red-dead-singleplayer

[grand phoenix]

The skin deep and zoologist achievements are really difficult because the animals I need won’t spawn it’s so annoying

[frigid cedar]

u want it that bad

[rose haven]

What do you mean he became skinny

[hidden moss]

i went back like a lot of days later and now he is not fat anymore

he then invited me inside again

hit me with a bat

took 1 dollar

i came back

he hid inside

i kicked the door open and then shot him

it was 1 dollar

[bronze pumice]

Could you send a screenshot, or is he already gone?

[hidden moss]

he is gone

he was like way skinnier than arthur actually

[bronze pumice]

Damn, I would have wanted to see that.

[hidden moss]

he said some stuff like "You are my pet now"

[hidden moss]

tbh i killed his wife, ran away and came back a chapter later

that might be the cause

[bronze pumice]

Are you sure it was the same house, and not another person?

[hidden moss]

it was the exact same house

he was wearing the same clothes

at first i tought it was a different house but nope

a little north of the city

[bronze pumice]

Okay.

How does that even happen? Did they also give him a separate skinny model? Is his weight adjustable?

[rose haven]

I think you're talking about sonny

The guy who drugs and r**es your character

[bronze pumice]

I thought he was talking about him too, but he said it was the same house.

[rose haven]

North of the city though

Only city is Saint Denis

[bronze pumice]

Yeah, I guess he got the houses mixed up.

[fallow prawn]

if you left a horse at shady belle at the end of chapter 4, will it be there after chapter 5?

tried to find it in the stable, wasnt there

[civic vault]

For me it was there in chapter 5

[fickle chasm]

you got the wrong house mister 😭

[fickle chasm]

you visited the r@pists house

not the aberdeen pig farm

[civic vault]

They really do spawn so fast lol. Their spawn number grows too if you manage to make it past the first few spawns that no amount of tonics would save you lol

[fickle chasm]

yep

[civic vault]

im gonna practice the path tonight. im not gonna try the bridge. my tukorman somehow doesnt like it

[fickle chasm]

it's easier with smaller horses

[civic vault]

gonna try the tall trees path

[fickle chasm]

isn't that longer tho?

[civic vault]

Yeah but doable

[fickle chasm]

oh alright

[civic vault]

Hmmm or maybe i'll get the white arabian ang bond with it to level 4 first before i try that challenge

i don't want to lose my tukorman on the bridge lol

[fickle chasm]

lmao

donkeys can do the jump easily

[civic vault]

The one time i tried to jump it i fell with my horse and it almost died. good thing i still had a reviver

[fickle chasm]

falling down there sucks

especially as john

[civic vault]

and the moment i fell down, dem lawmen spawn and started shooting at me

and i was in the middle of the river

had to give my horse and Arthur a ton of tonics

[fickle chasm]

loll

[civic vault]

if the fall didnt kill it, the lawmen would lol

[calm forge]

[civic vault]

[calm forge]

[calm forge]

what’s wrong

[civic vault]

Just tired from work

[civic vault]

i should get one for the lolz

[fickle chasm]

lmao

[midnight dawn]

Once you get to the bridge don't instantly jump, your horse usually is very agitated and tired from that long run. Stop, pat it and walk slowly, once you're on the bridge start galloping

Usually when horses are agitated they don't jump

[calm forge]

[frigid cedar]

yo the hatchet makes me feel like wolverine

u dont even need to tackle the enemy first

[hidden moss]

Really? They both wear the same outfit

I think

Idk

Never seen the r@pist

Or maybe it was him hold up imma Google rn

Ok so yeah it was the r@pist, they wear the same clothing

[fickle chasm]

yep

the aberdeens are located a bit further north west

iirc

[deft knot]

Fishing that legendary Muskie was a pain in the ass

[frigid cedar]

how long it took

[magic kite]

funny does anyone steam got problem???

[deft knot]

~30min... but like ~10min to stow it on my horse

Managed to get my horse swim to me since I always lost it when I went in the water but anyways got it

[true drift]

love how Arthur refers Jean-Marc as “John Mark” in his journal

[digital bay]

bruh who said hunting baits dont spawn new animals

they do

i put a herbivore bait and a moose spawned out of nowhere in the heartlands

and then i put a predator bait to complete the challenge and a boar also spawned out of nowhere in the heartlands

they both dont spawn there also i never saw any animals around for both of them and also when they spawned i could not see how many stars the animals had

so ig it spawns a new animal when there are no nearby animals around

[thick heron]

i’ve been playing for years and never noticed that. everytime i lay bait nothing happens or it starts to rain and of course nothing happens

[digital bay]

also they spawned like 10seconds after i put the bait but people say they wait for 10mins and nothing happens

[frigid cedar]

well is that your last legendary fish

[magic kite]

ok i found when i uninstall steam the game also gone

now i gonna download back

hope the save still there

otherwise i gonna restart again

[digital bay]

also i finally did master hunter and horseman in 1 day

[magic kite]

with Hunting Skin/Pelt

as perfect condition

[digital bay]

hardest ones was the one that asked you to kill 5 cougars with a bow

the rest are easy

[magic kite]

it easy for me tho

ride horse and keep looking the mini map and hear the sound

[digital bay]

i am almost done with herbalist but the last 2 i need to be john to finish it

[digital bay]

i did it in 40mins

[magic kite]

also make sure keep the horse calm too

[deft knot]

Nah my 7th I think

[limber swan]

I'm thinking about what to do with completion. Currently I'm in prologue and at 87% overall. But I really want to Arthur. Should I start again and try and get as much possible complete as Arthur?

I'm guessing I'd need to get further in the game to check of most things? Or is it possible from chapter 2?

[digital bay]

thats what i am doing

wait do you need to do every stranger mission to get 100% completion

[magic kite]

if my save gone i gonna start again

(deep dense sound

[deft knot]

I don't play any main quests I just enjoy hunting, fishing, sidequests and all that rn... Also my outfit must be fire or I don't even want to continue the story lol

[magic kite]

(dead cold eye of shadow

[limber swan]

No I think it's just a few

[digital bay]

yea i just need 10

[limber swan]

Question is, do I put the time in now and get my 87% to 100% on John

or play a chapter 2 arthur save

[digital bay]

depends if you really want to play as arthur

[deft knot]

Anyone here who prefers John over Arthur to play?

[limber swan]

I prefer Arthur because I had RDR1 to play as john 😄

[digital bay]

ffs i cant do sharpshooter 3 as arthur

there are no trains in chapter 6\

anyone know a mission i can replay that i can use a train and shoot 5 birds?

