red-dead-singleplayer

[proud cipher]

I wish there was some stranger missions in blackwater or new Austin

it’s just. 2 bounty missions and random encounters

[queen fossil]

Yeah it's pretty empty

[fiery stag]

I found some place in saint denis where you can climb really high I’m pretty sure police can’t get you there

[calm crow]

wait guys

how did the pinkertons know about the bank robbery in saint denis?

micah only snitched on the gang after the guarma chatp

chapter

[willow cosmos]

Micah has always been a snitch, Either they talked with him in chapter 1 when he came out of the snow or he's always been a rat because of the white hat

[calm crow]

white hat?

[willow cosmos]

Also he wears a white suit

[calm crow]

so?

[willow cosmos]

Yes to show the pinkertons to not shoot him

While all the other outlaws wear black hats

[calm crow]

ohhhh

i get it

[willow cosmos]

So that shows he was always a rat

[calm crow]

but i think he had a crush on mary beth😂

[fickle chasm]

in the wild west White usually meant the law and Black usually meant an Outlaw

[calm crow]

but the pinkertons wear black

[fickle chasm]

the hats i mean

idrk i js heard it somewhere lmfao

[proud cipher]

if you ever went to his camp after u got him out of strawberry

there is a wanted poster for dutch

[untold marsh]

Gambler 8 is fucking ridiculous

It's so hard to get that one beaten

You have to be sooo lucky

[boreal ermine]

is there mod for horseman 10 to less amount of horses?

[frigid cloud]

no

you just hope it spawns

[calm crow]

lol

[mellow sage]

Does anyone have a list of what plants do to you if you eat them raw? Like I've found thyme affects dead eye, and I won't eat sage or milkweed (uh oh, contradictions... one says milkweed helps your health core...) cause they are used to poison your weapons...

There's nothing online that I could find that is even close to comprehensive...

[hidden moss]

Is there any way to get 2 micah revolvers?

Like at all

[mellow sage]

I haven't even got him out of jail, cause he's a poo, but I do have dual wield now. Are Micah's revolvers better than other choices ingame?

You'd think given how mature the game is, that there'd be a list somewhere... I can't find it, and I prefer not hunting down 40 or so plants, eating them, and writing it down, if I didn't die from the test... (I play with 3 saves though...)

[hidden moss]

They're just really overpowered versions of double action better accuracy etc

And imo they look sm cooler

[mellow sage]

I read somewhere, that they "eventually" no longer show the description... that is false?

k

[mellow sage]

Idk, I just want that guy dead too...

It says Thyme if eating increases dead eye core? Idr seeing that, but when I'm relearning/learning something, I tunnel vision and sometimes don't see the obvious...

k, I'll check that out. ty

It's interesting how some servers allow pepe, and some servers have meltdowns like ice cream on a hot summer's day on the concrete.

[hidden moss]

Yeah they terrible in online

[willow cosmos]

Ye I- WAIT what if because the pinkertons always found the gang it's because of micah telling em where they are at

[fiery turtle]

No.

Micah was the rat right after Guarma. The reason why the Pinkertons found the gang everytime, was because they put so much heat on them, the shootings, the killings.

They drew the Pinkertons right to them.

[willow cosmos]

They dumb af

Attracting law like that

[fiery turtle]

Agreed.

[willow cosmos]

I wouldn't do that

[fiery turtle]

And they were always so curious to why they were always getting caught and killed.

Like Saint Denis robbery. They killed Angelo Bronte, trolly station, and more.

And they put too much heat on them.

They were way to predictable.

[mellow sage]

The Pinkertons were oligarch paid 'lawmen' that were run out of MANY towns irl because they stole stuff from the town's ppl, like cops do now with Civil Asset Forfeiture. "I Can Hire Half the Working Class To Fight the Other Half" - 1800s oligarch Jay Gould

The cops then weren't "good" by a long shot, at least in real history.

At least even in fiction, Robin Hood had only one Sheriff on Nottingham... I have 40,000 in NYC...

[fiery turtle]

We got sloppier than the town drunk.

And arthur was right.

Literally.

It was even said, that they knew Dutch was gonna go after it.

And it made sense.

They keep drawing too much attention.

Interesting. I never knew about that.

I swear there's so many details and secrets, even after 1.5K hours I still find more and more.

[vestal cipher]

yes im pretty sure its one of the rarest and best revolvers in the game

you can get it as both john and arthur

i dont think you can get it duel wield

[vestal cipher]

the blackwater police dept and pinkertons wear black

[mellow sage]

The Pinkertons were larger than the US Army for a time. I didn't know that...

Which is cheaper and more effective hunting birds for flight feathers: dual wield handguns or the varmint rifle?

[proud cipher]

probably varmint for long range

but if u want perfect bird use bow with small arrows and dead eye

[mellow sage]

k, ty. I'm gonna go to the swamp though, and hunt ravens or something for mo' flight feather per kill, so I wonder the distances...

[smoky flare]

Hello

[frail niche]

just watched the credits again, man this shit hits different

[wraith panther]

ngl rdr2 is really beautiful, especially with rain

[willow cosmos]

Yes

I love the graphics when the sun is setting

Beautiful

[proud cipher]

how the fuck are you supposed to complette hunting reuqest 4

ive been trying for over an hour to get a perfect skunk

but they dont spawn

[fiery turtle]

It's annoying.

[proud cipher]

finally

one fucking spawend

wat the fuck

another one spawend

[earnest aurora]

RNG playing games with you.

[proud cipher]

guess so

since it took A FUCKING HOUR

so ic ant do hunting request 5 as arthur

right

"mrs.hobbs has gone on vacation"

haha

[red helm]

Quite lame.

[proud cipher]

yeah idk why they dont want us completting it as arthur

would be much nicer considering that missions that you can do as arthur but choose to do as john the dialogue is weird

and feels boring

arthur has so much more depth and personality than john

even in the epilogue

@red helm can you do the ciggerate cards as arthur

[red helm]

Yes.

[red helm]

Well, it does make sense that the reward would go to John, once you see it. But, still, annoying.

