#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 601 of 1

cobalt chasm
#

Do side missions

#

put off story missions as long as you can, you experience way more of the game that way

midnight dawn
#

do legendary animals re spaw ?

magic kite
hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

what's with the rainbow pools next to the geysers?

#

Also why is it impossible to find wolves when you're hunting them, but when you're just riding along doing whatever like 4 will attack you

midnight dawn
#

Sinclair's quest is so confusing

#

Is he a time traveller ?

cobalt chasm
#

Probably

ember marsh
#

I already have a white arabian. Are there any other horses worth getting? I'm in chap 2 and don't have that much money

cobalt chasm
#

there are 2 other wild arabians you can get, a red one northwest of strawberry and a black one with white spot/stripes northwest of the indian reservation

#

The white one I think is the fastest but they all make NPCs do double takes so...

ember marsh
#

Are the fox trotter or the turkoman worth it?

cobalt chasm
#

I've never spent money on a horse when a quest didn't make me personally

#

I get attached to the ones I tame

sleek granite
#

yea

#

i got a shire from burning the tabacco fields

#

kept it

midnight dawn
#

But idk where exactly haven't gotten one myself

ember marsh
#

I'm around level 6 honor. I feel like any time I'm nearing level 7 I make some mistake (accidently kill an innocent person and accidently let a dear bleed out mainly). How can I avoid this?

midnight dawn
#

me too

#

it's frustrating because i'm trying to get a trophy

#

for some reason this games honor mechanics is the shittiest thing about it

#

sometimes it lowers your honor when you kill a deer or something

red helm
#

Honor is a bit whack, it's also super easy to raise/lower.

#

They didn't do that great of a job with that, or the crime system.

red helm
#

@midnight dawn fyi, for Herbalist 9, there is indeed 1 flower in the Blackwater region, however, that isn't the problem for that challenge, there is 4 flowers in the New Austin state.

ember marsh
ember marsh
red helm
#

However, if you want to Pay, you may want to go for a MFT or Turko.

ember marsh
#

Is there a good way to judge that?

red helm
#

Unfortunately no, there is no way of seeing a horses bravery, other than just using it for awhile...

ember marsh
#

I noticed my horse getting scared of predators and gun shots but she just neighs so it's alright

red helm
#

That's not to bad, and pretty much all horses will have some troubles. But, getting bucked at even the slightest sign of troubles can tend to get annoying.

ember marsh
#

I don't think I been bucked once with her due to how good the stamina is on Arabians

red helm
#

Getting bucked from being scared doesn't have anything to do with it's stamina.

ember marsh
#

Yeah but in rdo I push the horse a little too much sometimes so I do get bucked off, I haven't bought a horse yet so dealing with the crappy starter horse

cobalt chasm
#

I got the LotE Satchel!

red helm
#

Yay!

cobalt chasm
#

Turns out it's a lot easier with a spreadsheet for everything you need rather than going after each satchel at once

red helm
#

Just have a list of every pelt needed, Indeed.

midnight dawn
# hidden moss Nah

but if they don't respawn then why do i need 2 legendary bison pelts for the ghost bison outfit ?

red helm
midnight dawn
#

oh that's great

#

thanks

cobalt chasm
#

why is everyone at camp mad

#

The last story mission I did was rescue Sean

midnight dawn
#

do i lose honor if i kill the kkk members ?

#

i'm near them i don't wanna lose honor but i wanna blow them with dynamite

red helm
#

You gain honor for killing the KKK, actually. @midnight dawn

midnight dawn
#

man that felt really good i hogtied 5 of them and i lighted them up with a fire bottle

red helm
#

Sweet.

hidden moss
#

the kkk was a weird choice for rdr2

#

rdr1 one would've been better for that feature

#

bc of political correctness

cobalt chasm
#

I mean, political correctness aside when is it a bad idea to make the KKK something you can kill?

hidden moss
hidden moss
midnight dawn
hidden moss
#

Ah okey

hidden moss
#

eh

hidden moss
midnight dawn
#

bruh i collected pretty much everything i needed for the legend satchel at once

#

if i die and lose everything i might get cancer

#

why tf rattlesnakes don't die from a one hit small game arrow ?

cobalt chasm
#

I use throwing knives and normal arrows on snakes

vernal rampart
#

the head is much easier to see and easier to hit

#

love ur pfp by the way

#

yakuza 7 my beloved 🙏

cobalt chasm
#

YO I just got a perfect cougar pelt by shooting one that had chased a hispanic guy up a tree

vernal rampart
midnight dawn
#

These satchels are a big grind damn

#

I've only crafted 3 i still need 3 more

#

And i wanna get the other camp upgrades too

remote flower
#

I can't for the life of me trigger the Pearson's request

#

I want that jacket damn it

fluid cypress
midnight dawn
#

Man ... Can't wait to get legend satchel and that ghost Bison outfit

#

Amazing combo

#

I still have default arthur lmao

remote flower
#

Me too, and I need the satchel to collect the herbs for herbalist 7

#

damn miracle tonics

#

6 herbs for tonic

#

5 tonics

midnight dawn
#

I've been collecting for hours and i've only crafted 3 satchels

remote flower
#

= toomanyherbs

midnight dawn
#

The problem is in finding those small damn animals , beaver is so rare

vernal rampart
remote flower
#

I wish some of the optional stuff wasn't so grindy

#

and specific

vernal rampart
#

on my current playthrough i found a 3 star badger while just travelling not looking for it

vernal rampart
remote flower
#

When I travel, I find so many 3 star game, but if I'm actually hunting, oh man, they're gone

midnight dawn
#

I found a badger , squirrel , chipmunk at the same spot

#

But beaver and muskrat won't show up

remote flower
vernal rampart
#

what do you need muskrats for?

midnight dawn
#

I find them but their always 2 stars even tho i have legendary buck trinket

midnight dawn
vernal rampart
#

ah

#

does that include the rats you get from the saloon encounter?

