#isle-lore-theories
1 messages · Page 182 of 1
only dudes in their 30s allowed to be played as
becoming an old man would be kinda funny

very informative
i do wanna have cool costumes as a human tho, i want a cowboy hat
this conversation devolves into human nesting. so lets not and say we didnt.
what
i can't understand this for you. please just drop it.
i remember it 
i am trying so hard to not think about it
bruh i cannot type
can we talk about caves again?
how about the mutant humans use those caves and will have their stuff in them?
wonder why the underwater base is still there since its not a new base jus ta 1to1 copy of the northern jungle one
like the mutant humans will be playable, right? do i remember correctly?
should be ya
maybe meant to be a sunken base? maybe humans will be able to dive with right gear? 
imagine u spawn in as a neutral human and u can either go a more primal way and slowly become the mutant human or go more technical way and use vehicles and tools
Gen 1 are planned to be playable
its under the ocean floor so idk
sick, then i hope some caves or structures will have stuff dedicated to them or hints to their existence in the future
them being cave dwellers would be cool
Would be sick
I want to have a gen 1 cult in the volcano cave
or everyone would start out as a normal human and u would have the option to branch off
the volcano cult!
Ehh, I think gen 1 and gen 2 start off as their own separate things
the huge swamps cave cult!

i mean probably. i doubt you just pick it in the select screen
though i wouldent necessarily mind that, as long as they aren’t as strong as actual dino strains.
I wouldn’t mind gen 1’s whole thing being expanding their benefits from the replicator
replicator is in the dome and it is the thing we need to fix, i am calling it now
I don’t think so
we don’t know if the replicator is even on gateway iirc
just my theory
tartar sauce is where it is… my guess. but idk what tartarus even is
is it like an actual physical place or what
i dont think anyone knows
i would really like any lore info at all please dondi
what if its like actually a place in the map and humans need to find the hidden entrance for it, maybe the way to get is split and located in different human bases on the map by random so humans would need to actually move around and find the things needed? but going in there is dangerous so they need to survive and gather gear along the way?
that would be cool and also tie into strains
i doubt they would have it on the map right now or in the upcoming map even, seems like something they would add later
idr why but a while ago i had an idea that strain research was done at tartarus
there was also that text that says being displaced or whatever to tartarus was a punishment
meaning i think you probably were involved in strain research in some way, either as a strain being tested or some other way

it would make sense if a punishment is being placed into highly dangerous environment where even more dangerous research is going on
We likely won’t see a physical manifestation of the replicator in game last week heard
oh i see nvm then on that 
You remember the failed neuro experiments tapwing made?
ah really it’s like the biggest part of the lore
i do
ya this is what i was thinking. either u become a strain or they have strains hunt you lol
if u look at redacted documents
You are alive to suffer so that we may learn, and then you’ll do it again
so i mean, maybe that’s how u become a strain. u need to find redacted info. u get some fun lore then boom. strain
Don’t break your contract friendos, lineage displacement sounds rather unpleasant

huh
reminds me of sweetfoxwings
<@&933486433342222376>
Probably is
@weak pine ask lore questions here also it makes dinos it entoombs them it makes clones it makes abominations and such
NOOOOOO!!!
unironically someone else brought this up two days ago
so i'll send it again,
so here is the full Don quote
Don — 10/04/2024 12:35
The physical part of what you would expect to be the Replicator has a decided physical form, yes. It probably wouldn't be seen. But it's in notes. It has a concept that's been made.
It has no place in the game islands.
the humble spectator mode
hm?
i mean
I don't think it'll ever be put into the game, that actual art
if that is what you mean
hmmm
#isle-lore-theories message
as Don said this
that if they do another Isle game
he feels like they have to add it
IF
well
the replicator is full of subsystems
i think we'll definitely see its subsystems (like TOMB)
The Mainland
but its main body?
I don't mind not seeing it
and then having a proper storied game would be better to see it
i pictured the replicator being like an entire factory, similar to the areas in HZD that produce machines
cauldrons
a SP story isle spinoff would make me very happy
still sad i never got PC: genesis
one can only hope
honestly
knowing that it ain't here
I imagine it as a whole international 'organism' across AE (and maybe more...)-controlled islands/locations (whether controlled now or once controlled in the past that had enough presence to include the replicator)
every time i hear more about isle lore i feel like i know less
i always thought the replicator was just a machine somewhere lol
It could be, we dont know
I‘d rather know nothing until there is something to show for it
based
yeah
im always hesitant to get into isle lore that isn't firmly established in game, for fear it could be reworked or retconned
its why i am not a fan of getting soft lore comments by Don
precisely
as nice as it is and convenient
would you rather read the book, or the spoiler about its finale and high points on some sort of blog?
dripfed lore must continue until morale improves
i want all of us to read that very long, isled and stringy book, piece by piece
Trying to connect dots and clues and shrink the gaps of knowledge by well defined knowledge
its a lot of work
but something Don has slowly been working and redoing to get 'right' (for himself especially) for more then 10 years now
and so hopefully we find ourselves in the future doing this
maybe instead of needing to play the game for the sake of playing, we can truly play the game (long term) in the sake of learning about this pretty interesting and unique world that Don has made
Donditales: The Isle
the lore must flow
but maybe its best it doesn't yet
i don't know
what is better
the drip-fed production of "I've done something, so lets get it out then work on the next"
or
the get it once its all ready production, and experience it quite literally all in one
both have their own effects, honestly
like the glance sheets, environmental story telling, and hopefully more with humans
how i see it
drip fed feels modern and new
its a style of content sucking that we've properly invented over the last 50 or so years
which can feel a bit too sucky for the creators from the audience
For me, it can be something that is mass-produced and made to be properly contentified. Rather then just art as art.
But on the other hand
its speedy and quicker delivery times that 'keep people well fat' (happy) with content
but is this a bad thing?
Are we not animals of dopamine? So why should it change anything on how we feel about lore
if anything
almost potentially feeling like a deliberate 'well thats not how art is done!' sort of conservatism
Art can be done in any way you like
Being more rapidly produced, piece by piece, or all in one
but one thing dondi has made me lose hope on, back when he said humans wont have much more to them other than running around with guns vehicles and bases (it was something like that) i think it was a missed opportunity to have lore expressed by using humans as the missing piece as humans could understand writing, text without need of a mutation and the only hurdle being other humans and a player driven ecosystem.
Things like think-aloud methods, computers, terminals, docuements and those keycards that give access to certain areas
gosh that is poorly written but im on my phone
its understandable lol
yes
It would be interesting if tasks could somehow be assigned for the human players, then like the lore bits could be explore like an open map exploration type of thing
i, too, also find it sad and a bit of a disappointment :/
But i think a lot of these systems would be a lot better on a storymode/singleplayer game or mode
I love The Isle
but damn do i kinda really dislike the idea of multiplayer (outside of co-op), especially in this context for lore and story
Yeaaah
i think im making too many links to hzd and may be missing the mark for what dondi would like to do, but the isle seems like a fun way for it to be done on for a multiplayer game
the spinosaurus blocking the entrance to the lab:
i mean
from what we've seen
its only just a survive to survive sort of thing
no quests or proper missions
Which is cool and all
but how do you keep player retention or continuation?
i think humans will attract the kind of players from that one game
i forgot its name, the one where players are a rare occurrence and they may or may not kill you
with vc
i do wish humans had more to do
we'll have to see how it goes
do we know if they can like, build or anything? or if tribals can?
repair bases maybe
but not much from that
there is still plenty of time for them to change so im not too worried either
dinosaurs have their gameplay loop, humans will get a purpose too, hopefully
ill never forget how excited i was when Hope was newer and I found some papers in a human building lol
i tried reading them, only to see it was just Lorem Ipsum over and over
WELP!!!!
truth nuke
Nooooo haha
DayZ?