[fickle chasm]

hmm

no idts

[digital bay]

its so funny cause the mission the fine art of conversation is after the mission bridge to nowhere yet the guy still gets a train

[fickle chasm]

huh ?which guy?

[digital bay]

maybe 'the new south'?

[fickle chasm]

ohh

[digital bay]

the captain

[fickle chasm]

Captain Monroe?

ah

lmao

He avoided guarma but went straight down a cliff 😔

[digital bay]

lol

maybe the mission the new south thats the mission where you go capture a bounty while the train is moving

knowing this game there prob is a timer

[limber swan]

Like I don't think I can get the fishing rod without getting further in Chapter 2

So may just 100% as John then just make a new playthrough. Play as Bad guy arthur for the first time.

[digital bay]

i can think of 2 mission the chapter 1 train robbery and the 'new south' chapter 3 where you go capture a gang in a train

bruh i cant do the mission cause it says the law was alerted if i shoot

even tho there is a cop right next to me

[hidden moss]

so my horse ran outside the map

is there something east of Saint Denis that i do not know?

[frigid cedar]

do u have pic

[sleek granite]

there is the prison

[hidden moss]

oh, idk my horse just got flung and it didnt die

ill try to go on later

[lean sparrow]

Why do they kill bronte

[fierce valve]

Revenge

[fickle chasm]

Revenge for Daddy

wait no that's the braithwaites and the grays

[lean sparrow]

What did he do i forgot

[digital bay]

he talks about his dad at the start of the mission the new south

[lean sparrow]

Why does arthur go to the oil reservate

[fickle chasm]

to save Eagle Flies

[lean sparrow]

From what

[fickle chasm]

from dying

[lean sparrow]

How

Im talking about the first interaction with them

The chief

And eagle flies

[magic kite]

download complete

let check back my save files

yup still got it

[digital bay]

bro i hate this game so much

am just trying to have fun and an army of lemonye raiders ambush me with a machine gun and i die in 2sec and so does my horse

and my last save was like 2 and a half hours ago

[rose haven]

Ah I get you

What was your horse

[digital bay]

buell

[rose haven]

F

[digital bay]

worst thing is i was doing challenges ffs

now i have to do them all over again

i should turn on auto save at this point

[calm crow]

Im so confused

After Arthur calls Micah a rat Micah claims to be a “survivor”. Like everyone in the gang are survivors

[vernal storm]

Nooo not Buell

[digital bay]

he meant that he will do anything to survive

i dont think he went to the pinkertons

they prob caught him and threatened to kill him if he did not help

or he realised how screwed the gang was and decided to betray the gang and save himself

[vernal storm]

I think this one more

Micah betrays the gang to have all the money for himself. Or no?

[digital bay]

well if he did indeed help the pinkertons he could have gotten dutch's and the entire gang's bounty which is at least 25k? and earn freedom

[vernal storm]

Probably yeah

[digital bay]

maybe he also brought his friends joe and cleet to help him catch the gang and then betray them or split the money

but in rdo cleet is friends with micah a year before rdr2 starts

[vernal storm]

I thought about that. Micah killing Joe and Cleet

[digital bay]

thing is before the ending when dutch goes to micah he brings all the money from blackwater

so why did he not kill him then

[vernal storm]

Don’t know

Maybe Micah had further plans but John ruins it 🤷🏼‍♂️

[rose haven]

I find the theory that he didn't even rat on the gang interesting

[digital bay]

pretty sure he did but i guess maybe

[rose haven]

Oh yeah I don't believe it myself I just find it interesting

[calm crow]

Imagine Micah being suicidal

[rose haven]

Saw a dog barking at a bunch of vultures that were going at a dead coyote in van horn

[hidden moss]

anyone know what happens to the incest brother after killing his wife then running away? their house is just empty

[midnight dawn]

Probably went and married his cousin or something

Keeping it in the family

[hidden moss]

like legit

cant find any info on this

or anyone doing this

returned to his house later in game and still nothing

[calm crow]

Maybe killed himself

Maybe ran away

[rose haven]

It's the same if you return back for the money later, I kind of just thought they tried to fuck with the wrong person since it kind of looks like there was a struggle

[hidden moss]

thing is he didnt take any money from me

the moment i saw him the first time i went in killed the wife then ran away because he was fucking scarying me

[rose haven]

"Mm that meat is so tender"

Maybe someone robbed him then

[hidden moss]

idk

[manic fossil]

anyone know how to fix prompts when singleplayer modding?

[coarse terrace]

You can acquire buell? I just did the side quest by returning buell to his owner

Also, anyone know what the rabbit symbol means up near the veterans homestread- in grizzlies east?

[fierce valve]

What rabbit symbol?

[coarse terrace]

There’s a rabbit outline on the map

[fierce valve]

Must be where you can hunt rabbits

[craggy sage]

1 quick question do dead bodies that you kill on RRD2 Story mode stay where you left them

[patent ocean]

i did but he wasnt there and only the body he was eating on was there

[fierce valve]

Not really

They can despawn

Or if you keep them with you for a while, they probably could decay

[wise estuary]

Ohhh

Uh

All I can say is keep doing his quests

[coarse terrace]

[wise estuary]

How far in the story are you?

[coarse terrace]

Near the very end

[wise estuary]

Aight

Wait before you finish the quests with buell in em just go all in on the story

Trust me

[coarse terrace]

So finish the story first then go for buell after

[wise estuary]

Yep

[coarse terrace]

Okay

[grand owl]

I lost all my progress in the epilogue when steam had a cloud error, any way I can solve this issue? Like a mod to skip missions or something.

[digital raptor]

happy birthday

[fickle chasm]

lmao that's probably the funniest explanation i've seen

[fickle chasm]

yep he gives it you as a gift

[grand owl]

its been 3 days of me asking for help and I finally found a save file online of where I left off

[onyx cliff]

is there anything i must do as arthur to 100% the game

[red helm]

No, it's not missable.

...failable.. whatever.

[onyx cliff]

and how am i supposed to get the "errand boy achievement" -_-

im on chap 6 as arthur

i only got 3/5

but theres no more

[red helm]

Get 5 items for gang members? That one is actually missable.

If you don't get it by chapter 4, nope....

[onyx cliff]

dangit!

do i need those to 100%

[red helm]

Nope, not required for that. There is a checklist in the pause menu, check the Compendium-> Progression.

[onyx cliff]

cuz i can 100% then make a new playtbough and do that

nice

[red helm]

Indeed, get that Achievement in another play through.

[onyx cliff]

i got all the gambler achievements

i got the hard part out the way!

[red helm]

Challenge? Nice, that is the worse challenge set. Make sure you go to the Trapper and buy all the gambler set. It'll give you a Stat upgrade.