[proud cipher]

can i just become a chain smoker

and get them all that way

[red helm]

You don't have to smoke them, just go to your satchel and discard them all.

[proud cipher]

what

why do that

[red helm]

Like a thousand times faster?

[proud cipher]

wait

[lyric zephyr]

Place east of stable north ish of rhodes, guaranteed to spawn at night only as they are nocturnal

[proud cipher]

do i still get cards

[lyric zephyr]

East*

[proud cipher]

if i discard

tahiti i was searching long time near fort riggs

[red helm]

You get cards when you purchase them from the store, not when you smoke them.

[proud cipher]

finally got 2 of them

no i have like 90 packs in my satchel

if i discard all does it give me the cards

[red helm]

Trust me, it's what I did...

[proud cipher]

ok

[red helm]

You get the card when you get the pack.

[proud cipher]

wait so u can only get the reward as john?

[red helm]

For the Hunting Request, yes.

[proud cipher]

no

the cards

[red helm]

For the cards it doesn't matter.

[proud cipher]

ok

how do i discard

wait nvm

@red helm i discard all of them it gave me no cards

it dont even give me card when i smoke them

@red helm can you not smoke the ones u currently own nand u have to buy them all

[dreamy oracle]

Where can I get a Litchfield Repeater?

Sorry for not giving the question more detail, can you get a Litchfield repeater from alongside dead enemies, in freeroam, or given to you from a story mission? I know it’s purchasable from the Gunsmith

[wraith panther]

Is there normally a bear on the Hermit's roof?

[proud cipher]

which hermit

[wraith panther]

the one in Annesburg

[proud cipher]

dont think so

[wraith panther]

I heard growling noises and thought wtf, then saw a bear on the roof

[proud cipher]

weird

anyways ive sepnt 400 dollars on premium cigerates

[wraith panther]

for deadeye?

[proud cipher]

no

the cards

[wraith panther]

oh lol

[proud cipher]

the

FUCKING

CARDS

i need

12 more

cards

GIMME

CARDS

[wraith panther]

well

lots of luck

[proud cipher]

whbat u mean

[wraith panther]

I mean with the cards

[proud cipher]

i started with 77 cards discovered

now i have

137 cards discovereed

[wraith panther]

I just died from drowning because my horse ran out of energy

[proud cipher]

well u see

ive spent 450 dollars

on these damn things

so

idk about luck

[wraith panther]

ngl 450 does seem like a lot to spend on cigarettes

[proud cipher]

IM GOING

BROKE

[red helm]

You discard And Than buy more. Instead of sitting there for 30 minutes smoking 99 cigs..

[proud cipher]

yes

thats what am doing

guess whjat

another set completed

[red helm]

👍

[proud cipher]

4 sets left to complete

4 more cards to find

[red helm]

and yeah, it's a bunch of money. But the alternative it to wander all around the entire map.

[wraith panther]

yo wtf

[proud cipher]

well @red helm

[wraith panther]

why do I instantly drown when my horse throws me off in water

[proud cipher]

is some of the ccards in blackwater and new austin?

[red helm]

John can't swim.

[red helm]

Yes.

[proud cipher]

exactly

[wraith panther]

I'm doing this as Arthur

[proud cipher]

i cant go there

[mortal storm]

yo can u have an extra clean shaven + a mustache ?

[wraith panther]

he just seems to be drained of all his energy

[red helm]

Were you really far from land?

[proud cipher]

honey what is this 600 dollar transaction

[dreamy oracle]

So I only need to buy premium cigarettes then discard them to get a full set of cigarette cards?

[proud cipher]

premium cigerates......

[wraith panther]

kinda

[red helm]

several times, it's random what cards you get.

[proud cipher]

and another card found

[dreamy oracle]

Alright thanks for telling me

[red helm]

Yeah, there are certain places that you just instant die, even if you have a boat.

[wraith panther]

bruh

[proud cipher]

@red helm can i rob this guy and get my money back?

lol

[red helm]

The boat just suddenly sinks and you drown, it's sad.

[red helm]

Ha! I wish that is how it worked.

[proud cipher]

i need

2 more

fucking

card

s

maybe i should just find them

instead of spending more

hmmmmm

[red helm]

I'm sure there is a list online where they all are.

[proud cipher]

where is vistas of america card 6

and

[red helm]

¯_(ツ)_/¯

[proud cipher]

stars of the stage card 7

i hope none are in blackwater or new austin

[red helm]

I only remember where the Black Widow is.

[lyric zephyr]

Literally me every time i drive a boat with an engine on it lol, it just sinks but i think its because im too close to the world borders idk

[dreamy oracle]

I understand the effects of the drink they give you at Alderman Pig Farm eventually wear off after a little while but surely they could’ve put Arthur further away from their house than just in the woods next to it

[proud cipher]

DAMN

vista card is in new austin.......

[red helm]

I love the little boat with the steam engine, it's so fun to sail around in.

[wraith panther]

well it certainly is one of those places

shame

[proud cipher]

wait

@red helm

this video shows the card in one of the carts in the camp

but

[dreamy oracle]

Do I need one full card set of all the full card sets to get the Civil War Handcuffs

[proud cipher]

its in horseshoe overlook

[red helm]

With the corpse on top of him... Their mothers corpse? I wasn't clear on that.

[proud cipher]

do you think that it stil there

im in shady bell for camp

[red helm]

The first card set is always the Handcuffs, yes.

[red helm]

If you didn't loot it, I don't see why not.

[proud cipher]

LETS GO

i finsihed them all!!!!

but uh

540 dollars later....

[red helm]

Go mail them at the post office.

[proud cipher]

wait

[red helm]

Whee.. money.

[proud cipher]

NVM

i need one more card

marvels of travel

wait

i have discovered all of them though.....

oh wait

i remember i accidently sold 2 cards to a fence awhile aog

fuck

what do i do

[red helm]

Tsk tsk.

[proud cipher]

i have discovered them alkl

but dont hvae all

[red helm]

You have buy more Cig packs.

