reporting system of these games and you'll see the AI and mechanics behind it that was well paid by investors and others ^^
Its another range
vivid blaze
Well it's not like as if you're thinking about anything better than that. If you refuse to implement such an easy and basic security which so many games use (and is proven to be so effective), then good luck trying to do something better
And you know what? When you say that guardians face a lot of trouble, most of it is totally useless trouble coz they're fake accs. By having a email thing or any similar security will make things so much cleaner coz fake accs will be almost non existent.
meager gyro
Honestly.. we're going around in circles
I could sum up everything said before and you still wont want to read it carefully nor believe me 
Thanks for sharing your concerns 
vivid blaze
You're deliberately making it a circle. That's the problem
The problem is clear and obvious, and the possible solutions also
It's just that you guys make excuses on not to do it
meager gyro
Email verification isnt the only option 🤷
vivid blaze
Check the old chat. We've given so many possible solutions
I'm not arguing just about the email verification... I'm arguing about everything
The thing is, you cannot just ignore such a major problem and then expect people not to complain about it
meager gyro
Again It's not ignored ^-^
I don't know you previous chats I'm replying to your current feedback
if you want to sum up all of your suggestions to improve the game/ reporting system you can send me a quick dm and I'll check how/ if I can forward it or discuss it with you later
I'll sleep now its almost 5 am ^^
vivid blaze
Anyways I'm done with this for now. I gtg too. Good night
lethal storm
@runic dragon thank you very much
opaque oar
Maybe its nice to have a sell button for example talismans cuz i have like 11 sorcerer talismans and u can't play it so it would be nice if u have a sell button to sell that
mighty granite
@opaque oar Thanks for suggesting, but I'm sure it was suggested 4 months ago.
opaque oar
Ahh idk abt that😂
charred kiln
I think the bann rules in ranked should be harder
So like extra rule for ranked
So things like waste check, bad gameplay (so really extremly bad gameplay), non claiming (on day 3 or sth when theres a rolecall needed (when ur villager ofc)), slow tempo etc
Ranked is meant for high quality gameplay not for noobs who came fresh from quick game
restive carbon
add a message if you reported somebody and the person gets banned (like a thank you for reporting and keeping the community clean or something).
quaint bramble
@charred kiln The general game rules are undergoing an update right now, being more specified in places.
I dont think ranked should have different rules, stricter yes, but not so different. Extremely bad gameplay likely can be reported under gamethrow already, since it is harmful to your team, and ranked IS looked at a little differently by guardians. Rolecalls are to be discourged, not encouraged. Yes i know I dont play ranked a lot, but really thats kind of an easy way out of solving things, thats not skill in my opinion.. And if not from quickgame, then where do they come from? Ranked is more similar to quick than to sandbox in terms of role list.
@restive carbon I believe the devs are currently considering to add this function, I cannot guarantee it is being added though ^^
charred kiln
And waste checks?
Waste checks should be reported in bad situations
Also if theres like 2 villagers and 2 doc claims one of the villager is confirmed med and one of the villager is detective. One of the doc claim is doc and one of the doc claim is ww they ofc what u do then is not voting let detective check and doc on detective (shaman impossible) so if the detective checks the 2 doc claims with each other, thats reportable right?
quaint bramble
At the very least you can ask them why they checked this person, before reporting them. Just cause one person said 5 is good, doesnt mean they have to trust it right away if it looks like there is too much people claiming info roles. In the 2nd example, I think you should ask Alisonn if that is reportable. Reaching detective league doesnt immediately make players skilled in the detective role, even if they have experienced it before in quickgame, it's not a safe assumption with how low the ranked requirement is.
meager gyro
In addition adding a message you need to confirm that you're about to check someone who is already revealed or checked might solve it more efficiently than a rule 🤔
charred kiln
@quaint bramble if its the only info u must trust it
Only aura/det is confirmed aura/det
So if aura says 5 good and detective checks 5 with gunner reportable
Also waste check when confirmed rl says ill visit 5 and aura checks 5
Or priest waters 5 solo ded aura checks 5
quaint bramble
Again this is a specific thing, you make it sound wasteful and gamethrowy, but you should ask a guardian how they would view this if you do report it.
runic dragon
Hello here is my idea,
Why not create a second "mailbox" report, in French this time, which can be consulted by a team of French moderators, because there is a FR community that is quite present on the game, but unfortunately a lot of users can not speak English and therefore can not complain about another player.
Although moderators present in the game chat would be wiser.
Thanks to Philippe for the discord invitation.
peak knot
I have a suggestion for next ranked season. I think the current set-up for ranked has been used for at least 5 seasons straight (disregarding the new rv implementations previous one). I think that might bore some people out who don't feel the need to grind each season. For that reason, my suggestion to the devs is to for once, completely surprise us. I think some diversity would spice up the games and people will have to use their skills to adapt to new changes. Some ideas that could be considered:
- Rv renewal
- Role adjustments
- Role set-up adjustments
- League adjustments
- New types of reward
- Some sort of qualifiers for pro ranked?
- Visual changes (new animations)
- Involve clan performance in ranked
- Ranked 'situation' training?
etc.
pine jacinth
One things that could be helpfull to make ranked a bit harder : do not show the role of someone playing solo (fool sk arso ) when they die in the day , just show ww role when they die so that the village just know when they killed a ww.
Would force people to be a bit more activ in the game with their brains no matter wich role they have
warm swan
This is a very small feedback but I'd like to recommend it so when you're corrupted, when u try to talk or do anything you can't do, putting an animation of the "corrupted icon" as shaking wouldn't be bad at all, just a small shake so it means you can't do that
bronze pasture
A proper changelog.
There is no history in the app store, #game-updates isnt complete either and if it is for once then with a lot of text around it.
Introduce a channel/website/ingame tab/whatever seems right to have changes listed and sorted by version and type of change (additions/deletions/updates).
verbal pasture
Hello, is there a possibility to make a game mode where you can play with only people of your own level range? Because in all the games I play now there are some newbies who don’t know how to play, and just do whatever someone says, or they random shoot. After a while it’s no fun anymore for me to play.
charred kiln
@warm helm imo “spel verpesten” is a better translation than “opgeven” for gamethrowing. Opgeven klinkt meer echt als opgeven en er gen klaar mee zijn maar spel verpesten is meer de letterlijke vertaling van gamethrowing en past meer bij de acties die behoren tot gamethrowen
warm helm
@runic dragon heya! The problem with this is that we dont always have french staff available for that time, if we did this for every singe language possible we would have 50 people and probably even more and cant even get managed. Thank you for your concerns tho
@peak knot so, these changes only apply to ranked, but some things you suggest look that they can also work for other modes or are some small things. Anyways, i really like that, i will post it to #feedback-devs, thank you for your feedback <3
@pine jacinth this would not work for solo’s, but for wws this can perfecty work. I will post it to #feedback-devs, thank you for your feedback
@warm swan i think this only would cause some lagg and would be annoying when checking info about a role 😅
@bronze pasture this is idea is getting requested a lot, but now with #game-updates being incomplete it is really needed. So i will post it to #feedback-devs, thank you for your concerns <3
@verbal pasture this idea is suggested a lot before but the problem is that higher players would have to wait ages to play. Thank you for your feedback tho <3
@charred kiln it is a really old translation, but i will change it. Thank you for your concerns 
charred kiln
Your welcome ^^
sacred sable
Suggestion:
Make spirit seer and arso able to rechoose their targets.
Nothing I hate more than choosing a douse/check only for them to die last second before night ends because mm/jailor/witch kill
runic dragon
@warm helm But I think you will lose a number of users, the French community is unplayable, every game played turns into a fight in the chat.
I just gave an idea, for me I uninstall the game, I'm sick of being insulted every time.
Thank you to the team to be reactive on discord
Good luck to all 😊😉
vernal dune
Hey @sacred sable ! 
The ability to choose targets again has already been suggested a few times and is likely to be added in-game. Thanks for suggesting anyway!
sacred sable
Oh, thanks.
sudden dock
Why is the n word not bleeped...
peak knot
Because wwo players have n-pass
glacial warren
@peak knot that's not right, please don't spread wrong information.
@sudden dock that's a nice question. In any case, you can report players, which use the n-word. In the most cases.
peak knot
@glacial warren Lmao because that was not sarcasm
sudden dock
Yeah i reported them I'm just confused why its not bleeped 🤷♂️
glacial warren
Hm yes, but I think for me it is censored... Maybe it's written in another way 🤔
glacial warren
No I don't think that's necessary xD
sudden dock
Its weird cause its in the regular font, it just is plural
lament knoll
yea its weird sometimes plurals of words are censored but the singular isnt and sometimes the singular is censored but the plural isnt👀
forest rover
Right now we can just know how we died if we committed suicide,and I would want to know how I die when I die.Maybe,above role stats,it could be added a new statistics that would be dead stats.In this place it would explain how and how many times you died.
It would be for example:
Dead stats.
Lynched: 568
Killed by serial killer: 40
Burnt by arsonist : 62
Killed by werewolves: 806
Commited suicide as sect member : 32
Killed by jailer: 107
It would be also great if the survived games,the deaths (totally) and suicides were added into this category.About the suicide,it could be maybe in both (in dead stats and where it is right now) because it’s important to know this.
Adding to this feedback,it could be also done with another stats that would be the interacted stats,that would show things like how many times you have been shamaned,revealed,coupled,sected,
bitten,nightmared etc.
lament knoll
Heya @forest rover ^^
The first thing has indeed already been suggested before, less than a month ago, here is the link to it -> https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/638034243888611338
For the second suggestion about interaction stats, they have not been suggested in that way before, i don't see that much of an use in that either other than simply for fun... well why not i guess👀
I guess i'll give your second suggestion a post, i don't think i'll give the first one a repost, yet, or maybe i'll briefly add it at the end if you want me to ^^
However thanks for your suggestions and have a nice day!
forest rover
Oh ok I haven’t see that feedback 👀
Thx @lament knoll
median elbow
Theoretically speaking let's say I unlocked the entire platinum set. I need to score lower than the platinum rewards to unlocked the gold/silver/bronze outfits. Are "pros" suppose to act nooby and intentionally drop stats or can we just be given the option to unlock leagues lower than or equal to are current rank.
viscid tulip
Canni directly won in a 1v1 situation although Jailer was alive and still could have killed him so maybe don't make him win in 1v1
rigid bronze
@viscid tulip To be honest, it's already difficult to win as solo, I don't think it deserves a nerd like that
@median elbow To be honest I have no idea what happens if you reach twice top 10 👀 I guess you can only gold but I agree it would be cool if you could have the others gladiators 👍🏼 thanks for suggesting !
quaint bramble
@viscid tulip The jailer vs solo always ends in a direct win like this. Jailer is the only role in game that works like that, its not standard for all villagers. It's made like this, because theoretically the jailer could keep jailing the solo, forcing the game to go on for extra days and ending in a tie .
viscid tulip
Ok, thx 👀
rain fiber
Was it ever mentioned,to be able to change hair color?
quaint bramble
Yes thats definately been suggested before but it's sadly not possible at the moment because all outfits and hair items are svg files, they would need individual recolourling etc. (I dont know all the specifics but thats the general idea of it)
forest rover
Ok,let’s suppose hypothetically that marksman cannot kill villagers.That’s okay.Let’s say that if marksman shoots a villager then marksman dies because he receives his own shoot.
