red-dead-singleplayer

[mystic raven]

Cattleman supermacy!

[plain mirage]

do the castors ridge family respawn if they die in the ambush

[fluid cypress]

bruh that’s the best sidearm

That’s for every weapon lol even the max damage sidearm would probably need around 3 rounds. You need to be accurate when you use sidearms that’s why good accuracy reload and fire rate is important

[hidden moss]

Yessss

[mystic raven]

cattleman has the best gunshot sounds out of all revolvers

[hidden moss]

Cattle men is till better

[golden oasis]

hi

[calm crow]

Ehhhhh i dont see

[fluid cypress]

nope

schofield is simply superior

[fluid cypress]

Bruh how not, first thing I noticed about cleet was how scrawny he was. Joe is meh average body type but cleet is incredibly skinny, and he’s build like straight his whole body width is level

looks weird

[calm crow]

C’mon he’s not that skinny he’s like Sean or Javier

[fluid cypress]

He’s not but ok. It’s useless to argue if you’re gonna keep denying it

why are you so bothered anyways

[hidden moss]

Bruh I had a king and a ace and there was 2 king and a ace on the table and I accidentally pressed x

in poker

Was a 44$ pot aswell

[calm crow]

Im not…

But Ok

Anyway

I hear people discussing if Charles is 24 or 27

What’s ur thoughts?

[hidden moss]

Bruh I was fist fighting the raccoon hat guy in valentine and John kept pulling out his gun when I had it holstered

[primal osprey]

jesus christ

you can really tell that arthur doesn't like strauss

when you antagonise most gang members he just calls them lazy and shit like that

and with strauss its a straight up "i should slit your throat"

or "we should feed you to the wolves" lmao

[dark scaffold]

mauser pistol: 🤓
volcanic pistol: 😎

[glad brook]

Double action.*

[dark scaffold]

double action shoots sugar cubes

only good thing is its gold and shoots fast and reloads fast

[buoyant chasm]

Bro schofield with express ammo is really good

[cold parcel]

Alright, buried Micah.

Or mostly cremated his ass.

[hidden moss]

Cattlemn and lemat are obv better

[cold parcel]

Pfft, fists are better of course.

[hidden moss]

Grapling and dismissing is obv better

[cold parcel]

Getting drunk is obv better.

[hidden moss]

true

but getting obese is better

[dreamy oracle]

Micah’s revolver is the best revolver

[hidden moss]

Meh

[cold parcel]

Eh.

[dreamy oracle]

It’s faster than the double action and reloads faster

[cold parcel]

But the damage?

[hidden moss]

getting drunk with aurthur is almost impossible

[dreamy oracle]

That’s something I didn’t account for

[hidden moss]

double actions kinda suck

[cold parcel]

Getting John's og hair and clothes is non existent.

[hidden moss]

john gets drunk so fast

[cold parcel]

Too bad I hardly get drunk as John or Arthur.

[hidden moss]

hi

[cold parcel]

I did however burry Micah today.

Hello.

[hidden moss]

I like coop de noodel

[cold parcel]

What?

[hidden moss]

My pfp

[buoyant chasm]

how

[cold parcel]

I see an door.

[hidden moss]

I drank like 3 moonshine drunk

[cold parcel]

Grabbed his body and left.

[hidden moss]

No it’s a snake

I call him coop de noodel

I drank all the alcohol i could with aurthur didn't get drunk

So I randomly say it

[cold parcel]

That's kind of random, but okay.

[hidden moss]

That’s the point

😎

[cold parcel]

Doesn't relate to RDR2 tho.

[dreamy oracle]

You can’t move Micah after the epilogue

[cold parcel]

You can with a glitch.

[dreamy oracle]

Oh

[cold parcel]

Micah should be grateful I picked an okay spot for him.

[patent ocean]

Throw him in a fire

[hidden moss]

van horn dumbest place ever

I got into a duel disarmed him then the whole town came and tried to kill me

[dreamy oracle]

Really I killed everyone to try and get a minimum honor level because I was already close to it and they ran away

[hidden moss]

Gambler chalnge 8 is a pain

[hidden moss]

Sheeesh

[hidden moss]

Fr

I cried when doing it

I feel like fucking my high honnor of greeting people for an hour to go on a civilian murder spree

[civic vault]

ride that trolley and greet everyone it passes by, easier honor points

[hidden moss]

Well shit chalnge 9 is even worse

[mystic raven]

i love van horn for shotouts

no dumbass law trying to stop me

[ivory carbon]

This game is so good I’m 100 percenting it

I already finished all the challenges and stuff but I rest again so I could get all trophy’s

900 hours into this game and it is still so great

[exotic hedge]

I believe that I accidentally turned on debug tools in singleplayer. I'm playing with lenny's simple trainer. Is there any toggle to turn them off? don't know whjat they do and im seeing numbers at the top left when i focus on an npc. Whenever i press left alt it 'saves player info to log file'

[exotic hedge]

Im not sure if its an issue with lennys trainer or the game itself.

[hidden moss]

hey guys is ultimate/special edition worth the extra money
note: i only play story mode

Not really

maybe a few more robberys and free guns but u get those guns for free at one point

[wanton glade]

hey does anyone know where i can find the rdr2 directory? I cant find the rockstar folder, I have only found the rockstar games folder

[pine tinsel]

So how do I get a lot of quick money

Because I tried to rob a train and they recognize me instantly, and then I got 256 bounty at the start of the game with no money

[left compass]

Uhh, if you wanna risk being arthur in new austin there's an easy one

[glad brook]

If you haven't noticed yet the town is run by a bunch of outlaws.

[left compass]

Any of yall got the pirate hat? Neat little easter egg, even if it means nothing

[glad brook]

Yeah you get a cool sword too.

[left compass]

A what now

[glad brook]

Sword.