[proud cipher]

YAY

[wraith panther]

hmmm cigarettes the path to success

[proud cipher]

I CANT

FIND IT

i needc card 8

[civic vault]

If I sell my Tukorman back in the St. Denis stable, will I able to buy it again but with different personality?

[red helm]

It'd assume it would be new Turkoman.

[proud cipher]

dont worry fellas

I GOT

EM ALL

wait

no

[willow cosmos]

Huh?

[proud cipher]

i dont have card 9

..............

[willow cosmos]

Just buy them from a general store

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[proud cipher]

well

do

the cards

respawn?

[willow cosmos]

Maybe

Yes

[proud cipher]

they do?

yes or no pls

[willow cosmos]

After you sell them all you can only get them from premium cigarettes

But I got all my cards from buying them

[proud cipher]

its all good fellas

I GOT

EM ALL

[wraith panther]

GG

[willow cosmos]

You gonna be rich now xd

[red helm]

Totally....

[inland wadi]

Is it bad that I have never fully completed rdr2 story mode

[proud cipher]

yes

it is a sin

what the fuck

@red helm

wgat the fuck is this reward

26 god damn things

im guessing i wasnt supposed to mail them all at once lol

[red helm]

Perhaps not, but, yeah, a lot of things.

[wraith panther]

have you only been playing online?

[proud cipher]

well

i made profit

[willow cosmos]

Did somebody call me

[proud cipher]

i think u get 800?

right

[red helm]

Make sure you use the Handcuffs to make the Gator Trinket. Unsure if can sale them or not, but still... be careful, they are unique.

[willow cosmos]

Who didn't play story

[proud cipher]

and i spent like

around 700 dollars

so i make profit

ez

[red helm]

Also, I think the Quartz stone or something is needed for a Trinket as well... Just careful when you are selling stuffs to the fence.

[proud cipher]

how many legendary fish can u get as arthur

[red helm]

9-10?

[proud cipher]

i like how u get a perfect rabbit pelt from that

of all fucking things

a rabit pelt

[red helm]

Yeah, random.

[proud cipher]

i need

legendary alligator tooth

[red helm]

Can't get the Gator until Chapter 6, so... meh.

[proud cipher]

ok

i wont lose anything going to guarma right

[red helm]

Bullets...

[proud cipher]

ok

what lure is best for legendary fish

[red helm]

😆 But, No, you get your horse and stuff back after a bit.

[red helm]

You have to switch between all 3 special lures, depending on each one.

[proud cipher]

does game tell u whats best

[dreamy oracle]

I just realized Agent Ross is in RDR2

For a 2010 game RDR1 sure has some great graphics but so does Dead Space which is older than RDR1

[proud cipher]

have u guys played undead nightmare

help

how i send legendary fish to jeremy

[bleak forge]

@proud cipher u send em by mailing them

[proud cipher]

wait

oh im dumb

i thought i caught the fish

haha

[bleak forge]

Oh

[inland wadi]

I'm on the second mission of Chapter 5(Guarma)

[inland wadi]

Yeah but I'm almost done with story mode(Chapter 5)

Don't spoil pls

[bleak forge]

I won’t

Imo I think we should of played as Sadie instead of Arthur in rdr2

[proud cipher]

why

[bleak forge]

I like Sadie more than Arthur tbh.

Rockstar should allow us to be able to play as female protagonists in story mode

[proud cipher]

damn legendary smallmouth bass

is giant

22 pounds

[dreamy oracle]

How do I activate dead-eye in RDR1?

[proud cipher]

why i gotta give money to send fihs

fish

[dreamy oracle]

Probably because the fish are gigantic compared to the pieces of paper the rock/bone locations are written on

[hidden moss]

Sadie was selfish, only wanting revenge on the O’ Driscolls. She got the air balloon Arthur killed just cus she couldn’t prioritise the gang over her own feelings

Sadie as protagonists would’ve sucked

[bleak forge]

The gang started to fall apart from the blackwater massacre. Sadie would of been the greatest protagonists in rockstar history and at the point of the hot ballon the gang didn’t care about her or Arthur or John for that fact so she of course would prioritise her own feelings before the gang

[hidden moss]

True, though that mission wasn’t even for “the gang”. It was for Abigail, John, Jack & Arthur. And she still felt that her need for revenge was more important than those lives🤷‍♂️

I don’t see how she would’ve made a great protagonist at all tbh

[bleak forge]

Also true

She was hungry for revenge

If I was in her shoes I’d act the same way

[wraith panther]

no worries I'm still on Chapter 4

[mellow sage]

Noted. Don't sleep if Sadie is around.

I'm trying to fill in all I can with pamphlets and trinkets/talismans, but I'm pretty sure like above, the gator tooth is main quest locked.

Oh, I'm in Chap 2, and I'm also wondering if I really have to save Micah to get passed chap 2 ?

[wraith panther]

why can't you blow off the head of a cougar smh

the lack of realism smh

[mellow sage]

Hey, I finally can kill a charging cougar, I call that a win.

[wraith panther]

noice

[mellow sage]

I was trying to deadeye with a scope on a repeater and wonder why I was getting mauled. Guys here told me you can't use a scope with deadeye... derp.

Now I have a semi auto shotgun with slugs. Die predators die.

I really wish I could "accidentally" push the drunk preacher off the cliff at the back of the camp...

[wraith panther]

seems like you have murderous intent

calls sheriff

[mellow sage]

Sometimes for the greater good, there needs to be sacrifices...

[bleak forge]

I’d feel safe around Sadie tbh

[mellow sage]

The boy that's supposed to trigger the fishing quest, told me I was following him. I was really disgusted with myself. I can't find the mother to see the kid playing to trigger the quest...

[wraith panther]

I still don't get why you can't kill kids

[mellow sage]

I have ex-wife ptsd...

[mellow sage]

Well, if you've been watching media over the years, killing kids I THINK started with the first season of the Game of Thrones, first episode, when I stopped watching it... the first time.

[bleak forge]

Oh

[mellow sage]

There's a reason why ppl aren't shown adults killing kids, imo.

First as a father, no bueno.

