red-dead-singleplayer

[trim sail]

Okay!

[hidden moss]

i now have a 200 dollar bounty in new hanover

I tried to do the doctor robbery and uhhh, kinda shot my way out of valentine

yeah that happened to me too

lol if i go near valentine now im fucked

was not pleasant

oh no it was fun

i got to really test micahs revolvers

and it does the job

[sharp sinew]

why did Charles Smith change his haircut in chapter 6?

[cosmic epoch]

?

[ruby wasp]

THIS GAME

IS BORING

ASF

I just wanna go to the city

And free roam

And smoke mfers

Just started the game

I'm still in the snow

Doin this random mission

I keep skipping the cutscnes

Lmao

Yo

When do u go to the city

I swear 99% of this game is literally riding around on a horse or walking for ages

Lmfao

[fringe prawn]

Bruh

No way

[split onyx]

[cosmic epoch]

is your name a reference to KoTOR 2

[cosmic epoch]

Probably the wrong place to say this

Because for some reason criticising any part of RDR2 is bad

[cosmic epoch]

I agree

John is better

[hidden moss]

woooooow

[hot bluff]

John can't swim

Says enough

[cosmic epoch]

ironically who swam using Arthur

When you can just swim using your horse

[hot bluff]

I did actually

John also draws like a 5 year old

[cosmic epoch]

also using John can’t swim is a pretty shit reason

Same w the drawings

💀

[hot bluff]

Lots of people who didn’t do side stuff as Arthur

[cosmic epoch]

How about we talk about the part where he gave himself up without any illness cough cough Arthur cough cough to make sure his family lived

[cosmic epoch]

Arthur wouldn’t have been made without John

Think about that

💀

[hot bluff]

You actually this attached to a character from an old game? Lol

[cosmic epoch]

no

I haven’t touched red dead story in years

[sleek sundial]

john wouldnt have been made without arthur, bc of the ending

if ur talking ab rdr1 yeah arthur doesnt exist lol but hes supposed to ig

[cosmic epoch]

RDR1 came before RDR2

:troll:

[sleek sundial]

ik

[hot bluff]

That’s what he’s saying

💀

[sleek sundial]

yes ik

[cosmic epoch]

imagine getting killed off in the phantom menace

Packwatch

[sleek sundial]

speaking of red dead 1, its free with the new ps plus subscription thing

[hot bluff]

PlayStation??

[sleek sundial]

he didnt die tho he died in rebels

[cosmic epoch]

oh wait he didn’t die

[hot bluff]

Imagine losing your exclusives

[cosmic epoch]

😭😭😭

[cosmic epoch]

LMAOOO 😭😭😭😭

imagine losing Kojima

[hot bluff]

Giving Spider-Man to pc people like fr?

[cosmic epoch]

They also lost persona

It’s being put on Xbox

Ik persona is made by sega

[swift forge]

can i steal tobacco from a plantation then sell it

[red helm]

The flower?

[swift forge]

yeah

[red helm]

Of course you can pick it. However, you can't really sell those, I don't think. You use them for crafting Tonics and such.

[golden vector]

I thought you could sell plants to doctors

[red helm]

Eh, Well, even so, Making medicines and tonics is probably a better use.

[hidden moss]

What can o craft with a legendary elk pelt

[hidden moss]

Legendary Elk Moccasins, Legendary Elk Half Chaps, Legendary Elk Range Gloves

[hidden moss]

Do they give special effects?

I've hunted about 3 legendary animals cuz i cross paths with em but idrk what the pelts are used for so i sold them

Except for the elk

I kept it on my horse

Also anyone know good place to hunt badgers? They are impossible to find i keep finding 1 or 2 stars not 3

I neex them for legend of the east satchel

[slow fjord]

Legendary animals can give special effects through talismans

Just go to a fence and pick the craft option

[hidden moss]

Ight i think i have 2 legendary antlers or whatever its called

[finite canopy]

<@&645344672197247058>

[unkempt salmon]

around bolger glade and generally bottom part of scarlet meadows. I'd suggest getting that trinket that helps to spawn better pelts 😊

[hidden moss]

Ok thanks

[random edge]

Guys, can you help me? everyone said that we can find a silver dapple pinto missouri fox trotter in one of albert mason mission as arthur, but can you get the horse as john?

cause the horse looks pretty good

cause if i get that horse as arthur, the horse ends up being shot by the pinkertons in the last mission of chapter 6

[keen apex]

Hi any one knows how to use the save game from the disc version in the digital version for ps4 I don’t know why it didn’t recognize the already existing save game

[slow fjord]

Yeah just don't do that mission as arthur

[random edge]

but, only arthur that have that albert mason mission

arthur can herd horses

john cant

so john never got that mission

[midnight dawn]

That missions isn't available for John

And the dapple gray horse can be bought later on during epilogue 1 or 2 i don't remember exactly, for a 1000$

[naive glen]

what alber mason

what

[nimble jewel]

Hi, does someone know why when i'm playing rdr2 my gpu is been arround 65° but the using of the gpu is arround 2%, then its my cpu who's at 80% or 90% ?

[hidden moss]

so

I was hunting for a 3 star beaver

Got one while he was swimming

Tried to go get him

My horse accidentally bumped him and it made it sink

Back to another 20 minute hjnt

[naive glen]

is there any way to remove the second holster

and only keep one

and am i the only one hearing moans from the room 2A in the hotel from valentine?

[next ember]

Man i love javier

[hidden moss]

Yes. I never left camp.