[left compass]

Huh
Too bad the wrecked ship's collision is clunky, i couldn't find one

Also every time i look up read dead easter eggs there's a two headed skeleton for whatever reason
Is that like online lore significance or..?

and uhh, if the law kills you you'll lose less money than surrendering, and they'll stop looking for you

[brisk crow]

[hidden moss]

This dude is racist

[brisk crow]

what

[left compass]

unfortunately, so am i

[brisk crow]

i don't really care what race who is

i'm not really racist

[brisk crow]

but you my friend.

i got something really bad on screenshot

[left compass]

yourm

[brisk crow]

😡

[left compass]

I hope you're riding full speed and your horse hits a stump

[brisk crow]

i hate riding horses

it pisses me off so much

when you are doing sharp turns or something it feels so slow

[left compass]

Bring back donkeys, rockstar

[brisk crow]

Donkeys would be sick

[left compass]

Maybe in this supposed "mexico dlc" i hear rumors of

Average donkey faster than Arabian

[brisk crow]

what

[hidden moss]

I've noticed

[brisk crow]

than the Arabian horse breed?

[glad brook]

A race horse might be just for you then.

[left compass]

Yeah they can literally spin

[brisk crow]

i will keep that in mind.

[civic vault]

Whenever I change clothes on my horse, I can't change back to my custom outfit. It always looks the same. Anybody has the same glitch?

[normal herald]

storing outfits on horses works very weirdly

[civic vault]

Seems like i need to stay at the nearest inn to change my clothes back

[civic vault]

Are there some winter clothes at store besides the default blue?

[left compass]

John automatically has the winter cowboy outfit, with a dark warm jacket

I dunno about stores tho, sadly

And the winter cowboy is also one of the only ways to remove John's suspenders, so i mean...

[grave pollen]

If I didn’t manually save before the end of the game, how do I get the other endings?

[left compass]

I would say replay the missions, but your honor carries over i think... I'm sorry to say, i think you gotta restart the campaign

Or just watch them on youtube yknow

[grave pollen]

Alright

[left compass]

Wait why can't i send spoiler text

That's- just why

[brisk crow]

loser

[left compass]

Then I'll just spoil it i guess

No matter what ending you get, arthur gets killed by micah in some way

[brisk crow]

he does?

[left compass]

figured that's common sense, unless you're joking

[grave pollen]

All the endings are pretty similar, aren’t they?

[left compass]

Yeah, except for the worst possible ending, when you go for the money instead of helping john

[grave pollen]

Yeah

Do you still play as John in the end after all of them or no?

[left compass]

Yeah, he still runs off anyway

There's just no final moment shared between arthur and him

[grave pollen]

Thanks

[fluid cypress]

Why would you wanna use double action lol just use a good pistol then

[left hare]

[fluid cypress]

I just drink 2 moonshine and Arthur is on the verge of passing out

[left hare]

Arthur finna die from moonshine 💀

[fluid cypress]

lol

It only works if it’s consecutive tho like if you take a few seconds in between it won’t work

[left compass]

What's a good distance to throw molotovs at jack

[fluid cypress]

4 moonshine and you actually pass out

[fluid cypress]

huh?

[left compass]

I want to torch him

[left hare]

Idk snipe him

[fluid cypress]

Why don’t you torch Micah

[left hare]

Which camp u at

[fluid cypress]

You can burn him at strawberry when he’s in jail with a fire arrow near his feet

[left compass]

Beecher's hope lol

[fluid cypress]

Yeah but always make sure to run and blow the off of post office guy. He can’t just sit and watch me slaughter the entire town, paint the buildings red and pile the street with bodies

[fluid cypress]

You can’t rly throw motolovs at beecher’s hope, or get jack the introvert of 1907 marston to leave it

Well you can but only in some areas

I tried to burn the farm but the fire instantly stopped

*crops

[left compass]

predator bait works at the ranch. I just figured this out.

I just hold a grudge against jack because he refuses to bond with john

I think it's my honor level of literally 0

[solemn saddle]

Yk when you let micha outta strawberry jail ? And he says "you should come visit me arthur" where does he go? And can you visit him?

[left compass]

Yeah, it's vital to the story

Ayo i actually got john to perfect weight 😳

Man fuck you english

[civic vault]

I think it has to be in Chapter 6 and that's when you receive the letter from the mayor. That's how I remember it

[hidden moss]

Weird

I drank like hella bunch of alcohol as aurthur and like got drunk for a bit then got sober right away

[minor jolt]

Thanks if anyone answers this, please ping me if you have an answer

[fluid cypress]

answer what

[narrow gull]

what's the question

[pure widget]

overweight is the best one

[pure widget]

its a mission

[glad brook]

Heck no not in a western.

[pure widget]

no on the good ending arthur dies by tuberculosis but if you dont go for the gun micah kills him

and in the bad ending micah kills him with a knife

[glad brook]

Plus the double actions are alot quicker. I feel like Micah dual wielding them.

[hidden moss]

Micah is really good with them guns

[sly sandal]

crusty

[tawny monolith]

micah is such a little man

[pure widget]

micah is really a cool dude

i really like him on my 1st playthro

(SPOILER) of course after chapter 4 i started to get suspicious of him working with Milton and ross

and then started to hate him and hate him and hate him

i still hate ross more then him

how do i make my text spoiler

[fluid cypress]

then just use a better revolver, double action is literally useless

[pure widget]

it doesn't matter

they are npc's

use whatever you like

[fluid cypress]

if you make it spoiler the bot considers it as spam so just don’t

[pure widget]

thats so dumb

anyway the whole plot of rdr2 was already spoiled to the pepole who have played rdr1

[fluid cypress]

Ye it’s broken

Same thing with caps

[fluid cypress]

Not really

[pure widget]

like i already knew dutch is gonna betray

micah is gonna die

[fluid cypress]

No one knew abt Micah or how the gang ended or Arthur’s fate

[pure widget]

arthur is gonna die

since they werent in rdr1

[fluid cypress]

only thing they knew was Dutch gon get crazy

[fluid cypress]

Sadie Charles weren’t in rdr1 but they ain’t dead

[pure widget]

same as tilly, marry, karen

to think about it

[fluid cypress]

Karen died

[pure widget]

not that many survived

[pure widget]

wait where?

is her death an easter egg

?

[fluid cypress]

You can meet Mary Beth in epilogue she says she probably died due to drinking

[pure widget]

damn

i talked to mary in epilogue

[fluid cypress]

You can meet a lot of ppl in epilogue it’s kinda nice

[pure widget]

but my english wasn't that good 1st playing the game

[pure widget]

yea tilly, rains fall

tilly will come to john's ranch too

[fluid cypress]

She will?

[pure widget]

yup

[fluid cypress]

Doesn’t she just go to the tram and that’s it?

