#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 618 of 1

midnight dawn
#

He doesn't need him anymore , why did he let him live then

fierce valve
#

It’s best seen in the Go Back For The Money ending

midnight dawn
#

She was just trying to boil dutch's blood and make him mad , poor molly

fierce valve
#

He literally just grabbed the money and went

midnight dawn
#

It was just sitting there

fierce valve
#

Maybe he knows he could find Dutch again

#

Which he eventually did

fierce valve
#

He refused to listen to her after that

#

Molly was vital

#

But Dutch was ignorant

eager canopy
#

I understand he was a rat but he was still a mass murderer and other things than that

#

If he was caught they weren't gonna just let him go

fierce valve
#

The Pinkertons know he is the rat tho

#

He could just go back for the money with no problem

eager canopy
#

If you need evidence for that just look at what theg did to John after he did tbe governments dirty work

fierce valve
#

Dutch walked away bc he saw his flaws

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

And probably was in shock

eager canopy
#

Micah got what he wanted the entire time which was chaos just so he could make a few bucks

fierce valve
#

He didn’t need the chaos

#

It was Dutch

#

The Pinkertons knew damn well where the gang was

#

Dutch needed to draw some attention away but it didn’t hold very long

frigid cedar
#

made enemies of the army as well, as if the gang didn't have enough enemies

fierce valve
#

The Army didn’t even care

#

The Pinkertons came down on full force

eager canopy
#

I feel like when Arthur and Micah had their final fight cause Arthur knew he was going to die, Arthur should have given Micah TB

midnight dawn
#

I think the money that was in the end game was the black water money

fierce valve
#

The Army wasn’t vital enough until RDR1

fierce valve
#

But they made out with more money than that iirc

midnight dawn
#

Since in chapter 2 when breaking out micah's off the prison he says he'll bring dutch a peace offering ! We never got to see what was that peace offering

fierce valve
#

Like at least 100k

midnight dawn
#

So it most likely was the money

#

He took half split it with cleet and joe and gave the rest to dutch to maintain his trust

fierce valve
#

Dutch wasn’t as delusional by 2 tho

midnight dawn
#

Yeah it can be done in 3 or 2

fierce valve
#

And if it was the Blackwater money, Dutch would’ve used it to go to Tahiti

eager canopy
#

We both know that

fierce valve
#

What was his real plan then?

eager canopy
#

He used that as a way to string everyone along til the end

red helm
fierce valve
#

End his own gang?

midnight dawn
#

Nah , he's trust micah for ever once he gets the black water money lmao

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

Another possibility is the train heist they pulled off

eager canopy
fierce valve
#

But that seems somewhat implausible

midnight dawn
#

We didn't make that much throughout the course of the whole game

red helm
midnight dawn
frigid cedar
#

kek dutch not really that crazy until he left tons of cash and gold bars in the epilogue

midnight dawn
#

The Cornwall train bonds were only worth a thousand so that couldn't be it

red helm
#

Bond selling, all the random stuff. Meh, I don't know, ask Rockstar and their logic where it all came from.

fierce valve
#

Someone said the Blackwater money was at least 150k

#

But we only found 40k

#

So where’s the rest?

midnight dawn
#

Maybe split between his own gang

fierce valve
#

But what do they even use it for

#

Micah got his own gang by the epilogue

frigid cedar
fierce valve
#

Probably needed to pay them some dough

eager canopy
fierce valve
midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

Micah has about 50 something men

#

Maybe less

#

Or about that range

#

So he needs a lot of money

#

But we only saw Joe and Cleet

#

By Chap 6

#

So either he was paying off the Pinkertons

#

Or lining his own pockets

midnight dawn
#

So maybe that was black water's money idk. Since they couldn't have had 40k off those jobs

fierce valve
#

We know the take for the mission Sodom? Back to Gomorrah was about 12,500

midnight dawn
#

The bonds they had hardly went for a thousand, the bonds deal with Leviticus and the military wasn't sold yet and that didn't include the train job

#

So that is not enough

fierce valve
#

That was evenly split between the people in the heist

midnight dawn
#

Yeah you can see in Arthur's journal gang savings section it had around 17k only

#

It includes all the jobs they done

fierce valve
#

There are some possibilities for the missing money. They lost some dough in Blackwater as the result of the botched heist, leaving about one bag worth of 40k something and Micah went and grab that when he was a rat for the Pinkertons

#

Then he stored it in the chest

#

And told Dutch

#

Which would keep his ruse up

red helm
#

You're forgetting that train they just robbed right at the end of CHapter 6, There was a couple bags of money grabbed off the back of that Army train.

frigid cedar
#

ahhh

#

the final heist

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

But that wasn’t a whole lot and I’m sure they didn’t have enough time to store all that cash in one bag

frigid cedar
#

how u know that wasnt a whole lot

red helm
fierce valve
#

Abigail was captured before the gang managed to get back and she knew about the chest somehow

frigid cedar
fierce valve
#

So it can’t be train money

midnight dawn
#

Hard to say but good theories nonetheless

red helm
#

Why would they not have put it in with the other money, while Arthur and Sadie were off rescuing Sadie in Van Horn?

fierce valve
#

Tilly said the Pinkertons grabbed Abigail and Abigail in between that time found the chest and the key

#

And the whole gang was still with Dutch

#

And then they rode back

#

While Arthur goes to rescue Abigail with Sadie

midnight dawn
#

Yes

red helm
#

Hrm... maybe the chest had more than one key? Otherwise Dutch probably would've been a little annoyed when he noticed the key was missing.

