red-dead-singleplayer

[grim flint]

Okay

Thank you

[red helm]

Did you input a Cheat Code? Because that disables your ability to save.

[gloomy ingot]

nope, didnt know there were cheat codes

the problem seemed to be being in the camp, no idea why

[red helm]

Huh, odd.... Buggy darn game.

[wise gazelle]

Hunter 10 is done 🙂

dont check this disc cause the game will be spoiled lol

[grim flint]

Kk

[tame cairn]

Hello, I apologize if this isn't the right place to ask questions, but I'm trying to solve a problem I am having with playing RDR2. I tried looking online for a solution, but nothing is working, so I joined here in hopes for an answer in the community.
I am trying to play the single player mode offline, with no internet connection, however, when I do, the game starts up with text and it says "Activation Error" or something, I bought the game on Steam. Is there a way to play the game without an internet connection..?

[slow fjord]

I don't think there is actually because of the rockstar launcher needing to be online to start up the game

[tame cairn]

Ah I see, might as well just play with the connection on then. Or just connect to the internet and as soon as it authorizes I turn the connection off

[slow fjord]

Yeah

[tame cairn]

Thanks for the answer

[wicked cove]

rdr2 is really laggy for me at 5 fps after a dozen or so hours at 60+ fps on a 3060 is there anyway I can fix this?

I already reinstalled graphics drivers, reset all graphics to default etc

Even setting everything to the lowest it stutters allot and before I had everything on ultra

[wicked cove]

Start game offilne exit, steam offiline mode then try?

Nvm it was using wrong gpu?

[vale sky]

Hi

[slow fjord]

hello

[cosmic epoch]

You already made your first mistake

Looking stuff up about the game

That is how you get spoiled

[swift forge]

i finished chapter 1, killed 3 deer and bought like 10 pieces of beef from the butcher in valentine and apperently thats still not enough to make the food icon white for my camp

[cosmic epoch]

💀

Camp ledger

restock

[swift forge]

…im not supposed to donate to the butcher

[cosmic epoch]

It really doesn’t matter tbh it doesn’t have an impact besides Susan biting you out

[cosmic epoch]

That is one way to do it

But another way is what I just said

camp ledger > food > restock

[swift forge]

i see

[cosmic epoch]

it comes out of camp funds

[swift forge]

ok

[cosmic epoch]

Another tip

Don’t search anything up abt the game

I wouldn’t come here til you’ve finished the game either

Because you could be spoiled

[swift forge]

ive already got the ending spoiled thanks to tiktok 😁😁

[cosmic epoch]

💀

That is why

You never search anything up

About a game

You’re still playing

[swift forge]

yeah

it was some edit

[fiery turtle]

rip

[swift forge]

its ok ill probably still cry when i get to said point

[cosmic epoch]

Ironically

Getting spoiled was what made me play RDR2’s main story

💀

[swift forge]

i didnt even know it had a story i just thought it looked fun

so i got it

[wise gazelle]

finished all rock carvings + all dreamcatchers, got some of the other challenges done, might just play some more missions

[rain burrow]

Nice

[fluid vector]

Damn a side quest from a stranger a woman that ask for a ride, cause her horse is dying and what horse she use? A dang missiori fox trotter

[violet osprey]

Question: when youre leveling up your stats, for me it says "Level 8", but "bonus stat: 2/2" is this really mean level 10?

Cause i just need to finish the last 4 gambler challenges and ill get 2/2 bonus stamina. Idk if that means i have full stats or not though

Ik my base stats are fully leveled up

[civic widget]

Yes. you get your bonus stats from purchasing full sets from the challenges.

[violet osprey]

Yeah i just wasnt sure if those counted as "maximum stats" for that portion of the 100%

[hidden moss]

Where can I post Picture screenshot

[versed smelt]

#red-dead-media

[minor skiff]

People who play rdr on pc: how do u fish? Fishing with mouse is hard tho

[civic widget]

I press r a ton then reel intermittently while holding the rod parallel to the water. When a fish bites I hook it with the mouse and move the rod up with the mouse while reeling, stopping to move the rod based on movement if it's a big fish struggling. While I'm reeling, I constantly move the rod down and up quickly so I can drag it in faster.

[wise gazelle]

Finished the gambler challenges, went pretty well actually

[civic widget]

I admit, I cheated a little bit on five finger filet by writing up a macro for it 😛

[wise gazelle]

you only have to beat the first player haha that's just alternating two buttons x)

[wise gazelle]

I did quit the table after winning two matches of dominoes

not about to lose that streak lol

[hidden moss]

dutch straight up just said "fuck you" to arthur in a random encounter i got and that made me chuckle a good bit

[solemn saddle]

Hahaha

[gloomy ingot]

whats the fastest way to gain honor?

[hidden moss]

Hunt animals or do bounties

[wooden skiff]

Yo guys

Also you can throw fish back to the water @gloomy ingot

[wise gazelle]

saying hello to people in St Denis

[swift canyon]

how does hunting give you honor

[hidden moss]

When you skin the animal it gives you a bit of honor

[swift canyon]

never happened to me before

unless you mean in online

[hidden moss]

Donate to camp or just greet a bunch of people

[cosmic epoch]

Fastest is the missions

[gloomy ingot]

what kind?

