red-dead-singleplayer

[civic vault]

That's interesting

[sonic pivot]

dutchs actor actually used to be a heavy smoker then sometime after rdr1 was released he quit smoking

[civic vault]

Im not american so it's hard for me to trace their accents but it's interesting

[sonic pivot]

ive heard alot of american accents bc abt 90% of the movies tv shows and videogames im into are american

ive classed the incredibly strong southern accent as the "hillbilly/redneck" stereotype

like the accents a few of the npcs

like the lemoyne raiders

they have very strong southern accents obviously

due to their confederate roots

i still dont understand why confederates would call union soldiers 'yankees' in the american civil war

[civic vault]

Yeah the Lemoyne peeps are definitely the hillbilly sounding. Arthur's accent sounds a little Texan I guess - though I only know one guy who is from Texas.

I can be immensely wrong lol

[sonic pivot]

the lemoyne raiders are pretty stupid

[sonic pivot]

just wait until the american patriot goes on this channel and starts 'educating' us on the many american accents

[civic vault]

Trelawny has that weird accent that i mistook for british lol

[civic vault]

Im bracing for that lol

[sonic pivot]

he actually is english

[civic vault]

But it sounds weird to me like.. there's something off about it.

Like he sounds more like socialite with posh accent lol

[sonic pivot]

yeah i get what u mean, like it sounds english with a bit of american in there

[civic vault]

I actually like Charle's voice

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[civic vault]

Quiet and broody lol

And he's polite

[sonic pivot]

not when hes talking to poachers who get paid to kill bison and leave them to rot

lmao

[civic vault]

Yeah that felt a little too ragey for him lol

[hidden moss]

I describe Charles voice as gentle and quiet. He only talks when it's necessary, he doesn't like chit chat.

[civic vault]

Especially when Uncle tries to talk to him

[sonic pivot]

hes the kinda guy whos rly calm, but when u piss him off, oh boy ur in trouble

[civic vault]

It's hilarious lol

The very definition of strong silent type

Have Arthur AND Charles by your side and nobody would touch you

[sonic pivot]

yep

[sonic pivot]

man, i always feel safe when ive got charles by my side

even when going up against murfrees and skinners

[civic vault]

Same, and the coordinated shots with him feels so sleek

[sonic pivot]

and lets not forget, charles is the one who buried arthur

[civic vault]

I was so happy to see him in the epilogue

Arthur and Charles alone did make the best team

[sonic pivot]

and when micah called him a redskin and he threw that shithead on the ground

man that was satisfying

micah gets what he deserves

[civic vault]

One of the best things to watch

I really hated micah from the beginning

[red helm]

Those creep-o eyes of his. I definitely was suspicious of him from the beggining.

[civic vault]

and the fact that he seems like he wanted to do something dirty with Sadie at Colter

i mean, when they rescued her

i would've punched Micah right then

[sonic pivot]

every now and then i like to give arthur a 'good day', playing gambling games, fishing, feeding him well at the saloons, etc

just making arthur enjoy himself

[civic vault]

same!

giving him baths

I make sure he meets that pervy artist because he gives Arthur a good laugh

[red helm]

I'm not quite sure what his intentions were with Sadie in that missions, I mean, he knew Dutch and Arthur were right outside and about to come back in, so... kind of iffy there... Though, I wouldn't put it past him.

[sonic pivot]

i especially make sure arthur enjoys himself in chapter 6 when hes got tb

so that he can make the most of his last days

[civic vault]

and dress him up

[sonic pivot]

one day im gonna dress arthur as woody from toy story

[red helm]

That would be silly.

[civic vault]

It could be he assumed the gang was into that a bit. since he was just in the gang for only 6 months

[civic vault]

omg lol, but i'd see that lol

[sonic pivot]

thats the point

[red helm]

Nah, I'm pretty sure Dutch is quite clear on that subject.

[sonic pivot]

i mean until abigail was pregnant with jack alot of the male members of the gang slept with her

[red helm]

Yeah, with her permission.

[sonic pivot]

also micah claims to have impregnated jenny, or at least slept with her (jenny is the girl who died in blackwater)

[civic vault]

I like to think Arthur never slept with her, but he had some feelings - since he sorta hinted it in his journal.

[sonic pivot]

lets not forget about the creepy guy in the swamps who did u know what with arthur if u encountered him

[civic vault]

been avoiding cabins in swamps because of that

[slow trellis]

i just pretend he only robbed him

[red helm]

Ha.. understandable, but don't worry, explore away.

[sonic pivot]

i went back to his house and shot him with an explosive bullet

then set his house on fire

[red helm]

To quick, sneaky up and shot him with a fire arrow, so he can suffer.

[sonic pivot]

yeah i shoulda done that

apparently if u encounter him as john then after waking up john will limp for a bit

but idk for sure

[red helm]

I certainly didn't try that... nor want to try it.

[civic vault]

nasty guy i'd kill for low honor

[red helm]

I don't think you lose honor for killing him.

[civic vault]

Oh!

good lol

[red helm]

I don't remember, I wasn't paying attention.

[civic vault]

i should've beat up the racist in st. denis

i just shot him in the head lol

[dull geyser]

yea ppl wouldn't mind lmao

the ppl's reactions are like "about damn time"

[civic vault]

when i heard him shout that he's racist i just pulled up and shot him ded lol

[dull geyser]

I didn't lose honor I was prepared to lose some

[red helm]

Funner to mess with him.

[dull geyser]

I antagonized him first to see if he fights

[civic vault]

imma try next coz i heard he respawns lol

[red helm]

You can always make a manual save beforehand, and see how things pan out, Just in case.

[dull geyser]

then after I can't interact I looked if I can hit him

[hidden moss]

Gawd damn ansberg at 1200 bounty is cursed

[dull geyser]

lmao

[hidden moss]

drinking a tunic literally every 5 seconds

[fringe creek]

Ngl, ch6 is the worst chapter to see the gang in

[dull geyser]

yea

[fringe creek]

But I'm happy for those who survived because they could escape Dutch

[dull geyser]

almost everyone is a mess

[fringe creek]

Like ngl, Dutch was always a piece of shit who just wanted to fuck shit up without the law telling him what to do

Like every braindead libertarian

[dull geyser]

lmao

welp I think he was pretty cool with me at the beginning

chapter 4 he starts being a pain

he kinda gets on my nerves at that point

[fringe creek]

Micah can burn in hell too but even if he died in Strawberry, Dutch would have found a way to ruin it all

[dull geyser]

lenny should have told us he already got hanged

roll credits

[fringe creek]

Tho I'd say after Blackwater, the collapse of the gang was inevitable

Even before Blackwater, Dutch became a worse person

[civic vault]

Micah just sped up that process

and Hosea's death

[fringe creek]

Yea no one likes Micah

But it was still inevitable.

