#Feedback Requests

1 messages · Page 25 of 1

formal hedge
#

Are you using any transient shaping or no

finite finch
#

I think its cause of the triggers i added

#

I'll revise it out

finite finch
#

I think this ones brtter

#

Than the new mix

#

Kinda

#

Cuz I like my guitar tone here

vale vapor
#

huh

finite finch
formal hedge
finite finch
#

what should do when it clips?, low volume with limiter?

formal hedge
#

I feel like it's a bit weird sounding you guys know why @vale vapor @balmy forum

wraith hare
#

snare is too loud

balmy forum
vale vapor
#

Kick is just a tiny thud

#

everything is just super quiet overall

#

You need to look at some mixing tutorials from the ground up

#

it sounds like you're missing a lot of the fundamentals of mixing

#

you need to practice balancing your instruments better

versed remnant
wraith hare
finite finch
#

opinions?

#

@vale vapor

#

@formal hedge

vale vapor
#

there's something clipping or distorting i think

#

the bass has a bit too much sub as well

balmy forum
#

nice job at knocking off the plot in you

finite finch
#

I was thinking it is the bass

finite finch
#

Oh

#

I see the ref

finite finch
finite finch
#

@vale vaporhow do u usually mix metal vocals?

runic adder
#

this

finite finch
#

Thanks

runic adder
#

np o7

vale vapor
#

Sometimes i swap the smooth compressor with the last EQ

#

Sometimes i only use 2 compressors

halcyon holly
#

sometimes i do limiting

#

pro-l transparent, full lookahead, fastest attack and release

#

essentially a clipper with no distortion

#

make that makes sense

vale vapor
finite finch
#

i tried

vale vapor
#

the guitar has like no low end, and the vocals are pretty hard to understand

#

are you using an ir on the guitars? it sounds like they have no ir

vale vapor
#

Try a different IR

finite finch
#

K

finite finch
vale vapor
#

What?

finite finch
#

The guitar has lowend i think

finite finch
vale vapor
#

At least, it's not audible in the file you sent

finite finch
#

Well ima fix that up soon

finite finch
#

And abit of reverb

#

Except for the first scream it has ton reverb intentionally

#

Kind of

#

Also yeah im not proud on the guitar tone dw

vale vapor
#

EQ if you remember? LOL

#

You should def be EQing it

inland zinc
finite finch
#

Yes i did eq i forgot

inland zinc
#

Okay good LOL

finite finch
inland zinc
#

I'm the harsh vocalist, yes

finite finch
#

These vocals go hard bro

inland zinc
#

Thanks!

#

Xenon is our singer

finite finch
#

Pretty good

finite finch
#

Might have to check out the tutorial

#

From xenon

vale vapor
#

just make sure there isn't clipping on any tracks

finite finch
#

Is it clipping rn?

vale vapor
#

I can't tell, just make sure nothing is clipping in your daw

finite finch
#

Should i use this tutorial for help?

#

On vocals

vale vapor
#

Sure, though every vocal is different, and the EQ will need to be different for every voice type

inland zinc
#

Facts

finite finch
#

Yes i know that

vale vapor
inland zinc
#

Frightbox is goated

vale vapor
#

Facts

finite finch
vale vapor
#

Yes

finite finch
#

@vale vaporbetter?

vale vapor
#

balance is good, guitar still just sounds weird to me

finite finch
#

do u have good quality irs? maybe ones i have arent just that good for this mix

vale vapor
#

@finite finch

#

.

#

.

finite finch
#

bet

#

vocals saying: its just a matter of resistance, all the pain has been done, when i try to come back, its gone for long

#

dont judge me i wrote those randomly

wicked berry
#

with whatever ir you used differently

finite finch
#

That one

wicked berry
#

sick

finite finch
#

Almost cant understand them

vale vapor
finite finch
vale vapor
#

It sounds like you have the mids turned up all the way

finite finch
vale vapor
#

that IR doesn't sound like that on my amp

finite finch
#

Mids are not bringed up at all

#

In the eq

#

Just like 3db

#

Or 4

balmy forum
balmy forum
mint acorn
#

Is this remix ass ?

finite coral
shut igloo
#

@wicked berry @runic adder @versed remnant @tribal orbit

#

made a track after solid 3 months i think

#

let alone in metal genre

#

what do yall think of the riffs and mix

versed remnant
#

I fuck with the riffs

#

Your rythym feels a tad muddy

#

Maybe cut some some low and boost a bit of the high end like 8k+ to brighten it a tad

#

The mix is pretty good

#

I’ll take another listen later in my studio so i can hesr things better

#

The riffing is sick though

shut igloo
#

Snare sounds good tho right?

shut igloo
versed remnant
shut igloo
#

Alrightyy

versed remnant
# shut igloo Prolly cuz it's an 8 string

Yeah when i’m doing super low tunings i’ve been bosting the 8k hella and not cutting but dratically turning down my like 200- frequencies and sidechaining to my bass since i usually mirror my guitar riff with the bass so the bass takes care of the low area more and it feels less muddy

#

Usually only when i do 8 string tunings tho

#

However my seven string is also nsturally pretty dark

#

I do 8 string tunings on it and and 7 string tunings on my dinky bc i love how it sounds with the split coil 4th position

