red-dead-singleplayer

[fickle chasm]

oh damn

[fluid cypress]

Basically never need to buy horses again

[fickle chasm]

nicee

[hidden moss]

i like buying horses

[rapid magnet]

Me too

Ditching one of my old horses for a new one is my toxic trait

[fluid cypress]

Chopping off legs of random people’s horses when they ride at ridge wood farm is my toxic trait

[dreamy hearth]

I loaded it back but my horse was still gone

[hidden moss]

almost everyone's toxic trait is greet > greet > antagonize

[light rune]

Im trying to decide between the schofield revolver or the double action, which one should I go for?

[fickle chasm]

i love doing that

[fickle chasm]

there are wayyy better horses than the shire you can get another one

[shut tinsel]

I used both in the later game tbh

[hidden moss]

Schofield

[shut tinsel]

Schofield for main and double action offhand

Idk why

[light rune]

I’m deciding which ones to dual wield

[shut tinsel]

Schofield

I got it for free in like chapter 6 I think bcs I saved someone

So I just used it from then

[light rune]

Ok thnx

[civic vault]

Especially for saint denis people

[covert slate]

now thats just cringe

[covert slate]

absolutely

[amber halo]

Fishing for sockeye at o'creagh's while I wait for new respawns for cougar. Snag 10 fast as hell then they all just kept following the bait. Had 6 circling the bait. I guess after a certain time in the evening they just won't bite??? It was about 630 pm when they just ceased to bite. Anyone know if that's how it works? All over the line but they wouldn't bite.

[civic vault]

Omg i accidentally made arthur bald

Now he walter white lol

Gotta drink 10 hair tonics

And sleep a lot

[fluid cypress]

lol

i made john bald

he looked like hitman

had to cover up the embarrassment with a hat

[fluid cypress]

they only stack to 3

[civic vault]

Same rofl, i covered it with a hat

[civic vault]

Yeah i kept buying and drinking lol

And i slepted at the hotel for 3 days lol

[fluid cypress]

i wasted almost 1k by drinking them all at once

[fluid cypress]

lmao

arthur havin a nice nap after all the shit you put him through

[civic vault]

Rofl

After the date, imma drink more hair tonics

[sturdy wolf]

Who long would it take to complete the story mode

[fluid cypress]

i didnt do the date lol

made sense at the time

[fluid cypress]

about 70 hours

maybe more

depends

[civic vault]

Just wanted to give Arthur a down time lol

But i dont like mary too much

Always felt like she was using him

[sturdy wolf]

Awesome

[tepid quest]

Why cant I give jimmy brooks’ pen to Mary-beth? Seems like the obvious choice, but guess not

[fickle chasm]

50 hours or something

49 hours

[hidden moss]

100% completion of the entire game would take that long

[jade grove]

No

The game is roughly an 60 hour experience

Completion takes way longer

[hidden moss]

Google it

[fickle chasm]

172 hours for 100% completion

[jade grove]

Google

Ur googling how long it takes in a game

U never played it or smth

[hidden moss]

Oops

[jade grove]

Git gud nerd

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

More accurately would be 50

Unless you’re doing everything

I didn’t focus on strangers

[fluid cypress]

Wtf?

lmao what

are we playing the same red dead?

if you play the story non stop it’s 40-45 hours

by non stop I mean non stop

[hidden moss]

I was thinking something different

My bad

[fluid cypress]

I didn’t do much, barely any stranger missions till ch6 and most of the time I was just doing story nothing else still took about 80

Including the epilogue

[fluid cypress]

I had given Arthur quite a down time before that mission, also had to sleep so just wanted to get it over with quick and do a good story mission before going to bed

[fluid cypress]

Me neither, didn’t feel it in my first playthrough but in 2nd one she was giving bad vibes, only reason she came to him is cuz her (dead) hubby wasn’t around to be solve her problems and be her savior

[hidden moss]

i figured out a way for arthur to live

[reef musk]

in 2 days Ive played this game for 18 hours, the story is 51% complete, how long is this game dude

[amber halo]

😉

[amber halo]

VERY! I've blasted through main story 5 times finishing maybe 50% each time for around 1K hrs.
I'm now attempting to complete ALL challenges and I have been seeing hours and hours of missions and other stuff I never saw blasting through it.

[fluid cypress]

Lol I had been playing the game for like 4 months an hour every day then only did I finish it

[burnt flax]

Hi

[fluid cypress]

howdy there partner

[dreamy hearth]

According to Google the 1st black shire you get is the best one. The stars are incredible and there’s no other shire in the game that has those stars

Stats**

[hidden moss]

reset your game before the final mission

[keen birch]

Read if Arthur sucks and is worse than Micah.
Ignore if Micah is better than Arthur.

[fickle chasm]

Gae

[trail ivy]

Why are the cigars always sold out? I was in Valentine and then i went to St. Denis but both valentine and St. Denis was sold out

[jovial peak]

if something is sold out it means you are currently holding the mx of that item.

[fluid cypress]

means you have maximum and you can't buy more

[thick pewter]

Can I rob a bank post game on my own?

[fluid cypress]

nope

only trains

[thick pewter]

K how can I get money?

[fluid cypress]

if you have ultimate edition you get an additional bank roberry mission

[near panther]

Y'all check #general-media, I need help.

[fluid cypress]

which chapter?

[thick pewter]

How do I find those trains? And I'm guessing the ones with people

[thick pewter]

Postgame

[trail ivy]

I can't find them in my cunsamable wheel?

[fluid cypress]

its random, but if you wanna spawn one quick go to any station get a ticket to anywhere, once you reach just leave the train and follow it then u can rob it

[fluid cypress]

its in your satchel

you cant find everything in the wheel

[trail ivy]

Can i add it to my wheel?

[fluid cypress]

idk

[thick pewter]

What's the best strategy to robbing it

[trail ivy]

Just buy a ticker and rob it

[fluid cypress]

wait it should be on your deadeye section of the wheel

[trail ivy]

I did that only once because i want to first finish the game with good honor

[fluid cypress]

just dont its a waste you barely get any money and on top of thta a 200 bounty

what happened to the 20k

[thick pewter]

So is there any way I can make good money?

[jovial peak]

There is a tunnel just east of baccus bridge. Get a train to annesburg and stop the train once you get to that tunnel. In the tunnel the law cant get to you so you will be bounty free

[fluid cypress]

ridgewood farm goldbar glitch. If you wanna be more ethical just do treasure hunts and steal stages. Good ones sell for 50+

or rob a stable and get like an arabian or something then sell it for good muneh

[thick pewter]

What's the treasure hunts then?