[pure widget]

no

[fluid cypress]

how

do u trigger it

[pure widget]

its random

[fluid cypress]

oh

I’ll try that

[pure widget]

i only got it on my 2nd time replaying the campaign

[fluid cypress]

Meeting rains falls gives you a lot of honor for some reason

[pure widget]

i was surprised john knows him

[fluid cypress]

Yeah

also Pearson at Rhodes lol

you can blow him up

with dynamite

[pure widget]

i robed him lol

[fluid cypress]

I feel bad thinking about it

i reverted to an older save and tried not to cause trouble there

[pure widget]

me 2 but i loaded my old save before robbing him

wish they would fix john

john in rdr2 was no badass at all

[fluid cypress]

they did

tweak him

not perfect but better

keep him underweight

[pure widget]

his personality was much different in rdr2

in rdr1 he was a serious badass bounty hunter

[fluid cypress]

bro there’s another 4 years he’s still young in rdr2

[pure widget]

no wonder the pepole who only played rde2 dont like him that much

why didn't they give him his original hair?

[fluid cypress]

his daughters death probably make him more serious and stuff

that hasn’t happened yet

[fluid cypress]

Idk too lazy to code and model different lengths for it lol

[pure widget]

yea i think it happens 3 years before rdr1 story

[fluid cypress]

Yeah

one year after epilogue

[pure widget]

maybe it conflicted with arthurs hair

go to red dead media i posted a random custom outfit rate it out of 10

[fluid cypress]

how’d you get that poncho

[pure widget]

mods

[pine tinsel]

Does surrendering to bounty hunters do anything?

[pure widget]

i can give you the link to the mod

[fluid cypress]

i dont play on oc

pc*

[fluid cypress]

You get taken in

[pine tinsel]

Do you lose money?

[fluid cypress]

Yeah ofc

[pure widget]

pc version sucks

[fluid cypress]

depending on the bounty

[pure widget]

the blurnes the auto aim

[pine tinsel]

Yep am gonna run

[pure widget]

everything is bad about the pc version

console version is godly

i hope ps5 players get 60 fps patch

[fluid cypress]

if you wanna surrender do to lawmen killing bounty hunters wont increase your bounty

[fluid cypress]

It wont

r* too lazy

[pure widget]

yeah they are giving a 60 fps patch to their older game

GTA 5

[fluid cypress]

for 70$

[pure widget]

i dont have a ps5 but isn't it embarrassing that all new games have 60 fps patch

[fluid cypress]

yeah

[civic vault]

Is it because GTA is more profitable for them?

[pure widget]

but rockstar dosent

especially on a game they worked for 8 years

[pure widget]

yes

[fluid cypress]

Lots of little kids who wanna drive cars and shoot randoms

[civic vault]

Ah.. the tiny murderers

[pure widget]

ngl gta 5 story mode is really great

dude also another thing

you cant finish jamie's mission

on keyboard and mouse

its a bug

you have to use a controller or skip it

this proves they didnt even test the pc version

[fluid cypress]

which?

and how??

[civic vault]

I finished it on the PC version lol

[pure widget]

the duel with jamie

how?

[fluid cypress]

what about it

[random sedge]

Worked for me

[civic vault]

Yep, i was able to shoot off the gun from his hand

It worked

[pure widget]

for me the square tries to get full

[pure widget]

ik

[fluid cypress]

How does the draw work since pc doesnr have triggers?

[random sedge]

Hold left click

[pure widget]

but when i use controller i dosent full anything

it straight up draws the gun

[fluid cypress]

Oh, in consoles the speed at which you push it down matters

[pure widget]

you hold the mouse button

[random sedge]

Doesnt matter on pc

[pure widget]

left one

[pure widget]

on pc you cant go from running to walking

you have to fully stop

but there is a mod to fix that

[fluid cypress]

sad, it have support for trigger sensitive keyboards?

[pure widget]

idk whats that so i dont think it has

[fluid cypress]

It’s those keyboard where all keys have like pressure sensitivity like how much you press it it’s used in racing games mostly but some games have support for liek walking and stuff aswell

[pure widget]

yeah it dosent

[fluid cypress]

like if you push it less the vehicle goes slower or turns less

[pure widget]

thats why pepole play racing games on controller

when you hold W it goes to full

[fluid cypress]

tbh rdr2 feels much better with controller

[pure widget]

yea

all games do other then FPS games

[civic vault]

yeah

[fluid cypress]

feels like you have the gun in your hand especially how the gun controls are designed

[civic vault]

i have it both on ps4 and PC

[pure widget]

same

[civic vault]

and i first played it on PS4

[pure widget]

me too

[civic vault]

but when i switched to PC, im too used to the ps4 controller that i just connected it with bluetooth

i just miss the vibrations

[pure widget]

it will have latency tho

use DS4

[civic vault]

like Arthur's heartbeat

[pure widget]

i have vibration

use DS4 i think it will be fixed

you can change the buttons, change the colour of the colour bar

a lot of stuff

[civic vault]

So far i don't have issues with latency tho. It works fine. I'm satisfied

[civic vault]

I'll check that out

Ah i didn't realize i already installed DS4 when i was trying to get my controller working lol

i thought it was a different app

imma try to get the vibration working now

[tawny monolith]

vibration has also been found to he linked to early hand diseases such as, but not limited to: arthritis

not kidding actually

[pure widget]

search youtube

[civic vault]

But I did play the first chapter of my 2nd playthrough on keyboard and mouse.

including that Jamie mission

[pure widget]

maybe it was just my mouse

[civic vault]

yeah

but the rest of gameplay in that chapter i still found clunky and it's been years since i played with keyboard and mouse that i'm more accustomed to the controller now

[pure widget]

do you play on ps5 controller?

[civic vault]

Nope, just the ps4

[pure widget]

if so there is a mod that makes the trigger thingy (i dont know waht its called) to work

makes the game realistic

[civic vault]

you mean during draws?

[pure widget]

no

its all good

it makes the adaptive trigger feuture

[civic vault]

Ah

[pure widget]

to work on the game

[civic vault]

i busted all my budget so it's gonna be a while for me to have ps5 stuff lol

[pure widget]

yeah i play on a budget laptop lol

with a shitty mouse

[civic vault]

i bought this gaming laptop for work purposes but then i discovered rdr2 so yeah, it came with the perfect timing lol

[civic vault]

What specs do you have?