#

Drop G# periphery my beloved

versed remnant
versed remnant
shut igloo
#

I got this cort kx 508ms

#

The coil switch and middle pickup position

#

Sounds out of this world

#

With a clean tone

#

Holy shit itbfelt nice playing guitar after a long time

#

I think I picked up guitar after a solid month or so

finite finch
#

redid vocals

#

and added new ones

shut igloo
shut igloo
#

holyfok

finite finch
shut igloo
shut igloo
runic adder
#

nah idm

#

been a minute since someone pinged me here

shut igloo
#

aight aight

shut igloo
vale vapor
#

everything sounds quiet and kinda weird

#

muffled overall

vale vapor
#

guitars are kinda muddy with the bass

mint acorn
vale vapor
#

ah, not sure how i feel about it lol

shut igloo
balmy igloo
finite finch
#

accidentally made argent metal

#

@formal hedge thoughts?

formal hedge
#

Drums sound dubstep-ish

#

Guitar sounds weird but it's programmed so it makes sense

finite finch
#

Is the guitar tone good?

formal hedge
#

Not terrible

#

What are you using

finite finch
#

Thallamp

formal hedge
#

Honestly I would recommend trying something else

#

Thall Amp is weird sounding most times

finite finch
#

Most amps are very cpu intensove tho

#

Intensive*

formal hedge
#

Some of the LePou amps can sound kinda iffy though

finite finch
#

One instance of nam is 60% my cpu iirc

formal hedge
finite finch
#

Im cooked, fl studio

runic adder
#

Vro 🥀

formal hedge
runic adder
#

Use reaper

#

It’s infinitely lighter than like most other daws

finite finch
#

Yes but i dont get how to use reaper at all

formal hedge
formal hedge
#

Also recommend stuff from Reaper Mania

cerulean storm
cerulean storm
formal hedge
finite finch
#

How much did it take u guys to learn it

formal hedge
#

Like a week

#

Where as FL took me a year

cerulean storm
#

Idk, I don't really think you ever stop learning.

vale vapor
#

It is "ai"

#

It's machine learning

#

Not the same thing as generative ai

#

Also not the same thing as an LLM

formal hedge
#

OK that makes sense

vale vapor
#

NAM uses machine learning to "learn" the distortion characteristics of an amp

#

Then applies that to a preset you can load

formal hedge
#

The fact that tone3000 just says "uses AI" makes it very unclear

vale vapor
#

There weren't any rumors that NAM is ai, because it "is"

cerulean storm
#

What is NAM?

vale vapor
vale vapor
formal hedge
vale vapor
#

Free machine learning amp vst

cerulean storm
#

I see

vale vapor
#

Makes 1:1 clones of real life amps that users capture of their own amps

cerulean storm
#

I use Gojira X

vale vapor
#

Its got nothin on NDSP amps

formal hedge
vale vapor
#

You're just parroting literally eveything i told you

cerulean storm
formal hedge
vale vapor
cerulean storm
#

What kit_duh

vale vapor
#

Amps are not tied to a specific style of music for the most part, you can use any amp in any music

#

It's totally up to you

balmy forum
cerulean storm
formal hedge
balmy forum
#

i dont recomend ndsp

balmy forum
formal hedge
vale vapor
formal hedge
balmy forum
#

it also just started crashing now

#

so

cerulean storm
#

Btw I sent some songs earlier that I'd like to get some feedback on. I'm always left unsatisfied with my mixes.

balmy forum
cerulean storm
#

Why

balmy forum
#

its just

#

bad

cerulean storm
#

Well, I like it

balmy forum
#

unless you use a different cab it just sounds bad

cerulean storm
#

You got any other ones that's better?

formal hedge
#

Lemme find the message real quick

vale vapor
#

Use whatever you want!

formal hedge
vale vapor
#

I always talk about NAM and LePou so they have picked it up and that's all they talk about 🙃

cerulean storm
#

I see

vale vapor
#

I will always vouch for those over NDSP amps but you can use whatever you want

#

No reason to switch if you aren't having issues

formal hedge
cerulean storm
#

Yeah, there's probably many better alternatives out there. I just don't have the budget for a bunch of plugins right now.

vale vapor
#

Oh, leppu and nam are free

cerulean storm
#

Oh really

vale vapor
#

I only use free plugins for guitar and bass tones

#

Yes

cerulean storm
#

Yeah I have a free bass plugin too

vale vapor
#

SoftAmp PSA and BOD paired are amazing

#

With some compression and EQ it can sound incredible

#

The Growler is alright but more on the rocky side

cerulean storm
#

I have BOD, and some other thing I don't remember the name of😭

formal hedge
cerulean storm
vale vapor
#

It's alright but its more rocky, it can sound good if you pair it with another and split the frequencies

formal hedge
cerulean storm
#

Yeah

formal hedge
#

Just hot mode is enough distortion

#

I use BASS TR from audio assault paired with EQ and MMS S-Drive

cerulean storm
formal hedge
#

(I use pro-q 4 but any eq is fine)

cerulean storm
vale vapor
#

You don't need pro q

#

Just use TDR nova or Fruity Parametric II

#

parametric 2 is genuinely so good

#

On par with pro Q

balmy forum
#

over priced asf, how did you even get it?

