#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 645 of 1

stray void
#

Sonny Forelli?

mental furnace
#

I'll finish the game with it

stray void
#

Who's sonny

#

Ohhh

mental furnace
#

Every time I'm riding with him I admire everything

#

Also an npc said smth like

#

Ugh show me smth else

mental furnace
stray void
#

I think they got that idea from the classic western film "A Fistful of Dollars"

stray void
#

Dollars. Muneh

mental furnace
#

I did too

stray void
#

Same

mental furnace
#

Well

#

They're married

#

So

stray void
#

They must've made jack somehow

mental furnace
stray void
#

Those stories you hear are bullshit fan made myths

mental furnace
#

They look smh ffs

#

The mustache

#

Dang it

stray void
#

That evidence isn't good

mental furnace
#

It's 5am I won't be looking for more proof rn

#

What

hidden moss
#

javiers hot

open furnace
#

its a good thing that rockstar looked out for us white arabian users

#

so that it can respawn again at ake isabella

mental furnace
#

Too many users get more original

open furnace
mental furnace
#

Just bc it's fast it doesn't mean it's good

#

There are so many good horses

#

Arabians look like donkeys

stray void
#

Arabians are very pretty

mental furnace
#

Too small.

stray void
#

Big chunky horses look bad

#

A horse is meant to be small,light,and fast

hazy nacelle
#

Tennessee Walker best horse

torn sage
#

Literally the worst

hazy nacelle
#

True

mental furnace
#

They need strong fast war horses

#

Standardbred

open furnace
stray void
#

1.Arabian
2.Nokota
3.Appaloosa
No debating about this

mental furnace
#

Or thoroughbred

stray void
mental furnace
mental furnace
#

I'm just saying that they need horses that don't get too scared

#

And since almost all Arabians are taken from the wild

stray void
#

Just because something is liked by everyone doesn't mean it's bad

#

Even in real life,Arabian horses are valued more than any other horse

mental furnace
#

All I'm saying is that people should try smth more different than the best thing in game

#

It's just boring

open furnace
bold pagoda
mental furnace
hazy nacelle
#

It’s nice to not have to look at the same horse for hours upon hours so I would always switch horses each chapter.

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

I wish I did the veteran guy missions after chapter 6 so I could keep Buell.

#

great horse

hazy nacelle
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

in my current playthrough I've been through like 4 horses

open furnace
#

ive been through about 4 horses

#

ive used white arabian twice

keen birchBOT
bold pagoda
#

I had the black arabian you can get from saint denis (I think) for a while and then I stabled it for some other horse

hazy nacelle
#

Same

bold pagoda
open furnace
#

dont understand why youre basic for using the best horse option

torn sage
#

Missouri Fox Trotter is the best horse

bold pagoda
#

one time I got a horse killed because the idiot fell off a cliff while I was robbing a train

#

didn't even realize until it was too late

open furnace
hazy nacelle
#

I have killed several horses by being on my phone while playing and riding off a cliff.

open furnace
bold pagoda
bold pagoda
open furnace
#

my white arabian has saved its skin multiple times by stopping right before jumping off the cliff\

hazy nacelle
bold pagoda
#

lmao

open furnace
hazy nacelle
#

Unfortunate

torn sage
bold pagoda
#

horse: he never feeds me, I have 69 needles in my ass, and the pinkertons are after us. I've had enough runs off cliff

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

oh believe me, I do too, and the NPC's make sure to remind me how good of a job I do

open furnace
hazy nacelle
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

"it'll be whatever I goddamn want it to be"

torn sage
hazy nacelle
#

My source tells me otherwise

bold pagoda
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

too busy bullying micah

open furnace
#

i hate how we cant just kill him before greeting him in the camp in chapter 6 and get the good ending

bold pagoda
#

I also like to think that the horse likes the wild stuff instead of the stale, 2 year old hay that the guy from the stable has been trying to sell forever

hazy nacelle
bold pagoda
#

I'm addicted to the cigarette cards. I have no money left because of them.

open furnace
hazy nacelle
bold pagoda
open furnace
#

i dont need more canned pineapplesw

bold pagoda
#

after the epilogue I shot jack and never looked back

#

just ran

hazy nacelle
#

We are all addicted to canned pineapples

bold pagoda
#

you need a couple of mods

torn sage
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

rampage trainer and kill children

open furnace
#

what

bold pagoda
#

if you don't mind me sending you the links in dms I will

open furnace
#

under what option

#

i already have rampage

hazy nacelle
bold pagoda
#

that way you too can kill children

torn sage
hazy nacelle
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

once in game with rampage and kill children, you go to rampage>spawner>humans>cutscene>jackmarston

#

I have a lot of pictures of jacks that are actively on fire and already burnt

open furnace
#

i cant wait for rdr3 where jack marston gets lumbago

bold pagoda
torn sage
open furnace
bold pagoda
open furnace
bold pagoda
#

but thats boring

torn sage
bold pagoda
#

doing it the thicc boah morgan way is better

torn sage
hazy nacelle
#

You gotta slaughter the squirrel population out of rage because you can’t get a god damn snake to spawn.

open furnace
#

when poor bison pelt

bold pagoda
#

only do it until the game starts taking honor away

open furnace
#

also i just realised that every animal in beechers hope is 3 stars

hazy nacelle
#

$$$

bold pagoda
#

john good rancher confirmed?

torn sage
#

Without hacks

open furnace
#

get that infinite money

hazy nacelle
#

To buy canned pineapples

open furnace
#

just reload save and they all respawn back

torn sage
#

There’s also a glitch to get into new Austin to also get the legendary animals without hacks

#

As Arthur

hazy nacelle
#

Is it the graveyard mission glitch?