[midnight dawn]

Yeah you could probably do so by unequipping it from a clothe changing spot

[midnight dawn]

Yeah they're always having fun there

[midnight dawn]

Good mexican hombre but very dumb

Or rather delusional

[midnight dawn]

Side quest guy, you help him photograph the wildlife

[naive glen]

there s no option to remove offhand holsters

[acoustic spoke]

What? You can? I've tried doing it but it never worked, I just want Arthur to have 1 gun

[acoustic spoke]

Yea I think he was talking abt rdo

[naive glen]

: (

i like how cougars dont spawn nearby annesburg in story

even if it says on the map they do

but in rdo it's the only spot where i can find them

[midnight dawn]

Animal spawns in this game are weird even though they're marked on map doesn't mean they'll appear everytime, it's pretty rare

[naive glen]

i reckon animals spawns is weird

everytime i go through heartlands, there is some dead dear spawning

out of nowhere

[civic widget]

Game be like "Need spoonbills? FUCK YOU! Heres a fuckton of herons!"
Then after you spend 5 hours painstakingly getting all the spoonbill plumes, the game be like "HERE'S A FUCKTON OF THEM, EVEN OUTSIDE THEIR HABITAT!!!!"

Then you literally drown in a sea of spoonbills.

[hidden moss]

they do

more north, there's like a certain crossroads where they're almost guaranteed to spawn

[naive glen]

yea well that s just unlucky

check the time of day

maybe even the day of the week

[hidden moss]

Guys

I think the game has permanently removed micahs revolver from my inventory

I got it in ch1

And I just did the micah jailbreak

But I failed the mission and when I restarted the checkpoint micahs revolver was gun

It's not even in my weapon locker

Very weird

I'm gonna save and reload

It may be a bug related to the game thinking there should only only 1 instance of micahs revolver

And since micah would be using it in the mission, upon reloading the checkpoint they remove it from Arthur's inventory if he has it

Saved and reloaded and its still gone

It's fine though I have my own double action

But I guess that puts an end to the low honour/Micah themed run

[civic widget]

@hidden moss Hmm, you usually can't get it until after epilogue 2.

[hidden moss]

I used a trick in the ch1 mission where you fight the odriscol camp

Basically disarm a guy then run over to micah with him chasing you and the enemy will disarm micah, then you can pick it up

[civic widget]

Oh, so it's a bit of an exploit.

Can you keep it through the rest of the game?

[hidden moss]

Supposedly yeah

[vale fable]

Anyone Are you trying to run online

[hidden moss]

Except just ran into a bug

Which I explained above

[hidden moss]

#rdo-chat

[civic widget]

Hmm, does that mean you can dual wield micah's revolver after epilogue 2?

[hidden moss]

I googled this, no

The game only records one instance of the revolvers existsnce

So if you try to get one in epilogue 2 if you already own it, you won't be able to pick it up

And I believe that's why when I failed and restarted the checkpoint in the strawberry jailbreak on ch2 I lost the gun

Because it gave the one instance back to micah, and hence deleted it from Arthur's inventory

[rain burrow]

I made it to chapter 6

[hidden moss]

Keep going

It's a good game I've beat it 5 times

[rain burrow]

This is my first playthrough and I can say this is my favorite game of all time

[hidden moss]

Definitely up there with black flag

[rain burrow]

I bought rdr 1 on my Xbox aswell so I can play it after beating 2

[hidden moss]

Good choice

[rain burrow]

I've played undead nightmare before but I've never played the base game before

[hidden moss]

Anyone know how to wake up people you knocked out?

Not in game but irl just like, give their chest a real hard noogie

[hidden moss]

Good to know, danke

[naive glen]

hogtie them

and put them on the back of your horse

they will start wiggling

[hidden moss]

Oh thanks

[keen nest]

Anyone else spend far more time playing dress up than actually playing missions?

[naive glen]

or money

more money on clothes before unlocking all guns

I unlocked almost every clothing I can unlock at this point

and im in chapter 2

[red helm]

I had a Cougar jump at me, literally feet north of Annesburg. Definitely took me by surprise.

[keen nest]

That too. I despise the fact that I cannot save more than 4 at a time even off the horse

[naive glen]

I mean

you can pay 1 $ fee

to hotels

and go and change outfit

idk

I usually have my usual outfit

with is a hot weather

and an outfit I'm currently working on

to assure cold protection

and the ghost bison coat and hat might be actually useful

[red helm]

To many of the cool clothes are for Cold weather, rather unfortunate.

[naive glen]

yea

which is why im going to live in annesburg

or amber

fuck dutch

[red helm]

I had a really cool all black outfit, but it was considered Cold weather only, so I couldn't wear it to often(Black bear chaps and such).

[deep spear]

ay

[keen nest]

I know I can change anywhere but sometimes I swap out outfits or make one on the fly and have to delete one to save it and if I don’t note the parts it’s a pain to make it again

[naive glen]

I use the same black basic boots

[red helm]

Indeed, way to many to remember all the names of.

[naive glen]

with halfchaps

the black leather ones

it looks decent enough to me

[naive glen]

I'm using everyday pants - black

with some black basic boots

and halfchaps

it is black and works wih things

[red helm]

Cool.

[keen nest]

I can’t add a pic but I use the black big city hat farrier jacket black opulent vest town black pants and wingtip gaiters. Looks fly

[red helm]

I think the Coyote hat is what I went with for the black outfit.. Frig if I remember the name of anything else though.

[naive glen]

coyote gambler hat

best hat

[keen nest]

I need a fit for the coyote hat. Still don’t have one yet

[keen nest]

I’m actively looking at mine

[red helm]

Yeap, that one. It's a Smidge small, but otherwise, it looks cool.

[naive glen]

it s a crafted hat

[red helm]

Wouldn't be surprised, I made a bunch of the Trapper clothing.

[keen nest]

A shame I can’t wear almost any trapper stuff in C3 without getting the “too hot” advisory

[naive glen]

just ignore it

[red helm]

Eh, don't "ignore" it, you go through a lot more food that way, keeping your cores full that way.

[naive glen]

who cares about food

it is literally everywhere

you can hunt a deer with revolver Cook it and have food for 3 days

[red helm]

It's like 5 times faster core lose when you're wearing the wrong weather clothes. But, whatever, up to the player if they want to deal with the hassle of eating more/healing more.

