red-dead-singleplayer

[undone ginkgo]

And I have everything else

But I have no idea where to get a skunk

[swift canyon]

i see them near annesburg the most

idk tho

[hidden moss]

does anyone know a good horse name for me to put on my white female

[undone ginkgo]

Alright I'll start there

Thanks

[hidden moss]

So the vampire in saint denis…. Do you have to do anything other than the writings before he shows up in that alley?

[swift canyon]

no

thats all you need

oh, and it needs to be midnight

or around that time

[hidden moss]

Midnight ok that makes much more sense

[swift canyon]

which tailsman look the best

idk which one to go hunting for

[real lantern]

well

i dont know about talismans

but do you have the buck antler trinket?

[swift canyon]

i do

ill go after them all eventually, trinket and tailsman

i just want a cool one for my outfit

[real lantern]

have none of you ever noticed how in the mission where you and dutch go to lagras to talk with thomas

when you like

go to jules

find him

instead of the usual 'r' to greet or whatever it is on console, it's '2' to beckon

at least on pc

[swift canyon]

yeah

i mean it makes sense

your signaling to get out of the tree

[trim sail]

I have a perfect legendary bison pelt but I don’t know what to do with it, was about to sell it at a trapper but thought that I could use it for other things. If I sell it, does it still unlock clothes and stuff like that?

[swift canyon]

yeah

it unlocks them even if you dont sell it

but its always better to sell since you cant do anything else with it

[trim sail]

Okay! Thanks for answer

[hidden moss]

Ok ok I'm literally scared to death of the legendary bear

[swift canyon]

im sad that its so easy to kill tbh

a bear that big?

it should be able to kill you instantly

but you can somehow still endure an attack from a thousand pound bear

[hidden moss]

yes i know i have a gun that kills him easy

But it scares me that I don't know where he is and I just slipped off a rock

[swift canyon]

has anyone got tips for sharpshooter challenge 4?

this is horrible

[weary rose]

hi guys this more of an issue that i have when i try to launch singleplayer it crashes mid way look online for fixes tried everything but nothing even tried to reinstall the game and still doesnt work.

[swift canyon]

what do you play on?

[weary rose]

PC

[swift canyon]

is it a hardware issue?

[weary rose]

nop i have 155 hrs on the game

but i uninstalled the game and decided to reinstall it back

[swift canyon]

does online work? or is it the game as a whole

[weary rose]

whole game

[swift canyon]

might just be social club being social club

or maybe your pc is just being silly

[weary rose]

never had a issue before

[hidden moss]

I downloaded the game on my PC through EPIC GAMES. But I had a phase where I deleted all video games. Now I want to reinstall it. Will my data still be there?

Can someone please tell me 😭

[weary rose]

idk whether epic games has cloud saving

[swift canyon]

it does

but i think only some games do

[weary rose]

@swift canyon do u know how i can start fresh maybe one of my files are corrupted

[swift canyon]

im not much of a pc gamer

[weary rose]

oh u ps

[swift canyon]

but maybe uninstall ALL of the files linked to rdr2

pressing uninstall only gets rid of a few

idk if thatll fuck with saves tho

[weary rose]

hmm

any pc players u can direct me to

?

[swift canyon]

ask in #general

much more active than here

[swift canyon]

btw what launcher do you use

[weary rose]

rockstar

why?

[swift canyon]

it might be launcher being buggy

[weary rose]

nah u good sorted it out

after 2 hrs

[swift canyon]

what was it?

[hidden moss]

That gator in country pursuits, is it a legendary animal i can skin ?

[hidden moss]

Just did that one… that gator is it a legendary animal?

Because I low key want to kill it

[violet osprey]

Poker tips?

[lofty chasm]

All push them they always fold

Bruh epilogue gave us the house building banger

[violet osprey]

?

I mean to have them bust. Sorry shouldve specified

I dont know what good cards are

Can someone please help

[boreal stone]

What do you need help with?

[lofty chasm]

Go to the help and go to poker all the rules are there

[raven crest]

chapter 5 was the best what

your opinion

[humble pasture]

Yall now the best way to make a butt load of dough

On rdr2 not 1

[boreal stone]

Bounty’s,treasure maps,robbing people,robbing stores, I usually go for the treasure hunts

[wise gazelle]

at the beginning of ch2 there is a burned out village near your camp

it has a gold bar worth 500 gold

[boreal stone]

Yeah

[humble pasture]

How do i get treasure hunts

[boreal stone]

There’s a lot of treasure maps, I suggest looking some up

And there location

[humble pasture]

Ok

[boreal stone]

Glad I could help

[humble pasture]

Bout how much money they come with

[wise gazelle]

playing missions is also a good way tbh

and just by playing you'll find random npcs that will give you burglary tips

[humble pasture]

Thats worked so far

[boreal stone]

Different amounts,there’s one behind strawberry and it gives you over 3.000 dollars

[raven crest]

It is your opinion though

[humble pasture]

Ok thanks and are they easy to pick or are they gaurded and stuff

[boreal stone]

There easy to get

[boreal stone]

Like really easy

[humble pasture]

Ok thanks a lot man

[raven crest]

so off your terminology I think nasa is bad, everyone else thinks it's bad

[boreal stone]

Np man

[raven crest]

just cause you think it's bad don't mean everyone else does you'd think you would be smart with that walter white pfp

Are you stupid

' It doesn’t/barely affects the story = fact ' this is literally a repeat of what I'm talking about you think you are speaking for everyone

so?