[onyx cliff]

me thinks i di

did

thanks partner

[red helm]

and, any other challenge sets you've done.

No problem. The Herbalist challenge is the only one that is undoable as Arthur, without glitchy/mod non-sense.

[onyx cliff]

should i be wasting my time doing the dinosaur bone crap

i dont think i need to

[red helm]

Dinosaur bones, also, there is a couple in New Austin, so, wait until later.

[onyx cliff]

i got all the ones i could as arthur

and i can get all 6 gang hideouts as john yes

i have 3/6 currentyl

[red helm]

Well, Like I said, You'd have to do glitch/mod non-sense for the New Austin ones, so... bah.

[red helm]

Yeah, there is 2 Gangs you don't even meet as Arthur, so...

err.. 3...

[onyx cliff]

yeehaw

[quick pike]

do the night folk count as a gang?

[red helm]

Nope, they are not one.

[quick pike]

alrighty thank you

[patent ocean]

What’s the fastest way to get the exotics

[bronze pumice]

Which specific exotic items?

[patent ocean]

Just the birds

[bronze pumice]

Run around in the bayou until you find them. If they aren’t there, die, and then search again.

[patent ocean]

Ugh

[left ridge]

Hey y'all im playing this game first time. Can y'all give me some tips

[dusky coyote]

Honestly just don’t rush it explore and try to avoid spoilers

[hidden moss]

Yeah, and don't ever search rdr content related. Even the memes is of a form of spoiler

[midnight dawn]

everything is in lemoyne basically

a couple orchids you can find in new hanover

[keen pagoda]

Carry horse reviver!

They die so easily

[keen pagoda]

Ngl I kinda speedrun the story missions then explored later bcs it's easier to do some things when u finish story

[digital bay]

finally caught every single fish for survivalist 10

[ionic fern]

damnnn

[frozen spindle]

Anyone else having issues with single player just crashing your PC every hour or so? I've tried all the common fixes, all drivers are up-to-date I clear the pipeline cache stuff Everytime I go to play, playing in d12 with lower graphics settings and running as admin. But I cant play for more than an hour or so at a time and alot of the time it will just crash 10min or less into fresh start up

I've found it happens more often when taking missions, if I'm not in a mission it seems to be fine. (Be it strangers or main story's or w.e. they all have a larger chance to crash for me)

[drifting nacelle]

#pc-technical-stuff

[frozen spindle]

I don't even see the room >.> Been a while since I've checked in this server guess roles were changed or something at one time

[vernal rampart]

use gta series videos’ video its super helpful

[solar trench]

hi everyone i've finished game very long time ago but i discovered something and that is the accomplishments so i didn't finished one of them and it is the artificial intelligence

i've done the missions as arthur

my question is

can i unlock the accomplishment as john

or should i return to my arthur save ?

[midnight dawn]

Collect all of them at once , don't wait until you get each list. Since they're near each other

[midnight dawn]

You should return to Arthur's save

It's been 8 years lmao, that body has probably became a skeleton

Load arthur's save, find out marco Dragic's faith. You'll get the trophy and hop back on your john save again

[solar trench]

thx

[patent ocean]

Yeah I was thinking of doing that

[lone garnet]

I dont think I have killed all gangs

I got some odriscolls, skinners, del lobo

[heavy kelp]

hi

i have a question

my first time i passed rdr2 with john i had to 5 dresses in the horse but now i passed it again i only have 3, someone knows smth?

[midnight dawn]

Kill them before the epilogue

O'Driscolls go extinct

Oh nvm you're already at the epilogue

[frigid cedar]

i dont even understand your question

[heavy kelp]

the first time i played and finished epilogue i had up to 5 outifts in my saddle, the next time i played the epilogue(new game) i only have up to 3 outfits in the saddle, do you know why?

[heavy kelp]

sorry

[frigid cedar]

any pictures

[craggy sage]

do decayed bodies vanish?

or will they remain at that position forever?

[dusky coyote]

They decay

They get to the point where I think they’re skeletons

[heavy kelp]

i dont have any pictures, i deleted it and started again

[frigid cedar]

[heavy kelp]

do u think it was a bug or just a saddle type?

[dusky coyote]

Okay I think I know what you mean

Did you have the outfits before epilogue?

[heavy kelp]

nope

[dusky coyote]

You didn’t have them saved as Arthur?

[heavy kelp]

nope, they were deleted

so i made new ones

[dusky coyote]

hmm well then I’m not sure

[heavy kelp]

okay

[dusky coyote]

Cause if you have saved outfits as Arthur once you get to John they get deleted

[heavy kelp]

yes

that happened to me but it let me have up to 5 outfits in my saddle

[dusky coyote]

But it’s not anymore?

[heavy kelp]

no, when i started a new game and when i got again to the epilogue i only can have up to

3

[dusky coyote]

I think you need the upgraded satchel then you can carry more outfits

[heavy kelp]

the bag or the saddle?

[dusky coyote]

Bag

[heavy kelp]

i have the legend of the west bag

but when i first played i had arthur´s bag and let me have up to 5

[dusky coyote]

Nah for the horse

Not your satchel

The horse one

Buy it at the stable

[heavy kelp]

aa

i get it now

[dusky coyote]

Yeah

[heavy kelp]

i have the upgraded one

[dusky coyote]

Weird try looking it up

[heavy kelp]

ok

thx

[dusky coyote]

No problem

[heavy kelp]

heyy

u were right

now i have up to 5 again

tysm

[dusky coyote]

Haha nice

You’re welcome

[digital bay]

someone please help

i have been looking for 2 hours for the guy with the high stakes treasure map and i am losing it

i cant get him to spawn is there another location or a time for him to spawn?

[fierce valve]

You could just buy it from the fence later iirc

[digital bay]

i finally got him

here was west of monto's rest

[craggy sage]

how long does that take ( in real life hours )?

[rose haven]

Years alot of the time

Depends on where the body is though ofc

[craggy sage]

oh

do you know any mods which can prevent them from turning into skeletons?

[rose haven]

No unfortunately, why though btw

[dusky coyote]

If you sleep constantly the body decays

[craggy sage]

if i answer this message i could risk my discord account getting banned 😈 😈

[craggy sage]

well then , guess i'll be up day and night 😈

[dusky coyote]

Yes but Ingame sleeping

[rose haven]

You are only able to sleep a few times before you can't anymore so best off putting a marker down where the body is and just doing things in the game abit I guess

[rocky wing]

-_-

[dusky coyote]

.-.

[rose haven]

I fucking despise dominoes

[dusky coyote]

Why?