[fluid cypress]

bruh

check your satchel

you must have treasure maps in your in documents

if not do the gunslinger mission in ambarino and loot the shack to get the first one

[thick pewter]

Theres only 2

[fluid cypress]

bruh just do them you get alot of gold

[thick pewter]

What's do u mean by steal stages

[fluid cypress]

theres also hidden gold around

24 gold bars

[fluid cypress]

stagecoaches

[thick pewter]

K

What's good to spend money on

[fluid cypress]

anything u like

[jovial peak]

steal stage coach wagons and bring them top the wagon fence in emerald ranch

[fluid cypress]

what happened to your 20k?

[thick pewter]

Still have it

[fluid cypress]

tbh thee gold bar glitch is the best way to get money if you need more. no need to worry about those numbers again

[fluid cypress]

then why do you want more

[thick pewter]

Bcuz why not 🤣

[fluid cypress]

its more than enough to buy everything

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

ive played a good 40 hours post game and still have like 19k

[thick pewter]

K nice

Is the Lancaster rifle any good

How do I find stage coaches

[fluid cypress]

its a repeater not a rifle

man have you ever payed attention to this game

why so many questions in epilogue

[fluid cypress]

theyre around. like on the roads

[thick pewter]

Ye

[thick pewter]

K can I not get them from the person who u used to be able to at Rhodes train station?

[thick pewter]

Oops my bad

[fluid cypress]

good ones are usually in posh towns, follow one thats leaving a town and jack it

[thick pewter]

K thank you

[fluid cypress]

you can rob any you see but yeah he gives you limited special ones

also if you dont do the ones he gives you on time they will move on and you will lose it foreve

[thick pewter]

Ah k

[fluid cypress]

so talk to him when youre ready to do it

[buoyant chasm]

Fishing for legendaries is weird for me

I could get one first try and then not get another one after 30 mins of fishing

[fluid cypress]

welcome to random chance of getting stuff from lines of code

[indigo finch]

This lol

[ancient anchor]

guys

can someone help me

im trying to get a perfect pather pelt but they dont spawn and i have tryed all other methods

[thick knot]

Lol I just got perfect timing right when Micah said “I showed them, and I’ll show this whole town” he instantly got popped in the head and fell off the bridge lmao

If only that was canon

Also waited for my horse to shit in front of the jail bars when he was imprisoned

[slow escarp]

so I lost my gun in like a misson

is there a way to get it back?

[thick knot]

Check on ur horse

[slow escarp]

ok thanks

yeah its good

I had a heart attack there

[thick knot]

Yeah same thing happened to me with billy midnights pistol and it was so sad until I realized I didn’t actually lose it lmao

[slow escarp]

yea lol

[fluid cypress]

Lol you can’t lose your guns

Any gun you pick up even for a split second is now yours forever, with Arthur’s power of duplication

It’s kinda annoying with the worm weapons tho, they clog your inv for no reason and you can’t get rid of them

[slow escarp]

rip

[civic vault]

I think he had more care with that charlotte widow. If he wasnt sick he would run away with her.

[fluid cypress]

that was probably my favorite side mission in the entire game

Also kinda weird that it doesn’t have a name

[proud cipher]

the american inferno side mission is dumb i think

you talk to him once

[fluid cypress]

It’s first part is a random encounter instead of a stranger mission, but the rest play out like one

[proud cipher]

give him food twice

and then hes dead

like what

[fluid cypress]

What was it again?

Evelyn miller?

[proud cipher]

yes

[fluid cypress]

Don’t you fight some ppl for him or something

[proud cipher]

yeah

so

[fluid cypress]

I don’t remember I only did that on my old playthroughs

[proud cipher]

talk to him

ride with him once

give him food twice

and the next mission he dead

[fluid cypress]

Some random encounters felt a lot more genuine

The veteran at Rhodes was great

[fluid cypress]

His fate reminded me of gta a lot for some reason

[proud cipher]

how so

[fluid cypress]

Same for marko

Idk

[proud cipher]

thing is

thats the only story mission that u cant do as arthur

side mission i mean

[fluid cypress]

Satire and weightless deaths?

Maybe that’s why

[fluid cypress]

Yeah

Only for John

Also you can meet charlotte again as John

She looks old

[proud cipher]

how

she was young

its only been 7 years

[fluid cypress]

Idk she was in her mid to late 20s

Maybe it was the rain

[red helm]

Her and Mary Beth are my favorite characters.

[red helm]

No, definitely wasn't the rain. When you come back as John she looks like she aged 20-30 years, it's weird.

[hidden moss]

i uh got a problem that

when i change the graphic settings

it will slow me down\

[red helm]

Well, yeah, Higher Graphics = Your PC is working harder = slower preformance.

[civic vault]

I guess it's supposed to be a secret side mission. But Charlotte deserves to be a 2nd love interest. He had more chemistry with her.

[red helm]

👍

Would've been kind of weird, though, since you meet her when she is literally just finished burying her husband.

[civic vault]

I had an impression she was the same age as Arthur

[red helm]

Yeah, I assumed she was 35ish as well.

[civic vault]

I like Mary Beth too. Also she's the only woman Arthur can dance with.

[red helm]

Someone said they got to dance with Karen in Chapter 3.

[civic vault]

Had the stranger missjon been earlier and would span for accross chapters it wouldve worked i guess.

[civic vault]

Really? Aw I missed that if that was true. But when was that? I spent most time in camp in clemens point

[red helm]

Slightly, maybe... But chapter 1-6 is only a few months, so... eh.

[red helm]

I haven't gotten it, so, don't actually know myself, just what someone else said. Would be interesting to see, though.

[hidden moss]

nononon

i still got

1 more gb of vram left

theres no way

[red helm]

Not what your PC is telling you.

[hidden moss]

it keeps crashing after i change a graphic settings.

its probably a bug

even if i lower the graphic

its still crashing

[weak marten]

Do i need to agree to help mary Linton to get 100%?

[red helm]

No. She isn't listed in the 100% list.

[civic vault]

With all my exploring it felt like 1 year 🤣

Or more 🤣

[red helm]

Yeah, same. But, if you just add up the times it says when the chapters move...

[civic vault]

Ah well, i'll just ship it in a different cicumstance lol

But ngl Arthur is the first character that i dont mind having no ship

Im fine with him either way

[heavy bobcat]

Good i can ignore her shit in my 2nd play thru

No

I hate having to chase her lil brother 4 times because i keep missing his hand

[normal arrow]

bruh if your 30 years old you wouldn't look like an old hag -_-

[weak marten]

LET'S GOOOOO thank youu

I was so worried

This is my 9th playthrough and i wanted to do 100%

[runic jolt]

hey, lenny mod manager keeps crashing my game on launch, any ideas?