[naive glen]

I almost never eat

I m underweight

[red helm]

Ouf, The weight gaining mechanic isn't very good in this game.

[naive glen]

what are the benefits

less weight more stamina and less health

more weight more health less stamina

are they applying the 8mm bulletproof fat?

[red helm]

Yes, apparently fat makes you resistant to bullets.

[keen nest]

One day I’ll fat him super fat. I can barely keep him average though

[civic widget]

Anyone else usually forget about eating unless they're topping up cores?

My Arthur/John is always underweight.

[rain burrow]

I eat 3 times everyday in game and he's still super underweight

[mint stump]

Keeping up on weight in the game is hard asf sometimes, itll randomly shoot from average to underweight for no reason

[red helm]

The way to gain weight, Eat some food(Certain ones are better than others, like cook meat+herb, or chocolate bars). But then after you eat, you want to do a Cutscene(Sleep, Fast Travel, Mission), For your characters to actually update.

Until you do a Cutscene, it will not actually make any changes to your avatar.

[rain burrow]

Their was only like 1 time I was average weight

[mint stump]

Just eat a bunch of big game meat throught the in game day

[rain burrow]

I do

And I still am losing weight

[red helm]

There are actually Calories per each food you eat, and you can only benefit from X amounts, between Cutscene. I don't remember how much.

So, If you go a really long time between Cutscene, it'll be rough to gain weight.

[rain burrow]

I fast travel somewhere or sleep all the time so I get cutscenes often

[red helm]

Hrm... Odd. It's a weird system, and I always have troubles getting more then underweight as well.

[rain burrow]

I don't mind to much cause I'll take stamina over health 9 times out of 10

[mint stump]

Tbh after awhile it gets to be a pretty easy game stams definitely more important

[red helm]

But if Health goes to 0, Death, if Stamina goes to 0, you just have to stop and rest, no big deal.

But, not like it's a big deal, perfect weight is only something like a 15% boost. So not worth all the hassle.

Or.. whatever it is. If it was like 50%, or something significant, sure...

[hidden moss]

i never need stam

because i never run

why run when horse

well i did run on foot to get to my horse in a shootout in valentine. haha my bounty is 198 and im never paying it

thats in new hanover anyway

[chilly geyser]

Anyone here wants to be an odriscoll

[coral crane]

I shoot odriscolls on sight

[hidden moss]

being an odriscoll sounds shit

leader who doesnt care for you, constantly bullied by the van der lindes-

leader eventually gets hanged

[boreal stone]

Fr

It sucks to be them

And then ya got to fend for yourself without a leader

Sounds like shit

I love Alden the mailman

[boreal stone]

Same

[rain burrow]

When I see O'Driscolls in the wild I blow their heads off with a double barrel with slug rounds straight to the face

[hidden moss]

I typically try to duel them

cus you can lightly hold the fire button at any time to sort of do the duel thing

anyway since i lost micahs revolver i got my own double action and customized it

also customized a schofield for the same effects

now i duel wield them and duel with the double

[hidden moss]

Finally i got the legend of the east satchel

Time to buy 99 horse revives and health cures

[red helm]

Having more than like 10 Horse Revives on you at any one time is rather over kill. and then, if you like to explore, buying more than like 30-50 of anything else is also silly.

[naive glen]

yessssszs

[civic widget]

What about buying a shitton of premium cigarettes?

[naive glen]

so I m not the only one doing that

xD

[hidden moss]

i failed to tame the white arabian

sad times

i did get the legendary bison pelt

[naive glen]

how

xD

ride your horse next to it

jump on it

hold S and press A/D in the opposite direction of the horse's struggle

[hidden moss]

yeah i didnt know i had to hold back

it bucked me off, ran away and despawned

[acoustic spoke]

I always keep arthur fat in my opinion it looks better and the first thing I do when I spawn in is eat, I also go to saloons a lot and I eat there too

[cosmic epoch]

Eating is a thing?

[hidden moss]

I wonder what the coming chapters have for me, Arthur is amazing and I can't wait to finish the story...

[cosmic epoch]

Stay off here.

You will get spoiled.

[keen narwhal]

It’s not worth going on tik tok or here

[ember marsh]

Is the map in rdr1 the same as rdr2?

[proud zephyr]

i never played rdr1 but, im pree sure its like diff

cuz theres no mexico in rdr2(kinda)

new austins prob the same tho

[languid pecan]

Only the new austin area

[hidden moss]

i'm assuming if there was an actual mexico in rdr2 it'd be the same too

[languid pecan]

there was supposed to be mexico in rdr2, that's why there's the building. But later r* decided to cut it

[proud zephyr]

u can still _go_to mexico

technically

[languid pecan]

yep, there's the glitch

u can also go to guarma

[hidden moss]

it's not modeled fully though

[naive glen]

howwwwwwwwww

i want back to communism

[languid pecan]

there're many tutorials on yt

[naive glen]

ah

glitches

ya

[calm crow]

Rains falls a hippy

[hidden moss]

I would say is well modeled but not detailed (all the borders of the map are like these, far they see perfect but once you try to reach the edge, you can see there is not big details. mainly because that are not places you "can"go (you can verify these in north border, easter "river" zone border, south+ south east Rio Brabo etc

[naive glen]

one must not pass by free gun oil
one must clean weapon and then collect it

[fading adder]

kieran’s death really made me sad

and genuinely drove my rage for the o’driscolls, i still wish kieran lasted longer though

[languid pecan]

Yea he definitely deserved a better ending

well, not only kieran

[gloomy ingot]

best way to gain honor in rdr2 chapter 6? I cant donate any money

[fading adder]

yeah..

sean, he had a great personality

[desert coral]

Kick strauss out of camp

[gloomy ingot]

yeah ive already done all the story

[desert coral]

oh

[gloomy ingot]

I want max honor before I do last mission

[desert coral]

i honestly dont know

greet people or chance encounters

[fading adder]

yeah same, except in general

ive greeted like 100 people in saint denis

and i havent gone up a single level in honor

does your honor gain faster in the later chapters?

