#general-feedback-discussion

1 messages · Page 504 of 1

brittle bough
#

aye, taking away scent is the most readily available counterweight, its just a bit sad lol

valid zephyr
#

not sure how captions are that exploitable

elfin oyster
#

That would still be abused af Strike

#

Also Jenkens, the amount of times I dont pay attention to sound is astounding

valid zephyr
#

is you se bwrbrbrbrbrbbrb come up you still need to work out what makes that sound

elfin oyster
#

If I saw captions flare up I would never get ambushed

brittle bough
#

and they are exploitable because you dont have to pay attention to sounds, you just have to wait for captions to ever come up

elfin oyster
#

If you have ANY visual indicator you will ALWAYS know someone is around, but if you only rely on sound, you might not always know before its too late

brittle bough
#

maybe only have them come up if youre looking in the direction of the source?

lament thorn
#

As someone with terrible hearing and focusing skills I'd jump on captions and prompts

indigo sun
#

Well an ambush would have considerably less obvious waves, like how the noise is there but not as obvious

elfin oyster
#

Its way easier to detect any movements on the screen, then pay close attention to sound

#

Humans are basically designed that way, eyes are simply way better then ears

indigo sun
#

You could see it, but you have to be watching very intently to do so, like how you could hear it, but you need to be listening very intently to do so

elfin oyster
#

Lemme tell you I would immiedetly detect a small movement indicator

brittle bough
#

its still much easier to notice visual changes than auditory ones, alas

elfin oyster
#

Bet most people would, its really easy to see these things

indigo sun
#

Yeah it is easier to detect, but does that mean that people with poor or no hearing should be unable to play the game because someone else would use indicators to their advantage?

elfin oyster
#

Its just that Im very against making a game like this easier.

brittle bough
#

i think captions are viable if they only show up at the bottom if youre looking in the direction of the source, possibly being more transparent/opaque to indicate proximity/volume
it would give us the gift of seeing onomatopeia for all the calls, too

#

also, crouching probably shouldnt give any captions

elfin oyster
#

Most people look around a lot anyway, so they would still see the captions

#

I always dart my head back and forth when I travel

#

Also Strike, it doesnt make then UNABLE to play, it makes them more dependent on vision

brittle bough
#

hum. going back to trading out sniffing, maybe it could be replaced by a listening mechanic, and only for the same duration of the sniff the captions appear?

#

captions or directional indicators, either-or

elfin oyster
#

Could be a good counter

#

Would certainly stop people from choosing it just because it gets easier. And those who are impaired gets to choose what they believe is more important

indigo sun
#

Someone not-hearing impaired using the thing meant for hearing impaired people should not make it an invalid way of making the game more available for hearing impared people
There is so much to do with noise on this game, not everything is sight based. You need to be able to listen and if you can't do that, youre kinda screwed a bit. I cant look around and immediately see ai, i need to listen for it. If a juvi cant hear any ai, then how is it meant to find it? It would starve unless it got lucky and the ai spawned in a clearing

brittle bough
#

tbf ai will work differently, suggestions are meant to be considered in a post-recode environment generally

elfin oyster
#

But you shouldnt make the game easier for the entire community just because of a small minorities needs

#

If you did that it would be insanely easy, if you did it for everyone who needed it

brittle bough
#

but yeah, as unfortunate as it is since theres no way to truly know who needs the features, the features still have to have drawbacks to balance them

elfin oyster
#

If we knew the amount of actually hearing impaired we could do something like this, but it could just be 50-100 people, we dont know. And if its for a VERY small minority, whats the point? You should only impact the rest of the community if that minority is pretty big, like a 10% chunk or something

#

I sure as hell wouldnt want my game being easier for the sake of a few people. I believe the only options are leave it as it is, or do help them but also have a counterbalance such as the removal of sense of smell

#

Otherwise when will it stop? Will we help everybody, and thereby make the game childsplay?

indigo sun
#

@pulsar lake why are you putting things we know are coming in suggestions, like affinity, water rework, and body carrying?

#

I'm just not sure I understand putting these things in suggestions for future implementation if theyre already coming

pulsar lake
#

For make a rappel

indigo sun
#

Rappel?

paper oriole
#

seems pretty pointless lol

lethal shell
#

sorry kinda new to this discord, but is there any talk about increasing the Dilos crouch or walk speed?

indigo sun
#

Wrong channel, and I haven't heard anything about it.

plain orbit
#

release date ?

indigo sun
#

Read the rules, especially rule 9 @plain orbit

crimson phoenix
#

On the topic of a hearing mechanic, I came up with an idea as to how it could be used by the hearing impaired without being just as strong as a subtitle saying "Heavy carnivore footsteps." Listening could have a similar visual indicator as sniff does for direction (in game compass). it could be some red waves on the sides of the screen that expand and contract depending on the volume in that direction. Really though I don't know if this would be useful even to people who cant hear, because it would take a lot of effort to tell the difference between a taco 2 calling in the woods and an Allo f calling to his buddies

thorny lynx
#

Wrong channel, bud

crimson phoenix
#

fluff, im responding to teh peeps who were talkin here

thorny lynx
#

Sorry

#

Wasn't paying attention

barren zephyr
#

hello why not do a PS4 version? a lot of player would be happy,
the ps4 is powerful enough to support it with average quality

blazing charm
#

@barren zephyr Porting a game to another platform is alot of work, especially considering that the Isle's developmenet team is rather small. (No offense)

Not to mention the game is still heavy in development, if a console port of any kind is ever considered it needs to be after the PC release is finished.

barren zephyr
#

It is also not recommended to port an unfinished early access game from Steam to console.

barren zephyr
#

okay I understand, he could possibly have a console output once the game ended

night mountain
#

See theoretically that growth idea is good but it’d be awful right now with how ai works

barren zephyr
#

wut

azure arch
#

They want a feathered galli

#

What do you guys think of my sound suggestion for those with impaired hearing?

ocean vortex
#

I doubt that many players are hearing impaired tbh

night mountain
#

Has any of the hearing impaired suggestions been from people who actually need it? I've only seen it posed as a hypothetical

brittle bough
#

we shouldnt offer accessibility for minorities because they are minorities, obviously
and the original hearing impaired suggestion was by someone who was hearing impaired lol

night mountain
#

Oh ok fair. Either way I’m cool with something like this

keen trail
#

My main thought on the hearing impaired suggestions is that a lot of not hearing impaired people will use it for an advantage to know exactly where sounds are coming from, or they could use it to hear stuff they usually wouldn’t hear, like a hungry rex stomping a few feet away that you’d usually just barely be able to hear if you were paying attention, but the hungry carnis have to be extra cautious after this because if they get just a little to close, their hunt could be foiled.

elfin oyster
#

Any sort of visual clue would ruin the game for any predator. Lets not ruin the game just because 50 people or less need it.

#

If you wanna help minorities, do colour blind people, because that doesnt effect gameplay in a negative way

barren zephyr
#

Still think the smell should be better for certain dinos as they would have had better senses then other dinos

bold relic
#

Rex had a really good sense of smell and vision

barren zephyr
#

^^

paper oriole
#

Bigger AI is coming

#

Already

barren zephyr
#

Is it?

#

Explain Yo self?

paper oriole
#

...