[red helm]

Weird Rockstar thing. In Chapter 6, she looks like she is 35ish. But later in the Epilogue(7 years past), she looks like she is 70ish or whatever. Epic failage there.

[normal arrow]

yeah

[red helm]

Friggin Rockstar, ruining a hot ladies looks....

[dreamy oracle]

Is killing Black Belle required to get her gun or is her gun unobtainable

[thick knot]

I don’t think you ever see her again

Not sure if u get her gun

Idk

If there is a way idk I’ve played the game 4 times and haven’t seen it

[zinc remnant]

How do you kill her 💀

[dreamy oracle]

I checked on Reddit and I don’t think you can

I’m not sure

[zinc remnant]

Check every website

And

See how no "black belle" gun is there

[dreamy oracle]

I can’t believe it took me half a playthrough to notice that it was Midnight’s Pistol and not Revolver

[zinc remnant]

Yeah same

[dreamy oracle]

Is collecting all documents in the game required for 100% completion?

[red helm]

No. A lot of them are missable. You can see the 100% Checklist in the Menu and Progression area.

[dreamy oracle]

Alright thanks for telling me

[mild wave]

task manager - > click the drop down on red dead exe if there is one - > right click red dead under the drop down - > go to details - > right click the exe there - > set priority to high. that may fix the crashing. it did for me. probably wont fix the performance issue, but it should fix the crashing.

[amber halo]

S I G H!!!
I see that triggering the legendary panther is pretty much up for grabs. Frustrating.

[solid eagle]

Who would Sean, Lenny, Hosea, and Susan side with if they hadn't died between Arthur and John/Dutch and Micah?

I have a feeling that Hosea's smart enough to be with Arthur, and Lenny seems pretty close to him as well so they'd stay with him. Sean seems very blind to Dutch's issues so he'd probably go with him. That's just what I think though

[solid eagle]

if he did then yeah probably would go with arthur or just go with his own agenda

[fickle chasm]

Charles would side with Arthur if he didn't leave

[hidden moss]

LMAOOOO the auctioneer that you sell the sheep to for 18% something something, his little motion capture sequence had glitched, he just stood there like normal, but his book, pen and money clip were floating and animated by themself

and my sister is literally watching harry potter rn so I could just hear the theme of harry potter while it was floating it was absolutely hilarious omg

and I didnt record 😃 🔫

[runic jay]

Lol

Kinda sus

As Arthur Morgan

[hidden moss]

HAHAHA

[civic vault]

Did you try to get to the area at night?

I found the vampire. Killed him. Now i got a neat knife

[hidden moss]

Why is Arthur such a DICK to that German family he saved?

UGH I just wanna reach in to the screen and slap him silly

I know it's unrealistic but I want Arthur to have a male love interest 🧍 let me make him gay

[open tulip]

Agree

[open tulip]

He would back out and prob join a Irish gang

[civic vault]

And Micah wouldve died right there because Charles wouldve made sure.

[native forum]

🤨

[amber halo]

He can be brutal when needed. He was just being a minimalist and it rally does make sense. They're on the run, they can barely keep themselves safe and they start worrying about other people's families? Not a very prosperous move.
"You can't help anyone if you can't first help yourself."
Someone-some year

[hidden moss]

What

[hidden moss]

Rdr is a dead game

[undone hill]

Iknow Right

[fluid cypress]

:o

[hidden moss]

I want homo Arthur :(

[fluid cypress]

it’s really sad that he’s had a really horrifying homo experience already

wow saying really twice sounds bad

nonetheless homo arthur would still be dope

go to pc technical channel you’re more likely to receive help there

you need to get a pc role for that

from #roles

[little yoke]

oh sorry i just joined, let me delete it

thanks

[fluid cypress]

You don’t need to delete it, you can of course get help here aswell but it’s more likely you get a response in the pc channel

always happy to help btw

[civic vault]

I found a 3 star moose.... and it got away jdncjdfnr ugghhh

[fluid cypress]

lmao

[civic vault]

There are times i feel like im the best hunter and then there are times i feel like a dum dum lol

Literally lassoed the moose coz my horse was too far away for a rifle or anything

So i pulled and it dragged me

And until arthur let go lol

Found the moose by accident btw lol

[thick pewter]

Mickey's prob the best random npc

[shut tinsel]

Is it weird to say he's kinda cute

Ig sweet would prob be the better word

[thick pewter]

I just found him as John and talked to him and he brought up arthur

[shut tinsel]

I spoke to him as Arthur but then idk where to look as John

Is he still in valentine

[thick pewter]

I found him by valentine train station

[civic vault]

He's always at the train station

[thick pewter]

I swear I found him elsewhere once

[shut tinsel]

I really need to play the entire story again because I did barely any stranger missions as Arthur so I missed out on a lot of cutscenes and stuff

[civic vault]

Maybe you found the similar guy in rhodes. A war vet too but lost his leg

[shut tinsel]

Doesn't mickey say that he was never actually in the army

[thick pewter]

No I found him by some houses once I think

Mickey I mean

Houses in valentine

Outside them

[civic vault]

Ah, i guess not far from the train station

[shut tinsel]

It just means I have barely anything to do as john

[civic vault]

I think i remember him hanging out near the smaller saloon in valentine during my first playthrough. Now i always pass him by at the train station.

[thick pewter]

Ye i saw him at that saloon once

[civic vault]

The stranger missions are mostly nice. You should do all of them

[shut tinsel]

I've only done 1 complete playthrough

[shut tinsel]

I will

I just need to do another playthrough

I still refuse to get the low honour ending tho

[civic vault]

Yeah, arthur always deserve high honor ending

[shut tinsel]

Ye

[thick pewter]

I got low honor...

Didnt know there was multiple ways

At the end I was waiting for dead to pop up and it never did

[shut tinsel]

I had his ending spoiled for me so I didn't react as much as I would have but the horse hurt me so much

[thick pewter]

I thought the only ending was death to tb

[shut tinsel]

There is

Which is high honour

[thick pewter]

Ik

[shut tinsel]

In low honour micah kills him

[civic vault]

I got spoiled by youtube but i only knew about the high honor one at the time

And also tumblr

[shut tinsel]

Idc about trophies bcs I would cry way more if I got low honour

[fickle chasm]

guys i can't seem to enter the are of the lgendary moose it doesn't show up and i can only track frogs.

[shut tinsel]

Idk

I mainly just went through the story

[restive sparrow]

hello

[shut tinsel]

Hello

[civic vault]

Hmm... was any recent crime nearby?

[fickle chasm]

idts

[civic vault]

Hmmm

Maybe try to come back after a few game days

Go outside ambarino

Then come back

It happened to me on the legendary bear once. I just spent time outside the area and travelled back after like a week in the game

[fickle chasm]

also wtf happened to the proffeser-

[civic vault]

The one with the robot?

