red-dead-singleplayer

[civic vault]

Yeah i killed all of them

[dull geyser]

Yea

I managed to shoot some

[fickle chasm]

same

[civic vault]

i still haven't brought myself to do that option lol

[fickle chasm]

I made an arthur morgan playlist 🛐

[civic vault]

oh!

[fickle chasm]

🤝

[civic vault]

gimme

[dull geyser]

That ending was just really good

[civic vault]

i need a playlist

[merry widget]

Yes

[fickle chasm]

Direction was a whole another level

[glad brook]

Micah and Arthur both fight with knifes while surrounded by fire pretty bad*ss.

[merry widget]

Greet + Greet + Antagonize + Melee battle with intense music

[dull geyser]

Yes

[merry widget]

99% of the population would choose that ending

If it was called

"Go back for Micah"

[dull geyser]

Yea that ending was badass

[fickle chasm]

yep lmao

[merry widget]

but its for money

and like

im pretty sure everyone has like 5k if they are playing and exploring

[civic vault]

im too goody lol, i still wanna help john lol

[fickle chasm]

doesn't feel right to leave john

i've replayed that mission 4 times

and each time

i went to help john

[dull geyser]

I did the go for the money ending because I wanna see what happens if I do that choice

The part where arthur starts to go for the money was pretty badass

[merry widget]

DUTCH

MICAH

BILL

i dont remember the rest

[fickle chasm]

No spoilers please i wanna experience it :))

or nvm

[civic vault]

i saw it on youtube instead lol

[dull geyser]

Yea try to see that ending

[fickle chasm]

alrr

i'll do it rn

[dull geyser]

It's more like a badass ending

[fickle chasm]

than heroic

[dull geyser]

But the saving john one I think is canon

Cause that's where his redemption comes to play

[civic vault]

it should be canon

it makes more sense to me

[merry widget]

Yeah

Idk how people do low honor the first time they play

Imagine not seeing the sunrise

[fickle chasm]

that's very likely lol

[merry widget]

How

[dull geyser]

I tried low honor on my 4th playthrough

[fickle chasm]

most people don't know at first

[merry widget]

I cant do low honor

[fickle chasm]

that it affects

[merry widget]

He sounds like such a bitch towards the ending

[fickle chasm]

ending

[dull geyser]

It's a little bit uncomfortable at first because of that sound

But it starts getting fun ngl

[merry widget]

the wolf?

[civic vault]

i've always been high honor even if i didn't know about the honor system at first

[fickle chasm]

I'm doing a low honor playthrough rn

[dull geyser]

That and the sound of your honor going lower

[magic kite]

damn i feel like sometimes i wanna shoot enemy horse to looting

[merry widget]

Oh yeah

[magic kite]

they kick me to dead

[merry widget]

does anyone hate the fact that

When you kill the enemies horse

It lowers your honor

Like how does that make sense

Isnt it tactical

[dull geyser]

Yea

[fickle chasm]

Horse is innocent tho

[merry widget]

In red dead online it doesn't lower your honor

[sleek granite]

It should

[civic vault]

i notice my honor doesn't lower when i use the maxim gun on them when they by chasin'

[merry widget]

Hmm

[merry widget]

cuz i dont think anybody can control it lmao

am i the only person whose recently been liking rdo

[sleek granite]

Nope

I love it

[civic vault]

but when i rob people in the trolley robbery mission, i lose honor lol

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[civic vault]

im like.... isn't it part of the main mission lol

[dull geyser]

Yea I was thinking twice to press rob

[sleek granite]

What revolver should I use?

[civic vault]

why the game shaving off dem honor when that's the whole point rofl

[merry widget]

O YM GO

[dull geyser]

What looks the sexiest to you

[merry widget]

Or the train job

[sleek granite]

Fair enough

[merry widget]

Im pretty sure its a glitch but when john robs then u can rob them again

Idk ho

HOw but its a lot of extra money

[civic vault]

in the valentine bank job, when i chose to crack the safe instead of blowing it up, i lose less honor

[merry widget]

you know

[civic vault]

coz i get to not kill people as we escape

[merry widget]

i recently discovered in my 6th playthrough

that if u crack them and dont waste time there wont be any cops ready for you

it was really interesting

[civic vault]

yeah

[merry widget]

Yeah

[civic vault]

and a whole new escape scene apart of them eventually chasing you because someone shouts that the bank is robbed

[merry widget]

Yeah

[civic vault]

it's a smoother way to go through it

[merry widget]

I prefer exploding it though

Just seems more like what would be cannon

Oops

[dull geyser]

Yea I think R* reversed the heist options

[civic vault]

exploding it is quick, yeah

[dull geyser]

In gta 5 loud option gets more money

[civic vault]

i don't know hmmm... maybe arthur would've preferred it to go quieter because he was worried before that it'll be messy

[dull geyser]

Yea he seems to be pissed when things go south

[civic vault]

he doesn't want to cause unnecessary attention most of the time

[merry widget]

There should definitely be a chat where spoilers are allowed

I wanna discuss stuff

[dull geyser]

This is the chat lmao

[merry widget]

what

Oh ok

Well then

[civic vault]

we scream at newbies to leave when we speak spoilers lol

[merry widget]

I feel like regardless of Micah's actions things were gonna end up south anyways

[dull geyser]

Ppl warn new ppl of spoilers in this chat

[merry widget]

Oh ok

Like even as early as

Chapter 1

[dull geyser]

