red-dead-singleplayer

[boreal stone]

I suggest before you go hunting you get the buck trinket behind strawberrie

[slate vine]

Yep

[hardy surge]

There's a guy in the gun shop keeper's basement in Rhodes, but Dutch said not to use any guns there

[boreal stone]

Yeah

[hardy surge]

How do I rescue him?

[hidden moss]

Damn

I do not have any other arrows

I will make some later

[boreal stone]

Just confront the gun shop owner

[hidden moss]

Or i will just use springfield

[hidden moss]

Ok so is easy

[hardy surge]

Dutch doesn't want any trouble in Rhodes

[boreal stone]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

You do it the same as when you are robbing a store

[slate vine]

Lol dw about that

[boreal stone]

But he won’t know

[hidden moss]

Tho you are gonna have a different option to confront

Who tf is lily-may

[hardy surge]

I'm not getting any prompts to rob the store in there

Neither can I pull a gun on him

[boreal stone]

Arthur’s lover ex

[hidden moss]

Fr?

[boreal stone]

Yeah

[slate vine]

Yes

[hidden moss]

I just saw that kid throwing rocks at the water again

I stopped by

[hardy surge]

I think it's because Dutch made it so I can't use guns in Rhode at all

[boreal stone]

Lol

[subtle halo]

Her father seperated those two

[hidden moss]

Bro i want to kill him so much istg

He's so annoying

I tried to help him but he doesn't want to

I swear i wanna take my shotgun and blow his head off

[boreal stone]

Bludgeon him with you’re knife

[hidden moss]

Sure

"You wait lilly-may!I'll show you one day"

[boreal stone]

Lol

I killed him a long time ago

[hidden moss]

Fuck i can't kill him wtf

[boreal stone]

Annoying little shit

[hardy surge]

Do I tell Dutch there's someone under the gun smith's basement?

[boreal stone]

You can’t

[hardy surge]

Cause he won't let me use guns in Rhode

[hidden moss]

He ran away

Too bad

[slate vine]

I can't lol

[hardy surge]

Then how do I rescue him without a gun?

[boreal stone]

Sadly you just have to save him after chapter 3

[hardy surge]

Man

[hidden moss]

Dude RDR2 is so beautifull fr

[boreal stone]

Or before

[boreal stone]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

Is so cool

[random edge]

DUDDEE Dutch plan der linde just release me outta rhodes jail with dynamite and then he got shot by a bunch of grays and sheriff and died (He only had 1.50 dollars) i loot him and take his hat

[subtle halo]

Rdr2 happy ending confirmed

[hidden moss]

lmao

[boreal stone]

“Plan der linde” lol

[hidden moss]

Can anyone explain honor rank

Or levels

[subtle halo]

You just needed to have some more faith

[hidden moss]

Bro so this just happened

[random edge]

because he always had a damn plan

[hidden moss]

So i am going to my destination

And there's a NPC which is going the same way

He just said "You trailing me or something"

[random edge]

and MONEY

[hidden moss]

He's aggresive too

Should i just blow his head up

[random edge]

where?

[subtle halo]

Don't forget the quarter

[random edge]

in what town

[hidden moss]

There is no town

I am in the middle of i don't know

And this NPC

He's going the same way i am and he thinks i am following him

[boreal stone]

“We need MONEY Arthur AND some GODDAMN FAITH”

[random edge]

we head off to the tropics

and ends up in guarma

[kindred tiger]

I want to make the legendary cougar and wolf vest for Arthur I've already killed the wolf and sold its pelt and carcass but I need the cougar do you still keep the pelt you've sold to the trapper when you go to the epilogue

[subtle halo]

Cuz arthur didn't show enough faith in the ship

[random edge]

yeah that makes me pissed, an npc riding as fast as my horse and then he shoot me with a shotgun

[hidden moss]

He isn't shooting me

He's screaming at me

[random edge]

lucky john is not in that ship

[boreal stone]

Instead he’s in the ward

[random edge]

sometimes npc witness me for disturbing the peace when following them

[subtle halo]

Yeah OTHERWISE the ship would have ended in Timbuktu

[random edge]

true

[hidden moss]

Can anyone explain honor rank? Like what is level +1 or level -1

[boreal stone]

Lol

[hidden moss]

So i know what honor im in

[hidden moss]

Damn

[boreal stone]

So if you wanna check you’re honor hit down on D pad

[lucid trellis]

Different sort of stages of honor level give you different rewards and discounts/price hikes

[random edge]

umm, i think you cant keep the pelt

[lucid trellis]

High honor gives price discount scaling for every honor level

[hidden moss]

Yes but how do i know what stage im in

Theres no label when u hit down on dpad

[lucid trellis]

And low honor makes items more expensive

[random edge]

are u in ps

[subtle halo]

IT you do

[hidden moss]

Ye

Ps4

[subtle halo]

Though not sure

[random edge]

wait

[hidden moss]

Guys serious question

Arthur or john

[random edge]

lemme show you

[subtle halo]

Arthur

[lucid trellis]

If you do something honorable, eventually it'll have an animation where your honor increases without you pressing the dpad, that indicates a level up

[subtle halo]

Arthur

[hidden moss]

For me arthur i haven't played as John

[subtle halo]

Arthur

[boreal stone]

Arthur

[hidden moss]

But arthur gives me that Chad Vibe

[subtle halo]

Arthur

[hidden moss]

Same

[subtle halo]

Arthur

Arthur

[lucid trellis]

And you can just go check a general store to see what discount you're at

[subtle halo]

Arthur

[hidden moss]

Arthur all the way bro

[kindred tiger]

wait do i get to keep it

[hardy surge]

What time of day do squirrels usually spawn?

