#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 581 of 1

dreamy oracle
#

Should I bring a kayak/boat to where the Legendary Gar (Lagras Legendary Fish) is or do I have to catch it from one of the distant islands

#

If you like fast horses it’s good @proud cipher

proud cipher
#

ok

dreamy oracle
#

Does anyone know if the saddles you can get materials for then buy from the trapper are better than the most expensive improved saddle from the Valentine stable + hooded stirrups?

proud cipher
#

is the money box destroyed after chapter 4?

#

so i can still use it in chapter 5 after guarma

#

@hidden moss

red helm
red helm
red helm
proud cipher
#

cuz i wanna spend all the camp funds @red helm

#

and i gotta know what chapter i got to do that by

red helm
#

You haven't bought all the upgrades?

proud cipher
#

no

#

i ahve

red helm
#

Buy yourself a Chicken Coop, what are you waiting on?

proud cipher
#

i wanna spend it on the rest of stuff

#

i buy food and ammo

#

spend it all

red helm
#

.... some more bullets?

#

Again, what are you waiting for?

proud cipher
#

what

#

i just wanna know when i have to spend cmap funds by

red helm
#

Do it.

#

The other gang members sure aren't going to toss Thousands of dollars into it. I promise you that.

proud cipher
#

yeah i know lol

#

pearson

#

bat wing

#

charels

#

a penny

#

arthur

#

3 million dollars

red helm
#

Exactly, Bill putting in a Squirrel Tail isn't going to get you much else. So, there is no reason to wait until later.

#

In my second play through, I actually ignored the camp funds after Chapter 3. Didn't donate nothing.

proud cipher
#

everytime i try to open fast travel menu it disappears?

#

do i lose anything except ammo when i go to guarma

#

and comeback

red helm
#

No. And I was joking about bullets. Because you'll be shooting them out of your gun.

proud cipher
#

ok

dreamy oracle
dreamy oracle
young mica
#

what missions gives you the most money? apart from the last mission because everytime i watch a video where the person is doing chapter 5, they have 15k+ cash

dreamy oracle
#

They might have done an infinite gold glitch if those exist

young mica
#

oh ok

#

but what mission gives the most money

dreamy oracle
#

1 gold bar sells for $500.00, I’d say the mission that gives the most money is either the Valentine Heist or the final train robbery in Chapter 6

young mica
#

i got 300 bucks for a gold bar

dreamy oracle
#

You got it from the Germany guy at the end of chapter 2, right?

young mica
#

yes

#

let me guess

#

its a walmart gold bar

dreamy oracle
#

Probably

young mica
#

bruh

dreamy oracle
#

You get the gold bars worth $500.00 from treasure hunts

young mica
#

how do i do treasure hunts

dreamy oracle
#

I can send you a link to a map that helps with this and tell you how to unlock treasure maps, is that fine with you?

young mica
#

sure

edgy kraken
young mica
#

nice

edgy kraken
#

Can't remember the exact location though

young mica
#

its ok

edgy kraken
#

What chapter are you in?

fluid cypress
#

It all goes to Dutch your share is 0

#

for my last boy as well

proud cipher
#

@fluid cypress

#

never knew that

#

why did it all go to dutch?

glad brook
#

Some of it went to John's family.

dreamy oracle
#

Wait are you talking about the military train robbery or the one where Arthur can’t attend because he’s probably unconscious somewhere so they do it without him

fluid cypress
# dreamy oracle The one where John falls off

Yeah the last one I don’t think you get any money from that. Also in My Last Boy the gang gets a lot of money, after the mission it says total take but Arthur’s share is 0 the whole thing is gang share

fluid cypress
#

i don’t remember

dreamy oracle
#

I remember there was some moment in the game where Arthur passed out and shortly afterwards I got a notification about Gang Share, Arthur got $0

fluid cypress
#

Yeah that was in my last boy

#

They got money from the bonds

#

Dutch left Arthur to die

#

inadvertently caused eagle flies’s death

#

He didn’t go unconscious tho

proud cipher
#

help

#

im in chapter 4

#

and the pearson crafting thing and donate is always locked

hidden moss
#

Guys

#

Can some one answer my question?

#

Can i get a horse like Buell

#

In stranger missions

#

Like Hamish one

fickle chasm
hidden moss
#

I can get in John?

trail tapir
#

yeah

#

the missouri fox trotter

#

i have it rn

fickle chasm
hidden moss
#

Ok where is it?

#

I will get

trail tapir
#

its the best horse u can get as arthyur

hidden moss
#

Wait is it that photografer guy

trail tapir
#

unless you have an arabian fetish

hidden moss
trail tapir
hidden moss
#

I have that horse

trail tapir
#

its a joke

#

nvm

hidden moss
#

Like grey and white

#

What the

#

@trail tapir

trail tapir
#

check media channel

#

ill send u the vid

hidden moss
#

I can’t get the Red Chesnut Arabian

#

It doesn’t spawns

#

Do you know why?

trail tapir
#

What chapter r u in?

hidden moss
#

@trail tapir

#

I finished the game

trail tapir
#

idk then

hidden moss
#

I’m in John

trail tapir
#

are you going to the right place

hidden moss
#

Yes

#

Oliwanjua

#

Lake

trail tapir
#

idk then

hidden moss
#

I can get the White Arabian but not Warped and Chesnut

#

Maybe it’s about my jailbreaked ps4

void perch
#

What's the best horse?

frigid cloud
#

none

trail tapir
#

I put a video on how to get it in the media channel

#

You can get it in chapter 2

sinful echo
#

I learned something new

trail tapir
#

With a glitch

young mica
#

how much honour does arthur need in order to die peacefully instead of getting shot by micah

trail tapir
#

Just above half

sinful echo
#

And choose to Help John Flee

young mica
#

well im in chapter 6 and im slightly below half

#

any idea on how to raise honour quick

trail tapir
#

Greet everyone

young mica
#

wait nvm ill just do the gold glitch and donate 21 dollars to the camp

trail tapir
#

donate to any beggars

young mica
#

i have greeted 50 people today and i only got my honour raised once

sinful echo
#

Early in the Game Chores on the Campsite help aswell

young mica
sinful echo
#

Until you leave Shady Belle

young mica
#

yeah

#

.