#

Explain yo self? lol

barren zephyr
#

About bigger AI like what AI para?

night mountain
#

We need the opposite

#

remove ava

paper oriole
#

Larger and defensive AI is already planned, like acro and brachio. AI that will br harder to take down

barren zephyr
#

no ai survival creatures

paper oriole
#

And not spawn in your mouth like the current avas

night mountain
#

brachis fine since its big enough it can kick anythings ass

barren zephyr
#

Yeah that sounds terrible if they don't fight back at least

night mountain
#

make ai theris with velos behavior

paper oriole
#

Brachi should step on tard afk rexes lol

#

Yes make packs of 3 aggro theri

#

With cera turn radius

bold relic
#

And speed of herra

still temple
#

borealopelta is epic

#

nodosaurs could use some attention

night mountain
#

Seriously why is pachys whole bleed situation so bad? I don't get why they made it like that

grand brook
#

two words: rushed dino

#

when it first came to survival it was a hot mess, slow, loud breathing, took 2 hours to fill it's water, long growth, horrible bleed, mediocre damage...

blazing charm
#

I still do not understand the obsession with "accuracy", it's a video game.

formal vine
#

^

blazing charm
#

The amount of work that would need to go in to change the Stegosaurus model to look more "a c c u r a t e" is such a waste. It's already modeled, animated and skinned.

unique island
#

personally the stego looks fine, way better then what it used to be lol

grand brook
#

it looks fine to me, maybe the neck is shorter and it has less plates but the feet are fine and so is the model in general

bold relic
#

Many people play this game because they want to play 'a dinosaur life' so they want a high level of accuracy, but rn i think as far as i have seen it the stego model is fine

unique island
#

then they aren in the wrong game. Isle isnt highly realistic, its a monster dino game. Either way, as I said before the stego is fine, its far more "realistic" then its older models. The Box shaped stego... now that was all types of wrong xD

cyan flame
#

The current stego is realistic, the new stego is less so, more along the older "box" stego as it were. I'd prefer the more accurate version, it looks better to me than the stego we're getting, but it'll have to do :p

bold relic
#

It cant be highly realistic with the current dev team (no offense its just too smol)

grand brook
#

I get that honestly, but the game is basically the JP franchise 2.0, meaning dinos are not going to look a 100% accurate. If anything I'm actually surprised they compromise with most dinos between with a mix of accurate and JP anatomy

unique island
#

^ Dondi did say it himself that the game is somewhat inspired by JP

cyan flame
#

As for why people want accuracy, could be for all sorts of reason, from simply preferring things to be accurate, thinking the accurate version looks better, or whatever reasoning they may have. And it's not like we've not had a fair few remodels of critters already, not really sure why they changed the stego again for that matter..

grand brook
#

"somewhat"

#

sure

cyan flame
#

Yeah.. just a few calls that are pretty much JP.. somewhat indeed xD

unique island
#

when I mean somewhat I meant its just one of the inspirations behind the game. As there are multiple lol

grand brook
#

not saying the game is not good, but saying that it's only somewhat similar to JP is naive at best

cyan flame
#

Anyway, wish they'd just kept the current stego and done minor changes, than the new stocky one, but oh well xD

barren zephyr
#

Screw accuracy man. If the stego looks cool idc if it's accurate or not.

winter spear
#

good luck with the derpy ass anatomy and walking animations lmao

#

wouldnt look so out of place if done anatomically correct

#

its like giving a horse stubby legs and forgetting the joints

#

not to mention stego had hella more plates

#

if yall want just 'cool' shit thats part of it

valid zephyr
#

gameplay > realism

still temple
#

most accurate dino in TI is taco

valid zephyr
#

if a not realistic stego fits in more, then it's better to have than a realistic stego

#

realistic dibble for example would just be AI. It's tiny and would be useless

cyan flame
#

? :p

winter spear
#

A realistic stego would literally make animating it easier

#

And they wouldn't have to be remaking it all the time

#

The current stego is actually pretty realistic compared to the new. Just needs more plates, shorter legs, and well, more knowledge of how legs work

#

I mean dilo has the most complicated anatomy considering its bones, and the isle did fine

#

Why cant they just make stego legs work without them looking weird lmao

#

But ya know if you want weird stego legs that look weird when they walk, whateva

compact coyote
#

ohh wait, do you mean current stego in game

#

or the remodel

mellow maple
#

Realistic stego would make it better at what it's supposed to do tho, it'd have a longer tail 😛

#

My main problem with the Stego rn is that it's called stenops when it looks more like armatus.

#

Though the devs have made up their minds on how the Stego looks so there's no changing that.

viral creek
#

I like that we do have kind of a mix of jp anatomy and accurate anatomy

mellow maple
#

It does at least look like a stego.

viral creek
#

Utah for example. He looks like a jp raptor, but he at least dosen't have broken wrists

#

Stego is jp like

#

But at least his tail is nice n upright

#

Unlike many other depections of stego

#

Velociraptor is scaley

#

But at least it has accurate anatomy and size

#

Ok you get the idea,

mellow maple
#

Some better than others tho

viral creek
#

I wouldn't have our stego any other way tbh

#

He's beautiful the way he is

mellow maple
#

He's a good boi, better than spino imo

viral creek
#

Eh

#

New spino model has already been changed for the better

#

we just haven't seen it yet

#

I wouldn't diss spino until we've seen the completed new model

mellow maple
#

Fair, but I won't expect them to make the legs shorter and the snout narrower any time soooon kek.- Wait we should go back to #401464048610312195

valid zephyr
#

hope we get to see the new spoon soon

barren zephyr
#

I think dilo bite should do something other than bleed to make it more unique.
Maybe a dilo bite disables Nightvision and allows dilos to smell your body for 2 minutes or something.

thorny lynx
#

Why tho

#

They're already going to have an anticoagulant in their venom

#

Makes you bleed faster

paper oriole
#

Galli could be an omnivore but just let him eat tiny prey, eggs and the bugs that fly around

#

Tbh many current herbis having the option to eat tiny prey wouldnt hurt, deer and cows do it irl

#

Galli bite is too weak to eat most prey items we have in the game

jovial saddle
#

Giga was not 8 or 9 tonnes....

#

It was 6.8

#

And if giga did run at 50 kmh irl then it would literally break its legs

jovial saddle
#

The bleeder is good as it is

paper oriole
#

Oh lord another buff giga post

summer mist
#

nope not strong enough its to weak

paper oriole
#

Giga would be the most broken shit ever if it ran even near that fast

jovial saddle
#

Which reminds me

summer mist
#

a spino shouldnt even be an apex it was a fisher , giga was built for speed and bleed it had serated teeth and killed saurpods young and used it speed to doge tail swipes

paper oriole
#

Giga is already better at hunting mid tiers than rex

#

It isnt there to fight rex

summer mist
#

not really rex has a better ambush and faster sprint , all giga has is the walk

jovial saddle
#

Just cause spino was a fisher doesn’t mean it wasn’t an apex

paper oriole
#

Rex has 30sec stam

#

Giga will wear you down across the map

#

And regens stam much better

summer mist
#

come on the spino had a bbite force of 2 tones , i use to fight carcharodontosaurus and lose XD

jovial saddle
paper oriole
#

Last thing giga needs is a speed buff

jovial saddle
#

Planet Dinosaur is an outdated source of paleontology

lament thorn
#

I think you are forgetting something very important

#

this is a game

valid zephyr
jovial saddle
#

That too

valid zephyr
#

45kph giga with 50kph ambush and 8 tons mass.