[boreal stone]

No doubt Arthur

[hidden moss]

So the honor line thingy will show even though u didnt press it?

And that means u either leveled up or down

?

[lucid trellis]

Yeah, and you'll see the head indicator go up/down

That indicates a level change

[hidden moss]

Ok thanks

[subtle halo]

If you have sold the pelt then yes

[lucid trellis]

Otherwise doing honorable/dishonorable things just gives that icon on the right

[hidden moss]

Im gonna grind honor tomorrow after i reach chapter3

[kindred tiger]

oh ok thanks got me worried there

[subtle halo]

Just go to Saint Denis

And greet everyone

[hidden moss]

Or you can fish and throw back the fish in the water

Another easy way to get honor

Yea

Im gonna do greeting one

It seems faster than fishing becuz u have to wait

Ok

[hidden moss]

Hey guyd whats a good satchel to carry 40+ carrots and apples or so

Dutch

Tuberculosis

Bro what

oh

i thought i was

[hidden moss]

sorry idk

Provisions satchel

Ight thanks

Im gonna try to do the horse glitch in the mission "Horse flesh for dinner"

To get the black arabian

yo guys so like

i want your honest opinion on this

so

One of my friends, pirated the game on PC

when i asked him why he said "But i already had it on PS4, i don't wanna spend money to get the same game again"

You shouldn't pirate a game even if you've already bought it

[umbral kestrel]

Why doesn’t John wear Arthur’s hat in epilogue

[hidden moss]

Undermines all of the hard work and dedication the developers, actors, producers, designers etc. Put into it

[umbral kestrel]

Honestly if he already owns a copy and he’s paid for the experience pirating isn’t wrong in this case imo

[hidden moss]

Yeah that's what i think too

[umbral kestrel]

Bruh ur name

[hidden moss]

Is fine to pirate at this point

What's up with my name

[umbral kestrel]

Nth

[hidden moss]

I pirated the game for like 2 reasons

1. i already had it on PS4

2.I bought it on PC but then somehow lost my account

I had my account on epic games and one day it just fucking changed the email out of nowhere

I couldn't log in and i had already spent alot of money

No choice really

[umbral kestrel]

But it’s real cheap when it’s discounted

Plus can u even play online with a pirated ver

[hidden moss]

No you can't but i don't play online anyways

Piracy is a crime in alot of places

Yeah ik but it doesn't really count here

I already owned 2 copies of the game

Plus it is but in my country the cops don't arrest you for stealing lmao

[umbral kestrel]

No one gives a shit 🫣

They don’t bother

Checking

Unless it’s rly large scale

I pírate movies and tv shows everyday

[hidden moss]

If you aren't willing to pay for something you shouldn't have it

Hello

[umbral kestrel]

🫣

[wise gazelle]

Pirating is chad

Just cause I am willing to pay money for something doesn't mean I expect everyone else to

Poor people should play cool games as well

[wise gazelle]

Game is about a bunch of outlaws stealing and robbing their way through life

[hidden moss]

I was poor myself before but i still did not pirate a thing since I didn't want to undermine other people's hard work

If rockstar weren't a bigger company it is piracy twats who would make it so the people they employ are not paid the amount they should be

[wise gazelle]

Just stumbled on a cults cabin

[umbral kestrel]

Wut cult

[wise gazelle]

I think it's a reference to those people that committed suicide to be picked up by aliens and stuff

its creepy

[hardy surge]

Do panthers spawn at night or any time?

[hidden moss]

Any time

[hardy surge]

Can you lure them with average predator bait?

[hidden moss]

I haven't really used bait I kinda just ran around their region until one tried to kill me

But otherwise I doubt it, potent is the best way to go if you want to use bait

[hardy surge]

Perfect panther pelt

Let's goooo

[humble pasture]

Anyone knoe any ps4 rdr2 story mode glitches if so dm me

[gleaming basin]

im just asking this (its a glitch for the singleplayer not online)
does anyone know good outfit/chlothing glitches for arthur?

[subtle halo]

It's not exactly a glitch but it's sort of an exploit or more like a tip well after finishing the mission a fine night of dewbachy if you change your outfit the mission exclusive outfit would be gone to avoid this you have to just equip a hat and the game will save it. Also after the mission the wheel the hat which john is wearing is a special hat in order to get it for forever you will have to make the hat fall off and then wear it again

[lucid trellis]

Damn, the pirates got banned

Reap what you sow

[modest acorn]

May not be so cool anymore but i finally did horsemen 9 as Arthur and i now can die happy

[wise gazelle]

I assume those skills carry over from Arthur to the prologue

[brittle magnet]

How many fishing missions are in chapter3?

[gleaming basin]

with the camp people?

atleast 2 or more

[quick pike]

there's the mission with Dutch and Hosea, and then you can go fishing with Javier and with Kieran

[gleaming basin]

earlier i just saw pearson fishing behind dutchs tent so i joined him

it wasent a mission tho

[mint prairie]

Hello

[hidden moss]

I finished chap 2 (:

[patent ocean]

Does anyone know how to get rid of the grainy effect on pc?

[hidden moss]

How do I manually shoot people with dead eye

[steel night]

finish the mission "urban pleasures"

its in chapter 4

[hidden moss]

I don’t think so

I already unlocked it

But idk what the controls r

Ong I’m in the Aberdeen pig farm rn

[finite charm]

Down on the stick on Xbox.. The one you use to look around tap down on it

[hidden moss]

Oh right

[slow fjord]

Yes

[frail kernel]

wdym grainy effect

your resolution?

