#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 642 of 1

hidden moss
#

Chapter 6

#

have you finished red dead

#

I’m on chapter 4 and I know what’s gonna happen in chapter 6

#

So I won’t spoil

junior umbra
#

Which horse is It?

rancid sage
hidden moss
#

U will find him their

rancid sage
#

Oh alr

hidden moss
junior umbra
#

Im in chapter 3 but i needed to restart because Item requests im in chapter 2

rancid sage
#

@hidden moss how much is it

hidden moss
#

1200

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

I mean if u have finished red dead it’s no big deal

#

turkoman

#

or missouri fox trotter, those are the two best in the game

#

saying horse names isnt a spoiler bruh

junior umbra
#

How do i get dutch horse

hidden moss
#

dutches horse is a white arabian

junior umbra
#

His horse is beautiful

hidden moss
#

you can find one at lake isabella

rancid sage
junior umbra
junior umbra
hidden moss
junior umbra
rancid sage
#

@junior umbra what chapter u in

junior umbra
junior umbra
#

Now im in chapter 2

#

Chapter 3 is very fun

undone jolt
#

Omg I lost honor because I killed too many ducks even though I was going to skin them anyways for the parts

junior umbra
#

I have good honor rn

hidden moss
junior umbra
hidden moss
#

jack Marston...

#

Is not the son of jim Milton

#

But the son of rip van winkle

junior umbra
#

Who is Rip Van winkle

hidden moss
#

Do you not know rip van winkle?

junior umbra
#

And who is Jim miltom

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

Jim Milton

junior umbra
#

Im in chaprer 3

hidden moss
#

Rip van winkle is part of the van der linde gang

junior umbra
#

In the Mission where John Javier and Arthur steal horses

junior umbra
#

There is No Rip Van winkle

hidden moss
#

There is a rip van winkle

junior umbra
#

Who has even that name

hidden moss
#

It was the 1800s

junior umbra
#

Poor guy who has that name

hidden moss
#

Wanna know the ending?

junior umbra
#

No pls no

#

Stop

hidden moss
#

So you see the main plot of the story is for Arthur and john to look for rip van winkle and Jim Milton

#

Uh huh

#

Do you know what happens to Jim Milton?

junior umbra
#

Who the hell is Jim milton

harsh ruin
#

a Pinkerton guy

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

Do you know Arthur Callihan?

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

Cornwall?

junior umbra
#

Yes

#

Leviticus cornwall

hidden moss
junior umbra
#

Wth

hidden moss
#

Both

junior umbra
#

How

hidden moss
#

You see Micah and dutch are dating

harsh ruin
#

Jim Milton is Hosea

hidden moss
#

Yes

junior umbra
#

Bill is gay i think

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

Micah and dutch are dating

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

molly?

#

She's a side

harsh ruin
#

Dutch is not a gay, he is a moron

junior umbra
#

How is Rip Van winkle hosea micah and pinkerton

hidden moss
#

The lore is very complicated

somber hinge
#

OK quickly I need someone’s help one or two just choose which number one or two

junior umbra
#

One

somber hinge
#

Okay so I leave that dude trapped in the gunsmith there

harsh ruin
#

okay, jokes aside. Jim Milton is Arthur's actual name. Arthur Morgan is just his nickname

junior umbra
#

Oh that Boy who has the clothes on

junior umbra
somber hinge
#

In chapter three Time the first time you ever go to Rhodes there’s the dude trapped in the bottom of the gunsmith dressed up as the son

#

Yes

#

I was deciding whether or not I should leave him or not

harsh ruin
#

believe me

somber hinge
#

You have too make a compelling case

harsh ruin
#

it's better to free this poor guy

junior umbra
harsh ruin
somber hinge
#

Fucks that you can rob the place and take the gun whether not you free him

junior umbra
hidden moss
loud forum
#

ok so i have been gone for enough time that i dont remember shit about the main history

#

things about to be like a first playthrough

raven kettle
#

Idk if this the channel for this, but what's the quickest way to get money

weary light
#

find all goldbars scattered across the map and looting bounty hunters and selling rings and watches to the fence

high flint
#

can I hogtie dead animals? I have two perfect carcasses but i only brought one horse. can i drag it

#

nevermind

shut reef
#

Just finished the story yesterday. Even tho i knew what was gonna happen that was still amazing

lethal spindle
#

Sorry for your loss

junior umbra
hidden moss
#

You too

hidden moss
#

in valentine hotel I always hear muffled screaming and noises but i can’t get in anywhere. does anyone know where it is?

opal hound
#

I was just pissing and my pee stream split into half water and half piss like a five guys drink dispenser wtf 💀💀

opal hound
#

Why tf does my horse die so tucking easy in online mode

opal hound
#

No problem

#

I had to share

#

Where does everyone hang out in online mode

#

I can’t find anyone

tropic crag
#

hi hi, if anyone has any idea on how to fix gfx error for rdr2 please let me know

#

i bought the game yesterday and was so excited to play and then i got an error and my pc is fucked up

hallow cipher
#

guys

#

what if i kill mama watson before the stealing watson homestead mission

white oriole
wise gazelle
#

I found a 3 star bull moose, while I was on top of a cliff

#

Shot it, went down to skin it, it rotted in like less than the 2 minutes it took me to get down

high flint
#

should i go for druken harlot or lost girl?

hidden moss
#

Idk

high flint
#

for the valentine heist

hidden moss
#

And am i the only one who finds story so damn sad

#

Sadder than gta 4

wise gazelle
#

@high flint it doesnt matter

weary pecan
#

Is the only legendary panther in the game the giguerian or whatever on master hunter 14?

hidden moss
#

Anyone can help me

#

I am trying to do gambler 4

#

I mean 5

#

with dominos

#

But i dont understand how it works

wise gazelle
#

or how you play the game?

junior umbra
errant sun
#

I got a coach robbery tip from hector, and he said that I should plant explosives to deal with the guarded coach. I know I can place dynamite down and not set it off but is there any way to detonate it remotely? or do i just shoot it when the coach goes over the dynamite

torn sage
#

I don’t listen to hector I just deal with it my own way

#

By telling them to stop and then killing then and the waiting for the horses to not be spooked and then I steal the stuff

high flint
#

how do i add the stuff to make my beard grow longer

#

nevermind but i just saw an invisible thing that gave swanson a beer

hidden moss
languid nexus
#

bruh

#

when i approached a boat with a canoe

#

arthur just commit die

#

like

#

he left the boat and drowned faster then the speed of light

past pasture
#

thanks

errant sun
#

ok thanks

light karma
ember ferry
#

Hey guys why do my gun belt/holsters not save when I save a new outfit?