Could it be no man’s sky? I remember them saying it would be rare to find other ppl on the vast open space
thats the one i think
😔
lol
Tf is the overseer or whatever?
The Matriarch or Neurotenic Mastermind/Echdina?
Both ig
sure thing!
I'll start with Echidna / Neurotenic Master / Mother of the Cannibals
Echidna is a humanoid Neurotenic strain, most likely Gen 1 ... potentially a Gen2 strain but... likely not.
In essence, she is a neurotenic 'humanoid'.
Nonetheless!
She is able to perfectly replicate the voice of a human (especially the ones she's killed) and transmit it out via short-range transmissions to lure in unsuspecting humans, as if a siren.
She was also known to have a relationship with The Eyeless/Cannibals in Legacy (hence one of her epithets of "Mother of the Cannibals")
To what degree? We don't know ... could be something where Echidna turns Gen1s into Eyeless, potentially some sort of bodyguard or elite class she can make. Or potentially as a punishment... we don't really know
She was also given the description of "Carrier" by Dondi a few years back
which may link to NHJs (The neurotenic-related zombie lore ... i.e. the zombie event from last year and the year prior)
That being, potentially, a 'redo' of the "Neuro-Goo" topic brought up in legacy lore once ||the term Neuro Goo being a fan-term|| ... and so Echidna potentially being 'the carrier' of the NHJ 'Virus' and spreads it
...
but The Matriarch?
The Matriarch is an entirely seperate thing from the strains (Type-H / N / T)
However, has some connections to the research of Tissoplastics (type-Ts) because they share the similar research to growth of limbs / change of the body
however, specifically in legacy lore
The Matriarch was a completely adaptable organism ('not correct to call it a dinosaur') that is made within Tartarus
Where, once another profile (EIP) is complete, the Matriarch will redistribute within observable areas of Tartarus for study
That section is a bit interesting and some of us had a really unique chat about this idea a few weeks back
About the idea of EIPs 'being complete'
But it seems that AE needed profiles to be completed to properly allow created 'organisms' to properly function?
Again, Legacy lore. But I do wonder if this would ever come back as an idea.
Ty gng
why do the prehistoric life blink wideways?
"Sideways blinking is caused by a "nictitating membrane," a translucent third eyelid found in birds, reptiles, fish, and some mammals that moves horizontally or diagonally across the eye. This membrane protects the eye, keeps it moist, and clears debris while maintaining vision, acting like built-in goggles for hunting or flying."
well then why don't we have an ordinary blink as well. like we blink sideways and then normally?
We have eyelashes and tear canals instead to keep eyes clean and moist
We simply evolved differently
we still have our third eyelid technically, its the red things you see in the corner of our eye
no need for it now, just like tails
Isaac became LoreGPT
Holy Guacamole
Evil Guacamole!
Echidna like knuckles
No!!
Isnt the matriarch the physical embodiment of the replicator?
Isaac is turning into a clanker, guys
no
isaac has fallen
NOOOO
mmmm lore
I really need lore drops or at least a bit of content on humans in the steam trailer :/
either someone very silly or...
dondi whispered in your ear to distract you from the truth
in all seriousness though...
Matriarch hasn't ever really been 'the replicator'
If there was a time, then it would've been very short lasted
If anything (from the original message i sent)
The Matriarch may have been an EIP-controlled thing
User Inquiry: The Matriarch Coinciding with objective parameters to complete an EIP. I have developed a completely adaptable organism within Tartarus. Once another profile is complete, the Matriarch will redistribute within the observable areas of Tartarus for study. It is not correct to call it a dinosaur, but I have not given it a name.
Full user inquiry as well

an old animation i KNEW i've seen before
and was able to find recently
(I love finding the most rarest and abstract isle lore-related stuff sometimes)
Do you remember the neuro spino animations that were shown off?
Is there even like a whole lore behind the screen
I feel like theyre just kinda making it up as we go
i can guarantee they aren't.
#isle-lore-theories message
there is a whole lore document in the pinned comments.
there is probably some of those long lost deleted clips somewhere in a MeatyLock video
maybe even Anthomnia
nice
i wish Don didn't kill his clips
I remember a bunch of eyeless clips of him actually in-game
not just a test animation
oh well
i think there is one or two clips still in a MeatyLock video
but not the clips i want
anth has a bunch
somewhere
too bad no one really took the time to download the majority of these clips
it still surprises me that MeatyLock still has the CC role
so i wonder if i should contact him if he has any old lore videos
but
that would be stuff from basically 10-8 years ago
So I wonder...
my theory is legacy is canon to the lore, but takes place further back in the time line
my perception of it is basically every map, every model, and every variation of the game is a different stage of progression st AE
You guys think they’re gonna abandon tribals or nah?
Nah, they have animations (from what i've heard)
depends on what you define tribals as
Isle GPT, are tribals and gen 1's/eyeless essentially the same but different names from gateway until evrima?
certainly!
look, i wouldn't even do ' / ' for gen1s and eyeless
as they appear, to our knowledge (alongside confirmation from legacy), as two seperate things
but tribals is a bit of a unique thing
For me, I don't mind utilising the term 'tribal' synonymously with Gen1s
As, the legacy (the continuation of roughly 10 years or so) of 'tribals' has almost always been the big humanoid monsteroid fellas
... where there had only been a short period of time, a little grace point, where 'normal' human tribals were ever a thought
but i know a lot of people here do not like using the term Tribal, as it does lead to more standard human ideas and themes that isn't going to be the true case with Gen1s
with the eyeless though...
assume we know nothing besides being not true Gen1s
(except for the obvious: are 'blind' / eyeless)
Thanks Chat ✌️ So does that mean gen1 since eyeless arnt true gen1's are they cannon or are they a seperate "strain" of gen1?
maybe
Some theories include Eyeless being a Neurotenic Gen1
potentially Eyeless being a Gen1 later version (coming from the Dondi Gen1.5 quote)
||as we know Gen1s are not just 'one thing', not a moniker for one thing, and so there will be seperate versions of Gen1s. Like we've seen of their concept art||
They could also be specifically mutated "bodyguards" of Echidna
probably some more theories here and there
there is a specific way to obtain such (to become such) in Legacy
it was never added, but was teased by Dondi
which was also its official name
so if we learn of its true name
maybe we'll be able to know where it came from
Echidna is the nuerotenic human right?
my theory is that the eyeless are the next stage from gen 1s in the """"evolutionary path"""""
gen 1 -> prove your worth via sacrifices or whatever -> become eyeless -> go through a number of specific routes to become the strain you want to be
ye
Arent the eyeless cave dwellers?
i think you're thinking about the one old vega art
but that was a normal "gen1"
Ah ok
is interesting
the only thing i am curious about though is that Eyeless' share the same trait (being eyeless) as Neuros do
which can lead to the thought that they are standard neurotenic Gen1s
but
maybe, if you take your theory, the 'becoming eyeless as a reward' aspect
could be some sort of Herculean challenge
become blinded, receive your limitations and your sufferings
and prove your worth to the fullest extent

Yall are speaking a different language lol
A challenge that heightens the other 4 senses?
an interesting struggle
They give death angels vibes
(design wise, i like to think of those fellas from the last hunger games movie lol)
ye
Good series, read the books before you watch the movies tho thank me later
I dont have the time to read much anymore tbh
(after i finish Shogun, i think i'm gonna suffer and read hunger games)
ye
I tried to read LOTR i could not make it through the first book
yeah, very old style of writing
The hobbit however, love reading that one over and over haha
was about to say that lol
a lot easier and nicer read
but i appreciate the world building of the LOTR books
There’s a lot in the LOTR, good author but just it drags on a bit 
yeah
something made by someone who loved their work
but want you to put hours into reading sessions
but, none of these stories are as good enough as Isle Lore!!