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

So either there was not a lot of cash before and the gang managed to put most of the money in before everything went to shit or it was Blackwater money

fierce valve
midnight dawn
#

He'd have a collateral in case shits hit the fan

fierce valve
#

He probably didn’t

#

Since he had to be close to Dutch

red helm
#

I still highly doubt it was Blackwater money. I remember in Chapter 3, Micah asking Dutch, a few times, if he could go and get that money, since "He wouldn't be noticed". But Dutch would just ignore him.

fickle chasm
fierce valve
#

And you see him in camp mostly

fickle chasm
#

to find all of Micah's hideouts

#

each hideout you get quite some money

#

in epilogue btw

midnight dawn
#

Even in chapter 4 he was absent for sometime until the "big scores"

fierce valve
#

The Pinkertons probably did set something up

#

For Micah

#

Since they knew where he was

#

In the epilogue

fickle chasm
#

he's nowhere

fierce valve
fickle chasm
fierce valve
#

Since he didn’t become an informant until after Guarma

midnight dawn
fierce valve
midnight dawn
#

Since they document everything in newspaper

fierce valve
#

The Micah mystery remains unresolved

frigid cedar
#

at least he ded

fickle chasm
frigid cedar
#

imagine

midnight dawn
frigid cedar
#

shot him in the head but

#

rockstar writer doesn't agree

#

walked around and fell down

midnight dawn
#

True he could've sucked the bullet with his skin and changed it later

#

Since he's a snake

#

Goddamn rat

fierce valve
#

He is a snakerat

#

Not human

fickle chasm
#

so is he dead?

fierce valve
#

Confirmed

fickle chasm
#

or is he still slithering around somewhere

fierce valve
#

He is a rat(tle)snake

fickle chasm
#

lmao

frigid cedar
#

nice

#

so is jack a bandit now

#

why does he have to fake his grave

fierce valve
#

No

red helm
#

Perhaps since Micah's corpse is still up there, someone will find it, put robot parts in it, and turn him into a Cyborg....

fierce valve
#

Marko Dragic’s brother, Snarko Dragic

red helm
#

Totes.

frigid cedar
#

jack is a gunslinger

#

pretty gud one

#

only beat an old man

#

but still

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

You could see him doubt his guns after killing Ross tho

frigid cedar
#

wait theyre the same universe?

#

waaaaa\

fierce valve
#

What?

#

Ye I’m pretty sure

#

Cayo Perico has an Emerald Ranch easter egg

midnight dawn
#

I remember even seeing a tree in gta 5 that looked like rdr's model somewhere

#

Gta online i mean , a newer update

fickle chasm
#

my friend who plays GTA tried to whistle for his car after playing too much rdr2

midnight dawn
#

Your mechanic is out of whistling range

#

Try to bond more

fickle chasm
#

🤣

true drift
#

Man there Cattleman quickdraws so fast but it doesn’t kill

#

Even with express

hidden moss
#

how do you get rid of the white patches on your horse around the saddle

keen pagoda
#

Wdym if that's the coat u can't change it

#

U have to get a new horse if u don't like it

hidden moss
#

I get 180 dolar

hidden moss
midnight dawn
#

Esteban Cortez bounty poster doesn't appear for me

#

is there any fix ? i waited for days but nothing

rose haven
#

You have a bounty in New Austin at all?

midnight dawn
#

No nothing in new austin for some reason

#

I got plenty in black water

#

I basically couldn't get no Del lobo bounty

#

Oh nvm tumbleweed isn't like other locations

#

You have to witness a random encounter with the sheriff in order to trigger bounty hunts

vale heart
#

I really wondered why a long encounter for starting bounty hunts in Tumbleweed.

midnight dawn
#

Also about this if anyone is trying to do 100% , i believe meeting mary-beth and tilly as John counts as 2 missions even though they're not recorded in the mission list

vale heart
civic vault
#

I recently played Need For Speed and the muscle memory on my hand made me tap on the button for gas instead of just holding it and im like "Cars dont gallop you dum dum" lol

vale heart
#

Which encounter did you like when camping in forest? Arthur's encounter with Murfree Broods or John's encounter with Skinner Brothers.

midnight dawn
#

Hmm hard to say but probably skinner brothers , since they could've killed John easily

#

They got a knife to his throat without him noticing shows how scary they are

vale heart
midnight dawn
#

But I still think nightfolk are scarier since they're near the swamps and they fairly use the same methods as the skinner brothers. They're just mute lmao

vale heart
#

Like they should give a warning

#

For camping

midnight dawn
#

Well yeah they don't even talk

vale heart
#

But they can't

midnight dawn
#

I'm due to finish the 100% completion run tomorrow hooray

#

After nearly 500 hours now lmao

vale heart
midnight dawn
#

Hmm ? How do i make sure i stop at 99.9%?

#

Does it happen automatically and you can't finish the 100% until you visit Arthur's grave?

vale heart
#

You need to visit graves of fallen companions

#

Also if you visit arthur's grave before then there will be no cutscene but you can do 100% still.

midnight dawn
#

Yeah i know , I'm planning to do that since i wanna finish the points of interest

#

I'll leave Arthur's grave last then

vale heart
#

Hmm good idea.

hidden moss
#

I can hunt again legendary animal ?