Dude was trigger happy

[civic vault]

because of Dutch, yeah

[merry widget]

Its obvious

Like

uh

Yk

[dull geyser]

Things won't be going the way as planned

[merry widget]

In the blackwater cahpter

in the journal

Dutch doesn't buy an area of land for no valid reason

When they could've settled back then

[civic vault]

Dutch seems to be heading to the crazy route no matter what

[dull geyser]

Yea the rat talked dutch to getting to it

[merry widget]

Yeah

[dull geyser]

Arthur and hosea were on another job then the ferry massacre happened

[merry widget]

Yeah

[dull geyser]

Landon ricketts was there too so maybe he's the one who killed the callander boys

It's possible

[civic vault]

Even if the Tahiti thing goes to plan, i got the feeling they would've killed each other regardless

[dull geyser]

Yea

[civic vault]

Someone would get greedy

[dull geyser]

Guarma showed what the gang to tahiti would've been

[civic vault]

Dutch would be that person

[dull geyser]

Tahiti was just his trick anyways

[civic vault]

exactly

Arthur would end up trying to save the women and the people who still had the chance, and dying in the process

it's the same end for him i think

[merry widget]

Yeah cause the TB thing was gonna happen anyways

cause arthurs good

like generally

[queen fossil]

Tbh Tahiti would had been better

But just because France did rule it and there was no slavery

[civic vault]

what if arthur didn't have TB and they're in tahiti and Dutch decides to get greedy

[queen fossil]

Greedy as what?

[civic vault]

Arthur would've saved people but there's a high chance he would've survived because Charles would've been there with him

[civic vault]

like take all the money for himself. Go crazy. "Damn us all" like hosea warned

[queen fossil]

Then the gang could kill him, or set him up to the French authorities

[dull geyser]

Yea dutch might've prevented insanity if they made it to tahiti and it all goes right

[civic vault]

Or what if javier, bill and micah joined him in the greedy

on a second thought, i feel like Arthur would've split from the gang before tahiti would happen, given the what if he didn't have TB

[queen fossil]

He would not

[civic vault]

He did promise Mary

[queen fossil]

What snap him was Hosea's death

[civic vault]

Hosea kept him sane for a bit but during the Angelo Bronte revenge decisions, Hosea was going against him and he couldnt be controlled

[merry widget]

No, Dutch was Dutch

I think its pretty well known that saying

[fickle chasm]

I'm gonna cry again 😭

[merry widget]

Like people can pretend they're something they're not

But their true colors will show

or something

[civic vault]

Yeah, Hosea had some control but not enough

[dull geyser]

Yea john said the true dutch is just showing he did not change

[merry widget]

honestly

i wish hosea would've just escaped with bessie

or something

he was way too sweet

[civic vault]

It's something Arthur would've done

[dull geyser]

Both hosea and arthur would've been able to control dutch if arthur saw it coming at the same time as hosea

[civic vault]

Arthur was more like Hosea in attitude

[merry widget]

i dont think control is the right word

more like destroy his leadership

because honestly

[civic vault]

Like that scene where Arthur was the deciding vote on the bronte revenge

[merry widget]

dutch was all talk

[dull geyser]

Yea

[merry widget]

even from the

[dull geyser]

And micah was inflating his massive ego

[merry widget]

shootout scene

with fussar

like he was losing his gunslinging abilities as well

[dull geyser]

That's his greatest weapon

Words

[merry widget]

Yeah

[civic vault]

If Arthur saw it coming, maybe he would've helped Hosea take over the gang for its own good.

[queen fossil]

Ansd also what would the gand to when in Tahiti?

[merry widget]

That too

20 people doing grazing and farming?

Really?

[dull geyser]

They planned on being ranchers iirc

[civic vault]

yeah

[fickle chasm]

I never noticed the pinkertons in the bg when arthur confronts micah and the rest

till now

[civic vault]

Arthur didnt see the tahiti plan to be realistic from the getgo

[civic vault]

i saw them, they be sneaky

[merry widget]

wait

so they were waiting?

OMG

ok i gotta rewatch the scene

[queen fossil]

In a new country, where none of them known French or how Tahiti work

They would be in a more remoted place, but still one civilized by 1899

One controlled by an European power

[civic vault]

Like I said, Arthur would split after the bank job, and after everybody is okay

He wanted to retire

and be with Mary

He was just too loyal to Dutch

[queen fossil]

They would have better choices in Australia just because it would had been much easier for them to assimilate with the locals

Or New Zealand

[civic vault]

That woud be nice

but chances are they might end up washed up ashore in my country, also nearby lol

right at that time it's in war with america

Even Uncle mentions that war

[dull geyser]

Philippines?

