#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 574 of 1
He was excited to geld Kierans balls, He flirts with kieran by camp encounter etc
Oh my science
The first one just sounds like him being a psycho tho
True💀
He’s bald, isn’t he?
The second one is more convincing but I've never seen it
Yeah he offers kieran his drink that he was drinking
Why did he need that hair pomade
Hang on I’m tryna stab Jack with the poop pitchfork
Wtaf
Hol' up 
It won’t let me
how u get perfect boar skin
shoot with a bow in the head/upper neck
and ONLY the head if you use a gun
and if you use a gun use a big rifle
like a springfield or bolt action
ok
@vestal cipher do u know how to get perfect alligator skin
is springfiled rifle good for it
idk
i changed my name a long time ago
i hate how i lose honor for looting dead people
like lawmen or strangers
even if i didnt kill them
it has to be 3* beforehand
you can find it around Rhodes
very common
Read if Arthur sucks and is worse than Micah.
Ignore if Micah is better than Arthur.
@frigid cloud does it need to be 3 star boar for perfect pelt
3 star = perfect
2 star = good
1 star = poor
How do you get a perfect pelt
No
For small game
Use varmint rifle
For medium to large the Springfield or bow if u upgrade it are good
Ok thank you
I was walking around Saint Dennis and was robbed at gunpoint by some kids, shot them and got arrested. Then Hosea came with some booze and distracted the guards to rescue me. It's the first time this happens to me. Damn, I love that old man.
He is a great guy
Am I able to go into that guys basement who kidnapped the kid, didnt grab the Litchfield repeater
Brush?
Bet thanks
No but I don’t think it matters because you’re able to grab one during a mission or you can buy one
Yeah currently locked for me
Ill just keep donating 20s to the camp then lol
You get better honor from greeting people and doing those white blips you see on the map
No need to donate stuff just don’t shoot people too much
ola
Yeah just gotta start behaving by the end of the game so I get high honour ending
I got berated by that old ass lady at camp for killing innocent people even tho I have mid honor
I thought it was just anytime it shows Arthur its high honor and whenever it shows the skull its low
do u guys get all the camp upgrades
And theres not really any inbetween
for pearson
My icon is right in the middle of the bar
I just got the ones that give me fast travel, pearsons stuff and the leather workshop
And weapons
is it worth to get every crafting upgrade for pearson
Yeah but is it a skull or arthur
Well it was when I got yelled at by ms. grimhag but Dutch made me kill like 109 cops
Skull
I also like how you gain honor for killing the KKK
I just threw a dynamite stick in the middle of the crowd
Same
Iirc you dont if you dont let the full encounter play out, i made that mistake before or maybe its the other way around
I can check
I did it mid encounter and not only do you gain honor you gain health XP too
Lol i had the max health doing it anyway so i didnt see that
Why do I gotta lose honor for people who come at me first 
Its barely any though
They should have shown the amount you lost like they did in 1
If I go back to guarma as Arthur can I catalogue all the animals?
Or did I miss my chance
If I did that’s gonna piss me off cause I legit only have 1 animal not catalogued
Tbh i dont think any of the missions are open enough to let you get all the animals, depends where it is ig
Itll probably fail the mission if you go too far away etc
Nah there’s a way to get back to guarma
It’s easier with Arthur cause he can swim
And also there’s one point on guarma where u can sorta free roam
But I was a lil impatient
Oh that glitch
Yeah
Yes, but youd have to go back via a previous save which you cant do as youll lose any animals you got after
Its between the first and fourth missions there iirc
Pain in the membrane
I heard I could find a boat there
Or smth
Whatever I’m gonna just painfully ride back to shady belle while unshaken plays
Have you finished the game before by any chance
You could save time if your familiar with the place you go after shady belle
🤷♀️
I wonder just 1 thing about RDR 2: I thing it's the best game in gaming history. I have played it 400 hours and completed story 2 times. It has most detailed open world among all games but why there isn't any whrehouses? Why? I can shoot people, knife people, torture people, gamble, find dinosaur bones, blow something up, find treasures, ancient weapons but I can't have sx. Why?
Closest thing to it is bathing. But yeah I love the game too I played around 5000 hours of it and I'm addicted as you can already see
5000 hours? Aren't you still bored?
