Maybe so priest can't water a person that the mm tried to shoot?
#feedback-readonly
flint charm
unkempt junco
So that I said a noti only
serene lotus
tbh if a priest is dumb enough to water sb who has already been watered....then let him
unkempt junco
noti too maybe
woeful mesa
Idk if I should post this in feedback or bugs, but if we get killed as mm, the target is still here while I m pretty sure if we get revive it won t be there anymore. So it shouldn t appear
Maybe it happens with bh trap too not sure
unkempt junco
Or just leave a watermark if that player is watered lol
lament knoll
@unkempt junco okay so simply adding notifs like "that player has been watered before, are you sure you want to water him" or "this player is already revealed/you a already checked that player are you sure you wanna check again" right?
unkempt junco
yes
lament knoll
Alright, i'll post it and add that its a suggestion connected to carmi's 
serene lotus
I have another suggestion for that: Stop cutting off the chat history instead, so people can check themselves. If the game gives āadviceā/reminders for every simple action, where does the concept of strategy go?
flint charm
Can I just say that Carmi sounds adorible as heck
lament knoll
@serene lotus i think the chat history is getting resetted because of data storage issues
All the data can't be stored so the game chats get deleted
serene lotus
Is there a possibility to stop this? I think itās quiet annoying because information gets lost, or sometimes people claim roles from early on and say stuff like āI already claimed cupid day 1ā but youāre not even able to check it
lament knoll
Well that's also a great opportunity for werewolves in a 2 vs 1 matchš
They can claim that same role and then its a 50/50 if they win or not
If you could just easily scroll up there would be less claiming space and also less place for strategy 
serene lotus
I get your point š§ yah
uncut tusk
@unkempt junco Welp sorry I've been busy for some time.
So, uhm, I think the easiest thing to do is rather searching and filtering clans based on criteria.
Currently, you can for example filter clans based on the minimum level required.
Based on your suggestion... Hmm, you would add criteria like "minimum number of hours spent on the game", or xp, right? It kinda duplicates with the level criterion...
As for the idea about "all xp ever donated", as I said, it wouldn't be representative of how much xp that person give to the clan :/ I gave you 2 examples about it.
woeful mesa
that's true that saying check, I said it day 1 can help you if the people are lazy or don't find the info ut have still doubts if it was done or not
flint charm
I kind of understand and it seems like a good idea
But I can't decide anything āļø
woeful mesa
I think the chat in game should be stopped exactly where it shows.
the character's limit isn't the same when we type and when we send the message
Because actually it does:
original message: blablablablablabla I love the game
What is shown: blablablablablabla I lo...
warm swan
When someone wants to give an amount of roses, instead of giving 1 rose, then another one and the same over and over, add an option to "give a certain amount of roses" so it's easier to give roses and it's not a bit annoying to see roses flying to people around the game
uncut tusk
@woeful mesa Hello there, thanks for the idea! A similar one was already suggested though, here it is: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/629761874392514580 if you want to upvote it, feel free to :D
@warm swan Heya, it has been suggested quite recently in fact š Thanks for your idea though!
Here it is: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/624338804051804180
@runic dragon Heya! I believe it was suggested before, but I think it's a game of memory š¤ And adding a role you guess for each of the players is a bit tedious, imho š¤ What do you think?
woeful mesa
it's similar but my feedback is about the fact that we can still type even if the limit is reached, meaning the end of the message won't be seen @quaint bramble š
oops wrong ping @uncut tusk sorry Majestical
such a serious player, I wouldn't like being in the opposite team haha
ranked is for you xd
uncut tusk
@woeful mesa In the message I linked: "if you type too much its cut off" ;)
@runic dragon Hmmm... Thanks for the idea and the screenshots. I would even add some sort of text or icon next to each player you have a Note on, so that you don't need to check the Notes everytimes, to be quicker. What do you think? š
It has been suggested twice before but I'd give it a repost š
woeful mesa
oh yeah, I was focused on the 2nd part of the report thanks^^
serene lotus
hi i donāt wanna annoy yall but i gave a feedback earlier and would be very happy about a ~feedback for my feedback~
uncut tusk
@serene lotus Heya, I'm sorry but I haven't seen a message of yours that didn't get an answer already š Could you please tell me where it is located?
uncut tusk
Hmmm... I would rather say that the vast majority of RRV aren't provable right away š¤ I only see Mayor, Priest (if he wanna try his luck) and Pacifist...
serene lotus
In ranked, people usually claim rrv as soon day 1 starts. In this example, 1 13 14 (all the real rrvs) claimed rrv and also the arso and one of the wolves. Both mayors revealed themselves, and 14 can easily prove his role by saying āIām paci i will reveal player xā
So what else can the wolves claim besides doctor? Nothing
Any role that can somehow be proven is a negative thing for the wolves/solo roles. You usually get a healthy mix of rrvs in games, e.g. provable grumpy granny, and not provable bh or pitchfork man. So the detective/aura has to check and to confirm these people first
But when every role is provable, people can easily find out who is who - there is no need to check anyone if everybody is able to prove their own role to the village (besides doc)
craggy dagger
rv GG, players can usually tell whether an aura is fake or not depending on who they check first night
For instance, if an aura calls X evil and X is ww beserk, safe to say the aura is real no matter how many auras in game
serene lotus
yeah and you canāt even claim >false< aura rrv when you have 3 provable rrvs in a game. everyone will know that youāre a wolf.
craggy dagger
I canāt quite remember how many rv combos are instantly provable to village
Marksman Iād argue is provable over several days
After a long time playing, I have to say that the game is definitely village sided, but not as village sided as it feels
serene lotus
There is no such a thing. There are literally games where you can have 3 rrvs who cannot prove themselves (eg three pitchfork man - isnt very likely, but possible). But you can also have games with 3 mayors in it (not likely, but possible).
And in my opinion, having 3 provable rrv roles in one game isnāt fair for solo roles/wolves.
craggy dagger
To use an anecdote, there were 4 rv claims first day and 2 were provable, I was ww and claimed rv GG and the third rv(marksman) got shot
What monaps is saying here, is some games village has an inherent advantage for no reason besides RNG
serene lotus
yea exactly
Especially in hh games, where hh often even reveals their target - there is absolutely no way to win as ww/solo killer against such an op village
quaint bramble
But when you have random berserker wolf or shaman wolf, you got a stronger wolf team than usual, it works both ways
craggy dagger
Witch, GG, Mayor, Pacifist and Priest are all provable rv, and Iād add Marksman to the list too
quaint bramble
And I do understand your feedback about rrv here, but what is your concrete suggestion to change it?
We do already have a few solid ideas, posted to #feedback-devs a while back
serene lotus
But people literally do role call in ranked. If you refuse to claim a role after day 2, you usually get shot/lynched. you cannot say āoh iām rrv bhā when you have three other provable rrvs ig.
craggy dagger
If thereās only 1 det and 1 aura and theyāre both dead, ww shamans are functionally normal wws
My suggestion is make mayor/pacifist/witch/gg unique roles
So only one mayor etc can spawn in game
serene lotus
My feedback is: Leave at least one rrv role, that isnāt able to prove that they are rrv.
quaint bramble
role calls can probbalt be reported in ranked, if its before day 3 and seer/det still alive, but dont trust me 100% on that
craggy dagger
Iāve also suggested swap out an rv for a regular villager @serene lotus what do you think of this suggestion
No they canāt
Role calling is 100% correct play for village usually
serene lotus
Means: Make one of the rrvs bh, pitchfork man, doctor, aura, avenger, maybe even bg or red lady
floral heath
Swapping out an rv reduces the number of rvs in game, the wolves and killers benefit from more rvs in game
serene lotus
But ranked is all about rolecall and battling about who can fake/lie the best
I donāt mean to swap out one of the rrvs
craggy dagger
@floral heath I meant swap out an rv for a regular forkman, so village number doesnāt change
floral heath
Ranked is never about faking a lying, itās about confirming spots and eliminating everyone who doesnāt fit in
It is the main flaw of fixed rolelists
serene lotus
I mean: Make ONE (out of the three) RRVs in ranked games >not< provable
craggy dagger
Indeed
median elbow
+1 corruptor and cupid in ranked
craggy dagger
Corruptor yes, Cupid no
serene lotus
Ranked is indeed about somehow faking/lying. If you donāt bring any effort to fake a role as ww/solo role, you get killed. Unclaimed roles get killed first.
But you arent able to claim a wrong role if rrvs are all mayors and stuff like that
craggy dagger
Agreed, there is a meta in arsonist games that doctor will claim first day. It isnāt popular but it happens somewhere between 20-40% of arso games
floral heath
Well if all the rvs end up being mayors and Pacis then you just got unlucky claiming rv.
serene lotus
okay but even if you donāt claim rrv: what else can you do? Claim doc?
craggy dagger
Okay, I guess I should stick to claiming doctor when the real doctor dies š¤·
floral heath
Sometimes you donāt have to claim anything
quaint bramble
I think there is technically no way to add a 2nd rrv slot with a seperate set of roles, and i also dont think this will really make things easier
serene lotus
If all solo roles/wolves claim doc + the real doc does too, they will just keep on killing 5 fakers + the real one until everyone is dead
quaint bramble
and rolecalling should really not be a valid tactic so early on in the game
floral heath
Letās be honest tho.. how many games has that happened
craggy dagger
āWell if all the rvs end up being mayors and Pacis then you just got unlucky claiming rv.ā
serene lotus
If you donāt claim a role until day 3 or 4, you get killed. Idk where yall play but this is the way people usually play in ranked
craggy dagger
Unlucky is the exact word you use to describe this situation
floral heath
You got unlucky that 3 mayors even spawned in the first place
craggy dagger
Yes
serene lotus
Yes ofc itās unlucky
craggy dagger
Letās prevent the game from being an auto win for village!
serene lotus
- it isnāt fair
floral heath
Well it doesnāt happen every game
craggy dagger
It can happen and it does happen
If village can win for no other reason then certain roles being in game
And you as a developer can prevent this from happening
Why wouldnāt you?
serene lotus
You can scroll up to the screenshot I sent. We had two mayors and one paci as rrv. The game ended on day 3 with just 4 villagers being killed
Itās unlucky, yes. But it is also unbalanced.
craggy dagger
Why would you not take steps to ensure each game can have a consistent winrate for wolves/village/solos?
floral heath
Ideally, 3 mayors means an auto win for village but in practical that doesnāt always happen. Possibly medium died first and junior can claim anywhere from detective to jailor and other wolf can claim aura and leave the doc claim to the rest as there isnāt much more they can claim. There is also a possibility that the villagers are idiots and they go out of control thinking theyāve already won when in fact thereās a fool and sk in game who can still butcher them.
I canāt explain myself properly but itās not always the same in practical than it is in theory
craggy dagger
Wolves rarely have a wolf fake det and a wolf fake aura
floral heath
Hell we even have pacifists revealing each other š
craggy dagger
Granted, wolves usually have 1 person fake aura or det
So for compromise letās say wolves always have an aura fake OR a det fake but never both
serene lotus
But where is the point in claiming jailer? You will get killed by the real jailer instantly š
floral heath
Junior ww will do that obviously to get rid of bullets
craggy dagger
And letās say, for arguments sake, this ww is persuasive and ALWAYS gets the real aura/det shot
Jww wonāt always tag bullets.
serene lotus
Itās different in fool games, yuppp. But not in hh games because most of the time, hh always secretly plays for the village as well
floral heath
Yes, and so petition for Ranked Det games to only spawn fools and no hhs
runic dragon
#feedback-readonly there should be a seer chat at night where the seer cannot talk, but whenever the seer checks someone the chat says āānumberā is ātheir roleā so ppl donāt accidentally check the same person again
craggy dagger
And letās say for arguments sake that medium always dies first night
Our assumptions so far:
3 mayors in game
Med dies first night
One aura/det fake from wws
The real aura/det dies first
serene lotus
i think this ~no more hh games in ranked~ thingy has already been suggested before
floral heath
Hh is damaging against the other evil players because most reveal their target the first day anyway and even if they give fake target the village will let them live. And then when the wolf makes a brilliant play and gets a mislynch then the hh wins š
craggy dagger
Exactly!
