#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages Ā· Page 538 of 1
Then there's no reason for people to complain about it if it won't even be flared out like that all the time lol
well among other issues, honestly with troodon they should've just went with feathers on troodon and you'd be golden
I see
well still wouldn't call it idea, but I can live with that, I guess
Looks wise idm compy and troodon not being too diff. Troodon is quite a bit larger especially if ya look at the new thing in isle phase two.
They're different enough to be unique
tbh no
Like troodon looking like the silhouette of a person when standing straight up
honestly at a distance in gameplay I ccan actually see the two getting conflated, though that's not my concern really, it's that they made them really similar looking for no reason, both these animals look pretty different IRL so why would they just make them the same is both confusing and dissapointing
They honestly don't look that similar
They're different enough to distinguish the two easily
well not really, both of them are almost the same thing at a glance ignoring the disparity in size, as in super thin lanky small theropods which is dissapointing cause troodon is actually a really cool and interesting animal, honestly ignoring the drama and focusing purely on the designs POT has the better troodon model than the isle which is dissapointing cause the isle has the better artists
@hollow river @icy lion @pine sparrow @daring cosmos Remember to chat in here and not in #general-feedback
you got it cheef
ya big goof
im dum dum (ty)
I will say, the Utah pounce and the animations im seeing for it, with the instant kill by the trike, and hopefully other dinos... really makes utah more interesting. I cant wait to see the future for it.
@barren zephyr @hollow river @strange wave explain how a more distinctive herrerasaurus would be a bad thing
that's like removing dilo's notch, removing a distinctive anatomical trait of the dinosaur
and saber-esque teeth are very much cooler than a generic theropod head
nobody talked about this monster
your opinion
doesnt make it a bad suggestion
and look at this not all that distinct is it
never said Vlad's model was better
nobody talked about the reduced teeth
you could argue it since it's closer to the real deal while the other looks even more generic
ideally it'd have some soft tissue covering the teeth, but overall the main issue is that the skull isn't tall enough
and just like the spino its not changing and i honestly dont care
guess we like to settle for less then š¤·āāļø
@still temple not to sound brash, but I do notice that a lot in the isle community
anyway I think this is a pretty good depiction even if it isn't herrerasaurus itself I think I captures the inherant charm in herrerasaurs https://66.media.tumblr.com/f302ec74a9f277278bc14520206b992e/tumblr_nszubvCv2G1rj34fvo1_1280.jpg
Wait... did someone not like the new Spinosaurus? Heathens! Spino is a Gawd @_@
tbh the new one looks way too much like an american alligator, though it's spino so who cares
I mean, to be frank, we have no idea how dinosaurs were supposed to look anyway, but based on the skull, theres nothing wrong with the Spino having a allergatoery head.
people were complaining about "da skull is too short WA"
I mean, I guess it is kind of but meh
I also dont care
it looks AMAZING as it is
but just like to nitpick stupid shit that doesnt really matter
as its gonna be the same thing in a half week everybody will forget about it
The Deino and the Spino are the two im looking most forward to right now. I mean, if the Giga rework is great then that as well.
Im just hoping that the game will actualy be fun and enjoyable instead of a Rex and Utah party.
lol
looks too thick and lumpy and has a weird underbite, literally the old spino head was perfect, this new one looks like it came out of JW;E which I'd consider a downgrade
Woah woah woah. JW:E is amazing too.
Dont you dare be hatin
You say one more bad thing about it, we gonna throw down. š
bring it on green man
I'd settle for an actually playable game at this point.
Shrug
I dont want Rex to be a god anymore. I dont want these over populated dinosaurs and more variety. And damnit, I want a better Ai system
but yeah JW;E doesn't have a good aesthetics and the isle shouldn't be taking notes from the one place everyone copies their dinos from
JW:E for what it is imo has great aesthetics. It just has some things missing that would make it even better. I think its a fine game, but JP:OG was legit.
IMAGINE getting a perfectly fine model and almost instantly try and change it, like wtf be grateful
Woah now. The old spino was not that great. The head was amazing sure, but the new sail, the new body shape, the new claws.
All better imo
Could the head be better on the new model? Absolutely
@still temple you just need to stop bud. 
nah, like @hollow river said, My opinion so āļø
Oh and dont get me started on the old spinos legs. Yikes.
It felt short and stubby
@lofty sundial why are you so afraid of constructive critism? The game's dinosaurs could look a lot better, why the need to be so passive and complasant?
I dunno why the flame is so extreme, bhal agrees with him. I respect differences of opinion in regards to how the animal looks
Reminds me of those gangsters with their pants down to their knees and the big shirts xD
@mighty marten yeah there's a reason I just said the head, I like the new IRL spino a lot more, but the lumpy head of this isle one kinda cucks it from being truely good, which is annoying
@daring cosmos because criticism is fine but changing the Dinosaur to look more accurate although this is a more fictional game with weird designs and literally every new Dino this person tries to change it
I actually prefer the new herrera in every regard over the old one, but I understand if flaffy thinks it's too generic. However I do highly suspect that this one actually might have lips which cover his giant teeth.
@still temple sure your opinion, but no need to make a suggestion every time something is shown and try and change stuff.
@lofty sundial if you dont like my suggestion, ignore it
@lofty sundial if it were more accurate it'd look better tbh, and just because the game has a more fictional tone doesn't mean you need to make all your small theropods blend into each other
guess constructive criticism isn't allowed anymore
Models can be reworked at any time. I think we should have them focus on actually putting out something playable, then fixing models.
and when I mean playable, I mean not frustrating... well... bad.