#

can you even donate anymore after you leave shady belle?

sinful echo
#

No

#

You cant do donations in Beaver Holloe

young mica
#

well im screwed

sinful echo
#

Talk to people help strangers

#

Thats how i did it

young mica
#

ok

lyric zephyr
#

Any greet after the first one wont count towards the honor increase

young mica
#

do you mean I'll have to great everyone in saint denis?

#

every single person?

lyric zephyr
# young mica what do you mean

The fact you greeted 50 ppl and it only went up once obviously means you were greeting them by pressing greet more than once

young mica
#

oh

#

oh ok then

young mica
#

Does the gold glitch still work?

#

I’ve tried two different methods but it doesn’t work anymore

#

Are there other methods?

civic vault
#

Finally finished survivalist challenge 6

#

Such a grind to hunt scavangers

frigid cloud
frigid cloud
young mica
#

ok

shut tinsel
#

Like at the start of the chapter u can

civic vault
#

i just found out there's a way to get a turkoman early .___.

#

I should've known lol

frigid cloud
shut tinsel
#

Bcs someone smashes the box

#

It's abigail stealing from it I'm pretty sure

fickle chasm
shut tinsel
#

Nah bcs I swear Arthur tells John to do it and then u can find him telling abigail to do it when ur in camp

#

I'd try and find a vid of it but this server is annoying and doesn't allow links

young mica
#

what do you do with gold tooths

#

i just looted 4 gold tooths from a dead body during a random encounter

civic vault
young mica
#

ok

civic vault
#

I feel like in my current playthrough i did the timing wrong

#

Ah well 3rd playthrough is better i guess

fluid cypress
#

idk who told you that lol

civic vault
#

And the money chest got broken before that part

fluid cypress
civic vault
#

And i got my satchels pretty late

#

Ah well

#

And i got into the challenges late as well 😩

#

No wonder people are in their 10th playthrough lol

restive trout
#

I know it'd be weird but it'd be insanely cool if rockstar went and updated RD1 to add arthurs hat

queen fossil
#

I miss a lot of the early things in my current playtrough

young mica
#

bro wtf...

#

i think i just found a weird glitch

#

if you carry a pelt and try to stow it on your horse but something is blocking your way, arthur will go around the object but if you whistle, Arthur will literally throw the pelt onto the horse and get flinged nearby

#

i wish i recorded it but it was so random

#

yep it happened again

fluid cypress
civic vault
slate bloom
#

Arthur

hidden moss
#

How to unlock fishing?

queen fossil
#

You need to unlock the fishing rod

hidden moss
#

How to unlock it?

civic vault
#

You gotta go fishing with Jack

hidden moss
fickle chasm
civic vault
#

You gotta talk to Abigail. And she asks you to take Jack fishing.

hidden moss
#

Or the quest from Mary Linton?

civic vault
#

I can't remember, but maybe it'll pop in the map after you hunt bear with Hosea

hidden moss
#

Ima just play missions and have fun and hopefully fishing will appear after some time

civic vault
#

I don't think it's a missable mission so you shouldnt worry

subtle hull
#

To new players who are hunting legendary animals: always remember to manually save before hunting for the animal so incase you don't get a good kill, you can load back to try again... I have learned that the hard way... (this also applies to online... I think...)

frigid cloud
#

completely false, you can kill legendary animals with whatever you want

subtle hull
hidden moss
hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

^

subtle hull
civic vault
#

Yeah i used a shotgun on the legendary ram and it still got perfect pelt

hidden moss
frigid cloud
#

if u run over a deer when it's perfect, it'll ruin it but legendary animals are different

lyric zephyr
fickle chasm
mystic raven
civic vault
tribal ember
tribal ember
chilly dune
#

Are explosive arrows effective vs humans?

zinc remnant
#

yez

#

Normal arrows just one shot soo

#

ya

chilly dune
#

Where can I get these feathers for crafting? Like for upgraded arrows?

zinc remnant
#

Make a camp then you'll see the crafting items needed for that

#

arrows

primal osprey
#

what beardstyle do yall use?

zinc remnant
#

you need arrow pamphlets for crafting arrows

fluid cypress
mellow sage
#

What's the "best" talismans to have, after getting the "easy" ones with the Bison and the seashell thingie? Based on difficulty in obtaining...

mellow sage
# zinc remnant you need arrow pamphlets for crafting arrows

You don't need pamphlets to craft arrows, but you do need pamphlets to craft poison arrows... and DYNAMITE arrows. Dynamite arrows tend to reduce the quality of pelts, though, and though it kills both guys on wagons you want to steal, it tends to blow them up with the guys riding on the wagons... so they are hard to sell too.

mellow sage
# chilly dune Where can I get these feathers for crafting? Like for upgraded arrows?

I found a spot north of Saint whatever by the alligators that I use for feathers, cause you kill an alligator and the birds try to feed on it, and then you blow away the birds trying to feed on it, and you pluck them and then more birds try to feed on the alligator and the dead birds, and I blow them away...
Switch to a varmint rifle after you kill the alligator that seem not to ever move while on land...

mellow sage
dreamy oracle
#

You’ll find the most birds in Bayou Nwa and the surrounding area

hidden moss
#

I honestly kinda liked cleet from ch 6

#

Will I after some time complete all bounties in story and bounty posters will stop spawning?

sick jungle
#

Hey there just a quick question! I’v not long started the game and I want to try collect all the clothing and weapons. Is the list on the wiki all I need to worry about or is there anything anyone knows that I should watch out for? Thank you

#

I should say list of missables on the wiki!

hidden moss
dreamy oracle
#

These are weapons only obtainable during freeroam not missions

fickle chasm
#

mission limited weapons can only be found then

#

the others around the world are always there i tihnk

dreamy oracle
#

Adding on to what @fickle chasm said, these guns will appear yellow on the map instead of white

hollow tree
#

The Albert Mason mission popped up on my way up north to tame a horse

#

Is it long?

#

I dont wanna go back across the map again lmao

dreamy oracle
#

Can you refresh my memory about who Albert Mason is again?

hollow tree
#

I dont have a damn clue who he is

#

His mission just appeared on the map

dreamy oracle
#

I knew he’s a collectible side quest character but I’m not sure which one

#

Hang on I’ll search it up

#

No his missions aren’t long

#

It’s Wildlife Photography missions all you have to do is either get the animals in range of the camera or protect him

dreamy oracle
#

He only has about 5 or 6 missions to do

#

The last one isn’t even a mission it’s just a cutscene

hollow tree
#

Multiple?