[karmic sapphire]

Guarma good cuz turtles

But real turtles

With fins

Theyre real

Arthur even draws them

I-

You make a valid statement

[frail kernel]

chapter 5 was so much better than chapter 1

[hidden moss]

Literally so significant to the story guarma as a place is cool but it was little to do with anything and a lot to make Dutch crazy basically just filler

[hidden moss]

It was filler so I’d say no

My run down is

1. Chapter 3
2. Chapter 4
3. Chapter 6
   4.Chapter 2
4. Chapter 1
5. Chapter 5

I haven’t played epilogue yet

But what we should really be discussions is the the M1899

That gun is quite amazing

Beat pistol imo

[dull geyser]

Really good gun but my issue with it is you ran out of bullets before you even know it

But m1899s are indeed the best pistol of choice for me as well

[raven crest]

My favourite chapter was chapter 6 then 5

[frail kernel]

idec it was still unexpected and super fun

u cant say ud rather shoot deer in the neck and walk around a mountain to find john than shoot a warship down with a cannon

the siege was one of the best missions in the game

[violet osprey]

Best route for 17 minute dry dash from blackwater to vanhorn?

I was thinking of going around to owanjila dam to bards crossing, then follow the tracks

[violet osprey]

I just did it and it didnt count it even though i didnt touch water

What the hell

Does rain suddenly count cause i didnt touch water whatsoever

And i did it within 17 minutes cause i set a timer

OH WAIT

Im stupid lmao its vanhorn to blackwater

My bad

[hardy surge]

Doesn't matter, you'll need to craft all of them to get the best one

Just go hunting and have your wiki open next to you for easy access

That's what I did and I got them all in no time and it didn't take any fun out of it

[hidden moss]

Hey guys

I just hunted a panther

I went to a trapper

To make the saddle

But

I cant

[hardy surge]

Why

Do

[hidden moss]

It says i dont have thr stuff

[hardy surge]

You

Type

Like

This

[hidden moss]

IDJ

IDK

Its how we type in our country

Do i have to sell the pelt to the trapper to craft it??

[hardy surge]

Does the trapper say they need 3 star pelt?

[hidden moss]

Ye

[hardy surge]

Check what quality they need

[hidden moss]

I have one

I have a perfect panther pelt on my horse

[hardy surge]

Do you have 3 star pelt?

[hidden moss]

Ye

[hardy surge]

Take it out and bring it to him

[hidden moss]

How

Theres no option to remove it from the horse

[hardy surge]

Take it from the horse

What

[hidden moss]

When i look in to horse cargo

It says perfect panther pelt

Thrn the only options are back or discard

[hardy surge]

Stand next to the horse's side

Where the pelt is

[hidden moss]

Ok

Then

Theres no optiob

[hardy surge]

Idk I neever went to a trapper

[hidden moss]

The only optiond when i go to the horse is Horse Cargo and Draw rolling block rifle from horse

[hardy surge]

Look up a video if there's no one here to help you

[crude hamlet]

Is there a way to fix missing dialogue? Sometimes when I’m playing there can be an npcs in need and when I try to do something to help the option to greet them doesn’t come up

[red helm]

You have to Sale it to the Trapper. Than it will be in the Trapper Inventory, and you can craft things with it.

[normal relic]

Ik pelts glitch onto your horse so that's probably why you can't take it off the back of your horse

[red helm]

Plus, the horse has to be kind of close to the trapper, sometimes if it's to far away, the option to sale to him won't be there.

[normal relic]

Yep

[hidden moss]

You have to sell the pelt

In order to craft it

[red helm]

.... Literally just told you that...

[normal relic]

Yes that's what you do

Ranava just said it

[hidden moss]

I didnt see it

Sorry

[normal relic]

It's okay

[onyx solstice]

Is there a fast way of crafting split ammo

[keen narwhal]

Is short and medium scope the same range

Cause on the stats of the gun it doesn’t change

[onyx solstice]

Oh boy decided to start shooting everyone for the heck of it, and went from 0 bounty to 540 real quick lol

[quick pike]

I think short and medium scope are the same. The only difference I could think of would be how far you could see but idk if that's true. If the stats are the same, go for the cheaper one

[real lantern]

chapter 5 = best chapter

[keen narwhal]

Thanks

[keen narwhal]

Imo 2 or 3

5 is underrated tho

[real lantern]

i love the setting

and the actual challenge of not having anything you had

[quick pike]

I like the setting and the challenge but I still just ran through it after exploring for a bit

[keen narwhal]

Do u know where u ride to the area with Sadie and everyone met up

[quick pike]

honestly, 2 is my favorite camp

[real lantern]

yeah

[real lantern]

yeah i think it shouldve been a bit longer

[hidden moss]

Yeah that’s true

[real lantern]

like maybe 4-5 missions longer

[quick pike]

they could've done a lot more and I think they were intending to but had to cut it down

[real lantern]

there was a lot they cut down from the game

you can see bits and pieces left over in missions sometimes

[hidden moss]

So where would be the best place to sell the Charles chatenay art work and will I keep it as John

[real lantern]

yeah im pretty sure you just lose all food you had as arthur when you're john

and nothing else

not even ammo iirc

honestly they shouldve released a dlc with all of the extra shit if you ask me

but

rockstar being rockstar

i dont suppose there ever was a dlc planned

i just wish they'd done something with all of the out-of-map territory

[keen narwhal]

You can cut across to it and not go to shady belle

[keen narwhal]

Same

[kindred tiger]

is there a way to get a poncho in rdr2 story

[marble oasis]

Hello I have a question. In the story mode, can I discover 100% all 6 gangs?

[keen narwhal]

Probably

[keen narwhal]

I want to know that as well

[marble oasis]

If so, where are their locations. I found most of it and even looked it up on internet. Still dont have 100% discover

[kindred tiger]

i saw a video of a guy unlocking a poncho by killing a del lobo i just dont know if its mod

[keen narwhal]

I think finding them is one thing, the rest of it may be challenges with the gangs. Like there are random murders around the map that might be connected

[marble oasis]

Okay. Once you find a location and kill them, they return again right?

[keen narwhal]

If you are just finding them that doesn’t count you have to find there hideouts I’m pretty sure

[marble oasis]

I thought that once I kill them, they will be gone but in some locations they keep appearing over and over again

[marble oasis]

Yeah thats what I mean, I found most of their hideouts

[keen narwhal]

Not too sure honest

[marble oasis]

Where could I find the answers to that

[dull geyser]

No

The closest things you can get to a poncho are the cloaks on the trapper

[kindred tiger]

damn alright

[keen narwhal]

Can i do the item request in chap 3 even though i got them in chap 2 and haven’t given them yet?