#

All my outfits are the same in terms of gun belt and holster

weak jasper
#

I know this is not for read dead redemption 1, but I am not sure if I wanna keep playing but I’m hearing many say it’s really good so I do not know. I am trying to play it but all the missions so far feel like chores and are not too fun. Does it get good and how long does it take?

young lynx
hidden moss
young lynx
#

rdr1 is the sequel

#

rdr2 is the prequel

hidden moss
#

Yes I know mate.

young lynx
#

xd

hidden moss
#

That’s what I said

young lynx
#

what

#

u said prequel

hidden moss
#

I said it makes sense playing the prequel first which is rdr2.

young lynx
#

oh

#

mate

hidden moss
#

For me it’s 10

#

Pm

young lynx
#

its mid

#

omg

#

last msg: i thought #pet-pics was feet pics

severe stratus
#

Bruh

hidden moss
#

You use that skull thing way to much

#

Ohh~~ Arthur.

supple trout
#

Plz no feet pics

hidden moss
#

NOT ME

#

MARY

signal shoal
#

can someone help me I've been stuck on the proposing to abigail mission

#

nothing happens when I try to interact with her

rocky pine
#

Finally finished all the story mode achievements, only took 157 hours...

strange horizon
#

TIL that trappers get ALL feathers (except flight feathers) and to NOT give them to Pearson... And, once you've given a wagon load of feathers to Pearson you CAN'T get them back! ....

weary light
#

we need platinum trophy role

ember ferry
#

Please?

strange horizon
#

What's the pros v cons on Story mode v Online?

mystic raven
#

to oversimplify it

#

story mode is well..better by a mile

#

but r* dosent care about both

midnight dawn
mystic raven
strange horizon
midnight dawn
#

He's probably waiting for DLC's, yeah just forget about those lmao

#

But the game itself is entertaining as hell, you'll have a blast

ember ferry
#

how do you guys increase honor quickly?

#

i wanna get the classic black frock suit but my honor is too low

mystic raven
#

and online? yeah i dont even need to talk about it

#

its obvious there wont be any dlcs for story

strange horizon
#

What is wrong with online?

mystic raven
#

Well for one
No content

dry moth
#

How much damage does the bolt action rifle do?

strange horizon
#

so there's nothing there? you just log in, create a character and sit there?

mystic raven
#

Well no of course not

#

you do have stuff to do

strange horizon
#

I'm confused.. no content means there's no content...

mystic raven
#

but r* dosent update it

strange horizon
#

So no NEW content... for those who have played all the rest.. but for new players lots of content?

mystic raven
#

Well for new players, yeah sure there is content but besides what we already have

#

No new updates

ember ferry
mystic raven
#

Greet people

#

realese fish

#

Donate to camp

ember ferry
#

ive finished the game

strange horizon
#

Stop killing everyone you meet

mystic raven
#

that too

ember ferry
#

how long do i have to greet people to max honor out?

mystic raven
#

Every three ppl gives you honor

strange horizon
#

Stop robbing people

ember ferry
#

ok

mystic raven
#

anyways im currently playing rdr2

#

cya

strange horizon
#

I'm out hunting for all the damn feathers I donated to Pearson instead of taking them to teh trapper like I was SUPPOSED to do.... (really pisses me off that I didn't realize that earlier, lost a lot of time hunting birds.)

ember ferry
#

has anyone completed all the treasures

dry moth
#

Not yet

ember ferry
#

i mean all the gold bars in story mode

#

something like 12k

dry moth
#

Oh

#

Yeah no

ember ferry
#

surprisingly ive only completed one treasure hunt or something

#

never really paid attention to it during story mode

#

now that im done im working towards it

dry moth
#

Do you know how much damage does the bolt action rifle do?

ember ferry
#

a lot

strange horizon
#

3.2 damage

#

2 second google search.

heady remnant
#

How far in is the mission the "Bridge to nowhere"

#

the one where we blow up the bridge

#

to "create a distraction"

midnight dawn
midnight dawn
#

Literally two missions left for the end iirc.

heady remnant
#

oh really? alright, cheers

#

its 20:28pm for me rn, should i just go till the end?

midnight dawn
#

Yeah, you still got 2 epilogues to run through tmrw

#

Just so you know, there is no break between the last 2 missions.

heady remnant
#

right okay, ill do that tomorrow

midnight dawn
#

Finish what u gotta do before starting them

heady remnant
#

because want to watch a movie.

midnight dawn
#

Have fun

heady remnant
#

cheers for the pre warning

#

cheers

dusky meteor
#

Hey

#

What mission does everything really open up

strange horizon
ionic sigil
#

I have rdr2 but i also have 2 computers (1 at my dad 1 at my mom) and i was wondering is there a save file in the actual game directory that i can just upload to google drive and download it on my other computer?

hidden moss
#

lol do two save files at the same time

#

low honorr and high honour

ionic sigil
#

?

