#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 571 of 1

hidden moss
#

Antognize:hey moron

willow cosmos
#

Try looking near Rhodes they usually spawn around there

civic vault
#

Okie

hidden moss
#

Spawning

#

@willow cosmos

willow cosmos
#

Just keep on catching fish in that area and keep on storing them into you're satchel so they don't go on you're bait again or if that doesn't work just go to another spot and reel in again and repeat or set up a camp, sleep, save the game, then load in that save and then it should spawn

hidden moss
#

That old man that cries by the fire about his legacy and job and crap that you return his belongings to and burn some of it, I lasso'd him into the fire and got reputation + LMAO

#

He was racist I think

#

He's burnt to a crisp now oi oi

willow cosmos
#

Yeah he sold slaves

drifting nacelle
#

Arthur <> John?

willow cosmos
#

Arthur

#

It was proven by rockstar xd

willow cosmos
late notch
#

hi i wanna know whats the best chapter or best mission to save so that i can replay as arthur

civic vault
#

I finally found a badger in clemens point lol

#

Got 2 new satchels in like 4 hours lol

drifting nacelle
#

Ok

fluid fjord
#

arabian is good but so tiny

fluid fjord
civic vault
#

I wanted arthur riding higher than dutch lol

civic vault
#

I picked my victim for the horseman challenge.

#

The eugenics guy at saint denis

hidden moss
#

What’s the best horse in story

late notch
#

im not too far in the story so it wouldnt matter

civic vault
#

Is it your first playthrough?

late notch
#

yea

#

the story has mostly been spoiled for me so

#

thats why im asking

untold marsh
#

Hey if you guys/girls want a really fun challenge, hunt Florida panthers with free aim and a tomahawk improved

#

Shit is hard

untold marsh
fickle chasm
#

I currently have Beull

civic vault
hidden moss
#

What should I spend my money on

untold marsh
#

If you want to find an Arabian, then I can tell you

#

But it's a spoiler

hidden moss
#

Ok where

untold marsh
#

Can I DM?

#

Most don't want things spoiled

hidden moss
#

Yeah

civic vault
late notch
civic vault
# late notch 3

Well, you're a bit halfway. Unless the gang have just moved to the new camp

#

If you've just moved, then i guess it's okay to restart

late notch
#

oh ok

#

im close to finishing chapter 3 i thinl

#

so if i restart, does it delete my saves?

civic vault
#

Hmmm not sure about xbox version

late notch
#

oh ok

civic vault
#

Do you have the option to manually save?

late notch
#

yeah

#

well it can't hurt too bad to reply the story again

#

once im done

thick knot
#

When do you get buell I’m in ch 3 but I’ve played the game before and never gotten buell

civic vault
untold marsh
#

This may seem like a dumbass question but I'm tired of my weapons not staying on when I get off my horse

thick knot
#

Oh damn

untold marsh
#

Especially in town

#

Tf is going on

thick knot
#

U gotta make sure u have them equipped

untold marsh
#

I've been playing this game for around 300-500 hours now and still haven't figured it lut

#

I have

civic vault
untold marsh
#

Sometimes it holsters them while charging

#

Then they aren't on me when I get off

#

Most of the time it's fixed but

fluid fjord
#

the golden coat has always looked good to me

#

but pure stats damn the arabian is just a liiittle bit higher

untold marsh
#

Turkoman is a great choice

fluid fjord
#

turkoman is a good horse yeah

#

i used one in online

thick knot
#

Ardennes unbeatable

#

So thick

untold marsh
#

I wish the andrenas were better in speed and acl stats

thick knot
#

Thicc*

#

The speed makes less than a 10% difference

untold marsh
#

Usually use them for hideout farming

thick knot
#

So I don’t even look at speed stats

untold marsh
#

I see

thick knot
#

Just stamina and health

untold marsh
#

The most pretty imo are the black standardbreds

thick knot
#

Idk tbh I rlly like the white shire and Ardennes the most

civic vault
#

It all depends on the preference. I prefer fast and high stamina horses. But i dont mind than it's a bit slower that the mft

untold marsh
thick knot
#

White shire just looks like the white Arabian but huge

thick pewter
#

Do you reckon rdr3 could go over hosea as hes younger?

thick knot
#

And majestic

untold marsh
#

I will say tho, andrenas will almost never kick you

#

Bigger hitbox too 😂

civic vault
#

And i also like the tall ones.

thick knot
#

I think rdr3 would logically be further back following the story of young Arthur and the gang however you won’t be playing as Arthur

civic vault
#

My arthur has always had a big horse,

thick knot
#

Most likely somebody you don’t already know the fate of

thick pewter
thick knot
#

And yeah Arthur seems like the type of dude to ride a big horse

untold marsh
#

What's your guys favorite chapter of the story?

thick knot
#

Definitely not cause I need to be towering over Dutch and Micah at all times

thick knot
civic vault
#

And he's a big tough guy, it just matches well when he got a big horse

untold marsh
#

I think it's chapter 6

thick knot
#

Especially when he’s riding back from being tortured by the odriscolls

#

A big horse just fits

untold marsh
#

My favorite was the 2nd epilogue and chapter 3

thick knot
#

I actually have never finished the epilogue in any play through a

untold marsh
#

The first few missions were stale in chapter 3 imp

#

Imo

civic vault
untold marsh
#

Oh uh I'm around 80 percent completion lmao

civic vault
#

Just wanted to see the very end lol

thick knot
#

I did too

#

Just slapped Micah

#

Kinda mad how Micah always has the walk off death tho

#

Instead of being able to like

#

Dismember his limbs with a shotgun

civic vault
#

The epilogue just made me sad despite the happy scenes

thick knot
#

Like I don’t want anybody to recognize his body

hardy mauve
#

lmao same

untold marsh
thick knot
#

||Has anybody tried setting the barn you fight Micah in on fire||

#

Well not rlly barn

#

Whatever tf the shack is

untold marsh
#

Jail?