[hidden moss]

Yes

[keen narwhal]

Okay good cause i still have to get that pen to Mary beth

And I’m on the mission with the Germans rn

[hidden moss]

Ok other than horses ofc but that helps I’m trying to keep my valuables and all as well

[hidden moss]

Yeah I haven’t gotten it yet either lol

[keen narwhal]

I just restarted my game a couple weeks ago

[hidden moss]

Strauss?

[keen narwhal]

I’m gonna stick to chap 3 and not move on

[keen narwhal]

No the family

[hidden moss]

What are their names ?

I’m not ringing any bells about a German family

[keen narwhal]

Im not sure it’s the one where u find new camp and they give u a gold bar

[hidden moss]

Ooooohhh that one yeah that’s a good chapter

[keen narwhal]

I wanna stay as Arthur without tb so this save game will be in chap 3 only

[hidden moss]

They don’t have names but that gold bar gave me 300 dollars

[keen narwhal]

Gold?

[hidden moss]

Yeah I mean theoretically you could go till chapter 4

[keen narwhal]

If u pawn it gives u money

[keen narwhal]

Yeah but prime Arthur is 2-3 lmao

[hidden moss]

Yeah still in the rdo mindset

[keen narwhal]

I wanna switch between John and Arthur save games

[hidden moss]

Yeah true just chapter 4 is so good

[hidden moss]

Ah ok

[keen narwhal]

It is

[hidden moss]

I’m at the end of chapter 6 about

[keen narwhal]

🙁

[hidden moss]

I’m really starting to hate Micah

who am I kidding

I always hated him

[keen narwhal]

Is this your first play through?

[hidden moss]

I just want to put a bullet in his skull

[hidden moss]

Yes

[keen narwhal]

It’s a good game

[hidden moss]

Oh I have loved it so far

I also can’t wait to see how Dutch comes to his senses or lack their of … hopefully the previous

I liked him and his plans but Micah def making things harder

[keen narwhal]

Rip Hosea, Lenny, Sean etc

[hidden moss]

Ik

But that bitch Molly deserved that buckshot

[keen narwhal]

100%

[hidden moss]

I just want Dutch to do right by everyone

And get everyone the money including John

[keen narwhal]

What mission u on so far

[hidden moss]

Not because I want it to be equal but because I want to have money as John lmao

[keen narwhal]

Have u got any spoilers yet

[hidden moss]

I just did the lovers 5 but the chapter ones I just did the odriscoll hanging and I’m about to do eagle flies

[hidden moss]

Some

Most of which have happened already

[keen narwhal]

Like what?

[hidden moss]

Like tb Arthur Sean dying Hosea and Lenny

Guys

[keen narwhal]

Do you have low or high honour

[hidden moss]

I accidentally shot william

And ofc mocha being a snitch

And now hes running to report me

[hidden moss]

Who?

Does he come back later

[keen narwhal]

Who’s William

[hidden moss]

The dude who needs plants

[keen narwhal]

His name rings a bell

OH

[hidden moss]

The yarrow planrs

[keen narwhal]

i shot him as well

Im doing a low honour play rn

[hidden moss]

Does he come back later

[hidden moss]

Idts because no one really knows him 🤣

[keen narwhal]

Not sure

[hidden moss]

BRUH i lost a whole honor level becuz i accidentally shot him

I’ve seen him once and he’s not the most important

[hidden moss]

High

[keen narwhal]

He is

[keen narwhal]

Keep it high 🙁

[hidden moss]

Wdym?

[hidden moss]

Why ?

Why the sad face I mean

[keen narwhal]

You can get good recipes from him

[hidden moss]

Ohhh

[keen narwhal]

You get secret missions in chap 6 for high honour

[hidden moss]

Like the mrs downes

[keen narwhal]

Yes

Cherish my boah

[hidden moss]

Yeah I seen that whole thing I was dumb and watched it on YouTube

[keen narwhal]

It’s alright

[hidden moss]

A couple weeks ago

[keen narwhal]

Alright good luck I’m gonna keep playing mine

[hidden moss]

But answer me this

[keen narwhal]

?

[hidden moss]

Does Dutch come to a head and sorta clean his act up

[keen narwhal]

🙅🏽‍♂️ will not answer anything

[hidden moss]

I just need to know before I go to bed

[keen narwhal]

🙅🏽‍♂️🙅🏽‍♂️🙅🏽‍♂️

[hidden moss]

Because I’ll finish it tomorrow I just need to know if there’s hope

[keen narwhal]

Will not say anything

[hidden moss]

😑😓

Ok

[keen narwhal]

Too good of a game for spoilers

[hidden moss]

Well then

I’ll let you know tomorrow

[keen narwhal]

Alright

[marble oasis]

I finished the story a while back, now I am just trying to ride around an complete and collect different things

I am surprised how the game is still fun even after finishing the story

[real lantern]

yeah

its just replaying the story that isnt fun

[west crescent]

fuck

i had 1 dominoes win but after reloading the game it reset

fucking bullshit

[dull geyser]

Damn

[west crescent]

oh

my

fucking

god

i literally cant beat the npcs

i won 3 rounds and gor 4 points from it

[lofty chasm]

whats wrong

oh

[west crescent]

the npc won 3 or 4 rounds and got 37 points

[lofty chasm]

damn

[west crescent]

there is nothing i can do

this challenge is gonna take me like 12 hours

[lofty chasm]

try closing it and shutting off ur pc

[west crescent]

i need to complete this thouhg

woohoo i won another round

for 2 fucking points

[lofty chasm]

what game?