@daring cosmos false. It looks great as it is, and WAY more unique then the one Flaffy suggested. And no it doesnāt blend. @still temple no one said that donāt be a big baby because someone critiqued what you are doing.
@lofty sundial if you knew how to read, I specifically stated change the skull anatomy only, i was never opposed to the dewlap
whether the spino looks good or not is a matter of opinion and the dinos and devs will never please everyone
Seems like you're the one throwing a fit rather than me with all the name calling š¤·āāļø
ok not opposed to the dewlap
@lofty sundial you're acting very erratic, I hope you aren't taking any of this personally
@strange wave I didnt make that edit, if I did I would change the skull/teeth only
IMO I like everything on on the herrera model jake showed us except the teeth. The og dewlap and the jaw shape are good enough, but the teeth on herrera are much larger than on the model
I think the after image of the herarara is better than the former
but no the new aesthetic looks way too much JW which is the least original thing you could possibly do with dinosaurs right now
Thats a really big neck jingling thing
@daring cosmos Iām not. Iām just not a fan of seeing āguess we canāt have criticism anymoreā like no. And you really arenāt defending anything
ĀÆ_(ć)_/ĀÆ
personally I think the neck flap looks weird but I'm also not gonna be spending 5 hours staring at its neck lol
Same here but I donāt mind it
@lofty sundial "criticism is fine"
UNGRATEFUL
Anyways Iām gonna leave and end my argument here . And yes you were being ungrateful, that has nothing to do with criticism @still temple š
@lofty sundial uh, right.... But still I don't think you're addressing my points in any majorly arguementative way, you seem to just want everything to stay as is
Why don't you guys want longer more menacing teeth though, that's my question
@lofty sundial ungrateful? Are you high? Since when was this game free and why are you acting so sycophantly?
The game should look as good as it can and tbh the new model is kind of a downgrade, though that's not to say Vlad's is perfect I could definately point out a ton of issues there
Settle for less boys, that's the motto
"The game should look as good as it can and tbh the new model is kind of a downgrade" opinions...
How about we settle for an actually playable before we go all ham on models now?
Well so far it isnāt a downgrade not to mention we havenāt seen the full model and we havenāt seen the colors on so stop calling it less you 
yeah, but I've been trying to argue it
Trikkel, it not being a downgrade is your opinion.
actually wasnt the spino in the trailer a male?
@lofty sundial those are the least important parts and aren't going to save it if the heads all wonky
I thought it had like red male colors or some shit
@lofty sundial never said the vlad model was better š¤·āāļø
I didnāt say they you did
you've stated your opinion but then you say everyone elses is wrong and yours is better

Flaffy proposing an "upgrade" is fine as a suggestion, you have no right to call him ungrateful.
The devs can take it as they want.
the model isn't even done yet
maybe they'll make changes later on, who knows, just be grateful that herrera is even on the list man 
@shell willow that's awfully wishful thinking and also shit's never gonna change if you aren't even gonna discuss it
I didnāt say anyoneās opinion was wrong Iām just saying they were dumb suggestions to judge such when animating isnāt in, skin or fully body.
then again it isn't gonna change even if you do
@lofty sundial are you 14?
not trying to be offensive, it's just that you sound really young
Last I checked no. Maybe I traveled back in time
listen to your own advice and dont name call
@daring cosmos Is it so wrong to be wishful? Works in progress have the ability to change, I don't see why that's so hard to believe. Why does trikkel's age matter. Chill.
This is not going to go anywhere.
Why not provide constructive criticism when the model is WIP, a stage where changes can be made easily. Rather than waiting till everything is done and changes will be difficult to make?
@shell willow kinda if you want anything to change
Flaffy, as soon as he called you ungrateful you should know to avoid replying.
I personally don't want anything to change. I like it the way it is. I just won't complain if things do change.
fair
yeah that was something else
sounds like @lofty sundial treats the devs like god's that should never be questioned and anyone who does is some heathan herratic, which is why I think they're not very old
is it not? That's super what a preteen on the internet would do, but whatever, the point is that no one's making any arguements anymore other than weird culty character judgements
And that is also false. Iāve had conflicts etc and Iāve gotten a strike from one too. I donāt praise anyone or anything.
again its trikkels opinion and you keep saying its wrong and they should be shamed for it
but yeah the herrera model has issues and looks too much like a generic theropod for no reason, my guess is Dondi wanted to make it look fast cause it's suppoed to be a cheetah now even though that makes literally no sense, but I can live with that as long as the model looks good which I don't think it does for the reasons I've mentioned before
Gosh, its almost like most theropods look like each other
queue spino sub rex
@strange wave also everything here is obviously going to be opinion and I do think they should be said with conviction, problem is @lofty sundial is just emberassing itself with nonearguements
generic theropod
@shell willow no herrerasaurus IRL looks way more distinctive than the model, they strayed from the scource material to make something less memorable
less memorable?
Okay mate you can stop with @ ing me. Iām not even here anymore.
are you forgetting the giant dewlap
@daring cosmos They made it more memorable by taking creative liberties, making it recognizable to their game. That's the most unique looking herrerasaurus I've ever seen in my life, dude. I'll remember The Isle's herrera over any other for sure.
