#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages · Page 570 of 1
And a lot of the bigger animals already can't gain stam without resting too
@simple wasp so you mean if they want to nest they have to auto reveal their position to hostile megapacks which can then track them down and murder them? very bad idea.
a hostile mega pack of male maias smell a female maia with nest and go kill the female
as an example
yea dinos usually like there own species to it would be rare for something like that to happen
and i was saying it as if there wasnt a megapack
@valid zephyr if thats the case wouldnt the deinosuchus not have to eat for 4 real life days since they dont have to eat for a long time.
People that want to kill Will only see It as a easy kill, they wont care about being same species
ya @ ed the wrong person @simple wasp
yea but theres only 1 out of 5 people like that
i know
but i dont wanna retype it XD
you can just edit it?
There really isnt 1 to 5
Even then 1/5 is way too high for a obligatory decoy whenever you nest
it isnt as high as the amount of players that wont kill there own species without a good reasion
in officials packs of herbis wiping their own species is a daily thing
not for me
People just want blood
i rarely see it
also if i'm female and want to nest, i don't want every male player on the island being able to know my location
ive had the game since the acro was small and ive only seen that happen 30 times
but its not every male player
its every male of the same dino
I don't really see the point of that feature anyway. Why would the female even make a nest if they don't already have a male to fertilize it?
Rex, gigas and utahs do love canibalizing
yeah that's what i meant. still don't want it.
maybe it's because i play in basically the most toxic server in the entire game, but i prefer for only me and the people i'm nesting to know the location.
- a single male when they're needed
Nesting would be literally unviable for them
carnivores cannibalise constantly
and there is often a big maia or trike herd patrolling to kill their own species
Specially those i listed, larger playerbase=larger amount of idiots
i rarely see packs of the same dino killing the same species for carnivores yea but herbivores dont really kill there own that much
Ngl, if this was added I would probably use it to cannibalize. And I'm the type of person who hates it when people do that type of stuff
I'd argue that herbivores kill their own kind more than carnivores do
no i think carnivore kill there own more than herbivores
carnivore either do it for fun or for food
and herbivores would do it for fun
Carnivores usually pack up with their own species in my experience
There isnt really a difference between carni players and herbi players, people barely play like animals a player play a Utah and trike the same
Herbivores are more prone to being aggressive cause their playstyle is so boring right now
true but u can say the same as a carnivore
Not really. Being a carnivore is much more entertaining
since carnivores usually start megapacks
There are herbi megapacks too
But either way the nest thing isn't a very good idea because of how players are, its just unnecessary. Broadcasting could do the same thing
Too many bushes and too few herbis
well big herbi packs do need to migrate since they eat all bushes
well i see everyone with there crap suggestions and getting thumbs up and when i see a good suggestion it gets a thumbs down so i wanted to give a crap suggestion
but thats just my opinion
Well if that's your opinion, I don't see why you'd intentionally give a "crap suggestion" and then try to defend it
so i can see how many thumbs up i can get
but appearently theres something im not seeing
You're supposed to think the suggestion through, not just post one hoping to get thumbs up. Think about how players would use it and if it can be abused or not
Which one are you referring to?
the one where they wanted to add grass to bottom of swamp
Generally good suggestions get thumb ups and bad suggestion get thumb downs idk what you talking about
how is that a bad suggestion lmao
or certain plants you wouldnt even notice
That one doesn't need a lot of thought to it because it's a visual thing
all there asking is to put grass in water
And you would notice it because people are gonna be underwater now
short, sweet, simple, no downsides
its something u would glance and not even notice
vs dnos being able to actively track and possibly grief others nesting
It's something you don't notice but if t isn't there it looks bad
yea but wats the point of putting something if no one will notice it
Ambiance
but when someone gives a great suggestion it gets thumbs down
Dolphin ingame
i also have a example for that one too
Thats simply not true
id say people would notice it if theyre willing to thumb it
What's your example, parasyte?
@barren zephyr dude i like icthyo but spaming that Will only help people dislike it
plus were already getting underwater foliage, want that to be removed cuz no one will notice?
the suggestion that didnt get much attention as the "simple" ones was that deinosuchus should get a extreme ambush speed for 0.5 seconds to act as the deinosuchus launching out of the water to attack
isnt that already planned
Something like that is planned but not that exact thing for obvious reasons
Deino will be able to launch out of the water
But it won't be getting an extreme ambush speed. That could easily be abused
there was another good suggestion but i forgot that one
yea but its for a short amount of time
so it would be like it ambushed a dino that got too close to water
deinos getting its own "type" of ambush in the launch so why give it default ambush
i never even heard about the ambush its getting
did the ambush suggestion have a clock on it?
