#general-feedback-discussion
1 messages · Page 438 of 1
some poeple want to bite and run away
and wait
ooof
then go design the isle 2.0
maybe ill buy it
arm chair dev
yeah
ok dude i like the allo
i don't think i have any clue about how to make a game
its actually one of my fav dinos in the whole game...
and it doesn't have shit on the rex
is nobody listening to what im suggesting at this point
aight im putting shit in suggestions, cuz yall bugging me
its like Why play Draven is vayne beats you early game
one dino shouldn't vastly outclass another dino
Rex
its not a thing but*
in combat
below in therms of foodchain
not in survival
no
yes
ofcourse they should you dont fuck with rex as allo or giga
else why play anything besides apexes?
there's some serious nuance here, sure they should beat more things in combat but rex shouldn't have the same survivability as dilo or utah because that's ridiculous
Are you listening to your self
thats like saying
whats the point of playing herbivore
because you have more survivability
well, not with ai the way that it is rn
they dont really
though yeah actually
im out im losing my brain cells
a herd of maias probs has more survivability than anything else
allo is suppose to be weaker and outclassed by rex and giga
ye but do you bite them do death or play safe and let them bleed out
it depends
no
you that's dumb
allo has more effective flat damage than cerato
and a higher ambush mult
and longer duration
cerato has jaws of life
if you want to hunt things
he just bites
dont pick cerato
i killed sub rexes and sub gigas on cerato solo
if you want to chase down juvies and subs, you pick cerato

yeah
because that's what cerato is good at
no
i just want to hunt small tiers on allo
and mid tiers
Then do it
in groups
you can do it now
I wonder why
so why pick allo
you say that like growing a rex is hard..
literally the only case is faster travel time
but this game has shown time and time again people dont give a shit about growth time
its not hard
Hey
remember prog?
Sorry for interrupting, I'm new here
people still usually don't care about growth times
i dont want to change allo actually
i think rex is too fast
^
yes
its not the allo that is bad
you can
its the rex that is too good
im already seeing it on suggestions

people are suggesting, "speed allo and para and dibble and sucho up"
those speeds will move up
instead of fixing the rex 
then people will ask for dilo and cerato
then people will ask for utah and galli
then carno
^
then you know what you'll get?
the same frickin system scaled up by 1-2 mph
buff this buff that
giga was clearly busted
so they adjusted it
rex is fine and giga aswell
yeah
allo only problem is freaking bleed system
What about a console port, I'd pay for that even if the quality will be crap I'll still pay
doubt, sadly
dont expect
^
console port anytime soon

get a PC, it's superior
Not enough money
i wouldn't count on it
they said they will only focus on pc for now
I want to play it so bad but I cant
I have no PC in the house
Only console

Unless u could play it on the switch

If not a console port then they should maybe work on the fighting mechanic
Maybe have finishers or raptors jumping on top of larger Dino's or maybe even a fighting stance like in Jurassic park evolution
Soon
Imagine playing as a pterosaur
Thatll be so cool
I'm very good with coming up with highly unlikely ideas
Allo really doesn't need a Health increase, nor a growth time increase in that matter, It's in a very great spot as it is within the mid tiers, It's just outshined by Certain sub adult apexes that could use some re-looks.
But in all honesties, Allo is fine as is, The only thing it could really use is a minor, and I mean MINOR speed buff, but even that isn't needed
ye
Accept sub rex as your old and savior Nova
Subrex needs to sit the fuck down
Yes
Who stays at 1.0 though
I haven't seen a max sub rex since the time Watt, Kev and I decided to pack together
hm
Literally no one stays as max sub
Also
You'd see more if I didn't die mid-growth as often as I do.
They go straight to adult as quickly as possible
ok wait
but if people go straight to adult
from subrex
then therefore adult rex must be better than sub rex
but if subrex survivability >allo survivability
then rex survivability > allo survivability
Suggestion: Fix server issue where servers are not coming up. Seems pretty bad considering most people are having this problem.
Playable bary is pretty lame tbh. Id rather have it be a predatory AI. We already have sucho and forcing bary into a niche just because it has one or two differences with sucho doesn’t justify its inclusion. Maia/Para are decently unique in both looks and niches. Same with dryo/galli. Having bary be the small tier equivalent of sucho really isn’t that interesting and the time to create new models should be used on something that can actually bring something new
Did you even read it?
bary is also differing enough from sucho to make it a new playable
its a more terrestrial sucho variant that can switch between fish and land food
sucho is a specialist to water from whats been said before
spino, we dont know but we should expect fishing with him as said by punch a while ago
however, bary could be a playable just if it is then not a priority
seeing there are a lot of other carnivores that can be put before it
I mean, I thought we did a good job of giving it a unique gameplay feel and niche. I wouldn't really say it was just "one or two" differences.
plus, it being ai literally changes nothing about the fact that it will still be in game and it will still need its own stats and niche
Seems pointless to spend time and energy in yet another spinosaurid when something more unique like anky or herrera could be worked on
Never said Bary had to be prioritized over the development of something else, just something down the line.
@jovial arch
Allosaurus is only currently outshined by Trex, as a viable dinosaur, because of how easy it is to grow & form an apex pack, and how uncommon Small Tier "swarms" are ATM. Allosaurus is a much, much better defensive dinosaur than Tyrannosaurus; his alt turn is simply amazing, and Trex would kill for his bleed heal and ambush duration, furthermore high trot speed and stamina regen are also cards that it has that Trex does not. So while Trex has a far more potent offensive game, given it can ambush and kill everything in the game except Carnotaurus, Allosaurus has a much better defensive one.