I'd say so, it looks like some generic dromeosaur when the real deal is more unorthodox and aesthetic,
@strange wave the giant dewlap is just visual fluff that doesn't even look good
opinions...
contradiction
dewlaps can be done right and it extending is a good aesthetic choice, but what I'm getting at is as is the model isn't nearly as good as can be
@strange wave so?
they're opinions with backing
lmao what
not everything is immediately valid just because it's subjective
its an opinion that other people like it
So what if a few of its teeth aren't up to your perfect standard. The devs do what they want and I say they're doing a damn good job. The amount of contradictions in your words are vaporizing my braincells 
by that logic Batman v Superman is as good as a movie as citizen kane
@shell willow it's not just that, but why do you insist on worshiping the devs? They aren't untouchable gods that can do no wrong
again wish the saying that other people are less because they agree with the devs
How am I worshipping the devs? Giving them props for their hard work is suddenly cultish? Fr?
He isnāt worshipping he is being grateful, for the Dino even being added
You absolute pepega
i see a strawman and their name is copper
yes cause it's not paritucarly good work, they literally just could've told Jake to copy Scott Hartmans skeletal and add some fleshy bits
opinions
If you want to see worshipping get out of here and go to DOD discord Iām out this channel
Ciao
I mean that's a matter of opinion. some people are gonna like it and others wont. at the end of the day if that's how the devs want it to look then that's how its gonna look
Because... thats how... you make creatures. It's not like you can create an entirely different skeleton and be like "HERE! Herrera!"
We haven't even seen the whole body yet.
@lofty sundial grateful for a game you paid for and a dev who already set out to do this in the first place? lol wat? I think the isle has gone far and commend the devs and all that, but just flaunting critism because "YOU NO APPRECIATE" is absolutely insane
@shell willow that doesn't matter if the head sucks
the only thing off about the herrera so far is the teeth size and thats minor
copper you dont need to @ everybody whenever you talk
Copper, youāre just spitting opinions.
Nothing is fact. Itās just opinions and minority and majority
I just argued why the whole thing is weird, none of you have provided any other arguements other than "its fine" or "you should be grateful"
so?
You are the minority in this case
What's next, you wanna call me out for being 9 or something because I think you're being unappreciative? 
literally everything in this channel is going to be a opinion
so why do you act like yours is better
holy moly why is everyone so quick to defend the status quo?
@icy lion why do you defend the current model like it's better?
Also I got my game for free 
Because you're doing nothing but trying to shame us for thinking its fine? Idk man. You can have your opinions but we're allowed to have ours too.
because we think it is better
when did i lmao
@lofty sundial wtf is that even supposed to mean? Some one gave it to me as a gift so now I am indebted to the devs for life? Come on
god this is such a useless argument that will just keep going in circles
lol
@strange wave well I'm the only one arguing why JW deviant art recycled dinosaurs aren't that great
its not
"you bought the game so you suck the devs off" "you were gifted the game so you suck the devs off" literally what
your making such a big deal over teeth
@daring cosmos YOU. Are the one saying āgrateful for a game you payed forā youāre absolutely contradicting yourself .
teeth
huh?
and you are ignoring the giant expanding dewlap
wait this whole argument started over teeth? teeth you wont be looking at ever? XD
no I'm not, are you high?
If you want a counter argument, how about this:
It's based on an iguana right? Iguanas don't have janky teeth like herrera does irl. The isle isn't supposed to have realistic dinosaurs. It's fine for herrera to not have proper teeth because its not even a proper herrera. Look at our fucking utah.

this guys going in circles and is straw manning every response
@patent spade not it started because the new herrera model looks weirdly generic and wrong
how is it generic? It can't be more generic than allo
And you are making fat assumptions copper . Just cos I got the game for free doesnāt mean Iām sucking Dev toes. Just stop mate
idk how dewlap is generic
And donāt tag me
"JW deviant art recycled dinosaurs" IGNORING THE DEWLAP
you'd be surprised how many deviantart dinosaurs actually look really good.... I mean... tapwing is on deviantart
that was me literally telling you how insane your mentality is
yours perhaps
ya he said it's him
not even any spines smh
are you people insane? what in the hell is even happening anymore?
wheres the soft tissue?????
I've seen cultist with less blind dedication than you people
This can't be real
back to the "everybody think devs are gods cuz they dont agree"
Okay, uh bye then. Guess you canāt handle multiple enemies. Take it home bickers
what
Oh don't worry I can, but you gotta make at least an atom of sense first
why the spoonbill
You donāt make any sense either so I donāt mind
it's reacting to your insanity
uh
yes I do
can we just move on to something else cause this is just deteriorating into insulting each over opinions
Copper
We like herrera, you don't. You're allowed to hate the new herrera, but we're allowed to like the new herrera. Just because you don't like it doesn't mean we're wrong. It's all opinions. 
It's that simple
^^^^^^
Okay okay letās just stop here. Take it to dms if you want to
anyway im wondering if the current ai only dinos will be playable in the future cuz i love avas
We arenāt on topic anymore
ya imma dip before a blue person bans us all
same
I literally point out the flaw in your logic @lofty sundial saying "I didn't pay for the game sooo" and then I tell him "wtf does that mean? just cause someone gifted the game to me now I worship the devs" the point was to point out the flaw in your reasoning not my autobiographical tale aout me getting the game
would playing a velo be the same as playing a compy?
@shell willow yeah, but I'm the only one that's made an arguement so far that doesn't boil down to STFU THE DEVS WORK HARD BE GRATEFUL REEEE
@icy lion probably
Saying: Grateful for a game you paid for then I said I didnāt pay for this game I was gifted it and then you reacted badly
@lofty sundial I didn't react badly, I just pointed out how that means jack shit
that's cause the others actually like the way the herrera looks and dont like you calling them cultist and shit for it
Then why did you mention it in the first place ?????? 
the game isn't some gift for all, my point is that you're buying a product with cold hard cash it's not a gift it's a good that's paid for with currancy
what
@lofty sundial because you did
Trikkel: stfu and be grateful for th devs
XD
ok
Me: it's not free, why is it wrong to ask for quality in the revamps?