#

🤔

thick knot
#

No when you shoot him at the end

untold marsh
#

Oh

thick knot
#

When he’s hiding in the shack

untold marsh
#

Idk

#

That's smart honestly

thick knot
#

Ima try burning it down this time

#

Lmfao

untold marsh
#

Never thought of that

#

Damn bro

hardy mauve
#

same tbf

untold marsh
#

Don't think it's possible tho

thick knot
#

Idk it’s in the snow so might not be

#

But it is a wood shack

#

I’m theory might work

untold marsh
#

Really smart idea tho bro, I'm pretty impressed

#

Brooo

thick knot
#

||Yeah I aimed right at the door I knew the guards were gonna run out of||

untold marsh
#

Remember to spoiler stuff lol

thick knot
#

Oh

#

How do I do that

untold marsh
#

For the lads who haven't played

thick knot
#

I’ll edit my mags

#

Msgs

untold marsh
#

Okay here's an example

#

Put these on the end and beginning on your text ||

#

Two

thick knot
#

Ok thx

hardy mauve
#

i did that but i think my message got deleted

untold marsh
#

Fr

#

Mine did too

#

I just found out

#

That's stupid

hardy mauve
#

yeah

thick knot
#

Oh

untold marsh
#

🤦‍♂️

thick knot
#

Lol

untold marsh
#

Well for any other occasion, not trying to nitpick homie

thick knot
#

No I understand

untold marsh
#

That's just kinda what spoiled some of rdr2 for me

#

Lucy Lu did

thick knot
#

I wouldn’t wanna have the game spoiled for me either

hardy mauve
#

lol

untold marsh
#

Never forget that

untold marsh
#

This game is old anyway lmao

hardy mauve
#

yeah

untold marsh
#

It's like spoiling GOW at this point

hardy mauve
#

but by only 4 years nearly

untold marsh
#

Yeah 4 years

thick knot
#

It’s crazy how still I have not played a game with graphics like rdr2

#

And it’s been 4 years

hardy mauve
#

fr

untold marsh
#

RDR2 was robbed of a game of the year tbh

#

GOW stole that

thick knot
#

Yeah I hate to say it but I definitely enjoyed rdr2 more than gow

untold marsh
#

Yeah, much more detail and depth in RDR2

thick knot
#

Yup

untold marsh
#

Just wasn't as popular as RDR2

thick knot
#

Even just the open world

untold marsh
#

GOW

#

I mean

#

Yess

thick knot
#

Destroyed any game of its time

#

Lol

hardy mauve
#

is gow good or

#

what type of game is it

thick knot
#

Yeah gow is amazing

untold marsh
#

Imagine spending a whole ass 8 years on a game development and not get GOTY

#

It is

#

But no near as good as RDR2

thick knot
#

Yeah idk

#

Still has the best open world of all time

untold marsh
#

Where near

#

Anyway, I'm done ranting

#

Yup

hardy mauve
#

what type of game is it tho

#

i mostly like western games

untold marsh
#

GOW is basically a big ass baby sitting game

#

Bonding time with a child you don't know

hardy mauve
#

oh

#

i probs wont like it then lmao

untold marsh
#

It's the spartan kratos

#

The most used name throughout the game is "BOY"

#

BOY

hardy mauve
#

lol

untold marsh
#

Hardly ever calls him son

hardy mauve
#

Lol

untold marsh
#

Bro I sound so rantish

#

I'm so sorry

#

Lmao

hardy mauve
#

Lol its fine.

civic vault
#

At least Roger Clark won an award. He deserved to with that

thick knot
#

Getting naturalist role to lvl 5 fr killing my brain cells

#

Oh wait this is singleplayer chat

untold marsh
#

Lmao

mystic raven
#

i just found out gators eat floating bodies
(throwing the body in the swamp)

untold marsh
#

Is there any hideout bigger than gaptooth breech in RDR2?

mystic raven
thick knot
#

Lol

untold marsh
#

How bad is it if you have max bounty lvl?

#

Do they have like aimbot and insane dmg?

#

Or is it no different from a 300 dollar bounty

#

Are you wanted across all states?

#

I'm really debating it, it seems fun and a good challenge to maintain that 1,500k bounty

thick knot
#

Never tried it although you’d probably be hunted very very often lol

untold marsh
#

Probably, I really am anxious to try, that's a fatass bounty tho

mystic raven
#

yeah my guess is
More frequent bounty hunters will appear

#

Idk how to spell

#

damn

untold marsh
#

And more?

#

You're good bro

mystic raven
untold marsh
#

Sounds fun, just can't die lmao

mystic raven
#

oh and dont set up camp in the region u have abounty

#

you are gonna have a bad time

untold marsh
#

How come?

#

I'll be sure to do that lmal

#

Lmao

mystic raven
#

Bounty hunters track the smoke

untold marsh
#

That's a really cool detail

mystic raven
#

Can approach your camp

untold marsh
#

Can they cuff me in my sleep?

mystic raven
#

nah

untold marsh
#

That's a really cool detail

mystic raven
#

yup

#

thats why i love rdr2

untold marsh
#

Me too

mystic raven
#
  1. Its a game set in the american frontier
  2. Its super realistic
untold marsh
#

Yesss

untold marsh
mystic raven
#

sure

tribal ember
#

what can i do when i finish the game

fickle chasm
#

I killed the tumbleweed sherriff

fluid cypress
#

lol i always do that when he’s giving his stupid speeches

frigid cloud
tribal ember
frigid cloud
#

career mode or?

opal geode
#

So how much honor do I need to get a certain ending

shut tinsel
#

Over half to get high honour ending

#

Under half to get low honour ending

opal geode
#

Okay good

#

I figured it wouldn’t require me to have like super high

untold marsh
#

Is robbing trains solo that profitable?

#

I've only robbed one, and there was literally no one on the train...

