red-dead-singleplayer

[normal relic]

I met someone on rdo who dresses as John and Arthur

Yep it is

[vale heart]

I have never tried legend of the west outfit so idk the experience.

[normal relic]

I never seen it so idk

[fierce valve]

I would send a pic of it if I could

[normal relic]

In rdo i never dress up in dresses my character looks so weird riding on a horse with dresses on

I look more like an outlaw in rdo

[fierce valve]

There are more colors for outfits available in RdR2 in RDO right?

[normal relic]

Yes

[flat badge]

where can you find fight clubs? they seem like tons of fun

[torn remnant]

what beard level do you guys keep arthur at

i keep him at 2

[dire sentinel]

why did the the doctor in valentine have odriscolls in that security door in his shop?

[turbid oriole]

Rip ef

Goddamn it dutch

[raw quiver]

Fight Clubs? don't think They Exist

[torn remnant]

my game keeps goddamn crashing

after like 15 minutes of playing

its not any of the mods

ive checked

it just.. crashes for some reason

[sharp cliff]

There's no fight club BUT if your looking to fist fight a lot of people..

Saint Denis is where you wanna go

Near the factories, you'll find a lot of workers

they are really united because if you piss one off, they all come at you

and (I'm pretty sure) they don't have guns so they won't draw on you

i could be wrong but yeah check that out

[hidden moss]

try van horn 😏

[dire sentinel]

van horn is good for fist fighting, until one dude whips out their gun

[hidden moss]

definitely a short temper town

[sharp cliff]

Although the fact that the law won't interfere you in van horn..

and you can just murder and loot everyone and everything is.. pretty great

if you're a low honor guy that is

[hidden moss]

did the law get involved in thieves landing in rdr1

[sharp cliff]

I think they did

Thieves landing in rdr1 was a civilized place

[midnight dawn]

Chapter 3 is just as big as chapter 2

[hidden moss]

that's basically van horm

[sharp cliff]

I'm not sure, I don't remember

[midnight dawn]

There are 18 missions in both of them

[hidden moss]

chapter 5 is pointless just gonna say that

[sharp cliff]

Chapter 3 is best.

[midnight dawn]

I'm just starting the 3rd now

[hidden moss]

epilogue 2 has the best song in the entire game

[midnight dawn]

For the sake of bandit challenges

[sharp cliff]

Camp by the sea, great for fishing or going boating, everyone in the camp, good mood

chapter 3's end is where it starts getting depressing

okay, no spoilers I guess

[hidden moss]

yeah it definitely is

uh are spoiler tags not allowed

[drifting nacelle]

I think all chapters are great. That's very rare these days.

[sharp cliff]

Nice

[swift pond]

It's fun as hell tho

[hidden moss]

not really it could of been 3 missions long insted of 6

[swift pond]

Fav chapter in my opinion

[hidden moss]

or put 5 and 6 into a single chapter

[swift pond]

Took me by surprise and really showed how insane Dutch was driven

[swift pond]

Nothing wrong with a short chapter

[hidden moss]

yeah they showed his breaking point

[sharp cliff]

Chapter 1 is boring and the game should have the option to skip prologue.

[swift pond]

Yh it's slow but supposed to be like tutorial

[sharp cliff]

I also want there to be a NG+ so you don't have to grind for the legend of the east satchel everytime

but well they'll never do that

[swift pond]

Ikr

[hidden moss]

nah it teaches you the basics

[sharp cliff]

Not necessary for players returning for another playthrough

Like me, on my 4th

[swift pond]

Same

[sharp cliff]

I'm just saying it should give you the option to skip it

Like

Doesn't GTA 5 have the option to skip prologue now?

[hidden moss]

nope

[swift pond]

But chap 1 is still essential to show the tension with the odriscolls

[sharp cliff]

What? I'm pretty sure it does

[swift pond]

Does it?

[sharp cliff]

So you can get straight into Online

or something

[hidden moss]

yeah in a menu

[swift pond]

Yh online you can skip but story not sure

[sharp cliff]

again a returning player would know that lol

[swift pond]

I would rather experience the full story

[hidden moss]

so glad they fixed that sometimes you have to replay that mission to play gtao

[sharp cliff]

I would rather not playthrough the hour long prologue again

[swift pond]

Besides chapter 1 has a good heist and shootout will odriscolls

[sharp cliff]

I would much rather get into the open world and start exploring

[swift pond]

Fair enough

[sharp cliff]

I know but it's not like you get anything out of the train heist

[hidden moss]

if you are a returning player would it not be better to skip every mission you don't want to play

[sharp cliff]

the bonds are sold much later aren't they

I'm not saying every mission, I'm just saying the prologue

[swift pond]

It's about the experience for me not what you get

I love the story in games and chill exploring

[sharp cliff]

Well

If it was a thing in the game, it'd be an option

So you could play with or without the prologue, your choice

[swift pond]

Like red ded
and ghost of tsushima

Lesser grind

[hidden moss]

so it would be locked like a god of war 2018 you can only skip cut scenes in your second playthrough

[sharp cliff]

ghost of tsushima actually has u to skip prologue if ur doing a NG+ lol

[hidden moss]

i was fine with the one playthrough of ghost after doing every side quest tale thing

[sharp cliff]

I returned for a NG+ and I will again next month maybe

Game's a masterpiece

[hidden moss]

chapter 2 really saved the game for me

almost quit on it

[midnight dawn]

NG+ mechanics can't work for this game

[sharp cliff]

Yeah I figured

especially with the horse probably

[onyx canopy]

Found some moon knight cosplayers having a meeting by Rhodes, love this game

[willow thunder]

what's better, first person or third person?

[strange stream]

@willow thunder it's your prefable choice

[void perch]

First is crazy on a horse

[dense quarry]

fr

[midnight dawn]

I do first person if i go on massacre or a big gunfight

[glad brook]

Ttye.

[hidden moss]

Fact: If you ever want to test your guns, or simply go on a massacare, go to armadillo and let your anger out there.

[midnight dawn]

Or van horn

[hidden moss]

I perfer armadillo cuz they dont shoot back and even if they get angry/aggressive u can just pull ur gun out to intimidate/shoot them.

[turbid wind]

You can acctually get wanted tho in Van Horn not really in Armadillo

[fierce valve]

Where can I get topless John?