[patent ocean]

Uh kinda

[patent ocean]

Yk how grains look

Like grains of sand

It look like that

[frail kernel]

send me a screenshot

in dms

[patent ocean]

O

[frail kernel]

of ur screen in game

[patent ocean]

K

[boreal stone]

I hate not being able to access the stable In valentine until that stupid mission with Hosea (ngl it’s actually a funny mission)

[hidden moss]

i just killed like 8 KKK members

[boreal stone]

Chad

[uncut pond]

hey

[red helm]

Evening

[hidden moss]

gained some honor so worth it

[hidden moss]

Where's completed story chat

Because i need to say things

There’s one? If so i could use the role too

[hidden moss]

I would assume not, it sounds a tad pointless

[soft raven]

So on my old PS4 I got the ultimate edition. I traded it in to get the PS5 from Gamestop. Now when I download the game, only the special edition content is available to download.. not the ultimate edition. I've tried restoring licenses and both option 5s in safemode. Rebuild database and the other one. It still only lets me get special edition. And If I look at the ultimate edition in the ps store, it tells me I already own a different edition " rdr2 ultimate edition POP" and won't let me download it. I've seen people say they had to transfer data from their PS4 to get their ultimate edition or pre order content but where I traded mine in it isn't an option..

[verbal portal]

Fail

[misty sun]

I just realized that all or most missions related to the natives have some form of trumpets or drums in their mission themes

[boreal stone]

Yeah most of them

[hidden moss]

Hey guys where do u get leatherworking tools for pearson

[misty sun]

Ledger

At the donation box

[hidden moss]

I dont see him

[misty sun]

Wdym

[hidden moss]

Oh wait theres a button

Nvm

Fhanks

[misty sun]

Np

[hidden moss]

Oh no im going broke

[hidden moss]

thats why i wait to purchase it until i have the monies for it

[frail kernel]

is it possible to get legendary fish by just lobbing dynamite at them

[boreal stone]

No

lol

[frail kernel]

why not

u cant damage legendary animal pelts so why not fishes

[misty sun]

I mean

I thew a tomahawk at one

Those big fish

It was a one star but it works!

Oh wait legendary?

I don’t think so

[hidden moss]

Anyone know 3 star deer locations

[midnight dawn]

Legendary fish aren't near the shore usually, and if you manage to kill one with a dynamite you won't be able to pick it up

[hidden moss]

I found one got a perfec pelt

But then i tried taking it of the horse

And i thought u had to click discard

So 30 minute of deer hunting one

Gone

[midnight dawn]

Deer is literally everywhere just keep your eyes peeled

[hidden moss]

Ight

[misty sun]

Captain Monroe is the best side character

Change my mind

[boreal stone]

May I introduce strange man,Sadie Adler,the veteran (aka hamishe), hamishe Sinclair,black belle,and Hosea.

[red helm]

Charlotte.

[boreal stone]

Yes

[misty sun]

Veteran is a cool guy

[boreal stone]

Fr

[misty sun]

Black Belle is meh now

[boreal stone]

I miss him

[misty sun]

Same

I actually cried when he died

[red helm]

Black Belle was cool.

[boreal stone]

As Badass as she was there’s actually a cool secret in her hutch

[random edge]

when the veteran died, i burn him with molotov :)

[misty sun]

You psychopath

How could you

[random edge]

he will rot man, so i burn him and bring him to the lake near his house

[red helm]

The Exotic mission guy, Algernon Wasp? He is actually pretty neat. They just needed to make us gather significantly less items for those missions... Just way to many, it makes it so you don't even care about that story line when you turn them in.

[misty sun]

Never had the will to get his stuff

[boreal stone]

Yeah and when you’re finished he gives you a sick revolver

[misty sun]

Most brutal mission has to be that moonshine guy though

In Saint Denis

[red helm]

Exactly, someone said it's something like 180 items total.. or some ridiculous amount.

[red helm]

Electric Chair, that one is indeed funny, but yes, brutal.

[boreal stone]

I did that mission and regretted it

[misty sun]

It made me uncomfortable

[boreal stone]

Same

Still gives me chills

[misty sun]

I started HATING “oh no i fell! can you take me away from your initial destination?”

Those women

[boreal stone]

Lol

[red helm]

I like when you capture the guy and are riding back to Saint Denis with him, and Arthur is just explaining thing to him. Like, how Arthur saw some cattle after lightning hit them...

[boreal stone]

Yeah

That’s hilarious

[misty sun]

I shot one with a sawed off because I ENCOUNTERED HER THREE TIMES IN A ROW

[boreal stone]

Lmao 🤣

[red helm]

Sometimes that lady is actually a trap and a bunch of dudes try to rob you, so....

[misty sun]

I would’ve preferred the robbery

Is it just me or I love doing single player poker

Or blackjack

[boreal stone]

Who else loves going all rdr ending on van horniens?

[random edge]

yeah, i usually play pokers in van horn, ends up shooting the whole town

[red helm]

The Dialogs during the poker/blackjack games can be kind of funny.

[misty sun]

Nah I play it in Saint Denis

Whats your favourite state

[random edge]

west elizabeth

[red helm]

The Area around Strawberry is the prettiest.

[random edge]

and new hanover

[misty sun]

Mine has to be Ambarnio

Or New Austin

[random edge]

i love big valley and lake owanjila

[misty sun]

Dude the snow and mountain views are so fucking pretty

Ambarnio deserves to have a location other then Wapiti and Colter

[random edge]

i tried to go to the mountain where javier and arthur finds john, i tried to go to that mountain but my horse always slide down, and i tried it a few times still the same.