Not really I mostly play rdo and restart the story mode, finished it like 4 times now
The only gripes i have with 2 is the removal of liars dice and the other rdr1 minigames, no actual high stakes poker to make money off, no repeatable bounties, no safehouses and the focus on reD dEAd onLinE
We need mexico as a single player dlc lol
Yes, I want Mexico so much.
And shops at mcfarlanes ranch and a proper thieves landing lol
And maybe they should fix southern we and all of new austin to actually be accurate to the original rdr's stuff
Anyone know what the “Unknown Collectable” in the progression list is?
Oh nevermind. Something I haven’t discovered yet
Possibly
Ill tell you what it is if you want
Well it’s the hunting request, but it hasn’t appeared on my list even though i’ve done them all
Whats that one again lol
I would have thought it was the flower one or smth
As in legendary fish and animals?
Oh my god you’re right
I’m so blind
🤣
Hunting request is further down
Thank you!!
Np
I always think its funny how in chapter 4 at camp, all that goes on is dutch screaming at everyone and then everyone talking about TAHITI lol
Time to just go to the Denis domino's back and forth for the black Arabian
I swear in 2 as well fast horses are basically pointless unless all you do is avoid towns like the plague, as your speed limited
Like ive a max speed horse and its essentially the same as a middle of the road one through and near towns, and once it goes offroad it goes very slow although a trinket might fix that i cant remember
Plus, in towns, people/etc keep trying to get in front of you, So, not alot of point in going full gallop anyway.
And then, when you are in a forest type area, you obviously can't go full gallop either, so.. again, whee for high speed.
saint denis wanted after a ped walks right in front of your horse flashbacks
Oh and also, a good way to lose honor very quickly is to throw dynamite into a lake with loads of fish and it kills them all, you literally lose 2 full levels at a time lol
But it makes a really neat splashy animation.
I just got the horse from that polish guy
I swear he wasnt polish
He was
For a price 😈
Who is this exactly
The guy who had basically nothing
Stood in front of the table so you didn't look in there
Where is he
Thomas Downes?
iTs nOT aN aRAbiAn sO iTs bAd
-the rdo community in general
The red Arabian is the prettiest one.
Im so lost in rdo lol
Cant do anything without paying but I also have no money because I cant do anything
But, meh, I stopped using arabians a long time ago, because I got tired of their scaredy-cat-ness.
Cycle of torture
Just play sp 😎
Thats what im doing
Id like to play rdo but it just seems like everything is gonna be a grind
Like GTAO, but Ive already got everything in GTAO
Why would you want to play it when literally the same stuff is in rdr2 and its actually done correctly
☠️ gTaO
Idk
And half the people I meet in rdo are either tryhards or people dressed like a klansman
There are some cool people though
Theres no shows in red dead online 🤓
Red dead opressor mk2
😐
Tbh i wouldnt be surprsed if r* add some op thing into rdo just to keep the diehard tryhard fans happy
Can someone give me a 100% completion list for rdr2?
Its literally in the game though in progression
Says what you need, and how much of each thing
Damn bruh I know rdo is realistic but I didnt think theyd keep the poverty line this realistic
Rdo isnt realistic lol
Ppl didnt go around like players do
11 bucks to my name with no way to make money other than freeroam missions that im too underpowered for
And no ammo
bUy gOLd
Im literally just suicide bombing these 5 targets with a knife
And whenever I die just run back to camp and stab again
Join micah then 😈
He'll give you free gold
Why did they call Uncle Uncle?
Well, he's got LUMBAGO
Navy Revolvers.
Are there stranger missions I can only do in certain chapters or can I just get to like chapter 4 and then do all the stranger missions and bounty hunting? I’m trying to get 100%
there are certain missions that can only be done in certain chapters
I was in Armadillo earlier today, walking around, and a town crier is talking to me about how the city is ridden with disease (cholera, I think). And he hands me a pamphlet but I had the choice of accepting it or refusing it. I thought that was weird, that it was giving me a choice to say no to a piece of paper. Couple hours later and I feel like I made a mistake much like Arthur did with Downes. Is John gonna get sick?
Cholera is very rarely passed through casual contact, though.
Have you ever tried to get on your horse and end up grabbing someone?
YES
Once in the middle of saint denis
So many witnesses for "disturbing the peace"
Seems like only whenever I’m changing his clothes or getting his hair cut Arthur decides to make the most interrupting facial expressions ever.