Normally, this would mean that the worry of running into a Dilo swarm could dissuade picking a Trex; do you really want to grow 6hrs only to be cucked by a swarm? A single Allo can fend off wave after wave of Dilo/Utah, if skilled of course. And an abundance of mid tiers also means that growing into adult faster is much more valuable to survive when faced with an abundance of Utah/Dilo/Carno predation.
But Threetails, the problem isnt Trex's speed, or Subrex's versatility. It's that the metagame does not favor the advantages Allo has over Trex. In a Meta of Apex packs vs. Apex packs, due to how easy they are to grow and sustain, it isnt an issue of Trex being too fast. It's that being offensive is currently 10x more viable, and the threat of Small tier swarms is not nearly as grave as it has been in the past.
Circular balance, we've discussed before but alas...
One component is missing: Small tiers.
yeah
Simply because apexes can form such large groups.
i agree
Buffing Allo or nerfing Trex, in raw attributes, doesnt matter.
If you want Allos to be viable again, ironically, you need to make Small tiers viable
before really trying to tackle it
dilo turn buff and pitch black night wen
Are what have just fucked Allo
just make dilo viable and then everyone will be happy
except utahs but fuck them
Still needs a speed nerf imo
it won't die to anything but other apexes if it doesn't get one
it won't close the gap between mid tiers and apexes
Its not just hunger.
Hunger makes it easy to grow and sustain. but its still extremely strong in every aspect.
If this is in reference to Rex, one thing everyone seems to forget is the fact that Rex. Has. Asthma
doesn't matter 30 secs of stam is something i would take for every other aspect it gets in return
Damage: Amazing
Health: Amazing
Bleed resist: Amazing
Speed: Good
Hunger: Amazing
Ambush: Good
Stamina: Good enough
Find the weakness
his turn, which makes him huntable for small carnis
allos can do it
not with the speed buffs
they can
unless the rex has brain damage
i've done it, rex didn't have brain damage
you guys are the same speed
he can stay in place and alt turn
you don't stand a chance.... even in open ground
do you think we run in without ambush?
why are you saying i don't stand a chance when i've done it lol
his ambush turn is complete ass compared to ours, easy as fuck to juke
or just not good...
he doesn't need to rush you
just alt turn...
its so damn easy.....
its competent hands its not even possible imo...
a pack of skilled allos can still bite him regardless of him altturning
doubt it
you're free to do that but it's very much doable
it was before the speed buff
now i argue its pretty much impossible
Even I could play Rex and do it and i kind suck at it (or don't have much experience playing it)
@strange cliff That isn't how physics work.
if you don't have much experience why are you so sure 5-6+ allos can't do it when i'm telling you they can?
No it isn't.
im not suggesting it for physics reasons
cause i have experience playing allo
and i've hunted rexes before with a pack of allos
what does that add to balance tho
usually gigas just jet across the water to kill suchos
even if they cant eat them
waters supposed to be sorta safer
they slow down prettty damn fast, so personally i think that's fair play if he bites the sucho before his swimspeed turns into ass
its okay at big lakes and big parts of the lazy river
but the only two big lakes are twins and titan
well three i guess
it can catch up to sucho easily since therse no where to go
its a lot faster if it ambush sprints into the water
well ik that, but what's the difference between the giga doing it in a big lake and a small one
well then sorry you put your sucho at the wrong lake
@strange cliff they could also just give sucho an equivalent to sprinting, in water.
yes
Would be a lot less work lol
Than individually changing each dino and reworking momentum physics
Make it so you can select the type of music you hear. What I mean is. The ability to turn off/on or separately adjust the volume of things like day/night cue, player nearby, location music separately. I like the cue music but the constant music interferes with hearing things sometimes
@dreamy basin should require a skilled allo pack but i agree
1 apex bite to an allo should still be deadly imo
@shut gale Yes I agree, but a pack of four allos has to run from rex, and giga
@brisk sail Styracosaurus and Compsognathus actually both have models made
and iirc the devs said they'll be trying to use all their assets
oh, nice, good to know, Styraco is my number one fave dino, sharing the spot with allo
so Styraco is likely to at least be in the game, but if it'll be in survival, that's less certain
if it is ever put in survival that would be the only dino I would ever be, lol

@south flower the problem with that is it'll end up being like the Terms Of Service that nobody reads, and they'll just scroll to the bottom and check the box without actually reading the rules
at least if they break rules and get an admin called on them it'll alert the admins that this person might be a problem in the future
It’s one of those suggestions where it couldn’t hurt. However, as we already have a message of the day implemented for each official server, the fact that you have to click out of it to begin play is already grounds enough for us to not take pity when people don’t read the rules and wind up banned.
US3 doesn't have MoTD 😦
what's MoTD
i wanted to play on US 3 but when u on the dino selection menu your mouse is gone 😦
Message of The Day
Press windows key and click back on the game @barren zephyr
do that a few times it fixs it
@desert prairie ok thx will try next time
heh does he not know dilo is a bleeder?