#

cause thats usually how i get rats on my playthrough

midnight dawn
#

Those are normal rats they're easy to get

remote flower
#

muskrats are a different species I think, they're bigger

vernal rampart
#

damn

#

most muskrats i see while roaming are either 1 or 2 stars

midnight dawn
#

The problem is pretty much all the ingredients are very big game animals which you can only stow one at a time like elk , ox ...

#

So i'll have to travel from days lmao

vernal rampart
#

very irritating

remote flower
#

The 3 star I found was near a stream

#

In west elizabeth I think

midnight dawn
#

Yeah that's where i always hunt

#

You can find all sorts of animals there

remote flower
#

And like a lot of stuff in this game, it comes down to luck

midnight dawn
#

But the only good thing from hunting is that you get to find more interesting random encounters

#

I found the KKK three times today lmao

hidden moss
#

And do a massacre at St. Denis

remote flower
#

The one where they're lifting a cross is hillarious

#

you call them and the cross smashes them

midnight dawn
#

Yeah i saw that one lmao

vernal rampart
#

one time i think it was my 2nd playthrough i saw like 3 of the encounters within like an hour

#

it was funny cause i had not gotten any in that playthrough so far

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

hmmmm

remote flower
#

wait, 2?!

hidden moss
#

U cant

#

2?

vernal rampart
#

i think this one is my 6th, only completed around 3 though

hidden moss
#

Nah

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

nice

midnight dawn
#

This is my first lmao

hidden moss
#

Im at chapter 4 now

vernal rampart
midnight dawn
#

I played it 5 times but then i get so busy and forget the story and restart

remote flower
#

I'm on my 2nd, and I wanna see how much stuff I can do without leaving chapter 2

midnight dawn
vernal rampart
#

nice

hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

So I tracked down the serial killer guy

vernal rampart
#

im planning to 100% during this playthrough

cobalt chasm
#

do you really get no reward from that questline?

vernal rampart
vernal rampart
remote flower
hidden moss
kindred ferry
#

Hey do y’all know if there is a report a bug or glitch chat

midnight dawn
cobalt chasm
#

He jumped the sheriff who decided it was my fault and sent me off without so much as a thank you...

vernal rampart
#

i used the valentine train tracks murder for the birds of pray tomahawk challenge

#

helped a ton

cobalt chasm
#

Oh wait, my mistake

hidden moss
#

Gambler 8 is the worst challenge to exist

vernal rampart
midnight dawn
hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

apparently, you get $20 if you shoot him while he's attacking the sheriff, and nothing if the sheriff has to shoot him himself...

hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

that's stupid

midnight dawn
#

Three times

vernal rampart
#

oh damn

#

that is

#

something

midnight dawn
#

But 9 and 10 are walk in the park

remote flower
midnight dawn
#

At least until i finish collecting pelts

hidden moss
midnight dawn
vernal rampart
remote flower
midnight dawn
#

The only dishonorable thing that I did in this playthrough is feed the feminist woman in saint Denis to the gators

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

😨

remote flower
vernal rampart
#

oh my god i just realized im still at bandit 1 💀💀

remote flower
#

frustrating is a good definition

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

thats good

vernal rampart
remote flower
#

The only problem with Bandit is that you can't finish it at chapter 2

midnight dawn
#

This game is as a whole RNG wether you're doing gambler challenges or herbalist

cobalt chasm
#

NO

remote flower
cobalt chasm
#

the fast travel train ran over my horse!!!!

hidden moss
vernal rampart
cobalt chasm
#

no

remote flower
cobalt chasm
#

I had a horse reviver thank god

hidden moss
#

Cus he ran over ur horse

vernal rampart
midnight dawn
remote flower
vernal rampart
#

if its early i wont bother with bandit until later

#

thats late enough

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

gotta do this 9 minute dry dash bullshit 😞

hidden moss
#

My boyfriend finished it in 1h30

kindred ferry
#

Hey do y’all know if there is a report a bug or glitch chat

vernal rampart
#

btw how do i do master hunter 3?

remote flower
vernal rampart
#

i dont understand the instructions

hidden moss
midnight dawn
#

The only quest that's irritating me rn is dinosaur bones because i can't finish it now since there are bones in black water

vernal rampart
remote flower
vernal rampart
#

i think im just missing something cause i just dont really understand

hidden moss
vernal rampart
#

oh shit

#

that easy??

#

💀💀

midnight dawn
hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

Why are some outfits locked?

#

Like the Drover?

hidden moss
#

Honor

#

High honor

cobalt chasm
#

I have decent honor, ugh

#

ok, fine I'll go say high to people in saint denis

vernal rampart
remote flower
# midnight dawn What wagon ?

You know those covered wagons? They're very generic, look for the one with 5 arches, if you position the camera just right, the invisible sniper won't get you

hidden moss
#

10-15 minutes and ur done

#

Go in heartlands

#

There is a lot of animals

remote flower
#

@midnight dawn I'm sorry, the ones with 4 arches, the ones with 5 don't work

midnight dawn
remote flower
midnight dawn
#

Okay thanks i'll try

remote flower
#

I haven't yet, but I'll do it once I get to herbalist 9

midnight dawn
#

I'm doing the less fun challenges now so i can enjoy sharpshooter and bandit

remote flower
#

because I'll need to go to new austin too, so I'll gather the herbs and locate the bones at the same time

hidden moss
remote flower
#

I didn't know that

#

spent 2 hours trying and nothing

midnight dawn
#

Yeaah i saw that online it's dumb

#

And the annoying thing is you get a rolling block during the last chap 2 mission 🗿

hidden moss
remote flower
#

I was wondering, if you get the rifle and quit

#

the mission

#

or fail

#

you keep it?