open furnace
#

i praise you reload save for saving my horse, repopulating saint denis after i shot everyone and of course resapwning animals

torn sage
#

I do it by riding along the border at night and if I start to get gunned down I just consume a bunch of special health tonics and it works

hazy nacelle
#

wait that works

torn sage
#

Sure does

#

Like I said ride along the border

#

The left side of west Elizabeth

#

Sometimes it doesn’t work but it’s all about timing

#

Like sometimes I get gunned down before I can do anything

open furnace
torn sage
#

Exactly

open furnace
#

isnt it weird how some animal pelts make the satchel go from being able to store only 3 apples to 99 apples

torn sage
#

Yeah it is weird

open furnace
#

pokemon bag is weirder i guess

hazy nacelle
#

don’t question the animal pelts, they’re just magic

open furnace
#

or pearson

#

or fence

hazy nacelle
#

The people who asked questions became the animal pelts

bold pagoda
#

like jack

#

that rat

open furnace
#

guys leopold strauss was the rat

bold pagoda
#

I kicked him out

#

ez win

hazy nacelle
#

Gg

open furnace
# bold pagoda ez win

dutch reallt trusted a random ass guy who helped in a bar fight 8 months ago over someone who he has known and trusted for over 20 years

bold pagoda
#

so sad

open furnace
#

dutch do be mentally ill tho

bold pagoda
#

micah is such a rat

hazy nacelle
bold pagoda
#

if i had to live with micah I would have a mental illness too

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

yea but if you do then you become the rat

hazy nacelle
#

secret ending

bold pagoda
#

you get shot instead of molly

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

maybe it was the doctor

open furnace
#

which]

bold pagoda
#

i kill micah daily

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

and you can track him and find his shit and stuff

open furnace
hazy nacelle
#

Every time you enter camp

open furnace
#

after that you kill him and burn down the office

bold pagoda
#

"micah I found your shit outside of the pinkerton office while hunting the legendary rat"

open furnace
#

we can easily assume that before guarma, he was also a rat but simply less obedient

#

anyways do you think that we couldve gone to tahiti if i had pressed the reset weather button on rampage trainer

bold pagoda
#

my weapon of choice is calloway's revolver

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

calloway's revolver is just the regular schofield but sexier

open furnace
#

i like the volcanic pistol appearanc emore if its dripped out tho

bold pagoda
#

I like to put golden triggers on all my weapons except for sidearms

#

I prefer Tacitus Kilgore

open furnace
#

no but i cant customize the calloway revolver

bold pagoda
#

imo it's good enough as is

open furnace
#

no i need to drip it out further

#

same

#

my volcanic pistol is gold with everything, silver for barrel

bold pagoda
#

I have some golden features on my guns

open furnace
#

i have wasted a couple hundred dollars just customizing guns

bold pagoda
#

I like to go with all browned or blackened metal and gold triggers

#

and mahogany wood I think

#

can't remember rn

open furnace
#

i forgot my wood but i remember it being close to gold

torn sage
#

I go blued steel with gold engravings

#

Every gun

#

It’s so sexy

bold pagoda
#

kinda sounds beautiful

open furnace
#

idk how it sounds

#

what the fuck should i be covered with when i die thats not blood

bold pagoda
#

I always wind up covered in blood

#

it's not my fault that the deer I just shot needs skinning

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

it's not my fault that I just stabbed that man

#

the knife slipped

open furnace
#

its not my fault that the shotgun was loaded when i fire dit

bold pagoda
#

no really you don't need to go tell the law

#

it's not an issue

open furnace
#

you dont need to tell the law, theres no issue here, simply a protection of my pride and dignity is what it all is

bold pagoda
#

alright that's it all you fools are gonna die

#

whips out fire bottles

open furnace
#

sawed off shotgun? thats weak pulls out pump-shotgun

bold pagoda
#

grabs pump shotgun with explosive slugs

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

activates no reload auto cock

open furnace
#

thats also weak pulls out shotgun cannon with volatile dynamite bullets and turns on fast gun

bold pagoda
#

invents flamethrower

open furnace
#

average red dead online fight

bold pagoda
#

grabs maxim gun

open furnace
#

no, goes to south guarma, and takes the warships

#

oh fuck now this is world of warships

bold pagoda
#

grabs tuberculosis game over fools

open furnace
bold pagoda
#

you bastard now how do I make it past chapter 6

#

I had a boat to Tahiti and everything!

#

dies of TB

open furnace
#

grabs flying ufo tank with lasers from gta online\

#

idk if that actually exists but i am not surprised if rockstar implements it

#

unleashes undead virus from red dead redemption undead nightmare

solid eagle
#

when sending my horse off/fleeing, can they be affected by environmental threats such as wolves, crocodiles, and falling off from high altitudes?

split cedar
#

is there a way I can make it so I can hold A to make my horse go full speed

solid eagle
#

ight good i dont want her head getting bitten off by some hostile animal lmao

rough path
#

Gaming

marsh oracle
#

Ok, So I am doing the fishing mission with Jack. For some reason when i am reeling the fish in as soon as it gets to the surface it lets go even though I do not do a thing anyone know why?

#

Never mind

#

No like I would get it to me, and then as soon as i go to pull it up, the fish breaks off and just sits there

#

I fixed it

#

I just self suicided until, I could skip checkpoint

#

No, I am pulling out of the water. Meaning I have the fish in hand. and then it just falls through the air and glitches

#

I know how to fish it just glitched

#

I am not dumb

#

No. I dont know if you did not read the rest of that, but it glitched out. and just fell through the map

hidden moss
#

Nice pfp

ornate swallow
#

How do you get Arthur shirtless?