They should have established a decent, legal business

[civic vault]

Yeah

[fringe creek]

Like a ranch

[civic vault]

What John did lol

but yeah

[fringe creek]

Then get Strauss to handle the money laundering

[civic vault]

Dutch would be so bored in that

i think lol

kick out dutch before that happens lol

kill micah before it happens as well

[hidden moss]

Javier did nothing wrong

[sonic pivot]

i wrote an alternate ending for rdr2: arthur busts micah out of jail. when micah returns to camp strauss sends him to collect a debt from thomas downes, who gives them the money without hesitating, but accidentally coughed on micah. arthur takes jack fishing, and after milton and ross are about to leave, arthur tells jack to cover his ears and close his eyes. he then shoots milton and ross in the blink of an eye, then tells jack to open his eyes. arthur shows the surprise to jack, a new story book for him. then they return back to horseshoe and after a long conversation with hosea, dutch hands the leadership of the gang over to him. the gang heads west and arthur gets mary to come with him. the two get married and the gang lives a happy life, except for micah, who dies of tb

the end

[civic vault]

The true ending

[civic vault]

I remember the Javier's VA fought Rockstar to not have Javier point his gun towards Arthur and John in the end.

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[civic vault]

Javier didn't want to hurt them

[sonic pivot]

arthur and john were his 'brothers'

[hidden moss]

I feel like javier

Was

Uhmm

How do I explain this

[civic vault]

and he was confused at that point and at the same time didn't want to get shot by dutch so he stayed at Dutch's side

but that's just how i interpreted it

[sonic pivot]

explain what

[hidden moss]

I feel like everytime that Dutch did something that was absolutely crazy he missed it

And he didn't like micah

So it's like

Why would he do it other than to make Dutch proud or whatever

[civic vault]

He didn't see the whole picture

[hidden moss]

Yeah

Classic case of tunnel vision

I think him and Arthur were kinda jealous of Dutch's love for john

[civic vault]

I feel like Bill is more into the trying to impress Dutch

[sonic pivot]

bill on the other hand was loyal bc he wasnt very intelligent and he was just blinded by loyalty

[hidden moss]

I always saw Javier Arthur and john as like the van Der Linde sons

In a way

[civic vault]

I feel like Javier just wanted a family to belong into

and Bill is trying hard to impress Dutch

[sonic pivot]

did u know that micahs actor and bills actor both say their fav character is the trapper

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[civic vault]

especially when he said "why is it when i make mistakes i don't hear the end of it?"

[sonic pivot]

name one gang member who didnt have a depressing backstory

[civic vault]

I think we watched the same interview videos lol

[sonic pivot]

as far as ik the only gang member who isnt an orphan is pearson

[sonic pivot]

yeah

i think the trapper is pretty cool

he tells interesting stories when ur doing business with him

and i love the comments he makes when u bring him legendary animals

[upbeat tapir]

Am i the only one who loves giving arthur baths? Like, i like that he gets to relax and be clean at the same time

[sonic pivot]

no

everyone loves giving arthur baths

also ur nickname is concerning

[upbeat tapir]

Heheh

evil rat sounds

[sonic pivot]

why are u a devotee to the rat

[upbeat tapir]

Because rat

Rat is rat

I like rat and rats

[sonic pivot]

"waht about the munee in blaaackwadurrr" -micah bell iii

[upbeat tapir]

Listen man, no one loves the villians as much as i do, i love them all

[sonic pivot]

ok

[upbeat tapir]

Colm is personally my favourite because we have the same name

Also hes old peepaw

[sonic pivot]

cool

lmao

[civic vault]

rofl

i imagined that he hid the bodies first xD

But then again there would be blood stains on his short rofl

[sonic pivot]

i think most of the animals i need for zooligist

are birds

and a few snakes native to guarma

[limpid rapids]

I thought guarma was inaccessible

[sonic pivot]

it is

oh and i also need to study new austin animals

but im in ch4 rn

on my main save

how?

ok

im probs just gonna wait till i reach guarma through the story bc its easier

oh ok

rn im mainly focussed on beating gambler

gambler 8 is a pain in the ass

ive done all the challenges except gambler, survivalist and herbalist

the pain

once i beat gambler 8 i am never going to a blackjack table again

imagine arthur gets back in camp after completing horseman 9 and dutch is just like
"what the hell were you doing in blackwater?" and arthur just says
"i was doing horseman 9, dumbass."
dutch: understandable have a nice day

dunno how many health tonics i used

imagine doing horseman 9 with the default satchel

and only having 3 potent health tonics

ppl who do horseman 9 as john have no balls

[limpid rapids]

I dont even carry health tonics and i regretted it when i played American Venom

[sonic pivot]

damn

to anyone doing gambler 8 rn, heres some advice: be prepared to absolutely shit urself

i dreaded the day i reached gambler 8

the challenge that might just be the hardest thing abt 100%

like what was r* thinking when they added a challenge that was 90% luck based

i got to gambler 7 and was like "this challenge hasnt been hard so far, why does everyone think its so difficult?"

then i saw gambler 8

the VERY REASON that everyone hated the challenge set

i mean gambler 9 and 10 sound pretty hard

but i dont think theyr as bad as blackjack

i mean why couldnt r* just make it 3 blackjack wins in a row

[limpid rapids]

My newest American Venom run was so good i am proud of myself

All i did was chew on 10 tobaccos

[sonic pivot]

nice

i love how u can massacre an entire city and gain a $1000+ bounty then go to a post office and pay it off then all is forgiven

"the most wanted criminal in the countr- oh nevermind he payed off his bounty"

[hidden moss]

I massacred St. Denis after completing the Gambler Challenge

[sonic pivot]

when i beat gambler 8 imma shoot the blackjack dealer in the head

[vestal cipher]

make sure it doesnt get above 1500

[long nymph]

a fucking tree just fell on my fucking horse

are you fucking kidding me

thank god for auto save

and fuck the lumberjack

[verbal raptor]

i have a theory about the lost princess

My guess is that the girl locked in the Emerald ranch house is the princess of Luxemburg. Eugene (the owner) stole her while she was just a kid and she doesn't remeber much about her past, her "dad" acted as if she was his own daughter to family (we also never hear about him having a wife to make the daughter) and the dude that got shot is someone that found out about the girl being the princess before the RDR2 events and tried to save her but got shot and that's why the bloodstains are old. She was young at the time and looked similar to the picture from the post, after the killing happened, everyone just acted like they forgot about her since they didn't want to get in trouble but Eugene is still careful about people seeing and talking to his "daughter". Files about the grown-up princess have been found and she looks pretty similar to the girl inside the house.

DM me your thoughts

PS: Eugene let her walk around the ranch but ever since that shooting incident he was way more careful

damn, if it wasn't for that letter i think my theory could stand

[vagrant temple]

Isn’t the lost princess cut content?

[verbal raptor]

it would probably be a better mystery if she actually was

[vagrant temple]

So much of the game was cut

Agreed

Rockstar knows when enough is enough.