That would be good

[dense quarry]

Mod or glitch

2 ways

[fierce valve]

💀

Bro

Why can’t you make your character topless like GTA

[willow thunder]

so first person on a horse is not recommended?

[midnight dawn]

Nah i don't like fpp on horse

I only use it on gun fights because you can feel the recoil more and your character moves faster

[midnight dawn]

Bruh that lion mission damn, he slits arthur's throat

[midnight dawn]

Bruh why can i not kill this lion wtf

Oh nvm my weapon was in a very poor condition since i just picked it up lmao

[dense quarry]

Dirty gun literally shoots marshmallows

[flat badge]

love fist fighting in this game

[midnight dawn]

Damn, a grey striped thoroughbred is my new favorite horse

The game says there are 13 legendary fish but what are the two free spots for ?

[vale heart]

I use youtube for side missions which require 100%

[slate rain]

I think that's legal in New York

[plush vessel]

Is anyone expecting rdr3 ??

[vernal rampart]

not really

[plush vessel]

Why ??

[vernal rampart]

based off of rockstars treatment of online i just doubt they will put the effort in

[patent ocean]

How do I keep the rabbits at perfect cause when I shoot with arrows it becomes good

[vernal rampart]

varmint rifle

[patent ocean]

To get the satchels do I have to donate the pelts to pe radon

Pearson

[vernal rampart]

yes

[patent ocean]

Ok thx

[plush vessel]

The online of rdr2 is already dead

It’s not in the same level of gta online

But the story mode is better than gta

[umbral kestrel]

bruh

[umbral kestrel]

fax

i rly wish rockstar would do another game like rdr or gta that is set in another time

like medieval or sth

[cunning torrent]

is it normal that if im in red dead the rockstar games launcher keeps on loading

[plush pewter]

Anyone know how exotics work?

[turbid fable]

lol micah c

[vale heart]

Nope

[zinc geyser]

anyone know my whenever i go to do side mission, they sometimes disapear when i get to the spot, like it would show on the map when im 100km away, i go to it. and it just disapeared

[clear shuttle]

oh thats like the opposite of what's supposed to happen lmao. they're supposed to disappear when far away and reappear when close. hm that's odd

[torn remnant]

my rdr2 keeps crashing

after about 20 minutes of playing

i literally can't make any progress

ive uninstalled all my mods

and it's not fixed

[hidden moss]

does anyone know any good time saves for the mission old friends i'm trying to get the gold medal i'm shooting kieran horse then in camp i go all the way to dutch on horseback to save about 5-6 seconds

hey!

i just finished the uhh story mode of RDR2 for the first time, not too long ago

[torn remnant]

i would have finished chapter 2 by now

if the game didnt crash

every 20 minutes

meaning i can make literally no progress

[drifting nacelle]

1, 2 and 3 fav character?

[hidden moss]

my favorite character, besides arthur probably would be charles, really liked riding with him and liked his character a lot, but i think the whole arc of dutch was very interesting too

would it be better for me to spoiler tag stuff?

[vale heart]

Nice so now the game is freezing in black screen when trying to fast travel.

[cunning torrent]

is there a way to control the horse kick

[zinc geyser]

dont get kicked off 🤷‍♂️

[hidden moss]

even in a spoiler tag it gets removed even if you put hello in the tag but sadie adler was my favorite new character i would like to play as her in rdr3 if that ever happens

[civic vault]

I got a mustang and people complement the horse

I didnt know people sought mustangs

[hidden moss]

yeah sadie is a great character, loved her

[hidden moss]

what's the horsepower for your mustang?

[civic vault]

It's pretty low, imo. So i was surprised an npc complemented it

[vale heart]

I did a mistake

by playing as John

for legendary fishes

[hidden moss]

how is that a mistake?

[vale heart]

cause I can't catch Legendary Sockeye Salmon

[hidden moss]

what

[vale heart]

there is an ice plate

on the spot of legendary fish

[hidden moss]

does that effect the 100%

[vale heart]

Gonna use mods then

[vale heart]

yes

legendary fishes are required for 100%

[hidden moss]

so i've stiffed myself out of 100%

where is this legendary fish?

nah you gotta be trolling

[vale heart]

Lake isabelle.

[vale heart]

If you think I am trolling then check progress list.

It is mentioned to catch legendary fishes.

[cunning torrent]

no i meant the kick you can do ontop of the horse

[hidden moss]

well i am able to catch normal fish at that lake as john so the legendary fish should be able to catch as john

[magic kite]

lemonye raiders just send me a gattaling gun

good i can use to shoot the odrislco

[vale heart]

I couldn't catch legendary sockeye salmon

[hidden moss]

well i watched a video and the two rocks are not covered in ice and i still have a large body of water i can fish i've seen a red fish swimming i'm guessing that's the legendary fish

[vale heart]

As john or arthur?

[hidden moss]

john

[vale heart]

In video

I mean

[hidden moss]

no arthur in the video but i'm playing as john

[vale heart]

Try catching the legendary sockeye salmon as John then you'll know

[magic kite]

well damn the horse keep try to run away with gataling gun

but still i use that gun to shoot the fucking bear into hive hole

and shooted some odrisco head gone

like 3? or 4

i robbed an old man who found the gold

even i got dishonor but i need money for now xD

as i knock him out with gun

[keen pagoda]

Guys pls help I've finished the whole campaign including epilogue and have a bunch of money just sold my old horse and bought a new one for like a grand but I died and respawned and I'm back to a Tennessee walker is my horse lost it didn't die but I went to a stable and it's not there

How do I get it back

[hidden moss]

hello i went back had to buy the special lake lure then travelled all the way back to the lake and caught the legendary fish on my first try

[keen pagoda]

Guys help me

Idk what to do I spend loads on this horse and it's rly good

[hidden moss]

that's weird

[vale heart]

In my world, water is frozen on the spot of legendary sockeye salmon

[keen pagoda]

Jesus u took that long to type that

[vale heart]

I still don't understand.

[keen pagoda]

I want my horse u guys help

Please

[vale heart]

I used mod menu to do that but only perch was not available in mod menu so I did that only on my own.