Well i was going to say if a book series ever came out regarding the isle and lore i would def read it lol
what a world it would be if Don gave a professional author (nothing against Dondi of course, but someone who does books for a living!) his entire 60+ page timeline document of everything
Go make a novella or somethin'
just don't answer the isle lore
The isle fan series when
George R R Martin
i suppose we have some 
but not proper prose fan lore that is properly wide spread
as amazing GRRM's writing style would compliment isle lore...
Slower then isle development
Can't remember who but a while back someone reached out to him regarding Isle's story and stated "we should talk" but don't think anything came of it. There use to be a twitch clip about it
oh i think i remember a mention on that
reminds me of when Don messaged one of the devs from prehistoric kingdom about doing UI for Isle
just one of those neat messages that just never made its way...
Yeah, he was playing Apex with I beleive Baardo is the most I rememeber and oh gawd the PK collab too was something before
all i remember of the first is a mention to the stream probably some time after it happened
long time ago now...
What a wild coincidence seeing this gif in here of all places.
Funny…
because best show of the year
I wonder if we’ll ever get short films to explain some lore or give us stories of certain events
would be fire
Don please 
doesnt that describe the file recoveries in phase 3
Salt Lore!
yeah pretty much
alongside the ERRANT-291 document for stories on certain events
albeit, not a big event
but something that be alluding to bigger events and ideas
Somebody needs to
we already have actual lore short films
but i do wish we could get something that isn't just video explaining why dinosaur does X Y or Z

I mean human stuff
quite so, quite so
the sad part is that Don said he can't really do proper human stuff because he doesn't have space for mocap
which is a bummer
Wdym oh great and wise light claw
Also for April fools you should have changed your name to white claw and with a pic of the drink
I’ve always thought the same thing
quite so!
I've really enjoyed all the TCAM-style lore videos
but it cannot truly communicate everything lore-wise, in my opinion
And if you play on the same visual idea, it becomes a bit stale
Not for me bud, I’m the trail cam enjoyer
Agreed I still think they can do a lot with the tcam stuff but I think they should (and hopefully will) incorporate some other methods of sharing lore especially in game
Neuro spino is so cool to me 
Is this like a mutation or something? Why he look like he did hard drugs his whole life?
These anims are old tho, probably 7ish years old
He's right that was kinda hot
I have this one saved lol
Ain’t it tho
Whats going on here then
First one is sniffing, second is it’s EMP ability
Are they old animations or something?
From legacy
Honestly, with what we have right now with the TCAM stuff, they have explored quite a good amount of different styles.
But, I really commend the team, especially Dondi, for having every TCAM relatively being unique and stylistically different from each other, outside of the Trike and Diablo TCAM.
However.... the only difference is the Trike TCAM has an actual story to it, which is different from the Diablo TCAM... So, technically speaking, every TCAM video is and has been unique.
My only gripe is that we've been getting a lot of "Hey, why does X dinosaur do Y thing?" style video. Its fine, but it does get repetitive no matter how many times they change the TCAM style of each lore video.
It's just a lot on dinosaurs, which is fine ... being a majority dino game ...
but I just want some of this content starting to explore deeper in lore, more then we've ever gone into, like EIPs, humans, etc etc
I can very easily imagine TCAMs with humans in it.
However I think i'd prefer more short actual stories and not just hard, static TCAM cameras that aren't able to move and stuff.
Unless they really want to put a lot of effort into a TCAM vid.
I do think humans should get a lot of effort in videos, though
But yeah, I just hope that we get unique or at least heavier, more hard-hitting lore-wise videos that don't have to be TCAMs.
But if they muchc prefer this style. I just hope Don pushes towards giving us a bit more in that direction.
but yeah yay
Yea I agree I’m still betting that they explore those as development continues and (maybe) we actually reach implementation of that sort of thing but such is life as a lore nerd I suppose
🙏
especially by not making everything easily accessible
but also making us work hard to find these sort of things
I do kinda of find it a bit hypocritical of me
I want lore now
but i do want lore to be hidden yet discoverable
but we know that isn't the case yet...
the terminal is a good sign though that... soon...
it would be CRAZY though if there were some advancements to the Terminal for this HT/update
Exactly
the potential is kind of just sitting there waiting on the game to get to a decent spot which is sort of a shame but I understand
One can only hope 🤞
How come the neuro spino exist. Is it a freak accident or is it a counter to a specific type h dino
There’s three strain types, type h, type n, and type t
why are strains?
Medicine related potentially
why is the lore so complicated, lore man?
everything is complicated when you look deep into it
(The specific design and general idea was also basically a fan canon artwork by Tapwing before she was hired)
I need him.
He needs a hand
It took one.
How is everyone
That thang is like a fish
hope you are good first allosaurus, im alright, just got the game and allosaurus is actually my favorite dinosaur lol
fricking love big al
that carnotaurus is absolutely terrifying.
its heavily based on a stoplight loosejaw fish, bioluminescent red eyes and all
fish are basically irl neurotenics
just need to pluck out the eyes
pokemon type eyes
misleading and not the real thing
so how do i enter tartarus right now
what’s my next steps, as someone who wants to go
LLLRFL....
not really but!...
maybe it'll have some importance...
Sorry
Did you know oviraptor is the sole focus of the isles lore?
I do now
No rumple don’t abstract we need you to hate on allo more
I'm playing with 3 Allos on US 13, I'm using Cerato. If anyone from the server is interested, feel free to message me privately.
wrong channel 😔
sorry
you will pay
This is fun.
It is!
i should be compiling a lot of peoples' glance sheets
especially Lima's
i've seen a good handful of them now
Good and bad
honestly, Limas do be amazing
Dasharks as well are nice
they look so good.

one day we may see some ||the official ones of course|| in-game though
that'll be the day!
I have more.
i do wonder if there would be official glance sheets for them
or if they get a completely different (maybe more edgier) sheet
Rex build sheet leak perhamps?
🫣
I hope we get official files for creatures
🚬
please forgive me, but i had to check the terminal this update
even though it literally added like a single mb of data to the game
Oh you desperate soul.
1 mb was A LOT in the 90s! so! so!
lore starvation kicking in
soon :))
soon™
Good things await beyond the long great depression
i wish rex could js get a nerf
Wrong channel.
mb
I need to remake some of my older ones. Like the T-Carno needs to be altered. Troodon I'm okay with, and Hyper Rex I just kinda copied down the description from one of the old character sheets, which I'm not happy with. I'd rather craft another scenario similar to the N-Carno so that it doesn't feel like I'm trying to sell the IDEA of the Hyper Rex, but rather sell the idea that the document you're reading feels classified in some way.