#

I’ve seen a lot of videos where you Arthur does not have a shirt

dull geyser
#

You're gonna have to tap repeatedly to go full speed like when running on foot

#

I'd prefer it if they should've just made it rt to accelerate tho

hidden moss
cold sparrow
#

Who online right now ?

#

Wanna do bounties?

solar vessel
#

I just saved jack, how can I save this? It won't let me do such things atm

light karma
hidden moss
#

I've tried so many ways to kill Sherrif Malloy, but he lives for some reason,

light karma
#

i hanged the sheriff before

lucid trellis
#

I'm pretty sure I have all but 5 or so legendary animals left

hidden moss
#

why does johnny cash go so well with arthur

stray void
#

@hidden moss Brother Dege goes well with RDR2 in general

misty oracle
#

Nice pfp😏

rough path
#

PFPs are not my strong suit

#

Make sure to say howdy 468 times so that your honor isn't affected

brisk hatch
#

why i cant save the game

#

after i finished the train robbery, i quit.

lapis forge
#

it saves after every mission

#

before, and after. also when you bathe and sleep.

brisk hatch
#

ooh i never slept

lapis forge
#

but, if you completed the mission it should've saved.

brisk hatch
lapis forge
#

thats weird

misty oracle
#

Maybe you quit too soon, like you ended the mission but just barely and it didn’t save?

lapis forge
#

yeah

brisk hatch
#

yea i just press alt +f4

#

maybe

lapis forge
#

yeah, that must be why

misty oracle
#

Like you gotta let Morgan/John like walk a few seconds and you know you’ve completed it when like the location/time pop up and Arthur is standing yknow what I mean?

lucid trellis
brisk hatch
#

yea, i understood

lucid trellis
#

Now the question is who had the pfp first

brisk hatch
lucid trellis
#

We need to battle to the death

brisk hatch
#

it's tight for both of us

#

this server*

#

if i can't speak english smoothly, sorry

hidden moss
deft flint
#

@zealous glade @shut magnet Mario got unbanned

#

just need to invite em

shut magnet
#

Yeah I just heard

#

But he's got direct messages off so I added him instead so I could let him know

deft flint
#

I sent a friend request but he didn’t accept

finite pumice
#

yoo

short kindle
#

can i still save the boy from the gunsmiths basement in rhodes while playing with john?

finite pumice
#

yep

short kindle
#

well its not working for me

finite pumice
#

strange

short kindle
#

is it supposed to be in a certain time of day?

finite pumice
#

nah i dont think so

short kindle
#

wtf

#

and i cant even rob the gunsmith

finite pumice
#

thats strange

#

i never experienced this as john marston

#

so i dont really know

short kindle
#

well the boy is dead i think

#

because its been 8 years

finite pumice
#

maybe

#

maybe

short kindle
#

and when i look through the window i see some candles and 2 portraits

finite pumice
#

y'know your name seems really familar

short kindle
#

ok

short flume
finite pumice
#

had to throw that out

short flume
#

guys where can i find dutch after the game ended?

finite pumice
#

you cant

short flume
#

ah

#

K

short kindle
#

also the boy appeared

#

i just had to wait some time

finite pumice
#

oh

#

nice

brave ledge
#

is there a build house mission?

hidden moss
#

Yes

brave ledge
#

what chapter

hidden moss
#

I want to say in the Epilogue somewhere, haven't played RDR2 in a bit

frozen stone
#

Can u get the Gambler and the deauville and drover outfits in CH2?

frozen stone
#

i dont think u can say spoilers here, not sure tho

teal bay
#

oops sorry

unborn zinc
#

My profile picture is a spoiler tho 😢

deft flint
finite pumice
#

ayoo

deft flint
finite pumice
#

thats nice

#

thats nice

teal bay
#

Guys what the hell is the creepy scream which sounds like rake's one, what creature makes these sounds.

finite pumice
#

when?

#

during what chapter?

muted sierra
#

Hey guys, i know ive said this before, but are u guys aware that in RDR2, there's a soundtrack EXTREMELY similar to a sountrack from the movie "Lone Survivor?"

finite pumice
#

uhh, nope, never noticed that

muted sierra
finite pumice
#

yeah sure

muted sierra
#

DM or on the server?

finite pumice
#

dm

hidden moss
#

you just can't intentionally ruin it for someone

hazy nacelle
hidden moss
#

spoiler text gets auto deleted

unborn zinc
#

Ohh k

#

Replaying rdr2 I'm om chapter 4 rn and I have the trolley mission and the one where you meet rains fall

#

Any stuff I should do while Replaying?

hidden moss
#

try the go back for the money ending

#

once you're on 6

unborn zinc
#

Alr

#

Should I do low honour too

#

But I got positive honor rn so should I just do a save before the our best selves missions or my last boy and get neg honor?

#

So I can reload and go high ending

hidden moss
#

i mean if you've already done high honor why not try something new, both go back endings are good imo

unborn zinc
#

I haven't done money like ever

#

I just didn't have the guts

#

I'll go low honor help John ending later too

hidden moss
#

it's a really cinematic ending, i like it

unborn zinc
#

Yea

hidden moss
#

plus if you're high honor micah loses an eye

unborn zinc
#

I saw it on yt

#

I love the flames tbh

hidden moss
#

music is great too

unborn zinc
#

The action too

rain burrow
#

I beat rdr1

steady temple
#

Guys I just finished chapter 6 of rdr2 this morning

#

Arthur is a little bit shot in the face on the side of a cliff

wise inlet
#

Nice you must of got low honor ending

steady temple
#

Yeah I did

#

I had really low honor lol

wise inlet
#

Haha

#

I'm trying to keep mine high

#

I'm on chapter 3 rn

steady temple
#

Also how long is the epilogue in hours of play time

wise inlet
#

If you're going fast 5 to 6 hours but that's if you're rushing the missions but I'm not sure if your doing other aswell