[misty sun]

Arthurs lines when finish is so good

“You sir, are a fish.”

Dead chat

[frail terrace]

michas better than arthur in every aspect

[misty sun]

I do not understand your views

[patent ocean]

How do I get rid of the grainy effect on pc

[civic vault]

Maybe you're at the part where you need to go there on foot

[hidden moss]

Hey guys whats better

High or low honor?

[hearty knot]

Im about to start My Last Boy

[frail kernel]

low honor is for cynical pyscopaths who dont give a shit about the story and like to kill innocent people

but u get more loot from dead people + some other benefits idk

high honor gives discounts at shops, it’s harder to earn, and makes the story better imo

personally I do low honor at the start and nearing the end i do high honor as a part of the whole redemption thing

[hidden moss]

Low honor is fun but high honor is like an achievement

So ig ill just go high honor

Im still at middle

[frail kernel]

yeah thats a nicer way of putting it lol

[hidden moss]

Yo guys im trying to get provision satchel

But

Idk where to give the perfect pelt

There is no option to get it from thr horse

[hearty knot]

Should i start our best selves

[random edge]

still the same man

[random edge]

if you are high honor, arthur's grave will be full of flower, if arthur is low honor, there are no flowers in his grave

and if arthur is low honor, he will die tragic

low honor: in the end when arthur fights with micah, micah will shoot arthur's head.

High honor: In the end when arthur fights with micah, micah will leave arthur, and then arthur will enjoy his last sunrise

[hidden moss]

Hey guys

Does your honor lower when you

For ex

Punch someone but the game tells you to

[wheat pendant]

If you fast traveled to camp it despawned you gotta get another one

Either that or check horse cargo

[hidden moss]

What i did was

I checked horse cargo

It was there

There was no option to get it or something

So i thought i had to click discard

And then it gone

[wheat pendant]

well

You gotta get another perfect pelt

If you’re having a helluva hard time and don’t know the best spawn spots you can always go to #rdo-compendium

When you get to the cougar I suggest going north of Owanjila and either riding around or place potent/normal predator bait

and for the panther do the same thing but go south of braithwaite manor

[dull geyser]

No

[hearty knot]

My horse died nooo

[sinful sundial]

I need an Arthur plushie so bad

I want one

[hearty knot]

Arthur died nooo

[fickle chasm]

Welcome to Red Dead Depression my friend

[violet osprey]

My compendium says i have found the laramie gang hideout but total completion says i havent

[violet osprey]

Yeahhh i played my second playthrough and cried again today.

Anyways

Any tips on fixing this?

Also by gang hideouts does that mean 100%-ing the gang in the compendium or just finding the hideout?

Help

Ok nvm figured it out

[real lantern]

whats your guys' least favorite chapter?

[violet osprey]

Horseshoe Overlook

Felt kinda long

With nothing happening

[real lantern]

eh

fair enough

i always thought it was a bit of an extension to the tutorial

at least the first half

but half the things you're taught in there dont make sense to be taught in colter so i can see why it dragged onto there

[hidden moss]

Hey guys

Im planning on taming a white Arabian

Hey is rockstar down?

Any good saddles i should use?

[real lantern]

not sure saddles make a difference

just

get a white one

idk

[hidden moss]

hey

is rockstar down guys

[real lantern]

ive no clue why you're asking that in the singleplayer channel

nor do i have a clue in general

[hidden moss]

oh ok

mb

[hardy surge]

The White Arabian horse despawned on me and now it won't spawn back, is there a way to make it spawn?

I've been at Lake Isabella for more than 30 minutes now and the snow covered rocks are beginning to look like white horses

Looked it up and it's exactly what I feared

With the wonderful Red Dead 2's fast travel system that doesn't exist I need to travel all the way across the map to do a mission and wait 24 in-game hours

Awesome, thanks game

[real lantern]

fast travel to valentine

thats what i did

when i gave half a shit about the white arabian

[hardy surge]

How do I fast travel?

[potent nest]

You can take the train or coach

[real lantern]

get the camp upgrade

[hardy surge]

All for a horse

I'm gonna go play Minecraft

[real lantern]

you see what i mean

its too much work for a horse

[hardy surge]

One of the best horses

[real lantern]

doesnt really mean much

i caught a mustang for half the work and he's done me just fine

[hardy surge]

For you

I'm a completionist

It's an unliftable curse

[real lantern]

well

[hardy surge]

I'm gonna be forced to come back and get it eventually

[real lantern]

do you have a controller?

[hardy surge]

I play on keyboard

[real lantern]

but do you have one

at all

[hardy surge]

I do

[real lantern]

because it makes actually breaking the thing so easy

you just hold 5 o'clock on the left joystick

well off i go to spend half my money gambling

this totally isnt provoking any former health problems

[hardy surge]

@real lantern I broke it

[slow fjord]

The panther saddle's the best one in the game

Just get a perfect panther pelt and you can then craft it at a trapper

[hidden moss]

Ight

I'm really starting to like hunting especially because of the satisfaction and the rifle

[slow fjord]

Yeah hunting's good

[hidden moss]

Hey guys are saddles the only one you can craft or are there stirrups you can craft

[dull geyser]

a tie between the rattlesnake or panther saddle

i just got both so I don't have to choose

[dull geyser]

you can only buy stirrups and the trapper saddles have their own stirrups iirc

[hidden moss]

Ohh

So if i were to craft the panther saddle

It would already have a better stirrup

[misty sun]

Bolt action best

[hidden moss]

Cant unlock it ywt

[misty sun]

F

[misty sun]

Which playthrough are you on

I’m on my 8th

[hidden moss]

First

Chapter 3

[misty sun]

Oh

How come I joined rdr2 discord server after a whole year

Not even knowing it existed

[hidden moss]

Lol

If the game exists

It probably has a discord

[onyx cliff]

i found all the rock carvings for francis sinclair

how do i collect the reward

hes not on the map

[slow fjord]

Go to his shack

Or wait a bit

[onyx cliff]

ive waited a long time

ill try shack

[slow fjord]

Has it worked

[onyx cliff]

im doing somethi

exotic feathers

veryu tedious

[hidden moss]

He should send you an invitation in a day or two and you will be able to collect it at any of the post offices

[onyx cliff]

oops

ive had the invitation

lol

[hidden moss]

Did you read it?