I might try and do that with all of them. Because I wasn't taking them all too seriously in the storytelling aspect.
Thats just propaganda 
whatever gives hope in these dark times
Better grab all that hopium
now that i have my pc again i want to remake some of mine since i made them all on mobile lol
plus looking back at the official ones i think i crammed way too much writing

Apollo Engineering
What is this
Something I'm writing that relates to #isle-lore-theories message
Ah
Lore!!
please remove 2172 and do not use japanese yy/mm/dd 😔
but yay!!!
i do wish we could read the character names for errant-291 though...
nonetheless, yay!!
@acoustic osprey
man i really wish names were covered up like this or just a bit more darker so you have to do a bit of photoshopping. But still
I mean I can make them darker.
i really find it weird that half of the blacked out words in ERRANT-291 are fixable
and the other half are not
i think for a bit of realism, yeah
https://gyazo.com/b5189c13235c750b74ee83d073d4dde1
like these two on the top are a bit darker and harder to read
probably something you could 'photoshop' to read
sold it for the 1000 life contract...

is nice though
Why thank you
It might not be it's best as it's 3am and I've been trial and erroring for 3 hours.
I need your brutal critiques. I thrive off of it.
with this #isle-lore-theories message
you only made darker the ones i said were fine 
also curious on the classification NIBBS
I misread
Moreso just echoing was ERRANT's was. Nibbs is a funny nickname you give an amputee in some cases.
ah interesting
didn't know that lol
Yeah. So since he lost a hand, I thought it only fit. lol
Yeah that was my main inspiration for finding a fitting name.
537 might delve into my own little version of lore. Paragraph 4 being a hint towards that.
curious on if 537 (like how ERRANT is 291)
is supposed to be '291st' or the '537th' case of "X" classification
or coming off their employee 'number (assuming they had some, seeing as 291 had an employee badge)
ah ok
or else 537 cases of people getting their hands popped off is a bit too much lol
Haha
which you shall be doing, right :))
all i can give you is a pat on the back and words of encouragement
😎
That's all I need lmao
yeah!!
also is the species report supposed to be this?
(in the NIBBS report for [1] / 537-A)
because if anything
i would refer this less to a species report, being a glance sheet, and more of a species evaluation sheet or just "Species Glance Sheet/Document"
Loosely based on that, yes.
not saying you have to change the footnote
but i just know that, in lore, these are supposed to be not super helpful and more glances (to know a bit about X or Y creature)
Yeah, it's loosely tied to that. It probably wouldn't have any form of illustration at all. For that animal especially.
Maybe a still frame from the bodycam footage.
probably the only slight nitpick from the incident report nibbs sheet
nothing i can really see as needing criticism then
This should hopefully be the final rendition.
when it mentions the Neuro Carno
I'm curious whether you should keep it as "Neurotenic Strain" or just keep it as Type-N Strain
Not a nitpick
just a thought
Seeing as legacy basically only referred to strains as "Type-...X" etc
like with this
but this is Evrima. And the mediums for these are slightly different
however, the legacy loading screens were a bit interesting
they were one medium but the text 'coming from' (in lore) different mediums
such as this one, which is different from the last
as this one is specifically a AE-IRT (AE Incident Report Transcript)
I see Type-N as more of an abbreviation than anything. On an official report like this I'd feel it more appropriate to use the full name.
i just know they used "Type" a lot on legacy
Which is interesting
if anything
they'd probably, irl, use Neurotenic first then say Type-N after the first reference
like with Essays with abbreviations to things
Yeah that makes the most sense
saying that, am i missing some of the legacy loading screens
hm
nonetheless
i have nothing else to say, critique-wise, about your sheet
it is really nice
Why thank you. You made a lot of sense with the example of essays, so I just made that little change too. So, official final rendition. lol
🔥 🔥 🔥
so the severed hand showed signs of healing?
thats no normal employee...
hmm
'Beast' being used lightly here.
||i do need to watch AoT||
its very good and while watching made me think of the isle sometimes (mostly due to insanity)
Best representation I can find of what that poor expedition may or may not find if that request gets approved.
hmmmmm interesting
after i finish jjk
i am going to watch AoT
so i'll see
so was the hand from a strain-infected person then?
He might be now.
i finished aot and have started jjk now lol
are you asking for a model 👁️
see now, if you did Neuro Spino over Neuro Carno
life would be easier
tissoplastic guy due to limb wanting to regenerate? idk
neuro
i think Lima is doing Neuro Goo
the goop
i wonder if Lima is doing it to be linked with NHJs or a seperate Neurotenic-type thing from Neuro bite infections
i do like the idea of neurotenics having some contagious aspect
also i realised i didn't have the full crop photo of the old door
so i am send here because helpful
i think its on the legacy Archive doc
but nonetheless
i also hope they lean into the bioelectric stuff because the more i read about bioelectric fish, the more i realise theyre just irl neuros
mmmm
electric eels can communicate with each other through their electric signals and relay information down a "chain" of eels
also they can use their shocks to control the nervous systems of their prey
if they are trying to find hiding prey, theyll make them jerk or flinch to expose themselves. if theyre chasing fleeing prey, theyll make them freeze up
oh i just realised both this and the eyeless one are basically super slow invincible wobble edits

invincisle
Tf even is that
a theory that some of us have made relatively recently, WhiteFalcon, is that Omniraptor could have been an early dinosaur
basically one of the first dinosaurs AE made
or literally the first
In a period of time where AE may not have had been able to actually remake an actual pre-existing creature
and thus, had to put 'a bunch of things together' to get something
and that something may have had turned out to be Omniraptor
Who's theory is that I like it.
just a bunch of ours in one
its a relatively new thought
I think from last month or something
It makes sense
yeah!
The first one being basically a running Eagle.
Easy to handle and easy to nourish
seeing as AE started in plants
they likely had the tech to make living things
Just had to go around actually now swaping kingdoms from plants to animals
Then in Lore Omni could also have a feathered varient
Would be nice to hear from Dondi about the first breeding pair of Omni
Or the first Sisters like in JP
Adam and Eve or staying with Greek mythology Garamas and Noibe
Omniraptor likely is some hybrid or other custom made dinosaur
Though afaik we still don’t really know if any of the dinosaurs are really dinosaurs at all, like if they really contain dinosaur dna or if they’re just molded into the shape of what they expect a dinosaur to be (although the last trail cam video with Rex implies there is at least some dinosaur DNA)
yeah
it could truly be only Rex has some Paleo Rex DNA
or that after a certain point, Rex got Paleo DNA ... and evolved a mutation to use some sort of hidden gene from that DNA to use the Paleo Broadcast
However, with Omniraptor
I much prefer this theory 😔 #isle-lore-theories message
i don't really like Omniraptor just being stereotypical hybrid
when nothing else is really that besides Troodon
Isn’t troodon apparently derived from two other ingame dinos? Or something like that
They are bioegineered reptiles that look like dinosaurs based on Æ idea what a dinosaur that lived mya looked like
They made featherless chickens basically
I think no Dinosaur DNA was used they likely rebuilt the whole sequence from the ground up creating life
And modifying existing animal DNA.