Unlike other game studios

High quality open world > bloated massive open world

Talking about you, Ubisoft

SMH

[verbal raptor]

it would have been better if they worked one more year for the game, 2018 was a huge year for games, God Of War etc, and rdr2 kinda got left in the side by most gamers. If it was released at 2019 it might have gotten more attention

[vagrant temple]

RDR2 was already delayed twice lol

Before it came out

I’m pretty sure there’s a ton of cut mo cap scenes

Like Arthur’s son dying in the prologue

[verbal raptor]

idk i remeber my friends being way more excited for god of war rather than for rdr2

[vagrant temple]

God of War was very story focused and had good gameplay. I think people like it more because of the story. RDR2 is objectively better imo

People are suckers for emotional storytelling

As am I

Like The Last of Us

Go talk in #general

[hidden moss]

Is it possible to get dual wield guns in rdr1

[jovial helm]

From what I can remember you cannot, I don't think so

Maybe you can, I was just a kid so I wasn't very good at figuring stuff out

[civic vault]

I found the 6 gold bar treasure

Was fun

[crude glade]

how can i see side quests like bringing back jacks book and stuff like that? pc btw

[fluid cypress]

[vagrant temple]

Buy the game guide

Shows you every possible encounter and mission

[crude glade]

yeah but where can i see it? i remember a key that i could press to see things like this like bringing something to someone but its a small side quest

[vagrant temple]

You can go search for it online. Just Google “Red Dead Redemption 2 Official game guide”. You can also buy the physical book guide like I did

[crude glade]

oh ok ty

[hidden moss]

I just found a secret way so that arthur doesn't die

[civic vault]

I found the racist in St. Denis again. Fed him to the alligators.

[willow agate]

Guys

What do u think if hosea was still alive would dutch stop in all his bullshit!

Or hed do what he did!

[normal herald]

he was the one who kept dutch in line

[willow agate]

Actually people say taht accident in s denis

Make his head crack lol

[normal herald]

what accident?

[willow agate]

That accident on saint denis! That trolley

Arthur dutch lenny

[normal herald]

oh right

i doubt that tbh

i cant tell if someone deleted that message or if it got deleted cause i marked it as a spoiler by editing it

[hidden moss]

Bro @fluid cypress, the weapon customization is really clean tho

Love it

[rustic plinth]

nothing like running people into Rhodes while you can't use weapons until they die, cause a shootout and have the sherrifs do all the work for you lmao

[humble talon]

yep

[normal herald]

yeah its hilarious how even if you can't shoot or punch people you can still make them roll around the floor till they die, and there are no consequences

[rustic plinth]

also Arthur's greetings are great
runs into guy several times
uhh...hello?

[humble talon]

wait sadie is 25??

[weak charm]

Just started a low honor playthrough, played a bit of chapter 2 while trying to do some devious stuff. Just checked now and I have high honor

You just can't be a bad guy, it feels so bad

[hidden moss]

That's why it's called Redemption

[weak charm]

True true. I don't even know why they made other endings

So something just came on my mind

If you go to point six cabin at the beginning and kill the guys there

Then you do the keiran mission, would there be a different outcome?

Like, Arthur tells I was just there and there was no colm. They kill keiran. 5th different ending

Not sure

[rustic plinth]

don't think so tbh

[civic vault]

I did a robbery mission with Sean but we were headed to the house I robbed before. The people are still there. Not sure if it was the same people I killed. The only change was Arthur's dialogue which has him saying "I've been here before."

[weak charm]

Sad, thought I made a grand discovery

All I made was a fool of myself 😔

[humble talon]

im playing it rn and its laggy-

[fluid cypress]

What happens if you brutally murder them with you horse tho

tbh high honor return for the money seems to be the ending they had in mind cuz in the epilogue, Micah is just jumped by sadie on his left and he’s a very experienced gunman so left seems to be his blindspot. Same thing for Dutch shooting him from the left and him not being able to instakill John when he first pulled out his guns. Another thing idk if it’s true I read somewhere on Reddit that his corpse model has the eye scar no matter what ending you got

tho Arthur’s motives for returning for the money seem real stupid he gon die anyway and also other moral things along with the fact that if you don’t do anything the game will choose help John for you so basically shut up and help John Lmao

no, for helping Mary in ch2 if you don’t do anything the game chooses not to help

same for watching that show with her

but the show makes sense

i chose not to go

huh?

[normal herald]

same thing probably

[fluid cypress]

it chose not to help for me

[civic vault]

I prefer it if the other choice was "Go back and stop Dutch and Micah." It wouldve been a very interesting pick

[fluid cypress]

yeah that would make alottt of sense

makes sense my honor low by like a pixel

[civic vault]

And it was another way to have them stop getting to John.

[normal herald]

gentlemen

belgian draft horse vs ardennes

[stuck geyser]

Ardennes easily

[normal herald]

why

what does it do better than the belgian

besides having standard handling

[stuck geyser]

Ardennes is a war horse better for gunfights on horseback

[normal herald]

is it faster

nvm i just checked, it has better everything

i might get the regular coat ardennes and max out everything, i want a really big and reliable horse but still fast enough to not make long trips a nightmare

and the extra health is based cause i tend to have plenty of accidents

mostly just crashing into trees

[nova gust]

The best horse is the Amber Champagne Missouri Foxtrotter

[normal herald]

its fast but its not big and based

[nova gust]

I prefer speed over health

It’s easier to chase people and also run from enemies

My load out is the Springfield Rifle, Pump Action Shotgun and Double Mausers. It works for every situation

It’s fun chasing cops and then blowing a cops head off

[normal herald]

well, you can still get 6 speed and acceleration with the ardennes which is pretty decent

[short oriole]

Ö

:þ

[fluid cypress]

After u use any horse over 7 that feels super slow

I can’t go back after having a maxed speed ultimate edition horse

always get that, Arabian or mft cuz others just don’t feel like it

[nova gust]

I had my white Arabian for while but sold him because my Foxtrotter was better

[normal herald]

horses are complicated for me

i want a really big and cool one, but i want them to have decent speed as well

what's the best option for me?

[willow agate]

Damn you! Ur worst than micah!

ÒwÓ

[rustic plinth]

if i catch an animal during a mission and then abandon the mission, do i lose the animal?

[normal herald]

you stay in chapter 2, the happy chapter

after chapter 3 everything gets sad

the saddest rdr2 character is gavin's friend imo

[floral umbra]

I’m looking for my friend, he’s a tall bloke, Englishman

[normal herald]

i've seen him twice in rhodes, once in saint denis and once nearby the chapter 6 camp walking down the road

it just gets progressively sadder every time you see him, he's so frustrated and worried

[floral umbra]

He also shows up in black water in the epilogue still searching for Gavin

[normal herald]

7 years later

right?

[floral umbra]

8

He says he forgot what Gavin looks like, at that point he’s just going off a name

[jovial helm]

Don't you just hate when you want to get on your horse but your character grabs an npc instead in the middle of the city and you get 5 witnesses all running away and there is nothing you can do and law starts shooting at you and you try to run away so a $5 bounty becomes a $250 bounty 🥲🤡

[floral umbra]

Did that too, it sucks

[jovial helm]

Yeah... such a stupid mechanics, game shouldn't target npcs unless you hold to focus on them

[floral umbra]

Once I tried to flee my horse but I was too close and I punched it

I felt terrible

[jovial helm]

I tried to tell my horse to flee and I knocked out a random npc

[normal herald]

don't they just tell you to leave the area

[jovial helm]

No not on assault, it's gotta be minor crimes

[normal herald]

when i grab people and let them go the lawmen just tell me to go away

[jovial helm]

Like walking into someone, disturbing the peace, trespassing

[normal herald]

maybe i dont remember correctly

[jovial helm]

Depends if you get unarmed assault or disturbing the peace, I think if you tackle it's assault, grabbing is disturbing peace. But grabbing and then tackle is assault

[floral umbra]

I almost had to shoot up valentine because I got confused where my room was in the hotel

[jovial helm]

It's just a weird system. I hate the law and honor system in the game, not much makes sense and everything feels unclear and rigged against the player

[floral umbra]

I liked the honor/fame system in rdr

[normal herald]

i never played rdr, i should

[floral umbra]

Yes you should, the online still has people playing it surprisingly

[desert frigate]

Is the White Arabian horse too small for someone to ride in the backseat? Because I saved some stranger girl and she asked a lift back to town and she wouldn't get on my White Arabian, and eventually left to find her own way

or was that a bug

[floral umbra]

Did you have a pelt?