Is there a way I can search or find a list of things that are opened by chapter? Cause going someplace and it not being open (like a locked box for horse rise again, you ain't ded potion, until chap 6 or something...) doesn't work for me...

[wraith panther]

understandable

[mellow sage]

I didn't realize why "orgs" target children. As parents, it's pretty much the worst pain there can be, even worse than watchin a wife slowly die/get killed. The kids are actually loved by their parents more than parents love each other.

It seems to be instinctual, and I never realized I could love something that much until my first son.

It's not like the love of your pets, ppl, etc., and you don't notice/realize/experience it until it happens. Like part of the whole Operating System gets triggered with an update.

But with reference to the game, for me to get to Chap 3, I HAVE to complete all quests of chapter 2?

I HAVE to save Micah?

[wraith panther]

all the main story ones yes

[wraith panther]

sadly yes

[mellow sage]

k, that sucks, I'm suspicious that's why I can't trigger the fishing quest...

[wraith panther]

It just randomly triggered in the morning for me

[mellow sage]

I was like "EEEeeewww" when the kid said, 'you following me!?' //
I can't "accidentally" throw a second stick of dynamite when Micah pauses to do something and blow him up? He's immortal for some parts I assume?

Or I just fail the mission...?

[wraith panther]

Immortal probably not, but you'd fail the quest

[mellow sage]

k

[wraith panther]

it only triggers in the morning when he's asleep

I think that you've got to talk to his mother though

[mellow sage]

Oh, great, so I have to watch him sleep, wonder what he'll say when he wakes up and sees me watching him sleep... I forgot who's the mother too atm...

I can't like in other games, sneak up to an npc, and "put a grenade" in its pocket and they accidentally die? That would be nice for Micah in this game.

I'll watch a ytube video on the trigger thing again...

[wraith panther]

I was wrong sorry, you just need to talk to Abigail in the morning

he doesn't have to be sleeping

[mellow sage]

k, so I'll watch her sleep until she wakes up... what could go wrong?

[wraith panther]

slips a stick of dynamite into someone's backpocket

[mellow sage]

Exactly... I mean euthanasia can be for others...

[wraith panther]

a stick of dynamite is way easier than euthanasia

except if you need to clean it up

[mellow sage]

Well, my brain is burnt. I'm gonna relax from playing too much. Everyone enjoy, and stay safe...

[wraith panther]

well, have a lovely time

[proud cipher]

i dont wanna do the last mission in chapter 4

lenny and hosea die 😦

[proud cipher]

where can i find a row boat to get to sisika penitary

[civic vault]

Alright I'm gonna try.

[civic vault]

There's always 2 boats along the shore a stretch away clemens point, but maybe you can try on the east shoreline of st. denis

[proud cipher]

why does game say i caught fish but map say i didnt?

[red helm]

Game glitchy, don't worry about the map.

[proud cipher]

does the legendary animals map have animals you havent discovered yet

i dont see a single row boat

i stole a mans bot

boat

[fluid cypress]

Came across something interesting I hadn’t encountered in my previous playthroughs, after the Country Pursuits mission in ch4 Bronte’s men will ambush you in saint denis and get the law on you

pretty cool

[proud cipher]

do you mean the mission where u kill him

[fluid cypress]

no

before that

[proud cipher]

the trolley?

[fluid cypress]

no after that

[proud cipher]

the one where u go into swamp

and check some traps

[fluid cypress]

country pursuits is the one where you go with that boatman

yeah

[proud cipher]

hmm

[fluid cypress]

yeah that one

[proud cipher]

never happend to me

do you know that secret mission

[fluid cypress]

They were waiting at the bridge

[proud cipher]

where u kill 25 birds or something

oh

that

during the mission

yeah

[fluid cypress]

No

bruh in open world

[proud cipher]

oj

never happen to me before

[fluid cypress]

i was going to the trapper they just jumped me there

[proud cipher]

did u murder them

[fluid cypress]

Ofc

[proud cipher]

i just spend 5 years

getting 10 legendary fish

'for

45

[fluid cypress]

lmao

[proud cipher]

fucking

dollars

[fluid cypress]

i never bothered with fishing

[proud cipher]

and some succulent fish meat!!

well

[fluid cypress]

only for food sometimes

[proud cipher]

u need to do it for 100%

[fluid cypress]

Yeah I’m not doing that

[proud cipher]

i spent 600 dollars on premium cigerates earlier

so i could get every card

[fluid cypress]

Idk why my inv already had max premium ciggs as John I had like 99

[proud cipher]

discard

[fluid cypress]

it’s so tedious to smoke them all to get the cards

[proud cipher]

buy more

get cards

repeat

u dont need to smoke them

discard ur current ones

[fluid cypress]

huh

[proud cipher]

when u buy or pick up

you get the card

you dont need to smoke

[fluid cypress]

damn

didn’t know that

[proud cipher]

i dont wanna do final chapter 4 mission

cuz

hosea and lenny die

@fluid cypress do you know the secret mission where u gotta kill 25 of a certain bird

[civic vault]

Experienced that in my first playthrough. Caught me by surprise

[civic vault]

Im still in chapter 4 as well, been stretching it for the same reason lol

So i sold my Tukorman, and bought a new Tukorman, I'm gonna see if this one scares easily or not

[dreamy oracle]

Is RDR1 split into chapters like RDR2 or do I just do all the missions without moving somewhere new

[dreamy oracle]

Alright thanks for telling me

[dreamy oracle]

If you have a ton of Potent Health Cures and you hogtie all of the lawmen in missions like the one where you break Micah out of the Strawberry jail, you won’t lose honor when killing them. This is only if they’re hogtied though I think you still loose honor if you loot them. This is a tip for anyone who wants to do a high honor playthrough

[red helm]

Yeah, there are sort of chapters, but you don't move around in camps like RDR2. You get different places to save, like houses/cabins, or apartments.

[dreamy oracle]

Alright thanks for telling me

Is Bonnie McFarlane in RDR2?

[red helm]

She is not. If you go a tad south of Annesburg you'll find a boat on the shore with a guy that hands you a letter about her, and dies right afterwards. The letter I think is the only mention of her.
But, I think Bonnie is in Online, even thought she is like 14 or whatever...