#

Except guards ofc

thick knot
#

U gotta find a passenger train

#

It’s pretty profitable tho

vernal flax
#

It’s pretty easy near the end of the game

#

It gives you so many opportunities to get your honor up

lone garnet
#

I like john marston more than I like arthur I gotta say

opal geode
vernal flax
#

No but it’s easy to get lol

#

You might as well

#

Like I said you get so many opportunities to get your honor up in chapter 6

restive mortar
opal geode
restive mortar
#

You don't need to be maxed either way

vernal flax
#

Ya

opal geode
#

After the end of chapter 5 I feel like it’s fitting to be this way

vernal flax
#

Yup Arthur changed so much for the better with high honor

opal geode
#

The character development with Arthur is crazy

restive mortar
#

Personally i like to keep it really low throughout the game until I can max out low in chapter 6. Get the gun grips. Then I max it good. Unless doing a negative honor run.

vernal flax
#

Honestly low honor with Arthur don’t feel right

#

Especially after he gets TB

opal geode
#

Low honor Arthur is all I’ve ever known

restive mortar
#

If you've never done it. It's a different game. Dialog. Interactions. Everything

opal geode
#

Ive noticed the change in his demeanor

restive mortar
#

Why this game REQUIRES at least 2 playthroughs so you can see it both ways.

opal geode
#

Its very cool

vernal flax
#

To see all endings

opal geode
#

Theres 4?

restive mortar
#

True

opal geode
#

Good bad true and ?

vernal flax
#

You’ll see.

#

You’ll have a couple options

#

That’s all I’ll say

opal geode
#

its cool that rdr2 does what games like telltale can’t really

#

Having character development based on your choices

restive mortar
#

There's a descision you make at the end that determines your ending. Depending on what you pick you get a story ending for that pick. If your good it goes one way. If bad. Another.

vernal flax
#

Ya

restive mortar
#

So Yeah. Kinda gotta do it 4 times to see them all

opal geode
#

so that would be 4 alone depending on honor and the choice

vernal flax
#

Yup

opal geode
#

Wouldn’t there be one with the 2 chapters after?

vernal flax
#

Wdym

#

The epilogue?

opal geode
#

Yes

vernal flax
#

Oh

restive mortar
#

Nah. Epilogue is just you playing as John. Finishing 100%

fluid cypress
opal geode
#

ooo sounds interesting

vernal flax
#

The epilogue is house building simulator

restive mortar
#

The cutscene with everyone at the "end" of the epilogue plays out the same no matter your honor

opal geode
#

ooh okay

opal geode
fluid cypress
#

yeah epilogue honor doesn’t matter

#

not even for the little details like dialogue to npcs in open world it’s all the same

vernal flax
#

I shot up black water

restive mortar
#

Only real diff in honor in epilogue is shops discount

vernal flax
#

@opal geode what mission are you on

fluid cypress
simple wyvern
#

Just finished RDR2 for the first time

vernal flax
#

How was it

restive mortar
#

But by then you souls have everything she not really a issue... My John is always in the red lol

opal geode
fluid cypress
#

literally

simple wyvern
#

Absolutely phenomenal story, best story I've ever played in a video game in my entire life. Hands down. They did it well hooking the player into the game as soon as possible

vernal flax
restive mortar
#

Even more with the pig farm glitch 🤣🤣

fluid cypress
#

oh u mean deposit

simple wyvern
#

Favorite character was Trelawny

restive mortar
#

Aberdeen?

simple wyvern
#

I demand more Trelawny

restive mortar
#

Yeah ok. Lol was gonna say you don't know that?

vernal flax
simple wyvern
#

Red dead redemption 3: Trelawny Edition

fluid cypress
#

there’s another glitch in new Austin’s ridge wood farm, you can get unlimited gold bars

#

works on latest patch

vernal flax
#

They were Arthur’s or dies 😎

restive mortar
fluid cypress
#

Not worth it

restive mortar
simple wyvern
fluid cypress
restive mortar
#

Patched on Xbox last I heard

#

Will do more research if true

fluid cypress
#

ik some people who play on Xbox and they can do the glitch

restive mortar
#

Unless it's new the gold bar dupe glitch was patched on Xbox months ago.

#

I don't really keep up with exploits like that tho honestly. I just felt it was stupid to lose all Arthur's money at the end. Why I use the farm glitch.

simple wyvern
#

One thing I'm very sad about is your horse freaking dies at the end. I didn't know that until I researched it and was like NOOO because I spent most of the game training that damn Arabian horse to level 4. Took so long, I had it to level 4 for like an hour and then it died. Are you kidding me thisisfine

opal geode
#

think about it this way

#

Your horse would be very lonely since Arthur dies

simple wyvern
#

True but still, so much time

opal geode
#

I got my horse to level 4 and accidentally killed it like right after

vernal flax
opal geode
#

Because I was testing out the new drift things

vernal flax
#

Named him Midnight Sun

#

😔

fluid cypress
simple wyvern
#

See the horse death is supposed to make you sad, but if anything it made me pissed because of above

#

If I had it to level 4 for a while, ok I would've been sad

vernal flax
#

Did you guys get the Rose Grey Arabian in the epilogue

fluid cypress
#

I had the same horse since the Hosea mission lol, the ultimate edition horse is truly ultimate

vernal flax
#

The thoroughbred?

fluid cypress
#

yeah

restive mortar
vernal flax
restive mortar
#

Yeah the free thoroughbred from jump is nice to.

fluid cypress
restive mortar
#

But I like black Arabian from st Denis

vernal flax
#

Same

#

It’s so good

#

Good stamina

#

Good speed

#

Decent health

fluid cypress
#

black Arabian is tiny, gets scared ez while chad ultimate never bucked me off once in my first playthrough and is faster than the Arabian

#

Only stamina was lil less

restive mortar
vernal flax
#

Black Arabian had nearly full stamina at max horse bonding

fluid cypress
#

mft is pretty much the same as the ultimate but has a lot more stamina, but then again doesn’t have that race handling

simple wyvern
#

During my first playthrough, I parked my horse near the train tracks and went afk, my horse walked into the railroad tracks...and you know what happened next thisisfine

vernal flax
#

Ouch

#

😬

restive mortar
#

Yaah that mft glitch was nice till they patched that.