midnight dawn
vernal rampart
#

a fisher of men my beloved

hidden moss
remote flower
midnight dawn
#

There is a way you can get one

#

In chap 2

#

But

#

It has to be before the hosea bear mission

remote flower
#

I like that you can get some really strong weapons just by exploring the map, I got all shotties in chapter 2

midnight dawn
#

Well during the hosea mission I mean

remote flower
midnight dawn
#

Me too

hidden moss
cobalt chasm
#

Arthur: "Good morning mister!"
SD Kid: "You in over your head in the big city?"
Arthur: "Whatever you say!"
SD Kid: runs in terror yelling for help
Arthur: "Y'all have a great day now!"

hidden moss
#

Arthur: Hello mister!
Npc: hello sir
Arthur: I like ur face
Npc: thank you
Arthur: The kind I like to punch
Npc: I was just about to compliment u

candid arch
#

the ol' greet greet antagonize

cobalt chasm
#

I just got shot at by a bunch of kids in saint denis completely unprovoked!

hidden moss
#

Chapter 5 was too short

#

I just did it in an hour and a half

cobalt chasm
#

and now the law is after ME instead of the blasted delinquents

hidden moss
candid arch
hidden moss
#

They coulda gone so much further dude

#

Crazy shit

candid arch
#

never been shot by a Saint Denis kid before

hidden moss
#

Chapter 5 was eh

cobalt chasm
candid arch
#

the kids can snitch?

cobalt chasm
#

I mean that word would apply if I had done something to them to deserve it

candid arch
#

did you kill the teenager?

cobalt chasm
#

Well yeah after he put 4 rounds in my chest

#

tf am I supposed to do

hidden moss
#

Do a massacre.

candid arch
#

tf you thought

hidden moss
#

Kill the half of the city

#

Do a massacre

cobalt chasm
#

bruh I'm trying to get higher honor how would that help exactly

candid arch
#

the honor system is really confusing at times

#

like if you start killing a bunch of men the honor will start decreasing slowly instead of dropping down a level

cobalt chasm
#

what's the highest honor you can get in chap 2?

#

I heard it was capped

candid arch
#

idk

cobalt chasm
#

bruh why are kids the worst

#

every adult is so polite but the kids act like they want to piss off the 6' dude with 4 guns and a knife strapped to him

#

they called the cops on me again!!!

#

I said hello to the kid, told him he was funny, and now I've gotta hide from the police because I disturbed the peace

#

wtf!?

midnight dawn
#

Maybe pearson can make you a nice trinket out of it

cobalt chasm
#

I wish I could just tell the kid off and they'd do the smart thing and stop insulting random people

midnight dawn
cobalt chasm
#

ugh the eugenics guy is back

#

I fed him to gators once how is he still alive

cobalt chasm
#

I can't talk to anyone

violet jewel
#

Magic, I killed the stagecoach fence once and he came on back

cobalt chasm
#

I tried holding up a guy and now I can't interact with anyone, even the postman to pay my bounty

#

I just want to do the bandit challenges

violet jewel
#

Restart ur game

violet fern
#

Someone

#

Help me

#

Please...

#

The camp filled with cops to kill is too much for me

cobalt chasm
#

How the hell am I meant to rob people? They all just, walk away, or go get the law...

hidden moss
#

I just keep playing story mode

#

What happens if I surrender

#

To lawmen

fierce valve
hidden moss
fierce valve
#

It will erase it

#

Since you served time

hidden moss
#

Ohhhh

#

So let's say my bounty is 3000 in st denis

#

If I serve 1 min it goes away?

fierce valve
#

Never tried a bounty that high

#

But you can experiment

hidden moss
#

Yea it's 3000 lol

#

They take money?

fierce valve
hidden moss
#

Like from your bal for being in jail

#

Like if you die it takes away money

fierce valve
#

No I don’t think so

hidden moss
#

What about guns

fierce valve
#

Still there

hidden moss
#

Oooh

#

Thanks

fierce valve
#

They don’t take everything from you

#

💀

hidden moss
#

Wdym

#

They take stuff?

fierce valve
#

No

#

You’re gonna be fine boah

keen pagoda
keen pagoda
keen pagoda
#

Never tried always just shoot them and run away😂

candid arch
#

which one do you guys think is way more worse, the skinner brothers or the murfree blood?

icy cove
#

i think skinner brothers but theyre both horrendous

fickle chasm
#

They tortured Uncle 😔

#

How could you torture him of all people 😔

flint gull
#

murfree

twilit arrow
vale heart
#

Epilogue?

candid arch
#

oh you didnt know?

candid arch
fickle chasm
civic vault
austere prism
#

Me and my homies love and appreciate Uncle.

civic vault
#

The skinners be boilin' his lumbago

sleek granite
austere prism
fickle chasm
austere prism
#

Thank you kindly.

fickle chasm
tranquil zealot
austere prism
#

Big thank.

midnight dawn
#

Wrong emote

#

🫂

austere prism
#

I mean-

midnight dawn
#

... you mean-? 😳

austere prism
#

👉 👈

#

What if we..?

#

Haha jk jk ...

#

Unless..?

next nexus
#

👀

midnight dawn
#

I mean it's only homosexuality 💖

austere prism
#

Could just say no homo 👉 👈

#

And wear a nice pair of socks.

next nexus
#

Omg 😂

#

Leo is right tho

midnight dawn
#

I'm leo too now

next nexus
#

Oh my

#

YES

vale heart
#

Anyone here doing epilogue?

austere prism
#

I was for a while.