[fickle chasm]

ye

dude was lying dead on the floor

i js went in after visiting charlotte as john

[thick pewter]

I wish in postgame I could be arthur

[civic vault]

I havent gone there after that one time with the lightning. Maybe he killed himslef with the experiments lol

Or the robot killed him

[shut tinsel]

Do u think there will be a rdr3

I think there's a chance but it's rockstar

[thick pewter]

Idk prob

[shut tinsel]

I can see it going 4 ways

[fluid cypress]

The robot probably accidentally killed him. You can find the robot in ambarino crying to itself. Also marko was kinda dark and psychotic. He wanted to take over the world after being able to mass produce the bots

[fluid cypress]

He literally robs you and lies for money lmao but I see where he’s coming from it’s sad

[fickle chasm]

ohhh

[civic vault]

Im seeing double again rofl i thought @fluid cypress was replying to himself lol

[fluid cypress]

lmfao

[shut tinsel]

Following Jack after RDR1
Following Sadie in South America
Following Charles in Canada
Following the earlier days of the gang

[shut tinsel]

Fair enough

I kinda want it to be sadie in South America tbh

[thick pewter]

Does he?

[civic vault]

Another reason why i wanna complete every stranger mission. It's stuff like this that i miss the first time

[fluid cypress]

Charles and Sadie is no, sounds stupid. Jack would be nice but not rly Wild West anymore. Earlier days wouldn’t make much sense since we know what happens. Best to just go further back in time and follow a new story in the same universe with the same redemption and loyalty themes

[fluid cypress]

Yeah when he ‘holds’ you, you’ll lose some money

[thick pewter]

Oh ok

I never realised

[shut tinsel]

Ye me neither

[fluid cypress]

I don’t think it always happens

[thick pewter]

If I kill him as Arthur will he be there when I'm john?

[fluid cypress]

idk

[shut tinsel]

8 years shouldn't bring back the dead

So I'd say no?

[thick pewter]

Ye true but it might just put him back 🤣

[fluid cypress]

i don’t think he’s an npc that respawns

[thick pewter]

Ah k

[shut tinsel]

I think any npc that you can actually have an interaction with won't respawn

The basic ones in the background prob can

But not people like Mickey

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

Except shop keepers

And also people like bob Crawford ig?

Cuz he respawns for me

[thick pewter]

anyone here tried robbing valentine doctors?

[shut tinsel]

No

I've never robbed a store lol

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

ye I did

[civic vault]

I tried. Ended up with half of valentine dead

[fluid cypress]

got some cash and a schofield. Apparently there’s more cash deeper inside but didn’t have time to get to it

[civic vault]

My high honor tarnished lol

[fluid cypress]

lmao

I’ve been trying to rebuild honor in ch3 but it seems impossible

[thick pewter]

I just did the back of the shop

[fluid cypress]

Even tho it’s bad honor in grey idk why it won’t increase

[civic vault]

Yeah i was trying to look for more. I just panicked and shoot at anyone that tried to shoot me back

[fluid cypress]

lmao

[civic vault]

Rofl

[shut tinsel]

Apparently the story slowly lowers ur honour

So ig that would make sense

[fluid cypress]

Yeah the train robbery with John

[civic vault]

I think it's easier in chapter 4 with all the stranger missions

[fluid cypress]

you’re forced to lose honor

[shut tinsel]

Ye

And then the opposite happens in rdr1?

[fluid cypress]

I don’t like going into camp and Arthur talking about how he kills people, when I’m literally being super peaceful and nice all the time

[shut tinsel]

I was so confused and annoyed when I had to steal the wagon to stop the train

Bcs I was losing honour for killing people I had to kill

[fluid cypress]

Lol apparently if you steal it without killing anyone and manage to make it just out of the gates, just die lol. You’ll respawn with the wagon

[shut tinsel]

I hate when games punish you for something you can't control so it really pissed me off

[hidden moss]

bruh what was that rape song arthur dutch and forgot his name lmao were singing

[thick pewter]

Is there a specific way I can shoot someone to make them bleed out if they annoy me

[fluid cypress]

Throat

[thick pewter]

K ty

[fluid cypress]

Or generally torso area

[shut tinsel]

That was quick

Slightly worrying

[hidden moss]

it was gross like why'

[civic vault]

It happened to me rofl

[fluid cypress]

..

[thick pewter]

Does sheriff Malloy respawn?

[fluid cypress]

lmfao

i didn’t realize wtf

[thick pewter]

I think so bc ive killed him a few times I think

[hidden moss]

seriously though what was it and why where they laughing

it was while they were fishing

[fluid cypress]

bro wtf

[hidden moss]

about taters

[fluid cypress]

wtf

[civic vault]

What

[shut tinsel]

I'm confused and worried

[fluid cypress]

i didn’t even think of it that way

[hidden moss]

#red-dead-media

[civic vault]

All i remember it was taters

[hidden moss]

it said something about beating a girl who didnt want to get on

potato rape song

[fickle chasm]

lmfaoo

[shut tinsel]

Holy shit

[hidden moss]

oh she's being beaten for the potatoes?

[shut tinsel]

Ofc

[hidden moss]

what the fuck omg

[civic vault]

Same

[shut tinsel]

You don't beat people for potatoes

[thick pewter]

Is a superior Arabian rose gray coat female worth 1250?

[hidden moss]

😭 I thought the line "I asked a girl for some - mmhmm mhmm" meant sex

and then the taters done part was like supposed to be a joke

and then the beating and yeah

[civic vault]

You might be reading between the lines too much lol

[shut tinsel]

[hidden moss]

english as a school subject made me this way lmao

[thick pewter]

Or shall I buy another horse?

[fluid cypress]

I mean I thought about it being sex too but like didn’t think of the consent

[shut tinsel]

This feels like a r/iam14andthisisdeep post lmao

[hidden moss]

thats what I thought

[fluid cypress]

Yeah that’s what I thought

[hidden moss]

but apparently it's just potatoes lollll

[fluid cypress]

until she wasn’t a wife-

[thick pewter]

I'll get it anyway

[hidden moss]

the literal line about not waiting for it to be done and beating her up and doing mmhmm

I thought the mmhmmm meant like, sex and etc

anyway

[fluid cypress]

Rose gray?

[hidden moss]

it's not that deep but you don't have to look that deep in to it to think it's about yeah

[thick pewter]

Yep

[hidden moss]

it sounds really wrong anyway

[fluid cypress]

If you’re spending that much just get the black Arabian

[shut tinsel]

I can sort of see where ur coming from but the mmmm part is just humming for the song

[thick pewter]

K where can I buy it?