HH games are BETTER for village than fool games
HH games = higher village winrate
serene lotus
yes, hh games are more easier. And to be honest, I also search for hh games when iāve been ww 3 times in a row because iām sure that iāll finally be villager again and because i want to win
but there are still hh games that can be won for ww/sk/arso
But definitely NOT if you have three provable rrvs
craggy dagger
HH can be an extra vote for village, however fool majority of the time votes with wws in endgames
floral heath
Fool is strictly Solo, Hh is Village/Solo. Hh has an ability that helps him AND the Village win AND the Werewolf lose if they mislynch his target.
serene lotus
Yeah so I guess you heard my/our arguments for why such a thing as āMake at least one out of three rrvs in ranked none-provableā is needed/useful 
craggy dagger
How often do you think Med/jailer get mislynched?
floral heath
Hh only worked in previous seasons because the village would auto kill hh if he was ever revealed.
serene lotus
Med only gets mislynched if the revived player did not confirm the real medium and he dies again. But that also barely happens.
craggy dagger
Basically, I think the hh role needs a rework so he can side wws if his target dies
Med sometimes gets mislynched in nightmare ww is in game or when yours truly is wolf š
floral heath
I like the hh/survivor rework. So when his target dies, he wins as long as he survives until the end
serene lotus
And jailer almost never gets mislychned because thereās usually always gunner/or another villager who can confirm them
craggy dagger
Iāve also mislynched jailer before, but jailer very rarely is mislynched
I faked med and asked for jail when there wasnāt a good rev, he outed to me and got checked # and I said he wasnāt the real jailer
floral heath
Heās on the Werewolvesās to kill list, not the to lynch list š
craggy dagger
Letās just say the wolves thought I was a genius afterwards š
That sort of play from wws is really outlier
Population doesnāt play wolf like that ever
Back to the discussion, I think someway to prevent multiple insta-provable rvs from spawning is good for the game
floral heath
But the village would have asked you why you wanted jail in the first place if you were not med or gunner? Again the Jailor still has the bullet so the Jailor can execute either one
If you are Junior itās still a viable strategy
craggy dagger
I was ww shaman
Pretty sure it was a doctor only death first night
So I claimed medium in jail
And I look like a medium to village
floral heath
I assume it was hh game as the med wouldnāt revive doc in Fool game
craggy dagger
med doesnāt revive doc most games anyway
floral heath
I would on the 2nd night if it would mean we could confirm faster and have guaranteed an extra person
craggy dagger
80% of the time thereās only doc dead first night is a no rev
I asked for jail first night and I think it was explicit that I wasnāt gunner
serene lotus
but killing doc in the first night isnāt the best strategy anyway
forest rover
Normally doc isnāt killed in the first night @craggy dagger š
serene lotus
just generally saying, sometimes it happens ofc (especially in sk games)
craggy dagger
Normally jailer doesnāt get mislynched š
floral heath
And it would be explicit that you werenāt med either if you were jailed and med revived
craggy dagger
Med didnāt revive
floral heath
I thought u said they did xd
floral heath
Well only doc was dead so med could just bring back the jailer in exchange for your life but you are just wolf shaman..
serene lotus
this convo escalated quickly š„“
floral heath
You could try if you were junior tho lol
Lots of impossible strategies are possible with Junior
forest rover
Anyway intelligent players wonāt lynch someone that claims 
floral heath
Jailer can be mislynched if he hasnāt been confirmed after killing a player in jail.
craggy dagger
And I said that the jailer was fake
Jailer can still be mislynched if heās just done that Sir Felneus
serene lotus
and if two people claim jailer, village just letās them kill each other to prove their role
craggy dagger
He needs to jail a villager and say his number to be confirmed
forest rover
If he claims jailer then village should let him to jail a confirmed villager to prove himself,something that werewolves just cannot do it @floral heath
floral heath
But what if it was endgame?
craggy dagger
Jailer is generally proven by endgame
serene lotus
jailer usually gets confirmed by gunner/priest before it even comes that far
floral heath
We are only assuming we are in Ranked Det for now.. we are all pros here š
In any other modes the chance that the Jailor is mislynched is higher
serene lotus
Yes true
craggy dagger
I mean it was assumed we were talking about ranked
forest rover
But weāre talking about ranked right?š
serene lotus
yes we are
craggy dagger
What happens in other mode has no bearing to this discussion
serene lotus
no other game has 3 differents rrvs as far as i know š
craggy dagger
Seer hell does
quaint bramble
Heya I can see this is a very useful and necessary discussion, but could you please move it to #wov-chat or dm's, and come back here once you agreed on some concrete suggestions?
It's becoming a little floody for other feedbacks here...
floral heath
In every other mafia game Iāve seen a ranked game in they call it ELO hell š
serene lotus
I think we agreed
floral heath
Aight imma go, my Brain hurts
quaint bramble
well, post me a summary please ^^
serene lotus
@craggy dagger said āBack to the discussion, I think someway to prevent multiple insta-provable rvs from spawning is good for the gameā
craggy dagger
How long has it been since I sent my suggestions to majestic?
serene lotus
And what i said: Yeah so I guess you heard my/our arguments for why such a thing as āMake at least one out of three rrvs in ranked none-provableā is needed/useful
craggy dagger
If itās been 3 months then Ima request they get bumped
And I will continue to ask for these changes to have some recognition until ranked changes
serene lotus
And here is the ~case~ I was referring to. My argument is that ww/solo roles have no chance to win with three provable rrvs in one game as it is shown here - especially not with hh, since they mostly side with the village.
quaint bramble
Making 2 different rrv pools, sounds technically complicated to me.
I much prefer to address the problem in other ways, such as the previous results of making paci rsv for example
craggy dagger
One of the most infamous players in ranked, Sect agrees with the premise that making a confirmed forkman slot in ranked will actually improve village play
serene lotus
But whatās the point of that if you can still have three mayors (extreme example) in one game? 2 mayors in one game is quiet common tbh, and sometimes the third rrv is a provable role like mm, witch, granny as well
quaint bramble
And if you remove the provable rrvs from one pool, it is gonna inevitably increase the chance of protectors/aura/seer app in game which leads to whole new set of problems.
craggy dagger
Ranked det games
serene lotus
Ranked doesnt have seers anyway, at least not gold league
One of the most common strategies is to fake aura seer tho, so I wouldnt call that a problem
craggy dagger
Also shamaning auras when thereās multiple auras ig is good ww shaman play. So Iād say that multiple auras isnāt always a good thing
serene lotus
i agree
craggy dagger
Thats why replacing a random villager with a regular villager avoids all these problems you mention @quaint bramble
serene lotus
people are suspicious towards aura seers and claimed protectors anyway
but donāt get me wrong, i completely agree on the idea that paci should become rsv. i just donāt think that it solves the problem i was referring to
quaint bramble
@craggy dagger I agree, but you two clearly do not... why i suggested moving it out of this place and find something you agree on first š¤
craggy dagger
Monaps has never disagreed with my suggestion š¤
median elbow
Reposting +1 to corruptor and cupid coming to ranked
I want cupid more than corruptor
quaint bramble
Cupid is not a suitable role for ranked imo
median elbow
Why
craggy dagger
Because it changes win conditions
median elbow
Yeah I know
serene lotus
Okay so we have two suggestions that refer to the same problem:
- Removing one of the random regular villagers from ranked and replacing it with a pitchfork dude
- Making at least one of the three rrvs a role that is not able to prove themselves
forest rover
Same goes with head hunter 
š
quaint bramble
it requires being yet another team, and its actions border on teaming, which is very frusrating, for a competitive game mode.
serene lotus
Up to u what u make out of the suggestions tho
median elbow
Cupid would make rankedire interesting
runic dragon
I still insist in replace a RV with cursed
quaint bramble
Many top ranked players would take the easy way out and just reveal their ww couple eetc, just like what happens with hh
median elbow
I really want to see cupid more often no joke
forest rover
@serene lotus solution 1 wouldnāt be good because if I were forkman I will just claim that Iām forkman in day 1...
median elbow
@quaint bramble that's game throwing. Period.
craggy dagger
@forest rover so will wolves and there will be fighting over the claimspace
quaint bramble
and cupid should first be re-introduced in quickgame perhaps, so new ranekd players would be familiar with the role and its rules first as well
craggy dagger
Thatās not a fault of the suggestion, thatās a fault of the fixed rolelist
median elbow
What if cursed was added to rrv
forest rover
@craggy dagger wolves that will be proved that lies as they do normally with doc.
I also claim doc first day.
quaint bramble
Cursed as rrv has ben suggested before, so was making one rrv a forkman, both posted in feedback-devs
runic dragon
What if there was a shaman so ww could be seen as "good"
serene lotus
@forest rover i agree to that in some way, it was @craggy dagger idea.
Iām still sticking to my idea: Making at least one of the three rrvs a role that is not able to prove themselves
craggy dagger
Many players do not claim doc first day. I do think most forkman will claim forkman first day
median elbow
Rrv should NOT be changed just add cursed to rrv
craggy dagger
@median elbow thoughts on 3 mayor games
serene lotus
stop the disrespectful words towards pitchfork dudes tho š©
craggy dagger
@median elbow are 3 mayor games better for village then 3 forkman games?
median elbow
@forest rover that's okay. It really is. Ww team is underpowered. Village is overpowered
serene lotus
3 mayor games are easier for village than 3 pitchfork men ofc
forest rover
Lol but werewolves need to be underpowered @median elbow
median elbow
It's just become a debate at this point let's move
craggy dagger
Why move? Weāre discussing why ranked needs to change
quaint bramble
I could repost a link to older feedback-devs about this topic, if all you gonna do is suggest the same thing, or someting that is impossible (talking about the seperate rrv pool @serene lotus)
craggy dagger
And from that common ground, we can make ideas and have discourse on those ideas
serene lotus
@quaint bramble idk what you expect us to say/agree on tbh. We can take the discussion else where ofc, but i think that this āthree provable rrvsā is a thing we all agree about tbh
why is a separate rrv pool impossible tho?
quaint bramble
And i have repeated about 5 times, that it seems technically impossible, and results in side-effects too
median elbow
@craggy dagger I think I'd stop playing ranked if rrv was removed
craggy dagger
Are we supposed to talk about potential suggestions here or in general?
serene lotus
@median elbow that was never the plan lol
quaint bramble
since theyre currently only potential suggestions, i prefer if you discuss it somewhere else, and then solidify them into suggestions here.
craggy dagger
I donāt want all rv deleted, I want games which are definitively better for village, such as 3 mayor games, to be non existent
median elbow
@quaint bramble can cupid and corrupted be posted In #feedback-devs
craggy dagger
Will you add them to devs if we solidify them @quaint bramble ?
quaint bramble
You were there when people suggested to make it so, 3 of the same rrv should not be possible anymore. That is one i could repost again..
craggy dagger
Or at least think about it
median elbow
Cupid needs to be a thing. If pro players say there coupled with a ww it's a simple game throw report
Like an actual game throw report
quaint bramble
I recommend you to dig up some older #feedback-devs suggestions about rrv, and pick some to repost, besides your own new suggestions
@median elbow I am sorry but cupid to ranked is really not going to do well.