[civic vault]

Yep

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

[civic vault]

we have.... beaches.. better than Guarma

coconuts

tons of islands to hide from

but yeah at that time America was raining hell on us lol

[queen fossil]

I doubt they would have like to return from there they start

As by 1899 the Philippines were under American control

[civic vault]

yeah

but only the north part

not all of it

[merry widget]

i want to have amnesia

[queen fossil]

Still

[merry widget]

so i can experience red dead again

im on my 7th playthrough

still fun tho

[civic vault]

they could've ended up in one of the islands where like no poeple live and it's great lol

there was even a japanese soldier who stayed in my country for 20+ years because he thought ww2 was still going on, and he was hiding in a cave

killing folk and livestock

he went undetected until the 70's i think

so it's easy to hide lol

but back on track.... Dutch is still dutch

and he would go cray cray

[merry widget]

yes

istg if they just did more work for rdr online

Its pretty fun

I recently started playing it

Rank 20

[magic kite]

damn some camp people sure are rude

i harvesting something he shoting me

so i throw him firebottle

[dull geyser]

Lmao

I think australia was a really solid choice for the gang tho

[fickle chasm]

Damnn you get 42k

can i escape with this money?

like take some other direction

and run

[dull geyser]

Maybe

[queen fossil]

But still same problem with Tahiti, they can't resort to outlaws activities anymore

[dull geyser]

Yep

And still get in trouble too

[merry widget]

Lol

I saw someone win the knife fight with micah

The game glitches

[queen fossil]

Like yeah they can become ranchers, if for Dutch that would be okay

[merry widget]

Lol

No

Dutch likes being on the run

he likes causing trouble

[queen fossil]

Yeah i get that

But maybe Hosea can convince him

[fickle chasm]

an to get 100% you could get a boat back to america

[civic vault]

Dutch is stubborn, so maybe it'll cause the gang to split

[magic kite]

i wanna ask

what happen to the camp stuff???

like those pearson craft out one

[civic vault]

what chapter are you in?

[magic kite]

so far i see no side quest around chapter 3 i guess i gonna done the main quest

[undone maple]

You will get back all your stuff after back from guarma

[civic vault]

I guess for the camp upgrades it's just there

[undone maple]

also you can "get rob" by the alberdine pig farm,then take the money back as john to "transfer" the money

[magic kite]

ok then

[dull geyser]

I was gonna say something but it's spoilers tho

[undone maple]

Use the spoiler symble (use || before and after the text,also this channel is Ok for spoilers

[civic vault]

we just need to warn newbies

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

The camp decorations and upgrades won't be there after chapter 6

[civic vault]

yknow i didn't notice that

oh wait i thought you said during chapter 6 lol

[dull geyser]

Bruh I remember grinding for the camp decorations for god knows how long lmao

[undone maple]

Yah too bad there's aren't any decorations in beachers' hope

[dull geyser]

Yea

[civic vault]

next playthrough im gonna try to get the pearson jacket

the blue scout jacket

i heard it's rare

[magic kite]

oof i better take those stuff just sell toward the huntsman

i crafted some decoration

but never know those stuff will gone

[dull geyser]

Yea

I was pretty frustrated when I knew that after chapter 6

My back almost died and it just vanished

[magic kite]

sorry to hear that

[vale heart]

I also have many camp decoration in chapter 6

[dull geyser]

Yea

[vale heart]

But I really don't care about it.

[civic vault]

what's the best decoration?

[vale heart]

Decorations are only to make the camp look more beautiful and fascinating

[dull geyser]

The campfire one

was the best imo cause it has a homey vibe to it

[civic vault]

i only got the bone decor and i got lazy lol

[vale heart]

The moose antler decoration was too hard

[dull geyser]

Yea

[vale heart]

Had to wait for bull moose to spawn in colter

[civic vault]

it requires a 3 star moose right?

[dull geyser]

Yea

[vale heart]

Nah, I shot 2 star bull moose and still got the antler

[dull geyser]

I almost ran out of patience then I finally see one

Rdr2 be doing that on purpose istg

[civic vault]

they really do

like the game knows you looking for it

[civic vault]

I see, that's nice

[vale heart]

I think rockstar should work on fixing bull moose spawn because it took me 10 tries to spawn it.

[dull geyser]

Some animals are really hard to spawn

[civic vault]

i once saw a 3 star moose and it never spawned again

[dull geyser]

I had a hard time finding a 3 star elk too

[civic vault]

I think it took me 2 weeks in game time to spawn that in moonstone pond lol

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[vale heart]

I had a problem in finding a perfect bighorn ram but when I was doing missions, I saw perfect bighorn rams many times.

[tiny nymph]

I can spawn one in 5 minutes

[dull geyser]

I had to look twice if my eyes weren't playing with me when I saw a 3 star lol

[civic vault]

i camped, i looked and i saw none, i went back to sleep, then after 3 times, i left and did other stuff because the game limits sleeping frequency lol

[tiny nymph]

Sleep 2x max duration, save game, load game

It will re spawn

I got constant cougars abusing this for the challenges

[civic vault]

ah well, i already grinded for the elk and i don't need it anymore lol

cougars are easier to spawn

[tiny nymph]

Elk are even easier

[civic vault]

everytime i go to big valley there's always one

[tiny nymph]

Yes but a person wrote here that it took 2 weeks of in game time

They’re super easy to find I never had to attempt to spawn them

They’re close to the cougar too above Strawberry

[civic vault]

i meant the cougar

[tiny nymph]

Not always

It depends on the time of day too

For example armadillos spawn from 8pm to 8am

[civic vault]

somehow for me, the time of day didnt matter

same goes with cougar up north near raonoke

night or day it spawns

i killed one at night, i killed on during the day

breezed through the huntsman challenge

but i get more chances in big valley

Also i thought the panther only spawns at night, but then i saw it during 5pm game time

Maybe i got a time glitch

[tiny nymph]

It does spawn at night

Below Braithwaite Manor

[civic vault]

yeah, i know

[tiny nymph]

And near Beavers Hollow

[civic vault]

but i was shocked i got jumped scared while the sun was up

i was hunting for boars lol

[boreal basalt]

What's good fellas

I'm waiting at train tracks for a train to Rob

[civic vault]

go choo choo! rob em!