I said this
Trikkel: I got it for free.... :D
Implying its not good quality
oh you meant in survival, well that's my mistake, but you're still dumb
I'll explain why
just cause it's getting added shouldn't mean it doesn't have to look good too
what
Can we not call names pls ty
<@&401466542140817419> can someone please end this trash fire
right
Thank you
Who am I ending?
Now I can leave without being @ Ed
this non stop argument about the herrera
Itās turned away from Herrera
i just want to see the textures soon :c
that's an artifact of your own construction
Weāve become a little primal and insulted each other
Alright. Well... it's super late and I'm not nice. Get the conversation on track or you will be relocated.
o7
Rule 2.
I really wouldn't call them insults
you called us dumb but k
Don't propagate it. Drop it and move on.
its late, good night. ty for calming us down saoul
So help me god, Copper, if that message is continuing the discussion I just asked to move on from, there's gonna be sadness.
XD you're really that delicate? Come on? Ok I promise never to be mean to Trikkel boi again, is that fine with you?
Alright. Cool.
What a shame.
He has been kicked. For now.
Good.
ty mods
thank you
You're welcome, please just remember to be civil towards one another.
Sorry for getting a bit out of hand
Lol.
yea, ty mods
Im guessing someone got yeeted.
yea, long story. started with herrera dewlap lol
When I say "Stop", you guys gotta stop. But please continue with the dewlap.
Do we have to drop and roll?
dewlap is gud nuf said
@icy lion I hope it will be jiggly cause that would be hilarious XD
lmaoo right
its supposed to expand depending on the anger
spam turning to wiggle your neck
I wanna see it puff out like an Anole
maybe part of the 3 call?
hey if that's the case all fine by me
think less iguana more anole
look at him go
pretty boi
^ just have that be the case
eh I still think it looks weird but that's just me
i wonder how thick it is too
you think itll have the shading like the ptera wings? kinda glowy?
I hope it folds in like this too
it does, and I'd prefer it if it were rounder, though if we're getting really nitpicky I'd like it if it were more like an inflatable sack like it is right now, the flat dewlap has been done more times before I reckon
anoles are great
im too lazy to find the clip
i wonder how the textures are, i cant imagine will be getting the animations without textures
probably just gonna be the same default skin, but remade for this version sorta like we got with carno
@onyx cargo pretty sure the current stats of the dinos wont matter since everything is being changed but maybe I'm wrong
the most important question is is it gonna keep its title as fastest dino in the game
I need to harass things as Herrera on officials
i think hererras getting slowed down
from what I know it's meant to be super fast and climb trees now, which is pretty hillarious cause the real thing probably only reached a max of 26MPH, but I'm ok with that
again lost me at real thing
i wonder if the new patterns are the same/similar to old herrera
expect mottled if any of the survival dinosaurs are an indication
true, but para and maia have some p clean stripes
i remember seeing a white and brown striped concept for herra
really? When?
Cus I saw people were griping about the skull
it's pretty accurate
teeth are a little undersized
thanks for posting
Personally found the skull itself fine, teeth being a bit small was what I noticed when I looked at it but I thought it could have been the lips but wasn't sure
Often time a lot of what looks unique doesn't represent itself once soft tissue is added
Think about acrocanthosaurus, if restored properly it just looks like any other carcharodontosaur
regardless, did some talking with the art devs, we'll be bumpin up the tooth size
Thanks Jake, Cheers
*Baardo
Oh my b
The larger tooth size was the only thing that was bothering me, everything else was solid. I can't wait to see him in game.
My bad the name tripped me up
very epic, bigger menacing teeth
Indeed, Herrera's personality is one of nippiness so bigger chompers are much appreciated.
-winces at the shrink wrapped skin
But i still dig the design
Want big boi teeth for hereras
Big teeth for holding ongo things and being a pest
shrink wrapped?
The skin is just ....hmmm its too tight on the skull
its normal for reptiles' heads to lay tight on their skulls
Yes, but not entirely that tight and our tiny reptiles hardly have the bite force dinos did.
herrera was a small dino, tbh
Okay i'm really happy with that clip now. Dewlap won't be out all the time noice
True
I just feel it should be more iguana y
If you can see any of the empty spaces on the skull it's too shrinkwrapped
Shrinkwrapping is fine to keep visual consistency with other isle animals
It's not a problem for me
Like from a realism point
But this isn't realism it's the isle so I don't mind the shrinkwrapping
Same
I think its fine, just look at our cursed naked utah
It's also easier to tell the referencing from the original material if the anatomy is somewhat close to the skeletal
^
I dont mind it at all bc its just a game and im having hella fun
I just appreciate the fact theres a decent dino game actually out
Fun fact btw. Chickens are classified as reptiles technically
Oh damn guess that was a fluke of perspective, well nvm then all is good I guess
@onyx cargo I'd like to see the source on chickens being classified as reptiles?
Far as I'm aware they are classified as Aves
Its in off topic ^^
Ah, I see now
@covert hull I love all of your suggestions
id LOVE to see Nanotyrannus or possibly Pyroraptor would be cool as well. Pretty much any new species would be exciting to me though lol
I really want to see Iguanodon as a playable Dinosaur. Though I'd like to see more non-dinosaurs as well. Especially some of the crazy Triassic stuff if it needs to be from the Mesozoic. Saurosuchus would make an excellent quadrupedal predator.