#

Yeesh

#

Ill hit him up after i get my horse

dreamy oracle
#

Never buy fast travel just ride your horse from Armallio to Van Horn

chilly bramble
#

Hey , I gotta question

#

I used cheats yesterday and it didn’t let me save. I’m fine with that because now I want the save file I’m using to be for getting achievements

#

But idk if I can get achievements anymore cause I used cheats

#

Though they didn’t save

#

Anyone know if I can still get achievements?

dreamy oracle
#

I don’t think you can get achievements in the save file you cheated on

hollow tree
#

Can you hunt bison with a bow cus i found a legendary white bison

chilly bramble
#

Thanks for the help

proud cipher
#

for zoologist do i need to study every animal

dreamy oracle
#

It’ll be better to ask a mod about this, I haven’t used cheats before but I’ve read some of the stuff others answered when people asked this question @chilly bramble

proud cipher
#

or can i just skin them

dreamy oracle
proud cipher
#

and kill them

#

oh

dreamy oracle
#

Well

proud cipher
#

what

dreamy oracle
#

You can go for Zoologist (study every animal) and a different achievement you get for skinning every animal

proud cipher
#

ok

#

but i cant get zoologist just by killing the animal and skinning it?

dreamy oracle
#

I think you can but it says to get zoologist you have to Study the animal not skin it

proud cipher
#

ok

#

i cannot find the rainbow boa snake

dreamy oracle
#

It might be on Guarma

proud cipher
#

it is

#

but

#

i am on guarma

#

but cant f ind

dreamy oracle
#

Oh

proud cipher
#

is there anything to explore on guarma

#

like stuff to get

#

in the fort or la cappila

#

la capilla

mellow sage
#

I can't remember how on PC I can trigger dead eye without holding a weapon, so I can select everyone to shoot dead before they realize it...

hollow tree
#

How far should i search around Lake Isabella for the white arabian? I saw one while hunting a bison but i have no clue where it is now

proud cipher
#

why wont this snake spawn

#

the rainbow boa snake

mellow sage
#

If it's the legendary snake, you trigger the hunt? Idr if there even is a legendary snake (!)

mellow sage
hollow tree
#

Like, in game white out blindness?

mellow sage
#

I'm still trying to get good with lassoing again before I blow my chance to get that horse... I still suck...

mellow sage
#

But there's no game mech for snowblindness.

hollow tree
#

Maybe I missed it cus im a dunce but no it’s probably not white out

mellow sage
#

Also I've missed things right in front of me when I've tunnel visioned while being overwhelmed by complexity... so there's that too.

hollow tree
#

Right

#

So i just go back to the camp and come back after i slept for 72 hours?

mellow sage
#

...and sight distance you have the game set at... unless xbox doesn't have that option, idk.

I think sleeping is the best option, imo.

#

I think it's a general rule for the game, if something doesn't spawn, sleep 3 days come back. I think it takes 3 days for herbs to respawn too.

proud cipher
#

INVIS

#

snipper

#

ON

#

GUARMA
]

#

WHY

#

you cant go anywhere

mellow sage
#

All I know is Guarma thing has been talked about alot... don't know why though.

proud cipher
#

because sniper

#

am on guarma

#

trying to find

#

rainbow boa snake

hollow tree
#

Fuck

#

I gotta go all the way back down to rhodes

proud cipher
#

why

hidden moss
#

so in the who the hell is cornwall do the headshots re set if i die?

fickle chasm
#

GUys i can't get the high stakes treasure map jump any advice?

#

Got it nvm

vale heart
#

I remember in one of those camp conversations the foreshadowing between Dutch and Arthur is kind of like revealing the ending moment before completing all chapters.

#

I was shocked by Dutch's thoughts.

hollow tree
#

Question

#

So while im on the horse trying to tame it (white arabian)

#

Do i just keep pressing the button to calm it?

vale heart
#

Yes

hollow tree
#

Making sure cus its taking a minute

#

Okay it threw me off

#

I was on for a long time

vale heart
#

Idk I remember when I want to tame Andalusian so I went to Roanoke and it spawned near waterfalls and then I mounted it and kept pressing calm button and it worked

vale heart
hollow tree
vale heart
#

Oh maybe a bug

#

Have you encountered any bugs on xbox version before? @hollow tree

hollow tree
#

I got it

hollow tree
#

Well i think i mightve found a bug, one time it kept pathfinding in between some rocks it couldnt pass through but thats about it

vale heart
gleaming whale
#

woah

dreamy oracle
hollow tree
#

Idk

#

Ive never played rdr1

onyx cliff
#

Hi

#

If I sell a perfect pelt to the butcher, that won’t count towards Pearson or the trapper right

queen fossil
#

Yes

onyx cliff
#

ok

queen fossil
#

If you have a perfect pelt sell them always to pearson and the Canadian

onyx cliff
#

so theres no reason for the butcher

#

he odnt give me anything

queen fossil
#

No he don't

#

Is not even profitable

onyx cliff
#

Am I the only one who inspects every creature to see if it’s 3 stars lol

#

Even if I’m doing something else

narrow quest
#

Is there a glitch to kill micah

frigid cloud
#

finish the game

knotty grove
#

not at all

pale coyote
narrow quest
#

On the second playthrough all I do is run over micah

ember marsh
#

I have a $150 dollar bounty. How can I get rid of it without paying it off? Also I have a bounty wanted dead or alive. Can I get rid of that without finishing the game?

lyric zephyr
pale coyote
red helm
mellow sage
#

I can't find silver earrings for the Bison talisman (not the late game Titicaca one)... I have to rob trains or something?

red helm
# mellow sage I can't find silver earrings for the Bison talisman (not the late game Titicaca ...

I actually had a heck of a time with those too. If you don't want a Horrible bounty/honor lose. Go to the Station north of Strawberry(Wallace?), it's like south of the Grizzlies. It should have a general store and stuff attached to it as well. But there is normally a couple of rich people standing around waiting for a train. If it's 1-2 ladies, Rob them. But since there is no law around, after you rob, you can ride away real quick, until the "Attracting Law" redness goes away, and then Ride back and rob the new Rich people that spawned, if you rode far enough away.