#

wow

#

just fucking wow

paper oriole
#

How fucking stupid would it be to have an apex running around at carno speed

summer mist
#

take is walk from it give it slower walk and faster run giga is usless in apex fights and i shouldnt it should stand a chance to bleed it opponate out

paper oriole
#

LOL

viral creek
#

So you want giga's ambush to be faster than gallimimus

paper oriole
#

Giga isnt made to fight rex

viral creek
#

And run speed very fast

paper oriole
#

Wtf

viral creek
#

Also, I think the whole 50kph thing is outdated

summer mist
#

why/ it is the animal natural speed

jovial saddle
#

Literally everything he just said is either outdated or just plain out not true

summer mist
#

like saying that a carno should be slower cause its a game

paper oriole
#

Gameplay > "realism"

viral creek
#

I'm sorry, but what you're asking is to turn the entire game into giga simulator, cause every single animal will just die.

paper oriole
#

Carno isnt strong

valid zephyr
summer mist
#

why banlace it out the rex has bone break doesnt matter if your not skilled enought to avoid its bite

paper oriole
#

Youre suggesting an apex that shreds all mid tiers be buffed to outrun them

#

How broken is that

valid zephyr
#

and also that weight buff will make it destroy rex and trike

bold relic
#

If you are a skilled giga player you can win 1v1 rex

viral creek
#

A skilled giga can already take on a rex.

What you are asking is going to break the entire game

paper oriole
#

Bone break is getting rework

valid zephyr
#

basically asking to make giga the fist of god

jovial saddle
#

Carno speed giga?

#

Sounds hot

paper oriole
#

Imagine unironically asking for giga buff

viral creek
#

Also the ingame weight isn't based on real weight, it's just there to\ balance out damage

jovial saddle
#

^^^ and HP

bold relic
#

Lets just give the giga 200 tons 500km/h walk and immunity to fd

viral creek
#

That too

paper oriole
#

Just make giga 1 call instantly give 50 bleed to all rexes on the server too

summer mist
#

why not? the carno was an injurance dino it could keep this speed for long distances , somthing that weight 8 ton isnt going to be able to keep it for long 50kmh its factual speed for 20 secs

viral creek
#

🤦

paper oriole
#

Carno is a fukin weakling

valid zephyr
#

I can't even argue

#

i'm just crying

paper oriole
#

He isnt breaking anything

viral creek
#

We already have an ambush predator neiche either way, and that belongs to rex, who is still slower than that

paper oriole
#

This is sad

jovial saddle
#

Adult Giganotosaurus doesn’t need a buff

valid zephyr
#

@mossy mauve Your prophet is here.

bold relic
#

Isnt gigas ambush faster than rexes?

half mist
#

Nah

#

Rex has a faster ambush but it lasts like two seconds

paper oriole
#

Imagine unironically asking for 50km/h giga

summer mist
#

so was the giga is was so much smaller in frame then rex , the rex was a bull built like a blunt object , the giga was taller longer but smiler built to be faster and built to do bleed it had serrated teeth and was quick over short distances

viral creek
#

Rex has a really fast ambush, but only lasts 6 seconds.

#

Including the time it takes to build up that speed

jovial saddle
#

Ok first of all this game is supposed to be fun and semi-realistic

valid zephyr
#

not only 50kph, but 8 tons so it outfights rex and trike with ease

viral creek
#

Okay bearbox. I don't know if you've considered this

half mist
#

50km/h Giga would be able to outrun every small and mid tier except for Carno

jovial saddle
#

Second of all, speed estimates put T. rex as the fastest mega theropod

viral creek
#

But your accuracy dosen't mean shit when it involves breaking the entire balance of the game

#

Enough said.

valid zephyr
#

Giga that weight and speed would beat all dinos in the game by far in a fight, and run down all dinos except carno.

#

how would anything else survive

viral creek
#

We know these things

#

We know about giga irl

indigo sun
#

You need to consider other dinosaurs and balance before you ever bring realism into a game where dinosaurs who never lived together exist

viral creek
#

But we don't care

#

Cause it will ruin everything

summer mist
#

how? so its okay to have a spino whos isnt an apex do insane amounts of bleed and take insane punishment but cand have a dino run is normal speed for 15-20 secs and be its factual weight to give the giga an chance to be able to stand a chance killing a rex with bone break

paper oriole
#

No talking logic into this guy

half mist
#

Spino doesn't even do that much bleed?

jovial saddle
#

IT’S A SANDBOX DINO

paper oriole
#

Spino is getting rework

#

God

viral creek
#

Spinosaurus is a huge animal, and dosen't do much bleed nor damage. He's just really tanky

indigo sun
#

Spino's coming to survival so the sandbox argument isnt really valid for it anymore

valid zephyr
#

I'm forwarding this convo to tentacle. He will have an actual field day.

paper oriole
#

Do you keep up to date on isle news at all

viral creek
#

And giga can already take on a rex in the hands of a skilled player, or if it gets the jump on it

#

Now uh

half mist
#

Yea but Spino will get stat updates

#

It may be coming to survival but its stats are outdated

viral creek
#

Please consider the well being of the rest of the survival roster before bringing in your accuracy arguements that everybody aready knows about

jovial moss
#

wtf is going on dondiSquint

summer mist
#

the spino was a skinny walking fish i weight alot true , due to its sixe but it would get dicked by a rex 100% of the time in a real fight should be a mid teir

half mist
#

Skinny?

paper oriole
#

Another buff giga lmao

half mist
#

You call the heaviest theropod ever conceived skinny?

paper oriole
#

Thats what

jovial moss
#

even if you DID get your giga buffs @summer mist there would be no point to play the game as anything else, it would literally be giga simulator

jovial saddle
#

So 6.9 tonnes is skinny?

#

Spinosaurus is literally bigger than Giganotosaurus by 100 ish kg

viral creek
#

Even so, our new spinosaurus in game isn't a completely accurate spino

#

He's beefy

jovial saddle
#

^^^

jovial moss
#

it would face tank rex and trike, it would outspeed everything but an ambushing utah and carno, like wtf do u want

jovial saddle
#

It’s a fictional spino

#

Which is usually 9-11 tonnes

summer mist
#

look at the frame of the spino wasnt build to fight anything it was a killer fishermen end of , it use to fight carcharodontosaurus and lose

viral creek
#

Real spino, sure

jovial saddle
#

Oh

#

My

viral creek
#

Have you seen our new spino

jovial saddle
#

God

indigo sun
#

This isnt the real spino in this game

barren zephyr
#

@summer mist

viral creek
#

Let me fetch an image of the concept

barren zephyr
#

bearbox.

indigo sun
#

Do you understand that? Our spino does not look completely realistic

jovial saddle
#

Both theropods lived in Africa but they never crossed paths with each other

barren zephyr
#

I highly suggest you to contact an actual reliable source like Franoys

#

other than relying on shitty information

#

such as Google.

paper oriole
#

I dont think its worth trying to negotiate with this dude

jovial saddle
#

They even filled different niches so they wouldn’t even mess with each other

barren zephyr
#

it isnt

#

I can tell

#

if they use google

#

its not worth it

summer mist
#

yes of course , but if your try to recreate a animal atleast get sum things right

barren zephyr
#

But its right

#

You dummy

#

that buff giga suggestion is the most bruh suggestion ever

#

You just want giga to be as 10 ton rex killer

#

lol

#

why make giga faster than a fucking utah

summer mist
#

oi fuck you , istudied

#

v

jovial saddle
#

And make it faster than galli

barren zephyr
#

You studied google

viral creek
barren zephyr
#

you didnt study fuck shit

summer mist
#

ive studied paleontology for a long time

barren zephyr
#

LMAO

half mist
#

Uhuh

barren zephyr
#

YOU DIDNT

#

uhuh

#

you sure did

half mist
#

What are you

#

12

#

13

jovial saddle
#

LMFAOOOO

viral creek
#

Also bearbox, we know these facts. But we don't care. Because your accuracy is going to break the game.