[west crescent]

dominos

[lofty chasm]

oh

[west crescent]

im doing the gambler 9 challenge

[lofty chasm]

i have no idea

[west crescent]

in this game its 4-4 rounds won, and im losing by 31 points

such bullshit

[lofty chasm]

ok

it’s probably because ur on the challenge

[west crescent]

yeah

[lofty chasm]

it took me ages

[west crescent]

wtf were they even thinking making this

[lofty chasm]

idk

[west crescent]

im pretty sure the glitch where you can leave to not lose the streak was patched

[lofty chasm]

ya it was

[west crescent]

i even stopped playing yesterday while on a 1 streak and didnt have it when i launched the game

i left the table after the game ended, not even halfway through

[lofty chasm]

its defo patched

[west crescent]

it even said i had 1 out of 3

it just didnt save it

[lofty chasm]

oh

i just thought it was normal

i still kept trying though

where is it?

[west crescent]

hey finally

i got 8 points from winning a round

[lofty chasm]

nice

[west crescent]

wdym?

im still probably gonna lose

[lofty chasm]

wheres the dominoes table

[west crescent]

i have one win so far :(

im at the one in emerald ranch

[lofty chasm]

ok

[west crescent]

i just couldnt figure out how to do the other ones

too hard for my pea brain

[lofty chasm]

are u in off or online

[west crescent]

offline

[lofty chasm]

ok

chapter?

[west crescent]

i completed the story mode

[lofty chasm]

ok

[west crescent]

im trying to get all the achievement

this challenge is single handedly blocking me from getting the 100% completion achievement

fuck fuck fuck

there is no way i win this

[lofty chasm]

i got stuck on zoologist

[west crescent]

im at 97/100 for that

i doubt ill have trouble since i figured out a strategy to figure out what i needed

[lofty chasm]

nice

[swift canyon]

im contemplating whether to get the true 100% or not

[west crescent]

bruh dominos is so rigged

[swift canyon]

it is

[west crescent]

why didnt they just make it so you have to win 3 games

not 3 games in a row

[lofty chasm]

try the table in black water

[west crescent]

i have

i cant figure out how it works

[swift canyon]

is it challenge 10?

[lofty chasm]

saint denis

[west crescent]

challenge 9

[swift canyon]

ive never actually used the saint denis dominoes before

what game is it

[west crescent]

just won another round

ofc

2 points

[lofty chasm]

just keep doing it

[west crescent]

i feel like im never gonna get it

its annoying how i need to actually think too

[lofty chasm]

you will

[west crescent]

with gambler 8 and 10 you dont need to think

you just gotta click

[lofty chasm]

the poker one is sooooo easy

[west crescent]

ive already done it

but while doing another challenge

[lofty chasm]

ye

[swift canyon]

yeah ill never understand why they made some of the earlier challenges harder than the finale

[west crescent]

alr another round won

5 points

bruh

[lofty chasm]

bruh

[west crescent]

every round i win i get 5 points or less

[lofty chasm]

:

[west crescent]

but if the npc wins a round, it happens to be right after i draw nearly the whole lot of dominos

[lofty chasm]

[west crescent]

holy shit

fuck yes

i got 24 points from winning a round

now im only one point behind

[swift canyon]

🙏

[lofty chasm]

DAmn

[west crescent]

i feel like this game is gonna get my hopes up then proceed to fuck me in the ass with shitty rng

[swift canyon]

thats the red dead way

getting gold rush is gonna a pain in my ass

[west crescent]

omg

i have 3 dominos and all 3 of them are double numbers

[swift canyon]

[west crescent]

motherfucker

i fucking lost

after all that

i literally won more rounds but just got shitty ass fucking luck

now it is reset to zero

and i gotta do that like 20 more times before i get it

how strange... my honor just dropped

[lofty chasm]

what how

[west crescent]

i killed the npc

[lofty chasm]

oh

[west crescent]

on accident ofc

...

[lofty chasm]

ok

[swift canyon]

mood

[lofty chasm]

if u ever want to kill an npc just keep antagonise them

[swift canyon]

yeah

i found out that tricks good for challenges that require you to kill enemies in a specific way

saved my life fr

[lofty chasm]

ik

and u dont lose karma

[swift canyon]

i have before

it was weird

[lofty chasm]

ye

[west crescent]

i always have low honor lmao

i just play the way that makes it the most fun for me

and high honor was not

[lofty chasm]

i chose high honor for the achievement

[west crescent]

the achieveemtn where you do the optional honor story missions?

[lofty chasm]

no max out honor

[swift canyon]

low honor is so easy

i did Minimum honor for that achievement

[west crescent]

Same

[swift canyon]

and i still was max honor when i ended the game

its very easy to redeem yourself

[lofty chasm]

yes by saying hello to everyone in saint denis

[swift canyon]

i hate saint denis with a passion

my least favourite place in the game

[trim sail]

Where can you find black bears?

[swift canyon]

i find them in big valley the most

i think they can spawn in east new hanover and grizzlies too

[subtle halo]

I guess you never went to butcher's creek

[swift canyon]

i love butchers creek

its atmosphere is amazing

and its in my 2nd favourite region of the map

[subtle halo]

NANI!!

[spice monolith]

is there a way to stealth all the way on hideouts?

[swift canyon]

i dont think so

they're laid out in a way where it would be impossible to

[subtle halo]

Tbh I hate butcher's creek everyone starts attacking without any reason sometimes and all people are even more grumpier than the the people of Saint Denis also did i mention along with that temper they have guns and you u lose honor for killing them other than that after that stranger mission i can't just tolerate them though you can have your opinion

[swift canyon]

does anyone have advice for weapons expert 6

[swift canyon]

at least i can ride through without trampling 5 people a second

and you dont get law on you there

[unique pollen]

Saint denis is so bad

[swift canyon]

bro this legendary bison is bugged

the clues arent spawning

[unique pollen]

Is it the one in the grizzlies?

[summer sapphire]

Guys I have a problem, whenever I am using a gun like the the most expensive pistol (forgot the name) or the bow. It doesn’t fire unless I hold it

Got anyway to fix it?