#

Repeat, over and over, until you get a Silver Earring.

mellow sage
#

k, tyvm, because I was gonna try to time a train going thru a tunnel, cause the cops can't find you in the tunnel, if you stop the train before the tunnel ends... but you still lose honor, cause I'm just gonna shoot them instead of waiting for the oh, don't kill meh animations... I don't got the time...

red helm
#

Yeah, I was tempted to do that as well, but, I tried the Station thing first. Way easier, and the people respawn if you ride far enough away.

mellow sage
#

k, tyvm

#

I've tried 3x already to talk to abigal in the morning with her son playing around her, and it still is not triggering the fishing quest...

#

I suspect I have to save Micah first, and I hate that guy.

red helm
#

Does she have the mission there?

mellow sage
#

Not yet. I thought it was a dialogue trigger...

red helm
#

Hrm... Did you read the letter that Mary Linton sent you?

mellow sage
#

I just did that, I think it's her, I would have to double check, and I had to read and take a book too for something.

#

I didn't do that quest if it's to go see her, cause I remember IIRC it's a trap...

red helm
#

Hrm... I know people have put off rescuing Micah until Chapter 3, so I don't think that is it..

red helm
mellow sage
#

I'm starting to get better with deadeye, so it won't matter if it's a trap or not, so I'll do the other quests, but one in is a red zone, the Je marker... I'm not going there atm, given I don't like making my life harder, unless I have to do so. When I went there by accident there were cops all over the place, but I escaped.

red helm
mellow sage
#

hmmm, ok... I will prepare to die...

red helm
#

Nah, You'll be okay, if you go the 'sneaky' route.

mellow sage
#

k, I'll try it now... Idc about the Legendary Bison hunt over this quest... there's something Je gives IIRC that's good ... eventually.

red helm
#

Je?

mellow sage
#

That's what it looks like on the map, Idr the guy's name...

#

Javier

#

something

red helm
#

Well, if that's what the marker is down south of Strawberry, then, yeah that would be Javier. Odd they would choose Je, though.

minor jolt
#

It's JE because his last name is Escuela and J is for John's missions so

red helm
#

Oh! Right, right, duh... I was going with JaviEr for some reason....

mellow sage
#

Well, I got there no issues, cause cops are dumb in games too (!)

#

I'm retired FDNY EMS...

red helm
mellow sage
#

The stuff I could share, while at the same time knowing ppl would call bs on me, so I don't... Overall, the stalking death and disability was cool, the actual danger, no so much. I am always a fighter, so I channeled it that way, given even with my adv degree I would NOT be a weaponeer, no matter the money.

#

None of the bounty hunters wore silver ear rings... nor had that special watch...

red helm
#

Why would Bounty Hunters have silver earrings?

mellow sage
#

Cause I need them? ...and I've been watching so many woke media things I'd expect them to be wearing ear rings... even though ear rings IIRC were ways to show ownership of ppl to traders... but ppl wear ear rings all the time now, forget about history, no problemo.

#

Like cows get those tags in the ears?

red helm
#

Ha... umm, sure, sure...

mellow sage
#

Usually if I need something, they are removed like rabbits if I'm riding with a varmint rifle...

red helm
#

That is for mission/challenge's, usually, yeah. I think the Earrings and other items for crafting is just a oddness, other people I've talked to didn't have any troubles with that.

mellow sage
#

k, we will see. I'll assume the best until unable to get/do something for a long time.
I can't figure out how much eating will get him "average" weight...

#

I've been eating all the small animal meat... still not enough, like 6x/day.

#

I wonder if traveling even if fast traveling somehow affects your weight... idk.

red helm
mellow sage
#

k, let me check now, I just "woke up."

#

oh crap, I'm average, yay.

red helm
#

It's not very logically, so if you are the sort of person to go long periods without doing a cutscene, you'll never actually get a weight change...

mellow sage
#

In the Deadeye screen of Arthur's I can't find what "Undiscovered Perks" relate too. I thought one of my talismans which I can't find the screen for on PC... affects dead eye... the fox (well maybe a trinket...)

#

Wait, I found "equipment"

#

Yeah I have the fox claw trinket that increases time that oh, that eagle eye can stay active... ffs.

red helm
mellow sage
#

hmmm, ok, I'm just trying to front load things as much as possible...

#

So those undiscovered perks open from main mission quests only?

red helm
mellow sage
#

k, I didn't notice either my first play thru.

hidden moss
#

Wat animal is east to north east of the wallace fort

onyx cliff
#

this gam e is amazing

dire sentinel
#

//

#

oops

tight sundial
#

Hey Guys, anyone playing on PC have experience dealing with the 'Activation Error: Your Social Club account is not entitles to Red Dead Redemption 2." error? I've only been able to run the game twice since I got it, get this error every time. Bought game on Steam, tried troubleshooting w Rockstar support, zero help.

proud cipher
#

what chapter is there more bounty missions in

fiery turtle
#

Epilogue, once you've beat the game.

proud cipher
#

you guys know

#

in lakay

#

before the mission that ends chapter 5

#

you can see dutch is going crazy

#

he keeps repeating himself

#

"black to f3"

#

"bishop to g2"

#

unless my game glitched lol

onyx cliff
#

my friend has a problem - when he streams his red dead to discord, the audio doesnt go through for him

#

does anyone know a solution

#

when he doesnt stream its fine

minor jolt
civic vault
dire sentinel
#

does anyone know if you have to do herbalist 9 if youve already picked up all plants beforehand

tight sundial
# solemn saddle I bought it on epic

Are you letting me know it works better on Epic? I mainly bought it on steam to save $30 on a sale but every time I try and launch the game I get that error

solemn saddle
#

Yep got it on my PC on epic, works really.well

civic vault
#

That's weird. Some people bought it on Steam and it works well, even better because you can play offline. I guess i made the right decision to just buy the activation key

proud cipher
#

i hate chapter 6

#

its so depressing

#

the ccamp too

#

how many animals can you only discover as john

remote flower
#

I'm attempting to reach the Tumbleweed general store as Arthur in Ch. 2

#

any tips?