Yeah no offense i dont think "because it's real" is something that's really gonna sway the devs. They want creepy, almost that one jurassic park game troodon
nines is right the isle is not meant to be real not for every dino
@granite hamlet what about a sauropod? they're thought to continue growing, and are ideal for unlimited growth, i'd imagine
yeah, that would also work. That would give both sides (herb and carni) this feature and might even it out
and it would give Hypos a little challange (depending what sauropod it's gonna be)
⨠hating on featherless dinosaurs and continuously bringing up the fact that "dinosaurs had feathers" does not make you look cool and intelligent, it makes you look like a pedantic asshole āØ
phew i just had to get that out after like 3 people have been going on and on about it
Oh were other people complaining about this shit too? Did they at least have a better argument than "dis is for da realism!"
a feathered skin option would be cool, but "because this was reality" isn't enough of a reason for devs to spend however much extra money putting feathers on the models would take :/
nah it was basically the same reasoning
i think one of the devs suggested it might become an optional feature?
i mean, i am gonna be a little pedantic here too. In truth all dinos had the CHANCE to have had feathers (in whatever form) so saying they don't have them 100% is just false, except science proved it. For example that rex didn't have feathers on specific body areas (does not mean it didn't have any at all though). But back to the game itself, i personally don't mind them not having feathers (or having them). Except Theri, i only accept feathered Theri.
It was said in a past ask-a-dev that they might do feathered options
What's real is fine, but this game doesnt seem to give a shit about paleo-perfect accurate dinosaurs so suggesting something solely based on realism is kinda dumb.
yeah, that's what i said. I don't mind them having feathers ingame or not (except Theri). I could care less that Utha doesn't have feathers ingame, even if it had them in real life. It's the dev's game so they get to decide. I am okay with that.
i'd like to point out that feathers are rather limited on dinosaurs. only a few groups have them, even if the groups themselves are large, like maniraptorans
the majority of dinosaurs are either known for scaled skin or unlikely to have had feathers
nah, all dinosaurs have a common ancestor that had feathers and according to scientists all dinosaurs have had the potential to have them too. If they did or not, they would have to find out with skin impressions (which there rarely are any)
anyway, that's paleo talk though
it's theorised it's a basal trait, but that's still debated since ornithischian feathers are different from saurischian feathers, suggesting a different origin
make the skull smaller and it'll be perfect
you have to remember there are muscles and skin on top of the skull
Bruh, donāt tag devs unless you want a whooping
@cobalt coral monolophosaurus is planned to be its own thing
i realized that after i posted
@keen trail flyers are coming after terrestrial animals are done. You'll have to wait a good bit for it. No reason to suggest they put an animal that isnt a priority in the game anytime soon
I mean, if you knew it was far from likely why would you suggest it?
I didnāt know it was far from likely
Well now you are aware that fliers are still pretty far away
I didnāt even know when ptera was planned to come out. I just figured it might be after but if it wasnāt then there the suggestion
Ok
@indigo sun chill
K
@cobalt coral Give ourano some unique mechanic because we already have maia and tenonto is coming
@oblique sluice that's why I want Iguanodon. Hench boi
Actually, maybe one solution to live carry is allow the person to be carried to try and escape, which deals damage to them each time, lets say like a quarter of their health each time so after four times they would die and be free or something like that
@barren zephyr
@maiden talon Maybe some stam drain
stam drain for the person carrying?
I could see that working pretty well, also would make it so people would have to carefully plan out long intentional carries, like carrying hatchlings or something
@severe idol yea but I don't get put in a queue when trying to join a full server
@dense shuttle only females being able to pick up youngs and only in packs doesn't make sense, there should be some sort of scale
but its already being sdaid it wont get added...
which is why i said for females in their pack to be able to pick up hatchlings
And that's where they need to add a balance system in the way of maybe killing the animal while carying it depending on your bite force and animal or having some sort of timer
the whole point is that only females could pick up young because of there instinct not to kill there kid
are you not smart?
And somebody mentioned an escape system maybe which would also deal damage to you if you don't manage to do it
its a god damn hatchling
Yea, that wouldn't deal damage, of course, I know how that works and animals still do that
you are not on about my suggestion please stop talking t me
Yea, I get your point
But what I'm saying is that it doesn't make sense for only females to be able to pick up other dinos and only their little hatchlings
Just from a physics point
And I said that they should maybe add a balancing system to that, maybe like some sort of fatigue or escape system
the new croc should definetly be able to hide hatchlings in their mouth
I'm talking about picking up bigger things
dont speak about it here then
suggestion discussion smartass
Yea, and I'm talking about a suggestion
ur not tho
People have asked about this and I am also talking about Your suggestion and adding points to it
Thus I think that it counts here
also when a female would pick up a small one it should walk slower, so it can't run as fast as normal to save itself and the hatchling while being hunted but can hide
LADIES! You're both pretty. Now stay on target.
I did just say to leave it alone.
oop
It's still a discussion, just talking about a suggestion
but that suggestion wasnt my suggestion
And I'm talking about another one, and you interfered
ok
@azure dust
I asked Dondi for a Delta.