#

Why? What's up?

vale heart
#

Is hair growth stopped in epilogue?

austere prism
#

No?

vale heart
#

Epilogue Part 1, I mean

austere prism
#

What is Part 1 again?

vale heart
#

Epilogue 1

#

After Arthur's Death I mean.

austere prism
#

It might be.

vale heart
#

Hair growth stopped

#

Or slowed in epilogue

civic vault
#

Maybe you havent done enough sleep or fast travel

#

Doing those usually speeds it up a bit

lyric zephyr
dull geyser
#

You can't go mountain man mode atm

vale heart
#

Oof

#

This sucks

austere prism
#

more like suck deez nuts

#

I don't think I've gone full on mountainman ever in RDR2.

vale heart
#

But I can't.

#

Sad.

civic vault
#

I forgot John is stuck in that ranch playing farmer simulation

#

poop scooping simulation

vale heart
#

There are four cutscenes.

civic vault
#

What cutscene is that?

vale heart
civic vault
#

Or what are those cutscenes?

#

Nice

#

I'll try that

vale heart
#

Good luck

civic vault
#

But i got a long way to go. Resetted back to Chapter 2 and now on PS4

vale heart
#

It will take long so.

civic vault
#

After the badass train robbing mission, i'll start grinding for the satchels

vale heart
#

Hmm I used mod menu for satchels in single player.

#

I was kinda desperate for legend of the east satchel so I used that to boost the grind.

vale heart
civic vault
civic vault
vale heart
cobalt chasm
#

So as it turns out, getting a $250 bounty is difficult to survive...

civic vault
#

The only time i ever got that kind of bounty was when robbed that stagecoach with Micah

vale heart
cobalt chasm
#

I was chugging moonshine and chewing tobacco by the end of it

vale heart
#

I am already having John Morgan so I don't care about honor in epilogue tho.

cobalt chasm
#

My honor is still fairly high though interestingly enough

civic vault
vale heart
#

I had high honor before epilogue after that I have neutral honor.

#

Means balanced up in the middle.

civic vault
#

im also trying to find an early spawn of the Tukorman

#

I saw a video where it spawned early

dull geyser
#

The jim milton style

#

that part is like 45mins long iirc

vale heart
#

Hmm

vale heart
cobalt chasm
#

When does the horse fence get unlocked? The next bandit challenge has me selling the fence horses

#

NOOO

#

The game's making me go after downes!

#

I didn't want to yet I was putting it off

#

I didn't even hit him, I just kept threatening him why is he bleeding from the face?

#

And Arthur has tb, great...

vale heart
hidden moss
junior marsh
#

I just finished the story, I didn’t do any side missions only the main story will I still be able to do the side missions as John

vale heart
junior marsh
#

Ok thanks

vale heart
#

There are some side missions which only arthur can do that.

#

But you finished chapter 6 so it won't appear.

tranquil zealot
austere prism
#

Chapter 3.

cobalt chasm
#

"Micah would save you!"
"I don't think he would, but fine..."

#

where it all fell apart

#

Gosh I'm thinking through it, up till now I just hated micah for his guts and for what he does to arthur

#

but he really is the entire reason the gang falls apart...

austere prism
#

He's not the entire reason

#

But he's a pretty big reason why they did.

#

Hosea's passing contributed pretty heavily

vale heart
austere prism
#

Reverend Swanson is still an underrated character in my eyes

cobalt chasm
#

then he got molly to take the fall for it in a drunken stupor

#

Also I'm doing the LEEEEENNY mission, with the wolf heart trinket. So technically for Arthur to be this drunk he's consuming twice as much alcohol as usual for that cutscene.

austere prism
#

And? To say he's the sole reason why the gang fell is untrue

#

There's so many reasons why, but again, he is a pretty big reason why

cobalt chasm
#

Well you said Hosea's passing contributed pretty heavily. If it weren't for Micah, Hosea wouldn't have passed. Least not in that fashion.

midnight dawn
#

for the satches do all my pelts need to be perfect ?

cobalt chasm
#

yes

fleet heart
#

is companion quests only available in chaoter 2??

fluid cypress
#

no

shut tinsel
#

How many Calloway missions are there after you meet the legendary gunslingers

#

I've done the first one on the boat

#

So how many more

fluid cypress
#

One more

#

after the one on the boat in saint denis

shut tinsel
#

Ok

#

Are any of the gunslinger weapons actually good when compared to gunsmith guns

#

I use grangers revolver and midnight's pistol but idk if I should switch to something else

trail tapir
#

midnights pistol is the best pistol

#

the schofield revolver is probably the best imo

shut tinsel
#

I used it on my first playthrough

#

Bcs i got it for free after saving someone

#

But I didn't know if it was actually good

trail tapir
#

Yeah i would say the schofields is the best

#

definitely rock the midnights pistol tho

#

its sick

shut tinsel
#

I'm on c4 of my second playthrough rn

#

I keep thinking about continuing it but I'm dreading the bank heist

magic kite
#

that it i think i gonna punch dutch into dirt bag

#

(take heavy machine puncher

shut tinsel
magic kite
#

hmm the money box been smashed no wonder i don't see anymore

#

i think that would be micha or dutch work

fluid cypress
vale heart
#

There's a cigarette card mission bug

#

It shows up again if you pick premium cigarette

#

Even you have completed the mission.

magic kite
#

hmm i wanna ask

#

if once john got arthur bag will the stuff will all go to john?

shut tinsel
#

Yes except his money I believe

vale heart
#

But unique items will still be there.

magic kite
#

ok then i can do the legendary bull gator later

normal relic
#

I got Arthur's money

shut tinsel
#

There's a method to keep his money that I know of but idk if u keep it normally

magic kite
#

because the chain are need done 1 complete set of card

shut tinsel
#

Ye

normal relic
#

I don't remember how much i got on story

shut tinsel
#

U get robbed as Arthur and then go and get it back as john

vale heart
normal relic
#

Lol no idea

vale heart
#

You can throw fire bottles at him and he will survive it.