[hidden moss]

can you send me a picture of the lake in a dm

without a mod

[keen pagoda]

Wow rejected😭

Ig I'll have to get a new horse then

[vale heart]

Wait

[hidden moss]

maybe reload a previous save if possible

gotta admit i was starting to sweat with the legendary fish

[magic kite]

stupid horse

i try to save a npc from couger he doesn't want to go up

and he dead

i lose honor

[violet jewel]

cringo npc interaction

[tiny badge]

I had to escort a lady to emerald. On my way there on cinematic mode, we dropped near a sign post. The lady stuck above the post and i cant get her down. So i shot her 😂

[magic kite]

jesus i think she won't appear infront of you anymore

btw i think if pearson add skunk into the soup

[glad brook]

Everyone underestimates Pearson.

[cunning torrent]

is the kick the character does on a horse randomized (left or right)

[sleek granite]

I think so

[torn remnant]

damn

my arthur's hair got so much longer

now that i entered chapter 3

i think it's cause the hair growing limit of chapter 2 is smaller than chapter 3

[true drift]

Can i disarm people normally?

Like encounters in the world

[true drift]

like not in duels

[hidden moss]

you can

[true drift]

oh

[hidden moss]

btw if u do it with the tumbleweed sherrif he will pull another revolver from his off-hand

[true drift]

so i just aimed wrong

I aimed for his hand i must’ve shot his skull

[hidden moss]

plus for sharpshooter 8 u have to disarm 3 people without reloading

[plush pewter]

I have a question for everyone

Whats sharpshooting and things like that

[hidden moss]

shoot are there arms or hands

[hidden moss]

there challenges

[plush pewter]

What u get from it

[hidden moss]

u have to complete them if u wanna get 100%

[plush pewter]

Are they hard?

[hidden moss]

if u complete all of them u will get the legend of the east outfit

[hidden moss]

they get progressively more hard

[plush pewter]

Because i am rn working on 100%

In working on extoics rn but i dont understand a fuck of it

@hidden moss do u understand them?

[hidden moss]

i never tried exotics

[plush pewter]

Well for 100% u need to collect them

[hidden moss]

ik

[stuck apex]

I need some help when launching rdr i get an error FFFFFFF i dont know how to fix it

[plush pewter]

Just fix it

[vale heart]

Anyone robbed Mr. Pearson.

[violet jewel]

i dont think u can

[plush pewter]

I always rob pearson

[vale heart]

You can.

[violet jewel]

oh wow

[plush pewter]

L pearon

[vale heart]

You can't kill Pearson because he's invincible.

[plush pewter]

Sadly not

[vale heart]

Yeah.

[normal relic]

Nope never

[vale heart]

But you can

[plush pewter]

He did nothing ror the story

Lazy old fat man

[vale heart]

Only cooking and even cooked the food without washing hands.

[normal relic]

I want to rob him

[vale heart]

I never ate the camp stew

[normal relic]

He cooked for the gang

I did

[plush pewter]

Big jov

And then he cried because he missed it

Stupid fat man

[vale heart]

yeah.

[normal relic]

I don't mind him

[plush pewter]

dont act like that

He was the second rat

100%

[normal relic]

I might just try robbing him to see what he does

[vale heart]

I heard Pearson talked with Odriscolls.

[plush pewter]

Yes

[normal relic]

Really

[plush pewter]

colm got a nice neck

[vale heart]

Wdym

[plush pewter]

He got hanged

[normal relic]

Ohh

[vale heart]

Yeah cause of Dutch's plan.

[plush pewter]

Fuck dutch

he is cool

[normal relic]

I didn't like dutch

[plush pewter]

but he cant survive a fall

[vale heart]

Same.

[normal relic]

He was okay

[plush pewter]

I laughed so hard 12 years ago when i completed rdr1 in the first day

[normal relic]

But i couldn't trust him

[plush pewter]

Micah #1

[normal relic]

Dutch died in rdr1

Sadie acted like she was the boss of John in epilogue

[plush pewter]

sadie is a boss

Sadie #3 charles #2 JOHN #1

[vale heart]

Sadie sucks

[magic kite]

and tough like black belle

[normal relic]

Arthur Morgan is #1

[plush pewter]

nahhhh

Arhur trash

[normal relic]

Black Belle

Arthur is badasss

[plush pewter]

black belle cool

john is badass

[magic kite]

if they both together will be a rival

[normal relic]

Yep

[plush pewter]

John>arthur 100-0

[normal relic]

John and Arthur were like brothers

[magic kite]

they are brother just not in same bloodline

since they join the gang same time and day

[normal relic]

Yes

They had a special bond

[plush pewter]

John killed cleet joe micah dutch javier bill Arthur killed himself

[normal relic]

Arthur slowly died of tb

I cried on my first playthrough I'll cry more if i play it again

I completed story with high honor

I don't want to complete it with low honor

[vale heart]

Sheriff Malloy got angry

When I was carrying a rifle

In front of him

[keen birch]

Read, reply or ignore if Arthur sucks.

[vale heart]

Is chupacabra a myth?

@normal relic what do you think?

Chupacabra is a myth or it exist in reality?

[normal relic]

I think it's myth

[vale heart]

So if it's a myth then no need to worry about.

[vale heart]

Average angry npc dialogue "Ready to lose 'em teeth."

[fierce valve]

In Undead Nightmare it’s not

[vale heart]

I know.

[fierce valve]

Undead Nightmare is definitely very fun

I tamed the Four Horses of the Apocalypse and a Unicorn

[vale heart]

And it is not connected to the main story.

[fierce valve]

It happened before The Last Enemy That Shall Be Destroyed

It’s not canon

But it’s somewhat connected

[vale heart]

I don't think so.

Anyway

I can assume it tho.

[torn remnant]

oh my god

i found something really really disturbing in the gunsmith at rhodes

in the basement

basically

he had a guy in there with girl's clothing chained to a bed

and he was saying he punished him for being a bad boy or something

pretty weirdchamp of the gunsmith

so i shot him and freed the guy

[true drift]

Which is the best horse?

Besides those shiny arabians

Because when i be John i do not wanna tame a white or spend near 2k on a grey arabian as John

[midnight dawn]

american destillation mission is so bugged

[midnight dawn]

i use a thoroughbred now

it's grey

this method has been around for a while

there is even a youtube video for it

there is another method to get a free MFT but you can lose a bit of honor

[tardy flicker]

Hmm, I saw a similar video. But I don't think there was one quite like this

And I'm not sure if any work specifically for blackwater

Which has the fastest horse in the game

[midnight dawn]

they should work in blackwater too , if you can get wanted for vandalism

[sly ruin]

Soooo just getting back into rdr2 after like a 3year absence so…. Any things I shouldn’t miss cause last time I blitzed the main story and some minor side content😅

[fierce valve]

Silver Dapple Pinto MFT

A little bit cheaper

[midnight dawn]

gold rush is killing me

i hate timed missions

[true drift]

Isn’t that the horse that Albert Mason was picturing?