[tacit elm]

The volcanic pistol?

uh

[swift canyon]

probably the m16 whatever it is

the one from saint denis

[tacit elm]

Ah okay

[lofty chasm]

maybe the high roller

[swift canyon]

have you tried reloading?

the game i mean

[summer sapphire]

Yea that one

[summer sapphire]

I did

Before it worked but when I started a new game

It stopped

[subtle halo]

Try restarting

[swift canyon]

yeah

[summer sapphire]

I already finished the game lmao..

[random edge]

what chapter are you now?

[swift canyon]

most bugs in this game are fixed by reloading

[random edge]

or just reload your other save

[swift canyon]

its a shit gun anyway imo

the games doing you a favour

[lofty chasm]

ye volcanic is the best

[summer sapphire]

But I wanna use the bow

[swift canyon]

idk how the bows bugged

you have to hold to shoot normally

[summer sapphire]

And the same thing happens to throwing knives

[subtle halo]

I don't think you will have to do any dire steps reloading the game will most likely do the trick

[swift canyon]

yeah you cant use bows or throwing knives without holding at least a little bit

[subtle halo]

Reloading means restarting the game

[subtle halo]

I think you can use them but their shortened

Range is*

[summer sapphire]

Yea they are but they don’t like get in their shooting animation

Or ready to fire animation

Until after like 4 to 5 seconds

Of holding the fire button

[swift canyon]

idk then

[analog talon]

how tf do i clean my face in this game

[summer sapphire]

Bath or being in the water ig

[lofty chasm]

take a bath

[analog talon]

Weird I tried that and it didnt work

maybe its bugged

[lofty chasm]

prib

prob*

[potent nest]

I dont wanna rescue micah guys!! 😫

Its my third walkthrough

I gate that guy

😂

[real lantern]

as much as i hate him too i do kind of wish there was a secret ending where you sided with him

it wouldnt make any sense whatsoever but

idk why not

matter of a fact i wish there was a lot more different endings to the first six chapters than just those 4

do you guys know how many fail animations there are for losing the fight with micah

in the

uhh

'canon' ending

[potent nest]

No i don’t

[kindred tiger]

do saddles matter in story mode or is it only in only cause i keep hearing the improved gerden vaquero saddle is the best but i like the look of the improved kneller dakota saddles more

in online sorry

[swift canyon]

saddles matter in both

not as much as people make them out to matter

but they do matter

[summer sapphire]

What do they do?

[swift canyon]

they can decrease the speed that cores drain and how fast stamina runs down while running

[summer sapphire]

Alright thanks

[keen narwhal]

Yes they help the horse

But i wanna know what the best saddle is

Usually i rock the panther one but idk if it’s actually that good

[kindred tiger]

oh wait yea theres trapper saddles forgor about those imma check on those actually

[keen narwhal]

They are actually pretty easy, depends if ur a good hunter

Not to be a bitch or anything but i think I’m pretty flawless at hunting

[kindred tiger]

well since ive already finished the main story i think ill just try and go hunt i guess lol

[keen narwhal]

It’s honestly just very fun and interesting

[kindred tiger]

fr

[keen narwhal]

Make sure u have cover sent lotion

Or if your not a puss you’d let them come for you 😈

[potent nest]

I totally agree with you

Love hunting in this came

[kindred tiger]

lol btw is there a way to change the little strap behind the saddle bag its kinda a nit pic but i want it to match my saddle so bad lol

[keen narwhal]

Same

[keen narwhal]

That’s the hard part about saddles if your very into looks like me

[potent nest]

Sometimes I get way to into it and forgot time lol

[kindred tiger]

yea same guess i actually need to change the saddle bag lol

[keen narwhal]

I love hunting moose idk why lmao

I main white Arabian so it basically matches any saddle

[kindred tiger]

bro all the saddle bags honestly looks like doo doo except for the charcoal one when you want a clean black saddle

[keen narwhal]

Nah imo if you can mix up the colours to make them look nice it looks clean

That’s what i do

[kindred tiger]

looks like i gotta settle for weathered dark oak

[keen narwhal]

I usually get the third last saddle or the last saddle in black for starters

[kindred tiger]

🤝 agreed actually weathered dark oak actually matches my saddle now that i think of it and see it

[keen narwhal]

It’s all about player preference

[kindred tiger]

but i still wish you they can add more colors lol

[keen narwhal]

Honest

I wish you can put different saddles on ur horses and not rock the 1

[kindred tiger]

yea

[keen narwhal]

Like i can’t match my panther saddle with my black and white Missouri 💀

[kindred tiger]

lol

well bye now imma grind for the legendary panther cloak

[keen narwhal]

Good luck if it’s hard for you

[kindred tiger]

honest sounds tedious and time consuming but ill try my best thanks

[keen narwhal]

Idk if this makes me good at the game or weird but i did all hunting and master hunting challenges in 3-4 hours

[rustic yacht]

where do i buy clothes at

[keen narwhal]

Tailor or general store

[hidden moss]

Yo guyd what do you get after the mission "Ends of the earth"?

[deft flint]

who’s in the epilogue rn

[floral dagger]

Why are the gold missions so stupid

I wish previous stuff in the mission carried over

[frail kernel]

what

[frail kernel]

wdym

gold missions are mandatory for the story to progress

[floral dagger]

For example in the a quiet time in my first run of the mission I only escape the police then in my second run I met the guy and found Lenny but didn’t run from the police and it still gave me silver

Just annoying

[frail kernel]

you need to not get caught by the police, you need to apolagize and interact with Tommy, and you need to see Lenny having sex in the upstairs room while you're drunk

if you're talking about getting the gold medal

[neon saddle]

Hi, I have a problem with progressing in the game: In the mission where Arthur takes Jack to go fishing for the first time, once I reach the area where youre supposed to fish textures dont load properly and the game freezes once im in the area. I cant move, interact with anything. Only thing I can do is look around. Does anyone have a fix for this?

[candid arch]

question, is your pc decent enough to run rdr2 properly

or er, console?