[boreal basalt]

I'm just vibin

[civic vault]

how much honor do you lose when you rob trains?

[boreal basalt]

I have no idea im hella new to rdr2

Just started yesterday

[civic vault]

i never attempted lol

[boreal basalt]

I read online that we get p good money

And I need money

So

Yea

[civic vault]

then don't scroll up, we said a bunch of spoilers

[boreal basalt]

LOL

Aight

[civic vault]

and be careful here because we just spill spoilers lol

[boreal basalt]

I hate hiw the horse won't teleport to oyy

Like damn

[tiny nymph]

That’s the worst thing you can do to rob a train

Unless you like to wait

[boreal basalt]

I hate waiting but idk ehat else is there to do

[tiny nymph]

Buy a ticket to anywhere and rob the train that way

[boreal basalt]

God damn

Big brain mfker

[tiny nymph]

@boreal basalt

[boreal basalt]

Aight

Gon do that rn

[tiny nymph]

It spawns them because you’re in the train to go somewhere

Just put a bandana on and rob it

[boreal basalt]

AIGHT

Ty

[tiny nymph]

What’s your platform

[boreal basalt]

Pc

[tiny nymph]

You could use mods if you really want to be rich that bad early on

Or just play the game normally

[boreal basalt]

Nah idw to cheat

But I want money

So ill roba train

[civic vault]

look for treasure, always big money

get treasure maps

[boreal basalt]

Tried to hop on a train and died

LOL

[tiny nymph]

I don’t care about honor

I have low honor

I can get it back up from just greeting people

[boreal basalt]

@civic vault how

[tiny nymph]

Random strangers

Or go on YouTube

[civic vault]

you'll meet strangers with treasure maps

but you gotta explore to find them

[tiny nymph]

I’d go on YouTube either way

You’re not gonna understand the map

[boreal basalt]

Aight will do that

[tiny nymph]

If it’s moving you ride your horse next to it

[magic kite]

i wonder why fort wallace are red area

[tiny nymph]

It will give you an option to jump from the horse to the train

[magic kite]

and i shoted 3 person i got dishonor who are they i wonder

[tiny nymph]

Because it’s a military base

[magic kite]

oh

feel sorry for them

[tiny nymph]

I’ve chucked dynamite at them so they’d fall from the top to me

And I looted them for the document they have

[boreal basalt]

If I stay on a train at my station

Will it go ogg

Off

[tiny nymph]

Just buy a train ticket to anywhere dude

[magic kite]

feel like you zap the flies on the sky then they all fell down like the rain

[boreal basalt]

@tiny nymph I did

I'm on a train now

[civic vault]

@boreal basalt if you're avoiding spoilers, i think googling it is better because the next day youtube will recommend you spoiler filled videos and even the titles with spoilers on them.

[boreal basalt]

After buying a ticket

OK nvm

Its moving now

LOL

[tiny nymph]

Then yeah rob it

[boreal basalt]

Gon rob brb

[tiny nymph]

If you have dynamite or you can craft explosive ammo do that

There is a safe or 2 in the train

Also point your gun at people and demand them to give you money

[sleek granite]

Can u play story after you complete it, my friend says u can't

[tiny nymph]

Why would you not

[sleek granite]

Idk

[tiny nymph]

No offense, but your friend is mentally challenged

[boreal basalt]

bruh im wearinga mask

how they gon know its me

[sleek granite]

I know

Tho I started playing like a month ago so I just trust what he says

[tiny nymph]

If the cops arrive at the scene and you’re still there you will get a bounty on you

[boreal basalt]

When robbing a train shld I get rid of the conductor first

[tiny nymph]

Bandana covers your identity so when they report you it will suspect unknown

But if they arrive

And you’re still there

They know who you are

[magic kite]

also try wear different clothes and use different horse

[tiny nymph]

Doesn’t matter

[tiny nymph]

Clothes don’t matter

[magic kite]

ok then

[tiny nymph]

Unless it’s a town where you already have a bounty

And even then

I almost never got recognized with the same clothing

[hidden moss]

rob train in tunnel

[tiny nymph]

It doesn’t matter

[hidden moss]

no there a way to get no bounty

[tiny nymph]

You can drive the train btw

[boreal basalt]

yea

i shld get rid of conductor first

[tiny nymph]

Yeah using a bandana

[boreal basalt]

makes it so htat they cant stop the train

[hidden moss]

yea

[tiny nymph]

Then what is the tunnel idea for lol

[boreal basalt]

bruh all i get from a legendary buck is its trinket

[tiny nymph]

And pelt

[hidden moss]

there other way to make easy money

[boreal basalt]

isnt the pelt used to make the trinket

[tiny nymph]

Yeah it’s called using the gold glitch in 1.00

15k gold each time in less than 5 minutes

[tiny nymph]

The pelt is for the clothing

[hidden moss]

I dont know this one

[tiny nymph]

The trinket is for benefits

I believe the buck one is so that animals don’t rot in horseback

I might be mistaken with another animal

[tiny nymph]

Is your game on disk or digital

[hidden moss]

disk

[tiny nymph]

Then you can do it

That and the any horse glitch in chapter 2 for free

[boreal basalt]

how to use the pelt

[hidden moss]

ah ok

[tiny nymph]

You give it to a trapper

[boreal basalt]

idt i unlocked it yet

im at like mid chapter 2

[tiny nymph]

It’s already unlocked

[undone maple]

After hosea bear hunting should be open

[tiny nymph]

Which part of the map are you at right now I will tell you the nearest trapper

[tiny nymph]

It’s already open before

[boreal basalt]

valentine

[tiny nymph]

Grab a train ticket to Saint Denis

[hidden moss]

I did the gunslinger stranger mission and im at chapter one. I only went to 2 gunslinger but then I didnt have the other gunslinger photo. Is it a chapter 2 that I can do the others?