But,wait,isn’t marksman a villager?Why marksman cannot kill villagers but he can kill himself,even if he is a villager?This doesn’t make sense.
Well,let’s suppose that marksman just can kill one villager with his shoot,the marksman.This is also wrong.If marksman 1 shoots marksman 2,marksman 2 won’t die but marksman 1 will.I cannot find a logical reason to it,to be honest.
I know that Werewolf Online is not a really logical game,having things like a werewolf that kills people because he is cute.But marksman description is just lying,in my opinion.
I made a few options to change this,if possible.
1-Change the description.Something like “if you shoot a villager you will kill yourself because you wasted your arrow”.It’s a bad example but it has more sense than the description.
2-Make marksman able to kill just other marksman.This would explain why marksman is able to kill himself,because he just can kill marksmans.
3-If marksman shoots a villager,he doesn’t suicide but he lose the arrow.This would make marksman a rsv tho.
4-If marksman shoots,doesn’t matter who,the marked one dies.This would make marksman a rsv too.
Options 2 is a little nerf to village.
Option 3 is a little buff to village,but it’s a huge nerf if it makes marksman rsv.(No more mm in ranked)
Option 3 is a nerf to village.It makes marksman able to kill villagers and makes marksman rsv.
Sorry for the long message tho 😕
uncut tusk
@forest rover Hello there, thanks for your feedback. I think the role description is pretty clear, and you could interpret it like that, in its globality: "You cannot kill villagers, except yourself: if you try to shoot a villager, you will die." ;)
I don't think it's necessary to change mm's abiliy 😉 Unless you have arguments about why he needs to be buffed or nerfed.
forest rover
That’s the option 1 tho,to change the description.Clean is not the same as logical tho.If you said that you cannot kill villagers,it doesn’t make sense that you can kill yourself,because you’re a villager.Just changing the way of how it describe it would be fine @uncut tusk
uncut tusk
"If you try to kill a villager" (with the context about target) => if you try to kill someone else than you who is a villager (because you cannot put the target on yourself), then you will fail and kill yourself. It is not said "you cannot kill villager" in its "globality", if you get what I mean ^^
I honestly don't think there's any problem here, so far no one got a problem with understanding how it works 😅
sacred sable
Suggestion;
If the game censors the acronym STFU, should censor ALL the acronyms that involve cusses/swears -
I.E. GTFO, FYM, SMD, etc.
ripe stirrup
ik im not a helper, but i think stfu isnt censored
runic dragon
@sacred sable I forwarded the message to a mod^^ I'll reply to you as soon as I have more info
@ripe stirrup you can discuss feedbacks here, dw
sacred sable
I know someone suggested it since it involves a censored word, so figured suggesting censoring all acronyms thar bypass it
forest rover
I personally think that it does not make sense that you just cannot kill villagers but you can kill yourself,being a villager.
Even if it isn’t said in globality, @uncut tusk,I suppose that the arrow doesn’t work in any villager it means also you.The description that we have right now means that he receives the shoot.There’s no logical reason for it,even if you don’t think that.
I just wanted to reply,I get your point and it’s ok,even if I disagree 👀
uncut tusk
@forest rover Well basically you're talking about how the ability itself doesn't make sense (and I kinda agree with you, unless the arrow was enchanted or something), but it doesn't belong here 😅
forest rover
Not the ability at all,just the relation with the ability and the description.The ability is fine,but the description is not.That’s why I think that either a description/ability change would be better,but ofc a description change is easier and would solve it quicker.
Where does it belong then @uncut tusk?
signal lodge
I really think that players should have a kind of training course before playing ranked. I mean, not a long or hard one. But at least to know the main strategies (jail gunner, types of fake claims for determinated roles)
uncut tusk
@forest rover Well the thing is, as I said, you're apparently the first and only one to think it's not okay right now, I can't really put it in #feedback-devs and reasonably think it'll be accepted :/
forest rover
But I mean,where does it belong if it does not belong into feedback?
uncut tusk
I said that when I thought you were saying you don't think his ability makes sense 🤔
So it's not relevant anymore
forest rover
Ok thx @uncut tusk
viscid nebula
i think we could add to the server self-assignable roles for pronouns ("she/her", "he/him", "they/them") to avoid misgendering people, bc it seems to happen often
uncut tusk
@viscid nebula Heya, thanks for suggesting! Hmm, you're talking about the wwo game or this Discord server?
Also, you always can put in your profile (or custom status) whether you're male/female/other, if you'd like to tell others about it.
viscid nebula
i mean on the discord server
and yes, i guess you can, but i feel like this could be easier as people tend to change the status
lapis cargo
I think wwo should have a dark mode
uncut tusk
@lapis cargo Heya, thanks for suggesting! Actually, it has been suggested several times, you can upvote whichever you like ;)
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/639770552957009963
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/630523214073954324
@viscid nebula Thing is, if it's not a Discord feature available for everyone, then how can we "accept" it? 😅 We are not Discord developers, we do not take suggestions for improving Discord itself 😉
viscid nebula
oh, that's not what i mean! i mean a role like "sheriff" "junior werewolf" "helper" "guardian"
uncut tusk
Oh okay
So hmmm
@meager gyro What do you think about it?
meager gyro
We actually have a lot of different roles already and won't add much more especially if unrelated to server access or staff/translator/designer roles
Also we havent had big issues with misgendering people yet that would excuse any exceptions from that 👀
But thanks for the feedback 
viscid nebula
okay, thanks!
runic dragon
Not to be rude to the developers because i get that they are trying their best but ranked only being accessible to some people is really starting to piss people off in the community, especially when it gives people several days longer to gain sp, it's like this every season...
lunar salmon
But honestly... I'd love a little gender symbol to put on my game Avatar... I'm agender and I'd love for at least the people who care to use correct pronouns...
runic dragon
I don't exactly know the technical aspects that causes the issue, but i'm sure delaying the beginning of ranked is much better than just throwing half the players into it and dealing with the aftermath
lament knoll
Heya @runic dragon that seems to rather be a bug than an intended current game mechanic and we cannot suggest the devs to change bugs as a feedback.
we can only report them into #bugs-devs for them to see it and fix it.
I get that it "starts to piss people off"
But the game is in the beta for a reason... you got to expect bugs.
So all we can do is wait for it to get fixed, i am sorry for the inconveniences but we cannot do anything more.
runic dragon
Thanks min, sorry if it came across as rude, i just got frustrated since it's happened for the past several seasons, for now i will just report it to bugs with my device and hopefully it gets solved soon, thanks for taking the time to respond.
median elbow
Ranked should be reset again, this current bug is a disadvantage to a lot of players.
Ranked suggestion to improve it. Instead of basing ranked around skill have ranked revolve around leaderboard positions.
Top 500 can be gold
Top 1000 can be silver
And beyond can be bronze
And when players are offline they can be "ignored" temporarily from the leaderbaord
So top 500 could potentially be the top 600 at the current second if 100 out of the 500 people are offline
thick bolt
Ranked could be much better I think. Many things could be made to have better ranked games.
For example we could have a starting skill every season based on last season like so many other games. this would make people playing more in order to start in a better position next season. (of course it would have a limit. Like top 100 will start with 2000, 100-200 with 1900 or something like this).
I would love more set ups with more possibilities of claiming if you were a ww. This 3 rrvs set up is great but lots of people want something new. In a normal gold league game wws must be so strong and village should gamethrow to not win.
Another idea is that solo and wws would gain some skill, not over 10, when village lose. Lots of times sk and wws stay last after so much effort and they get nothing. This would be a motivation to get solos play better.
Clan ranking could get clans to push and participate more active. Clans are kind of forgotten in this game because the only thing you get is skins. Lots of people don't care about skins. We should make clans more important. Give them rewards in ranked games. We should just avoid teaming.
lament knoll
Heyya @median elbow
Sorry for the tardive answer...
I do agree that a reset for the players might be good to don't give some people unfair advantages or disadvantages but then again, it would also be unfair for the ones that played a lot and now for nothing...
I'll still put it up for evaluation in #feedback-devs ^^
About the second suggestion, there were a lottt of league changing suggestions made already, i do believe it has been suggested the way you did before, tho let me check again in #feedback-devs
Depending on whether when it was or if i can find a similar suggestion i might re/post that for you as well.
Thanks for your suggestions, they're appreciated❣
Heyaaa @thick bolt
Actually we got some of your suggestions proposed in a feedback that just got posted yesterday, here is a link to it if you would like to upvote it
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/648524074385145861
About the others such as solo and wws gaining skill when the village loses, ranked noob over here so please spare my little knowledge👀
Do you mean that if they lose but so does the village? Like if wws win, the solo role still gets some skill and if the solo wins the wws still get some skill as well?
If not -> feel free to correct me 👀
And about the little bit of xp to start with, i dont quite know about that... isn't the fun or the good thing that with every season you can start from new and not be advantaged or disadvantaged?
I also do think it has been suggested a few times before, it sounds like a very familar suggestion...
However, if you could specify these two suggestions i'd consider posting them for you ^^
Thanks in advance for your interest in improving the game, it's highly appreciated!
thick bolt
@lament knoll That's exactly what I mean.
- Example. A ww is left with sk and a villager. That villager has to either choose to vote for wws or sk, or he could just wait until sk can win. In order to reach that point where so many villagers are dead both sk and wws played so well and it's a pity that a villager will decide who deserved to win. this is why i recommend that a small amount of skill is give to the losing side.
2)As far as the starting skill is concerned, it is a system used in other games. For example in LeagueOfLeagends you have a ranking fall at the beginning of every season depended last season's final results. This is a good role not to get "pro" players to play with "noobs" I think that something like this would help everyone to enjoy their games.
lament knoll
Fair enough... i'll give it a post
Thanks for being so precise with your suggestions and have a nice day/night! 
green wind
It is still saying season 15 will start soon for me. And the hall of fame isn't loading top 100. It only shows me up to 11.
quaint bramble
@green wind the hall of fame one is a known bug. For the season not starting, it's also known but some people are able to get in after clearing cache and reinstalling the game, a few times. Thats the best advice i can give you right now..
next escarp
you should be able to take back your nightmares as nww, i nightmared someone and decided to take it back, but i couldnt, so i randomly nightmared someone. they were the fool. i got laughed at.
jagged wigeon
F
So i just won as the last ww against 12 people and i want to replay it. Would a replay/record feature be possible?
median elbow
@lament knoll I have been top 20 since ranked has reset. I am okay with another rank reset with this bug.
lament knoll
Heyaa @next escarp
Yea that has indeed already been suggested before and i agree with it ^^
Tho the last post of it has been several months ago and i guess a repost won't hurt, just in case.