I think Deinosuchus is just an overeginerred American alligator
Not the very crocodilian that lived in the Cretaceous
This would explain why Our Deinosuchus is very much a scaled up Alligator
Every minute feature of that beast screams alligator
The teeth, snout shape, jawline, backplates, underbelly, cheeks, large skull plate where the sexual male markings are
And that our Deinosuchus is very smooth and streamlined

And among Dinosaurs probably Allo and Maia are the only paleo accurate
Austro!
What would be the Lore behind Austro
Did Æ make a realistic Dinosaurs that's basically a bird
Austro would be the direct opposite of Omni.
So I guess Austro is newer
I wonder what the lore for Austro will be
basically
although, from what we know: "But what if we did this to animal X…"
full quote
'Troodon: Created from another dinosaur currently not in-game, a byproduct of an in-world character’s, “But what if we did this” to animal X…” -Dondi (Oct 25/26 2023)'
There’s likely some level of dna present due to the fact they acknowledge Rex’s paleo call as atavism, meaning it would have some level of Rex dna present for that trait to reemerge from the ancestor
Still wonder what that dinosaur could be. Cant be omni since it was already there. Velo maybe?
^^
#isle-lore-theories message
as well, WhiteFalcon
definitely something small
I still stand by my theory of megalania solely based on the troodon's swim style
Lol
<@&933486433342222376>
But Trex DNA is lost doesn't exist its a badly damaged sequence from mixed blood you find in a dead mosquito died and fossilised in Amber.
You better off engineer your own
Why did they make dinosaurs anyway
if we're going off irl lore, sure
but this is the isle
Challenge
The Isle is science fiction and science fiction are usually based on irl science
No lol
science fiction is 'fiction'
meaning
Fiction is any form of narrative, literature, film, or art created from the imagination rather than strictly based on history or fact
there is a complete spectrum of realism for fiction
to be fair
them extracting paleo dna isn't fairytale-level, to be fair
Bioengineering is that
its something JP did
we've also been told by Dondi that the idea of Clarkes Third Law is in place in lore
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic"
Rebuilding and mapping out the DNS sequence is also not a myth
Like how do you explain electricity to someone from the 18th century?
pretty much
How do you explain a touch screen phone to someone who was born in the 60s?
Magic is Science
well
i wouldn't say that specifically
the future feels like magic
but magic is not science
And the truth is that we could irl bioengineer birds to look like dinosaurs
there are things in magic that cannot physically exist, that exist outside the natural laws of the universe
but there are things in science that, if you go back in time, 'feels impossible' (thus equated to the idea of it being 'magic')
Æ be like
Yes Omni
Now eat the bug you cute bird
quite so
First Austroraptor
Engineered out of Herons and Falcons
This also explains how and why dinosaurs can change so rapidly and go under mutations so quickly
Both in lore and ingame
I would argue Clarkes Third Law is largely used as a hand wave by writers who wish to get away with something without their work being labeled fantasy.
Star Trek is Fantasy (matter cannot move the speed of light or greater, and if it did there would be dramatic implications)
Much of Michael Crichtons work is Science Fiction.
however, still applies to JP (both novels and movies)
but is explicitly stated to be the case with The Isle (specifically mentioned with the replicator, iirc. Although does not limit to just the replicator)
however, Star Trek isn't truly fantasy
just because things can be fanatical, doesn't mean it is fantasy (being that it doesn't fit generic fantasy tropes)
Yes, I suppose there's definitely a tolerance to the term.
Not all of Jurassic Park fits into scientific plausibility. And a little extra fiction apart from the science doesn't hurt the genre
And despite the impossibilities of faster then light travel, the primary subject of such dramas is still exploration of the scientific field (space).
of course
genres are an interesting topic
they're complex and not singular
Star Trek does include fantastical ideas and things that are pretty much magic to us
But it still, more or less, aligns far more with the general 20th-21st century ideas, themes and settings of a "Sci-fi"
"There is a point where certain modern technologies become indecipherable from magic." -some guy I don't remember his name
wait you already quoted it. bruh
Yeah lol
Wasn’t that quoted in an old Olympus transmitter message?
Also yeah I am really curious though to see just how far the isle goes in terms of its sci fi. A lot of sci fi stuff naturally converges with elements that are simply supernatural, but idk if the isle will do that
Neuros to me seem like the farthest stretch
But I kinda do want to see some of that stuff dip its toes in territory where you genuinely question if it’s just natural science at play or if there’s other forces at work
It’s always interesting when advanced technology ends up working in ways that make you question the supernatural, like how engineers on certain military tech will swear up and down that some computer program or machine is “haunted” lol
no
Was it a Dondi quote then? I remember something isle related saying that
I’ve heard this a few times but idk if it’s a true story or not. But this kinda thing is always interesting where even the programmers just acknowledge the machine is haunted lol
What the hell is this thing made out of?
God I love Venture Bros...
i wonder if there will be actual lore? and if thats something only the humans will be able to access to learn why the isle is the way it is
there is tons of actual lore. there is a whole document in the pinned messages.
why does the cloverfield movie have the same text format the isle lore videos do? They both use USGX, does it mean something in the real world or did they just use it for reference?
I believe it's a fairly common format for classified documentations.
def would like to know what this format is called, looks neat.
nice catch
Apparently the USGX doesn't have a known official meaning
but some say it could mean US Government "X" (for classified?)
http://www.usgx8810b467233px.com/ (link doesn't work anymore)
heh, apparently there was a whole official arg-esque website made for it
https://cloverfieldclues.blogspot.com/search/label/USGX
but coming off this
The latest, up-to-the-minute 10 Cloverfield Lane news, featuring Cloverfield video, audio, screenshots, interviews and coverage of the Cloverfield online sites: 1-18-08, Slusho, Tagrauto, JamieAndTeddy, TidoWave, FunAndPrettyThings
honestly
very interesting read
of course, nothing helpful for 'isle lore'
but, really cool nonetheless
basically another sort of terminal-esque ARG that i would not mind coming in
similar to the People Playground website
There it is yeah
Well if the isle file names have any sense to them then we can draw an idea of what they mean.
From the Cloverfield stuff we see it says DoD and NGTA which are both real things.
DoD being department of defense so whatever the isle is using in replacement in that ARCHIVE (7) thats where the file is and OL-TM must be another agency inside a government or AE.
problem is
we see two
OL-TM and OL-GH
i suppose could be seperate departments part of "OL"
Or we’re over analyzing this and they just put random numbers and letters lmao 
seeing as they're both post-injection evaluations
but
one is about Social Dynamics (animal behaviour)
and the other is about nutrient metabolism
wouldn't be the first...
i think some things are important though, more seemingly important due to their repeated presence as well
where others. Good to have them written down because they could be referred to again
stuff like ARCHIVE 7 / Archive (7) especially
i wouldn't be surprised if OL-TM and OL-GH are just random numbers with no true depth behind them, though
unless Dondi really wants everything to be super duper pitch perfect regarding everything
Which i do not see
If they did so
they would be making every model, even useless generic props and models
not worth the while
howeve, archive 7 is interesting
which goes to our archive 7 corruption theory
I have no idea what any of the theories for the isle are
i'll be honest
there isn't a great area to learn theories
despite the name of the channel
lol
honestly
theories for isle lore is a bit weird
not that our theories are bad
more so
Its pretty direct and there isn't a lot of lore to go off from to make larger and bigger theories
so every lore theory is more of a simple and quick question
with one or two theories behind it
hmm
about this though :))
maybe its time to resend my 'change isle theories to isle lore discussion' petition :))
Claw explain to me the lore behind the unknown/gen1
Seems like a fatal error or some kind of… ghost in the machine or was it intentionally made
Or if you about to type it in discussion u good lol
Heheh so how did they come about though? Was it an error? Or were they purposely made
we basically have only this for Gen1s:
Began as a retaliatory product by AE as an overengineered answer to
the question of, “What if something hits AE?”, and are an effective deterrent.