[pure widget]

1650ti

i7 10th gen

wbu?

[civic vault]

i7 as well, RTX 3060

[pure widget]

damnnnnnnnnnn

[civic vault]

i mainly use it for my video editing job so i needed to max out as much as i can with the graphics card lol

had to upgrade the ram to 24GB as well just to make sure

[pure widget]

video editing is amazing

[civic vault]

video editing used to be fun, now im tired of it lol

[pure widget]

do you work for a YouTuber? or work for companies when they need to make an ad

[tawny monolith]

aw man

no g8f

[pure widget]

also sorry for my bad English

[civic vault]

I work at a university that makes educational videos. Sometimes I make those cheesy AVPs for them

[pure widget]

wow props man

[civic vault]

kinda boring tho lol

but ah well

it's a stable job anyway

[pure widget]

yeah

[hidden moss]

[civic vault]

on my lunch break i just play rdr2 lol

good thing i'm working from home

[pure widget]

working from home is so good

[hidden moss]

I hate the gambler chalnges omg

[left compass]

I'd say he dies more of tuberculosis and having the shit beat out of him by micah

[civic vault]

seeing so many people complain about it makes me scared of it lol

[hidden moss]

I've been on chalnge 9 for hours

Stupid dominos

[left compass]

Why is blackjack only in like 2 fuckin casinos

It's like, the only casino game I'm kinda good at

[hidden moss]

can't wait for chalnge 10 where I have to win 3 poker games in a row :|

[pure widget]

anyway i have to go bye guys

have a good weekend

[civic vault]

bye!

[civic vault]

whoa

[left compass]

Wait a friggin second
Pearson's in the epilogue?

[hidden moss]

Yes

Tilly is to and mery beth

and rain falls

[left compass]

Oh i met marybeth, but i just now found Pearson in rhodes

[civic vault]

the Rain Falls one makes me sad

[hidden moss]

Tilly is in saint denis

[hidden moss]

Yeah

to bad there wasn't missions to tey and help him

[left compass]

Mind droppin a map location in the media chat?

[hidden moss]

idk I don't remember i think near church or something she's sitting on a bench

[fluid cypress]

At valentine post office infront of the tracks

[left compass]

That's... mary beth

[civic vault]

I just tagged you Tilly

[fluid cypress]

Rains falls is in annesburg train station

[fluid cypress]

oh

sorry

[civic vault]

She's easy to find, she's in one of the benches right outside the park near the tailor shop at St. Denis

I haven't met Mary Beth in the epilogue tho, i need to find her in this playthrough

[left compass]

Might've seen her and just kept walkin before, that's an obvious spot

[hidden moss]

Wheres aurthurs grave ?

I haven't visited it yet

[civic vault]

at the rocky hill next to the strange hobbit house

[hidden moss]

arthurs*

[left compass]

Finding rain falls first, kinda feel bad for him

[civic vault]

it was hard for me to reach and i almost got lost in those steep rock climbs lol and my horse almost died lol

[left compass]

Legend of the east satchel mfs with 99 horse revivers:

[hidden moss]

its cool rains falls gives you lots of honnor tho

[civic vault]

lol

[hidden moss]

when I get wanted for defending myself

[civic vault]

rofl, i remember once i was just passing through and this goat farmer just randomly got mad at me and whipped out his gun

i had to, of course, shoot back

then, "wanted: murder"

[left compass]

Jesus, didn't fallout teach you to break the legs in an unwanted situation?

[civic vault]

and then i had to pay the bounty, then arthur's dialogue fit the situuation saying "it was all a misunderstanding"

[hidden moss]

I got wanted for fighting back in a fist fight

[left compass]

Well it's not fighting back if you have a knife

[hidden moss]

or early john kept wiping out his gun for no reason!!

well I was fist fighting

[left compass]

Yknow you can punch with B, right

[hidden moss]

Yes ik

[left compass]

So why use RT

[hidden moss]

lt

LT

to lockon

I punched a women in a fight by accident when I didn't lock on

everyone pulled out there guns right away

[left compass]

Yeah intersexual brawls are not tolerated

[hidden moss]

I accidentally punched a horse once weird i can't survive a horse kick but can survive a dynamite blast

[left compass]

Wait, is there like some kind of reward for meeting all the seperated gang members, or is it just kinda fun little confrontations?

[solemn saddle]

Arthur just took jack fishing, so wholesome. Except for the assholes :(

[hidden moss]

eh just for fun

U write in the journal so thats something ig

[left compass]

John certainly isn't the writer arthur was

[hidden moss]

john sucks at it

[left compass]

Can't wait for people's reactions when rockstar releases another gta online dlc instead of this rdr remake people keep going on about

[hidden moss]

well I wonder whats gona come first gta6 or rdr3

[left compass]

Half life 3

But on a serious note, they're probably gonna hold out on gta6 for as long as physically possible

[hidden moss]

its probably done already ngl

its been like what almost 9 years?

[left compass]

Because people just LOVE gta online

[hidden moss]

I mean I don't mind gtao just wish rdo got updates

[left compass]

I've never played gta online and already the only thing i like about it is custom characters

[hidden moss]

I like the cars really

and pvp occasionally

[dark scaffold]

if they really and truly are focusing on gta6 nonetheless it would still come first

rdr2 took 7 years and 500 hrs of motion capturing

[civic vault]

his drawings make me cry laughing lol

[dark scaffold]

and with updated software and graphics since then it would take even longer

[hidden moss]

rdr3 will be better then gta6

[dark scaffold]

no doubt

[civic vault]

imma be an old lady by the time rdr3 comes out

[dark scaffold]

rdr2 proved rockstar can do great if they really take the time

[hidden moss]

if they had content updates for single player omg

but that would never happen in any of there games prob

[civic vault]

I want a dlc but it's a log shot

[hidden moss]

epilouge dlcs would be great

or unlimited Stanger missions and bounty hunting

[dark scaffold]

i think hosea would have kept the gang intact if he didnt die

[hidden moss]

idk maybe

dutch already hit his head

[dark scaffold]

i hear that all the time but i dont think thats what made the difference

i think he was just hiding the man he truly was

[hidden moss]

idk

feel like it was him hitting his head

but also hosea idk its confusing

[dark scaffold]

i guess thats everyones opinion

but arthurs reactions doesnt really hint about him hitting his head

especially when he killed the woman in guarma

[hidden moss]