And Corruptor could eventually be there, but that is not needed to be a feedback, it is needed to finish its sandbox phase first
analog yacht
i found like a glitch that if i spin the wheel i do not get the money prize, this happened 2 times in a row now, even when i refresh the app the money isnt there. i'm on an android if that information is usefull. hope this goes away. its now honestly a waste of time watching ads
serene lotus
The 3 mayors thing is just an example.
2 mayors and 1 paci (as the game I got into) is just as awful as 3 mayors. Idc about >what< exact roles they are, but I still think that three provable rrv roles are not fair.
I know that you mentioned before that you donāt know if it is possible to create such rrv pools and to make sure that at least one of them is none-provable ofc.
We literally just came up with the idea, the devs will know if it is possible and if yes, how. But that doesnāt change the content of our suggestion.
median elbow
@quaint bramble why can't cupid do well is the question
forest rover
Do you know what role needs to be in ranked?Zombie 
fallen rock
This is surely due to a connection problem checking your internet connection and if the problem persists signals it in #bugs-readonly @analog yacht
lament knoll
Omg no pls not
analog yacht
no my internet is great
median elbow
@forest rover yeah totally
lament knoll
Zombie in ranked sounds like pure terror
forest rover
Just if youāre werewolf @lament knoll
lament knoll
Also if you're villagerš
quaint bramble
@analog yacht If you clear your cache and then still dnt get gold after spinning, please report it in #bugs-readonly
To access this channel, check out the #rules-archived and give them a 
analog yacht
how do i clear cache lol
runic dragon
serene lotus
And when weāre already at it, another suggestion:
Deleting the app also deletes all the data. Even if you log back into your account after redownloading WWO, all your chat history got deleted as well. It would be great if that was able to prevent.
quaint bramble
@serene lotus That's because of the chat data being stored locally on your device, instead of being connected to your account. I dont know why exactly, but surely there's a good reason for this
cerulean yoke
Opaan
quaint bramble
@cerulean yoke Hello there, do you need help with anything? Got any ideas?
forest rover
So here goes my feedback.
I know this would be a minor feature,but I still thinking that it would be nice so I suggest that depending in the team youāre,in voting day you should have your vote in a different way.
-If youāre a villager,you will have the normal vote.
-If youāre a werewolf,you will have a hand with fur as vote.
-If youāre a zombie,you will have the vote that zombies has in night vote.
-If youāre the sect leader or a sect member,you will have a hand covered by a black glove as vote.
Who will see it?
Just you,and just in the player youāre voting.No one else will see it,and if thereās different people voting another people it will look as the normal vote.
And if it gets to every role (a customized vote) it would be,in my opinion,one of the coolest visual features that could be added
median elbow
Reame villager to forkman
runic dragon
we should get marriage bot
median elbow
No
quaint bramble
@forest rover Hmm this sounds like a fun extra visual idea, I will post it !
(I dont think literally every role should get a different hand though ^^)
forest rover
Thx @quaint bramble 
uncut tusk
@cerulean yoke Heya, do you have any feedback to suggest? š
cerulean yoke
To suave padrin
median elbow
What about the villager rename
quaint bramble
@median elbow Besides being funny, what is the point? š¤
uncut tusk
@cerulean yoke Ehmm please speak in English? š
median elbow
It's the universal name
quaint bramble
@median elbow it's a cute funny nickname, it's still a regular villager officially...
I can agree in renamin the emote here :forkman: but i dont know about changing it in the game.
median elbow
I don't see why not
glacial warren
@cerulean yoke I t you in #bot-commands talk English ^^'
runic dragon
glacial warren
^ if you mean this
forest rover
Well about @median elbow villager could be changed into forkman because of two reasons:
1)Because everyone call it forkman.
2)Because village is another term that is really similar to villager and new players could be confused.Itās also quite similar to rrv or rsv because it has villager in the name and you can get confused too
@quaint bramble
median elbow
@forest rover that's one of two reasons why I said that. The second reason crossed my mind as well
It's the universal name
lament knoll
I never saw anyone in game calling it forkman and imo that's an insider so i'd say it would confuse new players even more 
craggy dagger
Suggestion 1 Provable rvs mayor/pacifist/grandma/marksman/witch be made unique meaning only one of each can spawn in a ranked game.
This is because more than one of each of these rvs quantitively affects how likely village is to win in proportion to other factions.
Suggestion 2 change the 3 rrvs to make it so one rev slot includes the uniques, and two rrv pools that donāt
This is mainly to prevent there being multiple unique classes in the game whilst also keeping the spawn rate of doctors/bgs/auras etc consistent
Note: What rvs should or shouldnāt be unique is flexible and subject to change
fallen rock
Suggestion 1: Surely this increases the chances of winning for the village but there are also roles that decrease the chances of winning (villagers for example)
serene lotus
But his suggestion implies that you always have one of these unique/strong villagers. The goal of it isnāt to increase a villagers win, but to make a wolf/solo role win just as likely when the players used good strategy.
fallen rock
Suggestions 2: Roles change every week
frozen mirage
I have level 74 and I'm with players how have level 6
quaint bramble
@fallen rock The suggestion is actually aiming to decrease the chance of village wins
and roles change every week has nothing to do with ranked or rrv or this suggestion.
fallen rock
I think the chances of victory in the village are as they are
@quaint bramble Can you show me an example of an answer I could have done please
@frozen mirage Matchmaking by level has already been suggested
But I think that's the way it is because it's late and there aren't necessarily many players online
quaint bramble
@fallen rock Just give your opinion and reasons freely, and try not to sound like you are rejecting or approving it for feedback-devs, because you know you cant..
@frozen mirage If you want to play with more experienced people, then play Sandbox or ranked, or leave the lobby when you notice they all have simple avatars and try the next one.
Matchmaking based on levels has been suggested many times before, and currently isnt in the works.
fallen rock
Thanks
runic dragon
I suggest to give solo roles win (sk,arso,fool,and hh when lynching his target) more points , beetween 80-100 depending on lobbys rank
This way there will be less suicides from players giving up first day and will also help a bit the problem revolving hh as a role that allies with village too easily since he has even more to gain playing by himself amd deceiving village
thin dome
I know for a fact this is a repost and this is really needed, so I am gonna ask for it again. Can we please make sandbox mode for people with a level of 30 or higher??? The people new to the game need to learn how the game works before they can just go straight to sandbox mode. Plus, I feel like just some mode is needed where you only play with like other higher level players.
runic dragon
Tbh, I don't think matchmaking by level is a good idea. I used to a hyper noob, too. And those pros are who helped me. They teached me not to call out roles, not to lynch randomly, etc. And these are necessary. So please don't make matchmaking by level a real thing. Please!
ornate sun
I just have a minor issue about the translations
for this, éåø is commonly referred to gold coins, in monetary terms
gold league should just be éčęÆčµ
for this, it's not really āé«åā as é«å refers to high marks
it should be āęåā which means ranking
maybe it's because of the English version which is "highscores" but I feel that section is to see our ranks so "ranking/ęå" would be more accurate
glacial warren
@runic dragon heyo ^w^ to make the points you get higher, has already been suggested, but solo roles already give much more than normal Villager.
Yes of course then they would try harder, but if it's not balanced anymore, that's not fair for a Villager win ^^'
Even then thank you for your feedback and suggestion 
@thin dome hello and I'm sorry for the late reply.
Yes you are right, that this has been suggested before.
I really understand your point, since many players don't understand game mechanics and roles, but learning doing isn't that bad tho ^^
Thank you for your feedback anyways ^^ I will add it with a + one thumbs up in the database
@ornate sun okay! Thank you for reporting is, I will redirect it to the translators
celest cape
What if there are 2 or more Meds in custom game and 1 of them is racist in dead's chat. How can i report the right one?
ornate sun
@glacial warren thank you
celest cape
Feedbackers should have ā¢feedback role and @feedback ping
ornate sun
there's no specific people who can reply to your feedback, anyone can do that if they know the answer//know if it has been posted before/rejected before^^
but I don't play custom much and I don't know how it looks like that's why Im not answering your question ^^
one of the helpers/mod will reply u when they see it, don't worry !!
celest cape
But @feedback ping and ā¢feedback role can be useful, people that want to get notification if somebody pings @feedback to reply faster, can asign ā¢feedback role = useful thing
opaque pollen
Feedback is for everyone to discuss
glacial warren
Yep that's true ^^ feedback can be answered by everyone. Sure in the end the helper/mini mod/mod chooses if they post it in #feedback-devs, but it's also good to see the opinions of other members.
Many users won't even notice this role so there isn't any use on adding it anyways 
reply faster? Normally a staff member is responding and if there is one or not depends on the time zone
Now to you feedback ^^ I don't know, but mostly if someone is insulting others, he also does it in day chat.
celest cape
But he can do it only in night chat becuase he know nobody can report him
glacial warren
Ye do you have an idea how to fix this problem?
celest cape
Add his number to "Medium:" in daed chat. Med allways reveals him in dead chat and wws cant take advantage of it, and it solves this problem
ornate sun
not really. med doesn't always tell number. can be advantageous for bad roles this way. I won before because med made an awful typo of his number
sturdy epoch
how awful
+ 
= OTP
sturdy epoch
i only say my number when im about to revive someone so they can back me up if someone else is claiming
median elbow
Updated the list give me what ti change
RWV - Random Weak Villager
Villager
Cursed
Seer App
Tough Guy
Flower Child
Red Lady
Sheriff
RNV - Random Normal Villager
Cursed
Doctor
Bodyguard
Aura Seer
Beast Hunter
Pacifist
Priest
Avenger
Grumpy Granny
Mayor
RSV Random Strong Villager
Seer
Spirit Seer
Detective
Gunner
Witch
Marksman
RPV Random Powerful Villager
Jailer
Medium
President
Cupid
Majestical wait that's not a role
Had a long debate in general and we came up with a balanced system for ranked. Instead of 3 rrvs there are 3 rrvs broken down into a class system. RWV RNV and RSV. Powerful villagers would be for custom games. And of course this is just a concept developers can interchange where roles are placed.
- Cursed showing up twice is intentional.
@quaint bramble the ranking system is posted ^^
rain fiber
If its obvious who is last evil /sk,i think it shiuld be bannable if u didnt vote him
Priest (revealed) ,1 is doc and 15 is arso,15.Only them left,15 says 1 last ww
1 doesnt vote 15 and 15 burns them tommorow
15 wins
quaint bramble
@rain fiber This is already bannable, you can report it as gamethrowing/teaming.
But keep in mind, it might not have been that obvious for 1 who was who, or he was afk at this point.
rain fiber
Nah,he wasnt afk,he typed messages during voting time
Its either him or the other guy,how wasnt it obvious
quaint bramble
Thats still a 50% chance of getting it wrong š¤ So some people are scared to make that choice.
But as I said, if you think it was on purpose, then report him and let the guardians judge the situation, since they can actually read the chat.
random bone
It would be really helpful, if you could report and block a person, if you're not in a game with him/her.
light edge
If you dont vote in a must vote scenario. (2 vs 1) (3 vs 2) (5 vs 3 vs 1) it should also be bannable. If village gets outnumbered its lost
uncut tusk
@random bone Heya, thanks for your idea ! It was suggested before and apparently even accepted by Emanuel, but no news about it ever since. https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/614817329800413204
I'm going to give it a repost as a reminder š¤
@light edge Heya, you can report them for gamethrowing, but only guardians will decide if they really didn't vote because they were teaming (bannable) or if they really couldn't tell who is good or evil (not bannable) ;)
forest rover
That's because it is a really cool feedback @runic dragon
runic dragon
It is
normal wyvern
it got posted twice
normal wyvern
Probably caused by Discord problems
Okay, a few suggestions for the secret quiz.