#

unglicht

midnight dawn
#

if you replay a epilogue story mission where they talk about Arthur even though we did an honorable run you get disohonarble comments about him by default

#

hearing Charles say bad stuff about Arthur broke my heart

vale heart
#

As john?

midnight dawn
#

high honor

vale heart
#

Low?

midnight dawn
#

no

vale heart
#

Oh

#

And I wonder that replaying missions dialogue depends on honor.

#

but it's default.

hidden moss
#

Kill kkk s easy Honor

midnight dawn
#

i can't stop listening to the going back for the money theme

#

so badass

umbral kestrel
#

How do i trigger Edith downes mission in annesburg i hav max honor and visited the doctor already

midnight dawn
#

she is only available during chapter 6

hidden moss
#

somehow i got gold on the new south with only one objective complete lol

#

if only this was the case with other gold medals

vale heart
#

lmao

fierce valve
#

Like Albert Mason

#

Or Hamish

hidden moss
#

also the dinosaur lady you get some interesting unique dialogue

random sedge
#

Give it a day or two

vale heart
random sedge
#

Link?

vale heart
#

Today, I understood about deadeye levels in rdr1 and rdr2.

#

Rdr2 has two extra levels.

#

Level 4 (visible heart and head)
Level 5 (visible lung and stomach)

random sedge
#

1 Chapter 1, "Old Friends" Allows players to slow down time and drag the red x target across the enemy, auto-targeting them.
2 Chapter 2, "Pouring Forth Oil IV" Allows players to manually target enemies.
3 Chapter 4, "Urban Pleasures" Allows players to stay in Dead Eye mode after firing shots without marking targets.
4 Chapter 5, "Fleeting Joy" Allows the player to see the vital organs of their enemies (head and heart).
5 Chapter 6, "Goodbye, Dear Friend" Allows the player to see the vital organs of their enemies (lung and stomach).

vale heart
#

Oh yeah deadeye level increases in these missions

midnight dawn
#

i done all of those

#

I FINALLY am gonna kill micah

#

it is TIME

#

for the final mission

#

I'm gonna wear Arthur's clothes for this hehe

vale heart
#

I forgot @midnight dawn it was 99.8% to get that cutscene at arthur's grave.

#

But check ur progression in progress list

frigid cedar
#

ey found out PC version has extra trinkets

vale heart
#

You just need to found them.

drifting nacelle
#

Micah < Javier < Sadie < Uncle < Dutch < Hosea < John < Charles < Arthur

midnight dawn
#

it is done

#

micah vanished

#

seeing dutch there was surprising

#

but this doesn't even come close to chapter 6's ending

vernal rampart
#

did you get 100%?

midnight dawn
#

yes

#

well not i still need one more thing

#

visitng the graves

#

and that is it

vale heart
#

In story, yes.
But in game progress, no.

vernal rampart
#

visiting the graves will actually kill me

midnight dawn
#

and this mission was my 107th gold medal

vernal rampart
#

never done it before

vale heart
#

You did the mission "It's Art"?@midnight dawn

vernal rampart
#

hohoho

midnight dawn
#

won't take too long

vale heart
sharp mountain
#

Can someone give me smth fun to do after finishing rdr2

vernal rampart
#

wdym?

vale heart
fierce valve
#

One time I just wore a Cassimere Shirt and it looked funny in the confrontation

#

It’s like when your custom character appears in a cutscene

midnight dawn
#

goddamn these credit rolls are long

#

its like an entire country worked on this game

gloomy scarab
#

the hosea hunting mission still scares me

#

im doing it again for the 4th time and my horse ran away when hosea said to put saddle on other horse

reef hollow
#

Guys how do I cover satchel?

#

Only satchel

midnight dawn
#

you can't

turbid oriole
gloomy scarab
#

AAAAAAAAAA

#

i accidentaly deleted my first save

#

i just wanted to load that save and forgot i was in save game

digital bay
#

this sucks

#

i did all the story missions as arthur except the last 2 and now i cant do strauss debt mission penelope side mission or edith downes mission

#

so i will prob get low honor since most of the stuff i have to do will give me low honor especially the bandit challenge

#

not to mention i cant bounty hunt or do a coach robbery

#

great i cant even get any train tickets why is everything not available

#

is it because i blew the train bridge and thats why i cant get a train ticket?

cunning torrent
#

if i open rdr2 it still tells me "unable to launch game please verify your game data"

lean sparrow
#

Where can i find spoonbil plumes

gloomy scarab
vale heart
#

You deleted on your own.

gloomy scarab
#

well fuck

cunning torrent
#

my red dead is completely broken lol

gloomy scarab
#

so i have 3 save files of the same playthrough

ornate phoenix
#

im on the second epilogue... still cant believe that dutch all those years was a liar

midnight dawn
#

Blame bronte

#

If not for that false tip dutch wouldn't hit his head in the trolley

honest sable
#

dutch kills bronte in cold blood but like he said he do it for revenge

gloomy scarab
fiery stag
#

I just found out I can steal the train

#

Mind blonde

honest sable
#

beacuse arthur always use the word

fiery stag
fierce valve
gloomy scarab
#

took out a blockade with a dynamite and 2 shots from revolver

torn remnant
#

i have a fun idea

#

im gonna make a theoretical vs scenario of michael from gta and arthur pre-tb

#

to see who would win in a fight

#

Strength: Arthur
Speed: Michael
Agility: Michael
Durability: Arthur
Combat Speed: Arthur
Melee Combat: Arthur
Experience: Arthur
Equipment: Michael