I mean dilo is pretty bad rn, the bite comparison was a bit unnecessary since dilo is a bleeder but I think dilo definitely needs some changes
I'd like the black night back because right now you never know if the player you follow the sound or footsteps from runs around with high gamma and sees you from hundreds of meters away
@stuck coyote terrible suggestion the reduction on dilos bleed didnt hurt him
@obsidian matrix a.. rex counter?
since weight got also increased
ye
not something that counts the amount of rexes on a server
Give dilo better turn and ambush and make nights black as death
there
i fixed dilo
alright i'm just gonna go and hide now
xD
make dilos bleed bypass the sitting mechanic
fixed
seeing as how dilo was supposed to have some kind of venom in its bite anyways
Dont think thats an option and even you know that
ofcourse it is
i killed 7 carnos with dilo
he needs turn and ambush help thats all
Congrats
if dilo bleed bypasses the sitting bleed heal thing it would be very annoying if you win a fight against a dilo and then lose to it's weird venom
meh dilo just does not feel... fun
night vision is completely worthless on v3 right now
I think dilo needs better mobility and the black night
and dilo was supposed to be "the hunter of the night"
its like a very downgraded allo
@mystic kestrel the hell it didnt hurt him. Bleed the the ENTIRE purpose of the dilo
more weight
His bleed is fine
and the bleed was not lowered that much
I think it was set from 50 to 40
Giga doesnt even needs the bleed with its health and bite
giga is a apex bleeder
when hunting rexs and trikes it does
and should have 50 bleed not dilo
Lower bleed and slightly increased bite. What does that cause? the need to get more bites in
granted you will probably die when hunting rexes
@stuck coyote dilo is fine where it is
?????????
after doing some testing
Are you insane
dilo is fine
Right. getting two shot by literally everything isnt an issue
Well if u can turn better
u can juke better
see the correlation ? ergo u get hit less
TWO BITES TO BE KILLED
why i cant find servers?
ask in #🔧-legacy-troubleshooting-🔧
your going to juke 20+ times in a row before getting bit twice and killed?
MAYBE YOU SHOULD GET 2 SHOTTED BY SOMETHING 2X YOUR SIZE
@stuck coyote you are aware how fast dilo grows compared to allos growth?
it's fair
and allo has like 10 extra minutes of growing. big whoop
i killed allo in 3man group of dilos 1 got bit but we didnt allow allo to chase injured dilo
allo is a pack huneter right now
it can't solo becuase night is shit
and turn is terrible
10 minutes?
@rapid prawn democracy bud...ppl like or dislike your suggestions😉
@barren zephyr No, you just downvote because you are afraid of changes, you are sheeps.
An allo does not take long at all. especially for its helth, bite, stam, and bleed resist
i'm saying dilo should get 2 shot by allo
because it grows much faster than allo
and is lower tier
not even gonna aswer to that lol
@barren zephyr Because you can't
why are you so angry about people with an opinion on suggestions
@spiral pond Great job dude, I was going to drop it until you said "salty"
The thing is
in every game people complain about changes
you need to calm down son...your way to excited
@rapid prawn but there's a reason why this change is a horrible idea
maybe becouse people dont want 60-40 night
Then when they actually change things they are saying "oh I was wrong, this is a great idea"
1 dino
vs 15
@rapid prawn yes
one dino
it's fair the way it is
both night and day are the same time
Not really
All ambush dinos benefit in the night
i hunt at night with other dinos too...i see no point in your argument
day and night is 30mins each
day or night
thats for 5 mins
What does the sunrise and sunset count as?
that's 10 min in total
out of 30 mins
it's 1/3 of the time
and ?
it counts as dayight
i don't get what the issue is here zamasu
it's not a big deal
some animals need night to hunt better
Maybe not for you
your counting it as night when it is literally the light of day
Start your own server and change the day night times then
you sound like the type of person who doesn't play those animals and just want's life easier
It's in the game.ini file
I mean day does feel a bit short because of sunset/sunrise, but if people don't want a 60-40 then they can downvote it
Slam I just wrote what I counted it as
as it is the night has already been lightened up to the point of not even needing night vision unless your in a patch of trees.
The day is short, these people just thinks about themselves rather than improving the game. They are afraid of changes and egoistic
@rapid prawn you made a suggestion, the community reacted but the community doesnt make decisions around here....its up to the developers to make changes to the game or leave it the it is now, just accept that and move on.
I don't think we need thenyaw servers personally, I think V3 has to be made so there are less unused parts of it and the servers need to be improved to the map can hold more dinos -->feels less empty
Says the person trying to change the game to suit them.......................
Really? Because its more like trying to get in a change to benefit one group of dinos over the other group, instead of keeping it even. THAT is egotistic
@barren zephyr Man shut up already
you clearly excited and dont accept others opinions...
^
@barren zephyr A lion does not care what a sheep has to say
lol all you want but ur a sheep
why are you disrespecting me? i dont get it lol
<@&401466542140817419>
and you're rude and angry about something silly
Oi.
How am I more rude than you guys?
Come on fellas, go to #401470471750811669 or dm eachother
you're depicting yourself as something better because you have a different opinion
wrong place deino.
Sorry a out getting back late to my suggestion reply - Yeah I didn’t know if it would be something that would really make a difference, since as you mentioned you have to exit out the MoTD box anyhow. But as someone else mentioned, it could allow admins a better(?) means of knowing who has a higher chance at rule breaks and can use the possibility of having to check a server agreement box against a said rule breaker.
I mean, I know it’s not something guaranteed to work
May I ask what “whitelist” means?