formal hedge
#

Lmao

balmy forum
formal hedge
cerulean storm
balmy forum
vale vapor
balmy forum
#

or have you side chained the guitars

cerulean storm
formal hedge
#

Turn down chorus if it's on

balmy forum
cerulean storm
#

Yeah. -3

balmy forum
#

then ease off the treshhold, see if that fixes it

cerulean storm
#

I actually have a limiter on pretty much everything cause the mixes always get so quiet otherwise

vale vapor
#

Turn up everything until it's loud, but not clipping

#

Use less limiters, more slight compression

formal hedge
vale vapor
#

For busses, use light compressors

formal hedge
#

Kick is also weird sounding

#

Guitar tone is slightly off

#

Not bad but a lil off

cerulean storm
#

How do you mean?

#

Lead or rhythm?

formal hedge
#

Just do a high shelf on eq

cerulean storm
#

I've been trying to get the leads less "harsh" but if I cut away those frequencies they become very obscured

formal hedge
vale vapor
#

Do NOT saturate your guitar tone

#

Horrible advice

#

The amp is enough distortion

cerulean storm
#

I don't even know what that means😭

vale vapor
#

I would try a light EQ cut on the high end

#

But only the offending frequencies

finite finch
#

Thoughts?

#

I feel like the guitar tone needs more mids i scooped it too much

formal hedge
#

It makes it thin in a full mix

cerulean storm
cerulean storm
versed remnant
#

I need to bring back those rythyms guitars holy shit

#

hopefully this is a tad better

versed remnant
vale vapor
#

sounds like everything is being slammed into a limiter or compressor

#

drums are small sounding and narrow

#

overheads are also too loud

vale vapor
#

it just sounds mushy, washy, and bad

#

even perfectly aligned guitars just sound really watery and lack punch and impact

#

if you want a thick wall of guitar, just do regular 100% Left and 100% Right guitar, with a GOOD tone

#

quad guitars also have a lot of phase problems

#

Just double track each part like normal

wraith hare
#

Facts

balmy forum
#

kick is very bassy and sounds like a ice cream tub

inland anchor
#

Some wewowewo stuff

cerulean storm
#

I use limiters to make my plugins louder since as soon as I try to just turn up the volume they start clipping. Idk how to do it other than using limiters

vale vapor
#

Now frightbox likes to go a little overboard with dynamics, personally i like to push mine a little harder than him, but it's up to personal taste

cerulean storm
#

What exactly is a drum submix?

#

This is my drums

vale vapor
#

A submix is a bus, or in reaper, a folder track

#

So it'd be the parent folder of all your drums

#

That looks to be "drums master"

#

Channel 44

cerulean storm
#

Oh, yeah I understand

vale vapor
#

I assume all your drums audio is going through that channel

cerulean storm
#

Yes

cerulean storm
#

Not the individual tracks?

vale vapor
#

Pretty much

#

Your tracks should be loud, but not clipping

cerulean storm
#

Yeah, it's just that almost as soon as I turn the tracks up just a little bit they start clipping

#

Idk how to prevent them from doing that without limiters

vale vapor
#

What do you mean by a little bit

cerulean storm
#

Like maybe +2-3db

vale vapor
#

Oh😭 twin that's the problem

#

You don't ever need to boost them above 0

cerulean storm
#

OOOOOOOOH

vale vapor
#

0 is not a low volume, 0 is whats called "unity" aka LOUD

#

The faders go down to negative infinity

#

0 is not quiet

cerulean storm
#

DAMIT 😭

#

How did I not know

#

Me stupid

vale vapor
#

You should learn more basics of daws and audio LOL

cerulean storm
#

Yeah

#

I just have no one that could teach me so I had to try on my own

vale vapor
#

You should watch frightbox's videos, he's the best honestly

#

Good for beginners

cerulean storm
#

But should I still have a limiter on my master track? I've had one set to -3db since idk how long on every song

#

I don't have that Ozone plugin he has

runic adder
#

Limiter on the master is typically during the mastering process but yes

#

Honestly in the mixing phase you should have your tracks be p quiet actually

cerulean storm
#

Hm, interesting

runic adder
#

I typically set my loudest element, usually kick or snare, to -10db and mix around there

#

Loudness comes from mastering

cerulean storm
#

I see

#

Wish someone told me that a year ago😭 💀

runic adder
#

Damn

cerulean storm
runic adder
#

Sometimes, sometimes not

#

Sometimes I’ll set the drum bus to -10, sometimes it’ll be the individual drums I mess with

#

More often than not though I mess with the individual drum tracks

cerulean storm
#

How should I set a compressor on the master track?

#

I guess the stock plugin in Reaper is fine?

vale vapor
#

The ceiling at -3?