Winner: Arthur

Winning Difficulty: High

fierce valve
#

Man would just grab an RPG and just shoot him with it

torn remnant
#

the guys we see in the cutscenes and stuff

#

not the insane civilian slaughtering one man armies you play as lol

#

now

#

imagine what arthur would be

#

if he got his hands on modern automatic weapons

#

that would be fucking terrifying

wintry lake
#

is anyone else's game not launching on steam or is that just me?

patent ocean
#

Why does it keep telling me there’s a error and it makes me quit the game

gaunt crescent
#

Matchmaking doesnt work for me, smth might be up with rdr 💀

rich fable
#

I killed the legendary bear twice and got both pelts 😤

frigid cedar
#

Uwot

pseudo crypt
#

How many missions is epilogue part two?

drifting sparrow
pseudo crypt
#

Thanks

drifting sparrow
#

Mhm

pseudo crypt
#

Also, is it worth completing? I am after the housebuilding and I haven't really enjoyed it so far

drifting sparrow
pseudo crypt
#

Alright, thank you!

drifting sparrow
#

Yep

patent ocean
#

Why does it keep telling me error please reboot and restart the game on pc

agile plinth
#

how do i fix error rockstar 0x10001028

midnight dawn
#

It'd be a shame to stop at this point , you only need like 5 more missions

fierce valve
#

Part of me wishes they would add more Legendary Animals

#

Like a giant snake

#

Or a lion

normal relic
#

Right i agree

midnight dawn
#

A snake that is 5"9'

#

Very massive

fierce valve
#

He is a rat(tle)snake

frigid cedar
#

Wish we can hunt the legendary naked wolf man

hidden moss
#

are all legendary animals required for 100%

vale heart
#

I don't think so

#

You only need 5

midnight dawn
#

I finally can massacre everyone in all states without feeling bad lmao

#

I'll start with the children of saint denis

vale heart
midnight dawn
#

Who said shooting

vale heart
#

On pc, there's a mod to kill them.

midnight dawn
#

I'll blow them up

#

With dynamite or burn them

vale heart
#

I think there's an encounter like this

fickle chasm
vale heart
#

Where kids will lure you into alleyway and try to rob you.

#

In Saint Denis.

normal relic
fickle chasm
#

and then go back to that save so the encounter will come again

#

Infinit child murder

vale heart
normal relic
#

Ohh those kids vk

drifting nacelle
#

I want to kill the Saint Denis kids

#

But I can't

vale heart
normal relic
#

Those are the ones that steal the bag

drifting nacelle
vale heart
drifting nacelle
#

And the FPS are not the best

vale heart
vale heart
drifting nacelle
#

I could buy RDR2 on PC, but I don't want to pay 60$ again to play the same game

hidden moss
#

and on ps5 it's got a lot of bugs

drifting nacelle
# vale heart 30fps?

Yes, in Read Dead Online it's even worse, for example in Valentine you have 20

vale heart
drifting nacelle
#

What graphics card do you have?

normal relic
vale heart
vale heart
#

But there are gangs of those kids.

#

Also those kids are controlled by Bronte. @normal relic

drifting nacelle
#

How much FPS do you get?

#

60+ right?

vale heart
vale heart
vale heart
#

@normal relic how did you finish that mission in which kids stole Arthur's satchel?

#

Arthur gets ambushed by kids?

normal relic
#

i think so

vale heart
#

Or Arthur caught the kid quick?

normal relic
#

if i remember right Arthur caught the kid

vale heart
normal relic
vale heart
#

For that mission.

normal relic
#

Yep

fierce valve
#

There is a way to catch the kid pretty easily

#

Just wait for him to get off the roof

vale heart
#

Yeah

fierce valve
#

Or if you’re fast enough, get him when he gets off the trolley

vale heart
#

You also get gold medal

fierce valve
#

Or a faster way to do it, fire bottle the cart he jumps on

vale heart
#

For catching the kid quickly

fierce valve
vale heart
#

I saw a video

#

He gets to the alleyway quickly

#

And wait for the kid to spawn there

#

Then tackle him

digital bay
#

Did micah actually kill jacks dog?

#

I finally got all the read dead online trophys

vale heart
digital bay
#

Tbh i never saw the dog doing anything besides from standing on a table but still thats messed up lol

vale heart
#

But jack gets a new dog in epilogue 2

digital bay
#

Eh yea ig

keen narwhal
#

Anyone know where to get a Missouri Fox Trotter for free

hearty moth
#

Hey folks, what i have to do, to rob citizens without getting a wanted bounty?

midnight dawn
sharp sequoia
#

@vale hearthow much RAM u using on your set up while playing Red ded 2 mate?

#

have 16GB and soon will get 32GB i think its better for that game.

civic vault
#

finally got the white cougar

vale heart
civic vault
#

Yeah

civic vault
#

I have 24gb

vale heart
#

Really?

thick pewter
#

So I'm on xbox 1 s and it says rdr on the shop with xbox 360 does that mean I can only play it on only 360 or can I on mine

midnight dawn
#

Backwards compatibility

#

You can play it on xbox one s

thick pewter
#

K ty

hidden moss
#

is arthur and john the exact same character model cause i just put on arthur standard outfit and they look the exact same

vale heart
#

Rockstar messed up with jaw, ears and neck of John too.

hidden moss
#

wow i can't believe i never noticed it yeah his hair completely changed from chapter 1-6 lol

#

dude that's so lazy all these small details but they mess up the character model

vale heart
#

Yeah

#

They messed up one of their iconic character's model.