[cosmic epoch]

Second fastest is probably fish lol

Or greeting

[cosmic epoch]

there’s quite a few in chapter 6 that increase honour

I know there’s one in epilogue that increases honour a considerable amount

[gloomy ingot]

I kinda want it as quick as possible

im only on chapter 3

[cosmic epoch]

Well your honour is capped until chapter 6

🗿

Awful game design when you have outfits locked behind honour

[gloomy ingot]

wait WHAT

so i spent a thousand dollars on the camp for nothing?

ffs

[cosmic epoch]

lol

[acoustic spoke]

Uhh a month or so ago I had max honor in chapter 2

[cosmic epoch]

doubt

[calm crow]

Am i the only one noticed How confused Micah looked when Molly snitched on herself😂

[rough verge]

Guys

How do I buy red dead

While hiding it from parents

[slow fjord]

Just save up some money and buy it physically

You'll probably get a code for the game

[rough verge]

How am I supposed to buy it if every store can’t sell to underage

[slow fjord]

And besides most stores don't give a shit about your age

[rough verge]

Oh ok then

[slow fjord]

I got rdr2 even though I'm underage

[silent parcel]

that motherfucker dutch just walked away like nothing

that feels like such a plothole bruh

I mean its obvious why but bruh

[calm crow]

Yeah

[cosmic epoch]

Just save up the money for a gift card

All it would say is that you redeemed one I’d imagine

[plain nova]

If they add director mode it would make the game 1mx better

Imagine all the freedom

Playing as a native

Or hunting down animals as a bear, a croc or even a wolf

Heck being a jaguar

Just the freedom in the first place

But well

It sure ain't happening

Game came out 2018

Its 2022 now...

[lament dock]

anyone know how to fix the flickering directx12?

[silent parcel]

what

why do I have the exact same mission with mr black and white again with john

seems to be a common bug

[calm crow]

Or playing as dutch

[rough verge]

If you pay with a gift card on your own account but your dads account is linked will it send him an email?

[cosmic epoch]

well I’d imagine it would send him a receipt

Your only option in that case is to buy it physically

[winged mango]

when do I unlock manual saving?

im at the part where we raid the odriscolls by the laek

[steel night]

eastward bound i think

[rough verge]

Bout to start red dead let’s see if it’s good

[glad tinsel]

Arthur likes jack

[rough verge]

Alr

[unkempt kelp]

Why do horses kick me when I search their saddle bag

[candid pasture]

you have to calm the horse down first then search the saddle bags usually if they keep kicking me i just get pissed and just shoot the horse in the head

[unkempt kelp]

Haha

I calm them down and they keep on kicking me

[swift canyon]

some do that

only some let you search their saddles

[silent parcel]

I'm slightly confused

There is a whole area to the south west

Is that only relevant in online or what

there are no missions or anything leading there

[vernal rampart]

new austin?

[hidden moss]

You can’t go there during a majority of the Story Mode unfortunately

[coarse oar]

I just.. Witnessed Sean's death

[rough verge]

Ik but my parents see the 18 and say nope

Hide library button

Anyways it’s to late

Use three lines on Xbox button to hide from library

[limpid oyster]

It always catches the player off guard

.. why me ?

[hidden moss]

Just finished the game

Well, Arthur's story

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Ah nice

[hidden moss]

Why

[quiet patrol]

Same

[glad brook]

That area was added in really late during the games development. It's from the first Redemption game.

It's just more stuff to do for people that already finished the game.

[silent parcel]

That explains why it's so different and wild-west-y

[eternal swan]

Is it just me or do bunty hunters aim for your horse more than any other ai in the game

[red helm]

They are jerks, what do you expect?

[cosmic epoch]

Well it makes sense lol

They’d want you alive for the whole bounty

[eternal swan]

Fuckers permakilled my Arabian

[cosmic epoch]

Buy another

You can get the black in chapter 4

[eternal swan]

Then they proceeded to blow my Brains out while I am stunlocked by dogs

[red helm]

Don't have a Bounty.

[eternal swan]

I think I'm on chapter 6 though

[cosmic epoch]

I meant in stables

Go to Saint Denis stables

You can buy the black Arabian

[eternal swan]

Well you see I have 60 dollars

[cosmic epoch]

how are you broke

[eternal swan]

That won't even get me a saddler

[cosmic epoch]

🗿

[red helm]

It's so easy to get money, what have you been spending it all on?

[eternal swan]

Well I like me my camp upgrades and kitted guns

[eternal swan]

This dead fucking horse

[cosmic epoch]

Camp upgrades basically do nothing

[eternal swan]

I know but they look cool

[cosmic epoch]

And only kit the guns you use

[red helm]

Also, it's only about $3k for all the camp upgrades.

[cosmic epoch]

you get $3000 for the Rhodes bank heist iirc

[eternal swan]

Well back when I had money and a horse, i didn't forsee this being an issue

[cosmic epoch]

Well idk what to tell you man

Just use your very first horse

[eternal swan]

Gonna use my last bit of money to buy up a giant stock or cocaine gum and sprint to wherever it is you can tame the white Arabian

[cosmic epoch]

Sprint

sprint?

You’re not very uhhh

[eternal swan]

That one got glitched into oblivion

[cosmic epoch]

quick thinking aren’t you?

Just steal a horse

🗿

[eternal swan]

Stealing is wrong buddy I would never do that

[red helm]

There is always a Default horse to use, or at least some basic horse at the Camp.

[cosmic epoch]

you are insane if you’re gonna sprint up to the snowy mountains

Plain and simple

[eternal swan]

Running is basically as good as riding a lvl 1 Kentucky saddler

[red helm]

Way better than running all the way up to the Coltor area.

[red helm]

Ha... Umm... No...

[cosmic epoch]

lol what

[eternal swan]

With enough cocaine gum I will manage

[cosmic epoch]

Kentucky saddler is faster than running

[red helm]

Any Horse > Walking.

[eternal swan]

Yeah but it runs out of stamina so quick

[cosmic epoch]

Then

Use your money to buy horse steroids

[eternal swan]

Ah yes but I won't be waking. I will be sprinting in a cocaine fueled rage

[cosmic epoch]

Not cocaine gum

[red helm]

Any Horse > Running your dumb ass...

[eternal swan]

Cocaine gum at least sounds like it'd be a good time for Arthur

Can you overdose your horse in this game

[cosmic epoch]

no

But with the amount of cocaine gum you’d give Arthur to get to the mountains you’d probably OD

[red helm]

You'd think.

[eternal swan]

Better than waiting for the tuberculosis

[cosmic epoch]

yeah

But then again

The game that preaches realism falls flat

[red helm]

Not how the game works, but yeah...