[tardy flicker]

Well the issue is blackwater stable pens

They don't have openable gates

And the horses can't move around in them

[fierce valve]

Yes

[tardy flicker]

So you can't jump with the horse

[fierce valve]

You can buy it as John

For a little less than the Rose Grey Bay Arabian

Or you can tame the Red Chestnut Arabian

A little bit worse stats

But free

[tardy flicker]

I mean my strat works and is free :)

[fierce valve]

No.

[tardy flicker]

Actual pain though

I fully bonded with the horse the game gave me

And as soon as I did I got a white Albanian

As soon as I was bonded with it a chapter later horse goes bye bye

Now I need to do it all again for a 3rd time

[hidden moss]

How do you counterpunch NPCs

Do you hold square and press B when they throw a punch

[true drift]

My arthur currently has more money than John does after the epilogue

And then before the final mission as Arthur i’m going to the pigfarm to store the money and get stonks as john

[midnight dawn]

press X , square on ps , then punch

[willow thunder]

hmmmm, thinking about it

before, i used to just blitz the story mode of RDR2

But now...i ain't even doing the story missions much

just vibing in RDR2

grabbing some animals

etc.

[midnight dawn]

man ... i need to do a lot of fishing to redeem the sins i commited finishing bandit challenges

[torn remnant]

bro

breath of the wild used to be my favorite game of all time before rdr2

but now after like 40 hours of rdr2

the game looks kind of ugly

when i watch gameplay

ive been spoiled by rdr2

and i know for a fact that zelda was so beautiful when i played it

[midnight dawn]

it's slow , but far from ugly

and you don't make sense lmao , pick a favorite game . Breath of the wild or rdr2 ?

[torn remnant]

rdr2 beats zelda

purely cause of the story

in zelda the story is pretty like simple cause the game doesn't care about really telling a deep story, the story is just a way to give you some purpose

in rdr2 the story is one of the best stories ive ever seen

[hidden moss]

was zelda ever mostly about the story cause i only hear about gameplay

does anyone know if the legendary fish count towards survivalist 10 cause they are different types of fish

[midnight dawn]

no they don't

they're not different types of fish

there is a normal bluegill and a legendary bluegill they're the same

[hidden moss]

oh i thought they were

but it's annoying how they say catch 15 different types of fish but don't give you a tick for every fish you catch

[midnight dawn]

they're simple

you can catch them all in an hour unlike plants and flowers

just use the appropriate lure

[hidden moss]

yeah fishing is pretty simple but i would of been nice to add that

[sterile flint]

there is a lot of lore behind zelda

[hidden moss]

for some reason when i looked in my satchel in RDR2 i have like 3 meteorites in my satchel, i decided to sell them. but i swore in my own save (since the save i was playing on was my brothers from like 2019 or whatever, i have a seperate one as john) i only could find 2.

any of ya know where i could find the third one as john?

[midnight dawn]

Man ... All i need now is 2 herbalist challenges to get legend of the east for arthur ! Stupid Pinkertons

[untold ocean]

I have the 100% completion mode file

If anyone wants it

[neon snow]

The 15 fish to catch are:

1. Bluegill
2. Steelhead Trout
3. Bullhead Catfish
4. Sockeye Salmon
5. Largemouth Bass
6. Chain Pickerel
7. Smallmouth Bass
8. Redfin Pickerel
9. Muskie
10. Perch
11. Lake Sturgeon
12. Longnose Gar
13. Rock Bass
14. Northern Pike
15. Channel Catfish

[midnight dawn]

Sockeye salmon is the prettiest looking fish in game

[turbid wind]

okay I know I should know tihs and this is off topic but I've played threw the game and im doing it again now, and I still dont know how to manually shoot from the hip can someone tell me how? 😂

[versed smelt]

just don't aim, just press the fire button

[turbid wind]

tysm

[versed smelt]

np 😄

[midnight dawn]

And you could slowly pull down the trigger for some sharpshooting

It goes automatically to dead eye

[versed smelt]

oh yea

[turbid wind]

ty its kinda sad I didnt know tht lol

[versed smelt]

i forgot about that

it's not sad theres a lot of stuff we all don't know

[midnight dawn]

Yeah i just figured out lately how to ground and pound in a fist fight haha

[versed smelt]

i don't even know how to block punch hits

[midnight dawn]

Press square or B

I mean X

On xbox

[versed smelt]

well now i feel dumb

thank you LMAO

[midnight dawn]

You grapple with triangle or Y

And pound to the ground with L3

[versed smelt]

wow

lmaoo

appreciate it

[midnight dawn]

[fierce valve]

Do you just run and pull out a gun every time you’re in a fist fight?

[versed smelt]

no

lmaoo

[midnight dawn]

I mean tbh the execution animations are sick

[vale heart]

For me, the most brutal scene where Arthur nearly died was when odriscolls shot him in the cutscene.

[vernal rampart]

murfree cave for me

[vale heart]

Which mission?

[vernal rampart]

opening of chapter six i think?

the one where you go into beavers hallow with charles

[vale heart]

But Arthur didn't nearly die there.

I am talking about the brutal scenes where Arthur nearly died.

[vernal rampart]

ohhh

i thought you meant the most brutal scene for you was when arthur nearly died to the o’driscolls

my bad

i agree

[vale heart]

And that guy in guarma who punched Arthur a lot was second brutal scene for me where Arthur nearly died.

At least, he was about to die but he survived.

[true drift]

What is your guys favourite hat?

Besides the superior Arthur’s hat

[untold ocean]

Exotic hat

Extremely sexy

[fierce valve]

John’s Classic Hat

[true drift]

Fair enough

[untold ocean]

Dog shit

We want style

Not that uncool hat

[true drift]

Currently have to substitute the iguana big valley hat for it

Since i don’t have the stranger mission

[fierce valve]

The hat is nice tho

[untold ocean]

No

Exotic hat makes you look like an absolute boss with an elegantly stylish hat

[fierce valve]

John’s Classic Hat makes you feel like a real man

[midnight dawn]

Bison hat better

My arthur looks like a caveman

[fierce valve]

I literally do not wear any other hat bc the hats that are already equipped are perfect

[true drift]

Arthur is a beast for cassually carry deers

well john is too

[midnight dawn]

Arthur can carry deer through swamps and lakes

[clear shuttle]

Arthur can swim

[midnight dawn]

John can't

[clear shuttle]

guess what John CANT do

[midnight dawn]

Herd sheep

[true drift]

he can’t remember arthur in rdr1

[clear shuttle]

real talk whats you guys favorite ending?