#

Was cool having him early

fluid cypress
#

imo I’d trade off stamina and health for a bigger horse which doesn’t spook, like at all. Arabian just decked me off the get go while leaving saint denis

simple wyvern
#

There wasn't a npc horse or coach for miles around

vernal flax
#

True I bucked off one too many times with it

#

It got scared by snakes far too easily

simple wyvern
#

I had a long run.

fluid cypress
fluid cypress
restive mortar
simple wyvern
#

Pain

vernal flax
fluid cypress
#

i meant like with any horse, even those with less stamina you can just calm them every 15 secs and boom you have unlimited

simple wyvern
#

I also went off a cliff with my horseby accident, I somehow survived but it died

fluid cypress
#

lol horses don’t survive 6ft drops, even at max health

vernal flax
#

Horses go fucking flying if you hit a pebble bro

fluid cypress
#

lmao

simple wyvern
#

John/Arthur: falls 2 feet, OWWWW

restive mortar
vernal flax
#

I always carry horse reviver

restive mortar
#

Horse AI got nerfed and not in a good way lol

simple wyvern
#

Horse: y'know...I feel like dying today. It's a wonderful day to die

fluid cypress
#

pebble when Arthur: kicks pebble
pebble when horse: kicks horse 20ft in the air

simple wyvern
fluid cypress
#

guess pebble just hates horses

restive mortar
#

Some those horse collision dismounts tho. They provide good laughs. Just saying

fluid cypress
#

lol wagon riders are so entitled. They literally ran over my horse when I was afk, let’s just say they didn’t look the same after that

simple wyvern
#

Horses are also really dumb

#

They like to steer you into trees

hardy mauve
#

lol

simple wyvern
#

I always manage to smack right into a tree everytime I ride in a forest

vernal flax
#

I can’t tell you how many trees I’ve ran into

restive mortar
#

Yeah I love the straight up ones where you don't go forward. Never know where you'll land

hardy mauve
#

lmao

vernal flax
#

Sprinting with your horse in Saint Denis is so hard

#

I’ve hit so many people and had to reload saves

frigid cloud
#

ride slowly

vernal flax
#

Never

#

I got things to do

#

People to run over

#

And a beard to trim

dreamy oracle
#

I’m doing a second playthrough, trying to get 100% compendium completion, side quest completion, basically just trying to 100% the entire game, when I enter social club-rdr2-overview I can’t find my current playthrough, only John Marston and Online Character

#

What can I do to fix this? I’m still on Chapter 2 so I don’t have John yet in the second playthrough

fluid cypress
#

i like picking fights in the saint denis slums, sooo satisfying when they gang up on you and say they gon kill you n send you to your mamma but run and scream in horror when you pull out your gun and spill the brains of their friends

thick knot
#

I found out that they will still try to fist fight you even if you have a knife

hidden moss
#

Wassup y'all

thick knot
#

It’s so fun massacring the entire alleyway behind the stables

#

And hi

#

Man even though I’ve played this game before

#

Arthur’s conversation with the nun in saint denis

#

Hits

#

Yeah that’s what I’m talking abt just didn’t wanna spoil

#

It’s surreal af

#

Yeah the one where he discusses his fear right?

#

Yeah

#

That one hurts every time

#

Fr if you play through all the side missions the character development of Arthur is insane

#

Like my first play through I kinda rushed and missed a lot and at the end I was sad but like it was just a good game

#

And I was hella dishonorable

#

The 2nd time I did all the side quests and morally I couldn’t do dishonorable by the time Arthur was close to death

whole rune
#

Hello

#

I started RDR2 for the first time about 1 week ago. I'm just about to take down Angelo Brontë. Any tips?

broken dragon
#

@whole rune go for high honor

#

Do good deeds and don’t do bad deeds

nova vapor
#

e

reef musk
#

Oh I am already done, I am playing rdr1 now

whole rune
#

Okay, Thanks. (P.S - I know about the ending)

broken dragon
#

you already got spoiled?

whole rune
#

Not here but yep.

broken dragon
#

rip

whole rune
#

IKR

fluid cypress
#

bro you gotta slow down and spend some time with Arthur or you won’t feel it

whole rune
#

Okay.

#

Can I mention some spoilers though.

fluid cypress
#

There’s some great side missions in ch4 you need to do, they unlock some really great ones in ch6

fluid cypress
whole rune
#

Okay cool :)

#

RDR2 wants me to get RDR1 for one reason only.

#

I want to kill Dutch.

fluid cypress
#

lmao

#

i like to pretend rdr1 never happened and they lived happily ever after

whole rune
#

I know what happens and it makes me see right through Dutch in RDR2.

whole rune
fluid cypress
#

Most people knew Dutch was bad since uk, rdr1

#

Arthur was the sad surprise

whole rune
#

It's a prequel done expertly.

#

Sorry, I just really overanalyze things 😂

#

Anybody a fan of Fallout New Vegas?

#

There is a music video of Big Iron by Marty Robbins made in RDR2. It's absolutely amazing.

thick knot
#

You can get to ch 4 and do all the side quests easily in a week

#

It’s alot of hours but that’s not an unreasonable amount of time

fluid cypress
whole rune
#

Can I also mention something.

#

Something very controversial.

#

I don't like Arthur Morgan. I think (at the moment) he's a incredibly cruel person but I don't think he's fully to blame. I do also think (and kind of know) he's going to change.

#

Really?

#

I mean. I know people that think he's a saint.

#

Literally.

#

But he's really not at all.

#

Denfinely not at the moment.

vernal flax
whole rune
vernal flax
#

Even at high honor he wasn’t the best person

#

And he recognized that

whole rune
#

But this doesn't make him a bad protagonist at all.

#

It makes him incredibly compelling.

vernal flax
#

People may argue he only killed bad people, but that doesn’t change the fact that he still murdered hundreds of people

whole rune
vernal flax
#

I think what matters though is that he recognized he was a bad man and tried to help other people

whole rune
#

Absolutely.

vernal flax
#

If he couldn’t save himself he might as well use his time left to reflect and make sure people don’t have to suffer like he did

#

But yeah both Arthur and John and really bad men

whole rune
#

Yep but sadly people had. But he still paid the price at the end. And it was his inflicting of pain that made his death absolute.