paper oriole
#

Guys giga still wouldnt be able to catch ptera it wouldnt be fair, let giga fly too

barren zephyr
#

he is trolling

summer mist
#

bro im 22

barren zephyr
#

if you studied paleontology you wouldnt rely on google

indigo sun
#

How would giga being faster impact the rest of the dinosaurs in this game?

half mist
#

22 months?

indigo sun
#

Did you stop to think about that?

barren zephyr
#

If you studied paleontology you wouldnt use google as information

#

this man is frigging trolling

viral creek
#

^

oblique sluice
#

You studied paleo under a rock @summer mist

barren zephyr
#

yea this guy is 100% trolling @barren zephyr

#

<@&401466542140817419>

#

lets close this case

jovial moss
#

make giga swim faster than sucho while you're at it, gotta catch those pesky spinosaurids

barren zephyr
#

with a golden key

jovial moss
#

everyone must pay

#

giga master race

summer mist
#

i rely on google cause you muppets cant get facts right easier to show you , internet is a wealth of knowlogy , and that spino agian miles away from what it looked like trying to beaf it up and make it an apex when it wasnt

jovial saddle
#

Knowlogy

viral creek
#

I don't want to say this one more time

#

But we know these facts, we know about accuracy. But
We
Don't
Care.

neat flicker
#

And let's keep the sly remarks to ourselves and move back to discussing suggestions

viral creek
#

Why?
Because it will destroy all balance

jovial moss
#

because this is a g a m e

jovial saddle
#

Speed buff for sub giga yes yes

viral creek
#

Giga is getting his anims redone, hopefully sub and juvi giga get exclusive locomotion to help with his speed

jovial saddle
#

I never knew that

#

Huh

viral creek
#

@summer mist I have a question for you

paper oriole
#

Lmao imagine unironically suggesting giga outrun all mid tiers then call others stupid

viral creek
#

Do you want to break the entire game and make it so nobody plays literally anything but giga

jovial saddle
#

Imagine saying Giga was 10 tonnes

indigo sun
#

Do you think about the way the other dinosaurs in the game will be impacted or do you just think giga should be fast for realism @summer mist

oblique sluice
#

yEs BecAuSe iT's mY FaV dIno

barren zephyr
#

50kms is a paleo meme

#

like 1 ton utah

summer mist
#

the giga wasnt 10 tons ? it weight max of close to 9 ? the giga is bigger than a rex faster but has less bite force of course

viral creek
#

These animals lived in completely different time periods and different areas, they were never meant to coexist. So we need to balance them so they can coexist, even if it isn't 100% accurate.

barren zephyr
#

dumb

indigo sun
#

Answer the question

viral creek
#

^

jovial saddle
#

NO THEROPOD

#

WAS BIGGER

boreal raven
#

@summer mist The biggest giga they have found was thought to have weighed 13 tons.

jovial saddle
#

THAN

#

T. rex

#

Ok I’m done

viral creek
#

lol

barren zephyr
#

@boreal raven wrong

boreal raven
#

Explain. @barren zephyr

jovial saddle
#

Uh what

barren zephyr
jovial saddle
#

Giga wasn’t 13

#

6.8 tonnes

boreal raven
#

The BIGGEST.

#

Not average.

jovial saddle
#

What specimen was 13? Lmao

barren zephyr
#

the biggest theropod is 9.1 tons which is a tyrannosaurus

indigo sun
#

You got proof of that gryphon?

viral creek
#

Tyrannosaurus is the heaviest

jovial saddle
#

Better be a reliable source

viral creek
#

But not the biggest

summer mist
#

no both , the giga should be able to catch most mid tiers other than gail , rator , carno maybe cera in ambush , but the giga should be faster maybe not 50kmh but defo faster than what it is now , take the god walk form it give it a slower walk and faster run and ambush , like you smart guys keep saying it should be able to hunt mid tiers better than any other apex but , it should also be able to hold it on with other apexs to make the game enjoyable

jovial saddle
#

Biggest is heaviest

#

Giga was longer though

viral creek
#

Ok bearbox

paper oriole
#

I can feel my brain cells frying each time i read BearBox's arguments

viral creek
#

i am out lol

barren zephyr
#

Hey Beart

jovial saddle
#

You know what

barren zephyr
#

Look at my suggestion.ö

jovial saddle
#

I’m gonna go to the paleo chat

lilac swallow
#

50km/h i simply "why play anithing besides giga"

jovial saddle
#

Because I’m on my last brain cell

indigo sun
#

Everything else is fucked at that point seriously did you consider any other dinosaur?

oblique sluice
#

@barren zephyr Rex ambush is 5s

#

not 12

boreal raven
barren zephyr
#

I said make rex's ambush 12 seconds

jovial saddle
#

“T-rex”

lilac swallow
#

Yeah give giga 50kmph lets see how everyone goes guga

barren zephyr
#

While it has the faster ambush between giga and rex

jovial saddle
#

Yeah sorry pal but that’s not reliable

wintry cipher
#

8 seconds would be fine for it tbh. 12 seconds......good lord thats too long. thats not even an ambush at that point.

half mist
#

How does 14 tons = 8000 kilograms

barren zephyr
#

yea was gonna say that

boreal raven
#

Oh hi Tac lmao

half mist
#

Yo

valid zephyr
#

Gameplay > Realism

jovial saddle
#

^^^

summer mist
#

the spino was the heaviest dont no where you getting this info from

jovial saddle
#

That too

lilac swallow
#

Thats not even realistic

half mist
#

Even in short tons I don't think that adds up but lemme check

mossy mauve
#

Comrade I am proud of the buff giga person

jovial saddle
#

I swear

#

Giga

barren zephyr
#

Scotty officially makes Tyrannosaurus longer than Giga.

jovial saddle
#

Is

#

Perfect

#

As it is

#

It doesn’t need a buff

barren zephyr
#

Largest giganotosaurus is 12.80 meters long

jovial saddle
#

Or a nerf

lilac swallow
#

Seriously have you ever considered what would happen?

barren zephyr
#

Rex's base speed should be the same as giga imo.
But the rex has a faster ambush than the giga. While the giga gets a nerf to dmg and bb

wintry cipher
#

also; giga's only major threat is rex, while rex has to deal with allos, carnos, dilos and utahs, ceratos and diablos.

barren zephyr
#

Scotty pushes Tyrannosaurus to 13 meters long.

#

df

half mist
#

8000kg is 8.8 US tons

barren zephyr
#

nerf to dmg and alt

wintry cipher
#

the instant giga can reliably escape rex, it is op and unstoppable

barren zephyr
#

oh and Spinosaurus is lighter

indigo sun
#

@summer mist answer the question. Did you consider the fate of other playables or did you only think of giga for this "realistic" suggestion?

barren zephyr
#

its way less wider

#

and much more adapted to water

jovial saddle
#

Spinosaurus was 6.9 tonnes

#

Still a big boi

barren zephyr
#

its just a thin boi

summer mist
#

@indigo sun i anwserd that

jovial saddle
#

We should seriously move this to paleo chat

half mist
#

Spinosaurus was potentially the heaviest based off of higher estimates which, as of right now, are only theoretical

barren zephyr
#

@half mist

#

Wrong though

#

this is the most recent and updated GDI made for Spinosaurus

#

where would it be ok for me to ask a question about buying the game and devs?

lilac swallow
#

Stop with the paleo we are talking here about a serious suggestion about 50kmph giga

half mist
#

I'm not trying to say Spino is the heaviest lmao

barren zephyr
#

@barren zephyr discussion can work

half mist
#

I'm on your side

barren zephyr
#

gud

#

thanks

half mist
#

I'm saying based off of older estimates, it could potentially be the heaviest

#

But that's all theoretical

jovial saddle
#

@lilac swallow do you really think that 50kmph giga isn’t a joke?

barren zephyr
#

anyway making giga faster and ruining its trot like wtf

indigo sun
#

If giga is made faster, then that kind of fucks over everything. Giga obliterates every mid tier because of how high its bite force is and how much bleed it does. Adding on to make it even more powerful screws over other dinosaurs completely.

lilac swallow
#

I do think is serious and is sad

barren zephyr
#

Hey fun fact

#

Giga was actually SLOWER

#

than Tyrannosaurus

jovial saddle
#

Well you’re right on the second part

#

EXACTLY

barren zephyr
#

because it didnt have the running adaptations that Tyrannosaurus have.