[true drift]

Is there really competition?

[clear shuttle]

personally, although the help John ending is canon, I really like the return for the money ending

its such a badass ending and I just chose that ending on my second playthrough

high honor of course

when Arthur starts walking away from John and the soundtrack kicks in, it gets me hype every time

[vernal rampart]

for real!!!

[azure spade]

Hey can anyone carry me in any well paying missions on rd2 I’m new lvl 17 ain’t rlly know what I’m doin

[true drift]

this the single player chat

Should be bellow the single player chat

Rdo catagory

#rdo-chat

[azure spade]

Oh mb

Ty

[steady plume]

does each chapter have a specific gang that you have beef with?

[keen pagoda]

O I love that it's so funny it also means u can legally rob the gunsmith

[keen pagoda]

Kinda late but thanks anyway I just spent another grand on a horse

Guys how difficult is 100%-ing this game

In like 70 ish %

With story 100%

But low on challenges and compendium

[tawny nimbus]

yea kinda , first two chaptes o'driscolls , third chapter are the braithwaites and grays , chapter 4 bronte gang , chapter 5 the guys in guarma and chapter 6 i guess murfree brood

[true drift]

Does stranger missions become visible on your map like in chapter 6?

[keen pagoda]

I think maybe before

[keen pagoda]

Pretty much

But the epilogue u literally just build a house

Idk even know why

But then u can do whatever u want

So it's kinda cool

And u get like 20 grand from the last mission

So 😀

[tawny nimbus]

epilogue

damn i cant spoiler tag

you get what i mean who you fight

[sharp cliff]

Today I lost the law inside the store I robbed

I just killed the store owner, robbed the register, then got wanted and the cops were rushing in

I took cover behind the counter where the owner stands lmao and the law didn't see me

It was cool to see them investigate the shop though, but they didn't check behind the shelf

[sleek granite]

What horse should I grt

[civic vault]

Depends on what you prioritize. Do you want a pretty horse? A brave horse? A tall horse? A fast horse?

[civic vault]

I saw a youtuber show arthur hide behind bushes and the law just passed him commenting that they can't find him. Interesting to see them dumbfounded lol

I just notice that playing on PC will give me more spawn opportunities for hunting. On PS4 the animals spawn more seldomly

Or maybe im just being impatient lol

[sharp cliff]

Yeah you can hide in bushes, indicated by the player mark on the minimap turning black

It's the same in GTA 5 too

[sharp cliff]

I play on PS4, and I've had no trouble hunting for what I needed lol

Always found everything at the right spot

[neon snow]

It was really fun to do. I’d say the only one that was annoying was winning 3 games of dominoes in a row, but everything else was ok.

[true drift]

Why do i slowly turn when i’m reloading?

Like my sensitivity got decreased 50%

[civic vault]

Maybe i was just impatient lol

[midnight dawn]

You could just quit when losing , you don't lose your winning streak

[neon snow]

Yeah literally when you’re about to lose, but the first few times I didn’t realise you could do that lol so it took longer than it should hehe

[magic kite]

i gonna try to find legendary animals without starting any main mission

[magic kite]

it seems i cannot do any legendary hunt i guess

until i do hosea mission i guess

[turbid oriole]

Not very
My tips, do all the missions first and save the fetch and quest ones last
After do the challenges next, pick off master hunter and sharpshooter
Then bandit, the horseman is a bit of a pain in the ass to finish off
Weapon expert, then herbal and then finally gambler

After do the fetch and quest missions

Disclaimer: Those fetch and quest missions and gambler will make you want to jump off a cliff
And commit gravity

[magic kite]

well i try save bear hunter end up he dead with i shoot the bear dead and gain honor

[turbid oriole]

Weird

Very weird

[magic kite]

maybe because he still alive when he been attack by bear

and i shooting the bear

btw this time i counter a lot of bears

really

[midnight dawn]

How many unique misseable weapons are there

And how many animals are in guarma ?

[vale heart]

I don't think guarma animals are required for zoologist achievement.

[midnight dawn]

I want to get them nonetheless i wanna finish 560/560

[vale heart]

Survivalist challenges are easy af.

[magic kite]

but for fishing it hell

man another fixing horse shoes guy got kicked again rip

[vale heart]

Legendary fishes are hell

[magic kite]

Yup

[vale heart]

Those fishes are time taking.

[magic kite]

And make people get bored

[vale heart]

Bandit Challenges were fun.

[magic kite]

With getting negative honor for sure

[keen birch]

Read, reply or ignore if Arthur sucks.

[vale heart]

No, I mean it's fun to do as John

Cause John's honor doesn't matter.

[magic kite]

Hmmm ok

[midnight dawn]

Can the carolina parakeets be found in chapter 3 ?? I can't get them anywhere

[vale heart]

I still don't understand that Arthur has unique dialogues in New Austin but he isn't allowed there.

[glad brook]

Cut content.

[midnight dawn]

Well i guess rockstar knows it's fandom , they'll try getting into new austin even when they're not supposed to

[fierce valve]

They did

We all did

[midnight dawn]

I didn't , i'm too lazy

And all i need is literally 5 flowers to get the legend of east outfit as arthur

This carolina parakeets challenge is killing me

[willow thunder]

Should i upgrade lodging?

I maxed out medicine

[turbid oriole]

R* making garbage decisions

Plus using the lore excuse is complete bullshit

Since John in rdr1 never visited New Austin

[midnight dawn]

I mean it does make sense

Since they robbed cornwall multiple times and Pinkertons are on his payroll

[fierce valve]

Yes

Lodging gives you fast travel

[willow thunder]

honestly RDR2 is the first game where i don't blitz through the story

[hidden moss]

I think my game is broken

for noblest of men and a woman

the mission won't move on

I can't find Levin at valentine or St Denis

even tho I did the things with the legnds

[fierce valve]

What chapter are you on?