#

Even If they didn't give John's hairstyle it was ok but they messed up the whole body.

hidden moss
#

the other character models looked ok from rdr1 into rdr2 but not john

vale heart
#

Yeah

lean sparrow
#

How do i complete gambler 8!

hidden moss
#

is that blackjack

lean sparrow
#

Yes

midnight dawn
hidden moss
# lean sparrow Yes

go to rhodes and sit on the far left best bet is if 2-3 ppl are playing if you get cards like a 9 and 3 then leave the table then it resets the deck it may take a while

vale heart
#

@midnight dawn are there koalas in rdr2?

uncut berry
#

“we want them to feel like they’re still playing as Arthur” sounds like an excuse to me

#

any idea what really went down or do you think it was just them being lazy @vale heart

midnight dawn
scarlet holly
#

Oh wow
Micah just killed Arthur-

#

Is he really dead?

#

Am I gonna play as John forever from now

fickle chasm
scarlet holly
#

This feels kinda boring

#

He's... milking a cow

fickle chasm
#

first half is boring and kinda tedious

midnight dawn
#

Just finish arthur's unfinished tasks sadthumbsup

fickle chasm
#

second half is pretty fun

scarlet holly
midnight dawn
#

But they're like 5 minutes long

fickle chasm
scarlet holly
#

Dutch and Micah are still out there right?

midnight dawn
#

Yeah

fickle chasm
#

ye

vale heart
vale heart
#

John's Gambler Hat is only available in epilogue 1

scarlet holly
vale heart
#

So punch your horse and it will kick you then pick up the hat

scarlet holly
#

What does John's Gambler Hat look like?

vale heart
#

And John's hat will available permanently

fickle chasm
#

in epilogue 1

scarlet holly
vale heart
scarlet holly
#

Didn't Arthur give his hat to john?

#

Does he still have it?

vale heart
#

Also It's the hat from rdr1 (the game which came before rdr2)

vale heart
civic vault
vale heart
midnight dawn
civic vault
#

I had it upgraded a bit because i needed more ram for my job. But then i use it for gaming rofl

vale heart
uncut berry
#

just realized that the hat John has in rdr1 is the same one in the epilogue

gusty siren
uncut berry
#

i just uninstalled mine

hidden moss
#

what's the orange farm by lagras

#

with the gaurd

#

guard*

uncut berry
#

you're going to have to be more specific

uncut berry
#

lol someone on reddit said they uninstalled bf 2042 for rdr2 and it had 87% upvotes

uncut berry
#

i want 5 minutes alone in a room with the 13%

#

what parts of the map do bison most commonly reside? i want the legendary bear coat but i need a perfect pelt (i already got the legendary bear pelt from the hosea mission)

#

and i can only use improved arrows to my advantage because i haven't unlocked the sniper rifle yet :/

desert coral
hidden moss
#

some how my horse nearly died from fast travel from annesberg to st denis when it had full health and stamina cores

#

never had that happen before

hidden moss
#

do you mean lagras?

#

yeah it's by lagras

keen narwhal
midnight dawn
#

You get 10k after finishing the game , why don't you just buy it

#

Or 20k i don't remember

keen narwhal
#

20

midnight dawn
#

It's only 950

keen narwhal
#

I’ve already spent 19k lmao

#

I massacred tumble weed twice for killing my horse

#

I got 1500 dollar bounty twice

hidden moss
#

how have you spent 19k lol

last sierra
#

Whenever I do a train robbery in the tunnel in the grizzlies it always plays this creepy music with piano and I can't find it anywhere

thick pewter
#

Does honor matter in rdr1?

vale heart
# thick pewter Does honor matter in rdr1?

There isn't really a noticeable difference. You can make choices which all reach the same goal five seconds later, so it is pretty pointless incorporating a morality system that has no effect on the game other than how people react to you.

lean sparrow
#

Why cant i complete ride from van horn to blackwater in 17 min

#

I just did it in 15 min

#

Am i not allowed to fall

#

Or pause it

scarlet holly
#

Can I get my previous horse back after morgan dies?

#

I had a black arabian

drifting sparrow
#

RDR 2 made a HUGE difference with how much the honor system effects your game

drifting sparrow
#

i’m assuming you already got past the point of arthur dying

scarlet holly
drifting sparrow
#

Still miss my two black shires from my playthroughs

vale heart
#

I have Buell from Hamish

#

as john

#

And it is a bit brave horse in a way.

frosty canopy
#

how much money in camp funds should I have at chapter 6?

midnight dawn
#

I am in my ultimate form finally lmao

midnight dawn
#

Since all that money will be lost , someone will break the donation box

solar garnet
#

can someone hop in vc with me rq? i need help with something scripthook related

turbid oriole
#

I just do high honour with John because of the story arc

vale heart
#

I prefer to have two playthroughs of rdr1

turbid oriole
vale heart
#

One as high

#

Other as low

turbid oriole
#

If your attempting to use mods

solar garnet
#

how

turbid oriole
solar garnet
#

do i have to buy

#

@turbid oriole look in red dead media channel

#

i posted whats wrong there

frosty canopy
#

why cant I customise both of my volcanic pistols?

turbid oriole
#

Lemme go ask a friend for it

solar garnet
#

bet

midnight dawn
#

You can't have different customization on the same weapon type

frosty canopy
#

nope it sure doesnt

#

because only one of mine customised

midnight dawn
#

Does it show a diamond or something near the weapon at the gunsmith customization section?

frosty canopy
#

no worries worked it out!