Check this out: (At time: 1:24:07 )
https://www.twitch.tv/videos/534292714?filter=archives&sort=time
He basically read my "We want a delta at the end of the river, Pog in chat". Then there were 1000 Pogs in chat, then Dondi said:
Don't fucking say Pog for him, you're not getting a Delta at the end of THIS river. You have no idea how hard it is to make a Delta
My bad! Thank you for letting me know. ā¤ļø
It is cow
any actual reason?
we already have hadrosaurs
"If you post please add this dino (replace dino with animal), explain why the animal should be added and what mechanics it could have" - From the pinned messages of the channel. You need an actual reason to add an animal, because adding shit is very expensive.
not to mention that shitposting isn't taken kindly by admin, which this seems like
also yeah you can get a strike for troll suggestions, theyre really not a fan of them
wastes everyone's time
What do I have to go threw to suggest cow in game š
Cow would just be walking burgers. Free food
For milk
The only way i would see cows is if they go very deep into human stuff
And food
what would milk add to the game at all..
We have maia milk for that 
For hoomans to drink
i see no reason for these scientists to bring cows into the island that theyre very clearly controlling the ecosystem of.
or they could drink water
Ofc the guy called happycow likes this suggestion
Anyways only way i would see cows working is if they make humans pull a jurassic park if they get very advanced. But that wont happen
also the bit where 2/3 of people are lactose intolerant
Besides, hoomans can't drink water from pounds
i only see cows existing if they were using them as test shit in the beginning but without actual care, the cows would very quickly die off to the dinosaurs that assumed control of the island
They will poison themselfes
there's no empty niche a cow could occupy
they can, people who are taught to survive in the wild can sterilize water and also drinking from rivers is generally sort of alright
Yea magy already took the cow niche 
^
Don't you disrespect cow like that
But yea cows would just die of insanely quickly on a dino filled island
cow good animal
Hell cows if humans went extinct would go extinct too
Ye
cows are also highly adapted for grazing grass, so they'd not be short of food, but yeah, predation would devastate them once the predators were large enough to kill them
which, tbh, wouldn't take that long
gestation too long, competition from other herbivores, over predation from carnivores.
not particularly useful to humans. milk isn't even that great for you
Cows would make this game better.
give an example of how then
MILK
this is trolling
it isnt
there is no actual reason for cows to exist in the game. Humans would have been the ones containing and taking care of them and since humans clearly fucked up somewhere along the line and died or some shit, if they were in indoor facilities they wouldn't get any care and starve to death or some shit and if they were outdoors being grazed and not in a facility they woulda just been killed off nearly instantly. The only reason for cows to have possibly existed on the island was for testing and since testing is no longer happening they would have died off
excuse the pun but he's trying to get your goat
I'm very serious right now.
i know he's trolling. i want to see what sort of excuse he is capable of coming up with
i'm sure
A look into a damaged mind
not much competition from herbivores, since dinosaurs wouldn't eat that much grass, whereas a cow would mostly eat grass. if it wasn't for the predators, i think cows would've survived well enough around the herbivores
cows arent animals really designed for riding.
But we don't want cows to get killed ofc
if they were i'm sure they'd actually be used.
hypo cow maybe
i want a dev to see this convo

technically, no animal is "designed" for riding, we just happen to favour riding horses
good point
U guys are big bullies š”
yall still on this?
Yes
Look dude cows aint gonna work
nah we just want an explanation beyond 'cows make milk and can be ridden into battle' lmfao
Let's move on from cows.
Aw cmoon
thank you saoul
banhamma
Cows are dumb, slow, and don't live on uneven ground well. Go with goats.
That being said. New topic time.
OK that is disrespectful
I will only tell you to move on one more time. After that I will remove you.
Speaking of goats. Pachy mountain goat niche wen
doesn't the avg utah player already kind of act like it
pachy mountain goat niche is a good idea. has anyone made a suggestion about that yet?
OK I won't talk about cows anymore š
i like the idea of atmospheric changes with altitude, kinda tying in to the suggestion above the cows
a while ago nines
THey showed picks of those goats walkin on that dam
They had that in their suggestion
Nah best way to make it would be giving pachy insane lvls of fall damage reduction
i'm wondering if the Pachy would gain omnivory to parallel a recent theory, though i doubt it. if they did, it would make them even more like goats š
To also maintain that it's a place where humans were at one time and raising these dinosaurs. Goats are a more reliable food source than cows. It makes more sense for wild goats than cows. They breed faster, have less geographical limitations, and require less abundant herbaceous resources.
could just increase the incline required to make them fall and that would have the same effect
except it would be a 1 number edit
goats can get into some insane places. like trees and walls
maybe slightly more depending on where that is set
pachys do weigh a bit tho, do they not? pudgy chunks
you'd need a stronger tree, but why not?
i do like the idea of them reaching places others cant tho
How are u supossed to hunt goats than :\
we aren't talking literal goats
We are talkin bout makin pachys climb like goats
^
Ok
Sry
And I apologize bcs of spamming cows I just came with another of my weird ideas
Seriously though the live carry thing is such an easy fix
Have it work like a minute then you drop em
maybe it's not that simple?
@ashen elm you should have added barosaurus
if you only carry them for like a minute then whats the point of even having the feature
I might but what is or is not Barosaurus is kinda a mess rn. Traditional B. Lentus size is basically a even lighter D. Carnegii with switched neck-tail proportions. Then you get the giant Baro and that's š±
@kindred mango Sorry, i cant agree with punishing people for surviving, even big animals
i would rather my dino die to my own hands or at the hands of another player than for time to kill my dino
spend a week trying to grow your rex? well get fucked its dying of old age
kinda not fair to people putting time and effort into growing these big animals, especially with riskier behavior being encouraged in exchange for shorter growth
it would make growing anything pointless cause why bother when its gonna die of old age
you take that risk and earn your animal only to get fucked over in the end
a better suggestion somebody has already made was dinos gaining an "elder" status with some physical changes to show a rougher, more time-worn looking animal, but not dying of age or losing stats
I think the older the dinosaur, the stronger it gets. If your spino has been alive and has seen many things, it should be wise and do better. Yep. It survived countless volcanic eruptions? Well now the spino can make fire. Boom.