[hidden moss]

Nahhh Springfield bro

You would not really use them for the same animals anyways

I use the Springfield for everything

[misty sun]

Springfield is cool

It sounds nice

[hidden moss]

It.might be slow but it's good

And yea it sounds cool

I'd say the bolt action is best for mid sized animals for its higher ammo capacity and fire rate and Springfield for larger ones due to it being more powerful and accurate

[misty sun]

I mean

Both are basically the same

I only use bolt action because its faster

[hidden moss]

Are they now with the reasons I listed?

[misty sun]

Wdym “are they now“

[hidden moss]

Yo guys

When u switch to John

Do u still keep your money

Horses

Etc

You only keep unique items (like trinkets or talismans) and weapons I do believe.

So your money resets and horses????

[onyx cliff]

yes

you get johns horse

but trust me you wont have to worry about money

[hidden moss]

Why?

If i get gold bars as arthur maybe 8 and not sell them

Do they carry on to John?

I have 1 gold bar rn and i know 6 other locations i havent gotten

No I don't think so

It is a bit stupid indeed although I guess they could say John used them in the time skip as a canon reason

[slow fjord]

no

sell the gold bars

and before the final mission go to aberdeen pig farm

get robbed and kill the siblings

and leave the money at the house

[hidden moss]

Or just sell them and spend all of your money on random shit before

[slow fjord]

you can then pick up the money as john

[hidden moss]

So if im correct

Before final missjon in chapter 6 get all the gold bars sell them then go to aberdeen to get robbed

Then once you become John

You kill the people

And get the money?

Or you dont have to kill the people?

I dont wanna ruin my honor

[slow fjord]

You won't lose honour

[slow fjord]

Kill the people as Arthur

[floral dagger]

U don’t have to kill

If u don’t want

[hidden moss]

Well how will they rob me if i kill them?

Ohh

You mean

Once they rob you

Go back there

And then kill them

Then do the last 2 missions?

[floral dagger]

Yes

Just don’t take the money upstairs

[hidden moss]

Ok

Thanks

Im gonna get all 24 maybe in chap 4

You can just wait until after

[dull geyser]

Lenny's gonna give you one when you rob shady belle

The ones on the shady belle

[hidden moss]

I got a one already

[normal relic]

Cool

[hidden moss]

But its only tjr one where

You herd sheeps

So its not the best

But will do

[normal relic]

Gold bars

[hidden moss]

Oh

I thought he meant rifles

[normal relic]

Ohhh

Idk where the rifles are

I thought he was talking about gold bars and rifles

[hidden moss]

Oh dear, I have had the grave encounter with the guy who seemingly is a zoophile in RDR1

[gleaming basin]

i got two questions about the game

1. after arthur dies, if he have stabled horses like in valetine - can john go get those horses arthur has stabled?

2. The Arabian Horse - if arthur gets the horse and uses it, it will die in the last mission because that will be arthurs main horse - when playing as john after will it spawn again or is it dead forever?

[uncut berry]

1. no john cannot collect those horses, they're gone

2. no, the horse is dead forever

[gleaming basin]

oh thanks

[hidden moss]

You can get it back in the wild

Assuming you mean the white one

Idk if anyone knows this but Xbox’s don’t like soda in thier fans
But some how mine manages to attract one from across the room
I tripped in my hall way and the soda went flying right at my window and into my Xbox’s fans
Now I’m out $200
Yay me
my xbox is a homing soda missile magnet
now ill never get out of chapter 4

[gleaming basin]

the white one yes

up in the snow mountains

[hidden moss]

Yeah you will be able to find her again and tame her

[normal relic]

I still haven't found the white one yet

i have the black one

[hidden moss]

neither have i really want it tho

[normal relic]

i was going too after completing 100%

[gleaming basin]

so your saying that if arthur has the arabian (white) in the last mission and it dies - after a while john can then go and tame her?

[hidden moss]

Yes, I did it, as long as you go to the same spot you originally find her

[normal relic]

I never knew that

[gleaming basin]

kinda hard to tame her tho

[hidden moss]

It is no different to taming any other horse

[gleaming basin]

yeah

i just slowly walk to her and calms her

when i get near it gets scared and runs away

[hidden moss]

Yo guyd

If i sell one gold bar

So that means i would have 500$

[gleaming basin]

yes

[hidden moss]

Would that be enough until chaoter 6?

So then i can leave the treasure hunts and gold location for John to get

[gleaming basin]

yes

if you leave the goldbars leave john can go get them

if arthur still has gold bars in his satchel john can go sell them at a fence

[hidden moss]

So i guess i would just sell my one gold bar thrn continue the story

Then once i become john

After a few missiond

Ill go get the gold bars?

[hidden moss]

Wdym? I heard the gold dont carry over

[gleaming basin]

they dont?

man idk then

[normal relic]

What are the gold bars even for in story?