[dreamy oracle]

Alright thanks for telling me, I’ve heard the character’s name before but didn’t know which Red Dead game it was from

[civic vault]

I got the white Arabian

It's.... not as hard to break as other people say it would

[queen fossil]

It is sorta

I had to run a lot before catching her

[civic vault]

Okay, im now on my 2nd attempt to glitch arthur into new austin using the bounty on horse trick

hopefully i'll last longer lol

reached manzanita post

crap, my bounty died

going back to square 1

[queen fossil]

RIP

But why do you want to go to New Austin?

[civic vault]

dinosaur bones for Arthur lol

3rd attempt

im in breecher's hope

crap

he keeps dying in the river

maybe i shouldve picked a dead or live bounty

[fossil torrent]

guys why i cant interact with graves with arthur ?.

[fluid cypress]

Why is the cutscene with the dinosaur bone lady even voiced as Arthur if you aren’t supposed to get them all as him

speaking of, idk why but in guarma after a mission, I randomly got the prompt for collecting a dinosaur bone for some reason

[fossil torrent]

sometimes if u have good honor with arthur they have to say something for him

and rockstar by doing this make u miss arthur

[civic vault]

Because pre-release Arthur was supposed to have access to New Austin

[queen fossil]

And why this wasn't the case?

[frigid cloud]

got cut probably due to storyline

[fickle chasm]

They prolly wanted players to play more as John

[runic crater]

whos you guys favourite van der linde member?

[light finch]

charles cos hes a silent badass

[hidden moss]

When do you unlock horse fence in singleplayer? Can you be a bounty hunter in singleplayer?

[light finch]

yeah u can be a b hunter but theres only like 10 bountoes to collect as arthur

horse fence u get after doing the sheep mission with john in chaptwer 3

[hidden moss]

Can you do these bounties again after some time?

If I replay a mission in which I get cash, will I get cash again?

[light finch]

the bounty misaiona dont respawn

you have to reload your previous chqptera or replays or something to do them again

yes u will get cash again in thw replay but its not a farmable thing, it just replays the past game

[civic vault]

Yeah that's most probably it. There are audio files in the game for when Arthur asks for a stagecoach to take him to Blackwater and Tumbleweed. There are also stuff in New Austin that Arthur can sketch in his journal.

They didn't really erase everything that was set for Arthur in NA. They just set up an invisible sniper and a ton of pinkertons to kill him when he sets foot

[normal dirge]

Hey guys anyone use reshade with RDR2? I can't get it to work for whatever reason?

[young mica]

wait should you kill danburry? will he alert the guards once i leave?

the guy you interrogate for the files

yes

oh, alright then thanks for the help

[fickle chasm]

Nah the guards will get alerted if you leave lmao the dude doesn't say anything

[frigid cloud]

no

[frigid cloud]

not sheep, after stealing 3 horses from braithwaites with John and Javier

[fallen furnace]

hoses

i mean hosea

[fickle chasm]

I was just replaying the last train mission

and i just remembered dutch says "Ain't nobody gonna die"

🤦

[queen fossil]

How can i increase the weight of Arthur?

[fickle chasm]

Eat?

[queen fossil]

I do that but he won't gain weight

[civic vault]

I love how the game just gives you a weird random death lol

[civic vault]

Always eat big game meat, eat tons of sweets as well. Also sleep regularly, even more than 8 hours. Order the most expensive food at the saloon.

Basically pamper Arthur lol

Treat him good like you're playing a tamagotchi

[queen fossil]

Ah okay i see

[civic vault]

Also, give him tons of beer

It makes weight gain faster

[spark haven]

Can someone help me download a outfit mod on pc I swear I haven’t figured out how to download single player mods for any game yet

[queen fossil]

Willdo

[young mica]

how are you supposed to escape in the mission where you're tied up in an island its the mission after the failed bank robbery

i cant seem to escape from the god damn chair because I don't even know what to press

[civic vault]

That's the guarma chapter

[young mica]

the mission where arthur and part of the gang are stranded on an island

do you hold iy

it*

ok

didnt work

this is one of the most annoying missions

im just gonna skip the checkpoint

[civic vault]

I wish i can help but i use a ps4 controller on my laptop

But maybe try moving your mouse while you spam A and D

[earnest shell]

I was having trouble on this even during my 11th play through 💀.

The only way arthur escapes from the chair is if you keep up the proper momentum. Even if you delay for a split second.

Don’t spam the buttons, just have patience going back and forth.

[young mica]

oh alright

[fickle chasm]

damn i never had trouble with it

[void perch]

Racoons...

[proud cipher]

no no

s k u n k s

they don’t spawn

[void perch]

Skunks got a picture on the map racoons don't pain in the ass

[hidden moss]

i use granger revolver

[mellow sage]

If I want to get the Provisions satchel and I need 3 perfect pelts, how do I store them to be able to go get them crafted at camp?

I'm suspicious I can't carry all three pelts together.

Perfect Deer Pelt can be used along with a Perfect Bison Pelt and a Perfect Raccoon Pelt I can carry all three at the same time?

How about if I store it on my backup horse in camp, then I can transfer the 2 with the one I have on my primary horse, and I should be good?

Do pelts degrade?

k, just checking, cause it would suck to get perfect pelts and then not carry them back to camp... ty

[thick pewter]

Which saint denis theatre gives me the black Arabian encounter with that guy and his wife or something

[fluid cypress]

It’s not a theatre it’s kinda random where it happens

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

it’s mostly near a park or something look it up idrk

[thick pewter]

K

How do I get money if I'm staying in chapter 2?

[cloud fiber]

Do random encounters and side missions

[queen fossil]

You need to give one deer pelt at a time

But yeah you can store 3 pelts on your horse

[queen fossil]

There is a glitch that give you 50 $

Look about Van Horn Mansion on youtube

I never do that

[dreamy oracle]

I’ve encountered this one before but didn’t take the horse because I was busy doing Bandit 1, it’s in North Saint Denis near the graveyard

[broken pulsar]

anyone know where i can find robins?