proud cipher
#

yeah

#

good

#

luck

#

invisable sniper go brr

remote flower
#

I'm trying the carcass strategy

#

but the lawmen keep following me

#

If I manage to find a route where the lawmen don't follow me, I think I can evade the sniper

fickle chasm
dreamy oracle
remote flower
#

But like, how can I use it

dreamy oracle
#

It protects against invisible snipers

#

But wagons can break down

#

NPC bodies work better than animal carcasses by the way, gotta go, I want be able to answer any of your questions for a short while so you might be able to ask Ranava

proud cipher
#

@dreamy oracle

#

do you know how many animals that only john can study and kill

remote flower
dreamy oracle
#

Basically everything in New Austin @proud cipher

remote flower
#

Just one quick question, any covered wagon works?

proud cipher
#

i have 34 undiscovered animals

#

6 would be legendary

#

so

#

28

#

animals

dreamy oracle
dreamy oracle
remote flower
dreamy oracle
proud cipher
#

there is a proghorn

dreamy oracle
proud cipher
#

a cougar

#

and soemthing else

#

plus 3 legendary fish

remote flower
dreamy oracle
#

A cougar, a bison, and something else

proud cipher
#

cougar bison proghorn

#

3 legendary fish

dreamy oracle
remote flower
dreamy oracle
#

Trying making it flee before calling it once you get to New Austin and stock up on Potent/Special Horse and Human tonics

dreamy oracle
#

Gotta go now, bye everyone

remote flower
#

see ya, thanks again

proud cipher
#

holy fuck

#

the legendary gator is massive

red helm
dire sentinel
#

i havent played rdr2 in so long bro

red helm
dire sentinel
#

i forgot how to open up the challenges tab

proud cipher
#

@red helm

#

do you know why arthur is not geting pasted level 8 for stamina health and dead eye

#

i need max each level

#

why am i wanted dead or alive on such a huge chunk of the right side of mpa

fickle chasm
hearty kindle
#

so...

#

I really want to have all of the cool stuff as Arthur

#

and I was wondering

fickle chasm
hearty kindle
#

if I can get the earliest version of the game

hearty kindle
#

yeah ik

#

but

#

is it possible to get the earliest version of the game

fickle chasm
hearty kindle
#

pirate?

#

i heard u can just delete the application on ps4

fickle chasm
hearty kindle
#

then download it without any updates

fickle chasm
hearty kindle
#

yeah

fickle chasm
#

well then idk

hearty kindle
#

lol

#

oh

#

i couldnt see the PC

#

next to ur name

#

lol

fickle chasm
#

ig get the ps4 role and go to ps4 support chat

hearty kindle
#

?

#

oh

#

ok

#

thanks

fickle chasm
#

npp

gloomy warren
#

After completing the story as Arthur, is there a way to get his previously owned horses?

#

Like the horses you had stabled through the game

gloomy warren
#

ah bummer, thanks! i didn’t think so 😩

remote flower
#

god I'm so frustrated right now, I just can't get it to work

dreamy oracle
dreamy oracle
#

@red helm quick question, is there a way to steal a steamboat in Story mode? Besides this am I supposed to have the version of dead-eye that highlights fatal areas? I’m still in Chapter 3

dreamy oracle
remote flower
dreamy oracle
#

Anyways, for the people who want the version of Dead Eye that marks an X and auto fires, whilst in dead eye and aiming at an enemy/animal without using a rifle, you can press RB (Xbox) to get that X back but it only works when you click it and are aiming at any enemy in dead eye

hidden moss
#

Guys

#

I need help

#

For ps4

#

RDR2

#

Help

#

Red Chesnut Arabian does not spawns

#

I beat the game

#

I’m with John

dreamy oracle
#

Are you exactly where it appears?

hidden moss
#

Yes

#

Near olşwanjua

dreamy oracle
#

Have you encountered it before?

hidden moss
#

owanjila*

hidden moss
#

I didn’t even see her/him

dreamy oracle
#

Try going back to this exact location after sleeping in-game #red-dead-media

hidden moss
#

I can get the White Arabian and Grey Bay ones but not Warped and Red one i can’t get Warped Brinde Arabian and Red Chesnut Arabian

dreamy oracle
#

Where can I find the Grey Bay ones?

hidden moss
#

I meant i bought from Blackwater

dreamy oracle
#

Oh

hidden moss
#

I don’t think you can find

dreamy oracle
#

I’d just steal the Arabian horse from the Blackwater Stables but the Grey Arabian horses can’t cost that much right?

hidden moss
#

It cost 1150$ but if you finish the hole game it makes 987$

dreamy oracle
#

Oh I thought it would be less than $599.00

hidden moss
#

No no

#

It’s the best Arabian

dreamy oracle
#

Oh

hidden moss
#

At 4 Bond level all circles are full

#

I can send u a pic if you want

dreamy oracle
#

Oh I definitely need that horse

#

I always thought the best Arabian was the white one near Lake Isabella

hidden moss
#

And by the way i can’t find the Perlino Andulasian (idk how to write that name)

hidden moss
#

like*

#

But the games best horse is Missiouri Fox Trotter

dreamy oracle
#

Never heard of that one with that name but I have seen an Andulasian horse and cigarette card before

hidden moss
#

Hmm

#

Wait let me get the Gray Bay Arabians pic for you

dreamy oracle
#

You’ll find a lot of horses Northwest of Emerald Ranch, I’ve encountered some pretty good horses South of the Legendary Ram and the Andulasian may have been one of them

hidden moss
#

Wait lemme send the Andulasians pic on your dm

dreamy oracle
#

Oh sorry I confused Andulasian with Appaloosa

hidden moss
#

Let’s talk şn dm

dreamy oracle
#

Quick question for anyone who’s completed Gambler 4, do I just wait until someone leaves the table or is there more than just that?

proud cipher
dreamy oracle
#

Less than most, congrats

proud cipher
#

i just use springfiled and dead eye

#

hit it like 6 times in ehad

#

head

dreamy oracle
#

I’m planning on using every kind of arrow to kill it

#

The explosive arrow would probably kill it in the first hit

proud cipher
#

small arrows vs legendary gator

#

good

#

luck

dreamy oracle
#

I’ll record it to see how it goes, I might as well use the arrows since I just completed Survivalist 4 where you have to craft one of every arrow and I still have a ton of flight feathers after killing 15 Heron Birds in Bayou Nwa

#

Where can I get a Litchfield Repeater?

proud cipher
#

can someone explain to me why the repeating shotgun is locked in the gun store but i own it?

ancient sigil
#

Picked it up somewhere probably @proud cipher

young mica
#

what happens if you get caught with a dead or alive bounty?