[desert frigate]

no pelts

nothing in the back

[floral umbra]

Probably a glitch then

[desert frigate]

you sure its just not too small of a horse? maybe there's a limit to size of horses and whether they seat just 1 or 2

[floral umbra]

I don’t think so

[desert frigate]

alright then

[jovial helm]

Like you find a strangers body, sometimes you can loot it to find notes and not lose honor, sometimes you lose honor. Running in town and knocking down 50 ppl like you're 50000000 pounds heavy, but then tripping on a tiny rock will almost kill you.
Someone assaults you and you defend yourself - you get bounty and the law starts shooting you up with no option to surrender, while if I touch someone, instantly 8 witnesses all starts calling law and I get shot up

[desert frigate]

anyway she was left standing next to a signpost, I rammed her full speed with my horse

she died

didnt even lose honor, it was an accident

[floral umbra]

Nice

[jovial helm]

No, I've ridden with plenty npcs on back, all horses work the same. Must've been bugged

Urgh Horseman challenge 9 is such a pinta. Every time it starts raining when I'm about 50%-90% done -.-

[willow agate]

So umm

Anyone here knows catherine

It says u can visit her last time after all 3 missions with arthur

As john

So after that what happens she just disappear???

[steady horizon]

you mean Charlotte up by Roanoke Falls ?

[willow agate]

Shit

My mind! Sorry

I meant charlotte

I wasnt talking about that old hag who selled johns son

[jovial helm]

Anyone know how to make it stop raining? It's been raining every single time I've done Horseman 9. Now it's raining so much I can't even start the challenge, it's been raining 13 in games days a row, THIRTEEN. Been reloading game, sleeping, fast travelling. Nothing works. Every time I'm in Van Horn it's just raining... and every time I'm at Strawberry it's raining...

[calm crow]

Everyone says that leroys revolver is in luckys Cabin but It’s all cap

[jovial helm]

I barely had any rain before the challenge, I swear to god rockstar rigs the game, so as soon as you have to something for a challenge it's suddenly a million times harder

[willow agate]

So she just randomly dissapear

I wondered what happened to my friend trelawny

Nah

When john went he couldnt hear them anymore

Talk is that he went to newyork to work as a magician

And poor reverend

[normal herald]

arturo morginez

[hidden moss]

john would sell jack to get a sniff of sharpie

[willow agate]

I wonder if all the gang was alive till chapter 6

And in camp! Who would have sided with (dutch and micah)

And who would have sided with arthur

My guess

Arthur
(Hosea'lenny'sean'keiran'sadie'reverand'tilly'marybeth'miss grimshaw'karen'trelawny'charles' John'molly(coz shes had it with dutch)

And dutch
(Micah(and his two goons)
Bill
Xavier
Thats it?😕😕😕

[eternal kestrel]

id say charles would side with arthur

i forgot but i think sean was pretty close with dutch? so i think he'll pick dutch's side

oh nvm

[buoyant chasm]

Especially if you help him with Rains Fall and Eagle Flies

[eternal kestrel]

i read it again

dont forget pearson

[hidden moss]

Charles, Sadie, Lenny, Kieran, hose and maybe Sean would all side with Arthur for sure, if only they were there

Hosea*

[hidden moss]

Pearson’s a camp cook g, don’t know what he’d do lol

[eternal kestrel]

like a cornered tiger

im thinking of replaying rdr2 again i just finished the game

i breezed through chapter 1-2

but idk might ruin the experience, have you guys replayed the game

[hidden moss]

Yeah

I’ve replayed it about 5 times now

[hidden moss]

Don’t, get as much money as u can early game

and try get good stuff

[eternal kestrel]

definitely, also early game trinkets

[hidden moss]

yeah alot

[hidden moss]

agreed

[normal herald]

dude, my horse was replaced by some tennessee walker

it had lvl 1 bonding and everything, a completely different horse

i had to remake my old horse with the rampage trainer

my previous saves were affected too

how did this even happen?

[willow agate]

Does reverend and trelawny ever use a gun???

[sonic pivot]

late response but that seems like a good theory

[cold parcel]

No, I don't think so.

[willow agate]

Actually i had that u know teammates together roam with u in map glitch

[cold parcel]

They do use faith tho.

[willow agate]

I had reverend 'javier and hosea

[civic nest]

That's a glitch

Happened to me a few times

[willow agate]

And reverend didnt do anything just run off to someplace safe at shooting and

When the fight was over he just came near and said ! Hello mr.morgan

[red helm]

Rain doesn't effect those challenges, by 'Water' they mean rivers/lakes/etc.

[cold parcel]

You all getting rain?

I have not have rain on my game in an while.

[red helm]

When it rains it pours.

Sand storms in the New Austin region are so fun.

[cold parcel]

Yep.

Thunder is beautiful.

The sunrise is beautiful, especially in the grizzlies mountains in the morning.

[sonic pivot]

at the start of chapter 3 it doesnt rain at all until u burn the grays tobacco fields with sean

in scarlett meadows only tho

[red helm]

Oh, yeah, one time I was near The Loft, and I managed to get on top of it, right as the sun was coming up, with a clear sky. That was epic.

[cold parcel]

Epic moments.

[red helm]

Was kind of tempted to take a picture, but... eh.

[cold parcel]

It reminded me what Arthur saw for the last time, so i was like "Helloo Arturd!"

[sonic pivot]

guys whats ur fav horse coat colour?

mine is probs gold for the turkoman

[red helm]

The red Arabian is nice. and there is also a cherry coat Ardennes that looked nice.

[sonic pivot]

you mean the strawberry roan at the van horn stable?

or is it online exclusive

i wouldnt know bc i dont rly play online

[hidden moss]

mine Silver dapple pinto for Missouri fox trotter

[sonic pivot]

i always had a hard time deciding which mft coat looks better bc they both have the same stats but theyr both rly nice coats

and cost the same amount

[red helm]

Yes, that one. I knew I had the wrong name.

[sonic pivot]

yeah, the iron grey roan also looks pretty good, im so pissed they made it exclusive to preorder

[red helm]

Pre-order only, bah.

[cyan jetty]

algum br?

[hidden moss]

I always loved the look but it gives me bad luck or Something because i bought one he died i bought another he died so now i have the Golden coat for Turkoman

[sonic pivot]

its hard deciding which is better, mft or turkoman

[hidden moss]

Yea

[sonic pivot]

they both have great stats but in diff categories

the turkoman is braver due to being a war horse

[red helm]

I quite enjoy my Dark Bay Turkoman.