[cosmic epoch]

^^

Ironically

Chapter 6 is the longest

Despite Arthur being terminally ill

[civic vault]

Yeah i remember it being so long. But I guess us wanting to keep him alive for as long as we can adds to it

[violet osprey]

I had a dream when i was napping that Buell died and i killed the entirety of Valentine in revenge lmao

[civic vault]

Nice lol

Valentine people must paaaay!!

[violet osprey]

Like i think it was the Valentine police that killed him

And i was just furious

[clever moth]

I heard about a time where you could go to Abernathy farm right before the switch to John. When is that mission?

[quick pike]

there's a few missions before it, but Red Dead Redemption is the final mission.

[hidden moss]

How am I supposed to start "An American Pastoral Scene", because I've completed the missions required to unlock it and nothing is happening.

today i learned you can get micahs revolver as early as chapter 1

with that being said... I think it's time for the Micah run. Get his revolver and play with the lowest honor possible

only use his revolver where possible

it seems to be a method where you disarm an enemy and run him over to micah so he disarms micah

from there you can pick up the gun

so thats what im gonna do.

ill only use other weapons where im forced to

[hidden moss]

here's another thing to add to the micah run.

here ill see if i can find the video i watched

whenever you go into strawberry, kill everyone.

excluding law patrols sent after you

[hidden moss]

Funnily enough the method to get micahs revolver in ch2 involves causing a commotion while micah is in the strawberry prison

then shooting his left foot with a fire arrow while the law is outside the sherrifs office and the mission is greyed out

oh damn youtube links are blocked

yeah

want me to pm the video?

i think unless they're in media

idk

ill tru #red-dead-media

probably not actually

dont try that

it worked in there

oh

never mind

[hidden moss]

gonna test myself to see if it works tho

well im struggling to disarm the guy

i ended up tackling him twice

and he died

you could try the chapter 1 method

i am doing the ch1 method

where you lead the guy to micah to disarm him

i managed to lead him once

But he got killed by bill

i got him near micah but he was too occupied on me

ok i got it!

I got micahs revolver

nice

also love how micah now goes on a melee rampage

[light karma]

Y’all

Blackjack In rdr2 is easy

[mild basin]

Balls-

[hidden moss]

so you know how that method to get micahs revolver has a ch1 and ch2 method

i did the ch1

I wonder if i can do the ch2 to dual wield

[mild basin]

Scary

[west crescent]

can you go back to a previous save to get the errand boy trophy or is it completely missable if you dont get it your first run?

[versed smelt]

i’m p sure you can do it on a previous save

[west crescent]

i tried and the achievement progress didnt go up

theres only one other thing i can think of

my progress was 3/5 but all of those were in chapter 3+ but the save i am in now is chapter 2

do you think that I have to do all 5 again?

because I did 3 and the progress didnt move

[versed smelt]

Maybe not, i’m not too sure I think you’d be better checking out on google or sum

[west crescent]

i couldnt find anything

[versed smelt]

If you’re on chapter 2 surely you can do a minimum of 5 errands and get the achievement in that save?

[west crescent]

yeah im trying that right now

[versed smelt]

That should work

I don’t think it matters when you do it

[west crescent]

i did 3 when i was in chapter 3 and ive done 3 so far in my chapter 2 save

so if i do one more then ill find out

[versed smelt]

Hope it works out 👍

[west crescent]

same

i dont wnanna have 99% achievement completion

[versed smelt]

If you had a save after you done it in chapter 3 you’d probably of gotten it

[west crescent]

yeah

[versed smelt]

At least it’s not like the honour achievement, that one’s missable

All honourable missions

[west crescent]

completely missable?

[versed smelt]

Yh

[west crescent]

damn

i got it on accident during the epilogue

i was at the minimum honor the whole time as arthur lmao

[versed smelt]

I missed it on my first play through but I got it when I done it again, I had to start all over regardless so it wasn’t too bad. Done a bit more exploring as Arthur due to me rushing story the first time

[west crescent]

oh ok so you can still get it in another playthrough?

i thought you meant you could never get it again

[versed smelt]

no 😂 you can get it in a new play through but it’s tedious af since you don’t get it until like chapter 6 or epilogue

[west crescent]

yeah

im just worried that the item requests achievement is compeltely missabl

i guess ill find out in a few minutes after i finish this item request

[versed smelt]

I don’t think it is

[west crescent]

ayyyyyyyyy it worked

that is sooo relieveing

[versed smelt]

[west crescent]

i was so worried

[versed smelt]

Well done

[west crescent]

thank you

now i just need one more item request

[west crescent]

just got the achievement :D

[versed smelt]

🥳

[west crescent]

only 3 more rdr2 achievements to go

i hope there is enough people that play the online stuff for me to get the mvp 3 times achievement

[candid pasture]

then loses all red dead data

[west crescent]

i wish the game had cloud saves

[versed smelt]

tht ones tricky

i heard horse races are the best for it but idk

[final stratus]

Yo

What’s happenin y’all

[civic widget]

So the errand boy achievement is becoming more of a pain in the butt than the gold rush achievement.

I spent 6 hours in camp only for 1 request to show up.

[hidden moss]

so i unfortunately learned that no matter what you can only own one copy of micahs revolver

so i have no hope of dual wielding 2 of them

I thought I could cheat the system, but i was wrong

[coarse oar]

What's the fastest and has more ammo revolver

[civic widget]

Well, double-action revolver holds 6 rounds but is the fastest revolver, while the lemat holds the most ammo at 9 rounds + 1 shotgun round but is single-action.

[hidden moss]

i like micahs

its pretty much a faster double action

with 6 rounds

Honestly the best handgun is either the volcanic pistol or midnights pistol

[civic widget]

Well, you can carry more revolver ammo than pistol ammo too.

Otherwise pistols would be all around better.