[gloomy ingot]

well I know theres a cap in the earlier chapters

you cant get max honor before chapter 6

I had to find out the hard way by donating 1000 dollars in the donation box

[hushed trout]

could someone help me understand how my bounty will work out

i got a bounty of 158 and id like to try to rob the sidehustle for the doctor in valentie

if i pay off my bounty then try to rob it with my disguise (Different clothing and a mask on), will the lawmen instantly recognize me because i had a bounty previously

also for some reason im getting bounty hunters every now and then but im not arrested when seen by the sheriff and lawmen in town

if anyone knows why

[hidden moss]

from blackwater east the rdr1 map is the same. Rdr1 doesnt have any of new hanover, ambarino, or lemoyne, or anything north of blackwater like strwarberry. Rdr1 also doesn't have Guarma, but it does have mexico. If you go out of bounds south of new austin in rdr2 you can see that the layout of mexico is still there, just without roads and towns, indicating that mexico was possibly a part of the story that got cut in development. This is also backed up by the fact that arthur has unique dialogue in new Austin, showing that he was intended to travel there early in development.

Another cool detail is the sheer amount of detail going out of bounds north in Ambarino. Theres no towns or roads but there is just so much detailed land that it seems like they planned to make ambarino bigger, or put canada in the game

[naive glen]

nope

lawmen see right through the mask

it only works for civillians

lawmen can ignore it

[naive glen]

if the bounty hunters spawned, u re unable to do any other interaction untill they re gone

or until you get captured/ u die

[hidden moss]

I had a bounty hunter spawn while taking out an odriscol camp

turns out bounty hunters will kill odriscols

got plenty of money from looting those guys

[sleek sundial]

theres even a whole building in mexico just no floors, only walls

[hidden moss]

Is there any way I can avoid the end of the game

I don't really want that one

[hidden moss]

just dont do the saint denis bank robbery and be in ch4 for eternity

[hidden moss]

John>Arthur>Jack

thats my protagonist ranking

i cant rank red harlow cus i havent played red dead revolver

either way revolver isnt in the redemption world

[naive glen]

arthur>john

[naive glen]

dont ever rescue micah

u wont ever have an off hand holster

everything is good and nice

[hidden moss]

better yet

dont go to mr downes to get the debt

you'll never get TB, but you'll be stuck in ch2 forever

[acoustic spoke]

I like ch3 a little more, I'm just not doing the mission with Micah for the robbery

so he isn't in camp

the 2 holsters annoy me tho

[naive glen]

actually

it is not achoice

i didnt go to any debtors except for the polish guyc

cause i had to

and after a few days strauss forced me to go

[next ember]

[cosmic epoch]

yessir

You just get 100%

And then Arthur resurrects himself, gets his lungs removed and put on life support like Darth Vader

[naive glen]

bruv

[naive glen]

yes it is

[cosmic epoch]

what

[naive glen]

stop doing story missions

[cosmic epoch]

I’m clearly speaking the truth to this man or madam

[naive glen]

i mean

even after i finished

the story mode

i didnt go to desert

new austin

blackwater

i stood in the exact same areas

i used to run with arthur

so there s no point

[smoky cipher]

should I play again the whole story?

[naive glen]

if you have tons of time to spare sure

[cosmic epoch]

Did you guys not get the ending where Arthur gets resurrected in early 2000’s and out on life support like Vader?

[naive glen]

btw, make sure you do every discovery possible

before advancing to a new chapter

[smoky cipher]

I will

[naive glen]

you have to do the satchels before c6

[royal niche]

Does anyone have an account for me

[naive glen]

otherwise u ll never be able to do them again

[cosmic epoch]

wym

You can literally buy them from fence in van horn

[smoky cipher]

I want to play as arthur again I will do every secondary mission and stay in ch4 forever

[naive glen]

wait

can i buy them

during the

[cosmic epoch]

yes in epilogue

[naive glen]

arthur being alive

[cosmic epoch]

Epilogue only

[naive glen]

oh

wish i knew that sooner

nvm

[cosmic epoch]

I only play as John anyways

[naive glen]

also

when u go to guarma

make sure you do everything you have to

you cant go back

[cosmic epoch]

Tbh I think the fun I get out of using the companion glitch is dope

like fr fr going to valentine after doing that is really fun

[smoky cipher]

Going to restart the game go to valentine kill everyone and continue the story missions and stay in ch4 forever

[hidden moss]

Lol gl

[cosmic epoch]

you’re missing Sean tho

[lucid trellis]

Oh god, my last boy is next

[cosmic epoch]

W

Shooting up an oil factory is such a W

[lucid trellis]

Just gonna go feed arthur a shit ton of food and whiskey and give him a bath

[naive glen]

to make him fat

what's the minimum amount you can donate

to get the maximum honor

[cosmic epoch]

Fat Arthur with TB is about normal skinny

[naive glen]

ah i see

[cosmic epoch]

lol

I mean they had to portray it correctly

And a sign of tuberculosis is losing weight and struggling to gain it

[hidden moss]

donate to camp 21 dollars at a time

it seems to be most efficient for honour gaining

21 gives more honour than 20

[naive glen]

bruh i need to buy things worth about 400

it will take me ages

[hidden moss]

rob a train lol

get a train to annesburg, then ride ahead of it and when it sets off rob it

[naive glen]

i ll just donate

all at once

[hidden moss]

that way if you get a bounty it will be in ambarino

[naive glen]

btw which one is the upgrade for fast travel

[hidden moss]

also get explosive ammo so you can open the vaults on the train

[hidden moss]

arthurs lodging

[normal relic]

Robbing trains lol

[naive glen]

imagine robbing trains

when i can go treasure hunting

[normal relic]

I like robbing the shops

[naive glen]

or use my 10 gold bars i already have

[naive glen]

do you also rob a sho

shop

after u buy things

from it

?