Im being silly, but I do like the idea of Elder dinosaurs being stronger than younger ones, as they have the combat experience.
@humble nova we already have that
we have walk, trot run and sprint plus the shift one click to switch between would take too long to get from sprint to walk or trot to sprint
you feel
walk/trot is toggled by z
yeah thats what a sprint is
run is shift, "sprint" would be ambush
you can also sprint without ambush, just by holding "shift"
I bet dinosaurs didn't have to squat either to sprint
thats because its an ambush
- i think two types of running isn't needed
u have to be sneaky
it's just overcomplicating it for no reason
^
Even then, the game isn't historically accurate
@verbal scarab wrong channel
ight
Like that's not a valid argument at sll
im saying ur method of the walking- sprinting is unecessary
nonetheless, adding another way to run is just overcomplicating it lol
it works fine as it is rn
Gorest FumpToday at 3:56 PM
But irl you can Sprint without squatting right
Right
I said you don't have to squat to sprint and shouldn't have to
there's no need to add something else
then u said it wasnt historically accurate
like?
i know but thats the point of an ambush
if u look it up
itll tell you
we got four modes of movement already, ambush is a sprint and having to crouch doesnt mean shit its preparing to get into the sprint
thats not my point ur talking about something else
As in you are saying dinosaurs need to squat to sprint
exactly @indigo sun
the whole squatting thing is irrelevant
its because that's just how they implemented the sprint and it makes sense because it helps when hunting in game
a regular sprint wouldn't give any advantage at all
Yes it would
its about the modes of movement, even if you have to perform something specific to engage that movement
It's putting forth more effort to run
but you can already do that
Whether it's in a Chase or to get away
plus it'll have the same cool down and unbalance the game
the current system works fine
Yeah but it's also just regular running travel but to get away
it'll still have a cooldown like the current sprint does
but thats what the regular run is for
and they all have set speeds
adding extra speed for longer would achieve nothing
because everyone would just run a little faster
Think about it like this
i only see it good for travel but then again it isnt necessary
i know what you are saying
There's a run in dire situations and there's a run for travel
It seems unnatural to have the same animations for 2 different purposes
its just a little extra speed bro
the crouch is to hide and then run at something
its purposed towards hunting
itās a running start
if u wanna get away with it then use it
all the sprint is is running a little bit faster than you normally do
Yeah I know what an ambush is
then stop syaing it's something else
sure, herbis dont have ambush, but they're balanced for a different playstyle
^^
or they're already built to outrun predators under most circumstances
hold on
all the dinos have a defined playstyle (para is supposed to be quiet + unseen, galli = fast sprint anyway)
Para, quiet? Everytime I hear a para call I see the riders of Rohan appear.
because they aren't playing it how it is designed?
?
@tame hawk you need more than "add this animal" in your suggestion
u see rexes start 1 calling and challenging trikes and they just die
trikes out stat a rex
in a 1v1
unless that is what youre typing out currently, if so, apologies im used to the image coming after the suggestion
para's are slow and have little defense against apexes so they are more designed to a quiet playstyle they have loud calls to attract predators that's their counter
i think they mean "para is supposed to be quiet" as para should be played somewhat stealthily when they can, and just avoid apexes at all costs since they can't escape that well (?)
sorry originally you only had "idea: changyuraptor" and i didnt see any more typing happening because apparently my computer doesnt like me, but you added a bit more so ignore what I originally said
Oh no worries :D
What shall I provide if I wanna make a species suggestion? Playstyle, to which tier it belongs, maybe pictures?
what it is, what would make it stand out from the rest of the roster so it's not something like "add tarbo pls its cool"
but it takes too long to slow down
again
like in a fight when ur turning sharply fromt a sprint to walk its too long
plus sliding is being implemented
its something that isn't necessary as it doesnt really add much to the gameplay ngl
What?
^
Why would you need to go from sprint to walk in a millisecond
Your playing devils advocate for no reason
the conversation is just going in circles, there's no point in having it lol
Its a perfectly good system, looks sick and works perfectly fine on this game
so if ur movement style was implemented it'll be even more slow. plus ur max speed is already the sprint, each dino has a different speed. it'll be the same if u add ur extra sprint since it'll be added to all the dinos; no dino in particular
the isle is different
It just adds a chase animation and drains stam faster while boosting you a bit
again, it's essentially ambush with no charge-up system
Its a detail is all
so it's already in the game in some form
yeah but prey isnt gonna sprint
has different plays styles and fighting styles, it's unecessary
You are aying ambush and sprint are the same thing
prey can run, if it is fast it should get away
ur run system will be added to everything
adding it to the predators will make it unbalanced
ambush and sprint are the same it's both extra speed for a short time
dinos
because its literally a life-like feature that almost every life form on earth has
like u said before it isn't historically accurate or life like
?