[sonic pivot]

but the mft has max speed

[red helm]

Meh, a few points of speeds are whatever.

[sonic pivot]

did u get it from the mission where u steal the braithwaite horses?

[sonic pivot]

i have a black arabian with max speed because of a random encounter in lemoyne where some woman challenged me to a race

[red helm]

Ha, no, just in the Epilogue from the Blackwater Stable.

[sonic pivot]

ok

i prefer arabians bc even tho theyr skittish af they have the best all round stats

especially the rose grey

only horse in the game with max stamina and hp

there used to be a glitch where u could make any 2 random horses spawn

it was just outside saint denis

and u could load a save and there would be different horses

so u could get the rose grey as arthur

[red helm]

Meh, I used the red arabian for a long time, but got annoyed with the skittishness. Switched over to Buell, then a Turkoman. I really haven't noticed much difference, speed wise.

[hidden moss]

I never liked the look of arabians that much like they Got the best stats but i always wanted my horse to look good so thats why i had mft or turkoman

[sonic pivot]

well u only rly notice a difference in speed if ur timing urself

like with horseman 3, 6 and 9

i think the white arabian is oveerrated

[red helm]

Indeed, people have raced the Arabian and Morgan, and the time is very little difference.

[sonic pivot]

i mean sure statwise its the best horse u can get in the wild

[red helm]

So, really, 90% of horse choice is looks.

[sonic pivot]

pretty much

but i think the black arabian is pretty badass

and smth abt high stamina and health feels rly satisfying to me

just a thing abt me

[red helm]

In my second play through, I had Arthur using the Perlino Andalusian for a really long time, it was nice stats, and not very skittish.

[sonic pivot]

i think a good early game free horse is the dapple grey hungarian halfbred

u can get it in the first bounty mission

with benedict allbright

u can also sometimes get it from bounty hunters

[hidden moss]

I used Arabs only to chapter 3 because then i got mft with Really good saddle that got him to Really good stats

[red helm]

Saddle/stirrups are universal to all your horses, so....

[sonic pivot]

its incredibly hard to get the mft from the albert mason

i tried twice, failed both times

[sonic pivot]

beaver saddle and panther saddle are the best options

both can be crafted for free with the specific pelts at the trapper

[red helm]

Yeap, I got the Panther Saddle very early in chapter 2.

[sonic pivot]

panthers are a pain to hunt

not bc theyr deadly, but bc theyr rare

[red helm]

I was very lucky with Panthers. Mooses, however.....

[sonic pivot]

but i posted a panther location in #red-dead-media yesterday

[sonic pivot]

theres a moose northeast of colter i think

u can find it chilling on a cliff

but its not always perfect

but i found a moose near owanjila once

[red helm]

Yeah, I finally got a Bull Moose to appear west of The Loft, after 2 weeks of playing.... ugh

[sonic pivot]

and they spawn every now and then in northern roanoke

and in roanoke theyr usually perfect

do u prefer trapper garments or store bought clothes?

[red helm]

I've also seen some where the Perlino Andulusian spawns, under Brandywine.

Trapper, usually. I did buy up all the Store clothes, before I finished Chapter 6, because I messed up the Pig Farm glitch. So, I wanted to not waste all my money.

[sonic pivot]

theres a badger literally right behind the trapper at riggs station

and its always perfect

ALWAYS perfect

[red helm]

I once saw 2 perfect opposums right by RIggs station.

[sonic pivot]

yeah, trapper clothes are underrated

[sonic pivot]

ive found 1 perfect opposum in my entire time playing rdr2

it was in the southern heartlands

ive also only come across one owl

[red helm]

I've seen a bunch. Eris Fields is a good place for those kinds of animals(By the Face Rock)

[sonic pivot]

theres an owl on the roof of emerald station at night

[sonic pivot]

i hear bolger glade has alot of small game and boars

[red helm]

Yeap, I've seen the Owl at Emerald station, and one flying around there. Also saw a Great horned owl flying around by The Loft.

[sonic pivot]

have u ever seen a carolina parakeet?

theyr the rarest animal in game

[red helm]

I got a Flock of 8 Parakeets. once.

[sonic pivot]

and once u kill 25 they literally never spawn

bc uv driven them to extinction

[sonic pivot]

did u get neg honor when u killed the first one?

[red helm]

Studied, then quickly took out my repeater, deadeyed and blam blam. Didn't let any of them go.

Don't remember, was awhile ago.

[sonic pivot]

i have basically every animal for zooligist

except some birds and new austtin animals

[red helm]

I'm missing a handful, mostly the darn Guarma snakes. Blah.

[sonic pivot]

same

snakes are the only animal in the game to spawn in every region of the map including guarma

[red helm]

I got all the Macaws, when I was there, but the snakes were refusing to appear, and I was just eh...

[sonic pivot]

how many dreamcatchers have u found?

ive got 8/20

[red helm]

All. I have the 100% trophy

[sonic pivot]

nice

im grinding for as many challenges as possible before chapter 5

[red helm]

I found like 7 on my own. and 8 or so dino bones

[sonic pivot]

bc i wanna do them before arthur gets tb idk why

i just do

im on gambler 8

the most notorious challenge in the game

[red helm]

Stupid Gambler 8.

[sonic pivot]

nobody likes u, gambler 8

the whole gambler set is stupid

[red helm]

Another game I play, has a Casino, with Blackjack, and I was just "nope"

[sonic pivot]

what was r* thinking making a challenge set thats like 80% luck based

except for fff

fff is the only gambling game that doesnt require luck

[red helm]

Indeed, FFF it makes sense.

[sonic pivot]

and beating micah in fff at camp gives such a satisfying feeling

[red helm]

It should've been like "5 wins with 2 hits" Or... "1 win with 3 hits"... Something doable.

[sonic pivot]

on my first playthrough micah literally wasnt at horseshoe at all

[sonic pivot]

or like 3 wins in a row

just like with 9 and 10

[red helm]

Yeah.. something not awful.

[sonic pivot]

i mean wins in a row is still awful

but the current challenge is torture

does splitting make the challenge easier?

[red helm]

Indeed. I've heard other people taking 6-8 hours on the challenge.

[red helm]

Sort of, but it's just playing 2 games at once, so not really.

[sonic pivot]

i heard a quick method is if ur not confident with ur first 2 cards then leave the table and rejoin

[sonic pivot]

ok thanks anyway

[sonic pivot]

a speedrunner used this method

foor 100%

[red helm]

Some people talk about certain chairs having better luck...

[sonic pivot]

man got 100% in 36 hours

[sonic pivot]

thats probably bs

[red helm]

More than likely.

[sonic pivot]

i mean the only advantage of ur seat is if it means ur first each round

if ur on the far right seat

[red helm]

36 hours... I mean, You have to be very lucky with all the Hunting Requests/Exotics and such....

[sonic pivot]

then u go first

[sonic pivot]

i reckon he hunted all the animals before reading the requests

and also if he used the buy method for the cigarette cards

[red helm]

Yes, but even so, you are at the mercy of the random spawns and what not.