[rose haven]

Hardest gambling activity in the game for challenges

[dusky coyote]

Oh yeah it’s literally impossible

[frigid cedar]

i still have herbalist 10 and none of the gambling challenges yet

[red helm]

Gambling challenges, Poor you...

[thick heron]

what

[thick heron]

they do? i’ve been playing since beta and never noticed a skeleton. they just disappear off the map for me

carcasses decay but corpses disappear after i leave the area and come back

[dusky coyote]

I don’t know it’s weird you can look it up

I’ve seen a body decay pretty bad once after sleeping a few times

[red helm]

I've never seen a skeleton either, but also never tried to get them to decay that long either.

[rose haven]

It probs only happens if you stay near them or something

[calm crow]

Everytime i listen to rains fall’s voice i wanna sleep

[midnight dawn]

I like rains fall

[rose haven]

Out of all the gangs, who would win in an all out war (excluding the Van Der linde gang and including the night folk)

[midnight dawn]

Hmm ? Probably the O'Driscolls

Their man power is massive Colm has so many men. And if they die he gets new ones

Speaking of only in case Colm didn't die lmao

[glad brook]

Or the Lemoyne Raiders since they're a well respected militia with a good supply of high quality weapons in their possession.

[umbral tiger]

Yo guys i'm having currently a issue where the game is every few seconds stuttering any solution?

[hidden moss]

THERE ARE NO SPOILERS IN WHAT I AM ABOUT TO SAY. So yesterday I was in Brandywine Drop and going to Valentine. Not soon after starting my journey, I saw a man howling at a cougar. I thought that it was one of those chance encounters where people get attacked by cougars, so I killed it because I want to have high honor. But when I looked for the person there were zero people in sight. So, I went and went in the direction I last saw him in. When I got there, however, I saw a wolf. Therefore, I believe there are werewolves in Red Dead Redemption 2.

[fierce valve]

Not the craziest thing I’ve heard

But it is crazy

And doesn’t exist

[fickle chasm]

I think he might be talking about the Feral Man

[fierce valve]

Possibly

[main harbor]

[alpine chasm]

Geez ur name is just pretty much pumpkins

[acoustic spoke]

Maybe you had upgraded saddle bags the first time you played

[dusky coyote]

They figured it out

[hidden moss]

i got tons bug

[frigid cedar]

uwot

[hidden moss]

it was fixed when i turned it off and on

[thick pewter]

anyone know the best thing i can use to follow as an 100% guide thats efficient

also do i need gold medals on all story missions?

[frigid cedar]

kek first do u really want to

super tedious for basically no rewards

[thick pewter]

gives me something to do

is there anything i need to do in chap 1 for it or can i start in chapter 2

[fierce valve]

Technically you can’t do anything in Chapter 1

But you can start almost anything on Chapter 2

Knock out the ambient challenges first

[thick pewter]

whats that

[fierce valve]

Horseman

Sharpshooter

That kind of challenges

[thick pewter]

thats locked

most are

[fierce valve]

What part of the story are you on?

You can just search up a guide for most of this stuff

[thick pewter]

chapter 2 without any missions done

[heavy kelp]

yep,that was the thinng thx

[digital bay]

noooo now i have to do gambler 8

almost done with all the challenges

is it as bad as people say?

[heavy kelp]

i killed the gunsmith bcs of the bandit challenge, how much do i have to wait to g to his shop?

[rose haven]

All of the gambler challenges suck really

Except five finger fillet ones ig

[thick pewter]

when do you unlock fishing rod

[lean sparrow]

Why does the army take the native americans horses

[thick pewter]

how do u get the bandit challenge unlocked

[digital bay]

i get 8 points and he asks for insurance which means all the points are gone then i get a 6 and he asks the same thing

finally did gambler 8 in 50mins and now i have to win dominos 3 times in a row

[thick pewter]

can you meat bonnie in rdr2? i just saw a guy who had a letter for her

[sharp cliff]

In RDO, you can.

[violet osprey]

The legendary elk isnt showing for some reason.

Like it isnt telling me im in its territory

[frigid cedar]

the exact location can be a little annoying to find

[violet osprey]

Found it

Its farther north, the drawing is misleading lmao

[frigid cedar]

do be like that

i wish there was more stuff in the snowy areas

[keen pagoda]

Can I get lending a hand achievement after finishing the full game and replaying past missions

[digital bay]

no

you need to create a new game

[keen pagoda]

Why

@digital bay

[midnight dawn]

lending a hand you need to do mrs.Downe's missions , strauss , sadie etc...

replaying missions won't unlock these

main missions aren't optional honor missions

[keen pagoda]

Wait but if u go on progress and story u can replay them

Like do not seek absolution I never did bcs I never had high honor but I can replay it

[vernal rampart]

what are all the missions specifically

[midnight dawn]

no ? you cannot

only the missions you've done before could be replayed

lending a hand is a missable trophy basically

[digital bay]

you can still have a new game and the old playthrough

just save and dont delete

[keen pagoda]

But I never did it and I'm literally playing it now

[vernal rampart]

buck antler trinket is the most useless piece of garbage ever

[digital bay]

it works sometimes

[vernal rampart]

“sometimes” 1 in every 100

[digital bay]

do i need to complete the entire compendium to get 100%?

@midnight dawn

[glad brook]

You can.

Theres just nothing there.

[midnight dawn]

no you do not

just 50 animals are enough

48 equipments i think

36 weapons

you can check your companion app for requirements

[pliant hinge]

i did it

I DID IT

FINALLY

completed the gambler challenges and my controller is still intact

[frigid cedar]

[calm crow]

Who’s stronger, Arthur or 1907 John?

[vernal rampart]

arthur pre tb

[digital bay]

tbh it was actually alot easier than most people say it is

i did gambler 8 in 40-50mins gambler 9 in around 50mins (without losing) and gambler 10 in 20mins doing the boat casino missions in chapter 4 and who is not without sin in chapter 2

the mission (who is without sin) you always win the first time and the casino one you can use strauss to cheat

i learnt how to play dominos and blackjack (dominos is alot easier than people say it is) but the thing that i hate is the rng

[pliant hinge]

gambler 8 was the longest ive spent on a challenge

it's not based on difficulty, it's luck.

[frigid cedar]

just ask yoself, who can swim

[vernal rampart]

😏

[halcyon lava]

where tf do you find bison

[hearty moth]

Hey bandits, have a question, im trying to achieve Sharpshooter 6 where i have to kill an enemy with a sniper/marksman rifle for 660 feet.
Because of i don't know how big this distance is ingame i thought i can kill an enemy right after he spawns so the distance have to be enough. I ride to Hanging Dog Ranch, because i know there are enemies and killed some but did not get the achievement.