Whenever he sits in the barbers chair he looks like he’s suffering from indigestion.
Skinners
does rdr2 take place in colorado?
In which chapter are the hunting requests for the It’s Art achievement available?
It’s more like a bunch of places mirroring real areas smashed together
To me it kinda seem like it just takes place in america
yeah
There’s dry west like arizona or new mexico, there’s lemoyne like louisiana and so on
it’s a lot condensed into a smaller map
Speaking of America, after you come back from Guarma do you need to get a new horse
I’ve been trying to hunt many rabbits so I can rank up in one of the challenges am I just bad at hunting rabbits or do I need the legendary buck trinket in order to get a perfect pelt? If anyone will say it yes I have been using the Varmint Rifle
There’s a lot of rabbits in the Heartlands. Mostly east of the oil derrick scribble
It’s confirmed that lemoyne is Louisiana and saint denis is New Orleans
Use the bow instead
Y
Thanks
Can someone help me with this tho pls
Nope
Ty
You haven’t finished story?
Nope
Oh shi
I just started playing 2 weeks ago lol
It’s been out for a while though
Ooohhh
I was playing far cry 6 since October
Is it possible to fall off the prologue horse while in midair I’ve jumped down ledges with that horse that other horses either died on or fell on to
I just got my bounty hunter license today
???
Cool
But how are you doing in red dead?
Pretty good
I’m a little low level though
What chapter are you on
Me?
5
Both
I’ve finished story 4 times
Oh
I just got out of that island with those colorful ass birds
Guarma
Oh cool
Ye
I want to finish rage 2011 but I kind of feel like doing a low honor play through after I finish
Unpopular opinion: chapter 4 was pretty bad
I remember searching up the RDR2 Arthur endings before I finished the game for the first time, for some reason I never saw the bad honor help John ending
Oh
Bruh Arthur > rdr2 John
Rdr1 John >>>>> Arthur though
I remember there’s a side quest where you have to pluck birds and send it to this guy near Saint Denis and eventually you’ll get the Algernon Revolver, does anyone know if this mission is available in Chapter 2?
Let me try searching it up
although I didn’t finish all of the side quests, I mainly did the good ones
Same I’m not interested in the ones where you have to look for rocks and plants or something
Yeah
The dinosaur bones are actually kind of cool though
The Calloway side quests are really good
Duchesses and Other Animals
The old lady gave me a piece of quartz or something
Black Belle?
She ain’t even that old
I saw a rib cage in new Hanover and thought it was from a cow or ant
Oh nevermind I just realized Ruger was talking about the dinosaur bones
Oh
the dinosaur mission is so bad sorry
fr though
Fr
I got like 3 bones
this old hag really expects us to go around the map looking for 30 bones for a knife?
What is the knife?
my favorite side mission is the calloway quest
It’s cool to find pieces of dinosaurs but I am not spending time going through the entire world and mailing out coordinates of bones for a piece of a fucking rock or ant
idk its some archaoelogy knife
What chapter do I unlock the Calloway mission in?
I feel like it should be a main mission because it’s so good
2
Thanks
What’s the Calloway side mission
You get revolvers and money
where you have to go and find gunslingers who knew jimboy calloway & ask them questions for Theodore Levin's book
💀
Wait is that the chapter for the other Legendary Gunslinger missions for the one specifically for Calloway where you save him and then kidnap him after talking to an Annesberg Sheriff?
what time is it for y’all
Yea are you supposed to find their pictures on the cigarette cards
12:25
Pm or am
11:25
It’s dark
Oh same
So am
Yea
opinions on Micah?
nah
I don’t like him he sounds emo
Plus he’s old
And fat
I think he’s a great antagonist
Best one I’ve seen in a game so far
Ima leave chat before any spoilers show up
Go ahead
Talking about how Micah kills Dutch and turns Arthur into a sex slave or ant
Bro what 💀
Micah doesn’t kill Dutch
I’m still trying to process what I just read
Did you play rdr1?
Omg same
Dutch is in rdr1
No
Makes sense
If it comes after this game if I won’t have to worry about it until later
Dutch is in rdr1, so he doesn’t die in rdr2
I don’t want to spoil anything for you if you want to play RDR1 so I’ll let you spoil it yourself, either search up an entire playthrough of the game or search up an entire video of the mission And The Truth Will Set You Free
Bruh let him finish rdr2 first
You’re right
Skinners
Do i get anything for having max honor?