Thanks alot for your suggestion and have a nice day/night !
next escarp
🙂
median elbow
Filler items shouldn't be a thing.
quaint bramble
@median elbow There isnt really a way to avoid that, some outfits do not have 6 items, esp older ones (I know this isnt an older one)
median elbow
@quaint bramble wrong. This can be fixed by making this quest 5 days and slightly cheaper.
quaint bramble
Hm thats indeed an option as well, I will see when it was last suggested
median elbow
Another suggestion about quest...
As time decreases make the gold skip cheaper. For example "gems" cost in clash of clans decreases with time.
quaint bramble
Hm I am pretty sure the shorter quests has been suggested before, but I cannot find it in fb-devs right now so I will whip up a message and post this for you, unless you wanna write it out yourself?
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/612023108760764436
The 2nd idea was posted before a few months back, but I see Emanual disliked it... I am willing to repost it anyway though 👀
@median elbow
median elbow
Nah it doesn't need to be reported if it was already rejected
quaint bramble
I personally think it's a good idea, but yeah their word is what matters... he disliked it against 50 likes
lament knoll
Heyaaa @jagged wigeon sorry for the veryyy late answer...
I was investigating ittt and it was indeed suggested before and even very recently posted into fb devs ^^
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/644665286997573643
^if you wanna upvote it
Thanks for reporting and have a nice day/night.
ornate sun
14 RL visited someone that got attacked, but 9 visited 14, is this a bug?
14 didn't get attacked
next escarp
quaint bramble
@ornate sun Are both messages the same thing, they died from visiting someone evil? or someone who got attacked?
ornate sun
@quaint bramble the same thing, from someone getting attacked
@next escarp im not sure if it's a bug, cuz if it's meant to be like that, then I have feedback for the RL description
next escarp
ah ok
quaint bramble
@ornate sun to be honest, at this point i also cant think straight anymore, if this is supposed to happen or not :/
I am leaning towards i think it is normal, that if the visited person dies in any way, the other rl dies too
ornate sun
@quaint bramble what happened was ->
7(det) died
14 visited 7 (so died)
9 visited 14 who was not attacked (but still died)
median elbow
Avenger shouldn't be a hh target. If the avenger tags the hh the hh loses.
normal wyvern
It should be possible to see in the playerinfo in which clan this player currently is.
It should also said somewhere when they joined for the first time. People who joined before August 2018, have now a "joined date" so it shouldn't be a problem
green rune
?help
runic dragon
rigid bronze
@normal wyvern Heya, good idea but posting it to #feedback-devs makes no sense, contact TheCrazyMaffin#2986 if you want to suggest him things
@green rune Hey, please move to #bot-commands for that kind of stuff
normal wyvern
Maffin makes this? Thank you 
iron girder
-
When spectators join the game. Even if they leave. The show as 'off' instead. This is to prevent them from lying about false info to medium. Allowing a report.
-
Spectators should also be able to report a player.
runic dragon
Explain this please. Im tired of this...
glacial warren
@runic dragon pretty simple to explain. 10 is teaming with one of the wws, ich is reportable 
@iron girder hey ^^ it already has been suggested to be able to report spectators and also to be able to report as a spectator ^^
iron girder
Wow ok ty lol
west wind
In ranked games if you die night 1 and you never get revived you should win and lose less points since you have no control over the game
uncut tusk
@west wind Heya, thanks for your suggestion! A recent similar idea was posted, you can upvote it if you like :) https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/648129141140357130
west wind
@uncut tusk Hi, the one posted about 8 hours ago? That one mentions only the werewolves and solo roles but I was thinking more about the villagers because only villagers die night 1 usually and it's really annoying when the other villagers vote fool or hh's target and you lose the same points as them while you had no control over what happened
Edit: nvm i just found the link, i will upvote the idea; but it's still kind of different because I suggest still winning and losing points, just less
runic dragon
When will i get the glasses one? for posting ww related in youtube
glacial warren
@runic dragon when you have enough views, you can contact a Moderator with the link. Next time for questions use #questions
glacial warren
@runic dragon mods are @meager gyro and @pallid merlin
DM one of them and stay patient ^^
peak knot
@runic dragon Are you sure the ww didn't random vote anyone? If not, @glacial warren is correct.
glacial warren
?
peak knot
If the wolves are dumb and vote simultaneously, villagers could see that pattern
lament knoll
it was day 1
runic dragon
Lmao wtt? I did not suicide... when they lynch me off i exit... It's bug right?
next escarp
leaving is suiciding
vivid blaze
He didn't leave. He said he was lynched. In that case leaving isnt suiciding
glacial warren
Yep ^^ #bugs-readonly 😉 as far as I know it is a known bug
vivid blaze
It could be that u suicided right before u got lynched
Or also, it could be that u suicided a lot before this game and it took a while for the system to detect it. It has happened with me earlier.
But else it's a bug
vivid blaze
I'm so sick of all the nonsense and stupidity in game...
Remember when gunner random shoots someone and they don't report and make excuses??
Today gunner kept asking someone's role and he didn't answer at all which denotes that he's surely bad. So gunner shoots him and he's sk. Regardless of his role, it makes sense to shoot coz gunner did have a 'reason' as he wasn't answering any questions.
But then one of our deluded genius players say "Reported gunner for random" 👏👏
Total bs and stupidity. When it's actually random nobody reports but when it makes sense they do fraud 👏👏
Guess people out there just wanna be dumb and do opposite... and always hurt the innocent person. I hate to say it but some players really need brain surgery to get their senses fixed.
Unless they're doing it deliberately. Which is even worse than being deluded.
lament knoll
You are not forced to give your role at a role call as that is not the goal of the game?
Like if ur gonna role call anyways why not simply do it on day 1 so ppl dont waste their precious time?
If it was before day 3, even if not saying their role, that's not completely a valid reason to shoot, people can decide to, no matter if vilager or not, not say their role...
I can understand this player reporting, i have not been in the situation but from your description it seems like a, more or less, valid shot
From here on it's upon a guardian to judge. If the guardian does think it was random, looking at the chat, he'll take action.
Also taking into account previous actions they have been reported for before.
I see 0 point in complaining in this channel about a false report. These happen all the time that is no new thing.
And we cannot change false reporting, players will continue with false reporting until we disable reporting, which would obviously be a stupid thing.
I don't really get what your statement has to do with feedback? I see no Suggestion to change a current game mechanic?
So if you just want to share your experience and complain maybe do it in #wov-chat...
I understand your point but we can't stop people from reporting due to little knowledge, misunderstanding or saltiness.
vivid blaze
@lament knoll Somehow I did expect you'll say this so I'm not really surprised.
I hope you realize that role calling is the main pillar towards winning games. Sooner or later we have to role call.
And this case in particular, the seer was dead and we needed to do a role call. Coz someone can be fool and obviously we can't lynch him but shoot, and no response is the only way to identify a possible fool. Please be aware of these facts.
Also, at the very least, this is still atleast a reason to shoot so it makes it much less random than just blind shooting. But funny enough u can see people just wanna be dumb
But the thing is you know you guys confuse us so much. The rules say something, here you say something else and players do something else. There's literally isn't much match between rules you tell us here compared to the game rules.
Idk if you play the game much but if you don't, the kinda only main way to victory is by role calling which happens every game and at any random day. Now if you're gonna use it against my case then that's just harrassment.
Either u specify it in the rules or don't blame us.
lament knoll
I did not blame you in any way?
Neither did i say that it was random shooting?
I play the game frequently yeah, and yeah i got into role calls, at a reasonable time, role call on day 1-3 is not reasonable if there are info sources
You just take our answers to an unspecific case and transfer them to a way more specific one.
I did not say role call is nonsense per say, it's simply nonsense asking for roles in early game -> day 1-3 if there are several information sources alive.
I dont see any use in a role call on the first day as the game literally just started, same for the second day.
Rules are versatile in different situations, we can only give you the universal rule, of course some are different in certain scenarios.
If you want to have an answer upon a specific case:
tell us which case, ask us if the rule affects the scenario in the usual way or if that scenario leaves space for actions such as "random killing" if it's still random killing at that point.
Rules like random killing etc, are simply versatile rules that can depend on the situation that is going on.
We want a lot of stuff added to the rules or also simply more specified, changed etc and -> the rules are currently getting updated.
If you got any suggestions on what to change let me know in dms and i'll forward it to the people that take care of it.
latent saddle
why you dont make items checker for sending gift system.
so if i want to send offer for player X but player X bought that offer i get msg tell me that player X has that item are you still want to send the gift?
by that you wont waste your money if you sent offer for someone bought that offer you can know if he has it or not :\
lament knoll
Heyaa @latent saddle
This has indeed already been suggested before!
Tho the last time was in early August.
I think that is indeed a good idea and i'd like to give it a repost!
Thanks for your suggestion
latent saddle
yes pls
sacred sable
Dunno if this is suggested but:
Change Avenger info to say "After the fiest night, you can tag one person to kill when you die."
It doesn't say "after first night," so most would assume it's a villager jww.
charred kiln
Weird suggestion:
Add the option (yes the option so u dont need to) to make a password when u donate gold to the clan. Ive got like 11k gold and if someone wants to be annoying and donate all my gold to the clan im fcked
I know this is a weird suggestion
lament knoll
Yeah @sacred sable that was already suggested, it actually got changed few months ago that avenger can't tag in the first night, i assume that is why the description does not include it.
It is basically a villager jww but the probability that you kill someone good the first night is too high + random tagging in the first night is pretty unfair if you hit a solo role or ww by luck, also if you hit a villager of course.
I could not see it in #feedback-devs weirdly... however, only a small suggestion but i'll post it ig
Thanks for the suggestion
latent saddle
i can suggest here to edit item ?
lament knoll
We usually don't take feedback about changing existing in game items because the designer designed it that way for a reason
@charred kiln wouldn't that only be helpful if someone else has got access to your account?
You should only give the people access to your account whom you trust, if even anyone, and other than preventing other people which have got access to your account from doing that i see no other use?
unique storm
So yesterday I was able to play games for season 15 on my tablet.
Today on my phone I get "season 15 is starting soon" and can't play ranked.