#

His hamartia (fatal flaw) was himself.

#

GTG

vernal flax
#

Ight cya

mystic raven
#

I specificly kill raiders with the Springfield

#

from now on

#

damn traitors

fluid cypress
#

John in epilogue is like that little kid who’s playing in lawn not knowing about how much his parents have done and gone through

#

i am a legend at making shitty analogies

jaunty snow
#

can smo help i cant buy the trapper coat i have the perfect sheep hide on my horse please help

whole rune
#

Have you given it to Pearson or any Butcher. I really don't do hunting or fishing at all.

fluid cypress
#

to the trapper

#

Anything that’s sold to him can then be used to craft

#

unless it’s something that’s not in any recipes

#

that’s just profit

jaunty snow
jaunty snow
fluid cypress
#

same with person to get satchel and camp upgrades

fluid cypress
whole rune
#

@jaunty snow It's okay

#

I've got another controversial take.

#

RDR2 is a apology for GTA V

#

Don't get me wrong.

#

GTA V is a incredible game which deserves every accolade that it has received and every sale it has made.

#

But the writing of GTA V is ridiculous compared to RDR2

red helm
#

You're Wrong!! Kidding, kidding, I've never played GTA 5, but it doesn't seem all that neat, compared to their previous games(San Andreas, Vice city, etc).

whole rune
#

It makes GTA V look bad.

hidden moss
#

Rdr2 is just rdr2

#

Nothing to do with gta5

red helm
#

But, yeah, it's like comparing a apple to a orange. RDR and GTA aren't really the same genre, technically.

hidden moss
#

Just same devs

red helm
#

Or.... I guess, they kind of are... so, let's say, a apple to a pear.

hidden moss
#

Supposedly there in the same universe

whole rune
red helm
whole rune
#

Good point

hidden moss
whole rune
#

The Mount Chilad Mystery

#

Right

hidden moss
#

thats online

whole rune
#

It will take me ages to explain.

red helm
#

I mean, they are Rockstar games, so there is going to be a ton of Random Easter Eggs.

whole rune
#

There's a book in Franklins house by a J. Marston.

hidden moss
#

Yes its rockstar

#

rdr1

#

jack marston

whole rune
#

Yep.

hidden moss
#

he became a author

#

its just a easter egg

whole rune
#

🤷‍♂️

hidden moss
#

Every rockstar game has Easter eggs from previous games

whole rune
#

There's a lot more easter eggs but I would never be explored.

red helm
#

Yeap. Doesn't quite mean to much.

whole rune
#

Like seeing Dutch in the streets in Los Santos or CJ in Valentine.

#

But I do think there is a slim possibility.

red helm
#

In San Andreas, in the Hobby Stores, you could find action figures of Tony Vercetti, the main character of Vice City. Doesn't quite mean anything.

whole rune
#

But it could.

#

Probably not.

#

But it could.

cold gazelle
#

If i switch to john can i still go around and get all the hideouts

whole rune
#

I think so

#

I haven't played as him yet but it doesn't mention that he can't.

fluid cypress
#

so it makes sense

#

other things about rdr and gta are just Easter eggs

#

California, New York and such exist in rdr

#

not in gta

whole rune
#

🤷‍♂️

#

The government changing the names?

#

It could all be explained but it probably will never be explained.

#

We can only imagine.

fluid cypress
#

That’s just stupid

#

Let rdr be rdr

red helm
fluid cypress
#

Even the og red dead game isn’t in the redemption universe why would the completely unrelated gta be in rdr universe instead?

red helm
#

Rockstar logic be whack.

cold gazelle
fluid cypress
#

unless red Harlow is uncle shock2

cold gazelle
#

I named my hotse after harlow

red helm
# cold gazelle Thx I'm trying to 100% it lol

We discussed this a long time ago, if you could actually miss out on clearing out O'Driscoll gang in the compendium. But, However, as for the 100% trophy, it is NOT relevent, because that is just X gang hide outs, and not specific to O'Driscoll's themselves. So, don't worry about that. Just when looking at the gangs themselves, that part -might- be missable.

cold gazelle
#

So u just need a certain amount of hide outs cleared in all

red helm
#

Indeed, and there is plenty of Del Lobo's and others to choose from.

cold gazelle
#

Del lobos is the best gang in my opinion tbh

red helm
#

I've found them doing some rather horrible things, as well, so.. eh...

cold gazelle
#

Every gang does bad things

#

Why are they the only gang u really come across online though

red helm
#

Online be the Whack?

#

Night Folk are the coolest gang though. Even though, they aren't actually a 'gang' but, whatever.

civic vault
cold gazelle
#

Ya u never see them thou

celest bobcat
#

hello i have question when stabbing im only slashing how do i do the stabbing animation i know its weird to ask but im only slashing people and not doing the stab animation

civic vault
#

I think i gonna stay in chapter 4 for as long as possible

#

Get all the satchels, do all the challenges that i think are fun

#

Im not pushing for the 100% but imma max what i want to max

#

And antagnize micah everytime im in camp lol

#

Also during camp, Trelawny admitted that he has a family after I discovered his home in Saint Denis. Interesting tidbit

red helm
civic vault
#

I shoot vermin

fluid cypress
red helm
#

🗡️🩸🪦

civic vault
#

Im attached to my tukorman even though he's scared of everything

red helm
#

One time my Turkoman bucked me before the cougar was even aware of us. It was just laying near a river, really far away and before I knew it, I'm getting thrown...

civic vault
#

Yeah that be annoying

red helm
#

So, I stood up, pulled my Rifle, THAN the cougar noticed me, and I shot it before it started running towards me...... Dumb horse.

civic vault
#

A scaredy tank lol

#

I like how high its stamina is, hence why i tolerate

red helm
#

Yeah, it's usually pretty good about stuff... But that was a pretty sad display there.

civic vault
#

I only dread when i have to hunt for perfect panther pelt

#

Though i guess ill just do it on foot

#

Put some carnivore bait

red helm
#

I did those a long time before I had a Turko. I was using a Andalusian then, and it actually was pretty brave around the Panthers. thankfully.

civic vault
#

Maybe i should switch to my old horse for that i guess

#

My old american standardbred is braver

red helm
#

Always tricky to say how your horse is going to act around predators...