💀
same
Bruh
nah dw it'll be at camp but to get there you need to steal a horse
What type of horse is the Count
better dialogue, cutscenes, cheaper stuff in stores and a good ending
Elite
what’s the best pistol to use
Hungarian half bread
Cool ty
Thanks
Volcanic
I keep accidentally pointing my gun at people when I just want to say hello and they run
Dual volcanic or dual semi autos
I was in saint denis! And i antagonize a guy! He started to punch and stuff!
Sawed dutch came and shoot him!
idt you lose honor
Don’t hit R2 or RT or whatever pc is
For real
How is dutch there?
Is this during a mission?
what about the best revolver
Lol do the glitch thing
Navys
Navy
I don’t I just press left trigger and it makes me raise my gun
how do you get the navy revolver
Put it away?
This dude got bit by a snake and I wanted to get the option to save him but instead I put my revolver in his face and he bled to death
Buy it
Buy it
It’s only 275 I think
Idk
I don’t have it
Gun store
I was literally answering my own question
Idk I never put it away, sometimes it lets me look at them without raising my gun and sometimes it makes me threaten them
😐
half price on everything
dude wtf
Just put the gun away
is the navy revolver only in online
Ok
Yes
ye
Does that explain the free meat and goods?
yes
well what about best revolver in story mode
idk about free
schofield
Schofield, but for me it's the double action
or calloways
The free meat you not get that?
There are variants of the navy revolver only available online but you can buy the regular navy revolver in story mode
I like calloways
i prefer schofield
This Asian guy just yelled at me for no reason
I like the Litchfield
Litchfield
Litchfield
Lancaster is the only answer
Oooo those are nice too
Lancaster + express
More damg tho
lancaster is awesome
Litchfield + Express for hunting legendaries
Especially with express
Wait no I use regular repeater ammo
I just use bolt action rifle and express
Lancaster is weaker than the carbine
I use Springfield with Express for legendaries
Any rock rifle users?
There’s an entire red dead online folder of chats
My bad
Springfield? Lmao
why is everyone in my camp so goddamn broke, i’m donating hundreds of dollars while they only donate 5 dollars
It takes everything out in 1-2 shots so it works for me
Upgrade the place bro
Springfield wishes it was the bolt action rifle
More people will contribute
How
Bolt action is so bad
bolt action is better
Like the camp, upgrade the camps and sht
I’ll start using the bolt action rifle when I get the rare variant in Chapter 3
How
Like arthurs tent, dutch tent etc
just use carcano
i upgraded dutches tent already
Multiple shots so you don’t need to keep reloading, high shots especially with express
I don’t want to buy guns I just either steal them or find them
rolling block is better
The one that’s handed to you by that rebel huh
Can you switch from shoulder fire and scoped fire tho
Bet
Dawg how
Look at this mf
FR
Ay man
isnt the carcano weaker?
No
bruh my game is broken than
Carcano is tough my g
Can u shoulder fire the carcano or scoped fire only!!!
Ok then not buying it
Lol
Carcano is the best for long range
Nor is it a normal rifle, which is why I am not interest
Litchfield: taken from the basement of the gunsmith in Rhodes after I killed him.
Granger, Flaco, other gunslinger’s: taken
It’s a rifle bro lol just not a repeater
It’s a bolt action
Lancaster I thought
Scoped rifles and normal rifles are different
Imma head out now
You still have time to del-
Ahhhh damn
Aight imma head out too
bye
Not joking, different animals will die to a scoped rifle or a normal bolt action rifle
I know, and you can switch the scopes from shoulder to scoped
Scoped rifles that come with a scope on them already will only give you one option
Unless you remove the scope yourself which I’m not sure you can do
Unrelated I went to the lodging bar in saint denis and saw a guy who really looks like bill Clinton

Who is your least favorite character in the red dead series including red dead revolver and red dead online that isn’t Micah, Dutch, Strauss, Edgar Ross, or Harriet (RDO Naturalist)
Let him be bro
ok
Harriet? Hahahahahaha
Hmmm
griffon from revolver
You know I was thinking of someone still and then I drifted off and ended up watching NBA highlights from Lastnight
Lmaoooo
It’s pretty hard to find an answer mainly because you can’t pick any of the most hated and well known characters in Red Dead, not sure if I missed any from Revolver though
True true
Tbh I’d go with Micah’s accomplices lol
Clyde and Cleet or whatever their names were
Cleet and Joe
I hate the Cleet that stole Arthur's money
Do I get my guns back after returning from guarma
I checked the gun shop and it says that I have to buy them all again
@hidden moss gr8 name bro
Yk theres a glitch to get unlimited gold bars
No
Just send a dm
Alr
Thank you!