[hidden moss]

2

[fierce valve]

You have to wait a bit

[hidden moss]

darn

[fierce valve]

Until the mission pops up again

In later chapters

[hidden moss]

which chapter will I be able to do again

[slate laurel]

Are Spoilers OK here?

[fierce valve]

Around 3 or 4

[hidden moss]

do not

[slate laurel]

Ok

[fierce valve]

Yes, but I don’t recommend it rn

[hidden moss]

wait

yeah use /spoiler

[willow thunder]

how do you fast travel?

[fierce valve]

Purchase Arthur’s lodging upgrade

[willow thunder]

I got the fast travel thing

now what do i do in order to fast travel?

[keen birch]

Arthur sucks. Micah better. Deal with that fact.

[fierce valve]

Go to Arthur’s place in camp and go behind the wagon to find a map

The map will let you fast travel

You can also fast travel from a personal camp

You can set that up in the wilderness

[midnight dawn]

bruh i can't find one parakeet goddamnit

this is gonna ruin my plat

[red helm]

Someone mentioned that the Parakeets don't spawn anymore in the Epilogue. I can't confirm that, since I've only seen 1 flock of them, ever, as Arthur.

However, the mission to get 25 Parakeets has Zero to do with any trophies, So, don't worry about it.

[torn remnant]

so

while taking a little walk in the swamp

i run into a dude covered in blood who falls off his horse

and he tells me he needs a doctor

and im like sure ill take you to a doctor

but my horse isnt near

so i try to use his horse to take him to saint denis

the horse kicks me and kills him

[red helm]

Ouf...

[midnight dawn]

I just want to study them i'm not gonna kill all of them ... I think

I have OCD lmao

[torn remnant]

i wonder how many hours ive spent in rdr2 in like 1 week of having the game

[torn remnant]

im in chapter 3 rn

[red helm]

Definitely one of those, big bowl of fail moments. Rockstar and their failzor things.

[torn remnant]

i think ive put in like 50 hours

[torn remnant]

it adds to the charm for me tbh

[red helm]

When I did see them, It was a flock of 8, and they were all sitting next to the... Bayals Edge... The Strangers Cabin place, whatever it's called.

[midnight dawn]

They spawn throughout the bayou in flocks you can't find them flying , and they're so rare once you encounter them you have to wait like 2 in-game months to see them again

Unless you get lucky

And the flock has exactly 25 of them

[torn remnant]

rdr2 is such a good game

[torn remnant]

i was playing ac valhalla before rdr2

[red helm]

The last time that encounter happened for me, I was doing a low honor play through, so I just stood there and waited to see how long it would take for the dude to die. Actually gave up waiting after a few minutes, was a bit sad.

[torn remnant]

and rdr2 has made me realize how lame that game's open world is

like

i dont think ill ever be able to enjoy an ubisoft game now

having experienced rdr2's quality

[red helm]

2 in game months? Yeap, I believe this. Luckily I saw them from a distance and got the Study in, then Deadeyed with my Midnight and shot all 8 before they started to fly away.

[torn remnant]

btw

i love the beard and hair growing mechanic of this game so much

it's one of those things that shows you how spending time in the game actually has an impact on your character

[vast rose]

dont worry arthur i have a plan

[red helm]

Eh, the Hair growing and weight gaining mechanic can be a little unintuiative, especially for people that rarely fast travel/sleep. Like I was doing in my first play through.

[midnight dawn]

LEZGOOO

I closed the game and re-opened it and found them

[torn remnant]

you still experience the hair growing

cause of when some chapters start

[midnight dawn]

I dynamited tho fuckers

[torn remnant]

the game skips forward a few days

[midnight dawn]

Killed 20lmao

[torn remnant]

and usually when that happens you find yourself with really long hair and beard

[red helm]

Depends if you don't do missions very often, to get cut scenes.

[torn remnant]

i really like how even though the open world is so great

the missions have even better moments than the open world has

[red helm]

But yes, the open world is quite nice.

[torn remnant]

it makes it feel like special everytime you play a mission

unlike a lot of other open world games

where the story missions are just the open world activities

[red helm]

20 Parakeet's?

[midnight dawn]

I progressed to chapter 3 too yesterday i think

[midnight dawn]

Yep lmao

[red helm]

Holy crap, nice!

[midnight dawn]

I need 5 more for the challenge but idc for now

[red helm]

2 game months, yeah, don't hold your breath, just wait for chapter 6 for the next spawn...

[midnight dawn]

are all the maccaw parrots in guarma ?

[red helm]

More than likely. I think some of the snakes you can get elsewhere...

[midnight dawn]

hmm i need 30 more animals to finish all the list , seems many of them are in new austin and guarma only

[red helm]

Wouldn't surprise me, there is a bunch in New Austin.

[midnight dawn]

yeah 30 including those 4 locked legendary animals

i hate finding birds , mammals and other stuff are easy to find

[red helm]

Darn birds, indeed.

[true drift]

How do you do the slap and shoot consistantly?

It’s either me tackling and shooting or quickfiring 50% of the time

So it’s a standing still r2?

[vagrant anvil]

fun fact, 99.999999999% of the rdr population has a crush on Mary Beth.

[willow thunder]

I saw videos of people using dead eye on animals and there were red spots on them, how do i get that ability?

[midnight dawn]

That's a dead eye marking

What chapter you on ?

[willow thunder]

chapter 2

with my dead eye, i can mark multi people to shoot

[midnight dawn]

It marks it automatically does it not ?

[willow thunder]

yeah

[midnight dawn]

Yes

[willow thunder]

it marks auto

[midnight dawn]

There is a mission in chap2

Where you get a ability to manual mark

[willow thunder]

what mission is it called?

[midnight dawn]

The train robbery with john

[willow thunder]

oh.

[midnight dawn]

The famous scene in rdr2 lmao

[willow thunder]

thank you so much for helping

time to do the famous scene

[spring nexus]

hey guys, i got all 12 cardsets and have Sold 6 Sets but the other 6 wherent there to sell, can someone help me

[willow thunder]

also wanna know what's funny?

[midnight dawn]

You sould them ?

You meant mailed them ?

[willow thunder]

The fact that i almost don't do story missions at all

[midnight dawn]

Yeah me too lmao

I'm only in chapter 3 still

[spring nexus]

yea mailed

[midnight dawn]

I do challenges

[willow thunder]

because the game is actually amazing by itself lol

[midnight dawn]

You sure those other sets are complete? And not dupes ?