Do they already need to be "aggro" on me?

[halcyon lava]

660 feet?!

how far is that!?

[hearty moth]

It is 660 feet

or ~201m

[halcyon lava]

no like from what area

like such and such town to a specific shack

[hearty moth]

cant tell you ingame because didn't found a way to get distances yet

(except mods)

But like i said, im playing on Ultra settings and so i think it should be enough when the enemy is yet spawning 😅

[halcyon lava]

i play on medium so idk if my render distance can see that

[vernal rampart]

#red-dead-media

[frigid cedar]

what chapter u on

bisons super common at the end of game

[halcyon lava]

I'm on chapter 6

@frigid cedar

[frigid cedar]

not epilogue right

do u remember hunting bison with charles

[hearty moth]

You can also find them between Valentine and Emerald Ranch from BEginning

[frigid cedar]

can find it there

do they spawn in massive herd

[halcyon lava]

Yeah, I didn't go hunting with charles

[frigid cedar]

[halcyon lava]

Aparently you can buy the satchels from the fence at chapter 6

[frigid cedar]

yeah if i knew that

spent like 10 hours getting all the satchels in chapter 2

[halcyon lava]

I have all of em except the one that requires a perfect bison pelt

[frigid cedar]

well i googled bison spawn point

think somewhere in heartlands

[hearty moth]

Why? i liked to hunt the animals. Its a nice Challenge and if i would just rush the Game i could also use trainers.
The Bison was one of the easiest btw.

[frigid cedar]

why what

[red helm]

Well, sure, they are "easy" if you know where to look. But, if you don't.....

[red helm]

Just northwest of Emerald Ranch, there is a bunch of Ponds, keep going northwest, there is basically always a herd of Bison there. @halcyon lava

[fierce valve]

Isn’t it epilogue?

[halcyon lava]

Idk

[red helm]

Yeah, Fence only sales Satchels in the Epilogue.

[pseudo crypt]

I just got a disc for rdr1, is there any way I can play it on my pc?

[fallen canyon]

Tbh, chapter 6 had my favorite missions

[turbid oriole]

No

[pseudo crypt]

👍

[hidden moss]

if it has a playstation or xbox logo then you shall not use it on any other device

[patent ocean]

Why wont herons spawn for me?

[vernal rampart]

when you are on a quest/list that includes a certain animal on it rockstar has this extremely annoying (yet effective) way of lowering the spawn rate

[patent ocean]

Bruh

What’s the point

Of doing that

[vernal rampart]

make it more challenging

[patent ocean]

That’s stupid

[vernal rampart]

go ahead and get as many spoonbills as you can before the 4th duchesses list

gator eggs are really easy

the 3rd and 5th are VERY easy cause they are basically all orchids

[patent ocean]

BRO

did they remove spawn for some orchids?

[vernal rampart]

?

[patent ocean]

I went to get a moccasin orchid and its not even there

Oh mvm

[patent ocean]

How many spoonbills

[vernal rampart]

30 plumes

[patent ocean]

Bru wtf

Where I find them?

[vernal rampart]

all throughout lemoyne

more swamp/saint denis side than rhodes though

[patent ocean]

Breh

[digital bay]

no only if you are john

[midnight dawn]

Why would you guys even rush the story to play as john ffs lol

You spend alot of time as john in rdr1 anyway

And chapter 6's ending has a lot more meaning if you've met all the strangers

[keen pagoda]

Ik I should have spent more time on chapter 6 bcs I didn't finish some things and I cant do them as John

[fierce valve]

You can finish most of them as John

Except maybe some Charlotte missions

Or the Downes

[keen pagoda]

But not all

[fierce valve]

Yeah

I said most

[keen pagoda]

No but like the money lending and other sins

I never did the last one of them bcs I rushed chapter 6

[fierce valve]

Sometimes I don’t do it so I don’t have to kick Strauss out of camp

But he goes anyways

[midnight dawn]

It has more meaning if you do them tho

[midnight hill]

hi all!
i have a couple of questions 😁

1. what can affect the quality of a hunted animal after it's been hunted? like if i carry a carcass, and drive through water, etc., can it worsen it? or is it only the time you carry it around
2. are there any tips on searching for dinosaur bones, dreamcatchers, etc., or is it just the player going around and being careful to look around places?

[frigid cedar]

omg i never knew

[midnight dawn]

Yes to both haha, animals that fall in water might get ruined, and with time animals degrade and rot if not sold or eaten etc... Within 24 hours rdr2 time.

For the collectibles you could look up YouTube guides maybe

It's the fastest way of doing them

[midnight hill]

thank you kindly!! 😁 gonna have to gear up with yt videos then, because i am replaying rdr2 second time now and haven't seen a single dreamcatcher yet !

[fierce valve]

It’s the environment and temperature that usually affects the animal or depending on its condition and how you killed it

The water probably doesn’t affect it as much

[midnight dawn]

For birds, snakes ... it doesn't but they drown if not picked up in time, but for other animals it does degrade their pelt

[midnight hill]

Oh that's cool, I didn't know about that!! Thank you 👀

I had a rabbit or a turkey turn from good to bad on me so fast, I was rather surprised

[civic vault]

Anybody know how to do sharpshooter 9 without doing headshots?

[hallow sierra]

any tips for hunting legendary animals

idk where to store the pelts and stuff

[civic vault]

You can only sell the legendary pelts to the Trapper

[midnight dawn]

Hats off ?

Use a short range weapon in long range, shotgun works best. And try to paint them with dead eye a little higher.

Tag more than 3 enemies just to be sure

[civic vault]

I see

I how far should I be?

[midnight dawn]

Enough idk exactly haha

Use the semi auto shotgun it's the weakest i suppose

[hallow sierra]

oh ok

do they respawn after being hunted once?

[civic vault]

Nope, they dont respawn

[hallow sierra]

[civic vault]

Can i get that in St. Denis as Arthur?

[hallow sierra]

thats pretty sad but its realistic

[midnight dawn]

You can, yes

[civic vault]

Im gonna try

The semi auto shotgun is locked for me hmmm

Maybe sawed shotgun can be good enough??

[midnight dawn]

You can find a semi auto somewhere for free

I got mine for free but i don't remember where exactly

Maybe at the old lady's house robbery

[digital bay]

damn there are only 2 charlotte missions?

[digital bay]

is it the shoot 3 hats?

[digital bay]

why shot guns

best pistol

[civic vault]

Nope, theres a 3rd one where you get to meet her one last time

[civic vault]

Coz it has a large blast impact but shorter range

[daring hinge]

Can you only get Pearson's scout jacket in chapter 2?