#

Ceiling usually should be at -0.1

vale vapor
vale vapor
#

I think -10 is a bit excessive but its personal preference

runic adder
#

the limiter on the mmaster is gonna bring it up anyway lol

#

i'd rathe the headroom so I can blow the mix out with a classic deathcore 808

cerulean storm
runic adder
#

i typically set it to -0.2 lol

cerulean storm
#

Really

#

Doesn't it get really quiet?

runic adder
#

no

cerulean storm
#

What other plugins do you use in the master?

runic adder
#

unless I deliberately try to go loud as fuck

runic adder
cerulean storm
#

Okay. I'm sorry but I don't know what a saturation, mb compression or vanity is😭 🙏

cerulean storm
runic adder
#

reaper has like everything

#

there's an expansion pack for reaper plugins somewhere, i might be able to find it

#

anyway though

cerulean storm
#

I think I might already have it

runic adder
# cerulean storm Don't know if Reaper has something like that

saturation is a very common plugin/technique, adding harmonics on certain frequencies (quite literally saturating it with more harmonics, @halcyon holly could explain it better than I)
mb compression is short for multiband compression, essentially the love child of an eq and a compressor. You compress certain frequencies instead of the entire mix
vanity eq is just my name for it, I slap an eq with a spectrum analyzer (something like pro-q3 or reaper's stock EQ) and literally don't touch it at all. I call it vanity because all I do is look at it to gauge the mix

cerulean storm
#

Does Reaper have something i can do mb compression with or is there something free I can use?

fathom jewel
#

reaXcomp

vale vapor
#

Screw intersanple peaking

vale vapor
#

Tdr nova is amazing, its an EQ + MB comp

#

TDR nova and ReaComp are easily my most used plugins

#

You can get a pretty great mix using only those two plugins

#

If i had to choose 2 plugins to keep and lose everything else, it'd be those two

cerulean storm
#

Thanks!

#

Any specific frequensies that are typically good to focus on for mb comp?

vale vapor
#

Literally any frequency that is awkward/causing issues

#

On rhythm guitar i almost always have a dynamic shelf at 150hz and below, which helps palm mutes not sound as boomy and muddy

#

Multiband comp aka dynamic EQ is just for taming frequencies that keep coming up, but aren't always present

#

so it listens for the offending frequency and turns it down whenever it goes above a certain set threshold

#

Just don't overdo it

#

You generally don't need to cut or boost a whole ton

#

Just slight sound shaping

cerulean storm
runic adder
#

Idk where the original is so I can’t A/B it but this sounds good

cerulean storm
#

Thanks! Finally I'm doing something right

versed remnant
#

okay last audio file didnt work so hopefully this one does

#

Okay i NEED my drums to rout to a bus

#

Bc wtf is is going on

#

I need to knock the low end a bit

#

And turn them down overall

#

And to turn up that snare

#

That shit is NOT hitting

#

idk ab the snare tho

#

im so bad at snare processing

#

@tribal orbit @vale vapor could either of you maybe slide some advice about snare processing

#

Like an exact chain

#

I’m so bad at it

#

It doesn’t hit

#

And it sounds so blocky

#

I feel like

#

I’m also just realizing i think i forgot to turn off the cab in my amp sim

#

For the heavy guitars

#

So i think i’m double cabbing

#

So i’ll change that when i go back downstairs

vale vapor
#

Or a processed one

versed remnant
#

Some processing but not a lot but all i even have going on is eq cutting some frequencies that were pissing me off

#

And some comp and gating

vale vapor
#

Literally all you need (usually!!) Is corrective EQ, cut out frequencies below 180 with a lowcut, compress a fair amount, possibly eq a little more, and that's pretty much it

#

Make sure you are USING ROOM MICS because room mics are the MOST important part of the snare

vale vapor
versed remnant
#

Like 3~ db a piece

#

Give or take

#

They’re all in the like 200-600 range

#

Right above the body

#

I feel like thats probably whats making it sound boxy

versed remnant
#

I think i’ll try and turn up the room a bit more too

#

I feel like thats probably taking a lot of thr chsrscter and why its not hitting as hard as i want it to

halcyon holly
# versed remnant drums SHOULD be a tad better

Great close mic tone, maybe lacking a bit of body. Sounds like you've removed far too much in the midrange of the snare. Also add back some upper mids and lower treble. What is missing here though is room mics

#

I always like to use the analogy: what is a snare sound without a room mic? it's a piece of wood (stick) hitting another piece of wood (shell), and thats exactly what this sounds like. Your snare sounds like a piece of wood hitting another piece of wood

#

The solution is really easy. Room mics, overhead mics and reverb.

#

Overhead mics capture the close reaction in the room from the snare, the room mics capture the ambience and room's reaction to the snare, and the reverb is an effect layer

vale vapor
#

Yep

#

Spot on as usual ross

halcyon holly
versed remnant
#

Is what i understand from that

#

I do also wanna say i mix using a shitty $100 keyboard as my speaker and a like $20 pair of headphones that sound like shit

runic adder
#

keyboard = speaker?

balmy forum
#

@vale vapor https://youtu.be/JgO4cfPzn64?si=yXcWKFNyH-T4SDIh what do you think of this mix

New Album 'A Quiet and Harmless Living' out now: https://mattmaeson.lnk.to/albumID
Matt Maeson on Tour: https://mattmaeson.lnk.to/TourID

Video filmed and edited by Gabe Garcia.

Follow Matt Maeson:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mattmaeson/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/mattmaeson
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mattmaeson/
Soundcloud: ...