#

Things aswell

#

Idrk to be honest

rain burrow
#

For me the epilogue took like 12 hours

#

But I played slow

steady temple
#

If I were to pick the least fun chapter for me it would probably be chapter 5

wise inlet
#

Yeah a lot of people said that

steady temple
#

I didn't find it that fun

#

Also do I ever get my guns and horses back?

rain burrow
#

I wish they would have done more with guarma

wise inlet
#

After im done rdr2 I'm doing the first game too, so it will take me a long time to finish both games

rain burrow
steady temple
#

I had a black Arabian from Saint Denis and it was not at all cheap

#

I also had overly customised guns

wise inlet
#

It says something about it on the Red Dead story mode faqs chat

reef ore
#

Can we give spoilers here?

#

I am dead btw

carmine sentinel
#

Can some characters not be disarmed? I shot a stranger's gun three times and he won't drop it.

bold pagoda
hidden moss
vital radish
#

I'm here to ask something on this channel, why is it when I press single player to play normal story mode, it just takes me to undead nightmare without it asking me if I want to play normal story or undead nightmare

#

I have the digital game not the physical

wise inlet
keen birchBOT
#

Read if Arthur < Micah.

restive prairie
worldly turret
deft flint
#

quick question, if the White Arabian were to die would it respawn

carmine sentinel
#

I’ll try that. I’ve been shooting the gun itself with little luck.

I’m tired of murdering everyone who points a gun at me. Many don’t deserve it

bold pagoda
#

if u have enough health tonics and its only like one dude then you can just hogtie them and run for the hills

deft flint
#

if it doesn’t respawn gonna delete this playthrough

bold pagoda
deft flint
hidden moss
#

yes it does

#

I just searched it up

deft flint
#

great

bold pagoda
#

arabian trash

deft flint
#

Arabian are the best breeds in game

bold pagoda
#

starter horse better

deft flint
#

they are literally the fastest horses

#

and lose less stamina

hidden moss
#

the only bad part is taming them

deft flint
#

level 1 with an Arabian

#

they are still wild af

hidden moss
#

yup

deft flint
#

one time I let myself get robbed

#

the white Arabian did nothing

#

she didn’t kick the guy off

hidden moss
#

lmao

deft flint
#

so I shot him dead

#

on my first playthrough me and her were best friends

#

till she died during the final mission

bold pagoda
#

I never feel like taking shit from the npcs so I gun them all down if they try to rob me or hold me up or whatever malicious things they intend to do

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

very gruesome some of them

rose glade
#

Memories amiright

deft flint
#

my horse slipped

#

I died

#

she died

#

now i lost my Arabian

#

stuck with the regular horse

restive prairie
#

I was on chapter 4 but sadly saw spoilers so tha ending was pretty much useless

cosmic vessel
#

Guys

restive prairie
#

I might replay the game in a couple weeks or until I forget the story

cosmic vessel
#

do you think javier deserved to die

#

I know he wasn’t innocent but

#

at the the same token i think killing Javier on the spot is more merciful than having him publicly hanged

hidden moss
#

when did he die?

#

I don’t remember that

#

I finished the game and everything

cosmic vessel
#

In the first game

#

You kill havier

#

or hand him to ross

hidden moss
#

ohh i haven’t played that

cosmic vessel
#

You should definitely invest in playing that game

hidden moss
#

is it available on pc?

cosmic vessel
#

Most likely

#

you should definitely invest in playing it

hidden moss
#

Yeah I definitely will

cosmic vessel
#

It might not be for pc

hidden moss
#

dang it

#

is it on ps4?

cosmic vessel
#

Yea

#

i play it on ps

hidden moss
#

ok good, I will probably buy it on there then

cosmic vessel
#

i think its on sale

hidden moss
#

ok

pulsar elk
#

PS4 if you got the premium thingy, fuck if i remember the name i'm half asleep and high, you get both RDR2 and RDR free to play which is how I'm playing

hidden moss
#

ps now?

#

or ps plus?

pulsar elk
#

playstation plus extra

#

just opened my account to look

#

Way I understand it, RDR2 is prologue so starting there and then moving on to RDR is ideal which is what I'm doing.

#

I just came in here to very quietly hiss FMicah that is all, this game is giving me emotions. Icky icky freaking feels.

hidden moss
#

yeah they build crazy character detail its insane. They plot is also very good it has not a single plot hole that I can recall it really is a good game

pulsar elk
#

I'm so invested I find myself yelling at the screen lol I'm almost done with the story but I'm going to whip through and do a second run to get all the challenges. I def played through too quick this go.

cosmic vessel
#

Whos yalls fave character?

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

John is pretty funny

cosmic vessel
#

Honestly Susan is my fave

hidden moss
#

yeah

cosmic vessel
#

Second would be charles

hidden moss
#

oh i know who my fav is!