[sonic pivot]

true

at least rabbits and squirrels are common af

theyr literally the most common animals in game

why is it that u cant beat the hunting requests as arthur?

[red helm]

Yeap, I remember at one spot I had 7 Rabbits running around with my horse. Was pretty funny.

[sonic pivot]

rabbits are in so many challenges

hunting request 1, horseman 1, master hunter 2

and a buncha crafting recipes at the trapper

[red helm]

It's rather stupid, the last set, you'll get a mail saying that the lady is off on a vacation and won't be back for some time. So, no list....

[sonic pivot]

wonder why rockstar did that

[red helm]

Because they are Rockstar...

[sonic pivot]

probs bc of how u get the squirell as a decoration at beechers

[sonic pivot]

fr fr

i hate it when ppl say "tHe rDr2 mAp iS tInY"

its not abt map size its abt what content u can find in the map

ive discovered basically every cabin

almost all the cabins u can find excluding the ones in great plains tall trees and new austin

[red helm]

Tiny? Those people are weird.

[sonic pivot]

ikr

and others say that its a weird shape

but thats bc its literally 5 american states

i think lemoyne is basically entirely based off louisianna

but i wouldnt know bc im not american

[mystic raven]

i honestly hate when people say "omg rdr2 better than gta 5"
no shit bro
you compare a 2013 game to a 2018 game

its like comparing gta 4 and gta 5

Of course its better

But its also a diffirent genre

[sonic pivot]

i mean thats a matter of opinion

and i cant have an opinion on gta bc ive barely played it

[mystic raven]

Yeah your right
i kind of went overboard with that comment

[mystic raven]

Well, not diffirent genre but a diffirent

whats the word

[sonic pivot]

i mean its set in a different era

[mystic raven]

yes

[sonic pivot]

so different setting is the word ur looking for

[mystic raven]

Its just annoys me how people compare them
When one is much older than the other

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[mystic raven]

i love both games (i love rdr2 more tho)

Both are good
its just that there isnt a point in saying that one is more detailed when its 5 years apart from the other game

Oh well, sorry for that little rant
but you get what im trying to say

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[fringe maple]

does anyone know how long the storymode sale lasts

[sonic pivot]

ur gona have to ask another xbox user

[fringe maple]

o ye

LOL

[sonic pivot]

my 100% checklist so far (im in chapter 4)
10/10 stranger mission strands complete
5/5 bounty missions complete
25/25 chance encounters
gang ambush survived
1/1 point of interest
4/9 graves found (cant find any more due to current progress in the story)
4/30 dinosaur bones found
6/13 legendary fish caught
4/10 rock carvings found
1/1 cigarette card sets mailed
1/5 hunting requests
duchesses and other animals complete
treasure hunt chain complete
8/20 dreamcatchers
50/50 animal species discovered
10/10 equipment items discovered
10/10 fish discovered
20/20 plants discovered
48/48 weapons discovered
74/90 challenges completed
lvl 4 horse bonding completed

the closest thing to fixing it is looking as close as possible to the original john look

so just use hair tonics to reach max hair length

and make him clean shaven or smth

i think theres mods on pc to give john his og look

i mean since u play on pc u can install the john hair mod if u like

but its up to u

im not sure

anyone got tips for survivalist 6?

ive managed to attract scavenger animals and kill them but somehow it didnt count towards the challenge

[vocal vale]

Did you kill then while they were feeding? If it’s a bird and starts to fly away or if it’s a coyote/wolf and sees you it won’t count

[sonic pivot]

oh ok

thanks

[vocal vale]

Np just hit em with a bolt should be a clean kill

[sonic pivot]

cool

thanks

survivalist gambler and herbalist are the only challenge sets i havent beaten yet

[vocal vale]

Yeah I have them all except the gambler ones and a few stragglers

Dominoes is the bane of my existence

[sonic pivot]

if u play it at camp u wont risk losing any money

[vocal vale]

Im in the epilogue

[sonic pivot]

oh ok

gambler 8 makes me wanna break my controller

and shoot the dealer

the thing is

ive scored points in dominoes befoe

i just dunno how

i have no idea how u score points in dominoes

[vocal vale]

Yeah I really just don’t understand it. It has something to do with the combined amount of the edge pieces

[sonic pivot]

yeah

unless its draw

[civic vault]

That had me iffy on epilogue lol. I remember that I just had his hair long and just made his clothes default

[civic vault]

Yeah, it's that, just gotta pair up the edge pieces, and then you need to use up all the tiles before your opponent does to win

But im not sure how the game tabulates the score for it

[sonic pivot]

same

the only reason to play dominoes unless im doing gambler challenges is bc i like to play dominoes with good ol hosea

[sonic pivot]

i liked to put john in the outfits he wore in 1899

[civic vault]

Also some extra dialogue that i want to trigger. I wanna play with all the camp mates

[sonic pivot]

one time i played dominoes with mary beth and she said "lets raise the stakes, the winner gets to read the loser's journal"

[civic vault]

I stay in camp long enough for their stories tbh

[civic vault]

Nice!

[sonic pivot]

i love how arthur is so secretive abt his journal\

[civic vault]

Same

It's somehow endearing

[sonic pivot]

my fav camp dialogue is easily hoseas campfire stories

[civic vault]

I relate to that

I kept a private sketch book when i was younger, so i know why arthur is secretive lol

It's just too personal lol

[sonic pivot]

i love how despite having no known education in art arthur is actually amazing at sketching

[civic vault]

Yeah, i love to go to place where he sketches the landmark he finds there

[sonic pivot]

i love how johns drawings are horrible compared to arthurs

[civic vault]

Yes rofl

When i saw john's im like da heck lol

[sonic pivot]

but i mean im even worse at drawing than john

my friend made a rly cool drawing of these cartoon characters one time and he said its "ok", even tho its literally like 10x better than the best drawing ive ever done

[civic vault]

I sketch stuff like arthur but im more into drawing people than objects and places. But ive been rusty over the years

[sonic pivot]

like talented artists will make incredible drawings that seem super detailed and say "its not that good"

[civic vault]

I say mine is not good 🤣

[sonic pivot]

meanwhile i can barely do a drawing of a stick figure

[civic vault]

Buy honestly i just see flaws all the time lol

[sonic pivot]

i couldntt draw a straight line if i was using a ruler to help me

[civic vault]

Everybody starts with that, even great artists

It's a matter of motivate and practice

But yeah, it has to have more effort to be better

Arthur's sketches makes me wish i kept on drawing on my sketchbook

[vocal vale]

Yeah I wish I played through more of the non story as Arthur to have all the good journal stuff

[civic vault]

I think he even writes about the ghost in the swamp

[sonic pivot]

he writes abt the crazy hermit man

[civic vault]

And then he sketches animals

[hidden moss]

Well made new playthru

[sonic pivot]

i was just up in roanoke looking for golden currant then i hear
"gO aWaY! pIsS oFf! i aInT bUyInG iT, aNd i dOnT wAnT iT!"

god that hermit mans got issues

[civic vault]

lol

[vocal vale]

I didn’t realize how many Easter eggs were sci-fi related lmao

There’s like 3-4 UFO’s I have seen and a vampire

[civic vault]

I tried to shoot the ufo lol

There's also a giant

[vocal vale]

The bones?