#

Nah Ig

#

Incest family is inspired from the bloody benders.

#

It's a real story about serial killer family.

#

Who invites people to their house then kill them.

#

Just like incest family

#

They used to lure people by making them eat food.

normal relic
#

I hated that cellar with all the blood and body parts in story

sleek granite
#

Do I keep my clothes when I become john

fickle chasm
sleek granite
#

Ok

#

At least I keep my suit

echo frost
#

So... I met this wild guy...

sleek granite
#

Do I keep the money?

normal relic
#

I kept all of Arthur's clothes

#

I keep Arthur's hat on John all the time

sleek granite
#

Fair

#

I use a top hat

echo frost
sleek granite
#

Kill him

echo frost
#

Why????

sleek granite
#

Fun

echo frost
#

He was just living in the wild 💀

sleek granite
#

Kick him to death

#

Burn him

#

Cut his limbs off

echo frost
#

I can see you are a low honor player...

sleek granite
#

In story at least

#

Not in online

echo frost
#

I only torture odriscolls and murfrees

sleek granite
#

Fair enough

#

Makes sense

echo frost
#

So any other suggestions on what I should do with him

#

I cleaned him already

sleek granite
#

Take him to Ur camp

echo frost
#

Uhh...

sleek granite
#

Have him become a family member

echo frost
#

He counts as an enemy

#

So....

sleek granite
#

Oh...

#

Kill him

echo frost
#

I have a better idea

normal relic
#

I hate the odriscolls

echo frost
#

I will leave him near his wolves and let him starve death

sleek granite
#

Oh god

echo frost
#

So he can always see what I took from him

#

And I will face him away from the water

#

So he will never see whats coming for him

#

Thats better than killing him right?

#

Alright I did it 🤠

sleek granite
#

That was...

#

Cruel

echo frost
#

Well it's better than killing him.

#

He should enjoy the rest of his life near his loved ones.

#

Doesnt that sound beatiful?

magic kite
#

you both cruel

echo frost
#

Well at least im giving him a chance to survive

#

There are a lot of sharp rocks in that have.

#

And the teeth of his wolves are pretty near him.

#

If he would try he would probably untie himself

#

Probably...

magic kite
#

i don't think he have that knowledge

#

well i do tie him up before he stab me but i gonna leave it

#

if i free him i sure he still still gonan whack me dead

normal relic
#

Hogtie him and kill him

cobalt chasm
#

THIS GAME

#

has the nerve!

#

to charge me with murder for killing a gunsmith!

#

WHO SHOWS UP LATER with a BANDAGE around his head

#

It ain't murder if he ain't DEAD

lavish acorn
#

Can I get Honor Level 6 for Arthur in Chapter 4. I want to unlock the Hero pearl grip. Or do i have to wait until chapter six because the last 3 stages are unlocked until that chapter (or only the last 2/1 ?)

magic kite
#

i was wonder why the van horn mailman was very pale

#

there no way to be albino since he still has hair color

normal relic
#

That mail man there is very pale

magic kite
#

yup it most pale than ever seen around this game

normal relic
#

I wonder why he got so pale

vernal rampart
#

he has a condition i think!

candid arch
#

isn't he albino

cobalt chasm
#

I got midnights pistol

echo frost
vernal rampart
cobalt chasm
#

since when does rain make it cold?

echo frost
#

Since always...

#

Water makes your clothes wet and then they stick to you. And since almost no sunlight comes you cant dry. And from what I remember rain is mostly cold.

#

Anyway,

#

Can I meet the robot as Arthur?

cobalt chasm
#

yes

#

I have

#

well at least I watched it take 2 steps and die

echo frost
#

Oh yeah...

#

That

#

I recommend checking that place again some time later...

hidden moss
#

Man, i fucking hate Saint Denny

echo frost
#

They hate you too

hidden moss
#

I accidentally hit my horse on a guy and all the workmen came after me

echo frost
#

Ez

hidden moss
#

and i have a question

#

Can you see Otis Miller's funeral?

#

I was walking and found this

cobalt chasm
#

So I was trying to get the free black arabian by shooting the robber attacking the couple talking about chinaware in saint denis

#

long story short, the law chased me and the horse into the front of a train and the horse died

candid arch
#

lol

cobalt chasm
#

I immediately exited the game and reloaded, and I don't have a bounty, so is it possible to find that encounter again and get the horse?

magic kite
#

i kinda pity straus

#

even he lend the wrong people the money

hidden moss
#

Me and my gang only use Red arabian

magic kite
#

imegine a rainbow horse

hidden moss
magic kite
#

but i don't think that enough rainbow

hidden moss
magic kite
#

whole body is rainbow color

#

mix color

hidden moss
#

Sheeeesh

magic kite
#

xD

hidden moss
#

Looks cool

magic kite
#

but it also can be ugly in same time too

hidden moss
#

I think it's because it's surreal

#

Red Dead doesn't have as many "pop" elements so to speak

cobalt chasm
#

And I just got mugged in an ally for $1200

#

great

candid arch
cobalt chasm
#

Saint denis is the worst

#

Cops everywhere

umbral kestrel
#

Hey i just realized my calloway revolver is lost and does not appear on my compendium is there a fix?