[neon saddle]

Yeah. The game runs on high settings from 45-60 fps

Components for reference: R5 2600x, Gtx 1650 SUPER , 16gb 3200 Ram

[candid arch]

go to the area first before starting the mission to see if its loading correctly

or skip checkpoint

[neon saddle]

What do you mean by skip checkpoint

[candid arch]

mission fail thrice then you'll get the option

[neon saddle]

The textures arent loaded in anyways

I had a similar bug at the beginning of the game but I just changed the renderer and things worked

[candid arch]

vulkan api ftw

maybe do that again

see if the magic works

[neon saddle]

So try using Vulkan?

[candid arch]

yes

you telling me you aren't using vulkan currently?

[neon saddle]

I used it before but it got the same problem so I changed to directx12

Just changed back

Moment of truth

Still not working

The area just wont load and if I go away once ive been there the rest of the game just also doesnt load

Npcs start doing the T-pose ffs

[candid arch]

new discoveries and new problems just keep on rising

[neon saddle]

you know anything I could do?

[candid arch]

maybe uh decrease graphic settings?

I don't know I have never heard of that problem before

[neon saddle]

Tried that already

[neon saddle]

damn

[candid arch]

maybe restart?

like both your pc and rdr2

I don't really know how would that help but in a moment of desperation you would do anything

[warped salmon]

Give the pc a light kick
You'd be surprised how many times that's worked

[neon saddle]

huh

Just slap it? Like fr?

[warped salmon]

It's worked for me with a couple devices before

Give it a try

Just, not too hard

[neon saddle]

In game?

[warped salmon]

Anytime

Usually during gameplay tho, yeah

[neon saddle]

Lemme try...

Unfortunatly nothing

[candid arch]

the ol' "Technical Tap"

[neon saddle]

That would have been hilarious though

[warped salmon]

GTA wouldn't work once, punched my 360, shit ran perfectly afterwards

[neon saddle]

Lemme try again...

Yeah.. nothing

I give up at this point

shit wont work

Might consider getting the ps version

I mean its also on discount

[candid arch]

but you cant download mods and have a wacky fun ride in the wild west

[warped salmon]

Ok, well if that don't work, now it's time for hammer

Where's my sledge at?

[neon saddle]

I wasnt really considering downloading mods anyway

And if I decide to revisit the Pc version, I always can

[neon saddle]

Maybe a hydraulic press

[warped salmon]

M1911

[neon saddle]

rpg

[warped salmon]

Nuke

[neon saddle]

Nokia 3310

[warped salmon]

...

Shit, I can't beat that

[neon saddle]

The 3210 maybe could

But only maybe

A small maybe

[warped salmon]

Ok, now hold on, I gotta image hunt really quick

Hey, @candid arch, you have a really nice Profile picture

[candid arch]

oh thank you

[warped salmon]

Any chance you have it saved?
I would like to add it to my gallery

[candid arch]

oh

ok then

[frail kernel]

is lml and script hook working for anyone

[hidden moss]

Should I get a new horse? Kept the one I had from the start and I'm pretty connected
At the Braithwaite and grey part

[frail kernel]

wait for chapter 4

[vernal rampart]

yes

[frail kernel]

there's a lot of good and expensive horses

[vernal rampart]

true

[hidden moss]

Ah right

[frail kernel]

thatt's the chapter after the grays and braithwaites

[hidden moss]

Just went to sant denis for a new horse but there was none in there, just upgraded weapons

[vernal rampart]

i say wait until chapter 4 then get your honor up as much as possible so u get the discount

[hidden moss]

Yeah I've got a decent honour, maybe 3/4 up

[frail kernel]

u cant get the horses until you actually get to the chapter

[hidden moss]

Yeah I presumed

How close am I to chapter 4? Done the John and hosea mark on the map, doing the hosea mark rn, but then I've got the Dutch one

[frail kernel]

uh could you like specify what you did

i dont want to ask questions cuz ima spoil it

so just specify what you did in the chapter up to now

[hidden moss]

Going to torch the tobacco fields, past giving out free moonshine and stuff

[frail kernel]

ah okay

did you steal the prize horses yet

[hidden moss]

Yes

[frail kernel]

k so you're

hm

you're about 3/4 done

sorry it took so long my number thing isnt working so i have to legit look up and copy and paste the numbers

💀

[hidden moss]

na its good, thanks, chapter 4 is denis right?

[frail kernel]

well that's not where the gang hide out is but yeah it's centered around saint denis

[hidden moss]

awesome ty

[frail kernel]

yeah np

u got about

5 missions left

[gleaming basin]

i just realizewd that arthurs girlfriend mary said to arthur "just run and dont look back"
like what arthur said to john

i found this kinda detailed

[deft flint]

John said the same thing to Jack in RDR1

[gleaming basin]

yeah ik

[violet osprey]

When you do the dash challenges for horseman, does falling off your horse reset the timer/count as a fail?

[hidden moss]

Can I keep multiple horses? Just switch the saddle?

[flint yacht]

Should I worry about being good at killing strangers who try to rob, kill, etc while in ch 2?

[hidden moss]

believe so

[violet osprey]

I hate red dead horses

Absolutely despise them

[stray otter]

Why?

[violet osprey]

The only reason i keep failing horseman 9 is cause this stupid horse will trip and almost die every 30 seconds

[deft flint]

btw

[hidden moss]

once you get past a chapter 2 mission you can stable up to 5 horses and switch between them freely at a stable

[deft flint]

who is doing the epilogue rn or finished it

[violet osprey]

Em

Me*

Im on my second playthrough

[stray otter]

Me

[deft flint]

was your Arthur high or low honor

[gleaming basin]

can someone tell me a location where skunks spawn alot?

[violet osprey]

Low

[trim sail]

Me

[violet osprey]

In my first playthrough he was high

[trim sail]

High

[deft flint]

💀

[deft flint]

which ending did you pick

[hidden moss]

take a look at eris field in lemoyne

[trim sail]

follow John

[deft flint]

I feel like going back for the money so I can get revenge

one eyed Micah

[gleaming basin]

aight thanks

[hidden moss]

np

[deft flint]

but I’m not sure which ending should I go for ngl

[hidden moss]

Ah right, so I'll just attach one to one eith my saddle and bring it to a stable?