#

the cook dude

#

i forgot his name

cosmic vessel
#

Oh dam whats his name

hidden moss
#

Pierson?

cosmic vessel
#

does it start with a p

hidden moss
#

yes

cosmic vessel
#

yea

hidden moss
#

he is funny

#

i like him

cosmic vessel
#

Very

#

remember when he had issues with sadie

#

that was flattering to watch

hidden moss
#

lol

#

sadie is also pretty awesome

cosmic vessel
#

Shes very badass

hidden moss
#

yep

cosmic vessel
#

I hope she lived a good rest of her life

hidden moss
#

yea

cosmic vessel
#

I wish we got more info on what happened after to certain characters

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

like if you could play as them that would be pretty fun

#

take a long time to make but would be awesome

cosmic vessel
#

I doubt red dead 3 would have anything to do with the main protagonists

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

i hope after gta6 they focus on red dead again

cosmic vessel
#

Definitely

#

What did you name your horse?

hidden moss
#

My arabian i just left it at that lmao

cosmic vessel
#

Lol

hidden moss
#

but the first horse I had was named lightning mqueen

cosmic vessel
#

My Arabian was named finn

hidden moss
#

thats a good name

#

i am not creative so i dont name my horses unless a good name strikes me suddenly

cosmic vessel
#

God that scene hurt when those animals(pinkertons) slaughtered my horse

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

i almost cried

cosmic vessel
#

Same

hidden moss
#

that horse was there from almost the start

cosmic vessel
#

i nearly cried so many times

#

but i just forced myself to keep it together

hidden moss
#

yeah

#

its the only game thats almost made me cry

cosmic vessel
#

yea

bold pagoda
#

my horse was named carl

#

felt like a cool horse name to me ig

cosmic vessel
#

Carl must have been a good horse

hidden moss
#

thats a pretty good name too

bold pagoda
#

he was a pretty good boah

#

then John had Carl II to honor the original Carl

cosmic vessel
#

It makes me so sad and depressed that all of them used to be a family and then one thing led to another and it all fell apart.

bold pagoda
#

it's all Micah's fault

#

he's a rat

hidden moss
#

when I finally killed him I grabbed my shotgun and shot his head and all his limbs off

cosmic vessel
#

Ive finished mu third

hidden moss
#

or i guess when dutch killed him

hidden moss
#

I wish I got to kill him rather than dutch

cosmic vessel
#

drinking herself to death

bold pagoda
#

I'm near the end of my second playthrough I'm just taking forever to be satisfied with what Arthur has accomplished

cosmic vessel
#

I hate hate hate micah for killing susan

bold pagoda
#

I hate him for everything he did

#

I hate him for existing

hidden moss
#

I wish I never broke him outta jail

cosmic vessel
#

I hate micah because hes micah

#

Micah is a bitch

bold pagoda
cosmic vessel
#

A rootless existence in the world of red dead redemption

#

He practically tour the gang apart

#

My god poor hosea

bold pagoda
#

yeah and he bullied jack about it

cosmic vessel
#

God that son of a bitch

#

I also cant believe dutch was so selfish in the end. He left arthur, John and Abigail

bold pagoda
#

Dutch is just a coward

cosmic vessel
#

All dutch ever did was run away

restive prairie
#

Ditch*

cosmic vessel
#

LOL

bold pagoda
#

I really wish Arthur could've ran away with Mary

restive prairie
hidden moss
#

drowning is always fun

pulsar elk
bold pagoda
#

only thing is I think without Arthur everybody would've been fucked

hidden moss
cosmic vessel
#

Feed him to gators

#

I feel you

bold pagoda
#

throw him off of the Brandywine drop or whatever it's called

cosmic vessel
#

i personally have 3 top picks

hidden moss
#

Drop him off a cliff, then burn his body

cosmic vessel
#

O, But i fed arthurs sa to the gators and they had fun with him

bold pagoda
#
  1. Arthur
  2. Hosea
  3. Lenny
pulsar elk
#

I have not run into that yet, but I heard about it...and I have every itnention of headshotting him before he can get near me if I can

bold pagoda
#

my favourites

#

of course they didn't need to die

#

and all that

cosmic vessel
#

My faves 1. Susan Grimshaw 2. Charles 3. Javier

restive prairie
#

Same

bold pagoda
#

My favourite mission in the whole game was getting drunk with Lenny lmao

pulsar elk
#

^^^^^

bold pagoda
#

why del

cosmic vessel
#

I just dont feel like javier was all that bad in the end. I feel like he was in a way sort of scared of what might happened if he didn’t side with dutch

bold pagoda
#

is it the caps

pulsar elk
#

why was my message deleted? O_o

bold pagoda
#

probably caps

pulsar elk
#

ooh fair enough

cosmic vessel
#

ai cant get over susans death

#

its sick

#

dutch just watched

hidden moss
#

He a bitch

cosmic vessel
#

He shouldve

#

right there and then

#

When he had the chance

restive prairie
#

Yeah

#

That actually made me mad

hidden moss
#

I should've shot Micah

restive prairie
#

Facts 😎

cosmic vessel
#

Whenever i had the chance when i play as john i visit her grave

restive prairie
#

Yeah

cosmic vessel
#

100% agree

restive prairie
#

What

#

Damn

cosmic vessel
#

O

#

Dam malloy

#

Does anyone else feel bad for Catherine Braithwaite

#

It so sad

hidden moss
#

Nah, she a bitch

cosmic vessel
#

to watch he cry and sob as dutch throws her around

#

i think its a bit overkill

#

I mean but the house

#

it was so beautiful inside

#

She is a bitch for kidnapping him

restive prairie
#

Didn’t feel emotions until the end lol

cosmic vessel
#

He shouldn’t have trusted him in the first place that fool

hidden moss
#

God damn fools

restive prairie
#

Yeah

cosmic vessel
#

And lets not forget about poor Kieran

#

He saved Arthur’s life

hidden moss
#

I felt belad for him, damn O'Driscolls

pulsar elk
#

I wamted to shoot her.