[hidden moss]

I thought it was some cheeky sex song and then the beating the not waiting LMAO

[hidden moss]

I get that now 😭

[thick pewter]

I had the black one when I was Arthur

[hidden moss]

there was this racist in a bar and I did not hesitate to beat the shit out of him

[fluid cypress]

Saint denis stable

[thick pewter]

Is it worth buying the rose gray one for now rather than using Rachel

[hidden moss]

but then the law put the fattest bounty on me like tf

[fluid cypress]

Why buy horses when you can rob the stable

[thick pewter]

U can?

[shut tinsel]

I saw a kkk meeting as John and had to wait a second to clock what was happening before murdering all of them

[fluid cypress]

yeah

[hidden moss]

I don't do anything wrong in red dead that I dont gotta

[hidden moss]

oop HAHA

[thick pewter]

How it just does the cut scene?

[fluid cypress]

If you harass the racist in saint denis infront of the cops they don’t give a shit lmao

[fluid cypress]

There’s a way of doing it

[hidden moss]

I think it was another

said he killed a bunch of indians

[shut tinsel]

Is that the eugenics guy or someone else

[fluid cypress]

@thick pewter

[civic vault]

Yeah, except one time i dragged him around the city i got wanted for causing a distrubance

[fluid cypress]

idk

[hidden moss]

hello

[civic vault]

The eugenics guy i mean

[fluid cypress]

the dude who’s just preaching about ‘purity’

[shut tinsel]

Bcs I know there's a eugenics guy somewhere that you can kill without consequences and you gain honour for it

[shut tinsel]

Probably him

[civic vault]

The racoon hat hobo tho.... i hate him too.

I beat him up

[shut tinsel]

Who

[fluid cypress]

oh yeah him

[civic vault]

And i got jailed lol

[fluid cypress]

he thinks he’s tough

[civic vault]

And dutch helped me get out lol

[fluid cypress]

I never got those cutscenes

in my 3 playthroughs

[shut tinsel]

Me neither

[civic vault]

I tried for once to surrender

And see what happens

[shut tinsel]

I love how cops in story for both gta and rdr2 can actually arrest you but then in online they say surrender and then just open fire

[civic vault]

Omg lol. Oh well

I wanna get the cutscene where dutch blows up the jail cell wall

But i only got the one where he calls arthut tacitus

[thick pewter]

They killed the horse

I died

[civic vault]

Somehow i like fleeting joy. Brings me back memories of arthur being a badass

[fickle chasm]

Cruel world

[fluid cypress]

Bruh

git good

you need a strategy

I had a lot of fun doing this, felt like mission without cutscenes where u have to plan shit and it actually felt like some danger

losing the horse was a big risk

[fluid cypress]

Which version tho

There’s 2 by 2 different singers

[shut tinsel]

Either That's The Way It Is or the epilogue main theme

[fluid cypress]

American venom?

[shut tinsel]

Idk what it's called

[covert slate]

dutch is a dumbass

[fickle chasm]

the one which plays when john... jim milton puts his outfit back on

[covert slate]

period.

[shut tinsel]

It's just called Epilogue Theme on spotify

[fluid cypress]

ngl the ost version of blood feuds ancient and modern is the best

sounds better than the ingame version

[covert slate]

outlaws from the west

and blood feuds ancient and modern

i agree with spig

it sounds much better in game

[fluid cypress]

Main reason was the sick transitions between the tunes, in most of the game the different tunes in the same song just fade out and the next one fade but blood feuds had buildups and shit was dope asf

[hidden moss]

Y'all are replying to a week-old message lol

[shut tinsel]

Yes

[fluid cypress]

bruh

didn’t even realize

[hidden moss]

Favorite's gotta be American Venom. I know that's basic but it's too good.

[covert slate]

iddnt notice

i havent reached the mission in game so im not sure about what it is but to me american venom sounds a bit weird

just the song

[fluid cypress]

bro..

It’s op, the rdr1 theme

but better

[covert slate]

on second thought it sounds good

[hidden moss]

Peer pressure works

[covert slate]

im listening literally rn

[fluid cypress]

Listen to an edited version made by someone yt, it’s called the ultimate John marston theme

[tall jungle]

I prefer applying pressure to the wound to stop bleeding.

[shut tinsel]

Oh ye I've heard it

It's great

[fluid cypress]

has an amazing buildup

Instead of abruptly starting

[fluid cypress]

lmfao

[shut tinsel]

I was trying to find the name of John's theme so I searched it up and listened to that

[fluid cypress]

yeah

[shut tinsel]

It was good but not on spotify

So my life is ruined

[fluid cypress]

It’s a mix between American reprise Jim Milton rides again and american venom, all compiled beautifully

[fluid cypress]

rip

wait it has it tho?

[shut tinsel]

What

[fluid cypress]

wait

nvm

it’s a different app

has Option to play and download yt vids as audio but it’s weird af

[shut tinsel]

I have modded spotify so I need everything on spotify lol

[fluid cypress]

damn

cries in apple

hate how they revoke the third party apps

[thick pewter]

The stolen horse didnt follow

[fluid cypress]

bruh you had to feed it till it was your secondary horse

[thick pewter]

It still says its my temporary so what now

[shut tinsel]

Idk u could probably get it through panda helper

[fluid cypress]

yeah ik but it gets revoked after a while

[thick pewter]

I did it just didnt follow me 🤣

[fluid cypress]

idk fhen

[civic vault]

I was wondering whyit brought me back lol. Discord bugs are weird

[fluid cypress]

alternatively you could’ve ridden the horse itself

[thick pewter]

Oh

How would I have gotten it out it wouldnt jump the fence that it was behind

[fluid cypress]

i wanna try something more daring and high stakes: robbing 2 horses at once. Getting one lassoed and making the other one temp

[fluid cypress]

for me it just clipped through it when I whistled

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

imagine robbing 3

riding one, making 2nd temp and whistling and lassoing 3rd

Insane

But impossible probably

[thick pewter]

Its clipped now

[fluid cypress]

nice

[thick pewter]

Can u do this trick online?

[fluid cypress]

make the escape now

[fluid cypress]

I don’t think so

even if you can you’ll prolly be banned

[civic vault]

Definitely possible. Since nothing is hindering the whistling

[fluid cypress]

Idk how online works tbh

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

You might lose control of the lassoed one, or you might lose the temp horse if the one you’re riding creates a bond

[thick pewter]

I already did I just sneakily came back for it

[fluid cypress]

nice

which one’d you get

[thick pewter]

I think the arabian grey rose one from blackwater

[fluid cypress]

maybe, I’ve never seen it

i usually just have one horse

never get another

[thick pewter]

K

Can I ride the new one to the stable?