#

No but like

#

i have alot of time on the file

#

and i wont be back for like 6 weeks

hidden moss
#

im not sure bro im on xbox

blazing trench
#

i was looking for the arabian horse & i found it and hitched it to a tree while trying to remove the saddle from my current horse and i lost it seconds later as im in the mountains and every tree looks the same :/ can i still find it?

strange horizon
dusky meteor
strange horizon
#

On Steam?

ionic sigil
#

oh well its fine

strange horizon
#

do a file search for "Rockstar Games" and pick the one with "Documents" in the path...

strange horizon
pearl marlin
#

Or wait a few in game days

blazing trench
#

ok

#

ive seen the glitch before u have to go back to ur camp and wait a while

#

or whatever it is

#

but i hope it works cuz i spent 1 hour trying to find the horse and still nothing

torn sage
#

You don’t have to wait til you’re John

#

Just walk around do some missions and sleep then come back

#

Start your search again

#

So dw @blazing trench

blazing trench
torn sage
#

Yw

mystic raven
#

Poisinous trail

#

god idk how to spell some words

#

English isnt my first language

#

Poisinous

#

Poisnous

#

Im stupid

hidden moss
#

poisonous

#

you're welcome - an englishman

brisk solar
#

I just got the Double Barreled Shotgun and I'm very pleased with myself.

grand pivot
#

What are you supposed to do with money

#

Like I have 6k right now, is there anything I should do with it

torn sage
#

Buy all the guns in the game that you can and fully upgrade them

#

Get the legend of the east satchel from the fence

heavy kelp
#

is it nesecary to equip a bag to use it? or is it like talismans?

rare warren
#

I got drugged

#

And now it's all like an old grey movie

hidden moss
hidden moss
hidden moss
hidden moss
hidden moss
#

had my first run in with the KKK today

#

threw dynamite at them and gained honor

#

must have killed the leader, i didnt pay too much attention to which one that was

dusky meteor
#

Idk why but I found insulting people so entertaining

#

Arthur says some funny shit

high flint
#

should i kill anthony foreman or leave him be? I want the high honor ending so idk

lime ridge
#

So don't.

high flint
#

okay

#

dang it i pressed circle instead

hybrid belfry
vernal rampart
#

i dont think killing foreman gets you bad honor

#

after all the shit he pulled with tilly it would be nuts to make the player lose honor by game ending him

#

afaik as long as you have max honor at the end of the game then you get the high honor ending which isnt too difficult to achieve

icy relic
#

hi

midnight dawn
ember ferry
#

Do you guys know if I have to get every treasure map or if I know where the final treasure is I can just go there and get it?

icy relic
ember ferry
#

I’ll just go through the whole process anyway was just curious

icy relic
#

E

high flint
#

if only mr dutch didnt do that shitty train job

serene jackal
#

Can anyone help me with installing mods?

#

I want only Red Dead Offline and WhyEm’s

weary pecan
#

How can i save my tiger striped bay mustang as arthur, Do i just enter a stable or go back to brontes manor

high flint
hidden moss
light karma
weary pecan
wise gazelle
primal dawn
high flint
# light karma which bad train job 😂

I know it wasn't a train job but it was the train station one where he hit his goddamn head and then left arthur for dead on the true ending. Damn bastard. Then he committed self death which is even more stupid. Man's got plans but not the best ones.

#

also should i kill mr angelo or leave him?

#

never mind i dont have a choice

livid bison
#

I have a good arrow idea

#

A berserk arrow

narrow crane
livid bison
#

A berserk arrow should turn enemies against their allies when hit

#

With them in a rage state

#

But since rdr2 is realistic

#

And berserk arrows/darts are fictional

primal dawn
#

you can still stretch it

#

and make a reason for it

livid bison
#

Makes sense

primal dawn
#

like using certain herbs can make them go crazy or something

livid bison
#

That’s a great idea

#

But I looked it up

#

No substance can make someone into a violent psycho

primal dawn
#

Man

livid bison
#

Besides it might be copyrighted from assassins creed

formal flame
#

rip hosea n lenny😭

hidden moss
#

two goated characters

#

gone in the same mission

hidden moss
#

i love seeing the kkk members set up for their next meeting with the cross cause i always shoot one of them and the other 2 drop the cross and it falls on them and they die

narrow crane
livid bison
#

Didn’t know that

narrow crane
# livid bison Didn’t know that

Yea its pretty cool, or you can recreate the thing in far cry 5 were everyone was so high they become physically stronger and durable

prime estuary
ionic sigil
#

I need help. I cant craft the Legendary Elk half Chaps and Moccasins ,even tho i have both the perfect sheep and goat hide and the elk pelt?

#

the hides are on the horde right outside the trapper place in saint denis

strange horizon
#

Oh FFS .... fishing, line breaks every time. 3 star bird, head shot, bow (small game arrow) or varmint rifle, 1 star carcass... snakes 3 star, head shot varmint rifle or pistol, 1 star carcass. how the fuck do you get three star skins on birds and smaller prey?? every time you kill something it drops to 1. Don't say I don't what I'm doling.. got half a dozen 3 star iguana pelts and getting frustrated

heady remnant
#

spoiler

ive got to the bit where you play as someone else, but I've got to go off, and I've just walked into the shop to ge ta job, can I just leave and it save

weary pecan
whole willow
#

400 hours in the game and I am yet to see the woman in the window at Emerlad ranch

#

It’s like one of my RDR2 bucket list things

#

Is it during a certain point in the story? Because I just stole a stage coach from Shemus’ cousins

strange horizon
# weary pecan Tips you will be getting is to lasso them lol

Lassos don't work for smaller game./… "Your lasso is good for more than just wrangling your enemies. You can use it to tie up and kill animals too. If you do choose to use this method, be prepared to stab the animal you wrangle in the heart. This doesn't work for small animals like rabbits or anything smaller"

weary pecan
#

And i tried but got a jaw in my nexk

whole willow
#

Idk how I have 400+ hours in the game but have never seen either the emerald ranch window woman or the bayou ghost

hidden moss
#

Can we kill Micah in the prologue ?

hidden moss
#

i imagine if he did die in a mission it would fail the mission

#

I want Arthur to kill him so bad

whole willow
#

I kinda wish Arthur lived

#

And he leaves to start a new humble life

hidden moss
#

i feel like it was vital for arthurs character arc for him to get sick and die

whole willow
#

It is but I love him too much

hidden moss
#

if he hadn't fallen ill he wouldn't have changed into the good person we see by the end of the game

whole willow
#

That’s true

#

But still, I wish he lived just because it makes me sad

hidden moss
#

hello xbox series s how to tansition 30fps to 60fps please help.