@barren zephyr itchthyosaurus ain't great for a river dolphin niche, Pannoniasaurus would be better because it could atleast haul itself to other rivers when one drys up
This ⏲️
yea
It means it's already coming
that means it coming
oh
So any suggestion that has ⏲️ means it's already planned or something vey similar to it is planned
but couldnt some random have placed it
Yeah, but then there would only be one
just because he THINKS its coming
And I don't see why they would do that
You can also tell how credible it is by seeing who put it there
And again, if it has a lot of timers, then it's coming
sometimes the facepalm emote means the same thing like the more recent scent color suggestion
@neat beacon I think it would look weird having Pteranodons with different wings and having them fly differently. I think it would be better if there were different flying animals that specialize in different ways of flying. Rather than one animal having different wing designs. Could be cool if it's purely cosmetic tho
I was thinking of just making it cosmetic too
Then you should probably change around the suggestion to reflect that lol
yea id be fine with slight cosmetic differences
just got inspired by this lol
I wouldn't be surprised if we're already getting that come to think of it. Dondi did say we'd be able to customize things like Trikes horns and stuff
yeaa, but having the same animal fly differently would be odd. save it for another flyer imo
So change it to cosmetic
Yeah
there
You should probably delete it and repost it actually, since the people who downvoted likely aren't gonna remove the downvotes lol
yea, its a completely different suggestion now p much
there
👌

since its pretty much like the theri
@wraith breach
XD
@left nacelle what do u mean what did I say wrong ?
Oh your suggestion came off as a joke to me, my bad. But you probably should post suggestions that are pee/poo related, they can get you a strike quite easily
lol
No it's not a joke
thats understandable hes pretty much asking the devs to make a turd
Animals do that in real
lol
We are getting scratching and stuff. But there won't be any sort of territory system or peeing or anything like that
A lot of people in the community can be weirdos and people will turn that into weird stuff
Scratches and urine will work
No urine
no urine
get ready bitsy you are about to be attacked XD
People will do very gross things with that
i thiink there was mention of mudbathing and scratching trees being planned
i got attacked for my last suggestion too
You didn't get attacked lol
you literally called it a "crap suggestion you posted for likes" of course you were
There were 4 of us explaining what was wrong with it
ik
Attacking would be insulting it and saying it's a shit idea, which it wasn't
LMAO imagine saying you were attacked when they explained some shit
i didnt say yall were insulting me
It was actually a pretty unique suggestion compared to other ones I've seen, it just wouldn't work in game
Kinda what attacking means
Nice
Ye just removet he urine part
There's gonna be lots of stuff. Scratching, tree rubbing etc
No there isnt lol
i might get a strike for saying that
yea but werent they gunna add them if they got 50 something likes
Add what
and it ended up exceeding it
No, that's up to the devs
bird im not saying it again XD
No matter how many likes it has it is all up to them
It was a joke lol
Yeah, they have to agree it
its hard to tell if they joke or not
what do you mean by "mating", like just needing a male and female or (god forbid) animations?
Uh, no
no...
Theyre not adding mating animations no matter how many likes or upvotes anything gets
Unless you wanna pay bryan yourself for all the fuckton of pain youre going to put him through, he's not doing them
Like in what world
someone might donate them 1 mil to do it
I've many good suggestions for the isle game only
They wouldnt even do it then
they wouldnt add it into the game
It's not happening. Dondi said its not happening. Bryan would literally refuse to do it. You're not even allowed to joke about mating animations in general discussion anymore.
Nines is right they aren’t adding mating animations there is no need for it
dont joke about mating animations anywhere
Big facts
@ebon atlas that's already a thing that dondi showed off less than a week ago. It seems like footprints will remain yellow and I agree to that, adds more mystery as to "someone walked this way, should I go to them?". But water will be blue colored, plants will be green and I'm guessing (it hasn't been shown off yet) bodies/meat/gore will be red
someone might donate them 1 mil to do it
why is everyone so sensitive with that XD
The whole ass dev team is so against it
why the hell do ya'll want dinosaurs to literally have sex, damn
Playing animation is fine
it's not sensitive, it's disgust
i can understand the devs not liking it but why the viewer/player
its fucking gross thats way
I do not want porn in the isle
why
because its gross af
Because its nasty and its annoying when fuckers have been asking for this shit for years. We dont need dino sex in the game. It aint a porn game. Its a horror game.
i can understand the devs not liking it but why the viewer/player
@simple wasp because i dont want to see two dinosaurs fucking in the woods
I'm against porn anyway
yes it is, we don't want scalie porn on the game that's all man, and I may sound blunt but it's the truth at least in my opinion
i would love to go in front of everyone and just do that XD
what the fuck
wtf is wrong with you

Can this person get yeeted
everyone
Like, fuckin please.
what's wrong with this guy 
Stop trolling
everything i mean
yeah no wonder
im not i swear to god im serious
im not i swear to god im serious
@simple wasp even worse
What the actual fuck is wrong with you
Nasty ass imma just block and hope you get gone soon
U have troll in blood u don't even know
fuck it goodbye <@&401466542140817419>
im not saying i like it im saying it would be funny to disgust everyone
It would not be funny period.
It would be absolutely disgusting.