#

nope no I havnt

#

how to customise first and secondary pistols rdr2

frosty canopy
rose haven
#

Can you arrest anyone you catch doing a crime (except the vampire I guess) since I decided to bring the guy who accidentally shoots his friend in Rhodes to the sheriff

#

Got 7.75 from it too

violet osprey
#

What should i use to catch legendary fish?

fierce valve
#

Go to the Lagras Bait Shop

violet osprey
#

Ty

fierce valve
#

Buy the bait and lure there

rose haven
#

Yeah you just have to buy the special lure for all water types and you're set for the rest of it

thick pewter
#

Best way to get honor in rdr?

drifting nacelle
#

Greet NPCs, go fishing and throw the fishs back in the water

hearty moth
#

Is there anything i can do with [Gold Nugget], [Silver tooth] or [Gold Bar] next to selling??

drifting nacelle
#

Yes, you can keep it in your inventory

midnight dawn
midnight dawn
midnight dawn
#

I haven't played 1 yet

normal relic
naive lantern
#

rdr1

#

is old

#

don't play it

vernal rampart
#

ratio + ur wrong + bad opinion

normal relic
#

Rdr1 is fun

#

i played rdr1 first then when rdr2 came i played that

sharp cliff
#

Same

sharp cliff
#

RDR1 is a masterpiece

normal relic
#

Right

#

i enjoyed playing rdr1 good story

#

Same with rdr2

naive lantern
#

I played Rdr1 when it came out in high school

#

it was a good game

#

but it hasn't aged well

#

and it's absolute dog water compared to RDR2

vernal rampart
#

most games are lol

normal relic
#

Lol

#

i love the rdr games

#

I play rdr2 rdo alot

west crescent
#

it would be so cool if every building had an interior you could go into

lean sparrow
#

Are you allowed to pause in horseman 9

red helm
opaque geode
west crescent
#

ayyy my rdr1 disc came!

#

i literally got the notification that it had arrived right as i picked up my phone to check

#

now i just gotta buy a xbox so i can use it

#

eh too much work, plus idk if ill get enough fps

#

im just gonna get a used xbox one for $40

hollow viper
#

you need a beefy pc for it

#

or it wont run at all

west crescent
#

thats why im not doing it

#

my pc is good but not good enough

hollow viper
#

hiliarous how a modder on the freetime

#

can make a better john

#

than rockstar

#

tbh

red helm
#

Yes, it's rather annoying what they did with Epilogue John.

violet osprey
rose haven
#

Yh

red helm
violet osprey
#

Oh

red helm
# violet osprey Oh

What I eventually did, was use Eagle eye to find it, then switch around from one lure to another, until it would go for it.

violet osprey
#

Cause im tryna get the legendary gar

#

By lakay

#

Idk how to tell which fish is the legendary one tho

hollow viper
#

the biggest one

red helm
#

Then try the Special Lake lure first, ad if that doesn't work, try the river.

hollow viper
#

the legendaries are always the biggest ones there

#

its Swamp lure there

violet osprey
#

I just got eaten by an alligator lmao

red helm
#

Yeap, usually they are way bigger OR they look different than everything else around.

red helm
hidden moss
#

I just did american venom and shed one single tear

violet osprey
#

All the fish look big to me. Too many lake sturgeons and other gars

violet osprey
#

Yes i have been

hollow viper
#

ur blind then tbh

#

use Gta series videos to find it i guess

violet osprey
#

Are you mad at me or something bc it feels like you are

hollow viper
#

no

#

im just calling u blind

#

lol

violet osprey
#

Kinda rude but okay

hollow viper
#

also depends on where u are

red helm
hollow viper
#

some of the fish locations on the map are inaccurate asf

red helm
#

Yes, don't always trust the map.

violet osprey
red helm
violet osprey
#

I finally got it!!!

#

Tysm!!

rose haven
#

With special lures the legendary fish are the only ones that'll go for them

#

Or atleast that's how it's been for me

violet osprey
#

With the special lure too

rose haven
#

I was really lucky then ig

patent ocean
#

does anyone know why whenever i try to play rdr2 on my pc it just tells me error close the game and retry?

fallow wedge
#

Idk

pallid zenith
#

Does anyone know anything about the tree next to the mysterious hill house?

remote flower
#

Dude, Mary so evil for taking advantage of Arthur's feelings

vernal rampart
#

fr!

remote flower
#

I almost feel like rejecting her requests, but I know Arthur gets way more sad this way

fierce valve
#

He chose to fall in love with her

#

She didn’t manipulate him into loving her

#

It makes more sense for Arthur to help her than not

remote flower
#

Yeah, but she did went after him to ask for help, because she knew he wouldn't say no

#

That's straight up manipulation

fierce valve
#

She’s not exactly evil anyways

#

Her family was just falling apart

#

Arthur seemed like her only way to save some of it

#

Arthur saved Jamie from a suicide cult, and kept her father from selling her mother’s brooch for some money to get drunk and gamble

#

Arthur practically threw Mary away

#

For the gang

midnight dawn
remote flower
#

Cause they would be dead without him, Mary would be fine

midnight dawn
#

And she admits to her faults too

fierce valve
#

And Mary wanted Arthur to change his ways

#

That’s why she gave him the ring

#

And the picture

midnight dawn
fierce valve
#

So Arthur would know to do the right thing which is not going back to her but to turn his life around

remote flower
#

I just don't know, it gives me a sour taste when someone who stayed dead silent for so long, and the first time they contact you is for asking a favor.