(In terms of their original purpose)
the Eyeless though?
pft. Who knows
they were described by Don to be like "Gen 1.5"
#isle-lore-theories message
so likely made after Gen1s were originally created
honestly?
maybe the eyeless are what become of gen 1s if they evade capture after a retaliatory strike
overtime they slowly become eyeless basically
retalitory strike from what though 
i meant a retaliatory strike from AE against another company
they use the gen 1s to attack a rival company's facility, some escape
i know dondi described it as "enemy territory", so id assume theyre not just dropping them in a random office building in a bustling city lol
as funny as that would be
maybe other companies and their own private islands lol, if AE isnt the only one with their own The Isle™
what im talking about is the territory
if they just scatter in every direction out in the middle of nowhere from a facility, itd be difficult to catch every single one, and surely one would escape
mmmmm
eyeless being gen 1 "prime elder" so to speak
their eyes would have to morph into nothing though
as if it was never there
but maybe
the skin heals/grafts over the eyes naturally
or something
i wonder if they even need to capture the released gen1 after or not. surely if they already have chips/EIPs in dinosaurs, they could just remotely "shut off" any loose animal
suicide squad bomb in the head type thing lol
or i inject you with the neuro goo, sorry 😔
id guess its "forced evolution" to adapt to caves and low light environments, but hard to say if it was AE proper who did it, for some bioweapon ig, or if it was the replicator, or if it was "natural" weird stuff like augustus
its definitely a recurring thing though that whatever is being done to the organisms AE makes, they have a weird tendency to spontaneously mutate/adapt in weird ways
i do wonder, like outside of what happens to Gen1s or how is the eyeless..., how AE do these operations with Gen1s
especially with what you said
Once its finished, are these creatures built with some sort of biological planned obsolescence ... i know its not unique but maybe something like what JP did (Lysine Contingency...)
(i mean we literally have mutations as an ingame mechanic so makes sense ig)
yeah
specifically with SYNTHs (at least Dino synths), we know that they are a lot more 'mutatious' because of 'the machine'
but how? why? and just SYNTHs or could it be anything 'the machine' interacts with ... and if so, does it have to be during a SYNTHs creation or can it be re-designed while it is living?
i really wouldnt be surprised if AE had a built in "kill switch" for any animal they have in their system. if it has an EIP/tracker/chip/whatever, like the stuff seen on the death screen, id assume they can just hit the "terminate" button and down they go
tricky thing would be the cleanup. wouldnt want to leave a dozen corpses behind of your genetic monsters for authorities to link back to you, or other companies to reverse engineer
ig most reasonable thing, if doable, would be to "program" them to return to their deployment point or whatever so they can be retrieved and used again. more cost effective and means you dont leave too much evidence behind
although if one is killed in action, yeah that could be a problem
biotrace perchance...
we only know that ERRANT-291 (an 'employee') didn't have a biotrace ... but doesn't truly limit itself to being just for employees. As 291 could have been an AE-creation: A Generation Two.
and... #isle-lore-theories message
Don once referred to biotrace with Troodon (inferring that dinosaurs potentially did actually have biotraces as well)
So i would not be surprised if even Gen1s had biotraces
Which, potentially, have some sort of multi-utility purpose of being a tracker and 'kill switch' (etc)
personally
not too sure if they'd want kill switch over something that would knock out/subdue the 'creature' with the biotrace
But maybe they just have 'all of the above'; kill switch option, knock out option, etc
what would be easier
some sort of kill switch activated remotely
or training the questionably 'conscious' humanoid monsteroid to 'come back' as if a well trained dog
hm
the hard part, that i can think of, with kill switch
is that you'd need to know when they were finished
I doubt you could train and kept them (the Gen1s) trained to activate the kill switch themselves
Maybe this is where you insert Robo Quetz as your remote surveillance camera?
but is that a lot of enough over just training the Gen1s to come back
Could have some body cam on them
Part of me doesn’t think that AE being able to program/command them is out of the question. If they can create mind-hijacking tech and neuros anyway, seems relatively simple to make an organism that reacts in specific ways to specific impulses and is able to be “commanded” that way.
Even if just a simple “go here”, or “come back here” lol
i don't mean to say that it would be out of the question
but what would be more reliable and easier to do
but body cam would work
Kill switch would be easier for sure, but also messier. Means every gen1 is a single-use weapon, and also leaving behind clear evidence. Idk the legality of dropping cannibalistic human-adjacent monsters on people is but I assume it wouldn’t be good for AEs stock value
this is why i think they would, if they would prefer this over training them, use more so of a knock out system (through Biotrace?) rather then just killswitch
we know AE aren't afraid to pick up things
like how we know they pick up Rexs with Helis
True they could just sedate them somehow and bring in the cleanup crew
so they probably, if they do use the 'kill switch' option, just pick them up
whether alive or dead
Biotrace!!
Probably would be in their best interest anyway to send a team down to collect any valuable data left in whatever place they just raided
ye
Go in, collect gen1, verify the people who you want dead are dead, grab some goodies on the way out
they have sweep teams and checkpoint teams on islands
they probably have foreign para-troop style sweep teams for missions like that as well
the hope and want is that we can physically get any sort of lore media on this type of stuff 😔 🙏
Is Troodon still planned to be able to mimic things?
I wonder if Troodon will have humans on their diet. That would be funny lol
sorry krowdrah 😔
(also, we don't know. I believe it was said that it may come back. But likely not anytime soon. But i am not too sure)
Lol. I was going to ask what this had to do with lore
What in the abomination is Troodon?
Why make it so deadly? Was it an oopsie, or intentional?
all we know is this
Created from another dinosaur currently not in-game, a byproduct of an in-world character’s, “But what if we did this” to animal X…”
I need more troo lore 🙏
we all do
quite quite so
Feathered Dilos are hunting a Feathered Plateo
Plateo is still on the roster?