XD

you can get a maximum of 50$ back

[normal relic]

Yes i did that to the tailor in saint denis lol

[naive glen]

lmao

btw

[normal relic]

I bought new clothes turned around and robbed him

[naive glen]

having as much money as possible in saint denis before entering the shop is a must

[normal relic]

I did it as John lol

[naive glen]

in one of the first encounters

you get mugged

[hidden moss]

robbing trains can get you like a good 300

[naive glen]

by a douche

[hidden moss]

per train

[hushed trout]

does anyone know why law officers in towns won't arrest me even tho I got a bounty in that state

[normal relic]

I've tried robbing a train

[hushed trout]

in rdr2

[normal relic]

It's hard

[naive glen]

and the game gives you a procentual part of the money it stole in addition to your money back

[naive glen]

and your honor drops to 0

[hidden moss]

lol raising honour is easy tho

[normal relic]

Lol

True

[hidden moss]

just take a ride to saint denis

and talk to EVERYONE

[hushed trout]

anyone know why ^

[naive glen]

it's boring

[normal relic]

I can rob as many trains with John

[naive glen]

btw

did you hunt any rabbits

[normal relic]

Nope

[hidden moss]

the easiest thing to do for money imo is to just hunt bison and sell the pelt

[naive glen]

when u had to get rabbit pelt for the camp

i usually just wait near the butchering table

and someone will come and drop by a perfect quality rabbit

[normal relic]

I gotta try robbing a train as John

[naive glen]

;D

do it in the north

in a long tunnel

with no roads

[normal relic]

Up by Barrcus Station

Oh i know that long tunnel that's way up in Ambarino

[bleak charm]

can someone help me by verifying this issue? with the 516.40 driver, there is flickering inside Beecher's Hope. I've posted a video showing the issue in #red-dead-media

[normal relic]

I'll go check it out

[bleak charm]

thanks!

[normal relic]

Your welcome! I'll try to help the best I can

[smoky cipher]

Which chapter should I not finish in rdr2 as arthur

[naive glen]

2

do all things you can do up to the point when there s nothing left

[hushed trout]

y

[naive glen]

otherwise, go to chapter 4 before robbing the bank

[normal relic]

I've never seen that before that's weird that it flickers in Beechers Hope

[bleak charm]

it started happening to me yesterday after installing the 516.40 driver

then after installing 512.95 (the previous one) it stopped

[hushed trout]

does anyone know why law officers won't arrest me even tho I got a bounty

[bleak charm]

then started happening again after I installed 516.40

as shown in the video

[normal relic]

I wonder if that's the issue is that driver looks like it's causing the game to do that

[hidden moss]

Wait im in Ch 4

[bleak charm]

did you check it?

[naive glen]

are chores at the camp any useful

[normal relic]

Maybe your bounty isn't high enough

[hushed trout]

Why

[hidden moss]

Gets you honor

[hushed trout]

It's at

132

Dollars

I get bounty hunters

But in the city no one cares

[naive glen]

is it worth it?

[naive glen]

as long as you dont comit crimes nobody does

[hidden moss]

Kinda but not really

[hushed trout]

Not even sheriff?

[naive glen]

and bounty hunters are less likely to attack you in a town

[normal relic]

I watched it twice I'm still trying to figure out what could cause the flickering

[hushed trout]

I looked at him after I stabbed his progeny in the chest

He didn't care

Also

If I rob a bank will they know its me

Even with disguise

[bleak charm]

I was thinking you'd check it in-game, but then noticed that you're on xbox so I guess not xD

[cosmic epoch]

Bounty number doesn’t matter

If you have a bounty

You immediately get recognised

[hushed trout]

What if I pay it off then do it

Still get instant recognized?

[normal relic]

Lol yes I'm on xbox I never had that happen xD

[bleak charm]

I already contacted NVidia over this in multiple ways so I'm hoping it'll get escalated

[normal relic]

I hope they somehow fix it that's just insane what that type of driver did to the game

[hushed trout]

If I pay off a bounty then rob a bank do I get immediately recognized still?

[bleak charm]

drivers be like that sometimes I guess

[normal relic]

I guess so I don't play pc so idk lol

[bleak charm]

now the most important thing is that they acknowledge the issue

[normal relic]

But i tried helping even tho I'm on xbox

I've never experienced flickering on xbox

[bleak charm]

thanks

[normal relic]

Your welcome

Xbox sometimes has glitches in game too

I've had invisible strangers riding on their horses

[unborn hollow]

u can rob a bank?

[naive glen]

#red-dead-media

if anybody cares

[unborn hollow]

if u rob a shop i believe u dont gett caught

[naive glen]

i managed to stop a train

without getting a bounty

[normal relic]

I think you can rob banks idk

[naive glen]

with no guards in it

how do i rob it properly

[normal relic]

I've robbed the tailor and i got caught in Saint Denis

[naive glen]

what should i be looking for

[normal relic]

To rob a train?

[naive glen]

yea

[unborn hollow]

my honor after robbing a train ↘️↘️↘️↘️

[naive glen]

#red-dead-media

it's a cargo train

those that just run through cities without stopping

i managed to stop one without getting a bounty

[unborn hollow]

they worth tho?