whole willow
#

I hate that man

ornate swallow
#

Do you guys know any places where you can find good wild horses to tame and make them your main one

#

I only find Morgans, tenesse walker and Kentucky saddler in the wild

weary pecan
ornate swallow
hidden moss
weary pecan
#

Arabians are the fastest horses in the game and they are wild

ornate swallow
ornate swallow
#

And I travel a lot in the game

weary pecan
#

Ik they aint war

#

I mean i think thoroughbreds are good speed and not scared easily

#

But i had a white coat arabian lvl 4 bond it didnt scare so easily

ornate swallow
#

Oh ok then

weary pecan
#

But i like cowboy horses not slim race horses

ornate swallow
#

Also I’m in chapter 3

weary pecan
#

I go for andalusions, Mustangs etc

ornate swallow
#

If that effects something

ornate swallow
weary pecan
#

Nah if you want arabian its free

ornate swallow
#

Lets see mustangs

weary pecan
#

They are race and work

#

War and work

#

Not race

ornate swallow
#

Yea that’s good

weary pecan
#

But arabian is the best in the game you choose

ornate swallow
#

For now I’ll do mustang

weary pecan
#

It is just my personal preference

#

I got the tiger striped bay mustang wich you can only get in epilouge as john in new austin but i did not a glitch but im in chaper 4 and tamed it

ornate swallow
#

Hmm alright

#

What’s the glitch

weary pecan
#

Its in chapter 4

#

Have you played the story before?

ornate swallow
#

This is my first play through

weary pecan
#

Ok i wont spoil

ornate swallow
#

I already know everything tho lol

weary pecan
#

Ok

ornate swallow
#

I know what happens to Arthur and gang

weary pecan
#

In the mission angelo bronte a man of honour some of the first missions in ch4 your going to a cemetery

#

And some police shwo up and you gotta escape

#

I just run down to new austin and the sniper from god is disabled

ornate swallow
#

Damn

#

No mission barriers

weary pecan
#

And you can accsess new austin as arthur

ornate swallow
#

That’s cool

weary pecan
#

Ik

ornate swallow
#

But I need a horse now though

weary pecan
#

So you can do challegnes and stuff

#

Ik

ornate swallow
#

So maybe I need Arabian

#

I just hate my current horse

weary pecan
#

You got three coats wild

#

White coated, Warped brindle (black with stripes) and red chestnut

#

Red chestnut is the worst but still an arabian

ornate swallow
#

Alright

weary pecan
#

The white coated is up in lake isabella north west

#

Like in the corner of the lake too the left

#

Its a path

#

Up in the mountains

ornate swallow
#

Is it always in that exact location

weary pecan
#

Yes

#

Its easy to spot

ornate swallow
#

Because it’s white?

weary pecan
#

Nah

#

Its snow there

#

Gimme a sec

ornate swallow
#

Ok

hidden moss
#

common misconception

#

the arabian is tied for the best speed, and has the best handling and acceleration, however has awful health and is very skittish and likely to buck you off

#

the best horses are the missouri fox trotter and turkoman, offering similar stats the arabian, while having higher hp and more bravery.

#

the best free horse is the arabian though, yes

weary pecan
#

And he will save 1000 bucks

hidden moss
#

i honestly dont remember

#

all i remember is that the turkomann and missouri have higher

severe night
#

Hello got a Quick question about the hunting system in rdr2, how Do i get 3 stars and i never really did hunting in rdr2 so genuine answers pls

#

Yeah next to the name of the animal carcass

#

Yeah but is it when i get a good shot or is it randomized

#

And is bow and varmint rifle good starter weapons

#

Aight thanks

hidden moss
#

i think im gonna try find the arabian thats out by the wapiti reservation

amber eagle
#

What are some horses for online like the type that dont get scared from gunshots or dangerous animals

hidden moss
#

the turkoman is the bravest horse

#

but overall your best bet for horses is the missouri fox trotter

amber eagle
#

Ight thats for online right

hidden moss
#

online and singleplayer

amber eagle
#

Bet

#

Thanks

hidden moss
#

i officially own the warped brindle arabian

lime ridge
#

I thought there are no brave horse or horse that buck you off?

hidden moss
#

all horses have different hidden bravery stats

#

the turokman has the highest, and the arabian has a low one

#

the turokman is less likely to buck you off than the arabian as a result

lime ridge
#

I found this on another server. Someone has datamine and looked at the coding for horses, all horses are the same.

#

what's the bravest horse?
according to datamined information on horse temperament, the coding for horses' fear reactions are all the same. there are no discriminators for horse breed, horse class, or horse size. the only things that determine fear reactions are proximity to danger, duration in proximity to danger, type of danger (ex: gunshots, predators), calming, and bonding level. as a tip: make sure you are calming your horse if it is agitated or if you anticipate they'll become agitated. to calm, make sure you are holding down on the calm button - not spam clicking it.

TL;DR: every horse has the same temperament.

ornate swallow
#

For example

#

If you want a perfect rabbit carcass

#

You need to first find a 3 star rabbit

#

Then kill it with a small game arrow

#

The small game arrow is the perfect weapon to keep a small animal at 3 star

#

But you shoot the rabbit with a shotgun for example

#

The animal quality will reduce

velvet valley
#

i honestly dont remember

lime ridge
hidden moss
#

Is there any version where arthur doesnt get infected with TB

#

nop

lime ridge
#

I wish.😔

dull geyser
#

it sucks but yea

hidden moss
#

What if we dont do that mission in money lending

dull geyser
#

or you can just stop doing missions in chapter 2

#

that's the best we can get

hidden moss
#

What if we shoot him first

dull geyser
hidden moss
#

Hmmm

dull geyser
#

the tb part is inevitable man

hidden moss
#

Arthur was a good man

dull geyser
#

yep indeed

#

but we can only move on sadcat

hidden moss
#

Yeah 😁

dull geyser
#

i hope jack lived his life after rdr1

#

it's gonna suck if the cycle continued with him

hidden moss
# hidden moss What if we dont do that mission in money lending

unfortunately going to the downes ranch for the debt is a yellow story mission, which means you have to play to progress. Shooting or killing mr downes fails the mission, and you are forced to press the beat prompt at least once, which triggers the cutscene that ends the mission.