help
i have legendary beaver gloves
but they are not in my clothing thing
i look in gloves they not there
nvm
can you just keep smoking premium cigerates and get all the cards that way
When you found the perfect robin but you didn't........
That always confused me lmao
Bcs any guns and money and items you had on you during the bank heist would be at the bottom of the ocean
Wait what
When did he did that?
I missed that
Then i shouldve shot him as john
I refused to hang him just for sadie to shoot him soooooo
Eh I just couldn't do it
However much of a prick he was we just jumped him and put him in the gallows
Didn't feel right
Ye
I also couldnt do it before
I made all the honourable decisions but then I did barely any stranger missions
I saved hamish but then I forgot to go back and see him
Yeah, i made sure i completed those missions
One of the most depressing scenes in the game imho
The epilogue is gonna hurt me again despite the cheerful scenes with the Marstons
Yeah but tbh the epilogue wasnt that sad imo, apart from any parts reflecting on arthur
It wasnt as strong as other parts of the game like i said yesterday
Yeah
I mean
I only got sad because eveything good that happened to John was something Arthur could've had if he lived
And that huuuurts meeee
Well to be perfectly honest, john didnt really fully become good in the end, and he paid for it at the end of rdr1 when you think about it
Yeah well true
But
Man
When Arthur and Mary's photo was showed while John held the ring
Ripped my heart
The house building... he couldve been there helping to build it
Now i cry
And if he didnt kill micah, none of rdr would have happened, and they killed off a good villian and character lol
But man... if Arthur lived, John wouldve hunted him down in rdr1. Which is just as painful.
This stupid how you meant to catch the stagecaoch with micah idk
Tbh i think by that stage, arthur would have moved on and maybe have moved away with mary tbh
Magic
(Use a rifle)
That annoyed me too lol
Use deadeye as well
Kill the stagecoach ppl quick at the start
its fucking impossible it cant be done s
I have no clue how to use dead eye on my controller
Press the two analogue sticks at the same time while aiming a weapon, and aim at the heads of the people your meant to kill
easy for you so get on my account do it or thx for noting
can I skip or cancel the mission its to fucking hard it cant be done
Or just fail the same part 3 times and skip it
nope dont waste my time
I dont want to skip it
so either do it for me please or I am done here
You just said itS so hArd iM gOnnA sKip iT and now you dont want to?
For reference
Do what?
Your the one that can easily skip it, i dont see your issue
@lyric zephyr the mission I was stuck on did you do it yes or no
As in have i done it before, or have i magically done it for you?
fucking smart arse
And for reference, yes i did the mission before on mu first try
🤦♀️
Ah yes, because you wont skip the mission even after me telling you to you just take your anger out on everyone else
nope they made that mission to hard
red dead 2 has a lot of hard missions for no reason
dont give any excuses
the game is diffult and doesnt need to be
What so difficult about it
that mssion with micah for a start off with the stagecoach
What do you play on
me pc why
Just wondering I play on Xbox it’s easy to aim I don’t know if it’s the same on PC
no the missions are to hard for no reason
Its the length of some of the missions rather than the difficulty thats the issue
not really they are hard for no reason
And i cant see why you dont just skip one part of the mission and continue on from there
Why?
Rage quit the game and dont play it, or skip 20 seconds of the mission and keep playing it
Your choice
The Guarma mission took me so long
And the end of chapter 6
Tbh i just flew through it as i wanted to get it over with, the hardest part is that f'ing rocking the chair part
then how you did it straight away then
I did know how long it would take so I started it then I had to go to school so I never finished it and I had to restart it again it took me too long
Imo from the bank heist in 4 to the end of ch 6 should be played in like one continuous playthrough or else like the only game you play as the story seems to effect you more idk
Rip
Or at least do it so its the only thing you do when playing the game*
Was chapter 4 bank heist the last mission of chapter 4?