fierce valve
#

He will rise out of the grave

midnight dawn
#

If Arthur wasn't there all of them would've died tbh , maybe not the girls

fierce valve
#

So…

fierce valve
#

But John is too incompetent for his own good

midnight dawn
#

If Arthur wasn't there John would've left the gang long ago lmao

#

Well it's hard to say what could happen without Arthur

remote flower
#

John was too young at the time, didn't have the balls he has in RDR1 yet

fierce valve
#

Well a vaccine anyways

fierce valve
#

Maybe then he will be smarter and grow some balls

midnight dawn
#

It's kinda sad that you can't find O'Shea's Grave in rdr2

#

You can find eagle flies but not O'Shea

fierce valve
#

I don’t even think O’Shea got a grave

remote flower
#

Yeah, I feel bad for Molly

#

Grimshaw was way too quick, if she was that quick with Micah, a lot of problems would've been avoided.

fierce valve
#

So even if she shot Micah then and there, she would still be dead

#

💀

#

Joe probably would’ve shot her

#

Cleet doesn’t kill women, not that I know of

remote flower
#

In other words, probably a few more months of life for Arthur

fierce valve
#

Someone else would’ve probably killed him

#

Since there are still Micah’s two goons

#

Arthur doesn’t get off easy

#

The outlaw life doesn’t allow that

wispy pond
#

Oh

fierce valve
#

John in RDR1 is a prime example

remote flower
#

If he was killed, it would probably be by the pinkertons

normal relic
remote flower
#

Gaining more time for John

fierce valve
#

Ross was always willing to kill Arthur

#

Ever since they first met when he and Jack went fishing

remote flower
#

Arthur should've dead eyed the two by that river

#

Jack would've be shocked, but yeah

#

you do what you have to do

fierce valve
#

Jack would’ve been traumatized for the rest of his life

remote flower
#

Or not, I've seen kids go through worse and be just fine

fierce valve
#

Plus killing two high profile Pinkertons draws more attention on the gang

#

So bad idea

remote flower
#

I mean, just hide the body. But still, to be frank, the best way for the gang to have survived was to not rob the Cornwall train

fierce valve
#

Listen to Hosea the first time

#

There were more moneymakers than the train

#

Let the O’Driscolls get hunted down

#

The bank in Valentine, the various oddjobs we did, Lemoyne National Bank, and other scores

remote flower
#

Exactly, they would've been too busy looking for the O'driscolls

#

That smoke screen dutch wanted so much later on

#

was there in the start

#

Dude I just wanted a clean black duster coat

#

but rockstar said no

#

"go play the online"

hollow viper
#

Non modded story issue tbh

remote flower
#

console peasant issues

hollow viper
#

funniest thing is

rose haven
#

Can you get rid of that fucking insta kill sniper with mods?

hollow viper
#

ps4 had the best 1.00 patch

hollow viper
#

easy ASI mod

#

N done

remote flower
#

but I don't know if it's worth to downgrade to 1.00 and restart

hollow viper
#

its cool at 1.00 bc

#

Better facial animations

#

(TAA doesnt look fucking stupid)

#

runs better also in some cases

#

and john looks 373737 times better

remote flower
#

I know john looks better too

normal relic
#

If they didn't rob the train

remote flower
#

I don't know why the downgraded John

hollow viper
#

Bc its rockstar

#

monkies sitting at HQ

remote flower
rose haven
#

They're not bad devs

hollow viper
#

Rockstar when thier first good story game since 2008 was in 2018

#

(Gta 5s isnt good)

knotty slate
#

Hi, how do I full screen RDR2? I cant change it in settings

hollow viper
#

Its in the settings lmao

#

if u cant ur game is fucked

remote flower
rose haven
hollow viper
#

it just isnt good

#

Compared to older

#

(Gta 4s dlc>5)

#

also not 2008

knotty slate
hollow viper
#

2010

#

rdr1 exists

remote flower
#

GTA5 is just funny

knotty slate
hollow viper
#

rdr1 pc port when

#

(Never)

remote flower
#

The truth is that GTA Online made Rockstar complacent

hollow viper
#

pc mfs (me) when mfs cant play rdr

rose haven
hollow viper
#

Story is bland

#

and repetive

#

same missions over n over

#

+the side missions barely make sense at all

remote flower
#

I just don't know how people can still play GTA Online in 2022, like, what do you do during the whole time? Yeah, you can do some missions, but they're repetitive and lack depth. The cars are ugly, the graphics are dated, yeah, for a 2013 game it's great, but it doesn't make sense for that game to be the biggest money maker of the company.

#

Let this game die so Rockstar can make a better one ffs

worldly turret
#

probably because it might not me, Take Two, Rockstars parent company, takes over 60% of the money made from transactions

remote flower
hollow viper
#

😴

worldly turret
#

if anything, Take Two is making Rockstar focus on GTA Online over anything else, which explains why Rockstar themselves aren't working on the remakes, it gets pawned off to mobile companies

#

idk gta online has a lot to do but it's boring after a while

hollow viper
#

rockstar when modders make the game playable

#

litterally payday 2 moments all around

remote flower
#

If anything, Payday 2 has better missions

hollow viper
#

payday 2 is a shit game tho

#

lmao

remote flower
#

I have on my steam account, never downloaded, but I watched some streamers playing