Uuuh
you'd just be a creep doing that
hi mei
what do u even mean
do u go and do the thing in front of other people for fun or what
damn well srry for saything anything
like you'll be known as the creep and be avoided by everyone in the game
damn yall are saying im a troll look at all of u teaming up on one person
it's a horror game not a "fantasy" or whatever
i mean ofc
do u even know what u are talking about
because you are a troll
lets switch topic
Because you're absolutely gross af.
did u expect us to agree with u or smth, wth
gross and funny are 2 different thing and funny is the word
I'm moving on
What is going on?
if it's funny for u it aint funny for others
im being attacked by words
they want dino porn in game
Mating animations, CMG.
basically
I'm really confused of what is going on, but please keep it civil
mating animation stuff again
i didnt say i wanted mating animations
Like, just read parasyte's messages
YOU JUST DID
yes you did
just scroll up and u can see some of the stuff they were saying, its kind of gross
you did tho
u just did though??
i said it would be funny
Guys, chill
shit
I'm calm 🙌 idk about others, I'm more shocked than anything
it turned from a joke into some serious shit
it turned from a joke into some serious shit
@simple wasp o rly https://discordapp.com/channels/401464048610312193/423939730544132096/718903218096177152
Ok stop ✋ think about better ideas
mating animations have been "joked" around with and suggested a lot btw
Guys, drop it
ok
yes ma'am
ok
no it wont
its fine lol, you didnt push it and the scratching leaving tracks was only briefly mentioned on one of dondi's streams
I hope they still work on scratches and marks
i already made the mistake once im not gunna do it again XD
they will probably be worked on, for tracking specially
and well, mudbaths will hide your scent too so the marks will definetly be a thing
i think dondi said mudbaths wouldnt leave a scent but youd be able to clearly see that someone used it
and then maybe footprints from the mud would only be visual and not sniffable? thatd be kinda cool
dont know but yeah you'll be able to tell someone wallowed on the mud
@barren zephyr I could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure they're making allo an endurance hunter. Meaning it'll have high stamina and will chase things down, like we used to do back in the good ol' days
I mean, with that speed boost it got
Combined with super stam
It aint gonna be a good time for smalls
Oh yeah, didn't even think about that 
mfw they seem to be pushing allo as an ambush predator 
Yea I think allo needs to be ambush hunter to be fair to the smols
Especially with the size buff
No need for it to have crazy endurance
Give it insane speed for short distances
I don't think it'll be that bad. Seemingly everything's getting a speed buff. So it'll probably all balance out
I hope so because speedy allo sounds scary to smols
Eh i think some dinos, like rex, cerato, rugops etc shouldnt be punished for cannibalism
Agreed. I think mainly the non-social ones shouldn't be punished
Some should be rewarded even i think, might be too far tho idk
i think i remember hearing, way way back, about penalties for cannibalism under normal circumstances being planned (with the exception of Ceratosaurus or something, there was talk about a niche for a super-scavenger that could digest rotted flesh and that of its own kind)
not sure if these are the current plans, though
Uea cerato should just be able to eat any meat, be it rotten or cannibalism. Carno and rugops i think could be cannibals because there has been evidence of abelisaurid cannibalism.
And rex cannibalism would likely just be a side effect of eliminating competition
Maybe the animals that are meant to be solitary could be rewarded for cannibalism. Like apexes or carnos
Yeah or depending on niche, if herrera does snag the monitor lizard niche, it could eat juveniles but be discouraged from killing other adults for food
I made a suggestion about cannibalism a while ago and it got 40+ thumbs up but a few people didn't like it and I'm kinda curious why
Not a fan of making it based on "artifical" limits, social or otherwise. Cannibalism should be something you do when there's either no other food, or simply the most common food source, but I'd rather see the punishment in that you should want/need your own kind around, at the very least one other for nesting, and obviously packs need a pack to function well so.
That wouldn't be an artificial limit tho. If your animal gets sick from eating it's own kind, it's gonna make you not wanna do it. You could still do it, but you'd get sick
Outright preventing you from eating a corpse of your own species is an artificial limit
weren't carnos cannibals or something? it might be some other dino
Yeah, Buff just said that earlier
oop i didn't look back in the thread far enough then
Uea cerato should just be able to eat any meat, be it rotten or cannibalism. Carno and rugops i think could be cannibals because there has been evidence of abelisaurid cannibalism.
Here's what they said ☝️
@cunning tide Mapu and carcha are literally just giga but a little teensy bit different looks-wise
Also
They could potentially end up as alternate skins for giga or acro maybe?
Yeah thats about it
Adding photos doesnt make them not giga clones
Majungasaurus was seen to have cannibalised IRL
Aint majunga
Its mapu
Would perform no different from giga
And carcha's so similar they turned that into the juvi giga model
Did they? 😮 I had no idea
Mhm.
Huh... you learn something new every day, I guess – or rather, night 😆
Anyways yes, I agree. All abelisaurids should be able to cannibalise in The Isle
Maybe not all but i can agree at least some of em should be able to cannibalize
Personally I think Changyuraptor would work better than archaeopteryx. It's a good bit larger and could actually interact with other animals in the ecosystem
archaeopteryx isnt a good idea for the game
Perhaps honestly I was just looking for a glider with better turn radius than ptero
Its a neat animal but its very small
It was also the only glider I knew
Slightly larger glider might be a bit better
arche might not even glide tho
Ik
microraptor and changyuraptor do glide
But either way it's still an aerial creature
With better turn radius
That was my thought process
You liked your own suggestion
and changyuraptor is actually sizable
why?
I didnt say u have to I was just asking mb
this is a close up of a barberry bush with no leaves.
the thorns arent that sharp if your slow.