And change sadle now?

[fluid cypress]

Yeah

Take them both to a stable

don’t go in

just change saddle

[thick pewter]

K

[fluid cypress]

Then take the old horse and stable it

[thick pewter]

Poor Rachel

How do I change saddle 🤣

By rachel I have the hold up to saddle up prompt but not for Arabian

[fluid cypress]

Just lock on to your horse with L2/LT and use the up button to remove the saddle

then place it on the other horse

idk pc

[thick pewter]

That's how I tried

[thick pewter]

I got it now

[civic vault]

Does arthur really cry when a horse with max bond level dies?

[drifting nacelle]

Never saw this idk

Dont think so

[civic vault]

I saw a reddit post about it and then i saw a video. It's hard to tell if he really was crying

[drifting nacelle]

I think its a mod or something, bc I never saw that

[civic vault]

But the expression on his face makes it plausible

[drifting nacelle]

Maybe its just tb

[civic vault]

I dont think it's during the tb stage

[thick pewter]

What's a ghost train?

What do they do

[civic vault]

It's just there for you to see

[thick pewter]

K

I just went to the old camp by Rhodes in post game and I heard some dialogue does this happen when u visit all the old camps as john?

[covert slate]

if it does then thats really cool

[thick pewter]

K that's cool

[fickle chasm]

well... not exactly crying but he does stay with it and say thank you

[wild acorn]

O

☝️

[glad flicker]

What else is there for me to do i beat the epilogue and most side missions

[thick pewter]

Why tf has shady belle been reoccupied

[covert slate]

kill them all

[thick pewter]

I just got destroyed

[thick pewter]

R u in postgame?

[covert slate]

no

[thick pewter]

K nvm

[bright dawn]

omg.. i just got to chapter 6

im legit terrified

[fluid cypress]

Yeah John gets flashbacks

for every camp

[thick pewter]

K

I'm just tryna get to shady belle 🤣

[thick pewter]

I haven't got any at shady belle and I cant enter the building

[restive mortar]

Arthur losing at blackjack is hilarious 🤣🤣🤣

[fluid cypress]

You won’t get shady belle flashbacks unless you clear the occupant gang

i was creating a mass grave with all the dead bodies behind shady belle and while moving them I got the flashback

[thick pewter]

I did and it didnt come up

[fluid cypress]

doesn't happen all the time

[thick pewter]

K

[simple wyvern]

arthur!!!!!

[willow agate]

So i an in the mission of the boat

Where arthur and strauss is with javier!

So a guard is gonna shoot javier

And strauss picks up a bottle up and breaks it in the guards head!

[light finch]

lol

[crystal violet]

How to Itell my horses to stay put when Im hunting

[light finch]

right click ur horse and click stay

[crystal violet]

Tysm

Doesnt work for my main horse tho

[light finch]

u cant right click them sepperately ?

[thick pewter]

I've been here a while still nothing were u inside or outside

And now I've attracted bounty hunters I think

I lost them

And just accidentally blew myself up

[crystal violet]

I want to hunt legendary moose but bounty hunters keep coming...

[thick pewter]

Kill them if u can

Should only be like 8

[crystal violet]

I kill em and they come again layer

[thick pewter]

True

I've lost like 3k of the 20k and haven't bought anything 🤣

Whys the rhodes gunsmith scared of john the stuff I did to him like freeing the person he kidnapped was with arthur hows he know john

[crystal violet]

How long does it take for leg animals to respawn

[thick pewter]

Idk

[thick knot]

If you kill them I don’t think they do resplendent

Wtf

Autocorrect

Respawn

[crystal violet]

Bounty hunters scared em off or smth

Wait whay

[thick knot]

Oh if it jus ran off

[crystal violet]

U cant hunt one twice?

[thick knot]

U can find it again

Yeah if u hunt it and kill it I’m pretty sure that’s it

You can’t do it again

[crystal violet]

Bruh

[thick knot]

Yeah it kinda sucks but tbh the legendary hunts in story mode are a lot more fun than in online

[crystal violet]

Im strugglin to find clues

And the 4th wave of bounty hunters just came smh

[fluid cypress]

entering the area triggers it, better to try at some place like horseshoe overlook or clemens point

you mainly have to leave and re enter the area again and again

not just leave and enter the buildings

[thick pewter]

K

I found a pretty easy way to kill loads of police in blackwater

Kill bartender leave and lose wanted and whilst shop is shut smash glass and go in and shoot law from behind the bar

If the laws after me should I surrender or run and try and live

How come I didnt even have to kill the legendary fox

[crystal violet]

I thought they take ur money if u surrender

[thick pewter]

K I'll just try and live

Somehow I have high honor and a 1.5k bounty in 2 areas

[crystal violet]

Im in the legendary ram location but it doesnt say I entered the territory??

[thick pewter]

Idk

[thick knot]

Aw man was loving this run so much till now cause Sean’s bouta die and I have to do the mission to get more drippy in San denis

[thick pewter]

I never really cared for Sean 🤣

[thick knot]

Whattt

He was awesome lol

Especially when Arthur first rescued him and he was like pretending he would’ve left him there

Instantly made me like Sean lol

[thick pewter]

He is the Scottish one right?

[thick knot]

Irish

Yeah

[thick pewter]

My bad

[red helm]

Poor Sean, bit of a shame he went so quick, would've been nice to get to know him a bit better.

[thick pewter]

Ye he just annoyed me since he came on the mission he wasnt invited to

[thick knot]

Yeah he would’ve changed the whole ending if he survived tho

He woulda sided with Arthur and honestly they probably could’ve ended Micah there and then

And also him siding with Arthur could’ve changed others minds too

[red helm]

Well, yeah, if Arthur had more people on his side, during that stand off, Micah would've wussed out and it wouldn't have happened in the first place. Probably the whole reason he brought in Cleet and Joe in the first place.

[thick knot]

I think he would’ve still assumed he had more control of Sean was there tho

The whole gang rlly didn’t think much of Sean aside from Arthur

[red helm]

Eh, who knows what would've happened with Sean between Chapter 3 and 6, though. But, if Lenny, Hosea and Sean survived. Plus Charles and Sadie were there.

[thick pewter]

I swear he didnt pay his share to the gang half of the time though

[thick knot]

Oh yeah honestly if either one of them survived Micah wouldn’t have even tried

And yeah he never rlly did lol

But I wouldn’t pay my share either lol Dutch deserves the worst tent money can buy

[red helm]

Do you guys ever look at that Ledger book, No one but Arthur 'really' donates to that thing.