again, it's just over-complicating things for literally no reason
I was countering your argument
Because you were saying dinosaurs wouldve needed to squat
the game works fine as it is with the current run and ambush system
which is literally wrong
I like the idea of every animal having a trot and a max speed. just a different acceleration, so obviously a raptor is full speed much quicker than a trike
exactly you were arguing history
im pretty sure they just said you have to crouch to ambush in this game
When the game isnt accurate
i dont think anyone said dinosaurs needed to squat
so it wouldnt matter making your whole argument moot
bruh
the point of the game is inaccurate
its scientifically revived dinos, ofc it isnt gonna be the same
my argument is valid, urs isnt
it hasnt been this whole time
Its a life-like detail and you are saying its unecessary
the devs are trying to make it as life-like as possible whilst balancing the other stuff
their max speed is their run
sure, it might be life-like, but it's unnecessary because the current system works fine
thats why theres leaning
plus the sprint is a short burst
the current system works just fine and theres no reason to add in unnecessary stuff
having a longer sprint would have a stam cap anyway like the current one if u wanna go "life like"
they are working on life-like details and im pointing out another one
their run is supposed to be their all-out run as far as ik
Right now its both
with depleting stam
Its a travel run and a chase/hunt run
there will not be a sprint
people would just mirror eachother, if their prey accels then they accel
unnatural like sprinting off for about 2 minutes without stopping
it adds little to nothing
^^^^
thats what u were implying
Who ever said that was going to be necessary
to add an extra speed
bruh
ontop
You are literally adding bits of nothing you your pathetic argument
says you
you're the one arguing ove rsomething that ISNT NECESSARY BECAUSE IT IS ALREADY IN THE GAME
how is it proven
While your arguing about things no one even talked about
goddamn this is a shitshow to watch.
^
u sent a video from another game with a different mechanism
You said the sprint would take to slow to decellerate
sit back n watch them go
imagine taking a tight turn to bit and u have to slow down then turn to make it tight enough to bit the dino next to you
its like playing carno
trying to kill a utah
there are preset stats for each dino already for different hunting and play styles with differentspeeds, you're trying to make everything the same
again, if your prey accels, then you mirror them and accel
it literally adds nothing
sliding is already in the game = allo
Its just a chase/hunt animation
plus being added more efficiently in the recode
exactly
thats
what we have
been saying
no need to add more speed
you have an ambush
well yeah, it doesnt matter and is an irrelevant form of movement
predator has ambush because they can sneak up and ambush, run is their current long "sprint" it's their max run a sprint is a short burst
thats legit the definition of a sprint a short amount of speed

So your saying
u want it for longer in a progressive way with 1 button, we have different buttons already for it = it's quicker and it's the same
The sprint is their limit of acceleration
exactly for a short period
and they are too weak to speed up
u want it fo rlonger and progessively
no
i never said they were too weak to speed up
they already can
u making things up now
when did i say weak
ill listen when u listen to me
sliding is already involved with vanilla run within the recode build(?)
because obviously you left ur cataracts in too long
so adding extra speed literally means nothing
what if they are in the plains
well then the allo shouldnt be visible if it wants to ambush something
allo playstyle is to ambush because it isnt fast enough
Have you seen the new upcoming map
plus why would it kill a maia if it's faster than it
well then it shouldnt try hunt something in the plains? lol
its got less taller vegetation in areas
<@&401466542140817419> break these two up pls, been going at it for like 20 mins
and it's literally about nothing
Bruh
almost 40 
This is going no where. You two sort it out in DMs.
it's balancing, maia is mainly speed and no damage and allo is more damage and not much speed but makes up for it in the short burst
There will not be a second time of me saying it.
okay i'll end it now, gorest dump ur argument makes no sense and it will not be implemented :)
Theres been no good argument point from Exotic so I suppose ill end it
Good. Don't continue it.
Maybe Tobii Eye Tracking sometime in the future?
@scarlet thicket i do believe they said no to first person, at least for dinosaurs.
@simple maple - Can't control venom glands in baby rattlers is a misnomer. They're just more aggressive, thus bite more than once.
The more you know š
Good to know, I thought it seemed fishy lol
To be fair baby venomous dinosaurs would totally be less dangerous for a bite
Baby rattlers are only about the same because their venom is enough to kill you in one hit either way even if you arenāt getting some huge fat dose from a big adult
@barren zephyr why 4x stamina use for herbivore charge?
cause trike is Horrify already
so is a charging Rex if you're a herbi
Not wrong
I have killed rexs though I think trike is fine were its at so giving it this is kinda scary
i'm not sure what the stamina loss is for ambush, but if it is 2x for carnivore, wouldn't it make more sense for herbis to be the same for a charge?
why would herbi charge drain 4x stamina but carni ambush would still drain only 2x stamina
do i smell carni bias perhaps hmmm
No iam just kinda taking it at face value
Things that eat plants dont need to charge down plants
I love trike to be fair
rather play it then rex
no, but giving a charging herbivore with quadruple the stamina drain for a charge seems unfair if carnivore only had double
things that eat plants but get hunted on the regular need to charge down the carnis that hunt them tho
Trike's already not the fastest even when running, so it seems strange to penalise them so much
Id just like to see a charging mechanic
2x times is fine
I shall edit
I think herbivores have less stamina then most carnivores anyways could be wrong though
@thorny crag collision is planned and has been shown off already
ah sorry I have not seen
absolutely and a source for insect eaters š
yaaas ikr š
god not another god damn peeing suggestion
you miss pooping?
No organic waste, thanks. Its fuckin gross
not to mention pointless
tfw people suggest things that are already happening, like collision
from what I understand humans arent a priority and we wont be seeing them for a while
beipiao alt skin that makes it an insect eater 
Is flash assuming the tribals are some native people humans??
dunno I'm just ignoring it since we wont be seeing humans for a long time
what else would they be? o:
Have you not seen the tribal/cannibal model?