[hidden moss]

true

honestly when im palying casually im a bow main

even online i run around with a bow

you can't tell me it isnt fun to nail pinkertons in the head with an arrow

[coarse oar]

NoOo kieran's death he was so good

[odd gust]

ko2fww

cripps is a little annoying

with he's music

🧽

[hidden moss]

ok so since i cant get two copies of micahs revolver

im going to instead buy either a volcanic pistol or a schofield revolver

and customize it to match micahs

[meager token]

I’ve had ultimate edition for like a year now, and I’ve only played online once

Idk random info

[hidden moss]

use the double action

that's what micah uses

you can find one inside the cabin near pleasance in lemoyne

[obtuse bloom]

My rdr2 crashes when i put version.dll (asi loader) to the root directory, can someone help?

[hidden moss]

just found a little cottage near rhodes with a dead body of a woman outside and two dead bodies inside, i read the letter but still cant figure out who is the killer and why, can someone help?

DAMN IT

Hosea and Lenny😭

Im getting too emotionally attached to this game

[wise gazelle]

I think the woman killed the man and other woman out of jealousy

Then walked to the cart and shot herself

[midnight dawn]

iirc they were having an affair and she killed them then commited suicide

[sterile nest]

bad honor ending is more realistic rlly

[hidden moss]

Me and the boys waiting for the RDR1 Remake so Rockstar will finally fix John Marston in some form:

[neon stratus]

so it is real

[hidden moss]

oh yeah, it was confirmed

[neon stratus]

that’s what i’ve been waiting for to

yes baby

[hidden moss]

not dlc though

seperate game type thingy

like spiderman miles morales

[neon stratus]

haven’t heard about a dlc

what is it

oo

[hidden moss]

Seemingly they'll release it on its own for Xbox One and Series (and PS4 to 5) and then they'll release it in a bundle exclusive to Series and PS5 (Unless they release it for Xbox One and PS4 normally but i doubt it) with the Next-Gen Rerelease of RDR2 and the Remake of RDR1

it's most likely they'll reveal the remake before next-gen rdr2 but idk

[hidden moss]

some people theorized last year that if they were to remake rdr1 it would be in a dlc expansion for rdr2

but seemingly thats wrong (in a good way lol)

[neon stratus]

I heard about the remake but i wasn’t sure about it, and man I would love another red dead in the future. Not sure what it would be about tho to he honest

knowing rockstar they’d probably find something great

[hidden moss]

oh yeah, rockstar themselves confirmed that both RDR and GTa won't end anytime soon (although there may be large gaps inbetween them)

anyway here's what the confirmation was for the remake. "To answer several MPs in one go, yes, as i was able to confirm at the end of 2020, a next gen port of RDR2 has been underway for several months at Rockstar. With a remaster/remake project of the first RDR."

[buoyant chasm]

When will the rdr1 remake release?

[hidden moss]

Not really known. But it is known that it will be revealed really soon.

[acoustic spoke]

Oh god I hope it isn't gonna be a gta trilogy remaster 2.0

[hidden moss]

Is there anything to do/play/watch so i can understand thr history of the gang? All i know is that they failed a bank robbery in blackwater

It isnt really mentioned in rdr2

But in the first page of the journal it says they escaped from a failed bank robbery or something

[acoustic spoke]

Yt, people have made theories and history vids abt the vander linde gang

[dire cypress]

i come with news

my playstation went into safe mode

and i may have to reset all my data

[acoustic spoke]

Whats that

[dire cypress]

your playstation doesnt let you play and displays some options

if options 1 to 5 dont work 6 and 7 will delete your data

all of it

and your account

[hidden moss]

I hope they make a third game about the origin or something where u get to play as arthur before he joined and u get too see how they united

And in the end there was a cutscene of John paying respects to Arthur's grave

Idk

[acoustic spoke]

Thats already in the game if you get 100%

[hidden moss]

Yea but i mean after u complete the so called origins game its a cutscene of John paying respects to arthurs grave and all along it was just him remembering all that happened with arthur

[acoustic spoke]

That'd be kinda boring in my opinion but alr

[swift canyon]

i dont think red dead needs to be a trilogy

well, rd redemption anyway

[unkempt kelp]

Red dead Redemption needs a remaster

[hidden moss]

Seeing as they said Remake instead of full on Remaster, i feel that it won't be thankfully

also Grove Street Games currently only has the rights to work on GTA

[swift canyon]

thank god

[hidden moss]

You know, sometimes I wonder if other red dead characters can use deadeye

So far we've only ever seen Red Harlow, Arthur, John and Jack do so.

Because they're the playables

And there is no distinct evidence of other characters being able to

[civic widget]

Pretty sure I've seen dutch pull off some wild shots too.

[hidden moss]

Yeah but that's not proof

[civic widget]

I'm talking about split second acquiring a target and getting a headshot

[hidden moss]

It's not definitive proof though

How I would define proof would be a cutscene or gameplay from dutchs pov where the screen takes on the yellow hue and time slows

As a result there's no evidence to say they can

Yet little evidence to say they can't either

Which is why I wonder about it.

[midnight dawn]

This theory was proven wrong by sean's shooting lmao

He's so bad

Or maybe just starting to learn it

[hidden moss]

Well, Sean is young

[midnight dawn]

Lenny is younger

[hidden moss]

Perhaps he just hasn't got the hang of his quickdraw yet

[midnight dawn]

And he's so much better

[hidden moss]

Different backgrounds and gun experience

[midnight dawn]

Hell even karen is good

[midnight dawn]

Lenny didn't have so much experience it's not like he went on and on about killing people

[hidden moss]

Same thing

[midnight dawn]

He only killed his father's murderer at the age of 15 iirc

[hidden moss]

Well he would have had to get good with a gun to do so

Years of training after his father died I presume

And I'm unsure of Sean's story

[midnight dawn]

Maybe it was at point blank, and one kill wouldn't mean you're well trained lmao

[hidden moss]

Either way, just because Sean is a bad shot and Lenny is a good shot doesn't prove either side

Who knows, perhaps deadeye in the red dead universe is a genetic trait, just like blue eyes or blonde hair