#

Of course, there is the option of never doing the mission, but then you would be stuck in ch2 and miss out on about 75% of the game

#

alternatively, do the mission and never do the ch4 bank robbery mission, but then the same thing happens.

#

ive done extensive research on that mission explicitly

strange horizon
#

Blessed Are the Peacemakers... any hints or clues to escaping? I keep getting killed as I walk out of the cellar.....

hidden moss
#

use the minimap to see where enemies are looking

strange horizon
hidden moss
#

stealth kill one then take his gun and shoot the rest

strange horizon
#

ok, let's try that....

hidden moss
#

make sure to get your guns once you kill them all

#

theyre in a wodden shack, there should be a gun marker on the minimap

hexed magnet
#

Why did Rockstar not add the ability to button your coats?

hidden moss
#

that would be a neet detail

#

im still shocked by the option to spin your gun when holstering it

dull geyser
#

Or they just got lazy

sudden halo
#

(beware of spoilers)

About the Francis Sinclair stuff. If his father Tom Sinclair is from GTA 5 and is in the Epsilon Program then tom is dead in Rdr2 but alive in GTA 5. This might mean that Alive tom in GTA 5 would time travel to the Rdr2 timeline. So going off the fact that Tom is from Gta 5 but passed away in Rdr2, Tom could give birth to Francis in Rdr2 but shortly pass away, Francis then grows up and maybe uses Tom's time traveling methods to time travel back to GTA 5 and join the Epsilon Programm than time-traveled to Rdr2 to get Arthur/John to get rock carvings.

This is just a theory from me.

hexed magnet
hidden moss
hexed magnet
#

Thank you

shut silo
#

Can you have 2 different single player progress’s in 1 computer?

hexed magnet
#

I think so

#

I've only played once though

lime ridge
#

Yes, there is a save game system.

whole willow
#

I don’t know how I feel about the morality system. On one hand it’s simple end cool on the other I wish it allowed us to have a bit more of a code. Like robbing rude strangers and criminals isn’t going to give me a bad ending

mystic raven
#

I love doing bar fights

#

Plus i wont get wanted if its like a fight after i antagonize someone

#

so i just knock out people without any problems

mystic raven
#

and then they start a fight with you

dull geyser
#

I wish we had more tough mfs like the mountain man in valentine

hidden moss
#

The mountain man is the worst, he gets up and starts punching you, and you lose honor for punching back.

potent ridge
#

Helo

hidden moss
#

Chapter 6 spoilers, but

#

When the doctor diagnosed him and said something like "get some rest in a warm and dry place", I made sure to get my boy 19 hours of rest after each mission.

dull geyser
hidden moss
#

Yeah, I ran out of the saloon, knocked him out and went back, sadly it despawned.

#

and then everyone started shooting at me for some reason

dull geyser
#

Ah damn

#

I wear his hat whenever I go to valentine so he itches for a rematch and jumps u

neat rain
#

Arthur: “we need some money”
Also Arthur: has $8500 in his pocket

potent ridge
#

Shut yo ball ass up

#

Spoiler alert

opaque geode
potent ridge
#

Not like everyone downloaded it when it was released

river solstice
#

I finished the game on ps4 like 2 weeks ago

potent ridge
#

I'm on my 4th run

river solstice
#

even tho I bought the game back in 2019/2020 LMAO

#

rn on my 2nd on PC

potent ridge
#

Nice

keen jetty
#

Micah is my favorite character

hidden moss
#

Micah is the hero

#

I hate Arthur

#

Blacklung

weary light
#

i wish arthur would tell dutch "you let him damn us all" in the high honor endings, i can only imagine dutch instantly thinking of hosea when arthur tells that to dutch

river solstice
molten trout
rugged field
#

Yh its true

#

Btw how did u get playstation role

molten trout
rugged field
#

I dosent say anything about playstation role tho

opaque geode
neat rain
#

And beat it a few times

#

I lost count but I think this is my 4th playthrough

#

I don’t do 100% I just do all the missions and the side missions. I don’t do the dinosaur bones or the cigarette cards.

neat rain
rugged field
#

I honestly cant see it

whole willow
#

I want to experience everything I possibly can

#

I’m still trying to see the woman In the window at emerald ranch

neat rain
#

I’m trying to get as much money in the epilogue as I possibly can

#

I found a way to get your money from the main story to the epilogue idk if it still works tho. It worked a few years ago for some people

#

You go to a certain guy that robs all your money and go back to him in the epilogue and reclaim it

whole willow
#

I’m doing everything. I’m upgrading my camp as much as possible and such

neat rain
neat rain
#

They say I’m doing it wrong

neat rain
whole willow
#

I’ve never 100% the game before

neat rain
#

Me neither

whole willow
#

But I plan on it

sturdy frost
neat rain
whole willow
#

I need to stop buying so many games so I’m gonna take my time with this one

neat rain
whole willow
#

With all due respect, the games been out for 4 years I’m pretty sure the spoiler date has passed

wary oasis
#

Hardly a spoil

hidden moss
#

What are you doing here dutch

steady temple
#

guys how do i change outfits from my horse

#

im selecting the winter gunslinger outfit and releasing tab but it does nothing

#

wait nevermind i figured it out

#

i was standing on the wrong side

#

of the horse

whole willow
#

You can do it on the horseC stationary or moving very slowly

neat rain
neat rain
#

My Arthur has $8984.98. And the camp gets 50 cents of every dollar I get so how the hell do we not have enough money to go to Tahiti

#

I think camp actually gets more than that. I think they get half the total take

pearl marlin
neat rain
#

The big money stuff pretty much

#

Chapter 5 is Gilligan’s Island if they actually got off the island

neat rain
#

Can John do all the bounty missions. I want to save those for him.