#

looks like a L4D2 but with robberies

#

and builds

#

at least has more depth than GTA Online it seems

hollow viper
#

and its horribly unoptimized

#

it runs worse than gta online on max settings 32 players

#

it needs mods to make it playable

remote flower
#

Sometimes I wonder how some games can be so baddly optimized, it seems like the devs were intentionally making it worse

hollow viper
#

Its built on the diesel engine

#

Ofc its shit

remote flower
#

Like, if the game is very demanding, I kinda understand it being not very optimized, but there are some games out there with bad graphics, lame physics, enclosed environments, but the optimization sucks.

rose haven
#

Wish there was more of the strange man in rdr2

#

He's proper intriguing

normal relic
#

I haven't seen him yet

fierce valve
#

You can also see him in Armadillo in Herbert Moon’s shop

normal relic
#

Really

fierce valve
#

Yes

normal relic
#

Interesting

#

I wonder who this strange man is

rose haven
#

He's gavin

normal relic
#

Ohh

tight parcel
#

ending kinda balls

hidden moss
#

Low honor or high honor m8?

fierce valve
#

When I feel like it

knotty slate
#

Hi, how do I fullscreen RDR2? I reinstalled the game but still not working

knotty slate
patent ocean
knotty slate
#

rip ok

hot bluff
#

Are mods fixed yet after the update?

frigid cedar
#

Doubt it

kindred tiger
#

can you get ponchos as arthur?

midnight dawn
#

No ponchos in story mode i think

rose haven
#

Although I suppose you could probably mod some if you're on pc

spring lark
#

Revenge for Arthur Morgan I finally did it

kindred tiger
fallow wedge
#

sharp cliff
#

Forgot what it's called, can be crafted at the Trapper though

fierce valve
#

The cloaks?

lean sparrow
#

F**k gambler 8

midnight dawn
sharp cliff
#

Panther Cloak

shut pond
#

hi guys, does any of you know that when will the AB scripthook be updated?...

#

as it's not working for me atm, I can't play with mods

hollow viper
#

autohotkey usually does it

hollow viper
#

and its been 3 days so

#

ask in RDR2MODS discord

shut pond
hollow viper
#

yes

#

rn im playing with mods bc

#

i downgraded

#

to last patch

shut pond
#

uh.. can I do that on rockstar launcher?...

hollow viper
#

yes u can

#

but its harder

#

n rockstar launcher suck ass so

shut pond
#

lol..

#

then I'll wait

#

btw.. are mods savegame compatible?...

#

because I just started a new game and I plan to add mods when the scripthook will be fixed

hollow viper
#

mods cant break savegames

#

just DONT wear them if ur gona remove the mods

#

if its clothing n weapon stuff

shut pond
#

sure

#

but I don't plan to remove them lol

civic vault
#

ugh ive been playing for 5 hours trying to beat sharpshooter 8

#

i tried dem poison arrows too

#

sakjfssakljhsgsdf

hollow viper
#

is it?

civic vault
#

Yep

#

i put it off now coz im getting too frustrated

#

decided to hunt for birds just to get dem feathers for the hat

mental totem
#

I've just got the new scripthook, lml mod manager and asi and now my game keeps on crashing in-game, in the black and white loading screen. Any fixes?

hollow viper
#

and wait

hidden moss
hollow viper
#

fun fact

#

people do it as arthur too

#

(still possible to go to fort mercer)

hidden moss
#

well i guess you can go to a town aim your gun at someone then go into dead eye wait for them to pull their gun out then shoot it

hollow viper
#

litterally just use poison arrows

#

shoot them in the leg

#

done in a minute

hidden moss
#

honestly had no idea that was even a thing

hollow viper
#

they drop their weapon

#

and it counts so

hidden moss
#

well i should of done it that way sounds more easy

hollow viper
#

it is

hidden moss
#

noted for next time

hollow viper
#

the hat shooting one is gona be difficult for me atleast

#

im gona do litterally EVERYTHING in chapter 2

hidden moss
#

is that even possible

hollow viper
#

it is

#

with the power of

#

pc mods

#

im gona collect all the stuff

#

can do dino bones done

hidden moss
#

so it's not possible

hollow viper
#

cant do last fishermen mission

#

gona have to do it as john

#

before american venom

#

just gona do everything else as john that is not possible as arthur

hidden moss
#

well you can do all the side content as arthur then

hollow viper
#

that is what im gona do

hidden moss
#

any good spots to find a opossum

hollow viper
#

beside valentine

keen pagoda
#

If u chuck a hatchet at a tree but it lands too far up for u to pick up how do u get it

#

Can u cut down the tree

hidden moss
#

no you can't cut a tree down i would just try shoot it or use dynamite

#

probably won't work

hollow viper
#

usually makes them fall

warm mica
#

I wish rdr2 had nightwatch, liars dice, bank robberies, and mexico

hollow viper
#

well bank robberies it does

#

with mods

#

l o l

keen pagoda
hollow viper
#

Nothing there tho

hollow viper
#

if its not a 1 of a kind item

#

then ur kinda fucked

keen pagoda
normal relic
keen pagoda
#

Also I'm on horseman 10 and I'm tryna get all wild horses but I cant find Hungarian half bred I go to where they're meant to spawn and they aren't there

hollow viper
#

those are always weird imo

normal relic
#

I got alot to do in story

hollow viper
#

they spawn sometimes near blackwater

#

and sometimes they spawned right beside horseshoe overlook

#

at my first hour

#

in my playtrough

hidden moss
#

Does anyone have any thing about the loft in ambarino

rose haven
#

Most people seem to think it's just a former military post or hunting lodge

#

Nice place to stay either way

rustic geyser
#

U guys ever gonna host an event with a big lobby ?!

nova igloo