[naive glen]

idk

im trying to find out

nothing found

[unborn hollow]

they have jewellery i believe

[naive glen]

other than a few cans of food

i still have 2 wagons to check

yup

nothing but a few cans of food

and a little ammo

[unborn hollow]

RIP

[normal relic]

Those aren't worth anything

You need to rob the trains with the people on it

[naive glen]

#red-dead-media

i feel allmighty and powerful now

[unborn hollow]

robbing a train is @$$ i believe

[normal relic]

Nice

[naive glen]

fuck

i can't do it

[normal relic]

I robbed the Tailor lol

Go rob the shopkeepers

[naive glen]

all i want is

and i cant

without becoming wanted

what a shame

[hushed trout]

Ye I think so

[cosmic epoch]

Robbing trains suck balls

[naive glen]

banks are robbable during missions

[hidden moss]

how do you do a robbery without getting a wanted level

ive only done it once

[hushed trout]

U mean bounty

[hidden moss]

and i think it was because no one walked in the store during the robbery

[cosmic epoch]

The cops detect you in seconds once you start a robbery

[hushed trout]

Oh

[cosmic epoch]

Regardless of what you do

You get a witness

[hidden moss]

when i start a robbery I often start fine, but someone walks in and becomes a witness

[hushed trout]

If u pay off ur bounty and then do a robbery will u get instantly recognized

[cosmic epoch]

Window with no shops = witness seeing you through non existent window

[unborn hollow]

if u rob a train yes

[hidden moss]

i had one time in lemoyne where i robbed the general store and got away with no wanted level

or bounty

i think its because no one walked in and saw

[hushed trout]

How much train give

[hidden moss]

specifically rhodes-

[hidden moss]

around 300

if you open the vaults

[hushed trout]

How much is the bounty from it

[unborn hollow]

its risky

[naive glen]

and the bounty a lot

[hidden moss]

i know a trick to make the bounty negligible

or just not happen

[unborn hollow]

i often get around 100

[naive glen]

there are tips and tricks

on youtube

[hidden moss]

get a train to annesburg

[naive glen]

on how to rob a train without getting a bounty

[hushed trout]

They all old

[hidden moss]

then from annesburg rob the train when it leaves

[hushed trout]

From 3 years ago

[hidden moss]

youll be robbing it in ambarino

[naive glen]

it's a single player

game

bro

[hidden moss]

where the bounty doesnt really matter

[hushed trout]

So

[unborn hollow]

robbing a car then selling it is better

it is lame tho

[cosmic epoch]

There is no ambarino bounty

[hushed trout]

Don't they patch stuff

[naive glen]

btw

any clue where small game arrows disappear

[hushed trout]

Wut u mean

[unborn hollow]

am i the only one who hasnt crafted anything 😂😅

[normal relic]

I can never rob trains

Idk if they disappear

Your not the only one Jack

[hushed trout]

Also seriously does anyone know if u still get instant recognized if u just paid off a bounty and are robbing in the same state

[normal relic]

I never crafted much in story

I don't think you do Leo

[unborn hollow]

wear a mask leo

[hushed trout]

I did

But I hear it doesn't work sometimes

[normal relic]

Hm?

[hushed trout]

That if you wear the same clothing

It doesn't matter

[unborn hollow]

what did u rob leo

[normal relic]

Maybe your game is glicthed or something

[hushed trout]

I killed 40 lawmen

[normal relic]

Try changing different clothes

[hushed trout]

Does it work?

[normal relic]

Oh

[unborn hollow]

u will get recognized for a mass shooting

[normal relic]

Yep

[unborn hollow]

for robberies no

[hushed trout]

Ik

Ok

[unborn hollow]

for killing yes

[hushed trout]

What about knock out

Or hogtie

[unborn hollow]

if its in a remote area

[normal relic]

I got wanted for robbing the tailor in Saint Denis

[unborn hollow]

a hotgie can be recognizes as kidnapping

[hushed trout]

Ok also

[normal relic]

Yes

[hushed trout]

What if I don't have bounty and I'm in the investigative area

Do they auto arrest

[normal relic]

No I don't think

[hushed trout]

If they don't have a bright red witness

Ok thanks

[naive glen]

#red-dead-media

[normal relic]

Your welcome

[naive glen]

the trains is now human lifeforms free

[normal relic]

Lol boogey nice

[naive glen]

and i have a free 60$ bounty

[unborn hollow]

if u have witteneses try cathing the slap them one time and then threat them 😅

[normal relic]

i thought about hoping on rdr2 for just a bit

Lol Jack

Threating them is funnt

[naive glen]

#red-dead-media

i suppose these are the good loot rooms

where should i look exactly

[unborn hollow]

also if u leave a hotgie in the ground witnesses wil nlt recognise it as a kidnapping i believe

but if u stow them in a horse then yes

unles they are criminal u caught as a bounty hounter of course

[naive glen]

so i blowed up a few vaults

and i got 85 bucks

[normal relic]

Loot them

[naive glen]

aproximatively

[normal relic]

nice

[naive glen]

and a 60 bounty

and then out of nowehre im wanted again

and cops show out of nowhere

and i have 110$ bounty now

if this isnt what dinamite is for, then what's its purpose

[unborn hollow]

rip

[hidden moss]

you can use explosive ammo too

but you need to craft that

youll need to buy the recipe from a fence after ch4

and you need a lot of animal fat

[naive glen]

what

isnt' that craftable

from ch2

i crafted 5 revolver explosive ammo

[hidden moss]

huh

[naive glen]

i think that some recipes are already owned

[hidden moss]

maybe you can craft it without the recipe

[naive glen]

like split point ammo

or explosive

it is a recipe

[hidden moss]

maybe

[naive glen]

i checked

idk

i might as well found them

while treasure hunting

btw

am i the only one thinking that varmint rifle's sound effects from normal and dead eye are swapped?

i just have one question

where does seamus have enough money to buy 8 gold bars from me

[hidden moss]

from all those wagons duh

[frail kernel]

i rarely used the wagon fence except for bandit challenges

[dense zodiac]

Hey huh I'm playing rn, just hunting and...I just heard a loud woman screaming but there's nothing around? Only deers and sheep. It's in the middle of the day too 💀
Has anyone had this happening to them? I thought it was another random encounter but there's nothing about it online

[smoky cipher]

Can someone tell me an interesting place to go

[opal lark]

Is the bay arabian in single player because i can’t seem to find it

I just found the all black American standard bred where i was told to look instead

[hidden moss]

300 in west elizabeth in ch2

the micah breakout mission did it

[naive glen]

bruh

it is 100

i got 100 and i shot all cops

[opal lark]