@plucky widget Mercs aren't getting growth. Also this:
me when death
@plucky widget you trolling for sure
@steep dune
I see
Yep lol
I was gonna suggest something like Deino being based off of a snapping turtle but I figured that would be received poorly
Deino being based off a snapping turtle wouldn't make much sense considering it's literally a crocodile lol
Oh you mean Hypo deino? That makes more sense lmao
As far as I know tho, there isn't gonna be a Hypo deino
or am i @sudden hinge
@indigo sun Good idea! It kind of looks like a pigeon though 😛
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/d8/Changyuraptor.png
“More ceratopsians isn't a bad idea”
With all ceratopsians in the database we have 7, don't think we need more lmao. Also mapusaurus and carchardontosaurus are just giga with slight size adjustments, skins at best not new apexes
And even then, any more apexes would be too much for the ecosystem
Isnt the isle set on a tropical island? Doubt there'd be snowy winters
There'd likely be a wet and dry season
Yes, I said that it wouldn't make sense on the current map, because it's a tropical island.
That's why it would be something for future maps, that maybe are set in another climate zone
The old mod maps like the snow map and the tundra forest will probably make a comeback too anyhow
You have a point
Yeh
Now that I think of it
Yeah
I’ll try to see if there is anything special about Rajasaurus
Alright
I see that unlike Carnotaurus, Rajasaurus was actually able to head but creatures, and was primarily an ambush predator so it probably would have a bit lower ambush speed than an allo, and would have a tiny bit more control of turning than carnotaurus, and it could bite down on creatures with its mouth always open like an allo, so it most likely could be able to cause bleed 1 when biting. But this seems like a buffed up allo and I can tell by its skull that it probably had worse eyesight than a carno or allo, including night vision. But this is all an idea
abelisaurids were generally slow ambush hunters with explosive acceleration. and progression is irrelevant as its been replaced by survival.
Also, Rajasaurus would most likely not be as *t h i c c * as in other depictions
Oh
Now if feel old
dont get me wrong i like raja but i dont see how it can fit into the roster with cerato allo and sucho existing.
It’s okay, it’s only an idea
If I really was desperate into getting into the game, I would most likely remove some traits to make it a unique creature in the game, like removing bleed with a really good sent ability, I don’t know any dinosaurs that are based off using sent
rex was stated to have much stronger scent than utah but that doesn't mean its unique. lots of animals have good scent.
I also want to suggest lythronax, but I don’t have any real reason to have it in the game
It would basically just be an Alberto that does a lot of bleed, therefor it’s just an allo
1.) Youre not supposed to just say "oh buff this thing" why does it need the buff? How does it affect other players?
2.) Haven't you not played the game in like, forever? Have you played allo recently?
Allo's fine as it is, though everything is getting a speed increase for some reason
the speed boosts are probably cause the map is getting bigger and it'll be easier to travel
the speed boosts are mostly to be more accurate and fit more things into the roster.
ITA?
what do you mean ITA?
@supple talon do you mean ETA? 'caus if so just check #announcements
any italian players?
This is not the channel to ask
not the right chat
Who goes to islecord, sees #general-feedback-discussion and says "i think thats a good channel to ask for people to play"
that guy ^^^^
@zenith onyx I like that suggestion. Could be cool for a little "hard mode" too. Become elder and try surviving without a perk
no, once you choose the perk you shouldn't be able to change it mid-game
'cuz its too easy to equip the perk whenever you want, you could abuse it and change the perk depending on what you are doing
if you choose the wrong perk that's on you, next playthrough you'll know what to choose.
They never said "change it" they said remove it
Therefore, you remove the perk and then no perk
removing it wouldnt be too bad as long as you dont get to swap it out, so yuh i think itd be pretty interesting (elder w no perk)
Yeah, I think you should add that it outright removes the perk @zenith onyx. Some people seem to think that you mean you can swap it mid game
I think that should be mandatory
You think what should be mandatory?
That you can remove and swap out perks when you select your dinosaur
you shouldn't have to have the same perks and not be able to remove them the entire time you play the game
Well that probably will be a thing considering you'll probably only be able to have so many perks at a time
Yea
Maybe if you remove a perk you get half or less of the points back?
You shouldnt be able to swap it out mid game, it can be abusable/if you make it to the next life swapping it out would be better.
🤔
@worldly igloo Megalania would be a better fit for what you described imo. It's quadrupedal, it's fast, and it's bigger
And Megalania's already confirmed
Prestosuchus > Kaprosuchus
and long leg kapro is so fucking dead they found the paleo art of it right next to the fossils of the first sponges
Gonna be honest here, not sure why the Kapro suggestion is getting so much shit.