#

One time I went to get on my Anda, and it bucked me instantly.

civic vault
#

I notice when you're at the stables, you can see who's braver and who's a scaredy horse

red helm
#

Turns out, it was like 3 feet from a snake....

civic vault
#

The calm ones are the brave

red helm
#

Why it was Stand right next to a snake.... No idea... but.. that was funny afterwards, the horse just took off freaking out.

civic vault
red helm
#

It waited until I was getting on it, to buck me, and run off freaking out.... Like... WHy didn't it freak before I got to it?.... Confusing.

civic vault
#

It needs someone to buck off lol

red helm
#

Ha, right.

reef musk
#

How long do you reckon it takes an average guy to complete the story?

civic vault
#

Next on the list to do is kidnap the eugenics guy and use him for the horsman challenge

civic vault
red helm
civic vault
#

But if you take it on average pace with much exploring on the side, it'll be like a month.

reef musk
#

You sure? I completed the story and some side missions in 24 hours

red helm
#

... That seems rather quick

reef musk
#

I did not skip any cut scenes either

red helm
#

Did you just non-stop do main missions, one after the other?

reef musk
#

Pretty much

#

And some side missions

red helm
#

Well, you kind of missed a lot. But, play the games however they make you happy.

civic vault
#

Yep

reef musk
#

Ive done every mission

#

I think I missed like 2 in chapter 4

civic vault
#

Im sad theres only 2 interactions with the lonely giant

red helm
#

Yeah

civic vault
#

The vampire knife looks nice

hidden moss
#

Does anyone know how to catch the Legendary Longnose Gar?

#

It’s not working for me

fluid cypress
#

you sure your game isn't bugged or anything? Do you have any older saves that you can try catching the fish on?

#

I'd suggest searching reddit for answers or people who've had similar problems

hidden moss
#

@fluid cypress I finally caught it lol, I watched atleast 10 videos on it and only 1 of them worked. I just followed where this guy was standing on his video.

fluid cypress
#

lmao

hidden moss
#

The nostalgia starting rdr1 up

fluid cypress
#

im probably gonna get nostalgia after starting rdr2 up cuz of these exams

#

just a few more hours and ill be done with the past 2 months of hell

civic vault
#

What's the funniest horse name you've ever found?

#

I just discovered Liam Neighson and it had me cackling rofl

#

And Jon Bon Pony

golden mortar
#

I found a brown horse, gave him a mohawk and named him Bojack.

civic vault
#

😂

#

i once named my thoroughbred "Donkey"

humble echo
civic vault
keen birchBOT
#

Read if Arthur sucks and is worse than Micah.
Ignore if Micah is better than Arthur.

P.S. Arabian horses suck. Cry.

opal geode
#

evil bot

#

autocorrect is my biggest enemy

patent ocean
#

Is it possible to 100% with John?

fickle chasm
#

pretty sure

patent ocean
#

Don’t I have to do stuff with gang members

fickle chasm
patent ocean
#

I meant like do nothing as Arthur and everything as John

fickle chasm
#

not sure

patent ocean
#

Hm

fickle chasm
#

some stuff you do as arthur in the story itself

#

oh ye

#

some guns

#

can only be gotten as arthur

#

in certain quests

patent ocean
#

Dang it

fickle chasm
patent ocean
#

Yeah I got that

#

But I missed some stuff that I could have done with the gang like fishing or getting stuff for gang member

fickle chasm
#

and then Mausers pistol or something

fickle chasm
patent ocean
#

Oh

#

Breh

true bane
#

is anyone having issues with changing settings on pc

#

i change the smallest thing like brightness and suddenly EVERYTHING turns into a slide show bc it lags so much

#

i can barely alt f4 out of there

hidden moss
#

Does anyone know how to max out their Health, Stamina and Dead eye in Singleplayer, it says All of them are level 8/8 but the ring isn’t all the way around nor do I have “Reach maximum Health, Stamina and Dead Eye” completion done in my Total Completion list.

true bane
#

where are u checking

hidden moss
#

Under Player

true bane
#

is it all white

hidden moss
#

Do I need to unlock special perks in order for it to go up higher?

#

Never mind. I have to Complete 10/10 on all 9 challenges, lol

civic vault
#

I notice doing the challenges increases it so it might be that

hidden moss
#

I’m on a challenge Ride from Van Horn to Black Water in under 17 Minutes without touching any water, How would that work when there’s a river you need to cross right above Blackwater.

fickle chasm
hidden moss
#

And I don’t recall there being any bridges on that river

fickle chasm
#

hmmm

hidden moss
#

I’ll just watch a video

civic vault
#

whenever i ride from Saint Denis to south of Big Valley, i always use the train tracks. it helps avoid the water

hidden moss
#

I guess I have to ride all the way over to Owanjila Dam

civic vault
#

so maybe do that

hidden moss
#

only way to complete the challenge

civic vault
#

speaking of riding, i use less fast travel now coz i sorta enjoy the slow pace

#

sometimes i notice some random stuff along the way and check it out

fickle chasm
#

but when you gotta go from fucking annesburg to colter

civic vault
#

Yeah somehow i hate annesburg lol

#

Colter i dont mind

fickle chasm
hidden moss
#

i did it

fickle chasm
#

niceee

hidden moss
#

now I’m on the last challenge which seems even harder

fickle chasm
hidden moss
#

Break every wild horse breed

fickle chasm
#

ah.