▶ Play video
#

i want to make somthing like it but i dont know how to get that sound

versed remnant
#

And i can’t afford monitors

#

My bank acc is still -$50

runic adder
#

i see

versed remnant
#

Yeah..!

#

I know people say gear dlesn’t matter but in my situation i fear it may be time for an upgradr

versed remnant
#

Yeahhh

balmy forum
#

you dont need a $100000000000 SSL

versed remnant
#

I just need speakers that have more than just bass

balmy forum
#

but you def need at least a decent setup

versed remnant
#

And a computer upgradr bc my shit gets freezy

balmy forum
#

i think im just only gonna use cla mix hub

#

prevent overprocessing

vale vapor
#

Not my style of music

balmy forum
#

before you say its distorted as fuck

#

i know

#

lol

finite finch
#

so

#

how do i fix latency issues in reaper

balmy forum
finite finch
#

ill try it out

fathom jewel
# balmy forum tried to cover it

ah yes, the smashed super clippy drums

im way too familiar with this drum sound, it's honestly a recurring mistake I still kinda make without even realising

#

it's the bonk sound on the snare after boosting the fundamental on the entire snare bus (including all the mics snare top, snare btm, snr room, snr mono overhead or whatever else), I only boost it on the snr top mic, and brighthen up the snr room track so that it doesn't muddy up the mix, I blend the snr bottom track very subtlely only if absolutely necessary.

when the snare bottom track piles up in the room mic snare wire track, it clips and sounds ugly, the additional clipping or limiting on the drum bus just amplifies that sound

#

usually all the shells and cymbals go to one room track, but routing them in a way that separates cymbals and shells with nothing bleeding into each other, gives more control to your drum sound and overall mix

#

spending more time on routing is so worth it, saving it as a project template in both reaper and the outputs within kontakt to use for later helps a lot

young shore
finite finch
#

thoughts?

#

argent metal esque thing

halcyon holly
#

Also i'll say it again, for £20 you can get IEMs that compete with like...£200-300 closed back headphones

#

So at that price range go IEMs, not headphones

worthy sail
#

i switched to reaper and learnt some mix stuff, any tips on changing this rn would be really appreciated. Also how do i actually make well written drums? i feel like mine suck

livid frigate
finite finch
finite coral
blissful cliff
timber forum
finite coral
#

drums sound very raw and that sub drop at 46 sec is so loud

timber forum
#

That was kinda the point. Going for an older Deathcore sound. I miss the 09 bass drops that contort the mix lmao. I’ll turn it down

#

Idk what else to do with the drums . I have like 5 different plug ins attached to it

finite coral
finite finch
#

I mean the sub drops that distort the shit off the mix

timber forum
#

Yeah! Couple newer revival bands are going crazy with them. Especially psycho frame.

runic adder
#

I need to drop a massive 808 lowk

#

I’ve got a revival song or two cookin up and that’s the piece that was missing

#

Thanks for reminding me

timber forum
#

Yeah I heard yours in the chats it’s very good. Mines very mid compared lol

#

@runic adder

runic adder
#

I mean yeah in this case it’s more of a difference in experience

runic adder
timber forum
runic adder
#

I mean a lot of that comes from the base tone itself, if it’s too scooped or too much high end is there it’ll sound thin

timber forum
#

I felt like the bass was being super muddy

runic adder
#

As for the bass thing, I’ll have to relisten when I get home cuz I’m wearing my workout buds rn, but yeah idk if I heard it

timber forum
#

This is why I stopped writing cause I got really discouraged lol, no matter what I did I could never get the right sound

#

Also don’t have the best plugins. Just bias fx 2 .. use to have the slate digital all access pass which was awesome but it got too pricey for me

runic adder
#

It happens

#

I think the whole “can’t get the right sound” thing happens to everyone, at least I get stuck there a lot too lol

#

You don’t need the best plugins

timber forum
#

Fair enough .. I think my biggest issue is learning a EQ lol

#

I feel like that would fix a good chunk of the sound at least

runic adder
#

You can do a lot with free shit, Reaper’s stock plugins and the free expansion, ffree plugins like analog obsession, you can get super far with all that

#

Learning eq def will get you far, learn the tools you’ll be using and you can make do with whatever you have

#

It’s more important to know what you’re doing than having all the high end equipment

timber forum
#

Thanks for the insight. No matter how many videos I watch it’s always “just use this eq from (insert expensive brand)” .. like bruh I just wanna learn how the frequencies work haha

runic adder
#

Yeah nah lol

#

I get it

#

But the principles behind most of it is the same

timber forum
#

Thanks dude

runic adder
#

Yah

#

If I can find specific examples I can point out I will, but for now all I got is vague statements unfortunately

timber forum
#

Understandable, imma gonna keep pushing and not give up this time. I feel I have a little potential and that is enough this time haha

runic adder
#

That’s the spirit

#

I’d recommend these for free gear

timber forum
#

Hell yeah

vale vapor
runic adder
#

is it an issue?