-
I found a question about the loyalty tokens. One answer was that you get a special outfit, the knight. Now it sounds like it's the only outfit you could get with it. It should be changed so that you get more than just that knight through the loyalty tokens.
-
there should also be questions about the new roles. I only found questions that were relatively old and didn't even include Red Lady or Berserker. Maybe a rework would not be bad.
runic dragon
#feedback-readonly there should be a new feature where at night when the seer checks a person, the seer not only sees what the player is on the player board, but also in the chat box. I think this can remove the fact that the seeds can double check the same person.
Seer* not seeds
Chat moderators are you not here, or is this not a good enough suggestion, or what...
rose scroll
@runic dragon just be patience, they will reply as soon as they can š
uneven gust
Maybe boost a xp for winning as couple
vernal dune
@normal wyvern hey!
I don't know if the devs will update the secret quiz again, but in case they will, i'll post this to #feedback-devs since I agree with that 
@runic dragon 
This feature would buff the seer, making it more easier to remember who you checked
However, I think seer is already quite op. And I think something similar was already suggested too. So thank you for your suggestion anyway! 
@uneven gust you already get a lot of xp for winning as couple (95 xp), so I don't think it needs a boost currently 
normal wyvern
@vernal dune Thank you very much!
sudden dock
Okay, just an idea, but what if instead every game you pay 5 gold in ranked, if you lose a game in ranked you lose 5 gold.
that 5 gold is just tedious sometimes, ya know
And losing 5 gold if you lose makes you want to win more... and not gamethrow? As supposed to players who are good and don't gamethrow spending money
vernal dune
@sudden dock its basically the same thing... if you win you get your money back (and eventually even more). The problem with your suggestion is with the different teams: are villagers going to lose the same amount as a serial killer? The serial killer may win more coins, but in reality, paying 5 coins and getting them back + win bonus is the same.
So I don't think this will go in #feedback-devs
Thanks for the suggestion though
sudden dock
Maybe add a resign a button for when you want to stay in clan, but want to step down from co leader (or maybe even pass leadership onto another player in clan?
warm helm
That could be nice to add yea, thank you for your feedback
sick cave
Would be nice if it would be possible to buy more then one random outfit at one time, like 5 or 10 at one time and then maybe as bonus that u can choose one when u decide to buy 10 for example
runic dragon
how about putting Marriage bot in here š
rigid bronze
Afaik new bots won't be added unless real use of it š
@sick caveIn the shop section ? So with real money ?
sick cave
@rigid bronze yes with real money
sick cave
@rigid bronze thank u
normal wyvern
There should be a "back" button in the inventory so you can undo your mistakes. You missclick once and you have to search forever until you find the item again. The key would avoid the eternal search...
rigid bronze
@normal wyvern What would be the keywords ? š¤ The name of the outfit ?
normal wyvern
Keyword?
rigid bronze
Hum the words that match the search if u want
Like the words you need to search to find something
rigid bronze
Oh sorry xd I'm tired
Yea totally agree on the back button tho, tha is very much ^^
normal wyvern
mighty birch
Repost: Please make it so that when you are ingame you can open/see the game rules, to often we encounter people that think they don't break them
vivid blaze
How about we put a win-streak counter in profile? Like 8 ball pool and many other games have
And also best win streak maybe
woeful mesa
I checked but didn t find it anywhere, so I think in the rules it should be good to write that you should speak the good language in the good mode, like for sandbox it s english only, and for other modes it s kinda obvious but specifying it would be a good idea in my opinion
I checked but didn t find it anywhere, so I think in the rules it should be good to write that you should speak the good language in the good mode, like for sandbox it s english only, and for other modes it s kinda obvious but specifying it would be a good idea in my opinion
I think writing it in "others" can be an idea
lament knoll
Heyaaa @woeful mesa 
Actually we got this suggested a few times already but i don't think such stuff should be listed in the rules as it is common sense...
If you join a certain language lobby you have to speak that language that is needless to say, plus every time you want to play sandbox it tells you all over again that the language in sandbox is english
You can't join a match without being reminded again and after atleast 20 matches you should be able to memorize that sandbox is english only...
Also if someone after this obvious reminder every single time still speaks another language in sandbox people are kind enough to nicely ask them to speak english
After that there is just no other thing you can do 'bout reporting as those were 2 obvious reminders
I dont think we need a third
Thanks for your suggestion tho 
woeful mesa
oh okay thanks for the answer^^
lament knoll
You're welcome
Heyy @mighty birch
As this is a repost, i dont need to say that it was suggested before so i'll just get straight to the point 
I agree with that honestly, already thought it was an amazing suggestion when it was suggested first and i remember that was like a long time ago, i'd definitely have many advantages from such a feature as "read the rules again" usually doesn't really help muchš
Thanks for the suggestion, i'll repost it into #feedback-devs for you
Have a nice day
mighty birch
Thank you Min ā¤
lament knoll
You're welcome shawon
opaque pollen
I'd like Rules moved to main menu too
lament knoll
Heyyy @vivid blaze 
That sounds like a nice idea, could you describe a little more how it would show up in the profile?
Would it be like the stats or would it simply show how many win streaks you got, or show how many games you won consecutively?
I think it's a good idea i'd just like to know more detail so i can post a precise suggestion but also still get into how you actually meant it
vivid blaze
Just like 8 ball pool which has "win streak" and then the number next to it
It could be anywhere that's preference of what the developer chooses. But u get the idea
Basically my suggestion is to display win streak. Don't want to discuss further about how it could be done lol. If u wanna discuss maybe others can.
Or if you're satisfied u can forward this to devs
woeful mesa
@opaque pollen thanks for posting it, just want to say that before Min already answered me that it wasn t necessaryš
opaque pollen
@woeful mesa Yeah, but I hate "it isn't written in the rules" loopholes
woeful mesa
haha okay^^
opaque pollen
:thumbsup:
runic dragon
No
I mean a card game
Or something else but with ww style
Basically more ww games
runic dragon
Make discussion phase last 1:30 minute
uncut tusk
@runic dragon Hello there, thanks for suggesting!
Hmm, could you explain why you feel like it should be extended to 1,5 minute? It's already kinda long enough to wait an entire minute, plus the time to vote...
And in my opinion, part of the game is about being able to take decisions under pressure š
runic dragon
Well, sometimes 1:00 minute feels little and I think 30 extra seconds will add more discussion and extra possibilities both for wws and village
That.s my opinionšµ
uncut tusk
Thanks for suggesting it, again, it's really appreciated š But I highly doubt that idea would be accepted, honestly š
If you really want to play games with longer discussion times, you can play custom games š
Where you can define how long every phase lasts.
runic dragon
Oh :(
Yes but I only have little gold
Cannot afford that
Maybe reduce cost of costum games?š½
I will ask Philip
uncut tusk
500 gold isn't that high š
runic dragon
Make it 100 gold
uncut tusk
Please don't ask Philipp for that, you're supposed to suggest your ideas here š @runic dragon
runic dragon
Yes but Philip is dev so can make that
I will ask him if he can gift me with custom.games
Maybe he wants to be santa claus
Christmas is comingg
uncut tusk
Ehmm you know, this channel is for suggestions, if those are good they will be put to #feedback-devs and devs will look at it and maybe, if they like it, do them ;)
That's the way to do here, asking the devs directly will not help š
lament knoll
(Sorry for the late response) @vivid blaze alright, yeah i'll post it into #feedback-devs for you thanks for your suggestion
quaint bramble
@runic dragon Are you talking to me...? I wasn't here at all š¤
lament knoll
may be referring to surprise's pfpš
charred kiln
Ilike to give a suggestion on the last suggestion in #feedback-devs
Make also that u can see ur highest streak ever
runic dragon
@quaint bramble no I mean the one who answered
lament knoll
@charred kiln oof right i forgot to add that š
quaint bramble
They have a name and it's not Unicorn, also please stay nice. Try not to compare staff help with punching in the face š¤
lament knoll
Thanks for reminding me and enforcing that feedback
bronze pasture
Discord suggestion: I want to be able to set the language I get when doing bot commands (including English)
fallen rock
So translate the bots?
quaint bramble
@bronze pasture You already can, you click a flag in #welcome-to-wolvesville
bronze pasture
Regardless of the fact that it tells me "we already have a language for you", where is the flag for AE or BE, I don't mind what it is but English - please
quaint bramble
Perhaps you already reacted one before? I also heard it might assign you a language based on which language server you type in, but Im honestly not sure on the details of this, since it's really new and a little technical
bronze pasture
It always told me that you already had a language for me. Anyways - my point is to change this after it's set
Or if thats not possible for whatever reasons I don't have to know about, Id suggest not to assign a language unless the user specifically asks for it as in reacting to something or similar
charred kiln
@lament knoll can u also write that its suggested also by me in #feedback-devs its not a very big deal just giving a notice
lament knoll
Sure 
nocturne sierra
Number each rule so it is easier to reference when telling people to refer to a rule
median elbow
Remove this and make it open directly to the profile by default
@lament knoll add on suggestion to what was recently posted in #feedback-devs can this also have a win streak record boards and person records
Mostly the global record board of the win streak
lament knoll
@median elbow sounds good
Heyy @nocturne sierra 
This sounds like a nice idea and would indeed make referencing easier, i couldn't find it anywhere in #feedback-devs so i'll post it for you
Thanks for you suggestion
lament knoll
Ah sorry @median elbow forgot to answer to your suggestion above
That's indeed a good idea would prevent the issue of accidentally clicking on decline instead of the "Profile"
I didn't see this having been suggested before so i'll post it into #feedback-devs for you
Thanks for your contribution it's appreciated
median elbow
never posted it
desert fossil
I visited 2 at first night and i survived.
Then he was a ww and they starded accusing me for gamethrowing.
Is this a bug?
quaint bramble
@desert fossil If you are sure, that you didnt tap the persons next to him, or unselected him, then yeah please report this in #bugs-readonly :) Also for next time, you should ask things like this in #questions
steady schooner
I think fool role may need a buff
I propose fool should be immune to getting killed by werewolves at night
faint nymph
Hey bro i think ur game is going to get hackers
runic dragon
@faint nymph The game cannot be hacked š
runic dragon
Hmm
steady schooner
Okay hear me out
Headhunter has the ability to win with village so even if your target dies in any other way than getting lynched, they can still work with the village to win.