Sean doesn't have it, lenny does

[midnight dawn]

Perhaps

[swift canyon]

hes just playing on controller with free aim

give him a break

[swift canyon]

i mean he does talk to arthur while hes in dead eye when cornwall confronts you in valentine

[hidden moss]

I guess if we consider than cannon and not a gameplay oversight, that would at least confirm Dutch to posses deadeye

[full hawk]

So I’ve been trying to do the master hunter challenges so I can hunt the legendary panther and I need three perfect rabbit pelts, I have the varmint rifle and a bow with small game arrows and normal arrows, I already have two of the three but whenever I get the third pelt I can never put it in my satchel

[hidden moss]

Your satchel might be full, just sell some other pelts

Or get a satchel upgrade

[full hawk]

Ok I’ll try that

Thanks

[silent parcel]

wait

you're kidding me

rdr1 is not available on pc

well there goes your money, fuckers

[full hawk]

Ok so I emptied out most of my satchel and I got another three star rabbit but I can’t collect the pelt

[hidden moss]

Strange

Try getting a satchel upgrade

[full hawk]

How do you do that again

[hidden moss]

From pearson

[full hawk]

Ok

[hidden moss]

Or if you're in epilogue go to the trappers

[full hawk]

I’ll go check

[hidden moss]

I believe you need specific pelts to get satchel upgrades

Not sure I've never done it myself

[vital radish]

Idc what y’all say but chapter 2-4 are the best

[hidden moss]

Agreedd

Everything before Arthur gets diagnosed is fun

After that I just did story missions until it was over

[vital radish]

It’s not because it was before he got TB, it’s because of the missions

[silent parcel]

the lasso is bugged out again ffs

[hidden moss]

i dont think that bank mission was very fun...

I loved the Saint Denis bank robbery

The chaos of everything going wrong is great

It's just sad thst lenny dies is all

[silent parcel]

fucking HOSEA dies

he's the best fucking guy

[jagged kayak]

Chapter 3 is probably the worst chapter. Guarma is just behind it.

The blood feud mainly

“In the course of true love” is one of my least favorite gaming moments ever

[hidden moss]

Honestly I think most people would say ch2 and ch6 are the tied best

Maybe ch4 for some

[midnight dawn]

Chapter 5 is the absolute worst, even epilogue 1 beats it

[floral island]

People always talk about story characters deaths

But

Aint noone ever talk about Hamish

[candid arch]

yeah right, that side character

[floral island]

Yeah

That death got me a bit

[candid arch]

is there a way to loot him?

[floral island]

Nope

[candid arch]

whenever I kill the boar, it always falls on top of him

[cosmic epoch]

Idc he was suicidal

he should’ve stopped the bank job after everything they did

They shot up the entire police department

Killed the kingpin in Saint Denis

To consider him the brains of the gang is a shame after that

[silent parcel]

he was obviously avert to it

[cosmic epoch]

he wasn’t avert to them killing Brontë

[silent parcel]

I doubt he would have done it tho

[cosmic epoch]

And I’m sure with them living just outside Saint Denis one of them even just one of them would’ve heard about the town being shot the fuck up by 3 guys

[cosmic epoch]

it was stupid to go along with it

Saint Denis was too hot to touch

[silent parcel]

So you consider his mistake not leaving early

[cosmic epoch]

No

Not calling the thing off in the first place

[floral island]

Because Hosea was close with Jack

[cosmic epoch]

In fact he was vouching it

[floral island]

And bronte kidnapped Jack pretty much

[cosmic epoch]

what

[floral island]

And Hosea tried to stop the bank robbery

[silent parcel]

Yeah like an uncle

[floral island]

Hell Arthur even tried to

[cosmic epoch]

When lol

when

[floral island]

In the cutscene before it?

When they are at the house

[cosmic epoch]

The first cutscene in the bank heist is literally Hosea planning it

[floral island]

Hosea asks Arthur for his opinion on it

And Arthur sided with Dutch

[silent parcel]

He was overruled by arthur and dutch

[floral island]

^

Hosea told Dutch it was a bad idea

[cosmic epoch]

Thats Hosea saying not to kill Brontë

[floral island]

Listen to the cut scene

[cosmic epoch]

what cutscene

💀

[silent parcel]

And dutch while not as wise was definitely more of a talker and more convincing

[hidden moss]

dutch was all talk and no plan

[silent parcel]

The one where they talk about it and hosea is against it but will do it when arthur too agrees

[floral island]

How do you expect Dutch to listen to anyone in the mindset he was in?

He was beyond crazy at that time

[cosmic epoch]

that’s a good description

what mission

Is what I meant

[silent parcel]

bruh time to look at the wiki or sth

[cosmic epoch]

because

I am 99% sure

That the cutscene you’re talking about

[hidden moss]

Banking, The Old American Art

[cosmic epoch]

Is in when you go to kill Brontë

Not the bank job

[hidden moss]

Revenge Is A Dish Best Eaten

[cosmic epoch]

my 3 playthroughs have allowed me to memorise every cutscene 💀

[cosmic epoch]

Nah

[floral island]

@cosmic epoch Your right, Hosea did help plan

But he had a different plan

[cosmic epoch]

The mission where

[floral island]

Dutch didn't listen to his plan

[cosmic epoch]

You get the boat

[floral island]

And said he didn't like it

And then did his own thing

[cosmic epoch]

And find the alligator

[floral island]

Leading to Hosea's death

[cosmic epoch]

no lol

[floral island]

Only reason Hosea would've went along with that robbery is because Dutch told them it'd be a great escape

[hidden moss]

Country Pursuits

[silent parcel]

hosea was against killing bronte yes

[cosmic epoch]

They went along with hosea’s plan

Waited for his distraction

Whilst hosea’s plan was better than Dutch’s

[floral island]

🤷 Still, insulting Hosea for being the brains of the gang is wrong considering everything he did for it

[cosmic epoch]

I believe the best play was to not go for the bank

[floral island]