#

The only one I’ve done is the good honest snake oil one

#

That one you do in Rhodes is very foreshadowing towards his fate is why I had my doubts about that

#

The killer that tried to reform and be a family man

vestal idol
#

Who?

#

That one dude in the swamps

#

I just beat him to death lol

#

I'm sick

#

I killed him in front of his family

hidden moss
neat rain
neat rain
hidden moss
#

Mark Johnson,

#

I wanted to spare him but the game wouldn't give me any more bounties till i turned him in

#

I love Arthur to have a low honor

#

The only reason I kept his honor high was cause of the 50% discount.

lime ridge
hidden moss
steady granite
#

I have a story read dead question

hidden moss
stray otter
solid lichen
#

Got a question, just did the bank robbery mission and got 2500 bucks. Can i replay the mission and get another 2500 or does the restore point prevent that?

stark jay
#

It probably prevents that, (havent played in a while) it'd make sense to get money rewards once - thonkhaw

solid lichen
#

Yea most probably

olive charm
#

How do I get the fence to sell me all the weapons? They are locked

stark jay
#

You'll hafta progress thru story missions to unlock weapons, there's some unique weapons in stranger missions btw 👀

#

everytime i see gold guns i call em butterguns lol but ye its pretty cool!~

strange horizon
#

Is this a known bug?? On PC my repeaters and rifles all have scopes. As of right now, the Varmint rifle and the springfield will NOT toggle between Iron sights and the scope, while every other rifle/repeater will. Known bug??

strange horizon
high flint
#

can you save lenny?

#

it looks pretty easy to unless its scripted

stable orbit
#

No matter what the animation plays and he dies

high flint
#

oh for fucks sake

#

honestly dead eye could've easily just bang bang both of their heads

#

its stupid

dapper valley
#

lenny's death contributes a lot to the story

high flint
#

well its a piece of shit death. Lenny was such a good guy and a a comedic one at that. If only Arthur and Lenny could drink again.

dapper valley
#

they are drinking together in the skies my friend

hidden moss
#

on my 2nd play through, I tried everything to save him, but to no avail.

lime ridge
#

Someone once tried to set fire to the door they came in.

olive charm
hidden moss
#

but still not working

keen narwhal
#

Does Charles still pop up after you have finished the epilogue?

#

I think it’s a glitch because i greeted him and John said something bout Sadie having a lead to kill Micah

river solstice
#

Lol I just found out, if you shoot any church bell (I did it in Valentine) it will actually create a (distorted) bell sound

ember marsh
#

Why is John never at camp? I'm in chapter 3 and I never see him at camp

acoustic spoke
#

What missions fo you have available bc if John is involved he will be at the mission location

mystic raven
#

Something fun happend lmao

#

so basicly

#

i was riding towards the river to dump a body

#

and

#

i had to cross a bridge

#

but o'driscolls were waiting for me

#

so i pulled out a sniper rifle and decided to ambush them instead

#

im always cearful around bridges incase something like this happens

#

Dumb o'driscolls lmao

high flint
#

i have a luscious moustache and beard as Mr Morgan

narrow crane
mystic raven
#

do gang hideouts respawn?

#

or once you kill everyone there wont be anyone again?

hidden moss
#

and hanging dog ranch

#

and fort mercer

#

basically I think so lol

winged mango
#

I commited a crime and got away, but the police are still hanging around valentine with a dark red icon, and i cant' access any shops or whatever

#

how do I fix this?

keen narwhal
#

That’s what I’m saying because he’s in my camp and we spoke about how we are gonna kill Micah with Sadie

#

i think it’s a glitch

mystic raven
#

I love attacking gang hideouts

#

Thanks

#

Wiki says it takes one in-game week

gleaming basin
#

is there a currendly glitch to get john/arthur shirtless

#

no mods

#

its for an outfit not because im ga-

pliant frigate
solid eagle
#

You can’t go into debt, so surrender to the officers and you’ll lose the bounty

hidden moss
gleaming basin
#

in online you can but in singleplayer you cant

hidden moss
#

ahh gotcha

wraith panther
winged mango
#

i saw on my map a bounty poster, but when i went to valentine to check it out, it was gone?

digital ivy
#

How do I tell if I’m a good or bad person. When I look at my honor the only thing is see is store discount. Right now I have a 0% discount but I have done a good amount of good and only a little bad. Is there like a graph I can look at to see how close I am to either side?

wraith panther
#

wtf

#

are you in singleplayer?

digital ivy
calm crow
#

I can’t believe people are saying Javier is stronger than Bill

#

Like fr?

#

Do u guys believe Javier is stronger than Bill?

hidden moss
#

I swear I've always done my best to keep my honor high, but after a guy in Saint Denis stole from me, I've never felt so much like unloading two revolvers.

hidden moss
#

he’s slick and sneaky with his skill

calm crow
native arrow
#

Lol did anyone here ever treat themselves to some stew and whiskey at the camp near valentine? They got mad at me haha

gritty geyser
#

it was pretty funny

native arrow
#

Lol I didn't even know you could take from their stew

high flint
#

should i buy some random guy's book that is $50 and will supposedly make me rich?

lime ridge
#

No.

grizzled quartz
#

why can't i gain bonding xp for my horse when I calm it down. it is not max lvl and other activies such as feeding and cleaning it still gives xp

hidden moss
tranquil eagle
#

Anyone know where I can get the rio grande turkey? It’s giving me an aneurism

strange horizon
#

where the hell are the three star beavers? been wandering aroudn the legendary beaver spawn for 3 days and I've seen 1 1 star beaver (and yes the legendary is dead)

high flint
#

is it bad that im dangling a man over a brokwn bridge

strange horizon
#

well, does he deserve it?

high flint
#

well its a guy who tried to steal my horse so maybe

strange horizon
#

hell yes he derserves it..

steady temple
#

hey guys so uh

#

i had just completed the 'advertising' mission with Hosea in chapter 3, and when i got back to camp my horse was gone? it was a white arabian and level 3 bonding level

#

the "Arthur's Horse" marking on the index inside the map has completely disappeared?