Are either the warped brindle or bay arabian in single player

[naive glen]

what

[hidden moss]

i got like 200 dollars once

or twice

it is easy to get a high bounty in saint denis

[hidden moss]

well mine is 300

and ive done nothing but that mission in west elizabeth

other than that though, its 198 in new hanover

i might have robbed a store in valentine and shot all of the police-

[ember marsh]

Wouldn't Canada be too far? Like the game takes place in South of so Canada would be very far

[hidden moss]

true

[frail kernel]

well north of ambarino is wyoming

[civic widget]

That's a random encounter. It's a guy kidnapping a woman and she's hogtied on a horse he's riding

[deft flint]

something I’ll always remember

I gave a blind man some change

he told me something that foreshadowed Arthur’s fate

something along the lines of

do any good in the world before it’s too late or something like that

[jovial notch]

Damn

[deft flint]

@jovial notch you pinged me?

[hidden moss]

nah it was me sorry, I was replying saying that Blind Man Cassidy has a bunch of lines for both Arthur and John but I guess it got deleted because I used a spoiler

[jovial notch]

Huh

[midnight dawn]

Yeah he's some sort of angel or something, you can meet him multiple times being the last with john where he'll tell him how he's gonna die

Oh and i just found out if you take a picture of the strange man's cabin on the photo it'll say "serial killer"

[deft flint]

oh I had a theory of the strange man being responsible for the events of RDR2-RDR1

[midnight dawn]

Maybe it's some sort of ghost rider shits lmao he's some devil signing contracts with people

[deft flint]

basically the theory revolved around the Old Testament, the Blackwater incident and Arthur and John’s findings of the Strange Man

wanna hear it?

[midnight dawn]

Sure

[deft flint]

quick question, do you know what happened in Blackwater?

[midnight dawn]

The massacre? I would love to hear the theories

[deft flint]

yeah so @frail kernel made a theory that there was a rat in the gang before Micah (which he said was Abigail)

his evidence due to ingame dialogue and etc

considering the Pinkertons arrived too quickly

[midnight dawn]

Yeah dutch implied that in guarma before strangling the old lady

[deft flint]

and Dutch said it himself someone must of set it up

so I thought to myself

what if the Strange Man had something to do with the incident?

In Arthur’s journal he writes about someone that resembles Trelawny being sighted in Blackwater

which was the strange man

he seems to know everything before it happens

so what if he gave a Pinkertons a tip about the ferry job

[midnight dawn]

Yeah but what for, what did he do exactly and why would he choose to look like trelawny

[deft flint]

The Strange Man being a supernatural entity, I assume it’s to claim their souls to be damned

the ferry job set the downfall for the gang

and the deaths of most of its members

[midnight dawn]

That does sound reasonable, great theory but unfortunately we'll never get to know 😭

[deft flint]

I have a theory of him being God as well

[hidden moss]

just finished the Jim Boy Calloway mission

[frail kernel]

ill admit it's a lot of implications

and it only makes sense until about chapter 6

[midnight dawn]

Apparently this trelawny thing is a big thing online. A lot of people suspect that he is the strange man but can't decide between if the strange man can alter his looks or if that Trelawny is his embodiment.

But i think it's not the latter since the strange man is invulnerable unlike trelawny who got his shit beat and has dipped from the camp at the end because he has a family

[frail kernel]

the only thing in common is how they dress which is pretty much identical

other than that it's pretty obvious they aren't the same

[deft flint]

The Strange Man is more pale

he mentioned he had a son in RDR1

Trelawny also has a son

[hidden moss]

why is my scout jacket glitching out

the texture

[hidden moss]

today i saw the ending of undead nightmare

that feels really underwhelming lol

[midnight dawn]

Maybe he's been marching on earth for god knows how long, and the blind man is just one of his other incarnations.

[hidden moss]

they fix the zombie crisis only for it to pop up again with John as a zombie too

feels meh

[deft flint]

John can control himself tho

[hidden moss]

ik but still

kinda whack

[deft flint]

wanna hear about my theory of him being God?

[midnight dawn]

Yeah, go on

[deft flint]

alr note how when John shot the man 3 times

3 bullets
1- Uncle
2-John
3-Abigail

the final bullet represented Jack

but that’s irrelevant

but there’s a saying in the Bible

striking God and God strikes back sevenfold

believe it or not, John was killed with 21 bullets

3 x 7 = 21

[midnight dawn]

You got some impressive thinking haha

[deft flint]

my 2nd evidence

Herbert Moon and Armadillo

Herbert hinted he was the founder of the ghost town

Strange Man gave Herbert two choices

happiness or two generations

since Herbert picked the other choice

Armadillo was punished with a plague due to Herbert’s sins / choice

similar to how God punished Egypt with the 10 plagues due to the Pharaoh’s sins

[midnight dawn]

Who's herbert moon?

[deft flint]

the shopkeeper in armadillo

[frail kernel]

how do you know

[deft flint]

I told you before

[frail kernel]

i remember asking and u went “uh well i think it was”

like its an interesting theory but

[deft flint]

check dms

[frail kernel]

youd have to clip the scene and slow it

[frail kernel]

not all 15 were in the frame

and its up to the player how many die

[deft flint]

which is why I said 14-15

the player could of decided to kill some

or none at all

[frail kernel]

u can kill more than 1

[deft flint]

before getting shot down

[frail kernel]

right but

still, it doesnt show all of them in the cutscene where they fire

nvm

i mean

what im trying to say is

[deft flint]

it does from a side angle

[frail kernel]

how do u like

[deft flint]

if you kill some you can see the bodies from that angle

[frail kernel]

count each shot when they fire multiple shots per person, the player can kill multiple, and they fire at the same time

[deft flint]

how do I know that it was exactly 21 and not any other number?

imagine this scenario

where the player decides not to shoot at any Pinkertons

and instead gets lit up

there’s around 14 to 15 Pinkertons shooting at you

[frail kernel]

yea

[deft flint]

it’s 15 right

[frail kernel]

16 if u shoot no one

not including ross

[deft flint]

So 17 Pinkertons in total if we include Ross

but yeah 16

[frail kernel]

yea but ross isnt shown shooting

[deft flint]

now each 16 guards shoot at you

[frail kernel]

though he took out his revolver

[deft flint]

note how in the cutscene

5 more shots are fired

if you count them

[frail kernel]

wdym

like in the frame where they show john being hit?