Cuz dutch was listening to arthur for like one mission then micah started talking to dutch

[civic vault]

I think Micah wouldve turned Dutch against Hosea. But Hosea wouldve made John's escape easier imo

[hidden moss]

hosea would've killed micah imo

[civic vault]

That too

[hidden moss]

hosea threatened micah couple times

[civic vault]

And Arthur wouldve died in rest rather than after battle

[hidden moss]

moved to Tahiti became mango farmers and arthur would've lived longer

[dark scaffold]

i noticed how in the random gang event hosea threatens to kill bill, and he was still a fast draw for his age

[dark scaffold]

arthur i dont think would have went to tahiti

he mentions going to california

[dark scaffold]

dutch would never have betrayed hosea in my opinion

[civic vault]

Yeah Arthur was never really fond of the tahiti

[hidden moss]

calli would've been better anyways

[dark scaffold]

i reckon when hosea was young he was a very quick draw

[civic vault]

But judging by how he treated Arthur, there's a chance

[dark scaffold]

but that was after hosea dies

ultimately i think when hosea died micah made his move on dutch

[hidden moss]

If hosea never died micah would be killed by hosea or never become a rat

[dark scaffold]

i think micah told milton about blackwater

[hidden moss]

Hard to say with little information but idk

[dark scaffold]

micah would have been stronger, quicker and a faster hand so im not sure hed be able to

[dark scaffold]

its just a little theory of mine

[hidden moss]

even if micah killed hosea dutch would kill micah and other gang members would to

[civic vault]

Would Hosea find out that Micah is a rat or maybe he knew all along without evidence?

I think maybe Hosea had an inkling

[dark scaffold]

i think hosea definitely knew

if not he definitely would have discovered it

[hidden moss]

hosea is high rank member would be really hard to getaway with it

[civic vault]

But he couldnt convince Dutch early enough

[dark scaffold]

the thing is its a cycle

micah kills hosea, arthur would probably kill micah, dutch would kill arthur

[hidden moss]

how would that work?

[dark scaffold]

it would cause a chain reaction in the gang

[civic vault]

I like to imagine Hosea would cause a split in the gang early on if he tells Micah is a rat. And of course Arthur (and others) would side with Hosea. The remaining would side with Dutch

[hidden moss]

Micah isn't a high rank i don't think it would cause anything really

[dark scaffold]

although if arthur wasnt sick he would wipe the floor with micah

[dark scaffold]

i dont think the rank mattered, alot of people were mad when grimshaw shot karen

or molly i mean

[dark scaffold]

i think majority would side with hosea

[civic vault]

That's why Micah waited for Arthur to be too sick

Micah knew he couldnt take on a healthy Arthur

I mean he took the opportunity

[hidden moss]

Hosea alive i don't think dutch would side with micah

[dark scaffold]

the women would probably side with hosea, sadie would side with hosea, john would side with arthur, bill would probably side with dutch, micah with dutch, javier i dont really know

[dark scaffold]

yea i think so

[hidden moss]

Micah would just be killed

[dark scaffold]

micah was a coward

[civic vault]

If Cleet and Joe are in there, they're with Dutch

[hidden moss]

only if Javier didn't interupt grimsahw could've killed micah

wasn't susan a ex of dutch?

[dark scaffold]

that reminds me
i dont think cleet was ever a bad person, he was just in with micah at the time.
it hints to it in american venom when you interrogate him.
i chose to spare him bc i think he really changed, but sadie shoots him anyway

[dark scaffold]

i think so

[civic vault]

Javier was a bit confused but he chose Dutch so I think he would still side with Dutch.

[dark scaffold]

but if you look closely at him he never pointed his gun at arthur or john

[hidden moss]

Atleast he didn't aim his gun at john and arthur

[dark scaffold]

i think he chose dutch because he thought he had to

[civic vault]

I spared him too. When Sadie shot him im like "you got no honor system woman!" lol

[dark scaffold]

i felt bad

[hidden moss]

I didn't spare cleet

Cuz ik Sadie would shoot him

[civic vault]

It's like he agrees with Dutch but doesnt want to hurt anybody

[hidden moss]

Micah barely won against dieing arthur sad

[dark scaffold]

cleet never did anything wrong, even in the final train robbery, he celebrates with arthur and sadie for a second when they got the money

[civic vault]

You can notice when he starts berating Arthur by the time it's clear that he's sick. He was never that before.

[dark scaffold]

when arthur shouted at him to watch his tongue it genuienly scared me

[hidden moss]

it got me mad when micah was trying to boss around arthur

[civic vault]

Same

[dark scaffold]

seeing arthur all pale and bloodshot made me sad

[hidden moss]

thats kinda when I knew shit was gona go down soon

[dark scaffold]

am i the only one who cried when hosea died?
he was my favourite character

[civic vault]

I cried at him and lenny

[hidden moss]

wish I could like erase my memory of this game and play it again

[civic vault]

But i cried more for the horse

[dark scaffold]

lennys death was too fast for me to take in
it happened so fast i think he was done dirty

[dark scaffold]

i had the same arabian all game and i was so sad when it died

[hidden moss]

rdr2 the only game I teared up on lol

[civic vault]

Same rofl

[dark scaffold]

theres only 2 games ive teared up on.
rdr2 and spider man ps4

[civic vault]

I was bawling at Arthur's death

[dark scaffold]

same

i got low honour too bc i didnt know it made a difference

[hidden moss]

My first playthru i had the tenesene walker u get from Sadie's ranch

[civic vault]

And playing the epilogue hurt me because everything John was getting was something Arthur wouldve wanted

[dark scaffold]

i only got the arabian bc my uncle, who played the game before me, told me to get the white arabian

[dark scaffold]

it was so satisfying to empty bullets into micahs head

[civic vault]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

I got to like little bit above low honnor wasn't enough for high honnor tho

[dark scaffold]

i was originally gonna be high honour as john but that ended quickly when my horse got killed so i slaughtered half of saint denis

💀

[civic vault]

I got high honor

[hidden moss]

I was low honnor basicly the whole game as aurther just in chapter 6 I was mid honnor

[civic vault]

When Hosea and Lenny died i made Arthur drink 10 bottles of beer

[hidden moss]