Cause a ton of people have suggested kapro in the past, that people are biased against it
You'd probably need a really really good kapro suggestion for it to get any notable amount of upvotes
Kapro is cool but imp presto would just be a more viable/unique land croc in general
Why people dont like this suggestions
Cause there's other animals that would work better for what they described
And kapro is constantly being suggested
Between baryonix for semiaquatic and prestosuchus for more land oriented croc it would probably be invalidated
And what they described sounds kinda like what Megalania could be like. Which is an animal that's already coming
@left nacelle Yes you are right
I think it would be nice to add carcharodontosaurus to the game
new apex
Carchar is literally just Giga
dont think so
It's probably gonna be a Giga skin in the future
The devs have said that
Plus we don't really need anymore apexes. More apexes would be too much for the ecosystem imo
Only real diff between carchar and giga is the snout/ridge shape
Not even close to making it a unique animal
look at this head
Yeah, the head's different. That's it lol
this is cool man why dont like
Cause it costs the devs over $7000 to add a new animal
It would basically be like adding daspleto when we have alberto, basically the same dino
So they can't just add an animal cause it looks "cool"
It has to be unique and add something to the game
carcha is just giga.
You're a bit late lol
I do. I have no life 
@drifting ingot Pretty sure that's already coming, but I'm not 100% positive. Feel like I've heard it somewhere
oh fr? if so thats awesome
is patiently waiting for another yut suggestion
I'd be surprised if it doesn't tbh. Dondi's a bit of a perfectionist. I don't think he wants you just swimming across a flowing river
I can only say that carcharodontosaurus and Giga are both a very different predator and Carcharodontosaurus is very unique and has a unique tooth
How is Carchar unique?
The suggestion was for him to be a nocturnal glass cannon ambusher i think
Even the devs have said it isn't unique enough to be it's own animal. It's most likely just gonna be a DLC skin for Giga in the future
^
Troodon is tiny and deals DoT tho
they have very different body structures and lots of sharp teeth
exactly troo without venom but twice its size.
Not a big fan of yut i just think the suggestion was not bad lol. It is a high flat dps ambusher
Could say dilo is just a bigger troodon lol
giga body carc body
guys is titanoboa confirmed for the future? i see a lot of people talking about it
Oh god prehistoric wildlife
prehistoric wild life is bad 1 2 those arent compared 3 carch is legit a giga clone in every way.
you guys understand little ? please
carch is more of a giga clone than tarbo is a rex clone.
guys is titanoboa confirmed for the future? i see a lot of people talking about it
filipe said it was greenlit by dondi
If you didn't look at the key on the side, you wouldn't know which is which
or shant and edmontosaurus.
big snake time
Not really
this is wrong body
since he said its gonna take a long time to get added
No it's not lol
Also carchar is literally just a giga clone
look at spino
Prehistoric wildlife is wrong body
Prehistoric wildlife charts are also generally exaggerated
Just cause the spino in that one is a bit inaccurate doesn't mean they all are
They made spino fat, the size is still correct
The spino is a bit fatter and the sail is the wrong shape. That's it
carc body is not thick, slightly long , okay ?
looks do not determine what is unique or not
it is playstyle
Carchar would do exactly what giga does
Juvie giga ingame is using carchar model
Thats how not unique it is
But this face dont like giga you guys dont understnad
just different face
body size
and make carc
z3erk3r your argument is invalid.
Its literally just giga with stat variations
But it would be just like giga, and we don't need any more apexes
post it in memes if you want to.
And not ones that are large enough to create a playable
bi sktr git mk
Mrgh what don't you like about my idea? just curious-
I dont feel like sitting on a nest for X period of time only just to have it be infertile
fair.
@frank notch That would take up slots in the nest too
it incentivizes players to sit and do nothing and females wont be able to nest without a male.
They are diff species
But ingame they would function the exact same way z3rk
Which means they arent a good playable
Zerk, that's an inaccurate picture
ok, i just thought it might be a good idea because juvie ovis are going to have a difficult time-
all charodontosaurians from 120-90 mya are very similar the most different ones being acro and tyrannotitan.
@frank notch Ovi isn't just gonna eat eggs fyi. It's an omnivore
The animals appearance isnt what matters
its the playstyle
How would you make carchar different to giga in how it plays, without making it just another acro or rex or spino or giga
look at this face different
acro is not even a carcharodontosaur anymore i think might be an allosaurid.
ache- forgot about that xD
Ovi won't even be the only animal eating eggs either lol
acro is also slow and heavy made to be bulky carch giga and mapu were all faster.
acro is a train
well- dont you think the eggs spoiling makes sence?
ok.
and rotten eggs also smell horrible and make you horribly sick.
🤢 👉 🥚
RNG isn't exactly a good gameplay idea imo
yeah-
RNG is only good for certain things
welp every suggestion i've given isnt good ima just give up...'
me when chonker
🍰 🍰 🍰 🍰

acro was hella heavy and its build made it slower.