[lyric zephyr]

4. Someone gets a straight flush in poker

[shut tinsel]

I use grangers revolver in main slot and midnight's pistol in offhand

[blissful orbit]

Bruh got shot by a random dude for no reasons then a civilian called cops on me with her mind then i got told to move so i did then cops shot me in the back i tried to surrender and arthur pulled out a gun for some reasons

omg i can't play bc of that stupid "trouble to public oder"

[lyric zephyr]

Like im good ish at poker, but the amount of times ive seen the ai get a straight ace diamond flush or one of those is very unrealistic tbh

[lyric zephyr]

I believe rdr1's poker was worse in that regard, but at least you could cheat unless it was the high stakes one

Lol

[short oriole]

I think they rot though

[hidden moss]

i like murdering people with hammer

[next nexus]

Concerning, but ok

[neon snow]

Might be some under the SI of BARD’S CROSSING near Flatneck Station. Also along the coast under Flatneck Station.

Also the little island 🏝 west of Braithwaite Manor

The tiniest island

[primal scroll]

Hunting in Story Mode is so cool and immersive until you have to kill an animal that appears less often than there is a mass extinction event

[blissful orbit]

guys im doing red dead redemption mission

i don't know if i will be able to finish it

i didn't even saved before

Bruh micah shot grimshaw and dutch and the "gang" take his side javier and bill are really dumb idiots afterall

[ancient sigil]

@blissful orbit you can quit out of it if you let yourself die

I think you already finished it by now though

[red helm]

Right? Shots Grimshaw and everyone is like, "oh, Micah is the good guy, let's side with him." Totally, not f'd up at all there...

[proud cipher]

is killing all the legendary animals part of 100%

[red helm]

Nope, nor getting all the trinkets.

You can see the 100% checklist in the Pause menu, Progression section.

[vestal cipher]

fun fact

there is a way to ride and possibly get taima (charles' jhorse) for yourself after ch1

in ch3

when you save trelawny with charles

after killing the 3 bounty hunters, call your horse over and get on it

charles will spawn a duplicate of taima and ride with you

(one without a saddle on it)

and you can ride it around and idk if you can but maybe even switch the saddles too

possibly get taima for yourself

[red helm]

Huh, that's interesting.

[vestal cipher]

yeah

i just found that out

[next nexus]

My brain broke while reading that and idk why

[vestal cipher]

ok

is that a trans am in your pfp

leo

[next nexus]

Yea

Lol

[vestal cipher]

is it your

yours

[next nexus]

Forza 4

[vestal cipher]

oh wow

[next nexus]

Yea

[proud cipher]

is there any purpose of ciggerate ccards after u send all 12 sets to that guy

[vestal cipher]

i dont think you can sell them so im gonna say no

but i dont know

[red helm]

You can sell cards to the fence, yes.

[vestal cipher]

oh

how muhc

[red helm]

Like $1 or some such.

[vestal cipher]

how many are in a set

[red helm]

12?

[vestal cipher]

ok

144 dollars

good mney

especially for wild western days'

[red helm]

If they used the actual 1899 money values.

[vestal cipher]

werent 1$ in 1899 like

30 bucks todqay

irl i mean btw

i think

[willow cosmos]

1 buck? It was like 7 dollars

10 dollars was like 30

[vestal cipher]

oh damn

i was way off

[willow cosmos]

100 was like 2 grand

💀

[vestal cipher]

dude

what if

they invent time machines

and we take loans out

and travel to western times

and spend it

[willow cosmos]

OK ok

[vestal cipher]

wed be rich

[willow cosmos]

They would just cancel it

[red helm]

If Time Machines were invented, wouldn't we already know about it?

[willow cosmos]

Well

Huh

That's a good question

[vestal cipher]

i dont have an answer

[willow cosmos]

I mean to time travel we would have to go as fast as light which we will never do

[red helm]

Also, it would be hard to bring money back in time, because they would see the year or the new type of dollar bills and go "That is fake money".

[willow cosmos]

Im a space guy alr

All about space

[vestal cipher]

damn youre right

[willow cosmos]

Cuz to fast travel you need to go as fast as light in order to do so

[vestal cipher]

fast travelling sucks

i travelled from tubleweed to saint denis once

it took a while

[willow cosmos]

Time I mean💀

[vestal cipher]

ok

[willow cosmos]

Fuck I keep on getting fast travel and time travel mixed up

Been playing way too much rdr

[next nexus]

Lol

[willow cosmos]

Hey

Welcome to the server

[red helm]

Actually, right after the Big Bang, they calculated that matter was moving faster than light, for things to be where they are now.... Or some such.... So...

[vestal cipher]

@red helm what does the gunslinger role do

[red helm]

How should I know, this is the Single player room, silly billy.

[willow cosmos]

Say, I have a theory what if the universe keeps on expanding and expanding and when it gets to a limit it crumbles itself to nothing and causes the big bang then repeat for another like 60 billion years

[vestal cipher]

because you have it

[willow cosmos]

It's a good one

[red helm]

Oh! Ha, oops, thought you were using another word for Bounty Hunter. You get different roles for talking, like levels.

[willow cosmos]

Also who would even get 6000 hours on rdr2💀

Couldn't be me

[vestal cipher]

oh ok

[vestal cipher]

ive played for 19 hours straight

shit is addicting

[willow cosmos]

Like total?

What's ur total

[vestal cipher]

no

[willow cosmos]

Wait wait

[red helm]

That's actually a theory that a lot of people have, but actually Way more than 60 billion years, Or more than Trillions, and even over Quadrillion years.

[willow cosmos]

Yeah

[vestal cipher]

i gtg

good day

[willow cosmos]

Basically the big crumple whatever its called

Aight cya

Good night

[willow cosmos]

We will never know

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[red helm]

Probably not.

[proud cipher]

how hard is it to get to master hunter 9

[willow cosmos]

Which one is it?

I forgot

@proud cipher

[red helm]

Like, doing Hunter 1-8?

[willow cosmos]

Is it the bear one?