#

are you going to lose all your money?

#

I have killed 50 lawmen and they wont stop coming

civic vault
#

From my experience either the law will kill you if you don't surrender early enough

civic vault
#

Hmmmm I'm not sure

#

Maybe

#

it's been a while since i was caught

young mica
#

in that case ill just keep fighting off the law until i die

civic vault
#

I hate survivalist 7, the squirrels are suddenly hiding from me

young mica
#

lmao

#

oh well, I finally died after killing about 60-70 law men

#

I just lost 10 bucks

#

not bad

proud cipher
#

howcome i am wanted dead or alive on right side of map in chapter 5

civic vault
#

that's cheap for all the fun lol

proud cipher
#

6*

young mica
young mica
#

and the pinkertons are after you

proud cipher
#

@young mica i meant chapter 6

young mica
#

Yes

#

That's the reason

#

They're still after you because you robbed the bank lmao

civic vault
#

I need a chicken pen with 6 chickens

#

where can i find one?

#

Tip for those who need people to kill for challenges without losing honor, go to Hanging Dog ranch. Kill dem O'Driscolls. They always respawn.

frigid cloud
#

emerald ranch

frozen horizon
#

How can i do sharpshooter 8 quickly?

young mica
civic vault
#

lol

blissful orbit
#

I think i never saw a horse as coward and dumb as Rachel

#

She is litteraly scared of every animals and gunfights she die and fall insanely easily and she don't even have a high endurance

young mica
#

Quick question: Where can you buy an arabian? Mine just got ran over by a train

blissful orbit
#

holy

#

Saint denis i think

#

for the black one

#

white one is in the wild around lake isabella

young mica
blissful orbit
#

yes

#

and the last one

#

the red chesnut is around owanjila

young mica
#

Oh ok thanks for the help

young mica
#

got ran over by a train

blissful orbit
#

normaly there is a second spawn for the red chesnut

#

but idk where

#

lemme check

young mica
#

couldn't find it

blissful orbit
#

Okay i checked there is no 2 chesnut but there is another one a warped brindle around wapiti

civic vault
#

I sold my white Arabian. Goodbye Snowflake

young mica
#

Damn. An Arabian sure is expensive

civic vault
#

Yep

#

and such a tiny horse lol

#

put me off lol

blissful orbit
#

Guys the murfees shot my horse with some kind of shotgun and now he is going crazy

#

idk what they shot him with but it's weird and it looks painful

#

BRUH

#

Just got jumpscared

#

omg

#

in rdr2 fr

#

there was a trap that's why my horse was crazy

young mica
#

What?....

young mica
blissful orbit
#

yeah

young mica
#

I don't think there are jumpscares in rdr2, just creepy enemies

blissful orbit
#

there was murfees that shot me so i killed them

#

but then

#

my horses acted weird

young mica
#

I've never seen that before

blissful orbit
#

and i walked and suddenly i fell in a trap and john did a loud scream

blissful orbit
#

no

young mica
#

Oh ok

blissful orbit
#

but just like it was unexpected

#

almost had an heartattack

young mica
#

Is your horse scared?

blissful orbit
#

yes

young mica
#

Calm it

blissful orbit
#

ik i just did

young mica
#

Well then I don't know what to do

#

try feeding it\

#

brushing it

#

patting it

#

maybe it will stop it from acting weird

thick pewter
#

Is the bank robbery mission the last one in chapter 2?

young mica
#

Wait no

thick pewter
#

Ty

young mica
#

You still have to move to clemens point

#

I think I'd consider that a mission

#

There's 1 or 2 missions after the bank robbery

fallow sandal
#

I’ve moved on from Clemens point now

fickle chasm
#

Anyone know how to get honor fast

young mica
#

greet everyone you see

#

donate 21 dollars to the camp as donating more than 20 dollars gives you more honour

young mica
#

kick out strauss as that gives you alot of honour

young mica
#

well just release fish

fickle chasm
#

ok lmao

young mica
#

greet everyone

#

make good decisions

#

help people out in random encounters

#

those are probably the only things you can do to raise honour since you're john and not arthur anymore

onyx cliff
#

so the point of giving pelts to pearson is for crafting

#

will it tell me if i dont need to sell a skin if theres no available crafting upgrades that inculde it?

frigid cloud
#

nah won't

onyx cliff
#

damn

#

theres so many updgrades hard to keep track

fickle chasm
thick pewter
#

Anything bad happen if I kill the bounties whilst they are in there cell

#

As in do I need them for anything

high needle
#

I never tried that, but maybe if you kill them, the scenarios with them getting hanged etc. will not play or the second option would be that it would play either way because the devs didn't think about that.

I honestly don't know, this is my opinion and I never tried that.

frigid cloud
#

you can kill them but I don't know if it'll change anything later on but you can save them or let them get hanged

onyx cliff
#

wait.. do i have to keep the pelts in order to use them for crafting

#

or does pearson keep my donations

#

ah he does

#

thank god

thick pewter
#

I've never seen them hanged

#

I got Baker guy when I was Arthur and I'm now john hes still not been hanged

fluid cypress
#

weird glitch i encountered, when opening the basement doors to the serial killer (in american dreams i think it was?) the doors open, but theres more doors under it for some reason

thick pewter
#

How do I put the x on people with dead eye

fluid cypress
#

r1

#

wait u didnt know how to do that

#

bruh

#

i thought you were like

#

long time player

#

or something

#

rb on xbox

thick pewter
#

I just never really used dead eye

thick pewter
#

K

hidden moss
#

Hii

frosty helm
#

Yo

hidden moss
#

Guys

#

I need help

#

Is there anyone who can help me get the Real Deal trophy

#

Red Chesnut Arabian, Warped Brindle Arabian and Perlino Andulasion does not spawns on my game.Please help!!