#

metatarsal bone.

#

and its shorter knees

summer mist
#

wikipeidia dont cont mate

barren zephyr
#

..

lilac swallow
#

In fact Rex was a speedy boy It just was too heavy to run so fast

barren zephyr
#

GOOGLE doesnt count mate

jovial saddle
#

I’m gonna lose it

barren zephyr
#

You fucking kidding me man

#

This guy says wikipedia doesnt count

#

but relies on google

#

🤦

#

google is ten times worse

south flower
#

I feel that given the amount of bleed giga does, it doesn’t need to have a faster run. It’s like a Komodo dragon biting its prey and casually tracking it down. The giga relies on it’s bleed to kill prey most times if not hunting smaller tiers.

lilac swallow
#

Google is like Wikipedia but worse

barren zephyr
#

and wikipedia is accurate sometimes when its about the FOSSILS

mellow fox
#

Holy fucking shit, Giga might as well be my most favorite dinosaur but holy hell this suggestion with the 50km/h Giga is oblivious

barren zephyr
#

The mass estimates are not.

mellow fox
#

Please tell me it was a joke

jovial saddle
#

At least Wikipedia updated their models

indigo sun
#

Giga is not a spinter, it trots down prey after getting a bite, keeping it moving so it bleeds out.

jovial saddle
#

@mellow fox he isn’t joking

lilac swallow
#

Out of carno, who would survive that?

jovial saddle
#

He sadly isn’t joking

mellow fox
#

I am just leaving this here

paper oriole
#

Sadly it seems BearBox is serious... Seriously dense

mellow fox
barren zephyr
#

What the hell is with people.

#

What ya guys think of my suggestion?

#

inb4 fanboys

#

Yeah buff its nerf

summer mist
#

you people need to watch so basic walking with dinosaurs all over the show Xd

barren zephyr
#

..

#

well

#

well well

south flower
#

...

barren zephyr
#

we got a poser.

#

lets see:

jovial saddle
#

I’m about to say

#

The N WOrd

barren zephyr
#
  1. Claims hes a long time paleontologist but relies on google.
indigo sun
#

You seriously need to think about BASIC FUCKING BALANCE before you make suggestions on realism.

jovial saddle
#

Nigersaurus

lilac swallow
#

We could argue about a slight buff, but you are basically asking to twice its speed

summer mist
#

no need to get up set little girls

jovial saddle
#

@barren zephyr I don’t see why giga needs a dmg nerf

manic ibex
#

GUys I'm 22 I KnOw WhAt I'm TaLkInG ABOut

viral creek
#

Proper game balance > Muh realism

paper oriole
#

did somebody say NIGERSAURUS

barren zephyr
#

Because why rely on bleed when it can just 2 shot everything

#
  1. Even though he relies on google, whichs already a disgustingly gross way to get information about dinosaurs, states Wikipedia doesnt count even though Wikipedia itself is pretty accurate if you exclude the size and mass estimates.
south flower
#

Then resorts to namecalling. Oof

indigo sun
#

How does this impact mid tiers? Everyone goes giga and the people that dont die.

valid zephyr
#

realism is 100% irrelevent

jovial saddle
#

Yeah but

barren zephyr
#

When giga is supposed to be a bleeder

jovial saddle
#

350 dmg?

valid zephyr
#

game balance is more important

barren zephyr
#
  1. Thinks outdated documentaries are reliable.
jovial saddle
#

That’s rex food

barren zephyr
#

Then 400

#
  1. wants Giga to outrun everything but carno.
valid zephyr
#

walking with dinos is ancient

viral creek
#

Bearbox makes me cry salty tears.

jovial saddle
#

I’d be ok with 500-550 dmg

half mist
#

Guys guys Spino can totally kill Rex because it snapped its neck in JP3 11/10 reliable content

barren zephyr
#

450

jovial saddle
#

350 is just back to the way it was before

indigo sun
#

450-500 is alright for giga

barren zephyr
#

Yeah

paper oriole
#

500 for giga is good

barren zephyr
#

🍵

mossy mauve
#

Wait WHAT?

jovial saddle
#

600+ is overkill for mid tiers but it’s supposed to be a sauropod killer

barren zephyr
#

Its meant to be trotting out and bleeding out prey.

mossy mauve
#

giga needs BUFF

valid zephyr
#

walking with dinos has non feathered utah dondiGross

half mist
#

I feel 350 - 450 would be good for new Spino but idk

barren zephyr
#

but then imo, I feel like rex should be the base sprint speed as giga, while having the faster ambush of the two

#

@mossy mauve Shut the fuck up we are being serious here

mossy mauve
#

oh

barren zephyr
#

🤡 🎪

mossy mauve
#

I'll leave then

barren zephyr
#

So giga isn't a walking meal

valid zephyr
#

Awez is our savior, he will bring about the giga buffs.

covert oasis
#

My fucking brain cells

viral creek
#

Rex - DPS
Giga- DOT (damage over time)
Spino- Tank

The perfect balance

half mist
#

As all things should be

mossy mauve
#

Rex - deleted Giga - buffed Spino - never gets added

#

what a dream

mellow fox
#

Giga 500 damage but similar base sprint to Rex with Rex still having the superior ambush as well as a slight alt turn nerf and Giga should be pretty alright

jovial saddle
#

Spino should be the old fisherman

#

Not a tank

#

Mf is literally too skinny

half mist
#

It's an old fisherman that just happens to be a tank

jovial saddle
#

After the new model comes out

#

Then it’ll be beefy

barren zephyr
#

nah 350 giga and 500 rex

south flower
#

It may be different when spino gets a new mode though

lilac swallow
#

Ask for the second strongest playable to be also the second fastest

south flower
#

Model*

jovial saddle
#

It’s definitely getting an attack nerf

#

I MEAN

#

Hp nerf

jovial moss
#

rex and giga should just do 1 damage each but there's a 1 in 10 chance to instakill the person you bite, gotta keep the rng alive

valid zephyr
#

Can we have a discord hall of fame, for the greatest comments of all time to go?

viral creek
#

Please

jovial saddle
#

Wait lemme make a new suggestion

valid zephyr
#

the comments which will go down in history, and be remembered for generations to come

barren zephyr
#

Rex should have more mass too

mellow fox
#

You can nerf Giga all that you want just give it the ability to be able to actually force the bleed game on Rex or escape it from 40 meters if both start running at the same time (Rex doesn't even need to ambush for that catch as an "ambush predator")

half mist
#

Do what Nycta does and have a comment awards @valid zephyr

viral creek
#

i still remember uncleraptor

#

never forget

indigo sun
#

Shit man i think about uncleraptor sometimes and almost cry

barren zephyr
#

Ikr

mellow fox
#

Basically give Giga the ability to force the bleeding game on Rex if played well, nerf so it can't facetank and so it actually has to bleed prey

barren zephyr
#

Rex is just a race car

indigo sun
#

He's what got me my strike cause I called him a bitch and told him to stop bitching

barren zephyr
#

BearBox might aswell be Uncleraptor's alt

jovial moss
#

it;ll help when bone break isnt so RNG

#

gigas won't get leg break on the first hit every time

lilac swallow
#

Nah

paper oriole
#

This buff giga suggestion is worse than the mild diarrhea and firebreathing para suggestions

viral creek
barren zephyr
#

For being a slow runner rex is so fast

lilac swallow
#

Uncle would call us Rex fanboy

viral creek
#

I mean I'm all for firebreathing para

barren zephyr
#

Rex was nto a slow runner

#

Most of the time

#

Was not*

#

kazuto.