Only certain people are allowed, IE friends. If your name doesn't match the list you don't get in
You can also make it locked to being within a steam group, so someone needs to be a member to enter
Ohhh
I want to say a good player dilo can fuck up an utah
If you have finger to play
And no one Dino need to destroy rex in 1v1
Rex is ultimate fighter dinosaur
The only for my who will be able to destroy rex in 1v1 will be the reworked ankylosaurus
All other Dino will lose to rex in 1v1
Why? Why should trike not be able to 1v1 a Trex
That's silly.
I don't feel Anky or Trike should destroy Trex.
They BOTH should be dangerous to a Trex.
But "destroying" is like, Diablo vs Giga
Roflstomp
OK, not really destroying but the anky will have an adventage
After it's how the player will play
Why wouldnt Trike also have an advantage?
Trike cannot run away, so he must be able to fight.
It will come later
Same with Anky.
I’ve killed several rexes on a server as a spino. Without dying up until the fourth or so time because I was in a tricky spot.
After the recoding of game and affinity
And I want to say stats is nothing in game, yesterday if I have more than 10% food and 700 of ping, one of both trike I've figth was already dead.
But it was hard to tell if the Rex players I killed were noobs or not. Even with a broken leg I ass-road them because they didn’t keep distance lmao
Spoon?
You sucess to ass ride spoon?
Wow
Oh
No sry I've understand it was spinosaurus player but it's rex what you talk XD
Lmao yeah, I was spoon and they Rex
But you are the spino
Spino has the turn of gods.
^
Spinosaurus is too strong.
If you bone break at the first bite you kill it easy but if you don't, you'll destroy the rex after
I think he will have a big nerf when he will be rework
Nerf weight mass but buff hp
Like 7 or 8t and 9 000 hp or 11 000
But damage like 200
Or 150
Not necessarily, unless you’re a smart player. I had broken legs and killed a couple rexes before. It’s just using the turns to your advantage and such.
But there’s always going to be people that comment on dinos needing a nerf or buff. Always.
Because he don't have a super jaws
Or no
With bleed rework, apex need to have bigger damage but spoon will have a big mass
And enormous hp
But I don't think he will have too many damage
300 damage or 400
With 7 or 8t for mass
And 10 000 hp
Or 9000
And not a turn like he have now
Nerf the turn raptor jesus
Please
Or same mass than giga
I would agree on the turn radius for spino needing work, but only because I imagine with that big sail, I don’t see it making dramatic turns like it currently does.
Yes
Raptors I can understand the turn radius.
They are small and agile and in my opinion, so they could make the turns.
Ancalagonsaurus Smaugzillacus Asks: Will spinosaurus be added to survival?
Will we be getting a spinosaurus remodel and will it get implemented into survival?
Answer:
Yes.
By punch
But yes it's not soon
pretty sure don answered that one
but yeah i'd say atleast 3-5 months before we get spino
need to do the recode first after all
But why you want a better turn for dilo
I don’t see the point in a arctic/snowy landscape when dinos were cold-blooded reptiles
What's wrong with dilo turn? At a trot the diameter is the body length
dilo is really not that good atm, skilled players manage but it could use some improvements on mobility
Guy
Just walk
And stop with trot
When you are attacked by Utah you are juste un walk and the solo Utah will do nothing
And be sure you just stop in legs, bite, turn in walk and run immediately after.
Only thing wrong with Dilo is the cam needs to be moved back a bit, that's it
Even something like a few splashes of blood every couple of feet steps, with scent it would pop-out
RE: Solid ☝
and maybe not these giant blood splashes that, depending on the size of the dino, look like it lost all of it's blood in one tick?
Yeah something more like footsteps, where its more consistent, but red
@calm lily , rex is supposed to be a fast ambush hunter with stam problems in this game
and giga is supposed to be the endurance bleeder (it doesn't really depend on it's bleed rn)
If giga HAD to get a buff, I’d increase its size so it’s strides would match its new speed, and that would also make giga easier to spot
ye juvi dilo cam is too close but tbh no one gives a shit kinda sad
sammel u have to tag him
Yeah, juvi dilo cam is a problem
i can write it again in sugg vote that siht up
first dino was dilo when i first played
I think a slight giga speed buff (not faster than rex) would be fine so rexes need longer to catch up --> need to get closer before starting the ambush if it didn't impact other dinos that would be slower than giga if gigas were made faster
Making giga faster means making its ambush have lower mult, and speed up dibble and sucho again
giga would be ok with a very slight speed buff but not rexes speed
again, rex is the ambush pred, hes fast but in short bursts bc of shit stam and giga is the sprinter
I know
But even then
If you make giga run 30.9 he will be fast as sucho
And he already outruns dibble
I mean long growth time is one of the factors that limit bigger dino population a bit
A bit
I guess so
doesn't really seem to help as half the players are apexes rn
True
but it would probably be even higher if their growth time was lower
Maybe juvi apexes will be hell to play
Since I heard something about juvi rebalancing
I think apexes shouldn't be in packs of up to 5, it's just too easy to grow if you grow in a 4 member apex pack
and then grow to be the fifth member
2 per pack and 1 sub is fine for me
And 1 or 2 juvies at max with them
Or just 1 sub/juvi
Since a pair can already kill camas
I've thought about making the growth time of the adult stage longer, but not making the stats increase the same all the time (so at the start of the adult stage your stats increase way faster than at the end. In addition to that, it would be cool to have bigger AI (maybe hadro AI) spawning randomly on the map in small/medium sized herds, wandering around (maybe from lake to lake) so apexes (or packs of mid tiers) can find them and feed off of them for a good while but they have to wamder around to find them (because rn it is easier to get AI if you stay in one place compared to when moving around the map)
of course you can get unlucky and not find any herd, so smaller AI still has to be there in some form for the apexes
but it could maybe result in more apex fights because more apexes actively wander around
Do you consider Ava’s as small ai ?