😉 😉
If it makes you feel any better Z youll probably see this used as a skin in the future and pretend its a unique animal
i need to know current carc fosil
love that model
Hi everyone, I just saw that my comment on Kaprosuchus coming to The Isle was not well received at all. And I just wanted to ask why bringing Kaprosuchus to The Isle would be a bad idea?
scroll up
:(
"Muh favorite dino isn't in the game, add it into the game dwandwi"
Hi everyone, I just saw that my comment on Kaprosuchus coming to The Isle was not well received at all. And I just wanted to ask why bringing Kaprosuchus to The Isle would be a bad idea?
main issue i got with kapro is due to being the size of a modern croc, i doubt itll be to effective at doing stuff
Like, even if you go down the fictionalized long legged route, the bugger prolly wouldnt outrun anything that is a threat to em such as utah
Nor defend itself from em. Plus there exists better options land croc wise such as prestosuchus, who is like 400kg larger than cerato iirc
why people dont want apex
Cuz there aint many apex carnis you can add which are unique '
Carchar being one of em
bary
why baryonx has low atk damage
Your favorite dino shouldn't be determined by it stats anyway
utah 
Out of The Isle's animals, mine is Ptera. Out of prehistoric animals in general, my favorite is Anzu. But I have a lot of favorites
and ovi
I know Carc won't be added to the game, but I wish it was added 😕
It'll be a DLC skin for Giga
Like it'll make Giga look like Carchar, and give it different sounds. It might even give it different animations too
I think it would be nice if the carc tail is longer
It might be. It won't just be a texture change, it'll be a full on model change
Think of it kinda like (for lack of a better comparison) Fortnite. You get skins that completely change the look and model of things, but they function exactly the same
yes i understood what you mean
It will be nice to fly with Pteradon i want to play so much
Yeah. They're planning on doing that as DLC after the game comes out of Early Access. A Carchar skin for Giga was one of the only examples they gave actually
Yeah, I'm gonna be playing ptera a lot
lets make ptera pack
Well Ptera won't be out for a while lol
But if we come across each other in game, we can do that
I don't think carno will be in before Ptera
Ptera and Deino are likely to be the first ones added after Utah and Tenonto
Me when dryo 
i feel like Allosaurus has a good chance of being one of the first, as their implementing the utah pounce to work into the Allo's "huggies"
Cant f***ing wait to see that omg
allo is a bit to large to be in the first few.
allo will likely come after the first 14 and their counterparts.
Will the Dieno be able to snatch a Rex and drag it into the water
terrorbird is basically just a galli that vores juvies instead of kicking them
no need for it
A presto sounds like a good Idea, it would be scary as hell!🤣
a prestosuchus suddenly bursts out of the bushes
"PRESTO!!!"
“PRESTO CHANGO MOTHERF*CKER”
it just fits so well lol
It could out run predators, could fight back if caught off guard, and most importantly it has INFINITE MEME POTENTIAL!!
Will the Dieno be able to snatch a Rex and drag it into the water
@hasty light you seriously over estimate your overweight alligator
I would AT LEAST think the Dieno could pull in a sub mid-tear carnivore or even a just grown adult mid-tear carnivore like allo, cerato, or carno
cerato is not a mid tier carnivore
Pretty sure the biggest thing it can reliably take in is dibble
and thats spotty, because the dibble size is debated
“These are confusing times”
dibble is getting shrunk and deino might be upscaled and dondi still said that dibble might still be too big
the devs dont want cenozoic creatures in the game. could be a mod but its still just a dromeasaur that has a beak and big feet without arms.
the devs dont want cenozoic creatures in the game. could be a mod but its still just a dromeasaur that has a beak and big feet without arms.
Megalania and pelagornis are 2 cenozoic animals which the devs have shown support to add
One which is already confirmed
But yea, terror birds would prolly be a bit too similar to either utah or carno to work imo
megalania is different though.
i hate digging up quotes on discord because of how flawed the system is.
If Megalania has a big chance to come to The Isle does that mean there is a super small chance for something Prestosuchus to come because it would be another more land based quadrupedal carnivorous reptile?
i hate digging up quotes on discord because of how flawed the system is.
its better than twitch clips
How many fliers are confirmed? Or is it just ptero rn?
I guess Quetzal is somewhat confirmed because it was in the early game
ptera is the only confirmed one
quetz would need a remodel and some touch ups, and pela is like soft confirmed
Nice
So I heard about dinosaurs having skins?
Has anyone talked about dracorex being a pachy skin?
dracorex is basically the new juvie pachy model
it would be cool to see nontheless
Oh
Yeah dracorex is one of my fav dinos, looks badass.
May I ask who tapwing is? Is he an official or just a fan of the isle who does art?
I think Tapwing was a fan art creator that got hired to work on The Isle
That is what I heard tho so idk
tap is a dev
tapwing used to make fan art for the isle, but got hired as a dev
Ah, so what I was seeing was prob fan art from before he got hired (if what u said was true)
Because I saw hypo quetz, tisso stego, etc and thought it had to be from a fan because I heard herbs wont be getting strains.
Thnx for the info
tap's a girl btw
Octopi and squids is a pretty good idea on paper but if they are playable how would it work and if they are AI would there be a buff you get from eating them because if they give you the same rewards as eating any other AI creature what would be the point of trying to find it while it is camouflaged and then catch it in the water while it’s shooting ink, or it would be just to damn fast. Like I said I like the idea but the main problem is how would it work?
considering they are mollusks and of high intelligence, they'd probably give more food
Seems legit
Lol
to be fair, squid aren't intelligent
octopus are though
also, intelligence won't effect food they'd give. not like there's enough brains in there for a big nutrition boost
It’s more of a fun little game you play for a reward, I definitely don’t see them being playable though
Like an easier way to get a new thing rather than needing to properly make it to elder every time
How would y'all feel about a flying blood sucking dino?
Annoying, but I’m intrigued.
Kinda reminds me of Redbilled Oxpackers.