#

has my horse just gone like: you know what? stuff being here, and just left?

#

do i need to complete another mission to get it back or something?

pulsar elk
#

Have you tried popping into a stable to 'retrieve' him?

steady temple
#

i think he probably died

pulsar elk
#

I am ridiculous and forever hoofing it on foot out of range of whistling .... the stablehands probably lowkey laughing that my Arthur is forever losing his damn horse

steady temple
#

guess i buy new horse

#

also are there any horses that you can catch in the wild and are as good or better than the white arabian?

#

i enjoy breaking in horses

#

oh ok

pulsar elk
#

comprable but not better would be the Black Arabian in Saint Denis, Red Chestnut up by where the legendary buck is but that bitch was hellish to get. I mainly ride the brindle thoroughbred personally.

steady temple
#

it wasnt for me

pulsar elk
#

My only complaint is that he's a flighty little bitch but I like the handling.

steady temple
#

whats the best horse you can get in chapter 3 other than the white arabian

#

the morgan from valentine

#

okey

#

ima go check out saint denis stable

#

thats the only stable i havent been to

#

remember, i dont have a horse lol

#

i may have to go to rhodes then catch a train to saint denis

pulsar elk
#

First horse I got was the dapple palamino standardbred and I really loved him

steady temple
#

nah i bought rdr2 on steam

pulsar elk
#

^^^^

steady temple
#

ok

#

what do i steal a horse from a random guy, kill him then hide his body in the bushes so no one reports my crime?

pulsar elk
#

The way I personally do it is I just lasso the guy off, jump on and book it

steady temple
#

yea but what do i do with the guy afterwards

pulsar elk
#

Move fast enough and put enough space between you and there isn't anything they can do.

steady temple
#

ok

pulsar elk
#

I'd put a waypoint where you want to go before hand, that way you've got a "guide" for your get away

#

Milton, I like your style.

steady temple
#

k im gonna go back to playing rdr2 now

#

cya guys

pulsar elk
#

good luck!

#

^^^

lime ridge
#

If I'm not mistaken, you can get a black Arabian from that event.

#

And yes, I think so.

steady temple
#

i managed to get sir bob the white arabian back by retrieving him from stable

#

i wish i knew that sooner

pulsar elk
#

yay! Glad you got him back!

fading glacier
#

Sir Bob 💪🥰

steady temple
#

bro you know the lemoyne raiders

#

yeah i got out of saint denis with sir bob back in my hands and the stupid lemoyne raiders jumped me, killed me, stole my horse and the game gives me an effing tennessee walker back

#

im really sad now :(

#

ya but they were really quick

#

plus they had maxim gun

#

which is machine gun

#

anyway

#

lets hope i can just go back to saint denis and retrieve poor sir bob :(

#

i cant get it back

#

poor sir bob is gone forever

strange horizon
#

how the hell do you get small birds and mammals with the damn bow/small game arrows?? They want me to hunt a songbird no bigger than a baseball with a bow/arrow? delusional.

#

beter question .. not a rant.... for those who play on PC there are certain weapons that are hotkeyed to 1-9 .. I'm wondering if there is a way to hotkey the binocs to one of those lesser used numbers??

ornate swallow
#

What’s the best satchel in the game

#

And how do you craft it?

#

I only have Arthur’s satchel

#

I want a bigger satchel

strange horizon
#

Legend of he East.. and you have to create all the others first

#

take 7 perfect deer, badger, beaver, bison, boar, buck, cougar, 2 elk, squirrel, rabbit, raccon, iguana, wolf and panther to Pearson...

ornate swallow
#

Wow

mystic raven
#

I always do it when im up super close

#

then i just spray them

#

using r2

mystic raven
#

Fr?

#

What event is that

#

is it like a random encouter or?

#

a mission

lime ridge
#

Random.

lime ridge
primal dawn
hidden moss
hidden moss
primal dawn
#

they asked for bow and arrow tho

#

Varmint rifle is a million times better but idk what they need the bow for

hidden moss
#

bow is used for animals like squirrels and small birds

#

as far as I know you don't need to hit a headshot, just land a small game arrow, could be wrong though

primal dawn
#

right... rabbits are small too, if you can hit them you should be able to hit those as well

hidden moss
#

I just meant for a clean kill

primal dawn
#

so just take my comment and replace rabbit with small bird

hidden moss
#

I would agree though that it's a lot easier on keyboard and mouse

pseudo stone
#

Is being a bad guy fun?

flint gull
#

Yes

stray void
#

Any tips for doing the hunting requests?

#

And also the van horn to Blackwater horse challenge?

ionic sigil
#

I need help!

#

My game is like frozen

#

I cant move, but things are still hapening

#

And im hunted by 2 lawmen

#

but they arent shooting

#

i cant do anything

#

nvm fixed it

swift sentinel
#

How did you fix it?

pseudo stone
#

How do I brush horse? it keep saying press B but it wont brush do I need to buy a brush?

swift sentinel
#

Yes buy a brush at the stalls

#

If you’re playing on ps, stand next to your horse, L2 and then you see the option brush

waxen garden
#

Just started playing RDR2 on my PC. Wow, wish I didn't wait so long, this game is stunning on Ultra!

#

bit dark in doors mind, think i'll need to fiddle with brightness 😛

high flint
#

so I killed this lawman, shot his hands and feet off and I have no idea what to do with the body. dm me if you wanna see him

#

oh and i also threw atleast 75 tomahawks at his body

waxen garden
#

Is there a companion app to have a real time map up on my second monitor ?? Can’t seem to figure it out

hidden moss
#

Guys arthur is coughing a lot ?

stray void
#

@hidden moss that's intentional

rose glade
#

He’ll be ok

#

Just keep doing missions

#

👍

rose surge
#

@hidden moss He has Covid-19

hidden moss
sweet jay
#

Guys, if I use cheats in a story, In the other story will I be able to unlock trophies or can I no longer take them?

candid pasture
#

nah you won’t be able to earn trophies

hidden moss
torn sage
#

Just search rdr2 on your App Store

celest wedge
#

does anybody know the best location for wild hungarian half bred ?