[tiny nymph]

There’s a trapper in it

[undone maple]

yah nere the black market

[tiny nymph]

You can’t do it in chapter 1

[boreal basalt]

@tiny nymph aigjt ty

[hidden moss]

I did

[undone maple]

chapter one is colter

[tiny nymph]

The gunslingers that drop the guns?

That’s chapter 2

[hidden moss]

maybe I made a mistake somewhere

[tiny nymph]

Have you left the snow region

[hidden moss]

its when arthur get in Valentine

[hidden moss]

yes

[tiny nymph]

That’s chapter 2

[undone maple]

yah

[hidden moss]

oh ok

[boreal basalt]

nah uk what

im too lazy to rob a train

[undone maple]

you met the guy call plato or sth right?

[hidden moss]

but I couldnt see the other gunslinger photo

[hidden moss]

yes in the sallon

[undone maple]

you can just buy a ticket in mail station

[tiny nymph]

You can do Black Belle, Emmet Granger, Flaco Hernandez

Calloway is only chapter 4

[hidden moss]

oh ok

[undone maple]

Also the midnight?

[tiny nymph]

Yes and midnight

Forgot about him

[undone maple]

besto pistol

[boreal basalt]

oh yea got any tips for a beginner

[hidden moss]

what kind of tips

[tiny nymph]

Don’t rush the story

Explore

And do side missions

[hidden moss]

yea

my 1st playtrough I rushed but when you explore and do side mission its cooler in my opion

[shell bluff]

hi

[hidden moss]

hello

[shell bluff]

so whats this discord about

[hidden moss]

rdr2

[shell bluff]

i know that but what can i all do here

[hidden moss]

chat

[shell bluff]

figured

[hidden moss]

post photo

[shell bluff]

i beat the game before i might do it again

[hidden moss]

post videos

[shell bluff]

so uh should i change my name to make it more you know rdr

or pfp

[tiny nymph]

Minecraft

[shell bluff]

im not stupid i know its about rdr2

[hidden moss]

if you want too

[tiny nymph]

My mistake it’s Roblox

[shell bluff]

i've beat the game before got all guns upgraded my horse got alot of clothes then i got bored

[hidden moss]

stop or Arthur will die of cringe

[hidden moss]

restart

[magic kite]

hmm robbing the bank with cracking code sure won't get bounty i guess

[tiny nymph]

I don’t doubt there’s an Arthur roblox skin

[shell bluff]

roblox sucks

[hidden moss]

he dead now may he rest in peace

[tiny nymph]

Go do everything in New Austin with Arthur

[magic kite]

that might look ugly

[shell bluff]

arthur would shoot roblox in face

if he wernt dead

[magic kite]

agreed

[shell bluff]

RIP Arthur may he have bad honor but good man still inside

and got TB

becuz of that stupid man

ok let me change name

[boreal basalt]

@tiny nymph ngl idk which are side missions

I just do all the yellow ones

[sleek granite]

Ppl have probs made ine

[tiny nymph]

It’s a white icon instead of yellow

I know some of them that are available in chapter 2

Albert Mason

Jack Hall

[boreal basalt]

Does it show on the map?

[tiny nymph]

Yes

If you go near it

[shell bluff]

nvm dont feel like changing it

[sleek granite]

What chapter does he get tb in?

[tiny nymph]

Do you remember the location where you first played poker? The mission you saved the Reverend from the train

[tiny nymph]

2

[sleek granite]

I'm in chapter 3 and he doesn't have it

[tiny nymph]

He does

[shell bluff]

like 4 or 5

i forget

[tiny nymph]

Arthur gets TB in chapter 2

It starts developing late chapter 4

[sleek granite]

I never got the cutcene

[sleek granite]

Oh makes more sense

[tiny nymph]

Thomas Downes spat in your face

[boreal basalt]

@tiny nymph yea

[shell bluff]

yeah

[sleek granite]

Oh ye

[tiny nymph]

A side mission is near there

[shell bluff]

becuz of stupid strauss

[boreal basalt]

Btw I cleared a gang hudeout for the pump action

But did it before the quest that was needed

For the pump action to appear

[sleek granite]

Frick Strauss, all my homies hate Strauss

[boreal basalt]

How do I get it now

[shell bluff]

if he wouldnt of sent arthur on that mission he would have lived

[tiny nymph]

Yes you can get some weapons before the missions

Lancaster, Pump etc

[shell bluff]

when the TB devlopes it gets sad

[sleek granite]

Yep

[shell bluff]

for poor arthur

[sleek granite]

I hope in the next red dead u play as jack or smthn

[tiny nymph]

I don’t want another Red Dead Redemption

And you already play as Jack

In RDR1

[sleek granite]

You play as John's kid in rdr1?

[tiny nymph]

Have you not played the campaign in RDR1?