Yep
Its also the best place to stop imo if you wanna stay as arthur more or less forever lol
You can just avoid the eagle flies mission and like every member is at camp and you can do any camp requests or the pelts etc
is there a mod that imports rdo outfits into singleplayer?
Best place to stop is after rescuing Sean and not doing Thomas Downes or breaking out Micah mission
For ch2 i normally stop at the td and the keiran mission tbh
which one?
that's easy tho-
The second micah mission with the stagecoach, theyre too stubborn to skip it
do they know that dead eye exists-
🤷♀️
with dead eye that mission is realyy easy
Fr
Micah be like bruh
one of the easiest
you don't even get hurt that easily
ye that was kinda hard since you don't get much cover
Great
The horse I called 3 minutes ago finally came and slammed into the horse I was already riding
Now carrying a body and I cant call my horse
the mission is stupid thats why
I skipped it
that was literaly just to stupid
and to qucik
how people did it Idk but it was to hard it shouldnt have been
So tell you fucking smart arses how you did it
@errant glen I couldnt fuckintg do it okay
clearly I am fucking stupid
doesnt matter I did it
or skipped it
I was stuck on the stagecoach mission with micah
doesnt matter I just couldnt do it because I am fucking stupid
nope tried dead eyes didnt work tried to catch up and shoot them didnt work please explain what else I missed
I did catch up
I couldnt kill them
I did ride after hum
Fuck
nope
Shit
they just made it to hard didnt need to me
be
okay it was to hard
like why they had to idk
yes it fucking is
prove to me its not fucking hard you idiot
No need to have a tantrum😬
I didnt do it
I am just trying to tell you it was to hard but you all fucking pro gamers think it isnt
Ikr :evil-1:
Just get good
is there any way to replay side missions?
pretty sure they can be replayed in the menu based on what chapter you did them in
look up literally any video of someone doing it online
but I can't find the side missions
can you not find them, or do you not remember what they are called?
actually nvm, you cant replay them
a quick internet search revealed this
the one I want is "the noblest man and something else I don't remember"
looks like someone’s mad
a woman
you could just either go back to an older save or start a new game to play it idk
ikr, clearly a kid ngl
tbh those guns arent that good (unless its for compendium which i just read rip)
do you have an older save?
which one was it
granger's revolver
bro i've played like 1 shooting game- and that's rdr2
oh ye it goes if you leave it
thanks hosea
Rdr1 and 2's deadeye makes me rubbish at manual aiming in the rare time i play a fps game lmao
Does anyone else here think Dutch went insane due to the head injury he sustained in the mission where they were set up by bronte?
That, and micahs influence obviously
I just think Micah changed him
I think dutch just more or less wanted to get out
same 💀
Hosea stopped Micah from getting this close to Dutch
But what if this was Dutches "goddamn PLAN" the whole time lol
But also 
to mess up my aiming?
No, to destroy the van der lind gang lol
Wait nvm thought you replied to the other message
☠️ maybe ive gone crazy too lol
🤣🤣
Fuck rdo 

yo
this game is just needsly hard but hope all you enjoy bye
No
Every horse is worthy of respect, love, and appreciation. Even if it doesn’t meet your demands.
honestly john was the mastermind and the raat, he didnt like that i whipped that nae nae too hard so framed me
nah he just drank the lean juice
Exactly
You had the gangs best interests at heart, MONEH
Bruh
?
it’s not but ok, you enjoy aswell now
I found the corpse of a Chinese man outside Armadillo. And a cool hat.
Letter on him says he was looking for a family member. Is there any more to the story?