[hidden moss]

Lots of people say they dknt

[hidden moss]

Money

[gleaming basin]

i mean

[hidden moss]

If you already have them they dont

[normal relic]

Ohh

I never found any

[gleaming basin]

john gets 20k in the end

[hidden moss]

Because people say that id you collect gold bars as arthur you can sell them and then get robbed in the pig farm which then John can take back

They're easy to find with the treasure hunts

[hidden moss]

Bro it’s literally easy bags

But i just realized you have to kill a gang

[normal relic]

I tried finding the gold bar in the burnt ruins of Braithwaite Manor

[hidden moss]

It's only two people you would have to kill, but even with that it is easier to just get the gold as john

[hidden moss]

Aberdeen pig farm dope

[normal relic]

I missed alot when rushing story

[hidden moss]

I killed then all last night

[hidden moss]

You fooooool

Is selling just one gold bar then leaving the other treasure hunts to John a good idea?

[normal relic]

I was stupid and rushed it

[hidden moss]

Yes

[hidden moss]

[normal relic]

I never knew any of this stuff till now

[hidden moss]

Ight

I guess ill sell my 1 gold tomorrow thrn tame the arabisn

@hidden moss I started chap 3 last night

Arabian

Having an absolute BALL

Spend all your money before the final mission I recommend

[hidden moss]

I started earlier this morning

My fav mission so far is fishing

[hidden moss]

It’s so good

It was so wholesome

[hidden moss]

The train robbery mission is amazing

[normal relic]

I got to figure out how to make another new save to restart story

[hidden moss]

The one before chap 3?

The one with the oil thing

If yea then yea it was cool

The only downside is i had to pay a bounty

I think im on level +1 honor

Very cool

[hidden moss]

Yeah that’s the one

I skipped the fishing with hosea and Dutch

WHYYYYY

It was wholesome

I didn’t want to go fish

And i got some honor

[gleaming basin]

i did it

[hidden moss]

[gleaming basin]

i tamed the arabian horse

[hidden moss]

They was sharing old stories while fishing

[hidden moss]

Bruh it just made me want to do Aberdeen pig farm more

So I did it

Bruh

Im focused on getting high homor

Honor

Aberdeen pig farm was top notch

So the chance i get i take it

[hidden moss]

I’m the opposite

Bro I hate that i had to travel across the map just so i can send 2 love birds letter

Like bro im an outlaw with probably over 100 kills

Not a mailman

[hidden moss]

It is merely a brother and sister in an incestual relationship who drug you and steal from you who you then go back to kill.

Hey guys is the red Arabian worth taming

Im too lazy to kill 50 people judt to get money back so i guess ill just leave some gold bars for John to get

It aint that hard to get anyways just long

[hidden moss]

I killed then first tho

[hidden moss]

What r u talking about

[normal relic]

Idk never could find the red arabian in story

[hidden moss]

Treasure hunts

Theyre very easy to do

Its just always across the map

[hidden moss]

They werent in the story

[normal relic]

I think you can get treasure maps

Oh

[hidden moss]

Theyre in some place in thr lake besides the strawberry label on the map

White arabian is better though

So i guess ill just go for it

[normal relic]

Yep

So is the black one

I bought the black arabian in Saint Denis

[hidden moss]

I probably will as well

Either

Tame the white arabian

So i can bond 4 her

Then sell her in chap 4

To get the black one

[normal relic]

I want the white one

but I want to restart story

[hidden moss]

Loving Irish in RDR1

[normal relic]

Ikr

He was interesting

[dusky ferry]

Might force myself to play the story once a year instead of playing over and over again

[normal relic]

I want to restart story

I rushed it the first time because I didn't know there was more to do

[hidden moss]

Do you know how to save the game?

Manually I do mean

Yo guys do robbing homestead affect honor

Same steps basically to start a new game

[dusky ferry]

If you’ve only played though once it’s 100% worth a second play through

[hidden moss]

Also i saw that if you rob people with bandana on it doesnt affect honor is dat true?

[dusky ferry]

Nope

[hidden moss]

It would depend on the homestead really and no it is not.

Wdym depend on the homestead?

[dusky ferry]

Robing normal people will get you bad honor

[hidden moss]

So

If the home stead was owned by outlaws

Its fine

But if its just normal people

It would lower honor?

Precisely

[normal relic]

No I don't know how to do that

[hidden moss]

All you need to do is when playing story, go into the pause menu and then down to the story tab, it'll give you the options to save, load a save, exit the game or start a new one.

[normal relic]

Ohh

[hidden moss]

Hey does the panther saddle increase speed and accel?

Just asking before i hunt one

[normal relic]

Idk

[hidden moss]

Same I missed out on a lot bc I didn't know about the a
Side missions

[normal relic]

I plan to restart

[hidden moss]

I still haven't finished

Still doing John's bit

[slow fjord]

no

[misty sun]

Bronte is dead

[cedar quiver]

Best region for hunting?

I need some money and best way I can think of is hunting.

[gleaming basin]

is there a location with skunks spawning alot? i am hunting one for an outfit

[analog talon]

Hey! Does anyone know where I can catch large fish?

Not legendary but large

[winged adder]

big valley

[cedar quiver]

Ok. Where’s that on the map?

[gleaming basin]

let me show you it in dms

[cedar quiver]

Thanks

[cyan tartan]

Does a higher donation give more honor at the hideout
?

[hidden moss]

Chapter 3 is making me have so much fun

[frail kernel]

hunting isnt a really good way to make money unless theyre legendary pelts

[violet osprey]

Cedar waxwing hunting tips?