[sleek granite]

M8 I don't own it

I should probs get it

[tiny nymph]

Seems I have the spoiling power in my hands

[fickle chasm]

yess you run around and cause havoc in your daycare

[sleek granite]

I don't care if u spoil my friend spoiled rdr2 instantly for me

[shell bluff]

dutch is betrayer

[sleek granite]

The second I got it he told me Arthur died

[shell bluff]

so is micah

[tiny nymph]

You do know who you play after him right?

[sleek granite]

Nope

[tiny nymph]

And who you play as in RDR1

[magic kite]

well got bounty still as 5$

[tiny nymph]

Bruh

[sleek granite]

U play as John in rdr1

I think

[shell bluff]

yeah

[tiny nymph]

Exactly

Now put 2 and 2 together

[sleek granite]

Fair

[shell bluff]

they might make rdr3 that would suck

[tiny nymph]

If the ever make another Red Dead

[sleek granite]

The off hand holster would be a pain to use irl

[tiny nymph]

It will not be called Redemption

[shell bluff]

it be called just red dead

[sleek granite]

They should just make it on the hip

[tiny nymph]

How? It makes you able to dual wield

[civic vault]

Red dead... dead lol

[shell bluff]

for how many people are dead and the floors are read

red'

[tiny nymph]

No they’d call it Red Dead something else like they did with Red Dead Revolver

[sleek granite]

Well yes but it's in an impractical placd

[tiny nymph]

The Redemption story can’t continue anymore

[shell bluff]

thats a game already

[tiny nymph]

Otherwise it’s milked

[tiny nymph]

That’s why I said “like they did with Red Dead Revolver”

[shell bluff]

im not lying i found it on the store randomly

[sleek granite]

They should put the gunbelt on the left side and then it would work

Or turn the off hand jokester around

[fickle chasm]

Undead Nightmare two when :(

[tiny nymph]

I’ve never been bothered by the holster

[shell bluff]

its Arthur

[tiny nymph]

Can you imagine Zombie Arthur

[fickle chasm]

😩🤩

[sleek granite]

Im not particularly but it should be like Dutch's holsters

[civic vault]

And you play as dutch

[sleek granite]

Then quick drawing would be so much easier

[civic vault]

And the zombie world is in his crazy head

[sleek granite]

How crazy does Dutch go?

[tiny nymph]

Pretty crazy

He’s in both games so you see his downfall

[sleek granite]

What does he do tho? It can't be that bad

Yet again it's dutch

[tiny nymph]

Leaves Arthur to die

[sleek granite]

Oh jesus

[tiny nymph]

And other stuff

Tried to kill John

Etc

[sleek granite]

And they didn't kill him?

[civic vault]

Well....

[tiny nymph]

He dies in the first game

[sleek granite]

Good

[tiny nymph]

You do know that RDR1 happens after RDR2 right

[sleek granite]

I do not

But I do now

He deserves to die

[tiny nymph]

RDR2 takes place in 1899 and 1907

RDR1 takes place in 1911 and 1914

[sleek granite]

When does online mod take place?

[tiny nymph]

1898

[fickle chasm]

Crazy enough to see his dead gang members as Zombies

[shell bluff]

hi

whats going on

[fickle chasm]

No idea brother

[shell bluff]

oh are we taking about dutch

say where does dutch go after micah dies

[fickle chasm]

He left you to die 😔

[shell bluff]

yep and everyone went on micahs team during the gun fight at the camp

leaving just us vs them

speaking of which where is dutch

is he on?

[hidden moss]

"We can't fight gravity"

-Dutch

[shell bluff]

dutch is a damn trader

traitor

'

[hidden moss]

Micah used him

in a way

[shell bluff]

but he left arthur and john

[hidden moss]

yes

[shell bluff]

or i should say me

[hidden moss]

at the start he was a good one

[sleek granite]

I like his revolvers ngl

[hidden moss]

yea

you can do it in the gun shop

[sleek granite]

Hkw

How

I need them

[shell bluff]

he's a damn traitor though along with Micah

[sleek granite]

Maybe a traitor

But got some goddamn smexy guns

[shell bluff]

he may have had a plan but he only came for the money leaving john and arthur behind along with the other dead memebers still a traitor like they say once a traitor always a traitor

[hidden moss]

customization in the shop, idk if rly precise but u can play with the customization and make it ressemble to the gun of dutch

[hidden moss]

yea

[sleek granite]

Do you know which revolvers they r tho

[hidden moss]

but Dutch was a good man before he has taken arthur as a child

orphan

he also taken john

[shell bluff]

he may have but still

[hidden moss]

wait a min

[tiny nymph]

He forms a gang with Native Americans

[hidden moss]

schofield revolver

@sleek granite

[shell bluff]

really? or you pulling my leg

[hidden moss]

no its true

[tiny nymph]

Have you not played RDR1

[hidden moss]

in rdr1

[shell bluff]

i have but not beaten it

[tiny nymph]

I am going to Kermit suicide

[shell bluff]

i was like a misson away from it

[hidden moss]

rip

[hidden moss]

ah ok

[sleek granite]

Ok, I assume with a Frick ton of customisations

[hidden moss]

no

like 5

parts I think

[shell bluff]

my dad actully beat it almost i just messed around ngl

[raw bronze]

There aren’t many customizations lol

[tiny nymph]

Lobster Scooby

[hidden moss]

@sleek granite

look dms

[raw bronze]

Yes

[shell bluff]

im back

[hidden moss]

hi

[shell bluff]

so what happende

[hidden moss]

stuff

I dont rmb

[shell bluff]

like what?