The gang would've died sooner if it wasn't for Hosea's wisdom

And intelligence

[cosmic epoch]

yeah

I believe it was a foolish choice to go for the bank though

[floral island]

He didn't deserve the death he got

Your right but Dutch manipulated them

Even Hosea

[hidden moss]

should've robbed the tailor obviously

[floral island]

He told them this would be the way out

Everyone fell for it

[cosmic epoch]

Should’ve just left it entirely

Not head right back into the town

[floral island]

Robbing the most industrialized city in America was a horrible idea, yes

[cosmic epoch]

Wait a few months Atleast

[floral island]

It was suicide from the start

And Hosea's plan was good

Just

[cosmic epoch]

After the shit they did

It was so fucking stupid

[floral island]

I think the only unrealism shown in that game is the faces of all those gang members would've been everywhere

Realisticly

[cosmic epoch]

Yes

[floral island]

They wouldn't have gotten close to the bank

[cosmic epoch]

And they become fucking cops

In Rhodes

[floral island]

Yeah

Well

I think that was a trick the entire time

To try ambush the gang

Not as cops, but as the family

Gain the gangs trust, then boom

Ambush

[cosmic epoch]

Fair idea

[floral island]

Like they did

[hidden moss]

well I mean, to the game's credit you can't do anything bad in Rhodes or Caliga Hall until everything goes to crap

[cosmic epoch]

yeah

And then after that

[floral island]

Because your wearing a badge

[cosmic epoch]

Rhodes is on lockdown til chapter 4

It admittedly should’ve been on lockdown for a while longer

but there is time skips in between every chapter

[floral island]

Meh 🤷 Only person who died in RDR2 that deserved their death was Micah and Molly

Lenny, Hosea, Strausse, Arthur

Didn't deserve it

[cosmic epoch]

molly didn’t deserve it imo

But

[hidden moss]

Molly didn't even talk, she just wanted Dutch to love her

[floral island]

Molly's death is a tricky situation

She was just deep in love

And Dutch ignored her

[floral island]

But she portrayed it as she did

[cosmic epoch]

To be fair

[floral island]

She was drunk, yes

[cosmic epoch]

They all deserved death

[floral island]

But what was the gang supposed to do?

[hidden moss]

You'd think she just wanted to die

[floral island]

Not believe her?

[cosmic epoch]

They killed hundreds and hundreds

[floral island]

From a high honour prospective yeah

[cosmic epoch]

Even Arthur’s honour is bullshit imo

[floral island]

But Arthur tried to do good

Lenny was a lost kid

[cosmic epoch]

yeah he tried to make up for it

but

[floral island]

Strause didn't deserve the death he got , despite everything he did

Guy got tortured

[cosmic epoch]

Arthur killed hundreds and hundreds in the missions

[floral island]

How many deserved it though (besides the cops)

[cosmic epoch]

I believe the realistic ending is low honour help John

[floral island]

Majority of Arthur's kills were other gang members

Or criminals

[cosmic epoch]

well

In the games time yeah

[floral island]

We don't see what he did before this, to be honest

[cosmic epoch]

but there’s probably even more killed during the gangs 20 year run

[floral island]

Yeah

True

Lenny was a lost kid, he found hope in a bunch of men who swore to protect him

He didn't deserve the death

[cosmic epoch]

I still stand by the point the most realistic ending would be help John low honour

[floral island]

I wish Lenny got out of the life

[cosmic epoch]

There is no way Micah would leave Arthur

[floral island]

Debateable

[cosmic epoch]

considering Arthur exposed Micah’s whole rat thing

[balmy raft]

yeah lenny good boy.

[floral island]

Micah knew Arthur was gonna die

He wanted the money

[balmy raft]

Micah Rat !

[floral island]

Even if Micah didn't kill Arthur, he was gonna die anyways

He was incredibly sick

Micha just sped it up a few days early

[cosmic epoch]

Is it also just me or do yall prefer the lines that end low honour help johns ending

"Damn us both!"

[floral island]

Yeah

[balmy raft]

Arthur : 🤠

Micah : 🐭 🐁

[cosmic epoch]

also Micah isn’t really lying

[floral island]

Arthur's low honour playthrough showed his character more

[cosmic epoch]

Arthur isn’t really better than him

They’re both outlaws

They both killed a lot of people

[floral island]

Only difference is, Arthur had good intentions

Micah never did

[cosmic epoch]

yeah

[floral island]

Arthur wanted to get john out, then head to New Austin for cleaner air

He would've died before he reached new austin

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah

[floral island]

Either of Cholera

Or the TB

[balmy raft]

Arthur Morgan The Best Character.

[floral island]

He was a walking ghost

[cosmic epoch]

Honestly I’m still surprised how Arthur had all that energy

[floral island]

If you think of it he had no energy

He got tired from walking up a small hill

[cosmic epoch]

Judging by what’s his name again

[floral island]

Uh

The guy he got it from?

[cosmic epoch]

nah

[floral island]

Idk but ik who your talking about

[cosmic epoch]

Tombstone guy

The guy tombstones about

I can’t remember his name

But he spent his last few days just lying in his bed from TB

[floral island]

Holliday?

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah him

[floral island]

Yeah

[cosmic epoch]

He didn’t have the energy to even get up

[floral island]

TB hit people different though

[cosmic epoch]

fair

It’s all dependant on biological stuff like genes and immunity system etc etc

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah

[balmy raft]

I'm going to Tahiti at Red Dead Redemption 3

[floral island]

Hosea didn't really kill many people if you think of it

He only killed the bad guys

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah

Hosea tried to con his way out of bad situations

[floral island]

Strausse

That guy

Fucked people over

But

[cosmic epoch]

the German?

[floral island]

Didn't deserve torture

Yeah

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah

[floral island]

He got tortured by pinkertons for information and he didn't say a thing

And he died from his injuries

[cosmic epoch]

He was loyal to the end

Even if you booted him out of the gang

[floral island]

Yeah

[cosmic epoch]

He was a true patriot salutes (I just wanted to make a MGS3 reference 💀)

[floral island]

lol

[gloomy ingot]

Is rdr1 still worth playing in 2022 but or is it outdated? I know the visuals suck but what about the gameplay?