#

I just returned from guarda

#

Guarma

cobalt chasm
#

Cops don’t care if NPCs break the law unless it’s part of a specific scripted event where they do

#

You get mugged for a 1/3 of your worth with no way to get it back

midnight dawn
#

i'm about to finish legend of the east satchel finally

cobalt chasm
#

And to top it off I got arrested for stealing the horse of a dead mugger.

midnight dawn
magic kite
#

i hate that miner

#

so i shoot the bomb and he die by expolde

#

i sure he was the one beat him to dead

cobalt chasm
midnight dawn
cobalt chasm
#

the couple talking about china didn't mug me it was a guy that lured me into an ally

#

I KNEW IT WAS A TRAP even I just figured I'd have the chance to shoot him in the face if I played along...

midnight dawn
#

oh there are many encounters where arthur ends up in a grave

#

the killer secret , that incest couple and this one lmao

cobalt chasm
#

no the saint denis graveyard

#

couple of muggers dumped me there after taking 1200 off me

#

So this "free black arabian" which I still don't have has cost me near 1.5k...

#

fuck saint denis

cobalt chasm
#

Is there a way to see if you've encountered a random encounter? I'm trying to get the black Arabian from the couple being mugged in Saint Denis, and I already did it once, but the horse died almost immediately and I relogged, which removed the bounty for horse stealing. I suspect having done it once it won't happen again, idk. Really pissed off about it tbh.

hidden moss
#

Man

#

in my view, fuck the arabs, fox trotter still on top

normal relic
#

I'm sorry that happened to you there should be a way to get it again

#

I have 3 fox trotters

#

Just recently bought an arabian on rdo

cobalt chasm
hidden moss
#

There are black Fox trotters, including very beautiful ones

hidden moss
normal relic
#

I've never seen the black fox trotter before

hidden moss
#

I forgot to talk english

normal relic
#

It's okay

#

What breed is Micahs horse

vale heart
hidden moss
#

It's a glitch

cobalt chasm
#

I found the encounter again, same place

hidden moss
#

But we can

cobalt chasm
#

got the horse this time, took a better route out of town now that I know it's illegal to reclaim a dead mugger's horse

hidden moss
#

I even have a video that explains it, but it's in portuguese

vale heart
#

Oh

cobalt chasm
#

I still need to get my 1200 back though

#

hopefully arthur will yell or something if I see the npcs that did it again and I can blow their brains against a wall

midnight dawn
#

i got the satchel now i'm hunting for ghost bison outfit

normal relic
#

I don't have the ghost bison coat yet

hidden moss
#

@vale heart @cobalt chasm So basically you have to do this:

Get into a fight with someone and bring them close to the camp so the gang people can help you and start following you.

Then you kill them and steal the horse you want.

midnight dawn
#

i still need to hunt a legendary white bison and a legendary elk

hidden moss
midnight dawn
#

i don't speak spanish mister

normal relic
cobalt chasm
midnight dawn
#

oh i did get a ram today

#

legendary ram

hidden moss
#

Is Portuguese

#

It's very different from Spanish

midnight dawn
#

it's near the forest in strawberry

normal relic
#

I got the rutile and chalkhorn ram coats

hidden moss
#

There is the first clue

midnight dawn
#

thanks

#

how many tailors are there in game ?

normal relic
#

Blackwater Saint Denis are the only 2 i know of

cobalt chasm
#

So I got mugged in saint denis. I was riding around at night and some guy psstd me over and asked if I wanted to make some cash. Same thing had happened once in valentine, and that went well, so I wasn't to concerned. Either it's the same deal, or it's like every other robbery in this game and I can solve it with a quick draw.

#

Instead, I got knocked out from behind, and woke up in the saint denis grave yard $1,200 poorer.

#

Went back to the scene of the crime, no one in sight.

#

Is there a way to get my money back? Or is this to teach me to kill everyone even remotely suspicious?

normal relic
cobalt chasm
#

again, I'd been in a similar encounter and it went well. Guy asked me to rob someone else.

#

This guy did the same thing but it was a trap, which was scripted so I couldn't beat it.

#

At this point I'm tempted to just start shooting everyone. The max bounty is $300 so far as I can tell so if kill the whole damn city and loot the guy that mugged me that's at least $900 back...

normal relic
#

I'm sure you'd get your money back by doing that

signal wave
#

the max bounty is 1,500

cobalt chasm
#

oh

#

it didn't pass 300 just shooting lawmen in valentine

signal wave
#

it stops at 300 for civilians

#

you can increase it by shooting lawmen

green spire
#

can someone confirm if treasure map golden bars respawn in epilogue

#

since I am the high stakes 3 location and cannot search

#

I took them with Arthur

#

but I do not have the option now with John even though all golden bars disappeared

fierce valve
midnight dawn
#

Hello saori fan

fierce valve
#

Hi

green spire
#

@fierce valve didn't know about it

#

but also no one confirmed

#

if treasure map gold bars respawn

#

???

midnight dawn
#

what's the farm trick ???

vernal rampart
#

go to aberdeen pig farm before the ending missions and then come back as john

midnight dawn
#

what does it do exactly ?

worldly turret
#

stores Arthur's money for John to pick up later on

midnight dawn
#

Finally i got the ghost bison outfit and legend of east satchel

#

And I'm almost about to finish master hunter challenges

sleek granite
#

do i get to shoot micah?

cobalt chasm
#

You bond with your horse much faster if you traumatize them over and over to comfort them more often

midnight dawn
#

Did i screw up by killing the guy that always wants to race you ?

sleek granite
#

nope

midnight dawn
#

Because right after i beat him my horse's speed increased

#

But the asshole killed his poor horse so i had to kill him

sleek granite
#

he deserves it

#

idk

midnight dawn
#

what's a good beaver location ?

cobalt chasm
#

what gun is midnight's pistol this thing slaps

midnight dawn
#

bruh the legend of east satchel is so worth it

#

i can carry 99 of everything ? damn

midnight dawn
#

low damage but high fire rate

cobalt chasm
#

I mean it still kills on a headshot

midnight dawn
#

a volcanic kills from a range of a repeater

#

a mauser doesn't

cobalt chasm
#

I just lost honor for killing a dude on the side of the road?