I think maybe make the power gap between mid tiers and apexes smaller
For example: why grow 2/3 or apex time as sucho to just get 2 shot by giga
nah I think the apexes are good compared to the mid tiers, they can just grow too easily
right now most people play apex because they're so easy, if they were harder to grow it would be a big reward to have an adult apex
the reward should remain high but the risk needs to be higher
AI shouldn't spawn around Apexes 😉
It's so easy to find a secluded spot as apex, nest up and create an army
guys lol
it's already been said the juvi dilo cam is already being addressed next patch
just saying
smaller AI should at least not spawn so much that they can sustain themselves off of it forever, it should spawn a bit so they can last a bit longer without killing players (or my suggested hadrosaur AI) but the smaller AI should not be enough to keep them fed all the time
AI maybe only spawn at 20% hunger for apex instead of 70%
They are HUNTERS they should be forced to hunt
Most other carnivores are just opportunists, scavengers, and fish eaters(whenever that happens), the ammount of AI that spawn for mid-tier is more than enough to sustain them, same for apex... they just eat more often
It's just a little too easy to be an Apex
Especially with 5-6 people
yeah definitely
as I said I think it should be the high reward it is right now but it should be way harder to get it (I hope the devs will not do that by giving them crazy hunger drain as that would be just annoying)
It should be at least somewhat fun to play an apex but it should definitely be more challenging
Slower hunger drain with no AI spawns would allow them to actually find and hunt other dinos
no/less (etc)
and if they really can't catch players, they can eat the players AI 😂
like they sometimes do now with 'taxing utah rock'
utah rock needs to go away though imo, the utahs on there take away many player slots but because they sit in one place all the time the map feels even more empty than it does already
There's so many other rocks utahs can hop on... that's just the most central one, gets the most traffic
yeah true
maybe if full dino collision is added they can't stand on those tiny flat spots on rocks they use to get up to the top
because they jump against the rock and fall down again instead of jumping against it, their head sticking into it and them being able to just jump higher
give them concussions for doing it? 😄
They will still find a way, as Dr. Malcom says
Little side hops
it would be cool if running/jumping into things (like walls or other dinosaurs) would, in case of walls or dinos that are way bigger than you, give you concussions and in case of smaller dinos make them fall over
Except Pachy, they get a free pass
I can imagine a pachy running into something like a dilo causing it to fall over ( the dilo )
Or a quetz flying against a cliff and just dying from that
Well people sometimes just avoid eachother for the AI snaccs
Why have hunger if ai are just going to spawn in 20 feet away when you’re hungry
I literally just afk while growing my Dinos rn
Seriously
The map is too big not to have SOME ai
Yesterday while I was growing a Dilo
If AI spawns close to carnivores it does because it is less work for the server if people only get AI sometimes (when they're hungry) instead of all the time
I went and got dinner, did my laundry, and half my hw while I was growing it
But I think especially bigger AI herds (like hadros or sauropods) should just spawn randomly
well ai just start spawning at 70% hunger, I said it should be less for apex, to get them to do their hunting thing, but if all dinos had the same %before AI spawned, would it be any better?
I know without AI lots of people would be dying of starvation... there's been a few times where 5 in a row AI spawned inside the river, couldn't eat them, and was down to 2% hunger before I got one on land (sucho btw)
Didn't see any players during that time either though 😃 so, the AI is necessary
Unless people should be dying of hunger 😃
but currently, its impossible to die of hunger unless you miss every AI spawn
Maybe raising the player cap on the servers will add more competition for food..meaning, there will be more dinos fighting for one oro, taco or ava atm.
Which will improve the pvp and make the game more thrilling...this is supposed to be a survival horror game but to me its a walk in the park.
except v3 is fucking massive and other people have legit gone hours on a full server without seeing anyone else
so without ai they would've starved
Let em starve then 😈
V3 is a map for, like... 500 people
Making Giga faster than rex
Ah yes sure
That would instantly destroy the ecosystem
Rex or Giga’s stats aren’t the problem
They’re fucking everywhere
And theres too much of them
80% of the server is apexes
Gigas and Rexes are both a pest
As for Rex
Most balance issues started with it’s speedbuff
yeah buffing two other powerful carnivores wouldn't help anything at all it'd just make things worse
"utha", "ceria" 
@hazy sparrow yes it's a survival game but you shouldn't be penalised by dying from starvation because another player hasn't come your way
before the ai got patched you'd literally walk the entire map hoping for a player, not find one and die from starvation
lemme tell ya, growing a big boy rex and then dying from starvation isn't fun
@dense depot I know I'm like a day late, but let me put it this way: While it would be much more aesthetically pleasing to have short death/fight animations and such, it would be ineffective for combat if you're fighting multiple people or something like that. Imagine having a pack of ceratos on you as an allo, but the one thing stopping you from getting away is the animations that force play over your WASD movements. That's just my thought on it though.
@shell willow that's a good point. But it would add to realism. Like a pressed mouse button would trigger a finishing move. If you don't want it, so you wouldn't have to see it. As the title says suggestion discussing 😃😃
still no Apex limits to 2 adults..guess that the devs dont see a problem
What is the problem exactly????