#

It was pretty darn fast

jovial saddle
#

18 mph is slow?

barren zephyr
#

it just didnt sprint like a cheetah.

jovial saddle
#

That’s faster than a human

jovial moss
#

firebreathing para is a great suggestion lmao

barren zephyr
#

its actually 32/35 kmh

#

not 28

#

@jovial saddle

jovial saddle
#

Still really damn fast for a 9 tonne lizard

summer mist
#

anyone else want to abuse me a little more?

barren zephyr
#

indeed

#

df

lilac swallow
#

Rex was an speedy ostrich most of its life

barren zephyr
#

df

half mist
#

I mean if you're offering..

indigo sun
#

Oh i thought you left

barren zephyr
#

Scientists estimated that rex could run at 45 mp/h?

jovial saddle
#

Ok that’s kinky

barren zephyr
#

....

jovial moss
#

You just opened up another can of worms lol

barren zephyr
#

you been abusing our braincells since you first shown your existance.

paper oriole
#

No go to your room BearBox, and think about your actions

barren zephyr
#

@barren zephyr not 45 mph

#

fuck no

#

20 mph

indigo sun
#

Why did you come back though? Like, this isn't being rude but you left the conversation for like 5 minutes

barren zephyr
#

for rex

jovial saddle
#

Lmao remember that mega theropods couldn’t run

barren zephyr
#

20-22 mph

jovial saddle
#

They power walked

barren zephyr
#

I said

#

They could run @jovial saddle

#

Scientists estimated

#

Just not lift both feet off the ground

jovial saddle
#

Ooooh

jovial moss
#

imagine rex's model but using galli's trot animation

barren zephyr
#

oh god

#

hoppy thicc boi

summer mist
#

been here the whole time never left funny watching you lot cry

lilac swallow
#

I did

indigo sun
#

Okay bud

lilac swallow
#

Okay

barren zephyr
#

We were right all along

paper oriole
#

He frolic

barren zephyr
#

Troll.

lilac swallow
#

I think we didnt cry

indigo sun
#

Have fun watching

barren zephyr
lilac swallow
#

I may be wrong

mossy mauve
#

BearBox I'm on your side don't worry

jovial moss
#

no I definitely cried

mossy mauve
#

Giga needs a buff

indigo sun
#

Awez fuckin dont

paper oriole
#

Cried from laughter

barren zephyr
#

Awez.

#

This is why we hate you

mossy mauve
#

Ok I don't

viral creek
#

awez he'll think you're serious

mossy mauve
#

You don't hate me FeelsBadMan

barren zephyr
#

THIS is why I hate giga buff memes

lilac swallow
#

Awez you should know when to stop

summer mist
#

hate me all you want dont stop me thinking your a tit XD

barren zephyr
#

Because it may make people think you are serious

jovial saddle
#

@barren zephyr yes ty

viral creek
#

i mean it's ok to be wrong

lilac swallow
#

Yeah

indigo sun
#

No one said they hated you they were talking to awez.

lilac swallow
#

We are a tit

half mist
#

Jokes on you, I like tits

viral creek
#

mmmm

#

💦

mossy mauve
#

No one hates anyone here

summer mist
#

sorry for just putting in a suggestion next time i will just keep it to my self

indigo sun
#

Jokes on you, i am a tit

lilac swallow
#

Thats because we cant see balance on 50kmph giga

paper oriole
#

I doubt you think at all, Bear

barren zephyr
#

oh hey guys

#

all this resulted in nothing

#

the guy still thinks giga is a 50 kph 10 ton rex killer

jovial moss
#

next time think about how it would affect the game itself

barren zephyr
#

how intuitive it was

mellow fox
#

Can I call in a moderator already since the Giga buff dude is using insults now?

lilac swallow
#

I wouldnt play anything else

jovial moss
#

it would literally destroy the game, it literally would

mellow fox
#

breathes in

lilac swallow
#

Yeah

paper oriole
#

Hes done this before

barren zephyr
#

I already tagged a moderator but didnt really do anything, told us to not use sly remarks

mellow fox
lilac swallow
#

Pls do

barren zephyr
#

Maybe its time to do it now

mossy mauve
#

Leave em be who cares? peepoPat

viral creek
indigo sun
#

Every time someone makes a bad suggestion and people disagree its "GUeSs iLl NEvEr shArE mY oPINioN AgAIn!"

summer mist
#

so its okay for people to insult me but i can isult back noiceee

jovial saddle
#

I care about my last brain cell, thank you very much

mellow fox
#

@neat flicker dryoree

mossy mauve
#

Just shush we don't need admin slaps here

mellow fox
#

Can we shot this down

lilac swallow
#

Never insulted you mate

mossy mauve
#

chill down

mellow fox
neat flicker
#

The next person to insult someone is getting kicked

#

Cut the baby crap

mellow fox
#

Thanks OP

lilac swallow
#

True thanks

barren zephyr
#

Thanks

jovial saddle
#

Ty ma’am or sir

viral creek
#

thx

neat flicker
#

If you can't talk to one another without respect or you don't have anything nice to say, keep it to yourself.

#

This is for suggestion discussing only.

#

Move it back on track please

indigo sun
#

Fair enough

summer mist
#

well thank you for the popcorn moments boys 😛

jovial saddle
#

Sub giga is a walking burger for fully grown mid tiers and apexes

lilac swallow
#

Admiting is a troll

viral creek
#

That could be fix once giga gets his anims redone

jovial saddle
#

I hope so

barren zephyr
#

Now they have just admitted

mellow fox
#

ehm

Sub Giga fresh kills adult Cerato

viral creek
#

Hopefully he gets exclusive juvenile and sub anims like rex

mellow fox
#

Just FYI

barren zephyr
#

@mellow fox we needed two of us

#

though

jovial saddle
#

Yeah but the sprint is still slow

barren zephyr
#

one of us wouldnt do much i guess

mellow fox
#

I played like a potato @barren zephyr

jovial saddle
#

It’s hella s t r o n k but slow

barren zephyr
#

true you let him go inside your tail

lilac swallow
#

I hope every non adult doesnt feel like "just a smaller weaker and slower adult"

viral creek
#

^

mellow fox
#

I landed 4 less bite than I should have and you landed 4

#

It evens out

lilac swallow
#

Which in case of giga and trike is true

barren zephyr
#

well isnt that kind how younger animals are compared to the adults?