#

I mean he hadn't done anything yet but he tried to kill me and take my horse in my first run through so it's not like he wouldn't

midnight dawn
#

wtf is kill an oppossum playing possum ?

#

master hunter 9

#

ooooooh they mean kill a possum playing dead lmao

north path
#

My horse died and is no longer available at the stables either

#

Is it impossible to get it back now

midnight dawn
#

no

#

it's gone cowboy_sad

hidden moss
midnight dawn
#

broooo thank god i didn't kill a legenday panther yet

#

because master hunter 10 requires you to kill one and they don't respawn ??

dreamy oracle
#

The Legendary Panther isn’t available until you’re on Master Hunter 10

midnight dawn
#

ooh nice

#

Are there any legendary animals that don't spawn until later chapters ?

#

I wanna craft all the trinkets in chap 2

cobalt chasm
#

I wish everyone at camp would stop acting like dutch is a god...

midnight dawn
#

i wish molly would get a heart attack

#

i caught her yelling at karen and saying dutch lovers her lmao lulhaw

cobalt chasm
#

I just saw that too

#

and don't worry she get's a heart attack

#

lead poisoning I think

tranquil zealot
#

search it up on youtube

#

i found a 3 star beaver in 2 mins

midnight dawn
#

bruh wtf i got fucking jumped by the panther behind me

#

even tho the trail was leading in front

red helm
#

Why wouldn't a Panther ambush you from behind?

midnight dawn
#

true but the trail was leading another way

red helm
#

They can move pretty quick, the trail doesn't say anything about how fast they are moving.

late silo
#

theres also a place in roanoke ridge its like a dam but idk where it is

midnight dawn
#

brooooo there were fucking lemoyne raiders near the legendary panther

#

i think they killed it and i died too

red helm
cobalt chasm
#

I will say, as much as micah sucks, the mission where you rob a stagecoach with him is pretty cool

midnight dawn
#

i came back and massacred every one of them

#

i think panther is still alive too there is no cross in its icon on the map

red helm
midnight dawn
#

yeah i'll just camp in here and wait

red helm
#

Always make a manual save before taking on one of the legendary animals, especially the predator ones. "Save Early, Save Often."

tranquil zealot
#

how can i get max honor fast?

#

fishing?

midnight dawn
#

in chap 2 it's capped

#

you can't get max honor until later chapters

tranquil zealot
#

im just asking

#

about a way to get honor fast

midnight dawn
#

doing camp chores is easier

midnight dawn
#

where do i get special miracle tonic recipe pamphlet ?

#

i don't have it for herbalist 7 ?

red helm
mortal gull
#

You guys tyrna get 100 completion because i am too

midnight dawn
#

it isn't at the fence

midnight dawn
red helm
# tranquil zealot about a way to get honor fast

"fast" is a relative term. Easiest, however, is to walk around a town and greet everyone you see. Next is to fish and throw back. Then Camp Chores. most expensive is to donate $21 over and over to the camp. Or just find random Encounter's and do them the Honorable way.

mortal gull
red helm
midnight dawn
#

i'm checking youtube i think there is somewhere you could get it for free

mortal gull
red helm
#

Yeap, the area with the Trapper and the Fence, or by the Tailor.

mortal gull
mortal gull
midnight dawn
#

got the pamphlet

#

you can find it in the grizzlies

red helm
#

Oh, nice.

red helm
mortal gull
midnight dawn
#

It's in west Elizabeth

civic vault
# vale heart Where tho?

In Saint Denis, but in the outskirts. There's always a horse in the back yard of some houses. A different kind spawns everytime

glad brook
#

But that's someone else's horse.

#

What if someone stole your horse? Exacyly.

midnight dawn
#

herbalist 7 is annoying

#

i wish there was a merchat that sells plants

violet jewel
hidden moss
#

just a quick question i'm trying to get my honor back up in rdr2 and it feels like it's not increasing at all but i get the symbol on the right i'm donating money to camp and strangers greeting everyone in st denis and fishing and throwing the fish back in, am i missing something

midnight dawn
#

do you lose honor during bandit quests ?

midnight dawn
hidden moss
#

i saw on reddit if you donate $20 to your camp 12 times it will go up but i've donated about $3k and it hasn't moved but maybe my honor bar is glitched

cobalt chasm
#

w

#

t

#

f

#

some black widow bounty target can apparently run at the speed of sound and is armed with an instant kill knife?

midnight dawn
#

you can't raise your honor higher than lvl 6

#

there is a guide that says the earliest you can raise it to max is chap 4-5

hidden moss
#

how can you tell if it's at 2-3

midnight dawn
#

i myself in chap 2 and i can't raise it any higher

hidden moss
#

ok well i need to go and get more money since i lost a ton

vernal rampart
dull geyser
#

A lot of side activities can instantly up your honor

#

Don't donate to camp that much

midnight dawn
#

Oh well i give up on herbalist 9 for now

#

Ffs picking up 43 herbs is very boring and 6 of them can only be found in new austin

#

If it were only 1 plant in new austin it would've been so damn easy but 6 is too much

#

Well i'll leave it to john's part i'll start the other annoying challenges survivalist

gaunt bobcat
#

How many gold bars total are their and what’s a good guide to find them?

hidden moss
#

powerpyx has a guide for the gold bars but not every single one

gaunt bobcat
hidden moss
#

fairwale shanty has a golden nugget that always spawns if you turn off auto save and then ride to the loft and back

#

if you need money

#

and no i don't know how many gold bars are actually in the game

gaunt bobcat
#

I’d rather just get the bars cause I like the adventure idea but thanks

cobalt chasm
#

Uhg. You know as much as Micah says he hates "darkies" he sure doesn't seem to mind all the brown he's got on his nose...

midnight dawn
#

I hate fishing so much survivalist is gonna be hell on earth for me

#

Since you have to catch every single fish species

azure current
#

Any way of getting rid of the satchel

midnight dawn
#

Nope satchels are always equipped

#

You can swap to a different satchel once you craft it at camp

vagrant lynx
#

May I

slender trout
#

A

azure current
#

Any way of getting money out the camp donations?

spiral flare
#

No

karmic zephyr
#

Guys Is red dead single player worth it? I have played online and want to give story mode a shot

hidden moss
#

yes absolutely

#

one of the best storyline in singleplayer games

cobalt chasm
#

God the way Karen falls apart is probably the saddest arc in the game

#

what's the consensus on the double action revolver? Seems to focus on fire rate rather than damage

austere prism
#

It's a good gun.