Or

[proud cipher]

yeah

@red helm

[willow cosmos]

Just go manzita post and at those buildings there should be a pile of wood where you can stay in the middle of without dying

Idk if you know

[red helm]

I think the 6th one is where you have to kill and skin 5 Cougar's... and I think 8 is rough too... Kill 8 small game with small game arrows, Consecutatively.

[willow cosmos]

But nah its not really hard

The cougar one gets on my nerves

[proud cipher]

oh 8 will be cake

but uh

6

uh

n o

[red helm]

'cake'...

[proud cipher]

yeah

i am master of bird hunting

[red helm]

It's kill them in 1 shot.

[proud cipher]

just go to ronake valey

in the rive

r

so many birds

ez

[civic vault]

Master Hunter 8 is catching fish without a fishing rod if im not mistaken

[red helm]

Believe me, when you get to it, you'll see..

[willow cosmos]

Imo legend of the east outfit is crap just in it for the effects

[proud cipher]

how tf u do that

catch a fish without rod

[red helm]

Oh, maybe it's 7.. Or a different series.

[proud cipher]

tf

[willow cosmos]

Shoot em

[civic vault]

You can go the shoreline near Clemens point and shoot the fishes that are visible

[proud cipher]

oh

[civic vault]

That's how i did it

[red helm]

Yeap, use a gun, or just find a fish, already dead and washed up on shore.

[willow cosmos]

Or use dynamite

Old classic way

[red helm]

The fun way.

[proud cipher]

how hard is the secret bird mission

[willow cosmos]

Huh

[proud cipher]

hmm

there is secret mission

parakeets

[willow cosmos]

Not that hard

Just find and shoot and kill

[proud cipher]

are they rare to spawn

[willow cosmos]

No

Just in one location everytime

[proud cipher]

do challenges stack

like if u did 9 before 8

and u do 8

will it unlock 9 after u do 8

[civic vault]

Nope, you gotta do it in order

My white arabian is always scared, even more skittish than my Tukorman. I'm going back to my Tukorman.

[proud cipher]

my horse name is boah

[civic vault]

I named by white arabian snowflake lol

[proud cipher]

cuz he scared?

haha

[civic vault]

Yeah rofl

I name my tukorman Aurora

My MFT Sunset

My silver dappled thorobred Cotton

[proud cipher]

how long does it take to do all 90 challenges u think

[civic vault]

Hmm... judging by everyone's struggle on rhe Gambler challenge, it'll take a few months at least

[proud cipher]

a few months??

tf

[civic vault]

Yeah, ive seen people rage quit a couple of gambler challenges lol

And struggle over them for weeks

[red helm]

Gambler 8 sucks mega moose balls.

[proud cipher]

why

[red helm]

Oh, you will see. You'll see.

[proud cipher]

hmmmmmmm

[ancient trout]

Hey

tips to grow long head hair?

[red helm]

Hair Tonics and sleep.

[proud cipher]

where can i find black or grizzy bears

[red helm]

Big Valley, northwest of Strawberry is a good place for both. Annesburg is a good place for Black's.

[obtuse herald]

hey i just bought the game last night on rockstar, when i click play on steam it just loads up the store page on steam to buy it. someone help the customer service just doesnt understand me, help pls i really want to play this game.

[civic vault]

You didnt buy it on steam?

[obtuse herald]

tbh i bought it on g2a and it says i have it on rockstar but not steam

[civic vault]

You probably need the Rockstar launcher to be able to play it

[obtuse herald]

it says play on steam, there is no option to run it from the rockstar launcher

[civic vault]

Hmmmm

You bought the activation key right?

[obtuse herald]

i had the rdo before getting the single player, should i uninstall and try installing on rockstar

[obtuse herald]

yeah

[civic vault]

Im not sure what went wrong there but it sounds like the activation key is a bust. But have you inputted the activation key beforehand?

[obtuse herald]

yeah, i typed it in the rockstar launcher and then it said it was the game, it took a second to update my library. but it changed my rdo to just rdr2 and when i go to launch it, itsonly for online and it says i have to buy the single player option even though it says rdr2 on rockstar and not just the rdo launcher

im thinking i have to uninstall and then install it again but its a large game so i wanna make sure before doing it and waste time

[civic vault]

Since you typed it in the rockstar launcher, then you play it in the rockstar launcher.

That's how it worked with mine. I bought the activation key as well.

[obtuse herald]

i cant play it on there, it doesnt give me that option 😫

[civic vault]

That's so weird

Head to #how-to-pc and ask people there. Im sure you can find someone who knows this better

[obtuse herald]

i know i have tried uninstalling just about everything except for the huge game

for sure thanks for tha help

[obtuse herald]

online support right?

[civic vault]

Just go to that channel and ask for help there. It's not an official rdr2 online support but there people who know this stuff better

Ah wait, sorry my bad, i typed in the wrong channel. It's #pc-technical-stuff

@obtuse herald

[obtuse herald]

for sure, i uninstalled and its letting me install in the rockstar folder instead of steam's so fingers crossed

[civic vault]

I wanna play right now but im feeling the effects of the booster vaccine 😩

[obtuse herald]

oo dang. do you have a controller? its a much more relaxing game with one and you dont lose a lot of versatility

[civic vault]

Yep, i have my ps4 controller. It's just that my lelf arm suuuucks right now.

[obtuse herald]

big oof

[chilly dune]

I lost my horse because of these damn bounty hunters, it had max Bond and amazing stats 😭.

[civic vault]

Nuuuuuuu

[chilly dune]

I couldnt even revive it because I died right after

Imma tame the arabian, buying a horse is not worth it

[civic vault]

Are there other wild Arabians besides the white one?

[hidden moss]

Ye, a chestnute red, a tiger striped (smrhing like that) and a black one

Though the black one isn’t in the wild

[civic vault]

The chestnut one is near owanjila right?