@misty island 90% of the servers are Apex...to be more precise groups of 5 everywhere

So it shouldn’t be limiting the number of apex in a group
But the amount of apex in a server
That’s the solution
But they can’t do that because everyone wants to play them
i think that increasing its hunger and limiting groups would make ppl not picking Apex dinos...
its your opinion
i dont blame ppl that solo with Apex...its clearly more challenging
You just argued with your own point lol....
You said 90% of server population are apex
And limiting apex grouping would decrease the chances of ppl picking them
But then you say soloing is not a problem because “it’s clearly more challenging”
my point was that there should be a limit to Apex groups to 2 not to solo Rex...and most ppl wouldnt play Rex if they went solo that i can assure you 
Okay
"And limiting apex grouping would decrease the chances of ppl picking them"...thats totaly the point bud, if you cant survive has a solo/duo Rex than pick another dino...

@fiery iron discussions goes here
oh sorry lol I wasn't the guy who messaged there responding in the first place
Do some people have a Vendetta against the Dryo being able to nest in a Burrow?
Like, I don't see the problem with it unless you explain why
Dryos should die instantly upon spawning
lol nice
Or have no mouths to drink or eat, so they eventually starve, like the mayfly
Wow I really like how you formed your opinion mate it's not like people enjoy playing as Dryo and not only as Rex or Giga
dont bite the bait gojira
I really want someone to tell me why nests in Dryo burrows are a bad idea other than saying that Dryos should die instantly upon spawning
I like the idea tbh 😂 but i dont like dryos
Burrows are near invisble, only chance you'd catch a dryo would when he needed to drink/eat
I don't think so, Burrows are easy to spot if you are trying to find one
but, I see what you mean
But there should be more dinos that can get into those burrows in that case, all hatchlings of every carni/juvies etc
Is it like you're out in the open everyone else can hear you?
that would level the playing field for that kind of thing I'd say, you'll be able to nest in a burrow but if a juvie utahraptor appears...
Things inside the burrow then should be able to hear what's outside if it's close to the burrow, vibrations in the ground etc
But things inside sound dim
I'm asking, since the only time I find Dryos is when they're outside running. And that's only due to sound queues when they talk or whatever.
And in a world where all none-apexes need to be wary of strotting around. Having even less dinos around the world sitting in burrows, would make it less interesting.
they are quite large and have a big hole on em
Dryo would be one of the few dinosaurs to even get to burrow tho
like, that's only 1 dino lmao
do you think everything is equal? XD
No.. Have I said anything to imply that?
Like I've never really seen anyone who likes playing Dryo
"might"
"10%"
I'm saying this could make burrows somewhat useful in a sense
You asked why I voted no to your suggestion, this is why.
It's not a very good reason but okay
yes it is gojira
And I didn't think your suggestion was very good either. Glad we're at the same level
You know you can't really spot burrows that easily?
It's not like everyone is constantly looking down into the ground walking spying for Dryo burrows.
Since you need to look around you all the time trying to keep a look out for something that might be bigger and faster than you.
Dryo Burrows are pretty big... although... like quite damn large.
Apexes are also, quite damn large.
maybe from a dryo perspective dude xD
Which is what I try to avoid walking around.
do you think Apexes are trying to hunt Dryos of all things?
No I didn't say that
You imply that.
Also what's with "Apexes are also, quite damn large"
"tiny"
I'm looking around, to avoid not walking into the jaws of an apex predator.
Compared to the threats to me, it is tiny.
apexes are also quite damn large but are capable of hiding so well you can't see them
if you made a burrow in a dense forest, under some bushes, or even in the far corners of the map no one would be able to find it
I'm not attacking your personally Gojira, so you don't need to take it personally.
Not everyone will agree with you.
Such is the world
it is tiny Gojira...maybe for a velociraptor or a dryo its huge, but for any other dino its quite small and can easily mix with the environment so its truly hard to spot
was just thinking of a way to have them be more viable, specifically for nesting.
dryo is viable...its fast, tiny and has the burrow...
it has high chances of surviving for a long long time
not to speak that growing a dryo is like what? 30minutes? 1h?
and you can nest under a tree and you ll be fine...
but when it comes to nesting, Burrows are literally useless
you dont need the burrow to nest
Maybe the intention of adding then wasn't to improve nesting.
Burrows are worse for your survival than just hiding in a bush
you can nest in so many places has a dryo..its so small..the problem with ppl is that they make loads of noise and that attracts predators, if a dryo doesnt make sounds (which he doesnt need to) its really hard for someone to be killed has a damn tiny and fast dino
A carnivore can easily camp the burrow entrance if they really want you
Juking and hiding is a far better strat
You have a fuckton of stamina and are faster than most of your predators
Basically what I meant to say was that Burrowing seems useful for nesting personally and well, I see what Ditto is saying.
but, whatever
Dryo nesting is also useless
unless you want to spam nest Dryos into a big herd
useless? and why is that? lol
The time it takes for one Dryo egg
You can grow a near full adult in the time span and just run to whoever
that's basically the idea
There's actually no point in nesting
Outside of potentiality messing with people who click invites from randoms
by that logic theres no point in nesting has any dino, since you start with a juvie and save time
or aksing them
No
Dryos literally grow to near max adulthood in the same time
A juv Giga actually benefits from nesting
It's slow and takes forever to grow
Along with a parent
a carebear you mean? lol
No
A nested animal is not carebeared
Anyway
It takes 25 minutes to get an egg
Dryo reaches full adult in 30 minutes
Dryo is also very fast throughout its growth
I'd say Nesting as a Dryo is good if you got a lot of people that are able to, then get a Dryo army and live as a Family basically.