[red helm]

The Visuals are perfectly fine. and the Gameplay is good too, it'll take some getting used to, if you are used to RDR2. But it is a perfectly good game.

[hidden moss]

loving micahs revolver

i got myself a free double action in lemoyne

so once i do the micah jailbreak i can dual wield double actions like micah

[frail kernel]

not cholera

pretty sure that was only for the residents of armadillo

which is why travelers like john don't get it

[floral island]

Meh, realisticly he would've probably got it

RDR2 lore, probably not

[frail kernel]

yeah cuz of the curse

[floral island]

Yeah

RDR2 had their own way of portraying Cholera

[frail kernel]

he'd die but he'd live a lot longer

[floral island]

Only a few weeks most likely

[frail kernel]

how could he have gone to new austin with pinkerton patrols still in tall trees and great plains

[frail kernel]

no he lived a few weeks with tb in roanoke

[floral island]

Early stages though

[frail kernel]

and you live a lot longer in drier, warm areas with tb

[floral island]

He was on his last leg

[frail kernel]

like

years longer

[floral island]

At a certain stage yeah

But he was past that

He would've lived years if he rested

But he went around doing his shooting and running etc

His lungs were destroyed

TB probably would've killed him before he could settle down in New Austin

Even if he managed to avoid the entirety government on patrol

[frail kernel]

fair

[frail kernel]

which is like pretty much impossible

[floral island]

Meh probably not

[frail kernel]

if he even gets seen by a civilian in that area

[floral island]

He could've gone down the other side of the mountain

[frail kernel]

he's wanted there more than any region on the map

[floral island]

He avoided them for years before Chapter 6

[frail kernel]

yeah by not going down there

[floral island]

They were in Lemonye too

When they kept turning up

They just somehow avoided them

[frail kernel]

yeah but they were behind them

[floral island]

Or Pinkertons were stupid

[frail kernel]

the gang

[frail kernel]

the opposite lol

[floral island]

Your right but he could've gone down the other side of the mountain

[frail kernel]

like

[floral island]

Flanked the pinkertons

[frail kernel]

trek across the grizzlies

and the redemption mountains

[floral island]

And die of TB

Yeah

[frail kernel]

aint no way lmao

[floral island]

It was a lost situation

[frail kernel]

im just saying

[floral island]

He was gonna die either way

I think he knew that though

Which is why he just lay there

Gotta rememebr Pinkertons didn't even get on top of that mountain

[frail kernel]

oh wait

ohh

mb

[floral island]

If they did, they would've took his body

But instead he was buried

[frail kernel]

no he couldnt

[floral island]

Assuming by John

[frail kernel]

the pinkertons surrounded the entire hill

[frail kernel]

no

it wasnt john it was another gang member

i cant remember

i think charles

[floral island]

No

[frail kernel]

yeah it was charles he says it in the epilogue

[floral island]

Charles said he layed flowers

I mean

Could've meant buried too

But

[frail kernel]

no he said

he burried him

john didnt have time

he had to get to copperhead w/ his family

[floral island]

Ah

Always liked Charles

He was incredibly loyal to Arthur

[frail kernel]

"word got to me up north so i went back to burry him and miss grimshaw"

that's what he says

in the epilogue

[floral island]

He buried Grimshaw too?

Damn

[frail kernel]

yes

[floral island]

Has she even got a grave

In game

[frail kernel]

all gang members are burried that we see in the game

except molly

all the gang members that died ^

[floral island]

Molly was most likely fed to alligators

[frail kernel]

guh

no

[floral island]

Due to them being in the swamp

[frail kernel]

they

they werent in the swamp

they were in roanoke

that was beaver hollow

like the beginning of ch 6 i think it was the intro

[floral island]

I thought Molly was shot at the house

[frail kernel]

nope

[floral island]

It was the first scene then

[frail kernel]

she died at beaver hollow by ms grimshaw

[floral island]

Since it was after they moved

[frail kernel]

eys

first scene of beaver hollow

her body was burned

[floral island]

Feel bad for Molly

[frail kernel]

yea

ima start my 4th playthrough now

[floral island]

I'm onto the 6th

Probably my last one

[red helm]

I think they said they burned Molly. Not 100% sure.

[floral island]

They did

[frail kernel]

nope

they burned her

oh

[floral island]

Thats what they said lol

[frail kernel]

i thought u said burried

lmao

i am of. questionable intellegience

[red helm]

We all are.

[frail kernel]

yeah they burned her

[frail kernel]

avg rdr2 discord member

[floral island]

Although Grimshaw shot Molly, Dutch really killed her

By ignoring her love

Driving her to confess to something she didn't do

[frail kernel]

she was drunk

[red helm]

Yeah, Molly kept wanting to talk to Arthur about Dutch, and such. Felt bad for her afterwards, after knowing exactly what happened.

[floral island]

She did speak to Arthur

Just arthur didn't speak to Dutch

[red helm]

She didn't go to much into details with Arthur, from what I remember.

[floral island]

Yeah

[violet osprey]

Question: if i sleep for 24 in game hours at the ranch will the squirrel statue still disappear?

Nope it doesnt

I slept 37 hours

Dang

[hidden moss]

sorry

I only play online so couldn't help

[vale sky]

Hi

[hidden moss]

HI

[cosmic epoch]

Yeah they do

Because she’s a "rat"

[midnight dawn]

She did it to herself, the only thing worse than an Irish woman is a drunk Irish woman

[vale sky]

I have a question

Dutch money are blackwater money?

[hidden moss]

I just saved a Spanish woman from a cage

I accidentally aimed at her

😭

She ran away

What would have happened otherwise?