no. proceeds to murder horses who kick me when I loot saddle bags 
only as John tho. Arthur is a good boah, I never feel like doing something bad when it’s Arthur
You monster
I remember a south Asian man moving bodies of people who died of cholera near armadillo. Told me to steer clear of the place, don’t wanna die of shitting and pissing now
Tbh i could see both of them doing bad deeds
yes ofc, Arthur does bad deeds and I have done bad deeds as arthur but after playing the story it doesn’t feel right, especially after ch3 when shit gets serious
Yeah, but bad arthur still fits into the story in some way, and id say the low honor ending would make the micah haters happier in the epilogue but idk
killing someone after they instigated a fight
doing a stranger mission that involves killing loads of people
guys
can you get all the cigerate cards by smoking or do u need to find most of them
ok
yes, that is what happened. that injury also allowed micah to manipulate him easier
just go on youtube buddy
if you want find them all quick
I thought so
But like idk why he suddenly went so bad after guarma and outright started killing ppl for no reason etc (and in camp in ch4 dutch just rages at everyone, especially john and goes uber paranoid lol so it was probably before that)
you need to do it before you get to guarma from the boat or invis snipers will kill you because technically in the game guarma is a part of new austin
and both arthur and john are wanted in all of new austin
but john wont die because hes
yk
so you might be able to do go to guarma just without glitches as john
you guys know the island by rhodes where u can find crabs and iguanas
and snkaes
where do you find foxes on that island?
.
okay so i finished rdr2 with my gold bars and im in epilogue part 1 and i look in my valubles and dont see my gold bars
theres still invis snipers and john
at guarma
ok i saw one spawn there but run away and never found others
I dont think gold bars transfer to john
I wore that Skull Cap for a little bit, because it looked neat. But, as for the letter, I doubt you could find the family. There were some other random letters you could find some corpses, that just lead to dead ends, unfortunately.
Dont worry keep playing, you will get some money 
Poopie. But, yeah, you only keep Unique items when you switch to John.
gOld bArs arent in rdr2
They are in rdo obviously
Or idek if its the same thing
gold bars sell for 500 in rdr2
I found quite a few foxes over by the Trapper in Tall Trees. Also, over by Butcher Creek/Beaver Hollow area.
Nvm wasnt the same thing then lol
Apologies
Yes, Gold bars are a thing in Single player.
At least they arent bought via real money lol
That would be very silly. As easy as it is to get money.
what spoiler
Yes and you can sell them to a fence for 500 dollars each
Moneh!
Miss Marjorie's stage scene is hilarious. It had me cracked up laughing my butt off
the snake one?
Yeah lmao
i have a fear of reptiles
so i kinda hope shes alright
Evening, sire
why is the appleseed timber co abandoned
i was here like a few ingame days ago and i killed some wolves
and then a tree fell and killed a guy
and i come back and its abandoned
Because they deforested everything, and then left
Their job was done once the wolves were killed so they could continue
No
ok
and do you know why the guy that was building the house is gone now
i accidently kill him and try to go back and he shoot me so i kill em again
now i go back and they left
This is why
The house still gets built later on anyway and serves 0 purpose unlike some of the other "dynamic" places
ok
Also there's a railroad company somewhere in epilogue 1 and only epilogue 1
no
central union railroad co
its in chapter 2
the one where somene steal wages
i did that
i think theres a second part to it but idk
no
Right
why u delete mesage
i regret not going after the sachtels back in chapter 2
chapter 4 camp doesn't feel as homey
does the legendary gunslinger weapons save to john marston???
I think he was being sarcastic lmao, I also think head injury thing is stupid and Dutch showing his true colors without Hosea there to keep him check is what the real deal is
yes they do
Everything saves to John except horses, money, some valuables and food/ingredients. Everything else like your guns, saddles, equipment and such transfers to John
what?
so you dont get any of your money back?
im almost at the end
but that is so sad
i have $1500
on aurthur
i think you can save money
with the
aberdeen pig farm
horses? thats another problem
Hey all,
l am on my first game of RDR2 (yeah, l'm late l know) and l have found that l gathered the 3 parts of the meteorite.l searched on internet a bit and l only see peoples asking where to find it.
This is the answer : l don't know. l just saw my 3/3 meteorites on my way to sell some stuff.
Can somebody tell me if the answer has been found officially ?
Where can we find the 3rd part ?
And what to do with it if there is really a mystery or l can just sell them ?
Some informations about my game, in case it can help :
- l am at chapter 3
- l am playing with ScriptHook+NativeTrainer (maybe l made it spawn with the mod ? l don't know)
- l have visited the house related to the meteorite and the meteorite area itself (and looted everything)
Thanks all !
i dont think its a mystery tho
idk, everybody is speaking about a mystery, so l hope there is something secret ahah
Well, l will keep it anyway. My bag is a mess because l keep everything. 😄
same
Have you seen my friend ???
l am searching for him, l am so worried
Bruh i lost a legendary fish because of john drowning
Get John some floaties.