#

Not a very good gun if you wanna feel like a western cowboy though, as you can't fan the hammer or anything.

#

Its upside though is you don't need to take the time to cock the hammer inbetween shots.

dull geyser
#

But native americans arc hits harder imo

red helm
civic vault
#

Saves the controller

red helm
#

And your hand.

daring lichen
#

a question

#

after you do the last mission with albert mason

#

do you see him again as john?

#

anyone?

dull geyser
woeful imp
#

How does the story saving work? Like i took first bounty mission, i failed it, when in mission i can restart it, but if i cancel it, then i return somewhere, i looked at my saves and there's no saves leading to that mission, so i guess i can just get it again i guess, but it seems it's just better to fuck up and continue from that, than loading save? 😄

remote flower
#

I'm gonna start Herbalist 8, I just hope I'll finish before witnessing my grandchildren graduate

hidden moss
#

good luck

mortal gull
versed widget
#

How do I stop a horse that is Lv3 bond or above, without handbraking it (costs a lot of stamina)? Repeatedly tap the brake button?

sleek granite
#

Just hold the brake button

versed widget
#

HOLDING the brake button does a handbrake which costs a lot of stamina (or if stamina is low, core).

#

Also I'm talking about a horse, not a wagon, despite me using car terminology...

sleek granite
#

I honestly don't know

#

Maybe getting off the horse

#

That's what I do

tough atlas
#

Yo who’s tryna play red dead?

daring lichen
dull geyser
#

They mention arthur tho

#

But it's just one dialogue iirc

civic vault
mortal gull
#

Like 2 years ago bro😀

civic vault
#

i guess it's the braithwaite plan now

#

get cereberus

#

feed him a ton of carrots

civic vault
dull geyser
#

I ran out of food for him after trying to bond

#

So I just patted him until I finally got to bond lvl 1

civic vault
#

horses love dem pats

#

I'm still in chapter 2 so im just gonna grind for the satchels now and do most of the challenges for now

proud cipher
#

happy chapter

magic kite
#

Thinking if arthur become humaniod

proud cipher
#

if scientist guy didn’t die

#

maybe Arthur brain could be put into the robot

magic kite
#

Yup

#

Or time travel to make him become humaniod

#

And send him back to nuke micha and dutch

civic vault
#

Robo Arthur

#

cyborg arthur

#

that would've been a visually badass concept

#

but well

#

just in a different universe

magic kite
#

Or become automata(well you know the game)

civic vault
#

That game is tragic on its own. I've seen a friend play it

magic kite
#

I sure that will slice everything up

#

When john see arthur become humaniod

#

John: no fucking way what happen to you, aint you already dead?

civic vault
#

red dead robot

#

now im tempted to draw cyborg arthur

vale heart
#

Rockstar is gone. So gone that they can't even see it.

civic vault
#

rdr2 is their masterpiece... their last masterpiece

vale heart
#

Well yeah but Take Two is controlling their financial decisions that's why they are creating more and more cash grab opportunities so I don't think we will see any more AAA titles from Rockstar anymore or even if we see like rdr3 or gta 6 then they might be terrible.

civic vault
#

greed makes everything suck

vale heart
#

Yeah

#

Rockstar being Micah(I mean according to greedy behaviour)

hidden moss
#

Dude

#

I have the same horse since chapter one

#

Am I a sad human being

#

I am now in chapter 6

vale heart
#

No need to worry about.

daring lichen
#

how long is epilogue

civic vault
#

it's just 2 chapters

vale heart
#

I think three parts

violet jewel
vale heart
#

Oh

#

I haven't played the whole epilogue

civic vault
#

ive played the epilogue too fast

#

didnt even try to explore armadillo and other places

#

i just wanted micah to die lol

#

but now i'm gonna explore

vale heart
#

Remember, You can have 4 cutscenes every time you leave pronghorn ranch in epilogue 1 after you settle there then you can leave.

#

And in the fourth cutscene, John will mention about Arthur.

civic vault
#

also hearing about those places to be "empty" doesn't really entice me that much

vale heart
#

"Sure is hard country round these parts"

civic vault
#

lol

daring lichen
#

should i rush to finish the epilogue

#

or explore first

civic vault
#

Not really sure.

sterile flint
#

you should explore

#

theres always a ton to explore

#

tbh it’s more worth it to just finish the epilogue though

civic vault
#

I missed a ton as John

#

like

#

i guess i was too emotional back then lol

vale heart
#

You can get guns in epilogue part 1 early

#

I used to think you can only use gun after the mission

mortal gull
#

Imagine red dead 1 re make after john dies we get to play as jack and more missions as him

normal relic
#

That'd be cool

#

I got bored after completing rdr1 idk what else to do

sterile flint
#

wait nvm

austere prism
#

Okay.

#

All white outfits.

#

Your thoughts?

normal relic
#

All white outfits are cool

shut tinsel
#

Hmmmmm

rich kiln
#

@hallow mist Ride With Me

candid arch
#

it's a trap

young sapphire
#

Can someone help me?

#

I can't play any missions.