[cedar quiver]

What is then?

I

Don’t

Have

A

[hidden moss]

im on chapter 3 too

[cedar quiver]

Choice

[hidden moss]

I did the shiner mission and it’s so good

im not that far in

Speak to Dutch and you can do it

im at the begining of it

[hidden moss]

Robbing trains or hunting for treasure seems to typically make you the most amount of money

[violet osprey]

Do treasure maps

[cedar quiver]

They’re scams probably

[violet osprey]

I got like 5000+ dollars of gold from doing the jack hall, high stakes and poisonous trail maps

[cedar quiver]

Ol’Driscols will probably jump me

[violet osprey]

Then i dont know what to tell you

[void eagle]

why is it that the cops will shoot at me for literally just bumping into people while walking by accident?

[violet osprey]

Rockstar logic lol

[hidden moss]

How much money do you have

[hidden moss]

like 1.3K

around there

i just got off for a bit

Did you do gold bars?

no

probably should though

You can get like 9 gold bars easily

That’s £4500

euros?

$4500

is there a video on them

Yeah I’ll send it

[hidden moss]

Cheers Hogrider420 that is most definitely euros

dm it

[hidden moss]

Lol

I said pounds at first but I always say pounds as it’s just my currency

i got fast travel which will make it easy for me

[hidden moss]

Removes the fun tho

[violet osprey]

Can someone give me cedar waxwing hunting tips

[hidden moss]

not when you play it for a third time

[hidden moss]

Oh right

It kinda still does tho

As you don’t have like run ins with strangers and things like that

Ti's mad how you're able to skin horses, cats and dogs in RDR1

You can skin dogs?

Yes you are able to skin any animal in it

[west crescent]

bro the gambler 9 challenge is gonna make me kms

holy fucking shit

its like trying to beat a computer at chess on impossible difficulty

i literally cant win one game

and i have to win 3 in a row

this is gonnna be the one thing preventing me from getting 100%

[austere hornet]

wierd question, but have the horse fence brothers north of clemens point always had a wagon at their spot?

[west crescent]

omfg

the only time i win a round in dominos i get zero points

[hidden moss]

Which animal is better to hunt?

Uh, how exactly do you mean?

[hidden moss]

Sell

if that makes money

Idk

I was thinking about buying a gun to hunt but I don't know which one and how to unlock it

In terms of which makes the most money, anything proper rare, like panthers, moose, bears or cougars

[west crescent]

i have fucking 52 points and im gonnna lose

you cant beat a fucking npc they have infinite luck

fuck this stupid ass challenge

the person who made it can go fuck themselves

[hidden moss]

But really just hunt anything you see it isn't hard in this game with dead eye and the animals being deaf

[west crescent]

omg im gonna kms

i was about to fucking win and then i procedded to draw 5 more fucking tiles

FUCK

WHY

i literally cant 100% the game because of this bullshit

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[west crescent]

its impossible to win

i had 52 points and the npc had like 9

[hidden moss]

Cry more

[west crescent]

go fuck yourself

[violet osprey]

Bit rude innit

The gambler challenges are frustrating me too dont get me wrong but no need to be hostile

[hidden moss]

Woah

[west crescent]

ok

[hidden moss]

Ok

Ti's only bants and rants and cants and tants, dear boy

[patent ocean]

Does anyone know why I have this grainy effect on my pc?

[violet osprey]

Any tips on having npcs bust in poker

[west crescent]

go all in every time

if another npc also goes all in, and ends up losing, then they bust

it doesnt take too long

[wise gazelle]

found the stranger from newyork that's lost on his way to strawberry

should I rob him?

got the White Arabian too today

[frail kernel]

does anyone know how to fix clothes clipping

like half my coat dissapeared

this happens every playthrough im in since chapter 4

[hidden moss]

Hey guys in the rhodes hidden gold bar

Do you need the npc encounter

Or can you judt go there

[hidden moss]

I don't understand poker

I only play money

[wise gazelle]

lol look up a quick tutorial

there must be some explanation in the game as well

[wise gazelle]

just play well, and stay on the same table

[frail kernel]

too complicated, i got 2000 from valentine bank robbery and it costs $1 to buy in so i go all in every time

[hidden moss]

How I steal oil wagon

[frail kernel]

steal it

[violet osprey]

Hmm yes the floor here is made out of floor

[hidden moss]

lol

[cedar quiver]

Where all should I go to get the ghost bison set?

[dull geyser]

Trapper

You got the ghost bison?

[cedar quiver]

I mean the stuff

Wish I could buy the set but I’m gonna have to hunt down all the creatures for it

[cedar quiver]

Nope.

Also how do I make sure I don’t screw up the pelt?

[dull geyser]

Legendary animals' pelts don't get screwed

It's gonna be 3 star even if you kill it with a lot of firepower

[hidden moss]

Unless you use fire or dynamite

[dull geyser]

Yes

You might need a few animal pelts too

I don't remember them but they're needed as well

[hidden moss]

Looking at the wiki you will need 1 perfect sheep hide, 1 perfect goat hide and 1 perfect boar pelt

[dull geyser]

Yea

You come across a decent amount of boars so not much trouble getting a 3 star ig

[hidden moss]

Oh and the legendary elk

[dull geyser]

I thought it was the legendary elk?

[neon stratus]

been raining 3 days in a row now in game what a storm

[hidden moss]

Yeah I was thinking of moose when typing it for some reason

[dull geyser]

Oh ok

You can just kill a goat on a ranch

And sheep too

[cedar quiver]

Ok and where do they usually reside?