[stray otter]

Around lemoyne strawberry and ring neck creek

[trim sail]

Follow John

[deft flint]

I feel like following John gives you the “redemption” ending

[hidden moss]

so you need to get to bonding level 1 with a horse before you can stable it, which i believe happens automatically when you put a saddle on it

[deft flint]

where Arthur finally redeems himself

[gleaming basin]

when micah is one eyed i like how he says "Hello Scarface" to john while he looks like that

rockstar should have coded in so john answers "Long time you one eyed bastard" or something like that

[hidden moss]

then you can just ride it back and whistle to have your main (now counted as temporary) horse behind you

[deft flint]

John responded back to the insult where Micah said Arthur gave him the scar but at the same time Micah said he won the fight

so

wait

doesn’t Micah contract TB from Arthur in the high honor ending

Arthur bites his hand

[gleaming basin]

no i dont think

[trim sail]

What

[deft flint]

tuberculosis symptoms can remain dormant for years

[gleaming basin]

oh yeah i forgot

[hidden moss]

i'd say that follow john is the canon ending but go back for the money (aka get revenge) is a pretty awesome ending as well, great music and set

[deft flint]

since Micah steals the money anyway

does it add up to the money you receive at the end of the epilogue

[hidden moss]

pretty sure it doesn't change from $20k

since aren't micah and dutch at the camp before they find you in the follow john ending anyway?

and i thought the $20k was the blackwater money, not the camp saved money

[deft flint]

Micah had intentions of stealing the camp money

[gleaming basin]

well if you (as arthur) didnt pick up the gold bars around the map

john after can go take those sell them and prob get around 8k more

[hidden moss]

i mean you could also transfer your money from arthur to john with the aberdeen pig farm (if that still works)

just sell the gold bars before you get knocked out

apparently the non-treasure map gold bars respawn in the epilogue according to a reddit post

[crude ore]

Low honor gameplay

Kill everyone

[gleaming basin]

i bet everyone had low honor on their first playthrough

i mean most people

am i crazy or did i see something type and the text was removed under a second

[swift canyon]

sheesh chat was spoiler city fr

[swift canyon]

that one took me 3 times

the last time i failed cause i got jumped by some guys

it wasnt that difficult tho

just dont try to rush it

they give you a lot a spare time

[cedar quiver]

Hey so what all stuff can make my character vomit?

I want to vomit on the Marstons for the lols.

[viral leaf]

Do you have any horses herbs?

Any plants too like Oleander Sage will really mess you up

[cedar quiver]

Ok. Where can I buy them?

[swift canyon]

you cant

you need to pick them

oleander is found near the railroad where the legendary fish is near saint denis

[cedar quiver]

What can I buy then?

[swift canyon]

i dont think there is anything you can buy that makes you vomit

most of it is herbs

[wise gazelle]

does anyone know whether herbivore bait attracts small critters like rats and squirrels?

[boreal stone]

Nah I never tried it

[gleaming basin]

how high does my honor need to be before i can buy "The Gambler" outfit?

[wise gazelle]

Anyone know how the buck antler trinket actually works

[civic vault]

As far as i know it only attracts the medium to bigger sized herbivores

[boreal stone]

It increases your odds of getting a 3 star pelt

[wise gazelle]

but in what way?

[gleaming basin]

???

[hidden moss]

it's like the step below max honor

i believe it's filling up the bar as much as you can in chapter 2

since your honor gets capped

[keen narwhal]

Does anyone know what the last mission in chapter 3 is?

[frail kernel]

it makes it so that some guns work with shooting animals that previously didn't

[proper ledge]

Anyone know why every time i try to hunt the legendary gator it says there is too much activity

[frail kernel]

for example snakes need small game arrows for perfect pelts but if u use the trinket you can use varmint too

[frail kernel]

it's usually because of bounty hunters or you just commited a recent crime or killed someone recently

[keen narwhal]

don’t do anything bad like crimes or even kick a turtle

[frail kernel]

it works if you just ride away, wait a bit, then come back

for me it did at least

[proper ledge]

I dont have any bounties and ive been there multiple times day and night

[keen narwhal]

I always got them first try

[frail kernel]

yeah idk man just try the usual refreshing fixes like camping, saving and rejoining, riding far away then coming back later

[keen narwhal]

I’m trying to figure out the last mission in chapter 3

I wanna stay in it not move on

[proper ledge]

Idk ill wait somewhere untill night and then go back without my horse i guess

[frail kernel]

well i presume you don't care if i spoil the chapter then

[keen narwhal]

No I’ve finished the game a million times

[frail kernel]

ohh ok

battle of shady belle

it's where you clear out shady belle from lemoyne raiders

i think it's with john but i'm not sure

[keen narwhal]

That’s not the last mission i thought

Where u go with Lenny and he walks in drunk

[frail kernel]

that's different

that was to seize weapons and money

[keen narwhal]

idk i don’t remember

[frail kernel]

the mission you're thinking about is you and lenny capturing shady belle

[keen narwhal]

Oh no wait i remember that mission u said

i gotta avoid that

[frail kernel]

the last mission in chapter three is when you and john capture shady belle again for the gang to move in, and it has been reoccupied by the lemoyne raidders

[keen narwhal]

Yeah thanks

[proper ledge]

After you finish the epilogue can you find sadie or dutch

[frail kernel]

nope

[clear temple]

can someone guide me on getting the new austin plants as arthur?

[graceful token]

You did the angelo bronte mission ?

[dull geyser]

The angelo bronte mission is gonna be your best choice to do that

You can even get the tiger striped bay mustang

[wise gazelle]

spent almost the whole day playing and didn't do single mission lol

just shooting bounty hunters and hunting

• challenges

[wanton kite]

Anyone know why some of the legendary animals aren't on my map?