#

Anyone can help???

#

Please i need those horses!!!

#

If anyone sees this massage ping mi or DM me please!!!!

fluid cypress
hidden moss
#

What’s the last version

#

Tell me i’ll look

#

@fluid cypress

fluid cypress
#

idk

#

whats ur version

#

cuz all the horses u mentioned were added through updates

#

and werent in the base game before

#

@hidden moss

hidden moss
#

Where do i look the verison?

#

@fluid cypress

civic vault
#

Im watching a vacation houses tv series in netflix and the American vacation spot reminds me so much of red dead

#

All dem mountains

#

Ive been playing too much rdr2 i see it in everything

willow cosmos
#

Horse in real life=rdr2 reference

shut tinsel
#

They added the horses from rdr to real life

hidden moss
#

@fluid cypress I jailbreaked my ps4 and i think it’s old version i want those horses but i think i wont get it forever :(

willow cosmos
shut tinsel
#

And guns

hidden moss
#

They copied the wrold from RDR2

#

That’s haram

willow cosmos
#

How dare they👿

hidden moss
#

Right? How dare they!🤬

shut tinsel
#

They copied hats

shut tinsel
#

And women

fluid cypress
#

rip ig

hidden moss
fluid cypress
hidden moss
hidden moss
fluid cypress
#

yessir

hidden moss
#

same 😎

shut tinsel
fluid cypress
#

muslim gang

hidden moss
#

yeaaa

shut tinsel
#

I can't believe the world stole women from rdr

#

Such plagiarism

fluid cypress
#

ikr

#

they even stole balls

#

shame

shut tinsel
#

I don't want balls if they're not original

#

Take them away

hidden moss
#

Guys how do i look to the version?

mellow sage
# fickle chasm It'll show up as 'A' in the map dw

Interestingly, I had to talk to Abigall a few times before she triggered the quest with her son... that's the only thing it looks like I had to do to trigger the quest... that and not having stalker laws in the 19th century...
Even I would have noticed a large yellow A on my minimap... ffs.

mellow sage
#

What's weird is that I really can't remember why I wanted to be able to fish now...

#

Idt we get anything for perfect/legendary fish... other than part of 100% completion, right?

civic vault
slate vine
#

Lol

civic vault
#

What's the hardest legendary fish to catch?

slate vine
#

Um tbh I felt like all were same but bluegill one took a bit time idk why

arctic wren
#

The only one that took me a few tries was the one at lagras

civic vault
#

I thought the legendary sturgeon was gonna be hard but it turned out to be easier

arctic wren
#

All the others I got first time

mellow sage
#

I find it hard this playthru to see the fish "struggling" idk if it's just that my eyes are 3 years older, cause the game looks great for an "old" game... makes me wonder how new games look so bad, honestly.

#

Idk if I should use 1st or 3rd person... first person made it hard to see stuff because the pole was in the way most of the time, or it was just for the quest with the kid, idk.

civic vault
mellow sage
#

Given you guys are all PC atm, I can't trigger my Log with Z. I thought it was because I was in camp, near my horse, but now I can't trigger my Log to see my outstanding quests and stuff.

mellow sage
mellow sage
#

Then again I can get the second best horse by buying one, but Idr where, so I have to go on a gold and gold hunt again...

Oh, so Z is the right key, ruh roh. I'll check it again when I turn on my gaming pc today.

I'm on my potato. Discord using way too much resources data vacuuming everything on my pc when it's running...

civic vault
mellow sage
#

k... but I remember being good at deadeye, and I finally am getting good again, so I thought I needed to get good at lassoing cause I don't want to fail that hunt honestly.

civic vault
#

I'm on PC but I use a ps4 controller on bluetooth so I can't really help much. I wish I can add the PS4 tag on my name.

mellow sage
#

Idk y, but keeping my hands that close together for long periods of time feels really uncomfortable to me.
That's why I like keyboard and mouse, though controller gives really good assists with aim and lasso... which it doesn't for keyboard and mouse.

civic vault
#

My first playthrough was on ps4 so it was hard for me to shift into keyboard and mouse. The controller is easier for me

mellow sage
#

I found the aiming and movement way less snappy and hard to fine tune... but the keeping my hands that close together on the controller is uncomfortable, idk y other ppl don't feel that way... I'm not obese or even fat, so it's not that...

#

After an hour, holding the controller isn't uncomfortable to you?

civic vault
#

It's just how our arms are used to in different ways

#

my arms got used to be close together playing stuff

#

I used to play exclusively on pc before (with other games of course), mouse and keyboard, and used to resent doing shooter games on ps4 because i cant imagine having better aim. But after a while, i got too used to it that I can never go back to mouse and keyboard

#

im better at shooting with a controller now

mellow sage
#

Hmmm, humans adapt to any circumstance... (!)

blissful orbit
#

Guys im at a point in the story in which (spoiler) Uncle Reached terminal lumbago 😭

mellow sage
#

Until almost all the console games were just killing for killing's sake, and I no longer appreciated killing just to kill, I played both console and pc...

Now I don't even consider console games.

civic vault
#

So weird that everybody has different experiences with the legendary fish

blissful orbit
#

No he had lumbago now he got terminal lumbago he is gonna die it killed too many already not uncle!

mellow sage
#

All I know is Yarrow took away me being poisoned.

#

How is the gameplay of RDR1 and does it have a PC equivalent?

blissful orbit
#

ik already don't worry

mellow sage
#

Wth is lumbago?

blissful orbit
civic vault
#

attacks your back

blissful orbit
#

it killed a lot of peoples in USA back in early 20th century

river olive
#

is there a questions channel at all?

mellow sage
#

No kidding. Now I have to look it up. Until the 1920s or so when cheap meat became available life span was 40 years...