As in the dinosaur would be annoying
Atopo would basically be water dryo, maybe he can bury himself in the mud to hide too
Atopo is very original and deserve some love
way more than lurdu which is already in BoB and that is not actually proven semi-aquatic
why people dont want terror bird in the isle ?
deinocheirus would be a very cool addition to the isle @wraith breach
Utah and galli already do what terrorbirds would do
yea plz thumb up
but not big terrorbirds
so they know we want it :)))
@wraith breach The devs already know we want Deinochierus
i imagine it would be mostly herbrivore, eating vegetation from muddy swamps it would live in
oh
Also this, bitsy
well i wish there was a vote on deinochrus
Dondi jokingly said that it isn't coming. That doesn't mean it isn't, but if it is, we won't have it anytime soon
i can help u with explaining why it should be added bitsy
it would have been unique gameplay
okay he said if you post a new dino explain why and whats unique about it
@wraith breach What is it called?
deinocheirus
i think most unique thing about it is apex omnivore that we dont have
Okay but that's not unique enough
Ah right, thanks
it would live at very muddy swamps, where is not enough water for deino and spino to ambush it
Making an animal costs $7000+. Being an apex omnivore isn't enough
it looks like camel that eat meat
it would be so big, its strenght or big healt bar would help escape or fight
Right, so would you be able to just eat bushes and stuff and still survive, or would you need to eat both?
its galli family member
apex semi-aquatic herbrivore hunting fish
It doesn't really bring anything to the game tho. It's just a big omnivore. That's it
Right, thanks
no, its a big omnivore that live at water
is it semi aquatic jhonny?
almost
Beipi's also an omnivore that lives at water
oh cool like bears
So the water omnivore thing is already taken
but i imagine it spend most of its time at swamp
And then it would get destroyed by deinos
Beipi's also an omnivore that lives at water
@left nacelle but its small
it would live at very muddy swamps, where is not enough water for deino and spino to ambush it
@past berry
But there are no swamps like that on that map
its stronger than sucho
That would be a bad idea
Cause then everyone would go to those swamps where it's safe and the deinos would starve
If ya want Cheirus to be added, add a bit more uniqueness to it
like deinocheirus
I'm not opposed to Cheirus but I don't think that suggestion is detailed enough
More detail. Things that can make it more unique other than it being big
many creatures are modified
whats unique about spino and sucho?
Spino is a large semi-aquatic that'll run on the bottom of lakes like a hippo but can also compete with other apexes on land
Sucho is a large piscivore that eats fish but doesn't really swim to catch them, like a bear
i have read about life of dienocherus
all i know is that its omnivore and it can live without meat
or without grass
Well obviously it can live without grass. Grass didn't exist near it when it was alive
he doesnt need to wait for herd to come across lakes
maybe....
what grass didnt exist?
reduced fall camage thx to the massive body build

Grass didn't exist until right before the dinosaurs went extinct
reduced fall camage thx to the massive body build
@past berry That doesn't make much sense
But if it lives in a swamp it wouldn't need to worry about fall damage anyway
ik
lets say herb instead of grass
To me, Cheirus just seems like an omnivorous spino/theri. Or a large Beipiao that doesn't swim
it says
Actually BlueBird, I think grass might've just existed while Deinocheirus was alive... 🤔
that it was stronger than theri
@pale sorrel Yeah, I realized that, which is why I edited it to say it didn't live near grass. Cause grass wasn't all over the planet at that time
theri had swords instead of claws
lol
bitsy
blades
How about it's a wading omnivore, who is heavy enough to defend against the apexes of its area and not particularly fast. Its main diet would consist of fish and underwater plants, but it could eat a beipiao or younger deino if it had the chance to catch it.
And adult deinos could be it's main threat
How about it's a wading omnivore, who is heavy enough to defend against the apexes of its area and not particularly fast. Its main diet would consist of fish and underwater plants, but it could eat a beipiao or younger deino if it had the chance to catch it.
@indigo sun yes, but i dont think it would eat that big land prey
and @indigo sun yes good idea
You don't think it would eat beipiaos, Johnny? They're like the size of it's hand lol
Neither juvenile deinos or beipiao are really big land prey.