W
And I fucking massacred van horn
The one you take from the dead body of an enemy inside a barn at the end of a chapter 3 mission
I think it's he's already rotten early on. I got that weird comment from Dutch back in chapter 2 when he said "You'll betray me Arthur, you're the type." He's paranoid back then
Use the IGN Interactive Map for RDR2 the YouTube videos for finding all the cigarette cards are 2-3 hours long
I mean yeah, but it’s clear the game intends to make you broke boy marston
the pig farm is more or less a glitch
Ever since that head injury Dutch has been a lot more aggressive than usual. He even comments at the end of that mission that he doesn't feel well.
Well yeah the whole game is about Dutch’s descent to craziness and Arthur ascending to become a better man. Like poetry they say
head injury makes it stupid
If it were the case the game would emphasize on it and make it clear later
I agree. I don't really think it was the head injury
yeah John always talked about Dutch like ‘people become more of they truly are’ with someone in the epilogue if I remember
Even before chapter 2, the first indication should be Dutch going for the train heist to smite the O'Driscolls despite them in desperation to survive
like why would he say all that just for Dutch to go crazy cuz he got bonked on the head
what valuables dont save
exactly. Also how he acted like killing colm’s brother was nothing but when colm killed annabelle it was a big deal. Was a major red flag
Common stuff iirc like the belt buckles, pocket watches and stuff. Collectibles like reitlinger or whatever it was called and Catherine’s broche save
also that fake emerald
do gold bars save
nope
ok
i was going to save all my valuables for john so i could buy everything but guess not anymroe
is it better to give the cigerate cards to the collector or hold on to them or sell them to fence
if you wanna save your money, before doing our best selves sell all your gold and valuables, all you food and tonics aswell and then head to Aberdeen pig farm. Get robbed, come back and kill them but don’t take your money back just go do the mission then come back as John and you get all of Arthur’s money
ok
do you know if its possible to finish the fisher of fish as arthur and all of the hunting requests @fluid cypress
marston isnt broke at all
i wonder why he didnt share the 20k money with his wife and son
still
its
his
son and wife
ok probably not his son but
his wife
do u get all ur money back after chapter guarma and everything else
yeah
why so she can go be gold digger
Is there a low honor version and high honor version of the ending with john
No but the ending you choose with Arthur (go back for the money, help John) affects the ending of the epilogue, only one part of the ending though
nope
i don’t think so
but not sure since I don’t fish
Mans was earning 3$ a day that’s pretty broke ngl
3$ in 1899
think about it
it would be worth around
100$
nowday
What’s better prologue horse or the Arabian horse on the West side of Owanjia
So like
My horse died when I got ambushed by Lemoyne Raiders
And this was when my prolongued horse was leveled up and sht
Then i had to resort to a new horse
I was literally guttered when i lost my horse
Lemoyne raiders are so annoying
When I got ambushed and my horse died 10 of them started shooting at me from horseback at once

Assuming you meant the Epilogue, Rose Gray Arabian in the Blackwater Stable? That one is actually the best Arabian. and the one west of Owanjila, unfortunately has the lowest stats, though, I think it looks the best.
Yeah, the one you get from Sadie's ranch, I think is a Thoroughbred. However, there is no prologue. The game starts off with Chapter 1. So, I thought he was meaning the Epilogue...
Ah
i've always wondered what horse breed is Bodicea
always
save
i wish theres a way to get albino arabian
It's not but ok...
ikrr
ruins the fun
nope
Not sure if it works evertime but when people shoot first and i shoot back in defense, i dont get low honor and i aint wanted.
how do i play with other people
Get RDO
Don’t. It’s trash tbh. You either sell your soul and grind all week to have fun or pay for micro transactions. Just stick to single player, it’s much better
not to mention it isn’t even much fun even with friends it gets old quick
Can any1 Look at my pic in rdr fashion and tell me?
This belt buckle
the reason why arthur morgan got 5000$ bounty is because
he keeps a fat stack of miracle tonics in his inventory
Im doing the electric chair side mission and even though Arthur claims he doesnt understand what's gonna happen, he sure is smart enough to theorize it right
He's making analogies on the how lightning strikes on an animal
Smart dude despite what everyone thinks of him
Smarter than i thought he was