Both are Android devices
lament knoll
@unique storm #bugs-readonly anddd
We are very sorry for this problem with the ranked season being unplayable for some people, and it will be fixed asap. Please try to reinstall your game, and clear your cache, for some people this does work! If you still have problems after reinstalling, then please add your device and game version here, we are keeping a list!
runic dragon
Who pinged me?
vernal dune
I pinged you because I posted the image in the wrong channel 👀 look in #bugs-readonly
knotty kelp
when will i be able to play ranked??? i keep getting this "season 15 will start soon" msg
its annoying
vernal dune
@knotty kelp this is a known bug, the devs are working on it, please be patient.
vernal dune
It will be fixed soon.
quaint bramble
@knotty kelp You can try clearing cahce, removing the game completely and reinstalling it, for some people this works.
knotty kelp
I re installed thrice already
quaint bramble
That's the best i can tell you right now, I'm sorry. Other general fixes are switching internet connections or making sure you have some extra memory space to run the game, but they arent specific to this problem.
next escarp
when a bomber dies, the bombs should still go off.. the bombs dont die with them
warm helm
@next escarp this does happen when the bomber dies during the night that his bombs explode, but if you mean at day that didnt seem to be posted before, so i will post it, thanks for your feedback ❤️
woeful mesa
Hi, is it a new feature that bomb explodes when bb is killed during the day? From what I know it shouldn't explode lol
rigid bronze
That would more belong to #questions or maybe #bugs-readonly 👀
woeful mesa
Well that's a reaction to the last feedbacks devs, which seems wrong for me😅
but didn't want to directly say that it was wrong, that's why I asked, I should have asked somewhere else sorry
quaint bramble
Afaik it is the way Sonblo said above, they do go off if the bomber dies just before they are supposed to go off, but not in other cases.
And it doesnt make much sense to have them still explode in other scenarios, cause the bomber cant win anymore..
woeful mesa
@quaint bramble the bomb doesn t blow up when we lynch the bb at day, so the last feedback should only be about the night👀
quaint bramble
You could ask Sonblo to clarify it, I cant edit her message ^^
woeful mesa
@warm helm Hi, the last feedback dev is wrong, because if bb is killed during the day then the bomb doesn't blow up already^^
next escarp
but the bomb should blow up
woeful mesa
wait it is your feedback?
~~in that case the feedback is wrong, but for the night part lol, but I think it should be clarified👀 ~~
woeful mesa
Your feedback is about it should blow up, or shouldn't?🤔
next escarp
it should blow up
woeful mesa
then the feedback isn't clear, because it already does in the night
quaint bramble
@next escarp Agreed, at this point please specify, in which cases you want it to blow up? And hwats the point? Since he cant win anymore, he;s dead.
solo killers win by being last player standing aka alive
next escarp
when the bomber dies, the bombs planted (if they are planted) should still explode since bombs aren’t removed when the person who planted them dies
they’ll still explode at night
idk i thought it would just be interesting
quaint bramble
the person who presses the button to detonate them dies, thats another way of looking at it
and i think it is useless, like i said he cant win anyway
lament knoll
~~he could still kill some villagers and give the ww an advantage and technically he can't press the button either when he's jailed or he would automatically reveal himself👀
forest rover
Talking about bomber,bomber does not presses any button.Bombs explote without bomber permission.Because unlike arsonist,bomber cannot choose when he wants to explote the bombs.I would say that bombs have a timer,which imo would be the best explanation.Timer does not stop when the bomber puts the bombs even if bomber dies irl,so I agree with the feedback. 👀
Because if it were just a button,I would press it at day as bomber.Press a button wouldn’t reveal me I think.If we’re talking about bombs with timer,it explains why you cannot explote it at day.
With arsonist is easy to explain because if you think about it,imo villagers would find that arsonist is the one that comes to burn players,so it makes sense that you can just do it night
runic dragon
I think I had a stroke reading that
lament knoll
Well the bomber could set the timer any time if being realistic👀
But that'd make the role too op haha
pine jacinth
So basicly ranked are avaible for me and we have to catch up with ppl with 3k ?
Not really for those Who doesnt have access to ranked yet imo , idc for me but some who will get access to ranked in only 1-2 days will just be like "what is that "
quaint bramble
the first few games are qualification, if you win those you can get to detective league. It doesnt matter when you join the season, the qualificstion matches are alwasy there
lapis drum
Is there any way the selection for emotes can be narrowed down to the first frame of the emote? The exploding emote gets in the way of other emotes and I often tap it by mistake it’s under another one.
lament knoll
Heyaa @lapis drum this has actually been posted in #bugs-devs as bug already, i hope that the issues with that emote will get fixed soon
lapis drum
Very nice. Thanks!
pine jacinth
@quaint bramble if you are lucky enough to win those ranking game yea
woeful mesa
For the quest heroes, the name shown aren t the actual ones, and are in facts for some very old one (e.g MINX who changed name months ago, and baap, Piplup... are old names too), it would be cool if we could see the players' actual name^^
languid cape
There should be a option for players to choose if they want to show or hide their clan tags because some players don’t want their tag while they still want to remain in the clan
I know that the clan leader can choose to hide the tag for the whole clan but I think it should be a player option
prisma grove
So i dont know if it was already said because i never look in this chat, but how about making an option that the vice leader or the leader can take people who for example didnt spend some money for the quest out, so they dont participate in it?
lament knoll
Heyaaa @prisma grove
Yes, that has indeed already been suggested before, it get's suggested quite frequently but i do believe there was a pretty recent post about it in #feedback-devs
Well it's been a bit more than a month ago buuut: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/636509886804525076
There you go ^^
You can add a onto it and i hope that it'll get added soon as that is indeed a pretty handy feature
Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day!
prisma grove
Ok thanks you too
lament knoll
Heyaaa @languid cape
That seems like a nice idea and i do agree with it, this could also reduce clan focussing, atleast a tiny bit and i can totally understand that ppl dont really like the clan tag feature ^^
I did not see this having been suggested in that way before, or atleast i could not find it in #feedback-devs before suprisingly, i'll give it a post!
Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day!
languid cape
You too and yeah I get targeted for my tag
woeful mesa
should I repost my feedback about quest heroes's name? Or I missed the answer
runic dragon
I suggest decreasing the slot to 100 or 150 since its too hard to farm roses just for a slot
woeful mesa
I feel like a slot is way better than an outfit's part, so in my opinion the price should be higher than a piece of skin, so 250 isn t that bad👀
Just giving my opinion here though👀
lament knoll
oof sorry jojo i meant to answer gimme a sec
woeful mesa
don't be sorry lol, take your time^^
lament knoll
Heyaaa @woeful mesa
Actually that has been posted in form of a bug in #bugs-devs once, that names on the quest heroes board do sometimes not update when you change your name, so i guess that is rather a bug, anyhow, clearing the cache and restarting the app might work for it, and otherwise i'd like to get ur device and game version so i can add your info onto the database?
median elbow
How about not neither of those @runic dragon. How about this, 100, 150, 200, 250 and 350 for costume unlocks
Things like this
woeful mesa
Clearing/restarting changed nothing👀
Version: 0.39.3 finally the new one noice
Device: samsung s8
Thanks for your answer^^
prisma vector
Hello all, I am really loving the game but I have a few suggestions I want to provide.
My main gripe with the current game is that I feel the game is very unbalanced, my village win ratio in high ranked matches seems to be about 80% and I even believe that villagers don't even use optimal play even in high (5k+) ranked matches.
I have thought about it a lot and while there are many knobs that could be tweaked (role powers, role % appearance, etc), I think that the villager's most overpowered tool currently is how easy it is to confirm all roles.
I think the one idea I did have that I think could actually diminish this problem is having games with more roles that are undetermined. The more roles that are undetermined the harder it is for role calls to actually work. Specially if you purposelly try to remove roles that are easy to prove.
Example would be a Platinum League: You can now have RV detectives. Guaranteed Aura and Priest are removed, instead you now have 5 RVs. Wolves would lose guaranteed shaman and instead they now have 2 RWW.
The more I play the more noticeable it becomes that just role calling day 1 is quite literally the most optimal strategy. You can quickly dispose of duplicate roles and village's kill power is way beyond WWs + Solo, and they also have defense powers which other teams do not. But the reason this strategy is so optimal is because of the ratio of easily provable roles vs evil.
opaque pollen
@prisma vector Hello! Sorry for a late response; Discord is buggy for me tonight. Many suggestions have been made for Ranked, but I will add yours to #feedback-devs. So if I understand the core of your suggestions is that you would like more Random Villagers in Ranked to increase difficulty?
light edge
The actual problem is evil roles not claiming anything. The game will still be solved rather easily when evil roles don't claim anything...
Train new people to fake aura, rvs, doc and how to act villager.
There are many forced ww wins by perfect play from werewolfs just saying... most are just not trying.
lethal crypt
PLEASE re-evaluate the censorship system... having everyone being able to choose words and take away words that are censored did not work
Like if I said Im going to massacre this muffins Massa and muff would be censored also not to mention part of my legal name is censored because it just happens to also be part of a women’s product for periods
And ass isnt censored but bitch is. That doesnt make sense because since ass could technically be a donkey you would have to uncensor bitch because thats also another word thats been used as a curse yet can still mean female dog
vivid blaze
Hey helpers, and the entire game staff. I won't even bother explaining what happened in the game today but after what I saw, I just want to say 'good luck' trying to improve things considering the way you guys are currently.
prisma vector
@opaque pollen yes, eliminate some easily provable roles while adding more roles that aren't guaranteed. Another way to achieve it can be with RVs like Red Lady and MMs, which aren't protectors but also aren't easily provable
@light edge I don't agree and we can go over the math in private if you'd like but the only reason faking actually works is because not everyone claims, if everyone was to claim mathematically, villagers could always win due to their surplus of resources compared to other roles.
light edge
I did the math. And found it very interesting that some set ups are broken af.
I also made a couple of videos of forcing evil wins. you can find them in #videos
I am still waiting for jailer to claim day 1.
But everyone focuses in getting solid as village over getting solid as ww @prisma vector
prisma vector
Add me so I can message you in private if you'd like
I don't think it's about getting solid or not
WW wins require major leaps in judgement from at least a few villagers, which is easy in a game controlled by humans specially one where people aren't trying to min max specifically
light edge
added
hot stag
I don't know if this should be put here, but I think it would be cool to have a dark theme menu screen. It could be the night phase background, cuz tbh the regular menu screen is a bit bright for me at night 😅
lament knoll
Heyy @hot stag
First off, sorry for the late ansewer and yupp, this is the exactly right channel to put it so don't worry ^^
Dark theme/dark mode is indeed being suggested quite frequently, in fact just beginning of this month a suggestion for dark mode got posted again
here's the link for it: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/639770552957009963
You can give it a if you want to
Thanks for the suggestion and have a nice day!
woeful mesa
Hi, for the newly added notification system for ban, which says: Thank you, one of the player you recently reported got banned. I think it would be cool that we are able to see this message in game, like a private message. Because from what I saw it is nowhere in the game, only in notifs, and for people that don t use notifs they will never be able to see this message, or know that their report have been useful.