Or can I get it still in chapter 4?

[midnight dawn]

Collateral damage basically, a wider range more chances that the hat will fall

[raw pivot]

I think buell is the best horse, he actually feels alive(i know he hasn’t got the the best stats)

[digital bay]

you can get it if you go to the saint denis/rhodes saloon there is a table with like 6 people

all wearing hats and its better if you use a sidearm since range does not matter

[digital bay]

yea you just meet her and say goodbye

also i thought you will get more honor

[rose haven]

I genuinely just got in trouble with the police for taking a cigar

[digital bay]

you get a ton of honor for kicking strauss out and if you help the people in debt

[frigid cedar]

strauss kinda a dick for loan sharking

but at least he didn't spy like micah

[drifting nacelle]

He collected money for the gang

[midnight dawn]

Why would you go to saint denis if gang hideouts are a thing and they respawn instantly

[midnight dawn]

Not an amount that deserves to get TB over lmao

How much did he owe downes , less than 100$?

[midnight dawn]

It does matter actually, even a pistol could kill with a headshot and it's not guaranteed to knock it with a bodyshot

[frigid cedar]

arthur also to blame tbh

he was too violent

[midnight dawn]

Of course he deserves it

[rose haven]

It's a surprise Micah didnt get it from fighting him actually

[midnight dawn]

Arthur usually turns his head before coughing

He's respectful

[digital bay]

Cause its much harder and they are shooting at you and tanking cover?

The people on the table are right in front of you and standing next to each other

[rose haven]

Oughta intentionally cough in Micah's face at that point

[midnight dawn]

Bruh

You call that shooting ? Their accuracy is trash also just do the challenge and run away

[hidden moss]

@midnight dawn wow so you went to the grave

[civic vault]

I have 3 fishes left for survivalist 10 and i forgot to have a list prepped for this lol

I forgot some of the fish i caught

[vernal rampart]

suvivalist ten best challenge in the game

[civic vault]

Im guessing dem swamp fishes are all i uave left for them

*have

I rarely fish at the swamps

I wish the game shows the list that ive caught

[thick pewter]

What's best way for me to rob 3 stage coaches in 1 day

[vernal rampart]

just wait around emerald ranch and fence them

its a lot easier then robbing

[umbral kestrel]

I just ran into the veteran as Arthur

I can finish the first mission with him

And leave the second for John right

So I’ll get buell for John

[rose haven]

He has four iirc

As long as you don't do the last one with Arthur you can keep buell

[umbral kestrel]

Nice

Is there any special dialogue

U know Wut

Don’t tell me

Ignore this

Thx

[midnight dawn]

Steal the fast travel stage coach

There is a trick to make them spawn one after another

In emerald ranch there are two trees behind the post office run between them and a new stagecoach will spawn

[rose haven]

You can steal that?

[midnight dawn]

Yup

[last sierra]

Something which I don't get is why people would think uncle is red Harlow

It makes no sense

[digital bay]

make sure you do it at night

so you dont get caught

[keen pagoda]

Buell isn't that good

[umbral kestrel]

Looks is all that matters

[keen pagoda]

White arabian

[umbral kestrel]

Bored of that horse

[vernal rampart]

white arabian is overrated in most ways imo

[umbral kestrel]

Small asl

[vernal rampart]

including looks

[umbral kestrel]

If I could keep my silver pinto Missouri foxtrotter that would be awesome

But she gon die soon

[vernal rampart]

where did you get her?

[umbral kestrel]

From the wildlife photography mission

Took me hours

[vernal rampart]

ah

[umbral kestrel]

Until I found the wagon method

[rose haven]

Enjoying my amber champagne one rn

[umbral kestrel]

The silver pinto is the best looking coat imo

But the amber one is decent as well

Probably gonna grab it as John

[rose haven]

The speed stat for it is going to be max apparently when I get the bond up

[umbral kestrel]

Dunno why Arabian is considered the best horse in the game why mft exists

[rose haven]

The stats and they look pretty ig

[vernal rampart]

they are insanely skittish though

immediate turnoff for me

[umbral kestrel]

They r incredibly pussy

Knocks me off immediately when wolves appear

[vernal rampart]

lemoyne is impossible

[umbral kestrel]

Wdym

[vernal rampart]

alligators

[rose haven]

Tbh when I got my white Arabian as Arthur I never had trouble with it getting scared outside of the bayou

[vernal rampart]

snakes

i get immediately kicked off

[rose haven]

Only ever been bucked because of cougars

[umbral kestrel]

Cougars and wolves I stg

I haven’t rode the black and white Arabians since forever now

I just switch between the gold turkoman and my mst

[rose haven]

They're good at the start when you don't have much money

[umbral kestrel]

Yeah legit first horse I got

[rose haven]

In my first playthrough I stuck with the black shire Hosea gives you for a while

[umbral kestrel]

Wait he gave arthur a horse

Did I miss a mission

Tf

Cuz he dead already

[rose haven]

In the hunting mission

With the legendary bear

[umbral kestrel]

Oh

I didn’t know he gave a horse during that mission

I press stayed and killed the bear and that was it

[rose haven]

Most people just sell it I suppose

[keen pagoda]

Na I have that exact horse max bonding and if u also get a good saddle and stuff then it gets like 1 off

[frigid cedar]

tumbleweed stable has one with zebra coat

[patent ocean]

What’s the best horse in the game?

[thick heron]

that’s probably subjective but turkoman

[fickle chasm]

there isn't one

depends on the player

[patent ocean]

No fastest?

[thick heron]

this one is my favorite of all time

[thick heron]

fastest isn’t always best

fast horses are usually small so not as sturdy and easily spooked. big horses are slower but stronger and won’t buck you off as fast. just try each horse and see which fits you best

[patent ocean]

I’m not rich

[frigid cedar]

can just look at their stats

[vital aurora]

Ur pfp threw me off

[patent ocean]

Laugh out loudn

[thick heron]

there are wild horses also

i don’t mean buy them all

[midnight dawn]

Money don't matter in this game

You literally get everything for free

[thick pewter]

What mission gets you throwing knives?

These bandit challenges have caused me such low honor

Is 20% total completion good for only 2 missions into chapter 2 when going for 100%

[tawdry topaz]

fr when i did them my honour almost got to max dishonour

[thick pewter]

I've only done half of them as well and lost most of it 🤣

I cant do more bc I dont have horse fence yet

[tawdry topaz]

the gambler challenges tested my patience

[latent frigate]

Guys playing rdr2 rn, and the trains aren't allowing me to go to certain places, eg from saint Denis to Blackwater. Anyone know why? I'm in the epilogue btw, so it's not the broken bridge in that mission.