#

I don't feel sympathy for anyone who brings a child into their turf war

#

Kieran tho..that hurt my heart

cosmic vessel
#

I made sure to go back for her body

#

i robbed it

#

got a brooch

#

And after the Kieran situation they all split up and regrouped

#

but karen never regrouped with them

#

poor bastard drank herself to death

restive prairie
#

Yeah

cosmic vessel
#

Do yall think hosea could’ve still been alive if dutch walked out of the bank like Milton asked

#

Sad

restive prairie
#

I can never rob a place as John but I could as Arthur

#

Makes no sense

#

In my case of John robbin’ he just t-poses

#

Doesn’t help

#

Arthur only t-pose shoots

#

But does help

#

Damn

#

I can never last a second in that town

#

LESS GO

#

Lol

#

Yessir

#

Less gooo

#

Nice

#

Ok

#

Sure

#

I’m alright with it

#

If my DMs not open just tell me

cosmic vessel
#

I wanna see malloys deceased body

restive prairie
cosmic vessel
#

Oh what a beautiful sight that was

restive prairie
#

Yessir

cosmic vessel
#

I look forward to seeing the rest of their dead body’s

restive prairie
#

Same

high flint
#

Can i still meet the gang after finishing the epilogue?

hidden moss
#

I was bored so I was listening to the sound track rdr2 and damn it made me cry. Just the memories. When I first got red dead it wasn’t even that long ago it was like 6 months ago. Times we still tough I was stressed but the sound track makes me feel like those times were simpler. In my first play through I was experiencing everything in it for the first time and it was just so fucking amazing. The soundtrack makes me feel all of the those emotions again and damn this is just such a good game. I wish I could play it for the first time again. When and if they come out with a 3rd red dead I will be so happy. I will finally be able to do all of these things for the first time again.

next pier
#

why did no one warn me

high flint
#

thanks

#

now i just need to find out if i can keep hamish' hat

prisma robin
#

Hamish sincalir?

teal bay
finite pumice
#

oh

teal bay
#

that was creepy as hell

steady temple
#

Guys so I got rdr2 for my Xbox One S. The game came with 2 discs and it said on disc 1 to put disc 1 in first, it said it was the play disc so I was a bit skeptical but I did anyways. It finished the download, so I put disc 2 in and it said something that I forgot now. And when I put disc 1 back in it started everything again?

#

Does that mean disc 2 is the data disc and I should've put disc 2 in first?

#

Oh

#

I put the one with Sadie on it in the Xbox first

#

It said to put that one in first

#

Should I have put the one with Dutch on it in the Xbox first

slate bloom
#

U no what gets me about rdr2

hidden moss
#

My rdr2 just arrived

#

So happy about it

hidden moss
#

The high stakes treasure dude won't spawn

#

I've checked everywhere

opaque geode
#

Bro it just takes a while

#

i found him on accident

raven jasper
#

Oh wait I can share using a link, go check it out

fossil summit
#

I crashed on a bank robbery mission (chapter 3, I think Bill was planning it) right when I arrrived and now the mission is gone

#

.-.

acoustic spoke
#

I was in the theatre in saint denis and I was antagonizing and arthur said:"you belong in the kitchen!"

#

💀

patent ocean
#

What are some fun things to do when you have nothing else to do

torn sage
hidden moss
#

Van horn is the best, I enjoy getting shot by 50 different people for no reason and losing honor for shooting em

hidden moss
#

That's exactly what I'm gonna do when I'm done with maxing my naturalist role.

patent ocean
torn sage
#

I wouldn’t uninstall because if you feel like playing again you’d have to download all 100 gigs again

turbid oriole
#

Wait oh this is red dead

torn sage
#

SUS

restive prairie
#

He’s Dutch I

hidden moss
#

Can you buy a wagon in story mode?

#

to hold more fish and stuff

torn sage
#

You can steal one easily tho

hidden moss
torn sage
#

But once you get maxed out satchel there’s no need for storage like that

hidden moss
#

oh right

hidden moss
#

my satchel bad

#

i just got back from guarma so i dont have a trapper rn

#

in lakay

torn sage
#

Just go to one

#

In saint Denis or one of the ones that are scattered across the map

hidden moss
#

oh ok

#

thanks

torn sage
#

Yw

hidden moss
#

there’s one in saint denis, one near a place called pronghorn ranch far west of mount hagen. one un saint denis and that’s all i remember

#

also

torn sage
#

And you also can just do stuff for Pearson for the satchel

hidden moss
#

how dead is rdro

#

how dead is online mode

torn sage
#

Theyre slowly killing it

#

It’s not as alive as it used to be

hidden moss
#

is it still playable?

torn sage
#

Oh for sure

hidden moss
#

rdr2 is alive as single player with a bunch of people finding new stuff but rdo is slowly dying

#

like there are still games full of players?

#

i still see 10+ in every rdo server i go in

#

yh

#

i enter servers with like 20 players

torn sage
#

You can find people easily still

restive prairie
#

Bro I can never catch a fish in hamish quest

hidden moss
#

most ppl are in valentine

#

or near bounty boards

torn sage
#

Yeah and saint denis

#

I see ppl in bars 24/7

hidden moss
#

i just realised

#

what about the big fish that you have to stow

#

the satchel doesnt help with that?

hidden moss
torn sage
hidden moss
#

so i can still only stow 1 fish?

torn sage
#

You should be able to stow more afterwards for sure

restive prairie
#

It’s a fisho

hidden moss
#

oh good

restive prairie
#

So ofc

hidden moss
#

bruh i passed out on the way to the trapper

#

ive seen the spoilers

torn sage
#

Lmao

#

Depression incoming

hidden moss
#

ik what this is

restive prairie
#

Dutched rainbowcatjam

torn sage
#

I honestly think going to guarma made Arthur’s tb worse

#

From what I can tell in my playthroughs

hidden moss
#

it was him smokin a cigarette every goddamn cutscene

torn sage
#

Bro fr

hidden moss
#

i’m gonna fully explore guarma unlike quick grinding the chapter

#

can you go back to it after?