Also, and it can maybe be separated, in this system maybe show the player's name that has been banned?
runic dragon
The message "Somebody voted to skip the discussion" shouldn't appear when are you who voted
When you switch to preview a loyalty Outfit that you don't own, there should say how many tokens u need for your first item from that outfit
opaque pollen
@woeful mesa I don't agree with the banned name showing but I like the first feedback
woeful mesa
Yeah I separated it because it was another idea which wasn't directly linked with the first one, thanks for your answer^^
opaque pollen
I worry showing the username might be abused is all. I'll add the first but though!
Bit*
woeful mesa
I understand, thanks for posting it^^
glacial warren
@runic dragon hey ^^ the first thing sounds right xD but it is the normal system message and I think it should stay therso you know, that you are the first one, who voted to skip ^^
The second suggestion with the loyalty tokens is a nice idea and I searched it up, but couldn't find it in #feedback-devs ^^
You mean, that the description below the outfit change with the outfit picture right?
runic dragon
@glacial warren yes that's what i mean 
glacial warren
Okay! Thank you for the suggestion!
pine jacinth
Can we get this kind of behavior ban ?
If i write the biggest ticket moderator ever seen ?
placid cove
So played the game after a while. And still noticed some teaming. Reported everyone I could and was sure had no loopholes. Sadly some of the teamers were pretty high level. And I don't think bans are much of a help too. Hope you guys would implement a punishment system that on top of banning would make people loose exp, gold or roses for repeated teamers which I think would help reduce teaming.
@pine jacinth I'm just a player but I know people like that can be banned, just report them for random killing.
pine jacinth
Thats not random killing , imagine this gunner in real driving bro, i aint crossing road anymore knowing that such dumb people exist ans breath
Real life*
quaint bramble
@pine jacinth you can get them banned by reporting in-game. Please dont post such screenshots here, we cannot ban players as discord staff.
You might want to read #ingame-reports-archieved to see more info about our reporting system
@placid cove currently there is no extra punishment on top of a ban,but by repeated offenses the bans get longer and longer, if severe enough they can get semi permanent bans of months or even years length. If you are interested in more specific info about how guardians deal with repeat high lvl game throwers, you could contact them in dms.
runic dragon
New Mode Please?
Lately Sandbox was the only good mode...
Rank and Quick Game are literally underrated and sandbox is overrated. Can you add a mode where for 20+ Tokens can play?
runic dragon
Im tired of playing with people who target me first cuz of my skin... I suggest adding a mode where people who has 20+ tokens can go in...
spare steeple
My mom was uninstall the game accidentally then she install it and she cant enter the game
What should i do
hot stag
@lament knoll Ah, thank you so much!
rigid bronze
@spare steeple Hey, this isn't the right channel, but what is her problem ? She can't remember her logins details ?
Ah I saw you got help from somewhere else, sorry 😁
spare steeple
Okay😊
pine jacinth
Could we only allow people whos got AT LEAST 50 win and are lvl 20 to go in ranked ?
normal wyvern
You should receive a notification or a notification point when new roles are displayed in the role list. So you could quickly look at this and perhaps you could avoid these questions with "When will new roles be added". 
proper turret
I FOUND A GOOD ONE
Sorry its not in English, but its buying new clan icons. It costs 2000 gold, and yes the 2000 gold from clan money was used, but its '+2000' in Ledger!! This should be '-2000' in red for sure
in case the words r not in English,
아이콘=icon
방금 전=recently
기부=donation
quaint bramble
@proper turret Fun thing, I got the exact same issue in #bugs-readonly right now, I will probably report it there :) If you are the one buying it, what is your game version?
proper turret
ohhhh i thought this was for feedback so i didnt look on bugs 😂 hold on a sec
its 0.39.3
deft merlin
Last game: zombie claims first day as zombie saying a player could not be bitten; the village, obviously, does not kill the zombie but play for zombie team even if they are still all villagers; two werewolves are killed the first two days, exposed by the zombie who tried to bite them, the others ww suicide because they are playing against village+zombie as a single team; after, the villagers even try killing by votation a revived (therefore revealed) marksman (me) who was the only villager playing for village team. Then, i succeeded killing the first zombie, but died in the attempt to kill another villager who was supposed to be a zombie, as he tried to kill me. End of the game: zombies win...
An this is only one example, games with zombies are all the same.
Nobody of the other villagers will report the game, cause they all win as zombies at the end...
At this point, i really think zombies should be removed, if one can claim zombie first day and still win the game like that...
quaint bramble
@pine jacinth Sorry for the late reply, increasing ranked entry levels has bene suggested before, but its not currently being considered to be added to the game.
@normal wyvern A notification that their descriptions are in game, wouldnt really stop these questions, unless it would also have something like 'coming soon' in that description, which is something we could indeed suggest in feedback devs 🤔
@deft merlin Heya, we have gotten many suggestions for nerfing zombies or removing them from sandbox completely, but atm there are no plans for changes... However, what you described is absolutely gamethrowing, and against the rules. I understand that reporting every villager one by one is a lot of work, but at the very least report the people who are actively supporting the zombies in their chatting, and the ones who spoke up to lynch you as a confirmed villager. The guardians will review the chatlog and possibly ban the rest of them too, even if you did not directly report all of them!
normal wyvern
@quaint bramble Yea, I already thought about this. Maybe a little Icon on the role and when you click on it, it'll say "Comming soon"? 
thin dome
Can these be in alphabetical order please?
rigid bronze
@thin dome I agree, do you mind if I only say "in random roles description" ?
For #feedback-devs
thin dome
@rigid bronze go for it 🙂
rigid bronze
👍👍
charred kiln
I think like when ur doctor, doctor should still stay in the list or like when ur gunner. Now a lot of noobs get confused and when theyre rv they think there are only 2 rvs ig and not 3 becuz in the list its written 2 rvs.
I think this is better since the better players already get there arent 4 rvs when they are rv and the noobs also think there are 3 rvs
if its unclear tell it to me and ill send an explination with an ss
glacial warren
@charred kiln do you mean, that the rrv should be marked as random regular Villager? Or that there should be written, that there are 3 random regular villager? Or what exactly?
sacred sable
Personally, is confusing when RRV is a role on list so it dun show that you're actually RRV
prisma vector
I think he means even if you're avenger it should still say Regular Random Villager x3
instead of x2
So that newer players don't get confused and think there are only 2 rvs. Since more experienced players realize that them being an avenger means they are one of the 3 rvs. Sort of like when you're an rv Doctor or an rv Aura it still says x3
I agree that when I was first starting out I got confused by the same concept, I thought there were only 2 rvs in several games where I was an rv character, although after I learned the game a bit more this is a non-issue anymore
sacred sable
Suggestion:
Make new member donating gold to clan impossible for (24-72) hours to prevent scamming
Wanted to say 1-7 days but ehh
fallen rock
Making a system with reputation points, you can give other players either a or a 
, the number more and less is displayed on each player's profile. I think this idea can help make players behave better
forest rover
Imo a lot of people will give just dislike because they can.This would make difficult to have a good percentage 👀
sacred sable
I say reporting is fine on making people behave
Cuz devs/guardians can track your alts
strong walrus
I'd just be happy if BeastHunter wasn't allowed to trap himself... Would actually force them to help instead of doing what they do now, claim and sit there.
charred kiln
Ill give a better explanation with an ss later on
sacred sable
Oi
Who made it so HH target stick when target is revived?
charred kiln
But @prisma vector was right but i want to give a better explanation so others will understand it too
pine jacinth
@quaint bramble remember when i told you about the "no connexion found" when i launch the game right after i installed it ?
vernal dune
@sacred sable
Its the members choice if they want to donate straight away or not, so I dont think a limit is necessary...
Thanks for the suggestion anyway 
@fallen rock roses in game already act as some sort of karma system, and the report system as its opposite. So something similar is already in the game.
Thanks for the suggestion
@strong walrus it is true that this is quite a problem, so I'll add this as a suggestion in #feedback-devs 🌹
verbal pasture
Hi! I think it’s nice to have a red dot or other thing for the outfit they are using atm... because I want to use it for something but I don’t know what they’re using 😅
runic dragon
I would like to participate in a quest even if I joined the clan when it has already started.
Also would like that the Quest Heroes has some usage.
So at this:
You should be able to use your Quest Hero points to participate in a quest even if that quest has already started.
Note: If there's a tier active, you won't participate in that tier, you would participate in the next
glacial warren
@verbal pasture hey hey ^^ it's a nice idea, because like this you can always match up with friends, but the other thing is, when do you want to check it?
@runic dragon I like this idea ^^ do you have anything to add? And you mean, that you get quest hero points as points for you so if you join another clan u can use them?
runic dragon
@glacial warren Yup, exactly what you said
glacial warren
Okay! Thank you so much for the feedback!
woeful mesa
Hi. I don't really get the last feedback, in the case when I just joined a clan. Like if I join this clan, my quest heroes points are 0. It doesn't really make sense for me that something you gained in another clan can be used in the new clan. Quest heroes are linked only with your actual clan, and changed between the clans, so if you just joined a new clan the quest heroes point are at 0, not at for example 50 from your old clan...
runic dragon
@woeful mesa Yeah that's what I'm suggesting, when you leave some clan, the quest hero you had there now will be yours
woeful mesa
no I said totally the contrary lol
runic dragon
Yeye I know what u said, and I'm suggesting to it don't be as u said
I mean actually is like u said, but my suggestion I that the hero points you made in a clan now will be yours when you leave that clan
Maybe should be edited the feedback to be more understandable 🤔
woeful mesa
Yeah but quest heroes, are basically the heroes of the clan, the bests of the clan! and out of sudden they leave the clan, to join another one, so are you still a hero of the clan? No you're just a new player. Why should your achievements in another clan be usable in the new one?
And for the case like I'm alone or just 2 in the clan. We do a dozen of quests, and then decide to leave for a big clan. We would have been the quest heroes by gaining Idk, 3k exp per quest. and now we join the top 1 clan, with top players having more than 25k. We would never be able to get quest heroes points! But because we were in a noob clan before, we have a lot of these points, while other player from the top 1 clan have way less but make way more exp. It's very unfair.
runic dragon
Well the first it's really a good point.
Tho the points you made in another clan wouldn't be added to your actually clan, you just would be able to use them to participate in a quest already started, and if you for mistake pressed "Do not participate in clan quest" you'll have the quest heroes points to rejoin that quest in the next tier.