#

yes.

hidden moss
#

Is it still possible to achieve the Breaking and Entering trophy after finishing the game?

frigid cloud
#

yes @hidden moss

civic vault
#

They once prepped a dirt pit for me and i survived

#

i just gotta prep for nightfolk though, they make me panic

amber halo
#

Very interesting; I'm in Lakay looking for the Gar but our camp is Clements and I'm in ch 3. Very early ch 3. So I am trying to get the legendary mechanics going walking around when I find a repeater that is for "Camp Guards" leaned up against the wall to a shack. Wonder if it's always there but I have never noticed it before during any other playthrough.

dire sentinel
#

ive seen it in the first chapter, and you cant guard the camp

#

only others can, wish u could honestly

cedar cobalt
#

I just finished "The Noblest of Men and a Woman" and around 15 minutes after shooting Calloway and taking his gun, I logged off. Well, I just logged back on and I don't have his gun and yet my Autosave file says that I have 84% completion on the quest, and I'm on the Slim Grant section. What do I do? I don't have any manual save files that are recent, I only have one from like a month ago and that save is on Chapter 3.

civic vault
cedar cobalt
#

No idea what happened

fluid cypress
cedar cobalt
#

I have the other gunslinger weapons though

fluid cypress
#

check weapon locker?

cedar cobalt
#

Done that

#

I've tried everything

#

I just don't have it

#

I even went back to where the duel was

fluid cypress
#

so according to the game you did the mission and picked up the revolver right

#

do these guns appear in the compendium or they’re just normal according to that?

cedar cobalt
#

According to the game I killed Calloway and didn't pick up the gun

#

Yeah they do

#

That's the annoying part

fluid cypress
#

check the compendium is it discovered there

cedar cobalt
#

Nope

#

Granger's, Flaco's and Midnight's are though.

fluid cypress
#

that’s just sad

#

unfortunately I don’t think there’s a way to get them

#

unless you wanna go back to an older save

cedar cobalt
#

:(

#

I guess I'll suck it up and try for 100% on a different save.

fluid cypress
#

unless we’ll saving and reloading again might just magically make it re appear but that’s highly unlikely since it’s not even in compendium

cedar cobalt
#

I guess I learnt my lesson. Manual saves are the way to go.

fluid cypress
#

The save you have on ch3 is the same run?

cedar cobalt
#

Yeah

fluid cypress
#

you can just pick up from there then

cedar cobalt
#

Oh yeah

fluid cypress
#

maybe keep this one just for shenanigans

cedar cobalt
#

Good idea

#

That one already has honour. This one lost it fairly quickly, I'm afraid.

#

Thanks for your help :D

fluid cypress
#

anytime partner

hidden moss
wide shuttle
#

Guys

#

Best way to level up naturalist fast?

willow cosmos
spring lark
#

Kinda sad I haven’t finished the story mode since I really enjoyed the first RDR maybe some day wen internet gets canceled 🤷‍♂️

willow cosmos
civic vault
#

Same

civic vault
#

If i die in the middle of the hunt (panther mawling me) and i have pelts stowed on my horse, would I lose the pelts or are they still there?

fickle chasm
willow cosmos
civic vault
#

Ah ok

willow cosmos
#

As long as you have it on you're horse and not on Arthur it will stay

restive mortar
civic vault
#

Oh man, just survived that Night Folk stranger mission

#

First time i heard Arthur a bit scared

fickle chasm
civic vault
#

Night folk made you cry?

fickle chasm
#

and when one of em came up behind me i almost cried cause i was scared (yes i'm a coward for the most part)

civic vault
#

The worst part of it is that an alligator decided to crash my attack plan

#

Literally decided to run after me while the night folk was chasing me

#

And then i died

#

I restarted the mission and decided to use the bow instead for stealth and pick them off one by one

fickle chasm
civic vault
#

I panic with a gun lol

fickle chasm
civic vault
#

When it comes to night folk

fickle chasm
#

i was scared shitless

civic vault
#

Yeah they scare me more than the murfees

#

Murfees are just plain annoying

fickle chasm
#

same with the skinners

civic vault
#

Skinners i havent tried to encounter them the last time

#

But i hate that they climb trees

fickle chasm
civic vault
#

I tried to get into tall trees as arthur lol

#

Maybe i should use the wagon glitch

#

I forgot to do the bronte glitch

#

Just got caught up in the mission

fickle chasm
civic vault
#

Apparently after the grave robbing task, you have to get spotted by the lawmen in the cemetery and get wanted, then you finish the mission and then head straight to black water

#

I just read it on reddit and people got to do it

#

But some of them say the glitch doesnt work in some cases

trail tapir
#

yeah

#

i did it

#

idk if they patched it

#

this was a year ago

thick knot
#

Thank god for the trappers wizardry i died with the legendary buck

whole rune
#

What's wrong with Arthur, He's coughing up blood.

#

Oh god. Tuberculosis.

#

That's not what I was told at all.

#

This is awful.

#

@errant glen O.O

#

And I'm now flying a balloon.

fluid cypress
delicate yacht
shut tinsel
jovial tinsel
#

I love this game

vestal cipher
#

ok

whole rune
#

@fluid cypress Thank you

drifting nacelle
jovial tinsel
#

It's full of details and gameplay is awesome

drifting nacelle
#

Yeah

modest edge
#

Arthur is sexy af bro

#

Like those thighs

fluid cypress
#

looks like someone really wants to fuckarthur

#

jk

#

pls don’t attack me

#

only secretly, don’t tell this to anyone

hidden moss
#

Looking a player

#

To hang with

#

Trying to relearn red dead on xbox dm me if u can call

hidden moss
#

too bad he isnt gay 😔

modest edge
hidden moss
spring sluice
#

little brother is almost done with single player little does he know the pain coming his way

red helm
#

💧

civic vault
#

And this is why i wanna stay in chapter 4 for as long as possible. Keeping the boah strong and alive for a while longer

#

And also Hosea and Lenny

#

Kieran is missing already and i didnt even got the chance to give him the herb he requested ☹

drifting nacelle
#

I took a picture of lenny before I went to the bank

civic vault
#

That makes it sadder

#

😭

drifting nacelle
#

But at least I got one

civic vault
#

Is there a way to delete all of the photos in the photoroll at once instead of deleting it one by one?