#

i just assumed bandlab is like web browser garageband

balmy forum
#

and did you use AI for the vocals?

runic adder
#

so much hate on buster drums 😭

balmy forum
#

i know, imo it just sounds fake and over used

finite coral
balmy forum
#

programed?

finite coral
#

no just vocal stems

balmy forum
#

huh ok

finite coral
formal hedge
#

Pertty much everyone in the server uses it

formal hedge
balmy forum
#

becuase its not true

formal hedge
#

I don't understand that idea

finite coral
#

well its true for fl studio versions

formal hedge
#

I can make the same song in three diferent daws and you wouldn't know which is which

finite coral
#

sound engine is different

formal hedge
balmy forum
finite coral
#

yeah

formal hedge
#

I know they have different plugins and such but not really

finite coral
#

mostly matters for 1 to 1 remakes

balmy forum
#

yeah but thats not gonna effect the export sound or quality

balmy igloo
#

44k vs 48k

finite coral
#

44.1 always

vale vapor
finite coral
#

i didnt say it makes an audible difference

#

i said theres a difference 🤓

vale vapor
#

😭

#

This guy

finite coral
balmy forum
#

audible gasp im not the one getting clowned on by xenon

vale vapor
# runic adder is it an issue?

Yes; no external vst support, even someone incredibly good at any daw would struggle to properly make a good mix in bandlab

runic adder
#

fair

#

but from bandlab it's not hard to pivot to cakewalk, so ill give it that

#

same company and free

balmy forum
vale vapor
#

Yeah if you're trying to make metal you aren't gonna have a good time with either

balmy forum
#

true lol

balmy igloo
#

really want to see somebody make metal in openmpt

halcyon holly
#

I mean maybe not the best mix

#

but the tone is there

balmy forum
halcyon holly
#

There's been a few i've met. Problem is the tools in ableton aren't always the best choice for our genre

vale vapor
#

Yeah, i keep saying that

halcyon holly
#

Like you really want a traditional mixer for metal

balmy forum
halcyon holly
#

I've spent about 5 hours in ableton trying to figure out wtf it's "workflow" actually is

#

lol

#

I mean usually within the first 30 mins of a daw you can figure it out, but it's pretty different from everything i've ever used

#

clearly live / electronic / sound design based

#

which is fantastic

#

(and can be fantastic for metal, too)

formal hedge
#

This guy does

#

He's in the band structures

balmy forum
#

yeah, its works for everything, i would be using reaper but ive already donated them my liver and im too deep to switch now

formal hedge
balmy igloo
halcyon holly
#

and it freaks people out

#

For metal? i wouldn't personally use it

#

and i mean like - me, personally

#

not like i don't reccomend it

#

if it works for you for metal, use it

#

hell, mick gordon uses fl studio

#

idk how he does that, mental guy

balmy forum
balmy igloo
#

good ol micky g

vale vapor
#

I've seen some of his talks and he says he likes to use multiple daws for different reasons

#

Sometimes daisy chaining them

timber forum
#

Btw guys I’m not using BandLab! I’m using reaper, just use BandLab to share things cause it’s easiest for me.. everyone that said the drum tone was decent THANK YOU. I’m doing my best with what little knowledge I have

balmy forum
#

.

#

😂

halcyon holly
#

i believe he uses fl mainly

#

and pro tools for mixing

#

or atleast thats the last i heard of it

balmy forum
timber forum
#

Are there any free IRs I should be getting?

formal hedge
#

This one is great in particular but since XENON doesn't like when we agree on things, many amp Sims include decent IRs within them

#

@timber forum

timber forum
#

Gotcha thanks

formal hedge
balmy forum
#

xenon gave me this one i love it

formal hedge
#

You can get some at tone3000, the official website for sharing IRs/NAM Profiles

vale vapor
#

LOL

vale vapor
#

The more downloads, the more popular they are

#

And that usually means they're better

balmy forum
vale vapor
#

Yeah but some captures kinda suck cause someome did them wrong

#

More downloads = higher chance that it's a good, well made IR

balmy forum
#

how do you capture anyway

vale vapor
#

download their free program and send it audio through an amp of your choice

#

Or a cab

#

And it'll capture it

timber forum
#

You guys are awesome, sorry for so many questions

balmy forum
formal hedge
balmy forum
timber forum
#

Imma try my luck tonight with a new IR and re-track the guitars. Taking a lot of considerations from you guys and from fright on yt

vale vapor
#

Frightbox is amazing

formal hedge
balmy forum
formal hedge
balmy forum
#

its a really good starting point

timber forum
#

Thoughts on amped roots? I know it’s old just checking

formal hedge
timber forum
#

Bettttt

formal hedge
#

Top 3 free amp sims

timber forum
#

What would be your other 2?

balmy forum
formal hedge
vale vapor
#

NAM U

balmy forum
vale vapor
#

Neural amp modeler universal

#

Has some great captures

timber forum
#

Never heard of those. Excited to try them

balmy forum
#

i also made a free 5150 model that i edited a bit if you want it

timber forum
#

I’m not supposed!

#

I think I still have ninja installed from a couple years back

formal hedge
balmy forum
formal hedge
# balmy forum

Oh it's a vst, I assumed we were dealing with HTML again

balmy forum
# formal hedge Never heard of Ninja, you mind sending an example of what it sounds like?

This tone is too good to be free. Using the NaLex Ninja Amp Sim with MLSoundLab IRs and/or GGD Zilla Studio Cab IRs is absolutely UNREAL.