And as a hero of your clan you should have some benefits when you leave it
pine jacinth
anyway here is the thing notice for ranked access problem , when i install the game back i have a screen telling me game didnt find any connexion , i shut the game done and re launch it , after i can log in BUT when this message error occure i dont have (before the log in) message asking me to accept terms and rule and confirm that im over 13 , when i had it (only 1 times for like 20 uninstal and re instal) ranked worked. i tried to uninstall the game after that , had the connexion error message and couldnt join ranked.
woeful mesa
I get that part, but it should only be usable in the clan you gained these points then, not in another clan^^
And the benefit is to have your name on the heroes' list^^ of course some clans put some additional rewards for those heroes, but it's the clan's choice then. It's like the achievements, they are here for you to witness how good you've been with some roles, but don't give additional rewards^^
@glacial warren Hey^^ I'm pinging to make sure this doesn't get lost between our messages, I want to feedback on reaction to the last feedback devs that this system would be cool, but you can only use your points in the clan you gained those points. Also, the point when used doesn't disappeared from the quest heroes list, but only disappeared from the number of points you can use. Like if I have 6 quest heroes points, I use one for joining the quest in my clan, It would still be shown 6 but I only have 5 left to use^^
glacial warren
It's toons feedback so I think Toon has to agree 👀 then I would edit the message
woeful mesa
I want to make another feedback👀
glacial warren
Ooooh so just a feedback as addition to the other feedback?
woeful mesa
yeah, but which doesn't take count of the joining a new clan part, only if you were put at not joining the quest and suddenly want to join it, you can use your quest heroes points for it^^
But you would use these points only in the clan you gained them
runic dragon
I'm open to edit or repost it tho @woeful mesa @glacial warren
I think would be better
To make able to use Quest Heroes points as I said but only in your clan as jojo said, you would ping us both 🤔
glacial warren
Now I'm confused xD
woeful mesa
I think that's good like that, thanks^^
drowsy yarrow
can you add a message for when players change there name like: "old name" change his name to "new name"
like the messages in the clan for when people join or leave
uncut tusk
@drowsy yarrow Heya, thanks for suggesting!
Hmmm, do you mean, for your friends? And/or clan mates?
In both cases (and even more), there's already a suggestion where someone's last names would be listed in his profile.
What do you think about it? You can upvote it if you'd like:
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/648180110910029825
drowsy yarrow
i was thinking in the clan chat because some times you might not know if a player has change his name
i remember most of my friends but there are new mebers that change the name every few hours
runic dragon
Idk if this is a bugg or a feedback thingy.
But the quest heroes their names never match.
Alot of my clanmates are still having their old name.
quaint bramble
@runic dragon I've recently seen one or two posts about the same problem. I am trying to check if they were indeed posted in either the feedback/bugs-devs channel ^^
woeful mesa
Hi, the description message doesn t actually explain what "talk to a mentor" does. I know that it s explained elsewhere, but I think it would be cool to add it on this message too^^
it s a known bug, I reported the same yesterday haha
quaint bramble
@runic dragon @woeful mesa Ahh so thats why I had seen it before 👀 I would indeed consider this a bug rather than a feedback, but it is indeed already posted in some way not too long ago. If it's not fixed in a week or two, I would gladly repost this one 
I agree on the mentor message! It describes the email and discord option, but not the mentor option...
Honestly im not sure why the email is listed so prominently, since its supposed to be exclusive to account and payment issues, anything else would just get redirected to the discord.
SO I guess I will add my own part to your suggestion too ;)
Could you gimme a quick tip on where this message is found exactly? 😅
runic dragon
feedback: I love baguette buddy
lethal cedar
Hi, can I suggest that there can be discounts for the offers in the shop (did i use the wrong channel? 🤣 )
during special times eg. christmas, chinese new year, new year etc.
normal wyvern
@quaint bramble Sorry for the ping but I guess you didn't noticed my answer Here https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/416576750991048705/649292012595707934
woeful mesa
@quaint bramble sorry for the late answer, it s in the FAQ
Thanks for posting it btw^^
kindred depot
ive noticed that in game theres only two options for the gender: "female" and "male". as a person who identifies as neither of them it kinda makes things lowkey uncomfortable for me and maybe others with the same issue. i apologise if this is not the correct channel for this!
normal wyvern
No, there is 3 genders. Non-defined, male and female
kindred depot
oh, then i might be blind then. thank you^^
modest pebble
Avoid report spam for Guardians
Every report attempt cost gold. If report is valid, gold returned back to player. If report invalid, gold is gone.
This will also make players use the report and carefully explained what the problem is about instead of 1-5 word sentences.
high fable
@modest pebble Uh, I'd prefer not to report rather than losing some gold -.-
opal rampart
So, if you have no gold, you cant report? Thats sad.
light edge
Hi guys.
When you enter a ranked lobby.
How about you start being a spectator and can choose to join the lobby?
So you dont have to play when there are 15 players already (and within those 15 player 4 player constantly gamethrow)
Ty it would be appreciated
mighty granite
@light edge Nice idea, how should it be like though? A button, or something?
tough lance
Same way as spec currently works will be fine, hit the eye and you are a player
but isn't there a limit to the number of spectators?
lament knoll
Heyya @modest pebble
Spam reports get punished already if they are done without any evidence...
I dont see why we should that option to be honest because many invalids report were not done just for fun but simply because people reported too early and you cannot take back reports, of course this could encourage them to wait till the end to report but false reports can actually be from use, as a player does usually need to stack up 12 reports to get reviewed but even if not all of them are valid you can get banned ^^
Also not everyone has constantly got gold... these would not be able to report and make the game a better space... that doesn't really sound fair to me...
I do get your good intention behind it but this suggestion is coming with more disadvantages than advantages imo...
Still your suggestion and worrying about the guardians load of work is appreciated
@tough lance not really a limit, atleast not something we specifically know of but that could get tested ^^
Tho i do remember having seen lobbies with 10-20 spectators at least
Heyaa @lethal cedar
Interesting idea
Tho how much should that discount be? Like 25% or something? Should probably not be thaaat much; so maybe rather something between 25-30%
And only on the biggest holidays? Could be a tad difficult to manage as many holidays are religious -> Christmas, Eastern
And many are country specific or on different days of the year -> Chinese New Year, Italian Christmas and so on
To not get people feel offended etc :/
lethal cedar
yea just a bit of discount probs? and if its too religious and yall dont want people to get offended, maybe in the start/middle/end of certain months? or maybe more general ones like end of year promotion? or 9.9 sale, 11.11 sale?
lament knoll
Yeah, that could work!
Alright i could not find this having been in #feedback-devs so i guess i'll give it to post to get it evaluated :3
Thanks for your Suggestion and have a nice day!
thick bolt
@drowsy yarrow great idea
plush mural
This season is my 4th season I am playing. I wonder if there will be finally changes in the League-roles? Its kinda boring to have the same strategy options for months now . What about refreshing and exciting new roles ?
I could even propose many new lobby options that I think are fair balancced and in favour of both teams.
light edge
@mighty granite like it is now. press the button to spectate/ join lobby.
hasty imp
How about achievements: for example kill 3 wws as beast hunter . You would earn coins, items or xp for completing them
vernal dune
Hey @hasty imp!
This type of acheivements was already suggested a lot, and some other kind of acheviements are already in game.
Thank you for the suggestion anyway! 
vernal dune
just remove the -1 @native epoch
native epoch
Ok ty
runic dragon
A second tab.
So you have a tab for the outfit you can buy. And next to it there should be a tab to show every clan quest skin
runic dragon
Since you need so long to scroll down in a private chat to get to the last message, make it possible to delete messages for yourself, so you can get easier to the last messages.
sacred sable
Suggestion:
Disable ability to join spectators in pre-game
Sorey, let me specify:
Players IN pre-game shouldn't be able to switch to spectate.
quaint bramble
@plush mural In that time, some of the new roles got added to random werewolf and rrv, which did change up the mechanics. I do agree the main setup could be changed up as well though, and i think adapting to new role lists should be a welcome challenge to the ranked community.
If you have some full role list ideas you can send them to me in dm's and i might discuss them with others or pass them on to the devs :)
@runic dragon A second tab where...? And which outfits would it show? Since you cant buy most outfits directly after all.
The game currently doesnt have a place to see all possible outfits ingame, and Im not sure if there should be one just for quests, what would be the point exactly?
plush mural
dm´s ?
quaint bramble
@runic dragon Orrrrr don't you think the friend chat should just automatically scroll to the newest messages? 👀 That's expected behaviour and a much more logical fix, and been suggested before ^^
@plush mural direct message/private message here on discord
runic dragon
Well, I suggested it some time before and other ppl suggested it also, but it doesn't seem to get involved into the app 😕 that's why I suggested this...
It's really annoying to scroll down 😅
quaint bramble
@sacred sable What part do you classify as pregame? The ingame lobby? the count down?
Is this a ranked suggestion or a general one?
What do you think of Setto's similar suggestion a little bit further up, wiould this be a good fix for the problem?
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/416576750991048705/649587834503823360
runic dragon
@quaint bramble
It should be against the top ( but i couldnt draw there. )
Its to see all the quests.
And and check with every skins you have
Dont mind my drawning skills lmao
quaint bramble
@pallid merlin For the president thing... I dont think this role should be forced upon people. If you want to change it like that, alright but then allow people to toggle it off from the 'random role' since adding 16 random roles is the easiest (and probably most fun) way to get a chaotic lobby started. But it;s completely ruined if a president appears ^^
pallid merlin
"How? For example make them off for the rest of the game without dying (they won't be considered towards the minimum vote required)"
There was already several suggestions about removing certain roles from "random" 
quaint bramble
@runic dragon Ah I thought there were 2 different suggestions in there; a clan skin tab and a new inventory tab for buying outfits. I want to add the clan skin list suggestion to feedback devs, but I think it makes more sense to place it somewhere within the clan settings
runic dragon
Yeah sure!
It just fun to see every questskin. (:
sacred sable
Doesn't exactlt hit what I'm looking for @quaint bramble
And by pre-game, I mean the lobby entirely before game starts, timer or no
Because someone could just time spectating just as last player joins when timer begins and knock out a spot (which is always villager role)
And yeah, people abusing spectate when timer starts is annoying af.
This is a suggestion for ALL lobbies, ranked or no.
Either take the suicide count, or play the game, don't abuse something in a way that it wasn't intended for.
quaint bramble
@sacred sable I think if you see someone do this on purpose multiple times, you can report them with a screenshot to Alison, since she is the most experienced with ranked play.