[thick knot]

Yeah

[thick pewter]

I once put like 2k in there 💀

[thick knot]

And then they rag on Arthur for not donating

[thick pewter]

If a horse I own dies will it respawn?

Or do I have to get another?

[thick knot]

Not in story

[red helm]

Yeah, it's like everyone is putting Squirrel tails and bird feathers in there, then Arthur throws in $3k. Yet, all they do is nag Arthur every time he rides in.

[thick pewter]

RIP

I'll steal another from stables l8r than

[red helm]

You guys must be doing something odd to have your horses die so often. I remember going huge portions of my time with my horses barely getting hurt.

[thick pewter]

This is the 1st of my own horses to die

[red helm]

The last time my horse died was my own fault, I was testing out the broken bridge, near Blackwater...

[thick pewter]

I tried fighting 10 bounty hunters and accidentally ran into a tree with the horse then died myself so I couldn't even revive it

[red helm]

Didn't mean you, specifically, just a lot of people complain of horse deaths.

[thick pewter]

K true

[red helm]

Now, running into trees, tree stumps, trees laying on the ground, this I can understand.

Tree Stumps in particular, sometimes they are really hard to notice, especially when they are right, dead on, in front of your horse and your camera angle.

[thick pewter]

Ima prob go steal a rose gray coat arabian from black waters stables

[restive mortar]

Lol that's the true test of how tough you are in red dead. Not how many people you've killed but how many head on collisions with shit you've walked dear from...

Away*

[red helm]

Trees, One of the worst enemies in the game.

[thick pewter]

Good ol' Blackwater oh the times i had here to get the 1.5k bounty I currently have

Is 1.5k max bounty

[thick pewter]

Done it

[red helm]

Yes.

[thick pewter]

Turns out the law started blocking the roads so they've seen me with my horse if I die I lose it bc I haven't made it my main

[red helm]

Silly Law, always have to get in our business.

[thick pewter]

I lost them

[thick pewter]

I mean it's fair enough I did just steel an arabian horse from a stable in daylight 🤣

It's now perma mine

Ok this horse survived vs 9 bounty hunters good start

and I didnt run into a tree

[civic vault]

Yeah i meant in general

[thick pewter]

Why when someone shoots someone and I knock them out why do I get punished not them

[civic vault]

After my first playthrough, i never put more than $20 in it lol

[thick pewter]

Fair

[civic vault]

Ive seen a bunch of posts and screenshots, and one video. I dont want to try on my horse to find out lol

And yeah i think it happens after removing the saddle

Those screenshots have that in common

[amber halo]

Just started the 8 small animal kills in a row challenge, got 3 yesterday, crashed, got up today and did some stuff, jumped in game and those kills are gone. HAHAHAHAHA
I save habitually. Weird.

[thick pewter]

Help

[red helm]

I think the "Consecutive" part gets broken if you load. Be careful of that.

[thick pewter]

I'm surrounded by basically 40 lawman what do I do

[red helm]

Deadeye, Blam, blam. 40 dead law men. Easy Peasy.

[red helm]

I mean, if you don't want the Fast Travel ability. That is the only real reason to upgrade the camp, everything else is 'basically' worthless.

[thick pewter]

It's only like 25 check #red-dead-media

I'm guessing my best plan is to escape with horse

[red helm]

Oh, they aren't even near you? Yawnage.

[thick pewter]

I mean they're shooting at me 🤣

It's because I set a place on fire

[civic vault]

Yeah, except for that one. I get fast travel pretty early on and when i reach clemens point, the boat. Beyond that it's less $20 lol

[thick pewter]

I shot the lamp in that building and the 7 at the top of the pic are shooting at me

[red helm]

There are a lot of places to get free boats, so, eh...

[thick pewter]

Now 12 are shooting at me I tried going to my horse but the shots is scaring it

I died

[red helm]

Aww....

[civic vault]

Im too paranoid to have my horse get shot. So whenever imma attack a gang, i make sure im off my horse and its far enough

Or if they ambush me, i ride out fast before i get off and fill bodies with lead

[thick pewter]

Wheres John's family post game

[thick pewter]

Found them

[hidden moss]

Yeah they should be at the farm.

[thick pewter]

They were

[hidden moss]

Bro i cant find the arabian horse

[civic vault]

Which of Pearson's custom satchel is the best your guys opinion?

I got the tonics one but not sure which one i get next

[hidden moss]

WTF

This stupid horse wont appear

[distant shell]

anyone wanna do a mission

[hidden moss]

Does arabian horse have a chance to not appear

?

[candid pasture]

as the channel says at the top this is a red dead single player channel

[willow cosmos]

Which one are you talking about? If it's the white one then no they can always be found up near that lake in the snow part of the map if you are talking about other Arabians, I don't think so as I have never looked for any other Arabians atm

[hidden moss]

The lake

I cant find it

Litterally cant

[willow cosmos]

Think it's lake isabella it's near colter

[hidden moss]

Ye lake isabella but cant find it

The horse

Not the lake

[willow cosmos]

That's weird have you tried looking at the left section? They should always spawn near the road if not keep Riding around the road up and down

[hidden moss]

K

[willow cosmos]

Cuz that's where I always find them

[hidden moss]

I think one spawns near strawberry

[willow cosmos]

Which one if yk, might check it out

[hidden moss]

Its a red arabian

might be wrong location

but I'm pretty sure its somewhere near strawberry

[willow cosmos]

Yeah might check it, probably make it my main horse

[pliant stump]

I use the one I bought in chapter 2 😭

[civic vault]

Forgot to mention besides the legend of the east satchel

[zinc remnant]

Just buy one

Its like 600 dollars

Saint denis

[azure raptor]

it doesn't im pretty sure, but check by lake isabelle and if you dont find it near there keep searching or reload the game, you will find it at some point.

[crystal violet]

[red helm]

Whichever one you would get the most use out of, I guess.

[red helm]

And that's only if you're in the Epilogue. Arthur has to craft them.

[red helm]

There is indeed a Red arabian west of Strawberry, just northwest of lake Owanjila. Also, there is a Brindle coat near Wapati.

[hidden moss]

ah

I might give up on trying to 100% for a bit

[red helm]

There is a couple things with the 100% that just Suck mega Moose Balls.

[hidden moss]

yea

[red helm]

Most of the things are fun... But... yeah, I get ya.

[hidden moss]

The chalnges and exotics i have to do

[red helm]

Yeah, Exotics can bite me. Most of the Challenges are neat/interesting... But Gambler... ouf...

[hidden moss]

Is exotics required for 100%

[dreamy oracle]

I’ve just completed the 4 main gunslinger missions, Black Belle, Billy Midnight, Flaco Hernandez, and that other guy who raises hogs, does anyone know when I unlock the Calloway final gunslinger mission?