🔊 SPOTIFY: https://spoti.fi/3g1ALht
🔊 BANDCAMP: https://bit.ly/3g1AdYX
▶️ Everything Else: https://bit.ly/3yBFDk2

🎉 PATREON (Tabs/Stems/DIs/Tones): https://www.patreon.com/keyanhoushman...
...

▶ Play video
timber forum
balmy forum
#
  • fuzz and od pedal
formal hedge
#

A .vst3 is a plugin

timber forum
#

Don’t know how I didn’t see that lol

formal hedge
balmy forum
balmy forum
timber forum
#

With the tone3000 files, do they only work with nam or anything?

balmy forum
#

nah just any ir loader

#

nam is just reeeally good

#

nam UNIVERSAL

#

NOT nam

#

be carful hahaha

timber forum
#

lol glad you said that

#

What’s with the other one? Lol

balmy forum
#

its just more annoying to use

timber forum
#

Ahhh

balmy forum
#

bad ui and not as much customisability

balmy forum
#

wtf happened to the verse?

timber forum
#

That sounds great !

balmy forum
#

and why is it clipping wtf

finite finch
formal hedge
#

I've thought this about several of your mixes

#

If that's what you're going for you're going for it's fine, but if not you need to take a major step back lol

#

No offense

vale vapor
#

I don't want to point fingers or be demeaning at all

formal hedge
#

Yeah that could come off a little rude tbh

vale vapor
#

Just genuinely i think you need more experience

#

For the amount of advice you give out

balmy forum
balmy forum
#

jesus spelling

timber forum
#

Anyone on?

#

Is this better?

runic adder
#

Much

fathom jewel
timber forum
#

Okay newest mix here. Amped roots with new IR I found on tone 3000. No more clipping. Guitars now have dedicated DI tracks with a sub bus. Very minimal eq and compression throughout all tracks. Simplified mix using tips from frightbox. Let me know if it’s better please 🥹

balmy forum
formal hedge
balmy forum
#

i wouldnt say that

#

yeah the bass is loud

#

doesnt mean the guitars are inaudible -_-

timber forum
#

Didn’t have much time before work but turned them up a little and added a little bit of high end, low mids were already ducked but I did a little more. Might be worse now but all I had time for lol

balmy forum
#

it has the potential

timber forum
#

Yeah when I get home later!

#

Could be the guitar tone itself . I copied someone’s off YouTube cause it sounded good there. But once on here it’s nothing like it. Need to mess around with amp and mic on cab maybe?

balmy forum
#

there is one thing that every one needs to learn

timber forum
#

Okay okay lol

balmy forum
#

you are going to be better if you find who you are and how you write, find your style and it will lead to better songs

#

trying to copy someone else will only ever get you half way there

timber forum
#

Yeah true. I just need to learn a little more. I did it more for just a base line. I was initially looking for an older Deathcore tone but any videos out now days is just the modern metal sounds

#

Only reason I used my own cab instead of what they were using

balmy forum
#

thats what happened to me!

timber forum
#

Yeah lol

#

On a side note, is this at least better than the first one I sent? I’m just looking for little wins at this point hahaha

balmy forum
#

hmm, i beleve that the new tone is a lot better and its a lot better balenced

timber forum
#

Don’t be sorry bro you are helping me lmao

#

Cool cool, u didn’t virtually everything wrong on the first one. This one seems to have more potential for fine tuning and eq

vale vapor
balmy forum
runic adder
#

10 years ago i was writing shitty thrash metal lol

timber forum
#

okay.. now better? lol

balmy forum
timber forum
#

yay

balmy forum
#

thats a really good mix bro, would recomend turning up your drum room and bass as well c:

timber forum
#

hell yeah dude.. thanks to your help man

#

do i need to map individual midi drums?

#

or just turn up room as a whole

balmy forum
timber forum
#

nope lol

#

i got overwhelmed

balmy forum
#

ah, big issue

#

what drum kit do you use?

timber forum
#

ggd invasion

balmy forum
#

yeah definatly need to multi frouft

#

and i need spelling lessons

#

jesus

timber forum
#

lmao

balmy forum
#

do this!

timber forum
#

bettttttt

#

betterr question too.. where does the song go from here lmao

balmy forum
#

wdym?

timber forum
#

now i have tone right, i need to actually have more ideas

#

well i have intro and breakdown lmao

balmy forum
#

lol, try a chorus

#

also can i have the stems?

timber forum
#

problem is this type of deathcore dont really do choruses

#

or maybe i can to be different

#

how do i send you just the stems

balmy forum
#

reaper right?

timber forum
#

yes

balmy forum
#

do this for the drum midi

timber forum
#

sweet

balmy forum
timber forum
#

trying to figure out how to send

balmy forum
timber forum
#

can you dm me your email?

vale vapor
#

Aka a hook

#

Its just a repeating part that's catchy

balmy forum
#

hahaha @vale vapor i just got lepou legion

#

this is so good

vale vapor
#

I'm sayin

#

Especially with a good IR

balmy forum
vale vapor
#

Xenon type tone

#

Needs a tube screamer before the amp tho

balmy forum
#

it has one

timber forum
#

@vale vapor whatcha think of the new tone?