On the other hand, fool can only win if they get lynched, so they have only one win condition
runic dragon
Well, they probably have friends
And they trade information
Or they have multiple accounts
steady schooner
If fool has immunity to we attacks, werewolves may think that fool is solo killer and help the fool more making fool easier to win as
runic dragon
Like a lot of accounts
faint nymph
So it means he/she have around 7 phones!?
steady schooner
I mean there's a glitch where you can skip the stupid wheel of misfortune cutscene
runic dragon
@faint nymph Or 7 friends trading information via Discord/Facebook/Messenger
faint nymph
Yeah i got it thank's
runic dragon
Report them ig
please
I hate these people, so please just report them ig for me haha
faint nymph
I did
I hate too
They are destroying game with this kind of works
@runic dragon when ur racist problem of game will solve?
hearty drum
@faint nymph Hey, you can report in game if they have 12 report+ guardian will ban them ^^
faint nymph
It's for long time that i said we have to use vpn to play this game
@hearty drum i did
hearty drum
@faint nymph Alright and racist you can report in game and send screenshotsent to DM a guardian ^^ Btw you want talk pls go to #off-topic , #wov-chat ^^ and if you have some questions pls go to #questions š
white isle
sadly ive had to report multiple people while playing but i actually never know if the case really gets looked into.. it would be nice to get a message like 'we have seen your report from this time and we are working on it' or something like that? (idk how to say it, english isnt my first language sorry)
hearty drum
@white isle Hey š It has been suggest before, Also I hope it will be applied to the game soon š
warm swan
I'd honestly change the name of "crash" to "exit game" or just delete it because it's kinda hard to find the two options, you gotta do some stuff before and I don't think people uses it
hot valley
It is actually a button only the devs use ;) because it does "crash" your game
It is used to test what happens if a certain crash occurs
vivid blaze
These buttons should be more spaced between each other as they're so small we often press the wrong one
ornate sun
it's been suggested before
lament knoll
@median elbow sorry for posting tardive but i had wifi issues and then had to leave for school. Posted it now
quaint bramble
@vivid blaze Yup it's a good idea, recently been posted in #feedback-devs if you want to support it, here's the link
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/640495078808223744
quaint bramble
@noble spade It doesnt work here, but please just dont anyway. And if you wanna chat, you can do so in #wov-chat (about the game) or in #off-topic
noble spade
My bad @quaint bramble please forgive me š„ŗ
Lmao
Iām done
Hope everyone has a good day! š
runic dragon
@everyone
forest rover
Hey!In the game thereās a word banned tramp that means homeless.To be honest,I donāt think homeless is a strong word and even if this could be used as an insult,thereās a lot of insults that are not banned such as dumb.However,thatās not my feedback.The problem of tramp is that in spanish,thereās a word that is trampa.This word means trap,but because tramp is banned,you are not able to write trampa.It is also the official word in the beast hunterās description and itās really annoying that you cannot write a word that is part of the game language.Because tramp (in my opinion) itās not a really strong word,it would be very nice if tramp is deleted from the banned words.
woeful mesa
Hi, would it be possible to put an option to make or not the popcorn appearing for spectating(basically being able to spectate or not)? I'm weird and don't want to see the popcorn^^
night path
@woeful mesa on your friendlist?
woeful mesa
Yes^^
lament knoll
Heyaaa @forest rover
"Tramp" actually doesn't only mean homeless it's also a word for "an immoral woman which sleeps with everyone and anyone" -> slang word so i think it indeed is a strong word as it can and sometimes is used as a synonym for "hooker" or even ||slut|| feeling uncomfortable typing those aaah and won't get deleted from the banned words sorry
forest rover
I didnāt know the second meaning @lament knoll š
runic dragon
A dutch word " Hoor "
Is a muted word.
However, It says nothing bad ?
fallen rock
@runic dragon The word is surely an insult in another language
quaint bramble
@runic dragon It sounds identical to the less friendly English word for hooker
It's also a completely redundant word and shouldnt really be missed that much ^^
wooden yarrow
uncut tusk
I'm not making it on purpose, I promise š
@wooden yarrow Hello there, this channel is for feedback, not #questions š Please go there next time.
Reporting a gamethrower should be done in the game, you can swipe your finger from right to left to show the list of players. Click on the one you want to report, then on the bottom of their profile, click on "Report". Choose the report category and write any additional details then send it š
median elbow
Remove the "Tailsman" from the setting and just place it here so I can set up my tailsman for the next game much faster
rigid bronze
Agreed š
woeful mesa
talismans not tailsman
median elbow
Additional idea for the stonks 
make it so doubled xp is just a purchasable item. I would buy this
woeful mesa
you mean paying real money for getting it?š
median elbow
@woeful mesa rename talismans to tailsman because tails
Yes
You pay real money to remove ads - I did this. I would pay money for a permanent doubled xp
woeful mesa
but would the double exp still be available with ads?
median elbow
Yeah I still need to watch optional ads to double my xp currently
I also need to watch ads for this wheel thing - not sure why the button disappeared but I need to watch ads on this too
woeful mesa
that's normal that you need to watch ads haha
My question was about your feedback, in your idea will there be a way to still double exp with ads or only by paying money?
median elbow
Once you paid for the perk why would you watch ads to double xp
woeful mesa
if the wheel doesn't appear, either you have hit the 100 ads per day, either you can clear your cache/redowload the app and it should appear^^
median elbow
@rigid bronze my grammar was trash can you fix it in #feedback-devs
rigid bronze
Oh sure
median elbow
3#100
woeful mesa
nah what I mean is, will there be for those who didn't pay for it the possibility to still watch ads to double exp
median elbow
Oooh yes
Key mechanics don't need to be yeeted out of existence it's just a perk for people that don't do the whole ads thing
I do also have a few more suggestions to improve key mechanics in the game
This is similar to @runic dragon's idea with the rose wheel tickets. How about tickets for this wheel. And let me waste coins on this wheel (and hide this wheel)
woeful mesa
why tickets instead of direct gold?š
median elbow
Coins have no major reason to appear om this screen so give coins a reason to appear.
- you can't say it's to see how much gold you win because it drops roses
@woeful mesa Follow up with this
Rose tickets for the rose wheel that also takes roses'
Coin tickets for the coin wheel that should take coins
woeful mesa
I didn't get your first 2 linesš
quaint bramble
@median elbow you can already equip talismans in the lobby though š¤
and equipping them during a game makes no sense, you already got your role
quaint bramble
yeah thats why they were recently added to the lobbies, imo
median elbow
If you're in quick play and sometimes sandbox game start instantly
Adding it the top section would just give you time to set up the next games tailsman
Sure it's accessible in the setting tab however this would be the more logical location to place the tailsman button
quaint bramble
Well it;s alredy posted, we'll see how it goes, I'm just giving my personal (not professional) opinion, I find it redundant
serene compass
feedback for voting gallery (and maybe #dev-vote too) i think it would be a good idea to add a description with every outfit in the gallery, for example: ādesigned for battle passā ādesigned for questā ādesigned for limited offerā etc, since outfits that are designed for quest are usually simple and people might dislike it bc they donāt like it enough for a special offer. also i think this is really important for battle pass outfits, last time there wasnāt a vote in discord so no one really knew which outfits in voting gallery were āapplyingā to battle pass (i know the theme was pretty obvious but still) i really hope this can be added
(addition: i know all outfits currently in voting gallery probably canāt have it but like add it for all new outfits added)
uneven gust
Is someone they take into account about item shop like stfu frotnite
silver jetty
it would be great if you would get, by clicking on an (special-)item, an info that tells you where you got the item from.
i was searching for the baguette and now i got it but idk how ,_,
runic dragon
Can the text "Limited" be removed from the shop?
Before I Bought my first buyable outfit I was scared beause there says "Limited" I thought after a time I wouldn't have it anymore, and I'm seeing I'm not the one though like that.
With "You'll receive 1 random special outfit" it's understandable
serene compass
maybe change it to ālimited saleā? @runic dragon instead of removing it since it is limited by time
or something like that
runic dragon
Yup add a Sale I think is fine.
When I bought my first outfit I really thought it was to dissapear after a while
serene compass
i didnāt but i can see the problem there
silver jetty
uhm i think you should change smthš
theyre two accounts but changed their names and then after some time they changed their names back but on the quest heroes only one name is back to normal, the other one is still the old name.
i hope its understandable enough
||and no those names arent different, small L and capitalized i for example||
lament knoll
@serene compass i get it with the battle pass but i dont think such stuff should be implemented for regular outfits as you dont decide yourself whether your outfit gets a special offer or clan quest, the vote decides
Imo it is just normal that people rate simpler outfits lower and that'll automatically result in them rather getting into clan quest direction than special offer direction
It should be about opinion after all if you'd like to wear the outfit in game and you shouldn't rate differently only because it would get into another purpose and could also cause in people voting suggestions for special offers lower to get them as clan quests and like that for free instead of having to pay
Also i am not quite sure if all people in game even know how it's decided if an outfit gets a special offer or clan quest sooo idk
I dont really see an use with advantages for the special offer and clan quest thing but i could agree on the battle pass thing
serene compass
maybe just the bp then?
let me rephrase it one sec
feedback for voting gallery i think it would be a good idea to add a description for bp outfits in the gallery, for example: ādesigned for battle passā i think this is really important for battle pass outfits, last time there wasnāt a vote in discord so no one really knew which outfits in voting gallery were āapplyingā to battle pass (i know the theme was pretty obvious but still) i really hope this can be added
lament knoll
@silver jetty well the baguette is an easter egg so idk if you should get infos how you got items by easter eggs honestly š
Would only make revealing them much easier, to be honest... but i remember that something like this has been suggested before in several ways like the "info" button simply showing for every item etc
Tho i think that was a while back, so it might not be too bad to give it a little repost
For the baguette you might want to ask someone who got it aswell how it was gotten showing proof you already got it or similar,,, thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day
@serene compass doki doki i'll post that for you
Thanks alot for your suggestion and the detailed feedback, its appreciated
serene compass
lament knoll
@silver jetty doesn't seem to be intended if one is changed back to normal and the other one isn't...
Have you tried restarting your app and clearing your cache seeing if it shows accurately then?
If not let's meet in #bugs-readonly
As it could maybe have been intended if both usernames stayed their old versions but one changing and the other one staying the same seems odd
silver jetty
they changey their names back i think 3-6 days agoš
runic dragon
My feedback was skiped 
lament knoll
Ooh jesus sorry Toonieā¤
@runic dragon read it before but forgot to reply
Wanna update the message? š
I'd really like to post it 
needless to say your feedback is awesome as alwaxs so i wont
runic dragon
Skip Log
First option: Make a log where you can see who has pressed to skip
Second option: If you skipped appear a Skip icon in your Avatar.
There's already many things in your Avatar, Your Role, if you're coupled, you're revealed, if youre muted, so I don't think it be possible tho
Third option: Make like the "Vote to start" but to the skip
lament knoll
||it's discussion not "disscution" thoš||
fallen rock
Your designs are beautiful and illustrate your ideas perfectly, thank you for taking time to improve the gameā¤ļø
lament knoll
^ p r e a c h
Toon rules
runic dragon
Thank you so much 
So I should edit the "Disscution"? I think it's understandable tho š¬
Or does *"disscution" mean another thing?
uncut tusk
@runic dragon Heya, thanks for your detailed suggestion, it's nice to have various possibilities like that 
A similar suggestion was done not long ago though, it was much simpler than your idea(s): https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/625255332356292658
But your first and third suggestions are better, imho, as they give more details (when will the skip be reached, who unvoted to skip, etc.)
The first idea might lead to easy spam, though :/
I'd personally go for the third idea. But still write a system message for the first skip vote of the day š¤ What do you think?
If you want, you can edit it, it would look nicer in #feedback-devs... ;)
"Disscution" is not a real word as far as I know š
Suggestion about the edit: "(...) you can vote to skip it."
runic dragon
So the change the word "Limit" in the shop and the time skip log was both suggested? @uncut tusk
i just sent two Feedbacks not three š¤
uncut tusk
Oh sorry I didn't realize you also had suggested something about the "limited outfit" naming!
I believe this hasn't been suggested before, I'm going to put it to #feedback-devs, by replacing "limited" with "special". Is that what you want? You were discussing with nagini and they suggested to replace outfit with "sale", which wasn't your original intention at all, so I'm asking š
Sorry I wasn't clear, I meant your 3 options for the skip vote idea š
runic dragon
Updated:
**Can the text "You will receive 1 random limited outfit" be changed from the shop?
Change it for a "You will receive 1 random limited sale outfit"
When I bought my first outfit I thought it was to dissapear after a while
With N4GINI#5097**
Or also that "Special" instead of "Limited" also would work. What I want it's have cleared that isn't lĆmited in your inventory
uncut tusk
Alright I'll put it in #feedback-devs, thanks!