[thick pewter]

Bounty???

[tawdry topaz]

there is no train station in black water

[latent frigate]

Oh that's why lmao

[tawdry topaz]

lmao

[thick pewter]

I forgot about that 🤣 I'm used to rdr

Did anyone else kill the rhodes gunsmith?

[tawdry topaz]

no i feel kinda bad for him

[latent frigate]

Yep

As soon as I walked down the stairs into his basement with him I killed him

Didn't give him a chance

[tawdry topaz]

i used to blow his head off now i just rob him

[thick pewter]

Is one of the bandit challenges to rob a side business?

1st blackjack game I instantly won 🤣

[latent frigate]

I do both

[hidden moss]

huh

[tawdry topaz]

gambler 8 just wait for gambler 8

[thick pewter]

I've heard bad things about it but i dont want to know what it is b4 I get there 🤣 just so I can see how bad it is without being exactly told

[tawdry topaz]

and herbalist 9

yea i spent like 5 days on gambler 8 it is all based on luck

[thick pewter]

In game or irl 🤣

[tawdry topaz]

irl

[thick pewter]

How much of those 5 days were u playing 🤣

[tawdry topaz]

about 10 of the 24 hours in each day excluding the time i took off i think 💀

[thick pewter]

Jeez

[vernal rampart]

it took me 40 minutes

[thick pewter]

Hopefully I get lucky I guess

Just did gambler 2

Can I win 5 finger fillet solo or does it mean against people

[vernal rampart]

against people

[thick pewter]

Wheres best place to play others?

[vernal rampart]

anywhere

fillet is the most skill based of all the gambling options

[thick pewter]

But sometimes at valentine there aren't people so where am I most likely to find them

[vernal rampart]

there are locations in strawberry and van horn

van horn always has someone there for me

[thick pewter]

K I'll go there then ty

What train station is closest to van horn?

[silk vortex]

Annesburg. Btw To get the electric lantern from Marko dragic does it have To be midnight?

If someone knows

[vernal rampart]

wdym?

did you do the second mission?

[thick pewter]

Idek what that is

[vernal rampart]

i can help i just need more context

[silk vortex]

Yes i did and i came there To get it. I took it and the next day i didnt have it unless i took it

Forget that unless

And i have checked the laboratory many times but i can get anymore and i dont still have it

*can't

Inside

Sorry for my bad english

[vernal rampart]

yeah i dont know

[silk vortex]

Could be just bug

Just asking but how many here know about the micah revolver early glitch?

[thick pewter]

I do

[silk vortex]

If you have done it which way?

I remember there were 2 ways

[red helm]

Getting someone to slap Micah so he'll drop his gun?

[mellow vigil]

What is the wolf ending

[silk vortex]

Low honor?

[mellow vigil]

Damn

I had that the whole game

[silk vortex]

Well if you want you can play game another time and play at high honor like I did

[red helm]

Right, you get a different animal for different honors.

[silk vortex]

Wolf for low and deer for high

[red helm]

Supposed to be a Eagle for exact neutral.

[silk vortex]

Can there be exact neutral?

[red helm]

I'm sure it's doable, though, sounds tricky.

[silk vortex]

Okay and yes for that micah revolver thing

I personally like the Other way

[thick pewter]

I'm so bad a finger fillet

[red helm]

Practice makes perfect.

[thick pewter]

No matter how much I will lose 🤣

[silk vortex]

I did it so that bc i was bad at it i played the first March and change locagion

Match

[red helm]

Well, fortunately, you never Have to do more then the first Rounds, so...

[thick pewter]

Is 20% total completion good for only 2 missions into chapter 2 when going for 100%

[red helm]

Yeah, you get a Lot of % for doing the Story missions.

[silk vortex]

I am at 93 and have 2 challenge left

[thick pewter]

What's the difference between classic fillet and the others

[red helm]

You'll get up to like 75-85% from finishing the Story. the Side stuff will amount to the rest. So, don't expect to get a lot from them.

[silk vortex]

Some thing about how many times you can fail i guess?

[silk vortex]

Btw do you only use trains?

[vernal rampart]

tip for you salt: save up and buy upgrades for arthurs tent, you can eventually unlock fast travel thats free and goes to exact towns

[thick pewter]

Quite often why?

[silk vortex]

You know theres stagecoachess and when you create little camp at arthur you can fast travel completely free

[thick pewter]

Ik

But I think I needed to have been to van horn at least once to stage coach there ect

[silk vortex]

Well can you go To annesburg with train even without you been there

[thick pewter]

That's what i did then i went down to van horn

[silk vortex]

Oh so it works like that nevermind

[thick pewter]

I think Idk

I haven't used fast travel that much I find it more convenient for train ect

[silk vortex]

Okay

How many challenge have you done

[thick pewter]

17

[midnight dawn]

Save before every mission you do just to be safe

Missing one mission will result in ruining your completion

[silk vortex]

I never saved until chapter 4😄

[thick pewter]

Why does it not save after challenges

[midnight dawn]

The game has auto save yes.

It does save

[silk vortex]

But i overwrites itself

[thick pewter]

I have 1k from treasure as well so I'm fine I think

[midnight dawn]

You can fast travel using your wilderness camp

For free

[silk vortex]

I told him

[thick pewter]

I'm to lazy I find trains ect more convenient

And I normally have a bounty so pay it off then travel

[midnight dawn]

You find riding to a village then getting on a train more convenient than a press of a button? Damn

[thick pewter]

I'm already in town at time if I was in wilderness I'd camp

[midnight dawn]

Oh alright makes sense. Anyway be careful since missing stuff is easy

[silk vortex]

The most hilarious thing about trains is that i did bandit 10 by only taking canned vegetables 5 times in Row😂

[thick pewter]

Ye I will ty

[midnight dawn]

Yeah i did that too

[silk vortex]

Only bandit challenge To do without losing honor

@midnight dawn btw have you got 100%

[midnight dawn]

Yup

[silk vortex]

Nice

I have almost

[midnight dawn]

Good luck, It's fun

[red helm]

Most of it was fun.

[midnight dawn]

Not finding birds lmao i hated every second of that

[red helm]

If they hadn't done lame stuff like lower spawn rates on animals. It would've been better.

[silk vortex]

Yeah like I got gambler 8 in hour but the fucking exotics still wait for me. What way did you find every collectable? Trough youtube? @midnight dawn

[midnight dawn]

I found dreamcatchers by myself somehow they're easy to get, but everything else on YouTube lol

Can't waste 1000 hours looking for everything myself

[red helm]

Stupid orchids was one of the only things I gave up on and looked up on the internet for.