[midnight dawn]

The money "left" in blackwater is the gang's money, yes

[midnight dawn]

I don't think anything would've happened, probably a small piece of dialogue and that's it

[vale sky]

I meant that dutch chest

[hidden moss]

I see

[hidden moss]

The one where Uncle interrupts their convo to rob a Cornwall wagon?

Ok will look tonight

[red helm]

I think there is two times Molly tries to talk with Arthur, but then gets interrupted for other things, but yeah, that is one of them. That happens a couple other times, Arthur talks to one person, then another interrupts and a whole thing happens.

[hidden moss]

i got a white arabian

[midnight dawn]

Yup, its blackwater money

[civic widget]

Is it though? I thought the gang didn't obtain the blackwater money during the events in 1899, and Micah went back to Blackwater between 1899 and 1907 to retrieve the money.

[worldly turret]

Dutch's chest is the gang share money from robberies and such, Blackwater money is the money Micah retrieves and hides

[hidden moss]

In “horse flesh for dinner” The game will not let me calm and lead the horse

Ope nevermind

!

got too greedy trying to find another Arabian

so i hunted a Perfect Ram

[undone ginkgo]

It'd be super cool if rockstar made an Arthur Morgan cigarette card as part of the gunslinger set

And John could find it in the epilogue

Would be pretty cool

Imo

[subtle halo]

Yeah it will be cool though narrative wise it won't make much sense as whatever things arthur did wasn't public knowledge

[slow fjord]

It should've been in the epilogue

I mean he was quite well known

Honestly all of dutch's gang should've had legendary gunslingers cards

[midnight dawn]

He didn't count himself as a gunslinger, and killing all the others legendary ones was kept a secret

[hidden moss]

you can arthur morgans name permanently on a plaque in saint denis

theres a strangeer event where a girl asks you to donate to the construction of a building.

If you do so, in the epilogue you can find his name on a plaque on the building entrance, as a thank you to the people who helped build it

[slow fjord]

he had a 5000$ bounty in multiple states

Don't see a reason why he wouldn't be in a set of cards

[hidden moss]

in the camp theres no food or ammo or medicine but i cant donate or buy stuff because the charity box is broken, does anyone knows why?

[vale sky]

Ugh

[vale sky]

Cuz personal left i think

Pearson*

[midnight dawn]

"someone" has stolen it, you can't donate anymore nor buy upgrades

[hidden moss]

and how can i fix it

[rapid stream]

anyone know spawn of dark bay turkoman in epilogue part 2?

[undone ginkgo]

Wasn't he... wanted in every state

That's pretty public

Imo

[subtle halo]

Well he was mainly wanted thanks to the gang as a whole and his high involvement in most of the things and we are going by that logic then Dutch had a higher bounty but that doesn't mean he was way better it was just because he was the leader also i think most of the gunslingers used to get popular as a gunslinger due to duels and Arthur's duels with the gunslingers were written as it wasn't done by him

[subtle halo]

Also he wasn't wanted in ambarino

[cosmic epoch]

Someone broke it

The box

And the ledger is gone

[hidden moss]

is it because im in chapter 6?

[cosmic epoch]

yes

[hidden moss]

ohhhh

[cosmic epoch]

You’re in the endgame now

[hidden moss]

thank you

[cosmic epoch]

unless you have any interest in doing epilogue

Then you have another like 7-10 hours

[vast ledge]

Some guy stole from me so i tried to turn him into the law but then got arrested myself

[hidden moss]

Is there a limit has to how many wild Arabians i can get?

[swift canyon]

each can only spawn once

[rain yew]

can i get a new ending

[swift canyon]

wdym

[rain yew]

or gotta replay from the start

[swift canyon]

only if you have a save from before you ended

[rain yew]

damm

[normal relic]

To get a new ending you'd more then likely have to restart unless you did an auto save

[rain yew]

idk about the ending i got

[hidden moss]

Shit ok

[normal relic]

Did you do low or high honor?

[rain yew]

#general-media

[swift canyon]

low honor ending

both are bad, doesnt matter which you pick

the only way to get a good ending is to have high honor

[rain yew]

damm is the low honor endings random

[swift canyon]

nope

[rain yew]

or is there like a low low honer

[hidden moss]

I can still buy them though right?

[swift canyon]

....its based on your honor in game

[swift canyon]

yeah

[rain yew]

if there are 2 low honer endings and they arent random what decides what one u get?

[swift canyon]

no i mean, either the one you got or when you go back for the money

theyre both bad

[rain yew]

ohh

well the ending wasnt bad

okay thank u

[hidden moss]

Aight gotta wait until Shady Belle

Although I think im close

[fathom flower]

Just finished game on high honor in epilogue

[hidden moss]

i got the braithwaite manor mission!!!!!

I wish I played this game when it first came out

With a more active community

Feels bad

[fathom flower]

I should prolly check out that strange man cabin again for final painting

[zealous bay]

Can I bring in a member of one of the gangs to the sheriff? Or will that get counted as kidnapping

[karmic sapphire]

I uh

Dont think thats possible

Oh sorry you mean another

Gang

No you cant

I thought you were on about bringing your gang to the sheriff😅😅

[hidden moss]

ok well the Arabian is 787.50 dollars with high honor

[karmic sapphire]

Or you could get a free one in the wild

[hidden moss]

i did

i want 2 Arabians

[karmic sapphire]

Damn big goals

Cop the arabian

[hidden moss]

i have the white mare and the black mare

[karmic sapphire]

Combine the two and you get a gray mare

[hidden moss]

lol

[fathom flower]

I had the white and chestnut ref

Now i have silver dapple pinto

[trim sail]

What button do you press on ps and pc for all the information to pop up on the screen? (So you see where you are, the temperature and honor etc.)

[hidden moss]

for pc, it's left alt

[trim sail]

Okay thx 👍🏻

[swift forge]

is it normal that rdr2 is so quiet? like i have to turn up my volume really high compared to other games

[zealous bay]

PS should be down on the d-pad if you still need that (and if Xbox and PS have the same setup)

[hidden moss]

Probably your volume settings