#

I mean irl and logically?

lilac swallow
#

Nah

barren zephyr
#

even though this game is not really into logic

viral creek
#

Even if it were

#

That's no fun

barren zephyr
#

True

viral creek
#

That's why people afk

lilac swallow
#

Irl Rex is an example of not being just a smaller adult

barren zephyr
#

Yeah

paper oriole
#

Rex is an example of all stages being enjoyable to play

barren zephyr
#

It had its own unique niche at younger stages

paper oriole
#

Yea

lilac swallow
#

I wouldnt afk at all if i could enjoy my dinos whole grow time

paper oriole
#

A pack of rexes with a sub is very efficient

barren zephyr
#

Nights shouldnt be so damn boring either

jovial saddle
#

Sub rex is fast, strong, and you can ruin a cocky mid tier

barren zephyr
#

most people log at night

mellow fox
#

Generally it's a good idea to let weaker things escape while keep the strong bois slower

looking at Rex base speed
shakyeyes2

barren zephyr
#

the only dinosaur that is fun at night is Dilo.

#

Because it has good NV

viral creek
#

Rex base speed is still pretty slow

lilac swallow
#

But zero muh pitch black nights

barren zephyr
#

thenyaw.

#

I thought pitch black nights relates to the kind of game we are meant to play

#

but i realized it makes the game tedious

viral creek
#

I have a love hate relationship with the pitch black nights

barren zephyr
#

i liked pitch black nights

lilac swallow
#

I have pure hate

viral creek
#

It's defs creepy and opens up a cool new, nocturnal neiche. However it can get mega old

lilac swallow
#

Cant do shit, nor feel afraid because i know they cant see me neither

#

Is a moment of going afk thats all

viral creek
#

I think a good compromise would to have a relatively bright night, like on r2. But make the shadows pitch black

#

You'll need nv to see in the forest

lilac swallow
#

Exactly gulpy

jolly willow
#

are we talking about gamma abuse or whay

lilac swallow
#

Thats good

#

Nah

barren zephyr
#

We need the foggy nights back too

viral creek
#

I'll make that a suggestion

barren zephyr
#

I'll support it gulpy

lilac swallow
#

About non boring nights

#

But gulpy

jolly willow
#

o

#

well make night less fuckin oppressive lol

#

buff everyone's nv tbh

#

even dilos isn't good enough

jovial saddle
#

Wait what

lilac swallow
#

Put that dilos can see better like being able to see in the shadows on night

viral creek
#

Does anybody have that screenshot of old r2 night

#

with the dilo

lilac swallow
#

Old nv was better

#

It wasnt just a black and white limited sphere around your dino

barren zephyr
#

sadly I dont

lilac swallow
#

Me neither

#

@viral creek for dilo It could be that It can even see color

#

To help with its night Hunter nice

#

Niche

viral creek
#

I'm talking about overall, not exclusively dilo

#

Dilo already has a great time at night

lilac swallow
#

Yeah i know

#

But specifying dilo could help for "whats with dilo you taking away its niche"

half mist
#

I mean, aren't the dinosaurs going to get their more varied night vision thingies later on?

viral creek
#

I mean, dilo will still keep his niche

#

You'll need to use night vision in dense forests

#

So dilo will be able to see you before you see it in forested areas.

lilac swallow
#

I know

viral creek
#

You can also hide in more open areas if you have a solid camo

#

I mean I can see what you're saying, but I'm not gonna add something to my suggestion that I don't think we need, just to satisfy a few players

lilac swallow
#

Fair enought

wintry cipher
#

@viral creek finally someone who gets it

#

a mix of the two would be perfect

viral creek
#

That's the plan 😛

azure arch
#

Gahghh

sick crescent
azure arch
#

What does ✅ mean

#

In suggestions

#

Like, that's going to get added

random knoll
#

no

azure arch
#

or do people do that instead of thumbs up sometimes

random knoll
#

just people like it

azure arch
#

ok

#

My one suggestion got 43 ✅

feral wedge
#

It means people like it.

azure arch
#

Cool

#

How many checks/thumbs up does it take for a dev to notice it

#

And what does it mean when people 'pin' your suggestions

random knoll
#

the devs all ways look known and again

feral wedge
#

Nothing or anything could or could not be added from the channel.

#

Doesn't matter how much it's liked or disliked.

azure arch
#

I wish devs would put a special emoji if THEY like the idea

#

so you can see if a dev likes it or not

#

I can't scroll through all the reactions, lol..

paper oriole
#

yeees more sauropods ples

night mountain
paper oriole
#

Yea his size would be a little more viable than amarga

#

Tho they could just bump the size like diablo lol

#

Also nigersaurus ples

night mountain
#

god i want niger too ;c

#

could even make it really unique by baking it mostly grow on aquatic plants like some giant shopvac

paper oriole
#

Yea and uh

#

Give it an attack where it can swing its flatass face as a blunt weapon lmao

night mountain
#

I still like it sucking skin off like a walrus

#

have it just like pull a rexs arm or eye out with pure suction

#

that would be so scary no one would mess with it

paper oriole
#

Yes

barren zephyr
#

Awful

paper oriole
#

Awfully good

night mountain
#

make its roar literally just a distorted vacuum cleaner noise

paper oriole
#

Like autotuned industrial vacuum

#

Yo isnt microraptor like smaller than a velo

night mountain
#

crow sized

paper oriole
#

Comparing it to austro lol

night mountain
#

im down but devs said they wont add anything smaller than dryo ;c

paper oriole
#

Or maybe they were just comparing feathera

#

Theres a compy in the database so idk maybe as ai but i doubt theyd add microraptor

night mountain
#

micro would need to much i'd think

#

compys just small

#

micro would need climbing mechanics and stff to feel right

paper oriole
#

Micro would be scratch model for something that logically would just eat bugs and small gore

#

I mean id love to eat some bugs tho i hope that becomes a thing

night mountain
#

same ;c

#

make bugs playable

pseudo falcon
#

@barren zephyr I like the idea of having that dino in the game. However, the devs have stated multiple times that they won't add any playable dinos that are that small.

#

Figured you might like knowing, so there you go.

#

Well, we don't know exactly what ptera will be able to do, so maybe that'll fit the bill.

#

T'would be a nice and reasonable addition.

paper oriole
#

a little glider raptor would be nice, i think something like Zhenyuanlong would be more likely than micro though, it's closer to velo size, which is still probably too small for the devs to want to make playable any time soon though

hallow vigil
#

@drowsy heron #general-feedback isnt the place to talk to ppl, if u want to talk about a suggestion, do it here. If u have a question about this game in general, ask in #401464048610312195 (also no, flying dinos are not yet playable)

still temple
#

Zhenyuanlong is epic

drowsy heron
#

sorry

hallow vigil
#

no prob

still temple
#

@barren zephyr The smallest creature is going to be Taco. Any smaller = rejected

paper oriole
#

Zhen is roughly as long as a taco i think

still temple
#

Depends on the species, Zhen is larger than TI’s taco @paper oriole

#

Which is p. neimongoliensis

mossy mauve
#

would smell like shit and look like shit np

barren zephyr
#

Why does there always have to be a stinky turds suggestion Temptong

wicked fossil
#

Turds are immersive after all

barren zephyr
#

Tfw you thought the poopy suggestion would be the worst

#

looks at suggestions dondiPathetic

wicked fossil
#

Its gone now

valid zephyr
#

damn i missed it

wicked fossil
#

Trolls not allowed so it got yeeted fast

valid zephyr
#

the bar is low today

barren zephyr
valid zephyr
#

nothing compares to the buff giga suggestion

barren zephyr
#

I’m just... sigh

valid zephyr
#

but jesus christ that one is bad

wicked fossil
#

Bad troll is bad

valid zephyr
#

Sorry but aquatic anky just seems wierd. It would sink like a rock.

indigo sun
#

Why on earth would anky be semi-aquatic? it has no features that would imply it lived in water. I'm all for survival anky but semi-aquatic is a no.

lament spoke
#

I'd have to agree with that. Plus the no physical damage is a no no imo

barren zephyr
#

Hello everyone what to do if you are not looking for a server the isle hep me pls...

indigo sun
#

I agree with you there. Why wouldn't a giant ass club do a ton of damage?

oak shale
#

@devout blaze ngl semi aquatic anky doesn’t sound very plausible

devout blaze
#

I think semi-aquatic could be interesting since Anky is slow on land. Elephants are really heavy, yet they are quite good swimmers.

oak shale
#

Doesn’t make them semi aquatic

indigo sun
#

That doesnt make an elephant semi-aquatic.