[hidden moss]

1 more mission

[dreamy oracle]

Which mission

Do I just complete a story mission or do I have to give the guy who wanted information about Calloway the pictures to unlock it

[vestal cipher]

the black arabian is in the saint denis stable and the rose colored one is in the blackwater stable

so you can pretty much only get the rose one if you are john unless you have a ton of health tonics as arthur

[hidden moss]

no

I don't rhink

think*

[drowsy pilot]

Did anyone else cry at the end of chapter 5 ?

[hidden moss]

with the music? riding back to shady bell? or did you mean 6 lol

[drowsy pilot]

Music was amazing, talking about the part when he’s headed back in town and falls off the horse, trying not to spoil ha

And sees the deer in the street

[hidden moss]

oh

you mean when he gets diagnosed?

with

(banana)

[drowsy pilot]

Yes and he’s walking in the streets alone in his thoughts

[hidden moss]

mhm

he gets diagnosed with cool character right 👽

[drowsy pilot]

The best of character diagnosis. Trying to figure out what the deer means

[hidden moss]

it means

you have high honor

but if its a wolf/cayote you have low honour/ honor idk

[drowsy pilot]

That’s a nice detail thank you, all choked up over here

[hidden moss]

i have all gold guns because of one reason

valentine bank heist

xd

[drowsy pilot]

How do you get gold guns ?? Money or you have to do something special with the heist or is it an online thing ?

[hidden moss]

ah no i ment story

but you just costomise your guns at the gun smith

if you have enough money

lol

[drowsy pilot]

Oh ok gotcha haha I have a lot of extra money I don’t know what to do with

[hidden moss]

i recomend

buy pamphlets

not guns

[drowsy pilot]

I got most pamphlets so far I think, who sells pamphlets typically ?

[hidden moss]

the fence

found in roads and saint denis

[drowsy pilot]

Ok sweet I’ll double back and make sure I got them

[hidden moss]

you can sell gold bars and stuff there

Oh forgot to mention theres one at emerald ranch

[zinc remnant]

I replied to the arabian horse one

not the satchel

Its 600 in the stables on saint denis

I think

[misty folio]

What’s the point of the scar if we don’t learn how to heal?

[indigo finch]

Being a bad ass to npc 😬

[fluid cypress]

or being a bully

[amber halo]

Is everyone else getting really janky/iffy hunting "Clues/tips"? The bright orange one's that can't be missed if you tried?
Seems several legendary animals now don't trigger the hunting clues at least initially.

[fluid cypress]

Sometimes they don’t appear in eagle eye but are there on my mini map

unfortunately r* will never fix it

[civic vault]

I think you need come back a few in-game days for it to work. Happened to me when i was hunting the legendary bear

[amber halo]

I've never noticed mini map showing them. These never show and no legendary animal either. Finally after loading around 5 times they work.

[amber halo]

HAHAHAHA Hosea doesn't say shit about the skin from the legendary grizzly he was so terrified of. Dam fbm!!

[thick pewter]

Wheres the guy near valentine who got bit by a snake

Is there a way I can change what's in my auto save slot without deleting the save file?

[thick pewter]

I think I found it

[hidden moss]

I think hes near the gun shop

If i remember well

[thick pewter]

Ik that's after but what about b4 when u can go help him

[hidden moss]

Im pretty sure its random but hes near the wilderness

[thick pewter]

K

[fickle chasm]

i can't see clues of the legendary animals

i tihnk it's because of my horse making too much noise?

[fluid cypress]

save and restart, same happened to many

it’s broken

[fickle chasm]

oh kk

[fluid cypress]

every time I enter either the clues won’t show but stay on the map or they won’t show at all and the game just says ‘too much disturbance in the area’

it could be that some random event was triggered nearby but it happens every time

[fickle chasm]

oh for me it doesn't even say that

[fickle chasm]

ohhh ye last time i tried thsi woman was being kidnapped

so prolly that

[fluid cypress]

I just slept and came back, and did it at nighttime since less random events spawn

[fluid cypress]

Yeah maybe that

[fickle chasm]

Night folk

I wasted my goddamn herbivore bait

[willow cosmos]

I keep on getting that too it's annoying af but a little bit of riding around will fix that

[civic vault]

When you get all Pearson's satchels, can you switch back to a different satchel like clothes?

[willow cosmos]

Yeah

[fickle chasm]

i placed some bait and waited a bit far away with my rolling block rifle for 20 fucking minutes

and nothing showed up

[willow cosmos]

But the effects of the satchel will stay the same

[civic vault]

I see.. so i can get the materials satchel but still have the effects of the tonics satchel?

[willow cosmos]

Yes

[fickle chasm]

ohh ty

[fluid cypress]

They’re just cosmetic, when you unlock the satchel the effect applies and stays forever, no matter what you wear. You’re basically paying for the inv space instead the satchel is just a bonus. Same with all the bandoliers and gun belts

[fluid cypress]

They’re rare and only in specific locations so not too worried

[fickle chasm]

I accidentally killed the monk

i was gonna antagonize him

but i accidentally left my right click

[civic vault]

Yas

[civic vault]

Nice!

[hidden moss]

Having a problem getting 100% completion, there’s a certain legendary fish that I can’t catch, tried for like 2 hours and couldn’t get a hold of it, any tips?

and yes I’m using the correct lure for it

Longnose Gar, the one in Lagras

[hidden moss]

@errant glen

I’ve been using the Special Swamp Lure which is the required one, But every time I cast I usually just end up catching some other big fish, I’ve looked this up and other people have been having the same problems with it, I’m pretty sure within 2 hours of fishing straight I would of caught it by now, this is the only fish I’ve had problems with, every other legendary fish took me 1-2 casts to catch them.

[trail tapir]

i got it first try lmao

if its taken 2 hours then its definitely a game problem

shouldnt take that long at all

or ur just facing the completely wrong direction

check out a youtube video to see the direction and go to that exact same spot

[hidden moss]

Whenever I go for legendary fish I just cast randomly, it usually works every time except for this one

@trail tapir I’ll try that

[somber ginkgo]

Hello I am new and was wondering if someone would be able to give me some tips before I play?

[fluid cypress]

First tip: leave the server. leave any subreddits you’ve joined about rdr, unsubscribe from all rdr content and hide all of it from your yt home page. Just go in blind, let the game teach you cuz this game is way too good for being spoilt. Just avoid spoilers it will be worth it trust me

you can look into some detailed mechanics later when you’re a bit more experienced with the game

[somber ginkgo]

Okay

[willow cosmos]

Have you used the hold to reel option? To catch it easier when it bites the bait or are tou talking about it spawning?

[civic vault]

Anybody know where to find badgers?