I can kinda understand limiting the spectator function in ranked as well though, but the way you propose mean you can basically never switch to spectator in a lobby? If you allow everyone to do it once when they enter, it would still get messy with the 15-16th player
And in sb the 16th role is always cupid, which is a little less harmful for the game balance imo
sacred sable
I haven't seen it in ranked but I'm including ranked just in case
And why shouldn't it be ANY game when one vote csn matter zzz
Then you got people that quit just after timer starts
normal wyvern
@quaint bramble You didn't saw my ping again :(
quaint bramble
I did and forgot for a bit cause I was busy irl just now, I am chcking it now..
normal wyvern
Okay, no problem and don't worry. Take your time then ❤️
quaint bramble
I think just writing it on the role description is more noticable, but I;ll write both as options in the feedback ^^
normal wyvern
Yea, thank you very much
fierce shale
Hi , yes, can the heart clan icon be fix so there isnt a chunk missing?
rigid bronze
What do you mean by a chunk missing ?
woeful mesa
No matter the role, it s always the same roles around. I find it sad because it takes out some the "random" part. I m not saying there should be a real order, but it should be good to show different roles, like as if we almost got them, but finally missed them.
lament knoll
for me it's always cupid and medium so i'm rather glad i "didnt get em"👀
Yeah i do agree with that, sure the wheel doesn't decide ur role but it could been designed so you atleast get the feeling it does👀
It just feels boring only seeing the same two roles surrounding the one i actually got, i do believe this has not been suggested before, personally, and even if, not recently. And i'll post it for you
Thanks for your Suggestion and have a nice day! 
❤
@woeful mesa
woeful mesa
surely not in the mode from where come the pics, quickgame haha
Thanks for posting it, have a nice day too^^
fierce brook
Whenever I try to adjust the minimum level, I can’t tell where it is at. I would like it if there was some way to see it while using the slider.
Device: iPhone 6s
rigid bronze
That looks more like a #bugs-readonly 👀 afaik I can see when it changes
fierce brook
I let go every time the number changes
potent gate
Hi
forest rover
I suggest to bring the old number of vote back.I prefer the older version 😕
runic dragon
@forest rover ehy there ,^^ you mean a slightly thinner caption?
forest rover
I mean,first pic is the old design.Second one is the one we have now.I really prefer the old one @runic dragon 👀
lament knoll
fun fact, i could not tell what was the new and what the old version oof fish memory
rigid bronze
What do you mean ?
forest rover
Imo the new one looks more difficult to see and it wasn’t necessary to change 👀
runic dragon
Yes same ahah ^^
So you prefer the thicker one?
Ok, I will add this and see what people think about it 😄
@forest rover
forest rover
Thx you @runic dragon
And yes I prefer the thicker one that’s what I mean 👀
I needed to check thicker meaning 😅
runic dragon
Make it possible for co leaders to step down. Rather than the clan leader having to do it
drowsy yarrow
there are people that have already 4000 points
its little unfair for the rest of us that had to wait 4 days
umbral moat
I dont like it if your sheriff , and you find someone as a suspect , that you can't vote them until u pressed "Do not show again"
vernal dune
Hey @runic dragon! I don't see why this wouldn't be a thing, so I'll add it to #feedback-devs. Thanks for the suggestion
@drowsy yarrow We don't know what the devs will do after fixing the ranked issue. We hope for patience on your end, currently we cannot do anything.
@umbral moat This is actually a known bug, and will be fixed soon! Sorry for the inconvenience
fierce shale
Forget it,I'm at work and unable to explain
runic dragon
I’m so happy that the new update allows iPhone 11 users to see the time and other features that were blocked by the front camera I really appreciate this feature
uncut tusk
Thanks for your feedback!! We're really happy to see you enjoy one of the newest features
sudden dock
Introducing an idea: selectable styles. Some outfits could be selectable colors, or have different features. Maybe even female and male items could be squished together to make whatever gender you have selected to show. How you would get to this screen would be by holding down on the perfered item.
runic dragon
When someone join into spectator mode when the countdown has started the countdown should stop
At the moment if someone join into Spectator the countdown doesn't stop and the game starts with less players
sudden dock
And first name change should be free🤩
I highly disagree with showing outfits in ranked. Belive it or not, outfits show skill. They show skill, play time length, and much more.
woeful mesa
Hi, could the game be released fully? Like it is still considered as in beta testing, but the game is pretty much finished, speaking about the whole, not about new roles and so on^^
I would love to leave a comment on google play, but since it s considered as beta testing, I can t leave neither read any comment, which I find sad...
quaint bramble
@sudden dock Recoularable items arent a thing yet because it's technically not possible on the game atm, they are all svg files and wold need to be manually recoulered completely etc... I dont know the exact details, but yeah this doesnt exist for a reason
ALso i have no clue what you meant with "female and male items could be squished together"
sudden dock
Like battle pass items
quaint bramble
hm, I prefer to have both visible in my inventory :/
sudden dock
True
quaint bramble
@sudden dock Hm I havent really tried tapping anything on hidden profiles recently so i didnt know it was still possible to view avatars in ranked. It's not really been complained about recently though, it doesnt seem in high demand amongst the bigger ranked players.
@woeful mesa Only the devs know when they will release the game in full version. We do still get non-role updates regularly that need testing such as the spectator feature. And we get plentyy of bugs still, so I personally understand its not really ready for that yet...
woeful mesa
Yeah I understand... but the no comments part is sad, and Idk how it could be resolved besides doing this...
iron girder
Can we add a report section for 'Teaming'. You know the teaming that happens outside etc. I just had a game where 1 and 16 cross team outside by posing each other roles. (Seer and med)
Seems hard to categorize
quaint bramble
Teaming falls under gamethrowing usually, since its 2 people on the same side you could also put it under'other' if you feel thats better
Teaming doesnt really seem accurate as a word for 2 villagers helping eachother either tbh
@woeful mesa As far as I know you should still be able to post reviews in the app store, i know there's a bunch of them, but it could indeed be that this playstore beta tester thing interferes with that.. I'll have a look
rain fiber
New ranked season is bugged
Ive been ww in 80% of my games
And i simply cannot advance in skill points
quaint bramble
That's bad luck then :/ I havent heard any complaints about this at all, nor have I noticed it myself
quaint bramble
if you'r in gold league now you should be able to climb up a little smoother right
rain fiber
Or witch kills jailer
runic dragon
When someone join into spectator mode when the countdown has started the countdown should stop
rain fiber
And they dont get banned
runic dragon
At the moment if someone join into Spectator the countdown doesn't stop and the game starts with less players
quaint bramble
and you can report them for gamethrowing
quaint bramble
if youre sure they are repeat offenders, try contacting a guardian in dms
rain fiber
Thats what happens when i dont get picked for guardian.i would ban all of them for weeks
So the players can play normally
Without anger
quaint bramble
@runic dragon Pretty sure this has been posted in fb devs before, and we also got a few related feedbacks here yesterday
runic dragon
I see ty
rain fiber
How can someone be ok with game throwers
quaint bramble
Well I am sorry youre running into so much gamethrowers right nowm but as a discord staff member I cnnot help you with that. Reporting ingame and encouraging others to do so as ell is the best way to go
rain fiber
And sleeping guardians
quaint bramble
and like i said, if it is really such a big problem, you can contact them directly
You probably know Alisonn is a ranked player too, i wanna bet she bans gamethrowers on sight :P
rain fiber
If i contact a guardian,i wont get reply for days
Same with wiki badge and instagram item
So theres no point
quaint bramble
Still more effetcive than complaining about it here since they are the people that can do something
rain fiber
I spent $200 on the game,and it just made me toxic
quaint bramble
Im not denyin we need more guardians, but its not so easily fixed
rain fiber
I wanna see this games rebirth
quaint bramble
@woeful mesa Im also part of that beta program thingy, and it shows me that i can write feedback to Phillip 👀 And you can also press to leave it, which probably allows you to use the normal review system.
drowsy yarrow
replace the rose bouquet from the quest with a loot box instead because rose bouquet not worth it as a quest reward
sudden dock
Berserk should replace junior not alpha.
and you should be able to replace your name once
zenith kayak
You should be allowed to unselect once you choose to spectate
runic dragon
@zenith kayak You can press any empty spot to leave Spectator mode
If it's that what you meant
hot stag
Maybe add aura-oriented talismans. What I mean by this is that for a good aura talisman, you have a better chance of getting a "good" role. same thing with unknown and bad. I want this cuz I like being a villager more so I'd rather stick with those roles :)
lunar salmon
@hot stag I kinda like that. And maybe they can be cheaper since it's not for a specific role. Like 10 coins instead of 25.
runic dragon
Could we make it so that it’s possible we can toggle the level range of the players we play with? Perhaps we could set it so that the max level is around 10 levels above your own (so if you’re level 30 and you want to play with the highest-leveled players that you can, you select level 0 (not required to be 0) - 40; you cannot do 0 - 50)
|0————|10————|20————|30————40|
(Unsure if this looks correct on mobile)
The minimum gap between the range that you select has to be at least between 10 levels (so if you are level 30 and you want to play with the highest-leveled group of players possible , you’d have to select level 30 - 40; you cannot do 40-40)
|0————10————|20————|30————40|
I’m so tired of being skin focused every day, I’m always checked, killed or asked for a role during first day/night. I love ranked because I meet a lot of players that share the same experience, but because a new season has started, I’m stuck with the lower level players.
I know a lot of the players that skin focus are in the lower-level range, and I’m seriously tired of it. I just want to play in peace and find a way to combat skin focus
I don’t really know how to handle this for those that are level 200+ though, so maybe this should be thought through more
lapis drum
Has anyone already suggested spectator chat be separate from game chat? It’s extremely distracting and easy to abuse.
sacred sable
You mean dead chat?
Cuz spectators can only be seen by dead, and spectators don't have #s so you can tell who actually playing
Alsp, suggestion:
Update role descriptions to say "they/them" in place of "him/he"
Cuz gender equality
lament knoll
Heyaa @hot stag and @lunar salmon
Aura oriented Talisman -> nice idea and i am pretty sure it has already been suggested before, but i could not find it in #feedback-devs hmm...
I guess i'll give it a post, i'll merge your two suggestions to one as they serve the same purpose ^^
Thanks for your suggestions and have a nice day!
hot stag
Ah ok. Tysm!
lunar salmon
Thank you min! You're the best!
lapis drum
@sacred sable Yea from dead chat I meant
lament knoll
Heyaa @sudden dock
Berserk should replace junior hm... personally, i think a game with a junior and berserk is more efficent because alpha is a pretty weak werewolf, ability-wise, as his only a ability is having two votes and depending on the player that can be a huge disadvantage👀
But ig why not, i could put it up for evaluation in #feedback-devs
About the you should be able to replace your name once, what exactly do you mean? Could you specify that? :3
Heyy @drowsy yarrow yea i guess i get that... i mean in times of the rose wheel some ppl might be lucky to get some roses but lootboxes are indeed a bit more worth it
I'll give it a post so it can get evaluated, thanks for your feedback!
lapis drum
But they still spam chat and make it hard to focus
lament knoll
Heyyy @lapis drum
Yes i agree, they can also try to confuse the medium with fake info in order to help their friend etc, i dont really see the use of being able to chat with all dead players when being spectator, sure it's fun but that way you could still chat but spectators only
I guess i'll give it a post ^^
People have already been complaining about spectators confusing etc but i dont think it has been suggested before this way!