I killed all of saint denis after they died

susan got mad

[civic vault]

Rofl didnt know susan would react

[hidden moss]

Well she didn't really

it was a low honnor thing

[dark scaffold]

its too hard for me to resist shooting a random guy every once in a while

though the canon way to play is low honor until u get diagnosed with tb, then high honor

[lone garnet]

@dark scaffold LMFAO

[hidden moss]

I killed micah with like just summer gunslinger outfit

With arthurs cattlemen revolver:)

[civic vault]

John be freezing lol or he too pumped up to kill micah to notice lol

[civic vault]

Nice

[hidden moss]

I didn't get cold some how

[civic vault]

I guess its too much adrenaline rush lol

[hidden moss]

maybe

[dark scaffold]

im just a very angry man

[hidden moss]

Micah is also kinda ok in the beginning of chapter 6

Micah still respects arthur

just at the end of chapter 6 when micah thinks he's better he's a dick and needs to die

[lone garnet]

A lady begged me for help and a ride at the side of the road. So she jumped on and I began to ride with my rifle in my hand which I accidently fired into a bypassing rider. So she went Nutts and said "u r a killer" and ran off. I got pissed cause I had got halfway to her location so I rode after her and shot her dead

[civic vault]

The only chapter they fully agreed on was in Guarma i think lol

Coz both wanted to get out of Guarma lol

[dark scaffold]

i once accepted to give a ride to lady and when she said annesburg i was going to saint denis
so i got off my horse and emptied 6 bullets into her face

[lone garnet]

Hahahahahaha

[dark scaffold]

im a psychopath

[civic vault]

Death by low honor player lol

[lone garnet]

I executed the gavin guy twice, and he still keeps popping up everywhere

[dark scaffold]

the thing is if dutch didnt step on the gun arthur would have killed micah

but would have died in peace on the mountain

meaning john wouldnt have been found

meaning he wouldnt die

and uncle wouldnt die early

[hidden moss]

uncle was old

kinda funny the one person that done almost nothing in the gang out lived basically everyone

[civic vault]

Lumbago adds to the years rofl

I hated Dutch for stepping on the gun

Almost threw the controller lol

[hidden moss]

low honnor ending dutch stopped micah from stabbing arthur

Or going for money

[dark scaffold]

i kicked my chair and was holding my foot for the next 5 minutes

[hidden moss]

I was really ticked off and annoyed that dutch didn't kill micah right there someone u basically raised getting killed and u don't kill them

[civic vault]

Same

[dark scaffold]

completely off topic but i can imagine young john waking up arthur in the middle of the night saying ”arthur i frew up”

[hidden moss]

anyone notice stage coach people call john rip van winkle?

Sometimes

[civic vault]

It's the fake name he used during that stand off with Milton

[dark scaffold]

when ducth called him agent moron i died

[hidden moss]

Yeah but stage coaches when they wake u they say something and then rip van winkle

[civic vault]

Maybe John gave them that name?

[civic vault]

Lol yeah

[hidden moss]

that scene was bad ass ngl

[civic vault]

How old was John when he got into the gang? I knew Arthur was probably 15 or 16

[hidden moss]

When everyone pulled out a gun

[civic vault]

Shouldve killed Milton there, but yeah so badass next to the Braithwaite Manor scene

[hidden moss]

isn't john like 10 or 12 years younger then arthur ?

[hidden moss]

Braithwaite was probably the most badass scene

[hidden moss]

Wouldve ruined rdr1 kinda cuz Ross was there

[civic vault]

I kept replaying that scene in youtube after finishing that mission.

[civic vault]

Forgot about Ross being there

[lone garnet]

Have u guys played rdr1

[civic vault]

I don't remember ever being mentioned

[lone garnet]

Can't play since its not on pc or ps4

[hidden moss]

When milltion and Ross came to arthur and Jack fishing i wanted to wip out and use dead eye on them

[civic vault]

Arthur was about to do that I think, his hand was ready for the gun

[hidden moss]

Well john is like 28 or something and arthur is 36 in 1999

1899*

[civic vault]

Ah thats a huge gap

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[civic vault]

Arthur wouldve been baby sitting kiddie John

Which is wholesome lol

Maybe thats why he called John "the golden boy"

[hidden moss]

and john is dutchs favorite

[civic vault]

Yep

Probably why Arthur is more fond of Hosea

[hidden moss]

hosea the wise

[civic vault]

I wish there was more missions with him

Couldve seen more of that father and son bond

[hidden moss]

yeahhh

susan u see some mother figure when she nags you to clean and get your act straight lol

[civic vault]

Yes lol

[hidden moss]

Also wish she had more missions

[civic vault]

It wss just that one mission to rescue Tilly and then that spice request

I wanted mooore

[hidden moss]

she compliments you if u kill the guys real quick

[civic vault]

I think Susan's fave is Arthur coz his tent is always nice lol

Always says his things are all properly set up

[hidden moss]

besides in one camp but that wasn't really a camp

[civic vault]

Yeah in lakay?

[hidden moss]

Yep

[civic vault]

They were in a rush and she protected his things

Still tells that she likes Arthur more lol

[hidden moss]

john sleeps on the ground xD

[civic vault]

And sided with Arthur at the end

[hidden moss]

I hated when Susan got killed

[civic vault]

Yeah

At least have one of the guys get killed by her

[hidden moss]

like who else would be betraying you dutch a guy thats been in the gang little then a year or basicly your son

[civic vault]

Didnt he have a tent that actually looks like a tent?

[hidden moss]

doesn't have a bed tho

I also wondered why hosea slept on the ground

like aint he second in command lol

[civic vault]

And then Sean and Karen used that tent to do somethin' lol

[civic vault]

Same lol, im like "Hosea is that u on the ground??" lol

[hidden moss]

He even shared his sleeping space

Kinda weird

[civic vault]

Was it with Charles or with Lenny?

I forgot

[hidden moss]

Bill and Charles I think

[civic vault]

Gonna check it out later

Im at Clemens Point now

[hidden moss]

bever Hallow

for me

third play thru

[civic vault]

2nd playthrough for me

Still exploring and finding those stone carvings

The dinosaurs ive pretty much collected until epilogue

[hidden moss]

u ever find all the dream catchers ?

[civic vault]

I havent

Is there a stranger mission for that?