[civic vault]

Nope, like a talking giant

But you cant see him

You can just talk to him

Ive only seen it on youtube tho

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[vocal vale]

Is it a location or do you need to find multiple clues or sm

[sonic pivot]

ive encountered him

[sonic pivot]

u can find him pretty far east of wapiti

[civic vault]

I want to encounter the giant, and it requires you to study 30 animals i think

[vocal vale]

That’s not that many at all

[civic vault]

Yeah

And ive been lazy and get sidetracked all the time lol

[vocal vale]

But 30? I thought you got like 60-70 by just doing the fishing and hunting missions in the story

[eager canopy]

Any tips to maxing out health and deadeye stats?

[sonic pivot]

just look for valerian root and ginseng elixir

[fast raptor]

30 is not that much

ive studied atleast 40 by just playing

[sonic pivot]

doing chores, picking up cigarette packs and getting headshots without using deadeye levels up deadeye

melee combat and a few other things level up health

[fast raptor]

Hunting improves health the most

the best way to really max out health and stamina together is to try and grind for the legend of the east satchel

got my stamina to max and health to level 6 just hunting

[sonic pivot]

u need to complete all the challenge sets for actual max

i have level 10 health

and level 9 deadeye and stamina

[fast raptor]

Prolly my next grind, i been wanting that legend of the east vest

[eager canopy]

Where do i find that root?

And does it increase deadeye or health

[sonic pivot]

valerian root increases deadeye

ginseng elixir increases health

they are found throughout the map

but theres one encounter in saint denis

where theres a homeless guy saying he lost his money playing poker

interact with him and give him 25c

then he gives u ginseng elixir

[eager canopy]

Alr

[hidden moss]

ive robbed and killed that guy like in all my story mode playthroughs

[sonic pivot]

why...

[hidden moss]

it feels fun lol

idk why

[sonic pivot]

what is ur honor

[hidden moss]

red

[sonic pivot]

bruh

[hidden moss]

I have never got full good honor

[sonic pivot]

ive never had negative honor

literally never

[hidden moss]

i always get negative in a day

[sonic pivot]

good honor gives store discounts

[hidden moss]

because i like burning people

[sonic pivot]

max honor literally gives 50% off on everything u can buy

[hidden moss]

ah

[sonic pivot]

r u ok?

[hidden moss]

no

[sonic pivot]

fr

ur part of the 1% of the fanbase who likes having low honor

but i mean arthur with low honour has pretty badass lines

like when u beat a stranger in a fistfight or a duel low honor arthur is like "ill kill you again in hell my friend"

i still prefer high honor tbh

[fast raptor]

I honestly play high honor mostly because of the ending

[sonic pivot]

yeah

[fast raptor]

I will not let a rat get the best of me

It also feels nice helping people

even though I get bounties on me all the time because npcs always get the wrong idea

[sonic pivot]

i couldnt kill jimmy brooks if someone offered me $1m

[fast raptor]

yeah there’s just no good reason to lol, unless ur a psycho

[civic vault]

To avoid low honor, i just rob other gangs

let the bullets rain on their camp after listening to them talking

and then loot them lol

[fast raptor]

I used to bomb every single one of those and sometimes i would accidentally kill a person they took hostage and lose Hella honor 😭

[civic vault]

Yeah, i once tried to save a stagecoach from being robbed by the O'Driscolls but i accidentally ran over the driver

[normal herald]

how do you fix it

[civic nest]

That's the neat part

You don't

[normal herald]

i already found a "solution" for it by making an exact copy of my old horse with rampage trainer, but the stats get reset whenever i die, fail an objective, etc

it probably has to do with that tennessee walker you get in chapter 1, i hope the glitch can't happen in the epilogue

[hidden moss]

true

[fringe maple]

is deluxe even worth it

i dont think so

LOL

[glad brook]

Cool horse tho.

[white merlin]

Finally doing a low honor run, or as I am affectionately calling it, an Evil Arthur run

[red helm]

Low Honor is fun times.

[sonic pivot]

im having a 1v1 with pearson in poker

and i am determined to win

i will clean him out

[red helm]

You win that $2 from him.

[sonic pivot]

lmao

its not abt winning the money

its abt the triumph

of being the last man standing

[red helm]

Sure, sure.

[sonic pivot]

i WILL win

guys i just realised osman grove has 3 items needed for item requests

a book for jack, a pen for mary beth and a whiskey for sean

[fluid cypress]

lol, I shot some innocents along with odriscolls in a trail robbery thinking they were also odriscolls

had to kill them all

after that one

[sonic pivot]

lmao

[civic vault]

Nice! I already got the book for jack but i needed the pen for Mary beth

[civic vault]

harder to differentiate at night lol

[sonic pivot]

theres quite a few spots where u can find a book for jack

[civic vault]

I found it in the abandoned town in lemoyne, in the rundown school

[willow agate]

U know theres a hosea quest too

[sonic pivot]

the crime novel?

[willow agate]

He says: hey arthur coughs u mind helping me

Arthur : sure

Hosea: if ya step into some can ya find me some american gingseng*

[sonic pivot]

yeah

ive done that one before

[willow agate]

Arthur : sure ill look into it

Bruh u need to find 7 gingseng and hmgive it to him!
He says something cool!
(How can i repay u arthur)
Arthur: nah uve already done that

[sonic pivot]

its 1 ginseng...

and he gives u a health cure

[willow agate]

It not 1

I am sure

[sonic pivot]

it is

[civic vault]

Yep, he asked me to find ginseng, already given it to him. I'm trying to trigger the crime novel

[sonic pivot]

its ez

go to his tent and ull find a novel

pick it up to trigger the request

[civic vault]

Ah okie

I'll try that when i play later after work

[sonic pivot]

cool

[vapid lotus]

I have 1 dollar on my main save file and I’m trying to get 100%. What should I do to get money?

[pure carbon]

wtf john can't swim?

[civic vault]

He drowns

[sonic pivot]

rip bozo

[civic vault]

He wouldnt survive the shipwreck to Guarma

[pure carbon]

more reasons to restart the game

[sonic pivot]

i wondered why they didnt make it so john was also on guarma, then i realised his ass couldnt swim 🤣

imagine if he was on the casino riverboat

theyd need a wholeass canoe to bring with them

[civic vault]

Yes rofl

Abigail jokes about it before his proposal

[civic vault]

I was exploring the swamp and i heard a woman crying and im like NOPE

Not helping you lady

I wanna keep my horse alive

[orchid harness]

well there's only two things that will happen either it's a robbery or she's in danger

[civic vault]

Most likely it's Nightfolk

And it's at night

[orchid harness]

Never really met nightfolk walking through the swamp of lamoyne

[civic vault]

Oh hell naw

They attacked me once and i dont wanna let that happen again

[orchid harness]

plenty of raiders though

[civic vault]

They dont walk around they're hidden

They use a crying lady as bait

[orchid harness]

ah

I see

[civic vault]

They dont even talk and they would kill your horse

[orchid harness]

Speaking of raiders

[civic vault]

The crazy thing about my encounter with them is that it was during the day

I didnt think theyd attack me in daylight

[orchid harness]

I remember taking a bounty mission for their boss

and after I beat the game they still exist in 1907

[civic vault]

Yeah, theyd be back in Shady Belle

[orchid harness]

How come they can stay alive for so long

even the O'Drisscoll dies off soon after Colm died

[fluid cypress]

do I have to break Micah out of jail to progress to ch3?