Will you do the edit of the picture in your option #3 of the idea about skip vote? Or shall I put it as is?
runic dragon
I'll edit it later
runic dragon
Is it possible to add small animations to our graves?
For example in the new battlepass theres a grave with someone dying in acid or whatever that is with their hand reaching out. Maybe add a small animation to the acid and the person drowning? Same for other graves as well
uncut tusk
@runic dragon Hello, thanks for suggesting! Hmm, I think animations are pretty and all but are just too distracting from the game itself š Especially when they are not useful
runic dragon
Compact the logos if you have too many
Currently you can have
Coupled
Sected
Paci revealed
And that's already four
You can also have muted
So that's five
night path
@runic dragon Please don't spam, also how would this be done? I think the logos are fine how they are but im open to ideas!
runic dragon
That was like, the size of an image. That not spam.
But maybe have a box or something, and when clicked shows all the logos temporarily?
runic dragon
@noble spade I think gif like that goes better in #off-topic than here š
I think it's better now
Oh no
I forgot a thing
Jeez
Better?
fallen rock
@runic dragon yes it is better
runic dragon
@noble spade it is coming kinda annoying, could u delete it pls? I'm trying explain a feedback and you're sending gifs between it, if you want to do things like that go to #off-topic
runic dragon
@uncut tusk Yes I thought about the spam before suggest it, that's why I said a Log apart of the chat
@noble spade it's fine just that gifts like that its kinda spammy and annoying to some people (to me), in #off-topic there send a lot of gifs I think there would be perfect to send your gifs.
And I'm also out from here cuz I'm also starting to use this channel in off topic š¬
runic dragon
@mighty cypress That's already a feature if it's that what you mean
Maybe š¤, you can report it in #bugs-readonly tho
spare peak
How do i suggest an improvement
runic dragon
@spare peak I don't think there's a way to suggest š¤
Just tell what would you like to improve, if a Helper+ thinks is a good idea and wasnt suggested before he will put it in #feedback-devs to the Devs watch your idea
iron girder
We need a wwo shrug emoji
this is old ~> š¤·
normal wyvern
I'd like to add somewhere (maybe FAQ) who will win when your couple got converted but they are the last one alive. Because a lot of the new member don't know this can happen that couple can win when cupid died before converting in a sect/zombie game
magic smelt
Oh wrong server
fallen rock
@magic smelt Deleted it please
magic smelt
How
lament knoll
@magic smelt click and hold and then there's an option "delete"
Thanks
Next time please double check before you send something if it's actually the right server and channel please ;)
@normal wyvern
That indeed sounds like a good idea since questions about edge cases of cupid seem indeed to get asked frequently, i didn't see many people asking about this one but i think you wouldn't suggest if it if you weren't convinced it would be useful
I'll post it into #feedback-devs for you
tho in a sect game the couple wont win unless one of the lovers is the sl as otherwise to be the last two alive they'd need to kill the sl and then they'd die themselvesš
terse rover
In seer info should stand that they shouldn't say good roles like med i think, i see too much seer that just call the role of every player
normal wyvern
Thank you very much ā¤
craggy dagger
Amendment: Iād like an FAQ what your win condition is when youāre coupled period.
on what*
woeful mesa
Hi. Would it be possible to, when we want to buy an offer and send it to a friend, receive a code instead of instantally sending it to our friend? Like I want to offer this outfit for a special event like a birthday, but his birthday isn't when the offer is on, which is kinda sad.
glacial warren
@craggy dagger hey ^^ that's all listened in the roles description and system message š¤
@woeful mesa hey ^^ thank you for your suggestion. I will post it in #feedback-devs
woeful mesa
hey, okay thanks^^
glacial warren
You're welcome
opaque pollen
I'd worry people would save codes to resell
full falcon
When I'm trying to create a new combination for an outfit, the item category lists always reset when I switch from one to another and I'd have to scroll all the way down to the golden items, and this becomes exhausting really fast. Can it be possible that the game saves how far we scroll down after switching to another item category ?
uncut tusk
@runic dragon Thank you. Yeah I got it about the separate log, but it would still be potential spam in that separate log, preventing anyone to easily read who voted or un-voted to skip ;)
woeful mesa
@opaque pollen in that case make it so that the code can only be used by the friend we want to offer it to? If it's possible
@glacial warren maybe add this to my feedback, with Captain's commentš
glacial warren
@woeful mesa sure ^^
woeful mesa
thanks^^
glacial warren
Added
runic dragon
I think there should be an option that allows you to set some sort of a "close friends list". Close friends may appear first when inviting in a game and may have some other advantages idk
How is that fair lol
4 seers for christ sake
3 auras and 1 seer
š¤¦āāļø
normal wyvern
@uncut tusk Hey, I already suggested the feedback what Toon did already before..
uncut tusk
@normal wyvern Heya, I assume you talk about this message: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/416576750991048705/604269858930294806?
If I'm right, no one answered it at all, correct? I'm very sorry about that, I guess it should have been added at that time already, I wasn't helper at that time anyway š
It sometimes happen that some feedback here and there get overlooked simply because too many messages get posted š
In some cases, a feedback that wasn't accepted in the past by some helper might be accepted by another helper some time later, it happens š¤· To each their opinion, I'm sorry you didn't get lucky this time.
full falcon
What about my feedback ;-;
serene lotus
Show us the final skill points in the āHall Of Fameā from the previous ranked seasons
(and not sure if i should hop to #bugs-readonly about one player being on spot 10 and 11 at the same time?)
vernal dune
@full falcon that can be possible, i'll add this to #feedback-devs !
@serene lotus I don't know if it is really pertinent and if the skill points have been saved, so it may not be possible. But in case it can be, i'll add it to #feedback-devs to see! 
And yes, #10 and #11 being the same is a bug ;)
full falcon
Make it so that offline people are considered dead/not part of the village.
No one can lynch anyone and the game stagnates in this picture until someone dies by suicide
Skipping discussion doesn't really make a lot of sense because there will always be at least two teams in any given point in time in a match, when one team decides to skip discussion it is always unfavorable to the opposite team, and the opposite team -logically- will not skip discussion. Even if this "opposite team" is only one werewolf against 5 other villagers, needing all 6 votes to skip discussion in this case, and every other case, just doesn't make sense, it wastes 5 people's time because one player won't admit defeat. I suggest that the number of votes to skip discussion is half the number of the remaining players in a village or 75%
normal wyvern
@uncut tusk No, I meant it was posted before in #feedback-devs
uncut tusk
Oh I see it now, I'm sorry, I don't understand how I could have missed it š¤ Well then, the half of the suggestion that was about adding a system message should have been credited to you, I guess... Or be marked as a repost. Sorry about that š
Emanuel approved of the most recent feedback, btw
runic dragon
Did my feedback get noticed?š
normal wyvern
@uncut tusk don't worry, I just wasn't insecure about it
lament knoll
Heyaaa @runic dragon
Sorry your feedback didn't get responded toā¤
But such a suggestion has already been suggested before quite recently as well, to add the option to select "close friends" and making it a feature to then in the friendslist settings being able to select "close friends first"
But i'll add a +1 onto the suggestion for you, thanks for your contribution
lament knoll
Heyyy @full falcon for your most recent suggestion -> already been suggested pretty recently but in a bit of different way and it wasn't posted into #feedback-devs because the person didnt respond anymore afaik when asking questions about the feedback
Atleast that's how i remember it as it was me which took that feedback and i wasn't able to find it in feedback devs either.
However i'll post it into #feedback-devs for you
Thanks alot for your suggestion and have a nice day
full falcon
No problem
But what about the offline people and voting thinggie ? Has it already been suggested before ?
lament knoll
Yeah that was the one which was suggested before to not take them into consideration when it comes to needed votes
woeful mesa
the last feedback should be cut in half, because there are 2 in 1 no?š
lament knoll
Yeah my badš
woeful mesa
for the last feedback, I think there will be some notifications problem if someone goes off or come back from being off. Like if none are off when vote time appears: 5 vote are needed. But if during that time someone goes off, then only 4 votes will be needed, but it will still be written 5 needed (the notif being here before). Same for the contrary, and it can lead to some big confusions...
full falcon
Ps: There's a photo missing in the last feedback.
And @woeful mesa yeah I guess you're right unless the notification message for the necessary vote numbers changes accordingly, idk honestly I just wanted to suggest that cause it gets annoying when more than half the village is off, what would you suggest for that ?
woeful mesa
welp Idk, like some people keep losing connection so if we put a notif each time someone goes off it would be horrible... and I get off people are annoying but half the village off doesn't happen a lotš
deft merlin
Villagers steadily say zombie and sect are good roles, and they often play for them even if they are still in village team. This is considered as gamethrowing, but itās impossible to report, as most of the villagers donāt care about it...
rigid bronze
I sadly agree and already know that... Maybe you have an idea to prevent that ? @deft merlin
Hmm true, how would you make that not happen ? Lock at X votes needed when vote starts ? Or something else ? @woeful mesa
woeful mesa
well an idea would be maybe change the vote color when the limit is hit... But the notif would still be wrong so Idk, and I honestly use the notif in game to know if someone will die or not, so will be annoying...
and I actually disagree with this feedback lol,just pointing out a problem in it
and locking at X votes would be actually unfair
vivid blaze
There literally should be a system that can detect random shooting and ban automatically. Coz I'm sick of gunners shooting randomly and then randomly shooting again the one who says to report them. Furthermore the village makes excuse that "it was a bad role" and don't report and gunner gets away with it due to those biased noobs.
We've discussed about this before and its become so serious now it must be fixed one way or another
vernal dune
Hey @vivid blaze!
It would be very hard to detect random gunners, because the wws could just play well and make him shoot a villager.
If you have a suggestion on how to detect this we'll put this suggestion in consideration, but at the moment I can't think of how such a thing would be possible 
lament knoll
@full falcon sorry, my discord didn't include the picture for some reason, i'll try again
full falcon
Too late you destroyed my career, now everyone thinks I'm a retard š
runic dragon
I have some balance ideas zombies are too attractive cause they give you 75Xp so my ideo is to set this number of xp they get on 50 expect for the first zombie he get 75 xp that make that villager dont wanna winn as zombie and try to hunt them too instead of teaming with them. And nobody like to play as corruptor so make him more popular by give him 125 xp instand of 100 the effect is less suicides as corr
And another idea pls add a how many xp a role get if they winn at the role list
proven iron
Thats my idea when you have too much friends at some time some of them quits the game. I want to unfriend them but that isnt a select all option to make them selected friends to unfriend. You can only go their profile and unfriend them and this makes you more tired and loading profile gets too much time.
lapis drum
Can we add a rule that allowing solo killers to live to āhuntā wolves is cheating? Because clearly, itās cheating, but villagers donāt report because ātheyāre solo. Solo can do what they want.ā But if course the tone would be diff if you were a wolf.
forest rover
Solo also can hunt just village and wolves arenāt going to report it š
lapis drum
You know what Iām talking about. Iām referring to solo roles that intentionally kill wolves just so they can keep playing.
Also, random shooting canāt be deduced by chat log? Shooting a num that wasnāt in info or even spoke day one is clearly a random shot. Regardless if it hits a baddie or not, itās random and no one reports the shots that hits a baddie.
Same for priest.
forest rover
But solos are allowed to do that.Solo doesnāt need to kill just village.Of course,if solo kills werewolves it helps village and if solo kills village it helps werewolves.
lapis drum
If a solo player claims their role day one and says āI wonāt killā but then only kills who he is sure is a wolf; you think thatās fair?
forest rover
Unconfirmed is not the same as random.
lapis drum
So ur med. you say nothing day one and ur not in info. Youre unconfirmed. Gunner shot you.