it would just like bears
i would say hatchlings or compys
Compys would do nothing for it
They both live in the same environment as it, it could totally kill and eat them
They're like microscopic compared to it
ok, ok
The only way to make cherry more unique that I can think of is IF shallow swamps and marshes get added, and IF that would be it's natural habitat, then maybe it would could traverse though the mud better? As in other animals could get stuck or would become very slow, but cherry could still walk fast? Or give it the ability to dig for food, but I'm not sure if that's very unique
i said that
other thing about deinocheirus is that humans in the isle can tame it and feed herb to them xD
like camel
Meh
nonononon
Bitsy you have to explain mechanics and abilities apart from why they should add it
Yeah no taming
But I can't really think of anything else other than it being a bigger, more bulky theri
lol
Enslaving not taming
you cant compare it to theri
and why deinocheirus? We already have theri
theri cant survive without herb
But I can't really think of anything else other than it being a bigger, more bulky theri
@ebon crypt more swampy theri
HHH i can get my suggestion for the two I made a while back to explain how deinocheirus is not theri because i hate that argument
survival chances of deinocherius is 100
Possibly, but I don't know enough about this animal to really contribute to this discusion
lets remember deinocheirus cannot be unbeatable
how
Suggestions huge nevermind ill just say the basics of it
dinos are very expensive
and trike a carnivore
Thats crazy
thats non sense
Cheirus is less of a theri clone than giga is to Rex, yet we have both
buuuut
But Cheirus and Theri have similar anatomy
Also true, cheirus is Closer to galli
Theres no problem with theri, it wont look dumb being omni
On the same way as beipi
so it would be bigger, slower, stronger, swampy galli
fact is fact*
I don't think omni theri's a good idea tho. it would encourage them to hunt stuff
Unless you limit them somehow
it doesnt look slower
I don't think omni theri's a good idea tho. it would encourage them to hunt stuff
@left nacelle
You just dont buff too much the speed and problem solved
i want to compare it to a camel
make omni theri balanced
Therizinosaurus: Herbivore, uses its long claws to eat fruits and high leaves. Lives in the forest. It can run, and its claws do bleed but not a ton of raw damage.
Deinocheirus: Omnivore, wades in swamps and eats the fish and underwater plants. It can hit heavy, and can't run incredibly fast.
It's literally that simple
and it would run faster its galli family so it shud run faster?
Theyre ya go hon
not as fast as galli
"But the both have feathers long necks and Big arms they are the same"
They can be different animals even if they look kinda similar
Being in the same family doesn't mean they all run fast
But yall always wanna bitch about theri clone
Making theri an omnivore doesnt even feel right
I really prefer theri to avoid clone dinos
I dont even like cheirus, but the theri clone argument is yikes
no omni theri its a cute peaceful herbivore bird
Giga and Rex are literally clones by that logic
Diablo's just a worst triceratops
thats not
troodon is just a clone of sucho, utah, dilo
Oro is just smaller dryo
they have different morphology so different playstyles
giga is blleding rex
Thats ya logic hon
dibble is just a faster sub trike
If you act like that everything is similar
with no stmp
Its like:
rhino is big warthhog
Goat is small bull
its dumb to compare like that
They have different playstyles
Name Deinocheirus
Prehistoric Era Late Cretaceous
Classification Omnivore
Order Saurischia
Suborder Theropoda
Weight 7 – 9 tons (6.35 – 8.16 tonnes)
Length 33 feet (10 meters)
Height 12 feet at the hips (3.66 meters)
Maximum Speed 17 mph or faster
Territory Mongolia
do you think there was swamp or water in mongolia at that time
i doupt deino is swampy boi
The animals can behave entirely differently and provide two completely different playstyles but because it looks kinda similar we cant have it cause then it's a clone. The only similar shit is that theyve got feathers, stand upright, have claws (which, mind you, arent even the same length) and long necks. Wow. By that logic all therapods especially the carnivorous ones are all the same shit. Theyre all basic ass bitch dinosaurs but yall still keep addin em in anyways
Also the fact that cheirus would be a slow juggernaut while theri is a fast glass canon, yeah totally the same
But why adding deinocheirus if theri is getting rework and can have deinocheirus niche?
Because theri can have theri niche
If we're so concerned about clones, lets just forget about acro and alberto

Its like suggesting yutyrannus, when its just a feathered allo
Lets remove diablo while we're at it
Its totally not like that
We literally provided two different niches the animals could fill
And which different mechanics can have that theri cant have?
If we make theri to behave like cheirus we are losing theri in the proces
Why would you push theri into behaving like something else when it can have an entirely different playstyle
And which different mechanics can have that theri cant have?
@barren zephyr swamp
And we have beipi as omnivore therizinosaurid
but smol
yea stop compareing dinosaurs every dinosaurs is different from other. even terror bird is different.
Its ridiculous to add deinocheirus
One fishes is tanky and slow, the other is totally terrestrial not tanky at all and fast
terror bird utah and gallis are different
Like, i feel like i explained that shit pretty well did I not?
Do i need to repost it for you? Is there shit i need to clarify?
We have beipi at swamp and omnivore and theri on land to eat plants
This is just another "i dont personally like It so It shouldnt be here"
cheirus is a waste of sources
Yeah thats literally what this is
From now on imma just say any animal you want is a waste of resources
cheirus is a waste of sources
@barren zephyr u are a waste of sources
xD
But beipi is fucking 90kg while cheirus is 9000kg, a fucking 100x size difference
u r a waste of source lolllll
Literally totally different
beipi cannot have the same playstyle
Do you just not want big omnivores?
i do
You can say you dont want big omnivores
There are other options for apex omnivores
@barren zephyr why you dont like deino
but someone dooonttt
Is like saying we shouldnt have trike because we already have ava and stego
whats wrong with it
Then offer some, hon
i love it
or directly none apex omnivores
Its simply stupid
Thats not dragon
said someone wih a JP dilo
Cant have kentro now, we've already got stego
its a drawing of a website dude
Actually lets remove trike and stego altogether so that its fine for kentro and diablo to exist
They were just clones anyway
oh yes! what a great idea!
This whole argument is stupid, just for the fact that we already have both Rex and giga