[hidden moss]

I've only found one

[civic vault]

I guess I missed that stranger mission

[hidden moss]

Idk I found it randomly when my horse was out of range and i was in the wilderness

[civic vault]

Huh thats interesting

I wonder whats the use

[hidden moss]

Have to find 20

idk its weird

think u get something when u find all 20

[civic vault]

Google says finding all of them would reveal "a secret behind the dream catchers."

Has me curious

[hidden moss]

huh

i wonder if u need them for 100%

U do googeld it

[civic vault]

Maybe

But google results dont say you need it for 100%

It's unclear

[dark scaffold]

john was 12

[hidden moss]

I got a 1000$ bounty with just a ace

axe*

[civic vault]

I want a machete

Huh i guess gotta loot a dead nightfolk

I hate runnung into those guys

[mortal turret]

How to wear a mask during the cutscene?, I want to make arthur look more badass

[dark scaffold]

dont think you can

[mortal turret]

Aw 😦

[fluid cypress]

The completion tab has a section fro dream catchers

[civic vault]

Ah, so it's needed

[surreal plaza]

How long should I play chaper one I'm free roaming at the moment should I just jump to chaper 2?

[hidden moss]

It kinda depends on everyone

[dark scaffold]

not much to do in chapter 1, if you like ambarino just go back when you have more freedom

[civic vault]

There's a lot of dying eagles in Mt. Shann

Perfect feathers too

Just dropped dead

[surreal plaza]

Oh feather I go look thanks

[last geode]

lol

[willow agate]

Imagine not going to camp heading straight to std bar and finding molly ohshea

Lol

Arthor Morgan! Did dutcchhh send u!
Wwll tell him i oowe him nthing

[civic vault]

Near the giant skeleton. 3 eagles just dropped dead im not even sure why lol. Probably a glitch

I just got back to the camp after finsing all 10 stone carvings and Dutch is like "You have stopped working for us and the money box is empty!"

No Dutch shut up

Ms. Grimahaw is meaner tho lol

[civic vault]

Is that possible? I wish it's possible lol

[willow agate]

Reverend was a great story written character

He stopped drinking and he bacame a priest in newyork his own church!

He changed from a low to high character

And rckstar confirmed rdr3 so im waiting!❤️❤️

[fluid cypress]

It is I think

You can find her there

In the saint denis bar

Or saloon whatever you call it

[lone garnet]

How do I get the turkoman in the stable for free? Go in and shoot the place and then what

[pure widget]

Really?

Wow

[pure widget]

I even put money in the box and they still say that

[pure widget]

Wait when?

Didn't they confirm gta 6

[willow agate]

Rdr3 as well

[civic vault]

Yeah as always. Dutch even says he missed Arthur lol been away for too long

[civic vault]

Probably after GTA6

[pure widget]

At what year do you guys want the game to take place in?

[tawny monolith]

that'll be in like 3 years lmfao

I'd like to see pre ww1 1900s

even though canonically that doesn't make sense

[civic vault]

As someone who still wants to play as Arthur, I say before the Blackwater incident.

[pure widget]

I say at the early times of the gang

When they recruited arthur and john

But we still get to play as one of them

[tawny monolith]

a prequel i feel, would go nowhere

because it isn't very open ended

[pure widget]

True

[tawny monolith]

good writing comes from what you cannot expect

both rdrs were open ended

[pure widget]

I just hope we get to see John, and arthur again

[tawny monolith]

so it has to have a much larger gap

[civic vault]

That's why I think it should be like gta5 where you can play 3 characters. Arthur, John, and Mac Callendar

[tawny monolith]

eh

that would make it very arcadey

[pure widget]

That would be amazing

[tawny monolith]

and that would triple the workload of rockstar

[pure widget]

I was so disappointed when I couldn't play as john in rdr2

But well I finished the game and... my wish came true... in a bad way

[tawny monolith]

you also have to think about environment when thinking about the year it takes place in

going too far forward kind of destroys the freedom you had in 2

[civic vault]

Good thing i didnt play the first game lol

[tawny monolith]

I'd like to see a more developed version of it

maybe on the other coast

with war on the horizon

tbh i have no idea where the game can go from here

even with it being open ended i can't see myself caring about the story after Arthur's succesor

[civic vault]

The 1900's is too restrictive and the fanbase is hard to please with new characters because Arthur and John left pretty big shoes to fill. And it doesnt always work

[tawny monolith]

true

[civic vault]

So the compromise is go back into the past and play as three characters. But that's just me.

[tawny monolith]

but then again i don't see how we can fill them

[tawny monolith]

that's also restrictive under a different light

[civic vault]

Yeah well, it has to change with the story i guess

[tawny monolith]

and going just a few decades back won't make the game feel new

like what i said with environment

it'll be the same

actually

this is quite a stretch

but I'd like to see it in europe

that might be cool

[civic vault]

I think r* made two 3 possible scenarios because they left the Blackwater incident vague enough that people are curious about it - like intentionally vague.

Then they made Sadie and Charles go to different places. Sadie in South America. Charles is in Canada.

So R* created 3 possibilities for rdr3.

I guess it depends which R* thinks is more profitable

[fluid cypress]

Long ago take two said theyre gonna make more red dead games

[pure widget]

You missed out a great game

[tawny monolith]

but from the beginning you know what the big event is, in essence

[pure widget]

Not great

A legendry one

[tawny monolith]

it was good

[civic vault]

I first found out about rdr2 before rdr1, ah well

[pure widget]

Rdr1 had a true wild west felling

[tawny monolith]

i played like 30 hours of the undead dlc

[fluid cypress]

Orrrr just stick to the same themes of redemption and go further back to the wild west in its prime and create a new story with new characters

[dull geyser]

Yes

[tawny monolith]

or that

but again

further back will be the same

[civic vault]

Like i said, it's just me lol

[fluid cypress]

I dont see how van der linde story would go anywhere

[tawny monolith]

so i think the progression of time with maybe you following the gang's footsteps and learning about them

[pure widget]

I hope we dont play as sadie or Charles in the next game lmao

[tawny monolith]

yeah

[fluid cypress]

they could follow jack after rdr1 but it is it even wild west anymore

[tawny monolith]

imagine if we play as the nun

[civic vault]

Rofl

[pure widget]

Yeah Jack stoy will be good too

[dull geyser]