drifting nacelle
#

Nope, I guess not

civic vault
#

Ugh

drifting nacelle
#

Yeah its rly annoying

civic vault
#

I guess screenshot it is

#

Too lazy to go through all in the photoroll

#

It even loads slower for me

drifting nacelle
#

For me too

azure raptor
#

for the people that have best in the west (100% Completion Achievement) how was it to get?

frigid cloud
#

waste of time

azure raptor
#

since Im doing one of those 100% runs right now, and am currently at 58.8

azure raptor
#

but I've finished game multiple times, might as well start getting the achievements

red helm
#

Unsure about 'waste of time', but... irritating and ugh...

red helm
hardy mauve
#

hi

#

So I’m trying to get 100% completion in story mode and I’m wondering what do we have to do to achieve that?

azure raptor
hardy mauve
#

Alr ty

hidden moss
#

Guys

#

Whos better

#

The 450 horse at straw berry

#

Or

#

The white arabian horse

keen birchBOT
jolly mulch
#

I have a $300 bounty on the south side of the map after breaking some guy out of jail. How do I get rid of it without paying?

#

I had to flee back to the north side, because even the towns are marked red as hostile

hidden moss
#

Anyonr answerr

civic vault
hidden moss
#

@civic vault i have a question

#

Which horse better the 450 in straw berry or arabian horse

jolly mulch
civic vault
#

What's the breed of the 450 horse? I cant remember. It depends on the breed and your preference. I personally dont like arabians

hidden moss
#

@civic vault thoroughbred

#

Brindle

civic vault
civic vault
#

Arabians have high stats hence why most people choose it

#

But i personally like Tukormans better

hidden moss
#

@civic vault so i put saddle in it if it dies it will be back right?

civic vault
#

If it dies, it's gone forever.

hidden moss
#

.

#

Why when the other horses die

#

They come back

civic vault
#

If it's dying and then you reatart, it's possible

hidden moss
#

So u telling me to stack on horse revivers

civic vault
#

But if you're talking about wild horses, i think some respawn.

I meant that if the particular horse that you own dies, it's gone forever

#

You gotta buy or break another one

hidden moss
#

I gotta break another one for arabin to stay?

civic vault
civic vault
hidden moss
#

General store sells them?

civic vault
#

Yep general store

civic vault
hidden moss
#

Question

#

I have this thing called

#

Ammolite

#

And fluorite

#

Are they valueable?

civic vault
#

It's worth $25, you can sell it to the fence

hidden moss
#

I stole it from bird nest

#

Btw

#

How do i buy ammo

civic vault
hidden moss
#

K thx

civic vault
#

Or gun store if the town you're in has one

hidden moss
#

iam at chapter 3 btw

civic vault
#

Then nearest town is Rhodes and you can either go to the gun store or general store

hidden moss
#

Ima go sell my valueables

civic vault
#

👍

hidden moss
#

Oh nice o driscolls in the wau

#

Way

#

Wdym a scrap paper i heard u said treasure

#

@civic vault u think i should start rdo

civic vault
#

It's up to you, some people like it, some people don't, see for yourself

hidden moss
#

the thing is

#

I dont know how to earn money

civic vault
#

Dude

#

There's like so many ways to earn money

#

Google it

hidden moss
#

Back

#

I was robbing a train

#

Bec it stopped

civic vault
#

You can also find treasure for quick big bucks

#

Google the treasure and you'll find a lot of guides

true bane
#

I can’t put the || thingies so I don’t spoil parts of the game for other people

#

ugh

#

well whatever

#

counterproductive but. Ok

civic vault
#

Yeah somehow admins decided to not allow spoiler tags

true bane
#

I love how you can tell that Dutch is slowly going insane throughout the game and chapters

civic vault
#

At least they should add a spoiler channel

true bane
#

yuhp

supple sonnet
#

Should I do another playthrough

worldly turret
#
  1. games been out over 3 years
  2. people shouldn't join a big discord or any discord if they don't want spoikers
  3. people abused the spoiler tags to hide slurs
  4. we had a spoiler free channel for 2 years after launch, wasn't used
supple sonnet
#

Which will be my sixth or seventh play through

true bane
#

but that’ll still spoil things for ppl who want to talk about stuff but arent finished yet

true bane
#

some ppl just want to find buddies and talk about the story while they’re experiencing it

#

I’ve heard practically nothing about red dead and I’ve been on the internet and the gaming side of social media for 3 years

#

auto mod the slurs, not the spoilers

worldly turret
#

yeah, you don't know how it works then lmao

true bane
#

uhh I do thanks?

worldly turret
#

the || will bypass the slur

true bane
#

cuz either way ppl will still say slurs and then everyone can see

#

add || before and after in the automod for slurs then

#

problems solved

worldly turret
#

again, you don't know how it works lol

#

people bypass it by going ni||cecar or whatever|| and it'll bypass the filter

true bane
#

I do, considering I’m usually used for technical support in servers.

#

then add the ||? it’ll still solve ur problem

worldly turret
#

that would literally mean doing that for every letter in every word that isn't allowed

true bane
#

that’s not that time consuming LOL

worldly turret
#

it is when you account all the slurs and filtered words we have, especially since people like to make new bypasses and then those get added LOL

true bane
#

automod doesn’t solve everything anyways, that’s why mods exist

#

the experience of the game can b ruined for noobs who need tips bc of the lack of censoring

worldly turret
#

and having automod on spoiler tags solved said bypassing issue :)

#

again, people shouldn't join a large community if they don't want to get spoiled, especially when it's been out for years now

true bane
#

again, not everyone is involved and red dead genuinely isn’t talked about that much

#

some people need help too

#

I joined bc of a glitch

#

my items didn’t show up in the ledger or box when I donated

supple trout
dreamy oracle
#

So I have a question about the Gold Rush role, is it incredibly hard to get in this server, gotta do it all first try without redoing the mission from the Progress/Story tab of the pause menu with proof or do you just need proof that you actually have the achievement/trophy

ancient sigil
#

Or the reddit

supple trout
jolly mulch
#

Very important question, how do I get my hat back without having to go back to camp?

civic vault
jolly mulch
#

It becomes more annoying since it’s a cowboy game