#

i took my time from chapter 2 and then did the story missions so quick

torn sage
#

I glitched back there and got all animals I could

torn sage
hidden moss
#

you can glitch back

#

that sucks

#

but i’m too lazy to

#

missed opportunity

#

it would be a cool dlc

torn sage
#

I’ve been back there twice thru glitch

#

And studied the animals

hidden moss
#

you can glitch there in freeplay?

torn sage
#

Yessir

hidden moss
#

I don't see any satchel upgrades at the trapper in saint denis?

#

sorry for all the questions

torn sage
#

You’re good

#

It’s at Pearson

#

Or at a fence in the epilogue

hidden moss
#

oh ok

#

i have neither rn lol

unborn zinc
#

Finally started chapter 6
Chapter 5 was short tbh

steep fable
#

hi is this the place to ask questions? i wanna know if i hunt animals, would it be the same selling price for every place or its dif each place i sell?

torn sage
#

But if you’re looking to make money there’s better ways

steep fable
torn sage
#

Ofc

#

There’s treasure hunting which’s gives about 1,000 to 2,000 dollars in gold bars depending on the treasure hunt and then there bounty hunting which gives a decent amount but once you get all the gold bars and sell them at a fence all of that money will last awhile

#

There’s tons of YouTube guides showing each and every gold bar location

#

There’s also a few that don’t require a treasure map like the statue puzzle or the train wreck gold bars

steep fable
#

but i thought treasure hunting makes your rank go down?

#

maybe im wrong here

#

or is that robbery

steep fable
torn sage
hidden moss
steep fable
#

ah is theres any regular farming method that i could do it over and over or something?

steep fable
hidden moss
#

treasure hunting doesn't make you lose honor, but robbing people does

steep fable
#

i did get a free 10 gold bar code, should i spend it on something valueble?

#

what should i spend it on

torn sage
#

Guns, a good horse, etc

steep fable
#

ah okay

restive prairie
#

Noises

torn sage
#

On god

#

Noises go brrrr

restive prairie
#

Facts

hidden moss
#

how do i get an iguana skin

acoustic spoke
#

Where are you in the story?

hidden moss
#

just entered chapter 6

acoustic spoke
#

First playthrough?

hidden moss
#

yes

acoustic spoke
#

Aight you're gonna have to wait until after chapter 6 cause you can't get an inguana skin at where you are

#

Just keep playing the story

hidden moss
#

iguana are in new austin?

acoustic spoke
#

Yes

#

You can enter after chapter 6

#

Or try and do it with a meat shield or smt

#

To protect from the new austin sniper

hidden moss
#

whos that

acoustic spoke
#

When you go to new austin there's an invisible sniper that tries to kill you cause the game doesn't want you to go there

steep fable
#

doing bounties hunting has a limit?

raven jasper
acoustic spoke
#

Really?

acoustic spoke
steep fable
#

i see, btw is theres a way to open map without going to the menu? on ps4

steep fable
raven jasper
acoustic spoke
sick oar
#

Anyone know a concrete way to find the Rio Grande wild turkey? It's the last animal I need for the platinum

split cedar
#

Bro, I just got robbed for 400 dollars I'm pissed

#

saint dinise i swear to god

mossy ferry
#

Have u tried not getting robbed?

split cedar
#

im gonna wait till night and slit their throats uwu

restive prairie
#

Gj

#

Hope you do it well

lucid trellis
#

Jesus christ, Beaver Hollow is genuinely so depressing

restive prairie
#

Damn

lucid trellis
#

I never noticed in my first playthrough but the ambiance and sounds are just so

#

Isolating

#

If that makes sense

restive prairie
#

Yessiree

lime ridge
#

That's why I'm more adventurous than staying in camp in chapter 6.

lucid trellis
#

Just standing in Beaver Hollow, seeing how everyone's gone, listening to the wind through the trees, watching as everything slowly unfurls into chaos

restive prairie
#

Yeah

solemn saddle
#

Yeah im in beaver hollow rn and I'm just grinding through the missions Trying to get it all over and done with, because rn it's just really depressing and sad

#

Why are they all mad at Arthur tho like what did he do?

sterile surge
#

Cus he got tuberculosis

lucid trellis
split cedar
#

i never got my money back

steep fable
#

so i wanted to hunt this legendary animal, but it keeps saying that theres too much activity to track it? what does that mean

torn sage
scarlet blade
#

Are we allowed to discuss modding in here?

#

All I'm trying to do is get PS5 icons instead of xbox and I'm having trouble

torn sage
scarlet blade
torn sage
#

If it’s story mode modding this is the place

hidden moss
#

pretty sure you can do it here; in the rules, exploits, glitches, and hacks are not allowed while mod discussion is neither condoned nor punished

lucid trellis
#

Gambler 8 is THE BANE OF MY EXISTENCE

hidden moss
#

i feel your pain, took me 3 hours

torn sage
#

The gambler challenges in general are just a pain

lucid trellis
#

Currently been trying for an hour and I only have ONE

foggy hazel
#

Oof

lucid trellis
#

This would be so much less tedious if the game let you skip the dealing and playing of cards

hidden moss
#

definitely, i'd recommend sitting in the first spot if you can to at least see if you can stand up and sit down faster

lucid trellis
#

Yep, I'm in Rhodes at the very first seat so I'm luckily being dealt toward first

#

The things I do to see that percentage go up

hidden moss
#

hahaha the 47.3% to 47.5% euphoria rush

lucid trellis
#

Right now I'm at exactly 90%

#

Still can't believe there are 30 freaking dinosaur bones, in both my playthroughs I've only found one

hidden moss
#

i know right, in fairness they are usually off the beaten path

#

for many of them there's not many other reasons to be where they are

scarlet vigil
#

What pc specs do you guys have? Planning on buying RDR2 on PC

hidden moss
hazy nacelle
#

What do you even get for getting all the the dinosaur bones?

solemn saddle
#

Thanks!

hazy nacelle
#

Thats the dumbest reward I’ve ever seen.