Yea they won't be having that wild west feel

[pure widget]

He is a good charecter

[dull geyser]

But they're pretty solid ideas for DLCs

[pure widget]

Yeah

[tawny monolith]

oh mwn

[fluid cypress]

Its not rly wild west then it will be like hanger 13‘s mafia games

[tawny monolith]

i couldn't imagine all the dlc of characters

[pure widget]

Rdr1,rdr2,mafia definitive edition

Are the only games made me cry

Shodow of war ending left me speechless

[civic vault]

Sadie is uninteresting for me

[fluid cypress]

I havent rly played mafia

[tawny monolith]

oh i haven't even finished rdr2 and it's made me cry so many times

[pure widget]

Play the new one

[civic vault]

Charles is cool but i like him better as a companion

[fluid cypress]

shes a cool character but true

[fluid cypress]

Rn im saving my bank for gow and horizon 2 but layer this year ill see

[tawny monolith]

i got the horse from the mumfree broods stagecoach thing, one of a kind, cried when i killed her

[civic vault]

Sadie is good as a companion as well but i dont want her story

[dull geyser]

Yea

[pure widget]

Same

[fluid cypress]

theres nothing to it

[dull geyser]

She's just going on a rampage every time

[pure widget]

Ngl she only cared about killing odrisco boys

[civic vault]

To which Arthur doesnt care anymore

[dull geyser]

You know what's coming when you take her kn missions lmao

[fluid cypress]

yeah after that she just needed a reason to fill people with lead without much moral implications

[civic vault]

Lol

[tawny monolith]

I'd like to see the missing royalty girl found actually

[civic vault]

Yeah

[tawny monolith]

too bad they dropped that

there's definitely so much stuff that they dropped

[fluid cypress]

I thought it was a secret side mission or something

[tawny monolith]

it was at one point

was going to i mean

[civic vault]

It was scrapped

[pure widget]

Frank something was also a good charecter they didn't add to the game

[tawny monolith]

gavin!

[fluid cypress]

Scrapped content just like mexico and the river monster

[tawny monolith]

yeag mexico would be interesting

play with the del lobos or something

[fluid cypress]

people on reddit been saying mexico had been updated after an rdo update

[tawny monolith]

eh?

why?

[fluid cypress]

more finished textured and vegetation

its kinda true i noticed alot more plants there and it didnt look as scuffed as before

[civic vault]

Sneaky updates

[fluid cypress]

Yeah

[tawny monolith]

interesting

[pure widget]

Will rdo still get update?

Its been so long

[civic vault]

I hope they fix the floating guy during dead eye on that last train job lol

[fluid cypress]

they did that for adding new weapons and tweaks aswell sneaky story mode stuff with the rdo updates

[tawny monolith]

oh they need to fix the O'Driscoll/lemoyne raider camps guys spawning incorrectly

like in the ground and stuff

[fluid cypress]

lol i found a guy at an odriscoll camp who kept falling through the ground and teleporting back up, only to fall again

[tawny monolith]

biggest bug I've noticed

[tawny monolith]

yeah that's what i mean

[fluid cypress]

yeah same only glitch i noticed

[tawny monolith]

and here

let me find the second biggest bug I've found

[fluid cypress]

Except that one time when i stopped outside valentine post office and got teleported to the roof for some reason

[tawny monolith]

man link no work

[pure widget]

That item requires gold to purchase do you have some?

SHUT THE FUCK UP

[fluid cypress]

Put it in #red-dead-media

[tawny monolith]

me fr

[fluid cypress]

i dont play rdo

[tawny monolith]

#red-dead-media

my sirs

[fluid cypress]

lol

[pure widget]

I cant watch it because youtube is banned in iran

[tawny monolith]

last remaining footage of my dear horse

[fluid cypress]

tf?

fr?

[pure widget]

Yeah

[tawny monolith]

I'll send the file dw

[fluid cypress]

why

[pure widget]

Twitter,facebook alot of social media apps

[fluid cypress]

why tho

[pure widget]

Rockstar launcher it self

[dull geyser]

Sheesh

[pure widget]

Battle.net

[dull geyser]

Why is it banned tho?

[pure widget]

They are all banned

[pure widget]

Cuz its an American company

[dull geyser]

Ohh

[fluid cypress]

Makes sense

[pure widget]

Don't know why steam isn't banned

[tawny monolith]

huh

[pure widget]

Thank god

[tawny monolith]

weird

[fluid cypress]

but hey, vpn

[pure widget]

They ban vpns

[green spire]

@pure widget rockstar launcher is banned in Iran ?

[pure widget]

Like most vpns you can't connect

[fluid cypress]

vpn apps can be downloaded still?

[pure widget]

It dosent work

[pure widget]

Yeah

But dosent connect to server

[green spire]

@pure widget are you from Qom or Teheran

[fluid cypress]

thats odd

[green spire]

😎

[pure widget]

We have to buy a premium one

[pure widget]

Kerman lol

[fluid cypress]

Its good investment

[green spire]

oh

so you are in the desert

nice

😎

[pure widget]

Bruh lol

[fluid cypress]

you should consider buying it yt is basically my life atm lol

not just entertainment tho alot of stuff like help and shit

[green spire]

Persian history is fascinating

[dull geyser]

Yea my pc would've probably been dead if it wasn't for yt lmao

[fluid cypress]

lol

[green spire]

@pure widget how do you play RDR2 then

[pure widget]

Steam

[green spire]

if Rockstar launcher is banned ?

aha

interesting

Isn't Steam American too

[pure widget]

Idk why its not banned

But let's hope it wont

[dull geyser]

Yea

[pure widget]

Cuz if so I am fucked

[green spire]

Hm gotta contact Ali Khomeini

[dull geyser]

I think valve is an american company

[fluid cypress]

How do people pass time there tho

[green spire]

[pure widget]

They mostly go to instagram

Or reddit

They aren't banned to

The worst part is that

Our fucking president has a Twitter account while Twitter is banned for us

[green spire]

@pure widget Ali Khomeini ?

[dull geyser]

Lmao

[green spire]

[pure widget]

Khomeini is dead

Khamenei

[green spire]

lol

[tawny monolith]

#red-dead-media

[green spire]

@pure widget Idk how to spell those names

I just know it's Ali Kh-something

[pure widget]

Lmao

They horse flied