Thanks alot for your suggestion, it's highly appreciated, have a nice day! :3
lapis drum
Awesome. Thanks @lament knoll 😊
lament knoll
Heyy @sacred sable
Yes -> changing pronouns to gender neutral ones was already suggested and i am pretty sure one of the devs already said that thed were onto it but until today i've seen no signs of that so i guess i'll give it a repost
Just as a gentle reminder ^^
This would also make gender neutral people feel more comfortable, i personally avoid using gender specific pronouns while talking anyways but having it in the desc as well seems like an easy but convenient change
Thanks for your feedback, it's appreciated, have a nice day! ❣
sudden dock
So in the new update it now costs 100 gold to change your name. You should have 1 free name change
sacred sable
Tfw I keep being called he in game when avatar clearly looks female-
modest pebble
Red Lady was dead on that day but managed to slip in and took advantage of the delayed killed & revived players. It’s like a 1-2 seconds window
lament knoll
Heyyy @runic dragon
That's a nice suggestion i guess :p
I personally do not play ranked so i cannot totally relate but we get suggested setting level limits quite frequently and your suggestion seems like a nice simple one ^^
I do not think it has been suggested that way before so i'll give it a post
looks correct on mobile btw, atleast imo :p
Thanks for your concerns and your suggestion, it's appreciated! Have a nice day!
Heeeya @modest pebble
This is a known bug, and not really something feedback-ish, if people are abusing that bug you can report them for bug abusing in game, after maybe telling them that you should not use a bug for your own advantage...
If you ask me that person did know that there is a possibility that they'll be able to use the delay to their advantage or otherwise they would've not given their info that quickly...
Thanks for your concerns tho, the devs are aware of this delay which gives this sort of advantage and it's the same for seer as well...
Tho if you wanna form it into a feedback how about "to avoid people taking advantage of this 1-2 seconds window between being killed and being revived window, people which just died should have a 10 seconds chat block until they can chat in the dead chat" ?
cedar hinge
President, while being a custom game character, is downright trash. It hurts the village by wasting protection, but he doesn't have any abilities! Not even extra voting power. President doesn't even help the village one bit. Also Jr WW and WW BS destroy President. It's really unplayable.
modest pebble
@lament knoll thats a long essay but ty for ✍🏻 to explain. However I believe bugs or feedback is okay. When I got to bugs they say its on feedback and when im at feedback... yeap
light edge
@mighty granite so yaay or nay to my idea?
lament knoll
Odd @sudden dock i remembered that has been suggested before but couldn't find it, hmm i'll give it a post then
Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day!
cedar hinge
@lament knoll Hello...?
normal wyvern
Sometimes you don't really know which item goes to which category. Specially special offers have mostly this problem. I'd suggest when you open a lootbox with items, you'll see on each item a circle in which category this item depends. This is a small grey circle with the icon of this category, e.g. eyes or mouth category. If you don't want to see this, you can turn it off in the settings.
lament knoll
Heyyy yes @cedar hinge sorry i was busy posting the suggestions... ^^'
That's why president is only available in custom, it is a broke which most likely wont ever be available in any other gamemode, there have been several fixes already been suggested now it's up to the devs whether to fix it or not..
Thanks for your concerns tho and have a nice day
cedar hinge
Ok, so it was just another requested President delete/fix. 😅
glacial warren
How would you fix the president? Roles won't be removed 🤔
normal wyvern
(Feedback above from me. Thanks, just scared of if it's get flooded)
runic dragon
This is awful -,- im tired!
I always get checked by seer first, i always get killed first and i always get shooted first cuz of my outfits. The people who doesn't have outfits tend to get people with cool outfits first. I suggest adding a new mode like sandbox that only players with 30-50 loyalty tokens can get into.
cedar hinge
Roles won't be removed?
Oh sorry
How to fix: President has 2 lives and has 3x voting power.
runic dragon
@cedar hinge thats just o.p and it will make president broken
cedar hinge
But it gives the village a disadvantage
Another suggestion: 3x voting power, that's it.
And the current "he gets killed-village loses" thing.
normal wyvern
But the role is only in custom games and just for fun there...
cedar hinge
I know...
I just think it has a negative impact on their side, which no role should have
cedar hinge
I mean, it's feedback on the role.
#role-ideas-readonly is not for role fixes but new role ideas???
normal wyvern
@runic dragon to buff/nerf roles -> #feedback-readonly
rain fiber
When u get banner,you should recieve a screenshot of the game for which u were banned
normal wyvern
@runic dragon He is only available in custom games
cedar hinge
Yes
rain fiber
Banned*
runic dragon
scroll up
normal wyvern
Only a mini mod is online. Just be patient until one is here ^^
woeful mesa
@quaint bramble sorry for the late answer, but well only the dev can see the feedback, not the people who discover the app and want to see what people think about it sadly
opaque pollen
Everyone can see reviews though
normal wyvern
@opaque pollen Can you check the feedbacks above?
opaque pollen
Which one? :Love:
normal wyvern
opaque pollen
Ahh. Or like in Love Nikki that has a new dot by a category to show you received a new item in that section. Like a new hair, new shirt, etc. indication
I thibk someone with more experience with President and such retired roles should chip in about the President one
Suggestions for other modes like level restrictions have already been suggested many times in the past 👍
normal wyvern
Yea this would also fit with a dot. Maybe a green dot then? To not confuse ppl with the blue dots
opaque pollen
Yeah just something that indicates something is new/never worn
normal wyvern
Yep!
woeful mesa
Hi, can the equipped talismans be put at the top of the list? It would make it easier to see what we re using and if we want to unequip one^^
normal wyvern
So is it possible to post it in #feedback-devs. I'm not sure if it's suggested before ❤️ @opaque pollen
opaque pollen
Yeah, I'll post it! Sorry was getting ready for bed
normal wyvern
Don't worry and take your time <3
opaque pollen
Maybe like?
normal wyvern
Yep!
floral heath
Suggestion: Left and Right front items
Some forms of these already exist but for items that are made of 2 items (I.e. A sword and Shield), it should be possible to classify them as their own type known as dual items where the items are made with both a left side and a right side. It should be possible to equip only the left or the right side (I.e. Only the Shield equipped on the left or only the Sword on the right). They can still be equipped together but the front items should have 2 categories, left front item and right front item.
runic dragon
STOP THIS! 3 ACCOUNTS IN ONE GAME!!! ITS DEFINITELY CREATING!
rigid bronze
What do you suggest to counter that
runic dragon
ITS UNFAIR! I SUGGEST BANNING THEM IMMEDIATELY FOR WEEKS SO THEY WOULD LEARN NOT TO CHEAT
3 days is too easy
giving them penalty so they would learn big time will leason learn them
rigid bronze
@floral heath To be honest I don't really like this idea because it would prevent some very cool front items that would be all avatar long 👀
@runic dragon Also you can try directly DMing a Guardian with this case
BoyHanQuoc#6473 is online
And please don't caps lock 👀
floral heath
@rigid bronze it doesn’t prevent that. You can still equip left and front items together (which are just the existing item) but there is the ADDED choice to only equip 1 side of it (if you want to use another part for the other side for example)
floral heath
For example you have 2 sword and shield items. If they come together it’s still possible to wear them both at the same time. But it can also be possible to wear the left side of one of the parts and the right side of another
If u get what I mean
rigid bronze
Yea I totally understand dw
@floral heath Okay, it will be voted in the designers channel to see if they would like doing it
runic dragon
Likely been suggested many times before but i'm really all for adding new leagues, whenever ranked resets i lose my interest for the game, silver is full of people who barley know how to play the game or gamethrow and everyone is pretty much instantly put there, which also makes it easy to get to gold, I was going to aim for top 100 this season but it's hard to do that when there isn't established leagues for serious players, just wanted to share my own opinion on the matter.
Thanks for the link setto, hard to keep track of all the suggestions lmao
it’s oki lol
i’m bored
ornate sun
not sure if this has been suggested, can we lower the gold cost to change username? like it's not really fair to pay 100 gold to avoid getting killed day 1
like 10 gold is reasonable
floral heath
Well actually it’s about 100 gold to avoid being targeted and another 100 gold to change back 😂
cedar hinge
@runic dragon If they can get 3 accounts, banning them has no use. They can just make another
serene lotus
The ability to switch into spectator mode during the automatic starting countdown needs to be changed. You should either take it away completely so that it is impossible to switch once the countdown started/once the lobby is full or you should resign the starting countdown in a way that it stops (and starts once full) again as soon as somebody switches during the last seconds.
At the moment, many people in ranked (and maybe in other game modes too ...?) use it to „escape“ the game in the very last second, e.g. if they don‘t recognize enough good players in that lobby. The problem is that the game then always starts with 15 or even 14 people.
mighty granite
@light edge Ah, very sorry, I forgot about about that, well I think this is also a good idea still, and afaik it isn't suggested yet, so I'll put it into #feedback-devs and sorry for inconvenience.
mighty granite
@ornate sun Not sure it's good, but I'll post it in #feedback-devs so devs can see it. Thanks for suggesting. 🤔
light edge
@mighty granite People are waiting for new leagues. like really they are begging for it. Any chance the devs will hear the rank regulars?
mighty granite
@light edge You mean the stuck at season 14 bug?
light edge
I mean the Seer hell Det game leagues
High ranked players should be automatically promoted to det games. Some are stuck because if throwers and doesnt matter their skill they cant escape.
mighty granite
Oh, devs should see everything in #feedback-devs, if they see it and it's needed, mostly, they will adjust something, so maybe the're doing something now. 🤔
vale gyro
Suggestion for the server here: Remove discord links from the untrustworthy link list in your bot so you can post reference links to a posted picture instead of needing to download and upload it again.
mighty granite
@serene lotus The countdown should stop when the room isn't full, but when there are 16 people and someone join spectator, the countdown doesn't stop, that's a #bugs-readonly, and it's known. Sorry for inconvenience.
@vale gyro You mean copying a picture link from discord and post the link somewhere else?
vale gyro
Yes, you know these discordapp links of pics right?
mighty granite
I thought it's approved according to approved links in #bot-commands?
vale gyro
Imo doesn't make much sense to restrict those because in the end the result is the same whether i link it or upload the picture. But on data constantly needing to upload something can get a bit annoying, y'know?