[civic vault]

It's fate

[fluid cypress]

bruh

I thought you could do a strange kindness without freeing him

[civic vault]

Idk if it was modded or something but i saw a youtube video where you dont break out micah but escapes anyway

[sonic pivot]

that encounter made me shit myself

[sonic pivot]

sadly yes

[civic vault]

It's so creepy

I dislike the swamp even more at night now lol

[sonic pivot]

now that ive beaten the exotics mission

i am NEVER going to the swamps again

[hidden moss]

Uh can anyone help me out

I like used cheats

And now just achieved a trophy but didn’t get the trophy.

I saved the game before but still I’m not getting the trophy

And I do not wanna start a new game

[jovial helm]

uses cheats expects an award

[fluid cypress]

lmao

[civic vault]

I guess the Raiders were more passionate about their group and maybe someone was installed as a leader. I think a lot of the O'Driscolls don't like Colm. Like he only had a faithful few who were willing to plan his escape from hanging.

[cyan night]

How early in the epilogue can I just go off and start to explore?

[civic vault]

I think after John is hired in Pronghorn Ranch

[hidden moss]

Lol yeah it’s fixed now

[fluid cypress]

well as soon as he’s hired you can but it’s not recommended, like at all. You have nothing and the game makes sure you don’t survive the first mile out of there, whatever route you choose you will be jumped by the Laramie boys

there’s no way to defend yourself, only thing you have is a knife and you have no health items or food so you’ll die if you rush in with it. So without spoilers just complete epilogue part I and then you can free roam

[rustic plinth]

just did the Sodom? back to Gomorrah mission and didn't get any money afterwards

[whole dawn]

is there not a place to sleep in the ranch?

and store your guns and stuff

i think i just can't find it

[fluid cypress]

In the bedroom go to the left side of the bed, now here’s the thing idk why tf did r* think it was a good idea to put fast travel there so you’ll see the option for fast travel when you stand there, you have to press r1 when the prompt appears to switch focus between items. So switch to the bed or vice versa and you can sleep

[whole dawn]

ohh lmao. i knew it would be there. i thought i was dumb for not seeing it. thanks a lot

[fluid cypress]

np r* made it hard so I don’t blame you

[normal herald]

challenge accepted

[fluid cypress]

lmao

i wish there was a way to just not equip any weapons

for sidearms

[nocturne spindle]

Or if you could remove the off-hand holster

[fluid cypress]

you can?

[nocturne spindle]

No, but I wish you could

[fluid cypress]

Just learnt that putting weapons in the weapon locker makes them unavailable on your horse

Finally can get rid of the worn weapons clogging up my weapon inv

[nocturne spindle]

Bruh that's the whole point of the locker

[fluid cypress]

I didn’t know

Never used it

[fluid cypress]

I thought it was just accessing your weapons to change your load out in your camp/room without horse

like gunsmith

200 hours and still discovering shit this game is amazing

[nocturne spindle]

The gun locker was added way after the game's release with the NPC camp members' pajamas

2 years ago

[civic vault]

So... they didnt have pajamas before? Lol

Or they wore something different?

Ah lol

I made Arthur drunk around the camp

He started singing lol

[latent fossil]

Hello, is anyone interested in joining my Read Dead Redemption PS4 Online crew. Were a Pvp/Pve crew. We're well established. We protect are members from any and all outside or inside threats. We also do mass pelt glitches, bounties, collecting, Moonshiner and trader runs. We help are members with any and all things from missions to building up your fighting ability. We stand united in Deviant Sinners. Come and stand with us.

[hidden moss]

man micah is genuinely pretty good in early chapters

[cyan night]

If anyone cares, have you noticed whether the weapons compendium in the game matches the weapons compendium at the rockstar social club website. The website used to say I had 46 collected when I actually had collected 52 according to the game. Now I've collected even more than 52, but the website says I have 35 so it has oddly gone down even more. I've emailed them and they said "We understand your issue and we are aware of this and we are working towards finding a fix for this". But I was just curious if it is just affecting me or if it is widespread. All my other compendium entries are correct. PS - I know this isn't some major issue.

[cold parcel]

Is there any way to make the trains ride theirself? Like when I'm wanted, I wanna shoot cops who are after me on an train.

[hidden moss]

not really anyway

[red helm]

Drive the train, and, fire your gun? Crazy talk.

[cold parcel]

I wish it was that simple.

[hidden moss]

well u can drive then stop driving it but it'll slow down pretty fast

But imagine if u could switch between john and aurthur thru out the whole game

[red helm]

Like.. bounce between doing missions as one or the other... or do you mean have like, John following you around as Arthur?

[hidden moss]

kinda like how gta5 protagonists are

idk

[red helm]

Eh, I never played GTA5, but I sort of know what you mean. I thought it would've been neat to play Sadie.

[hidden moss]

yeah plus doing missions with John and Sadie are usually better

[red helm]

They had some interesting ones.

[vocal vale]

Why is the legendary fish in the swamp so hard lmao

It just took me 30 minutes and I’m doing the other ones and they’re all infinitely easier

[hidden moss]

Help john or get the money?

[sonic pivot]

lets be real

no one got the money on their first playthrough

[red helm]

The one next to Lakay? Usually once I spot them, they aren't that bad to get. However, it's actually finding them, since they tend to not be all that close to the picture they place on the map.

[sonic pivot]

just heard arthur drop the f bomb

[hidden moss]

wtf

just finished the game first time

[sonic pivot]

nice

[delicate yacht]

Cool

I'm trying to do the 100% completion

If I can

[sonic pivot]

same

[wanton loom]

Lol god bless you with doing the exotics, boring and stupid ash

[sonic pivot]

ive done the exotics

[delicate yacht]

I haven't done the first part of the exotics yet

😔

[dark scaffold]

where exactly is arthurs grave

[sonic pivot]

near the mysterious hill home point of interest

[dark scaffold]

i hate to ask but i havent found where that is either

[sonic pivot]

just south of the 'i' in ambarino

[dark scaffold]

thanks

[sonic pivot]

np

ping me if u need any more help finding it

[left compass]

Hey, after the epilogue with john, does honor really even matter anymore..? Cuz I've just been going all out, standing off entire towns, and i think mine's in the negatives.

[sonic pivot]

it only rly matters if u want discounts at stores

[left compass]

So now i can just outlaw all i want until i get bored?

[sonic pivot]

ig so

if thats what u wanna do

[left compass]

Well the people of saint denis keep looking at me funny
So yeah wanted dead or alive time

[sonic pivot]

lmao

[civic vault]

When?

[sonic pivot]

random encounter in roanoke at night

the murfrees have a stranger tied to a tree

and u hear him screaming

then u intervene and arthur says 'let him go you kin f*cking bastards!'