balmy forum
#

xenon would be proud

timber forum
#

able to get a couple more riffs down just for ideas. not where they are going to go probably. love that my guitar sounds halfway decent now lol

formal hedge
formal hedge
timber forum
#

Thanks dude! Agreed!

balmy forum
#

you sound likke the slogan to fivverr rn

sharp mountain
timber forum
#

sounds good dude

sharp mountain
#

also thank yall for those comments about the mix ^^

balmy forum
sharp mountain
#

yeah, but its after the clipper so i dont believe its doing anything

#

at least, since it doesnt have any peaks to deal with

balmy forum
#

Limiter always last

sharp mountain
#

mhmm, thats how i have it on my chain (i should have specified that earlier)

balmy forum
#

Are you using a master compressor

sharp mountain
#

yeah, at the very start of the chain

#

3:1, 240 ms attack, 320 ms release, but checking it rn, it isnt really applying any gain reduction

balmy forum
#

add a little

#

look for 0.5-2db of GR and the limiters attenuation only shaving of the top

sharp mountain
#

okay yeah that improves the sound a bit

it does naturally lower the loudness a bit, and adjusting the input gain in my clipper does bring back some distortion, but it is lesser than before

#

either way thank you sm ^^

balmy forum
#

No problem c:

timber forum
balmy forum
balmy forum
timber forum
#

No, I’m still trying to get guitar right first. I shouldn’t have asked how the mix was, more like how are the levels and guitar lol

runic adder
#

Still a mix question, so you’re right

#

Hold on I’ll listen in a minute

#

Nvm it’s not letting me listen to it on mobile

timber forum
#

Yeah my biggest thing right now is volumes and guitar tone. Once I finish a rough draft of the full song I’ll go back in and start tackling things one by one

runic adder
#

The balance is good yea

#

Same w guitars

#

Good job 👍🏽

timber forum
#

Sweeeeet

finite finch
#

another sketch using @balmy forum amp

#

the song is supposed to sound raw and dry like 2000s metalcore btw

balmy forum
vale vapor
vale vapor
# finite finch

kick is too loud and has too much sub, guitar sounds okay for it being midi, has a little too much mids

finite finch
vale vapor
#

just turn your mids down

#

in the amp

timber forum
potent depot
#

Hey all. Just made a new demo on my new setup. Would like some feeback

real harness
#

Guys, I wrote a thing, which Im suspiciously proud of. For some reason Im enjoying the mixing of it, which i conducted, a bit too much, especially the heavy ending. I might be delusional, so please tell me of I am.

timber forum
balmy forum
potent depot
balmy forum
potent depot
#

Ml drums

balmy forum
#

ah, search up how to multi rout them

potent depot
#

When I parallel compress I blend the two busses

balmy forum
#

ok cool. watch some videos on drum mixing

vale vapor
#

Frightbox >>>

#

@balmy forum resend that frightbox video i always send

vale vapor
#

The drum mixing one

#

I sent it to you a while ago

balmy forum
#

i dont remember lol

real harness
balmy forum
#

i like it

#

oh jesus i just got to the blast beats

real harness
real harness
#

But thx

#

Weird music is cool music

#

Usually

#

Imo

fathom jewel
versed remnant
#

My drum bus is clipping pretty bad i feel like

versed remnant
#

I think i shoudl turn up the drums

#

At least the kick and snare

halcyon holly
#

kick is far too loud

#

and clicky

#

Is this drums of destruction?

versed remnant
#

Dude how did you know that

#

Yeah

halcyon holly
#

nah it's a very easily recognisable drumkit

versed remnant
halcyon holly
#

You just gotta work on balance, nothing much else to say here. rhythms are low in the mix, leads are high in the mix, snare is too quiet, cymbals are too high in the mix

#

Rhythms are still getting buried behind leads, kicks and cymbals here

#

Bring it right back to the fundamentals. Contrast between your song and another person's

versed remnant
#

should i boost the mids some more bc i have a like 2db cut on the rythym bus in the mids

#

brought the cymbals and leads down, rythym up, and turned up the snare

#

Okay the lead needs to be just a tad louder i think

hollow tulip
#

unfashionably late but touhou mentioned!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

potent depot
hollow tulip
#

some parts are giving Chimata Tenkyuu's theme. gotta love that ZUNpet 👍 👍

it's looking promising, I don't think I have any qualms for the mixing of the drums, guitars, and bass
but yeah the delay piano part near the end does need some adjustments considering it somewhat overpowers the rest of the instruments

hollow tulip
# versed remnant

IMO the rhythm guitar and bass' volumes should also be a tad bit higher as to not let it get too buried by the lead guitar and drums

#

otherwise, nice

#

recovered from the writer's block here's hoping it doesn't relapse
short wip of fusing metal and artcore (the kind you usually hear in rhythm games)

sullen vector
sullen vector
#

ive actually made a ton of stuff using the touhou soundfont but a lot of the time the actual composition doesnt really take inspo from the game so it ends up sounding wack

#

(im kind of a touhou larper so please forgive me)

hollow tulip
#

that's what happened to me

sullen vector
sullen vector
hollow tulip
hollow tulip
hollow tulip
#

i'm probably gonna make a remake of this idk

versed remnant