It would be the 2nd early Jurassic dinosaurs
Do you think it would make sense if lore if some dinosaurs would be feathered and some not?
there already is some
I am asking about the lore side of it
Twas ugly
But in the same species
Like some Omni specimen would be feathered some wouldn’t
currently, in lore, we just have Galli having both feathered and non-feathered
That's a milestone
Once you have a principle you could apply to that to every other birds
lol
New gif added to my collection
quite so
Aye
Is that an Angus McLuaghlin reference?
the fact that at one point, Angus McLuaghlin could be considered a canonical person in the isles lore is really funny to me
pc and isle have such different tones that it kinda helps them not being connected. love pc but its a lot less serious and a lot more tf2 goofiness
is lore still alive
gotta love it tho
The Lore is merely biding it's time
put that out, it isnt good for you
And yet, this place holds us no less tightly than the cigarette...
wow... 😔
Sorry 
i forgive you
Yay
what cryptic imagery is this?
the glitching screens from legacy
turns out the one 'new' AE logo that used to be on the water tanks was actually in the game since legacy
and with a tiny change
that being the top point (the middle corner) is a straight corner
where the one in-game right now has a slight imperfection
interesting
<@&933486433342222376>
yeah!
apologies for the yappening though
I think i get too excited about lore though
but i love The Isle Lore
i'm glad i'm not super glued to this
as often as i look to be here (Because, really, i find myself too preoccupied with lore)
So coming in here once every few hours is really nice
with or without a solid conversation
same here, i think this games lore is so awesome
we just have no information about it whatsoever so most discussions are filled with “oh itd be cool if this was real” instead of “this could mean this…”
i wish it was kind of like fnaf where they have SOMETHING to work with
we have nothing but a singular bread crumb
i really like delving into games with expansive and complicated lore, it kind of just scratches an itch in my brain ESPECIALLY this game
DONDI PLEASE ADD SOME LORE TO HORDETEST
devs can you ban that guy, hes kinda a scammer
<@&933486433342222376> guess they stopped giving away free nitro
noooo, i missed my chance
It is ok
😞
Also when the report says 'horrible screams', this is what I meant.
aww, i assumed it was a large 'OWWIIIEEEE"

ive beeen living down there
sorry for all the screams
why did you clip this from futiles video
zen
Quite so
Futilesummer..
WHAT
WOAGHHH
Your pfp looks up terrified at such an image
do we have any information on when we’ll have access to the atrium currently on gateway?
i think we’ll get something in a lore focused update considering the implications on what’s supposed to be inside
Nope
😔
we do know (somewhat) what will be inside right?
arbourburst or something like that?
Nada
does this have the rio de janeiro filter? 😭
beautiful
who is this new guy
@hardy tulip
We don’t even know if it got snapped on hordetest or not
Cause it looked cool why else?
Testing
Test 2
why have you done this SilkyTT
I am sorry I had to 😭
@twilit token
So here we are this is the chat were we talk about lore
The Game's lore was also collected and wrote down by Issac in one document
Is there a timeline/established lore that we have to string together?
There should be one
Realistically in the past Æ [ApolloEngineering] did modify plants for farming
Not entirely
I assume the first generation of Dinosaurs made by Æ had died out.
We are their descendents
Tis why dinosaurs can breed and reproduce
lore theories document
Thank you
🫡
So we are people mind in dino body? Why does silly Dino game have disturbing lore? Are humans class 1 and 2 actual creatures you can find in game?
Ghost in the shell
Although I think that's total cringe
Adds nothing to the core and rather irrelevant
Who cares about the thoughts of an animal?
Who cares about the personality of a player playing an animal in the Isle?
So far only in lore
There were a couple of tests in the past but they can barely be called lore friendly with the best intention
Humans are only lore not in game (yet)?
Not in the game in their lore friendly form
Lore is usually more than just the back story of a game
The game itself built around the lore and concept made by the devs
Not vice versa
Just like how the spreadsheets and the facility sheets were released
👍 I'm still reading the doc I'll let you know if I have more questions
Sure, but ask others I don't know everything
Thanks for helping me now I'm too invested not to get the game
So they found a guy with no idea how he got there and he died upon trying to leave the facility?
That sounds like some clone with a kill switch.
Did I miss something?
Convenient heart attack?
This is why he wanted to steal a radio signal designation sheet
Or cover up
And a general alert structures and connections documents that could give any 3rd party companies a leverage to disrupt Æ operations on the Island
Basically this sheets let's you cut the line of communication between underground and above ground facilities from Olympus Command
I think those handwritten messages were made by 291
I doubt he was alone if one sweep team went missing.
Dinosaurs
A flock of angry Omni or Dilophosaurus or a subadult Trex could do wonders
Ahh I forgot this was a Dino game for a sec lol
I think a heartattack is a cover story the spy was dispatched by other means
But this document is important
If 291 was able to give the information to his supervisors
Then Æ could have been compromised and communication to the Island was lost
Which could result in the immediate evacuation of the Island
As furthermore safe work on the Island would not be possible
So his company can swoop in and take research and dinos once everyone leaves?
Devman introduced a lot of human facilities and laboratories even a hospital which they model in a way that a lot of equipment left everywhere
Rather destroy Æ from the inside
I don't know
The Lore will change a lot in the future
But core things like Errant 291 will be pivotal
Ok I need to go its 1am rn I'm hooked so hopefully I can become a dinosaur and join the isle in the near future.
well, the hope is that lore won't change a lot
As Don wrote a very large 70+ page document
but we'll know a lot more and things will change from our original theories...
which is where the fun begins
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1J3FnAzKdtmlIYzTfgSlevTgGLcn8h-Zaxlqn3WEicVw/edit Not sure if anybody gave you this already, but it's handy
The Isle Theory Document Created by: Rumplestiltskin Maintained by: Rumplestiltskin and The Isaac? Foreword by: 1tinydinosaur (PSA: Primal Carnage, both the original and Extinction, are no longer connected to The Isle’s Lore) You can comment on anything that needs to be added, changed, or remov...
Based on your PFP you would enjoy Trex real good
Prehistoric chicken
Lore
i think i'm going to do a little vote, a little thing like i used to do a long time ago
just to gather opinions on what people think how lore should be implemented
basically 2 very basic but very contrasting ideas
because you can really do one or the other
Bepi kinda looks like a chicken and it's one of the only ones with feathers
Environmental story telling, sunken ships, glance sheets on tables, documents, different stuff, destroyed vehicles, human facilities, human corpses, destruction that tells a story what happened
Lore videos released by devs even showing content that not in the game or doesn't take place on the Island.
Text Journals combined of environmental story telling about lore events without certainty so it leaves room for speculation
What I mean under different stuff is like a knocked over tree fell on a power transfer unit
Cuts the electric to the facility and of office chair falls on in back inside the security booth
more specifically about the broad idea on how to release Lore.
to sum it up for the vote when i make it:
- do you want lore to come out when its full done
or
- drip-fed style lore where whatever is made, when ready, is released. Piece by piece. Bit by bit
if that makes sense
I think I’m going to do a little vote, something I used to do a long time ago, just to gather opinions on how people think lore should be implemented.
Basically, I have two very basic ideas, but they’re very contrasting…pretty much polarising.
Either you do this, or you do that, holistically, in terms of the general philosophy of making and releasing lore for The Isle, because you can really only lean one way or the other.
More specifically, this is about the broad idea of how to release the lore.
To sum it up for the vote when I make it:
Either one, do you want lore to come out when it’s fully done … released as a complete package?
Something like a proper AAA video game, especially older story games that weren’t live service, where everything is just there on release (story-wise, ignoring DLCs.).
Or the other option is drip-fed style lore, where whatever is ready gets released piece by piece, bit by bit
Its similar to games like Sea of Thieves or Fortnite.
Sea of Thieves has more of a lore storytelling approach, whereas Fortnite used to, but now it’s kind of derailed.
So yeah
I want to play devil’s advocate a bit here.
Of course, there are issues on both sides, but with the piece-by-piece approach specifically, I feel like it’s very iffy. Something I think maybe I’m leaning away from. Maybe. I think.
A lot of games lose their heart because of this system. In my opinion and from i’ve seen in my time playing games.
It’s something of a very modern idea for games, releasing something that isn’t truly complete, because it isn’t holistically finished.
Adding more and more to the story over time.
It can work, like with FNAF, but then you look at FNAF now compared to the first two games and think, what actually happened?