[midnight dawn]

Don't buy weapons

Explore the world you find them for free

And there are some rare ones

[willow thunder]

really?

[spring nexus]

i have 144

[midnight dawn]

Yeah , do homestead robberies , you get tips from people you help around the world

[midnight dawn]

Specifically a prison escapist , free him from his handcuffs and he'll tip you on robberies

[willow thunder]

damn

[midnight dawn]

Hmm that's weird

Maybe close your game or camp for a day

[midnight dawn]

Have you done the noble of men ? The legendary sharpshooters quest?

[willow thunder]

uhh...how can i check quests again?

[midnight dawn]

Press left on the D-pad

[willow thunder]

i'm PC.

[midnight dawn]

Not sure , but did you kill those 3 sharpshooters ? That quest with the drunk guy

[willow thunder]

i don't remember.

prob not

[midnight dawn]

Okay then , well everyone of them drops a rare gun that can be missed

They got cool engravings

Keep your eyes on them

[willow thunder]

wait a second

i have the quest "the noblest of men"

and a woman

[midnight dawn]

Yeah that one

You done it ?

[willow thunder]

nope

[midnight dawn]

Good , then do it and well you kill each sharpshooter except the woman they drop guns

[willow thunder]

so kill every sharpshooter except the woman

[midnight dawn]

Yeah

Cool missions , you gunsling

[willow thunder]

it's high noon...

i'm gonna go to billy

[midnight dawn]

Oh billy drops the best gun out of all of them

A Mauser

[willow thunder]

alright

so the deal is

just fucking shoot them to death?

[midnight dawn]

No haha they're gunslingers

You know that cowboy stuff , quick draw

[willow thunder]

oh yeah

sooo is there gonna be a game?

[midnight dawn]

Yes

[willow thunder]

like it will say when to shoot?

[midnight dawn]

The deal is draw faster than them

[willow thunder]

(or deadeye them)

so wait

[midnight dawn]

You press the shooting button slowly until it fills a little bit

And press it harder to shoot

[willow thunder]

...i don't understand

[midnight dawn]

Hmmm it's hard to explain, don't shoot right away but rather fill up the dead eye for like 2 seconds then shoot

Dw if you die you retry

[willow thunder]

so just wait for 2 seconds

then bam

[midnight dawn]

Yep

Don't wait as in stand still and do nothing

Press the mouse or whatever you aim with slowly

[willow thunder]

so just click slowly?

or just aim at him?

[midnight dawn]

There is no aiming in gunslinging

[willow thunder]

oh

[midnight dawn]

Hold it sloooowly for 2 seconds then press it

[willow thunder]

so just hold the right click slowly?

[midnight dawn]

Yeah

[willow thunder]

then press left click?

[midnight dawn]

Yes

[willow thunder]

so just hold the right click, and then 2 seconds later press left click

[midnight dawn]

Correct , you can practice it before going there i think

You can gunsling in free roam

[willow thunder]

wait really?

how?

[midnight dawn]

Do as i said earlier slowly them shoot

[willow thunder]

or is it like pressing left click to aim weapon?

hold on

i'm very confused

how can you find people who will gunsling you in free roam?

[hidden moss]

has anyone seen a npc use a outhouse before i've just seen it for the first time

i didn't even think it was programmed into the game

[snow iron]

How do I change between manual and automatic dead eye on pc?

[fierce valve]

Like the marks?

The marks you have to unlock as you go through the story to manually mark your targets

The automatic will have to stay until you reach like Chapter 3

[midnight dawn]

Chapter 2*

There is a train robbery mission

You unlock manual there

[willow thunder]

I got midnight's pistol

you said billy got the best weapon out of the gunslingers

[willow thunder]

this one right here, is midnight's pistol the best?

[torn remnant]

why do some npcs seem to think that

a warning shot means they should run away

when you have a gun pointed at them

instead of complying

[midnight dawn]

It's not the best sidearm in game , it's the best compared to what the others give

[willow thunder]

oh.

[torn remnant]

btw

whats the best revolver in the game

[willow thunder]

so the others give garbage?

[midnight dawn]

The best revolver in game is schofield / lemat

[midnight dawn]

They give default Revolver but with engravings that are unique

You can't find them anywhere else

[willow thunder]

so the midnight pistol is different?

[midnight dawn]

But as i said play the game and discover those encounters that i mentioned and you'll get a free Schofield and a free volcanic

[willow thunder]

AYO?

[midnight dawn]

Which are the actual best revolver and pistol in game

Well in chapter 2 you can get a free Schofield/ volcanic / mauser / pump action / semi auto shotgun/ double barreled / lancaster repeater .

You don't need to spend any cash

Oh and plus like 15 unique blades / hatchets

And around 7 unique hats

[willow thunder]

...what the fuck.

[midnight dawn]

So free roaming and discovering stuff is good

[willow thunder]

wait how do you get them for free?

by doing these gunslinger encounters?

[midnight dawn]

You get tips from strangers about robberies and when you rob you find hidden weapons

[willow thunder]

which one is better, schofield or volcanic?

[midnight dawn]

They're different class

One is a revolver and the other is a pistol

Can't compare them together

[willow thunder]

oh.

[midnight dawn]

You can dual wield them tho

[willow thunder]

...WHAT

okay then

[midnight dawn]

Buy an off hand holster from gunsmith

[willow thunder]

i alr have off hand holster

[midnight dawn]

Nice then you can dual wield

[vernal rampart]

i usually use schofields they look really good

[midnight dawn]

volcanic sounds like a canon too very powerful gun

and has a range of a repeater

[willow thunder]

I got the manual mark

but now there's just one problem.

I still don't have the red spots on a target

should i buy the volcanic?

and schofield?

hello?

[sullen crow]

No Schofield

[willow thunder]

why?

[civic vault]

Is the Evans repeater really good? I usually use Lancaster but I've seen some comments that evans repeater sucks.