[deft flint]

yeah

[frail kernel]

well u said yourself

the pinkertons fired more than once

each one

they shot 1-3 times

shit

wait

[deft flint]

?

[frail kernel]

nvm

counting the shots in the scene rn

yeah

it depends how many you kill

you can get shot only like

15 times

still cool theory though

if R* made it so that no matter what, 21 bullets were fired

itd be a lot more plausible

[deft flint]

word of advice

always pay attention to the smallest details

but my RDO character is a better protagonist than Arthur and John

no cap

[naive glen]

any tips on clearing the hideout from hanging dog ranch

[hidden moss]

use cover and tonics

and dead eye

[naive glen]

ran straight into the house

it was the guy with the machine gun shooting me through crates

[fading adder]

does arthur become uncomfortable when you ride in the rain as opposed to normally?

[boreal wave]

You guys ever be on a mission and then when one of your companions takes the reigns on the wagon they just...sit there?

[ebon rock]

Does anyone know a consistent cougar spawn location i have been looking for 2 days

[hybrid oasis]

I have mods for on and every time I open the game in closes at the rockstar opening, why?

[wise gazelle]

next to lake ouwanjila

river that's west of the trapper

[hidden moss]

Cougars should spawn in around Black Bone Forest, Gaptooth Ridge, Cholla Springs, Great Plains, Northern Roanoke Ridge, and sometimes in Southern New Hanover

Oh yeah, for Panthers, they typically spawn outside of Braithwaite Manor if you're interested

[ebon rock]

Nothing spawns there, or anywhere in that region.

[cosmic epoch]

aww sweet! A schizo thread

[cosmic epoch]

I don’t know lmao

Once you lose like the tiniest bit of your health core

Arthur starts scrunching his face up in pain

[wise gazelle]

use bait its my go to spot

[sonic fractal]

Hai

[lilac bramble]

if I decide to replay a mission and complete the requirements for gold, will it register?

[lavish acorn]

Hello,

do you guys know whether the gambler 9 glicht still works?

(standing up from the table and entering a new game without the streak being lost)

[native meteor]

whats the point in buying newspaper ?

[jovial notch]

Some bits at some points have things that relate to the gang, and end game but I’m not going to spoil it

[native meteor]

how do you read a newspaper?

i only found out how to buy them

[lilac bramble]

open ur pouch and select them

[floral island]

question for anyone to answer

Was Arthur a good person?

[lilac bramble]

generally yes, but that also depends on what u do

[acoustic spoke]

YES I finally got the skunk hat I was literally on my way to the trapper to sell a perfect alligator pelt and I encountered a perfect skunk

[native meteor]

im on chapter 4 atm

is it too late to increase my honour or

[native meteor]

how do i open that

[lilac bramble]

hold b

[cosmic epoch]

Why wouldn’t it?

[cosmic epoch]

No lmao

He killed hundreds and hundreds in the missions Atleast

God knows what happened before 1899

[zinc wharf]

instead of putting pomade on my hair in the saint denis barber

i made arthur bald

[jovial notch]

You press R or whatever button is prompts to read

[cosmic epoch]

Give him a goatee

Heisenberg.

[zinc wharf]

luckily i saved up on facial hair so hes gonna look like walter white now

was doing it on the mission where they play cards in the river boat

[cosmic epoch]

good job

[native meteor]

i catched a criminal

where do i put him?

[cosmic epoch]

catched?

[cosmic epoch]

Sheriffs office

lol

[native meteor]

oh ok

[lilac bramble]

I believe I tried long ago but it didnt work out

[jovial notch]

No and yes. To us, he was amazing and we worship him, but really to everyone else outside of the gang, robbing banks? Killing other people (like the o’ Driscolls, other people like civilians don’t know what they’ve done to deserve death) having massive shootouts in towns like black water… but all of that stuff was justified within the gang but not outside of it

[cosmic epoch]

It should work

[cosmic epoch]

When you think about it outside of Arthur’s POV

[lilac bramble]

trying do do 100%, really hope so

[jovial notch]

He’s evil

[cosmic epoch]

It’s clear he wasn’t a good guy Atleast until the end when he had good intentions

[floral island]

He also robbed many people

Like the mission with Hosea

[cosmic epoch]

he was good at the end but that was a little late 💀

[floral island]

They stole that wagon from a guy and robbed his house

[jovial notch]

He had good intentions for the gang

[cosmic epoch]

yeah

[jovial notch]

but really think about it as the Pinkertons

[cosmic epoch]

As I said prior

[jovial notch]

or anyone else

[cosmic epoch]

During RDR2

He killed hundreds and hundreds

[floral island]

He died for the gang pretty much, when he got diagnosed he could've left, went to New Austin and rested - probably would've survived. Instead he chose to stick around and do jobs and shit for the gang

[jovial notch]

Yep

[cosmic epoch]

Before 1899 how many others did he kill and or rob

[floral island]

Can't count the Blackwater Massacre as I believe he wasn't involved too much in that

[lilac bramble]

almost all he did he did it for a reason, so I think its a tie

[jovial notch]

Well rockstar did a perfect way of getting us to think he’s the good guy even when he’s bad

[cosmic epoch]

iirc Chapter 6 has a few cut files of where you escape w John

And are on the run

[floral island]

He robbed civilians 🤷

Killed civilians

[jovial notch]

like they made us feel bad for him, like Micah killing his son and wife