#

its the last horse to break for the horseman 10

sweet jay
tepid yacht
#

Where can I meet old gang members after completing the epilouge?

near kernel
#

hey if you dont collect the weapons carried by the gunslingers in the noblest of men, and a woman can you come back for them later or are they just gone

torn sage
#

They’re gone

#

You can’t get them if you didn’t pick them up

near kernel
#

man that f#cking sucks

torn sage
#

Just look around for them and you’ll see

#

Pearson is the easiest to find

#

He runs the general store

shell hedge
#

hey there, can anyone help me with this
i enabled cloud saving and it has overwritten my chapter 6 save
so now i have two american venom saves
one says [Autosave] American Venom

river solstice
#

The creator of the RDR2 VR mod just got DMCA'd by TakeTwo

lucid trellis
river solstice
#

I doubt that

lucid trellis
#

We can always hope

#

Even though knowing rockstar it isn't happening

river solstice
#

I just looked at the rocktar support page for mods, Something about that mods are allowed aslong as its non-commercial. The only way to get the mod is through his patreon aka hes making money with his mod. But idk if thats the reason since its his code.

#

also dont know if that means you cant make money of mods.

lucid trellis
#

Ah, that makes more sense

river solstice
#

Im not sure.. They do offer server hosting but thats not making money from the code/mod itself.

hidden moss
solid estuary
#

Howdy yall, i really need some help

#

I got rdr2 almost a year ago and it started up once ONLY once...i played 8 hours then the next day it wouldnt start 😦 and i spent 6 months trying everything...iv talked to many support peeps and they all tell me to try the same stuff over and over...its now been 11 months and im still trying

Im desperate for help

hidden moss
#

Anyone can give some tips for a newbie? I play Singleplayer atm. 😦

bold pagoda
mystic raven
bold pagoda
#

that's how i played my first playthrough

mystic raven
#

Thats how i play every playthrough

bold pagoda
#

killed everything that moved only to be redeemed for ALL my sins by kicking strauss out

mystic raven
#

commits acts against humanity
kicks out strauss
God: Understandable,have a nice day

bold pagoda
#

I found a new meat source

#

step one: find jack.
step two: C O O K J A C K
step three: mission passed, +respect

mystic raven
#

It all makes sense now, Jack was the rat all along
How else would the pinkertons find him and Arthur? It was a set up all along
He ratted the whole time

#

I mean the whole "i hate you uncle Arthur"

#

But of course nobody could blame an innocent boy
That was his plan all along!

bold pagoda
#

oh yeah I forgot step 4, if you cook jack then arthur lives and his TB is automatically cured

tepid yacht
#

what if it was

#

dutch

hidden moss
#

just the limbs

bold pagoda
hidden moss
bold pagoda
#

I haven't even touched it cuz i hear it's complete shit

#

story will keep you entertained for a very long time

#

just do side quests whenever possible because they're engaging and fun

#

and take it slow

#

don't rush through the entire game

hidden moss
#

I hate it lol. 🤐 I also hate the default outfits too.

bold pagoda
#

u hate the singleplayer so far?

hidden moss
#

Just the clothes.

bold pagoda
#

eh I do too tbh

#

i can't will myself to wear anything other than the basic outfit I scraped together in the beginning

#

none of it looks outlaw, cowboy enough

#

most of it is lame

#

but it's whatever ig

hidden moss
#

I wish I could play as a female character in the singleplayer though haha

mystic raven
#

what did you do?

#

Lmao

#

I dont play online but in singleplayer Bounty hunters coming after me is super rare tbh
I only had to deal with them just yesterday

#

I Always try to pay off my bounty as soon as possible

#

Or

#

i surrender if i dont have enough money

#

i commit a small crime

#

and surrender

hidden moss
#

I think I shot an outlaw and threw someone on the tracks. Haha.

#

I had like a $50 bounty.

vivid anchor
#

I've been trying to get Lenny to drop rifle for 6 hour straight in chapter 2, everytime he placed rifle at the side of his horse I dynamite but the rifle went missing or poof instead

#

I couldn't track where it drops or if it's even dropped at all

silver herald
#

Arthur dies what a bozo

#

He’s an L

#

Like bro just shoot Micah

hidden moss
#

Damn, spoiler

steady temple
#

does fast travelling from arthur's map in camp bring your horse with you?

rigid pewter
#

because right after you get to play as marston

#

god forbid 💀

vivid anchor
hidden moss
#

what do ya guys recommend

#

i beat the whole story already

#

and i kinda like being arthur more than john

#

Blackwater will always have me wanted

#

Or is there a way to remove

neat rain
#

I’m at the sad part of the story

#

It’s like my 4th or 5th time and it still gets me

#

Chapter 6

hidden moss
#

guys save editor aint working

#

it says i have an update needed but i downloaded the latest version

steady temple
#

also whats the best area to find elk

#

i need perfect elk pelt for trapper

gusty arrow
hidden moss
#

bounty

#

tumbeweedians i hate

#

you bump into them ONCE or run into them while on a horse, they immediantly pull a gun on you

#

guys i hate being john

hidden moss
#

i wanna go back

#

😭

#

johns cool

#

i wish after were done with the game like i am

#

I think he's sad for arthur's death

#

i wish we could play as anybody

#

nah

hidden moss
#

arthur was just a better character

#

dude

#

in general

#

and arthur's cooler

#

no

#

my opinion

#

i like them both

#

theyre cool

#

oh fk u

#

I dont like playing as john just cause free roam without missions gets boring

hidden moss
#

i dont like playing as john because arthur was just funnier and john sounds like he smokes 50 packs a day

#

im like done done with the game now i just go around and rescue horses or mess with people or find side quests

hidden moss
#

john doesnt have as much as humor as arthur

#

arthur said to micah something about "if your looking for your balls theyre in blackwater"

#

You get attached to arthur the whole game and then u just play as some other guy

#

AAHHAH

hidden moss