[midnight dawn]

Lancaster is the best repeater in game

Evans is pretty trashy

[civic vault]

Ah I see

I guess some folks who like Evans repeater like it for the 24 bullets before reload

I'm just confused that some comments say it's good

[worldly turret]

just like horses, I don't think it matters in story because of dead eye slowing time, a full reload anytime you activate dead eye and marking so just use what you like

[fierce valve]

Get the Schofeld

It’s probably the best revolver

[silver swallow]

my horse broken

[willow thunder]

got both of em

now i can dual wield

[civic vault]

That makes sense. I like how this game is very accommodating to people's unique gameplay

[midnight dawn]

You'd have to get all guns for compendium's sake anyway

So it doesn't hurt

[civic vault]

I guess so

[midnight dawn]

Chapter 3 has been so fast for me , and it's one of the longest chapters. I guess staying in chapter 2 for a 100 hours is enough to get everything almost done

[civic vault]

Yeah

I tried to stay longer in chapter 2 as well

But I wanted the free rolling block, so had no choice but to move on eventually

[midnight dawn]

I finished chapter 2 with 83/90 challenges and 480/560 in my compendium

[civic vault]

whoa

[midnight dawn]

Yeah me too

[civic vault]

I've only just finished 20+ of the challenges

then again, I prioritized the treasures and the satchels in chapter 2

I'm gonna try to stay in chapter 3 the longest i guess

[midnight dawn]

Yeah i did get those too it took a grind

I'm 10/17 missions in chapter 3 , I don't have much to do in it

And i try to get gold in all my missions

For the gold rush achievement

[civic vault]

im also looking forward to get the turkorman from the stealing horses missions.

[midnight dawn]

Yep i missed that one unfortunately

[civic vault]

i have 68 carrots in my satchel lol

[midnight dawn]

It purchasable from the stables in chap 4 i think

[civic vault]

Yeah, i got it in chapter 4 in my previous playthrough but I wanted to get the turk early

and the braithwaite one looks so beautiful

dark bay turk

[midnight dawn]

Too bad i missed it , i just did that mission yesterday too damnit Imao

Does a Turkoman have a common coat ?

[civic vault]

As far as i know it only has the golden coat and the dark bay coat

I liked the golden coat enough but i think the dark bay is superior

the gold coat just reminds me of my American standardbred that I first bought in chapter 2

Sadly it died when it ran into a moving train. RIP Dante

[midnight dawn]

Damn the train must've been driven by vergil

[civic vault]

rofl

Right now i have a black American Standardbred that I tamed from the wild

It's been a good gurl so far

[midnight dawn]

Eh i'll stick to my white arabian until endgame

She's dying with me

I named her after Arthur's first horse Boadecia

[civic vault]

I've been wondering about Boadecia. She sounds like a war horse

like an Ardennes or a Shire

[normal relic]

I had a white shire

[civic vault]

Because maybe Hosea gave the black shire to him because it looked similar to Boadecia

[civic vault]

How is it so far?

[normal relic]

It was good i always had them in story

[midnight dawn]

I use a thoroughbred sometime

Gray striped

[civic vault]

i wanted to like shires because they're beautiful but they're too slow for my taste 😭 I'll just admire them from afar I guess

[civic vault]

Oh! I have that one in the stables as my back up

[normal relic]

Awww i love the shires you should just get one!

[civic vault]

Maybe as a back up horse. I have an Ardennes as my chonk back up. Imma sell it and maybe buy a shire instead

[midnight dawn]

I'm not gonna take Buell as arthur

I'll leave it to john

[fierce valve]

I always finish Hamish’s story as John

[normal relic]

Yay shires are so beautiful

[civic vault]

Good bye Diana the Ardennes, may you have a good owner lol

[normal relic]

Lol

[hearty moth]

Hey folks, i have a question to upgrading items like bags.
To upgrade i have to donate pelts to the camp, but is it important WHEN to donate? So when donating now like 3 deer pelts and want to upgrade later, does this counts for three bag upgrades because everyone needs one or isnt it allowed to wait to long after donating?

[versed smelt]

no it doesn’t, you need to donate them whenever you have all the materials for the satchels. And if you move onto the next one and you need deer pelt again you’ll need to get it again unfortunately

You just gotta do em one at a time basically

[midnight dawn]

I heard there is glitch you can get a MFT in another way other than albert mason

[fierce valve]

Don’t talk about it

[midnight dawn]

Oh

[hearty moth]

but when i need 3 different pelts for one upgrade, can i donate one or two i already have and donate the third one later or do i have to donate all three together?

[midnight dawn]

Why ?

[fierce valve]

Rule 15

[versed smelt]

all together

[midnight dawn]

Oh my bad

[hearty moth]

i see, thank you

[versed smelt]

no problem

[civic vault]

Actually, I tried donating as much as I can in my current playthrough even though the satchel upgrades were still locked. When they did unlock, it records everything I donated. So I think it's possible to give as much amount as needed to other satchels as well

That's how i got the satchels quickly

[versed smelt]

Damn that’s news to me, my bad then

I done them all one at a time

@hearty moth

[civic vault]

I thought it was one at a time as well before. I only discovered it in my current playthrough

[midnight dawn]

Well before donating to pearson it shows that it's either going for camp funds or for "nothing" , nothing means crafting

[civic vault]

I was hoping to get the rare Pearson jacket. I missed it 😦

[midnight dawn]

Anything that's going for camp funds isn't required for crafting

[midnight dawn]

How do you get it ?

[civic vault]

It's a rare Pearson task. Some people have discovered it has to be early in chapter 2 and Arthur's cores have to be low and it has to be during the day. I'm not sure about the other conditions. But it's extremely rare for him to offer to make the jacket for Arthur that most players don't even get that task. For the jacket itself I think you have to hunt for perfect rabbit pelts but I forgot how many

[hearty moth]

It's called "Rabbit Denim Scout Jacket"

[civic vault]

I had Pearson offer me the jacket just once, in my first playthrough. I didn't know it was that rare and I passed it on.

[hearty moth]

And you dont need to empty all cores, just to lower your health

But it has to happen before rescuing Sean

"At 10-10:30 AM jump from the cliff at camp . After respawning go back to camp asap. Check Pearson until he goes behind his stew preparing desk with a beer . When he does that greet him . If he says “Are you ok me Morgan , you look a little peaky” then he will give u the request ."

[civic vault]

Ah well, I have to put that on the next playthrough lol

[willow thunder]

also the reason i progressed through the story a bit is 1: free sniper rifle lets gooooo | 2: I needed to get manual mark

what story mission allows you to see vital points in Dead Eye?

so you are telling me i have to go to chapter 5 in order to see vital points?

smh.

[fierce valve]

Chapter 5 mission Fleeting Joy

[willow thunder]

yeah i think i'm just gonna stay in chapter 2