[hidden moss]

oh yeah

Dutch is a traitor

[shell bluff]

?

ill read back on messeges

[hidden moss]

ok

[shell bluff]

oh John Marston was here?

[hidden moss]

yes

[shell bluff]

cool

so i should go ill tell you guys if i find anything weird in rdr2

bye

[hidden moss]

ok bye

[hearty kindle]

is their any point of getting the legends of the east satchel in chapter 4?

[queen fossil]

I finally found the Cuttler Hat

[magic kite]

hmm i think know why sean die of the part

oh the spoiler symbol are unable to use here

also damn that braithwaith can just just go into giant boiling oil cooking pot

[unkempt latch]

Use the mark as spoiler discord feature

[magic kite]

huh???

arthur make up hmm still easy to look through it

[bleak charm]

Is there a way to fix the TAA/DLSS blur without using resolution scaling? It's driving me mad and is the reason why I've been playing the game without any AA whatsoever (which is also horrible but in a different way, more tolerable for me at least)

[merry widget]

Its ok

Apparently there is no problem discussing spoilers

[magic kite]

well it seems the gray kinda see arthur and sean somehow i guess

arthur barely keep joining them and helping them and both agaist all together

but braithwaith are the worst already

not let go even the child

someone forget save the game

errr

no symbol

otherwise they will block you

yup

ok

start from 0

even you know the whole story

nope

but i watched some spoiler

but kind forget a lot too

[candid arch]

same as GTA 5

[hidden moss]

Classic

[candid arch]

rockstar games when the main objective is to not create another story that involves betrayal

[keen tiger]

Hey got a question about horses. I tamed a wild horse, and before putting a saddle on or anything else I set up camp briefly to cook some food (forgot winter clothing) the camp moved my location a bit, and when I finished cooking the horse was gone. I checked stables nothing there, I assume I lost it?

[tacit bear]

where do i find bears

?

[keen tiger]

I did..no sign of it, just my old horse

[tacit bear]

the one used to make sadales

black bear

i think

[magic kite]

well funny

i just done the stole horse to sell

end up i meet them again otherside got the camper

mean camper so i shot him and grab his horse

and he don't want to buy the horse

for now

[small hedge]

Should I get red dead 1?

[keen tiger]

To find the horse again out in the wild is it best I save and relog or can I just sleep?

[small hedge]

Like what

It’s only $20

Ik but red dead 2 is $60

Dang

Well gl with that

[boreal basalt]

Anyone knows the order of legendary animals to hunt

Like which one ti get first etc

[small hedge]

I don’t think it matters but

Get the buck

The trinket is very good for hunting

[boreal basalt]

Got that already

Just got to go to the trapper and deal with the pelt

[small hedge]

Alr well get the alligator if you have it unlocked it gives some really nice clothes

[boreal basalt]

That's the only legendary animal I got do far

[small hedge]

You have to be in chapter 6 tho so

[boreal basalt]

I'm chapter 2 only

oh

[small hedge]

Ah

[boreal basalt]

LOL

HAHAHAH

@hidden moss oh that

I got raped

No cap

Bro slapped me once

And I died

[small hedge]

I killed it with a revolver lol

Idk how

[boreal basalt]

Bruh

I landed like 5 rifle shots on him and he didn't die

I panicked thinking wtf

Then he slapped me

[small hedge]

Just a normal cattleman revolver

After he grabbed me

[boreal basalt]

I was below

LOL

Rigjt after hosea

I went up

Bro saw le

I shot him 5 times

And he slipped me

Slapped

Btw is the pelt of the legendary buck good

Yea ik

[small hedge]

The bear clothes are pretty good

[small hedge]

Eh no

Idk the price

But

It just makes a vest

[boreal basalt]

So the bucks pelt isn't that good

Damn

[small hedge]

Worth it for the trinket

[boreal basalt]

Yea

@hidden moss how many chapters are there

In the game

Oh

So you finished the game first

[small hedge]

I’m in the epilogue and have almost all of them left

[boreal basalt]

I'm only at chapter 2

P new to thus

The travelling before I got fast travel was killing me

[small hedge]

Well gl because you got a looong way to go

[boreal basalt]

Coudlnt even get the pump action shotgun

[void perch]

Hunting is such a pain in the ass when you are looking for what you want

Can't find a bear

[keen tiger]

How Do I make the White Arabian spawn? I had it earlier but it vanished before I saddle it

I did that 3 times

nothing

do I need to go do a mission or something?

[hidden moss]

I got White Arabian almost every time i went for Flaco

[mortal bison]

I've gotten a problem currently im doing the mission An honest day's labors but right before John and Sadie is going to attack she just freezes and doesent say anything else just nothing I have tried multiple things and it just won't work if anyone could fix this is would make my day.

[hidden moss]

Device?

[mortal bison]

PC

I'm on steam

[blazing solstice]

I'm wanting to mod but needing help I'm trying to use Lenny's mod loader with mods from Nexus mods

[mortal bison]

You have to make sure that your using the right scripthook

[hidden moss]

Oh sorry i don't know anything about RDR2 on PC :/

[blazing solstice]

There's different ones?

[supple trout]

Move to DMs for that

[blazing solstice]

Ok

[supple trout]

Thanks 🙏

[hidden moss]

@mortal bison try to restart the mission

[mortal bison]

I've tried

But when I like go to die my game just loads and loads and loads so I have to close it

[hidden moss]

And you can not complete the mission?

with the bug?