#

What about for giving all the legendary fish to that one guy?

#

Rhodes.

#

The story side quests be having the worst rewards. What about the cigarette card guy? Do you get nothing from that as well?

worthy creek
#

is it possible at all to get to blackwater in RDR2 singleplayer

#

ive tried, but its just instant wanted

hazy nacelle
worthy creek
#

yeah i know the one youre talking about

hazy nacelle
#

Bruh. For the dinosaur side quest I was getting my hopes up about some giant dinosaur skeleton you could put at camp or something.

hidden moss
#

/ New austin

worthy creek
hidden moss
#

Ch. 4 start the mission. "Bronte, A man of honor". do the mission. Near the end when you have to escape from the law. Escape them. And you can go to New austin.

#

Just dont die at all.

#

or it wont work anymore.

#

oh and dont finish the mission.

hazy nacelle
#

It also doesn’t work if you replay the mission right?

hidden moss
#

mhm

#

you just cant finish challenges. thats all

#

but you can explore.

steep fable
#

so im in the mission where i have to kill all 4 people and get their weapons.the gunslingers i think, but then when i kill the second guy and i pick up his gun, my other gun drops. How do i keep both? if i cant, whose i should keep?

stoic quarry
#

if they are both the special weapons they should be stored on your horse

#

just make sure to pick up both atleast once to make sure its in your inventory

uneven gust
#

Can someone tell me if Im doing something wrong? Ive been trying to get the katata elk for almost 24 hours now and no luck

uneven gust
#

I did

#

and theres 0

uneven gust
#

Online

dull geyser
#

But spoilers

winter kettle
frozen stone
#

How do i know what level my honor is?

upbeat flint
#

i used the tutorial horse for the whole game 💪

upbeat flint
frozen stone
#

What is level 5 honor?

solemn folio
frozen stone
#

okay

solemn folio
#

u have*

#

the highest is the level 6

frozen stone
#

i have 25%

#

is that 6 or 5

solemn folio
#

in 5 u have the 25%

frozen stone
#

okay then i am 5

#

can u get the lvl 6 in ch2?

solemn folio
#

no

frozen stone
#

alright

solemn folio
#

in the character 2 no

#

in the endings characters yea

frozen stone
#

okay

hidden moss
upbeat flint
hidden moss
#

TRU

#

he most definitely would.

winter kettle
frozen stone
#

pc

winter kettle
#

On the PS4 it's the bottom button on the left hand side

#

Ah I don't know PC controls

bold pagoda
lucid trellis
#

Nah, I doubt that

Bronte is shown to at least have some sort of morals, and he obviously cared for Jack while he was in the mansion
Plus, having Jack be shipped off to Guarma for child labor wouldn't work, as Guarma is shown to only use adult slave labor

Bronte is also never shown to have any capacity for shipping people off for child labor, if they wanted to imply that there'd be more showing it than just a party guest

vast oak
#

Guys i need help, im trying to get a turkoman and im at that place north of denis, ive saved and reloaded like 20 times but i keep only getting Tennesse walker Kentucky saddler and Morgan. How rare are the others?? Or is it impossible to get them early game?

lucid trellis
#

If Bronte gave him to Fussar, that'd just anger the Van der Lindes more, I don't srr why he'd poke the bear

#

Plus in 1899 slavery was abolished, the Braithwaites aren't going through all the trouble of shipping a child off to a foreign country

#

That's possible, but Dutch is pretty infamous in the states and I assume the Braithwaites would have told him where they got Jack from

vast oak
hazy nacelle
#

I don’t think they are available until chapter four at St. Denis stables.

vast oak
#

I saw a youtube video where they found them without buying and i think they said that it was possible from 2 but after an hour of only getting 3 kinds of hordens it feels wrong

#

Also, how do you get into new chapters? Completing missions?

torn sage
#

Yeah but you’re not able to get a turkoman til chapter four

#

@vast oak don’t waste your time on a turkoman wait til chapter four and buy a Missouri Fox Trotter

#

And yes it’s impossible to get the best horses early game. Unless you go and tame a white Arabian

#

Which you can do as early as chapter 2

#

But trust me when I say grind to chapter 4 and get a Missouri Fox Trotter

#

The Fox Trotter is available at the other stable that’s in lemoyne closer to emerald ranch

vast oak
torn sage
#

And plus the fox trotter has some really good cores when you get it to level 4 bonding

vast oak
#

According to the most videos I have seen turk has less chance to get scared, anyways I can get both and see which I like most. Also u get to new chapters by doing missions, right?

dull geyser
#

Horse bravery still depends on the horse not the breed

#

But mfts are always solid picks for a horse

hidden moss
#

Thes game is never gonna die

bold pagoda
#

but don't rush it

#

take ur time

vast oak
#

Without spoiling, i saw something about ”epilogue” i dont know what it is but after it, will i loose weapons and mounts? If thats the case, should i wait until after that and buy the horse then? And Will i lose anything else?

acoustic spoke
#

You will lose mounts but not guns I thinm

#

Think

vast oak
#

Okay, is it really late game or should i buy horse us until that too?

acoustic spoke
#

I mean if you're gonna buy them I'm pretty sure you can get them at the "epilogue"