[versed smelt]

You need to actually go to the area and get notified that “You have entered legendary animal territory” and your map should update then

[wanton kite]

I've gone to them and I havent got any of the notifications

[versed smelt]

e

ok

hang on

@wanton kite Filter it to legendary animal only and it will show you the exact location for the animals

Then just go there in your own game and you should get notified for it

[wanton kite]

Okay I'll try it thanks

[wise gazelle]

losing honour for killing bounty hunter dogs is kinda annoying

[lucid trellis]

I keep having this thing where, with no missions active, no side quests currently happening, and no random encounters occurring, I get a message saying "Cannot set up camp right now" when I'm trying to set a camp up no matter where in the game map I am

[hidden moss]

Bro chap 3 has so much rpbberies

Before chap 3 i had 80$

Now i have done like 5 missions in chap 3

And i have 500

[frail kernel]

ur gonna have a lot more than that

by the end of chapter three

[quick pike]

you get so much money, especially in chapter 4 and 6

[frail kernel]

imo

guarma is the best chapter

except for grinding

[hidden moss]

Hey guys

How much capacity does the provision satchel increase

[frail kernel]

everything to 99

so for example canned goods were originally 3, now you can hold 96 more

doesn't increase ammo though

[hidden moss]

So i met the guy who will buy you something at the store in rhodes

But i cant pick

Cuz when i try to press claim it says i cant carry anymore

[hidden moss]

Isnt that the legend of the east?

[frail kernel]

dude im so stupid it's like 1 am here and im tired af

[frail kernel]

sorry

yeah ur right

[hidden moss]

Lol its fine

[frail kernel]

it makes it 5 instead of 3 i think

idk might be 15

[hidden moss]

Nvm i figured it out its bec of my mask

[frail kernel]

anyways, i would get it just for LoE

[hidden moss]

Ye i think its 5

Bruh 2 extra capacity but so hard to get

I did like an hour hunt just for a racoon

[frail kernel]

yeah ik it'll be worth it for LoE though

[frail kernel]

badgers and raccoons are pretty much just luck

[hidden moss]

Yea

[frail kernel]

cougars and panthers i can deal with

[hidden moss]

I might try and get LoE before chap 3

Chap 4

Im in chap 3 rn

[frail kernel]

honestly i really don't see any difference for grinding in chapter 3 and chapter 4 except for youre in a different camp

[hidden moss]

Ye im just lazy lol

[frail kernel]

chapter 5+ is when grinding is pretty much over

also i love chapter 4 because mafia + cowboys is so cool

[hidden moss]

Hey guys i got a black arabian from the mission “horse flesh for dinner” with a glitch i cant put a saddle on it so i tried going to a stable but i cant

So does anyone know how to remove it to being my horse?

[native meteor]

does honour really matter in this game

i kinda enjoy killing npcs lol

im in chapter 3 atm

[keen narwhal]

If your shoot them once some of them run away

[stray otter]

Yes it’s very important

[hearty moth]

Hey folks, im on Guarma now and i want to get all animals there. Im exactly on the spot for the snakes but they wonÄT spawn. I also saved and restarted the game because it was mentioned in a forum, but still no snake spawn there. Is it possible that its bugged?

[native meteor]

so should i have a good rep or bad

[stray otter]

Your choice

[native meteor]

why is it important tho

can you tell me which one is better

like does it effect the ending of the game or something

[desert coral]

Find out for yourself

[stray otter]

Play and find out

[placid crow]

Hey i guys. Can someone maybe help me install a few red dead mods? ps i play on steam

[gleaming basin]

is it pretty much me or

was micah from chapter 1 to 5 like kinda nice to arthur? and wasent such a bastard. right in chapter 6 he just became mean to arthur for no reason and tried to make dutch trust him instead of arthuri

[hidden moss]

He was picked up by the pinkertons. They used him as a mole in the gang

[stray otter]

He was always and asshole but he definitely gets worse when the Pinkertons pick him up

[hidden moss]

true

[native meteor]

i just

cut a bear skin

what can i do with it

can i sell it for good money?

[stray otter]

If it’s in good quality yes If not a few dollars

[native meteor]

how do i know if its good quality

also is crafting important in this game

[stray otter]

When you pick it up does it say poor quality or what

[native meteor]

can i like craft good guns or something

[stray otter]

No you have to buy guns

[native meteor]

also do you think its a good idea to pay of bountys? do i get a high honor or something

[stray otter]

But you can craft ammo

[stray otter]

It means you won’t have bounty hunters after you and it makes it easier to get away with store robbery’s

[native meteor]

nothing to do with honour?

[stray otter]

No but kinda you did get that bounty somehow

[native meteor]

yeah cuz i got a 5k bounty on me

whats the best way to make money in single player?

[stray otter]

Damn what did you do murder a pet store full of puppy’s

[native meteor]

i just keep killing everone

i treated it like 6 stars in gta 5

💀

[stray otter]

You get money through the story but also robbing stores looting bodies and hunting and selling to the butcher

[native meteor]

is it important to save up money

or can i spend it on guns and stuff

[stray otter]

You can buy flashy stuff or donate it to the camp your choice also remember to upgrade the camp

[native meteor]

also the bear skin is stowed on my hourse...do i just pick it up and take it to a general store?

[stray otter]

Butcher

[native meteor]

what perks do i get for upgrading

the memebers wont die right

[stray otter]

New tents and stuff

[native meteor]

does that even matter

seems like cosmetics to me

[stray otter]

Not really but one makes it so you can fast travel from Arthur’s tent

[native meteor]

oh wow

im in chapter 3 atm

is it ok if i read #713479649530871898

i heard theres spoilers

so how do i know when i can read it 💀

chapter 5?

[stray otter]

I’ll check for you

[stray otter]

Read it after you finish the story

[native meteor]

aight thanks

also where do i sell gold ingot? @stray otter

[stray otter]

Sell gold at a fence

[stray otter]

There is one in saint denis and emerald ranch

[native meteor]

is it called "Fence"