I Found 7 Dreamcatcher and 6 Bones, before looking those up. A few of those bones were in some crazy spots...

[silk vortex]

True. I found an site that contains almost every location you need includin cigarette cards, some spawn locations, bones, dreamcatchers, fish, animals, treasure maps, rock cravings so almost everything

[midnight dawn]

Intresting, but don't waste time looking for 144 cig cards , just buy premium cig packs from a general store

[silk vortex]

I bought every card but i thought i could mention it

And by those fish and animals i mean the legendary ones

[red helm]

I really enjoy exploring things on my own. But, yeah, some things just get tedious at some point. Didn't feel like going over every square inch of the map for stuff. Would've been different if they put things like Bones in spots that actually made sense, but most of them just seemed to be in random ass spots...

[midnight dawn]

There is a compendium in this server, you can use it for an idea on animal spawn locations

It might help you with finding what you're looking for

[red helm]

Indeed, the #rdo-compendium channel is mostly fine for Story mode.

[silk vortex]

Nice knowing. If i remember right i have only left 2 challenge, exotics, graves and story bc i want To finish it with the legend of the east outfit

[midnight dawn]

Nice, you're not far off then

[red helm]

Saving Graves for last is advised.

Or at least, a certain one...

[midnight dawn]

It doesn't really matter I found out

[red helm]

Probably not, but still, it feels right.

[midnight dawn]

Since you get that secret scene anyway even after visiting all graves before finishing the game

Yeah

[red helm]

One of the first things I did in my second play through, when I got free movements, was walk over to Davey's grave and see if I could visit it.

[silk vortex]

The cowpoke you mean by that certain one? I might have something To do that i dont remember

Still

The only thing i havent been spoiled about is the 100% ending

Or scene

[red helm]

It's a very nice scene.

[silk vortex]

I belive so, But good night for now

[red helm]

Take care.

[silk vortex]

Same

[violet osprey]

2 questions:

1: does the skin deep advancement include domestic animals like pigs, sheep, etc?

2: by "skin every species" does it mean general species (like does skinning a buck also count as just skinning a deer) or all animals as a whole?

[red helm]

1: More than likely.
2:Not sure there. But, I mean, may as well...

[violet osprey]

Alright. Also, anyone have any reccomended routes for horseman 6?

[red helm]

Which one is that? Strawberry to Saint Denis?

[violet osprey]

Yeah. Without touching water

[red helm]

Right, just take the road southeast, until you get to Riggs Station, then take the Train tracks all the way.

[violet osprey]

Alright. Ty

[red helm]

Train Tracks are basically always your friend. You never have to worry about some idiot wagon's pulling in front of you, or other horses. Just the super rare occasion where a Train actually comes, but they are always very obvious.

[violet osprey]

Yeah, i did pretty good on the valentines to rhodes thing, had a little over a minute left

I set a timer the moment i enter the town when doing stuff like this to help, plus i have the white arabian so shes also pretty good

[red helm]

Arabians are a good way to go for those challenges. or just straight up traveling. I don't really care for them otherwise, though. Scaredy cats, get on my nerves quick.

[violet osprey]

Currently just trying to level her bonding up, then ill probably just stable her and return to my saddler

[red helm]

There is a Andalusian that spawns on a ledge of the Brandywine Waterfall(West of Annesburg), that is a real nice general purpose horse.

[wild flare]

I need help

[vernal rampart]

?

[plain sleet]

Where do I find beard tonic

[wary oasis]

General store

[plain sleet]

Thanks

How long did it take you to get 100%

[wary oasis]

I did nearly everything you could apart from a few hats so about 500hrs

You can get it much quicker

[plain sleet]

Imagine if you put that many hours into a job no offence

[wary oasis]

Yeah I've worked for longer than that

[plain sleet]

Tbf I have 800 hours on gta5

Actually I think it's 1k now

[wary oasis]

I get bored before that amount

[plain sleet]

It was online

[west crescent]

hell yeah

i was doing the gambling challenge and i got someone to bust out first try

fuck

i did it again and was so happy but left the table too early

[grand owl]

is it possible to get rdr1 on pc?

[thick heron]

emulator

[midnight timber]

I bought rdr2 story yesterday

[vernal rampart]

bro im so stupid 💀 i just forgot about it cause i never get it

[vernal rampart]

have fun soldier 🙏

are you gonna try to 100%

[midnight timber]

Hi

[fickle chasm]

lmao

[hallow sierra]

can legendary animal pelts only be used once for crafting

[fierce valve]

Yes

You sell it to the trapper and that’s about it

[hallow sierra]

ohh ok

thanks

[digital bay]

i already have buell as arthur i want to get the pink arabian as john

why is no one active nowadays

[keen pagoda]

Pink?

[fierce valve]

Rose Grey Bay?

[digital bay]

yea pretty sure its the best horse

[fierce valve]

Yes

Max health and stamina

Fully bonded

Good horse

[keen pagoda]

Why u say pink

[digital bay]

also is the legend of the east outfit cool?

[digital bay]

it is

[fierce valve]

Rose is semi pink

So it is pink

[fierce valve]

Legend of the West better

But sure

[keen pagoda]

I got so close to max bonding but then it fell off a cliff

[digital bay]

i just need to do 7 more sharpshooter and bandit and 2 more herbalist to complete all challenges

[keen pagoda]

The horse is basically grey trust me

[fierce valve]

No

[digital bay]

there are 2 different ones?

[fierce valve]

It’s semi pink

[keen pagoda]

It's rly not

[fierce valve]

In 2 different games

[digital bay]

oh

[fierce valve]

It shines a small shade of rose

[keen pagoda]

Ok well I'm back to my classic mft now

And getting higher bonding on white and red arabian

[digital bay]

i could have gotten 5 easy gold medals if i did the last strauss mission and edith downes mission

i did not know they will be
unavailable before the last mission

[keen pagoda]

That's a shame

U in epilogue now?

[digital bay]

not yet

i wanna do everything i can as arthur

[keen pagoda]

U should

[digital bay]

and then the rest as john

[keen pagoda]

I didn't and regretted it

Now I can't get lending a hand trophy

Have to do another playthrough

[fierce valve]

What are all the missions for lending a hand anyways?

I got like 90%

[keen pagoda]

We loved once and true all of them
Good honest snake oil
Money lending and other sins all
Course of true love all
Help a brother out
Brothers and sisters one and all
Fatherhood and other dreams all
Do not seek absolution all
Archeology for beginners
Honor amongst thieves
Mrs Sadie Adler widow all

@fierce valve

[fierce valve]

Huh

I think I did all of that