#

hippos would be at least semi aquatic but elephants arent. And they also arent basically a giant rock.

devout blaze
#

I know. I thought it might make anky gameplay interesting even though its not realistic

indigo sun
#

Anky can be interesting. It's an armored tank, which nothing else really has armor, and one of the few herbivores with a possibility of bonebreak

lament spoke
#

Well even though this isn't saurian with the realism you still have to follow the laws of nature

devout blaze
#

Anky is an amazing creature. I do hope a unique niche is found for it

random knoll
#

brekaing ankles

oak shale
#

Brusing ribs

lament spoke
#

Being a tank that can't Chase you down and you put yourself at your own risk to fight it

#

Anky should defensively be the best herbivore

devout blaze
#

I believe (though I can't find stats of swim speeds) that current anky in the Isle is a faster swimmer then runner. I thought it'd be interesting to consider a "semi-aquatic" angle

lament spoke
#

Well that's just how the anky was balanced. Many of the way the dinos interact with the water needs to be changed

paper oriole
#

Having anky rely purely on outside interference to kill its assailants is dumb tho

lament spoke
#

Yeah honestly that's the biggest issue that I have with it

#

I don't agree with the semi aquatic but doing no damage is not a good thing

indigo sun
#

Anky seriously looks like it would avoid swimming more than anything. And yeah, i dont see why it wouldnt do damage beyond breaking bone with the bigass club tail

devout blaze
#

Thanks for your feedback guys

paper oriole
#

It is already incapable of running, it deserves to be deadly, and even if he could escape to water which is also weird.. hed just be free spino snack

lament spoke
#

Also if you're using hippos as reference. Hippos can't swim so keep that in mind

devout blaze
#

Anky and elephants would be pretty close in weight. That was more my reference

paper oriole
#

There are other options for semi aquatic herbivores that will hopefully happen in the future, but anky deserves his spot as a deadly tank

devout blaze
#

I certainly agree he should be a deadly tank

lament spoke
#

Too slow to go after you but if you decide to go for the anky you better know what you're doing should be anky's niche

indigo sun
#

The physical appearance is more what you should pay attention to. The tail and legs and overall wide flat body shape doesnt make it seem like a great swimmer. It could at most be a slow-moving log

paper oriole
#

His attacks should have lethal potential, not just breaking bones and hoping a nearby opportunist peels his attacker

devout blaze
#

It could be a slow log that drifts downriver dondiThink

lament spoke
#

Deino will kinda already do thag

#

But the thagomizer will likely pull it down and it's legs are too short to reliably keep itself up

#

The semi aquatic herb isn't a bad idea. You just picked the wrong dino

devout blaze
#

A badly broken bone would often be lethal, if you're stuck in the open and can't limp under a tree. Be interesting if "permanent" effects were added after combat recode, e.g if your leg is broken in combat, it affects your dinosaur even after it heals (like Prophet's suggestion)

#

A rex messes with an anky, gets a broken leg, the anky leaves but the rex has a permanent effect from that

lament thorn
#

You always want to make sure the attacker won't just keep biting the Anky even with a broken leg

#

So doing a lot of dmg is needed too

devout blaze
#

In the document I had a "Shattered Leg" where the dinosaur that gets its leg broken by an anky can't move for a while. This gives the anky time to leave

paper oriole
#

Na if anky hits your ribs or face you shouldnt just go "aw man i cant chase it anymore" you should perish

#

A sauropod would work better as a water dweller imo since at least they have the ability to stick their head out of the water as they walk along the lakebed

devout blaze
#

Interesting. But if their head was sticking out of the water it'd probably be vulnerable to a neck strike from Deino

#

(not against the idea. I read books with sauropods in the water as a kid and loved it)

lament thorn
#

Wouldn't they be at risk if there head was under the water too?

#

Just don't get into water with large Deinos

paper oriole
#

Probably, i mean sauropods tho are very high risk to predators on land tho so theyd be making themselves vulnerable by choice really

#

Gotta give them some weakness for playability

devout blaze
#

I would love a semi-aquatic herbi with viable gameplay

paper oriole
#

It would also depend on the sauropod in question, and the deino in question. Hopefully we see more sauropods added in the future especially as playable

devout blaze
#

Yes. Hail Cama. Hail Brachi

paper oriole
#

I hope we see use of the sauro they have buried in the database too, may havr been bronto id have to recheck

#

Also smaller tier sauros like my boi nigersaurus

devout blaze
#

(Amargasaurus looks badass)

paper oriole
#

Bajadasaurus would be more viable than amarga imo, either way i want one of em

#

Things like baja/amarga, styraco and kentro could also open up a nice niche for reflection damage

#

Since styraco and kentro are in database already

devout blaze
#

Have to head off now. Thanks for the discussion B.T I hope you have a lovely night. Thank you to everyone who took the time to read and react to my post. May you all have a great day/night!

paper oriole
#

Aight see you around

#

dreams of nigersaurus

#

Make it a hatchlings worse nightmare

#

Or should i say... Nigermare

oak shale
#

dondiWTF @paper oriole

lament thorn
#

I have no words

paper oriole
#

:3

still temple
#

semi aquatic herbi is cool. Anky for semi aquatic is bad

indigo sun
#

We said that already

paper oriole
#

tbh i want local voice chat as an option because all the screechers that'd use it and you could hear them static scream in their mic at you while you attacked them

#

i hope thered be a cross species option too so i can hear the salt from juvie rexes i kick as a galli

random forge
#

it would make alot of sense if you could hear ONLY your grp members, and not randoms

#

betrayal grp members are the lowest of lows

#

dont do that.

lament thorn
#

dont trust people

random forge
#

could you tell me your ign ? so i can avoid u 😂

paper oriole
#

/bites big, burly rex
rex: ear piercing 9yr old screeches

random forge
#

you would be surprised by the amount of 50y who play rex

#

theres alot of them ! i rarely meet 8y in voice chat

lament thorn
#

the moms dont let them

steady cosmos
#

Young people dont like to play this game

random knoll
#

too much gore

steady cosmos
#

that young

#

impatient

#

get angry when they die

#

uninstall game

random forge
#

true that

sick pecan
#

what’s with isle players and wanting dino dumps

velvet siren
#

Ye I don't get it either, why not just scent marks for territory?

indigo sun
#

Cause scat fetishists

umbral prairie
#

I don't really get what territories would do, they either reveal you to potential predators or drive off potential prey

still temple
#

it gives an excuse for people that have scat fetishes to live out their fantasies in a dinosaur game

umbral prairie
#

so scalie scat fetish?

#

that sounds

#

uh

#

weird

#

or better: very disgusting

tulip mason
#

Honestly I do believe dinos should be going to the bathroom as weird as it sounds. It can work with scent. The game scum has such a feature and going to the bathroom is a real inconvenience and can cost your death if you fail to go at the right time.

viral creek
#

you gotta go when you gotta go

#

ew

#

don't shit in my darn water

#

especially if i'm a deino/sucho

barren zephyr
#

Poor suchos

indigo sun
#

Shitting wouldnt be taken seriously at all