[mortal bison]

Nope

its just stuck like that

nothing I can do

eh I think ima just restart the whole game but keep that save file

[hidden moss]

Try it

but careful to not delete whole progress

[glossy belfry]

they fucked up the "you, sir, are a fish" line in my language 😭

for me, they translated it as "my, my, what a fish"
it just doesn't hit the same

[hidden moss]

lol

Its like you would say You have a kind face,face kind punch kind

just

wtf

xd

But i love the rare line: You old battleaxe

[versed widget]

Did a stranger mission where some gansters stole a wagon from an "african american" (I don't want to be cancelled on discord) doctor. In the cutscene after the mission, the doc gave me a book, and when I "inspect document" after the cutscene, I'm reading a pamphlet?

[hidden moss]

I got it too.

I mean

Even the perfect game isn't perfect.

Orrr

you have the book in inventory

[versed widget]

inventory shows a pamphlet and no book

[red helm]

It's indeed just a pamphlet.

[versed widget]

I kinda miss GTA5's F1 menu (especially the quick GPS)

I have both GTA5 and RDR2 on Steam. Both game show the R* launcher for some time before the game appears, but RDR2 stays on the launcher for longer than GTA5? Why?

[hidden moss]

Uhm maybe the RDR2 is a lot younger than GTA 5 and have a more details and missions so it is more harder for PC to run it faster.

[versed widget]

So you mean when the launcher screen shows, it's loading the actual game instead of doing some social club weirdness? If that's the case then makes sense

[hidden moss]

Yep loading game

[glossy belfry]

i'm pretty sure the launcher is just doing social club stuff + denuvo doing its "thing"

[dire sentinel]

so i was saving someone, and when i fired at the odriscoll, the victim ran in front of the bullet

now im wanted

[candid arch]

ps3 arthur morgan

[dire sentinel]

why is the shop owner always like "you gonna buy something"

are u going to ignore the fact i just spent 200 dollars at your store

[civic vault]

Rofl

The rhodes general store owner is so impatient

When i bought a ton of gin he was like "I DONT HAVE ALL TIME"

Well, sorry sir, i just wanna get drunk

[bleak forge]

Rockstar really made the shop owners annoying cunts didn’t they

[austere prism]

I like the Valentine gunstore owner 👉 👈

[bleak forge]

Yuh

[civic vault]

Yeah he chill

The valentine general store owner is gossipy lol

[austere prism]

He feels like a cool uncle or something.

[civic vault]

The rhodes one is always rude. "Didnt know you could read" well excuuuse me sir.

[bleak forge]

I feel bad for the annesburg gun shop owner

[austere prism]

Gunstore owners seem to be the coolest.

Except the Rhodes one.

Me and my homies hate the Rhodes gunstore owner.

[civic vault]

The rhodes one i rescued the kid in his basement

[bleak forge]

He said “my pa got killed in this store when I was a boy” like sir I’m only here for ma bread roll

[civic vault]

Rofl

[bleak forge]

Truth

[dire sentinel]

i was buying cigarettes at rhodes for the mission, and i heard you get a discount on them not reputation-based so after i finished also made sure he was finished

[civic vault]

The st. Denis tailor likes to praise a lot lol

"That looks fiiine on you" lol

I chuckle

[bleak forge]

The blackwater tailor is rude

[civic vault]

Yeah, also impatient

[austere prism]

"Pardon my saying, but you look downright handsome in that."

[civic vault]

I havent gone there before. Im gonna try on my play later

[civic vault]

He got a thing for arthur

[austere prism]

And Marston.

[civic vault]

He got a thing for rugged men who wanna wear something nice lol

[bleak forge]

Facts

I just want online clothing in singleplayer

[austere prism]

Don't we all?

[civic vault]

Are there mods for clothes?

[bleak forge]

I want to wear Dutch’s outfit

[bleak forge]

Yea

On pc

I’m on ps unfortunately

[civic vault]

Ahhh

Im not into mods but id get the clothes one

Turning this game into sims lol

[bleak forge]

Ikr

😂

[civic vault]

I have sims 4 so later i might try to create an arthur sim lol

[halcyon lava]

Why is it so damn hard to 100%

[candid arch]

cause

big world

[civic vault]

Big and grindy world

[unique bluff]

Hiii

[civic vault]

Hello

[candid arch]

also lonely, but full of life

the nature is beautiful

[civic vault]

It does get a bit lonely. Sometimes i slow up the riding just to hear Arthur sing

[unique bluff]

I really need some help because I can’t seem to figure it out, but I can’t continue my story missions, i got my honor to max positive and max dishonorable i still can’t play them how come

[candid arch]

the Houser brothers really know how to make incredible stuff

[bleak forge]

What chapter u on

[civic vault]

Do you see any story icons on the map? The yellow ones?

[unique bluff]

No

[candid arch]

what chapter are you on?

[unique bluff]

Like none at all I haven’t even been able to play them for what like almost a few months already

[halcyon lava]

Hmm

[civic vault]

Or are they grayed out or locked?

[unique bluff]

I cant see them at all

They’re not on my map

[candid arch]

what. chapter. are. you. on.

thats the important part

maybe you're at Epilogue 2, maybe you finished the game

[unique bluff]

Hi sorry i dont know exactly i cant even remember but I already finished the horley missions like some past that and im rank 43 if tHat helps

[candid arch]

oh nvm rdo

[unique bluff]

No

I have both

Rdo and the full game

[candid arch]

you're talking about red dead online right