[hidden moss]

You can find sheep and goats around ranches, boars you can find over most of lemoyne

[cedar quiver]

Ok

[hidden moss]

Guys

Do the satchel carry over to John?

Like for ex

I have the legend of the east satchel

Will it carry over to John

Yes

On that all clothes carry over to John too

[crude hamlet]

Could anyone please help me out, I started playing for about a week ago and during my playthrough I have been getting a lot of slow rendering and sometimes Arthur will stand idle when trying to loot items, one time I even fell out of the world because the game couldn’t render the floor I was waking in, sometimes it kinda feels like my PS4 can’t even run the game properly, is there a fix to this or at least something I can do to help?

[hidden moss]

What chapter is a proper time to get it

[hidden moss]

The only time i lag when i play is whenver im in a town like valentine rhodes saint denis or something

Ok thanks

[peak fog]

Thank you

[hidden moss]

Need to start utilizing Pearsons tools

[glad brook]

The most important character in the game.

[hidden moss]

Pearson?

[dull geyser]

Yea

You can even buy the legend of the east satchel with john

[dull geyser]

If you didn't get it with arthur

I agree it looks pretty good but I like calloway's revolver more

Otis miller's revolver is the epilogue one

Yea

I like his revolver because its engraving is a bully reference as well

[normal relic]

I got micahs revolver

[dull geyser]

noice

u killed him?

[hidden moss]

Schofield or double action?

[dull geyser]

i personally use schofields but it's your choice double actions are really fast

just pick what looks better tbh they both work well

[normal relic]

Yep I did

[slow fjord]

Either a double action or a schofield

Nice

Good choice

[sly sandal]

I also got Micah's revolver but it disappeared from my weapon wheel in chapter 3 and it's nowhere to be found. Not even in my weapon's locker lol

I do have dual John's revolvers tho

[hidden moss]

Volcanic revolver is mmmm

[hardy surge]

Do cougars spawn once a day? Because every time I snipe one I can't find another in the area

Never mind

Found 2 in the same area

Guess I just had some bad luck yesterday

[hidden moss]

Hey guys i just got a robbery tip to rob aberdeen farm

But you get robbed there

So how do i rob them

Without being robbed

[slow fjord]

just shoot them when you meet them for the first time

[random edge]

reload your save after you hunt cougar

they should spawn again

[hardy surge]

You rob them before they rob you

[hidden moss]

Ight

Also

Anyone know racoon locations

I need pelts

[hardy surge]

And if they rob you anyway, double rob, that'll cancel out their robbery in the end because you take your stuff back and some of their stuff too

[random edge]

in rhodes maybe? around the braithwaite manor

because i usually step on a racoon near the braithwaite manor

[dull geyser]

I got mine on the woods outside of clemens point

Im pretty sure they know when you're looking for them lmaoo

They don't appear when you need them

[hidden moss]

Hey guys

I went to the farm

Killed the dude outside

Then the girl rushed out the door

And stabbed me

I went back and they not there

[grave shale]

You mean the pigfarm? Well you will never see them again ig

[hardy surge]

It's better to just google

Unless you like sinking hours and days into riding your horse around the entire map up, down, left right and around

[peak pebble]

im thinking in maybe a few months maybe replaying rdr2 again. I feel like I rushed and missed a few major parts and just didnt explore a lot, idk

[dull geyser]

Yea there's a lot of things I missed during my first playthrough too

I missed more than I imagined

[midnight dawn]

I got my 100% during my first

[dull geyser]

Damn

[midnight dawn]

I don't like replaying games even if they're top tier

[dull geyser]

Yea I get that feeling too just on other games tho

[swift canyon]

why the fuck do trains sometimes stay in stations for a solid 10 mins

this is so annoying

[gleaming basin]

anyone know a location where skunks spawn alot?

[swift canyon]

i find them the most near annesburg

i think they spawn in grizzlies (east) too

[peak pebble]

yeah and I got the bad ending unfortunately

the low honor one

[hidden moss]

All i keep seeing is it saying that you get robbed and u go back and take it back

[hardy surge]

I'm replying to raccoon locations

I have no idea what mission you're talking about

[swift canyon]

they replied to the wrong message

[hardy surge]

Or have they?

[swift canyon]

nah they're talking about if you get robbed at the pig farm you can get your money back

[hidden moss]

Ohhhh

Well

I did

And went to the locatjons

But there was only snakes

Badgers

Guys

Whats a good satchel to craft for my first?

[hidden moss]

Ive been playing for a week and a half and im still in chap 2

I tamed an arabian today

Then tomorrowm imma make a panther saddle

And make a satchel

Idk what satchel though

[swift canyon]

well how many can you make?

[sly sandal]

Good luk

luck*

For some reason it took me like 4 hours to find a perfect panther

[wise gazelle]

Should I sell legendary pelts to the trapper? Kind of forgot how it works

he takes money for it though, it doesn't say crafting

[onyx solstice]

Is there a fast way of crafting split ammo

[onyx solstice]

Yea sell them and they become part of crafting

[wise gazelle]

ty fam

hunting is so much fun

[onyx solstice]

Yea I'm hunting rn too lol

I don't think I will even need all the satchel upgrades but im just doing it so I have a reason to hunt

[wise gazelle]

these bounty hunters wont leave me alone lol

I'm trying to do this legendary hunt but bounty hunters keep showing up

[onyx solstice]

It's nice that your honor doesn't go down when killing them though

[wise gazelle]

yes but it does if you accidently nail their horses

[undone ginkgo]

Where do you find skunks? I'm trying to complete the Uncle item request in the epilogue