It takes over double the time to get a full adult Dryo from nesting
If you don't Nest, it would take forever for them to come to you
@barren zephyr check out my suggestion about faeces and nesting see if you agree with it
I just wanna if you think it would balance out the herbivores and carnivores
Is collision with other players something that's being worked on? At this point in a fight we just run straight through eachother and the first player who ends up behind the other one will win the fight. However if collisions where on and you could like, say almost push eachother off, or bump into each other that would change the whole fighting system.
@barren zephyr sry I was in class and on my phone I don’t think I can copy it via it, try going to the suggestion tab and search my name
I think they fixed the burrows so that you can grow after you’ve exited a burrow, and now hatchlings can enter burrows if I remember correctly (lemme know if I’m wrong) - so even if you can’t nest in the burrow, you can have a nest right close to the burrow and your young can remain by the burrow in case something comes by.
K I’ve said “burrow” enough lmao
@barren zephyr
Faeces implementation and it’s uses
So I was wondering if it be would possible that the game could implement a system involving making use of faeces. The idea is to let players mark their territories while adding benefits and disadvantages for both carnivores and herbivores.
In general, faeces would come in different sizes and appear in different colours according to their host’s diet under tracking mode when a player sniffs.
This would let herbivores avoid predator territories and allow hunters to locate their prey in a more generic location while only providing minimum informations. Which could lead to tactics like bluffing about the size of the pack you are in and such ectectect.
However this would not be exactly a fun change to the isle as it is already hard enough, so here’s an extension of my idea to spice things up a little.
Except for only being as a mark indicator, faeces would also attract AI in a balanced way.
For herbivores, a herbivore dropping would attract AI carnivores, this wouldn’t just increase the danger for the herbivore players but in fact protects them. Since the hunters will now have to watch out for AI predators that might interfere with their hunt or even being hurt or killed by an AI predator.
As for carnivores, their faeces would enhance the chances of herbivore food spawning. Not only attracting bigger and more AI plant eating dinos but also more meat eating players. Increasing both danger and benefits.
Now at this point, the game would have distinctive play styles between different species or even different packs in the same species.
I just played this game for a couple of days, so if any of my immature ideas were already mentioned at some point. Please pardon me for wasting ur time going through my wall of text with poor English but thanks for sticking till the end. Wish you all good luck and a wonder life in the island of 💀
and this one
Nesting features that favours herbivores more
Wouldn’t it be cool if there is a more advantage to being hatched rather than just spawning in a juv so you saving the walk and wait and extra half and hour??? I mean it’s fine and pretty balance between the time consumption and risk a player is taking, but it gets really old after a while.
So my suggestion is as followed :
Nesting requires a pair of dedicated (invite like groups??or smthing) male and female, and they would provide a growth bonus to all their hatchings when within both of their “buff” radius, at a cost of increase in food consumption to both parents and the children.
My idea is to let apex carnivores to only be able to rise 1-2 kids at the same time, as they have to constantly look for food WITH their kids instead of camping Ava’s and wait for 7hrs.
So it would be something like this: (Just a wide guess for the numbers)
Apex Carnivores , +50% growth and 75% food consumption to hatchlings until subs stage, but also +75% food consumption for parents per hatchlings in the vicinity. Small/medium buff radius.
Apex herbivores , +70% growth and 100% food consumption to hatchlings until subs stage, but also +80% food consumption for parents per hatchlings in the vicinity. Medium/large buff radius.
The same numbers are used for herbivores, but the difference is, there are usually more concentrated spawn of food source for herbivores. So they wouldn’t have to constantly wonder the map until the food runs out.
Eventually this would develop into a way more realistic game as the players would be rewarded for acting what dinos would actually do —> Herbs migrates in packs to nesting grounds, and carnis roam around their hunting ground for food. And I think it would also work with my previous 💩 suggestions
Idk is this is gonna work or not but ya thanks for sticking till the end
Good lord that wall of text
sry..
i was supposed to pm him
but i am not comfortable with adding people on discord... so
👌
@misty island sorry took a while to read it. And it has some good points but then again this would force herbivores to move constantly and risk more than they already do. Herbivores life is already dangerous and this wouldn't help it.
But i liked the idea of having 2 people as parents. And that's how it should be, we aren't snails after all. Growth rates are pretty balanced but for some those should be made faster when they add new dinos. Some growth times (7h) is ridiculous and for players who have only 2h/day play time this is too much.
So to finish my wall of text, id say that there should be two parents and growth rates made faster for those whose go above 6h.
thats the thing
you provides different ways
for people to play
and ofcause it wouldnt be depending on the food rate now
there should also be a tweak
maybe in specific area and such
I think server hosts should have more options on things. Like how often AI spawn and so on.
In settings when they make server
But not after making it
@barren zephyr why?
I mean rex is supposed to be the fast ambush hunter in this game
and giga is supposed to fill the niche of an endurance hunter
Giga was probably faster irl but the dinos in this game are not supposed to be entirely accurate, plus rex being a slow endurance hunter would mean that it needed a bigger rework (because endurance hunter and bb don't quite fit together)
ya but it should be changable tho...
Rex is good as it is now. Just the growth time is little salty to swallow.
it deserves a longer growth time if anything
I mean apexes are too easy to play right now

In real world rex didn't do rong runs, mainly short sprints and it scavenged corpses more than hunted.