Is that not random?
forest rover
If a solo killer claims to be solo killer he should be lynched.Itās also village fault š
lapis drum
Letās stop playing semantics here.
forest rover
I mean with priest.With gunner you should start it in day 3.
lapis drum
Seriously.
We have trigger happy gunners shooting both docs down within first two days. Thats why this is being brought up.
Or gunners shooting auras because āthey were susā
This is a far bigger issue than shooting unconfirmed.
forest rover
It depends on the context.However,guardians are the ones that accept if a report if valid or not.
I think that if you think it is reportable,you should report it.Then they will decide.
lapis drum
I always report bad behavior as well as suggest ways to reduce it.
forest rover
My question is why do you think that a solo is not able to kill who he wants to.
lapis drum
Again if a solo role INTENTIONALLY kills only ww, how is that fair to wolves?
If thatās the case, wolves should be allowed to kill solo
forest rover
Do you mean that fool isnāt able to vote because it doesnāt help in fool win condition?That if a fool helps village to win,wolves should report them?That if fool helps werewolves,village should report fool?Thatās intentionally too.
lapis drum
Fool isnāt a killing role.
So that doesnt apply.
Weāre talking solo killers here.
forest rover
I think weāre talking about other roles that are not village neither werewolves.
lapis drum
Also fool can be killed by anyone
forest rover
Because fool can decide too who is going to win.
lapis drum
Weāre talking SOLO KILLERS
lament knoll
Sometimes gunners are in situations where they just need to shoot or they'll lose -> a 4 vs 5 situation, 5 villagers, 4 werewolves or a 2 vs 3 vs 1 situation, 3 ww, 2 vill, 1 solo killer
Now you can wait a day until the werewolves win and you lose (in the second scenario assuming they found out the solo wanting to vote it out the next day)
Or you shoot, based on which persons were confirmed and which are not and actually may still get a chance to win...
And yes such situations can also happen before day 3, if, for example, ww activates frenzy, a bomber is in game
So a random shooting system detecting and insta reporting would not be fully effective as it could get alot of fake auto reports and also just because someone was told to be good that doesnt effectively mean they really are
Wws giving fake info - for example
Spirit seer saying people are good if they aren't which is a bug or also could mean that they simply didnt kill tonight and so on
lapis drum
Ok. Youāre missing my point completely.
forest rover
I just think your point is not correct.
lapis drum
@lament knoll Deductive shooting is fine but not random shooting.
Exactly because youāre missing it
Of course fool is gonna mess up the game cuz his goal is to get voted.
But he cant kill and he can be killed by anyone
Whereas sk and arso cannot be killed by wolves. How is it fair that the village allows him to live for the sole purpose of killing wolves for village??
Thatās c h e a t i n g
forest rover
But itās not cheating just for solo killers.Itās cheating too for village.Also,how do you know that the sk claim is right?
lament knoll
Well i gotta side with sheep tho
Of course it's not fair that solo killers only kill wolves but thats their decision
And also leaving alive a solo killer is gamethrowing so once someone claims to be a solo role even if saying "wont kill" it's still your duty to kill them -> shoot, witch killing etc etc etc if a fool is in game
And also if that person claims to be solo killer and isn't a solo killer, nor fool (nor ww, imo even if ww) = report them for gamethrowing
lapis drum
So yall are saying that wolves should report the entire village and not solo. Got it.
lament knoll
? I didnt say any of that lmao
lapis drum
Since the genera concensus seems to be āSolo can do what they wantā I think wolves should be able to kill them then.
runic dragon
lapis drum
Wolves already have an extremely thin line of defense as it is and now itās ok to let solo hunt them?
Well youre saying its more the villageās fault than solo
lament knoll
You cant report a solo killing role for doing their job thats it.
forest rover
Then next thing will be to make solo killer not able to kill right?Making solo killer able to be killed by werewolves is the worst feedback Iād ever see tbh š
lapis drum
Since solo can make the decision to only kill wolves, a team that DEPENDS on them, then solo should be killable by wolves.
lament knoll
- was suggested many times before already
lapis drum
Well since everyone excuses solo, what else can wolves do?
Seriously this game leaves so little room for wolves to succeed.
forest rover
Tell jww to tag solo killer
lament knoll
Solo is already hard to win making it killable by wolves would nerf it by like a landmile
lapis drum
And now weāre okay with letting solo join village to pummel them without a fight.
Smart villages would leave jr last anyway.
+even if solo dies from tag. That means you gotta leave strong villagers in game.
forest rover
How does solo killer knows who are werewolves and who are not?š
lapis drum
thereās literally no way around it for wolves. But itās fine.
I stand by my suggestions
lament knoll
Solo killers wont receive a nerf even if it's a buff for wws... we get dozens of feedback about buffing solo killers so i see no point in nerfing them
Also its pretty easy, jww is only useful once he gets killed; you found the solo? You are jww?
Tell the village who the solo is, if they wanna kill you afterwards they'll lose another important role as well
Yeah you can stand by your suggestion we didnt try to change your mind.
lapis drum
I just think this game should be renamed to villager online. Cuz the wolves get absolutely no love.
spiral torrent
If I see that right, the date of the day where the quest was finished is shown in quest history. I would prefer seeing both starting and ending date (for example 10/31/19-11/05/19)
lapis drum
And it doesnāt seem like much is being done to balance game for wolves in ranked.
lament knoll
Just telling you that guardians decide what gets banned or not and not us, plus i see no reason in being able to report solo killers if all they do is doing their job + you dont know if a solo killer kills ww intentionally or not
Wws get major buffs and we're still searching for more.
Your suggestion got declined if you got another one for buffing ww then hit us up.
If not cut the discussion here please, thanks.
forest rover
Wolves in ranked are balanced enough,in my opinion.A buff for wolves will just nerf a lot village.Also recently in rw were added berserk & nightmare and these 2 ww are really strong tbh.
lapis drum
Yea yall arent reading my entire posts, so letās quit. My suggestion is, āMake solo killers intentionally killing ONLY wolves reportable.ā
Done.
lament knoll
And my answer is:
You can't know if a solo killer kills intentionally only wolves, solo killers got no seer ability so they cant magically see if someone is ww or not, and if the seer found a ww the village will kill them.
The solo killer can kill whoever they want to kill, killing wws is biting in their own neck, if you think the solo killer is teaming with the villager you can already report them for teaming and reports for teaming are common sense so i dont think there is need for putting it up for #feedback-devs as its possible already.
Still thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day.
full falcon
After kicking someone from a clan, there should be a 48h cooldown before that person can send a request to join again
lament knoll
@spiral torrent
Heyaaa
That indeed seems like a nice idea and pretty reasonable as it could be nice to see in how much time you finished quests in total, for example, as sometimes you take longer, sometimes you take less than 6 days
It's not really a very necessarily needed feature but to be honest a nice perk and good to know as additional information
Thanks for your suggestion, i'll post it into #feedback-devs for you ;)
spiral torrent
Haha yeah it's just a tiny thing. However, thank you very much ((:
forest rover
Hey!I think that when priest waters someone that is not werewolf and he dies,village is just losing a villager with just the few knowledge that the watered player is not a werewolf.If we think about what the priestās water does,what if when werewolves attack a watered player,the watered player dies but because he was watered with the priestās water,the weakest werewolf will die with him?
tawny flame
If this happens I will water seer for protection š, but nice idea, priest is nearly useless if didn't water a werewolf
runic dragon
^ It's like a bh trap š¤
forest rover
Not exactly because the watered player still die
runic dragon
I would add that if when you throw water to a not Werewolf if Werewolves atack that watered people the weakest ww will die, But that the water effect only work one or 2 nights
forest rover
I mean,holy water will kill a werewolf,even if it is in a bottle or in a watered player.
Because it still being holy water
tawny flame
Reasonable
Like drunk player in ww offline, ww can kill him but can't kill the night after cause they are drunk
forest rover
Well yes I donāt mind about the time that it lasts I just want that priest suicide has a better use that just confirm if the player is a werewolf or not @runic dragon
lament knoll
Idk, that would make the priest just another protector role which dies for protection 
sounds like a bh and tg mutation with the only change being the moment he dies
Also how would it affect the frenzy? It can't kill the protector as the protector is already dead so in that way it's pretty op tho
And frenzy will only kill the protector not the protected one since the new patch so it would just leave the frenzy being wasted in case priest waters the seer in late voting phase as you cant unactivate the frenzy
runic dragon
Make berserk able to unactivate frenzy š¤·š»āāļø
tawny flame
Then making his water like jail protection, ww can't get close to holy water, it will prevent the kill without killing a ww. This way it's not op
lament knoll
^ sounds reasonable
Would only make it for one day max tho
Because the holy water on a player would dry within a few hours max and lose its effect like that so it should maximum last one night ^^
runic dragon
Thereās this user in my game and nobody wanted to report him even though he was making inappropriate comments
There should be a timer/cooldown beetween the moment you leave and the moment you join a ranked game
It s annoying when the 16th player that join a game leave and rejoin repeatedly until the game starts with 15 players
Even a 5-10 seconds cooldown would be enough
lament knoll
@runic dragon heyaa, this is nothing for this channel, i guess you reported them in game?
You can also report to a guardian in this case
Just send them the screen shots
runic dragon
lament knoll
Choose one of these
Sorry that this happened to you :/
forest rover
I think that make it lasts one night would be ok.However,about frenzy,werewolves know who is the watered one,so they should just not attack the watered player @lament knoll
lament knoll
Well if the watered player is the seer, that's pretty unfortunate as like this the frenzy would result in nothing 'bout a ww dyingš
forest rover
Thereās more different frenzy target like gunner.However,this would last just one night so weāre talking about a really specific case.This wouldnāt happen so often.
lament knoll
Hm, i'll add two options the one with only protecting how minimoni suggested and the one with protecting and killing so the devs can choose if they like any and if yes which version
Thanks for your suggestion
forest rover
Ok thx @lament knoll
brave folio
Can we show badges and avatars in ranked games? Just hide the stats, i think itās really cool if people can see how many badges we have or how the outfits we mix 
full falcon
So what about my feedback?
lament knoll
@full falcon right, lost myself in research during it, sorry ā¤
This sounds good, it has kind of been suggested before but only in a similar way and long time ago.
And your suggestion sounds reasonable and definitely different enough, i'll post it into #feedback-devs for you
Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day 
full falcon
You too ^
lament knoll
Also forgot to answer to yours @runic dragon sorry ā¤
Usually the countdown stops if someone leaves but afaik the rejoining and leaving all over again sometimes causes this bug to happen, with games starting with underneath 15 players
So your suggestion is to make a cooldown before you can rejoin a ranked game right?
There has something for this issue been suggested before: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/631859244521488419
But not in that exact way, atleast i couldn't find any suggestion like that
I'll post it into #feedback-devs for you, thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day 
lapis stag
The battle pass should be easier. In order to buy your way through it you'd have to have 200,000 coins
I've only gotten through an entire battlepass once when it was 600 xp
runic dragon
@lament knoll yes a countdown before you can click on "play " again
Thank you really much :)
lament knoll
@lapis stag the battle pass should be a challenge after all, it should not be easy to finish it in time but rather difficult, that is what makes it so exclusive.
If you play actively 60 days for 100 tiers are sometimes even too much, the bp got higher in terms of xp because we got players complaining that it is way too easy, the items arent exclusive and so on
We get alot suggestions to change the battle pass but we never seem to get to an agreement where everyone is happy
Tho if you wanna accomplish the battle pass you just need to be an active player; if you arent you can't expect to get it fully
lapis stag
I legit play every day
I'm level 124
With thousands of games.