#

Wait, the "disease" lumbago is lifting wrong? How did that kill you?

blissful orbit
#

it's a joke

#

it's basicly back pain but uncle uses it to not work

civic vault
#

i just realized my dad had lumbago lol

mellow sage
#

My wife in the 19th century wouldn't call it a joke if I said, no hunny I got me some lumbago, my back hurts.

river olive
#

anyone know if theres a way to summon your horse to emerald ranch if its in valentine stables

blissful orbit
mellow sage
frigid cloud
#

ok lol

mellow sage
blissful orbit
#

Stadia player

frigid cloud
#

neither

#

I don't play rdr2

mellow sage
#

Ah ha!

blissful orbit
#

what

frigid cloud
#

I mean I used to

#

I got platinum trophy then quit

mellow sage
blissful orbit
#

You can't leave RDR2 it's a life that always catch back to you...

mellow sage
mellow sage
frigid cloud
mellow sage
river olive
frigid cloud
#

lol

mellow sage
#

What was a lie? There's only pie.

ember marsh
#

I have a bounty in ambarino. I don't have the money to pay it off. Can I serve jail time to get rid of it?

frigid cloud
#

yes

mellow sage
#

Oh no, the bane of my existence: Bob the Builder. Get the song out of my head!

civic vault
#

lol

mellow sage
#

I have bob the builder ptsd because I had to watch it with my sons before iPads allowed you to watch other things on cable.

ember marsh
blissful orbit
#

no

#

you ain't wanted in other states

mellow sage
#

Over and over and over... then I watched it too and realized the "authority" figures in Bob the builder with totalitarian mob bosses... what kind of thing to teach children?

frigid cloud
civic vault
#

You get some cool cutscens of gang members busting you our of jail

blissful orbit
mellow sage
#

I thought I could pay off bounties in other post offices?

blissful orbit
#

there is nothing in ambarino

#

the only town is desert

frigid cloud
#

yeah, so I have no idea

#

drawing cops from other states I guess

blissful orbit
#

they stop chase you when you get out

ember marsh
#

So I just have to pay it off?

blissful orbit
#

i guess

ember marsh
#

I have no other option?

mellow sage
#

Idts

blissful orbit
#

even if you get arrested if you have the money they still take some

mellow sage
#

You spent all the gold in the game already?

blissful orbit
#

yeah get some gold bars

mellow sage
#

Or even gold nuggets

blissful orbit
#

i just did a treasure for 3k dollars

#

even did another one for 500 on the way

mellow sage
#

Which one is that?

frigid cloud
#

treasures are op

blissful orbit
mellow sage
#

k, ty

frigid cloud
#

are you playing currently? @mellow sage

mellow sage
#

No, this is my potato. I do not run big data vacuums on my gaming pc

blissful orbit
#

milestones of opulence

mellow sage
#

Discord is really bad doing that.

ember marsh
#

I'm in chapter 2. Can I sell gold bars yet?

mellow sage
mellow sage
frigid cloud
#

yeah, fences are unlocked except the one in emerald ranch

blissful orbit
#

when it's bc i just traducted the name my game is in french

#

i think it's the landmarks treasures in english

frigid cloud
#

that's correct

blissful orbit
#

name is a bit less epic

mellow sage
ember marsh
# mellow sage yes

So I do the spines of America mission then I can start getting them to sell?

blissful orbit
frigid cloud
#

other fences are unlocked before that too...

mellow sage
#

If it's true that the Saint Denis fence is open or the Rhodes one is, you're golden, if not just do the chap 2 quest that opens the fence in Emerald ranch then.

#

Now I'm inspired to go legendary hunting that Tainty Bison (idr the T word in the name) I thought that area was blocked like Blackwater...

#

Though I do have to go get more gold too.

ember marsh
#

How much do the gold bars sell for?

frigid cloud
#

500$

blissful orbit
mellow sage
#

I'm doing it for a talisman I think... not a trinket.

blissful orbit
#

check the compendium wiki or ingame encyclopedia it should tell you with what to kill

#

if you don't know then just kill it with a bow if it's smaller then bow with small game arrow and you gotta one shot it or poison it

#

aim for the head

mellow sage
#

I think I have everything but the legendary pelt cause I thought that section of the map was closed off.

No I know what animals use what weapons... it's that I don't have a rifle yet, and my dead eye aint good enough not to shoot it 2x or in the wrong spot. I'm getting close.

Perfect deer pelts are in every satchel, so that's part of my job today.

blissful orbit
#

just released the legendary animals map spoil you the full map at the end of the game

mellow sage
#

I have improved arrows for big game, just in case before the rifle... for perfect pelts, but I haven't tried that yet until I get good enough with deadeye like I was a year or so ago...

blissful orbit
#

also legendary animals don't need light gun

#

like even if it's a beaver

#

Take a shotgun and destroy him

#

pelt won't be damaged normaly

#

don't go too far tho like don't try burning him

hidden moss
#

Guys how can i see my version

blissful orbit
#

version

mellow sage
#

I'm 2/3rd the way there to better deadeye... I still can't go into deadeye without drawing my weapon to blow ppl's heads off before they realize it.

Yeah, the legendary animals I use a pump action shot gun with slugs... but the Moose turned on me after 3 hits in dead eye, so I hit him again in his nads manually.

#

Can I use deadeye with a scope? It looks like on ytube videos you can... ppl here said no.

hidden moss
#

Guys how can i see my version???

mellow sage
#

PC guys won't know.

hidden moss
#

Hm

#

Why?

mellow sage
#

They don't play on PS4?

hidden moss
#

There is verison in PC too ?

mellow sage
#

I think so, I didn't notice.

hidden moss
#

Alright

mellow sage
#

Bug fixes wouldn't be the same necessarily on all platforms.

mellow sage
#

Would someone be so kind as to tell me what the + icon on the top right corner of my screen relates to? I'm thinking resupplying tonics or something? I don't want to look it up in a random walk online if I can help it.

#

Nvm, I bought a resupply, and that did it...

civic vault
#

i robbed the upstairs poker place above the gunsmith in St. Denis, while I had a psycho mask on to see how people would react

#

the scared faces are fitting lol

deft knot
#

is legendary animals just once or do they respwan

frigid cloud
#

once

deft knot
#

i died with legendary on horse it was away after

frigid cloud
frosty helm
#

Bruh I blew rhoades gunsmith head off and he respawned

#

😢

#

A little bit disappointing

deft knot
spring sluice
#

bro i was legit running around the woods looking for things to hunt

#

and all of a sudden some dude shouted "it didnt work kill him"

#

like they were going to legit ambush me if i stayed on the path

thick pewter
#

Whats the best Best pistol to kill 100s of police?

#

/revolver

vale heart
#

Schofield revolver