So..... Yah
I'd be fine if apexes had a longer growth during their adult stage, with stats increasing faster at the start then at the end
Yah but think about it. You play and grow 6-10h rex u'll lose to some giga or small drop in mountainside
thats the risk you take going apex
apex is already high reward, but the risk is too low
Still 4h would be enough too
no buts, 6-7 hours for a rex isnt that bad considering mid tiers are only 4
definitely not, all dino growth times would have to be lowered then
you’re saying a rex should have the same growth as an allo 
and that would result in people being more careless because they can just grow another one easily
^^
Shiro how long you think some bigger dinos who are 11k tonnage will take to grow? 11h?
In the end it gets too long
It's not too long, people can logout and come back whenever they want
there have to be other factors besides long growth, but making apex growth time shorter would just not work
Ok
I mean look at the servers now, already flooded with apexes
I saw 2 sub-rexes logout when they heard carnos in the distance... it's a fact of life 😃
But if they add for example 35k ton long necks it wont be good if they take 20h. Also those need to have some kind of predator to be able to kill em. Or those wont be playable.
I think they said they didn't want playable sauropods of that size
because the gameplay would be slow and boring
could be wrong though
Sammel its flooded because Herbivore is only food atm. They need to raise some herbies atk like Steggyes
iirc brachi is going to be AI and playable in sandbox
nah not really, even if herbis were not just food apexes could still afk grow in a bush in a corner of the map
it would increase the amount of herbi players a bit
Lol... Idk what game you play but my carnivores will starve if i afk in bush
It used to be possible to afk from juvi raptor to sub but not anymore
yeah of course you have to get some AI every now and them but the AI spawns in mass literally ten meters away from you
Again. Not in server i play
where do you play
it spawns pretty much everywhere I've been so far on the map, and always so close that I could find the AI in a minute or faster
Yah if it spawns. For me i may go for 20km and not find any AI nor hear one. I think its because i move too fast through regions.
I've written a suggestion on AI improvement for apex gameplay if you scroll up a bit in #general-feedback but apparently nobody liked it
yeah you have a higher chance of getting AI if you stay around one place, if you travel around it feels like the AI spawns behind you
Thats because the AI DOES spawn behind you
also nobody got that they could put reactions on the single suggestions, unless they all disliked all three suggestions
Because you're moving
Atm carnivores are getting bad light since there is too many of them. In Pangaea there has been estimated to be 80% meat eaters and of them 40% are apexes.
This is why its hard as Herbi to survive if you don't camp one bush.
lmao its not like people grow in one sitting
@split granite useless suggestion
Someone explain why they don't atm.
why are you giving limits to utahs
and stegos cant sniff because they aren’t a survival dinosaur
literally
give it time
It's a low priority dino, the ones in survival are the ones they are working on the most
survival dinos are getting priority ye^
and you don’t need to repeat your comments we saw you like two hrs ago lol..
@split granite because they are sandobx dinos
not survival
thats why
they are not complete
i suggest playing on official if you want to be actually giving constructive suggestions
once they are actually considered for survival gameplay they will be updated...
its not about how fast a dino grow that makes it difficult
its about how risky it is
if a sub or juv rex glows in Q
no rex is ever gonna make it even you can grow one in 4 hrs
and having high food consumption when growing is exactly what i was trying to say in my suggestion
you increase the risk of growing one
instead of making it more annoying and time wasting
if you think about it
7hrs 10usd/hr wages thats 70dollars for a grown rex
is that really reasonable?
Yes, when compared to other games where you invest time
Every other game is a time investment, assigning a monetary value is a bit ridiculous
^^ plus apex are apex!! it seems like it should be difficult to raise one to adulthood imo. i'd rather have to really work for a payoff than have it be handed to me on a platter personally
i am ont saying its not fine atm
i am just saying it for ones who wanted to lengthen the growth time
since people are not doing anything but sitting ther anyways
it require time investment yes but it could be more engaging not just watching a tree all day long
cus at the end of the day its the experience instead of the things you got out of a game that counts
guys would an all mute button be useful for some?
sometimes i wanna play solo and fkin nest inv pops up every 4 minutes
F3
?
just F3 whoever spams you
They should attempt to implement a DND (Do Not Disturb) mode
fragon explain pls what happens by pressing F3
not like there would be ten different nest at once lol
but ya
a flight mode would help
You block one person at a time @barren zephyr it doesn't solve the problem, only one symptom
fucking running in the trees and a invite comes up
ye ok that doesnt help at all
ye fragon
they should rework the appearance of the nest or group inv too big
can't see shit
but like a private mode would help
ya
@clear turret Think of a trike with a broken front leg. Would you slam that leg onto the ground if it was broken? That would hurt like a bitch.
no shit sherlock, but the realism card doesnt mean much. This is a video game
The point of breaking your leg is so you can't use it effectively
Rex breaks Trike leg so it can't stomp
rex gets a lucky bone break, and literally anything that relies on a stomp is food. Cant run, cant fight. why even bother playing anything other than rex then?
Because Trike needs a b uff. It's not a rex problem. It's a trike problem
trike should have bone break to compensate for rex having it
kinda unfair that only carnivores have a bone smasher
Who the fuck says I am exclusively refering to trike anyways? literally everything auto loses when rex gets a lucky bonebreak because it also disables alt turn. it is an RNG "I win" button
Such civility...
lol
Then if you are not a trike, don't let the rex bite you