[blissful orbit]

Arabian aren't that good

[hidden moss]

The chestnut is amazing. Named mine Strawberry😄

[blissful orbit]

The horses you buy are better

i maxed affection a white arabian and got 3/4 of a full stamina circle

missouri fox trotter is wayy better and black arabian is really good too

but the wild one it's good but far from the best

[hidden moss]

U can use custom crafted saddles to make any basic horse good though

[civic vault]

Im thinking of selling my white arabian because it just... gets annoying scared all the time lol

[blissful orbit]

Yeah get a perfect crocodile if you got the sniper or panther if you only got a bow

[blissful orbit]

get a war horse or a shire

[civic vault]

I have my Tukorman but its personality doesnt match the war type lol

It gets a lot scaredy than my MFT

I have the panther saddle as well

[blissful orbit]

i heard crocodile is better but i took it bc it's easier to craft you need to unlock the rolling block tho

[civic vault]

I have the alligator saddle too. Yeah the gator is better for the health stats i think.

I guess it depends on what horse you got

The panther has the highest stat of stamina so i usually use it on my tukorman

[blissful orbit]

I just started epilogue i love it so far it feels like a fresh start from litteraly nothing no money guns items not even a lasso

and i don't know anything except at some point john go help sadie and buy a ranch

[civic vault]

First playthrough?

[blissful orbit]

yes

but i played RDO before and watched gameplay

so i knew a lot about the 6 chapters

but epilogue litteraly nothing

[civic vault]

Regardless, welcome to the red dead depression club

[blissful orbit]

lol

[civic vault]

I still cry on the inside about arthur lol

[blissful orbit]

i actualy waited a bit less than a year before playing story mode it was soo expensive i only got RDO for 5 euros then bought story mode a few months ago when it was -50%

[blissful orbit]

also im waiting for the part where i land a bullet in micah's skull and then ill play RDR1 so i can finish the others

[civic vault]

Yeah i bought rdr2 when it was half as well, last year during Christmas break. I think maybe it caused an influx of new rdr2 gamers. It's nice.

[blissful orbit]

yeah i heard in january it reached as much sales as GTAV but no matter how well the game does R* let it die and then is like "but it don't do money why should we work on it????"

How i do john RDR1 haircut and beard

[civic vault]

Nice nd sad at the same time

[blissful orbit]

man they could atleast communicate but they don't

[civic vault]

That's the most annoying part of the epilogue. Theres no way to get John's original haircut

I just let it grow long and never give him a beard

[blissful orbit]

did i lost the gunslinger's revolvers

like flaco's, granger's and calloway's

[hearty kindle]

What are the 3 horses in the Braithwaite horse stealing mission in chapter 3?

[blissful orbit]

arabian

the 3 variants

well there is 4 with dutch's unique one but there is 3 in braithwaite

[hearty kindle]

?

i know

their is one turkoman

one white arabian

[blissful orbit]

and a black one?

[hearty kindle]

and one other horse

yeah

i think its an arabian

[blissful orbit]

that's a black arabian

[hearty kindle]

but like...

why isnt anyone trying to get that one

over the white arabian

like

[blissful orbit]

Black arabian cost money

[hearty kindle]

ive watched some videos

and theyve all stolen

the white

arabian

[blissful orbit]

oh you mean the mission

[hearty kindle]

and the turkoman

what were u

[blissful orbit]

turkoman is better i think atleast better than white one and the rest of the group take the other horses anyways

[hearty kindle]

talking about?

?

wait

let me see

for a sec

[blissful orbit]

Why kids sound like they are 30 but are like 1m20

[hidden moss]

The world may never know

[hearty kindle]

ok

i found out

its a black arabian

but im not sure if it has better stats than the white arabian

love how u guys r talking about how children talk

but arent realizing that u guys r talking as children would

thanks anyway

[blissful orbit]

np

[proud cipher]

help guys

for master hunter 7

do i need to kill 2 predators and 2 herbivore

or just 1 of each

[civic vault]

I think 1 of each

[queen fossil]

I have a white arabian and i like him

I'm used to scared horses tbh

I have a Nokota since chapter 2

All maxed out

[red helm]

My arm was quite sore as well, from the Booster shot, if you have a Heating Pad that really helped out a lot, though. If you don't have one of those, maybe a Hot water bottle or something.

[proud cipher]

time to get my 6th jab

[young mica]

what happens to the gold on the failed bank job? I thought dutch still had some of the gold when the gang gets washed up on the island in chapter 5

[proud cipher]

what the fuck

"kill an oppusm playing possum"

what the fuck

[civic vault]

yeah rofl

i found the opposum in big valley

near where the cougar spawns

[hearty kindle]

i cant find bucks

that r 3 stars

anywhere

i find like 100 pronghorn bucks

but they dont count as bucks when u craft a satchel

just pronghorns

mad annoying

[young mica]

bruh why didn't dutch take the gold back after he strangles the old woman💀

rescuing javier

yes

yep maybe that's the reason

[civic vault]

Heartlands is your best bet for it

[young mica]

where can i sell a legendary boar pelt?

[hearty kindle]

the trapper

in saint denis

[young mica]

oh ok

[hearty kindle]

(that's where I go)

most of the time

their are trappers in other places

[young mica]

...

[hearty kindle]

but saint denis is kind of like a special spot

[young mica]

as soon as i got to the trapper

arthur fell down and started coughing

[hearty kindle]

ohhhh

[young mica]

damn game

[hearty kindle]

this part is special

dw

just wait

[young mica]

ok

[hearty kindle]

its a part of the story

lol

[hearty kindle]

yo

did u finish the coughing part?

[young mica]

yes

[hearty kindle]

it took u to the doctor

right?

[young mica]

my horse almost got ran over by a trolley after i left the doctor's

[hearty kindle]

lol

what horse r u using ?

[hearty kindle]

u probably take that back now

lol

now that u know what happened

[young mica]

yep

[young mica]

its a tennesse walker

[hearty kindle]

damn

why

r u torturing urself

the game is trying to kill ur horse because its trying to make u get a better one lol

[young mica]

lmao

[vale heart]

lmao, I remember turning off cloud save so that if my horse will die then I will reload the previous save file.

[proud cipher]

guys

i find white arabian in snow

is it good horse

[sweet forum]

no it’s one of the worst horses in the game