If I'm having a hard time despite that, I'm sure other people are too
I mean roughly you make 100xp per game
Battle pass is over 700
That's 7 games
And 100 tiers.
If you do the math that's pretty extreme.
lament knoll
Heyaaa 
@brave folio
I dont 100% think your suggestion could be very useful tho mostly because i dont play ranked so i see no issue in that i guess
I can understand that you'd like people to see your avatars and badges etc if you're proud of them but i think i'll put this into feedback devs for ya
Thanks for the suggestion 
Have a nice day! 
brave folio
Okay thanks 
bleak ore
I have an suggestion for the game: I keep having some struggle to memorize people that I met in game and change the nickname after a while, even on my own clan. Why there is no any blank space on each profile that we could type a note about the player so we won't need to memorize the profile anymore? Thanks
lament knoll
@lapis stag well we got people which finished the bp already by playing only...
I am also for rather smaller bps with less xp and then more of them but those suggestions got suggested quite alot before so now it's up to the devs to change it
uncut tusk
@bleak ore Hello there, thanks for suggesting!
A similar idea was already suggested idea though, but several months ago: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/603833107979829269
What do you think about it?
I have a question though. Will you really take the time to add a note for every single player you want to keep track of?
bleak ore
Not every single player, only those I wanna remember :)
I used to remember every friend, but there are some player on my clan that I want to write some notes about
uncut tusk
Well I'm going to put it in #feedback-devs then š Thanks for your idea š
bleak ore
sure! thank you :))
runic dragon
Medium always gets killed first in the game so I was thinking if I can come up with another role kinda like seer app but for medium
serene compass
idk if this is for feedback or bug but i have the app language on english but the badge descriptions show in dutch (i am dutch but i donāt get why they arenāt in english)
uncut tusk
@runic dragon Hello, thanks for your idea! Hmm, I don't think it's advisable to add that role though, as medium is a very powerful role, evil roles already struggle to win, and medium does not "always get killed first"... ;)
@serene compass Hello, it is a known bug actually, could you please tell me your device and app version?
runic dragon
Iām just saying though
Cause sometimes med suicides which puts the whole game in jeopardy
I just think their should be a alternative role for med
uncut tusk
Suicides can happen with any kinds of roles, not necessarily strong villager ones š
Any strong player dying for one reason or another is game-changing
That's part of the game š
Maybe, if you're a ww, you get lucky and kill a strong role
Or maybe not
uncut tusk
Medium is already a very strong role š Buffing him is really not a good thing to do
serene compass
0.38.02 iphone xr @uncut tusk
uncut tusk
Thanks!
runic dragon
Add a register for we see how many roses did we spend for rose wheel (golden wheel)
^I wanna add to it, show how many gold we won from there
runic dragon
Change Host
Be able to give your host without need leave the room
Will appear a crown next to every player
If you click in that crown will appear a thing like this
The Gold Crown is to the Actual host
sudden dock
There should be an info section for the battle pass. One thing that could go into is the explanation behind item changes. FE:
Items in the battlepass may change at any time due to bugs, or confusion about the item.
fierce dragon
lament knoll
Heyaaa
@runic dragon and @runic dragon for your rose wheel feedback:
Want me to fuse it together?
These seem like two nice suggestions for the rose wheel ^^
But where should it be displayed tho?
Underneath your roses and coin count?
I took a few minutes to try to do an example of how it'd look like underneath that count, you can tell me if that's what you imagined or if i totally missed it and you just want me to post your suggestions without visual!
And be honest because it's your ideaš
I'll post it either way so just express what you think about it,, thanks for your suggestions
@runic dragon
For your other feedback, this has indeed been suggested before, but that was several months ago and didn't have a visual to it
I really like this idea honestly and i also love the execution of the visual, it looks good and gives off an idea of how it could look like
I'll post it for you! Thanks for your suggestion and have a nice day
runic dragon
@lament knoll i was thinking more in a "I" (Information) icon where you press and pop up a log with all the info: box u got, roses u spent, gold you got, icons you got and items you got
lament knoll
@runic dragon hmm could you circle a place where that "ā¹" would show up?
median elbow
Can we not have 2 of the same role in quick play again? It causes confusion to new players
lament knoll
Heyaaa @fierce dragon 
This has already been suggested before quite recently, you can add a onto it tho:
https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/636594338595471391
Thanks for your suggestion anyways and have a nice day
runic dragon
@lament knoll I think there's fine
lament knoll
Oki doki
runic dragon
You should be able to give for someone gold without buying the gold with real money but with the gold that you have
It was suggested before sort the items from your inventory? Like: All | Easter Eggs | Clan Quest | Special Offer
It looks nice with little "i"
Add the option to sell chests.
Each chest should be sold at the cost of 50 gold so that it's well balanced (if you are lucky enough you can get 500 or 150 gold u.u ).
sudden dock
There should be an info section for the battle pass. One thing that could go into is the explanation behind item changes. FE:
Items in the battlepass may change at any time due to bugs, or confusion about the item.
runic dragon
Since we got the option to not choose male or female it would be good if the bp doesent show male bp
And get male items from bp
But both
You get what im saying i guess
This is not only in bp
Its like male option nothing changes besides lootboxes
drowsy yarrow
i had 3 games
1st game the gunner was random shooting and people were suiciding
2nd game i say 10 was medium but 3 humans vote 10
and in the 3rd game 3 who was doc was repeating day1 "3 good" and "3=6" when detective was dead and that make him look like a fool
so maybe you should increase the lvl or wins to join ranked again
quaint bramble
@runic dragon We usually reject this kind of idea, because being able to trade gold, means you can watch unlimited ads and share the gold with their other accounts etc.
@runic dragon With the rarity colour, at the moment it's already pretty much sorted for offers and clan quests, imo
@runic dragon What would be the benefit of this idea? I think most of the time you could get more than 50 gold from them, and they dont take that much time to open š¤
runic dragon
@quaint bramble I see, I was thinking in something like that
quaint bramble
@sudden dock I don't think a BP-specific changelog is really needed, they hardly ever change anything and its usually really small things.
We already got suggestions for a proper patch notes button in-game, which would include this kind of changes too.
@runic dragon Hmm that looks nice, but I think we have gotten better suggestions that do similar things, such as sorting your items from new-old or being able to favourite them?
sudden dock
Ok cool
runic dragon
@quaint bramble well, I think since grey item=5 gold and blue one= 15 gold and most of the times you get 3 grey items it would be worth it...
Maybe you can increase the price to 75/100
sharp holly
There should be a option after you click the blue (?) button at the main page that shows the latest changes, especially role adjustments. This can help players know the changes and not find out only in a game itself
quaint bramble
@runic dragon No matter gender you have selected, you get both outfit versions from the BP.
It you havent selected one, then what should the BP tab show? :/
what you are saying only happens on daily rewards; the devs have refused that we can get both versions from it(sadly). It defaults to the male version if you havent set a gender, I kind of believe thats better than not giving outfitds at all, since male-style tends to be more usable for neutral people, than female.
@drowsy yarrow Im sorry but you know this gets suggested a lot, and as far as i know there's currently no plans to raise the entry level for ranked. You should report people who break rules, or try reminding them that they are wasting everyone's money and time ^^
@sharp holly We do need a proper patch notes button and this has already been posted to #feedback-devs a few times, gotten a š from Emanuel. So hopefully one day this will be a thing
sharp holly
one day?
quaint bramble
Yeah, I dont know how long it will take them obviously.
drowsy yarrow
i cant play much because of my work, when i finally got time and play 3 games back to back they went disastrously. so i'm little frustrated because i lost 100 skill points
quaint bramble
@median elbow Sorry for the very late response... the double aura seer in quickgame is very common, and i think it is listed clearly enough...
median elbow
@quaint bramble true that is very true but you got no idea how many random quick plays I've been in where this happens
I can get more evidence to backup my claim that 2 auras causes confusion if needed
runic dragon
It's also the designs who choose where his item goes?
There are a Earrings that are in Mask section and I would like use it in combination with mask (Would like it be moved to front icon)
median elbow
Or a category dedicated to ears
runic dragon
Well there are only 4/5 ears so I don't think they deserve a own category
I would like it tho
median elbow
(Reposting)
For the stonks make it so doubled xp is just a purchasable perk. I would buy this
@runic dragon I have like 4 mouths lol
runic dragon
But there are already a lot mouth and people is making them too often, earings aren't made often like that
primal notch
Ill suggest to add a bot in here talk to me and Ill respong what I mean from the bot to be added
kind nexus
1971 skill, nice ^^
runic dragon
Put two gender button to change at the moment which gender you want to see
Or make able to slide to change gender
Sorry for the workless edition
sudden dock
oh i like this 
novel fable
can a white space be added below the button too? bc currently the list content touches the categories text
vernal dune
@runic dragon earring idea, you're right! It should probably go in the front section, but if there is already a front item in the outfit it may be because of that
Gender idea is also a possible idea, so i'll add both suggestions to #feedback-devs! Thank you for the suggestions! 
@median elbow probably could exist, and as you see emanuel just saw the idea, so it might be good for #feedback-devs and it has no other problems. Thanks for the idea!
@primal notch we won't add bots here anytime soon unless they have a real purpose ^^
median elbow
@vernal dune It looks like he said yes to my idea lol
vernal dune
@novel fable this space already exists for the non-selected category, so I think it is fine at the moment. Thanks for the suggestion though
median elbow
Idk what he means by "1971 skill" but it sounds like he likes it already
Since it's a purchasable perk about skill
And skills/ranks don't really do anything tbh. It's just something that's there to give you grabbing rights and loot crates occasionally
runic dragon
@quaint bramble im not talking about daily rewards im saying that it shows the male skin in inventory insread of both
modest pebble
Fool and HH is also solo role. Thereās coin reward implication for this
normal wyvern
In addition to this: https://discordapp.com/channels/414179354814185498/452605920233652224/641871693316489234
Shouldn't this the same for the wheel of fortune then? I mean more people use the wheel of fortune so why don't add this to it either? Of course I meant the how much gold you got from it, roses either.
warm helm
@normal wyvern yes it should, i will post it to #feedback-devs, thanks for your feedback ā¤
@modest pebble hey, what do you mean with this or what is your feedback for that?
normal wyvern
Thank you very much ā¤
frozen mirage
New ability to sect (sect is very easy to kill)
SECT Sacrifice--SECT can to Sacrifice a player to kill (sacrificed player can't be revived by med)
If sect try to sacrifice a WW the werewolf will die
merry bobcat
let us have option to turn off talisman in custom mode for our own games. reason because i equip all the village talisman i have and i dont want them used in custom game yet it take too long to remove them all...
novel fable
this message makes it look like random shooting and suicide are allowed in other game modes, but it's not. it could be replaced by "disrespecting any rules will result in a harsher punishment than usually" or something like that
vernal dune
Hey @frozen mirage !
I disagree when you say sect is easy to kill, if the leader plans strategically and sects a doc or beast hunter, they can be protected rrom the werewolves!
Anyway, the idea itself is not that great because sect's goal is to convert everyone, not kill everyone. If they want to kill a ww, they would have to lynch him instead, else it would be too easy to get rid of them.
Thanks for the suggestion 
@merry bobcat there is already an option to disable talismans in custom games!
@novel fable
I agree with what you say and that it can be quite confusing. I'll add that in #feedback-devs
Thank you for the suggestion!
novel fable
ty
frozen mirage
@vernal dune good point :)
runic dragon
Add all the roles from werewolf ijln the online game like doubleganger
fallen rock
Some roles are not balanced
strange tusk
How can I become a mentor?!
runic dragon