Scott Cawthon did piece-by-piece lore, adding to the story with each game, but it wasn’t holistically complete from the start. Turning its story into something of a very unique piece of spaghetti. People do enjoy it, but basically every FNAFer knows how jumbled and ‘bad’ the actual lore-crafting has been. Even if the individual stories are ok.
So this philosophy often leads to creatives struggling to balance quantity with quality, imo.
A lot of the time, it’s driven by production needs or money. It’s more profitable to have weekly or monthly content drops that keep player engagement up.
Which is fair.
But to me, that can feel a bit desensitised and can ruin things.
It can make authors feel like their creative work is being pushed into a system just to make money, instead of something that originally came from passion.
Starting to feel like it’s “factory made” … from the machine.
And so, I think a big issue with it all is that it becomes very “gamey.”
The way we interact with it becomes more like, “I want content, I want content,” instead of, “Here’s the full experience: Enjoy it.”
But I must admit that it's faster.
If we went with the first option, it would be slow. Terribly slow.
We wouldn’t get content for ages.
But the thing is, we’re kind of already in that in-between stage right now.
We’re just waiting and waiting.
And I’m fine with waiting, but if we’re going to wait this long, maybe it would be better to just release things when it's practically fully and actually ready.
But heck. Maybe that is the plan now.
But maybe Dondi’s plan is to drip-feed until everything is ready, because we know he’s written a lot. A lot of basis of the world - unlike with FNAF, which basically had nothing ready for the lore on the whole.
I believe in him as a creative.
I know he cares about what he’s making and is making the game how he wants it.
But at the same time, from a customer perspective and trying to think from both sides, it just feels like drip-fed lore can lose that passion … for all of us and possibly for him.
I don’t know how he feels about it, and he might not respond, which is fair.
I guess I’m just at a point where I’m thinking it might be better to have things delayed and then released in one big update.
It doesn’t mean it has to be completely binary, these philosophies. If anything, it's more of a spectrum.
For example, you could have a large initial release, maybe when Evrima becomes the main branch (just hypothetically), where a majority of the lore is added.
Not everything, but maybe around 70-75%, enough to form a real foundation.
That way, we actually have something to work with.
Because, right now, it’s really hard to form proper and better lore theories because everything is so minimal or hidden.
We only really know about the dinosaurs and small bits about other creations like humans, Gen 1s, Gen 2s, etc.
If we had a strong base, people could start making proper theories and connecting things.
Then, after that, you could still add smaller pieces over time, drip-feed in a better way, once the foundation is already there.
I don’t know.
I genuinely don’t know, though.
What do you think? What do you take from this?
I hope that made sense.
a bit of a wall though
yikes
I feel like you're right on the lore needing strong base before more lore can be drip-fed to us. If there is no strong base to get people interested then the little lore what is given just will fail to connect. There is only so few of us who even know anything about the lore and all of that lore is so shaky at places.
This w Isaac
Piece by piece vs completed:
I mean I think the lore should be done by the time we truly start getting our hands on it. But it should still be drip fed in game basically we shouldn’t be getting lore as it’s written (even if that kind of sucks atm) I kinda have a little faith that dondi knows how to cook up something good and really get us hooked if he gets invested
The thing about this is that while we don’t really get to influence the game the way I wish we could in this scenario the best part is is that eventually you do actually get a large chunk of the game ironed out and ready at once vs suffering through it all
It’s sort of like the whole question of “should evrima have released later” deal. At the time everyone was almost looking for a much more complete “recode” and were disappointed at the result they got in hand but then again it had been a minute since we had gotten much in the way of isle stuff and (I would hope at least) that the community had a small hand in actually helping iron out some of the decisions that make evrima what it is rn and hopefully that trend will continue
Anyways I’m js yapping I lwk didn’t even finish reading ur message Isaac lol
<@&933486433342222376>
I like to think that the humans are Apollo engineer workers who were sent to retrieve something left behind but their pickup is not coming back

i think i'm on the side of doing a bit of both
Preferring the large basis of lore. Not just TCAMs on Dinosaurs
But lore. Worldbuilding.
The things Don talks about, but properly fleshed out and in in any way possible...
And once that happens
over time, drip fed-style after.
I think that would be a nice balance
yay
my worry with piece by piece is that plans could be changed as the lore is coming, resulting in potential retcons and stuff
but if its all put in once its 100% done, then that wouldnt happen
but i want my lore 😔
thats one reason why I hope Don just, instead of just dropping things whenever they're ready piece by piece, puts a majority (like 70% or whatever. As abstract as that is) of 'lore' into the game in some way or another in one sort of big release
mayhaps
or maybe don could draft out all the lore to finalize it, then put it into the game piece by piece (but still finalized so no retcons)
to be honest
it's probably the thing has has been doing
and has been doing for years now
i think we're up to like book 3 or 4 now, in terms of complete re-writing and re-formatting lots of lore for Don
Don did a big document, a whole timeline, crazy amount of pages at the beginning of last year
bros certainly had a lot of time to iron it out lol
lol
Getting my pc back today 
yay
but...
😔
you have no idea how often this happens
specifically made that gif for it lol
I guess my thumb just be pressing shi
lol
doing a bit of clean up in my folders
i think this is mostly it of notable things
I know i don't have Thenyaw
just
I don't really think there was anything truly noteworthy generally from Thenyaw lore-wise
what the frick frack is Site-12?
might be spero
isaac is it spero.
Reclamation of Site 12. Code: OLYMPUS
from an old old Isle twitter post
so potentially it may have been OLYMPUS
what and where is OLYMPUS? pft...
maybe it was the early idea of what Spero would be...
spero honestly looks better than gateway
ohh thats cool
i have to disagree
we didn't get see much of Gateway
Spero just had nicer and more vibey lighting
which we've had close to and similar to
Which is less a map thing and more of a lighting thing
We never really got to see a proper look at the level design of it properly, though
quite so!
gateway feels... so empty for some reason, especially after the removal of west access
i disagree with this! Gateway is honestly a really “bland” (atleast so far!) map if thats the way to say it. From what ive seen of Spero it looked great
and also the textures on some things on gateway are….
just look at the atrium man😭
even v3 didn't felt empty, it was cool and nice
but somehow gateway just feels... empty, i don't know
v3 was, for me, brought down by the very lackluster movement in the game
a lot of the dinosaurs felt super slow and with V3 being so big i felt like i traveled just a tiny bit of the map in 2h of gameplay
and i also love just exploring environments from high above, so the lack of flyers really didnt help
thats honestly what i liked about v3, the hugeness
i like a map thats a little more compact honestly, thats the one thing gateway has going for it
this version of gateway was great, but the current one.... ehh?
had so much lore and other potentials
yeah the outline of new Gateway is just...
totally agree
this gateway kinda…sucks
v0.20 was peak
compare the other outlines
new Gateway is just... yeah...
redwoods will save gateway though
thats maybe why it feels overall bad
and hopefully includes LAB IX...
I NEEDED THIS
yay
doesnt feel like and island tbh
yeah. Its a very weird shape
ehhh i wouldnt count on it
i don't think AE would've turned Gateway into such.
but we'll see...
I MUST!!
the places had lots of potential for lore stuff...
send in the old leaked Gateway image 😔
there was even some facility enterances on that island down to the right
they need to bring west access back and unfrick up the textures on some things
indeed they had